50TH CONGRESS,    HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES. J Ex. Doc. 1
  2d Session.                                   pt. 2, vol. II.




                   ANNUAL REPORT

                             OF TIIE




CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,
                 UNITED STATES ARMY,

                             TO   THE




         SECRETARY                       OF WAR,
                              FOR




                       THE YEAR 1888.




                  IN   FOUR         PARTS.




                         PART           I.




                       WASHINGTON:
                GOVERNMENT   PRINTING OFFICE.

                             1888.
                                                CONTENTS.
                               [Alphabetical index will be found at the end of each part.]




                                                                     PART          I.

OFFICERS OF THE CORPS OF ENGINEERS.....                                              ....-......                ......-....            .......    3


                            SEA-COAST AND LAKE FRONTIER DEFENSES.

GENERAL DISCUSSION ......                        .................
ESTIMATES OF APPROPRIATIONS FOR 1889-'90 .............--................
                                                                                ......             ..........          .............
                                                                                                                                                  5
                                                                                                                                                  4



                                             THE BOARD OF ENGINEERS.

Officers constituting Board, 5; Subjects considered and reported upon, 6; Additional
             duties of individual members, 6; Sea-coast fortifications, 8.

POST OF WILLETS POINT, ENGINEER SCHOOL OF APPLICATION, BAT-
TALION OF ENGINEERS, AND ENGINEER DEPOT AT WILLETS POINT,
NEW YORK HARBOR.

Post of Willets Point, School of Application, Battalion of Engineers, 8; Experi-
  ments, Engineer Depot, Public Buildings and Construction, Statement of Funds, 9.

                                  RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.
GENERAL STATEMENT............-------.........................................                                                                    10


                               ATLANTIC COAST AND GULF OF MEXICO.

IN CHARGE OF LIEUT. COL. JARED A. SMITH, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Lubec Channel, Me., Moose-a-bee Bar, Me., 11; Narraguagus River, Me., 12; break-
water from Mount Desert to Porcupine Island, Me., Bagaduce River, Me., Bangor
Harbor and Penobscot River, Me., 13; Belfast Harbor, Me., Camden Harbor, Me.,
14; Rockport Harbor, Me., Rockland Harbor, Me., 15; Kennebec River at Bath,
and from Augusta to lower end of Perkins Island, Me., Portland Harbor, Me., 16;
channel in Back Cove, Portland, Me., 17 ; breakwater at mouth of Saco River, Me.,
Saco River, Me., 18; Kennebunk River, Me.,'York Harbor, Me., 19; Portsmouth
Harbor, N. H., Bellamy River, N. H., Cocheco River, N. H., 20; harbor of refuge,
at Little Harbor, N. H., 21; examinations and surveys, 22.
IN   CHARGE OF LIEUT. COL. GEORGE L.                                   GILLESPIE, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Newburyport Harbor, Mass., 22; Merrimac River, Mass., 23; Powow river, Mass.,
Ipswich River, Mass., 24; harbor of refuge, Sandy Bay, Cape Ann, Mass., Glou-
cester Harbor, Mass., 2%; Manchester Harbor, Mass., Lynn Harbor, Mass., 26;
Winthrop Harbor, Mass., Boston Harbor, Mass., 27; Malden River, Mass., Hing-
ham Harbor, Mass., 29; Scituate Harbor, Mass., 30; Plymouth Harbor Mass.,
Wellfleet Harbor, Mass., 31; Provincetown Harbor, Mass., examinations and sur-
veys, 32.
            ENG 88-                 I
II                                         CONTENTS.

IN    CHARGE OF MAJ. WILLIAM        R.    LIVERMORE, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Harbor of refuge at Hyannis, Mass., harbor of refuge at Nantucket,             Mass., 33;
     harbor at Vineyard Haven, Mass., Wood's Holl Harbor, Mass., 34; Wareham Har-
     bor, Mass., 35; New Bedford Harbor, Mass., Westport Harbor, Maus., 36; Taunton
     River, Mass., 37; Warren River, R. I., Pawtucket River, R. I., 38; Providence
     River and Narragansett Bay, R. I., 39; removal of Green Jacket Shoal, Providence
     River, R. I., Newport Harbor, R. I., 40; harbor of refuge at Block Island, R. I., 41;
     Pawcatuck River, R. I. and Conn., harbor of refuge at Stonington, Conn., 43; ex-
     aminations and surveys, 44.
IN CHARGE OF LIEUT. COL. D.         C.   HOUSTON, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Thames River, Conn.; New London Harbor, Conn., 45; Connecticut River, Mass.
  and Conn., 46; Clinton Harbor, Conn., 47 ; New Haven Harbor, Conn., break-
  water at New Haven, Conn., 48; Milford Harbor, Conn., 49; Housatonic River,
  Conn., Bridgeport Harbor, Conn., 50; Black Rock Harbor, Conn., Norwalk Har-
bor, Conn., 51; Harbor at Five-mile River, Conn., Stanford Harbor, Conn., 52; Port
  Chester Harbor, N. Y., Mamaroneck Harbor, N. Y.,'53; Echo Harbor, New
  Rochelle, N. Y., New Rochelle Harbor, N. Y., 54; East Chester Creek, N. Y.,
  Greenport Harbor, N. Y., 55; Glen Cove Harbor, N. Y., Flushing Bay, N. Y., 56;
removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navigation, 57.
IN CHARGE OF LIEUT. COL. WALTER MCFARLAND, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Hudson River, N. Y., 57; harbor at Saugerties, N. Y., harbor at Rondout, N. Y., 58;
Harlem River, N. Y., 59; removing obstructions in the East River and at Hell Gate,
N. Y., 60; Newtown Creek, N. Y., Buttermilk Channel New York Harbor, 61; Gow-
anus Bay, N. Y., 62; New York Harbor, 63; Sheepshead Bay, N. Y., 64; Canarsie
Bay, N. Y., 65; Sumpawanus Inlet, N. Y., channel between Staten Island and New
Jersey, 66; Raritan Bay, N. J.,.removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or en-
dangering navigation, 67; examinations and survey, 67 and 68.
IN    CHARGE OF CAPT. GEORGE MCC. DERBY, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Passaic River, N. J., 68; Elizabeth River, N. J., 69; Rahway River, N. J., 70; Wood-
bridge Creek, N. J., Raritan River, N. J., 71; South River, N. J., 72; Cheesequakes
Creek, N. J., Keyport Harbor, N. J., 73; Mattawan Creek, N. J., Shrewsbury River,
N. J., 74; Manasquan River, N. J., 75.
IN    CHARGE OF LIEUT. COL. HENRY M. ROBERT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Delaware River, Pa. and N. J., 76; Frankford Creek, Pa., 77; harbor of Philadel-
phia, removal of Smith's Island and Windmill Island, Pa., and Petty's Island,
     N. J., Schuylkill River, Pa., 78; ice-harbor at Marcus Hook, Pa., 79; ice-harbor
     at the head of Delaware Bay, Del., 80; construction of iron pier in Delaware
     Bay, near Lewes, Del., harbor at Delaware Breakwater, Del., 81; Rancocas River,
     N. J., 82; Woodbury Creek, N. J., Mantua Creek, N. J., 83; Raccoon River, N. J.,
     Salem River, N. J., Cohansey Creek, N. J., 84; removal of wrecks from Delaware
     Bay and River, removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navi-
     gation, survey of harbor at Atlantic City, N. J., 85; United States Commission ad-
     visory to the Board of Harbor Commissioners of Philadelphia, Pa.,86; examination
     and survey, 86.
IN CHARGE OF MR. WILLIAM F. SMITH, U.            S. AGENT-

Maurice River, N. J., 86; Wilmington Harbor, Del., 87; ice-harbor at New Castle,
Del., Duck Creek, Del.,      88;
                                Saint Jones River, Del., 89; Mispillion Creek, Del.,
Broadkiln River, Del., Indian River, Del., 90; inland water-way from Chincoteague
Bay, Va. to Delaware Bay at or near Lewes, Del., Susquehanna River above and
below Havre de Grace, Md., 91; Fairlee Creek or Inlet, Md., Corsica Creek, Md., 92;
Choptank River, Md., Cambridge Harbor, Md., 93; Nanticoke River, Del., Broad
Creek, Del., from its mouth to Laurel, 94; Pocomoke River, Md, removing sunken
vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navigation, 95.
IN    CHARGE OF COL WILLIAM P.           CRAIGHILL,   CORPS OF ENGINEERS-

Patapsco River and Channel to Baltimore, Md., 95 ; James River, Va., 97 ; Nansemond
     River, Va., including the mouths of Bennett and Chuckatuck creeks, harbor of Nor-
     folk and its approaches, Va.,98 ; approach to Norfolk Harbor and the United States
     (Norfolk) navy-yard, between Lambert's Point and Fort Norfolk, Va., 99; Archer's
     Hope River, Va., Appomattox River, Va., 101; Currituck Sound, Coanjok Bay, and
     North River Bar, N. C., 102; Nottoway River, Va., 103; removing sunken vessels or
     craft obstructing or endangering navigation, 104.
                                           CONTENTS.                                     III

t   IN   CHARGE OF LIEUT. COL. PETER C. HAINS, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
    Potomac River at Washington, D. C., 104; reconstruction of the Aqueduct Bridge,
      Georgetown, D. C. ; bridge across the Eastern Branch of the Potomac River, D. C.,
      1065; wharf at Fort Monroe, Va., 107; survey, 107.

    IN   CHARGE OF MR. S.   T.   ABERT,   U.   S. AGENT-
    Channel at Mount Vernon, Va., Neabsco Creek, Va., 108; Breton Bay (Leinardtown)
     Md., Nomini Creek, Va., 109; harbor at entrance of St. Jerome's Creek, Md., Pa-
     tuxent River, Md. from Benedict to Hill's Landing, 110; Rappahannock River,
     Va., Totusky River, Va., 111; Urbana Creek, Va., Mattaponi River, Va., Pa-
     munky River, Va., 112; York River, Va., 113; Chickahominy River, Va., Staunton
     River, Va., 114; Dan River between Madison, N. C., and Danville, Va., Roanoke
     River, N. C., 115; French Broad River, N. C., removing sunken vessels or craft
     obstructing or endangering navigation, 116; examination and survey, 116.

    IN CHARGE OF CAPT. WILLIAM H.         BIXBY, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-

    Pamlico and Tar rivers, N. C., Contentnia Creek, N. C., 117; Trent River, N. C,, 118 ;
      Neuse River, N. C., 119; inland water-way between New Berne and Beaufort, N. C.,
      120; harbor at Beaufort, N. C., 121; inland water-way between Beaufort Harbor
      and New River, N. C. 122; New River, N. C., Black River, N. C., 123; Cape Fear
      River, N. C., 124 and 125; Waccemaw River, N. C. and S. C., 126; Yadkin River,
      N. C., 127; Little Pee Dee River, S. C., Lumber River, N. C., Clark Creek or River,
      S. C., 128; Great Pee Dee River, S. C., harbor at Georgetown, S. C., 129; Mingo
      Creek or River, S. C., Winyaw Bay, S. C., 130; Santee River, S. C., 131; Wateree
      River, S. C., 132; Congaree River, S. C., 133; examinations and surveys, 134.

    IN   CHARGE OF LIEUT.    FREDERIC     V.   ABBOT,   ConPs OF ENGINEERS-

    Charleston Harbor, S. C., 134; Wappoo Cut, S. C., 135; Ashley River, S. C., Edisto River
     S. C., 136; Salkiehatchie River, S. C., 137; removing sunken vessels or craft ob-
     structing or endangering navigation, 138; examinations and surveys, 138.

    IN   CHARGE OFr LIEUT. O,. M.   CARTER, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
    Savannah Harbor and River, Ga., 138; Savannah River, Ga., 139; Savannah River
      above Augusta, Ga., Romley Marsh, Ga., 140; Altamaha River, Ga., Doboy Bar,
      Ga., 141; Brunswick Harbor, Ga., Jekyl Creek, Ga., Cumberland Sound, Ga. and
      Fla., 142; examinations and surveys, 143.

    IN CHARGE OF CAPT. Wt.        M. BLACK, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
    St. John's River, Fla., 143; Volusia Bar, Fla., harbor at Saint Augustine, Fla., 145;
      northwest entrance Key West Harbor, Fla., Caloosahatchie River, Fla., 146; Pease
       River, Fla., Manatee River, Fla., 147; Tampa Bay, Fla., 148; Withlacoochee River,
       Fla., harbor at Cedar Keys, Fla., 149; Suwanee River, Fla., 150; removing sunken
       vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navigation, 151; examinations and sur-
       veys, 151.

    IN   CHARGE OF CAPT.    R.   L. HOXIE,     CORPS OF ENGINEERS-

    Apalachicola River, Fla., 151; Apalachicola Bay, Fla., La Grange Bayou, Fla., Pen-
     sacola Harbor, Fla., 152; Choctawhatchee River, Fla. and Ala., Escambia and
     Conecuh Rivers, Fla., and Ala., 153 ; Oconee River, Ga., 154; Ocmulgee River, Ga.,
     Flint River, Ga., 155; Coosa River, Ga., and Ala. Chattahoochee River, Ga. and
     Ala., Tallapoosa River, Ala, 156; Cahawba River, Ala, 157; Alabama River, Ala.,
     removing sunken vessels and craft obstructing or endangering navigation, 158;
     examinations and surveys, 159.

    IN CHARGE OF MAJOR A. N.       DAMRELL, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-

    Mobile Harbor, 159; Black Warrior River from Tuscaloosa to Daniel's Creek, Ala.,
     Warrior, River, Ala., and Miss., 160; Tombigbee River, Ala., from Walker's bridge to
     Fulton, Tombigbee River from Fulton to Vienna, 161; Tombigbee River, below
     Vienna, 162; Noxubee River, Miss., Pascagoula River, Miss., 163; Harbor at Biloxi,
     Miss., Pearl River, Miss. between Edinburgh and Carthage, 164; Pearl River,
     Miss. from Jackson to Carthage, Pearl River, Miss. below Jackson, 165; examina-
     tion and survey, 166.
IV                                      CONTENTS.

IN CHARGE OF CAPT. W. L. FISK, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Inspection of the improvement of the South Pass of the Mississippi River, 166; Tche-
  functe River and Bogue Falia, La., Tickfaw River, La., 167; Amite River, La., Bayou
  La Fourche, La., 168; Bayou Terrebonne, La., Bayou Plaquemine, La., 169; Bayou
  Courtableau, La., 170; Calcasieu River and Pass, La., Bayou Pierre, Miss., 171; Sa-
  bine Pass, Tex., 172.
IN   CHARGE OF MAJ. O. H. ERNST, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Entrance to Galveston Harbor, Tex., 172; Ship-channel in Galveston Bay, Tex., 173;
Trinity River, Tex., Buffalo Bayou, Tex., 174; mouth of Brazos River, Tex., Pass
  Cavallo Inlet to Matagorda Bay, Tex.,.,Aransas Pass and Bay up to Rockport and
Corpus Chiisti, Tex., 175; harbor at Brazos Santiago, Tex., 176.
                                   WESTERN RIVERS.
IN CHARGE OF CAPT. J. H. WILLARD, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Red River, La. and Ark., 176; survey of Red River, Cypress Bayou, Tex. and La.,
  177; Ouachita and Black Rivers, Ark. and La., Ouachita River, Ark. above Cam-
  den, Bavoq D'Arbonne, La., 178; Little River, La., Bayou Bartholomew, La. and
  Ark., Bayou Bceuf, La., 179; Tensas River and Bayou Macon, La., Bayous Ronde-
  way and Vidal, La. by removing obstructions, 180; Big Black River, Miss., Yazoo
  River, Miss., Tchula Lake, Miss., 181; Tallahatchee River, Miss., Steele's Bayou,
  Miss., 182; Big Sunflower River, Miss., Big Hatchee River, Tenn., Forked Deer
  River, Tenn., 183; water-gauges on the Mississippi River and its principal trib-
  utaries, 184.
IN   CHARGE OF CAPT. H.    S. TABOR,     CORPS OF ENGINEERS-

Red River above Fulton, Ark., 184; Little Red River, Ark., removing obstruc-
  tions in Arkansas River, Ark., 185; Arkansas. River, Ark. and Kans., 186; Petit
Jean River, Ark., 187; Fourche River, Ark., White River, Ark., 188; Cache River,
Ark., Black River, Ark. and Mo., 189; Black River, Mo., St. Francis River, Ark.,
  St. Francis River, Mo. from Greenville to the Arkansas State line, 190; Little River,
Mo. from Hornersville to its junction with the St. Francis River, 191.
IN   CHARGE OF MAJ. A.    M. MILLER, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-

Removing snags and wrecks from the Mississippi and Missouri Rivers, 191; remov-
  ing obstructions Missouri River, Mississippi River between the Ohio and Illinois
  Rivers, 192; Gasconade River, Mo.,194; Osage River, Mo. and Kan., 195; exami-
  nations and survey, 195.

IN   CHARGE OF CAPT. E.    H.   RUFFNER,   CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Mississippi River between the Des Moines Rapids and the mouth of the Illinois River,
196.
IN   CHARGE OF MAJ. A.    MACKENZIE, CORPS OF ENGINESERS-
Upper Mississippi River, operations of snag-boats and dredge-boats, 196; Mississippi
River from Minneapolis to Des Moines Rapids, 197; Des Moines Rapids (Mississippi
River), operating and care of Des Moines Rapids Canal, 198; Dry-dock at Des
  Moines Rapids Canal, harbors of refuge on Lake Pepin at Lake City, Minn., 199;
harbors of refuge on Lake Pepin at Stockholm, Wis., 200.
IN CHARGE OF MAJ. CHARLES J. ALLEN, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Preservation of the Falls of St. Anthorfy, Minn., 200; Construction of lock and dam
  on the Mississippi River at Meeker's Island, Minn., Mississippi River above the Falls
  of St. Anthony, Minn., 201; Reservoirs at headwaters of the Mississippi River, 202;
  Chippewa River, including Yellow Banks, Wis., St. Croix River, Wis. and Minn.,
  203; Minnesota River, Minn., Red River of the North, Minn. and Dak., 204; Mis-
  souri River from Sioux City, Iowa, to Fort Benton, Mont., 205; Yellowstone River,
  Mont. and Dak., 206; examinations and surveys, 206.
IN   CHARGE OF LIEUT.    COL. J.   W.   BARLOW,   CORPS OF ENGINEBRS-
Tennessee River, 207; French Broad River, Tenn., 208; Little Tennessee River,
  Tenn., Hiawassee River, Tenn., Clinch River, Tenn., 209; Duck River, Tenn.,
  Cumberland River, Tenn. and Ky., 210; South Fork of Cumberland River, Ky., 211;
  Caney Fork River, Tenn., 212; examinations and survey, 212.
                                         CONTENTS.                                  V

IN   CHARGE OF LIEUT. COL. WILLIAM E. MERRILL, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Ohio River, 213; operating and care of Davis Island Dam Ohio River, 314; Mo-
nongahela River, W. Va. and Pa., operating and care of lock and dam No. 9,
Monongahela River, 215; Allegheney River, Pa., dam at Herr's Island Alle-
gheney River, ice-harbor at mouth of Muskingum River, Ohio, 216; Muskingum
River, Ohio, operating and care of the locks and dams on the Muskingum River,
  Ohio, 217; examinations and surveys, 218.
IN   CHARGE OF MAJ. AMOS           STICKNEY, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Falls of the Ohio, Louisville, Ky., 218; Indiana Chute Falls of the Ohio River, op-
  erating and care of the Louisville and Portland Canal, 219; Wabash River, Ind.
  and Ill., 220; White River, Ind., Tradewater River, Ky., 221.
IN   CHARGE OF COL. WILLIAM P.          CRAIGHILL, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-

Great Kanawha River, W. Va., 222; operating and care of locks and dams on the
Great Kanawha River, W. Va., harbor of refuge at mouth of Great Kanawha River,
W. Va., 223; Elk River, W. Va., Ganley River, W. Va., 224; New River, Va. and W.
Va., 225; examinations, 226.
IN CHARGE OF CAPT. D.    W.    LOCKWOOD, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Kentucky River, Ky., 226; operating and keeping in repair locks and dams on the
Kentucky River, Ky., Licking River, Ky. from Farmer's to West Liberty, Big
Sandy River, W. Va. and Ky., 2"27; Guyandotte River, WV.Va., Little Kanawha
River, W. Va., 228; Buckhannon River, W. Va., 229; examinations and surveys, 229.
IN CHARGE OF CAPT. JAMES B. QUINN, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Harbor at Duluth, Minn., 229; harbor at Superior Bay and St. Louis Bay, Wis.,
230; harbor at Agate Bay, Minn., 231; harbor at Grand Marais, Minn., 232.
IN   CHARGE OF MAJ. CHARLES E.          L.   B.   DAVIS, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-

Ashland Harbor, Wis., Ontonagon Harbor, Mich., Eagle Harbor, Mich., 233; estab-
lishment and maintenance of harbor-lines in Portage Lake, Mich., Marquette Har-
bor, Mich., 234; harbor of refuge Grand Marias, Mich., Manistique Harbor, Mich.,
235; Cedar River Harbor, Mich., Menomonee Harbor, Mich. and Wis., 236; Oconto
Harbor, Wis., Pensaukee Harbor, Wis., 237; Green Bay Harbor, Wis., harbor of
refuge at entrance of Sturgeon Bay Canal, Wis., 238; Ahnapee Harbor, Wis., Ke-
waunee Harbor, Wis., 239; Two Rivers Harbor, Wis., Manitowoc Harbor, Wis., 240;
Sheboygan Harbor, Wis., 241; Port Washington Harbor, Wis., 242.
IN   CHARGE OF CAPT. W.       L.    MARSHALL,     CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Harbor of refuge, Milwaukee Bay, Wis., 242; Milwaukee Harbor, Wis., 243; Racine
Harbor, Wis., Kenosha Harbor, Wis., 244; Waukegan Harbor, Ill., Fox and Wis-
consin Rivers, Wis., 245; operating and care of locks and dams on the Fox and Wis-
consin Rivers, Wis., Chicago Harbor, Ill., 247; Calumet Harbor, Ill., 248; Illinois
River, Ill., 249; Calumet River, Ill. and Ind., 250.
IN   CHARGE OF MAJ. S.    M.       MANSFIELD,     CORPS OF ENGINEERS-

Charlevoix Harbor and entrance to Pine Lake, Mich., 251; Frankford Harbor, Mich.,
252; harbor of refuge at Portage Lake, Mich., Manistee Harbor, Mich., Ludington
Harbor, Mich., 253; Pentwater Harbor, Mich., White River Harbor, Mich., 254.;
Muskegon Harbor, Mich., Grand Haven Harbor, Mich., 255; Black Lake Harbor,
Mich., Saugatuck Harbor, Mich., 256; South Haven Harbor, Mich., Saint Joseph
Harbor, Mich., 257; Saint Joseph River, Mich. from its mouth to Berrien Springs,
Michigan City Harbor, Ind., 258.
IN   CHARGE OF LIEUT. COL. O. M. POE, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
St. Mary's Falls Canal and River, Mich., 259; operating and care of St. Mary's
  Falls Canal, Mich., dry-dock at St. Mary's Falls Canal, Mich., 260; Hay Lake
  Channel, St. Mary's River, Mich., harbor at Sheboygan, Mich., 261; harbor at
  Thunder Bay, Mich., 262; harbor at Au Sable, Mich., Saginaw River, Mich., 263;
  harbor of refuge at Sand Beach Lake Huron, Mich., mouth of Black River, Mich.,
  264; Clinton River, Mich., St. Clair Flats Canal, Mich., 265 ; operating and care of
  St. Clair Flats Canal, Mich., 236; Grosse Point Channel, Mich., Detroit River,
  Mich., 267; Rouge River, Mich. at its junction with Detroit River and up the river
   as far as the bridge of St. Louis and Wabash Railroad, 268,
VI                                             CONTENTS.

IN CHARGE OF MAJ. L. COOPER OVERMAN, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Monroe Harbor, Mich., 268; Toledo Harbor, Ohio, 269; Port Clinton Harbor, Ohio,
270; Sandusky City Harbor, Ohio, Sandusky River, Ohio, 271; Huron Harbor, Ohio,
Vermillion Harbor, Ohio, 272; Black River Harbor, Ohio, Rocky River, Ohio, 273;
Cleveland Harbor, Ohio, 274; Fairport Harbor, Ohio, 275; Ashtabula Harbor, Ohio,
Conneaut Harbor, Ohio, 276.
IN CHARGE OF CAPT. F.      A. MAHAN, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Erie Harbor, Penn., 277; preservation and protection of the Peninsula of Presque
Isle (Erie Harbor) Penn., Dunkirk Harbor, N. Y., 278; Buffalo Harbor, N. Y., Tona-
wanda Harbor and Niagara River, N. Y., 279; Wilson Harbor, N. Y., Olcott Har-
bor, N. Y., 280; Oak Orchard Harbor, N. Y., 281; examination and survey, 282.

IN   CHARGE OF CAPT. CARL F.                 PALFREY,    CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Charlotte Harbor, N. Y., Great Sodas Harbor, N. Y., 282; Little Sodus Harbor, N.Y.,
283; Oswego Harbor, N. Y., 284; Sackett's Harbor, N. Y., 285.
IN   CHARGE OF MAJ. M.       B.    ADAMS,        CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Ogdensburgh Harbor, N. Y., 285; Grass River (at Massena), N. Y., breakwater at
Rouse's Point, Lake Champlain, N. Y., 286; Swanton Harbor, Vt., channel between
the islands of North Hero and South Hero (Lake Champlain) Vt., breakwater at
Gordon's Landing (Lake Champlain) Vt., 287 ; Plattsburgh Harbor, N. Y., Burling-
ton Harbor, Vt., 288; Otter Creek, Vt., Ticonderoga River, N. Y., narrows at Lake
Champlain, N. Y. and Vt., 289.

                                              PACIFIC COAST.
IN   CHARGE OF COL. G. H.         MENDELL, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Napa River, Cal., Oakland Harbor, Cal., 290; Redwood Harbor, Cal., survey of
San Francisco Harbor, San Pablo and Suisun bays, Straits of Carquinez, and
mouths of Sacramento and San Joaquin rivers, Cal., 291.

IN   CHARGE OF. MAJ. W.      H.        H.    BENYAURD,    CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Harbor at San Lius Obispo, Cal., Wilmington Harbor, Cal., 292; San Diego Harbor,
Cal., surveys of San Diego Harbor, Newport Harbor, and San Lius Obispo Har-
bor, Cal., 293; examination and surveys, 293.
IN   CHARGE OF MAJ. WILLIAM H.                 HEUER, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
San Joaquin River, Stockton and Mormon Sloughs, Cal., 293; Mokelumne River,
  Cal., 294; Sacramento and Feather rivers, Cal., Petaluma Creek, Cal., 295; Hum-
  boldt Harbor and Bay, Cal., 296.

IN   CHARGE OF CAPT. WILLARD YOUNG, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Coquille River, Oregon, 296; entrance to Coos Bay, Oregon, 297; Umpqua River,
Oregon, 2398; entrance to Yaquina Bay, Oregon, 299; Tillamook Bay and Bar, Ore-
gon, 300; examination and survey, 300.
IN   CHARGE OF MAJ. THOMAS H.                 HANDBURY,     CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Mouth of the Columbia River, Oregon and Wash., construction of canal at the Cas-
cades (Columbia River) Oregon, 301; Chehalis River, Wash., 302; Skagit Steila-
quamish Nootsack Snohomish and Snoqualmie rivers, Wash., gauging waters of
the Columbia River, Oregon, 303; examinations and surveys, 304.
IN CHARGE OF MAJOR W.             A.        JONES, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Columbia and Lower Willamette rivers below Portland, Oregon 304; Upper Willa-
mette River, Oregon, Upper Columbia and Snake Rivers, Oregon and Wash., 305;
Lower Clearwater River, Idaho, Cowlitz River, Wash., 306.

EXAMINATIONS, SURVEYS, AND CONTINGENCIES OF RIVERS AND HAR-
                           BORS.
Estimate of funds required ..............................................................   306
                                     CONTENTS.                                      VII

                        MISSISSIPPI RIVER COMMISSION....._............. 306

                         MISSOURI RIVER COMMISSION....................              307

         BRIDGING NAVIGABLE WATERS OF                THE   UNITED STATES ....       307

Report of the Board of Engineers relative to the construction of certain brides across
the Missouri, Mississippi, and Illinois rivers, 307; bridge across Staten Island Sound,
known as Arthur Kill; report of Board of Engineers on Senate Bill No. 1850, Fiftieth
Congress, first session, to authorize the construction of a bridge across the waters of
Arthur Kill at or near the town of Westfield, Staten Island; highway bridge across
that part of the waters of Lake Champlain lying between the towns of North Hero
and Alburgh,Vt.; bridge of the Kansas City, Topeka and Western Railroad Company
  across Missouri River at Sibley, Mo.; bridge of the Chicago, Saint Louis and New
Orleans Railroad Company across the Ohio River at East Cairo, Ky.; free wagon
bridge across the Cumberland River near the city of Nashville, Tenn.; bridge of
the Ohio River Railroad Company across Great Kanawha River near Point Pleasant,
W. Va.; bridge across the west channel of the Detroit River, to connect Belle Isle
Park with the mainland; international bridge of the Sault Sainte Marie Bridge
Company across Sainte Marie River; bridge of the Nebraska Railway Company
across Missouri River at Nebraska City, 308; combined railway and wagon bridge
of the Omaha and Council Bluffs Railway and Bridge Company across Missouri
River between Omaha, Nebr., and Council Bluffs, Iowa; bridge of the New York
  and Long Island Bridge Company across the East River between the city of New
York and Long Island; bridge of the Ohio Valley Railway Company across the
Tradewater River, Ky.; bridge of the Sioux City Bridge Company across the Mis-
souri River at Sioux City, Iowa; highway bridge of the Central Railway and Bridge
Company of Newport, Ky., across the Ohio River, between Cincinnati, Ohio, and
Newport, Ky.; bridges of the Georgia Pacific Railroad Company across the Sun-
flower and Yazoo rivers; high bridge across the Mississippi River at Dubuque,
Iowa; bridge of the Ohio Connecting Railway Company across the Ohio River,
near the mouth of Cork's Run, in Allegheny County, Pa.; bridge of the Georgia
Pacific Railway Company across the Tombigbee River at Waverly, Miss. ; bridge
of the Memphis and Charleston Railroad Company across the Tennessee River at
Chattanooga, Tenn.; bridge of the Kansas City and Memphis Railway and Bridge
Company across the Mississippi River at Memphis, Tenn.,'309.
INTERFERENCES WITH NAVIGATION BY BRIDGES, CAUSEWAYS,                               AND
                   OTHER STRUCTURES.---..--.....................-----..             309

OCCUPANCY OF AND INJURY TO PUBLIC WORKS BY CORPORATIONS
                    AND INDIVIDITALS .............................. 310

                                  MISCELLANEOUS.
IN CHARGE OF MAJ. G.     J.   LYDECKER, CORPS OF ENGINEERS-
Washington Aqueduct, increasing the water supply of the city of Washington, D.
      C., 310; erection of fish-ways at the Great Falls of the Potomac, 312.

IN CHARGE OF COL. JOHN M.      WILSON, U.   S. A.-
Improvement and care of public buildings and grounds in the District of Columbia,
  312; underground telegraph and telephone lines, Washington Monument, 313.
CONSTRUCTION AND IMPROVEMENT OF ROADS AND BRIDGES IN THE
              YELLOWSTONE NATIONAL PARK...... ..... ........ 314

                   NORTHERN AND NORTHWESTERN LAKES.
Annual water levels; printing and distribution of charts ....................      . 316
                    MILITARY AND GEOGRAPHICAL MAPS................ 316

                   RECONNAISSANCES AND EXPLORATIONS.
Officers on duty in military divisions and departments, 316, 317; operations in Divis-
ion of the Missouri, Department of the Columbia, Division of the Pacific, and De-
partment of Platte, 317; estimate of funds required, 318.
VIII                                               CONTENTS.

                           OFFICE OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS.
Officers in charge of divisions .................----..............................          19

           STATEMENT SHOWING RANK AND DUTIES OF OFFICERS ...... 320


                                          APPENDIX No. 1.
         REPORT OF MAJ. WILLIAM R. KING, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
Post of Willets Point, N. Y., 345; Engineer School of Application, 347; Battalion
  of Engineers, 349; Recruiting, 350; Experiments, 351; Engineer Depot, Public
  Buildings and Constructions, Depot property, 355; Work of the depot, statement
  of funds, 356; Appendixes, 357.



                       RIVERS               AND HARBORS,                              ETC.

                                              APPENDIX A.

   REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. JARED A. SMITH, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMENTS.-Lubec Channel, Me., 374; Moose-a-bec Bar, Me., 376; Narraguagus
  River, Me., 378; Bangor Harbor and Penobscot River, Me., 379; Belfast Harbor,
  Me., 381; Rockland Harbor, Me., 384; Portland Harbor, Me., 385; channel in Back
  Cove, Portland, Me., 387; breakwater at mouth of Saco River, Me., 389; Saco River,
  Me., 390; Kennebunk River, Me., 392; York Harbor, Me., 393; Portsmouth Har-
   bor, N. H., 394 ; Cocheco River, N. H., 396 ; harbor of refuge at Little Harbor, N. H.,
  397.
EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS.-Bayoduce [Bagaduce] River, Me., between the towns
  of Penobscot and Brooksville, 398; Camden Harbor, Me., 403; Rockport Harbor,
  Me., 407; Kennebec River, Me., at Bath, and from Augusta to lower end of Perkin's
  Island, 412; Penobscot River, Me., from Bangor to Bucksport Narrows, 425.


                                              APPENDIX B.

REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. GEORGE L. GILLESPIE, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENT.-Newburyport Harbor, Mass., 433; Merrimac River, Mass.. 436; Ips-
  wich River, Mass., 438; harbor of refuge, Sandy Bay, Cape Ann, Mass., 439; Glou-
  cestor Harbor, Mass., 442; Lynn Harbor, Mass., 445; Boston Harbor, Mass., 447;
  Malden River, Mass., 456i; Hingham Harbor, Mass., 456; Scituate Harbor, Mass.,
  458; Plymouth Harbor, Mass., 459; Provincetown Harbor, Mass., 462.
EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS.-Manchester harbor, Mass., 463; Winthrop Harbor,
  Mass., 468; Duxbury Harbor, Mass., 472; Wellfleet Harbor, Mass., 476.


                                              APPENDIX C.

    REPORT OF MAJ. WILLIAM R. LIVERMORE, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Harbor of refuge at Hyannis, Mass., 484; harbor of refuge at
  Nantucket, Mass., 486; Wood's Holl Harbor, Mass., 488; Wareham Harbor, Mass.,
  489; Westport Harbor, Mass., 491 ; Taunton River, Mass., 492; Warren River, R. I.,
  494; Pawtucket River, R. I., 496; Providence River and Narragansett Bay, R. I.,
  498; removal of Green Jacket Shoal, Providence River, R. I., 500; Newport Har-
  bor, R. I., 502; harbor of refuge at Block Island, 1. I., 504; Little Narragansett
  Bay, R. I. and Conn., 508; Pawcatuck River, R. I. and Conn., 509; harbor of
  refuge at Stonington, Conn., 511.
EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS.-New Bedford Harbor, Mass., 513; Taunton River,
  Mass., 515.
                                    CONTENTS.                                       IX


                                 APPENDIX D.
    REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. D. C. HOUSTON, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Thames River, Conn., 521; New London Harbor, Conn., 525; Con-
  necticut River, Mass. and Conn., 527; Clinton Harbor, Conn., 538; New Haven
  Harbor, Conn., 540 ; breakwater at New Haven, Conn., 544; Milford Harbor, Conn.,
  548; Housatonic River, Conn., 551; Bridgeport Harbor, Conn., 555; Black Rock
  Harbor, Conn., 558; Southport Harbor, Conn., 561; Norwalk Harbor, Conn., 562;
  Stamford harbor, Conn., 564; Port Chester Harbor, N. Y., 567; Mamaroneck Har-
  bor, N. Y., 569; Echo Harbor, New Rochelle, N. Y., 570; New Rochelle Harbor,
  N. Y., 572; East Chester Creek, N. Y., 574; Greenport Harbor, N. Y., 577; Port
  Jefferson Harbor, N. Y., 578; Flushing Bay, N. Y., 581; removing sunken vessels
  or craft obstructing or endangering navigation, 583.

                                  APPENDIX E.

REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. WALTER McFARLAND,                      CORPS OF ENGINEER.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Hudson River, N. Y., 588; Harbor of Saugerties, N. Y., 594; Har-
  bor at Rondout, N. Y., 596; Harlem River, N. Y., 598; removing obstructions in
  the East River and at Hell Gate, N. Y., 603; Newtown Creek, N. Y., 606; Butter-
  milk Channel, N. Y., 610; Gowanus Bay, N. Y., 613; New York Harbor, 617;
  Sheepshead Bay, N. Y., 624; Harbor at Canarsie Bay, N. Y., 627; Sumpawanus In-
  let, N. Y., 629; channel between Staten Island and New Jersey, 631; Raritan Bay,
  N. J., 633; removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering naviga-
  tion, 637.
EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEY.-Spring Creek, N. Y., 638; Hudson River, N.Y., be-
  tween New Baltimore and Coxsackie, 640.

                                  APPENDIX F.
    REPORT OF CAPT. GEORGE McC. DERBY, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Passaic River, N. J., 645; Elizabeth River, N. J., 648; Rahway
  River, N. J., 649; Woodbridge Creek, N. J., 650; Raritan River, N. J., i52; South
  River, N. J., 657; Cheesequakes Creek, N. J., 661; Keyport Harbor, N. J., 662;
  Mattawan Creek, N. J., 663; Shrewsbury River, N. J., 665; Manasquan River, N.
  J., 667.
                                  APPENDIX G.
      REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. HENRY M. ROBERT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS*
IMPROVEMENT.-Delaware River, Pa. and N. J., 669; Frankford Creek, Pa., 698;
  Schuylkill River, Pa., 699; ice-harbor at Marcus Hook, Pa., 701; ice-harbor
  at the head of Delaware Bay, Del., 704; construction of iron pier in Delaware
  Bay, near Lewes, Del., 705; harbor at Delaware Breakwater, Del., 707; Rancocas
  River, N. J., 708; Woodbury Creek, N, J., 710; Mantua Creek, N. J., 711; Raccoon
  River, N. J., 712; Salem River, N. J., 712; Cohansey Creek, N. J., 714; removal of
  wreck from Delaware Bay and River, 716; removing sunken vessels or craft ob-
  structing or endangering navigation, 716; survey of harbor at Atlantic City, N. J.,
  717; United States Commission advisory to the Board of Harbor Commissioners of
  Philadelphia, Pa., 718.
EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEY.-Thoroughfare from Cape May to the Great Bay north
  of Atlantic City, N. J., 724.
                                 APPENDIX H.
      REPORT OF MR. WILLIAM F. SMITH, UNITED STATES AGENT.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Maurice River, N. J., 738; Wilmington Harbor, Del., 739; ice-har-
  bor at New Castle, Del., 740; Duck Creek, Del., 741; Saint Jones River, Del., 742 ;
  Mispillion Creek, Del., 743; Broad kiln River, Del., 744; Indian River, Del., 744; in-
  land water-way from Chincoteague Bay, Va., to Delaware Bay, at or near Lewes,
  Del., 745; Susquehanna River above and below Havre de Grace, Md., 746; Chester
  River at Kent Island Narrows, Md., 747 ; Corsica Creek, Md., 747 ; Choptank River,
  Md., 748; Nanticoke River, Del., 749; Broad Creek, Del., from its mouth to Laurel,
  750; Wicomico River, Md., 751; Upper Thoroughfare between Deil's Island and the
  mainland, 751; Pocomoke River, Md., 752; removing sunken vessels or craft ob-
  structing or endangering navigation, 753.
X                                    CONTENTS.


                                    PART II.
                                  APPENDIX I.

    REPORT OF COL. WILLIAM P. CRAIGHILL, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Patapsco River and channel to Baltimore, Md., 756; Annapolis
  Harbor, Md., 761; James River, Va., 761; harbor of Norfolk, and its approaches,
  Va., 766; approach to Norfolk Harbor and the United States (Norfolk) navy-yard,
  between Lambert's Point and Fort Norfolk, Va., 767; Archer's Hope River, Va.,
  768; Appomattox River, Va., 768; North Landing River, Va. and N. C., 770 ; Cur-
  rituck Sound, Coanjok Bay, and North River Bar, N. C., 770; Blackwater River,
  Va., 772; Nottaway River, Va., 773; Meherrin River, N. C., 773; Edenton Bay, N.
  C., 773; removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navigation,
  774.
                                  APPENDIX J.
     REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. PETER C. HAINS, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Potomae River at Washington, D. C., 777; reconstruction of the
  Aqueduct Bridge, Georgetown, D. C., 789; bridge across the Eastern Branch of
  the Potomao River, D. C., 795; Shenandoah River, W. Va., 804; wharf at Fort
  Monroe, Va., 804.
SURVEY.-James Creek Canal, emptying into Anacostia River, D. C., 807.

                                  APPENDIX K.
             REPORT OF MR. S. T. ABERT, UNITED STATES AGENT.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Channel at Mount Vernon, Va., 813; Neabsco Creek, Va., 814;
  Breton Bay, Leonardtown, Md., 815; Nomini Creek, Va., 816; harbor at entrance
  of St. Jerome's Creek, Md., 818; Rappahannock River, Va., 819; Totusky River,
  Va., 824; Urbana Creek, Va., 825; Mattaponi River, Va., 826 ; Pamunky River,
  Va., 828; York River, Va., 830; Chicahominy River, Va., 832; Staunton River,
  Va., 834; Dan River, between Madison, N. C., and Danville, Va., 838; Roanoke
  River, N. C., 840; French Broad River, N. C., 843; removing sunken vessels or
  craft obstructing or endangering navigation, 845.
EXAMINATION AND SURVEY.-Patuxent River, Md., from Benedict to Hill's Land-
  ing, 846.
                                  APPENDIX L.
        REPORT OF CAPT. WILLIAM H. BIXBY, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENT.-Pamlico and Tar rivers, N. C., 854; Contentnia Creek, N. C., 858;
  Trent River, N. C., 862; Neuse River N. C., 866; Inland water-way between New
  Berne and Beaufort, N. C., 871; Harbor at Beaufort, N. C., 875; Inland water-way
  between Beaufort Harbor and New River, N. C., through Bogue Sound, 882; New
  River N. C., 885; Black River, N. C., 889; Cape Feai River, N. C., 893; Waccemaw
  River, S. C., 912; Yadkin River, N. C., 917; Great Pee Dee River, S. C., 920; Harbor
  at Georgetown, S. C., 925; Winyaw Bay, S. C., 929; Santee River, S. C., 933;
  Wateree River, S. C., 939; Congaree River, S. C., 943.
EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS.-Yadkin River, N. C., from the South Carolina line to
    the Narrows, N. C., 948; Catawba River, N. C., 958.

                                  APPENDIX M.
REPORT OF FIRST. LIEUT. FREDERIC V. ABBOT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Charleston Harbor, S. C., 970; Wappoo Cut, S. C., 980; Ashley
  River, S. C., 983; Edisto River, S. C., 985; Salkiehatchie River, S. C., 987; remov-
  ing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navigation, 990.
EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYs.-North fork of the Edisto River, S. C., in the counties
  of Orangeburgh and Lexington, 991; Mosquito Creek, between the South Edisto
  and Ashepoo rivers, with a view to connect the South Edisto with the Ashepoo at
  or near Fenwick's Island, S. C., 997.
                                     CONTENTS.                                      xl

                                  APPENDIX N.
    REPORT OF FIRST LIEUT. O. M. CARTER, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Savannah Harbor and River, Ga., 1005; Savannah River, between
  Savannah A~d Augusta, Ga., 1026; Savannah River, above Augusta, Ga., 1030;
  Romley Marsh, Ga., 1033; Altamaha River, Ga., 1035; Doboy Bar, Ga., 1041; Bruns-
  wick Harbor, Ga., 1044; Cumberland Sound, Ga. and Fla., 1050.
EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS.-Savannah River from Cross Tides above Savannah to
  the bar, with a view to obtaining '28 feet of water in the channel, 1056; Jekyl
  Creek, Ga., 1073.
                   *              APPENDIX O.

     REPORT OF CAPT. WILLIAM M. BLACK, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-St. John's River, Fla., 1079;     Volusia Bar, Fla., 1088; Upper St.
  John's River, Fla., 1090; Northwest entiance Key West Harbor, Fla., 1092; Ca-
  loosahatchie River Fla., 1093; Pease River, Fla., 1102; Manatee River, Fla., 1107;
  Tampa Bay, Fla., 1112; Withlacoochee River, Fla., 1114; harbor at Cedar Keys,
  Fla., 1116; Suwanee River, Fla., 1118; removing sunken vessels or craft obstruct-
  ing or endangering navigation, 1122.
EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS.-Saint Augustine, Fla., for a deep-sea channel on the
  outer bar, 1123; Punta Rassa Harbor, Fla., 1154.

                                  APPENDIX P.

          REPORT OF CAPT. R. L. HOXIE, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Apalachicola River, Fla., 1159; Apalachicola Bay, Fla., 1160; La
  Grange Bayou, Fla., 1162; Pensacola Iarbor, Fla., 1163; Choctawhatchee River,
  Fla. and Ala., 1166; Escambia and Conecuh rivers, Fla. and Ala., 1169; Oconee
  River, Ga., 1170; Ocmulgee River, Ga., 1173; Oostenaula and Coosawattee rivers,
  Ga., 1175; Flint River, Ga., 1175; Coosa River, Ga. and Ala., 1178; Chattahoochee
  River, Ga. and Ala., 1181; Tallapoosa River, Ala., 1184; Cahawba River, Ala.,
  1185; Alabama River, Ala., 1187; removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or
  endangering navigation, 1189; resurvey of outer and inner bars at Pensacola,
  Fla., 1191.
                                 APPENDIX Q.
        REPORT OF MAJ. A. N. DAMRELL, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Mobile Harbor, Ala., 1193; Black Warrior River, from Tuscaloosa
  to Daniel's Creek, Ala., 1198; Warrior River, Ala., 1200; Tombigbee River, from
  Fulton to Vienna, 1204; Tombigbee River, below Vienna, 1206; Noxubee River,
  Miss., 1208; Pascagoula River, Miss., 1210; Harborat Biloxi Bay, Miss., 1214; Pearl
  River, Miss., between Edinburgh and Carthage, 1216; Pearl River, Miss., from
  Jackson to Carthage, 1218; Pearl River, Miss., below Jackson, 1221.
EXAMINATION AND SURVEY.-Tombigbee River, to ascertain what improvement is
  necessary to make said river continuously navigable from Vienna, Ala., to Walker's
  Bridge, Miss., 1226i survey of the Warrior River below Tuscaloosa; the Tombig-
  bee River from its mouth up to Vienna, and from Vienna up to Walker Bridge, 1227.

                                 APPENDIX R.
           REPORT OF CAPT. W. L. FISK, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
INSPECTION.-Improvement      at the South Pass of the Mississippi River, 1229.

                                  APPENDIX S.

           REPORT OF CAPT. W. L. FISK, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Tchefuncte Riverand Bogue Falia, La., 1243 ; Tangipahoa River, La.,
  1245; Tickfaw River, La., 1246; Amite River, La., 1247; Bayou La Fourche, La.,
  1248; Bayou Terrebonne, La., 1250; Bayou Black, La., 1251; Bayou Teche, La., 1253;
  connecting Bayou Teche with Grand Lake at Charenton, La., 1253; Bayou Courta-
  bleau, La., 1254; Calcasieu River and Pass, La., 1256; Bayou Pierre, Miss., 1258; Sa-
  bine River, La. and Tex., 1259; Neches River, Tex., 1260; Sabine Pass, Tex., 1261.
XII                                  CONTENTS.

                                 APPENDIX T.

           REPORT OF MAJ. O. H. ERNST, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENT.-Entrance to Galveston Harbor, Tex., 1265; ship-chan nel in Galves-
  ton Bay, Tex., 1279; Trinity River, Tex., 1285; Buffalo Bayou, Tex., 1286 ; mouth of
  Brazos River, Tex., 1291; Pass Cavallo Inlet to Matagorda Bay, Tex., 1301; Aransas
  Pass and Bay, up to Rockport and Corpus Christi, Tex., 1307; harbor at Brazos
  Santiago, Tex., 1320.
                                 APPENDIX U.
      REPORT OF CAPT. JOSEPH H. WILLARD, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMENT.-Red River, La. and Ark., 1331; Cypress Bayou, Tex. and La., 134:1;
  Ouachita and Black Rivers, Ark. and La., 1346; Bayou D'Arboune, La., 1349;
  Bayou Bartholomew, La. and Ark., 1351 ; Bayou Boeuf, La., 1353 ; Tensas River and
  Bayou Macon, La., 1354; Big Black River, Miss., 1356; Yazoo River, Miss., 1359;
  Tchula Lake, Miss., 1361; Yallabusha River, Miss., 1362; Tallahatchee River, Miss.,
  1363; Steele's Bayou, Miss., 1364; Big Sunflower River, Miss., 1365; Big Hatchee
  River, Tenn., 1367; Forked Deer River, Tenn., 1369; water-gauges on the Missis-
  sippi River and its principal tributaries, 1370.

                                  APPENDIX V.

           REPORT OF CAPT. H. S. TABER, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENT.-Red River above Fulton, Ark., 1375; Little Red River, Ark., 1377;
  removing obstructions in Arkansas River, Ark., 1378; Arkansas River, Ark., 1380;
  Petit Jean River, Ark., 1400; Fourche River, Ark., 1402; White River, Ark., 1403;
  Black River, Ark. and Mo., 1413; St. Francis River, Ark., 1414.


                                  PART       III.

                                 APPENDIX W.

          REPORT OF MAJ. A. M. MILLER, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Removing snags and wrecks from the Mississippi and Missouri rivers,
  1419; Mississippi River between the Ohio and Illinois rivers, 1422; Gasconade River,
  Mo., 1448; Osage River, Mo. and Kan., 1450.
EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEY.-Mississippi River, at Rush Island Bend and Ivy Land-
  ing, Ill., 1452; Kaskaskia River, from New Athens to its mouth, 1453.


                                 APPENDIX X.

        REPORT OF CAPT. E. H. RUFFNER, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENT.-Mississippi      River between the Des Moines Rapids and the mouth of
  the Illinois River, 1461.

                                 APPENDIX Y.

   REPORT OF MAJ. ALEXANDER MACKENZIE, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMENTS.-Upper Mississippi River, operations of snag-boats and dredge-boats,
  1471; Misisssippi River from Des Moines Rapids to mouth of the Illinois River,
  1479; Mississippi River from Saint Paul to Des Moines Rapids, 1480; Des Moines
  Rapids, Mississippi River, 1518; operating and care of Des Moines Rapids Canal,
  1521; Dry-dock at Des Moines Rapids Canal, 1527; ice-harbor at Dubuque, Iowa.,
  1529; harbors of refuge on Lake Pepin, at Lake City, Minn., 1529; harbors of
  refuge on Lake Pepin, at Stockholm, Wis., 1532.
                                     CONTENTS.                                    XIII


                                 APPENDIX Z.
      REPORT OF MAJ. CHARLES J. ALLEN, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROvEMENTS.-Preservation of the Falls of St. Anthony, Minn., 1536; Construction
  of lock and dam on the Mississippi River at Meeker's Island, Minn., 1536; Missis-
  sippi River above the Falls of St. Anthony, Minn., 1537; reservoirs at headwaters
  of the Mississippi River, 1539; Chippewa River, includingYellow Banks, Wis., 1542;
  St. Croix River, Wis. and Minn., 1547; Minnesota River, Minn., 1551; Red River ofthe
  North, Minn. and Dak., 1552; construction of lock and dam at Goose Rapids, Red
  River of the North, Minn. and Dak., 1555; survey for reservoirs at the sources of
  the Mississippi, St. Croix, Chippewa, and Wisconsin rivers, 1555; Missouri River from
  Sioux City, Iowa, to Fort Benton, Mont., 1556 ; Yellowstone River, Mont. and Dak.,
  1559.
EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS.-Mississippi River between Saint Paul and St. An-
  thony's Falls, Minn., 1560; Minnesota River, with a view to its improvement by
  locks and darns, 1571; Red River of the North, Minn., from Moorhead to Fergus
  Falls, 1584.

                               APPENDIX A A.
    REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. J. W. BARLOW, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMENTS.-Tennessee River, 1591; French Broad River, Tenn., 1602; Little
  Tennessee River, Tenn., 1604; Hiawassee River, Tenn., 1605; Clinch River, Tenn.,
  1606; Duck River, Tenn., 1610; Cumberland River, Tenn. and Ky., 1611; South
  Fork of Cumberland River, Ky., 1633; Caney Fork River, Tenn., 1634.
EXAMINATION AND SURVEY.-Obeil's [Obey's] River from the point where improve-
  ments have heretofore been made to the mouth of the West Fork, Tenn., 1636;
  Bear Creek, Miss. and Ala. [Big Bear Creek, Miss. and Ala.], 1639.

                                 APPENDIX B B.
REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. WILLIAM E. MERRILL, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMENTS.-Ohio River, 1644; operating and care of Davis Island Dam, Ohic
  River, 1670; Monongahela River, W. Va. and Pa., 1676; operating and care of
  lock and dam No. 9, Monongahela River, 1P8; Allegheny River, Pa., 1680; lock
  and dam at Herr's Island, Allegheny River, 1682; ice-harbor at month of Mus-
  kingum River, Ohio, 1683; operating and care of the locks and dams on the Mus-
  kingum River, Ohio, 1684.
EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS.-Ohio River, near the city of Evansville, Ind., to de-
  termine what, if anything, will be necessary to prevent a change of the channel
  of the river in front of that city, 1715; Big Hockhocking River, Ohio, from its
  mouth to Coolville, 1719.

                                APPENDIX C C.
        REPORT OF MAJ. AMOS STICKNEY, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Falls of the Ohio and enlargement of Louisville and Portland
  Canal, Louisville, Ky., 1723; Indiana Chute, Falls of the Ohio River, 1727; operat-
  ing and care of the Louisville and Portland Canal, 1728; Wabash River, Ind. and
  Ill., 1738; White River, Ind., 1745; Tradewater River, Ky., 1747.

                                APPENDIX D D.
    REPORT OF COL. WILLIAM P. CRAIGHILL, CORP OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENT.-Great Kanawha River, W. Va., 1749; operating and care of locks
  and dams on the Great Kanawha River, W. Va., 1756; harbor of refuge at mouth
  of Great Kanawha River, W. Va., 1759; Elk River, W. Va., 1760; New River, Va.
  and W. Va., 1760.
EXAMINATION.-Gauley River and Meadow River, W. Va., 1761.
XIV                                 CONTENTS.


                              APPENDIX E            E.

       REPORT OF CAPT. D. W. LOCKWOOD, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Kentucky River, Ky., 1770; operating and keeping in repair locks
  and dams on the Kentucky River, Ky., 1775; Big Sandy River, W. Va. and Ky.,
  1786; Guyandotte River, W. Va., 1791; Little Kanawha River, W. Va., 1792;
  Buckhannon River, W. Va., 1794.
EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS.-Louisa [Levisa] Fork of Sandy River, Va., 1795;
  Salt River, Ky., 1798.
                                APPENDIX F F.
        REPORT OF CAPT. JAMES B. QUINN, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMENTS.-Harbor at Duluth, Minn., 1803; harbor at Superior Bay and St.
  Louis Bay, Wis., 1809; harbor at Agate Bay, Minn., 1812; harbor at Grand Marais,
  Minn., 1814.
                               APPENDIX G G.
   REPORT OF MAJ. CHARLES E. L. B. DAVIS, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Ashland Harbor, Wis., 1817; Ontanagon Harbor, Mich., 1819;
  Eagle Harbor, Mich., 1821; establishment and maintenance of harbor-lines in Port-
  age Lake, Mich., 1822; Marquette Harbor, Mich., 1831; harbor of refuge, Grand
  Marais, Mich., 1832; Manistique Harbor, Mich., 1835; Cedar River Harbor, Mich.,
  1835; Menomonee Harbor, Mich. and Wis., 1837; Oconto Harbor, Wis., 1839; Pen-
  saukee Harbor, Wis., 1841; Green Bay Harbor, Wis., 1842; harbor of refuge at en-
  trance of Sturgeon Bay Canal, Wis., 1844; Ahnapee Harbor, Wis., 1846; Kewaunee
  Harbor, Wis., 1848; Two Rivers Harbor, Wis., 1850; Manitowoc Harbor, Wis.,
  1851; Sheboygan Harbor, Wis., 1853; Port Washington Harbor, Wis., 1856.

                               APPENDIX H H.
       REPORT OF CAPT. WV. L. MARSHALL, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Harbor of refuge, Milwaukee Bay, Wis., 1859; Milwaukee Har-
  bor, Wis., 1862; Racine Harbor, Wis., 1865; Kenosha Harbor, Wis., 1866; Wauke-
  gan Harbor, Ill., 1867; Fox and Wisconsin rivers, Wis., 1869; operating and care of
  locks and dams on the Fox and Wisconsin rivers, Wis., 1878; Chicago Harbor, Ill.,
  1886; Calumet Harbor, Ill., 1888; Illinois River, Ill., 1889; Calumet River, Ill. and
  Ind., 1896; surveys for Hennepin Canal, 1898.

                                APPENDIX I I.
       REPORT OF MAJ. S. M. MANSFIELD, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Charlevoix Harbor and entrance to Pine Lake, Mich., 1899; Frank-
  ford Harbor, Mich., 1901; harbor of refuge at Portage Lake, Mich., 1903; Man-
  istee Harbor, Mich., 1904; Ludington Harbor, Mich., 1905; Pentwater Harbor,
  Mich.,1907 ; White River Harbor, Mich.,1908; Muskegon Harbor, Mich.,1910; Grand
  Haven Harbor, Mich., 1911; Black Lake Harbor, Mich., 1913; Saugatuck Harbor,
  Mich., 1914 ; South Haven Harbor, Mich., 1916; Saint Joseph Harbor, Mich., 1917
  Michigan City Harbor, Ind., 1919.

                               APPENDIX J J.
      REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. O. M. POE, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPRONEMENTS.-St. Mary's Falls Canal and River, Mich., 1924; operating and care
  of St. Mary's Falls Canal, Mich., 197; Dry-dock at St. Mary's Falls Canal, Mich.,
  1953; Hay Lake Channel, St. Mary's River, Mich., 1954; harbor at Sheboygan,
  Mich., 1958; harbor at Thunder Bay, Mich., 1961 ; harbor at Au Sable, Mich., 1962;
  Saginaw River, Mich., 1963; harbor of refuge at Sand Beach, Lake Huron, Mich.,
  1968; steam-launch or tug for harbor of refuge at Sand Beach, Lake Huron, Mich.,
  1972; ice-harbor of refuge at Belle River, Mich., 1972; Clinton River, Mich., 1973;
  St. Clair Flats Canal, Mich., 1975; operating and care of St. Clair Flats Canal,
  Mich., 1976; Grosse Point Channel, Mich., 1978; Detroit River, Mich., 1978.
                                    CONTENTS.                                     XV


                               APPENDIX K K.
     REPORT OF MAJ. L. COOPER OVERMAN, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Monroe Harbor, Mich., 1981; Toledo Harbor, Ohio, 1983; Port Clin-
  ton Harbor, Ohio, 1986 ; Sandusky City Harbor, Ohio, 1988; Sandusky River, Ohio,
  1996; Huron Harbor, Ohio, 1997; Vermillion Harbor, Ohio, 1998; Black River
  Harbor, Ohio, 1999; Rocky River, Ohio, 2001; Cleveland Harbor, Ohio, 2001; Fair-
  port Harbor, Ohio, 2011; Ashtabula Harbor, Ohio, 2013; Conneaut Harbor, Ohio,
  2015.
                                APPENDIX L L.

    REPORT OF CAPT. FREDERICK A. MAHAN, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Erie Harbor, Pa., 2017; Dunkirk Harbor, N. Y., 2024; Buffalo
  Harbor, N. Y., 2028; Niagara River, N. Y., 2056; Wilson Harbor, N. Y., 2057; Olcott
  Harbor, N. Y., 2059; Oak Orchard Harbor, N. Y., 2062.
EXAMINATION AND SURVEY.-Tonawanda Harbor and Niagara River, N. Y., between
  Black Rock and Tonawanda, with a view to a 16-foot channel, 2064.

                               APPENDIX M M.

      REPORT OF CAPT. CARL F. PALFREY, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENT.-Charlotte      Harbor, N. Y., 2069; Pultneyville, N. Y., 2073; Great
  Sodus Harbor, N. Y., 2075; Little Sodus Harbor, N. Y., 2079; Oswego Harbor, N.
  Y., 2082; Sackett's Harbor, N. Y., 2086.

                               APPENDIX N N.

      REPORT OF MAJ. MILTON B. ADAMS, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Ogdensburgh Harbor, N. Y., 2089; Grass River (at Massena), N. Y.,
  2092; breakwater at Rouse's Point, Lake Champlain, N. Y., 2093; Swanton Har-
  bor, Vt., 2094; breakwater at Gordon's Landing, Lake Champlain, Vt., 2095; Platts-
  burgh Harbor, N. Y., 2097; Burlington Harbor,Vt., 2098; Otter Creek, Vt., 2100;
  Ticonderoga River, N. Y., 2101; Narrows at Lake Champlain, N. Y. and Vt., 2102.

                               APPENDIX 0 0.
        REPORT OF COL. G. H. MENDELL, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Oakland Harbor, Cal., 2105 ; Redwood Harbor, Cal., 2108; survey of
  San Francisco Harbor, San Pablo and Suisun bays, Straits of Carquinez, and
  mouths of Sacramento and San Joaquin rivers, Cal., 2108.

                               APPENDIX P P.

     REPORT OF MAJ. W. H. H. BENYAURD, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Wilmington Harbor, Cal., 2111; San Diego Harbor, Cal., 2114.
EXAMINATION AND SURVEY.-Entrance and outer bar at San Diego, Cal., 2114;
  Newport Harbor, Cal., 2118; San Pedro Bay, Cal., 2122.

                               APPENDIX Q Q.

     REPORT OF MAJ. WILLIAM H. HElUER, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

IMPROVEMENTS.-San      Joaquin River, Stockton and Mormon sloughs,        Cal., 2129;
  Mokelumue River, Cal., 2131; Sacramento and Feather rivers, Cal., 2132; Peta-
  luma Creek, Cal., 2133; Humboldt Harbor and Bay, Cal., 2135.
XVI                                   CONTENTS.

                                APPENDIX R 1I.
        REPORT OF CAPT. WILLARD YOUNG, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Mouth of Coquille River, Oregon, 2137; entrance to Coos Bay, Ore-
  gon, 2141; Umpqua River, Oregon, 2144; entrance to Yaquina Bay, Oregon, 2146.
EXAMINATION AND SURVEY.-Tillamook Bay and Bar, Oregon, 2150.


                                APPENDIX S S.
      REPORT OF MAJ. THOMAS H. HANDBURY, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Mouth of the Columbia River, Oregon and Wash., 2155; construc-
  tion of canal at the Cascades, Columbia River, Oregon, 2161; Chehalis River, Wash.,
  2174; Skagit, Steilaquamish, Nootsack, Snohomish, and Snoqualmie rivers, Wash.,
  2176; gauging waters of the Columbia River, Oregon, 2177.
EXAMINATIONS.-Wood River, Oregon, 2177; Link River, Oregon, 2179.


                                APPENDIX T T.

       REPORT OF MAJ. WILLIAM A. JONES, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENT.-Columbia and Lower Willamette Rivers, below Portland, Oregon,
  2185; Upper Willamette River, Oregon, 2187; Upper Columbia and Snake Rivers,
  Oregon and. Wash., 2188; Lower Clearwater River, Idaho, 2189; Cowlitz River,
  Wash., 2190.


                                  PART IV.

                               APPENDIX U U.
             REPORTS OF THE MISSISSIPPI RIVER COMMISSION.

  Q. A. GIILMORE, Colonel of Engineers, Bvt. Maj. Gen. U. S. A. (president until his
death, April 7, 1888),
  C. B. COMSTOCK, Lieut. Col. of Engineers, Bvt. Brig. Gen. U. S. A. (president from
April 10, 1888),
  CHARLES R. SUTER, Lieut. Col. of Engineers, U. S. A.,
  O. H. ERNST, Major of Engineers, U. S. A. (from May 15, 1888),
  Mr. HENRY MITCHELL, U. S. Coast and Geodetic Survey,
  Mr. B. M. HARROD, Civil Engineer,
  Mr. S. W. FERGUSON, Civil Engineer,
Mr. ROBERT S.     TAYLOR,
                     Commissioners.

REPORT OF OPERATIONS FROM JULY 1 TO NOVEMBER 1,               1887-

Surveys, construction, 2191; first district, second district, 2192; third district, 2193;
  fourth district, money statement, 2194; operations in the first district, 2195; oper-
  ations in the second district, 2203.

ANNUAL REPORT FOR THE FISCAL YEAR-
Survey and examinations, 2214; Construction-General service, first district, 2214;
second district, third district, 2215; fourth district, 2217; remarks, 2218; list of ap-
pendices, list of plates, 2219; effect of overflow on velocity and flood height, 2220;
elevations and descriptions of secondary triangulation stations, Cairo to Donald-
sonville, 2232; geographical positions of tertiary points, Keokuk to Cairo, 2244;
High-water marks of 1888, 2250; low-water gauge-readings, 1887-'88, 2251; table of
low-water soundings on bars, 1886-'87, 2251; report of committee on construction,
2252; operations in the first district, 2262; operations in the second district, 2270 ;
operations in the third district, 2276; operations in the fourth district, 2294.
                                      CONTENTS.                                      XVII

                                 APPENDIX V V.

              REPORT OF THE MISSOURI RIVER COMMISSION.

  CHARLES R. SUTER, Lieut. Col. of Engineers, U. S. A., president,
  ALEX. MACKENZIE, Major of Engineers, U. S. A.,
  O. H. ERNsT, Major of Engineers, U. S. A.,
  Mr. G. C. BROADHEAD,
  Mr. WM. J. BROATCH,
                    Commissioners.
Surveys, construction, 2313; plant, surveys at special localities, recommendations,
" 2314; money statement, 2315; report of the secretary, '2317; report of the secretary
  on precise leveling, 2327; description of elevations and bench-marks, 2328; phys-
  ical data, 2355; report of the president, 2356; reports of operations by assistant
  engineers, 2357, 2359.

                                APPENDIX W W.
         BRIDGING NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THE UNITED STATES.
Report of the Board of Engineers relative to the construction of certain bridges
across the Missouri, Mississippi, and Illinois rivers, 2371: bridge across Staten Isl-
and Sound, known as Arthur Kill, 2421; report of Board of Engineers on Senate
bill No. 1850, Fiftieth Congress, first session, to authorize the construction of a bridge
across the waters of Arthur Kill at or near the town of Westfield, Staten Island,
2430, highway bridge across that part of the waters of Lake Champlain lying be-
tween the towns of North Hero and Alburgh, Vt., 2431; bridge of the Kansas City,
Topeka and Western Railroad Company across Missouri River at Sibley, Mo., 2434;
bridge of the Chicago, Saint Louis and New Orleans Railroad Company across the
Ohio River at East Cairo, Ky., 2436; free wagon bridge across the Cumberland
River near the city of Nashville, Tenn., 2438; bridge of the Ohio River Railroad
Company across Great Kanawha River, near Point Pleasant, W. Va., 2444; bridge
across the west channel of the Detroit River, to connect Belle Island Park with the
mainland, 2450; international bridge of the Sault Sainte Marie Bridge Company
across Sainte Marie River, 2456; bridge of the Nebraska Railway Company across
Missouri River at Nebraska City, 2464; combined railway and wagon bridge of the
Omaha and Council Bluffs Railway and Bridge Company across Missouri River
between Omaha, Nebr., and Council Bluffs, Iowa, 246i; bridge of the New York
and Long Island Bridge Company across the East River between the city of
New York and Long Island, 2470; bridge of the Ohio Valley Railway Com-
pany across the Tradewater River, Ky., 2472; bridge of the Sioux City Bridge
Company across the Missouri River at Sioux City, Iowa, 2474; highway bridge
of the Central Railway and Bridge Company of Newport, Ky., across the Ohio
River, between Cincinnati, Ohio, and Newport, Ky., 2480; bridges of the.Geor-
gia Pacific Railroad Company across the Sunflower and Yazoo rivers, 2485; high
bridge across the Mississippi River at Dubuque, Iowa, 2492; bridge of the Ohio
Connecting Railway Company across the Ohio River, near the mouth of Cork's
Run, in Allegheny County, Pa., 2497; bridge of the Georgia Pacific Railway Com-
pany across the Tombigbee River at Waverly, Miss., 2507; bridge of the Memphis
and Charleston Railroad Company across the Tennessee River at Chattanooga,
Tenn., 2510; bridge of the Kansas City and Memphis Railway and Bridge Company
across the Mississippi River at Memphis, Tenn., 2514; reports respecting interfer-
ences with navigation by bridges, causeways, and other structures, 2525.

                                 APPENDIX X             X.

OCCUPANCY AND INJURY TO PUBLIC WORKS BY CORPORATIONS AND
                     INDIVIDUALS, 2687.

                                 APPENDIX Y Y.

         REPORT OF MAJ. G. J. LYDECKER, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
IMPROVEMENTS.-Washington Aqueduct, 2749; increasing the water supply of the
  city of Washington, D. C., 2755; erection of fish-ways at the Great Falls of the
  Potomac, 2766.
        ENG 88----II
XVIII                                             CONTENTS.


                                         APPENDIX Z Z.
                 REPORT OF COL. JOHN M. WILSON, U. S. ARMY.
Improvement and care of public buildings and grounds in the District of Columbia,
  2769; underground wires for telegraph and telephone service to connect the sev-
  eral Departments and Bureaus of the Government in Washington City, 2794;
  Washington Monument, 2799.


                                      APPENDIX A A A.

         REPORT OF MAJ. CHARLES J. ALLEN, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
CONSTRUCTION and improvement of roads and bridges in the Yellowstone Na-
  tional Park......... .....-- ................. .............. .................. 2803


                                       APPENDIX B B B.

                   THE NORTHERN AND NORTHWESTERN LAKES.
ANNUAL WATER LEVELS. .............................                                      ............            ..........            2807

REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. O.              M. POE,            CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
Issue of published charts ....           .............          .... .....      ..           ..................-......                2810


                                       APPENDIX CC C.

    EXPLORATIONS AND SURVEYS IN DIVISIONS AND DEPARTMENTS.
REPORT OF CAPT. WILLIAM L.                 MARSHALL,          CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
  Engineer operations in the Division of the Missourri ........................                                                       2813

REPORT OF LIEUT. WILLIAM C.                   LANGFITT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
  Engineer operations in the Department of the Columbia                                   ---------.....
                                                                                                     .                         .      2816

REPORT OF LIEUT. JAMES E. RUNCIE, FIRST ARTILLERY, ACTING ENGINEER OFFICER.
  Engineer operations in the Division of the Pacific                         ...... ...........                    ......-..          2817

REPOR'     OF LIEUT. H.        M.   CHITTENDEN,             CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
  Engineer operations in the Department of the Platte                            ....         ...............                  ....   2818

LAWS AFFECTING THE CORPS OF ENGINEERS, FIFTIETH CONGRESS, FIRST SES-
  SION, 1887-'18 ....... ............ .... ................ .....................                                                     2821
[EXTRACT FROM THE ANNUAL REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF WAR.]

                                             WAR DEPARTMENT,
                                  Washington City, November 30, 1888.


                          ENGINEER    BUREAU.

   The attention of Congress is again invited to the defenseless condi-
tion of. our sea-coast and lake frontiers. The last appropriation for the
permanent defenses of the country was made in 1875, and has long
since been exhausted. The importance of immediate and liberal action
looking to the effective defense of our principal sea-ports has been fully
set forth in previous reports, especially in that of November 30, 1886.
It would appear now more important than ever that such action should
be taken at the second session of the present Congress in view of the
fact that the last session gave appropriations for the construction of
heavy ordnance. Without heavy platforms, s.trong armored protection,
and other permanent emplacements, these guns and mortars when fin-
ished will be of comparatively little use.
   The building of modern gun and mortar batteries requires longer
periods of time than the construction of the armament. It would ap-
pear the part of wisdom that the preparation of these two important
components of a well equipped defense should prdceed simultaneously.
For the beginning of the construction of such defenses an appropria-
tion of $2,840,000 is asked for.
   For the preservation and repair of the existing works, many of which
are still of great value for secondary defense or as important parts of
the contemplated new primary defense, no funds have been available
since the appropriation of March 3, 1885. The consequent rapid and
extensive deterioration is fully set forth in the report of the Chief of
Engineers. For the preservation and repair of existing works $200,000
is requested.
   Torpedoes and submarine mines are now acknowledged by all nations
to be absolutely necessary to the efficient defense of harbors and sea-
ports. For the purchase of these, and the necessary appliances for
operating them, for experimenting to ascertain the best of the many
torpedo inventions, and for the continuing of the construction of the
necessary casemates, cable galleries, etc., for working the submarine
                                                                 XIX
      ENG 88--III
XX    EXTRACT FROM ANNUAL REPORT OF SECRETARY OF WAR.

mine and torpedo systems, $1,890,000 is recommended. A torpedo-
shed for the storage of torpedo material for use in San Francisco Har-
bor, to cost about $22,000, should also be constructed.
   The Engineer School of Application at Willets Point has continued
its good work under many disadvantageous circumstances. General
practical instruction to the younger engineer officers has been given,
and several artillery officers have taken a special course in torpedo serv-
ice. Attention is invited to the report of the Chief of Engineers on
the subject of the post of Willets Point and the engineer depot and
Engineer Battalion.
   For the incidental expenses of the depot, for purchase and repair of
instruments, the purchase of material for instruction, for the library,
and for a model room, $20,000 is requested.
   Rivers and harbors.-The river and harbor act passed during the
second session of the Forty-ninth Congress failing to become a law, the
works for the improvement of rivers and harbors have been prosecuted
during the last fiscal year with funds derived from balances remainining
on hand from the appropriations of the act of August 5, 1886, together
with such few remnants of former appropriations as were available. In
many instances, these being barely sufficient to provide for the care of
the public property pertaining to the works, operations were necessarily
suspended, to the great detriment of the improvements concerned. The
report of the Chief of Engineers sets forth the condition of each im-
provement, the extent of the work performed during the past fiscal year,
and the amount of money expended. In compliance with the provisions
of the river and harbor act of March 2, 1867, estimates are presented of
the amount that can be profitably expended during the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1890, together with the probable cost of completion.
   Such of the reports of examinations and surveys for improvements
at places required acld provided for in the river and harbor act of Au-
gust 5, 1886, as were not inserted in the annual report of the Chief of
Engineers for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, were separately
transmitted to Congress during the present session as received.
   A statement is given in the report of the Chief of Engineers of the
action taken during the past fiscal year upon plans and locations of
bridges proposed to be built over navigable waters under authority of
Congress and subject to the approval of the Secretary of War. Ex-
aminations were also made, whenever requested by committees of Con-
gress, of proposed bills authorizing the construction of bridges upon
which the views of the War Department were desired. A statement
is also given of the work accomplished in the removal of wrecks ob
structing or endangering navigation, for which provision is made in the
river and harbor act of June 14, 1880, and enlarged by the river and
harbor act of August 2, 1882.
  Under section 4 of the river and harbor act of August 4, 1886, which
requires the Secretary of War to report to Congress whether any
      EXTRACT FROM ANNUAL REPORT OF SECRETARY OF WAR.                 XXI

bridges, causeways, or structures now erected, or in process of erection,
do or will interfere with free and safe navigation, and if so, to report
the best mode of altering or constructing the same; and which also re-
quires a report to be made to Congress of all cases in which piers,
breakwaters, locks, and dams, or other structures or works built or
made by the United States in aid of commerce or navigation are
used, occupied, or injured by a corporation or individual, and the
extent and mode of such use, occupation, or injury, the Chief of
Engineers was directed to report thereon as required by the act. A
communication enumerating all instances of interference with free and
safe navigation, not previously reported to Congress, was transmitted
to the House of Representatives December 10, 1887, and on January
3, 1888, enumerating in like manner instances of the use or the occu-
pancy of, or injury to, public works.
   Improvement of South Pass, Mississippi River.-The record of this
work, in last annual report of the Department, was brought down
to September 29, 1887. Since that date the channel has been main-
tained, as required by law, for the full period of one year, to Septem.
ber 29, 1888, for which payments have been made amounting to $100,000.
There has also been paid $50,000 for one year's interest on the
$1,000,000 retained, making the total expenditures to September 29,
1888, inclusive, $5,600,000.
   During the year mentioned there has been no failure ii the mainte-
nance of the channel.
   Under the provisions of the act of March 3, 1875, and an.endatory
acts, one-half of the $1,000,000 remaining as security in the possession
of the United States is to be released and paid to James B. Eads, his
assigns or legal representatives, when the prescribed channel shall have
been maintained for ten years, and as such period of maintenance will
in all probability expire during the fiscal year 1890, an estimate for an
appropriation of $500,000 has accordingly been submitted for the action
of Congress. Should the appropriation not be made then, under the
provisions of the act of March 3, 1875, the Secretary of the Treasury is
directed to issue the bonds of the United States, bearing five per cent.
interest, to said Eads or his legal representatives, in payment at par
of the warrant issued by the Secretary of War, as directed in the same
act.
    Water supply of Washington, D. 0.- The work of lining the tunnel
with masonry had advanced September 1, 1888, in its total length to
13,080 feet, and there remained to be lined at that date 7,616 feet. The
tunnel work was stopped on September 30, 1887, when the appropria-
tion became exhausted. The deficiency act, approved March 30, 1888,
appropriated the sum of $355,000 to complete the tunnel.           )n the
reservoirs the work under contract was completed in October, 1887.
The construction of the influent and effluent gate-houses, necessary be-
fore water can be let in, has been begun.
XXII   EXTRACT FROM ANNUAL REPORT OF SECRETARY OF WAR.

   The Potomac Flats.-In execution of the plan projected for this im-
provement, there has been dredged a channel from 350 to 550 feet wide
and 20 feet deep, between Georgetown and Giesboro Point. The Wash-
ington channel has been dredged to a width of 350 feet and 20 feet deep,
all the material being deposited on the flats, and up to the present time
about 544 acres have been reclaimed from the overflow of ordinary high
tide. Of the 12,000,000 cubic yards required to raise the flats to the pro-
posed height of 3 feet above the highest freshets, about 6,511,000 have
been deposited. On June 30, 1888, the expenditure for this improve-
ment amounted to $1,247,495, less than half the estimated cost of the
whole work.
   A communication was transmitted to the House of Representatives
February 18, 1888, calling attention to the probability of damage to this
improvement, as well as to the water front of the city, from ice gorges
and freshets and to the necessity of rebuilding, without delay, the
Long Bridge, with wide spans and open piers, offering the least resist-
ance to the flow of water in order to avert such damage. The right to
repeal or annul the act of June 21, 1870, permitting the Baltimore and
Potomac Railroad to use this bridge was reserved to Congress.
   Attention is called to the report upon the construction of roads and
bridges in the Yellowstone National Park, and to the necessity of
further appropriation for this purpose. The number of visitors in-
creases yearly, and in order that the Park may be fully maintained for
the purpose for which Congress intended it, its various objects of in-
terest should be made readily accessible. Owing to the lateness of the
session at which appropriations are frequently made by Congress, the
season when expenditures can be made here to the best advantage is
lost for the fiscal year. It is therefore recommended, in order that
work may be done at the most favorable time of the year, that appro-
priations for this object be made without limit, as is the case with the
items of the river and harbor acts.
   The small appropriation stated in the estimates for surveys required
for military purposes, for the publication of maps, including lake charts
and local surveys, and for additions to the engraved plates for the use
of the War Department, is earnestly recommended.

                 BRIDGES OVER NAVIGABLE WATERS.

  Attention is called to a recommendation in my report of 1885, and
repeated in the reports of 1886 and 1887, that action is required on the
part of Congress in the case of navigable streams within the limits of a
State. Until Congress assumes control of such subject the power of a
State over bridges across navigable streams within its limits is plenary.
  The Attorney-General has decided that section 8 of the River and
Harbor act of 1884 does not prevent the erection of bridges that obstruct
such streams; and the ninth and tenth sections of the River and Harbor
act of 1888 seem only to authorize the bringing of suits and a punish.
   EXTRACT FROM ANNUAL REPORT OF SECRETARY OF WAR.               XXIII

ment by fine for obstruction. There are some cases where a railroad
company could afford to pay the fine of $500 per month rather than
make a proper bridge.
  It is therefore suggested that some action should be taken by Con-
gress to enforce the rights of the United States in navigable streams
within the limits of a State, and thus give effect to the duty resting
upon the Government to protect navigation thereon.

      EN(   88---IV
              ANNUAL REPORT

                    OF TIHE




CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,
        UNITED     STATES     ARMY.




                 1888.


ENG 88---1
                                                 REPORT
                                                        OF



      THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,
                                  UNITED            STATES             ARMY.




                               OFFICE OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,
                                                UNITED STATES ARMY,
                                   Washington, D. C., October 1, 1888.
  SIR: I have the honor to present for your information the following
report upon the duties and operations of the Engineer Department for
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888:

             OFFICERS               OF      THE        CORPS           OF           ENGINEERS.

   The number of officers holding commissions in the Corps of Engineers,
United States Army, at the end of the fiscal year was 107.
   Since the last annual report the Corps has lost by retirement, death,
and resignation five of its officers: Brig..Gen. James C. Duane, who
was retired June 30, 1888, under the provisions of section 1 of the act
of Congress approved June 30, 182; Col. Quincy A. Gillmore, who died
at Brooklyn, N. Y., April 7, 1888; Capt. George M. Wheeler, who was
retired June 15, 1888, in conformity with section 1251 Revised Statutes;
Capt. Albert H. Payson, who resigned December 1, 1887; and Lieut.
Oscar T. Crosby, who resigned October 22, 1887.
   There have been added to the Corps three second lieutenants: two
by promotion of graduates from the Military Academy, and one by
transfer from the line. Three additional second lieutenants were ap-
pointed from the Military Academy to date from June 11, 1888, but
they did not become available for duty until after the close of the fiscal
year, and are therefore not included in the strength of the Corps.
   On the 30th of June, 1888, the officers were distributed as follows:
Office Chief of Engineers....................                      ............................                  4
Fortifications and river and harbor works...... ........                        .          ......
                                                                                         .....      ........    20
Fortifications, river and harbor works, Board of Engineers,.and Board of Visitors..                              2
Fortifications, river and harbor works, Board of Engineers, and supervising en-
  gineer ...............................              ... .. ..             ------...
                                                                                    ..........     ....... ..    1
Fortifications, Board of Engineers, post of Willets Point, Engineer School of Ap-
  plication, and Battalion of Engineers.... ........................                           ...........
Fortifications, river and harbor works, and light-house duty ...................                                 2
Fortifications, river and harbor works, and supervising engineer...............                                  1
River and harbor works ........           ............-      -............................                      22
River and harbor works and light-house duty ..................................                                   4
River and harbor works and engineer officer, military division..................                                 1
River and harbor works, Mississippi River Commission, and Missouri .iver Com-
    mission .............................             .. ............. .......................                   1
4             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

River and harbor works and Missouri River Commission ...............----.......                                                          1
Mississippi River Commission, Missouri River Commission, and light-house duty                                                            1
Board of Engineers, Board of Visitors, and Light-House Board... ..                                                 .........             1
Board of Engineers and Board of Visitors ....-......-......-..................                                                           1
Bpard of Engineers, Board of Visitors, and Mississippi River Commission ......                                                           1
Public buildings and grounds ....          _............ ..........----..--...............                                               1
Washington Aqueduct ......---.......----.----------      ---  ---- ------------------...........----                                     2
Battalion of Engineers and Engineer School of Application ...................                                                           12
Under      orders     .............--........--                            -----    ------    ------    ------     --........            2
Leave of absence ..........-------   ------ -- ---------- ----- ---- ---- ---..........-- 6
Detached, on duty as engineer officers of military departments, with Light-House
  Establishment, at Military Academy, with Board of Commissioners of the Dis-
  trict of Columbia, with the Mississippi and Missouri River Commissions, and
  at U. S. Infantry and Cavalry School---....---------------...----.....-------..-....-----.... 20
                                                                                                                                        107
    The officers detached were on duty as follows:
Col. John G. Parke, Superintendent Military Academy................                                               ..............         1
Maj. David P. Heap, engineer third light-house district ........................                                                         1
Maj. William Ludlow, engineer fourth light-house district ......................                                                         1
Maj. Charles W. Raymond, Engineer Commissioner of the District of Columbia.                                                              1
Maj. William S. Stanton, engineer first and second light-house districts...... ...                                                       1
Maj. James F. Gregory, engineer secretary of the Light-House Board...........                                                            1
Capt. John C. Mallery, engineer fifth and sixth light-house districts.... .........                                                      1
Capt. Charles F. Powell, secretary and disbursing officer of the Mississippi River
  Commission ......--         ..------..........----- ..--------- ---- -----                           -. --------------....             1
Capt. John G. D. Knight, instructor of engineering at the U. S. Infantry and Cav-
  alry School ........----....--------................-----      ---........--- ............---.... ----....------....      .....----     1
Capt. Philip M. Price and Lieut. John Biddle, on duty with Company E, Bat-
  talion of Engineers, and at the Military Academy ...-                                                                  ......          2
Capt. Thomas W. Symons and Lieut. James L. Lusk, assistants to the Engineer
  Commissioner of the District of Columbia--------------------------------..............                                                 2
Lieut. Theodore A. Bingham, secretary and disbursing officer of the Missouri
  River Commission ---..............--------             -- ---- -....-                 --- -....---
                                                                                                ....-----....
                                                                             --....--....---......-     -.. ----..--.......               1
Lieuts. Gustav J. Fiebeger, George W Goethals, and Eugene J. Spencer, on duty
  at the Military Academy -..                               --....... ...........      ----........................                      3
Lieut. John Millis, assistant to engineer, third light-house district ..............                                                     1
Lieut. William C. Langfitt, engineer officer Department of the Columbia .......                                                          1
Lieut. Hiram M. Chittenden, engineer officer Department of the Platte.........                                                           1
                                                                                                                                        20

              SEA.-COAST AND LAKE FRONTIER DEFENSES.

  The act of February 10, 1875, gave the last appropriation for the
construction of permanent defenses. Upon the expenditure of that ap-
propriation all construction work ceased.                                            The wisdom of providing for
the public defense in time of peace, and while the Government is in a
condition of financial prosperity, would appear to be too self-evident to
need further demonstration. The matter has received the earnest at-
tention of my predecessors for years past; their recommendations, as
set forth in their printed annual reports, are exhaustive and are fully
concurred in by me.
  Attention is again invited to the detailed estimates for the construc-
tion of gun and mortar batteries, prepared by The Board of Engineers,
and printed on page 11 of the last annual report. The total is pre-
sented in the estimates herewith, as are also estimates for the construc-
tion of torpedo casemates and galleries, and for the purchase of torpedo
material for the defense of our chief sea-ports.
     The acts of 1876, 1877, 178, 1879, and 1880 appropriated each year
for the protection, preservation, and repair of fortifications and other
works of defense, $100,000; the acts of 1881, 1882, 1883, and 1884 gave
annually $175,000, and the act of 1885, $1005000. This latter was the
                                       THE BOARD                  OF ENGINEERS.                                                     5-




last appropriation, and was practically exhausted by the end of the
fiscal year for which it was appropriated. The estimates of this office
for the fiscal years ending June 30, 1887, 1888, and 1889, were $175,000
each, and the estimate for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, has been
increased by $25,000 to cover additional damage' and deterioration in-
cident to over two years of absolute neglect. The failure to obtain any
appropriations for 1887 necessitated the practical abandonment of all
permanent and other defenses where there were no garrisons, or where
ordnance sergeants could not be detailed to take charge.         Portable
property was secured as well as possible and the fort-keepers dis-
charged.
   Neglect of any structure, however massive or well built, results in
more or less rapid deterioration, and we find to-day everything con-
nected with our permanent defenses, which are dependent upon annual
appropriations for their maintenance and repair, going to rack and ruin;
slopes overgrown with grass and weeds and gullied by the rain; walks
and roads ragged and untrimmed and full of holes and breaks; ditches
and drains filled up or fallen in and pools of stagnant water on the
parades and in the casemates; the sewers in bad order with the conse-
quent evils ; mortar and cement falling from the joints of masonry for
want of repointing; timber gun and ammunition platforms rotten or
decayed, and permanent concrete or masonry platforms settling or out
of plumb, thus preventing the proper service of the guns; casemates
and quarters leaky, unhealthy, and uninhabitable; magazines damp
and useless; revetment walls on water fronts falling down, and waves
making serious and rapid encroachments on valuable ground, thus
impairing eligible sites for future works, and generally about the un-
garrisoned forts an appearance of total abandonment and decay, and
from the commanders of garrisoned forts continued and urgent appeals
to keep the works in proper repair for the comfort and convenience of
the garrison and the efficient use of the armaments.
   Many of these works are still of value, either in themselves directly
for minor defense, or, in connection with new works projected for the
defense of our harbors. The estimate submitted is for the preservation
and repair-of such fortifications as are still of value.

          ESTIMATES               OF APPROPRIATIONS REQUIRED                                       FOR 1889-'90.

For construction of gun and mortar batteries for defense of our chief sea-
  ports .----..- ------...------...... ----....---......--....------------........--.... ........----....--..-...--. -$2,       840, 000
For protection, preservation, and repair of, and preparation of plans for,
  fortifications for which there may be no special appropriation available.                                                     200, 000
For purchase of submarine mines and necessary appliances to operate
  them for closing the channels leading to our principal sea-ports ... -                                               --       300, 000
For needful casemates, cable galleries, etc., to render it possible to oper-
  ate submarine mines ... . ....................-          -..                           ....... .-..........--               1,560, 000
For continuing torpedo experiments and for practical instruction of
  engineer troops in the details of service ......................                                                 ..     --.    30, 000
For torpedo shed at San Francisco Harbor.............................---                                                .        22,000

          Total ........                                                             --- ..
                                   ....----- ..---....----....................... .....-----               ......        4,952,000

                                         THE BOARD OF ENGINEERS.

  The Board of Engineers stationed in New York City consisted of Col.
Thomas Lincoln Casey, Col. Henry L. Abbott, Col. William P. Craig-
hill, Col. Cyrus B. -Comstock, Lieut. Col. David C. Houston, Lieut. Col.
Walter McFarland, Maj. William R. King, and, when so ordered, the
officer in charge of the work under consideration.
       SREPORT   OF THE C1IEEP     OF    NGINEEltS, U. S. A1MY.

   During the fiscal year the Board has considered the questions referred
to it by the Chief of Engineers, and of the reports submitted the follow-
ing is a brief summary:
   1887, July 5. Relative to the cutting down of cribs of the Buffalo
Breakwater to receive masonry superstructure.
   July 11. Improvement of Shrewsbury River, New Jersey.
   July 19. Improvement of Aransas Pass, Texas.
   July 19. On design for a disappearing gun-carriage by Maj. M. B.
Adams, Corps of Engineers.
   August 2. Estimates for appropriations for coast defenses, including
submarine mines, for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.
   October 24. Submarine defenses of New York Harbor.
   November 11. Improvement of Brazos River, Pass Cavallo, and
Brazos Santiago, Texas.
   November 11. Submarine defenses of Boston Harbor.
   December 20. Study for a typical mortar battery.
   1888, January 3. In relation to Senate bill No. 62, Fiftieth Congress,
first session, to provide for fortifications and other sea-coast defenses.
   January 17. Submarine defenses of San Francisco Harbor.
   January 20. In relation to Senate bill No. 1241, Fiftieth Congress,
first session, to prevent obstructive or injurious deposits in New York
Harbor.
   February 10. Deepening of channels in New York Harbor.
   February 11. In relation to Senate bill No. 1448 and House bill No.
4923, Fiftieth Congress, first session, for the establishment of a Bureau
of Harbors and Water-ways.
   March 16. On the paper of Prof. L. M. Haupt, of the University of
Pennsylvania, relative to the physical features at harbor entrances.
   March 16. Improvement of the Arkansas River.
   March 16. Estimates for placing Fort Moultrie in a state of defense.
   April 16. On leasing Government lands at Sandy Hook for hotel
purposes.
   April 25. Same subject.
   May 4. On proposed right of way to the Birmingham, Mobile, and
Navy Cove Harbor Railroad Company across the military reservation
at Fort Morgan, Ala.
   June 15. On design for a disappearing gun-carriage by Maj. M. B.
Adams, Corps of Engineers.
   June 15. Submarine defenses of Hampton Roads.
   In the performance of the duties of the Board, the following personal
examinations by committees were made:
    1887, July 7.. Visit to the forts in New York Harbor in connection
with locations for torpedo casemates.
    1888, May 3. Attendance at the annual examination of officers at the
Engineer Sphool of Application, Willets Point, N. Y.
   June 22. Annual inspection of the Engineer School of Application,
Willets Point, N. Y.
   In addition to their duties with The Board of Engineers the individual
members have been otherwise engaged as follows :
   Col. Thos. Lincoln Casey, the President of the Board, has, as a
member of the Light-House Board under the Treasury Department,
attended the meetings of the Board from time to time in Washington.
He continued in charge of the Washington National Monument until
April 4, 1888, when he was relieved at his own request. He remained
in charge of the construction of the State, War, and Navy Departments
building until May 31, 1888, at which date the accounts and office were
                     THE BOARD      OF ENGINEERS.                       7

closed and his final report rendered to the Secretary of War. He has
also served as a member of the Board of Visitors to the Engineer School
of Application at Willets Point; as a member of Board of Engineer
Officers on bridges across the Arthur Kill, Staten Island, New York;
and upon special boards for the examination of officers of the Corps
of Engineers for promotion.
   Col. Henry L. Abbot has continued in charge of certain experiments
with torpedoes and as a member of the Board of Officers and Civilians
on Coast Defense. He has served as a member of the Board of Visi-
tors to the Engineer School of Application and of special boards for the
examination of officers of the Corps of Engineers for promotion, and on
board to report on plan and location of bridge across the Mississippi
River at Dubuque, Iowa. He examined and reported upon the site of
the new bridge across the Arthur Kill, Staten Island, New York, and
delivered a course of lectures on sea-coast defense at the Naval War
College, Newport, R. I., during the term beginning in September, 1887.
He was assigned to the charge of the office, the river and harbor works,
and the fortifications of the late General Q. A. Gillmore at his decease,
and has supervised the transfer of these works to the several officers
now in charge. This duty is still unfinished.
    Col. William P. Craighill has continued as a member of the Board
since December 24, 1886, for the consideration of such matters of impor-
tance as the Chief of Engineers has designated. In addition to conduct-
ing the works of river and harbor improvement and fortifications with
which he has been charged, he has been supervising engineer of the
districts of Captains Hinman, Bixby, and Black; Lieutenants Abbot
and Carter, United States Corps of Engineers, and Mr. S. T. Abert,
United States agent, and has served on special boards as follows: For
improvement of Cape Fear River, North Carolina; on improvement of
the Potomac River, District of Columbia; on permanent improvement
of Delaware River and Bay ; on construction of the locks and canal at
the Cascades, Columbia River, Oregon; on removal of islands and
shoals in Delaware River between Philadelphia, Pa., and Camden, N.
J., and as a member of joint advisory board to State harbor commis-
sioners of Norfolk, Portsmouth, and Norfolk County, Va.
    Col. C. B. Comstock returned to duty from sick leave of absence De-
cember 5, 1887. He has continued a member of the Mississippi River
Commission, and has been its president since May 10, 1888; he has also
served as a member of the Board of Visitors to the Engineer School of
Application; on boards for improvement of Cape Fear River, and the
Potomac River in the vicinity of Washington; and on board to consider
and report upon removal of islands and shoals in Delaware River be-
tween Philadelphia, Pa., and Camden, N. J.; also a member of board
for examination of officers of the Corps of Engineers for promotion.
    Lieut. Col. D. C. Houston has been the disbursing officer of The Board
of Engineers. He has conducted the various works of river and harbor
improvement and of fortifications under his charge, and has served as a
a member of the Board of Visitors to the Engineer School of Application.
    Lieut. Col. Walter McFarland, in addition to conducting the works
of river and harbor improvement and of fortifications with which he is
charged, has served as a member of the Board of Visitors to the Engi-
neer School of Application and of the Board on Improvement of Dela-
ware River and Bay. He also inspected the works in charge of Majors
Ernst and Damrell and Captains Hoxie, Taber, and Black.
  Major William R. King has commanded the Post, the Engineer School
of Application, the Engineer Depot, and the Battalion of Engineers at
8      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Willets Point, New York. He has had charge of the construction of
Fort Schuyler, of fort and engineer depot at Willet's Point, of tor-
pedoes for harbor defense, and of experiments with torpedoes; also
charge of the construction of officers' quarters, mess, etc., at Willets
Point, and of disbursements for the same. He has served on special board
for examination of officers of the Corps of Engineers for promotion, and
on board of engineer officers on bridges across the Arthur Kill, Staten
Island, New York.
  Sea-coast fortifications.-The Board of Engineers has nothing further
to add to its reports of last year, contained in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1887, respecting the necessity for modern de-
fenses along the sea-board, and the urgency for the emplacement of
high-power guns and rifled mortars in our important harbors, together
with the preparation for the working and establishing of obstructions
by mines in the fairways of approach to the several harbors in ques-
tion.
POST OF WILLETS POINT, NEW YORK-ENGINEER SCHOOL OF APPLI-
     CATION-BATTALION OF ENGINEERS-ENGINEER DEPOT.
                POST OF WILLETS POINT, NEW YORK.

  At the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, the garrison con-
sisted of 20 commissioned officers and 352 enlisted men.
  During the year the Quartermaster's Department completed several
much-needed improvements, such as the supply of water from the flush-
ing works, bath-tubs, water-closets, etc., in barracks and quarters, an
adequate sewerage system, new double set of officers' quarters, and new
hospital; and began the laying of a system of brick side-walks.
  Improvements recommended are: A new set of barracks; new quar-
termaster's and commissary store-house, properly located; to clean out
and deepen the lagoon and ditch between the post and main land; the
reconstruction of the soldiers' laboratory destroyed by fire in Novem-
ber, 1886; and a suitable building to contain the collection of engineer
models.
  The health of the garrison has been satisfactory (but four deaths, two
accidental, in a population of over 600). With recent improvements
and these herein proposed but little future trouble is anticipated.
                       SCHOOL OF APPLICATION.

   During the past year two officers of engineers completed a three
years' course, and three artillery officers a seven months course, and
have been relieved.
   The library of the school has received valuable accessions, and $500
is asked for the next year.
   The officers have visited several large manufacturing establishments
in the vicinity, witnessing mechanical operations, etc., of professional
interest.
   A greater number of artillery officers can be accommodated for
instruction in torpedo service, and it is recommended that officers of
cavalry and infantry, who so desire, be detailed for such instruction
when enough artillery officers are not available.
                      BATTALION    OF ENGINEERS.

  The legal strength is 752 enlisted men in five companies; the author-
ized strength is 450. Companies A, B, and C are stationed at Willets
                          POST OF WILLETS POINT,                                     ETC.                        9



Point, New York; Company E, at West Point, N. Y. Company D is
not organized.
  A roster of officers and changes is given in report.
   Recruiting has been done by enlistments and re-enlistments at Wil-
lets Point, and by assignment from the general depot at David's Island,
New York Harbor.
   During the year the losses have been 134 and the gains 134.
   The battalion has been drilled and instructed in the various subjects
pertaining to their duties as engineer troops.

                                      EXPERIMENTS.


  In the absence of appropriations for '' torpedoes for harbor defense*"
for the past two years, no addition could be made to the supply of
materials, and no systematic course of experiments could be made
towairds the future development of the system, to keep pace with
improvements constantly being made in such appliances abroad.
   A few simple experiments were, however, made with such facilities
as were available, a brief account of which will be found in the report
of the officer in charge of the Engineer School and Depot at Willets
Point (Appendix No. 1).

    ENGINEER DEPOT-PUBLIC BUILDINGS                                             AND CONSTRUCTIONS.


   The building for an officers' mess and library was completed and oc-
cupied during the year.
    Instruments have been purchased, repaired, and, when required,
issued to officers of the Corps in the field.
    Observatory dome repainted. Water brought into officers' labora-
tory. The printing, book-binding, draughting, photographing, litho-
graphing, engine-driving, general work of repair and preservation of
property, buildings, and care of animals, have been done by engineer
soldiers. The steamer David Bushnell was placed on the ways during
the winter, but could not be repaired aid launched in the spring, owing
to a failure of the appropriation for the'~trpedo service.
    A small testing-machine was improvised for measuring the strength
of wire, rope, etc.
    Materials required were purchased and issued for use here, and the
,necessary office work of the depot was performed.
                                      STATEMENT OF FUNDS.


Congress appropriated for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888...........                                $6,500.00
Of this has been expended and pledged ...... ---.................        .....                            6,494.32
No appropriation as yet available for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1889,
  except an extension for the month of July, 1888, of.....................                                  540.99

There will be required for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890-
    For incidental expenses of depot ...................................                                 $5, 000. 00
    For purchase of materials for instruction ...........................                                 1, 500.)0
    For purchase and repair of instruments .............................                                  5, 000. 00
    For purchase of professional works for the library                             ..................        500.00
    For a building to contain engineer models ............-.... ..                                 ...    8, 000. 00

      In all..-      ------- --......      e...   ...............--   --.................                20, 000.00
   (See Appendix No. 1.)
10           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                   RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.

   The funds with which the works for the improvement of rivers and
harbors were prosecuted during the past fiscal year were, owing to the
failure of the river and harbor act passed dluring the second session of
the Forty-ninth Congress to become a law, derived from balances re-
maining on hand from the act of August 5, 1886, t!)gether with such
few remnants of former appropriations as were available. In many in-
stances these being only sufficient to provide for the care of the public
property pertaining to the works, operations were necessarily suspended,
to the great detriment of the improvements concerned.
   A brief statement, derived from the reports of the officers in charge
of the several works, given below, sets forth the condition of each im-
lprovement, the extent of work performed during the last fiscal year,
the amount expended, and, in compliance with the provisions of the
river and harbor act approved March 2, 1867, estimates of the amount
that   can    be   profitably   expended   during   the   fiscal   year   ending   June   30,

1890, with the probable cost of completion.
   Although, as a general rule, regard is necessarily had, in the prepa-
ration of these estimates, to the more intimate acquaintance of the en-
gineer officer in charge with the requirements of each locality, they
have been carefully revised and amended when deemed advisable-, in
this office, the most economical administration of the works being con-
sidered as well as the average of the grants by Congress for each work
during the past few years; and it has sometimes been necessary to
make changes in the officer's estimates of the probable amount required
for completion in consequence of appropriations made by the river and
harbor act of August 11, 1888.
   The examinations and surveys provided for by the river and harbor
act of August 5, 1886, have been made and the results thereof reported
to Congress from time to time, and such of them as were not contained
in the report of this office for 1887 will be found in the appendix to this
report.
   Examinations were made during the fiscal year of such plans and loca-
tions as were submitted by parties interested, of bridges proposed to be
built over navigable waters subject to the approval of the Secretary of
War. A brief statement is given of the action had in such cases.
   Examinations were also made whenever requested by committees of
Congress, of proposed bills authorizing the construction of bridges, upon
which the views of the War Department were desired. Of bills so ex-
amined during the present session of Congress to the close of the fiscal
year, sixty originated in the Senate and eighty in the House of Repre-
sentatives.
   The reports heretofore made to Congress, up to the end of the fiscal
year, in compliance with the requirements of section 2 of the river and
harbor act of July 5,1884, and section 4 of that of August 5, 1886, of in-
stances where bridges, causeways, or other structures erected or in proc-
ess of erection do or will interfere with free and safe navigation; and
also of instances in which piers, breakwaters, or other works built by
the'United States in aid of commerce or navigation are used, occupied,
or injured by a corporation or individual, will be found in Appendix
WW 23 and XX, respectively, of this report.
  A statement is also given of the work accomplished in the removal of
wrecks obstructing or endangering navigation, general provision for
which was made in the river and harbor act approved June 14,,1880, en-
larged by provision of the river and harbor act of August 2, 1882.
                       RIVER AND HARBOR                   IMtRROV M ETS.                             11
           ATLANTIC COAST AND GULF'                                    OF MEXICO.

IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE STATES OF MAINE
                   AND NEW HAMPSHIRE.

   Officer in charge, Lieut. Col. Jared A. Smith, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Lubec Channel, iMaine.-This channel lies between the eastern ex-
tremity of Maizne and Campo-Bello Island, belonging to the Dominion
of Canada. Originally the channel was but 5 feet in depth at mean low
water, and but 2 feet at low water of spring tides.
   The original project of improvement adopted in 1879, proposed wid-
ening and deepening the channel by dredging, where necessary, from
the Narrows to the Western Bar Beacon, so as to give a width of 200
feet and a depth of 12 feet at mean low water, or 9 feet at low water of
spring tides. This part was completed in 1883.
   The present project contemplates increasing the width to 275 feet, and
to 300 feet in the bends. Length of channel, 21 miles.
   The amount expended upon this improvement to June 30, 1887, was
$139,932.04. The resulting improvement to navigation in this thorough.
fare has been great, as it has made a channel of the specified depth,
and varying from 200 to 278 feet wide, besides a stone jetty near the
Narrows to direct the strong current.
   During the last fiscal year there has been expended the sum of
$9,057.93, in widening the channel by dredging, resulting in obtaining
its full width for nearly half the length from the lower end.
   The estimated cost of completing the improvement heretofore ap-
proved is $22,500.
   It is proposed to expend any funds which may be availalle for the
ensuing year in widening the channel to complete the present project as
far as practicable.
July 1, 1887, amount available...... ........-..........                  ..... ...... ....   $9, 067. 96
July 1, 1888, amount expended during the fiscal year, exclusive of liabili-
  ties outstanding July 1, 1887 .........................................                      9,057.93
July 1, 1888, balance available . -  .... -_. .... ......         ...... ........                  10. 03
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888-...................                      ....   20, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.--------...--......--------20, 010.03
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                      2,500.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                    2, 500. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix A 1.)
  2. Moose a bec Bar, Maine.-The project for this improvement was
adopted in 1881, the object being to give a direct channel over the bar
having a width of 200 feet and a depth of 14 feet at mean low water.
The old channel was indirect, crooked, and dangerous.
  The entire amount expended to June 30, 1887, upon the improvement
has been $30,393.11.
  The dredged channel over the bar was completed in September, 1885,
and there remains to complete the project only the removal of the small
ledge known as " Steamboat Ledge." The amount available is sufficient
to complete the work as originally planned.
  The detailed survey of the ledge was completed in June, 1887, and a
contract for removal of " Steamboat Ledge" to a depth of 15 feet at mean
low water was concluded in August.
12       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEER1S, U. S. ARMY.

   Various delays have occurred to the contractor, so that the work is
still unfinished. The work thus far completed under the contract has
not been sufficient to improve the channel nor to involve any payments
under the contract.
   The contract has been extended to September 29, 188, at which time
it is expected that the removal of the ledge will be completed.
   This channel is a thoroughfare for a very large number of coasting
vessels and steamers. The improvements thus far made have been of
very great benefit to navigation. The amount on hand will be expended
in completing the original project.
   The appropriation available will be expended in widening the chan-
nel and in the removal of some dangerous ledges one-half mile west of
the bar.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..............................        ......      $9, 606. 89
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ................ ......      569. 81
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..........................       878.85
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts ..........       1, 621. 00
                                                                                  3,069.66
July 1, 188,   balance available ....................................             6, 537.23
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .. ... ....
                                                       -....         ....... 15,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889........................21,537.23
     (See Appendix A 2.)
   3. IVarraguagus River, Maine.-The obstruction to navigation con-
sisted in a bar extending from the anchorage known as " deep hole,"
near Fickett's Point, to deep water, the shoalest part having only'4 feet
at extreme low water and only 5N feet at mean low water.
   The project for improvement adopted in 1886 consists in dredging a
channel 11 feet deep at low water to the steam-boat landing at Long
Point, and thence 9 feet deep to the deep hble, or anchorage, the width
of the channel to be 200 feet throughout, except in the reach by the
steam-boat wharf, where it is to be increased to 300 feet.
   The estithated expense of the improvement was $50,000. The only
expenses incurred previous to June 30, 1887, were for the necessary
preparatory work, amounting to $257. In the last fiscal year there has
been expended the sum of $9,743. Total expenditures, $10,000. A
channel1 feet deep has been dredged from deep water to a point above
the lower steam-boat wharf, a distance of 5,000 feet, of which 3,550 feet
is 50 feet wide and the remaining distance 75 feet wide. The lower
steam-boat wharf can now be reached by steam-boats at all ordinary
low-water stages, but this is of little value, as the steamers must wait
for high water to enable them to turn around.
   The mouth of the Narraguagus River forms a harbor which-is some-
what used as an anchorage by coasting vessels. The steamers of the
Portland, Bangor and Machias Steamboat Company touch at the Mill-
bridge landing (Long Point) four times each week.
   The $10,000 appropriated will be used in continuing the improve-
ment. The balance required to complete the improvement is estimated
at $30,000.
July 1, 1887, amount available -------....... ...... ..--..----    -------- $9, 743 00
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 -.............----.... ........................   9,743 00

Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ......- -...
                                                        .
                                                      -....      -- . 10, 000 00
                                                            ........
                  RIVER AND HARBOR             IMPROVEMENTS.                          13
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........--$30,000 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890. 10,-000 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix, A 3.)
   4. For commencing the construction of a breakwater from Mount Desert
to Porcupine Island, Maine.-This is a new work. The officer in charge,
in his report upon the survey, made in compliance with the act of
August 5, 1886, printed in Appendix A of the Report of the Chief of Eno
gineers for 1887, page 483, stated that with the view to affording pro-
tection on the south and southeast sides of the harbor a breakwater is
necessary, and that the only practicable location for it is between Round
Porcupine Island ana one of the adjacent points in Mount Desert Isl-
and. The estimated( cost of the work is given at $500,000.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates for com-
mencing the work $50,000, and $100,000 may be profitably expended in
continuing it during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..........          ....--.... $50, 000.00
                                                                ..--
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .-- .. 450,000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30, 1890 100, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   5. Bagaduce River, Maine.-To comply with the requirements of the
river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, a preliminary examination and
survey was made of the Bagaduce River between the towns of Penob-
scot and Brooksville, Me.
   A report of the results of the survey was transmitted to Congress
Feb:uary 8, 1888, and printed as House Ex. Doc. No. 157, Fiftieth Con-
gress, first session.
   The estimated cost of straightening and deepening the channel,
proposed by the officer in charge, to give a width of 100 feet from
Bridge's Point to the village of South Penobscot, with a depth of 5 feet
at low water, is $45,000.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, contains an appropria-
tion of $3,000 for the proposed improvement, and $10,000 may be prof-
itably expended in continuing it during the fiscal year ending June
30, 1890.
                                                 ......-.---
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ....                       -$3,
                                                                  ... -......      000.00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project. - -...        42, 000. 00
  Amountthat can beprofitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890       10, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   6. Bangor Harbor and Penobscot River, Maine.-The present project
for this improvement consists in widening the channel to 300 feet by
dredging opposite Bangor to a depth of 11 feet at extreme low water,
also to widen the channel and remove obstructions in Crosby's Narrows.
   The estimated cost of the entire improvement is $75,000.
   The former channel at Bangor was too narrow to accommodate the
numerous vessels in connection with the lumber rafts, which often re-
quire much space.
   There was expended upon the work to June 30, 1887, the sum of
 $20,403.97. The result was the required increase of width for a distance
of over half a mile.
   A contract for continuing the work has been in force during the last
year, but the contractors have not made satisfactory progress.                       The
14           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S ARMY.

improvement has been somewhat extended during the year. Work
under the contract will be completed on or before October 15, 1888.
  The amount expended during the fiscal year has been $4,391.10.
  The balance of the available funds will be expended in continuing the
contract, with the.necessary contingent expenses.
  The estimated amount required to complete the project is $40,000.
  Under the requirements of the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886,
a preliminary examination and survey were made of the Penobscot
River from Bangor to Bucksport, Me. A report of the results of the
survey was transmitted to Congress February 8, 1888, and printed as
House Ex. Doc. No. 133, Fiftieth Congress, first session.
  The officer in charge estimates the cost of the improvement he pro-
poses at $365,000.
  The amount available will be expended between Bangor and Crosby's
Narrows, and Bucksport and Winterport.
July 1,1887, amount available ...--...--......--......----...--..          ..............        $14, 596.03
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ......----......-----......----......       $3, 868. 35
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities..---------..                ..-...                  522.75
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts ....-......                        9, 822.92
                                                                                                         --       14,214.02

July 1, 1888, balance available ......                                                          .....-    _..:      3..................-
                                                                                                                     382.01
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..- ...................                                              50,000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.................. -50,                                           382.01

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project, subject
Sto revision..................................-----------------------------..... ------..........---.. .. 355.000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 100 000. 00
1Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
I harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix A 4.)
  7. Belfast Harbor, Maine.-The harbor was originally shallow along
the wharf-fronts, east-side, so that vessels could only land on high stages
of water. A project for the improvement of this harbor was adopted
in 1876, the object being to enable vessels drawing 10 to 12 feet of water
to reach the wharves at all stages of the tide.
  Up to June 30, 1887, there had been expended the sum of $22,193.20.
  The west side of the harbor has been improved so that there is 10
feet at mean low water in the upper part and 11 to 12 feet in the lower
part.
  The officer in charge recommends that the area of the harbor be in-
creased by dredging the shoal on the northeast side to a depth not less
than 8 feet at low water. He estimates the expense of dredging at
$15,600, provided it can be expended in one sum.
  The amount expended in the last fiscal year, making examination and
report, has been $20.64.
July 1,1887, amount available ....... ...  ...... .... ..... ............. $2,806.80
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1,1887 ....--......              ....................................                                 20. 64

July 1, 1888, balance available ......                  _...              . .              .   ......     .....     2, 786. 16
   (See Appendix A 5.)
  8. Camden Harbor,Maine.-To comply with the requirements of the
river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, a preliminary examination and
survey were made of Camden Harbor. A report of the results was
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                15
transmitted to Congress February 2, 1888, and printed as House Ex.
Doc. No. 141, Fiftieth Congress, first session.
  A survey of this harbor was made in 1872, and subsequently two
channels, each 80 feet wide and 6 feet deep, were dredged to the upper
part of the basin. The present project contemplates dredging the ap-
proach to these channels to a depth of 10 and 12 feet; the deepening
of the channels to 10 feet, and their extension to the upper end of the
harbor with a depth of 5 feet at mean low water, at an estimated cost
of $25,520.
  The'river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $5,000 for
this work, and a further sum of $10,000 could be profitably expended
thereon during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 -.... ....................      5, 000.00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-...-- -20,     520. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 10, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  9. Rockport Harbor, Maine.-The river and harbor act of August 5,
1886, provided for a preliminary examination and survey of Rockport
Harbor. A report of the results of the survey was transmitted to Con-
gress February 2, 1888, and printed as House Ex. Doc. No. 141, Fiftieth
Congress, first session, which contains an estimate of $14,000 for remov-
ing a shoal in the vicinity of the wharves to a depth of 12 feet mean low
water. The present depth upon this shoal varies from li feet to 11
feet.
  The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $10,000 for
this harbor, and an additional sum of $4,000 could be profitably ex-
pended in completing the removal of this shoal during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ....--.....................-- $10,000.00
  Amountthat canbe profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890     4,000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   10. Harborat Rockland, Maine.-The project for improving this harbor
adopted in 1881, consists in the construction of two breakwaters to
protect the shipping in the harbor and to make it a harbor of refuge.
The harbor was open to all easterly winds and seas, and the break-
waters when completed will afford still water and good anchorage.
   There had been expended on the improvement to June 30, 1887, the
sum of $105,631.76.
   As a result the breakwater from Jameson's Point had been completed
its full length of 1,900 feet from high-water mark on shore, and to a
height of 5 feet above mean low water. It has been found necessary
to raise the top to mean high-water level, and this work has been com-
menced at the outer extremity.
   During the year ending June 30, 1888, there has been expended the
sum of $14,684.84. As a result the breakwater has been completed to
high-water level, for a distance of 271 feet from the outer end, making it
20 feet wide on top.
   The beacon has been removed from its old position and re-erected on
the outer end of the breakwater.
   The estimated cost of completing the first breakwater to the level of
high water, and the second to mean sea-level, as originally planned, is
$650,000. The amount that has been appropriated for this work is
$122,500.
I1   A
               REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The raising of the breakwater is expected to stop the seas which, at
high water, now dash over its top.
  The amount available and that asked for, will be applied towards
completing the Jameson's Point breakwater to the level of high water.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..----..--...... ......             ...........---. .... $16, 868. 24
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887..... .--.--- .--...-      ......................              14,684. 84
July 1, 1888, balance available ....... ...... ....     ---......---......--------......
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 - .... _......
                                                                                                      2, 183. 40
                                                                                                  30, 000. 00
                                                                                     -.............


Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889..................                           32, 183. 40

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-........ 497, 500.00
     SAmount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 75, 000.00
         Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
          harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
         (See Appendix A 6.)
    11. Kennebec River at Bath and from Augusta to lower end of Perkins
Island, Maine.-To comply with the requirements of the river and har-
bor act of August 5, 1886, a preliminary examination and survey were
made of the Kennebec River at the localities named.
    A report of the results of the survey was transmitted to Congress
January 26, 1888, and printed in House Ex. Doc. No. 133, Fiftieth Con-
gress, first session.
    The former project for improving the river, completed in 1877, pro-
vided for a channel from Richmond to Gardiner, a distance of 11 miles,
100 feet wide and 10 feet deep at low water, or 151 feet at high water,
aitd from Gardiner to Augusta, 6 miles more, 100 feet wide, 6± feet deep
at low water and 114 feet deep at high water.
    The survey in question was limited to the portion of the river between
Augusta and Gardiner and detached localities below.
    The improvements proposed by the officer in charge are estimated to
cost $410,500, the first in importance being the improvement of " Love-
jo 's Narrows," at an estimated cost of $100,100.
   'The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $75,000
for this work, and $75,000 may be profitably expended in continuing it
during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888-...._....     ........... .... $75, 000. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.--...... 335, 500. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 75, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  12. Harborat Portland, Maine.-The former projects for improving
this harbor have been completed, and a depth of 17 feet mean low water
has been obtained in all places where heretofore there was less than
16 feet, and the depth of 21 feet was extended beyond Galt Wharf to
the southeast corner of Franklin Wharf. The present project consists
in deepening the channel to give a depth of 29 feet at mean low water
and a width of 500 feet to the wharves used by the largest transatlantic
steamers at all stages of the tide.
  The part of the harbor requiring this improvement had but 21 feet
depth at low water, while the large steamers using it frequently draw
as much as 27 feet.
  Previous to June 30, 1887, there had been expended upon the project
the sum of $2,040.59),. mainly upon the preliminary work required. Dur-
ing the last year 198,872 cubic yards of material have been dredged and
                             RIVER          AND       HARBOR            IMPROVEMENTS.                                       17
removed, resulting in giving a depth of 29 feet over an area of about-
1.600 feet in length and 400 feet wide.
  'The amount expended in last fiscal year was $27,951.75.
  The completion of the chahuel will be a great benefit to the facilities
for receiving and shipping by transatlantic steamers and other large
vessels.
  The funds available and those asked for are to be expended in com-
pleting the project.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..................                            ......    ...----......--.             $27,959. 41
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstandling July 1, 1887.....-------..................                      ................---.....              27,951.75

July 1, 1888, balance available ....----................................                                        .          7. 66
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888................                                                        40,000.00

Amount available for fiscalyear ending June 30, 1889... ................ ..                                          40,007. 66

  (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project --.-       65, 000. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 65, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix A 7.)
   13. Channel in Back Cove, Portland, Maine.-The project for this
improvement, adopted in 1886, consists in widening and deepening the
channel to give 12 feet depth at mean low water and a width of 300
feet for a distance of about 5,600 feet, following the harbor comms-
sioners' line.
   Originally the channel was only navigable at high stages of water;
it was but 8 feet deep at low water, and that depth did not extend more
than half its length.
   Amount expended to June 30, 1887, was but $1,447.37, which was
mainly for necessary surveys, maps, and other preliminary work.
   During the last year, under the contract previously reported, there
has been removed 49,602 cubic yards of material from the channel.
   The expense of this work has been $9,281.02.
   The resulting channel has the full depth and width of 72 feet for over
2,000 feet, and a width of 24 feet for 930 feet additional.
   Fifty thousand dollars could be profitably expended in each year
until the improvement is complete. The amount available and that
asked is to be applied to extending and widening the channel.
   The widening the channel as planned will greatly increase the facili-
ties for receiving and shipping numerous freights, such as coal and
building materials.
July 1, 1887, amount available-----..----......---.....    .......................             $24, 802.63
July 1,1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of lia-
  bilities outsanding July 1, 1887----------..-......----....--.--------......     $6, 880. 35
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..............            .........           2, 400. 67
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts .. .......                      14, 950. 00
                                                                                                                     24, 231.02

July 1, 1888, balance available----..-...--..---.......---....------.-----.---------------.......                        571.61
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 18388 ..........                                        ............        25, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 33, 1889 .........                                   ..........         25, 571, 61

           ENG 88--2
18           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

{Amount   (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ $128, 750.00
  Amount that can be profitablyexpended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 50. 000 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix A 8.)
   14. Breakwater at mouth of Saco River, Maine.--This breakwater was
partially built in 1869 to 1873. In 1883 it was found necessary to com-
plete the breakwater to the full height of 15 feet and top width of 12
feet, to secure the object of preventing the sand from drifting into the
channel, and maintaining a bar at the mouth of the Saco River.
   There had been expended upon this work to the 30th of June, 1887,
the sum of $20,024.04.
   As a result, the breakwater had been fully completed from its outer
end, a distance of 710 feet, except the cap stones for 100 feet.
   The completion of the breakwater thus far has had no perceptible
effect upon the depth of water over the bar.
   In the last fiscal year there has been expended the sum of $7,474.48.
   The breakwater has been entirely completed to a point 1,310 feet from
the outer end, repaired a further distance of 292 feet, and the beacon
has been placed in a vertical position.
The original estimate, as amended, for completion of old breakwater was... $70, 000
Amount appropriated ---.....---
                     .          - --..--- -......-- - -.... -......- ..--....--- ......-- .----.......
                                                                                            ....                      27,500

Estimated amount still required.                     .....      ..............             .................           42, 500
  This sum can be profitably expended in a single year.
  The amount available and that asked for year ending June 30, 1890,
are to be applied to completion of old breakwater.
July 1, 1887,amount available......................                                  ...     .......   .........   $7, 475.96
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 187 ..............................................                                            7, 474. 48

July 1, 1888, balance available -.................. .. ..... ...........        ....                                     1.48
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 -.............          -........                                    12, 500.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 --....-...........                                           12, 501. 48

  Amount :estimated) required for completion of existing project-.-.__---                                          30, 000.00
   Amount that can be profitably expendedinfiscalyearending June 30,1890                                           30, Q00. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix A 9.)
   15. Saco River, Maine.--The present project for improving the Saco
River was adopted in 1886, its object being to give a channel having
not less than 6 feet of water, at low water, to the cities of Saco and
Biddeford.
  The channel was obstructed by bars, and in one place by a ledge,
and does not give more than 34 feet of water at mean low water, though
a large portion is much deeper.
  The estimated expense, excluding the works necessary to remove the
bar at the mouth, was $50,000.
   Previous to June 30, 1887, the amount expended was $564.76. The
expenditure was for the necessary surveys and preparatory work.
  During the last year there has been expended the sum of $11.871.56.
As a result the ledge at Little Islands has been removed, and the ad-
jacent bars have been dredged to a depth of 6 feet at mean low water.
A channel has also been dredged along the front of the coal wharves.
  The amount available and that asked is to be applied in continuing
the project.
                          RIVER         AND        thtRBOR        IMPROVEMENTS.                                                  19
Ju'y 1, 1887, amount available ............................. ............ - $11, 935.24
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1887..............................................                                                 11,871.56
July 1, 1888, balance available .......................                           ......     ............                      63. 68
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888                          ..    --....... ....         ..        ....        10, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ....-                                ............              .    10, 063. 68

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                                  40, 000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                              25, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
1   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix A 10.)
   16. Kennebunk River, Maine.-All the projects for improving this river
have been completed.
  There have been no appropriations since 1881.
  The small balance remaining June 30, 1887, has been partly expended
in making needed repairs upon the old wooden pier.
  The works completed consist of stone piers, supplemented by crib-
work to keep the channel open at and near the mouth.
  Total expended to June 30, 1887, $64,8J8.66.
  No further improvements are at present contemplated.
July 1, 1887, amount available ...---......-..............................                                                  $336. 34
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887....................     .....................                                                     236. 92
July 1, 1888, balance available....---............--..---..........--------------....------....----                            99. 42
   (See Appendix A 11.)
   17. Harborat York, Maine.-The project for this improvement adopted
in 1886, has for its object the widening of the channel in three bends
where it did not exceed 75 feet of a navigable depth, and where the
tidal currents are very rapid. The channel at the points mentioned is
to be widened by dredging and removing such rock as may be found.
   The expenditures previous to June, 1887, were but $680.65, making no
apparent change in the channel.
   During the last year dredging has been done at two of the points
mentioned.
   The amount expended in fiscal year is $12,247.46.
   The work accomplished thus far has not produced any material ben-
efit. The entire completion, however, of the work proposed will greatly
improve the navigation to and from the inner anchorage.
   Part of the rock to be removed has been found a solid ledge instead
of loose rocks, and the original estimate has, therefore, been increased
by the amount necessary to remove this ledge, which is estimated to
be $14,000.
   The amount available and that asked for is to be applied to complet-
ing the project.
July 1, 1887, amount available -.---...
                                     ..............                                .          .......                    $14, 319.35
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887......................................-----------------------........                           12,247.46
                                      ......
July 1, 1888, balance available ---..--..    ...............                                     ..........                2,071.89
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888. ..............                                    ........                 10, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.......--............                                                12, 071.89
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-------19,000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 19,000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix A 12.)
20         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  18. Harbor at Portsmouth, New Hampshire.-The project for improv-
ing this harbor was adopted in 1879, the object being to check the strong
tidal currents in the harbor and to give a navigab.e depth over the ledge
known as Gangway Rock, opposite the navy-yard.
   To June 30, 1887, there had been expended the sum of $94,730.36.
   In the last fiscal year there has been expended the sum of $11,874 58.
   The results are the entire removal of Gangway Rock to a depth of 20
feet at mean low water, the completion of the breakwater to stop the
cross currents coming in from between Great and Goat islands, and a
part of the ledge projecting from Badger's Island.
   There remains to complete the original project only the removal of
the remaining ledge on the point projecting from Badger's Island
   The officer in charge recommends that no further work be done upon
that point, except so far as it may be considered desirable to remove
the ledge to a depth not less than 18 feet, in order that passing vessels
may not be injured by being drifted upon the jagged rock.
   The estimated amount required to complete the original project is
$25,000, but this is not recommended.
                                                                                   ......
July 1, 1887. amount available......----.....................-------------........--.--            $12,269.64
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 187 .................                  ................---..........          11,874.58

July 1, 1888, balance available.......... ...... ........ ...... ...... ...... 395.06
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.......................... 15, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889....................                           15, 395. 06

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                            5,000.00
  Amount that can be profit ably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                        5,000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1863 and 1867.
   (See Appendix A 13.)
   19. Bellamy River, eew Hampshire.-This is a new work, based upon
the survey made in obedience to the requirements of the river and har-
bor act of August 5, 1886, in which the officer in charge reports that
the river is a small tidal branch of the Piscataqua River, or an arm of
Great Bay, which connects with the Piscataqua at Dora Point, 4 miles
above the bridge at Portsmouth, N. I., which it is proposed to improve
by dredging with the view to obtaining a channel sufficient to admit.
vessels of 500 or 600 tons to ascend to the head of navigation at that
stage.
   The estimated cost of the improvement, consisting of a channel 50 feet
wide at bottom with 45-degree slopes, 5 feet depth at mean low water,
is $28,000.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, contains an appropria-
tion of $10,000 for the proposed work. It is estimated that $18,000 can
be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ....................                           ...   $10, 000.00


  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 18, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   20. Cocheco River, New Hampshire.-The present project for improv-
ing the Cocheco River has for its object a channel 50 feet wide, with a
depth of 5 feet at mean low water, or 11~ feet at mean high water, to
the city ofDover, N. H.
                        RIVER AND HARBOR                             IMPROVEMENTS:                       21
  The channel was obstructed by a ledge of rock, and by sand, gravel,
and bowlders, which gave a channel depth of less than 3 feet at mean
low water.
  The original estimate for cost of the work was $47,000.
  Expenditures to June 30, 1887, $28,497.36.
  During the last year the removal of the solid ledge has been com-
pleted.
  A great improvement to the navigation of the river has already re-
sulted, but to obtain the full benefit the remaining obstructions should
be removed.
  The amount available will be applied to completing the improvement.
July 1, 1887, amount available .........                       ..............................     $9,502.64
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  ouitstanding July 1, 1587 .............  ....---- --.... .... ..... ......                       9,184. 75

July 1, 1888, balance available         ........................
                                               .........................                             317.89
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ..........................                           9,000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.......... ..........                         9, 317. 89
   (See Appendix A 14.)
   21. Harbor of Refuge at Little Harbor, New Hampshire.-The present
project for this improvement consists in dredging a channel 100 feet
wide and 9 feet deep at mean low water for a distance of about 3,000
feet to the small anchorage, which is to be slightly enlarged.
   The object of the improvement is to form a harbor of refuge for ves-
sels when they can not get into Portsmouth Harbor.
   The harbor has a sandy bottom, and is for the most part shallow.
The channel originally had an average of less than 6 feet at low water.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $349.71.
   During the last year a part of the channel, 75 feet wide and 2,400
feet long, has been excavated to a depth of 9 feet by dredging.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year has been $9,558.05.
   The resulting channel causes no benefit thus far, because it does not
extend to the deep water inside.
   The funds available for ensuing year and for year ending June 30,
1890, will be expended in carrying out enlarged project in accordance
with the act of August 11, 1888.
   The increased depth and area to be dredged is estimated by the
officer in charge to cost $95,000. If the project is to include the two
protecting jetties proposed by him, $70,000 will have to be added to
this amount.
July 1, 1887, amount available          .......-- ..----..........--.....--......--...... $9, 650.29
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.............
                                ----              ............--..--....---- _....----------.. 9, 558, 05

July 1, 1888, balance available-----
                               ......---.....---..........--------...............-------------.        92. 24
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.                    ..-........... .....- .         20, 000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30,1889.-...........-......                          20, 092.24

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project......
                                                                    -                             98, 000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 50, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix A 15.)
22        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

EXAMINATIONS. AND SURVEYS FOR IMPROVEMENT, TO COMPLY WITH
  REQUIREMENTS OF THE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT OF AUGUST 5,
  1886.

  It appearing, after preliminary examination by the local engineer,
that the localities were worthy of improvement, Lieutenant-Colonel
Smith was charged with and completed the following surveys, the re-
sults of which were transmitted to Congress and printed as Executive
Documents of the Fiftieth Congress, first session:
  1. Bayoduce [Bagaduce] River, Maine, between the towns of Penobsoot
and Brooksville.-Printedin House Ex. Doc. No. 157. (See also Appen-
dix A 16.)
  2. Camden Harbor, Maine.-Printed in House Ex. Doc. No. 141. (See
also Appendix A 17.)
  3. Rockport Harbor, Maine.-Printed in House Ex. Doc. No. 141. (See
also Appendix A 18.)
  4. Kennebec River, Maine, at Bath, and from Augusta, to lower end of
Perkin's Island.-Printedin House Ex. Doc. No. 133.-(See also Appen-
dix A 19.)
  5. Penobscot River, Maine,from Bangorto Bucksport Narrows.-Printed
in House Ex. Doc. No. 133. (See also Appendix A 20.)

     IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS            IN   MASSACHUSETTS.

   Officer in charge, Lieut. Col. George L. Gillespie, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Newburyport Harbor, Massachusetts.-The object of the improve-
ment is to create a channel through the outer bar, 1,000 feet wide and
with a least depth of 17 feet at mean low water, or 24J feet at mean
high water. The project adopted in 1880, and modified in 1863, is to
build two converging rubble-stone jetties, so located as to give a proper
direction to the current, and thereby produce and maintain the desired
result.
   The estimated cost of the project was $375,000, and the amount ap-
propriated to date is $207,500.
   To June 30, 1888, $207,498.27 had been expended.
   During the fiscal year 3,443 tons of rubble-stone were deposited in the
north jetty.
   The north jetty is now 2,675 feet long, of which 1,930 feet are fully
complete(l, and the residue, 745 feet, is a core of stone built up to low
water.
   The south jetty is 1,300 feet long, of which 1,077 feet are fully com-
pleted, and the residue, 223 feet, is a core of stone built up to low water.
   The Plum Island Dike is 817 feet long, 5- feet high above mean low
water, except near the center where a weir is left temporarily, 150 feet
long, and 2 feet deep at mean low water.
   The sand-catch in rear of the softh jetty is in two branches, one 480
feet long and one 572 feet.
   All these works are in good order.
   The expenditures during the year were $1 7.622.07.
   The balance available July 1, 1888, is $1.73. To complete the im-
provements $167,500 will be required, of which $50,000 could be ex
pended to advantage during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
   A survey of the bar was made in June, 1888. It showed a decided
advance in the improvement; three deep navigable channels cross the
bar, one 11.2 feet deep, and the other two, each 10.7 feet deep at mean
low water.
                   RIVER AND HARBOR             IMPROVEMENTS.                        23
   The advantages to be derived from the completion of the project are
t he deepening and widening of the channel across the bar, thereby af-
fording a harbor of refuge on the inside of Salisbury Point, and also
affording easy access at high water to the wharves at Newburyport
for vessels drawing 17 feet approximately.
July 1, 1887, amount available.........-----...--...--....---..-------......---- -$17, 623. 80
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                                          ...--------- -- --- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- 17, 622. 07
  outstanding July 1, 1887.----..----.. -....
                                                                 --
July 1, 1888, balance available......------------....--................
                                                           ....--..---......   1. 73
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..........-................ 25, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889. --.................     25, 001.73
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....         142, 500. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 50, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix B 1.)
   2. Merrimac River, Mass achusetts.-The object of the improvement is
to straighten, deepen, and widen the natural channel of the river from
its mouth to the Upper Falls, a distance of 214 miles.
   The channel originally was narrow, crooked, and much obstructed by
ledges, bowlders, and shoals, and below Newburyport by ledges, cribs,
piers, and wrecks. At mean low water vessels drawing not to exceed
7 feet could cross the bar and proceed about 6 miles above Newbury-
port. The mean rise or fall of the tide at the mouth of the river is 7,
feet; at Haverhill Bridge, 4 feet.
   The project originally a lopted in 1870 proposed to remove obstruc-
tions from the Upper and Lower Falls, to remove Gangway Rock, to re-
move the wreck of the schooner Globe, and to remove the " Boilers."
The cost was estimated at $69,025.
   This project was revised and extended in 1874 to include the removal
of rocks at Deer Island and at Rock Dridges, and at Little Currier's
Shoal, so that the channel should have the following depths at ordinary
high-water stages of the river:
   From the mouth to Deer Island Bridge (5 miles), 161 feet; from Deer
Island Bridge to Haverhill Bridge (12f, miles), 12 feet; thence to the
foot of Mitchell's Falls (14 miles), 10 feet; through Mitchell's Falls to
the head of the Upper Falls (21 miles), not less than 44 feet, with the
mill water at Lawrence running. This revised project was estimated to
cost $147,000.
   The total appropriations to date have been $170,500.
   The total expenditures to June 30, 1888, were $170,498.43, and the
river channel had been improved in accordance with the modified proj-
ect, with the exception of the removal of the " Boilers," upon which no
work has been done.
   During the fiscal year the high-water grade line of the river during
the spring freshet was established.from Lawrence to the mouth.
   To complete the improvement, so that the same depth of water which
has been obtained through Mitchell's Falls can be carried to Lawrence,
additional work will be required at the falls above Haverhill, which is
estimated to cost $11,000, and additional improvements could be made
in the lower part of the river, which are estimated to cost $11,500, or a
total of $22,500.
   The improved channel is in good order, and meets all existing de-
mands of commerce. No appropriation is recommended for the year
ending June 30, 1890.
24          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1887, amount available ----.- --........--....-      .-.-                                          -     $290.04
July 1, 1h88, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ....................                                     $282. 47
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ...... -....................                                 6. 00
                                                                                                  --              288. 4'

July 1, 1888, balance available.... ..............                   ........................                        1. 5.
  (See Appendix B 2.)
  3 Pozcow River, Massachusetts.-In compliance with river and harbor
act of July 5, 1884, a preliminary examination and survey were made
of Powow River. The result of the survey was submitted to Congress
February 2, 1885, and printed as House Ex. Doc. No. 179, Forty-eighth
Congress, second session, and also as Appendix B 15, Annual Report
of Chief of Engineers, 1885. The project proposed contemplates deep-
ening the channel to 12 feet for a distance of 9,600 feet, at an estimated
cost of $77,000.
  The.river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $3,000 for
this work, and $10,000 may be profitably expended in continuing it
during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                                        $3, 000. 00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                       74, 000, 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                    10, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   4. Ipswich River, Massachusetts.-Ipswich River empties into Plum
Island Sound about 9 miles south of Newburyport, Mass. It is navi-
gable from its mouth to the wharves at Ipswich, a distance of 3 miles.
Before improvement at low water not to exceed 1 feet draught could
be carried in a narrow channel.
   The mean rise or fall of the tide is 8.4 feet. The object of the im-
provement is to widen and deepen the natural channel of the river.
   The original project was submitted in 1875. It proposed a channel 60
feet wide and 4 feet deep at mean low water,- at an estimated cost of
$25,000.
   But one appropriation has been made for this improvement, that of
August 5, 1886, for $2,500.
   No operations were in progress during the year.
   The improvement remains in good order, and the navigable channel
is at least 40 feet wide and 4 feet deep at mean low water.
   The total expenditures to date have been $2,500.
   No balance is available July 1, 1888.
   To complete the improvement so far as the nature of the present
commerce justifies will require an appropriation of $2,500, all of which
could be expended to advantage during the fiscal year ending June 30,
1890, in widening the cut at "The Shoals" to 60 feet and in extending
it to the "Deep Hole" above "Heard's Point."
   The prospective benefits to commerce are increased facilities and
safety for navigation.
July\ 1, 1887, amount available -....-.....     ---.............                                                  $246.79
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ......  .......     ..........-----...----..
                                                                 .   ........                                      246.79
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888....---.....-----........---........                               2,500.00

   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                    2 500. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix B 3.)
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                    25
   5. Harborof Refuge, Sandy Bay, Cape Ann, Massachusetts.-Thisbay is
situated at the northeastern extremity pf Cape Ann, Massachusests.
It is open to the full effect of easterly and northeasterly gales,
   The proposed improvement contemplates the construction of a
national harbor of refuge of the first class. The anchorage covered by
the proposed breakwater will contain 1,377 acres.
   No definite project for the masonry construction of the breakwater
above the rubble mound has been adopted. To the level of 22 feet below
mean low water it will consist of a mound of rubble-stone 40 feet wide
on top.
   The estimated cost of the improvement is $5,000,000.
   The total amount appropriated to date has been $200,000.
   The expenditures to June 30, 1888, were $194,125.24.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, 83,935 tons of rubble-
stone were deposited in the breakwater.
   The condition of the improvement on June 30, 1888, was as follows:
242,934 tons stone had been deposited, by which 2,200 running feet of
the substructure of the breakwater were essentially completed.
   The balance available July 1, 1888, $5,874.76, will beexpended in mak-
ing a survey of the substructure.
   To complete the project will require an appropriation of $4,800,000, of
which amount $100,000 could be expended to advantage during the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
   The prospective benefits to commerce and navigation by the construc-
tion of this harbor of refuge are increased safety to life and property
and a consequent reduction in freights and insurance.
July 1, 1887, amount available ...........                ............................               $75,916. 09
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 _....-.............                          $58, 571.09
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities....................                               11,470.24
                                                                                               -      70, 041.33

July 1, 1888, balance available....................                       ............ .........       5,874.76
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .                             ...... ............      100, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...... ............                             105,874.76

  Amouut (estimated) required for completion of existing project.----.-4,700, 000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal year ending June30,1890                            100, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix B 4.)
   6. Gloucester Harbor, Massachusetts.-The general project submitted
January 20, 1871, in compliance with the act of July 11, 1870, proposed
to clear the harbor of sunken rocks, and to build a stone breakwater
from Eastern Point to Round Rock Shoal. The operations in execution
of this general project, under the acts of July 11, 1870, and June 10, 1872,
have been confined solely to the removal of isolated sunken rocks, spe-
cially obstructive to the navigation of the inner harbor.
   The act of July 10, 1872, appropriated $10,000, which sum was ap-
plied to the removal of Clam Rock, Pinnacle Rock, rock off J. Friend's
Wharf, rock off Pew's Wharf, and a portion of Babson's Ledge.
   The act of August 5, 1886, appropriated $5,000 for a survey of the
harbor and for continuing work on Babson's Ledge. The survey was
completed in December, 1886, and a report and general project, based
on this survey, for the improvement of the harbor was published in the
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1887, page 500.
26        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $10,000 for " dredging Har-
bor Cove and removing ledge and bowlders obstructing approach to
the wharves between Harbor Cove and Pew's Wharf," which is a por-
tion of the general project before referred to. The officer in charge es-
timated that this part of the project would cost $65,000.
July 1, 1887, amount available......--- ---- ....---     -----...-----
                                               ......---..
                                                      ....---- ..............           3, 003. 29
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ...................           .....-....-....-.... .....     3,003.29



{Amount
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................

          (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........ 55, 000. 00
  Amount thatcan be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 20,000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                       10, 000. 00




   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix B 5.)
   7. Manchester Harbor, Massachusetts.-In compliance with the provis-
ions of the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, a preliminary ex-
amination and survey were made of Manchester Harbor. The result
of this survey was transmitted to Congress January 10, 1888, and
printed in House Ex. Doec. No. 85, Fiftieth Congress, first session. The
project proposed contemplates dredging a channel for a draught of 4
feet at mean low water from Proctor's Point to the town wharves, a
distance of 3,900 feet, and the removal of a portion of a ledge of rock at
Proctor's Point, at an estimated cost of $14,000.
  The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $2,500 for
this work, and $5,000 may be profitably expended in continuing it dur-
ing the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1F88.... ......            ..... ..........   $2,500. 00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project               -..     11,500. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890             5, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   8. Lynn Harbor, Massachusetts.-Theobject of this improvement is to
obtain a more direct, wider, and deeper channel of approach to the city
wharves. The original channels were narrow and crooked, and had but
6 feet depth at mean low water, and the greater part of the harbor
was bare at low water.
   The project was adopted in 1884. It proposed a channel 200 feet wide
and 10 feet deep at mean low water through the outer and inner bars.
The outer improved channel is 3,610 feet long; the inner one 6,450 feet.
It is supposed that the inner channel will need occasional dredging.
To aid in keeping the outer channel open a training-wall is proposed,
if experience shall show it to be necessary.. The cost of the project, as
revised in 1885, was $157,000. The total appropriations to date are
$66,000. The expenditures to June 30, 1888, were $65,962.60. During
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, a survey of the improved channels
was made, and it was found that they had suffered no serious deteriora-
tion and were essentially as at the date of the last annual report.
   The outer channel is now completed. The inner channel is 150 feet
wide, 10 feet deep at mean low water. No work has been done on the
training-wall, as it has not yet been found necessary.
   To complete the project would require an appropriation of $81,000.
   To extend the inner channel to the basin between the city wharves
would cost $25,000, a total of $106,000.  The training-wall isestimated
to cost $66,500
                     RIVER      AND IARBOR            IMPROVEMENTS                              27
  Twenty-four thousand dollars could be expended to advantage dur-
ing the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, in widening the inner channel
and its extension to the inner basin. Thei prospective benefits to com-
merce are increased facilities and safety to navigation.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..     ..     .......---.     ...---    .-..-........       $566. 86
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.-   .--.--    ------------
                                                ..-      ---------------                    529. 46

July 1, 1888, balance available         -..--...---     ; --.         ----.---.....           37. 40
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888............-............                   10, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889           ............-----.....   10, 037.40


  Amount hat can be protitablyexpended infiscal year ending June :30, 1890               24, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix B 6:)
   9. Winthrop Harbor, Massachusetts.-To comply with the provisions
of the river and harbor a ct of August 5, 1886, a preliminary examina-
tion and survey were made of Winthrop Harbor.
   A report of the results of the survey was transmitted to Congress
January 10, 1888, and printed as House Ex. Doec. No. 85, Fiftieth Con.
gress, first session.
   It is proposed to dredge a channel 3,900 feet long, 50 feet wide, and
6 feet deep, to connect Rice's Wharf with the back channel, in order
that vessels of light draught may reach Winthrop at all stages of tide,
by way of the Bird Island Channel, at an estimated cost of $17,600.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, contains an appropria-
tion of $1,000 for this work.
   It is estimated that $5,000 can be profitably expended during the fis-
cal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.---..........$.                            $1, 000.00
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........   16,600. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 5,000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   10. Boston Harbor, Massachusetts.-The object of this improvement
is, first, to preserve the harbor by protecting the islands and headlands;
and, second, to improve it by widening, straightening, and deepening
the channels.
   The projects adopted for this purpose since 1866 have been mainly in
accordance with the recommendations of the United States commis-
sioners, whose labors terminated during that year. .The works of
preservation consist of sea-walls, aprons, jetties, etc., which protect the
shores of the islands and headlands, prevent additional wash into the
channels, control the tidal scour, and preserve the full height of anchor-
age shelter for vessels in the roadsteads. Such have been built or re-
paired at Point Allerton and the islands of Great Brewster, Lovell,
Gallop, Long, Deer, Rainsford, George's, and Castle.
    The works of improvement have been by dredging and blasting, by
which means many dangerous rocks and shoals have been removed,
and the main ship-channel enlarged from 100 feet wide and 18 feetdeep
at mean low water, so that it now is at least 600 feet wide and 23 feet
deep at mean low water.
    The following tributary channels have also been improved:
    1. Charles River.-The natural channel of this river has been widened,
28           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

straightened, and deepened, so that from its mouth up to Western
Avenue Bridge, a distance of 44 miles, the channel has a width of 200
feet and a depth of 7 feet at-mean low water; thence to Arsenal Street
Bridge, 24 miles, the channel has a least width of 80 feet and a least
depth of 6 feet.
   2. Fort Point Channel.-This important branch of the main ship-chan-
nel originally had a least depth of 12 feet at its entrance, and the
channel was narrow and crooked. It has been widened to 175-feet
and deepened to 23 feet at mean low water from its mouth to Congress
Street Bridge, a distance of 1,900 feet.
   3. Hinghiam Harbor.-(See separate report.)
   4. Nantasket Beach Channel. The project adopted in 1880 was to widen
and deepen the channel so that it would be at least 100 feet wide and
94 feet deep at mean low water. The project was completed in 1881 and
1883.
   5. Channel between Nix's Mate and Long Island.-This channel had
originally 44 feet depth at mean low water. A cut has been made
through the bar 200 feet wide, 550 feet long, and 12 feet deep at mean
low water.
   This improved channel has proved to be of great convenience to the
local commerce, and should be widenedto 300 feet and deepened to 15
feet, mean low water, and its axis slightly changed.
   6. Broad Sound.-An obstruction called " Barrel Rock" was removed
in 1869.
   The total apppropriations to date for this harbor have been, since
187, $1,663,750.
   The expenditures to June 30, 1888, were $1,654,020.74 (inclusive of
outstanding liabilities).
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, 65,576 cubic yards of mate-
rial were dredged from the " Lower Middle" Shoal-and 3,430 cubic yards
from the Narrows. The dredging at the "Lower Middle" uncovered three
small ledges, and a contract for their removal was executed, under
which work will be commenced early in July, 1888. When this contract
is c'ompleted the channel here will be 1,000 feet wide.       Six hundred
and seventeen running feetof the coping course were reset at the Great
Brewster sea-wall, and minor repairs made to the Deer Island sea-walls.
   The several works of improvement are in good order and show no seri-
ous deterioration.
   The existing works of preservation are generally in good order, but
some of them require repairs and extensions.
   The balance available July 1, 1888, will be expended in removing the
small ledges uncovered by the dredging at the " Lower Middle."
   The benefits to be derived from. the proposed expenditure are addi-
tional safety and convenience to the commerce of this important harbor.
  The amounts recommended by the officer in charge for expenditure for
improvements in Boston Harbor, Massachusetts, during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1890, are as follows:
Extension of sea-wall:
                                                                  ..........--...--.--..-
    George's Island-------...................------------- ....----                           --...--....----....   $10, 000
    Gallop's Island . ........ .....                     ... ........      ....         ....
                                                                                     ......   .......---             15,000
Extension, etc., of sea-wall at Long Island ...... .....                              .......... .... ...             3, 000
Sea-walls at south and east bluffs of Governor's Island ......................                                           80, 000
Widening main ship-channel at the "Upper Middle"           ....        -........                           .....--.     250, 000
Completing Fort Point Channel .................     --- -..----....       -..                           ......        . 60, 000
Widening and deepening Nix's Mate Channel.----...... .--         . .- -.....-                                  ...--.    25,000
Survey of main ship-channel east of Long Island Head..---. ---..--...--..                                               6,000
       Total...... ..... ..          ......      ... ..................           ....... ........ ....             449, 000
                       RIVER       AND      HARBOR         IMPROVEMENTS.                                29
July 1, 1887, amount available .---- - - -----                 .
                                                           - ---..                         .    $34,718. 42
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 187 .......---------- -- ------- -.              3, 396. 04
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities........ ..-....---.---.             ---.    1,587. 12
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts..... ---...                     6 600. 00
                                                                                      --         31, 583.16


July 1, 1888, balance available..--..----........-........---.....----..-----.....--.....----      3, 129.26
Amount appropriated by act of Agust 11, 1888......                    .......... .....---     .. 125, 000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889....................                       128,129.26


  Amount that can be protitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 200, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix B 7.)
  11. Malden River, Massachusetts.-The object of the improvement is
to increase the width and depth of the river channel from its mouth to
the second bridge in Malden.
  Previously to the improvement there was a navigable depth of barely
7 feet at mean high water. The mean rise or fall of the tide is 9.8 feet.
  The project originally proposed in 1880 was to excavate a channel 100
feet wide, 12 feet deep at mean high water, up to the second bridge in
Maiden, with two " cut-offs," one east of the island, near the mouth of
the river, and one through the marsh, about one-half mile above.
   This project was modified in 1882. It was then proposed to improve
the natural channel of the river, so that it would be 100 feet wide, 12
feet deep at mean high water to the first bridge at Malden, and thence
to the second bridge 75 feet wide, with the same depth.
  The cost of the original project was estimated to be $40,000.
  The total appropriations for this work are $10,000.
  The expenditures to June 30, 1888, were $10,000. No work was done
during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
  The channel of the river has a least width of 50 feet (70 feet at turns),
with a depth of 12 feet at mean high water from its mouth to the first
bridge in Malden.
  There is no balance available July 1, 1888.
   The improved channel is in good order.
   No appropriation is recommended for the year ending June 30, 1890.
  To complete the project it is estimated will cost $37,000.
   (See Appendix B 8.)
   12. Hingham Harbor, Massachusetts.-The object of the work is to
widen and deepen the natural channel, which was 30 feet wide and 4
feet deep, so that it will be 100 feet wide and 10 feet deep at mean low
water.
   The project was originally proposed in 1874 and was modified in 1885.
The original project was estimated to cost $11,000. The project of 1885
was to cost an additional sum of $18,750.
   The total amount appropriated has been $16,000. The amount ex-
pended to June 30, 1888, was $16,000.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, no operations were in
progress.
   The channel is now 100 feet wide and 8 feet deep throughout, and at
the ledge, where operations have been in progress under the modified
project, the channel is 10 feet deep at mean low water in a cut through
the ledge 50 feet wide.
30         REPORT OF THE                CHIEF         OF ENGINEERS,                    U. 8.             ARM Y.

   To completethe present project will require an appropriation of $8,000,
all of which could be expended to advantage during the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1890.
   No balance is available July 1, 1888.
   The prospective benefits to commerce are increased facilities and
safety to navigation.
.July 1, 1887, amount available ......-- .            .                   .--------......
                                                          .......----------------                                   $76.74
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of .4abflities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ............-------...----.---  --..........-..--..-...--.......---.                      76. 74
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .                      -.......... ......             .. ..    .    5,000.00

 (Aaount (estimated) required for completion of existing project. -----                                           8,, 00.000
  Amountthat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1390                                       8, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and har-
    bor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix B 9.)
   13. Scituate Harbor,Massachusetts.--This harbor is on the west shore
of Massachusetts Bay, about 14 miles south of Boston Light.
   The object of the improvement is to create a harbor of refuge for ves-
sels bound to Boston from the eastward, which are too far south of their
true course to clear the dangerous ledges near Minot's Ledge light.
   Originally the harbor had a low-water area of about 57 acres, more
than 6 acres of which had a depth of at least 3 feet at mean low water.
It was entirely open to the action of easterly gales, and its entrance
was obstructed by sunken bowlders.
   The project adopted in 1880 is to build two breakwaters, one from
t" Cedar Point " on the north side of the entrance, and the other from the
'" First Cliff" on the south side; and to dredge the area inclosed, and'in
front of the entrance.
   The estimated cost of the improvement is $290,000.
   The total appropriations to date are $47,500.
   The expenditures to June 30, 1888, were $47,500.
   No operations were in progress during the fiscal year ending June
30, 1888.
   The condition of the improvement is as follows: The north break-
water is essentially completed. Nothing has been done on the south
breakwater. The entrance channel is 1,600 feet long, 100 feet wide, and
5 feet deep, at mean low water. The anchorage basin is 350 by 450
feet in area, 7 feet deep at mean low water.
    No balauce is available July 1, 1888.
   To complete the improvement will require an appropriation of
$242,500.
    During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, $25,000 could be ex-
pended to advantage in commencing the south breakwater, and in en-
larging the anchorage basin and the channel to the town wharves. The
prospective benefits to commerce by the completion of this improvement
are the creation of an. additional harbor of refuge on this much-
frequented, dangerous coast.
July 1, 1887, amount available...................--....--......-----......-----......------                        $474.72
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
      outstanding July 1, 1887          ...........   ............               _.............-......              474.72

Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888............        - - - - ....- ...
                                             - - - - - - - - - -......          - -.                              5, 000. 00
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....-------.... 2',7, 500. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 25, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix B 10.)
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                  31
   14. Plymouth Harbor, Mlfassachusetts.-Plymouth Harbor is 30 miles
south of Boston. The object of its improvement is to perpetuate the har-
bor by the preservation of Long. Beach, which forms it, and to deepen
and widen the channels of approach to an enlarged anchorage basin in
in front of the town wharves.
   The various devices employed for the preservation of Long Beach are
described in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for the year
1877.
   The original project for improvement was adopted in 1875, and modi-
fied in 1877 and 1884. The modified project proposed an improved
channel 2,286 feet long, 150 feet wide, and 9 feet deep at mean low
water; leading to an anchorage basin 866 feet long, 150 feet wide, and
9 feet deep, at mean low water.
   From 1866 to'date $114,800 have been appropriated for this harbor.
The expenditures to June 30, 1888, were:
For beach protection ..........--      ............        ............................                        $72, 587.56
For dredging, etc.....---..--..--....--......--..---......... ............-----......                           42, 212. 44
             -------.............. ......
       Total ......                                   ..     ...........---               .......   ........   114,800.00

   During the fiscal year 8,312 cubic yards were dredged from the im-
proved channel and basin. The channel is 115 feet wide and 9 feet deep
at mean low water; the basin is 800 feet long, 9 feet deep for 90 feet of
its width, nearest the town wharves, with an average of 5 feet deep for
the remainder.
   A survey of the improvement made in June, 1888, showed no deteri-
oration sinc* operations were suspended in July, 1887.
   Long Beach is in good order throughout.
   No balance is available July 1, 1888.
   To complete the present project will cost $9,500.
   The prospective benefits to commerce are increased facilities and safety
to navigation.
July 1, 1887, amount available .-.....--..-.                   ..
                                             -- ... .....-....--       ..--.... ......                         $2, 957. 39
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 .----............    ....... ...... -- ...... .... ......---                          2, 957.39
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, l88             ..... .........--...-....                               6, 000.00


  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                    9, 500. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix B 11.)
   15. Wellfleet Harbor, Massachusetts.-To comply with the require-
mients of the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, a preliminary ex-
amination and survey were made of Wellfleet Harbor, Cape Cod Bay.
A report of the results of the survey was transmitted to Congress Jan-
nary 10, 1888, and printed in House Ex. Doe. No. 85, Fiftieth Congress,
first session.
   The proposed improvement contemplates the connection of the inner
harbor, known as the Deep Hole Anchorage,with the wharves at Well-
fleet by the excavation of a channel 4,200 feet long, 100 feet wide at
bottom, and 6 feet deep at mean low water, at an estimated cost of
$24,000.
   Previous work at this harbor, consisting of the removal of several
dangerous rocks, was completed in 1873 under appropriation of $5,000
made by river and harbor act of June 10, 1872.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $7,000 for
32        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,. U. S. ARMY.

this work. It is estimated that $10,000 can be profitably expended dur-
ing the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888            .........................               $7,000.00


  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 10,000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  16. Provincetown Harbor, iMiassachusetts.-This is one of the most val-
uable harbors of refuge on the Atlantic coast, and its existence depends
entirely on the preservation of the sandy beaches inclosing it.
  The project for its improvement was adopted in 1866 and modified in
1869, 1872, and 1873. It consists in the construction of detached bulk-
heads of wood and stone, jetties of wood and brush, dikes, sand-catches,
and the extensive planting of beach grass, which has been remarkably
successful.
   From June, 1864, the allotments and appropriations for this harbor
have been $139,478.44.
   The amount expended to June, 1888, was $139,328.09.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, a wood and brush sand-
catch, 232 feet long, was built on Long Point, near Wood End Light;
the sand-catch near Abel Hill Dike was strengthened and enlarged, and
about 5 acres of marsh grass were planted on House Point Island Flats.
   At the date of this report all the works of preservation are in good
order.
  The balance available July 1, 1888, will be expended in examinations,
etc.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, $2,500 could be expended
to advantage in the repair of probable storm damages to the beaches.
  The prospective benefit to commerce is the preservation of an impor-
tant harbor of refuge.
July 1, 1887, amount available ...- .............        .....................                   $2, 144.04
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ................................ ................                      1, 993. 69
July 1, 1888, balance available ......      ..........      .....         ............   .....      150. 35
Amout appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.............._.............                          7, 000.00


 {Amount
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.....................

          (estimated) required for completion of existing project---------2,500.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                             2, 500.00
                                                                                                  7,150.35




    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix B 12.)

EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS FOR IMPROVEMENT, TO COMPLY WITH
  REQUIREMENTS OF THE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT OF AUGUST 5, 1886.

  It appearing, after preliminary examination by the local engineer,
that the localities were worthy of improvement, Lieut. Col. Gillespie
was charged with and completed the following surveys, the results of
which were transmitted to Congress and printed in House Ex. Doc. No.
85, Fiftieth Congress, first session.
  1. Manchester Harbor, Massachusetts.-(See also Appendix B 13.)
  2. Winthrop Harbor, Massachusetts.-(See also Appendix B 14.)
  3. Duxbury Harbor, Massachusetts.-(See also Appendix B 15.)
  4. Wellfleet Harbor, Massachusetts.-(See also Appendix B 16.)
                        RIVER       AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                      33
IMPROVEMIENT OF HARBORS AND RIVERS ON THE SOUTHERN COAST OF
       MASSACHUSETTS AND IN                     RHODE ISLAND AND CONNECTICUT.

   Officer in charge, Maj. W. R. Livermore, Corps of Engineers, with
Lieut. T. L. Casey, Corps of Engineers, under his immediate orders since
October 26, 1887.
   1. Harborqf Refuge at Hyannis,Massachusetts.-Thisharbor before im-
provetent was an open roadstead exposed to southerly storms. In the
years 1827-'38 a breakwater of riprap granite 1,170 feet long was con-
structed, covering an anchorage of about 175 acres, the entrance to
which has a depth of about 151 feet. Between the years 1852 and 1882
extensive repairs were made in increasing the width of its base and the
size of the stone forming its sides and top.
   The depth of water inside the breakwater is insufficient for many ves-
sels that seek the harbor for refuge, and the present approved project
contemplates dredging the area protected by the breakwater to a depth
of 15 feet at mean low water, at an estimated cost of $45,743.20. Con-
gress made an appropriation of $10,000 therefor in the act of August 5,
1886.
   The amount previously expended on this work up to June 30, 1887,
was 124,163.18, with which the breakwater had been completed accord-
ing to the original project and the subsequent plans for strengthening
it. The amount expended during the last fiscal year, including out-
standing liabilities, was $3,724.19 (making a total of $127,887.37 ex-
pended to June 30, 1888). The result has been the increase of the 15k-
foot anchorage area protected by the breakwater by about 6.9 acres.
   The amount available and the appropriation of $20,000 asked for is
to be applied to extending the 15k-foot anchorage area.
July 1, 1887, amount available---------............--......------          .----.......----...----..------. $9, 194. 40
July 1,    1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887......- ..............                          $3, 369. 11
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities .            .. ....   ..... .....     .   ... .        355. 08
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts...........                              5,449. 39
                                                                                                     -     9, 173. 58

                                      -
July 1, 1888, balance available---....... .......... ......... ..... .... .                                     20.82
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                                   10, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30.1889....................                                  10, 020. 82

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--.......
                                                                 0
                                                                                                         25,632. 00
  Amount that can beprofitably expeudedin fiscal year ending June3 , 1890                                20,000, 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections                          2 of    river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix C 1.)
   2. Harbor of Refuge at Nantucket, Mllassachusetts.-This harbor is the
only one between the harbors of Martha's Vineyard (Vineyard Haven
and Edgartown) and Provincetown, a distance of about 100 miles, except
the small harbor of Hyannis, on the north side of Nantucket Sound.
It has deep water inside, and the object of the improvement is to make
it a harbor of refuge for vessels plying between ports north and south
of Cape Cod.
   Before the commencement of the present work there was a shoal
about 1. miles in width outside the entrance, through which the chan-
nel or line of best water was only about 6 feet deep, and very crooked,
and subject to changes in location.
   The present approved project is to construct jetties of riprap stone,
projecting from either side of the present entrance to the harbor, for
       ENG 88--3
34        REPORT        OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

the purpose of concentrating the strength of the tidal currents, and
excavating a channel of 15 feet depth, by scour, and at the places
where the full depth required will not be reached by this means, to
complete the work by dredging.
   The amount expended on this project up to the close of the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1887, was $111,531.77, and the result was the construc-
tion of the west jetty to a point 3,955 feet from the shore, and the east
jetty to a distance of 330 feet from the initial point on the shore, and
partially for an additional distance of 50 feet.
   The amount expended during the last fiscal year, including outstand-
ing liabilities, was $7,618.92 (making a total of $119,150.69 expended to
June 30, 1888). The construction of the east jetty was continued and
fully completed to a distance of about 385 feet from the initial point on
the shore, and the foundation was laid and the jetty partially completed
for an additional distance of 200 feet. The improvement in the depth
of water noted as having followed the construction of the west jetty is
still maintained.
   The amount asked for, $50,000, is to be applied to the further exten-
sion of the east jetty.
July 1, 1887, amount available.........   ...................................               $13, 468.23
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ..............                ..... .... $6, 926.68
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ...          ...........          .......     692. 24
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts...........                    5, 849. 31
                                                                                              13, 468.23

Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.........................                        20, 000.00

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-                      - .   2 :30, 000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                  50, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix C 2.)
   3. Harborat Vineyard Haven, Massachusetts.-Thisis a new work. A.
survey was made in compliance with the requirements of the river and
harbor act of August 5, 1886.
   The proposed project contemplates increasing its anchorage capacity,
the dredging of the shoals which occupy a large portion of it, to a depth
of 15 feet, and for completion of the protection of the harbor in north-
westerly storms, the construction of a breakwater extending from a point
nearly opposite to the West Chop to a point northeasterly from the
East Chop, with jetties projecting from either chop, etc., the width
of the western entrance to be 1,000 feet with a least depth of 25 feet at
mean low water, at an estimated cost of $3,983,956.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, contains an appropria-
tion of $25,000 for this work, and $250,000 may be profitably expended
in continuing it during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...               ....   .. ...............     $25, 000.00

  A mount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ...... 3, 958, 956. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
    30, 1890 ............................................... ............                    250, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river
    and harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     4. Wood's Boll Harbor, MIassachusetts.-Before improvement the site
of the present works was a submerged point of land extending from the
shore of the harbor. The adopted project for the improvement of the
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                         35
    Great Harbor, Wood's Holl, was for the construction of retaining-walls
    on the shore, a hollow pier and wharves for the use of the United States
    Fish Commission, and to serve also as a coaling station for vessels of the
    Revenue Marine and other branches of the public service, and as a har-
    bor of refuge, also for the removal of dangerous rocks from the strait of
    Wood's Holl.
       A supplemental project for dredging in the rear of the coal-wharf ex-
    tension to afford a berth for public vessels was approved November 27,
    1885.
       The amount expended on these works up to June 30, 1887, was
    $91,955.50. The retaining and pier walls, all the wharves, except a
    small amount of planking on coal wharf extension, the dredging of the
    interior of the hollow pier, the berths for vessels, and in rear of coal
    wharf extension had been completed, and the dangerous rocks in the
    straits removed.
      The amount expended during the last fiscal year, including liabilities
    outstanding June 30, 1888, was $451.16, (making a total of $92,406.66
    expended to June 30, 1888). The remainder of the planking was placed
    upon the coal-wharf and the project completed.
    July 1, 1887, amount available.................................... ......    $451.16
    July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
      outstanding July 1, 1887-.
                              ..-.-.......................      ..      .    .   451.16
       (See Appendix C 3.)
        5. Wareham Harbor, Massachusetts.-The object of the improvement
    is to deepen and widen the channel leading from Buzzard's Bay to
    Wareham. The commerce of Wareham is carried on in sailing-vessels,
    and the channel is to be made a beating channel for such vessels. An-
    other object of the improvement is the raising of Long Beach.
        Before improvement, the ruling depth in the harbor was about 7 feet
    at mean low water, in a narrow and very crooked channel. Long Beach,
    a narrow sand-spit at the mouth of the harbor, was washed and abraded
    by the waves and currents at high water, and the material was car-
    ried into and shoaled the channel inside.
        The original approved project of 1871, for the improvement, and its
    subsequent modifications, provides for a channel 250 feet wide and 10
    feet deep at mean low water from Barney's Point down to the entrance
    to the harbor. Above Barney's Point the width of the channel is to be
    350 feet, with the same depth-10 feet-as below that point. The plan
    includes also the raising and strengthening of Long Beach, of which a
     large portion was submerged at low water, to carry it above the storm
     waves and currents and to hold it there, in order to prevent the filling
    of the improved channel above by material abraded from the beach.
        The total amount expended on the improvement up to the close of the
    fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, including outstanding liabilities at that
      late, was $69,704.14, and the result was that the channel in the upper
    part of the harbor in front of the wharves was carried to its full width
    and completed, and the eastern half of the second and third reaches
    below the wharves, and one-fourth of the fourth reach, which extends
    to Barney's Point, were deepened to 10 feet at mean low water. The
    channel for about one-half its width from Barney's Point to Wareham
    has been deepened to 10 feet. Long Beach has been raised above high-
    water storm-tides, so that the wash of sand into the improved channel
    inside the beach has been stopped.
       The ruling depth of the approaches to Wareham has been increased
/   from 7 to 0 feet, and the channel greatly widened in all the reaches.
36         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U: S. ARMY.

Vessels of larger draught can be carried to Wareham than formerly.
The increase in width of channel was a great help to all vessels in beat-
ing in and out of the harbor.
   The amount expended during the last fiscal year, including outstand-
ing liabilities June 30, 1888, was $2,320.49 (making a total of $72,024.63
expended to June 30, 1888), and the result was the further widening of
the eastern half of the fourth reach below the wharves.
   It is proposed to apply the balanc. on hand July 1, 1888, and the
amount asked for ($4,000) towards the completion of the channel from
the deep water above Long Beach to Wareham, and the further building
up of Long Beach.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..........................................                      $10,295.96
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 .......................                     $1, 816. 50
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..............                   ...........     503.99
July 1, 1888, amouut covered by existing contracts ...........                       7,975.47
                                                                                                10, 295. 96
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ..........                                        4.............
                                                                                                4,000. 00


  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                   12, 300.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix C 4.)
  6. New Bedford Harbor, iMassachusetts.-To comply with the require-
ments of the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, a preliminary
examination and survey were made of New Bedford Harbor.
   A report of the results of the survey was transmitted to Congress,
January 10, 1888, and printed in House Ex. Doc. No. 86, Fiftieth Con-
gress, first session.
   It is proposed to excavate a channel 200 feet wide and 18 feet deep,
at an estimated cost of $35,000.
  The sum of $20,000, appropriated by acts of March 3, 1875, and August
14, 1876, for this harbor, wasexpended in dredging. No work has been
done since 1878.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, contains an appropri-
ation of $10,000 for the harbor, and the sum of $20,000 may be lrotita-
bly expended in continuinuing the improvement during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1890.


{Amount
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.......................... $10, 000.00

          (estimated) required for completion of existing project........
  Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal year ending June 30,1890
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                               25,000.00
                                                                                               20,000.00
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  7. Westport Harbor, Massachusetts.-The object of the improvement is
to prevent the washing away of Horse Neck Point and the filling of the
channel by the eroded sand.
  Before the commencement of the improvement the site of the present
work was a point of sand forming the northern and eastern boundary
of the entrance to the harbor and subject to erosion by the sea and tides.
The approved project is to construct wooden jetties, filled with stone, at
the end of Horse Neck Point, to stop the wearing of this point; the
number and spacing of the jetties to depend on the price at which the
work is let.
The available funds were sufficient to construct but one jetty. Work
                       RIVER       AND     HARBOR           IMPROVEMENTS.                                37
was commenced June 22, 1857, and was completed July 28, 1887.                                           No
further work is proposed.
  The total expenditure has been $1,000.
July 1, 1887, amount available.............---         ......   ..............   ......   .....--.   $890.66
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities out-
  standing July 1, 1887...------.....----......----..................--........----......--.          890.66
   (See Appendix C 5.)
   8. Taunton Rivr, Zllassachusetts.-The object of the improvement is
to deepen and widen the channel leading to the city of Taunton, at the
head of navigation, so that vessels of 11 feet draught can reach the city
at high water.
   In its original condition the channel was narrow and obstructed by
bowlders, and from Berkley Bridge to Taunton the depth was not, in
places, more than 5 feet at mean high water. A vessel of 30 tons bur-
den was as large as could go up to Taunton.
   The approved project of 1871 and its subsequent modifications pro-
vide for a channel 60 feet wide and 11 feet deep from weir bridge to
the ship-yard; a channel 80 feet wide (100 fret at the bends) and 11 feet
deep from the ship-yard down to and through the Needles and Brigg's
Shoal; thence to Berkley Bridge a channel of the same width and 12
feet deep, and from Berkley Bridge to the deep water at Dighton the
channel was to be 100 fret wide and 12 feet deep. The depths are es-
timated from high water. The ledge which crosses the bottom of the
river at Peter's Point, and the numerous bowlders which lay on the
bottom and sides of the channel from Taunton to Dighton, were to be
removed. The amount expended on the improvement of the river up
to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, was $153,618.35.
    With the exception that but 40 feet of the 60 feet of width could be
dredged between the bridge at Weir and the ship-yard, on account of
interfering with private property, and that the hardness and depth of
material at the sides, the 80-foot channel was not in all cases dredged
to its full width, the channel down to Berkley Bridge had been com-
pleted. The channel as proposed between Berkley Bridge and Digh-
ton had been completed, with the exception of a small amount of diedg
ing and the removal of the bowlders. The channel had been cleared
of bowlders from Taunton down to Berkley Bridge. The work of re-
moval of the ledge at Peter's Point had been completed. The material
blasted in the channel had been dredged and deposited in the form of
.a half-tide dam running from Reuben's Island to the west shore of the
river, with the view of accelerating the current in the dredged channel
.off and above Dighton, and preventing delosits in this part of the chan-
nel.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year to .Tune 30, 1888, includ-
ing outstanding liabilities, was $3,317.59, making a total expenditure
of $ 156,935.94 to June 30, 1888. The results were the completion of
the channel as proposed between Berkley Bridge and Dighton, with
the exception of a small amount of ledge rock uncovered in dredging
below Peter's Point, leaving the channel above Berkley Bridge as at
the beginning of the fiscal year, as stated above. Vessels of 11 feet
draught can now reach Taunton, at the head of navigation.
   There remains to complete the existing project, widening and deep-
cuning at a few points. A map of a survey of parts of Taunton River,
with report thereon and prqject for further improvement, were sub-
mitted to Congress January                  10,
                                   1888, and printed as House Ex. Doe.
No. 86, Fiftieth Congress, first session.
38          RE'PORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The estimated cost of this additional improvement is $14,051.
July 1, 1887, amount available-......---.... ...     ..... ...... ..... .... ....          $3, :381. 6
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 .----..----..
                                       .... ........  .. .. ...... .............            3, 317. 59
July 1, 1888, balance available.............. ................              ............        64.06
   (See Appendix C 6.)
   9. Warren River, Rhode Island.--Warren River is an arm of Narra-
gansett Bay north of -the harbor of Bristol. No appropriation for its
improvement had been made until by the act approved August 5, 1886,
Congress appropriated $5,000 for the purpose. The obstructions to
navigation were a rocky reef below Little Island and a submerged
bowlder near mid-channel opposite the lower wharves of the town of
Warren. The approved project provided for the removal of these ob-
structions as far as could be done with an expenditure of $5,000.
  The submerged bowlder was removed and an area of about 1.8 acres
extending 550 feet along the narrowest part of the channel was cleared
of the projecting points of ledge and bowlders between the months of
August and November, 1887.
  This completed the improvement as far as projected.
July 1, 1887, amount available .......... ................. ......     ..... $4,969.50
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 .....................................          ... ......        4,699. 39

July 1, 1888, balance available........................................                        270. 11
   (See Appendix C 7,)
   10. Pawtucket River, Rhode Island.-Before improvement the channel
in the river had a ruling depth of about 5 feet at mean low water.
   The original project for its improvement provided for a channel 75
feet wide and 7 feet deep at mean low water. This project was com-
pleted between the years 1868-1876.
   The approved project of 1883 provides for the excavation by dredging
of a channel 100 feet wide and 12 feet deep at mean low water from the
deep water above Red Bridge to the ledge opposite Grant & Co.'s Wharf
at Pawtucket; thence the excavation by blasting of a channel through
the ledge to Pawtucket Bridge of the same depth and 40 feet wide.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $110,969.70. The chan-
nel had been excavated under the original project to a width of 75 feet
and a ruling depth of 7 feet at mean low water, and under the project
as modified in 1883 a new channel 12 feet deep and 100 feet wide, with
wide enlargements at the bends, had been carried from its mouth at the
deep water just above Red Bridge, a distance of about 9,940 feet, to a
point about 2,200 feet above a line drawn from Bucklin's Island to Swan
Point Wharf.
   The amount expended during the last fiscal year to June 30,1888, in-
cluding outstanding liabilities, was $20,160.29 (making a total expendi-
ture of $131,129.99, to June 30, 1888), and the result is the extension of
the channel about 2,800 feet up the river.
   This completed portion of the channel is already a great benefit to the
commerce of the river ; a ruling depth of about 6 feet can be carried from
the upper end of our present work to Pawtucket.
   The work yet to be done is to excavate by dredging the channel 12
feet deep and 100 feet wide from Bass Rock to a point opposite Grant
& Co.'s Wharf, and from thence to Pawtucket Bridge to deepen the chan-
nel through the ledge to the same depth with a width of 40 feet.
  With the $50,000 asked for it is proposed to extend this channel far.
ther up the river.
                         RIVER AND             HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                             39'
July 1, 1887, amount available ......       ........... .. ...... .... ...... ...... $21,036.26
July 1, 1883, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ..........................----..............----...        20,160.29
July 1, 1888, balance available ......................----...........--                      --.            875.97
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888--..----......                       ..........---....    35, 000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30,1889 ....................                              35,875. 97

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 367, 500. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 50,000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix C 8.)
   11. Providence River and NarragansettBay, Rhode Island.-The object
of this improvement is to furnish a wide and deep channel for foreign
and coastwise commerce from the ocean to Providence.
   Before the improvement of the river was commenced in 1853 many
shoals obstructed naviga:Ion, and at one point in the channel, a place
called 6"The Crook," the available low-water depth was but 42 feet.
There was expended between 1852 and the 30th June, 1882, $290,459.34
in deepening the channel, first to 9 feet, then to 12 feet, then to 14 feet,
and again to 23 feet, as the increasing sizes of vessels and the growing
commerce of Providence demanded. Bulkhead Rock was also removed
(luring this period to a depth of 20 feet below mean low water.
    The approved project of 1878, modified in 1882, under which the work
is now in progress, provides for a channel 25 feet deep and 300 feet
wide, suitable for large ocean vessels, extending from Fox Point, in the
city of Providence, to the deep water of Narragansett Bay, and for an
anchorage basin between Fox and Field's Points, 300 feet wide, at a
depth of 25 feet; 600 feet wide, at a depth of 20 feet; 725 feet wide, at
a depth of 18 feet; 940 feet wide, at a depth of 12 feet; 1,06i0 feet wide,
at a depth of 6 feet.
    The amount expended on the present project up to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, was $222,836.68. At that date about
one-half of the excavation required for the anchorage basin above Field's
Point had been done, Bulkhead Rock had been removed, and the 25-
foot channel, 300 feet wide, from Providence to the deep water of Nar-
ragansett Bay, had been completed.
    The amount expended during the last fiscal year to June 30, 1888, in-
cluding outstanding liabilities, was $19,762.92 (making a total of
 $242,599.60 expended to June 30, 1888). The result was the comple-
tion of the excavation of the 20-foot anchorage area in the Fox Point
Reach and about ono-fourth of the same area in the Sassafras Point
Reach.
    There is required for the completion of the existing project the exca-
vation of the remainder of the anchorage basin between Fox and Field's
points.
   With the amount available and the $100,000 asked for it is proposed
to enlarge the anchorage area.
July 1, 1887, amount available..--.............-----..----..--............----------...........        $20, 763.95
July. 1, 188s, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                                  ...---------...--..--....-----............
   outstanding July 1, 187 .-------.----                                                                   19,762. 92
                                                                                ----...---.....--..-----.....

July 1, 1888, balance available ....................       ............... ..........                   1,001.03
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ..................              .......                  40, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 18-9 ...............                                  41,001.03
40        REPORT OF THE CHIEF                  OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......-$165,000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 100,000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix C 9.)
   12. Removal of Green Jacket Shoal, Providence River, Rhode Island.-
This shoal is in that part of Providence River which constitutes the
harbor of Providence. It lies off the wharves on the south front of the
city, and occupies a part of the harbor that is required for anchorage
purposes, covering an area of about 18 acres between the 15-foot curves.
   The adopted project is the removal of the entire shoal to a depth of
25 feet at mean low water, limiting the work by lines drawn 200 feet
from the harbor lines.
   The amount expended during the last fiscal year, including outstand-
ing liabilities, to June 30, 1888, was $24,388.13 (making a total expen-
diture of $25,155.60 to June 30, 1888), and the result was the excava-
tion of an area of about 9{ acres on the western side of the shoal to a
depth of 25 feet at mean low water, making an important addition to
the anchorage facilities of Providence Harbor. With the amount avail-
able and that asked for, it is proposed to continue the removal of the
shoal as far as possible.
July 1, 1887, amount available ......             _........ ... ....   .....   ............             $25, 482.53
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.. .... .... .... . ...__........ ............                                 24, 388. 13

July 1, 1888, balance available .-- ........ ........ ........                 ......          ......     1, 094.40
Amount appropriated lby act of August 11, 188 ......      ..........                    .........        28, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                29, 094.40

  Amount that can be profitably expendedinfiscal year ending June 30,1890- 30, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix C 10.)
   13. Newport Harbor, Rhode Island.-Before improvement the capacity
of the inner harbor was limited by shoals, and it was not adequate to
the number and size of the vessels seeking it for refuge. The southern
or main entrance was obstructed by a bar which stretched out from
Goat Island, and the general business wharves of the city could not be
reached at low tide by vessels drawing more than 8 feet.
   The original project and its subsequent modifications under which
work is now carried on are substantially as follows:
   Deepening the southern entrance to 15 feet at mean low water, cut-
ting away a portion of the spit which stretches out from the southerly
end of Goat Island to the same depth, and constructing a jetty on the
southwest shore of the island to arrest the drift of littoral sand and
gravel into the entrance of the harbor; deepening to 13 feet at mean
low water the area included between the 13-foot curve on the west, a
line drawn from the southwest corner of Perry Mill Wharf to Lime Rock
on the south, the harbor line on the east, and a line drawn parallel to
and 50 feet from the city wharf on the north; deepening to 10 feet at
mean low water the area northwest of a line drawnfrom Lime Rock
through the spindle, which is in the southeast part of the harbor, and
excavating a channel 10 feet deep at mean low water along and out-
side the harbor line south to a point opposite the gas company's wharf.
Also the excavation of a channel 750 feet wide and 15 feet deep at
mean low water around and to the eastward of the dolphin, which marks
                       RIVER       AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                        41
the Goat Island Spit, cutting away the spit to a depth of 15 feet at
mean low water northward to a line drawn from the dolphin to clear the
permanent dock at Fort Adams by 100 feet, and the construction of ad-
ditional jetties on the western shore of Goat Island.
   The amount expended up to the close of the fiscal year ending June
30, 1887, was $107,563.87, with the following results:
   Of the area to be dredged to 13 feet within the harbor about nine-
tenths had been completed, except at a few places in the northern part
of the harbor, where the material was found too hard for the dredge in
use at the time. The channel along and outside the harbor line south
to a point opposite the gas company's wharf and the 15-foot channel,
750 feet wide, around and to the eastward of the dolphin on Goat
IslandSpit, had been completed, with the exception of a strip along
the western edge and to the north of the dolphin. The increase of
width to be made between the 15-foot curves at the southern entrance
by dredging in the slpit south of Goat Island had been completed. Of
the total area to be deepened within the harbor (about 90 acres) about
two-thirds have been completed. The berth for vessels at the quar-
termaster's wharf at Fort Adams was deepened to 10 feet at mean low
water, and the effectual stopping for the present of the supply of lit-
toral sand and gravel from the outside of Goat Island into the southern
entrance by the jetty on the southwest shore of the island. The south-
ern entrance is completed for vessels of 15 feet draught.
    The amount expended during the last fiscal year to June 30, 1883, in-
eluding outstanding liabilities, was $560.36 (making a total expenditure
of $108,124.23 to June 30, 1888), and the result was the completion of the
contract then in force by the removal of a few bowlders found while
dredging in the 13-foot anchorage area.
    The work required to complete the existing project is the dredging of
a narrow strip along the western edge of the 750-foot channel around
and to the eastward of the dolphin on the Goat Island Spit, the remain-
der of the excavation within the harbor of the anchorage area of 13
feet depth, and the excavation, also within the harbor, of the anchorage
area of 10 feet depth; also the building of additional jetties outside of
Goat Island whenever they may be required to arrest the drift of littoral
sand and gravel into the harbor entrance.
July 1, 1887, amount available.... ....-...... ....-........................                  $638. 16
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887..............................................                        560. 36'
July 1, 1888, balance available .              ...........    .........        ..   .....        77.80
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888............ ..........                        12, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889..................                     12, 077. 80

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........                   40, 000, 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                 25, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix C 11.)
   14. Harbor of Refuge at Block Island, Rhode Island.-The object of
the improvement is to furnish a harbor of refuge for vessels engagedin
foreign and coastwise commerce.
   Before the construction of the present harbor Block Island had no
harbor which afforded p)rotection for decked vessels. The original pro-
ject and its subsequent modifications provide for a harbor of refuge on
the eastern side of the island, consisting of an inner harbor or basin
for small vessels and an exterior for large ones.                               The basin was to be
42           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

about 250 feet by 300 feet in area and inclosed, with the exception of an
opening 80 feet wide. The exterior harbor was to be formed by a
riprap breakwater, which has been built. About 300 feet from the sea
end of this breakwater, which is 1,900 feet long, a gap 200 feet long was
left for the convenience of vessels. The present project contemplates
the filling of this gap, which was found to let in too much sea in stormy
weather, and the enlargement of the inner harbor by the construction
of riprap walls inclosing an anchorage of about 18 acres.
    The total expenditures up to June 30, 1887, were $325,024.17.
   The inner harbor and the main breakwater, built in prolongation
of the eastern side of the inner harbor and extending 1,900 feet from
the shore, were constructed in the years 1870 to 1879, inclusive. The
utility of the work at once became apparent. In stormy weather the
inner harbor, especially, was filled with fishermen and coasters, and it
soon became necessary to increase its depth from 7 feet, to which it had
been dredged in the first instance, to 9 feet at mean low water. In 1883
a strorng jetty was built out from the cliff to the eastward of the inner
harbor, andsa masonry wall was constructed on the inside of the crib-
work forming the eastern side of the inner harbor. The filling in the
gap in the main breakwater was carried to the height of about 1I feet
above mean high water, and at the close of the work under the last
contract about one-half of the total amount of stone required for the
completion of this work had been delivered and placed in the gap.
    The sea, which formerly came into the outer harbor through the gap
in the main breakwater in easterly storms, had been stopped by this
partial filling.
    During the last fiscal year work has beeninnprogress on the filling of
the gap in the breakwater and commencing the enlargement of the
inner harbor. That portion of the current contract relating to the fill-
ing of the gap has been completed and the building of the riprap walls
inclosing the enlarged inner harbor has been commenced.
    It is proposed to apply the funds available July 1, 1888, to carrying
on the work of the enlargement of the inner harbor. The appropria-
tion asked for is for the completion of the filling of the gap in the break-
water, the restoring of the breakwater to its original dimensions, and
the continuation of the enlargement of the inner harbor.
    The result was the filling of the gap to within one-seventh of the total
estimated amount, the construction of the timber jetty filled with stone
forming the shore end of the western wall of the proposed enlarged inner
harbor, and the commencement of the construction of its north wall.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..................                 ............                 $19, 975.83
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ...              .........  .......     .. $10, 049.21
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..........................                    3, 9:34.74
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts............                      5, 215. 09
                                                                                        --      19,199. 04

July 1,1888, balance available:
      Breakwater.......................                           .............           ......   197.31
      Inner harbor...... ..               ..........-..........          ..............            579. 48
                                                                                                                776.794
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ..............                                                 15, 000.00,
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889------.......-.                                         15, 776.79

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30, 1890                                  25, 000.   00,
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix C 12.)
                        RIVER AND HARBOR                      IMPROVEMENTS.

  15. Pawcatuck River, Rhode Island and Connecticut.--The navigable
part of the Pawcatuck River extends from the town of Westerly to Little
Narragansett Bay, and the object of the improvement is to deepen and
widen the channel leading from this bay to Westerly.
  Before improvement the channel was crooked and obstructed by nu-
merous shoals, on some of which there was but 11 feet of water at mean
low water.
   By appropriations made in the years 1871 to 1875 the river was im-
proved by the excavation of a channel 5, feet deep at mean low water
and 75 feet wide below the wharves, and from 35 to 40 feet wide between
the upper and lower wharves. The present approved project contem-
plates the further widening of the channel to 100 feet below the wharves
and by an additional width of two cuts of an ordinary dredging ma-
chine, or about 40 feet between the lower and upper wharves; also the
deepening of the entire channel to 8 feet at mean low water, at an esti-
mated cost of $38,637. The amount expended on the original project
was $50,000, and it was completed.
   The amount expended on the present project to June 30, 1888, includ-
ing outstanding liabilities, was $10,463.62, and the result was the com
pletion of the channel to its full width and depth from the deep water
opposite the village of Lottery to a point near the lower end of Major's
Island, with the exception of a small amount of ledge rock which ex-
tends into the channel near Certain Draw Point and at the Pawcatuck
Rock.
   The work required to complete the existing project is the dredging
of the channel to a depth of 8 feet at mean low water and width of 100(
feet from the upper end of the present work to Westerly, and a width
of 40 feet between the upper and lower wharves of that town; also the
removal of a small amount of ledge rock when uncovered by dredging.
July 1, 1887, amount available .........-..---.... ...........................                     $8, 464. 88
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1837 ...........                 ..... - .. ....   $5, 184. 13
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities......-......-- .. -....... .                    1,744. 37
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts ..........                         1, 137. 38
                                                                                                     ),065.88

July 1, 1898, balance available... ...................-- ..----    ....--- ........                    399. 00
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ....................--.                              10, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ................----                    .    10, 399.00,


  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 16, 700.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix C 14.)
   16. Harbor of Refuge at Stonington, Connecticut.-StoningtonHarbor
originally was an open bay, unprotected from southerly storms, and ob-
structed by a shoal having a low-water depth of but 6 feet at the shoalest
part. A short breakwater was constructed in the years 1828-'31, at a
cost of $34,766.65, for the protection of the commerce of the town. The
enlarged project of 1871 for the improvement of the harbor and its sub-
sequent modification, under which work is now carried on, embraced
dredging in the upper harbor and the construction of two breakwaters
in the outer harbor. One of these, the western, was to be built out from
Wamphassuck Point, the southwestern limit of the harbor, and to ex-
tend about 2,000 feet; and the other, the eastern, was to extend from the
vicinity of Bartlett's Reef to the Middle Ground. The western break-
44         REPORT OF TIHE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

water was completed in 1880, at a cost of $103,190. The amount ex-
pended in dredging in the upper harbor was about $45,000. The posi-
tion of the western end of the eastern breakwater has not been deter-
mined.
   The amount expended upon the eastern breakwater up to the close of
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, was $105,115.19, and its length at
that date was 2,150 feet.
   The amount expended during the last fiscal year to June 30, 1888, in-
cluding outstanding liabilities, was $4,433.71 (making a total expendi-
ture of $109,548.90 to June 30, 1888), and the result was the extension
of the eastern breakwater to a point about 2,210 feet from its eastern
extremity.
  The work required is to finish the construction of the eastern break-
water. In case it be found that sufficient protection to the harbor of
refuge has been afforded when the range from Stonington Light to the
middle of Wicopessit Island is reached the length of the breakwater yet
to be built will be about 360 feet. Should it be decided to extend it to
the Middle Ground it will require about 150 feet more.
  The completion of this work will afford a thoroughly protected an-
chorage for vessels drawing 18 feet of water and( a harbor of refuge for
the commerce which daily passes between Long Island Sound and the
eastward.
   It is proposed to apply the amount available and that asked for to
the extension of the eastern breakwater.
July 1, 1887, amount available .......--....-.........   _        .... ............   $4, 884. 51
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1b87 ... ....    .     -..-.--- ....-------                      4, 433. 71
July 1, 1888, balance available- . ..- ..-... .......... ...... .... ........            450. 80
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                8,000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................               , 450. 80


  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890          '25, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix C 15.)

EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS FOR IMPROVEMENT, TO COMPLY WITH
   REQUIREMENTS OF THE                RIVER AND         HARBOR ACT          OF AUGUST 5,
   1886.
  It appearing, after preliminary examination by the local engineer,
that the localities were worthy of improvement, Major Livermore was
charged with and c(omlieted the following surveys, the results of which
were transmitted to Congress and p)rinted in House Ex. Doc. No. 86,
Fiftieth Congress, first session:
  1. New Bedford EHa   rbor, iIassachusetts.-(See also Appendix C 16.)
  2. Taunton River, iMassachusetts.-(See also Appendix C 17.)

IMPROVEMENT OF CONNECTICUT RIVER, 1MASSACHUSETTS AND CON-
  NECTICUT, AND OF RIVERS AND HIARBORS   ON LONG   ISLAND
  SOUND, CONNECTICUT AND NEW YORK.

  Officer in charge, Lieut. Col. D. C. Houston, Corps of Engineers,
with Lieut. J. C. Sanford, Corps of Engineers, under his immediate
orders.
                      RIVER       AND      HARBOR         IMPROVEMIENTS.

   1. Thames River, Connecticut.-This river is a tidal stream extending
from the city of Norwich 15 miles south to Long Island Sound. For 11
miles above its mouth the depth ranges from 13 to 80 feet. Improve-
ments have been confined to a stretch of 3& miles below Norwich, in
which the most troublesome bars lie. In 1829 the channel depth over
these bars was about 6 feet at mean low water.
   In 1836 a project was adopted for making the channel 100 feet wide
and 14 feet deep at high water (11 feet at low water) by dredging and
by building piers. In 1878 a channel 14 feet deep at low water was
projected, and in 1882 a modification was adopted providing for a chan-
nel 200 feet wide and 14 feet deep, to be obtained by dredging and by
building five dikes or training-walls along the outer curves of the chan-
nel. The estimated cost was $203,080, and a balance of $20,000 from
previous appropriations was then available.
   The total amount appropriated for this river is $304,300, of which
$102,286.87 has been expended since the adoption of the present project.
   Three of the proposed dikes have been completed, and 3,093 linear
feet of the fourth one, or about two-thirds of its projected length, have
been built. Dredging was done between the dikes in 1882, 1883, 1884,
and 1887. The three completed dikes need slight repairs. The chan-
nel has about 10) feet available depth at low water.
   During the past fiscal year, including outstanding liabilities and ex-
cluding existing contracts, $13,136.87 have been expended in extending
the fourth dike, in repairing the others, and in dredging.
   Thirty-five thousand dollars could be advantageously expended in a
single year in completing the remaining dikes and in dredging. The
estimate for completing existing project has been enlarged by $24,000,
the sum required for deepening the channel to 16 feet up to Allen's
Point.
July 1, 1887, amount available ........................................ $21,137.76
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887..--..-------..................--------   $13, 136. 87
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts...........                    6,650. 00
                                                                                              19, 786. 87
                                                                                              S


July 1, 1888, balance available . ... ............................. ......                     1, 350. 89
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ......................                          50, 000.(0

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...................                      51,350.89



  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix D 1.)
   2. New London Harbor, Connecticut.--This harbor includes the lower
3 miles of Thames River, from the New London wharves to Long
Island Sound.
   The project for its improvement, adopted in 1880 and slightly mod-
fied in 1882, provides for removing to a depth of 16 feet at mean low
water the southerly part of a shoal of sand and bowlders lying east of
the New London Northern Railroad Wharf. The original depth on this
part of the shoal was from 5 to 15 feet.
   Nineteen thousand eight hundred dollars have been appropriated
and expended on this work.
   The required depth has been made over nearly the whole area con-
46          REPORT         OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

templated in the project, which is regarded as completed, no further
work under it being desired.
                                                                           $204. 33
July 1, 1887,amount available .----............-----.-----------........------....
July 1,1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 .............--------..............
                                                    ----..........----....    2.94
July 1, 1888, balance available                                                  201.39
                                              --............---.--------......------.......----
  (See Appendix D 2.)
  3. Connecticut River, Massachusetts and Connecticut, above Hartford.-
From Holyoke, Mass., 34 miles above Hartford, down to Enfield Falls
or Rapids, a distance of 18 miles, there is a fair channel 4 to5 feet deep.
Enfield Rapids extends about 5 miles over a rocky and uneven bed,
with a total fall of 32 feet. From the foot of Enfield Rapids to Hart-
ford, a distance of 11 miles, the river-bed is broad and sandy, with a
channel from 2 to 5 feet deep at low water. Several years ago the
Connecticut River Company constructed a small canal around Enfield
Rapids, through which boats of 3 feet draught and 80 feet length can
pass.
  The several projects under which work has been done have been for
dredging at Barber's Landing and for wing-dams. In 1878 plans and
estimates were submitted for the construction of a canal 8 feet deep
around Enfield Rapids; these estimates were revised in 1880. The es-
timated cost of this canal was $1,322,805; it was not considered advis-
able to begin construction with a less sum than $450,000, which has
not yet been appropriated.
   Up to the close of the present fiscal year $100,000 have been appro-
priated for this part of the river, of which $90,866.80 have been ex-
pended.
   All the work done has been dredging, construction of seven wing-
dams and repair of the same.
   No work was done during the past fiscal year.
   The funds on hand from previous appropriations are sufficient for such
repairs and temporary improvement as may be needed during the en-
suing year.
   The benefit to be secured by a.permanent improvement would be the
reduction of cost of transporting bulky materials to and from a large
manufacturing district, now wholly dependent on railroads.
July 1,1887, amount available ......................................                      $9,133.20
July 1, 1888, balance available ...........           ......-.............   ......   .    9,133.30
   (See Appendix D 3.)
   Below Hartford.-BetweenHartford and Long Island Sound, a distance
of 50 miles by course of channel, the depth on the two bars was for-
merly 5 feet at low water, the worst places being between Hartford and
-Middletown, a distance of 19 miles, and at Saybrook Bar, at the mouth
of the river. Dredging was carried on and small wing-dams were con-
structed by private parties and by a State corporation up to 1868, with
no permanent benefit.
   In 1868 a project for improvement by the United States was sub-
mitted, under which a pile-dike was built at Hartford and annual dredg-
ing done on the bars below Hartford until 1883. In 1873 a project for
the construction of three jetties on Saybrook Bar was adopted; two of
these have been built; the third will probably not be required. In
1880 a project for permanent improvement on six of the worst bars be-
tween Hartford and Middletown was adopted; it contemplated building
riprap wing-dams, rectifying the banks and protecting the caving banks
                          RIVER AND HARBOR                       IMPROVEMENTS.                     47
by mattresses, at a total estimated cost of $330,487. It was arterward
found necessary to extend the project to include annual dredging at
these and otter bars and the extension and repair of the Saybrook jet-
ties. The total amount appropriated since the adoption of the above
project is $161,250; two of the contemplated permanent works have
been built, a training-wall at Hartford Bar and a wing-dam at Glaston-
bury Bar, their total cost being $40,715.34. In addition to the work
included in the estimate of $330,487, the east and west jetties at Say-
brook have been extended and repaired and a channel 120 feet wide
and 12 feet deep has been dredged between them, and frtm $5,000 to
 $10,000 have been annually expended in dredging to maintain a depth
of 9 feet on the bars betweenl Hartford and Haddam Island.
   Experience, has shown that, on account of the height and frequency
of freshets in this river, the permanent works projected in 1880 would
be inadequate to maintain the desired depth or even to materially re-
4uce   the amount of dredging annually required; therefore, in Decem-
ber, 1887, a new project was adopted, confining future operations to the
completion of the Saybrook jetties to a height of 5 feet above high
water, with a top width of 6 feet and widening the channel between
the jetties to 400 feet with a depth of 12 feet at mean low water, at an
estimated cost of $80,000, with annual dredging to maintain a 9-foot
channel between Hartford and Long Island Sound, at an average cost
of $10,000 per year.
   During the past fiscal year, including outstanding liabilities, $8,991.43
have been expended in repairing the Saybrook jetties and in dredging
to maintain the 9-foot channel.
   During the next fiscal year the Saybrook jetties could be completed
as designed and the proposed dredging could be done at an estimated
cost of $90,000, including $10,000 required for annual maintenance of
channels.
July 1, 1887, amount available------.. . ----..----... ......          .   .............    $21, 222.80
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ........................                 $7,311. 76
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities..... ....          ........-....   ...      1, 679.67
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts...........                     8,487.00
                                                                                             17, 478.43

July 1, 1888, balance available .........................................                     3,744. 37
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188 ...........................                     10,000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                    13,744.37

IAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                     80, 000.00
   Amount required for annual maintenance of channel.................                        10,000.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                25, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections                    2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix D 3.)
  4. Clinton Harbor, Connecticut.--This harbor is 10 miles west of the
mouth of the Connecticut River. Its channel runs for nearly a mile
inside of a beach through which a breach was made about the year 1840,
after which the channel shoaled in two places to about 4 feet depth,
where the depth had been 8 feet.
  The project for improvement, adopted in 1882, provided for closing
the breach and, if that did not restore the channel depth, for dredging
a channel 100 feet wide and 6 feet deep at mean low water through
the shoals. The entire cost was estimated at $10,000.
48           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Three thousand dollars have been appropriated for this harbor, of
which $2,747.27 have been expended.
  A riprap dike was built across the breach in 1883; it requires some
repair. The channel depth has not changed since 18S2.
  Nothing was done during the past fiscal year.
  Seven thousand dollars, the estimated amount required to complete
the project, couldl be profitably expended for that purpose in the fol-
lowing fiscal year.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..---..--..--........---.......................------------------    $252. 73
July 1, 1888, balance available ..............                        ............   ...........     '.252.73

IAmount (estimated)   required for completion of existing project.... ....                         7, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending J une 30, 1890                      7,000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
       harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix D 4.)
  5. New         Raven
                  Harbor, Connecticut.-The original available low-water
depth up to the wharves in this harbor was about 9 feet.
  The first project for deepening the channel provided for making it 13
feet deep, which was.done in 1871; it was widened at different times
until 1878, when a project was adopted for dredging a channel 16 feet
deep and not less 400 feet wide. In 1882 a project was adopted for build-
ing a dike to extend out from Sandy Point, with an arm 3,200 feet long
and parallel to the channel, in order to contract the channel and make
the depth to be obtained by dredging permanent. Thirth-eight thou-
sand dollars have been expended on this dike, and $46,000 are estimated
as required to complete it.
  Up to the close of the fiscal year $261,000 have been appropriated
for this harbor and nearly all expende-d.
  A 16 foot channel from 400 to 600 feet wide has been obtained all the
way up the harbor, except over the Fort Hale Bar, where the depth is
13 feet. The shore arm and 1,359 feet of the channel-arm of the Sandy
Point Dike have been built.
  During the past fiscal year $6,488.95 have been expended in extend-
ing the Sandy Point Dike 570 feet.
   The surm of $93,000 is estim ated as required to complete the dike and
to do the necessary dredging to make 16 feet depth over the Fort Hale
Bar.
July 1, 1887, amount available.....-.....-....-..-.......-...-.-....                               $7, 818.93
July 1, 188, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
     outstanding July 1, 1887 ..........................................                            6, 488.95
July 1, 1888, balance available ...............................................                    1,329. 98
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                           15, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889....................                         16, 329.98

  (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                          78, 000. 00
  SAmount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                       30, 000. 00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1886 and 1867.
     (See Appendix D 5.)
   6. Breakwater at New Haven, Connecticut.-In 1880 a project was
adopted for making a large and convenient harbor of refuge at the en-
trance to New Haven Harbor by the construction of two riprap break-
waters, the first to be 3.300 feet long, extending northeasterly from the
light-house on southwest ledge to Quixes ledge, the second to be 4,200
                        RIVER AND            HARBOR             IMPROVEMENTS.                                     49
feet long, extending northwesterly from Luddington Rock. The esti-
mated cost was $1,311,134. No modification of the project has been
made, except slight changes of cross-section in 1880.
  The total amount appropriated for this work is $295,000, of which
$288,497.64 have been expended.
  The east breakwater has been built to a length of 2,818 feet, being
nearly seven-eighths of its projected length. The west breakwater is
not begun.
   During the past fiscal year, including outstanding liabilities, and ex-
cluding existing contracts, $41,475.13 have been expended and the break-
water has been extended 406 linear feet; a contract for further exten-
sion is in progress.
   The amount estimated as necessary to comple the east breakwater is
$40,000; this could be done and work on the west breakwater pros-
ecuted at the same time.
   One hundred thousand dollars could be profitably expended on the
two breakwaters during the ensuing year.
July 1, 1887, amount available ......-..................   ................          $47, 977.49
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887. ---......----..               $39, 786.28
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities . .....................                                  1,688.85
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts.----....----......                          6,411.15
                                                                                                           47, 886. 28
July 1, 1888, balance available............              ....      .......................           ..         91.21
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.......................                                      75, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ..................                                  75,091.21

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..-                                       941,134.00
  Amountthat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June, 30, 1890 100, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix D 6.)
   7. Mlilford Harbor, Connecticut.-Thisharbor consists of a broad open
bay, from the head of which a small tidal stream extends three-quarters
of a mile inland to the upper wharf. Originally the depth on the bar at
the mouth of the river was less than 2 feet at mean low tide; the chan-
nel in the river ran nearly bare in places.
   Under the first project of improvement, adopted in 1872, a channel 4
feet deep and 100 feet wide was excavated through the bar and thence
40 to 60 feet wide to the upper wharf; small jetties were built to pro-
tect the east bank from erosion and two jetties were built to preserve
the channel on the bar, at a total cost of $34,600. In 1881 a project
was adopted for making a channel over the bar, to be 8 feet deep at
mean low water and 100 feet wide, at an estimated cost of $11,000.
   The total sum appropriated for this harbor is $39,600; of this $4,758.98
have been expended on the last project and the 8-foot channel has been
made 65 feet wide.
   No work was done during the past fiscal year.
   The remainder of the project could be satisfactorily completed in one
year at the estimated cost of $6,000.
July 1, 1887, amount available ......................................                                        $241.02
July 1, 1888, balance available---........            ...... .......        ................                  241.02
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...--------...-------------..................                 5,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...................                                   5,241.02

          ENG 88-----4
50          REPORT         OF THE CHIEF                 OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

     Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ......                             $1, 000. 00
     Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                         1, 000.00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
 .     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix D 7.)
  8. Housatonic River, Connecticut.-The navigable part of this river
extends from Derby, Conn., to Long Island Sound, a distance of 13
miles, and was originally obstructed by several bars, upon which the
low-water depth was from 3 to 5 feet.
  In 1871 a project was adopted for making and maintaining a channel
100 feet wide and 7 feet deep at mean low water throughout this dis-
tance. Besides the necessary dredging, it contemplated building a
breakwater east of the channel over the bar at the river's mouth.
  The amount appropriated for this river is $76,242, of which $74,494.59
have been expended, including outstanding liabilities.
  A channel of the required depth has been dredged several times
through the worst bars. The present available depth over them now is
about 5 feet at mean low water. Drew's Rock has been removed to a
depth of 7 feet at mean low water.
  Revised estimates of cost of the breakwater at the mouth of the river
and of the necessary dredging, have been submitted, amounting to
$202,000; $70,000 of this could be advantageously expended during
the ensuing fiscal year.
                                                                                                          $6, 975. 37
July 1, 1887, amount available.....-----..------ ----......--- -....----......------....--..------....---....
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ---..................----------..                  $825.96
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ......................                              4,444.00
                                                                                                         5,269. 96
July 1, 1888, balance available-- .... .... .... ................-- ....                     ......      1,705.41
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ........................                                  35, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                               36, 705.41'

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- -.... - 167, 000. 00
   Amountthat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30, 1890 70, 000.00
I Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
l harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix D 8.)
  9. Bridgeport Harbor, Connecticut.-The available depth in this har-
bor was originally 5 feet at mean low water.
  The first project for improvement provided for an 8-foot channel over
the outer and inner bars; this was dredged on the outer bar in 1837,
and on both bars in 1853. In 1871 a project was adopted for making a
channel 12 feet deep and 100 feet wide, subsequently modified to 300
feet, and for building a jetty on the east shore to check the influx of
sand. This was accomplished in 1882, and a new project was adopted
for widening to 600 feet the channel from the Inner Beacon to the Nau-
gatuck Railroad Wharf, to                   p)rovide
                                    for vessels driven in by bad weather
without blocking the main channel. The estimated cost of the latter
project was $60,000. It is very nearly completed; a small area remains
near the Inner Beacon, which it is considered desirable to dredge.
  The total amount appropriated for this harbor is $232,485.38, of
which $35,000 have been appropriated for and nearly all expended upon
the project of 1882.
  During the past fiscal year dredging has been done upon part of the
area near the Inner Beacon.
  -An estimate for widening the channel above the railroad wharf, in
                            RIVER AND HARBOR                           IMPROVEMENTS.                           51
order to relieve the crowding of the channel at that point, has been
submitted. The cost is estimated at $17,000.
                                                                        $2,478. 07
July 1, 1887, amount available .....................................--------------
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887......................... $321.01
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..........................                             1,960. 00
                                                                                                          2,281.01
July 1, 1888, balance available..........................................     197.06
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...--..................-- .. 10, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889................                                    10, 197.06

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........-   7,000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 7, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix D 9.)
  10. Black Rock Harbor, Connecticut.-This harbor consists of a bay
partly sheltered by Fairweather Island and of two small streams ex-
tending inland from the head of the bay. The depth in Cedar Creek,
the more important of these streams, was from 2 to 4 feet at mean low
water and the channel was narrow and very crooked.
  The project for improvement submitted in 1883 includes dredging a
channel 3,300 feet long, 80 feet wide, and 6 feet deep, to extend up
Cedar Creek, and a breakwater from Fairweather Island to the main-
land. The estimated cost was $80,000.
  Twenty-five thousand dollars have been appropriated for and nearly
all expended under this project.
  The breakwater has been built to the full length, but not to the
width and height projected, and the channel has been dredged 80 feet
wide, but has filled in at the sides so that the available width is about
60 feet.
  During the past fiscal year $2,391.29 have been expended in dredging
to widen the channel as above.
                                -------.----....---.. ............-------------.........
July 1, 1887, amount available..........                                     $2,531.59
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887................................................                                2, 391. 29

July 1, 1888, balance available .............................  ..........                                    140. 30
Amount appropriated by act of August. 11, 1888 .........................                                 10, 000.00



 {Amount
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                10,140.30

               (estimated) required              for   completion of existing project..---               45, 000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                              20. 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix D 10.)
  11. Norwalk Harbor, Connecticut.-This harbor consists of the tidal
part of Norwalk River, extending from Norwalk, Conn., to Long Island
Sound, a distance of 3 miles. South Norwalk is 1- miles below Nor-
walk. Originally the depth up to South Norwalk was about 5 feet at
mean low water; between there and Norwalk the bed ran nearly bare.
  The first project for improvement contemplated a channel 100 feet
wide and 6 feet deep from Long Island Sound to Norwalk. In 1881
the project was modified to provide for 8 feet depth below South Nor-
walk. The last estimate upon this work places the cost from commence-
ment at $84,000.
52         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Up to the close of the fiscal year $77,246.66 had been appropriated for
this project and nearly all expended. Some parts of the river have re-
quired dredging several times.
  A channel has been dredged 100 feet wide and 8 feet deep up to South
Norwalk, and thence to Norwalk from 60 to 100 feet wide and 6 feet deep.
This channel is in navigable condition, though it has shoaled somewhat
in places.
   No work was done during the past fiscal year.
   For the next fiscal year $7,000 could be profitably applied towards
completing the present project and maintaining the channel depths.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $28,000
for the improvement of this harbor, and provides that $25,000 of this
amount shall be expended in dredging and deepening the channel in
the lower harbor up to Wilson's Point. The officer in charge estimates
that this dredging will cost $52,900.
July 1, 1887, amount available--......     ......................              .......      ...       $560.04
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 187--..--..........-                    --....
                                                   --..--........                      --
                                                                  --...................----     .        56.94
July 1, 1888, balance available -----..........---------------..--------..---- --                         3. 10
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ..................           ,....                    28, 000. 03
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .. .. .. ...                       ......     28, 503. 10
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........
                                                                     _                              31,900. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expendedlin fiscal year ending June30, 1890                         20, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix D 12.)
  12. Harborat Five Mile River, Connecticut.-This is a new work. A
preliminary examination and survey of this harbor were made in com-
pliance with the requirements of the river and harbor act approved
August 5, 1886.
  The proposed project contemplates deepening the harbor and ap-
proaches so as to give 8 feet at mean low water. It is proposed to dredge
a channel 8 feet deep, 100 feet wide, and 6,000 feet long at an estimated
cost of $25,000 and an annual expenditure of about $1,000 for mainte-
nance.
  The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates for this
work $5,000, and a further sum of $10,000 may be profitably expended
in continuing it during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ............................                          $5, 000.00

   Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal year endingJune 30,1890                          10, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  13. Stamford Harbor, Connecticut.-Thisharbor consists of a shallow
bay on the north shore of Long Island Sound and of the tidal part, about
three-fourths of a mile long, of Mill River. The original depth in this
part of the river at mean low water was from 1 to 3 feet, gradually in
creasing in the bay to depth of 12 feet.
  The project for improvement, proposed in 1883 and adopted in 1886,
provides for dredging a channel 80 feet wide and 5 feet deep at mean
low water from the bay to the head of the harbor, at an estimated cost
of $20,000.
   Ten thousand dollars have been appropriated and expended under
f;his project, making a channel 75 feet wide for more than half its pro.
jected length and 25 to 50 feet wide for the rest of the length.
                           RIVER AND               HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                               53
  During the past fiscal year $5,469.66 were expended and the contract
under which the above dredging was done was completed.
July 1, 1897, amount av'ilable................--.......--....                   ......
                                                                             ---....---------.                 $5, 693.74
July 1, 1888, amount e pended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887..          -.-                         ...------------------.
                                                     ..-...--------.                                            5, 469.66

July 1, 1888, balance available .--.....--.....--.........--------------..-------..........---............        224. 08
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.....                             --..
                                                                              .....--               ....
                                                                                                ....---         5, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ----
                                                      ..................-------.                                5, 224.08

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..-... .--                                     5,000. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                   5, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1865 and 1867.
   (See Appendix D 13.)
  14. Port Chester Harbor, New York.-This harbor consists of a bay
opening into Long Island Sound at the mouth of the Byram River, and
of the lower part of the river itself, which is navigable for about a mile
above its month.
  The original available depth in the river was not above a foot at low
water, and Salt Rock in the river and Sunken Rock in the bay were
considered dangerous obstructions.
  The scheme for improvement adopted in 1871 provided for the re-
moval of these rocks to 9 and 11 feet depth, respectively, and for the
construction of a breakwater on the bar at the mouth of the harbor at
an estimated cost of $96,632.
  In 1881 the project was amended to provide for dredging a channel
21 feet deep and from 60 to 100 feet wide from the bay to the vicinity
of the wharves.
  The total amount appropriated for this harbor is $27,000, which has
been nearly all expended.    Salt Rock has been removed to the required
depth of 9 fees at mean low water, and a channel "- feet deep and from
40 to 100 feet wide has been completed to a point' 150 feet below the
bridge at Port Chester, and thence carried, with a width of 25 feet, to
the bridge.
July 1, 1887, amount available-- .....                --...........--....         --......--..........            $24. 77

                                                           ---...---
                                                         ...---........----------......
July 1, 1888, balance available---....- -..------....------..                                            ...        24.77
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ......-            -- - ...........                      ....     5, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889....................                                       5,024.77

{Amount        (estimated) required for completion of existing project ......
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year enuding June 30, 1890
                                                                                                               64, 632. 00
                                                                                                               10, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix D 14.)
   15. Mamaroneck Harbor, iNew York.-This harbor consists of a nar-
row inlet opening into a broad bay. Several dangerous rocks lie in or
near the channel. The low-water depth to the old steam-boat wharf,
about half-way up the inlet, was 5 feet ; from there to the upper wharves
it was about 1 foot.
   A project for improvement was adopted in 1882, providing for the
removal of one rock to 4 feet depth, of five rocks to 7 feet depth, and for
making a channel 100 feet wide and 7 feet deep up to the old steam-boat
wharf, thence to the village wharves 80 feet wide and 4 feet deep; the
estimated cost was $43,000.
54           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Fifteen thousand dollars have been appropriated for this harbor and
nearly all expended.
  Three of the rocks have been removed to the required depth; no
dredging has been done. The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888,
made no appropriation for this harbor.
July 1, 1887, amount available .........................................                                             $220. 5~
July 1, 1888, balance available ....---------------......------......--......---......-----......-----......---.-220.55
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....... 28,000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix D 15.)
  16. Echo Harbor,New Rochelle, New York.--The channel of this harbor
was obstructed by two reefs, Start Rock and Sheepshead Rock, the former
bare at low water, the latter covered to a foot depth or more.
  The project for improvement adopted in 1876 provided for the removal
of these reefs to 7 feet and 9 feet depths, respectively. The estimated
cost was $38,955.38.
  Twenty-two thousand dollars have been appropriated for this harbor,
of which $18,956.03 have been expended. Start Rock has been wholly
removed to 7 feet depth and part of Sheepshead Rock to 9 feet depth.
  The available funds were not sufficient for continuing operations on
Sheepshead Rock, and nothing has been done during the last fiscal year.
  According to the estimate the amount required for completion of the
project is $17,000.
July 1, 1887, amount available........                      ........               ......-..
                                                                              ---....                ....--...     .        $3, 043.97
July 1, 1888, balance available ------------
                                 .---.-.--.                                ---------------                              -   3, 043. 97


   Amountthatcan be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                                   8,000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections                                  2 of       river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix D )6.)
  17. New Rochelle Harbor, New York.-This harbor consists mainly of
a narrow and crooked channel lying between rocky islands.
  The project for improvement, adopted in 1881, provided for the re-
moval of two rocks and for dredging and removing a reef, to secure a
channel 8 feet deep and 100 feet wide between Hunter's Island and Glen
Island.
  The estimated cost was $40,825.
   Thirty-five thousand dollars have been appropriated for this work;
of this sum $25,865.03, including outstandi)ng liabilities have been ex-
pended.
  The channel has been dredged to a depth of 6 feet and the rock re-
moved to a depth of 7 feet; one of the rocks, Corning Rock, has been
removed to the required depth of 12 feet; upon the other, Rock C, no
work has been done.
  Two rocks, not shown on the original survey, have been removed dur-
ing the past fiscal year to a depth of 8 feet and 71 feet respectively.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..--............              --..................-...... $16, 843.66
.luly 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
   liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887-.--------.  ........           $7, 518.69
July 1,1888, outstanding liabilities ...............                          ........
                                                                                   -                       190. 00
                                                                                                                             7,
                                                                                                                             ---------
                                                                                                                                708. 69
July 1, 1888, balance available ...                   .............      ... ....       ..........               ....        9, 134.97
     (See Appendix D 17).
                          RIVER AND              HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                  55
   18. East Chester Creek,New York.-This is a small tidal stream, empty-
ing into Pelham Bay; it was navigable at high tide for vessels drawing
7 feet up to Lockwood's, a distance of' 2 miles. The rise of tide is 7.1 feet.
   The project for improvement, adopted in 1872 and subsequently modi-
fied, provided for a channel 9 feet deep at mean high water, extending
to a point 3,000 feet above Lockwood's and terminating at the upper end
in a tidal basin, and for 5,800 feet of diking to maintain the channel.
A revised estimated cost of the project, as modified, is placed by the
officer in charge at $221,100.
   Sixty-four thousand dollars have been appropriated, and of this
amount $56,379.80, including outstanding liabilities and excluding ex-
isting contracts, have been expended.
   The channel has been made 9 feet deep and 125 feet wide to the head
of Goose Island, one-half mile from the mouth of the creek; thence to
Town Dock from 40 to 90 feet wide, and from Town Dock to Lock-
wood's 100 feet wide, and 1,235 linear feet of diking have been built.
   A contract for dredging was entered into July 11, 1887, and annulled
August 18, 1887, on account of the contractor's failure to begin work.
A second contract was entered into May 11, 1888; work under this
contract is now in progress.
July 1, 1887, amount available-..-... ----......--..-..........                        ..........-----...       $9,673.78
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ....... .................   $1, 256.18
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities .................. ..-. ....     797.40
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts ...........      6,852.60
                                                                                                                 8, 906. 18'

July 1, 1888, balance available ...........................   ........                                              767.60
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.......... .........                                           .    5, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .... ......... ......                                     5, 767.60
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....... 152,100. 00
   Amount that can be profitablyexpended in fiscal year endingJune30,1890 10,000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix D 18.)
   19. Greenport Harbor, New York.-This harbor, at the eastern end of
Long Island, is exposed to easterly storms. Its anchorage-ground,
which was sheltered by Joshua's Point, has materially shoaled by ero-
sion of the point and by the influx of drifting sand.
   The project of improvement, adopted in 1882, provided for construction
of a riprap breakwater, extending from Joshua's Point 1,700 feet in a
southeasterly course, to arrest drifting sand, to check the erosion of
the point, and to increase the sheltered area. Its cost was estimated
at $46,000.
   Twenty-five thousand dollars have been appropriated for this habor,
of which $24,959.90 have been expended.
   The breakwater has been built out to a depth of 15.4 feet a distance
of 1,437 feet. One thousand eight hundred and six and one-quarter
tons of stone have been placed in the breakwater during the past fiscal
year.
July 1, 1887, amount available................                     ..    .......   ... ..............           $2, 957. 93
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.................. .........----------------------------------.........---....         2, 917. 83
July 1, 1888, balance available ..---.. ........... ..............    .
                                                                    ....             ....
                                                                                ....--                              40. 10
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ----.......----......---.....----....
                                                                            --------                             5,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending Jnne :30, 1889. .....-..-- -..--......                                   5 040. 10
56          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,18J0                                   10, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix D 19.)
   20. Glen Cove Harbor, New York.-This is a new work. The harbor
is a part of Hempstead Bay. An examination and survey of it was
made in compliance with the requirements of the river and harbor act
of August 5, 1886, and the report thereon printed as Appendix D 26 of
the Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1887.
   The proposed improvement consists in the construction of a breakwater
from Musquito Point in a westerly direction to a length of about 2,500
feet, to afford shelter to vessels lying at anchor, waiting to pass into the
harbor, and to protect its entrance. The estimated cost of the proposed
breakwater is $201,960.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, makes an appropriation
of $20,000 for improving the harbor, and a further sum of $30,000 may be
profitably expended in continuing it during the fiscal year ending June
:30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ...-...-..........                                    ..... $20, 000. 00


  Amountthatcan beprofitablyexpendedin fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 30, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 3 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   21. Flushing Bay, New Yorkc.--Before improvement, the available
depth in this broad, shallow bay and in the channel leading up to
Flushing was less than 4 feet at mean low water.
   The project for improvement, adopted in 1879, contemplated building
16,700 feet of diking, to form a tidal basin, which by filling and dis-
charging through the main channel would maintain a channel depth of
6 feet or more at mean low water after once dredging; the material of
the bottom is soft mud. The estimated cost of this work was $173,500.
   Seventythousand dollars have been appropriated for this work, of
which $68,979.74 have been expended.
   The dike on the west side of the channel has been built 3,057 feet
long.
   During the past fiscal year the channel leading up the bay and creek
to Flushing has been widened to 200 feet for a length of 2,400 feet, and
a branch channel 1,450 feet long and 55 feet wide dredged to the steam-
boat landing at the head of the bay.
   Thirty-five thousand dollars could be profitably expended during the
ensuing fiscal year in extending the dikes and maintaining the channel
depth.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..................                               .... ...... ..........             $5, 201.38
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887..........................................------------------------------------------....  4, 181.12
July 1, 1888, balance available ....                   ......   .....   ....................          ....       1,020. 26
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ...............--                              ..--     ....     15,000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889....... ---.........                                      16, 020. 26
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-- .----. 88, 500. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 35, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix D 21.)
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                          57
   22. Removing sunken vessels or crafts obstructing or endangering navi-
gation.-The contract for removal of the wreck of the sloop-scow George
C. Bloomner, sun k in the Connecticut River, at Hartford Conn., which
was in force at the date of the last annual report, was completed during
the summer of 1887; the wreck was entirely removed.
    Under section 4 of act of Congress approved June 14, 1880, notice to
owners of the schooner R. H. Daly, wrecked and sunk in the Connecti-
.cut River, near Saybrook Point, Conn., was duly published; subse-
quently arrangement for her removal was made, and the work was done
in December, 1887.
    Under the same law, the wreck of the Louise Bliss was removed in
December, 1887, after publishing the required notice to owners. This
vessel was a three-masted schooner, wrecked and sunk in November,
1885, in the west end of Long Sand Shoal, Long Island Sound, about 6
miles southwest from the mouth of the Copnecticut River.
    April 14, 1887, the schooner Emma J. Higgins was wrecked and sunk
in about 11 fathoms of water about 6 miles southwest of Black Rock Har-
bor, Connecticut; her spars were broken off about low-water level and
were a source of danger to vessels navigating that part of the sound.
Under the same law, after duly publishing notice to owners, the spars
of this vessel were removed, so as to make a clear depth of more than
25 feet over the wreck.
    (See Appendix D 23.)

IMPROVEMENT OF HUDSON RIVER AND OF HARBORS OF RONDOUT
  AND SAUGERTIES, NEW YORK-REMOVING OBSTRUCTIONS IN EAST
  RIVER AND HELL GATE-IMPROVEMENT    OF ENTRANCE TO NEW
  YORK HARBOR-IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE
  VICINITY OF NEW YORK AND IN NORTHERN NEW JERSEY.

   Officer in charge, Lieut. Col. Walker McFarland, Corps of Engineers,
having under his immediate orders Capt. George McC. Derby, Corps of
Engineers. These works were in temporary charge of Lieut. Col. G. L.
Gillespie, Corps of Engineers, from January 1, 1888, to June 29, 1888.
   1. Hudson River, New York.-The improvement of this river has been
restricted by the wording of the appropriation acts to that part of it
lying between Troy, at the head of navigation, 6 miles above Albany,
and New Baltimore, about 14 miles below Albany.
   Before the improvement was begun the navigable depth in the chan-
nel between New Baltimore and Albany was 71 feet at mean low water;
between Albany and Troy, 4 feet.
   The plan of improvement adopted in 1867 proposed making the nav-
igable depth between New Baltimore and Albany 11 feet, and between
Albany and Troy 9 feet. This was to be accomplished by the construc-
tion of longitudinal dikes to direct the currents and by dredging.
   All the dikes provided for in this plan have not yet.been built, but the
work so far done has resulted in securing a channel depth of 10 feet
nearly all the way from New Baltimore to Albany, and of 8 feet nearly
all the way from Albany to Troy. The shoal spots make the navigable
depths in those parts of the river 9j feet and 7 feet, respectively.
   The estimated cost of making this improvement as modified subse-
quently was $1,078,304, and the appropriations amount to $1,053,538.
   A large part of this amount has, however, from the necessity of the
case, been applied to the repair of decaying dikes instead of to the con-
struction of the new dikes yet to be built.
58          REPORT           OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S,.ARMY.

  A close examination of the works made within the past year shows
that---
The completion of the new works required and the removal of the rock at
  Van Wie's Point will cost probably ......------ _-----....         .     ...... $120,000
And the repair of the old works below Albany---------....................          103,000
And the repair of the old works above Albany --......        ...... ......    ....  37, 000

         Total ...............-----         ---.-   -----------                   ----..-................ 260,000
   These last are rapidly deteriorating and need immediate repair in
order to prevent great injury to the channel.
  During the past year the repairs at the West Dike at New Baltimore,
the Roah Hook Dike, and the Middle Dike at Coeymans have been com-
pleted.
July 1, 1887, amount available--............ ..............................                      $23, 018. 50
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 .........----------------------......................------------....   1,560. 22
July 1, 1888, balance available ................-.........................                             21,458.28
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888............ .............                                75, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889- -..... --............                           96, 458. 28
iAmount (estimated)              required for completion of existing project-.                       185, 000.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 100, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix E 1.)

   2. Harbor at Saugerties, New York.-This harbor is formed by the
mouth of Esopus Creek, which empties into the Hudson River on the
west bank, about 100 miles above New York.
   The plan of improvement which has been adopted for it provides for
securing a channel depth of 8 feet at mean low water by the construc-
tion of two parallel dikes about 300 feet apart, curved slightly down-
stream at the outer ends, and by dredging between them, if necessary.
   The estimated cost of this improvement is $52,000, of which $20,000
have been already appropriated. During the past year the south dike,
2,363k feet long, has been built at a cost of $16,048.16.
July 1, 1887, amount available..........................................                              $19,939.95
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities oustanding July 1, 1887............ .............. $13, 303.09
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ...................          3, 938. 17
                                                                                                       17, 241.26
July 1, 1888, balance available ......-...............................-                           .     2,698. 69
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                                12, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ..........-..---                      ...        14,698.69


   Amountthatcanbe profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30,1890 20, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix E 2.)
  3. Harbor at Rondout, New York.-This harbor lies at the mouth of
Rondout Creek, about 90 miles above New York, on the west side of
the Hudson River. The project for its improvement adopted in 1872
proposes to secure a channel depth of 13 feet at mean low water by
means of parallel dikes and by dredging between them, the estimated
cost being $172,000.
                    RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                     59
   The project was completed in 1880, the actual cost being only $90,000,
since which time such small appropriations as have been made have
been applied to the repair of the dikes.
  The channel maintains its depth and will continue to do so until the
dikes are broken through. These dikes are much decayed and oight
to be replaced, and $5,000 can well be applied to this purpose during
the coming year.
   Work during the past year has been confined to replacing the fender
piles of the north dike and repairing a couple of small breaks in it.
                                              ... ............ ..--$2,560. 36
July 1, 1887, amount available....................-----
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                                       --...---               -..-------
  outstanding July 1, 1887---..---..--......--..-------....----..          ---  2, 409. 14
                                                                         --...........

                                                                        151.22
July 1, 1888, balance available ...........................-------......---.....--
                                                            ....--.. 5,000. 00
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..--...--......---
                                                      ......--
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889....-------..------------.
                                                                   ........       5, 151.22

  Amount (estimated) required for repairs............................             5. 000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890      5, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix E 3.)
    4. Harlem River, New York.-The Harlem River and Spuyten Duyvil
Creek are both included in this improvement, and at present the former
is navigable for vessels of 12 feet draught to Morris Dock, about 6 miles
from its junction with the East River; the latter for about 1. miles from
the Hudson for vessels of 8 feet draught and only at high water. The
object of the improvement is to make a channel connecting these two
streams, so that vessels may pass through from the East River to the
Hudson, and the principal work is the cut which is to connect them.
'Though there is an interchange of waters now to some extent, there is
no navigable channel except for row-boats.
    The project for the improvement was originally adopted in 1875, and
was for a channel 350 feet wide and 15 feet deep at mean low water.
In 1879 the width of the channel was changed to 400 feet, except in the
rock-cut through Dyckman's Meadow, where, owing to the large in-
crease of the cost if a change were made, the width was to be restricted
to 350 feet, but the depth was to be increased to 18 feet at mean low
water.
     The amount expended upon the improvement up to the close of the
tiscil year ending June 30, 1887, was $987.77.
     As the appropriations, though made June 18, 1878, and March 3,
1 879, were not available until May 3, 1887, owing to the delay produced
by the legal proceedings for the acquirement of the land, the condition
of the streams remained the same as before the project for the improve-
ment was adopted.
     During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, there has been expended
 $41,17-.68 on the cut through Dyckman's Meadow, for engineering ex-
periments in structures for protecting the sides of the channel, and for
boring to determine the nature of the substrata on the marsh. When
the present contract is completed, about 700 feet of the channel through
Dyckman's Meadow will be finished to the width of 350 feet and depth
of 18 feet at mean low water.
     The amount that can1 be profitably expended during the year ending
June 30, 1890, is $500,000, and wvould be applied to excavating the
channel through the       marsh
                              between Dyckman's Meadow and the Hud-
60          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

son River, and to structures for protecting the sides and probably the
bottom of the new channel.
  The estimated amount required for the completion of the work ac-
cording to the present approved project is $2,300,000.
July 1, 1887, amount available ......                             ............
                                                   ......----......----                   -....   $399, 012. 23
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887--.....---...........       $41, 179. 68
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ...-----------------.....
                                                          ..-.......  18, 288. 07
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts ........          268, 261.76
                                                                                                   327, 729.51

July 1, 1888, balance available ......................................                     -        71, 282. 72
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...................... -                               70, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889-                       ...............       141, 282. 72

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ...... 2, 230, 000. 00
I Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
( 30, 1890............ ......-..-------------------------------             500, 000. 00
I Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
 ( harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E 4.)
   5. Removing obstructionsin the East River and Hell Gate, New York.-
Hell Gate is the worst obstruction in the narrow strait connecting Long
Island Sound with New York Harbor, known as the East River.
   At this point the channel turns at right angles around Hallet's Point,
opposite the mouth of the Harlem River, and the curren runs with a
velocity varying at different stages of the tide from 3 to 10 miles an
hour over or around Way's Reef, Pot Rock, Shell Drake, Hallet's Point,
Negro Point, Holmes Rock, Hog's Back, Heel Tap, Flood Rock, Hen
and Chickens, Gridiron, Mill Rocks, The Negro Heads, Rhinelander's
Reef, and Bread and Cheese.
   Besides this most serious obstruction there are many other rocks and
reefs in the East River, especially those off Thirty-fourth street and
Ninth street, which are dangerous to its crowded navigation, and which
ought to be removed.
  The plan of ifnprovement adopted some years ago proposed the build-
ing of sea-walls over some of these rocks, and the reduction of others
to a depth of 26 feet below mean low water.
   In accordance with this plan, Diamond Reef, near Governor's Island,
Coenties Reef, off Coenties Slip, Pilgrim Rock, off Nineteenth street,
and a reef near the North Brot her Island have been cut down, and at
Hell Gate 3 acres of Hallet's Point have been removed to the required
depth; Pot Rock has been cut down to 23 feet below mean low water,
Frying Pan to 18 feet, and Heel Tap to 21 feet; while Flood Rock, cov-
ering 9 acres and including the Negro Heads, Hen and Chickens, and
Gridiron, has been blown up and nearly one quarter of it removed.
Sea-walls have been built by the Government on Great and Little Mill
Rocks, and by the city authorities on Bread and Cheese Reef. The
work of removing rock at Hallet's Point and Flood Rock has been done
by mining, and- at the other points by the United States steam-drill
scow.
  During the past year the only work done was the removal of 19,548
tons of rock by contract from Flood Rock, which resulted in increasing
by 60 feet the width of the Newton Channel lying between Flood Rock
and Mill Rocks.
  The work of removing the wreck of Flood Rock and the other rocks
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                     61

mentioned both in Hell Gate and in the East River ought to be con-
tinued, and $500,000 could be profitably expended next year in this way.
July 1, 1887, amount available ....                                         $24,717. 62
                                                             ..--..------....
                                                           ....
                                       . .. .. -........----.....--
Received from sales of fuel to officers...------------.------.---..........      52.49

                                                                                                 24, 770. 11
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
                                                            ------..
                                                           ---------
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887-----.----.......----. $8, 301.95
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities..    ..................       383. 00
                                                                                                  8,684.95
July 1, 1888, balance available---.-..--...............------..
                                                 ...----           16,085. 16
                                                    ----------.............--.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...                  250, 000.00
                                                   ...............---.
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889........-.. ......                         266, 085. 16

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.       1, 238, 840. 67
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
                             -----........------..-----
    1890 -..-----..-.....--.------......                  -----..----........------------....   500, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E 5.)
   6. Newtown Creek, New York.-This is a small tidal stream, about 4
miles long, running through the eastern part of Brooklyn and empty-
ing into the East River opposite Thirty-fourth street, New York City.
   It had formerly a depth of 121 feet at the mouth, gradually decreas-
ing to 4 feet at the head.
   Its present condition shows a depth of 18 feet at the mouth, and from
81 to 10 feet at the head.
   The original project for its improvement adopted in 1880, but modi-
fled in 1884, provided for a channel 240 feet wide and 21 feet deep, ex-
tending from the mouth up to Vernon Avenue Bridge; and from that
point up to the head of navigation, on both branches, a channel decreas-
ing from 175 to 100 feet in width and from 18 to 10 feet in depth.
   Work during the fiscal year has been confined to dredging an 18-foot
channel below Vernon Avenue Bridge, and a 10-foot channel at the
head of navigation on both branches of the creek above Maspeth avenue.
   No permanent benefit can be derived from dredging in the upper
part of the creek until the banks, composed of soft mud, are protected
by bulkheads, since the material washes into the dredged channels.
   The commerce of the creek is very large.
July 1, 1887, amount available ...         ....................... .......---....               $2, 577.23
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887................................ ......-...--.   1, 034. 40
July 1, 1888, balance available...... ............................... 1,542. 83
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 . --...
                                                    .....
                                                        ............  25, 000. 00
                                                                     ----
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...----.........--....                     26, 542. 83


Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                     50, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix E 6:)
  7. Buttermilk Channel, New York Harbor.-This channel lies between
the city of Brooklyr1, New York, andGovernor's Island, New York Har-
bor, and is obstructed at its upper end, where it joins the East River,
by a shoal over which there was formerly a least depth of 9) feet at
62 .REPORT                 OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

mean low water. The crest of this shoal lay about 800 feet outside the
line of the Brooklyn wharves.
   The original project of improvement, adopted in 1881, provided for
the removal to a depth of 26 feet at mean low water of such parts of
the shoal as came within 850 feet of the Brooklyn wharves, which
would take off the crest of the shoal, and ought to give nowhere a
depth of less than 15 feet water on it.
   The estimated cost of the improvement was $210,000, of which
$190,000 bad been appropriated up to June 30, 1886.
   With this the channel has been widened to the full width proposed,
and deepened to not less than 24, and probably 26, feet at mean low
water; but this is not certain, as no survey has been made since 1884.
   In view of the increasing importance of the wharves on the Brook-
lyn shore, and the difficulty experienced by deep-draught vessels in
getting up to them by reason of this shoal, it was recommended in 1885
that the whole shoal be removed to a depth of 26 feet, and this recom-
mendation was tacitly approved by Congress by the act of August 5,
1886, which appropriated $56,250 for this purpose.    This amount not
being sufficient, however, to cut the whole down to a depth of 26 feet
at mean low water, it was decided to cut it down to 22 feet, leaving
the additional depth of 4 feet to be got under future appropriations.
   Under this appropriation the whole shoal was removed to a depth of
22 feet at mean low water.
   This has already proved a benefit to navigation; but, in view of the
large passing commerce, it is very desirable to give the full depth of
26 feet.
July 1, 1887, amount available---........-------.------------ ------..--..---..                               $9, 461.94
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ....--------......--......-----.---.....--..---.---..--.--------------....          3, 604. 78
July 1, 1888, balance available......
                                 -    .......                   - -....      -   --...   --....-..........     5,857. 16
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.........................                                       100, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889....................                                    105, 857. 16
   (See Appendix E 7.)
   8. Gowanus Bay, New York.-The depth of water in the channels of
Gowanus Creek and Bay was originally only from 7 to 12 feet at mean
low water, which was wholly insufficient for the passage of vessels em-
ployed in the commerce of the district.
   The plan of improvement, adopted in 1881, provided for giving a
depth of 18 feet to the channels in the bay leading up to the mouth of
the creek on both the north and south sides, and for carrying the im-
provement with the same depth up the creek to Hamilton Avenue
Bridge, a distance of about 1 mile.
   The channel widths were to be 200 feet, except for the last few hun-
dred feet up to the bridge, in which distance the width would gradually
decrease.
   The estimated cost of this improvement was $192,564.90, of which
$65,000 had been appropriated up to June 30, 1886. With this money
the northern channel leading up to the creek had been completed, and
the dredging carried on up the creek to within 2,100 feet of Hamilton
Avenue Bridge; and the southern channel had been dredged to within
2,000 feet of the mouth of the creek.
   The act of August 5, 1886, appropriatel $7,500 for the improvement.
This was applied to dredging a channel 1,500 long and 40 feet wide at
bottom, from the end of the last dredging in the creek up towards Ham-
                         RIVER        AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                 63
ilton Avenue Bridge. The depth obtained was 18 feet, but owing to
the softness of the material it has since filled in to 15 feet.
   The rates of wharfage in New York Harbor are now so high that the
necessity for getting additional wharf room has become imperative, and
nowhere can it be so easily had as in Gowanus Bay.
   Eventually the channels here must be made both wider and deeper
than they will be under the present plan of improvement, but for the
present they should be deepened to 18 feet.
   No work has been done during the present fiscal year, owing to the
want of funds.
July 1, 1887, amount available ........---------......----............---------.----......------------...... $64. 31
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.--..-------......   ----......----...........---- .---........---......    -----    1. 00

                                     ......-------.....--................ ......-----
July 1, 1888, balance available.....--                                                                      63. 31
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ..........................                               60, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889....................                              60, 063.31

 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-........                             60, 000. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                           60, 000. 00
1 Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river. and
L harbor acts of 15i6 and 1867.
     (See Appendix E 8.)
   9. New York- Harbor.-Beforethe improvement of the main entrance
into New York Harbor was undertaken by the United States, the least
depth in mid-channel on the bar was 23.7 feet, at mean low water, and
the same depth could be carried across three other shoals between the
bar and deep water in the harbor.
   A large proportion of the vast commerce of the port which is carried
on in vessels of great draught could only cross these shoals at, or near,
high water.
   The prqject for the improvement of Gedney's Channel was approved
by the Secretary of War in December, 1884, and its extension to cover
the whole of the main entrance to the harbor received his approval
December 27, 1886.
   It provides for dredging a channel 1,000 feet wide and 30 feet deep
at mean low water, from deep water below the Narrows through the
Main Ship Channel and Gedney's Channel to deep water outside the
bar; maintaining this channel, should it be necessary, either by peri-
odical dredging, or by contracting the entrance by the construction of
a dike running across the shoals from Coney Island side, with suitable
protection for the head of Sandy Hook to prevent its being scoured
away by the increased current.
   The estimated cost of obtaining the dredged channel is $1,490,000 for
dredging 4,300,000 cubic yards ; and the entire cost of the improvement,
should the contraction works prove to be necessary, is estimated at be-
tween $5,000,000 and $6,000,000.
    Under this project an extended survey of the lower bay had been
made on which the method of improvement was based, and 303,869
cubic yards of sand had been dredged from Gedney's Channel at the
close of the last fiscal year.
    This had resulted in ptoducing a channel of good navigable width
across the bar 25 feet deep at mean low water; but no practical benefit
to navigation had resulted, since no increase in depth had been obtained
on the shoals inside the bar; the application of the funds having been
restricted by the language of the appropriation act to Gedney's Channel
only.
64         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  During the past fiscal year both the bar and the inner shoals have
been dredged under contract with the Joseph Edwards Dredging Com-
pany, and 580,405 cubic yards of sand and mud have been removed at
281 cents per cubic yard. A channel has been obtained not less than
500 feet wide in which the least depths between the steamer wharves
and the ocean, is 26 feet on the bar, and 25.4 feet on the shoal west of
Flynn's Knoll in the lower bay.
  These dimensions are sufficient to enable the largest steamers arriv-
ing off the bar as now loaded to reach their wharves without delay at
average low tide; and they also permit any of the large steamers leav-
ing the port at high water, as is usual, to go to sea loaded fully 2 feet
deeper than was ever practicable before.
  The dredged channels have been thoroughly buoyed, and as soon as
the pilots have become familiar with the new channels the port of New
York will reap the full benefit of the results.
  Surveys made in December, 1887, and May, 1888, show that no shoal-
ing whatever had taken place on the bar in the interval of six months
during which no dredging was done there. As a like comparison was
made a year ago with precisely the same result, there are good grounds
for expecting that the dredged channel across the bar may maintain its
new dimensions by the action of the currents alone.
  Arrangements have been made for increasing the number of dredges
at work on the shoals, and it is expected that the existing contracts for
the removal of 2,200,000 cubic yards will be completed at the time
specified, December 1, 1888.
  The amount needed outside of the present appropriation to widen
these channels to 1,000 feet, and to deepen them to 30 feet at mean low
water as required by the plan of improvement, is $160,000; and this
amount could be well expended in the next fiscal year.
                              ......----- ....---......----....---.......--.....----.
July 1, 1887, amount available------                                                    $742, 293. 27
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ..................... $137, 714.37
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities.................. ......    60, 467.95
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts.......... 461,586.27
                                                                                         659, 768. 59

July 1, 1888, balance available .........................................                 82, 524.68
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ........................                   380, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                462, 524.68

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 160, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix E 9.)
   10. Sheepshead Bay, New York.-The project for the improvement of
this bay, adopted in 1879, provided for maintaining the natural outlet
of the bay-into Rockaway Inlet by means of diking and dredging, and
for contracting the water-way in the bay above the entrance by means
of dikes so as to afford a channel 6 feet deep up to the head of naviga-
tion, about 2 miles above the mouth.
   The depth of water at the mouth was about 2 feet, but the channel
was unCertain and shifting.
   The estimated cost of the improvement was $100,000.
   A resurvey was made in 1882, when the old outlet was found to be
nearly closed up, and it was then proposed to cut a new outlet 6 feet
deep and 100 feet wide north of the old one into Dead-Horse Inlet, and
                        RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.-                                                      65
to dredge the interior channels of the bay to a depth of 6 feet at mean
low water.
  The estimated cost of this was $34,200, of which $16,000 had been
appropriated up to June 30, 1886.
   After some correspondence and delay the new outlet was excavated
and protected on the north side by a bulkhead built partly by the prop-
erty owners and partly by the contractor who was doing the dredging
for the Government.
   The present appropriation will be applied to deepening the channel
through the bay, though no permanent good can result from it.
   The navigation of the bay is restricted almost entirely to pleasure
boats used by the Coney Island and Gravesend Bay hotels, and there
seems to be no present necessity for further appropriations for this im-
provement.
July 1, 1887, amount available-----.----..... ----....---....
                                                       --.... .. ...---..----............ $5, 283.73
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                                                   -----
  outstanding July 1, 1887 .---..........------.........----........--      ............      166. 17
July 1, 1888, balance available ..........--.... -..........................                           5,117.56
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888            ...          -............ ..-....            5, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889------------....................                 10,117.56
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--....                                 8,200. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E 10.)
   11. Canarsie Bay, New York.-The plan of improvement adopted for
this harbor in 1879 proposed to obtain a channel 6 feet deep at mean
low water by means of diking and dredging from the 6-foot curve in
Jamaica Bay up to the Canarsie Dock, a distance of about 3,500 feet.
   The estimated cost of this improvement was $88,000, of which $33,000
have been appropriated up to the close of the fiscal year ending June
30, 1888. With this amount a pile-dike 1,150 feet long has been built
on the north side of the outer end of the channel, and a channel from
5 to 6 feet deep and from 50 to 125 feet wide has been kept open from
the 6-foot curve in Jamaica Bay up to the dock at Canarsie Landing.
   The appropriation of August 5, 1886, has been applied during the
fiscal year to dredging three shoals in the channel, and to beginning
the construction of 850 linear feet of the south dike, which work is still
in progress.
   As the channel can not be regarded as secure before the south dike
is completed, it is recommended that $10,000 be appropriated for this
purpose and for such dredging as may become necessary.
July 1, 1887, amount available--- ....        -...... ..- .     .-.             .     ......         $10, 066. 75
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887.................-------------------....   $1, 630. 38
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts ..........                        8, 389. 50
                                                                                                 -    10, 019. 88

July 1, 1888, balance available ......- ----.............. --..--....               ----......             46. 87
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.......................                                  10, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30f 1889...... ..............                            10, 046.87

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                          10, 000. 00
  Submtitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1666 and 186g.
   (See Appendix E 11.)
       ENG 88-   5
 66         REPORT OF THE CHIEF                               OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   12. Sumpawanus Inlet, New York.-The project for the improvement of
this inlet, known locally as Sumpwams Creek, adopted in 1880, pro-
vided for dredging a channel about 4,500 feet long, and from 100 to
150 feet wide and 5 feet deep at mean low water, beginning at the
5-foot curve in the Great South Bay and extending up to the town of
Babylon, Long Island.
   The chaunel depth at the time of the adoption of the project varied
from 5 feet in the bay at mean low water to 2 feet at the wharf at the
mouth of the creek, and from 1 to 2 feet up the creek a distance of a
little over half a mile.
   The rise and fall of the tide is so slight here that there is no scour in
the channel; nor could an efficient scour be obtained by contracting
the channel width.
   Therefore, it was decided to get the channel desired by dredging from
the deeper waters of the bay up to the steam-boat wharf at the mouth
of the creek, a distance of 1,500 feet, and thence up the creek for a
distance of about 3,500 feet; the estimated cost being $23,115.
   Seven thousand dollars was applied towards obtaining a channel up
to the steam-boat wharf, but shoaling has occurred since the work was
done in 1883. The commerce of the town of Babylon, which lies on the
creek, is almost entirely moved now by rail, and there appears to be little
reason for restoring or completing the channel to the steam-boat wharf
at the mouth of the creek, and none whatever for constructing it up to
Babylon, two-thirds of a mile above.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, contains no appropria-
tion for this work.
July 1,1887, amount available------........                           .........................                        $81.88
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1887...........             ................                ......   ......     --
                                                                                                       --........       10. 00

July 1, 1888, balance available - ....................                                  ..... ......   .....            71.88

SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......                                            16,000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix E 12.)
  13. Channel between Staten Island and New Jersey.--The improvement
of this channel, so far, has been restricted to that part of it about 1
miles long which lies east of Elizabethport, N. J., and at the mouth of
Newark Bay.
  This part of the channel had formerly a depth of only 91 feet in it at
mean low water; at present it has a depth of not less than 13 feet for
widths varying from 300 to 400 feet.
  The present project for its improvment is a modification of that pro-
posed in 1876, and provides for obtaining a channel 400 feet wide and 13
feet deep at mean low water, by means of dredging and, if necessary, dik-
ing, the estimated cost being $210,000. Of this amount $119,000 have
been already appropriated.
  Work during the fiscal year has been confined to widening the eastern
and western ends of the channel to 400 feet.
July 1, 1887, amount available--         ___.._._.............                     ...........     . ..             $1, 926.25
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887-------------------....................................------------------....              1,115.65
July 1, 1888, balance available ......................................-...                                             810.60
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ..........................                                            15, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                           15,810.60
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                          67
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project                               ........
                                                                                                   ----     $76, 000.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                30, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1837.
     (See Appendix E 13.)
     14. Raritan Bay, New Jersey.-The project of improvement now be-
  ing executed provides for opening a channel from Ward's Point, oppo-
  site Perth Amboy, N. J., past Seguine's Point, Staten Island, and out
- into the deep water of the Lower Bay of New York. The channel to
  be 21 feet deep at mean low water and 300 feet wide. Also a channel
  leading from this up to the wharves of South Amboy, 15 feet deep at
  mean low water and 300 feet wide.
     Work previous to 1887 was confined to dredging a 21 foot channel
  through the shoal east of Seguine's Point; but the channel has filled
  in materially again during the last three years.
     Duping the past fiscal year it was expected to obtain a 21-foot dhan-
  nel from Ward's Point past Great Beds Light; but the channel was
  found to be shoaler than had been anticipated, and the funds were not
  sufficient to complete it.
     The channel leading to South Amboy has'not been begun.
     To complete the project of improvement, the whole balance of the
original estimates of last year, namely, $57,500, will be needed.
July 1, 1887, amount available---..--.---.........--....----.........---..........                          $37, 579. 03
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
   liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887---------
                                          .......                ----
                                                  - -....--....---....                       $33, 636. 18
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities                  . --- ..--...--                ....
                                                                          --......--......     2,935. 13
                                                                                                             S6, 571. 31

July 1, 1888, balance available...........---------------.....---.....-----....------..........---......      1,007.72
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888............---------.....---- -........                        25,000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889......-......-...-.                                     26,007.72

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-. . 57, 500. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 47, 500. CO
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sect ions 2 of river and
  . harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E 14.)
   15. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering naviga-
tion.-(1)' Sloop Locomotive.-Hudson River. This sloop, sunk in the
Hudson River, off Saugerties, N. Y., in August, 1887, was removed at
a cost of $317.94, by hired labor, October 27 and 28, 1887.
   (2) Bark        Quickstep.-New
                              York Harbor. This vessel was wrecked on
the west side of the main ship-channel, New York Harbor, in 1887, and
was removed under contract, at a cost of $3,200, during the fiscal year.
  (3) Wreck of a canal-boat in flarlein River near Bigh Bridge.-The
wreck was removed at a cost of $175, by the Baxter Wrecking Coin-
pany, during December, 1887, and January, 1888.
  (See Appendix E 15.)

EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS FOR IMPROVEMENT, TO COMPLY WITH
REQUIREMENTS OF THE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT OF AUGUST 5, 1886.

  The required preliminary examination of Spring Creek, New York, was
made by the local engineer, Lieutenant-Colonel McFarland, and reported
by him as not worthy of improvement. The results were transmitted
to Congress and printed as House Ex. Doe. No. 70, Fittieth Congress,
second session. (See also Appendix E 16.)
68          REPORT OF TH                     _CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  It appearing, after preliminary examination by the local engineer,
that the locality was worthy of improvement, Lieutenant-Colonel Gilles-
pie completed the survey of Hudson River, New York, between New Balti-
more and Coxsackie, the results of which were transmitted to Congress
and printed as House Ex: Doe. 265, Fiftieth Congress, first session.
(See also Appendix E 17.)
IMPROVEMENT                OF RIVERS IN NORTHERN NEW JERSEY, AND OF THE
                                  HARBOR OF KEYPORT.

   Officer in charge,'Capt. George McC. Derby, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Passaic River, New Jersey.-This river is being improved under two
separate projects, the first applying to the river above Center street, or
Pennsylvania Railroad Bridge, Newark, as far as Passaic, a distance of
8 miles, and the second to the lower course of the river, from the Center
Street Bridge to beyond the shoals in Newark Bay, a distance of 7J
miles.
   a. Passaic River, above Newark.- Before its improvement was under-
taken, the upper part of the river had a navigable 6-foot channel, ex-
cept at Middle, Belleville, Rutherford Park, and Holzman's Bars, where
the depths were 4.5 feet, 3.9 feet, 3 feet, and 3.5 feet, respectively.
   The project of improvement was adopted in 1872, and provided for a
channel across the above shoals from 7 to 6 feet deep at mealn low
water, and from 200 to 50 feet wide, to be obtained by dredging and
diking, at a cost of $123,924. It was modified in 1885, by extending
the channel, below Middle Bar, 1,500 feet, to the Erie Railroad Bridge,
increasing the estimate to $129,000.
   Under this project $123,762.04 had been expended to June 30, 1887,
and channels of the required depth had been dredged from 60 to 75 feet
wide, excepting for a distance of 1,500 feet above the Erie Railroad
Bridge.
   There has been no work done on the upper river during the fiscal
year, no method of applying efficiently the small allotment of $2,250
made by the act of August 5, 1886, having been found. The condition
of the river remains unchanged.
   The population of the townships on the Passaic, above Newark, in-
cluding the city of Paterson, was returned in 1885 as 114,726, and the
commerce of the upper river was valued in 1884 at $1,032,000. The
number of vessels passing the Center Street Draw-bridge during the'
year 1887 has been 10,040, compared with 9,485 in 1886 and 6,271 in 1879.
   The expenditures during the year have been for draughting (old
records) and administration.
   The balance of the estimate for the completion of the existing project,
 $7,512, can be expended profitably as regards the efficient prosecution
of the work during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, and if appro.
priated will be expended in dredging the channels to the dimensions
required by the project.
July 1, 1887, amount available............ ............                           ......   ......    ......      $2, 487.96
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.-------------.....---....----........----....------.-----....- .......-..-----.....        345.50

July 1, 1888, balance available --..----...----......-- ..----.---------.......-----.---                -.........--- 2, 142. 46
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .....             -..       .........-....                              7, 500.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889........,........                                            9, 642, 46
     (See Appendix F 1.)
                          RIVER AND 1HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                        69
  b. PassaicRiver, below Newark.-The lower portion of the river, from
the Center Street Bridge to Newark Bay, was first surveyed by the
Engineer Department in 1879. The greatest depth in the channel, at
a point above the Elbow Beacon, was only 7.1 feet, and in many places
the greatest depth was 7.5 feet at mean low water.
   A project was adopted, based on this survey, providing for obtain-
ing, by diking and dredging, a channel 200 feet wide and 10 feet deep
at mean low water from the Center Street Bridge to Newark Bay, at a
cost of $232,875.
   This project was modified in 1884, pursuant to the river and harbor
act of that year, providing for extending the dike at the mouth of the
river into the bay a distance of 8,000 feet, and for dredging a channel
across the shoal in Newark Bay 200 feet wide and 10 feet deep at mean
low water, increasing the original estimate to $353,875.
   June 30, 1887, $149,223.60, exclusive of outstanding liabilities, had
been expended under this project; the dike at the mouth had been ex-
tended about 1,700 feet, making a total length of 5,705 feet. The chan-
nel through the shoal in the bay had been dredged to the required
dimensions, as also the channel up the river, as far as the Newark and
New York Railroad Bridge. The remainder of the distance to the
Center Street Bridge, the 10-foot channel had only been dredged from
130 to 100 feet in width. These results had been of very great benefit
to the large commerce of the river, which was estimated in 1881 at
1,200,000 tons, valued at $30,000,000.
   The contract for the extension of the dike at the mouth of the river
was completed September 7; 500.3 feet of dike were constructed during
the fiscal year, making the total length of the dike 6,205 feet.
   The expenditures during the year amount to $1,782.25, for construc-
tion and inspection of dike, surveying, and administration.
July 1, 1887, amount available ....--...------.--------.......---- --.-----............--....----...       $4, 895. 40
July 1, 1888, amount expended ddring fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887...................----            ...---. $1,603.25
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ........................----- ----.                          179. 00
                                                                                                           1,782. 25

July 1, 1888, balance available ......-............ ....--- --.. ...... --....                            3, 113. 15
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888-...--------..----...-..--------.........--                 27, 500. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889----..---..... ....                        --...    30, 613. 15
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- - -.                              --   154, 375.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                              60, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F 1.)
   2. Elizabeth River, New Jersey.-This stream, which is 2- miles from
its mouth to the head of navigation at Broad street, Elizabeth, has a
width of from 50 to 90 feet, and before its improvement the wharves in
the city could only be reached at high water by vessels drawing less
than 4 feet; its commerce was estimated at 45,000 tons annually. The
range of the tide was about 4.7 feet at its mouth, and 3.4 feet at Bridge
street.
   The project for the improvement was adopted in 1878, and provides
for obtaining, by dredging, a channel 60 feet wide and 7 feet deep at
high water from the mouth of the river to the bead of navigation, at
an estimated cost of $25,530.
   The amount expended under this project to June 30, 1887, was
$26,708.66, and a channel had been dredged to the required depth to
70          REPORT, OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

within 1,000 feet of the Broad Street Bridge. A slight increase in the
commerce of the stream had been observed.
  There has been no appropriation for this work since 1882. The con-
dition of the river has deteriorated since work was suspended. When
last examined vessels drawing 5 feet could ascend the river to the head
of thedredged channel at high tide. The commerce of the river is about
30,000 tons, but no substantial increase can be expected while the river
remains in its present condition. A coal-yard established last year has
done a business of about 6,000 tons.
   The city of Elizabeth has a population of about 33,000, and does an
active commerce over two important lines of railroad, a considerable
portion of which would take the water route, to great advantage, if ad-
equate facilities existed. It is stated that the establishment of the coal-
yard on the river has reduced the retail price of coal 50 cents per ton.
   The estimated amount required for the completion of the improve:
ment is $16,160.
July 1, 1887, amount available ....... ..................
                                              _               ............--....                               $291.34
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887..........................      ............  ........- -                               13. 08
July 1, 1888, balance available .....                  ..... ....    ............ .....       .........         278.26

SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......                                     16,160.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix F 2.)
  3. Rahway River, New Jersey.-In its original condition the Rahway
River had a depth of 8 feet and more at mean high water from its
mouth to Bricktown, 3a miles; 7 feet to Edgar's Dock, 4k miles; 4.4
feet to Milton Avenue Bridge, 4( miles; and 4 feet to Main Street
Bridge, 5 miles in the town of Rahway. Its commerce was estimated
at 120,000 tons, and three attempts had been made to establish a line
of steam-boats on the river, but had failed on account of the bad con-
dition of the stream.
   The original project for its improvement was adopted in 1878, and
provided for dredging a channel 125 feet wide and 8 feet deep at high
water from Bricktown to Milton Avenue Bridge, and 100 feet wide from
that point to Main Street Bridge. The tide rises about 5 feet at the
mouth and 4 feet at the head of navigation.
   June 30, 1887, $36,918.13 had been expended under this project,
which had resulted in the formation of a channel 7 feet deep at high
water, and from 100 to 50 feet in width to within 550 feet of the head
of navigation. It has, however, not proved permanent.
   The commerce of the river had not increased, though freight rates to
Rahway had been materially reduced as a result of the improvement of
the -river.
  There has been no appropriation for this work since 1882.
July 1, 1887, amount available.......................................-----------------------------------..      $81.87
July 1, 1818, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ..--.-.------                             .--------------------.---                    14. 20
July 1, 1888, balance available ...........                     ..... ...... ....       ............   ..        67.67

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                    29, 250. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix F 3.)
                         RIVER     AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                   71
   4. Woodbridge Creek, New Jersey.--In its original condition this stream
was obstructed at its mouth by a bar having a depth of 9.8 feet on its
crest at high water, and by two shoalsjust inside the mouth. From these
shoals a good 12-foot channel existed to above Anderson's Brick Works,
seven-eighths of a mile from the mouth, above which point, however,
many shoals occurred, though a narrow 8-foot channel existed as far as
Salamdander Dock, 1 miles from the mouth. The town of Woodbridge,
and numerous fire-brick, tile, and drain-pipe works, situated on the
creek, did a considerable trade, estimated at 126,000 tons annually.
The range of the tide is about 5 feet.
   The project for improving the creek was adopted in 1878, and pro-
vides for obtaining by dredging and diking a channel 80 feet wide and
12 feet deep at mean high water from the mouth to Salamander Dock,
at an estimated cost of $13,800, increased in 1884 to $29,000.
   The amount expended under this project to June 30, 1887, was $19,000,
with which the required dike had been constructed, and a 12-foot chan-
nel, from 80 to 25 feet wide, had been obtained as far as Valentine's
Dock, 1 miles, and a 9-foot channel 80 feet wide thence to Town Dock,
1,200 feet further up; and the creek was also widened 20 feet at the
elbow opposite Salamander Dock. No increase in the commerce of the
creek had been observed.
   There has been no appropriation for this work since 1882; there were
no funds available during the last fiscal year, and no expenditures.
The condition of the channel has deteriorated since work was suspended,
and shoals are complained of both above and below Valentine's Dock.
There has been no increase in the amount of commerce reported above,
which is already very large in proportion to the size of the stream.
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ $10, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F 4.)
   5. RaritanRiver, New Jersey.-Before its improvement by the United
States, the Raritan River had a depth of 8.5 feet at "The Stakes," 3
miles; of 6.5 feet at the "Middle Grounnds," 4 miles; of 7.5 feet at
Whitehead's Sand Dock, 81 miles, and between this point and New
Brunswick, 124 miles above the mouth, the channel was obstructed by
a number of rocky shoals with depths of from 8.4 feet to 6.9 feet at mean
low water. The city of New Brunswick and the Delaware and Raritan
Canal, which terminates here, together with extensive brick-yards on
the South River, did a large commerce on the stream, estimated in 1871
at 3,053,857 tons per annum.
   The present project was adopted in 1874, and provides for obtaining,
by diking and dredging, and where necessary, by drilling and blasting
rock, a channel 200 feet wide and 10 feet deep at mean low water, from
the mouth to New Brunswick, at a cost of $2,093,662.05. It was modi-
fied in 1881, pursuant to the river and harbor act of March 3 of that year,
by adding to it the dredging of the South Channel, about 13,000 feet
long, 100 feet wide, and 5) feet deep at mean low water, from Kearney's
Dock to Crab Island.
   Under this project $447,638.57 had been expended June 30, 1887, in
constructing the dikes required by the project at "The Stakes" and
"Middle Grounds," in dredging channnels 200 feet wide and 12 feet
deep   at   mean   low     water   at   these   points,   and   in   drilling,   blasting   and

dredging a channel of the same dimensions across the rocky shoal at
Whitebheads Sand Dock. Under the two special allotments made for it
72          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

in the acts of March 3, 1881, and August 2, 1882, the South Channel
was dredged to the required depth for a distance of 4,000 feet. These
improvements have been of great benefit to navigation, permitting the
large tows in use on the river to reach a point 4 miles below New Bruns-
wick at all stages of the tide.
   The expenditures during the fiscal year amount to $9,082.05.
   The rock-drilling plant has been put in good working order, surveys
have been made of the shoal below Martin's Dock, and dredging has
been begun on the lower shoal.
   The balance now available will be expended this season in extending
the 10-foot channel to Martin's Dock, :IL miles below New Brunswick,
and in constructing a dike at the "Middle Grounds."
July 1, 1887, amount available---............-              --............          ---..--...---......         $23, 651.91
Amouut received from Captain Derby for sale of fuel (March 31 and June
                   ......---.....------....--------..........--.....--..---.--..-...............
29, 1888)------.....-----                                                                                             2. 00
                                                                                                                23, 653. 91
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887-----....--------.......------....              $8, 896. 49
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ...............                   ......
                                                                    -185.                                  56
                                                                                                                  9, 082. 05
July 1, 1888, balance available................ ........................                                        14,571.86
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .... ..................                                           50, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889-                           .......       ---......         64,571.86

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-...... 1,572, 412. 05
I Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
    30, 1890..---.------.------------------.....                          100,000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F 5.)
   6. South River, New Jersey.-Before the improvement of this stream
was undertaken by the United States the navigation of the lower 2.
miles of its course had been abandoned, and a canal dredged at private
expense, from a short distance below Washington to Sayreville on the
Raritan River. In 1880,' when the present project for improving the
river was adopted, the mouth of this canal on account of its faulty loca-
tion had shoaled to a depth of 4.6 feet at mean low water, and the best
depth in the canal some distance above had decreased to 3.3 feet.
Above Washington a depth of 2.7 feet existed to Bissett's, 3J miles,
and of 2.5 feet to Old Bridge, the head of navigation, 61 miles above
the mouth of the canal at Sayreville.
   The present project adopted in 1880 provides for closing the river be-
low the head of the canal, correcting the direction of the mouth of the
latter, and obtaining by diking and dredging a depth of 8 feet mean
low water to Washington, 6 feet to Bissett's, and 4 feet to Old Bridge,
straightening the channel at two points by cutting across the meadow;
it was estimated to cost $194,95.
   The amount expended under this project to June 30, 1887, was $55,-
863.31, exclusive of outstanding liabilities, with which the direction of
the mouth of the canal had been changed, the dikes below Washington
completed, and a small amount of dredging done on a shoal above
Washington.
   During the last fiscal year the funds available have been expended,
a shoal at the mouth of Washington Canal has been removed, and a
channel dredged 60 feet wide through the canal and 50 feet wide across
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                 73
the shoal in the river below Washington.                          Vessels drawing 6 feet can
reach Washington at mean low water.
                                                                           $5,111.75
July 1, 1887, amount available ....-------.....................-----.......-....-----.
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887......................-----------------------------------..............4, 820.09
July 1, 1888, balance available .--------------------.                        ......--
                                                                                     ...         291. 66
Amount appropriated by act of August 1.1, 1888......................---..
                                                          ------------                         5,000.00
                                                                  --   5, 291.66
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .--...----..-----.........
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.... .... 128, 695. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 10, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    -harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F 6.)
   7. Cheesequakes Creek, New Jersey.-In its original condition the stream
was obstructed at its mouth by a sand-bar, on which the best depth was
1 foot at mean low water; for about a mile of its length the channel
had a depth of 6 feet, but the remainder had generally a depth of 3
feet and less. The range of the tide is 5.1 feet. Five hundred and
forty-six small vessels passed the draw at the mouth of the creek in
1878.
   The project for this improvement was adopted in 1879, and provides
for obtaining by dredging and diking a channel 5 feet deep at mean low
water, and 200 feet wide, at the mouth of the creek, and 4 feet deep with
a width of from 100 to 50 feet to the head of navigation at Whitehead's
Dock, 3 miles from the mouth.
   The amount expended under this project to June 30, 1887, was
$40,000; the least depth in the improved channel at the mouth was 4.5
feet at mean low water; no work had been done on the shoals above,
and no increase in the commerce of the creek had been observed.
   There have been no funds available during the year ending June 30,
1888, and no expenditures. The condition of the creek and its traffic
remain substantially unchanged.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, contains no appropria-
tioni for this work.
   The estimated amount required for the completion of the improve-
ment is $50,000.
   (See Appendix F 7.)
   8. Keyport Harbor, New Jerscy.-Keyport Harbor was originally ac-
cessible at low water only to vessels drawing less than 4 feet. Before
its improvement was undertaken by the United States a 6-foot channel
had been dredged at private expense, which had shoaled in 1872 to 5)
feet, and in 1882 to 5 feet, the range of the tide being 4.7 feet. A large
commerce was carried on, however, valued at $2,932,000.
   The project for the improvement was adopted in 1873, and provided
for dredging a channel 4,700 feet long, 8 feet deep at mean low water,
and 200 feet wid(e from the steam-boat dock to the 8 foot contour in
Raritan Bay, at an estimated cost of $30,475. The revised estimate of
1884 was for $40,475.
   The amount expended under this project to June 30, 1887, was $30,-
020.51, with which a'channel had been dredged from the 8-foot depth
in Raritan Bay to Keyport Wharf, a'distance of 5,000 feet, with a width
of 200 feet for the first 4,200 feet, and 160 feet for the remainder.
   The river and harbor act of 1888 made no appropriation for this
work.
74           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, t.                                                 S. ARMY.

July 1, 1887, amount available-----.... ......................                     ...............------
                                                                                             ------.            454.49
July 1, 1885, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 .....................------------------------...               $22. 38
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities . - - -.................                         ..               5. 00
                                                                                                                 27. 38

July 1, 1888, balance available------...... .--------.....-----......--......------......--...-- ......         427. 11

SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....... 10,000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix F 8.)
   9. Mattawan G Creek, New Jersey.-Before its improvement by the Gov-
ernmen.t this small stream was obstructed at its entrance into Keyport
Harbor by a mud flat, on which the best depth at the worst section was
3.1 feet at mean low water, though the 3-foot channel was too narrow
and tortuous for use. Above this flat a good 4-foot channel existed to
al miles above the mouth, and thence to the steam-boat dock at Matta-
wan 3.5 feet, shoaling to 1.8 feet at the freight dock, 600 feet above, and
1- miles from the mouth. The range of the tide is 4.7 feet. Notwith-
standing the above difficulties it carried commerce valued in 1880 at
$800,000.
   The I)roject for the improvment was adopted in 1881, and provides
for dredging a channel 4 feet deep at mean low water, and 100 feet wide
from the mouth to Winkson Creek, and thence 75 feet wide to the rail-
road bridge at Mattawan, 250 feet above the freight dock, at an esti.
mated cost of $33,120.
   To June 30, 1887, the amount expended under this project was $21,000,
with which a channel had been dredged, giving the required depth from
the mouth to the freight dock at Mattawan, with widths varying from
100 to 30 feet.
   The estimated value of the commerce of the creek had increased to
over $2,000,000 in 1885, amounting to 130,000 tons.
   There has been no appropriation for this stream since 1882; there
were no funds available for the past fiscal year, and there have been no
expenditures. The condition of the stream has deteriorated since work
was suspended, and complaints are made of shoaling at the mouth of
the river. There has been no increase in the amount of commerce re-
ported above, which is already very large in proportion to the facilities
offered by the stream.
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....... $12,120.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix F 9.)
   10. Shrewsbury River, New Jersey.-When the present project for this
improvement was adopted in 1879 the river was obstructed by a number
of shifting sand-bars, which had caused the complete suspension of navi-
gation in the South Branch, and only permitted the passage of vessels
engaged in commerce up the North Branch at or near high water. A
considerable trade was carried on, however, even under these difficult
conditions.
  The originally-adopted project for the improvement was to dredge a
channel 6 feet deep at mean low water and from 300 to 150 feet in width,
accross the shoals from the mouth to Red Bank, on the North Branch,
8 miles, and Branchport, on the South Branch, 9 miles, maintaining
these channels by longitudinal dikes. This project has not been modi-
                       RIVER AND HARBOR                 IMPROVEMENTS.                                 75
fled as to the end sought, but the estimates of the diking, dredging, and
cost have been increased from time to time.
   The amount expended on the project to June 30, 1887; was $196,933.50,
exclusive of existing contracts, which had resulted in the material im-
provement of the river, the commerce of which had been more than
trebled since the commencement of the improvement.
   During the last fiscal year $3,186.43, exclusive of existing contracts,
have been expended in constructing 2,564 linear feet of stone dikes at
and near the junction of the North and South Branches of the river, in
making tidal observations, and for administration. The condition of
the river channels remains the same as last year. A depth of 5.9 feet
exists on the bar at the mouth of the river at mean low water, and 5.5
feet can be carried to Red Bank and 4.4 feet to Brancl'port.
July 1, 1887, amount available................ ......................                   ....    $7,456. 50
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887..............----.....      $3, 085.08
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..................
                                         --------------------------.
                                                              ....     101.35
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts ............     2, 915.95
                                                                                                 6,102.38

July 1, 1888, balance available.........       ....   .........   _   .............    .....     1,354. 12
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.......................                    .....   10, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ---..                    ..... .......    11, 354.12
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- - - --.                       40,062.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                     20, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F 10.)
   11. Manasquan River, New Jersey.--In its original condition this
stream had a depth of from 6 to 4 feet at mean low water for several
miles above its mouth, but was obstructed at its outlet into the ocean
by a' sand-spit, which had deflected the stream into a channel parallel
with the beach, communicating with the ocean across shifting sand-
bars, on which the best depth did not exceed 1I feet at mean low water;
mean range of tide, 2.4 feet. In severe storms this channel was sometimes
entirely closed by the sand, remaining so until the fresh water in the
river had accumulated sufficiently to force a new outlet. Under these
conditions the river could not be used by commerce.
   The project for its improvement was adopted in 1879, and contem-
plated dredging the lower river and obtaining by means of jetties a
permanent outlet nearly at right angles to the beach, with a depth of
6 feet at mean low water, at an estimated cost of $52,120.
   The amount expended on this project to June 30, 1887, was $39,000,
with which two jetties had been constructed, but neither to its full
length, appropriations having ceased in 1882. No permanent improve-
ment had been effected.
   There were no expenditures on account of this work during the year
ending June 30, 1888, there being no funds available.
   As there is no commerce on the river now, and no population or inter-
ests sufficient to support a trade at all commensurate with the cost of
making the river available, it does not seem likely that it is the in-
tention of Congress to complete this work, particularly as no appro-
priation has been made for it in several years.
SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.-------.... $33, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F 11.)
76     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

IMPROVEMENT OF DELAWARE AND SCHUYLKILL RIVERS AND OF
  RIVERS IN NEW JERSEY-IIHARBOR IMPROVEMENTS IN DELAWARE
  RIVER AND BAY-CONSTRUCTION OF PIER AT LEWES-DELAWARE
  BREAKWATER.

   O~fficer in charge, Lieut. Col. Henry M. Robert, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Delaware River, Pennsylvania and New Jersey.-Trenton, the head
of natural navigation on the Delaware River, is about 30 miles above
the upper part of the port of Philadelphia. In its original condition
this part of the river was obstructed by shoals at the following locali-
ties: Between Bordentown and Trenton, a distance of about 5 miles, a
narrow and circuitous channel existed, which carried from 3 to 6 feet at
mean low water; at Kinkora Bar, about 9 miles below Trenton, a shoal,
carrying from 7 to 8 feet, and at Five Mile Bar, at the upper part of
Philadelphia, a shoal carrying only 3 or 4 feet at mean low water.
   Below Philadelphia the river in its original condition presented ob-
structions at Mifflin Bar which reduced the depth at mean low water to
17 feet, at Schooner Ledge and Cherry Island Flats to 18 feet, at Bulk-
head Shoals and Dan Baker Shoal to about 20 feet.
   The project for the comprehensive improvement of the Delaware River
between Trenton and the upper part of Philadelphia has not yet been
considered. Efforts in the past have been directed toward relieving
commerce from the obstructions which exist in the upper 9 miles of the
river, or that part between Kinkora Bar and Trenton. A detailed sur-
vey of the river between Bridesburg and Trenton has been made for
the purpose of obtaining the necessary data for determining upon a coin-
prehensive plan for the permanent improvement of the river between
Trenton and the upper part of Philadelphia to meet the requirements
of commerce, and also of the plan adopted for the improvement of the
river at and below Philadelphia.
   Previous to 1885 the efforts to improve the river between Philadelphia
and the bay have been confined to dredging, except at Schooner Ledge,
where solid rock has been removed, under appropriations for special
localities, antd also under general appropriations for the Delaware River
below Bridesburg.
   A Board of Engineers, convened by direction of the Secretary of War
for the purpose of considering the subject of the permanent improve-
ment of Delaware River and Bay, recommended, under date of January
23,1885, the formation of a ship-channel from a point opposite Philadel-
phia, and about midway between the American Ship-building Company's
yard and the Gas Trust Wharf to deep water in Delaware Bay, having
a least width of 600 feet and a depth of 26 feet at mean low water. The
formation of such a channel is to be obtained, except at Schooner Ledge,
where rock would require to be removed, by regulating the tidal flow
by means of dikes, with recourse to dredging where necessary as an
aid to such contracting and regulating works. The estimated cost of
obtaining a channel of the above dimensions is about $2,425,000, which
covers the estimated cost of the permanent improvement of the Dela-
ware River between the upper part of Philadelphia and deep water in
the bay. The entire cost of the permanent improvement of the river
between Trenton, N. J., and its mouth can not be stated until after the
completion of the project and estimate for its improvement between
Bridesburg and Trenton.
  The entire amount expended on the improvement of the Delaware
River from 1836 to June 30, 1887, under appropriations both for special
localities and the general river was $1,613,038.27, of which'$103,347.17
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                               77
    was expended on that part of the river bet ween Trenton and the upper
    part of Philadelphia. As a result of this expenditure there had been
    formed at the latter date a channel of navigable width and 74 feet deep
    at mean low water through the bars between Bridesburg and Borden-
    town; a channel across Five Mile Bar 6. feet deep, and past the bar,
    between its south side and Petty's Island, a channel 9 feet deep; a
    channel 450 feet wide and from 24 to 26 feet .deep through the shoal
    areas at Port Richmond; a channel across Mifflin Bar 250 feet wide and
    from 224 to 23 feet deep; a channel through Schooner Ledge 330 feet
    wide and 24 feet deep; a channel through Cherry Island Flats from 200
    to 450 feet wide and froW 24 to 26 feet deep; and a channel across Bulk-
    head Shoals 600 feet wide and from 20 to 21 feet deep.
       The channel between Philadelphia and Camden, across Smith's Island
    Bar, has been improved by the formation of a dredged cut protected by
    revetment, so as to give a channel 150 feet wide with a minimum depth
    of 64 feet at mean low water.
       During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, the sum of $78,526 62,
    which includes the liabilities outstanding June 30, 1887, was expended
    in surveys, examinations, and tidal observations; in dike construction
    at Mifflin Bar and Reedy Island, and in the maintenance of a channel
    between Philadelphia and Camden across Smith's Island Bar, making
    a total expenditure since 1836 of $1,691,564.89, of which $339,564.89
    has been expended on present project.
       The dike at Mifflin Bar is yet incomplete, and the consequent extent
    of its action on the bar quite limited; a recent examination shows that
    the condition of the bar has practically remained unchanged during the
    past year. The dike at Reedy Island was commenced last year and its
    construction has not yet reached an extent sufficient to affect the shoal
    areas it was designed to improve. The channel across Smith's Island
    Bar has maintained a depth of from 8 to 10 feet at mean low water for
    a minimum width of 70 feet.
       The channels at Schooner Ledge, Cherry Island Flats, and Bulkhead
    Shoal have remained unchanged during the year.
    July 1, 1887, amount available ...  . ......-.........-                     ......   ......        ....     $94, 594. 64
    July 1, 1887, covered by existing contracts..................                         ......-------....      43, 581. 98

                                                                                                               138, 176. 62
    July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
      liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887---...---        ..... .....----.   $67, 741.51
    July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ................            -......   8, 195. 58
    July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts ..--.......         -------
                                                                               36,205.04
                                                                                                                112,142.13
I
    July 1, 1888, balance available......         ...........   - -_.................                            26, 034.49
    Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...- -..-................                                      250, 000. 00

    Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889-----------------                                     276, 034. 49

      Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-......                                   1,965,000. 00
      Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
         1890 ............................-----................................                                 500,000.00
      Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
        harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
       (See Appendix G 1.)
      2. Frankford Creek, Pennsylvania.-This creek flows eastward to the
    Delaware River, through the northern portion of the city of Philadel-
    phia. The grounds of the Frankford Arsenal border upon the left bank
    of the creek. In its original condition it had a low-water width of
     78        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

     about 100 feet, and a low-water depth of about 5 feet at its mouth, above
     which it rapidly shoaled, for a distance of about 3 miles, to the head of
     tidal flow.
       The original project proposed the formation of a dredged channel 50
     feet wide from its mouth to Frankford avenue, a distance of about 3
     miles, the channel to have a depth of 3 feet at mean low water at its
     upper end, and increasing to 7 feet at its mouth. The estimated cost
     was $40,000.
       The act of August 2, 1882, appropriated $10,000, which was applied to
'"   the formation of a dredged channel 7 feet deep from its mouth to Horse
     shoe Bend.
       The creek being entirely within the corporate limits of Philadelphia
     is being regulated by the city, and no further appropriation for its im-
     provement by the United States is recommended.
        No work has been done since 1883. The amount expended to June
     30, 1888, was $9,735.50.
     July 1, 1887, amount available.---- ...---...... .....----...............-......             $264.50
     July 1, 1888, balance available.......... ....      .......   ...... ..... ...... ....        264.50

       Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-------....... 30, 000. 00
       Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
         harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
        (See Appendix G 2.)
        3. Harbor of Philadelphia, removal of Smith's Island and Windmill
     Island, Pennsylvania, and Petty's Island, New Jersey.-This is a new
     work. In obedience to the requirements of the joint resolution of Con-
     gress, approved March 5, 1888, a Board of three engineers was appointed
     by the War Department ' to examine and report in relation to the Dela-
     ware River between the city of Philadelphia, Pa., and Camden, N. J.,
     and for other purposes," and its report was transmitted to Congress
     April 7, 1888, and printed as House Ex. Doc. No. 260, Fiftieth Congress,
     first session.
        The plan of improvement proposed by the Board is the forming of a
     channel albng the Philadelphia shore from Kaign's Point to Fisher's
     Point of ample depth, and about 2,000 feet in width, at a distance from
     the present wharf-line not exceeding 300 feet, to permit the extension
     of wharves and the widening of Delaware avenue at their shore ends,
     the removal of Smith's and Windmill islands and adjacent shoals, so as
     to give a 26-foot channel, about 1,000 feet wide, along the revised Phila-
     delphia channel from Kaign's Point to the foot of Petty's Island. The
     estimated cost of the work is $3,500,000.
        The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $500,000
     for the work, of which not to exceed $300,000 is to be applied to the pur-
     chase of islands; and a further sum of $500,000 may be profitably ex-
     pended in continuing it during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
     Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .......-....-...-                     .    $500,000.00

     (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... 3, 000, 000.00
     ( Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
          1890 ................--------............-----
                                                      ................---.....----.            500, 000.00
     I Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     ( harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
       4. Schuylkill River, Pennsylvania.-When the work of improvement
     was commenced in 1870, there was a channel of entrance into the mouth
     of the river carrying a depth of only 15 feet at mean low water,
                         RIVER AND            HARBOR          IMPROVEMENTS.                              79
   The original project under which work was commenced in 1870 pro-
posed the formation of a channel 100 feet wide with a depth of 20 feet
from the mouth of the river to Gibson's Point, and a depth of 18 feet
from thence to Chestnut Street Bridge in Philadelphia.
   In 1875 and 1883 this project was amended so as to increase the mean
low-water channel between the mouth and Girard Point to 400 feet
wide and 24 feet deep, and from Girard Point to Gibson's Point to 250
feet wide and 20 feet deep.
   The amount expended upon these projects to June 30, 1887, was
$368,315.13, and had resulted in the formation of a channel as follows:
Between the mouth and Girard Point Piers, a distance of about 1 mile,
the minimum channel was 150 feet wide and from 18 to 19 feet deep at
mean low water; from Girard Point to Gibson's Point, a distance of
about 3 miles, the channel was 150 to 200 feet wide and 20 feet deep;
from Gibson's Point to Chestnut Street Bridge, a distance of about 3
miles, the channel was of navigable width and 18 feet deep at mean
low water. This latter reach of river has required no other improve-
ment than the removal of about 1,000 cubic yards of rock near Locust
and South streets.
  During the past fiscal year there have been no operations, available
funds having been practically exhausted in the year ending June 30,
1887; $204 was expended for office expenses.
  In the opinion of the officer in charge the shoal areas between the
mouth, and Girard Point can be more economically improved by the
construction of a dike than by the hitherto proposed dredging.
July 1, 1887, amount available.....----.......     .......         ..........-....-....             $434. 87
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1687 --.  ....... . ....... ..... ................                __ ....      204.00

July 1, 1888, balance available........-....... .....                     ....... . ....... .         230. 87
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888. .                                   ........
                                                                          -.-.....-......         25, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                         25,230. 87

TAmount   (estimated) required for completion of existing project ......
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June30,1890
                                                                                                  91, 210.00
                                                                                                  50, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix G 3.)
   5. Ice-harbor at Marcus Hook, Pennsylvania.-Thiswork in its present
plan was commenced in 1867, the object being to provide a harbor to
protect vessels against moving ice.
   The original project, with the amendments thereto, proposed the con-
struction of stone piers behind which vessels could anchor, and the con-
struction of a bulkhead, about 1,800 feet in length, parallel to the shore-
line, and about 150 feet outside of high-water line, together with the
deepening by dredging of the area behind the piers and in front of the
bulkhead.
   The amount expended from 1866 to June 30, 1887, was $179,791.86,
and resulted in the construction of two shore-piers and seven detached
ice-piers; the deepening by dredging to a depth of from 18 to 24 feet
of the area behind the two upper pairs of ice-piers, and the placing of
nine groups of mooring piles, seven of which were placed at low-water
line and two behind the ice-piers. Extensive repairs have been made
to the shore and landing piers from time to tile.
   The work done had rendered available about 6 acres of harbor area
with a depth of from 8 to 24 feet, and about 2 acres with a depth of
from 12 to 18 feet at mean low water.
80          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                           IT. S.    ARMY.

   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $14,127.43 was expended
in removing Pier No. 6 from its previous site on a pile foundation and re-
building it upon a crib foundation at a point 100 feet inshore from the
lower ice-pier. Two groups of mooring piles were placed between ex-
isting piers, and 58,000 cubic yards of material dredged from the pre-
vious shoal areas at the lower part of the harbor. This dredging has
increased the area of that part which is under the protection of the
piers from 6 acres to 10 acres. The depth at low water which covers
this area is from 18 to 24 feet. The total expenditure to June 30, 1888,
has been $193,919.29.
   The two landing or shore piers, over twenty years old and made of
timber, and also several of the ice-piers, are in need of repairs, and the
efficiency of the harbor would be increased by additional dredging.
   The officer in charge recommends the abandonment, for reasons given
in his report, of that part of the present project which provides for the
construction of a bulkhead along the land-face of the harbor, and sug-
gests that, at least for the present, available funds be applied to the
full development of the present harbor by repairs to the piers and
dredging.
July 1, 1887, amount available ............ ...... ......     ..........                          ......          $6, 586.54
July 1, 1887, amount covered by existing contracts ..................                                  ....        7,621. 60

                                                                                                               14, 208. 14
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 187.............---------....--- ---- ....----....---------....---------...... ---...... 14, 127. 43

July 1, 1888, balance available ................
Amount appropriated by act of August                     11,  -
                                                             18
                                                                      ..
                                                                     ....
                                                                                __
                                                                            ..-......    ...... ....
                                                                            ...... ..............
                                                                                                              .        80.71
                                                                                                                  15, 000. 00
                                                     ...................
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889----    ----        ----                                     15, 060.71

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ......   ..                                      20, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                      20, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of      river  and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix G 4.)
    6. Ice-harbor at head of Delaware Bay, Delaware.-The act of August
2, 1882, appropriated $25,000 for the commencement of work on the ice-
harbor at the head of Delaware Bay, to include the removal of some
sunken piers, the remains of an old ice-harbor, in the channel east of
Reedy Island, Delaware.
* The necessity for an ice-harbor at the head of Delaware Bay has long
been recognized,' and considerable study has been devoted to the ques-
tions of location and general plan of construction. As to location, the
prevailing judgment would place the iceharbor at or very near Liston's
Point. The plan of construction which has been hitherto proposed in
general terms provided for a nearly inclosed area by means ofa barrier,
to protect vessels against moving ice. This barrier was to consist of
iron piles placed at intervals and connected with an iron superstructure
so arranged as to either hold or ward the ice from the area within the
barrier. The cost of such an ice-harbor has been variously estimated
at from $300,000 to $400,000.
    In the opinion of the officer in charge, the plan of detached ice-
breakers, as heretofore used in all the ice harbors on the Delaware River,
is preferable to that of am inclosed area, which latter would prevent the
broken ice from escaping from the harbor; but as to whether these ice-
breakers should consist of stone piers, or pile piers, or floating pontons,
requires more time for decision,
                         RIVER        AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                             81

  The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $8,723.07, of which $3,700
was applied to the removal of the sunken piers back of Reedy Island,
as provided in the act of August 2, 1882, making the appropriation of
$25,000. The balance was expended in surveys, examinations, and pre-
liminary studies.
  During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $1,216.37 was expended
for office expenses.
  No appropriation is recommended at present by the officer in charge.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..........................................                   ....    $17, 493.30
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887................             ...........        .. ..........
                                                                                    ........ ....     1,216. 37
July 1, 1888, balance available.... .                  .....................................         16,276. 93
   (See Appendix G 5.)
   7. Construction of/iron pier in Delaware Bay, near Lewes, Delaware.-
The original project for this work proposed the construction of a land-
ing-pier about 1,700 feet in length, extending from the shore south of
the breakwater into Delaware Bay to a depth of 22 feet at mean low
water, the pier to consist of a substructure of wrought-iron screw-piles
surmounted with a timber superstructure. The work was commenced
in 1871 and completed, except as to superstructure, in 1880.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $368,375.06, and resulted
in the construction of 1,155 linear feet of pier 21 feet in width, and 546
linear feet 42 feet in width, or a total length of 1,701 feet. The depth
of water at the outer end of the pier-head was about 21 feet at mean
low water.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, nothing was expended.
   During the gale of March 12, 1888, five of the wrought-iron screw-
piles were injured by the collision of a wrecked schooner. The injury
to the pier was limited to- its half width for a distance of about 125
feet. The officer in charge estimates that the cost of repairing this in-
jury will probably reach $6,000.
   From the decayed condition of the timber supestruction it is not
available for use by the railroad to which the right was given to use
the pier under the provisions of the act of July 15, 1870.
   If the pier is to be rendered available for the general purposes of the
Government, and also for railroad traffic, as contemplated in the act
above referred to, the officer in charge recommends the replacing of the
present decayed wooden superstructure by permanent iron-work at an
estimated cost of $93.000.
July 1, 1887, amount available, ...............................----------..---....                     $124.94
                                     .--......................-----------------.....--......
July 1, 1888, balance available,---------------                                                         124. 94

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project, .....-. $15, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix G 6.)
   8. Delaware Breakwater Harbor, Delaware.-Under act of Congress,
May 7, 1822, $22,700 was appropriated for a survey of Delaware Bay,
near Cape Henlopen, for the purpose of determining upon the site for a
harbor of shelter. In 1828 an appropriation of $250.000 was made for
commencing the work under a plan submitted by a Board of Commis-
sioners appointed by Congress.
   The project of the Board contemplated the construction in the concar-
ity of the bay, just inside Cape Henlopen, of two massive works on the
        ENG 88-6
82           REPORT OF THE CHIEF                            OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

pierres perdues or riprap system, separated by an interval or gap of
1,390 feet-the greater, called the breakwater, to afford safe anchorage
during gales from the north and east; the other, called the ice-breaker,
to protect shipping against northwesterly gales and the heavy drifting
ice of the bay.
   This project was completed in 1869, under aggregate appropriations,
including the first for survey of $2,192,103.70. The stone used in the
work amounted to 892,528 gross tons, and varied from one-quarter of'a
ton to 7 tons in weight, the smaller constituting the bulk of the mass,
the larger used to cover the exterior slopes.
  As comnpleted in 1869 the breakwater is 2,558 feet long, and the ice-
breaker 1,359 feet long on top. The average width on top is 22 feet,
and at base 160 feet. The top is from 12 to 14 feet above mean low
water.
   In 1882 a project was adopted for closing the gap between the break-
water and the ice-breaker by means of a random stone foundation with
a concrete superstructure. The random stone foundation is to be brought
to a height of 12 feet below low water, with a width on top of 48 feet.
The concrete superstructure is to have a width on bottom of 24 feet,
rising to a height of 12 feet above mean low water, with a width on
top of 12 feet. The estimated cost of this project was $675,000.
   In 1883 and 1884 the project was modified by providing a foundation
of brush mattresses for the random stone substructure, and omitting
the construction of a pile bridge across the gap, which formed part of
the project of 1882 for closing the gap.
   From the beginning of the work in 1822 to June 30, 1887, the total
amount expended was 82,445,667.73, of which $253,564.03 was expended
on the project of 1882 for closing the gap.
   The officer in charge calls attention to the fact that the completion
of the work will probably cost more than the $418,750 estimated in the
money statement. A revision of the estimate should be postponed until
the completion of the foundation which is in progress.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $2,155.88 was expended
for office expenses and care of public property. The total expenditure
to June 30, 1888, has been $2,447,823.61, of which $255,719.91 has been
under present project.
July 1, 1887, amount available----............---------------..----.....--..----.....-----.....---..........    $2, 685. 97
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                                                   ---- ---..-.......--........-------.
  outstanding July 1, 1887..--...........--.......----..                                                         2, 155. 88

July 1, 188.8, balance available............                    .   ...    ..- ................----.               530.   09
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888- .................-.....                                         100, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 189 ...................                                       100,530.09

iAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing pro ect..       .... 318, 750. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal y-eare (cnding ;e ]0. 1890 200. 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix G 7.)
  9. Rancocas River, New Jersey.-The Rancocas is a comparatively
large and important stream, 200 yards wide at its mouth, and narrows
to about 400 feet at a distance of 8 miles above. As is usual with rivers
entering into the Delaware Bay and River, a bar exists at its mouth,
difficult to treat effectively and cheaply on account of the liability of
the cuts to close up unless protected by deflecting dikes. There is, how-
                   RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                   83
ever, a low-water navigable depth of nearly 8 feet over this bar at pres-
ent.
  The original project provided for a low-water channel from 150 to 200
feet wide and 6 feet deep at low water to Centreton, 74 miles above the
mouth, and eventually a 5-foot low-water channel to Mount Holly, 54
miles above Centreton. The estimated cost of the whole was $82,000.
The amount expended up to June 30, 1887, was $19,899.91, resulting in
the construction of a dike from the head of Hamill's Island to the north
bank of the river, and a 64-foot low-water channel 150 feet wide cut
through Coates's Bar.
  Nothing was expended during the last fiscal year.
  Nothing has been appropriated by last river and harbor act.
July 1, 1887, amount available       ....-......................... ...-..-
                                    ..                                   .      $100.09
July 1, 1888, balance available .........................................        100. 09

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......       62,000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix G 8.)
   10. Woodbury Creek, New Jersey.-The lower part of Woodbury Creek,
from its mouth to the Crown Point Road Bridge, is considered to have
sufficient depth of water at high stages of the tide for the needs of
navigation. The portion which should be improved is the reach ex-
tending from this bridge to the Broad Street Bridge, in the town of
Woodbury, at the head of navigation. At low tide this portion of the
creek is almost entirely devoid of water, but the range of tide being
between 5 and 6 feet, small vessels can ascend at high stages.
   The project of 1883 proposed to dredge a channel affording a high-
water depth of 8 feet and a width of 40 feet from Crown Point Road
Bridge to Broad Street Bridge in the town of Woodbury, at an esti-
mated cost of $15,000. This channel when once made is to be main-
tained by the parties interested.
   The partial dredging of a channel being of no commercial value, ex-
penditures have been withheld to await further appropriation sufficient
to complete the dredging as far as Woodbury.
July 1, 1887, amount available .................... . ...........-......      $4,549. 69
July 1, 1888, balance available ..........................................     4,549. 69

                                                                 ---
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........      10, 500.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix G 9.)
   11. Mantua Creek, New Jersey.-The original project for this improve-
ment contemplates the construction of a low-water channel 10 feet deep
and 80 feet wide at the mouth of the creek, which is to diminish to 4
feet in depth and 40 feet in width at the town of Mantua, situated
some 11 miles from the mouth, at an estimated cost of $35,000.
   The stream in its natural condition possesses good depth of water for
a distance of 3 or 4 miles from the Delaware River, having a low-water
depth of 9 feet throughout this distance. Above this, however, the
channel depth slowly diminishes, until at Mantua there is a low-water
depth of only 2 feet.
   No money has yet been expended on the work, and since whatever
dredging done here would not be permanent, no further appropriation
is recommended.
84            REPORT OF THE CHIEF                            OF ENGINEERS, U. S ARMY.

July 1. 1887, amount available- ---....----------------------                                                      $3, 000. O
July 1, 1888, balance available......----......---- -.....----..----...--......------.....------....                3,000. 00

SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-........ 32,000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   See Appendix G 10.)
   12. Raccoon River, New Jersey.-This river has a high-water width at
its mouth of about 450 feet, gradually diminishing to 100 feet at Swedes-
borough, about 9J miles up stream. There is a good 4-foot low-water
channel, and a high-water channel of from 9 to 10 feet from the mouth
of the river to more than half the distance to Swedesborough. The
serious and extensive obstructions are found within 2 miles of that
town. There are four bridges across the stream. Two of these are
located at Bridgeport, about 2 miles above the mouth of the river, and
the other two at Swedesborough. The lower one of the two latter is
the Swedesborough Railroad Bridge, and barges can pass under it. The
upper one is the Main Street Bridge, and is the head of navigation.
   The project submitted with the report on the survey, dated February
20, 1883, contemplates making the navigation up to Main Street Bridge
in Swedesborough more safe and less difficult for the class of vessels
now navigating the stream by dredging, at an estimated cost of $18,000.
   The sum of $757.23 was expended up to June 30, 1883, for surveys,
and nothing since, the balance on hand being held to await further ap-
propriation.
July 1, 1887, amount available...........                     . ..-.....................                   .....   ,$2, 242. 77
July 1, 1888, balance available ..........                  ............             .... .....   ...........       2, 242.77

                                                                         --
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- ........                                        16, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix G 11.)
   13. Salem River, New Jersey.-The original navigable capacity of this
stream was 6 feet at low water over the bar in Salem Cove, and 3 to 4
feet at low water on the shoals at Biddle's Landing.
  The originally adopted project consisted in dredging an 8-foot low-
water channel as wide as the vessels needed, through the bar in Salem
Cove. Subsequently the work was changed to the shoals in the canal
and river above the latter.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $13,009.34, resulting in a
low-water channel 8 feet deep and 110 feet wide through the bar in
Salem Cove, and a channel 60 feet wide and from 6 to 7 feet deep at low
water from the head of the canal to a point about 200 feet above Biddle's
Landing.
  Nothing was expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
  The estimated amount required to complete the work according to the
existing project, that is, to Hoxie's Landing, is $4,000. If the improve-
ment is carried up to Sharptown the amount would be $37,000.
July 1, 1887, amount available..---.....--...........             ...........----....---. --                        1, 490. 66
                                                          .----..----.--..-------...-..----.
July 1, 1888, balance available .--....---....---.....-----.                                                        1, 490. 66

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.... -.-.                                          4, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix G 12.)
  14. Cohansey Creek, New Jersey.-Cohansey Creek, in its original con-
dition, was navigable to Bridgetonl, 20 miles above its mouth, through
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                              85
a tortuous channel of ample depth. The obstructions to its free navi-
gation were found at Bridgeton and at its mouth, where the creek dis-
charged across a soft mud-bar without any well-defined channel. The
gas and water mains of the city of Bridgeton cross the creek at Broad
street, at a level of only 4 feet below low water, and prevent the further
deepening of the channel above them. In the event of the city author-
ities lowering the pipes to a proper depth, the amount required to com-
plete the project by carrying a 6-foot low-water channel to the Nail
Works Bridge would be about $5,500.
   The original project contemplated the construction of a channel at
Bridgeton 130 feet wide and 4 feet deep, at a total cost of $30,000. This
was modified to reduce the width to 80 feet, and to increase the depth
at mean low water to 7 feet from the lower steam-boat landing to the
bridge, and above that point to 5 feet. This project, as again amended
in June, 1880, contemplates bringing the 7-foot low-water channel from
deep water below the lower steam-boat landing upward as far as the
Commerce Street Bridge, and thence to the Nail Works Bridge a low-
water channel of 6 feet, the channel to be 100 feet wide at its lower end
and to decrease to 50 feet at the upper bridge.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $36,000. The 7-
foot low-water channel has been widened and straightened, and it is
now 90 feet wide between the upper and lower steam-boat wharves, and
70 feet above that to the bridge.
  SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project. .......                                     $5, 500. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix G 13.)
   15. Removal of wrecks from DelawareBay and River.-During the past
fiscal year the obstructing parts of the wreck of the schooner David
Lee, lying near Fourteen Foot Bank Light, Delaware Bay, were removed.
July 1, 1887, amount available......................-----                .--........       ..........          $2, 290.60
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887..--                                               ....
                                                                             -..---....
                               -..--.--.........---..-..----....--- ---......--         ...-----.               1,531.98
                                                   .......
July 1, 1888, balance available ...........---....--..                         .............            ....      75. 62
  (See Appendix G 14.)
  16. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructingor endangering naviga-
tion.-During the past fiscal year the following wrecks were removed
under the provisions of the act of June 14, 1880: The schooner G. H.
Bent, from Delaware Breakwater Harbor, and the steamer Blanche Hen-
derson, from the port of Philadelphia. After being raised the latter was
sold at public auction for the sum of $570.
  (See Appendix G 15.)
  17. Survey of harbor at Atlantic City, New Jersey.-The report of the
Board of Engineers upon this subject was submitted under date of
May 31, 1887, and is to be found in the Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1887, pages 815-819.
  During the past fiscal year the maps and data of the survey and re-
port were assembled and placed on the office files.
July 1, 1887, amount available ......--...... ...................  ..........
                                                                       --                                      $2, 798. 32
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ..............     ..................... .....--.                                    1,217. 93
July 1, 1888, balance available ......................................                                  ....    1, 580.39
    (See Appendix G 16.)
86      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARM Y.

   18. United States Commission Advisory to the Board of Haror    Comis
sioners of Philadelphia,Pennsylvania.-The United States Commission
Advisory to the Board of Harbor Commissioners of Philadelphia have
had under consideration the establishment of the Port-Wardens' lines.
During the past fiscal year the Port-Wardens' line from Bridesburg to
the upper limits of the city on the Delaware River front were fixed by
the Commission and adopted by the municipal authorities.
   The Commission was requested to report upon the problem of the
removal of Smith's and Windmill Islands and adjacent shoals for the
purpose of extending the wharves on' the Pennsylvania side of the river.
Their report on this subject, submitted under date of December 15, 1887,
expresses the belief that it would be feasible to advance the Port-War-
dens' line 300 feet in the center of the city front on the Delaware River,
provided certain modifications were made in the harbor, including the
removal of Smith's and Windmill Islands and the shoals adjacent
thereto and a portion of Petty's Island.
   (See Appendix G 17.)

EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEY FOR IMPROVEMENTS, TO COMPLY WITH
  REQUIREMENTS OF TIlE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT OF AUGUST
  5, 1886.

  It appearing, after preliminary examination, that the locality was
worthy of improvement, Lieutenant-Colonel Robert, Corps of Engi-
neers, was charged with the survey of the thoroughfare running back of
the ocean from Cape May to the Great Bay north of Atlantic City, N. J.,
the results of which were transmitted to Congress and printed as House
Ex. Doc. No. 306, Fiftieth Congress, first session.
  (See Appendix G 18.)

IMPROVEMENT OF HARBORS AND RIVERS IN THE STATES OF DELA-
  WARE AND MARYLAND, AND OF MAURICE RIVER, NEW JERSEY, AND
  OF THE INLAND WATER-WAY FROM CHINCOTEAGUE BAY, VIRGINIA,
  TO DELAWARE BAY.

   Engineer in charge, Mr. William F. Smith, United States Agent.
   1. Maurice River, New Jersey.-The entrance of this river into the
Delaware Bay has a low-water depth of 5 feet. From its mouth to a
point 4 miles below Millville, N. J., the head of navigation, there is a
navigable channel varying in depth from 10 feet to 20 feet, and from
thence to Millville the channel originally had an average depth of 2
feet at low water. The tide rises 6.1 feet.
   The original project adopted for this improvement is to construct, by
dredging, a 6-foiot low-water navigation from the mouth of the river to
Millville, and a 4-foot low-water navigation along the front of the town;
the width of channel to be 100 feet.
   The estimated cost was $112,000. The amount expended to the close
of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, is $20,032.74, and at that date
a channel had been dredged to a depth varying from 5 to 6 feet at low
water, from 50 to 100 feet in width, including a cut-off through the
point of land at Silver Run, through which the right of way was given
to the United States free of cost. This cut-off shortened the distance
in the 4 miles of river under improvement 1,300 feet.
  The work was advertised for continuing the improvement, under the
appropriation of August 5, 1886. The amount expended during the
                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                           87
fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is $4,952.42, resulting in increasing
the width of the channel from 50 feet to 100 feet at bottom, a distance
of 3,050 feet, giving a depth of 6 feet at low water. The 100-foot
channel has been extended to within 5,350 feet of the head of naviga-
tion.
July 1, 1887, amount available ...............-------------- ..- -   -- -- -- -- - --
                                                                   .........            4,967.26
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887         -   ........--.-
                                           ---..--          ---.   ---------- " ----     4, 952.42

July 1, 1888, balance available ......  ............ .. .... ............                   14.84
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888- ------.----...             .------       10, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.--..--.............               10, 014. 84

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .------ 77, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 20, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix I 1.)            "
   2. Wilmington Harbor, Delaware.-The entrance of this harbor from
the Delaware River had originally but 9 feet low-water draught. The
original project for this improvement was for the attainment of a 12-
foot low-water navigation at the entrance; this work continued from
1871 to 1880.
   In 1880 a modified project was adopted, the object of which is to give
a 15-foot low-water navigation from the entrance to the Delaware Rail-
road Bridge. In 1884 the project was again amended, which provided
for an additional length of 322 feet to the jetty. The condition of the
harbor in 1880 was as follows:
   From the entrance and to the city of Wilmington, Del., a 12-foot low-
water navigation existed. Between Third and Market Street bridges,
4,000 feet, covering the main city front, the 12-foot navigation continued
with a reduced width averaging about 50 feet, and a 15-foot low-water
depth existed about one-fourth of the distance. Between Market Street
and the Delaware Western Railroad Bridge the channel increases in
both dimensions, with numerous soundings over 20 feet and an average
width of 100 feet. The depth thence to the Pulp Works was from 9 to
11 feet, and thence to the Delaware Railroad Bridge the depth remains
about the same, with the exception of a distance of 2,000 feet below
Dupont's powder wharf, over which the average low water is 4 to 5
feet. During the present fiscal year the dredging was continued from
a point 6,200 feet inside the mouth of the harbor to the end of the jetty,
excavating the channel 75 feet wide and 15 feet deep at mean low
water. This was completed in July, and work was suspended for want
of funds.
   The total amount expended to close of the fiscal year ending June
30, 1888, is $255,028.57, and has resulted in securing a channel 75
feet in width and 15 feet in depth at mean low water (except at two
places where the material is very soft and the channel has filled to 10
feet) from the entrance of the harbor to Market street, and excavating
a channel from Market Street Bridge to the Pulp Works, a 12-foot low-
water navigation. No work having been done and no examination
made above Market Street Bridge during the year, the condition of the
12-foot channel dredged there is unknown. The amount available and
that asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, if appropriated, will
be applied to continuing the improvement in accordance with the pro-
88          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

ject adopted. The amount estimated to maintain the improvement is
from $5,000 to $10,000 annually.
July 1, 1887, amount available ....................    .....-------------------------------..------..........
                                                                                           $8, 199. 26
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1887 ....................-   .......................               .6, 033. 05
July 1, 1888, balance available ..............................-----------------------.......--              2, 166. 21
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888                    ....   ...................            30, 000. 00



{Amount
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .......--............
             (estimated) required for completion of existing
     Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                   project-.....117,
                                                                                                       32, 166. 21

                                                                                                  50, 000.00
                                                                                                              634.00


       harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
      (See Appendix H 2.)
   3. Ice-harbor at New Castle, Delaware.-The original project for this
improvement was to build stone piers in the Delaware River at New
Castle, Del., to provide a harbor of refuge for vessels during the ice
season.
  The piers, eight in number, have been completed, and the area of
the harbor dredged to a depth of 18 feet at mean low water.
  During the fiscal year the work done consisted in repair of damages
to one of the piers caused by collision from a vessel, and placing rip-
rap around the bottom of two piers to prevent scouring. Amount ex-
pended during the current fiscal year is $853.20. One of the piers is
in a most insecure condition and requires rebuilding, and the dredging
should also be extended beyond the piers to produce a current through
the harbor to prevent filling, and the amount asked for the fiscal year
June 30, 1890, if appropriated, will be applied to this object. The total
amount asked for should be available before the work of rebuilding the
pier has commenced.
July 1, 1887, amount available .-------------............      .........
                                                          ----......------------                            $833.20
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
     outstanding July 1, 1887--        .--.....----.----------------...-------..............-------------     853.20
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.........................                                  7,500. 00
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......                                 8, 100.00
) Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                            8, 100.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
I harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix H 3.)
   4. Duck Creek, Delaware.-In its original condition this stream was
obstructed by a bar at its entrance, having 3 feet draught at low water,
and between the mouth and Smyrna, the head of navigation, there ex-
isted nine shoals with a minimum depth of 2.5 feet.
   The original adopted project was to excavate a channel through the
bar at the mouth 8 feet in depth at mean low water, and 100 feet in
width, and to remove the shoals by dredging to the same depth as far
as Smyrna.
   In compliance with the act of August 5, 1886, a survey was made of
this stream, and a modified project with estimate of cost of improve-
ment was submitted (see Annual Report of Chief of Engineers for 1887,
page 800). It is deemed at present that a channel 60 feet wide and 7
feet deep at mean low water inside the creek, and at the entrance a
channel 100 feet wide and 7 feetin depth at mean low water, is sufficient
for the needs of commerce.
  The estimated cost of the dredging is $37,365.20. It is barely possi-
                            RIVER AND                HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                  89
ble that annual dredging to the amount of 10,000 cubic yards may keep
a practicable channel over the bar 100 feet wide.
   A more permanent improvement would require the construction of a
jetty 2,000 feet in length, which would cost, of wood, $20,000 ; of stone,
 $53,333.20.
    In 1880 and 1881 $10,000 was expended in dredging a channel through
the bar at the entrance to 8 feet in depth at mean low water, but the
survey of 1887 shows the work had filled to 4J feet.
   The citizens have spent $6,500 in dredging inside the creek.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888........................ $10,000.00
I Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........                                         27, 365.20
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                      10, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements' of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix H 4.)
   5. St. Jones River, Delchware.-Before the improvement of this river
was commenced the entrance from the Delaware River had only 2 feet
of water on it at mean low tide.
   From the mouth to Lebanon there existed only a 4-foot low-water
navigation, and from thence to Dover 2.5 feet at low water.
   Many bends also interfered with navigation, and between Lebanon
and Dover navigation was obstructed by overhanging trees.
   The original project adopted for the improvement provided for a 6-
foot low-water navigation by excavating a channel through the bar at the
entrance 100 feet wide, to be protected by a jetty ; to remove the shoals
and make several cut-offs, by dredging, between the mouth of the river
and Dover, and in 1887 the project was amended to include removal of
overhanging trees from the banks of the river. During the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, a channel 40 feet wide and 6 feet deep at mean
low water was completed from a point about one fourth of a mile below
Dover to that place and a turning-basin excavated; through the bar
at the entrance to the river a channel 40 feet wide and 4 feet deep at
low water was excavated a length of 1,050 feet. The appropriation
being about exhausted, the citizens interested in the navigation em-
ployed the dredging company to extend this channel 1,350 feet further,
for which they paid from their private funds. Th,. banks were also
cleared of overhanging trees between Lebanon and Dover. To the
close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $24,999.64 have been ex-
pended in all on this improvement, and has resulted in giving a 4-foot
low-water navigation over the entrance to the river and a 6-foot low-
water navigation thence to Dover, the head of navigation, distance
about 21 miles. A steamer makes regular trips between Dover and
Philadelphia, and the railroad freight rates have been considerably re-
duced.
July 1, 1887, amount available .........................................                                           $2,245. 86
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887-----..-------....--....--..-....--.......--......------- --...----. .......... ----      2,245.50

July 1, 1888, balance available ............ .................. ......                                           ... .       36
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888. .............       .......                                          15, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .... ..............                                          15, 000. 36
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....... 20, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 10, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix T 5.)
90        REPORT       OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. AR1IY.

   6. Mispillion Creek, Delaware.-This stream has a width of 1abon-ut 90
feet at Milford, the head of navigation, increasing to 240 feet at its mouth.
The entrance from Delaware Bay had a depth of 1. feet at mean low
water, and between the mouth and Milford were several shoals having
a depth from 4 to 5 feet over them.
   The original project was to make a 6-foot low-water navigation with
a width of 40 feet from the mouth to the head of navigation. This proj-
ect was amended in 1881 to include the improvement of the entrance
from Delaware Bay, providing a 4-foot low-water navigable entrance.
The tide rises 4- feet at the entrance and 21 feet at Milford.
   The amount expended to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30,
1888, is $13,500. This amount was applied to dredging the shoals be-
tween the mouth of the river anti Milford to a depth of 6 feet at mean
low water, and the work done was of much benefit to the ship-building
and commercial interests of the locality.
   Nothing has been done since 1883 for want of funds, and the condi-
tion of the stream at present is unknown for the same reason.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888----..--...--......-----............    $3, 500. 00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........            55, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix H 6.)
   7. Broadkiln River, Delaware.--Before any improvement was made in
this river the channel was narrow, shallow, and tortuous, and nearly
dry at its entrance into Delaware Bay at low water, and navigable for
only small crafts. The original project adopted for the improvement
proposed giving a 6-foot low-water navigation from Delaware Bay to
Milton, the head of navigation.
   The amount expended to the close of the fiscal year ending June, 30,
1887, is $25,000, which resulted in giving a channel 6 feet in depth at
mean low water, and inno place less than 40 feet in width from the mouth
of the river to Milton.
   The benefit due to the improvement is the saving in time of two to
three days in passing from the mouth to Milton. There were no opera-
tions during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, for want of funds, and
for the same reason the condition of the river at that date is unknown.
   The total amount that has been appropriated for this river is $25,000.
The amount asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, if appro-
priated, will be applied to the improvement of the entrance with a view
to attaining a 6-foot low-water navigation.


{Amount
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ----- -........- ----...-..-----...... $10, 000.00
           (estimated) required for completion of existing project------- 21,500.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscalyear ending June 30, 1890
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                     10, 000.00
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix H 7.)
  8. Indian River, Delaware.-This river originally was available for
only 2 feet navigation at mean low water. The original project for the
improvement contemplates dredging a channel 80 feet wide and 4 feet
deep through        ,The
                     Bulkhead," thence straight to the inlet, and pro-
tecting it by the construction of a dike on its northern side. The cost
was estimated at $50,000.
  The amount expended up to the close of the fiscal year ending June
30, 1888, is $10,000. A channel was dredged through the Bulkhead
                     RIVER     AND       HARBOR                 IMPROVEMENTS.                                        91
Shoal 4 feet in depth, with a width of 80 feet for two-thirds of the
length, and 60 feet in width for the other one-third. It is reported that
the channel filled up soon after it was made, and no benefit was derived
from the improvement.
   No work has been done on this improvement since 1883 for want of
funds.
   The dredging will cost more than the original estimate, and should
the work be continued the appropriation should be sufficient to con-
struct the protecting work as well as to excavate the channel, to derive
any benefit from the improvement.
  Amount (estimated; required for completion of existing project........                                   $50, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix H 8.)
   9. Inland water-wayfrom Chincoteague Bay, Virginia, to DelawareBay,
at or near Lewes, Deaware.--The project adopted for this improvement
is to connect, by dredging, the natural waters between Chincoteague
Bay, Virginia, and Delaware Bay, Delaware, forming a continuous
water-way 70 feet wide at bottom and 6 feet in depth at mean low water.
   The route was surveyed in 1884, and the report is contained in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers, 1885.
   The act of August 5, 1886, appropriated $18,750 for the commence-
ment of the improvement, and directed the sum '" to be used from Chin-
coteague Bay to Indian River Bay."
   The Delaware legislature passed an act in 1887 providing for the pur-
chase of the right of way and donating the same to the United States.
The work will be commenced as soon as the title to the lands needed
for the right of way has been approved at the Department of Justice.
   The total amount expended to the close of the fiscal year ending June
30, 1888, is $821.41, which was applied to surveys to locate the route
between Assawamom Bay and Indian River Bay.
July 1, 1887, amount available ......         ...      .       ..
                                                             ..--    ....   ......   ... ...... --....     $17, 946. 57
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ......       ..................                              .          .               17.

July 1, 13888, balance available............ .. .............                          .....     .......    17, 928.59
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ....................                              ......      50, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .........                                ........      67, 928.59
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...-.-.                                    281,   250,00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                50, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements                         of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   See Appendix H 9.)
   10. Susquehanna River above and below Havre de Grace, Maryland.-Be-
fore the improvement of this river it was obstructed by two shoals
between the light-house at Havre de Grace and Spesutia Island, over
which the depths were only 5 feet and 6 feet at mean low water; and
above Havre de Grace, near Watson's Island, the channel was too nar-
row for the ice to pass off, which caused dangerous ice gorges.
  The original project adopted for the improvement was for a 12-foot
low-water navigation, and in 1882 it was amended, the object being to
afford a 15-foot low-water navigation below Havre de Grace. Above
Havre de Grace the project has been to increase the width and depth
of the channel near Watson's Island, to prevent ice-gorges.
   The amount expended to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30,
92        REPORT OF THIE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

1887, is$148,890, and at that date the channel a4ove Havre de Grace,
near Watson's Islandl, had been increased 400 feet in width at the upper
end of the shoal, and 300 feet at the lower end of the shoal.
   There has been no work done on the shoals below Havre de Grace
since 1885, as Congress directed the last appropriations to be all spent
above, and the condition of the channel is not known at this date.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888. ......-............ .... $10, 000. 00

  Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal year ending June 30, 1890        10, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix H 10.)
   11. Fairlee Creek or Inlet, larland.-This is a new work. An ex-
amination and survey was made in compliance with the requirements of
the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, and printed as Appendix H
of the Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1887.
   The improvement proposed is the removal of the bar by dredging to 7
feet, which is the least efficient depth, at an estimated cost of $3,545.75,
and the dredging of a channel 7 feet deep and 100 feet wide from the
mouth to the turning basin, at an estimated cost, including contingen-
cies, of about $12,000, making an aggregate of $15,558.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates for the
improvement $5,000, and a further sum of $11,000 may be profitably
expended in continuing it during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .................          ........$5,000.00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.... ...           10, 558.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890       11, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   12. Corsica Creek, Mllaryland.-Before the improvement of this stream
it was navigable for steamers only as far as Hooper's Landing; from
thence to Centreville freight was transported by lighters.
   The originally adopted project for this improvement proposed to
construct, by dredging, a channel 100 feet wide and 8 feet deep at mean
low water from Hooper's Landing to the town of Centreville, and to
excavate a turning basin at the terjninus.
   The total amount expended to the close.of the present fiscal year is
$20,000, and has resulted in giving a channel 100 feet wide at bottom
and 8. feet in depth at low water from a point 2,300 feet above Hooper's
Lauding to Clark's Wharf; a cut of 60 feet was taken off the point op-
posite the wharf; from thence to the county bridge, 1,000 feet, a chan-
nel was excavated 75 feet wide and 81 feet deep at low water, and the
turning basin dredged there. The channel excavated has been in con-
stant use, and the facilities for commerce and navigation greatly in-
creased and the freight rates reduced.
   There were no operations during the current year for want of funds.
   The amount available will be applied to dredging the channel 100
feet wide at bottom and 8 feet deep at low water from Hooper's Landing
to a point 2,301 feet above, which will complete the project.
July 1, 1887, amount available--....---...----..----..................---..........                  $19.49
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.---... ..----..-....---..........------------- .....------
                                                                                    --...........---..19.49
                                                                                             ..--..----.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...... --..--.      ..-....
                                                                    ........       10, 000.00
     (See Appendix H 12.)
                     RIVER ANDtHARBOR               IMPROVEMENTS.                           93
   13. Choptank River, Maryland.-Beforethe improvement of this river,
the navigable channel, except at one point, as high up as Denton, had a
depth of 9 to 10 feet at low water. Between Denton and Greensborough
the width varied from 100 feet to 650 feet, and the depth from 2 feet to
8 feet at mean low water.
   The original project for the improvement was to give an 8-foot low-
water navigation 75 feet in width between Denton and Greensborough,
Md., by dredging through the numerous shoals. During the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, a channel was excavated 25 feet wide and 8.5 feet
deep at low water a distance of 2,738 feet, and 40 feet wide and 7 feet
deep at low water a length of 7,036 feet; also a turning-basin at
Greensborough 125 feet long and 100 feet wide in addition to the chan-
nel width. The total amount of material removed is 45,220 cubic
yards. The total amount expended to the close of the present fiscal
year is $30,000, and has resulted in securing a channel from 5 feet to 8
feet in depth and from 25 feet to 75 feet in width, between Denton and
Greensborough, Md.
   The dredging has been at shoals with less depth than 5 feet. Future
appropriations will be applied to increasing the 5-foot shoals to 8 feet
at low water and the width to 75 feet, as recommended in the pro-
ject.
July 1, 1887, amount available................ ....         .......... ........      $8, 849.97
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 .- ....................  ..................        ....    8, 849. 97
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.......................                  7, 500.00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...-..               39, 500. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890         10, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix H 13.)
   14. Cambridge Harbor,Maryland.-An examination and survey of this
harbor were made under the requirements of the river and harbor act
of August 5, 1886, and the report made is printed in Appendix H of the
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1887.
  A survey of the harbor was made in 1870 and its improvement was
commenced in 1873, when the commerce was carried by one 300-ton
steamer and one sailing vessel. Since 1871 the United States has ex-
pended $32,500 in dredging the harbor and entrance to a depth of 8.5
feet at mean low water, to the great benefit of commerce.
  The improvement proposed by the officer in charge of the survey con-
templates dredging a channel 12 feet deep and 150 feet wide from the
Choptank Rliver to the railroad wharf, and in the inner harbor 10 feet
deep. The inner harbor above the bridge to be dredged 150 feet wide,
500 feet long, and 8 feet deep, at an estimated cost of $17,736.60. It is
also estimated that $500 to $1,000 will be required annually to maintain
the channel.
  The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $5,000 for
this harbor, and a further sum of $13,000 may be profitably expended
in continuing it during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................              $5, 000.00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..--------......     12, 736.60
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890         13, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
94      REPORT      OF THE      CHIEF       OF ENGINEERS,            U   S. ARMY.

   15. Xanticoke River, Delaware.-By act of Angust .5, 1886, $10,000
was   appropriated for "continuing the improvement up to and near the
town of Laurel, Delaware." Before any improvement was made the
depth of water between Pottsville and Laurel, a distance of 4 miles,
varied from 3 feet to one-half foot, and vessels could not reach Laurel.
In 1882 a channel was excavated 32 feet wide and 6 feet deep at mean
low water, from the railroad bridge at Laurel to a point 6,900 feet down-
stream, and for a further distance of 4,300 feet the natural channel
straightens by cutting off some sharp bends. In 1886 a survey was
made of the river, and a continuous 5-foot low-water navigation was
found to extend to a point 7,000 feet below the turning-basin at Laurel,
and a 4-foot low-water navigation 2,900 feet below the same place. The
project adopted for the expenditure of the available funds was to ex-
tend the 5-foot low-water navigation to the turning-basin, the channel
to be 45 feet in width, and to cut off several sharp bends in the lower
part of the river. The price for which the dredging was contracted be-
ing much less than was estimated, more work was done than originally
proposed.
   The total amount expended to the close of the present fiscal year is
$10,000, and the following is the result, viz: Commencing at the turn-
ing-basin and working down-stream, a channel 45 feet wide and 5 feet
in depth at low water was excavated to the Delaware Railroad Bridge,
a distance of 1,950 feet. From the Delaware Railroad Bridge to the in-
tersection of the 7-foot curve, a distance of 12,350 feet, a channel 50 feet
wide and 6 feet in depth at low water was excavated ; and at three bends
the width increased to 60, 70, and 60 feet, respectively. Also, at Col-
lin's Bar, about one-half mile further down-stream, a cut was exca-
vated 600 feet in length, 50 feet in width, and 6 feet deep at low water.
   The citizens of Laurel expended between $12,000 and $13,000 in build-
ing wharves and dredging in front of them.
July 1, 1887, amount available.............................. ............             $8,939. 09
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887-   --...................   .. ..   ...........-.....   .     ,939.09

For balance of statement see money statement for Broad Creek, Delaware.
   (See Appendix H 14.)
   16. Broad Creek, Delaware,from its mouth to Laurel.--This is a prong
of Nanticoke River. The original project was to make a channel 7 feet
in depth and 60 feet wide to the town of Laurel, the estimated cost of
which was $46,500; if training-walls to regulate the water-way are con-
structed, the estimate should be increased to $60,000. This project was
modified in 1883, and the dimensions of the channel recommended were
reduced to 6 feet in depth at mean low water and 50 feet in width, and
the building of dikes for the protection of the channel. The estimated
cost of the latter project is $32,625. The amount.expended up to the
close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is $20,000, and a channel
was excavated 32 feet wide and 6 feet deep at mean low water, from
the railroad bridge at Laurel to a point about 6,900 feet. down-stream,
and the natural channel below this point straightened and widened by
cutting off some sharp points for a further distance of 4,300 feet.
   There has been no appropriation for Broad Creek since 1882.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ---- .----.....---..       $5,000.00
                                                                ......--......
IAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....... 27; 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 10, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   (harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix I 15.)
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                      95
  17. Pocomoke River, Maryland.-This river was obstructed by four
abrupt bends, which render navigation both difficult and dangerous at
all times, and when the winds were high they were almost impassable.
  The original project adopted for the improvement is to make a cut-off
through the low neck of land or swamp forming the bends, giving a
channel 80 feet wide and 7 feet deep at mean low water; the cut-off to
be 1,100 feet in length; the right of way for the cut-off to be conveyed
to the United States free of cost.
   The title to the land for the right of way having been approved and
the land accepted by the Secretary of War, the work was advertised
and a contract made with the Atlas Dredging Company for 10 cents per
cubic yard, place measurement. The price being less than the original
estimate, it was recommended and approved to apply the balance of
the funds to removal of several shoals to a depth of 7 feet at low water
below the cut-off, and dredging a turning-basin at Snow Hill.
   The amount expended during the present fiscal year is $6,777.51, in-
cluding outstanding liabilities, and the improvement as recommended
in the above project has been completed.
   At this date there is a good 7-foot low-water navigation to Snow Hill,
Md., the head of navigation.
July 1, 1887, amount available ......        -............--------....-----                                          $S, 000. 00
                                                                                        --....--............---......--
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of lia-
  bilities outstanding July 1, 1887...............................$---     4, 132.41
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities.... . ....... .... . ....... .... .. 2,645. 10
                                                                                                                    6,1777.51

July 1, 1888, balance available ................                      ...     .......      .....   ......    ....   1, 222.49
  (See Appendix H 18.)
  18. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangeringnaviga-
tion.-At the close of the last fiscal year a contract had been made with
Mr. Edward T. Veasey, of Lewes, Del., under provision of section 4 of
the act of June 14, 1880, for the removal of the wreck of the steam-pro-
peller J. I. Van Doren from the Broadkiln River, Delaware. The work
was begun promptly and completed by the 20th of July, 1887, at a total
cost of $242.13. The wreck was of no value.
  (See Appendix H 19.)

IMPROVEMENT OF PATAPSCO RIVER AND CHANNEL TO BALTIMORE,
  MARYLAND ; OF THE HARBORI   OF NORFOLK, VIRGINIA ; APPROACH
  TO NORFOLK HARBOR, VIRGINIA; OF CURRITUCK SOUND, AND CO-
  ANJOK BAY, AND OF NORTH RIVER BAR, NORTH CAROLINA ; OF JAMES
  AND APPOMATTOX RIVERS, VIRGINIA; AND OF CERTAIN OTHER
  RIVERS IN VIRGINIA AND NORTH CAROLINIA.

  Officer in charge, Col. William P. Craighill, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Channel to Baltimore, Maryland.-The depth of this channel has
been by successive steps increased from 17 feet at mean low water to
27 feet, with an average rise of tide of about 18 inches.
  The project of improvement first adopted and commenced in October,
1853, had for its object to give a channel 22 feet at mean low water with
a width of 150 feet.
  Little was done before the late war, but afterwards these dimensions
were increased, a depth of 24 feet at mean low water being determined
upon with a width of channel ranging from 250 to 400 feet.
  This channel was completed in 1874, important changes of position
having been giving to a portion of it, by which the distance was materi-
ally lessened and the expense of maintenance decreased.
96                REPORT OF THE CHIEF                                          OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The object of the improvement was to permit the approach to Balti-
more, at mean low water, of vessels drawing from 224 to 23 feet, and at
ordinary high water of vessels drawing 24 and 24.E feet.
  The last appropriation previous to 1884 was in August, 1882, $450,000,
their being none in 1883.
  This was expended in giving a depth of 27 feet in the Fort McHenry,
Brewerton, and Craighill branches of the channel, and in the " Cut-off"
between the Brewerton and Craighill branches.
  For want of funds the work of improvement was entirely suspended
during the whole of the year ending June 30, 1886.
  The following were the widths of the respective branches of the chan-
nel June 30, 1886, with a depth of 27 feet at mean low water:
                                                                                                                                                          Feet.
Craighill Channel----
                  ....---------....-----....-......---------......--......---------....----.....---......-------......----...... 350
Cut-off Channel      .... ...... ..........                ....................                 ...................              300
Brewerton Channel ......--------....----...... ----......------......--......----......-------....--......--
                                                                                                         ----- ....-----..... - 250
Fort McHenry Channel .... ...... ..........--                               .....      ..--.............           .........     250
  With the appropriation of $150,000 of August 5, 1886, the channels
have been widened, so that the following is true of them at mean low
water:

       Name of channel.                                                                     Width.                                                       Depth.


                                                                                                                                                         Feet.
Craighill, below Cut-off...               400 feet..........................                       ...--- ...............--..              .........--       27
Cut-off-------------..................... 400 feet------...................................-----------------------------------......................         27
Brewerton. above Cut-off .. Generally 275 feet; a short portion 250 feet......................                                                               27
Fort McHenry............250 feet, except for a length of 1,000 feet above lower end, where                                                                   27
                                                 it is 300 feet.


   Nothing has been done in the Craighill Channel above the Cut-off, or
in Brewerton below it, for several years, and the depth of those portions
is probably but 24 feet at low water. It is not expected to deepen these
sections of the channel, as the deepening of the Cut-off to 27 feet makes
it unnecessary. By the making of the Cut-off the lengths of the Craig-
hill and Brewerton divisions of the channel are shortened, and thus the
whole distance from Baltimore to the deep waters of the bay is mate-
rially lessened. The cost of maintenance is also decreased.
   Though the depth of 27 feet at low water has been reached and seems
to suffice for present needs, the width of the channel is still insufficient
for easy or safe navigation by large vessels whose length is considerably
greater than the width of the channel.
   To give a uniform width of 400 feet throughout, with a depth of 27
feet at low water, will require $100,000. For the same depth the widths
of 500 or 600 feet will cost, respectively, $650,000 and $1,300,000.
   Up to June 30, 1888, the United States had expended $2,203,601.67,
with the result indicated above. The city of Baltimore and the State
of Maryland, chiefly the former, had also contributed to the same ob-
ject more than $500,000.
   Operations were suspended in June, 1887, for want of funds, and
nothing was done except some surveys in the year ending Jhne 30,1888.
July 1, 1887, amount available--.....................................----                                                                       $12, 798. 31
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.......................... ..................---                                                                           8,772.82
July 1, 188, balance available........................................                                                                               4, 025.49
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ........................                                                                           300, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889....-....-....- .....---.                                                                   304,025. 49
                            RIVER          AND        HARBOR             IMPROVEMENTS.                           97
( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..... $1, 000, 000. 00
I Amount that can be profitably expended in the fiscal year ending June
(           .....------..-.. --..................------..----....----------..-----------..... ........
    30, 1890-----                                                                                        500, 000. 00
I Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
l harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix I 1.)
   2. James River, Virginia.-When the improvement of the James River
was regularly undertaken by the Government the navigation was ob-
structed by sunken vessels, by remains of military bridges, and by other
obstructions put into the river during the late war to prevent the Na-
tional fleets from approaching too close to Richmond.
   There were also other natural obstructions. Rockett's Reef and Rich-
mond Bar had only 7 feet of water at mean low tide. From Warwick
Bar to Richmond the channel was crooked and obstructed by danger-
ous rocks and ledges, the Dutch Gap Cut-off was not then open and the
river was in a poor condition as regards its availability for commercial
purposes.
   The original project of improvement was to secure a depth of 18 feet
at full tide (corresponding to about 15 feet at low tide) to Richmond,
with a channel width of 180 feet. This project had reached an ad-
vanced stage of progress when Congress, by act approved July 5, 1884,
adopted the project looking to 22 feet at mean low tide from the sea to
Richmond ; the width to be 400 feet from tlbe sea to City Point, 300 from
thence to Drewry's Bluff, and 200 feet from thence to Richmond.
   The failure of the river and harbor bill of 1885 restricted the opera-
tions of the year ending June 30, 1886, to the exl)enditure of less than
$20,00): upon a project estimated to cost several millions. The condi-
tion of a year before was barely maintained. The total expenditure of *
the United States upon this river up to July 1, 1886, was $825,203.94.
In addition the city of Richmond had spent nearly $3500,000. The re-
sults of these expenditures may be stated as follows: Swan Point
Shoal, where the depth had been only 16.5 feet at mean low tide, was
deepened to 20 feet.
   This increase of depth added a foot to the available depth' of the river
from its mouth to Kingsland Reach, a distance of 98 miles. The Dutch
Gap Cut off, which was originally of no use to navigation, had been
widened to 300 feet, with a depth of about 18 feet, shortening the dis-
tance to Richmond 5. miles. From Drewry's Bluff to the ship-locks at
Richmond the depth had been increased from 7 feet at low tide to the
present depth of about 13.5 feet at low tide.
   July 1, 1886, the available balance was $2,559.27. The additional
sum of $112,500 was provided by the law of August 5, 1886.
   After the long suspension of active operations much time was con.
sumed in bringing contractors to the work on reasonable terms. The
available funds were expended by the end of December, 1887, in dredg-
ing at Kingsland Reach, Randolph Flats, and near Stearns Dike; in
constructing training-walls and wing-dams at Randolph Flats, and in
excavating rock at Goode's.
   No very great effect could be expected from the expenditure of this
small sum. The condition of the river at the close of the work may be
stated as follows:
   The available draught from the sea to City Point at high tide was 19-
feet; thence to Falling Creek, 19 feet; thence to Richmond, 164 feet.
   When the proposed improvement is completed, an annual expendi-
ture of $20,000 will be necessary for the maintenance of the channel.
The amount that may be advantageously expended during the fiscal
          ENG 88--7
98          REPORT         OF     T 1 TE      CHIEF          OF ENGINEERS.                           U. S         ARMY

year ending June 30, 1890, is put at 8400000i    less than one tenth the
estimated cost of the adopted project.
  Operations ceased in December, 1887, for want of funds, and the sea-
son of 1888 was more than half gone at the close of the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1888, without anything being done or any preparations for
work being possible.
  The total amount expended on this river by the United States up to
June 30,1888, has been $939,215.23, which includes the sumn of 8208,330.68,
expended since the new project has been entered upon to give a depth
of 22 feet at mean low water.
July 1, 1887, amount available .....................---.....                                           -......- ...        8101, 94'2. 12
July 1, 1688, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1,        1887...---------------............------.....--.....---------------..............               100, 894.14
July 1, 1888, balance available              ....------            ---...........--.....-......----....--....--.... --            1, 047. 98
                                                                     .
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188 ..-.. - -.. _ ........-...                                                  -225,      000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.................                                                           26, 047. 98
 (AAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... 4, 161, )70. 45
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
               ------ ---------------......---------......---......-----......--..--..--...-----
     180 ......----.................                                                             400, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
 (. harbor acts of 166 alnd 16(7.
   (See Appmidix I 3.)
   3. 'ansenmond River, Virginia, including the mouths of Bennett and
Chuckatuck creeks.--From 1873 to 1878, inclusive, the expenditures
made by the United States for the above improvement amounted to
the sum of $37,000. The work consisted of removal of wrecks, snags,
and similar obstructions, dredging at different localities, and building
dikes at mouth of Western Branch. No work has been done since 1880.
   In obedience to the requirements of the river and harbor act of
August 5, 1886, a preliminary examination and survey were made of
the river, and is printed in Appendix L 13 of the Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1887.
   The plan of improvement proposed provides for a channel not less
than 100 feet wide at bottom, 12 feet deep at mean low water from the
head of navigation to the mouth of Western Branch, 5.37 miles, includ-
ing a turning-basin 200 feet square, 300 feet below Suffolk Bridge, by
(lredging, and the construction of spurs and training-walls, and a chan-
nel of like depth from mouth of Western Branch to deep water at Town
Point, 200 feet wide at bottom at its upper end and gradually increas-
ing to at least 400 feet at its lower end, etc., the total estimated cost
being in round numbers $152,500.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates                                                                      $10,000
for the work, and $15,000 may be profitably expended in continuing it
(luring the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 18 .... --- --....--...-                                    --..--........              10, 000. 00

JAmount  (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......
   Amonuntthat can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June :30,1 9)
                                                                                                                             142, 500.00
                                                                                                                              15,000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 167.
  4. Harbor of Nofolk and its approaches, Virginia.-Nothinghas been
done at this locality             (luring
                          the year ending June 30. 1888.
  The project for improvement adopted in 1877 was to deepen and
widen the clhannel at the mouth of the Southern Branch and along the
Berkley and Portsmouth Flats, in the harbor proper, and for the ap.
                           RIVER         AND       HARBOR           IMPROVEMENTS.                                   99
proaches to dredge a channel 500 feet wide and 25 feet deep at ordinary
low water through the bars at the Western Branch and Sewell's Point.
   The revised project of 1885 is as follows: (1) To secure a channel
not less that 25 feet deep and 500 feet wide at ordinary low water, by
dredging from the deep water of Hampton Roads to Norfolk and the
United States navy-yard on the Southern Branch, and also to secure a
channel in the Eastern Branch at the same stage, not less than 22 feet
deep with a width at least 300 feet at the Norfolk and Western Rail-
road Bridge, and gradually increasing to about 700 feet at its mouth,
by dredging between said points; and (2) to ultimately dredge the en-
tire area bounded by lines parallel to and 75 feet from the Port War-
den lines to a depth not less than 25 feet at ordinary low water, from
Fort Norfolk to the United States navy-yard, and not less than 22 feet
deep from the mouth of the Eastern Branch to Campostella Bridge, and
to construct a bulk-head at Berkley Flats.
   With slight modifications all operaions have been conducted in ac-
cordance therewith. The amount expended to June 30, 1886, was
$383,112.59, which resulted in a channel at least 25 feet deep and not
less than 200 feet wide at ordinary low water, from the deep water of
Hampton Roads to the United States navy-yard, and also a channel at
least 22 feet deep and not less than 200 feet wide at same stage in the
Eastern Branch up to the Norfolk and Western Railroad Bridge.
   Cursory examinations show that the former channel is good, except
at Sewell's Point, where it has contracted somewhat and shoaled in
places. The ruling depth is 24 feet, save near Buoy No. 2, where it is 21
feet at mean low water. It is possible that the contemplated survey of
this reach will determine that this portion of the straight dredged chan-
nel will have to be abandoned for the natural channel further inshore,
which deep-draught vessels now navigate.
   The Eastern Branch Channel has deteriorated slightly, the ruling
depth being 21 feet at mean low water.
   There was expended in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, $49,151.34,
which was applied to the building of a steam-tender for use on this and
other works and to the removal of 265,570 cubic yards of material,
measured in scows, from the Southern Branch. This dredging resulted
in a channel at least 25 feet deep and from 125 to 500 feet wide at mean
low water, from its mouth to the upper end of the navy-yard.
   To complete this work, so far as can be foreseen, will require the ex-
penditure of $457,744.56.
July 1, 1887, amount available--..........-----......--......                  ..................            $2, 769. 82
July 1, 1888, amnonut expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ..--...--..........--......--........-----.....--......                            1, 242. 82
July 1, 1888, balance available ......------........----------..------....------..........------...... --     1,527.00
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 18 .--- --...........--........                                     50, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...... ............                                    51, 527. 00

   Amount (e timated) required for completion of existing project -......                                   407, 744.56
   Amonnt that can be l)rofitlly expended in fiscal yearending June 301890                                  100, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with.requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix 1 4.)
   5. Approach to Norfolk Harbor and the United States (Norfolk) Navy-
yard, between Lainbert'sPoint and Fort Yorfolk. -Nothing has been done
at this locality d(lring the year emunding June 30, 1888.
100    REPORT    OF   THE CHIEF    OF   ENGINEERS,    U. S   ARMY.

    The original condition of the channel was good, with the exception of
a bar opposite the mouth of the Western Branch, on some parts of which
the running depth was only about 15 feet at mean low water.
    The project for the improvement adopted in 1878 was to dredge this
bar for a distance of 4,800 feet to a width of 500 feet and a depth of 25
feet at mean low water.
    The amount expended on this work to July 5, 1884, can not be stated,
as it can not be separated from the sum total of the general expendi-
tures for the work of improving the harbor at Norfolk, Va., and its ap-
proaches, of which this was a part up to that date.
    The result obtained from the expenditures at this point to November,
1880, was a channel 4,400 feet long, 265 feet wide, and 25 feet deep at
mean low water, which greatly facilitated navigation and commerce.
This channel has since shoaled to 24 feet in places, and contracted con-
siderably.
    No work was done in this locality thereafter until subsequent to the
passage of the act of July 5, 1884, which appropriated $50,000 specifi-
cally for widening the channel.
    There was expended in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, $381.36,
which was applied to surveying the locality in question and preparing
map of same.
    A Board of Engineer Officers was convened August, 1834, to prepare
a project for the application of this appropriation. The Board reported
a plan involving, in conjunction with dredging, the construction of a
like at or near Pinner Point, expressing at the same time doubts
whether, under the phraseology of the law, any part of the money could
be applied to a work of construction.
    However, the requirements of navigation demanding the widening of
the channel, as contemplated in the project already commenced and
partly executed, by dredging, it was recommended that the existing ap-
propriation be applied to widening the channel between Lambert's
Point and Fort Norfolk by dredging along the eastern side thereof.
This having been approved, the work was done accordingly.
    There was expended in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, $46,768.64,
which was applied to the removal of 469,944 cubic yards of material,
measured in scows, resulting in a straight channel not less than 25 feet
deep and at least 400 feet wide at mean low water the entire length of
this approach. Formerly the channel had an angle in it. This work
has materially benefited navigation and commerce.
     There was expended in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, $32,348.92,
which was applied to the building of a steam-tender for use on this and
other works, and to the removal of 179,992 cubic yards of material,
measured in scows, from the vicinity of Lambert's Point Light. This
  dredging resulted in a channel at least 25 feet deep and not less than
  600 feet wide at mean low water from the main ship-channel to the
  Lambert's Point Coal Pier, about 1,000 feet.
     Soon after the completion of this dredging, and as a preper precau-
  tion before commencing the proposed dike, the entire reach was resur-
  veyed and a map of same made. This disclosed the fact that there ex-
  isted a straight channel through it at least 25 feet deep and not less
  than 450 feet wide at mean low water, which had improved since it was
  dredged in 1885; and seemed to be self sustaining. The officer in charge
  reported accordingly, recommending that the construction of the dike be
indefinitely postponed and that the money therefor be applied to addi-
tional dredging. The matter was referred to a Board of Engineer Offi-
                          RIVER        AND        HARBOR               IMPROVEMENTS.                               101
cers, and their report thereon was submitted to the Secretary of War,
who directed, on June 15, 1887, that-
  The money reserved for the dike will be held until the proper position of the dike
can be determined, and the whole subject will be submitted to Congress at its next
session.
July 1, 1887, amount available............. -......--..--------......                                       $108,001.08
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887........---------.-- --....---...............---------- .....----.....----.            476.08

July 1, 1888, balance available.............
                              --------...................--------....                                        107, 525.00
Amount appropriated by act of August 11,41888..-.                                      .-----.-.---------     10, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889........--..-----.....                                  117, 55.00
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......                                     10, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix I 5.)
   6. Archer's Hope River, Virginia.-Priorto the commencement of this
work there existed a natural channel about 4 feet deep in the river,
which could ndt be reached on account of the bar near its mouth, where
it enters the James River.
   The original project, adopted in 1881, is to dredge a channel 6 feet
deep and not less than 50 feet wide from the mouth to Williamsburgh,
5 miles above, where it is crossed by the Chesapeake and Ohio Railroad.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1884, is $9,874.79, which resulted
in a channel 2,300 feet long, 6 feet deep, and 50 feet wide at mean low
water from the mouth up. This did not carry the channel over the bar,
which is 700 feet longer. No material benefit to navigation and com-
merce has yet been realized. There have been no operations since.
   The small amount expended since June 30, 1887, has been applied to
contingencies.   The last examination, made in June, 1885, showed that
the outer end of the dredged channel had shoaled about 1 foot, and
that the inner part was in good condition.
July 1, 1887, amount available .........................................                                         $20. 63
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1887 ........       ----      ..----.--..-------.............                              20. 63
    (See Appendix I 6.)
    7. Appomattox River, Virginia.-At the close of the late war the nav-
igation of this river was in such a condition that the depth of water on
more than one of the shoals did not exceed 61 feet at high tide, and this
depth was diminished by 3 feet at low tide. The plan of improvement
adopted in 1870 was to attain a depth of 12 feet at high tide, with as
much width of channel as the river would bear. This plan has been
steadily adhered to, constant progress being made towards its comple-
tion from year to year by the use of the money granted by Congress. The
means depended on have been revetments, jetties, dams, and training-
walls, with resort to the dredge only when the needs of commerce re-
quired immediate work in the channel to give more width or depth than
had been attained under the slower operations of the structures men-
tioned, of which the system has not yet been fully carried out for want of
sufficient funds. Puddledock Cut, 2 miles long, has been enlarged, and
the river was diverted from old channel into it. The amount expended
by the United States up to June 30, 1886, on the project adopted in 1870,
$381,234.24, resulted in securing a turning-basin at Petersburgh about
155 by 110 feet and a navigable channel of 12 feet and upwards at high
tie, with some short shoals renaiiig from Petersburgh down to Point
102          REPORT           OF     THE       CHIEF         OF      ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

of Rocks, all of which vastly benefited navigation and largely increased
the extensive commerce carried over this river.
   The extraordinary freshet of July, 1886, caused the channel to de-
teriorate.
   There was expended in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, the sum
of $18,829.53, including outstanding liabilities, which was applied as
follows: The river was resurveyed and mapped from the head of navi-
gation to the natural deep water at Point of Rocks, 7b miles, after
which dredging, etc., was continued.
   An aggregate of 25,047 cubic yards of material, measured in scows,
was removed from the channel at Puddledock Cut, Rushmore's, and Ga t-
hng's shoals. A number of the jetties, dams, and training-walls out-
side the limits of Peterburgh Harbor were repaired more or less to pre-
serve their efficiency. A revetment, 348 feet in length, was built along
the left bank at the upper end of Puddledock Cut. The construction
of Rushmore's training-wall, 607 feet long, and of Sunken Island Dam,
276 linear feet in length, was begun in the previous fiscal year and
completed in July, 1887. The foregoing has resulted in generally ob-
literating the bad efficts of the freshet and, it is believed, will guard
against similar ones in future to any great extent. An annual expend-
iture of $5,000 will be required to maintain the work after the com-
pletion of the project, as is the case with all works of this class.
   The principal portion of the work projected has been done, and in
the main perfornms the service required of it. The condition of perma.
nence of the deepened and improved channel seems to be nearly reached
under the influence of its regulation. The truth of this statement is
confirmed by the diminished use of the dredge year by year. The best
results can not be said to be reached until its services can be dispensed
with under ordinary circumstances.
July 1, 1887, amount available--------------------------------...................-------......................       $822.77
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ....---........--.... ......----.....------------..........                --
                                                                                                      --.             762. 82
July 1, 1888, balance available ............----........---..............                            .......            59. 95
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .1...........                                      .     ....    .   15 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889......-....-.........                                         15, 059. 95

   Amount thatcan be protitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                       18, 900. 00
   Submitted in compliance with reqluirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix I 7.)
   S. Currituck Sound, Coanjok Bay, and North River Bar, North Caro-
lina.--Previousto the commencement of this improvement there was
an indifferent natural channel with a depth of from 5 to 7 feet at low
water, which had been partially dredged, in the sound and bay, by the
Albemarle and Chesapeake Canal Company.
   The original project, adopted in 1878, is to obtain a channel 80 feet wide
at bottom and 9 feet deep at ordinary winter water, by dredging the en-
tire length of the sound, 10. miles, to which was added, in 1880, the pro-
ject to prolong this channel by dredg ing through the bay about 2 miles,
and to construct a shell dike 9,600 feet along the westerly side of the
channel through the latter to maintain it. In 1885 it was further en-
larged by the project to dredge a straight channel through North River
Bar 7,150 feet long, 150 feet wide, andl 9.4 feet d(leep at ordinary low
water.
                          RIVER           AND     HARBOR           IMPROVEMENTS.                                      103
  The amount expended to June 30, 1885, is $123,500, and resulted in
the construction of the dike and a channel in the sound and bay from
40 to 80 feet wide, the entire length and depth prqjected, all of which
greatly improved navigation and increased the commerce over this im-
portant inland water route.
  The entire channel was surveyed last in April and May, 1885, to as-
certain its condition, which was found to be quite good, although
shoaled in places. This is probably due very largely to steamers
grounding out of the channel and creating shoals in their efforts to get
off. To restore and complete the work will require the removal of
215,075 cubic yards of material measured in place.
   There were no operations or expenditures during the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1886.
   There was expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, the
sum of $1,729.20, including outstanding liabilities, $1,500 of which was
applied to the building of a steam-tender for use on this and other
works, and the balance to dredging. An attempt was made to dredge
a channel across North River Bar, but, owing to the failure of the con-
tractors to carry out their contract, very little was done.
   The work was re-advertised and after much delay resumed by a new
contractor, November 19, 1887. The appropriation was exhausted April
10, 1888. The result of the dredging was a channel 40 feet in width,
8,350 feet long, and 9.8 feet deep. To be useful such a narrow channel,
more than a mile and a half long, should be carefully buoyed or other-
wise distinctly marked. Owing to the exposure of the locality the
permanence of the artificial channel is doubtful.
July 1, 1887, amount available ....         ..........---------......----------......----...--.....------.   $9, 770. 80
July 1, 1889, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabihties
  outstanding July 1, 1887 .---..---------..--...--.....................----------------.....---------.         9, 456. 48

July 1, 18-8, balance available..------------..............----.........................
                                                                                   ---                               314. :32
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1688 ......---......-.....-----      ....                              7,    00.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .                               -   -     -.................. 7, 814.32

iAmount (estimated)      required for completion of existing project--..---.....                              47, 700. 00
   Amountthat can h rofital)v expende l in fiscal year ending June 30, 1,90                                   20, OGBO.0
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866          and(l
                              1837.
   (See Appendix I 9.)
   9. Nottoway River, Virginia.-Priorto impnrovement the condition of
this river at low water was as follows: At the mouth of the navigable
depth was only 2 feet. due to sunken logs; thence to the Seaboard and
Roanoke Railroad Bridge, 19 miles, the channel was from 9 to 25 feet
deep and much obstructed by a war blockade of sunken vessels, and
also by snags, overhanging growth, etc. The next reach, to Peter's
Bridge, 31 miles, was so filled with snags, logs, etc., that it was with
difficulty that a fiat-boat of 1-foot draught could pass over it.
   The original project, adopted in 1881, was to obtain a channel not less
than 60 feet wide and at least 9 feet deep from the mouth to the railroad
bridge, and 2 feet deep thence to Peter's Bridge, by removing the said
obstructions.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1882, is $6,420.30, which completed
the project for the lower 20 miles. There have been no operations since.
   This improvement has not led to the development of much trade on
the river. There is no regular line of boats there. The river is crossed(
by the railroad and for some distance is paralleled, about 5 miles off, by
the Blackwater River, on which are lines of steamers.
104         REPORT         OF     THE      CHIEF        OF ENGINEERS,                U. S. ARMY.

   The last examination, made in June, 135, showed that the portion be-
low the railroad bridge was i fair cndition, while that above had again
become obstructed by logs, etc., owing to the careless manner in which
they had been handled and rafted. For this reason the river is not
susceptible of entire and permanent improvement.
July 1,1887, amount availabe------------------------------------...................................--   $246. 16
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 187 ...------------.................                                             246.16
                                                                                        --.............--..
   (See Appendix I 11.)
   10. Removing sunken ressels or craft obstructing or endangeringnaviga-
tion.-Notice was received February 3, 1888, that the wreck of the barge
Marion, near Lambert Point lighthouse, Norfolk Harbor, Virginia, was
a dangerous obstruction to navigation.
   Correspondence with the owners, the Thames Towboat Company of
New London, Conn., elicited the information that the company proposed
to raise the barge. After much delay, the vessel was finally reported,
May 14, 1888, completely removed without expense to the United States.
   A petition from citizens of North Carolina for the removal of the
wrecked schooner Dorcas and Eliza from the Pasquotank River, North
Carolina, was received February 7, 1888. An examination of the wreck
proved her to be dangerous to navigation. After advertisement for
proposals for the removal, a contract was made with the lowest bidder,
Mr. W. H. French, under date of April 6, 1888. The vessel was en-
tirely taken up and the contract completed April 20, 1888.
   Information was received March 9, 1888, that the sunken barge Harry,
off Turkey Point, Chesapeake Bay, was in the track of vessels navigat-
ing those waters and dangerous to them.
   Arrangements were made to advertise for proposals for her removal,
but in the mean time the company having a marine risk on the vessel,
The Phenix Insurance Company, of New York, showed a disposition to
raise her. This was finally done May 4. 188, without expense to the
United States.
   (See Appendix I 14.)
IMPROVEMENT OF THE POTOMAC RIVER AT WASHINGTON; RECON-
  STRUCTION OF TIIE AQUEDUCT BRIDGE AT GEORGETOWN, AND CON-
  STRUCTION OF BRIDGE ACROSS THE EASTERN BRANCH OF THE PO-
  TOMAC RIVER AT WASIIINGTON.

   Officer in charge, Lieut. Col. Peter C. Hains, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Potomac River at Washington, District of Columbia.-The project
for the improvement of the Potomac River in the vicinity of Washing-
ton, D. C., was adopted by act of Congress passed August 2, 1882, and
has for its object the improvement of the navigation of the river by
widening and deepening its channels so as to accommodate vessels of
the largest class that can reach Giesboro' Point; the establishment of
harbor lines beyond which no obstructions, such as wharves, etc., should
be built, and at the same time to fill and raise the marshes or flats in
front of the city above overflow by the highest freshets, the material
taken from the river in deepening and widening the channel to be used
in filling the flats.
  Before the improvement was commenced the flats or marshes in front
of the city had become so offensive that certain parts of the city in their
neighborhood were not habitable.
  The channel to Georgetown was narrow and crooked, and had not
                 RIVER   AND   HARBOR     IMPROVEMENTS.                105
sufficient depth to accommodate vessels sailing to and from that port.
The Washington Channel between Long Bridge and the Arsenal was
also inadequate to the wants of commerce. Vessels drawing 16 feet
frequently grounded in the Georgetown Channel, and that depth was
only maintained by frequent dredging.
   The expenditures for the improvement have thus far amounted to
$1,247,494.90, and have given a channel from Giesboro' Point to George-
town about 500 feet wide and 20 feet deep (except where the depth has
been somewhat reduced by the deposits of freshets), and a channel
along the wharves from Washington Barracks 20 feet deep and about
350 feet wide. About 6,506,200 cubic yards of material have been de-
posited on the flats, raising an area of about 544 acres of marshes to a
height of from 4 to 10 feet above mean low tide. More than half the
entire work has been done at a total expenditure of $1,247,494.90, less
than half the estimated cost of the entire work.
   The dredging during the past year was done chiefly by contract. On
Section II dredging in the Tidal Reservoir and in the Virginia Chan-
nel was in progress, and about three-fourths of the proposed excava-
tion in the former is completed. All the material was deposited on the
flats.
   On Section III the construction of embankment was continued and
completed; about 400,000 cubic yards of material were also excavated
from the Washington Channel and deposited on this portion of the flats.
   All the contracts for dredging and filling the flats have been com-
pleted, and no others have been made because of lack of funds.
   The construction of the Reservoir Outlet has been in progress dur-
ing the year, and the foundation for the main structure is now about
completed. This has been a work of great difficulty owing to the soft
nature, to a great depth, of the material forming the bed of the river
at ths place. The work is being done by hired labor.
   The officer in charge refers to the necessity for action in regard to the
sewer canal at the foot of Seventeenth street, as discussed in former
reports. He also reports in regard to Section 1, that portion of the flats
upon which work was stopped because of the requirement of Congress
that no money should be expended upon any portion of the flats against
which title claims adverse to the United States had been made, that
certain work is necessary to secure the work already done from possi-
ble destruction, and recommends that the restrictions contained in the
river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, and of the act approved August
5, 1836, be so modified as to permit of the necessary protective work.
   Long Bridge and the necessity for Congressional action in regard to
it is a prominent topic in the report of the officer in charge of this im-
provement. His report of February 11, 1888, upon the danger, not only
to the improvement but to the city itself, from freshets and ice gorges,
should Long Bridge be allowed to remain as it is, was transmitted to
the Speaker of the House of Representatives by the Secretary of War
(see House Ex. Doe. No. 170, Fiftieth Congress, first session).
   The Long Bridge is controlled by the Baltimore and Potomac Rail-
road Company, being a free gift from the United States (as per act ap-
proved June 21, 1870). The officials of the railroad company claim that
the improvement of the Potomac Liiver will endanger that part of the
structure spanning the Washington Channel. A conflict of interests
seems probable, and the officer, while not of the opinion that the bridge
will be endangered, recommends that Congress require the railroad conm-
pany to erect such a structure at this place as will meet the new condi-
tions.
  106        REPORT         OF    THE      CHIEF        OF     ENGINEERS,                            U. S. ARMY.

   The amount of $600,000 can be profitably expended during the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1890, in widening the channels of the river and
raising the flats with the material excavated.
July 1,
July           amrount available.
          1887, amount
       1, 188,          avilale ....
                                   --    _.-----------2oO,351.60
                                          ... .   .... .... ........................                                     ... 0, 3j1. 60
July 1, 1888, amount expended during liscal year, exclusive
   of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887---         .......--......                $222, 556. 50
July 1, 1858, outstanding liabilities.--    -               -------.----               1,970. 40
July 1, 18 8, amount covered )by     existing contracts ........                       2, 410. 00
                                                                                                                          227, 23'. 90

                                 ......---------......----..---.......- ---......
  July 1, 1888, balance available-----                                            --......--...... 23, 124. 70
• Amount appropriated by act of August 11,               ---........-............                300,000. (0
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 19--                                       ......-- - -
                                                                                          ....-                ....      32-, 124.70

  (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... 1,141,365.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in the fiscal year ending June
       30, 1890 ...----------------------------------------------------                                                  600,000.00
   I Submitted   in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
       harbor acts of 1866 and 18.,7.
     (See Appendix J 1.)
    2. Reconstruction of the Aqueduct Bridge, Georgetown, District of
Columbia.-Conigress,by an act approved June 21, 1886, authorized the
purchase of' the Aqueduct Bridge, a wooden structure resting on stone
piers, spanning the Potomac River at Georgetown, D. C., and appro-
priated $240,000 for that purpose and its reconstruction.
    Certain claims, etc., affecting the title to the bridge being in exist-
ence when the bridge was conveyed to the Government, the interests
of the United States were protected by the retention of a portion of
the purchase money until the said claims were adjudicated. The officer
in charge reports that the last payment on account of the purchase
of the bridge has been made.
    Proceedings have been instituted looking to the condemnation of the
north abutment as provided in the act authorizing the purchase and
reconstruction of the bridge. This matter is yet unsettled.
    The bridge has been in course of reconstruction in accordance with the
approved project which contemplated that an iron bridge having a clear
width of roadway of 24 feet, with two sidewalks each (6 feet wide in
the clear, be substituted for the old wooden superstructure which had
become unsafe for travel. The new bridge was opened for public use on
March 3, 1888. The contract fobr the reconstruction of the buidge
proper was completed May 5, 1888. For several reasons, the principal
of which was want of efficient management on the part of the con-
tractor, this part of the work has taken a longer time than was thought
necessary, though every effort was made on behalf of the United States
to hasten its completion. There remains some work to be done on the
approaches. This is in progress, under contract, and will be completed
in the near future.
July 1, 1887, amount available .......-- -......-------      ....--......   ---     ..................
                                                                                        ------                            22,   712. 37
July 1, 1588, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
                                              ---         --
   liabilities outstanding July 1, 187 ........................                                           9, 262.66
July 1, 1888,    outstanding liabilities. .........------....--............                                9,210. 10
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts ......----....                                          4, 110. 75
                                                                                                      ---                111, 583. 51
July 1, 188,     balance available ........               ..........              .........                              11,12. 86
     (See Appendix J 2.)
     3. Bridge across the Eastern Branch of the Potomac River, Districtof
  Columia.-This                rV(;k w;a- ;oi-t oizedi                iby act of (Conr' cs                               appl)Ied0cc
                          RIVER         AND      HARBOR           IMPROVEMENTS.                                  107
February 23, 1887, which appropriated $110,000 for the construction of
a substantial wooden, iron, or masonry bridge, and provided that sur-
veys be made to determine the length, width, and height thereof. The
officer in charge made a report upon the survey, which was referred to
a Board of Engineer Officers, which concurred in his recommendations
that the direction of the bridge be a line forming an angle about six
degrees to the southward of the line of Pennsylvania avenue extended,
and that the width be not less than 32 feet, and the height of roadway
35 feet above low tide.
   Bids were invited for a bridge possessing the above features, and a
contract was made for the completion of the entire structure, including
approaches, for a total price of $105,000.
   Some time was lost in acquiring title to the site of the eastern ap-
proach, and some by reason of unfavorable weather, which hindered out-
door operations, but the chief cause of delay is a controversy with the
Baltimore and Potomac Railroad Company, whose tracks are to be
spansld by the westerly end of the bridge.
   Congress by act approved May 14, 1888, made an additional appro-
I)riation of 80$,000 to provide for modifying the plaus so as to best ac-
commodate traffic over and under the bridge, with a proviso that the
Baltimore and Potomac Railroad Company pay their just and fair pro-
portion of the cost of the changes at the west end.
   A conference has been had for the purpose of adjusting the matter,
but no agreement has been arrived at. Changes acceptable to the Gov-
ernment are regarded as too costly by the railroad company, while
those meeting the wishes of the company, in regard to cost, do not pro-
vide for a construction acceptable to the Government.
July 1, 1887, amount available...........------------.----------....--.........--------....---............ $109, 578. 30
Amount appropriated by act of May 14, 188..                             ............ ..-------------.......   60,000.00
                                                                                                         1t9, 578. 30
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 187--......-........----  --
                                                           ....-- ..---.                 10, 713.70
July 1, 1838, outstanding liabilities                   -..-----...............--....       ,    9.
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts--..--.......                          89, 50.15
                                                                                                         108, 42:.   56


                                ......----....--.....-- ...--...---........
July 1, 1888, balance available----                                                             ......     61, 154.74
   (See Appendix J 3.)
   4. WVhauf at Fort lonroe, Virlinia.--The act providing for the sundry
civil expenses of the Government for the fiscal year ending June 30,
1887, al)l)rop)riated $100.000 for the construction of a new wharf and
improvements to the roadway leading thereto, on the Government res-
ervation at Fortress lIonroe. The selection ot the most suitable site,
and also of the plan and selection of the most suitable material for its
construction, was referred to a Board consisting of Col. J. C. Tidball,
First Artillery, Lieut. Col. J. G. Chandler, Deputy Quartermaster-Gen-
eral, and Lieut. Col. P. C. Hains, Corps of Engineers, whose reconimen-
dations were approved by the Secretary of War, and the work placed
in charge of Lieutenant-Colonel Hains.
   After some modifications of the plau, to reduce its cost, a contract
was entered into for the work, and at the close of the fiscal year the
greater part of the material had been prelareared by the contractor and
was being delivered at the site of the work.
   (See Appendix J 5.)
   5. ,S81rry/of
             0he    TJa ny Creel- Ca al. emtt),tyilg a tto A)ac)stia River, in the
city of aI.S:hialto.-B\ irelc ion 4f tie ecretary (at War, Lieutenant-
108      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Colonel Hains was directed to assume charge of the surveys and the
preparation of plans and estimates for improving the low lands in the
immediate vicinity of the Washington Barracks with a view to improv-
ing the sanitary condition of that post, the funds required for this
purpose being provided by the Quartermaster-General's Department.
  The report submitted of the results of this survey contains two plans
of improvement suggested by Lieutenant-Colonel lains, the details of
which will be found in Appendix J 6.

IMPROVEMENT OF PATUXENT RIVER AND OF THE HARBORS AT BRE-
  TON BAY AND SAINT JEROME'S CREEK, MARYLAND-OF THE CHAN-
  NEL AT MOUNT VERNON-OF RAPPAHANNOCK RIVER, AND YORK
  RIVER, VIRGINIA-OF TRIBUTARIES OF THE LOWER POTOMAC, AND
  OF CERTAIN RIVERS IN VIRGINIA AND NORTH CAROLINA.

   Engineer in charge, Mr. S. T. Abert, United States Agent; Supervis-
ing Engineer, Col. W. P. Craighill, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Channel at Mount Vernon, Virginia.-Previous to the commence-
ment of this improvement there was a depth of but 4 feet at low water
over the wide flat between the wharf at Mount Vernon and the main
channel of the Potomac River, a distance of 19900 feet. The present
project, adopted in 1879, is to excavate a channel from deep water of
the Potomac River to the wharf at Mount Vernon, which shall have,
when completed, a width of 150 feet, and a navigable depth of from 6
to 7 feet at low water, with a turning-basin at the wharf.
   The amount expended to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30,
1888, is $8,500.
   A channel was secured 145 feet wide, with a depth varying from 7 to
9 feet, from the Potomac Channel to the wharf, and a circular turning-
basin at the wharf, of the same depth, with a radius of 150 feet. No
work has been done since 1881 and no examination has been made
since that date, but a steamer drawing 4 feet finds great difficulty in
making a turn at the pier.
   On the recommendation of the superintendent of Mount Vernon it is
proposed, in the report of 1888, to increase the width to 200 feet and
the depth to from 9 to 10 feet at low water, with a turning-basin of 200
feet radius. This modification is necessary to meet the requirements
of trade during the period of low water, and will increase the estimate
$2,500, making a total due on estimate of $8,500.
   The engineer in charge believes that $8,500 will be necessary for
widening the channel, enlarging the turning-basin, and removing the
silt which has been deposited in the cut; that this sum will complete
the improvement required by the present needs of navigation, and can
be economically expended in the year ending June 30, 1)90.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888     ............................   $6, 000. 00

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........         2,500. 00
  Amountthat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890      2, 500. 0
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 186 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K 1.)
   2. Neabsco Creek, Virginia.-The obstruction to navigation in this
stream consists of a wide flat at the mouth, about 1- miles in length,
over which but 21 feet could be carried at low water, and several short
bars in the upper part of the creek where the channel is narrow and tor-
                           RIVER         AND      HARBO)R          IMPROVEMENTS.                        109
tuous. The present project was adopted in 1881, and contemplated the
excavation of a channel through the bars, 100 feet wide and 7 feet deep
at low water, from the Potomac River to Atkinson's Upper Landing
(including a channel to Atkinson's Lower Landing and Willis's Wharf),
a distance of about 14,800 feet.
  The amount expended to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30,
1888, is $5,000. When work ceased in 1882 the channel was 50 feet
wide and from 4 to 5 feet deep at low water from the Potomac River to
a point 1,800 feet above Willis's Wharf.
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ $20,000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1837.
   (See Appendix K 2.)
   3. Breton Bay, Leonardtown, Maryland.--The harbor of Leonardtown,
at the upper end of Breton Bay, prior to the commencement of the
present improvement, had a least depth of 5 feet at low water, which
was insufficient for the passage of steamers to and from the Leonard-
town Wharf. The bar which extended to the 9-foot curve in the bay
was about 1 mile in length.
   The present project for the improvement, adopted in 1878 and modi-
fied in 1886, is to excavate a channel with a width of 200 feet for a dis-
tance of 1) miles, and to enlarge the turning-basin to a breadth of 400
feet and a length of 800 feet. The depth is to be not less than 10 feet
at low water.
   Up to June 30, 1888, $29,173.96 have been expended. A basin has
been secured 645 feet long by 370 feet wide, narrowing to a width of
150 feet in 335 feet; and a channel 150 feet wide for a distance of 1,870
feet, and 185 feet wide for a further distance of 1,420 feet. The depths
vary from 8.5 to 13.3 feet at low water.
July 1, 1887, amount available..........................................                              $992. 37
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 .......           ... _..................     .............. .              666. 33
July 1, 1888, balance available ..........................................                             326. 04
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888....                            ...............   ..    3, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.............. ....                             3, 326.04
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ......                             17, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                        10, 000. 00
  SSubmitted   in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 180i7.
   (See Appendix K 3.)
   4. Nomini Creek, Virginia.--This stream is an important tributary of
the Potomac, 8: miles below Washington. Navigation was obstructed
by a bar of sand and oyster-shells at its mouth, over which but 3 feet
could be carried at low water, and the approach to the bar was further
obstructed by the cross-tide and an exceedingly rapid current. The
length of the bar from the 9-foot curve in the river to the 9-foot curve
in Nomini Creek is 5,700. After passing the bar 81 feet can be carried
to Nomini Ferry, 3 miles above the mouth.
   The project, modified in 1885, is to cut a channel with a width of 200
feet, and also to dredge a training-channel and to sink a mattress for
the purpose of diverting the cross curtent. The depth should be not
less than 10 feet at low water. The amount estimated in 1885 for this
purpose was $30,000.
110          REPORT            OF     TIIE      CHIEF          OF ENGINEERS,                   U. S. ARMY.

  The landings in Nomini Creek are the most important of those made
by the Baltimore and Potomac River boats. Pilots find great difficulty
in navigating the channel, and from their representations it is believed
that the unfinished cut nas filled from 30 to 40 per cent. since the date
of the last dredging. It will, in consequence, be necessary to increase
the estimate from $30,000 to $40,000, and this increase is recommended.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1888, is $32,500, which resulted in
securing at channel 100 feet wide and 9 feet deep from the 9-foot curve
in the bay to White Oak Point, a distance of 4,400 feet.
   No work has been done since 1882, and unless the channel is shortly
redredged this creek must be closed to steamers.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1                   _5, .....
                                           . .............. ....       000. 00
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........
   Amoulnt that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending J unc 30), 18)
                                                                                                                      ,
                                                                                                                     35,0    00
                                                                                                                     10, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix K 4.)
  5. Harborat entrance of Saint Jerome's C reelk, ]Maryland.-The outer
bar in the bay has a length of 2,193 feet from the 9-foot curve in the
bay to Carsey's Point, in the creek. The least depth of water on it be-
fore improvement was 2.8 feet. The average depth in the channels to
the ponds used by the Fish Commission for hatching oysters was one-
half toot. The length of the inner channel to the wharf of the Fish
Commission is 3,742 feet.
  The project for the improvement of this harbor was adopted in 1881,
and contemplated dredging a channel 100 feet wide and 9 feet deep at
low water through the outer bar at the mouth of the creek; and a chan-
nel 40 feet wide and 6 feet deep through the south prong of the creek,
the material therefrom to be thrown up in a die so as to form a pond
for the purposes of the United States Fish Commission. The channel
through the outer bar was made navigable and the ponds were formed.
The preservation of the depth on the outer bar is doubtful. This har-
bor is situated at a desirable point for a refuge for oyster-boats.
 * Up to June 30, 1888, $25,138.60 were expended.
                                   .........................................
July 1, 1887, amount available-------------------------------------                                                  $1,770.00
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 187 ......------......------ ......------....---....----......---- ....------------.........      408.60
July 1, 1888, balance available ...................------------------------..----......-------.........               1, 361.40
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........ 26,000.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 18, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix K 5.)
  6. Patuxent River, Maryland, from Benedict to Hill's Landing.-To
comply with the requirements of the river andl harbor act of August 5,
1886, a preliminary examination was made, and a survey of parts of the
Patuxeut River between the points designated.
  A report of the results of the survey was transmitted to Congress
February 14, 1888, and printed as House Ex. Doc. No. 162, Fiftieth Con-
gress, first session.
  The proposed improvement to consist of dredging a cut 200 feet wide
and from 12 to 13 feet in depth, which will give, when completed, a
channel of about 100 feet wide at low water, and 12 feet in dept.h.
                         RIVER        AND      HARBOR          IMPROVEMENTS.                                 11 1
   The estimated cost for the two bars being about $80,000.
   l1he river and harbor act of August 11, 1888 contains an appropria-
tion of $5,000 for this improvement, and a further sum of $10,000 may
be profitably expended in continuing it during the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 18............-                       -       - -- -----..    $5, 001). 00
JAmount   (estimated) required for completion of existingo project - - _-                              75,000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending J une 30,1890
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections of river and               2                   10,000.  00
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   7. Rappahannock River, Virginia.-The distance from Fredericks-
burgh to the mouth of the river is 106;- miles. The present project for
the improvement of this river was adopted in 1871 and modified in 1879,
the object being to provide a channel 150 feet wide and 10 feet deep
through the bar at Fredericksburgh; channels 100 feet wide and 10 feet
deep through the bars between Fredericksburgh and Port Royal; and
channels 200 feet wide and 15 feet deep through two bars between Port
Royal and Tappahannock, where a larger class of vessels must be pro-
vided for. Between March 3, 1871, and June 30, 1879, 90,500 were
expended on the first project.
  The amount expended on the present project from June 14, 1880, to
June 30, 1887, is $81,278.76, and during the fiscal year ending June 30,
1888, $15,363.68, including outstanding liabilities, were expended, mak-
ing a total to June 30, 1888, of $96,642.44. This amount has been ex-
pended in dredging, in the construction and repair of longitudinal and
spur-dikes, in planting locusts and willows, and in the blasting and
removal of rock. It has secured navigable channels at Fredericksburgh,
Pollocks, Bernard's, Pratt's, Spottswood, Castle Ferry, and Farley Vale
bars, extending over a distance of 12.6 miles. Between Fredericksburgh
and Farley Vale the least depth on June 30, 1888, was 8 feet at low
water, and the width about 100 feet. Below Farley Vale steamers have
less difficulty in navigating the river.
July 1,1887, amount available ..........................................                               $15, 721.24
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
    liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 .......                          -......-..... $15, 362. 01
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ......-......-......-..----                              1.67
                                                                                                        15, 363. (8

                                                                            ..............
July 1, 1888, balance available ......---------...--..--------.........-----------.......--------           357. 56
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888... -..----...                              -... ...
                                                                                               -..-.... 15, 000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                               15,357.5

 {Amount  (estimated) required for completion of existing project.. ....    179, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 30, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
       harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K 6.)
  8. Totusky River, Virginia.-The obstructions to the navigation of this
river consisted of two bars; one at its mouth, which forms a part of
the wide flat between the outlet of the river and the navigable channel
of the    ItRanpahannock,
                       having a least depth of 4. feet, and the other,
about 2. miles above the mouth, known as Booker's Bar, having a rul-
ing depth of 3 feet. •
  Ten thousand dollars were appropriated up to August 2, 1882. This
sum has been expended in building and repairing a longitudinal dike
112        REPORT OF           THE      CHIEF                  OF    ENGINEERS,                   U. S. ARMY.

2,117 feet in length, the effect of which has been to scour out the chan-
nel to a depth of 3, feet at low water.
July 1, 1887, amount available......----- ----.......------.......--.............--.. -                                      $400. 82
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ..          .....................                   ....   .........                 .....- .      400. 82

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....-....                                                  12, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K 7.)
  9. Urbana Creek, Virginia.-Prior to the commencement of this im-
provement the navigation was obstructed by a bar at the mouth over
which but 6 feet of water could be carried.
  The present project was adopted in 1879, the object being to excavate
a channel through the bar 150 feet wide and 10 feet deep at low water.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1888, is $15,500.
  The expenditure resulted in securing a channel of 10 feet in depth at
low water and of 120 feet in width at the narrowest part through the
outer bars. A turning-basin 200 feet wide, 300 feet long, and 10 feet
deep has been made at the wharf, and also a channel of approach within
the creek 1,090 feet long, 80 feet wide, and 10 feet deep at low water.
SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....... $7, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K 8.)
   10. ]Jlattaponi River, Tirginia.-This stream is navigable for 56 miles.
Previous to the commencement of the improvement the river was ob-
structed by numerous bars and by snags, wrecks, and overhanging trees.
The object of the improvement adopted in 1880 was to provide a chan-
nel 40 feet wide and 5. feet deep at low water by the removal of snags,
drift-logs, wrecks, and overhanging trees, and by dredging through the
bars. The channel through Robinson and Latan6's bars will have a
width of 40 feet at bottom and a depth of 6 feet at low water. The
amount expended to June 30, 1887, is $7,201.32, and during the year
ending June*30, 1888, $5,981.98 have been expended, making a total to
June 30, 1888, of $13,183.30. This sum was expended in snagging oper-
ations and the removal of wrecks, logs, and overhanging trees for a
length of river of about 34 miles and in building a dike at Robinson's
Bar.
July 1, 1887, amount available ------..--..----.....--              ......-.....................                           $6, 098.68
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 .... .... ..............
                                                          ---                                         $5, 980. 09
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities.......... ................                                            1.89
                                                                                                                            5, 981.98

July 1, 1888, balance available...... ........................                                    ...........                  116.70
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                                                     3, 000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889-..............                                             ....       3,116.70

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project - -... ..... 23,000. 00
   Amount that can beprofitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 10, 000.00
                                                                                                                 -
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K 9.)
   11. Pamunky Rtver, Virginia.-The present project was adopted in
1880, the object being to provide a channel 40 feet wide and from 3 to 5
                        RIVER AND HARBOR              IMPROVEMENTS.                        113
feet deep from Ianovertowni to New Castle Ferry, a distance of 9 miles,
and 10)0 feet wide and 7 feet deep at low water on two of the lower bars.
   The total expenditure to June 30, 1887, is $6,457.47, and during the
fiscal year ending June 30,, 1888, $5,943.50 have been expended, mak-
ing a total to June 30, 1888, of $12,400.97. This sum was expended in
the removal of snags, wrecks, logs, and overhanging trees from 16-
miles of the river and in building dikes at Skidmore and Spring bars.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..........................................          $6, 042. 53
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabities
  outstanding July 1,1887...... ............................              ........  5,943. 50
July 1, 1888, balance available.- ............    ......................                   99. 03
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                3, 000. 00


{Amount
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889....................
          (estimated) required for completion of existing project- ---. --
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890
  Submitted in compliance with requirments of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                       3,099. 03
                                                                                      13,000.00
                                                                                       8, 000.00
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See appendix K 10.)
   12. York River, Virginia.-The navigation of the river prior to the
commencement of the present improvement was obstructed by a bar at
the mouth of Potopotank Creek, having a least depth of 19 feet at low
water; and a bar about 8) miles above at West Point, Va., having a
least depth of 14 feet.
   The present project was adopted in 1880, the object being to provide
a channel 22 feet deep at low water, and 400 feet wide through the
bars; and also a basin of the same depth, connecting with the channel
above the wharves.
   The first appropriation ($1,0,000), made June 14, 1880, was applied to
the improvement of Potopotank Bar, through which a channel 105 feet
wide and 22 feet deep was made by dredging. The appropriations since
1880 have been applied to dredging a channel below West Point.
   The amount expended up to June 30, 1888, is $95,348.62. The ex-
penditures at West Point have resulted in giving a channel 190 feet
wide for a distance of 750 feet; 230 feet wide for a distance of 2,060
feet; 190 feet wide for a distance of 6,290 feet; 180 feet wide for a dis-
tance of 1,200 feet, and 100 feet wide for a distance of 1,000 feet, all
distances being stated successively and in a descending order. The
depth in the channel varies from 17.8 to 25.6 feet at low water.
   The width, when the channel is completed, will be 400 feet, and the
depth at low water will be 22 feet, which dimensions will be necessary
for vessels beating up to West Point.
July 1, 1887, amount available... .................. ...................   $3, 656. 28
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1887... ..................         ..................   ....      254. 9Q

July 1, 1888, balance available ................ ......................... ....        3,401. 38
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..........................               30, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ....................            33,401.38
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-- .....    127, 250.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 50, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements 9f sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix K 11.)
          h~G d~8----.
114         REPORT OF THE                 CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U                         S. ARMY.

   13. Chickahominy River, Virginia.-The present project was adopted
in 1878, the object being to dredge channels from 100 to 150 feet wide
through Windsor Shades, Old Fort, and Binn's bars, to a depth of not
less than 8 feet at low water. The whole of the appropriations, amount-
ing to $19,000, have been expended.
   On June 30, 1887, the bars at Windsor Shades and Old Fort had a
depth of from 8 to 9 feet and a width of about 75 feet. At Binn's Bar
the depth was between 71 and 8) feet, and the width about 160 feet.
The channel through the bar at the mouth had a width of about 200
feet and a depth of from 14 to 15 feet. The depths given refer to low
water. The length of the cut through the bar at the mouth of the
river is 1,700 feet.
   For the completion of the project for the improvement of the upper
part of the river, and for re-examinations of the old bars and the new
ones which have formed since the commencement of the work, $10,000
are required.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...----...........------------------.......-.           $2, 500.00
  Amount (estimae+1) required for completion of existing project-------                               7,500. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                          5, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K 12.)
   14. Staunton River, Virginia.--The project for the improvement of
this river between Brook Neal and Randolph Station, 31 miles below,
on the Richmond and Danville Railroad, was adopted in 1879, the ob-
ject being to secure a navigable channel, not less than 35 feet wide and
2 feet deep at low water, through the various ledges and sand-bars,
which obstruct navigation.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1887 is $29,006.67, and during the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $3,105.33 havebeen expended, making
a total to June 30, 1888, of $32,112.00.
   About 294 miles of the river have been opened for navigation by
small steamers.
   The project for the improvement of the part of the river between Pig
River and Brook Neal was adopted in 1882, the object being to secure a
navigable channel for bateaux, not less than 14 feet wide and from 1
to 2 feet deep at low water, with a slope of water-surface at rapids not
greater than 10 feet to the mile.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1887, is $3,606.77, and during the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $2,966.27, including outstanding lia-
bilities, were expended, making a total to June 30, 1888, of $6,573.04.
This expenditure resulted in opening a channel from the railroad bridge
to a distance of 184 miles above.
July 1, 1887, amount available._            ......     .....    -----          ---           --      $6, 886. 56
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ..                      -..-     -- - -........$-6, 068. 60
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities...........................                             3. 00
                                                                                                      6, 07 1. 60
July 1, 1888, balance available .......... ..... ...                          ........--.............    814. 96
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 . ..                        ...- .... ......
                                                                                      -      .... .   5, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889--
                                                     ......                           ...   --...     5,814.96

   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                        20, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix K 13.)
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                               115
  15. Dan River, between Madison, North Carolina, and Danville, Vir-
ginia.-The object   of the first project for this improvement, adopted in
1880, was to provide a channel for navigation not less than 35 feet wide,
but it was afterwards modified to a channel of not less than 16 feet
wide and 2 feet deep in the rapids at low water. The amount expended
to June 30, 1887, is $36,789.92, and during the fiscal year ending June
30, 1888, $13,298.89, including outstanding liabilities, were expended,
making a total to June 30, 1888, of $50,088.81. This expenditure has
resulted in the excavation of rock from the channel between Madison
and Danville and in building crib-dams at Slink's Shoals. The amount
due on estimate will be expended in building dams at the falls of great-
est descent, in excavating gravel-bars, and in rock excavation below
Eagle Falls.
July 1, 1887, amount available......--..................------------.                                ......   $13, 710,08
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 187......- - .- - - . - -       -
                                                               - $12, 558. 96
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities.- ..--......--        -.        739. 93
                                                                                                               13, 298. 89

                                  ....
July 1, 1888, balance available------            ---................... ....            ..........                 411. 19
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.. ......                                       7, 00. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K 14.)
   16. Roanoke River, North Carolina.--Thefirst project for the improve-
ment of this river was made in 1871, the object being to improve navi-
gation by the removal of rocks near Weldon and Halifax, and all wrecks,
snags, and overhanging trees at various other points; and to dredge
channels through the numerous bars and shoals. A part only of this
project was adopted.
   The appropriation of $5,000, made August 2, 1882, was expended in
repairing two dikes at Indian Highland Bar. A survey was also made
to ascertain the changes which had taken place since 1871.
   The amount expended under the first project to June 30, 1884, was
$45,000, and was chiefly for the removal of wrecks and blockades, and
for blasting rock near Weldon. The first appropriation under the pres-
ent project ($3,000, made July 5, 1884) was not sufficient to prosecute
the work economically. With the $20,000 appropriated August 5, 1886,
it was applied to building and operating a steam-plant. Coshake Creek
for its whole length, 1 miles, and the Thoroughfare, a distance of 2
miles, were cleared of obstructions; 10.5 miles of the river channel
were wholly cleared, and 10.8 miles partially cleared of obstructions.
In all, about 25 miles of channel were improved.
   The appropriations for the present project to June 30, 1888, amount to
$23,000. Of this sum, $8,978.34 were expended to June 30, 1887; and
during the year ending June 30, 1888, $11,457.38, including outstand-
ing liabilities, were expended, making a total to June 30, 1888, of
$20,435.72.
July 1, 1887, amount available ...... ....--. ....... . .............                             ......      $14, 021. 66
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 .. ----.........--                       ....     $11, 364. 65
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ...................                      ....            92.73
                                                                                                               11, 457.38
July 1, 1888, balance available...----... .... ......   ............                   ......----...            2, 564.28
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........                                 ..........             40. 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...............                                          42,564.28
116       REPORT      OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.
                                                                            1
(Amount   (estimted    renired   for   completion   of   exitil~   'proi   t _ _ _ _ _.1i0   000   CO
Amount that canbeprofitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 45, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections of river and 2
   harbor acts of 1866 and 18,17.
  (See Appendix K 15)
  17. French Broad River, North Carolina.-The first prqject for the
improvement of this river was adopted in 1878, the object being to se-
cure a channel 35 feet wide and not less than 2 feet deep at iow water
between Brevard and Big Buck Shoals, a distance of 31.6 miles.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1882, was $37,780.22, with the fol-
lowing results: A survey of the river between Brevard and Big Buck
Shoals; the improvement of the various shoals and rapids by means of
rock and gravel excavation, and the construction of wing dams for a
distance of 26 miles below Brevard.
  The act of August 2, 1882, appropriated $5,000 for improving the
river ' from Smith's Bridge up." A survey from Smith's Bridge (near
Asheville) to the foot of Long Shoal, a distance of 12.09 miles, was
made in 1882, and a project adopted for securing a channel 30 feet wide
and not less than 2- feet deep at low water for this distance. The esti-
mates amounted to $76,000. In the fiscal year ended June 30, 1884,
this part of the river was improved for a distance of 4 miles above the
bridge, under a special act of appropriation.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1888, is $43,000.
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-....... $79, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix K 16.)
  18. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering naviga-
tion.-The wreck of the schooner Spray, abandoned by her owners and
beached in 1885, was reported on April 14, 1887, as an obstruction to
navigation. The usual notice of thirty days to persons interested was
published, and proposals were opened June 6, 1887.
  The lowest bidder exceeded the amount ($1,100) allowed by the Secre-
tary of War. Authority was obtained June 13, 1887, and in July of the
same year, for the sum allotted, the wreck was removed by hired labor
with the steam-plant belonging to the Rappahannock River improve-
ment.
  Three wrecks, near Ayletts, in the Mattaponi River, Virginia, were
reported on February 23, 1888, as obstructions to navigation.
  The usual notice of thirty days to persons interested was published,
and proposals were opened April 28, 1888. Mr. William I. French, of
Norfolk, Va.; was the lowest bidder, and a contract was made with him
for $1,800, the work to be completed by August 9, 1888.
  The work of removal commenced June 12, .1888, and was completed
according to the specifications during the month.
  (See Appendix K 17.)
EX MINATION AND SURVEY FOR IMPROVEMENT, TO COMPLY WITI RE-
  QUIREMENTS OF THE RIVER AND HARIOR ACT OF AUGUST 5, 1886.
  It appearing, after preliminary examination by the local engineer,
that the locality was worthy of improvement, Mr. Abert was charged
with and completed the following survey, the results of which were
                                              r Doc. No. 162, Fiftieth
transmitted to Congress and printed as House Ex.
Congress, first session.
   1. Patuxent River, Maryland, from Benedict to Hill's Landing.-(See
also Appendix K 18.)
                            RIVER          AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                     117
IMPROVEMENT                 OF CERTAIN RIVERS AND HARBORS OF NORTH CARO-
                                LINA AND SOUTH CAROLINA.

  Officer in charge, Capt. W. HI. Bixly, Corps of Engineers, having un-
der his immediate orders First Lieut. H. Taylor, Corps of Engineers.
Supervising engineer, Col. W. P. Craighill, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Pamlico and Tar rivers, North Carolina.-The Pamlico and Tar
rivers are different portions of a single stream, the upper portion being
called the Tar.
   When placed under improvement in 1876, the Pamlico River had an
available depth of only 3 feet at low water in its upper portion, near
Washington. The Tar River had during eight months of the year an
available depth of from 2 to 3 feet for 49 miles up to Tarborough, its
practical limit of navigation. The channel of the combined stream was
almost completely obstructed by two war blockades, and by floating
and sunken stumps and logs, and by overhanging trees.
   The original project of 1876 (for the Pamlico) and of 1879 (for the Tar),
as since slightly modified and continued to date, proposed to secure
a clear channel 9 feet deep at low water up to Washington; thence a
channel 60 feet wide and 3 feet deep at low water, 23 miles further to
Greenville, and thence a channel 60 feet wide and 20 inches deep, 26
miles further to Tarborough. The final total cost of this work was es-
timated in 1887 to be $75,000. These estimates have since been in-
creased to $76,000. The total amount appropriated up to June 30, 1888,
is $58,000, the appropriation for the two rivers being consolidated in
1880.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $1,663.72, including out-
standing liabilities, was spent in removing dangerous obstructions from
the portion of the river from 5 miles above to 4 miles below Greenville,
where navigation was most obstructed, and in caring for property, etc.
All work in the field was stopped in September, 1887, because the avail-
able funds were no longer sufficient for advantageous use.
   Up to June 30, 1888, a total of $57,776.33 has been spent upon this
improvement in securing a good chunnel at least 9 feet deep at low
water and at least 108 feet wide from Pamlico Sound, 37 miles, up to
Washington; thence a fair channel 60 feet wide and 3 feet deep all the
year, 23 miles, to Greenville, and thence a similar channel for eight
months of the year, 26 miles, to Tarborough.
   After the improvement is finished, its proper maintenance may cost
from $1,000 to $3,000 per year.
July 1, 1887, amount available-                  .
                                        .-.. ......            ............ ............                            $1, 887. 39
July 1, 1r88, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ..--            -........-....-...... $1, 653. 39
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..........................                         10. 33
                                                                                                                     1,663. 72
July 1, 1888, balance available ....------------......----------......----......--- ----....----....--...........      223.67
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888-..........................            --                              10, 000.00
,Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                          10, 223.67
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project - ----                                             8,000.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                        8, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
       harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix L 1.)
  2. Contentnia Creek, North Carolina.-When placed under improve-
ment in 1881 this stream had a depth of about 3 feet, during nine
 118      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

months of the year, from its mouth in the euse upward about 63 miles
to Stantonsburgh, its practical limit of navigation; but its channel
was completely blocked at all stages of water by sunken logs and
stumps, and by floating obstructions.
    The original project of 1881, as continued to date, proposed to secure
a safe and unobstructed 3 foot navigation over this distance during the
high-water season of about nine months. The final total cost of this
work was estimated in 1885 at $75,000.        These estimates have since
been increased to $77,500. The total amount appropriated up to June,
30, 1888, is $40,000.
    During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $5,529.59, including out-
standing liabilities, was spent in removing dangerous obstructions over
the entire length of the improvement (mainly in the upper portion of
the river), and in care of property, etc. All work in the field was stoI)ped
in March, 1888, because the available funds were no longer sufficient for
advantageous use.
    Up to June 30, 1888, a total of $39,548.68 has been spent in securing
a moderately well-cleared 3-foot navigation over the 31 miles from its
mouth up to Snow Hill, and a roughly-cleared 3-foot navigation over
32 miles further to Stantonsburgh, during the high-water season. In
consequence of this two steamers make bi-weekly trips to Snow Hill
during nine months of the year, and flats ply between Snow Hill and
Stantonsburgh. The present commerce is about -$800,000, and israp-
idly increasing.
    After the improvement is finished its proper maintenance may cost
from $1,000 to $3,000 per year.
July 1, 1887, amount available .......   ....... ........ ....... .. ...
                                         ......                                       $5,980. 91
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ........          ............   $5, 518. 32
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities...... ......    ..........-....        11. 27
                                                                                 --    5, 529.59

July 1, 1888, balance available .................... . ......-....-
                                                                 -- ......               451.32
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.......... ...............                5,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................              5, 451.32
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project -...                 32, 500. 00
  Amountthat canbeprofitablyexpended          i1 fiscal yearendingJune 30,1890        10, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections ' of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L 2.)
    3. Trent River, North Carolina.-When placed under improvement in
1879 this river had a 6-foot to 8 foot roughly-cleared navigation from
its mouth, at New Berne, up 21 miles to Pollocksville, and a light-
                                        Quakr Bridge. Above Polocks-
draught navigation 9 miles further to Quaker
ville the bars, snags, and trees prevented all navigation, except occa-
sionally by small flat-boats during high freshets.
    The original projects of 1879 to 1880, as continued to date, assumed
that 6 to 8 feet of water could be carried at all stages from its mouth
21 miles to Pollocksville, and proposed to secure a thoroughly cleared
3-foot navigation, with at least 50 feet channel width at all stages of
water, from Pollocksville 22 miles up to Trenton, the practical limit of
steam-boat navigation, using the balance of the funds to improve the
channel from its mouth, 30 miles upwards to Pollocksville and Quaker
  Bridge. The final total cost of this work was estimated in 1885 at
  $56,500. These estimates have been increased to $59,000. The total
- amount appropriated up to June 30 is $45,500.
                   RIVER     AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                          119
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $673.25, including out-
standing liabilities, was spent in removing the few dangerous obstruc-
tions which had fallen into the river during the preceding year, and in
caring for property, etc. Work in the field was carried on only from
October 20 to December 9, 1887. The most important work to be done
was that of dredging and blasting at Foy's Flats. Attempts were made
all during the year to hire the dredging or a suitable dredge, but the
amount of funds available for this work was so small that nothing could
be obtained at any advantageous terms. Consequently further work
awaits future appropriations.
   Up to June 30, 1888, a total of $42,704.98 has been spent in all upon
this improvement, in securing a moderately well-cleared 6-foot to 8-foot
navigation at all stages (8 to 9 feet at ordinary stages) from New Berne
30 miles up to Quaker Bridge; and thence a thoroughly-cleared 3-foot
navigation at least 50 feet wide at all stages 13 miles further to Trenton,
and an excellent turning-basin at Trenton. In consequence of this im-
provement, a steam-boat navigation has been permanently established
over the entire river to Trenton.
   The proper maintenance of the improved channel may cost from $1,000
to $2,000 per year.
July 1, 1887, amount available .-.-.             .,---..--..--.                     -...                  $3, 468.27
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ........................                               $576.38
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities....................    .....                                96.87
                                                                                                             673. 25


July 1, 1888, balance available.       .   ..- .. ......          ....   ....   s.._....      ...-         2, 795. 02
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888............                                  .........      5,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...................                                   7, 795.02
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project --------                                  8,500. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                8, 500. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L 3.)
  4. Neuse River, North Carolina.-When placed under improvement
in 1878 this river had during nine months of the year a 9-foot depth of
channel from its mouth 40 miles up to New Berne, thence a 4-foot depth
50 miles further to Kinston, thence a 3-foot depth 46 miles further to
Goldsborough, and thence a 2-foot depth 62 miles further to Smithfield,
this channel depth being reduced during the low-water season to 8 feet
at New Berne, 2 feet at Kinston, and 1 foot at Smithfield. Over the
whole 198 miles the river was so blocked by war and other obstructions
that navigation was impracticable.
  The original projects of 1871 for below Goldsborough, and of 1879 for
above Goldsborough, contemplated the removal of the war blockades
and natural obstructions and the excavation of a few cut-offs, so as to
get 4.5 feet at low water all the year to Goldsborough, and 3 feet during
nine months to Smithfield. The projects of 1878, 1880, and 1883, as
continued to date, propose to remove all sunken logs, snags, floating,
and other obstructions, and to contract the channel-way by jetties, so
as to assure during the entire year an unobstructed 8-foot navigation
40 miles up to New Berne, and a similar 4-foot navigation 50 miles
further to Kinston, and during nine months of the year a 3-foot navi-
gation 108 miles further to Smithfield. The final total cost of this work
was estimated in 1885 at $370,000.
120        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   These estimates have been increased to $374,000.                                 The total amot
appropriated therefor up to June 30, 1888, is $232,500.
  During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $5,977.22, including out-
standing liabilities, was spent in contracting by jetties about one-half
mile of the river between Kinston and New Berne, in removing danger-
ous obstructions from 59 miles of river just above and below Kinston, in
rebuilding plant, and in caring for property, etc.
   Up to June 30, 1888, a total of $226,017.60 has been spent in all upon
this improvement, giving a moderately well-cleared channel over the
entire length of the river, allowing an 8-foot navigation 40 miles to
New Berne, and a 3-foot navigation 50 miles further to Kinston all the
year; also a fair 3-foot navigation 46 miles further to Goldsborough
(luring nine months per year, and still 62 miles further to Smithfield six
months per year.
  After the improvement is finished its proper maintenance may cost
from $2,000 to $6,000 per year.
July 1,1887, amount available...... ..........................                      .....-....        12, 459.62
July 1, 1888,    amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities   outstanding July 1, 1887 --......... .........         --...          5,73 2.32
July 1, 1888,   outstanding liabilities ........    ..................                   244. 90
July 1, 1888,   amount covered by existing contracts ...........                      1, 650. 00
                                                                                                 --    7, 627. 22

July 1, 1888, balance available...........................................                             4,832.40
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...... .....                      ..      .........      15, 000. 00


{Amount
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889-------..-------....--..-...--....
          (estimated) required for completion of existing project....-.... 126, 500. 00
  Amountthat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 30, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                                      19, 832. 40



    harbor acts of 1666 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L 4.)
   5. Inland water-way between New Berne and Beaufort,North Carolina.-
The inland line of navigation from New Berne to Beaufort Harbor, via
Clubfoot, fHarlowe, and Newport rivers, was established by the State
of North Carolina about 1826, and was used thereafter by small craft
until about 1856, when its locks broke down and the route was aban-
doned. This line, about 42 miles in total length, extends from New
Berne about 23 miles down the Neuse River, 6 miles up Clubfoot River,
3.21 miles through the Clubfoot and Harlowe Canal, 3.5 miles down
Harlowe River, and 6 miles through Newport River to Beaufort Harbor.
About 1880 the line was re opened by the New Berne and Beaufort
Canal Company.
   When placed under improvement in 1885, this route allowed the pas-
sage of small boats of 15 feet width and 3 feet draught, but the com-
merce was practically nothing.
   The original project of 1883 reported this route as worthy of improve-
ment, providing that Congress desired to extend the already existing
lines of navigation from the Chesapeake southward, and estimated the
cost of a channel 80 feet wide and 9 feet deep at $883,580, increased by
the cost of a tide-lock and the canal company's franchise.
   A .modified project of 1884 for the expenditure of the funds then
available, as continued to date, proposed to widen and deepen Harlowe
Creek so as to secure a through canal of 5 feet depth at mean low water,
and of 30 feet bottom width from the mouth of Harlowe Creek upwards
3.25 miles to its head, and to use the remaining funds upon similar works
upon Clubfoot River. The total final cost of this latter project (includ-
                        RIVER AND IHARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                              121
ing also the continuation of the same work through the canal) was esti-
mated in 886 at $92,000. The total amount appropriated therefor up
to June 30, 1888, is $20,000.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $3,313.20, including out-
standing liabilities, was spent in inspection and superintendence, in
care of property, etc., and in widening and deepening itarlowe Creek
to the proposed dimensions over a length of 873 feet, the dredging having
been done under contracts still in force.
   Up to June 30, 1888, a total of $6,812.45 has been spent in all upon
this improvement, on necessary surveys, in the removal of the worst
logs and stumps in the existing channel, and in dredging the creek to
30 feet width and 5 feet depth at low water over a length of 873 feet,
and to a width and depth through the entire creek sufficient to allow
the passage of small sail-boats. In consequence of this, several hun-
dred sail-boats have been passed through the canal, and the commerce
of this route, now about $190,000, is rapidly increasing. If the improve-
ment is completed it will be of much value as a connecting link between
Pamlico Sound and Beaufort Harbor, and would complete an otherwise
already existing inland navigation from the Chesapeake to Beaufort,
N. C.
  After the proposed channel is opened its proper maintenance may cost
from $1,000 to $3,000 per year.
July 1, 1887, amount available--............--...... ........................                 $16, 500. 75
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ......---............--......            $2, 743. 87
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities .-................            ......         569. 33
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts ...........                  12, 667.65
                                                                                               15,980. 85
                                ....................
July 1, 1888, balance available--                    ......................                        519.90
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .. ..................                       .    15, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...................                       15,519.90
(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......
                                                                   --                         57, 000. 00
 .Amountthbat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                   30, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L 5.)
   6. Harborat Beaufort, North Carolina.-This harbor, at the eastern
terminus of the Atlantic and North Carolina Railroad, is the only har-
bor of any importance between Chesapeake Bay and Wilmington, N.
C., a distance of over 300 miles.
   When placed under improvement in 1880 it possessed a bar entrance
of 15.3 feet least depth at mean low water, with an average rise and fall
of tide of 3 feet. At this time, however, the northern entrance was
rapidly deteriorating; its width, measured from Fort Macon Point to
Shackleford Point, having increased 500 feet between the years 1864
and 1880, and 900 feet more between the years 1880 and 1881, and its
bar having rapidly and proportionally shoaled. From the bar the har-
bor possessed a channel of 25 feet depth upwards for 3.7 miles to the
Atlantic and North Carolina Railroad Wharf at Morehead City, and a
branch channel of 9 feet depth for six-tenths of a mile up to Bulkhead
Channel, and of 2 feet minimum depth for six-tenths of a mile further
to the wharves of Beaufort City, where coasting vessels had a good
wharfage of 7 feet depth and 1,800 feet length.
   The projects of 1881, 1882, and 1884, as continued to date, proposed
to secure this harbor by stopping further erosion of the sand-banks at
 122         REPORT OF TIlE CIIIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                          S. ARMY.

Shackleford Point and Fort Macon Point, and thus stopping further
deterioration of the bar entrance, and proposed to open a 5-foot chan-
nel 100 feet wide to Beaufort City. The total final cost of this work was
estimated in 1887 at $163,000. The total amount appropriated therefor
up to June 30, 1888, is $90,000.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $5,783.29, including out-
standing liabilities, was spent in strengthening existing jetties at
Shackleford Point and Fort Macon Point, in building catch-sand fences
at Fort Macon Point, in minor surveys, and in care of property, etc.
All work in the field, except some slight necessary repairs to the main
jetty at Shackleford Point, was stopped in October, 1887, because the
available funds were no longer sufficient for advantageous use.
   Up to June 30, 1888, a total of $88,869.48 has been spent in all upon
this improvement, in successfully stopping the erosion of Shackleford
Point and Fort Macon Point, in probably arresting the shoaling upon
this bar, and in making a survey of the present condition of the harbor
entrance preparatory to the definite location of future works. No
special improvement of commerce nor depth of water was thereby ex-
pected or obtained, but the retrograde movement has been in general
arrested, the old shore-lines have commenced to reform as desired, and
the former good condition of the harbor is being rapidly re-established.
   The improvement, once thoroughly finished, should be comparatively
permanent.
July 1, 1887, amount available ....----------......
                                                  ------......------......-----....----....--......--..... $6, 913. 81
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887.......... ...............                            $5, 617. 67
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ................                 ..........                  165.62
                                                                                                          5,783.29

July 1, 1888, balance available .....................................                               .    1, 130. 52
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ..........                        ...............         35, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ........                        ....   .......    36, 130. 52
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project. -. --                                 38,000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                            38, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of seCtions 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L 6.)
   7. Inland water-way between Beaufort Harbor and New River, North
Carolina.--Whenplaced under improvement in 1886 there was a channel
18 inches deep at low water from Beaufort to the town of Swansborough,
on White Oak River; thence a 3-foot depth at mid-tide, 6 miles further
to Bear Inlet and Creek; thence a 6-inch depth at low water 11 miles
further to New River, whence boats of 5 feet draught could proceed 14
miles further to the town of Jacksonville. Its commerce was then about
$200,000 per year.
  The original project of 1885, as continued to date, recommended the
establishment of a channel of at least 3 feet depth at low water from
Beaufort to Swansborough. The total final cost of this work was esti-
mated in 1887 at $50,000. The total amount appropriated therefor up
to June 30, 1888, is $10,000.
  During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $6,265.94, including out-
standing liabilities, was spent in inspection and superintendence, in
care of property, etc., and in dredging the proposed channel-way to
partial width and depth under contracts still in force.
  Up to June 30, 1888, a total of $6,676.51 has been spent upon this
improvement in securing a channel-way of at least 40 feet width and of
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                           123
3 feet depth at low water, part way from Beaufort Harbor to Swans-
borough.
   The improvement, once thoroughly finished, should be comparatively
permanent.
July 1, 1887, amount available .........................................                                    $9, 589. 43
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ......--------......-----......------......            $3, 573. 19
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities -------.-------.....--------....
                                         ...                                                   2, 692.75
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts ...........                                 2,595.97
                                                                                                             8, 861.91
July 1, 1888, balance available ........................-              ......--.....                            727.52
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888-----..---..----....................-------.                    5, 000.00



{Amount                                              ..................------
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889---
          (estimated) required for completion of existing project........
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                                        .    5, 727.52
                                                                                                             35, 000.00
                                                                                                            35, 000.00

   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L 7.)
  8. New River, North Carolina.-When placed under improvement in
1882, this river had very poor facilities for transporting goods to market.
Its outlet to the ocean was blocked by an oyster-rock barricade, through
which there existed only a long and very crooked channel of 50 feet
width and 3 feet depth at low water.
  The original project, as continued to date, proposed to secure a 150-
foot channel, 5 feet deep at low water, from the upper river to the ocean,
by dredging. The total final cost of this work was estimated in 1885
at $40,000. The total amount appropriated up to June 30, 1888, is
$20,000.
  During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $8,191.37 was spent in
inspection and superintendence, in care of property, and in dredging
the proposed channel to partial width and depth. All work in the field
was stopped in February, 1888, because the available funds were no
longer sufficient for advantageous use.
   Up to June 30, 1888, a total of $18,183.41 has been spent in all upon
this improvement, in replacing the long and crooked channel by a
shorter and straighter channel of at least 40 feet bottom width and 3.5
feet depth at low water. The new channel is already in daily use by the
craft entering New River from the ocean, and is steadily deepening
under the scour of the river and tidal currents.
  This improvement, once thoroughly completed, should be permanent.
July 1, 1887, amount available...... ..................                  ..................                 $10,007.96
July 1, 1888. amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ..........-.................. .................                                    8, 191. 37
July 1, 1888, balance available ...........................             ...........                           1,816. 59
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                                       3, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889....................                                     4, 816. 59
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......    17,000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 17, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L 8.)
   9. Black River, North Carolina.--When placed under improvement in
1886, this river had a moderately well cleared channel from its mouth
(in the Cape Fear River, 14 miles above Wilmington) 22 miles upwards
124        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

to Point Caswell, with 2.5 feet depth at low-water and 4 feet depth at
high tide, thence a roughly cleared navigation 48 miles further to near
Lisbon, with 2.5 feet depth during nine months per year and with 6
feet depth during six months per year.
   The original project of 1885, as continued to date, proposed to secure a
fairly cleared natural channel over the entire river from its mouth up 70
miles to near Lisbon, then a 4-foot channel below Point Caswell, and
then an improved channel through the Narrows. The total final cost
of this work was estimated in 1885 at $33,500. The total amount ap-
propriated up to June 30, 1888, is $3,000.
                                               J
   During the fiscal year ending uife 30, 1888, $2,224.61, including out-
standing liabilities, was spent in removing the worst obstructions from
the channel and banks of 43 miles of river above Point Caswell, and
in care of property, etc. All work in the field was stopped in January,
1888, because the available funds were no longer sufficient for advan-
tageous use.
    Up to June 30, 1888, a total of $2,267.31 has been spent upon this
improvement in the removal of the worst obstructions over the entire
river.
   After this improvement is finished, its proper maintenance may cost
from $1,000 to $3,000 per year.
July 1, 1887, amount available---..----....-..--.....---....--....- ----------..-
                                                                         .......---..---....      $2, 97. 30
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887.......... ...............                    $2, 211.41
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities.................... ......                           13. 20
                                                                                                 2, 224.61

July 1, 1888, balance available .........              _............ ............   .... ....       732. 69

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..--------30, 500. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in tiscalyearending June, 30,1890                      10, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   See Appendix L 9.)
   10. Cape Fear River, North Carolina.-Above Wilmington.-When
placed under improvement in 1881 the Cape Fear River above Wilming-
ton was navigable during the nine months of the year from Wilmington
112 miles upwards to Fayetteville, but the channel for the upper 75
miles was badly obstructed by logs, snags, overhanging trees, and
shoals, and for the upper 66 miles it was full of shoals on which there
was not more than 12 to 14 inches of water during the low-water season.
At that time the navigation was owned by private parties.
   The original project of 1881-'82, as continued to date, proposed to
buy out the private owners of the river for $10,000, then to clear out its
natural obstructions and to further provide a continuous channel over
its upper 66 miles by dredging and by artificially contracting its water-
ways through at least thirty-two shoals. The total cost of this work
was estimated in 1885, by the officer in charge, at $480,000 for a 3-foot
actual channel depth up to Fayetteville during eleven or twelve months
of the year. The total amount appropriated up to June 30, 1888, is
$76.250.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $8,054.08, including out-
standing liabilities, was spent in removing all the dangerous obstruc-
tions within the limits of the improvement, in contracting the channel
by jetties along about a mile length of the river between Elizabethtown
and Fayetteville, and in repair and care of property, etc. All work in
the field was stopped during a large part of the year because the avail-
able funds were not sufficient for continuous advantageous work.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                          125
  Up to June 30, 1888, a total of $73,887.02 has been spent in all upon
this improvement, giving a moderately well cleared channel over the
whole length of the river, a moderately good 4-foot continuous channel
during the entire year from Wilmington, 44 miles, to Kelly's Cove;
thence a similar 2-foot channel 26 miles further to Elizabethtown, and
thence a similar 1-foot channel 42 miles further to Fayetteville, in-
creased to 5-foot draught from Wilmington to Fayetteville during seven
mouths of the year.
  After this improvement is completed its proper maintenance may
cost from $1,000 to $3,000 per year.
July 1, 1887, amount available .--..---......-----.........--------------.----...........--------.......... $10, 417. 06
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887.......--------------------................. - $6, 460. 32
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities..                  ..................--..                 1, 559. 36
                                                                                                               8,019. 68
July 1, 1888, balance available .........................................                                      2, 397. 38
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ..--                                 .....---.-                 12,000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...................                                     14, 397. 38
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                    188, 000. 00
   Amountthat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                  60,000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L 10.)
   At and below Wilmington.-When placed under improvement in 1829
the Cape Fear River below Wilmington had three bar entrances with
least depths as follows : About 9 feet at the Baldhead Channel, 9 feet
at the Rip Channel, and 10 feet at New Inlet Channel, these bars being,
respectively, 9, 6, and 2 miles below the point which was then the head
of the river's delta. From the head of this delta 20 miles up to Wil-
mington there were several shoals with a least depth of 7.5 feet at low
water.
   The original projects of 1827 tol 847 proposed to improve the upper 20
milesby dredging and byjetty contraction of the channel. Two hundred
and three thousand two hundred and four dollars and fifty-nine cents
were spent during this time in increasing the depth upon the shoals to
9.5 feet at low water, equal to that at the bar entrances. At or about
this time the shore at Fort Caswell, opposite Baldhead Point, was pro-
tected by stone jetties, under an appropriation for the preservation of
fortifications.
   The projects of 1852 to 1857 proposed to deepen the water at the main
entrance by jetties at Baldhead Point and by jetty and dike obstruc-
tions between Zeke's Island and Smith's Island, near New Inlet, and
suggested the possible future necessity of closing New Inlet. One hun-
dred and fifty-six thousand two hundred and ninety-six dollars and
twenty-six cents was spent during this time upon these works, never fully
completed for want of funds.
   The project of 1870 proposed a crib closure of the space (4,403 feet
long) between Smith's and Zeke's islands (finished in 1873) to prevent
further widening of New Inlet. The projects of 1870 to 1872 proposed
the complete closure of New Inlet (begun in 1875 and finished in 1881)
in order to deepen the water at the main (Baldhead) bar entrance.
The projects of 1872 to 1885, as continued to date, proposed the exten-
sion of the New Inlet Dam 2 miles further down the stream, to prevent
the further erosion of Smith's Island at the Swashes. The project of
1875, as continued to date, proposed the occasional use of dredging
126          REPORT_ OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

upon the outer bar to assist the tidal currents in gradually localizing,
straightening, deepening, and fixing the bar entrances to obtain first
a 12-foot depth at low water and then a 14-foot depth. The projects of
1874 to 1881 for the 20 miles above New Inlet, as continued to date,
proposed dredging and occasional diking wherever necessary across
shoals, so as to secure first a 12-foot channel 200 feet wide and after-
ward a 16-foot channel 270 feet wide at low water over this whole
length. The total final cost of this work under the projects of 1870 to
1885 was estimated in 1886 at $2,110,000. These estimates have now
been increased to $2,120,000. The total amount appropriated therefor
up to June 30, 1888, is $1,860,000.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $77,055.49, including
outstanding liabilites, was spent in opening a continuous channel of at
least 185 feet in width and 16 feet in depth at low water from Wilming-
ton to the ocean bar, in placing stone in position upon the dike extend-
ing southward from Zeke's Island, in dredging upon the newly-pro-
jected bar entrance at Baldhead Channel, in repair and care of plant,
in minor surveys of the river, and in office work. These surveys show
the recent work to have given very satisfactory results.
   Up to June 30, 1888, a total of $1,851,001.74 has been spent in all
upon the proposed improvements of 1870 to 1882 with great success,
obtaining a 14 to 14.5 feet least depth of water at the main bar en-
trance and completing a channel of 16 feet depth and at least 185 feet
width 28 miles further to Wilmington. This depth, combined with the
average rise of tide of 4.5 feet at the bar and 2.5 at Wilmington, is such
that at present vessels loaded to 16 feet draught (9.5 feet more than in
1871) can readily go from Wilmington to the ocean in a single tide and
any day of the year.
   After the improvement is finished its proper maintenance may cost
from $5,000 to $15,000 per year for a few years, but the improvement
should be fairly permament.
July 1, 1887, amount available.---------........................................                 $86, 053.75
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887----  .-.....--...----...----.....-----... $74, 149. 56
July 1, 1888, outstandingliabilities ..........................                       2, 940. 33
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts.. ........                         3, 045. 00
                                                                                                            80,134.89

July 1, 1888, balance available........................................--------------------------------------. 5, 918. 86
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.......................... 245, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.......                               ....           250,918.86
   (See Appendix L 10.)
   11. Waccemaw River, North Carolina and South Carolina.---hen
placed under improvement in 1880, this river was navigable for 12-foot-
draught boats at all stages of water from Georgetown, Winyaw Bay,
26 miles, to Bull Creek, and at high water 6 miles farther, to Buck's lower
mills; thence for 7-foot-draught boats at high water 31 miles further, to
Conwayborough; thence it possessed an obstructed channel for 3-foot-
draught boats at ordinary low water 109 miles, to Reeve's Ferry, the
present head of steam navigation; thence an obstructed channel with
3-foot-depth at high water for 42 miles, to Lake Waccemaw.
   The original project of 1880, as continued to date, proposed to secure
a channel 12 feet deep at all stages of water, with 80 feet bottom width,
from the mouth of the river upward to Conwayborough, and afterwards
a cleared channel to Lake Waccemaw. The total final cost of this work
                                RIVER           AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                        127
was estimated, in 1885, at $138,400; the total amount appropriated there-
for up to June 30, 1888, $50,400.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $4,501.46, including out-
Atanding liabilities, were spent in removing obstructions from 45 miles
of river just below Conway, in slight additions to the existing jetties, in
minor surveys of the river over its entire length, in caring for property,
etc. All work in the field was stopped in September, 1887, because the
available funds were no longer sufficient for advantageous use.
   Up'to June 30, 1888, a total of $49,613.54 has been spent in all upon
this improvement, giving a thoroughly cleared channel with 100 feet
least width, and 8.8 feet least depth at high water as far as Conway, and
with 45 feet width and 3 feet depth for 45 miles above Conway.
   After this improvement is finished its proper maintenance may cost
from $1,000 to $4,000 per year.
July 1, 1887, amount available ....--....................--------------------.....------...    ...-----. $5, 287. 92
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ......-........                 -         ....    $4, 418. 00
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ...............                    ..........           83. 46
                                                                                                           4,501. 46

July 1, 1888, balance available..............----....................-------.--.......                        786.46
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 - ..-                                      -. .   .....
                                                                                                  ......   15, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .--.....---............                              15, 786.46
   Amount (estimated) requhed for completion of existing project-------- 73, 000.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 18, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L 11.)
   12. Yadkin River, North Carolina.-Thisriver (which is the upper end
of the Great Pee Dee River) has a total length of about 200 miles and
a drainage area of 4,320 square miles. Its middle third, extending from
the railroad bridge near Salisbury, 64 miles upward, to the foot of Bean
Shoal, is the only portion so far under improvement by the General
Government.
   When placed under improvement in 1880, this portion of the Yadkin
River had its navigation completely obstructed by rock ledges, fish and
mill dams, and numerous shoals, with a greatest depth of 1 foot at ordi-
nary low water on some of its shoals and ledges.
   The original project of 1879 proposes to secure a 2.5 to 3-foot steam-
boat navigation during the entire year over the 64. miles above the Sal-
isbury Railroad Bridge. The total final cost of the work necessary to
give the desired depth over the entire 641 miles, and during only mean
winter stages of water (two-thirds of the year), was estimated in 1887
at $400,000. The total amount appropriated therefor up to June 30,
1888, is $87,000.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $7,692.02, including out-
standing liabilities, was spent in removing rock and sand from the chan-
nel, in building jetties, in carefully surveying ledges and dams, in caring
for the property, and in office work. All work in the field was suspended
from November, 1887, to May, 1888, on account of cold and high water.
   Up to June 30, 1888, a total of $84,957.92 has been spent in all upon
this improvement in securing a good channel for flat-boats (and only an
indifferent channel for steam-boats) of 40 to 70 feet channel width and
from 2 to 21 feet channel depth during. mean winter stages of water
(eight months of the year) from the Salisbury Railroad Bridge, 28 miles
upwards, to above Hartley's Mill.
128         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The improvement; once thoroughly completed, should be compara-
tively permanent.
July 1, 1887, amount available .........................................                           $9, 734. 10
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887- ........................                   $6,924.96
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities..-              -...................              767. 07
                                                                                                    7, 692. 02

July 1, 1888, balance available ........---------.. ...... ...........-                .       .    2, 042. 08
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ....................-----------------------.....     10, 000. 00
                                                               ---
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 -..................                          12, 042.08
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing'project- ....       303,000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 20, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and"
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L 12.)
   13. Little PeeDee River, South Carolina.-This is a new work. A pre-
liminary examination and survey were made in compliance with the pro-
visions of the river and harbor, act approved August 5, 1886, and a re-
port of the results thereof was printed as Appendix M 24 of the Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1887.
   The proposed improve ment contemplates the removal of logs, trees,
and snags from the bed of the river at an estimated cost of $50,000.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $5,000 for
this work, and a further sum of $10,000 may be profitably expended in
continuing it during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act August 11, 1828 ......-............                      ......         $5, 000. 00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- ------                           45,000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                       10, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   14. Lumber River, North Carolina.-This is a new work. In obedience
to the requirements of the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, an
examination and survey were made of the Lumber River and a report
thereon is printed as Appendix M 21 of the Report of the Chief of En-
gineers for 1887.
  The improvement proposed is the removal of snags, logs, and over-
hanging trees on 98 miles of the river below Lumberton, at an estimated
cost of $35,000.
  The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $5,000 for
this work, and a further sum of $10,000 may be profitably expended in
continuing it during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.- ---..- ---. --------. 5, 000. 00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- .- ----                          30, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                       10, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  15. Clark Creek or River, South Carolina.--Thisis a new work. In ac-
cordance with the provisions of the river and harbor act of August 5,
1886, a preliminary examination and survey were made of Clark Creek,
and the reports thereon are printed as Appendix M 23 of the Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1887.
  The navigation of Clark Creek is impracticable by reason of over-
hanging trees, logs, and snags, which obstruct it.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                      129
  The estimated cost of removing these obstructions is $7,500.
  The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, makes an appropriation
of $2,500 for the work, and a further sum of $5,000 may be profitably
expended in continuing it during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.. .....                           . ..............        $2, 500, 000

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ...-----                                 5, 000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                               5, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   16. Great Pee Dee River, South Carolina.-When placed under im-
provement in 1880 this river was dangerously obstructed with snags
and logs. Otherwise it was easily reached at a point 7 miles above its
mouth by 9-foot draught boats coming from the ocean through the Wac-
cemaw River and Bull Creek; thence it was navigable for the same
boats 24 miles further to Smith's Mills, and thence for 3.5-foot draught
boats at low water 54 miles further from Smith's Mills to Little Bluff,
or at high water 110 miles further, from Smith's Mills to Cheraw, the
present head of steam navigation, 171 miles above Georgetown.
   The original project of 1880, as continued to date, proposed to secure
a thoroughly cleared 9-foot navigation to Smith's Mills and a 3.5-foot
navigation to Cheraw at all stages of water. The total final cost of this
work was estimated in 1885 at $117,000. The total amount appropri-
ated therefor up to June 30, 1888, is $47,000.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 188, $8,673.58, including out-
standing liabilities, was spent in removing the worst obstructions over
the entire length of the river, in minor surveys along the river, in caring
for the property, etc. All work in the field was stopped in May, 1888,
because the available funds were no longer sufficient for advantageous
use.
   Up to June 30, 1888, a total of $46,031.69 has been spent in all upon
this improvement, giving at all ordinary stages of water a well cleared
9-foot navigation 61 miles upward to Smith's Mills, and a fairly cleared
3.5-foot navigation at low water 50 miles further to the railroad station
at Pee Dee, or at high water, 110 miles further, from Smith's Mills to
Cheraw.
   After the improvement is finished its proper maintenance may cost
from $2,000 to $5,000 per year.
July 1, 1887, amount available -.....-------......--                      .--..-
                                                   -....----.....-----..- ---                    ----
                                                                                       ...------.....     9, 641.89
July 1, 1888, amount expended during tiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 .................--             -        .... $8, 562. 49
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ...........            ......---........             111. 09
                                                                                                 --       8, 673. 58

July 1, 1888, balance available .... ....................................                                   968. 31
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .... ......                         ............          20, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889-...................                                20, 968. 31

iAmount   (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......                               50,000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                             25,000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with iequirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix L 13.)
  17. Harborat Georgetown, South Carolina.-When placed under im-
provement in 1880, this harbor had an excellent and well-protected an-
chorage of at least 1 mile in length, 150 feet width, and 15 feet depth.
           EiCGQ---
130        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

A bar of about 2,850 feet in length and with only 9 feet depth of water
was the only obstacle to an otherwise good 13-foot navigation from
Georgetown, 13 miles to the ocean.
  The original project of 1881, as continued to date, proposed to secure
a dredged channel of 200 feet bottom width and 12 feet low-water depth
entirely through this bar. The total final cost of this work was esti-
mated in 1885 at $39,000. These.estimates are now raised to $42,000.
The total amount appropriated therefor up to June 30, 1888, is $17,000.
  During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $211.60, including out-
standing liabilities, was spent in caring for property, in office work, etc.
All work in the field was suspended during the entire year because the
available funds were not sufficient for advantageous use.
  Up to June 30, 1888, a total of $16,834.10 has been spent in all upon
this improvement, giving a through cut entirely across the bar, with 12
feet low-water depth, and with a variable width of from 80 to 100 feet.
  The channel, once thoroughly opened, will probably be permanent.
July 1, 1887, amount available..-------..---........-------- ------......--..--......
                                                                     ............--....                      $377. 50
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887......................                     $201. 60
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities...... ......               ..........                      10. 00
                                                                                                                211. 60
July 1, 1888, balance available ......-        -    ..........           ......    ...........                  165. 90
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ......                     ..       ........        ....      7, 500. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889. ................                                     7, 665.90

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 17, 500.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year endingJune30,1890 17,500.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L 14.)
   18. Mingo Creekor River, South Carolina.--Thisis a new work. In obe-
dience to the requirements of the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886,
a preliminary examination and survey were made of the above creek,
and the report thereon is printed as Appendix M 22 of the Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1887.
   It is estimated that $17,000 will be required to remove the obstruc-
tions from this stream.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $5,000 for
this work, and a further sum of $12,000 may be profitably expended in
continuing it during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888                                     .....
                                                                                     .                    $......-.
                                                                                                          $5, 000. 00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....... 12, 000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30, 1890 12, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   19. Winyaw Bay, South Carolina.-When placed under improvement
in 1886 this bay had only 9 feet least depth upon its bar entrance, with
a 12-foot channe 1 the rest of the way to Georgetown.
   The original project of 1885 proposed to secure a permanent bar en-
trance from 15 to 20 feet depth at low water. The total final cost of
this work was estimated in 1885 at $800,000 for a bar depth at 12 feet
(and $2,500,000 for a bar depth of from 15 to 20 feet) at low water. The
total amount appropriated therefor up to June 30, 1888, is $18,750.
  During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $1,126.30, including out-
                        RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                      131
standing liabilities, was spent in surveys and necessary preparations
for the principal work of diking, and in the care of property, etc, All
work was suspended during the entire year because the available funds
were not sufficient for advantageous use.
  Up to June 30, 1888, a total of $3,751.72 has been spent upon this
improvement in making necessary preparations for beginning work as
soon as the available funds shall be sufficient for advantageous use.
  The channel, once thoroughly opened, will probably retain its depth
permanently.
                                      .........--------...
July 1,1887, amount available.----..---                          ---.         --     *$16, 124.58
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
 --iabilities outstanding July 1, 1887. ..----.
                                              ..----. .......          ---
                                                                        .... $990.63
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities...... ...... .............              135.67
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts..               .-.        800.00
                                                                                                        1, 926. 30

July 1, 1888, balance available.....................................14,                                   198.28
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..- ..                                ..........        100, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889..................                              114.198.28
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project, to be
     revised by special board...             ....---........   ......   ........   ....-----....   2, 381,250. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
             .....----...........--
    30, 1890---------               ----................------........................               300, 000.00
I Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
l harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L 15.)
   20. Santee River, South Carolina.-When placed under improvement
in 1880 this river had its navigation considerably obstructed and blocked
at all stages of water by sunken logs, snags, and floating timber. Its
bar entrance was narrow, crooked, and shifting, with only about 4 feet
depth of water at low tide, and so situated as to be very difficult and
expensive to improve.
   The original project of 1880 proposed to provide the river with a good
outlet through Mosquito Creek to Winyaw Bay by deepening and
straightening this creek to 50 feet width and 7 feet depth; and to se-
cure a safe and unobstructed 7-foot navigation in the river itself from
its mouth 154 miles upward to Wright's Bluff, and thence a similar 5-
foot navigation 30 miles further to its head in the Congaree and Wateree
rivers.
   The total final cost of this work was estimated, in 1886, at $346,500, of
which $271,300 for Mosquito Creek and $75,200 for the Santee River
proper.
   A modified project of 1881, for the expenditure of the funds then
available, as continued to date, proposed to secure to the river a straight-
ened canalized outlet to Winyaw Bay through Mosquito Creek, 7 miles
long, 30 feet wide, and 6 feet deep at mean low water, and to construct
one draw-bridge over this creek. The total final cost of this work was
estimated in 1886 at $144,000, with $5,000 additional for a tide-lock, as
required by Congress; in all, $149,000. The total amount appropriated
therefor up to June 30, 1888, is $75,750.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $522.24, including out-
standing liabilities, was spent in draining and diking the ground on
the ocean side of the canal, in building a catch-sand fence, in minor
surveys along the river, in the care of property, and in office work, etc.
               * Erroneously stated on last annual statement as $16,174,58,
132        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

All dredging and other work, though much needed, was suspended dur-
ing the entire year because the available funds were not sufficient for
advantageous use.
  Up to June 30, 1888, a total of $70,521.24 has been spent in all upon
this improvement, in opening a passage at least 30 feet wide and 5
feet deep at high water from Mosquito Creek to Winyaw Bay, in mak-
ing necessary surveys of the whole improvement, and in building a
draw-bridge over the creek (in accordance with the provisions of the
cession of right of way for the canal). The effects of this work upon
the rice interests of the neighborhood have been and will be beneficial
rather than detrimental.
  After this improvement is finished its proper maintenance may cost
from $3,000 to $5,000 per year.
July 1, J887, amount available ..--  -       -...-----------------------.. $5, 751.00
July 7, 1887, amount received from sale to another work ................     -- 11.24
                                                                                                                 5,762.24
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ............           ......         .....                  516. 24
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..........-........                    ....- .                    6. 00
                                                                                                            -       522.24

July 1, 1888, balance available -- -       --   - ______-o-
                                                        --             _ .           ................            5,240.00
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888-......           --....-          ..............                  24, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                       29, 210. 00

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                     47, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L 16.)
   21. Wateree River, South Carolina.-When placed under improve-
ment in 1882 this river had a low-water depth of from 3 to 4 feet from
its mouth in the Santee upward 68 miles to Camden, its practicable
limit of steam navigation. From its mouth upward 14 miles the river
was complely blocked at all stages of water by sunken logs and stumps
and by floating obstructions, and at moderate stages by the bridges of
the South Carolina and Wilmington, Columbia and Augusta railroads
(without draws); thence 54 miles to Camden navigation was possible,
but dangerous, except during high water.
   The original project of 1881-'82, as continaed to date, proposed to
secure a safe and unobstructed 4-foot navigation over this entire dis-
tance at all stages of water. The total final cost of this work was esti-
mated in 1885 at $58,000. These estimates are now raised to $60,000.
The total amouht appropriated therefor up to June 30. 1888, is $35,500.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $1,878.88, including out-
standing liabilities, was spent in minor surveys along the river, in the
care of property, etc. The main work of snagging was suspended dur-
ing the entire year, partly to await the insertion of draws in the railroad
bridges over the river, and partly because the available funds were not
sufficient for advantageous use.
   Up to June 30, 1888, a total of $34,660.98 has been spent in all upon
this improvement, giving a thoroughly cleared 4-foot navigation at all
stages of water from the mouth of the river 11 miles upward, and thence
a fairly well-cleared 4-foot navigation over the rest of the river, 57 miles,
to Camden.
   After the improvement is finished its proper maintenance may cost
from $1,000 to $3,000 per year.-
                        RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                          133
July 1, 1887, amount available-- ..................----........--..                        ---- $2,717. 90
                                                                             ........------..---
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887----..---------------...............--. $1, 753. 66
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..........................                       125. 22
                                                                                                         --                 1,878.88
July 1, 1888, balance available.             ....                     ..                                             --
                                                                                                                 -.--...       839. 02
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 . ...... .... .... ..........                                                12, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ----....--...........---.                                            12, 839.02


   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                               12,500.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    See Appendix L 17.)
   22. Congaree River, South Carolina.-When placed under improvement
in 1886 this river had a low-water depth of from 3 to 4 feet from its
mouth 48 miles upward to the railroad bridge at Columbia, and thence
a I-foot low-water depth 2 miles further to its head, the navigation of
the lower 47 miles from the mouth upward to Granby being blocked at
all stages of water by the South Carolina Railroad Bridge (without a
draw), and secondly by sunken logs, snags, overhanging trees, and the
navigation of the upper 3 miles above Granby being prevented by its
swift current and numerous rock ledges and bowlders.
   The original project of 1885 proposed for at least $30,000 to secure
thoroughly cleared 4-foot navigation below Granby at all stages of
water, and estimated at $24,500 (not recommended for improvement at
that time) the cost of a cleared 100-foot channel through the shoals
above Granby up to the city of Columbia. The entire work was recom-
mended in 1887, and the total final cost of the work was estimated, as
before, at $54,500. The total amount appropriated for this work up to
June 30, 1888, is $7,500.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30. 1888, $2,038.05, including out-
standing liabilities, was spent in all upon this improvement in removing
dangerous obstructions from the entire river below Granby, in making
minor surveys of the river, and in the care of property, etc. All work
of snagging was stopped in October, 1887, because the available funds
were no longer sufficient for advantageous use.
   Up to June 30, 1888, a, total of $6,928.86 has been, spent upon this
improvement, giving a fairly well-cleared navigation of 70 feet width
and 4 feet depth at low water over the entire river below Granby.
   After this improvement is finished its proper maintenance may cost
from $1,000 to $2,000 per year.
July 1, 1887, amount available ....................                        ...   ..................                        $2, 609. 19
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887.----...........-- ....-----....-.... 2, 004.38
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities --...--..--......... .......------..                                     33. 67
                                                                                                                            2, 038. 05

July 1, 1888, balance available ...                 ...................              ................                         571. 14
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ..........                                ... ...               ..... -       7,500. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 -...................                                                  8, 071. 14

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project -- ---
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890
                                                                                                        ...-.              39,500.00
                                                                                                                           10, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L 18.)
134     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,             IT. S.   ARMY.

EXAMINATIONS    TO COMPLY WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE RIVER
                AND HARBOR ACT OF AUGUST 5, 1886.

  The following localities were, after examination, reported by the local
engineer as not at this time worthy of improvement:
  1. Yadkin River from South Carolina line to the Narrows, North Caro-
lina.-Reportprinted in House Ex. Doc. No. 58, Fiftieth Congress, first
session. (See, also, Appendix L 19.)
  2. Catawba River, North Carolina.--Reportprinted in House Ex. Doc.
No. 5, Fiftieth Congress, first session. (See, also, Appendix L 20.)


IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS              ON THE COAST OF SOUTH
                        CAROLINA.

   Officers in charge, Col. Q. A. Gillmore, Corps of Engineers, to April
6, 1888; Col. Henry L. Abbot, Corps of Engineers, from April 6 to
April 20, 1888; since which date Lieut. F. V. Abbot, Corps of Engi-
neers, with Col. William P. Craighill, Corps of Engineers, Supervising
Engineer.
   1. Charleston Harbor, South Carolina.-The work of improvement in
progress since 1878 comprises two jetties, composed of riprap stone
resting upon a foundation mattress of logs and brush, with a mattress
hearting wherever deemed advantageous.
   The two jetties spring, respectively, from Sullivan's and Morris islands,
and converge on curves in such manner as to cros the bar on parallel
lines at a distance of about 2,900 feet from each other. The object of
the work is to establish and maintain an improved channel across the
bar of not less than 21 feet navigable depth at mean low water, where
heretofore the available low-water depth has usually not exceeded 11)
feet.
   The estimated cost of the project is $3,000,000. A revision of this
project and estimate has been ordered before further work is done.
   The following work is reported to have been done during the past fiscal
year :
   North Jetty.-This jetty has been re-inforced during the year by the
deposit of 7,613 cubic yards of riprap distributed over the middle 36
feet, between points 8,400 feet and 12,184 feet from the shore end.
   South Jetty.-Where the jetty crosses the deep pocket, east of the
main ship-channel, it was raised for a length of 434 feet by depositing
along the middle 30 feet about 2,282 cubic yards of riprap stone. For
a length of 1,293 feet, beginning at a point about 14,207 feet from the
shore end, about 3,232 cubic yards of stone were distributed over the
middle 36 feet of the jetty, for the purpose of strengthening and pre-
serving the work already done, which is here almost up to low water and
much exposed to breakers.
   The expenditures from the beginning of operations under the exist-
ing project to June 30, 1887, were $1,399,346.49.     During the last fiscal
year the sum of $64,686.50, including outstanding liabilities, was ex-
pended.
   No extension of the jetties seaward was made during the year.
Measured along their axes, the outer end of the bottom course of the
north jetty is located 14,327 feet from its shore end on Sullivan's
Island; that of the south jetty, 16,440 feet from the present shore end
on Morris Island.
  No material changes in the condition of the jetties are reported.
The damaged shore end of the south jetty, between the high and low
                     RIVER       AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                       135
water lines of the beach of Morris Island, has been repaired. The head
of Morris Island has cut away rapidly. This action has continued
along the whole length surveyed, but is not over 70 feet at the jetty,
and 30 feet a quarter of a mile south of it. On Sullivan's Island no
marked changes have occurred.
  The engineer officer in charge reports indications of considerable
activity of ebb scour between the outer parts of the jetties.
  The two spur-jetties built in 1884 for the protection of a portion of
the shore of Mount Pleasant are stated to be in good condition.
  It is intended to retain the balance on hand on July 1, 1888, iu case
repairs are needed.
   The appropriations for this improvement aggregate at present $1,-
482,500. The total expenditures have been $1,464,032.99, including
outstanding liabilities.
July 1, 1887, amount available-........................................                   $83,153.51
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ......................           $64, 376. 25
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ........................               310.25
                                                                                           64, 686. 50
July 1, 1888, balance available.            .............         ............             18,467.01
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888. ..           ...........          ......   350, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889..................                   368, 467.01

 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project (to be
    revised) ..........-....-....-.....................................  1,175, 000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,     750,000.00
    1890.
i Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix M 1.)
   2. Wappoo Cut, South Carolina.-Wappoo Cut is a narrow, crooked
tidal stream, separating James Island from the mainland and connect-
ing Stono and Ashley rivers.
   The project of improvement contemplates the establishment of a
straighter channel, 6 feet deep and 90 feet wide at low water, at an es-
timated cost of $34,000. In its unimproved condition only 2 to 4 feet
could be carried over the principal shoals at mean low water.
   The plan of improvement comprised dredging at the entrances from
Ashley and Stono rivers and through a portion of the cut; a cut-off
through the marsh about 2 miles from Ashley River, closing three small
tidal branches; and the construction of a short jetty at both the Stono
and Ashley rivers.
    Four appropriations aggregating $28,000 have thus far been made for
this improvement, of which the last, amounting to $5,000, was made by
act approved August 5, 1886.
    The first three appropriations were expended in improving Elliott's
Cut and bar at its Stono mouth, in making a solid cut through the
marsh of the neck of the bend known as Devil's Elbow, and in deepen
ing the tortuous channel between these places.     Some dredging was
done on the bar at the entrance from Ashley River. A dam was built
across the tidal branch named Pomnpey's Cut, and a number of snags
and overhanging trees were removed. The total expenditures to June
30, 1887, were $22,999.63.
    The work which has been done, mostly in the shallow westerly por-
tion of Wappoo Cut, has resulted in a considerable increase of its navi-
gable depth. The full width contemplated has not yet been obtained.
136          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEES, tt. 8. ARMY.

   The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, is $27,796.42.
July 1, 1887, amount available......----....................................                                        $5,000.37
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ........................ ............   .........                                         4,796.79
July 1, 1888, balance available .........................................                                              203.58
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ...... .... .... ...-----------...                                     5,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                            5,203.58
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of revised project ---------. 60, 000.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 35, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix M 2.)
   3. Ashley River, South Carolina.-Ashley River is about 40 miles in
length and runs in a generally southeasterly direction. At its mouth
the city of Charleston occupies the left bank.
   The plan of improvement comprised (1) the removal of a shoal at a
place named Accabee, about 8 miles above the city of Charleston, where,
according to a survey made in 1873, there was then only 9 feet of water
at low tide; and (2) the removal of a shoal just below the Wando Phos-
phate Works, where only 6 feet of water was found at low tide. It was
proposed to increase the draught of water over these shoals by dredg-
ing to a depth of from 10 to 11 feet at mean low tide, at an estimated
cost of $5,000.
   Of four appropriations made for this work, the first three, aggrega-
ting $4,500, were expended in improving the river at the places indica-
ted, obtaining low-water depths of from 10 to 11 feet on widths of from
100 to over 200 feet. This satisfactory condition of the river has con-
tinued during the past fiscal year, for which reason the last appropria-
tion of $1,000, made by act approved August 5, 1886, was held in reserve
until it should appear expedient or necessary to expend it.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, was $4,494.91.
July 1, 1887, amount available ................                         ..........................                  $1,031,54
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 -------------------------                                          $26. 17
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities .................... .......                                           .28
                                                                                                                        26. 45

July 1, 1888, balance available ................................                                     ...........      1,005.09
    (See Appendix M 3.)
   4. Edisto River, South Carolina.-The Edisto is one of the principal
riversof South Carolina. It is formed by the junction of the North and
South Forks, which unite in the southern part of Orangeburgh County.
The South Fork, commonly known as the South Edisto, is the main river.
    The obstructions to navigation consist of numerous bends, logs, snags,
overhanging trees, and piles; also of shoals, generally of sand, but in
some places of hard clay.
    The plan of improvement contemplates the establishment of a chan-
nel available at all seasons of the year for the navigation of light-
draught steam-boats from the sea to the junction of the North and South
Forks, a distance of 183 miles, and from that point to Guignard's Land-
ing, 77 miles higher up, for rafts and fiat-boats. The plan embraces
enlarging all the new channels now in progress of formation, cutting
off bends, shutting off lateral arms of the river, removing shoals, snags,
logs, piles, and other obstructions, and building a deflecting jetty. The
cost of the project was estimated at $33,385.
                    RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                      137
  Three appropriations made by Congress in the years 1882, 1884, and
1886, respectively, and aggregating $16,000, were expended previous to
July 1, 1887.
  The work heretofore done comprised the removal of a large number
of snags, logs, overhanging trees, and piles in the reaches within 130
miles of the mouth of the river; the improvement of a natural cut-off
known as the ' Suck" 50 miles above Jacksonborough, to make it the
regular channel ; the closing of incipient cut-offs and outlets, and trim-
ming the banks. These operations cost the sum of $15,830.85. They
materially benefited navigation by shortening the time and reducing
the expense of trips.
  The total expenditures up to June 30, 1888, were $15,854.85.
July 1, 1887, amount available ....-- ..........................----......           $169. 15
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                                           ----           ...... ..---------..-.
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ......-----..................---                            24.00

July 1, 1888, balance available ...     .......
                                             .....                    - ..
                                                      ...... ...... ....-
                                                 ......                               145. 15
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.........................
                                               -5,                                    000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...................           5,145. 15

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ..-.              12,385. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended infiscal year ending June 30, 1890        12, 400. 00
  Submitted in compliance wilh requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix : 4.)
   5: Salkiehatchie River, South Carolina.-The Salkiehatchie rises in
Aiken County, South Carolina, and flows into the Atlantic Ocean. The
lower part of the river is known as the Combahee. Above a point named
Hickory Hill, about 44 miles from the coast, the river was obstructed
at numerous places by piles, logs, trees, and sand-bars.
   The project of improvement contemplates the removal of these ob-
structions for the purpose of establishing a continuous channel suitable
for flat-boats and rafts from a point 5 miles above Toby's Bluff down to
Hickory Hill, a distance of about 77 miles by river. The cost of the
project was estimated at $18,000.
   Prior to July 1, 1887, three appropriations, made in the years 1882,
1884, and 1886, respectively, and aggregating $10,000, were expended
in this improvement.
  The work done by means of the first appropriations consisted in thor-
oughly clearing the lowest 12-mile reach of the Salkiehatchie between
Hickory Hill and the Charleston and Savannah Railroad Bridge and
improving the reaches, aggregating 80 miles in length, from that bridge
to Broxton's Fork by removing from the channel over 11,800 snags,
stumps, logs, trees, etc., closing over 129 outlets, cutting off numerous
projecting points, and other miscellaneous work. One dam was built.
  The sum of $9,638.66 was expended in these operations. Lack of
funds has prevented any work in the past year.
  A substantial improvement of the river is reported.
  The total expenditure to June 30, 1888, was $9,662.66, including out-
standing liabilities.
                                                                        $361.34
July 1, 1887, amount available......--..--........---..........-----------..----........
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.....-   - - - -.....            ....
                                                  ............     ......   ....       24.00

                                     -.....- ...........
July 1, 1888, balance available---..---                       ..              ....
                                                                    ---.........     337. 34
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .................     .........      3,000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...................           3,337. 34
138      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--    ......
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890
                                                                               5, 000.00
                                                                               5, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix M 5.)
  6. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navi-
gation.-During the past fiscal year the wreck of a trading boat was
removed from the Chehaw River, South Carolina, and the wreck of the
steamer Alice Clark was taken from the inside passage between Charles.
ton, S. C., and Savannah, Ga., and sold at public auction; authority,
section 4, act of June 14, 1880.
   (See Appendix M 6.)

EXAMINATION       TO COMPLY WITH REQUIREMENTS OF THE RIVER AND
                      HARBOR ACT OF JULY 5, 1884.

  Under the river and harbor act of July 5, 1884, Colonel Gillmore was
also charged with the preliminary examination of the North Fork of the
Edisto River in the counties of Orangeburghand Lexington, South Carolina.
His report on this examination is submitted herewith. (See Appendix
M. 7.)

EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS FOR IMPROVEMENT, TO COMPLY WITH
REQUIRMENTS OF THE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT OF AUGUST 5, 1886.

  It appearing, after preliminary examination by the local engineer, that
the locality was worthy of improvement, Colonel Gillmore was charged
with and completed the survey of Mosquito Creek between the South Edisto
and Ashepoo rivers, with a view to connect the South Edisto with the Ash-
epoo at or near              sland, South Carolina, the results of which
                            ienwick's
were transmitted to Congress and printed in House Ex. Doc. No. 117,
Fiftieth Congress, first session. (See also Appendix M 8.)

IMPROVEMENT OF CERTAIN RIVERS AND HARBORS IN GEORGIA, AND
        OF CUMBERLAND SOUND, GEORGIA AND FLORIDA.

   Officers in charge, Col. Q. A. Gillmore, Corps of Engineers, to April
6, 1888; Col. Henry L. Abbot, Corps of Engineers, from April 6, to
April 24, 1888, since which date Lieut. O. M. Carter, Corps of Engineers,
with Col. Wm. P. Craighill, Corps of Engineers, Supervising Engineer,
   1. Savannah River and Harbor, Georgia.-The plan according to which
operations have up to the present time been carried on in the Savannah
Harbor and River was adopted in 1873, and modified and enlarged in
1879 and again in 1882. It contemplated the establishment of a chan-
nel from Tybee Roads to the city of Savannah, navigable at high water
for vessels of 22 feet draught, and the widening of the river opposite
the city to 600 feet, of uniform depth with the balance of the channel.
The cost was originally estimated at $482,000, and as amended and en-
larged at $1,212,000.
   In 1887, in obedience to an act of Congress, plans were submitted for
obtaining a high-water channel 28 feet deep from the city of Savannah
to the sea.
   The cost was estimated at $6,660,000.
  In 1873, prior to improvement, the channel was, in places, not more
than 9 feet deep at mean low water, and the usual bigh-water draught
of vessels was not more than 14.5 feet.
                        RIVER       AND        fARIOR IMPkEMENTS.                                   139
  During the fiscal year just closed 817.93 cubic yards of brush fascines
and 429.23 cubic yards of riprap stone were employed in the work.
Operations were suspended on July 3,1887, on account of lack of funds.
   The expenditures during the year amounted to $3,227.54.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, including all outstand-
ing liabilities, is $1,031,581.35, and has resulted in securing a navigable
channel from the city to the sea with a least mean low-water depth of
12.4 feet, a gain of 3.4 feet since the work was begun. The gain in navi-
gable depth is somewhat greater than here shown, and vessels of from 20
to 21 feet draught now go from the city to the sea on a single tide.
   The estimated reduction in freight rates, due to the improvements al-
ready executed, is 25 per cent., which effects an annual saving in freights
alone of more than the total sum of money expended by the United
States upon the harbor within the last twenty-five years. There is no
reason to believe that future expenditures for this work would yield a
less valuable return. The sum necessary to complete the improvement
according to the plans for obtaining 28 feet of water from the city to
the sea is estimated at $6,660,000.
July 1, 1887, amount available ........................               ..........---   ..- .   $3, 646.19
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887....--..................                   2, 545.23
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ...-.....                --...............    680.31
                                                                                        -       3, 225. 54


                                          ....
July 1, 1888, balance available ............       .....           . ..        420. 65
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..................... ...... 180, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ..................                      180, 420.65

IAmount    that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1890, in maintaining existing works ..-.........-....-. -  -    --    50,000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix N 1.)
   2. Savannah River, Georgia.-The present project for the improve-
ment of this river was adopted in 1880, the object being to secure a
low-water steam-boat channel not less than 5 feet in depth between the
cities of Augusta and Savannah, Ga.
   The cost of the improvement was originally estimated at $91,000, and
in 1887, for reasons given in the Annual Report of that year, at $176,000.
Prior to the improvement navigation was much impeded by logs, snags,
piles, and other obstructions. The depth at summer low water over some
of the shoals did not exceed 2 or 3 feet.
   No work was done during the last fiscal year on account of lack of
funds. The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, including all out-
standing liabilities, is $72,349.77, and has resulted in improving the
condition of the shoals near Augusta, and in removing the most dan-
gerous obstruction to navigation throughout the whole extent of the
river, no accidents to steam-boats having occurred since these obstruc-
tions were removed.
   The amount necessary to complete the improvement can not be esti-
mated in advance of an examination, to be made as soon as funds are
available and the stage of the river will permit, the amounts given in
previous reports upon this work as necessary to complete the improve-
ment being, for reasons given in the report of the engineer in charge,
too small.
140          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1887, amount available. .- -- - -----------.--.                                 .
                                                                                  ----------                          $154.92
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ------........... ......                                         $3. 19
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ......-------------------------..............                      1. 50
                                                                                                                         4.69

July 1, 1888, balance available ......-- .................................                                            150.23
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                                            21,000.00



{Amount
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...................

          (estimated) required for completion of existing project- --
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                ------------------
                                                                              85, 000.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 40, 000.00
                                                                                                                   21,150.:23




      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix N 2.)
   3. Savannah River above Augusta, Georgia.-The project for the im-
provement of this river was adopted in 1879, the object being to secure
a low-water pole-boat channel, 30 feet in width and 3 feet in depth,
between Augusta and Trotter's Shoal, 64 miles above. The cost of the
improvement, which was not based upon accurate surveys, was esti-
mated at $45,000.
   The obstructions to navigation consisted chiefly of rock ledges run-
ning across the channel, bowlders of various sizes, and shoals of gravel,
with depths at low-water stage of from 1 to 2 feet.
   No work has been done upon this river since August, 1883.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, including all outstand
ing liabilities, is $38,296.98, and has resulted in improving the medium-
stage channel through a few of the rock ledges, and in removing some
of the most dangerous bowlders obstructing navigation. No additional
commerce has been developed upon the stream by the work done, nor
have freight rates been appreciably reduced by that cause, although no
accidents to pole-boats have occurred since the work of improvement
was done.
July 1, 1887, amount available....................---- ..................  $822.71
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 -------- - ---------------- ------------------   119. 69
July 1, 1888, balance available...... ..-                        ..........           ...............            ..    703. 02
   (See Appendix N 3.)
   4. Romley Marsh, Georgia.-The project for the improvement of this
locality was adopted in 1880, the object being to open a cut, with a mini-
mum bottom width of 48 feet and a mean low-water depth of 7 feet,
between Dead Man's Hammock Creek on the north and Wassaw Creek
on the south. The cost was estimated at $38,720.
   The natural channel is extremely crooked and difficult to navigate,
and at the shoalest part not more than than 3.5 feet deep at mean low
water. No work was done during the last fiscal year.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, including all outstanding
liabilities, is $46,887.22, including $9,633.77, advanced by private par-
ties, and has resulted in the completion of the work, secring a navi-
gable channel between Wassaw and Ossabaw Sounds with a low-
water depth of not less than 4.2 feet. The cut is not located in the
most suitaable place, either for maintenance or for the convenience of
shipping.
  No appropriation is asked for the next fiscal year.
                    RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                         141
July 1, 1887, amount available ............................. ...... ....              $396. 20
July 1, 1-88, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ................ ....
                                               .........................               174.65
                                                                         221.55
July 1, 1888, balance available ......................... ......-----......
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ............--......... 4, 633.77
                                                                 - -....
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889....--. --..- ......            4, 855. 32
  (See Appendix N 4.)
   5. Altamaha River, Georgia.-The present project for the improve-
ment of this river was adopted in 1880, the object being to secure a
steam-boat channel 80 feet in width and 3 feet in depth at low-water
stage between Darien, Ga., and the junction of the Oconee and Oc-
mulgee Rivers. The cost of improvement was originally estimated at
$60,000, and in 1884 at $75,000.
   Prior to improvement navigation was much impeded by logs, snags,
and other obstructions, the low-water depth at some points not exceed-
ing 2 feet.
   During the fiscal year just closed 424 snags and 998 other obstruc-
tions, such as logs, stumps, overhanging trees, etc., were removed.
The expenditures amounted to $7,109.11.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, including all outstand-
ing liabilities, is $45,071.03, and has resulted in removing the most
dangerous obstructions, no interruption to steam-boat navigation hav-
ing occurred during the year.
July 1, 1887, amount available .................. ...............--.... $7,038.08
Amount transferred from Doboy Bar......--             ..
                                       ............-----               ...------.    4, 204. 60
                                                                                    11, 242.68
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887-------                        --------....------.... -- 7,109. 11
                                                 ...........--...
                           ......---------....---......----......-----
July 1, 1888, balance available............  ..
                                              ...................-....               4, 133.57
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ............ ...... ......            10, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ........         14, 133.57
                                                           -----..........-----
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project -. .....  -20, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 20, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix N 5.)
   6. Doboy Bar, Georgia.-The project for the improvement of this bar
was adopted in 1886. It provides for the experimental expenditure of a
small sum of money with the object of deepening the bar by propeller
sluicing or hydraulic excavating.
   The natural channel is crooked, with minimum low-water depths of
not more than 11.1 feet.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, including all outstand-
ing liabilities, is $5,795.40, which was applied to carrying on the work
of scraping and hydr'aulic excavating during the last fiscal year, with
no permanent useful result.
   The commercial importance of the locality does not now seem to
justify permanent improvement, and there is no reason to expect. satis-
factory results from the expenditure of small sums of money in tempo-
rary improvement.
July 1, 1887, amount available .......................---
                                                  -     ....-----...... $10, 000.00
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ......................... $5,795.40
Transferred to Altamaha River .............        ............. 4,204. 60
                                                                                    10,o
   (See Appendix N 6.)
142          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.. S ARMY.

   7. Brunswick Harbor, Georgia.-The present project for the improve-
ment of this harbor was adopted in 1880, and modified and enlarged in
1886, the object being to secure a navigable channel not less than 15
feet deep at mean low water. The mean rise and fall of tide is 6.8 feet.
The cost of the project of 1880 was estimated at $73,187.50 and as en-
larged in 1886 at $190,000, inclusive of appropriations already made.
   In 1880, prior to improvement, the channel was not more than 9 feet
deep at mean low water.
   No work was done during the fiscal year just closed on account of
lack of funds.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1880, including all outstanding lia-
bilities, is $92,463.27, and has resulted in securing a navigable low-water
channel not less than 11.5 feet deep.
July 1, 1887, amount available...... ....................................                                         $88. 44
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of lia-
  bilities outstanding July 1, 1887................................ $1.84
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ...              ........................                    49.87
                                                                                                                   51.71


July 1, 1888, balance available ......................                                   .......                   36.73
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888                          ...................             ..   35, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889..                             ...................     33, 036.73

iAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......
Amountthat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890
                                                                                                            62, 500. 00
                                                                                                            62, 500.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections                            2   of river and
     harbor acts of 1860 and 1867.
   (See Appendix N 7.)
  8. Jekyl Creek, Georgia.-This is a new work. In compliance with
the requirements of the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, a pre-
liminary examination and survey were made of Jekyl Creek, and the re-
port thereon was transmitted to Congress January20, 1888, and printed
in House Ex. Doc. No. 117, Fiftieth Congress, first session.
   The project for improvement is to obtain at the shallow reaches an
improved low-water depth of 7 feet, by the construction of training-
walls and dredging, at an estimated cost of $38,500.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $5,000 for
the work, and a further sum of $10,000 may be profitably expended in
continuing it during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188.-.........................                                     $5, 000. 00

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project. - - -
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890
                                                                                                   -        33, 500. 00
                                                                                                            10, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    9. Cumberland Sound, Georgia and Florida.-The present project for
the improvement of the entrance to this sound was adopted in 1879,
the object being to secure a navigable low-water channel across the bar
from 20 to 21 feet in depth. The cost of improvement was estimated
at $2,071,023.
    Prior to improvement the low-water depths of the entrance varied
from 11 to 12.5 feet, with a mean rise and fall of tide of 5.9 feet.
   During the fiscal year just closed the second course of the south jetty
was advanced seaward 3,505 1 feet. Operations were suspended on ac-
count of the exhaustion of funds on November 26, 1887. During the
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                             143
year an accurate triangulation of the harbor was made for use in future
surveys.
  The expenditures amounted to $59,711.62. The total amount expended
to June 30, 1888, including all outstanding liabilities, is $366,494.26.
  It is proposed during the coming year, with any funds which may be-
come available, to raise and perhaps extend the south jetty.
   The amount estimated as necessary to complete the improvement is
$1,591,000.
July 1, 1887, amount available....                 ................................        $60, 717. 36
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887......................................                    ....      59, 711. 62

July 1, 1888, balance available ...................                ....       .....          1,005. 74
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888......................                        112, 500.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .................                    113, 505.74

(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ...... 1, 591, 000. 00
SAmount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1890 ...........-- --........... . ................ .......
                                                            ......... .....-- 500, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix N 8.)

EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS FOR IMPROVEMENT, TO COMPLY WITH
  REQUIREMENTS OF THE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT OF AUGUST 5,
   1886.
  It appearing, after preliminary examination by the local engineer,
that the localities were worthy of improvement, Colonel Gillmore was
charged with and completed the following surveys, the results of which
were transmitted to Congress and printed as Executive Documents of
the Fiftieth Congress, first session:
   1. Savannah River from Cross Tides, above Savannah,to the Bar, with
a view to obtaining 28 feet of water in the channel.-Printed in House Ex.
Doc. No. 57. (See also Appendix N 9.)
  2. Jekyl Creek, Georgia.-Printedin House Ex. Doc. No. 117. (See
also Appendix N 10.)

IMPROVEMENT OF               CERTAIN        RIVERS AND HARBORS                     IN   THE    STATE
                                           OF FLORIDA.

   Officer in charge, Capt. William M. Black, Corps of Engineers, with
Lieut. D. DuB. Gaillard, Corps of Engineers, under his immediate orders.
Supervising Engineer, Col. William P. Craighill, Corps of Engineers.
   1. St. John's River, Florida.-Operationsfor the improvement of this
river have been carried on in conformity with a plan submitted by the
late General Gillmore, Corps of Engineers, in 1879. This plan contem-
plates the formation of a continuous 15-foot channel in the St. John's
River, between Jacksonville and the ocean. The project was in two
parts: 1, the formation of a channel across the bar at the mouth by the
contraction produced by two jetties starting from opposite sides of the
river at its mouth, and so directed that the outer ends on the bar shall
be approximately parallel and 1,600 feet apart; 2, the improvement of
some defective reaches in the river near Dame's Point. The estimated
cost of the two parts of the project were $1,306,500 and $120,000, re-
144     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

spectively. All work up to the present time has been done on the first
portion of the project, under five appropriations aggregating $675,000,
and made for improving " the channel over the bar at the mouth."
    Before improvement, the channel over the bar had an available mean
low-water depth varying from 5 to 7 feet, and shifted north and south
through an area a mile in length.
    On June 30, 1887, the south jetty had a total length of 6,667 feet, of
which 2,650 feet were built to the level of mean low-water. The north
jetty had a total length of 5,603 feet, of which 3,000 feet had its crest at
the level of mean low water. Neither jetty was built with a full sized
cross-section. Both are composed of one or more layers of log and
brush mattresses covered with riprap stone. The effects of the work
were to form a straight channel across the bar, which had a least mean
.low-water depth of 9.8 feet.
     Operations during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, were contin-
ued under the remainder of the appropriation made in act approved
August 5, 1886. The greater part of the work was done under contract.
Work by hired labor was confined to a small amount of experimental
concrete work, and to operations for connecting the north jetty with the
light shifting sand beach, which, from their nature, could not have been
done advantageously by contract. The old sailing gap of the south
jetty was closed, the foundation of the north jetty was extended 909
feet, and its superstructure built to the level of mean low water, with a
crest 12 feet wide and side slopes of 1 on 1, for a distance of 1,800
feet; the shore extension was strengthened and made stable with side
and wing walls of riprap, and the jetty was raised to full height and
capped with concrete for a distance of 148 feet. Work on the jetties
was suspended (excepting the experimental concrete work) early in Feb-
ruary, 1888, for lack of funds. All work was suspended in April and
the plant stored.
     The south jetty is now 6,667 feet long, and its crest for 4,100 feet from
the shore end is at the level of mean low water, and for the remaining
distance at an average mean low-water depth of 6 feet. The north jetty
is 6,585 feet long. Its crest is at full height for 553 feet, at mean low-
  water level for 5,079 feet, and at a depth varying from 0 to 10 feet for the
remaining distance.
     The channel across the bar has steadily improved during the year.
  At the date of the last survey in May, the least depth on the bar was
  over 13 feet. On account of the divergence of an increased portion of
  the ebb flow from the river through the false channel along the north
jetty, the shoaling on the jetty middle ground has continued and the
  channel depth there is now less than that on the bar. The completion
  of the jetty work will remove this shoal, but if this work is too long de-
  layed this obstruction may become serious.
     Of the three reaches between Jacksonville and the ocean, where the
  channel depth is less than 15 feet on the bar, the jetty middle ground,
  and that near Dame's Point, the last is now the most obstructive to
  navigation. Its depth (9 to 10 feet) now controls the lading of vessels
  entering the St. John's, and its improvement is earnestly desired, in
  order to gain the full benefits of the successful work at the bar. It is
  recommended that future appropriations be made for the entire project
  " for improving St. John's River, between Jacksonville and the ocean,"
  under the aggregate estimate. It is thought the jetty work can be com-
pleted with the amount of the original estimate yet unappropriated,
viz, $631,500. The aggregate estimate for the completion of the project
will then be $751,500.
                       RIVER       AND        HARBOR        IMPROVEMENTS.                                 145
July 1, 17, amount available            ......-......---   .....-....--......-----......---.....   $111, 741. 77
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ........................-              $107, 252. 57
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities .--.---------.....---..-----......-----       446. 33
                                                                                                    107, 698.90

July 1, 1888, balance available .....................                   ..... ....---.......          4,042.87
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.                      -..- -- - - - - ...- ...-..
                                                                                           --       175, 000. 00
                                                             ......-
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.-- - -....           -.
                                                                           --
                                                                  - ...---..-                       179, 042. 87

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.. - -...... 576, 500. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 300, 000. 00
                                                                                          -
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix 0 1.)
   2. ITolusia Bar, Florida.-VolusiaBar is situated at the head of Lake
George and is formed by materials brought down by the St. John's River,
and deposited at the point where the current of the narrow river loses its
velocity, as the bed widens to form the lake. The usual depth on the
bar, before operations began, was from 31 to 4 feet. At times this depth
was diminished so much as to stop navigation entirely.
   The adopted plan of improvement was to contract the waters on the
bar by the construction of two converging brush and stone jetties, with
a view to causing a scour to the depth of 6 feet. Should the depth
caused by the jetties not be sufficient, recourse was to be had to dredg-
ing. Between the jetties on the bar, lines of guide-piles were placed
to keel) vessels off the jetties and to define the channel clearly.
   In 1887 it was decided to limit the channel depth sought to the 5
feet then obtained, on account of the evident shoaling in the lake be-
yond the jetties and because that depth was sufficient for the require-
ments of the existing river commerce.
   Up to June 30, 1887, $24,287.43 had been expended, including liabili-
ties then outstanding. The jetties had been built to their full length
and to a height sufficient to produce the desired effect; two lines of
firmly-set fender-piles defined the jetty channel on the crest of the bar;
and a straight channel with a minimun mean low-water depth of 5 feet
had been obtained. During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, opera-
tions were limited to the necessary examinations. At the last examina-
tion, made in April, 1888, the work was found in good condition and the
channel depth had been maintained.
July 1, 1887, amount available...------...........--------....--...... ..-- --.                         $712. 57
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887---...-------- ------..-------------------.                                   359. 01
July 1, 1888, balance available....----.---.. -------------..
                                                           --     -----  -----                          353.56
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888------... - .-....-..- _....                               500. 00
                                                                   -853.56
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889----....................

    1890, for repairs ...----------------------------------------------                                 500. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix 0 2.)
   3. Harbor at Saint Augustine, Florida.-Thisis a new work. In com-
pliance with the requirements of the river and harbor att of August
5, 1886, an examination and survey were made of " Saint Augustine
for a deep-sea channel on the outer bar, Florida," and the report of the
         ENG 88-           10
146         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

results thereof was transmitted to Congress January 11, 1888, and
printed in House Ex. Doe. No. 87, Fiftieth Congress, first session.
   The project proposed for the improvement of the entrance is to con-
centrate the flow over the bar, and thus increase the scour by the con-
struction of solid converging jetties, etc., at an estimated cost of
$1,467,888.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, a,ppropriates $35,000
for improving the harbor, but directs that the subject be referred to a
Board of Engineers, whose report is to be laid before Congress at its
next session. No estimate for the next fiscal year can be submitted
until the report of this Board is received, when it will be transmitted
to Congress.
   4. Northwest entrance, Key West Harbor,                bar having a          Florida.-A
channel depth of 10.5 feet obstructs the northern entrance to this har-
bor. During storms the available depth is so much reduced, that vessels
bound to and from Gulf ports can not use it, but are compelled to make
a d6tour of about a hundred miles by Dry Tortugas to enter or leave
the Gulf.
   An examination of the entrance with a view to its improvement was
made in 1867 and again in 1881. In 1882 Congress made an appropria-
tion of $25,000 for dredging a channel 300 feet wide and 17 feet deep
deep across the bar.
   The work was done in 1883. Before commencing it the officer in
charge expressed an opinion that the work would not be permanent.
In 1884 the channel had filled.
   In a~t approved August 5, 1886, $2,500 were appropriated for a new
examination and survey of the bar. This was made in December, 1886,
and January, 1887. The bar was found to be formed and maintained
by interfering tidal currents.
   No funds were available for operations during the past fiscal year.
                                                ......--------- ...........
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888----------         -                  $25, 000. 00
                                                                            -...--....

 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project, subject
    to revision.....---....---... ......-------.....-----....-----........------..........--------.....----------..... 583, 000. 00
   Amountthat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 100, 000.00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
 .    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix 0 4.)
  5. CaloosahatcheeRiver, Florida.-Beforeimprovement, the lower part
of the river was so obstructed by oyster-bars that the available channel
depth was only 5 feet. About 17 miles above the mouth the river
loses the characteristics of an estuary, and there are numerous islands
and a broad shoal.
  The projectadopted in 1882 called for the formation, by dredging, of
a channel 100 feet wide and 7 feet deep from the bay to Fort Meyers, a
distance of 14 miles. In 1886 this project was modified, so as to include
the improvement of the upper river as far as Fort Thompson, by removal
of snags and overhanging trees.
   Up to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, $13,044.72 had
been expended under these projects. A channel of the required width,
and having a least depth of 6 feet, had been formed below Fort Meyers,
and one of the worst reaches of the river, extending 4) miles above
Fort Denaud; had been cleared of snags and overhanging trees. During
the past fiscal year, owing to the small sum available, it was not possi-
ble to resume the snagging operations, which had been stopped by high
water in June, 1887. Work was therefore confined to plotting the notes
                              RIVER          AND       HARBOR             IMPROVEMENTS.                                     147
of a survey made in the previous fiscal year, and in preparing maps
of the river.
July 1, 1887, amount available ......----......                        --..........----..........-....----......         $955. 28
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding Juy     1, 1887 ........                            --
                                                          ......----.---.........                        $691. 5
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities-----------.......------------..........                               73.67
                                                                                                            -----         765. 20

,July 1, 1888, balance available ....---...---- ---- -----.......--....--..---..----.........--...---------......---      190. 08
Amount appropriated by act of August 11,1888......-----.- -..- -- ---- -....-----.                                     10,009.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889-                                   ....--......---..      .--... 10, 190. 08
   (See Appendix O 5.)
   6. Pease River, Florida.-This river rises about the center of Polk
County, Florida, and flows southwest into Charlotte Harbor. For the
last 12 miles of its course it has the caracteristics of an estuary. The
rest of the stream flows through a heavily-wooded and sparsely-popu-
lated country, and is much obstructed by fallen trees, snags, rocks, and
bars. It is subject to great changes of level. During the low-water
season not more than 14 inches to 24 inches of water can be relied on.
   The project for its improvement, adopted in 1881, is to improve it for
high-water navigation by the removal from the channel of snags, over-
hanging trees, and loose rocks between Fort Meade and the mouth, a
distance, by river, of about 100 miles. Since the project was adopted
the Florida Southern Railroad has been opened along the river.
   The amount expended up to June 30,1887, was $12,016.74. The river
was cleared for a distance of 64 miles.
   In the act approved August 5, 1886, $13,000 was appropriated for im-
proving Manatee and Pease rivers, of which $5,000 could be expended
on Pease River.
   As no p>ractical benefit could be derived from expending so small a
sum on the improvement of this river, it was decided to reserve $2,000
with which to make a survey on which a project could be founded, and
to expend the remainder in improving Manatee River.
   The field work of the survey has been completed and plotted.
July 1, 1887, amount available ......----....---- .---..................----------..---..--...------..----               $983. 26
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                              ----                --....-------------------...--...
  outstanding July 1, 1887 -......................------                                                                  780. 73
July 1, 1888, balance available ......--.......-----.....................-----                            .......         202. 53

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........                                             25,000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix O 6.)
   7. Manatee River, Florida.-The portion of the Manatee River under
improvement is the last reach between Rocky Bluff and the mouth, a
distance of about 12 miles. This has a mid-channel depth of from 7 to
20 feet. The general width is about three-fourths of a mile. At, the
mouth is a long shoal with a minimum depth of 8} feet. Between Pal-
metto and Manatee, about 6 miles from the mouth, is another bar cov-
ered by from 3 to 5 feet of water.
  The river was examined in 1881. An appropriation of $12,000 for its
improvement was made in 1882. The project adopted had for its
object to form a channel 100 feet wide and 13 feet deep at mean low
water from Tampa Bay to McNeill's Point (Palma Sola). The appro-
priation was expended in 1883-81, and a cut 2,150 feet long was made,
varying in width from 35 to 60 feet, and having a depth of 12} feet.
148      REPORT      OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                   U. S. ARMY.

  In act approved August 5, 1886, $13,000 were appropriated for im-
proving Manatee and Pease rivers, of which $11,000 were allotted to
work on Manatee River.
   Owing to the changed commercial conditions since the adoption of
the project, brought about by the extension of the railroad to Tampa,
the transfer to Tampa of the principal Gulf steam-ship lines, and the
service of the smaller towns around Tampa Bay by coasting steamers
from Tampa, the project was modified, to provide for the passage of
these lighter-draught vessels to all of the towns of the lower river by
the removal of the bar above Palmetto.
  A survey of this bar was made, and operations for its removal by
dredging were commenced on August 22, and finished on September
27, 1887. Fifteen thousand three hundred and two and three-tenths
cubic yards of soft material were removed, giving a cut 2,412 feet long,
65 feet wide, and 8 feet deep. A survey made in January, 1888, shows
that the dredged cut had shoaled at its extreme ends, but had main-
tained its depth at other places.
  In accordance with the project for a survey of the Manatee River,
Florida, approved December 22, 1886, a survey of the river was made
in December, 1887, and January, 1888, and maps of the river were
plotted.
July 1, 1887, amount available ......---......-----.............................
                                                                           10, 390.48
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 187 .---------.....------......---............
                                                --.....------..         9,774. 61
                                                          --------......--....

July 1, 1888, balance available ................ ...... ...........
                                                              -----......    615,87
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...... ............ .... .... 5,000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.-.-.---. ....       .      5,615. b7
iAmount (estimated)    required for completion of existing project .......      45, 000.00
  Amountthat can be profitably expeuded in fiscalyear ending June 30,1890        8,000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix O 7.)
   8. Tampa Bay, Florida.-The harbor at Tampa, at the head of this bay,
was separated from deep water by a fiat 2 miles wide. Through this was
a narrow channel with an average available depth of about 5 feet, formed
by the waters of Hillsborough River.
   The present project was adopted in1880, and has for its object the for-
mation of a 9-foot channel from the 9-foot curve in the bay to the
wharves at Tampa, in Hillsborough River, 150 feet wide in the bay and
200 feet wide in the river, at an estimated cost of $97,000.
   Up to June 30, 1887, $59,941.17 had been expended.
   The work consisted entirely of dredging and rock excavation, and ex-
tended over a length of 8,215 feet, with a width varying from 60 feet
in the bay to 150 feet in the river. This channel has been filled some-
what by the tidal currents, and on June 30, 1887, it had a depth along
the center line of from 8.3 to 9 feet, with a width of about 60 feet.
   In the act approved August 5, 1886, $10,000 were appropriated for
this work. Under this appropriation operations were commenced on
June 29, 1887, and completed on August 12, 1887, giving a clear chan-
nel, 9 feet deep, at the bend at the mouth of Hillsborough River, vary-
ing in width from 200 feet in the river to 50 feet in the bay.
   In the annual report for 1886 it was estimated that $73,000 would be
required to complete the project.
   Duringthe past year a point in the deep water of this bay, Porto
.Tampa, has been connected with Tampa by the extension of the South
                       RIVER       AND     HARBOR         IMPROVEMENTS.                                          149
Florida Railway, and has become the terminus of the Key West and
Havana line of steamers. Fifteen feet of water can now be carried
to Porto Tampa. At an estimated cost of $63,000 for dredging, 20 feet
of water can be carried from the Gulf of Mexico to this point. The
total estimated cos t of the modified project is $88,000.
  Existing project is for a channel 200 feet width, of 20 feet depth from
the outer bar to Mangrove or Bushy Point, which is estimated to cost
$50,000.
                                                   ....----..----............-..........----- $9, 6:32. 18
July 1, 1887, amount available-- ..........---------..--------
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 -.-...-----.--.             ----        $8, 603. 22
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities...
                                     ------------------------                                 97.50
                                                                                                             8, 700. 72

July 1, 1888, balance available ..........--..................-----........                                    91.46
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .................-
                                                 --          ---                - -      -.. -        ..    25,000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June :30, 1889 ...... .--......--                             ..    25, 931. 46
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......    2---
                                                                             5, 000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending Juno 30,1890 25, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix O 8.)
  9. Withlacoochee River, Florida.-The river was examined with a
view to its improvement in 1879. The adopted project calls for the re-
moval of snags, overhanging trees, and loose rocks, and some of the
worst shoals between the Gulf and Pemberton Ferry, a distance of
about 100 miles, so as to permit boats of 2 feet draught to navigate the
river during half the year.
   The normal width of the river varies from 75 to 150 feet, though in
many places its bed widens in a cypress swamp or grass marsh, through
which a sluggish current passes in narrow winding lagoons. At other
places the river is obstructed by loose rocks. The depth varies from 1
foot to 7J feet.
  Three appropriations have been made for the improvement of this
stream, aggregating $13,000, and, excepting at three points, navigation
has been opened according to the project. Owing to a lack of funds no
work was done during the last fiscal year beyond caring for the public
property.
July 1, 1857, amount availble .-..........----...               .....----......-.......----......-            $138. 77

July 1, 1888, balance available .......... .. ..........     ......       ....                         ..       138. 77
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ............ ...............                                   5, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...........-
                                                                -                  - - --.......---          5, 138.77

iAmount   (estimated) required for completion of existing project .... ....                                  5, 400. 00
  Amount that can be profitablIy expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                 5, 400.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections                         2 of river       and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix O 9.)
   10. Harbor at Cedar Keys, Florida.-Theimprovement of this harbor
has been carried on from time to time under various appropriations made
since 1872. It was obstructed by a shoal locally called the Bulkhead or
Middle Ground, lying between Way Key and the main ship-channel; at
several points in the main ship-channel the rock which everywhere
underlies the harbor at a slight depth, by its outcropping, has decreased
the general 12-foot depth of the channels to from 7 to 9 feet. The pres-
150           REPORT OF THE                           CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                      U. S ARMY.

ent project for the improvement of the harbor was adopted in 188 , and
contemplates the formation of a channel 200 feet wide and 10 feet deep
through these shoals. An appropriation of $5,000 was made in 1884 for
work under this project. With this a cut was made partially across one
of these shoals. This cut has remained clear.
  In act approved August 5, 1886, $7,000 were appropriated for contin-
uing this improvement. This amount was applied to re-opening a cut
through the middle ground and changing its direction so as to insure
greater permanence. Operations were begun on October 5 and corn pleted
October 29, 1887; 12,944.7 cubic yards of soft material were removed,
giving a cut 1,200 feet long, 70 feet wide, and 10.7 feet deep. An examni-
nation of the cut made June 13, 1888, shows that very little shoaling has
taken place.
  The estimated cost of completing the project by dredging is         500.
                                                                    Q46
July 1, 1887, amount available --...---------.--- ----------.--..----------- 6, 717. 81
July 1, 1888, amount expendea during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887------.--- ------------.     -$6,514.    47
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities...... ...... ...... ........         97. 75
                                                                                                                                             6, 612. 22

July   1,   1888,   balance   available............-------------..---......------......------....----......------.....---10.                           59

Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...                                                        ................---------....        7, 500. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889......------......--........                                                            7, 605. 59

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project     ........                                                              46, 500. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal year ending Juno 30,1890                                                                 15, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix 0 10.)
  11. Suwance River, Florida.-A project for its improvement was
adopted in 1880. It contemplates the formation of a channel 150 feet
wide and 5 feet deep, from the Gulf (through the bars at the passes) as
far up the river as New Branford (Roland's Bluff). From there toElla-
ville the channel is to be 60 feet wide and 4 feet deep.
   Up to June 30, 1886, $17,940 had been expended under contracts in
dredging in the east pass. A channel 5,835 feet long, 60 feet wide, and
5 feet deep at mean low water had been cut.
   By act of August 5, 1886, $5,000 were appropriated for this work.
During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887. the channel between New
Branford and Luraville was cleared and opened to the full size and
width, excepting at three points, where the channel has a minimum
width of 35 feet and depth of 3 feet. Work was stopped by high water.
   During the past fiscal year work was confined principally to rock
blasting at Double Island and Strip Jacket Shoals, between Luraville
and New Branford. A channel has been blasted through these shoals
having an average width of 60 feet and depth of 4 feet.
   The work thus far done has rendered navigation throughout the year
possible for boats drawing 2 feet of water between the mouth of the
river and Luraville, 20 miles above New Branford.
July 1, 1887, amount available .         ........................            - .. ...- ......                                                2, 009. 88
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887..         ....---          ...-- --..     $1, 530.97
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities.................... .......                      35. 25
                                                                                                                                     _---    1,   566. 22

                                                           ---....
July 1, 1888, balance available-.... --....-....-.... ......-....  ...--...- ...--.                                                            443.66
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 --............-------....-.... .....                                                          1, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 - - ----------- ---                                                                   15, 443. 66
                    RIVER AND            HARBOR       IMPROVEMENTS.                                      151

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                          17,200.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix 0 11.)
   12. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering naviga-
tion.-An examination made in March, 1888, showed that obstructions
endangering navigation existed at the following points, viz:
   (1) Wreck of a United States transport, 18 miles south of Palatka.
   (2) Portion of wreck of steamer Maple Leaf, 15 miles south of Jackson-
ville.
   (3) Wreck of German brig near jetty channel, St. John's River,
Florida. Authority to take the necessary steps for the removal of these
obstructions, at an estimated cost of $5,890, was granted April 23, 1888.
   On May 2, 1888, application was made to postpone the work of re-
moval till fall. This application was approved by the Department on
May 10, 1888.
   (See Appendix O 12.)
EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS FOR IMPROVEMIENT, TO COMPLY WITH
REQUIREMENTS OF THE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT OF AUGUST 5, 1886.

  It appearing, after preliminary examination by the local engineer,
that the localities were worthy of improvement, Captain Black was
charged with and completed the following surveys, the results of which
were transmitted to Congress and printed in House Ex. Doe. No. 87,
Fiftieth Congress, first session :
  1. aint Augustine, Florida,for a deep-sea channel on the outer bar.-
(See also Appendix 0 13.)
  2. PuntaRassa Harbor, Florida.-(Seealso Appendix         14.)                        0
IMPROVEMENT           OF CERTAIN RIVERS IN THE STATES                                      OF       FLORIDA,
                           GEORGIA, AND ALABAMA.

   Officer in charge, Capt. H. L. ioxie, Corps of Engineers.
   1. ApalachicolaRiver, Florida.--Theapproved project for the improve-
ment of this river contemplated securing a channel 100 feet wide and
6 feet deep at low water, by removing snags and overhanging trees
as well as widening and straightening Moccasin Slough.
   The improvement is completed as projected, the river being in a good
navigable condition, and only requiring the removal of the annual ac-
cumulation of snags and overhanging trees and such work as can be
done with the amount of $2,000, which has been estimated as necessary
annually for preserving the improvement.
   The balance available and the appropriation asked for are to be ap-
plied to preserving the improvement by the removal of obstructions ac-
cording to the project.
July 1, 1887, amount available .----..........----..-----     ------.--...--...------..------.         $687.58
July 1, 1888, balance available.....--    ----...--............     ................            .       687. 58
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                               2, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.......--------------......--                    2,687.58

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                           2, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix P 1.)
152         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  2. Apalachicola Bay, Florida.-A bar existed at the mouth of the Ap-
alachicola River, extending from one-half mile below the town of Ap-
alachicola, Fla., to the lower anchorage. The minimum channel depth
of water over this bar was 3- feet. The plan of improvement was the
deepening of the channel to 11 feet with a width of 100 feet (see the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1879, pages 823 and 824).
at an estimated cost of $100,000.
  The expenditure of $66,756.51 of the amount appropriated for this
work has resulted in a channel-way 3,635 feet long, 60 feet wide, and 9
feet deep at mean low water on the 18th of August, 1887. To complete
the project about 150,000 cubic yards of material remains to be dredged.
  The results have not been satisfactory. It has been thought that if
the cut upon this bar could be carried through iowith one appropriation
the silting of the channel would take place much less rapidly.
July 1, 1887, amount available .-----------------................-------.....--...    3,223.69
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887                            $2, 980. 20
                                                             .... $..................
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ................ .........          16.05
                                                                                                     2,996.25

July 1, 1888, balance available ....-
                                  ---................. .----..--------....-------....--------.... 227. 44
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .- ......                         .... 20, 000.00
                                                                        -...........
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................
                                                             --                                     20,227.44

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                         40, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix P 2.)
  3. LaGrange Bayou, Florida.-The plan of improvement adopted was
made pursuant to an examination of this bayou in 1881, under an act
of Congress approved March 3, 1881, and contemplates the deepening
of the channel through the bayou, so as to admit of the passage of ves-
sels drawing 4) feet at mean low water, the work to be done by dredg-
ing.
  Up to June 30, 1888, there had been expended on this work the sum
of $2,000, allotted from the appropriation of $20,000 made by an act ap-
proved August 2, 1882, for the improvement of the Choctawhatchee
River, Florida, the two improvements being closely related. The result
has been to secure a channel 5 feet in depth at mean low water.
                                                                   2, 000. 00
July 1, 1887, amount available ..-----.-----.....------......--......-......------
                                                       ----------

July 1, 1888, balance available-.......---......------.----...........----..----.--------------........2, 000. 00
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ..........................                                3,000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                             5, 000.   0
  (See Appendix P 3.)
  4. Harbor at Pensacola, Florida.-Theplan of improvement adopted
in 1881 contemplates dredging a channel 300 feet wide and 24 feet deep
at mean low water across the inner bar for temporary relief of the nav-
igation of this harbor, and the preservation of the site of old Fort Mc-
Ree, by the construction of suitable works of shore protection, with a
view to retaining this position for defensive purposes and preventing
further changes in the tidal currents through the continued abrasion
of the shore at this point.
  The expenditure up to June 30, 1888, of $213,130.02 has resulted in
obtaining temporarily a channel 120 f'et wide and 24 feet deep at mean
                       RIVER       AND     HARBOR           IMPROVEMENTS.                                      153
low water across the shoal inside the bar, and in stopping the abrasion
of the shore-line at Fort McRee. This channel was not maintained by
the tidal currents, and on June 30, 1888, was reported to be about 22 feet
in depth at mean low water, showing no diminution in depth during the
past year and a gain of 2.6 feet over the depth existing when the work
was commenced. The width of this channel diminishes continuously by
the advance of the Middle Ground Shoal upon its northern border.
   An annual outlay will be necessary to maintain the dredged channel
until the permanent improvement of this harbor shall have been author-
ized by Congress.
   The enforced cessation of work on account of no appropriation for the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, has resulted in further injury to the
jetties and the postponement of relief to navigation.
July 1, 1887, amount available ...---...........--......           ......        ............            $11, 424. 83
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
    liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887..... .... - .... ........                    $9, 554. 85
July 1, 1888, outstanding iabilities...           .......          ....     ..              684. 14
                                                                                                          10, 238.99

July 1, 1888, balance available................--- ......------
                                                   --...----..---......                                 1, 185. 84
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ................                      .......-----------
                                                                                                 -     35,000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .-..-..-....- ......                                36, 185. 84
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project -------... 25,000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 25, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix P 4.)
   5. Choctawlhatchee River, Floridaand Alabama.-The present plan of
improvement was adopted in 1872 and modified in 1880, pursuant to an
examination made under the act of March 3, 1879. It contemplates the
improvement of the river from its mouth to Newton, Ala., an estimated
distance of 252 miles, so as to obtain a low-water navigable channel
from its mouth to Geneva, and a navigable high-water channel from
Geneva to Newton, Ala.
   The expenditure up to June 30, 1888, of $84,788.84, has resulted in
giving a navigable channel at mean low water from the mouth of the
river to Geneva, and a partially improved channel from Geneva to Pates
Creek, a distance of 25 miles (12 miles below Newton, Ala.).
                                    .........---------.....--....---...----. ---------
July 1, 1887, amount available--...--------                                                                5, 284. 98
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 .....---------................
                                                           --------                     3, 073.82
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities .----------.......---..---------. ----.               276. 39
                                                                                                           3, 350. 21

July 1, 1888, balance available...............-----------.........---............                          1,934.77
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ....--- ................      ......                        10, 000. 00

                                                       -
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889......    - - - --
                                                            ......   ....                       .. ..-    11, 934. 77

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ..----- ....                             25, 832. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                              15, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix P 5.)
  6. Escambia and Conecuh Rivers, Florida and Alabama.-The plan of
improvement for this river, adopted pursuant to partial examinations
and surveys made in 1878 and 1879, contemplates the removal of snags
and sunken logs and other obstructions from the channel, closing cut-
154          REPORT          OF TIIE CHIEF                   OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

offs and cutting through rock shoals from the mouth of the river in
Pensacola Bay to Indian Creek, an estimated distance of 273 miles, for
the purpose of facilitating the movement of timber down the river afford-
ing at the same time facilities for steam boat navigation.
   The expenditure up to June 30, 1888, of $45,325.28 has resulted in
dredging a channel through the bar at the mouth of the river, and in
the removal of obstructions to navigation, so that at the present time
the river is navigable at ordinary stages for steam-boats drawing 5, feet
of water from Ferry Pass to Skinner's Landing, a distance of 17 miles,
and for boats drawing 3 feet to the Alabama State line.
July 1, 1887, amount available.                   .    -- ---.... -               -- -   --   - - -.........       .   $9, 855. 52
Receipts from sale of fuel to officers ....----------...------                           - -- -      - - - ---. . --          22. 50
                                                                                                                        9, 878. 02
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding duly 1, 1887 ......
                                        --    ......- -....----
                                                         --     ..
                                                                -....                                  $6,067. 00
July 1,1888, outstanding liabilities....                   - - -.....................                      479.74
                                                                                                                        6, 546. 74
July 1, 1888, balance available --..........------..........----------------..........-------..---......----            3, 331. 28
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .. ...... .... .... .... .... ..                                         10, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889- ....---......--...-....                                         13, 331. 8

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                              25, 430. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                           15, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 18,7.
    (See Appendix P 6.)
   7. Oconee Riv er, Georgia.-The State of Georgia has expended about
$35,000 for the improvement of this river. The first examination made
by authority of the United States was in 1874, and a plan of improve-
ment was subsequently adopted which contemplated the removal of logs
and snags from the channel and cutting through rock-reefs where nec-
essary, in order to secure a depth of about 3 feet at low water from the
mouth of the river to Milledgeville, Ga. The result of the work done
up to June 30, 1888, has been to enable steam-boats navigating this
river to run on a stage of water 4 feet lower than that at which naviga-
tion was possible before the improvement, but it has not been possible
to maintain this. On May 23, 1888, a steam snag-boat for joint use upon
this river and the Ocrmulgee was completed and delivered to the United
States under contract with Messrs. Mi. A. Sweeney & Bro., of Jefferson-
ville, Ind., immediately equipped for service and placed at work on the
Oconee.
July 1, 1887, amount available-----............---------- ..-- -----......--             ..
                                                                      -...--..-------- ---                              7,.      25
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887--..............---        ----
                                                                ...-.               , 661. 09
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities--......--- --....---............----....        388. 93
                                                                                                                        - ,   00O.02

                                                                                      .....-------....
July 1, 1888, balance available --..----............--------......----.....-----...-----.                               1,726. 23
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                                                12, 500. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1.889--..---..--..--........                                          14,226.23

iAmount                                                            -- - - -
          (estimated) required for completion of existing project....
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890
                                                                                                                       55, 000. 00
                                                                                                                       20, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix P 7.)
                             RIVER         AND HARBOR                   IMPROVEMENTS.                                           155
   8. Ocmulgee River, Georgia.-The present plan of improvement is
based upon an examination made in 1875, when the obstructions were
found to be snags, sand and gravel bars, rock-reefs, overhanging trees,
and submerged rafts, in a shifting and tortuous channel, with a varying
depth of from 22 inches to 4 feet at low water. The project for the im-
provement of the river contemplates the removal of these obstructions.
   The expenditure up to June 30, 1888, of $62,533.72 has resulted in
securing a good navigable channel at low water between Hawkinsville
and the junction of the Oconee, while many of the more serious obstruc-
tions have been removed, but it has not been possible to maintain this.
On May 23, 1888, a steam snag-boat for joint use upon this river and the
Oconee was completed and delivered to the United States under' con-
tract witt Messrs. M. A. Sweeney & Bro., of Jeffersonville, Ind., imme-
diately equipped for service and placed at work on the Oconee.
July 1, 1887, amount available...-----.---..----.
                                              ...............---                               .-     --   -....       .   $6,936. 78
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1., 1887...... ---- ..-....---..-   .                                 $4, 970. 50
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities........... .... .... .......                                          82. 45
                                                                                                                            5, 052. 95
July 1, 1888, balance available--------------------------------------..........................................             1, 83.83
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..                      -...- .-..                ...- -.                     15, 000. t0
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ..........-......---                                                 16, 883. 83
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-........ 55, 500. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 20, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix P 8.)
  9. Flint River, Georgia.-The present project for the improvement of
this river was adopted in 1873 and modified in 1880, the object of the
original project being to afford a channel 100 feet wide and 3 feet deep
at ordinary low water from its mouth up to Albany, Ga., and of the
modification to improve for high-water navigation that portion of the
river between Albany and Montezuma. The river before the improve-
ment was commenced was only navigable at low water from its mouth
up to Bainbridge, and even that portion was narrow, crooked, and dan-
gerous. The expenditure up to June 30, 1888, of $113,917.23 has re-
sulted in obtaining a high-water channel from its mouth up to Albany
and a low-water channel of the projected depth from its mouth ,ip to
Blue Spring Shoal, about 4 miles below Albany; also a partially com-
pleted high-water channel over that portion of the river between Al-
bany and Montezuma.
Jul 1, 1887, amount available ................----------.......---.. -----.--......---------.........----. 12, 403. 28
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ......-----.....----. -------- -- -$9, 290. 75
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities...-----..-.................----.                                     834.22
                                                                                                                           10, 124. 97
                                                                                                                           i-

                                       ---------............------
July 1, 1888, balance available ----....---.........------..                             ----...--....--------..            2, 278. 31
                                                 - --....
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ......-                                         ....     ....-.      -       20, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889----
                                                       ......---- ....--....
                                                                   --                                                      22,278. 31


   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                              30, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix P 10.)
156          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

     10. Coosa River, Georgia and Alabama.-A plan was adopted in 1875
to provide a channel not less than 80 feet wide and 3 feet deep at low
water between Rome, Ga., and the Selma, Rome and Dalton Railroad
Bridge, an estimated distance of 236 miles, increasing the depth over
the lesser rock shoals and over sand and gravel bars by excavations and
by works of contraction, and overcoming the more serious obstructions
by the construction of locks and dams.
  The expenditure up to June 30, 1888, of $461,155.50 has resulted in
securing a fair navigable channel from Rome, Ga., to Greensport, Ala.,
and has nearly completed the work of improvement to the Coosa, River
coal-fields.
                                                                                        -23,999.52
July 1, 1887, amount available-----........-----......-------....----......--.....--..-......
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887......................... $21, 455. 02
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..                     ............                      -....-....      1, 603.52
                                                                                                                               23, 058. 54

July 1, 1888, balance available.-----------....                       --..-----.....---....-............     ....   ....----      940. 98
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...... .                                       .. ......           ......         60, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.-------------------...................                                   60,940.98

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project, subject
    to revision .... ...--------------......------......------..........- ----....-         ---....------....-- ..... 234, 400.00
                                                                                    --....---......
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 100, 000. 0(
 |Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
 ( harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix P 11.)
     11. Chattahoochee River, Georgia and Alabama.-The present plan of im-
provement (adopted in 1873) contemplates a low-water channel 4 feet
in depth and 100 feet in width from Columbus, Ga., to Chattahoochee,
Fla., a distance of 162k miles, by the removal of snags and other ob-
structions from the channel and overhanging trees from the banks by
the excavation of rock shoals and by works of contraction.
   The expenditure up to June 30, 1888, of $220,134.04 has resulted in
securing a fair navigable channel between Chattahoochee and Eufaula
at all seasons of the year, and between Eufaula and Columbus at all
times, except during the prevalence of extreme low water. The limited
annual appropriations for this improvement have not been sufficient to
maintain the works of contraction constructed, nor to extend or modify
them as required.
July 1, 1887, amount available.......---------------........ ---......----....--....
                                                                           ---........--..----.--                              16,504. 67
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887---...... ..................
                                                             --                        $13, 620. 50
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..............-...-......                             554. 27
                                                                                                                               14,174. 77

July 1, 1888, balance available ...------              ---.. ------ --------                               ----..        --.    2, 329.90
                                              -
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...                                                  ...--------... ..             0, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                                      22, 329. 90
     Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....- .... 112, 300. 00
     Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 40, 000. 00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
       harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
      (See Appendix P 12.)
     12. Tallapoosa River, Alabana.-The plan of improvement adopted
pursuant to an examination and partial survey of this river, made under
an act of Co:ingress approved June 14, 1880), contemplated obtaining a
                       RIVER       AND      HARBOR         IMPROVEMENTS.                                          157
navigable channel from the mouth of the river to the foot of Tallassee
Reefs, 2 miles below the town of Tallassee, a distance of 48 miles,
with a least depth of 3 feet and a width of 60 feet at low water, by the
removal of logs and snags from the channel, cutting overhanging trees
from the banks, excavating the prescribed channel through certain rock-
reefs, and removing certain sand and gravel bars by works of contrac-
tion and by dredging.
   The expenditure up to June 30, 1888, of $30,700.86 has resulted in
clearing out all logs and snags from the river channel and improving
one of the rock-reefs, so as to admit of navigation at a mAderate stage
of water for a distance of 48 miles from the mouth of the river.
July 1, 1887, amount available--------.....---..-..-....----................-------..--....                  $5, 428.67
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887--..---..-----.......---.......    .... $3, 611.53
                                                                         ---
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities                      ..         -520.15     52-..----
                                                                                                              4,131, 68
July 1, 1888, balance available .........................................                                     1,296.99
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888- ..-.....-......                         ....-....              7, 500. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889                   .......-------------..------......    8, 796. 99

( Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890,
   for maintenance----    .-- ---------......
          -......--......---              ------....       ......---- --.....--.....----.
                                                      ------......                                            5, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
L  harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix P 13.)
   13. Cahaba River, Alabama.-Under the act of Congress approved
June 23, 1874, and an act approved June 14, 1880, examinations and a
partial survey of this river were made in 1874 and in 1880, pursuant to
which the present plan of improvement was adopted. This contem-
plates a channel 60 feet wide and 3 feet deep at low water from the
mouth of the river to Centreville, Ala., a distance of 88 miles, by re-
moving logs and snags from the channel, cutting overhanging trees
from the banks, protecting caving banks from further erosion, remov-
ing rock-reefs, gravel-bars, and sand-bars by excavation, and by works
of contraction and widening the narrow portions of the river, all at cer-
tain specified points.
   The expenditure up to June 30, 1888, of $29,698.15, has resulted in
clearing the river channel of logs and snags and removing overhanging
trees from the month of the river to Centreville, and in maintaining
this degree of improvement up to the close of the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1886. Since that time no work has been done because of the
proviso in the river and harbor act approved August 5, 1886, that "no
part of said sum ($7,500 appropriated for this work) shall be expended
until the officer in charge shall have reported that the railroad and
other bridges across said river have been provided with good and suffi-
cient draw openings." These bridges continue to obstruct the naviga-
tion of the river, not having been provided with draw openings. The
working plant of the Cahaba River has been transferred to the Escam-
bia and Conecuh improvement. Legislation is recommended to remove
these obstructing bridges.
   It is proposed to apply the amount on hand and the appropriation
asked for to the removal of logs and snags from the channel and over-
hanging trees from the banks and to the progressive improvement of
the river channel in conformity with the modified project which is given
in the letter of transmittal herewith, provided the existing legal impedi-
ments to the progress of this work shall be removed.
158         REPORT          OF     THE      CHIEF         OF ENGINEERS,                      U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1887, amount available .-..--......--.--- -..-
                                                  ....----....----..-------............----....------       $7, 801. 85
July 1, 1888, balance available ---------........---..........--..---..--........---......                   7,801.85
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 157, 500.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 20, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix P 14.)
   14. Alabama River, Alabama.-The plan of improvement adopted pur-
suant to an examination and partial survey of this river made under an
act of Congress approved March 3, 1875, contemplated obtaining a
channel 200 feet in width and 4 feet in depth at low water from the mouth
of the Alabama, 50 miles above Mobile, to Wetumpka, Ala., a distance
of 323 miles, by the removal of snags, logs, etc., from the channel, cut-
ting overhanging trea from the banks, protecting caving banks from
further erosion and removing rock-reefs, gravel and sand bars by blast-
ing, dredging, and works of contraction at certain specified points of
the river. The expenditure up to June 30, 1688, of $142,712.56 has re-
sulted in clearing the river channel from its mouth to Wetumpka of all
logs and snags obstructing navigation, and in maintaining this degree of
improvement. Works of contraction have been constructed to a lim-
ited extent, but it has not been practicable, with the funds available,
to keep them in repair nor to extend them or modify them as required.
For several years past operations have been almost exclusively con-
fined to the removal of snags from the channel. Since the commence-
ment of work in 1878, the removal of 10,660 of these obstructions has
been reported.
July 1, 1887, amount available .....----...........----..----.........----..----......--------........ $10, 091.57
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887.................----------------------..           ,$7,804. 13
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ....................--- ....                            639. 21
                                                                                                             8, 443.34

July 1, 1888, balance available------------..........          -----....---...........----   ------------    1, 648. 23
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..........- ..............                                     20, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889                               .-...-.. ... ......     21, 648. 23

 [Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......                                     65,000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                40, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1.866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix P 15.)
   15. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering naviga-
tion.-Under authority of the Secretary of War, proposals were invited
for the removal of the wreck of the ship Bride of Lorne from the en-
trance to Pensacola Harbor, Florida, and a contract awarded August
19, 1887, at a total compensation of $2,995.
   The contractor claims that the work has been completed. But a
fragment of wreck still remains at a distance of about 458 feet from the
position of the ship. The officer in charge being of opinion that it i-
part of the same, payment has been -suspended pending the decision of
this question.
   Under authority of the Secretary of War, proposals were invited for
the removal of the bark Laigia, sunk near Quarantine Station, Pensa-
cola Harbor, and a contract awarded at a total compensation of $950.
  The work has been completed and the contractor paid in full.
  The removal of these wrecks will greatly benefit the commerce of the
port.
  (See Appendix P 16.)
                         RIVER       AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                            159
EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS FOR IMPROVEMENT, TO COMPLY WITH
REQUIREMENTS OF THE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT OF AUGUST 5, 1886.
   Under the provisions of section 6 of the river and harbor act approved
August 5, 1886, Captain Hoxie was charged with resurvey of outer and
inner bars at Pensacola, Fla., which has not yet been completed owing
to insufficient amount of the allotment practicable for this purpos(
from the appropriation for examinations and surveys made by the act.
The officer in charge, in a communication to this office dated March 7.
1888, recommended a specific appropriation of $5,000 for the purpos(
of making proper survey and examination at this locality, and his com
munication was transmitted to Congress from the War Department
March 15, 1888, and printed as House Ex. Doc. No. 226, Fiftieth Con-
gress, first session. (See also Appendix P 17.)
IMPROVEMENT OF THE HARBOR OF MOBILE, OF WARRIOR, TOMBIG-
  BEE, AND ILACK WARRIOR RIVERS, ALAEAMA, AND OF CERTAIN
  RIVERS IN MISSISSIPPI-IMPROVEMENT OF CHANNEL TO BILOXI BAY.
  Officer in charge, Maj. A. N. Damrell, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Mobile Harbor, Alabama.-The present project for the improvement
of this harbor was adopted in March, 1880, the object being to afford
a channel of entrance from the Gulf of Mexico to the city of Mobile of
200 feet width and not less than 17 feet depth at mean low water.
  The channel had originally a minimum depth of 51 feet through Choc-
taw Pass and 8 feet in Dog River Bar.
  This was deepened by dredging, under appropriations from 1826 to
1852 of $228,830.68, to 10 feet through both.
  In 1860 the channel in Choctaw Pass had shoaled to 7? feet.
  From 1870 to 1878 the channel was deepened by dredging to 13 feet,
under appropriations amounting to $401,000.
  On the piesent project the amount expended to June 30, 1887, is
8747,561.10, and resulted in obtaining a channel with a minimum width
of 140 feet and a maximum width of 300 feet, a minimum depth of 17
feet and a maximum depth of 23 feet.
  The amount expended during the fiscal year ended June 30, 1888, is
$2,281.03, and was used in construction of pile clusters to mark dredged
channel, care and preservation of boats and property, and in making
an examination to ascertain condition of dredged channel in June, 1888,
there not being sufficient money available to accomplish anything on
the improvement.
  The channel has shoaled so that now the minimum depth is 14 feet
and maximum 23 feet.
  The act of August 11, 1888, making appropriation for this harbor,
provides for continuing the improvement on enlarged project for secur-
ing a channel 23 feet deep and 280 feet wide. This channel was esti-
mated to cost $ 1,500,000. (See Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1885, page 1374.)
  The amount available and appropriation asked for is to be applied to
continuing the improvement in accordance with the modified project.
July 1,1887, amount available ..........----------------------...........------------........ --      , 438. 90
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1 1887--
                          .....-------------------               ---- ---------------..--             , 281.00

July 1, 1888, balance available .•.1---- ..-----             -     ---.       ------                   17.   58
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ....---------....----                250,000. 00
                                                                       ......------------
                                                             ....---..----
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .................                            250, 157. 84
160         REPORT          OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
                                                                         1-, 250, 000. 00     -......
S1890-..........-----------------            ------------------- ----                              500,000.00
                                                                                      --........------............
i Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
L    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix Q 1.)
  2. Black Warrior River, A labarna,from Tuscaloosa to Daniels Creek.-
The present project for the improvement of this section of the river was
adopted in 1886, the object being to afford a water-way for the transpor-
tation of coal in barges from the Warrior coal fields to the Gulf of
Mexico.
   The present natural channel is only navigable during very high water,
and is even then extremely dangerous.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $5,150.02, and resulted
in completion of a survey for preparation of plans and estimates for
doing the work, the final adoption of plans, and in commencing a sur-
vey for purchase of lands for lock-sites, etc.
  The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is
$6,495.33, and resulted in completing the survey for purchase of land
for lock-sites, etc., and in making preparations for commencing the work
of constructing Lock No. 1 by hired labor and purchase of materials by
contract as far as possible.
  After careful revision by the officer in charge, the estimate of the cost
of this improvement has been increased to $741,670.
  The amount available and that asked for will be applied to the con-
struction of the locks and dams, beginning with Lock No. 1.
July 1, 1887, amount available....--- ----....--......   ....----....--........----...---..                  $101, 099. 98
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ....--...............------
                                               ----------------....----.... ....------------....------......     6, 495. ?3
                              ......----..............---.............---....
July 1, 1888, balance available--                                                                           94,604. 6
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888........--------------....--.... ----....---.....             100, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ....................
                                                                  - -                                      194,604.65

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...     _ _ 539, 420. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 300, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix Q 2.)
   3. Warrior and Tombigbee rivers Alabama, and Mississippi.-a. War-
rior River, Alabama.-The present project for the improve ment of this
river was adopted in 1875, the object being to obtain a channel 4 feet
deep and 80 feet wide at ordinary low water from its junction with the
Tombigbee up to Tuscaloosa.
   The channel at that time was not navigable at low water and was
much obstructed at a medium stage.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was about $99,145.42 (exact
figures can not be given for the years 1875-1882, inclusive; the appro-
priation was made for the Warrior and Tombigbee rivers jointly, with-
out any special allotment for each, and therefore no separate account
was kept), and resulted in obtaining a channel safely and easily navi-
gable at a stage of water fully 3 feet lower than was formerly practica-
ble, enabling boats of 3 feet draught to run when the water is 1 foot
above ordinary low water.
   The amount of $16,910 was expended during the fi scal year ending
June 30, 1888, in a survey of the river andl the preservation of the im -
                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                              161
provement previouslymadeof 42 miles of river from a point one-half mile
above the mouth to a point one-half mile below Millwood.
July 1, 1887, amount available ......------------......----------------......----......------......-......-......   $17,242.96
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1887---.                    .....   ......      .....   ...... ......----..........--- .      16,940. 00

July 1, 1888, balance available..........................................----------                                     302. 96
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188...........................                                              18, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                            18, 302.96


   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                         17, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Q 3.)
   b. Tombigbee River, Alabama, from Walker's Bridge to _Fulton.-This
is a new work. To comply with the requirements of the river and har-
bor act of August 5, 1886, a preliminary examination and survey were
made of the " Tombigbee River to ascertain what improvement is nec-
essary to make said river continuously navigable from Vienna, Ala.,
to Walker's Bridge, Mississippi," and the report thereon accompanies
this report as Appendix Q 10.
   The proposed improvement contemplates the removal of snags and
overhanging trees to obtain a high water channel from Walker's Bridge
to the mouth, at an estimated cost of $11,000.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $4,000 for
this work, and a further sum of $4,000 may be profitably expended in
continuing it during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..-----......................--.                                        $4,000.00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project -..-                                                7,000.00
  Amount that can bo profitabiy expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                          4,000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   c. Tombigbee River from Fulton to Vienna.-The project for the im-
provement of the river between Columbus and Fulton was adopted in
1873, the object being to give a good high-water navigation throughout
by the removal of snags and overhanging trees.
   The channel before improvement was not navigable at all from Ful-
ton down to Cotton Gin Port. From Cotton Gin Port down to Aber-
deen, about 35 miles, it was navigable for small barges carrying about
125 bales of cotton. From Aberdeen to Columbus, about 65 miles, nav-
igation was difficult when the river was 12 feet above ordinary low
water.
   The project for the improvement of the portion of the river between
Columbus and Vienna was adopted in 1879, the object being to afford
a channel of navigable width 3 feet deep during ordinary low water.
   Before the improvement was commenced the channel was much ob-
structed by snags and overhanging trees, and there was only 1 foot of
water on some of the bars during ordinary low water.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was about $72,098.76 (exact
figures can not be given for reasons stated in Warrior River Report),
and resulted in the completion of the proposed improvement (during
the year 1886 in preservation of improvement already obtained) of that
section of the river from Fulton down to Columbus, and in giving such a
channel from Columbus down to Vienna that navigation was possible
        ENG 88-11
162       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

on a 2-foot rise for boats drawing 3 feet, and the accomplishment of
over one-half of the work projected.
  The amount of $6,552.62 was expended during the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1888, and resulted in the preservation of the improvement
previously made by contract of 25 miles of the river from Rodgers
Fields to Hancocks.
  The amount available and the appropriation asked for are to be ex-
pended in continuing the improvement as projected, and it is expected
will complete it.
July 1, 1887, amount available .__..--..--...    ....---.........................                       $7, 451. 29
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887..     --........ --....---.. ---....     .- ---..--..-..                      6,552.6
July 1, 1888, balance available ....--.......--                --..........--......---....      ---.       898.67
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888............---------------.... ....             .... .     6, 500. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .                  .....---........                7, 398. 67

   (See Appendix Q 3.)
   d. Tombigbee River, below Vienna.-The project for the improvement
of this portion of the river was adopted in 1879, the object being to afford
a channel of navigable width and 4 feet depth at ordinary low water from
the mouth up to D)emopolis, and 3 feet deep from DI)emopolis iup to Vi-
enna.
   Before the improvement was commenced the river was navigable from
the mouth up to Bladen Springs, 143 miles above Mobile, during the
entire year, but was obstructed by snags. From Bladen Springs up to
Demopolis, 243 miles above Mobile, navigation was suspended about
two months yearly during low water.
   From Demopolis up to Vienna the channel was much obstructed by
snags and overhanging trees, and the water was so shoal on the bars
that navigation was only attempted on a considerable rise. A railroad
bridge at Jones's Bluff also gave considerable trouble.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was about $95,696.59 (exact
figures can not be given, for reasons stated in Warrior River report),
and resulted in obtaining an unobstructed channel with 3 feet depth of
water from the mouth up to Tompkins Bluff, 197 miles above Mobile,
with 2 feet depth up to Kirkpatrick's, 260 miles above Mobile, and 1
foot depth (all at ordinary low water) up to Vienna, and in defraying
expense of watching and caring for the public property, and on a sur-
vey. A considerable portion of the sum has been used in preservation
of the improvement previously made.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is
$10,762.72, and resulted in the preservation of the improvement of 471
miles of river between Bee Tree Bar and Singleton by contract.
   The amount available and the appropriation asked for are to be ex-
pended in continuing the improvement according to the project adopted,
and will probably complete it.
July 1, 1887, amount available........--- ..... ... ........        ...... .....-----. 10, 864. 98
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887----...----------------------.-------------............      10,762.72
                                ----...............
July 1, 1888, balance available .                   . ....---- ..........                    ......         102. 26
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888....... .... .........                              ....    6, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889- .-.....--- ....--....                     ....    6, 102. 26
                          RIVER AND HARBOR                        IMPROVEMENTS.                              163

   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                           6, 900. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix Q 3.)
   4. Noxubee River, illississippi.-The present I)roject for the improve-
ment of this river was adopted in 1880, the object being to afford a
channel for small river steamers from its mouth up to Macon, Miss., of
navigable width and depth during about nine months of the year, or
when the water is above ordinary low-water stage.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $38,679.95, and resulted
in obtaining a channel partially improved from the mouth of the river
up to Macon, and a wholly improved channel (according to project) from
Macon down to a point 28 miles below and from the mouth of the river
to a point 30, miles above, giving a river 582 miles wholly improved
and 33 miles partially improved. The amount expended during the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is $4,783.85, and resulted in the full
improvement of 7 miles of river from a point 28 miles to a point 35 miles
below Macon, so that there is now 65N miles wholly and 26 miles par-
tially improved.
   Such obstructions as had lodged during the last high water in that
part of the river from Macon down wholly improved up to June 30, 1887,
were removed.
July 1, 1887, amount available..                   -....--............ ..-----....--         --- ...    6, 320. 05
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887------------
                         ....                             -          .--..------......------
                                       ----..-..--..------............             ....------....       4, 783. 85

                                          .........--------------...-....-..--....---......-....----
July 1, 1888, balance available...-----...----                                                         1,536. 20
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..........---- ...............                            5, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30,1889.....-----.........---------...---..-.             6,536.20


  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year endling June 30, 1890                          10, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Q 4.)
    5. Pascagoula River, Mississippi.-The present project for the im-
p>rovement of this river was adopted in 1886, the object being to afford
a channel of navigable width and minimum depth of 12 feet at mean
low water from Moss Point to the anchorage in the bay, and to main-
tain the river above Moss Point in its improved condition.
    The channel before the improvement commenced had a least depth
of 3 feet. This was increased to 7, feet, with a width of 180 feet, by
dredging, from 1878-1880, at a cost of about $45,000.
    From the light-house near the mouth of the river throughout the en-
tire length, there is a navigable channel, obtained by the removal of
snags and overhanging trees, from 1881 to 1884, inclusive, at a cost of
about $15,000.
    The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is
$23,117.70, and resulted in obtaining a channel, by dredging through
the bar at the mouth of the river, with a minimum width of 135 feet
and a maximum width of 205 feet, and a minimum depth of 9.5 feet at
mean low water.
   The officer in charge reports that it has feen necessary to increase
the estimate for the completio of this work owing to the hardness of
a portion of the material to be dredged.
164          REPORT- OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The amount available and the appropriation asked for are to be ex-
pended in the further improvement of the channel according to pro-
ject, and in the removal of such obstructions in the river above Moss
Point as have lodged during the suspension of the work.
July 1, 1887, amount available-----.........              ...........             ..       --....--.......... $23, 605.25
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887-..----.......--------......................---...---...-------------..---..----.    23,117.70
July 1, 1888, balance available...............----- ..-.... ....                                   --............ 487.55
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ...-.--.      -                                -- -- ---         27, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ..........                               .... ....       27, 487. 55


   Amount that canbe profitable expended in fiscal year ending June30, 1890                                    50, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Q 5.)
  6. Harbor at Biloxi, Mississippi.-The present project for the im-
provement of this harbor was adopted in 1882, the object being to af-
ford a channel of entrance from Mississippi Sound to the wharves at
Biloxi, of navigable width and 8 feet deep. The channel before was
41 feet deep at the shoalest part.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $976.36, and resulted
in making a survey of the bar from Mississippi Sound to Biloxi, for the
purpose of locating the proposed channel.
  The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is
$16,177.05, and resulted in dredging a channel 8 feet deep throughout
at mean low tide, and 126 feet wide from the 8-foot curve outside in
Mississippi Sound, for a distance of 2,150 feet, thence 84 feet wide for
a further distance of 2,000 feet, and thence 124 feet wide a further dis-
tance of 1,030 feet to the 8-foot curve in Biloxi Bay.
July 1, 1887, amount available........ ....            ----......---..................   ---------- $16, 523.64
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 .....----...------------------------.........----......-------..................---. 16,177. 05
July 1, 1888, balance available ......-------......----..----------... ..........--------...--.......---...        346. 59
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 . ......                                       - - ....... - .
                                                                                       -......-                18, 500. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...................----18,                                    846. 59


   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 19, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Q 6.)
  7. Pearl River, Mississippi, between Edinburgh and Carthage.--The
project for the improvement of this portion of the river was adopted in
1884, the object being to obtain a good high-water channel throughout
for the use of steamers during six or eight months of the year.
  Before the improvement was commenced navigation was only possi-
ble during very high water, and was even then troublesome.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $3,637.04, and resulted
in such improvement of the whole distance as to permit of the passage
of steam-boats of 3- feet draught with comparative ease and safety on
a rise of 5 feet above ordinary low water.
  The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is
$1,058.59, and resulted in the fiull improvement of this portion of the
                          RIVER        AND       HARBOR          IMPROVEMENTS.                                   165
river, from Edinburgh to Carthage, 244 miles, so that boats of 3) feet
draught can navigate safely on a rise of 5 feet above ordinary low
water.
                                                                             -----
July 1, 1887, amount available..--.....----..--......----.......................                            1,113.51
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.............................................-- ---- ----.                        1, 058. 59

July 1, 1888, balance available -------..----.--....................---------                ----............
                                                                                   ..---...----                   54. 92
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...-...-- -                                   . -
                                                                                ...-- ---...-          ..     5, 000. 00
                                                                  ---    ---
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ..---..--......---......                              5,054.92
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project---.---. -5, 964.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 6,000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Q 7.)
   8. Pearl River, Mississippi from Jackson to Carthage.-The present
project for the improvement of this portion of the river was adopted in
1880, the object being to obtain a channel of 5 feet depth and of naviga-
ble width throughout.
   Before the improvement was commenced navigation, even during high
water, was difficult on account of snags and overhanging trees.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $18,769.40, and resulted
in such improvement of 59 miles of river from Carthage down to Par-
tins Bluff, that boats of 3 feet draught of water can navigate this dis-
tance on a 4-foot rise above ordinary low water.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is
$1,979.62, and resulted in the improvement of 62 miles of river from
Carthage down to a point 1 mile below Harvey's Bluff, so that light-
draught boats can navigate this distance with comparative safety on
a 3-foot rise above ordinary low water.
July 1, 1887, amount available..--...-------..-                                       -....--
                                                                                     ....-
                                                 ---....--..--...---.----....--..---..     -----          $1,980. 60
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ......-------------------......................-------------------....           1, 979.62
July 1, 1888, balance available ......................-----------------..-- ------                                  .98
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188                        .. ..... .... ......       ....         2, 500. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                   2,500.98

IAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......--                                26, 500. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                5, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix Q 8.)
  9. Pearl River, Mississippi, below Jackson.-The present project for
the improvement of this portion of the river was adopted in 1880, the
object being to obtain a channel 5 feet deep at ordinary low water and
of navigable width from the moutl of the river up to Jackson.
   Before the improvement the river was not navigable at all at low
water and was difficult at high water.
  The amount expended on the work to Junue 30, 1887, was $87,307.50,
and resulted in the complete improvement of that section of the river
from the head of the cut-off near the head of West Pearl River down
to the mouth at the Rigolets, a distance of 51 miles, and the partial im-
prvement of the river from Jackson downi to the cut-off, a distance of
264 miles.
  The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is
16 6         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

$4,807.95, and resulted in the closing of Farr Slough, situated 23 miles
above the New Orleans and North Easton Railroad Bridge.
July 1, 1887, amount available................-...... ....... ..........                               $4,817.50
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 .... -.... --..
                                      ..........   ....  ................                               4, 807.95
July 1, 1888, balance available ..........--------...........................                                9.55
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ..........................                               15, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.........----                      --..........   15,009.55
    Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .-...... 55, 000.00
    Amount that can be proitablly expended in fiscal year ending Julne 30,1890                         30, 000.00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix Q 9.)
EXAMINATION AN)D SURVEY FOR IMPROVEMENT) TO COMPLY WITH
  REQUIREMENTS OF TIIE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT OF AUGUST 5,
     1886.
  It appearing, after preliminary examination by the local engineer,
that the locality was worthy of improvement, Major Damrell was
charged with survey of the Tombigbee River to ascertain what improve-
ment is necessary to make said river continuously navigable from Vienna,
Ala., to Walker's Bridge, Miss., the results of which are still incomplete,
but will be submitted when received.
  For preliminary report on this survey see Appendix Q 10.
INSPECTION OF               THE      IMPROVEMENT OF THE                         SOUTH        PASS OF THE
                                       MISSISSIPPI RIVER.

  Inspecting officers, Maj. W. H. Heuer, Corps of Engineers, to Octo-
ber 31, 1887, and Capt. W. L. Fisk, Corps of Engineers, since that date.
  The inspecting officer inhis annual report states that the channel re-
quired by law, viz, " through the jetties " at the mouth of South Pass
S26 feet in depth, not less than 200 feet in width at the bottom, and
having through it a-central depth of 30 feet without regard to width,"
also " a channel having a navigable depth of 26 feet" through the shoal
                                           1
at the head of the pass, and ' through the pass itself," has been main-
tained throughout the year. No dredging has been done in the jetties,
pass, or vicinity since February, 1883.
   The channel beyond the jetties is somewhat better than last year, be-
ing 250 feet wide between thel 26-foot contours and 110 feet between
the 30-foot contours, instead of 210 feet and 60 feet, respectively.
   Over the fan-shaped area beyond the ends of the jetties, embracing
1    square miles, the deposit has averaged .31 foot, or an aggregate fill
of 400,000 cubic yards.
  No vessels have been aground in the pass or jetties during the year,
although the channel has been no better than last year.
July 1, 1887. amount available------------------------------.........................-------............. $1,502. 39
Amount appropriated by act of March 30, 1888............-........-                                   .... 8,800. 00
                                                                                                       10, 302. 39
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ..----------------------------------------                                  10,297. 98
July 1, 1883, balaice available ............ ........- ---..... .. --.....                                  4.41
Amrount appropriatedl by act of August 11, 188 .--..--   ...-.............                             10,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...............                                  10,004. 41
     (See Appendix R.)
                     RIVER       AND      HARBOR   IMPROVEMENTS.                   167
IMPROVEMENT OF VARIOUS WATER-COURSES IN THE STATE OF LOU-
  ISIANA, AND OF BAYOU PIERRE, MISSISSIPPI--IMPROVE1VENT OF
  SABINE PASS, TEXAS.

  Officers in charge, Maj. W. H. Heuer, Corps of Engineers, until Octo-
ber 31, 1887; since which date Capt. V. L. Fisk, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Tchefuncte River and Bogue Falia,Louisiana.-The river isnaviga-
ble for steamers drawing 5 feet to Old Landing, about 10 or 12 miles
above its mouth, and then for lighter-draught schooners to Covington,
about 2 miles further up on the Bogue Falia. The bar at the mouth of
the river had a depth of 41 feet on it at the lowest stage of the water.
The project for the improvement of the river was made in 1880, and
contemplated the removal of overhanging trees, logs, etc., in channel,
and the dredging of the bar at its mouth.
   The obstructions, such as overhanging trees, logs in bed, etc., were
removed, but the bar at the mouth was not dredged, as it would be
likely to reform.
   To prevent this, or retard its reformation, the officer in charge in 1884
recommended the building of a breakwater, extending into the lake for
2,500 feet and then dredging a channel through the bar.
   With the two appropriations of $1,500 each, made in 1881 and 1882,
the obstructions below Covington were removed. Part of the unex-
pended balance was used for the construction of the breakwater extend-
ing 820 feet into the lake.
   The original estimated cost of improving the river was $5,460, but
this did not include building a breakwater across the bar. The project,
as modified in 1884, is estimated to cost $20,400. This has not yet re-
ceived the sanction of Congress.
   At the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, $3,000 had been
expended on this improvement, at which time the navigation had been
improved for schooners to Covington in consequence of removal of
snags and overhanging trees, and it is thought that the breakwater has
retarded the drift of sand on the bar at the river's mouth.
   Twenty-five hundred dollars was appropriated by Congress in August,
1886, to improve Bogue Falia, between Old Landing and Covington.
Early in 1887 operations began, and channels were cut through the bars
in this stretch of bayou 5 feet in depth and 30 to 60 feet wide, giving
better navigation to schooners to and from Covington.
   To carry out the project for making the mouth of the Tchefuncte a
harbor of refuge, $19,000 will be required.
   Otherwise no money for the further improvement of this stream
during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, is required.
                                                                                $727. 13
July 1, 1887, amount available .--..--..---.............----.......---- -..........
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
outstanding July 1, 1887.......----------....                                600.00
                                                          ---..--...--......----..............

July 1, 1888, balance available ...............................-.........        127.13
  (See Appendix S 1.)
  2. Tickfaw River and its tributaries,Louisiana.-In1879 Congress au-
thorized an examination of this river. A project was submitted in 1881
to clean out the river and its navigable branches-the Natalbany,
Blood, and Ponchatoula rivers--by removing logs, snags, trees, etc., at
an estimated cost of $10,230.
   In 1881-'82-'8(; Congress made aplpropriationls aggregating $6,000,
anmd 20 miles of etl6 Ticlkfaw a Id the Natall):, to(Spriigfield, the head
168          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

of navigation, have been improved. Work was also done on the Pon-
chatoula as far as it was thought advisable.
   The Blood River was also cleaned out as far as navigable. Only a
little wood and some saw-logs are carried or floated on this stream.
   The improvement is not permanent, as obstructions will reform in all
these streams.
   The work has been completed in accordance with the original project.
The officer in charge calls attention to the fact that most of the obstruc-
tions in these rivers are caused by the careless felling of trees for lum-
ber.
July 1, 1887, amount available           ....------....-----......
                                       --------                       ..... ------......------.....------.....    $290.04
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887--..--....--.--..-------........................----------- -..---.....---               120. 00
July 1, 1888, balance available-----.............--- --------..--.........--------------............      170.04
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188-......             - ----        .- - -- -- -.............----.
                                                                                                       1, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ..........                                  ........       1, 170. 04
       (See Appendix S 3.)
   3. Amite River, Louisiana.-Before improvement the river was ob-
structed by snags, sunkenlogs, and trees. One or two small steam-boats
and a few sailing vessels were employed in the commerce of the river. In
1880 a project was made to remove obstructions above Bayou Manchac,
so as to get 5 feet depth, as far as appropriations would permit. Eight
thousand dollars was apprqpriated, and the improvement of 40 miles
of river above Bayou Manchac was contracted for. The work was of
little benefit to commerce. In 1881 $5,000 more was appropriated to
continue the work. In 1883 the project was modified so as to improve
the river below Bayou Manchac, and work was done upon about 8 miles
of the river.
   In 1886 $2,000 more was appropriated to continue the improvement.
This was applied to that portion of the river below Bayou Manchac,
and principally between there and Port Vincent. Work was resumed
in November, 1886, and completed in January, 1887, and the channel
cleared.
   The improvement is not a permanent one, as new obstructions will
form from the caving banks.
   The estimated annual expenses of cleaning out this stream is $2,000.
   The original estimated cost of the work was $23,760; of which $15,000
has been appropriated and $14,666.67 spent.
July 1, 1887, amount available. ---.......                       .............                        ....        $333. 33

July 1, 1888, balance available...                 ........................................                        333. 33
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.........................                                           5, 000. 00


 {Amountfiscal
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ....................
          (estimated) required for completion of existing project........
  Amount that can be profitably expended in      year endiug June 30,1890
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                                                 5,333. 33
                                                                                                                 6,260. 00
                                                                                                                 6, 300.00
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix S 4.)
   4. Bayou La IFourche, Louisiana.-The natural channel was much ob-
structed by snags, overhanging trees, shoals, and wrecks. The original
project, adopted in 1879, had for its object the removal of these obstruc-
tions.
   The amount expended on this work up to end of fiscal year ending
June 30, 1884, was $24,998.24.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                    169
  The amount expended during fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, was
$3,756.21 for care of property, gauge-readings, and continuing im-
provement. Much relief has been given to commerce by removal of
snags, etc.
  The project adopted is that for the canalizing of the bayou, connect-
ing it,with the Mississippi by a lock at its head. This improvement is
estimated as costing $450,000, with $31,000 annual expense of main-
tenance, this including $22,500 interest on original cost of $450,000 at 5
per cent.
July 1, 1887, amount available                .......-------..----....--....--....--....---..-...----..--..               $79. 61

July 1, 1888, balance available ......                         ..........----..
                                 ------.......... ,------....---....                   79. 61
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188         --.........................- 50, 000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .....-......-..-                                            ..   50, 079. 61

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.---- ---. 400, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30, 1890 100, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix S 5.)
   5. Bayou Terrebonne, Louisiana.-This work was examined by di-
rection of Congress in 1879. The estimated, cost of the improvement
was $18,800, afterwards increased to $38,800, and was to consist of
dredging a channel 4 feet deep, and clearing out all obstructions to
Iounma, La.
  The following amounts have been appropriated by Congress : in 1880,
$10,000; in 1881, $8,800; in 1882, $7,000; 1886, $10,000; total, $35,800.
  When this work was commenced in 1880, the Bayou Terrebonne, in
many places, was but little more than a drainage ditch, being but 11
feet wide where the dredge commenced work. The first 7, miles of
dredging terminated about 151 miles below Houma.
   In 1882, work was resumed and continued to within about 10} miles
of Houma. In 1886, work was again resumed, and during the fiscal
year 1886-'87, the channel was lengthened 4.1 miles. The dredge con-
tinuing work until December 17, 1887, carried the channel to the rail-
road depoatat Houma and there dug a turning-basin, which completes
the work according to the approved project and within the estimated
cost, viz, $3,000.
   To maintain will require annual dredging at an estimated cost of
$1,000.
July 1, 1887, amount available ........................----...----..-----.....------....--..                           $3, 891. 13
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ..............................................                                               3, 371.46
July 1, 1888, balance available-------
                                  .----................------               ......-....------......--------....            519. 67
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ......                                ...     .....-.......               3, OO. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .........-........                                               3,519. 67
   (See Appendix S 6.)
  6. Bayou Plaqueminc,Louisiana.-Thisis a new work. To comply with
the requirements of the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, a pre-
liminary examination and survey were made of the mouth of Plaque-
mine, with a view to its connection with the Mississippi River by locks
and also Bayou Plaquemine and other connecting streams to form the
best route to Grand Lake, Louisiana. The report of the result of the sur-
vey is printed in Senate Ex. Doc. No. 21, Forty-ninth Congress, second
170        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

session, and also as Appendix S 21, of the Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1887.
  The proposed project provides for the opening of the water route,
indicated by removal of snags and dredging, and constructing a lock
at the mouth of Bayou Plaquemine at an estimated cost of $1,708,250.
  The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $100,000
for this' work, and a further sum of $200,000 may be profitably ex-
pended in continuing it during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ......................                              -100,         000.00
(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... 1, 608.250.00
I Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 3:0,
S1890 .......----------......................................................
                                                           ---------          200,000.00
I Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river
.   andharbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   7. Bayou Courtableau,Louisiana.-An examination was made of this
stream in 1879. The estimated cost of improving it below Port Barre
was $40,000.
   In June, 1880, Congress appropriated $7,500 to commence work, the
project being to close some of the bayous that at high water ran from
the Courtableau and thus force all         wate flowing out of the bayou
                                   all the water
over the Little Devil Bar at its mouth.
   After this bar was removed, locks and dams were to be constructed
so as to give slackwater navigation to Washington, La. In 1883, this
estimate was increased to $78.500, and provided for a masonry instead of
a timber lock.
   In 1882 one dam was built on the Big Fordoche, another in the Little
Fordoche, and trees were slashed in some of the smaller bayous with a
view to checking the flow of water through them. The effect was to in-
crease the depth of water over Little Devil Bar.
   In 1884 one of the dams was cut and Little Devil Bar reformed. In
1885 this dam was rebuilt and the other dam which was damaged was
repaired.
   In 1886, these two dams.were again repaired and another was nearly
completed in Bayou English.
   A sudden rise in the Atchafalaya prevented the work from being con-
tinued and a portion of the last was destroyed.
   During the fiscal year 1887-'88, the Bayou English dam was repaired
and completed, Bayou Mamzelle was closed, and the wings of the dam
closing the Big Fordoche were repaired. At the time work ceased, early
in November last, the bar was cutting out rapidly, there being then a
channel of 3 to 5 feet, while when work begun there was one of but a
few inches. However, at that time the closure of Old River prevented
any communication with the Mississippi River.
   Recent inquiry leads to the belief that the dams are all in good con-
dition at this time, but the back water from the Atchafallaya is so high
that nothing is known regarding the present condition of the bar.
   It will be useless to attempt any work on lock construction until Little
Devil Bar is gotten rid of.
   The estimate for closing the bayous is $7,107.90.
July 1, 1887, amount available............ .........................                                         $2, 902. 16
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstandiig Suly 1, 1887--..-------.................--.......--.----.....---..--......-
                                                                                       -----..... --          2,571.29
                                .........................................----------.
July 1, 1888, balance available----                                                                             330.87
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .. . . -...........                                             5,000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .................                                .5,      330.87
                        RIVER AND HARBOR                   IMPROVEMENTS.                                    171
                                                                         ---- $7,107.90
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project----........
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                            7, 000.00
  Submitted ii compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix S 10.)
   8. Calcasieu River and Pass, Louisiana.-In1874 and again in 1882-'83
dredged channels were cut through the flats in Calcasieu Lake above
Calcasieu Pass.
   The dredged channel was 8 feet deep and 70 feet wide by 7,500 feet
long.
   In 1885 this channel had again shoaled to a depth of 31 feet and
needed redredging, but an unfortunate wording of the appropriation,
 " Improving Calcasieu River," prevented its application to this work.
In 1886 this was remedied, and funds heretofore appropriated for Cal-
casieu River became available for both the pass and the river. Con-
tracts were made in 1886 for building two lines of piles and planking
about 120 feet apart and a mile or more in length, between which a
channel 100 feet in width and 6 feet in depth was to be dredged, and the
excavated material thrown outside of the lines of the piles.
   The excavation of a channel 100 feet wide and 6 feet deep through a
bar at the junction of the river and lake was included in the contracts.
   Work was commenced on the lines of piles and planking in the winter
of 1886. In the spring of 1887 operations were resumed and the pile-
work and planking partially completed, when the contract was annulled
January 3, 1888.
   During this long delay the revetment was badly damaged by the te-
redo, and this showing the life of timber to be so short in that locality
it was proposed to modify the project so far as to omit the revetment.
   This was approved by the Chief of Engineers, January 12, 1888, and
authority given to do the work with Government plant.
   Under this authority work was begun in March, and is now progress-
ing satisfactorily.
   The results will not be permanent, but it is thought that the improve-
ment on the lower bar will last much longer' than heretofore.
July 1, 1887, amount availabl ....-------....--    -- -----.....--........----.
                                             -....--...........       $17, 2:31.37
Forfeited to United States by annullment of contract
                                                  --.....-----.......       14.43
                                                                                                      17, 245. 80
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887-          --   --    -             .----- $10, 376. 28
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ...................-------------------             632. 80
                                                                                                      11, 009. 08

July 1, 1888, balance available..........--------..--....- ---------..--...--------......--- ----....
                                                                                                  6, 236.72
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888....-...-
                                                 ---- ........ .....                            ...   10, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889..--                      --------......         16,236.72
   (See Appendix S 11.)
  9. Bayou Pierre, Mlississippi.--Te preliminary examination of this
bayou was authorized by Congress and made in 1884.
  A full report of the examination was published in the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1885.
  Part of the bayou was deemed worthy of partial improvement by the
removal of logs, snags, and overhanging trees. In August, 1886, Con-
gress appropriated $5,000 for this work. With this money the snag-
boat formerly in use on the Tech6 improvement, then no longer required
for that work, was put in thorough repair ad used for cleaning out the
bayou,
172          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY

  The channel contemplated in the project has been completed.
  The improvement made will not be permament, as the same kind of
obstructions are likely to reform at any time.
July 1, 1887, amount available .........................                     ......  ....                                $1,052.64
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ..............             ......................------......                                   1,034.22
July 1, 1888, balance available ------..--..---....--..------.........-------................                                 18.42
    (See Appendix S 12.)
    10. Sabine Pass, Texas.-The object of this improvement is to obtain
deep water at this locality so as to give an outlet to the products of eastern
Texas and western Louisiana, and give a good harbor on the Gulf Coast.
Dredging was done here in 1878 and 1880, but the excavated channels re-
filled. In 1882 a project was made to get deep water by means of two
jetties of brush and stone, and to dredge between them if found neces-
sary, the estimated total cost of the work being $3,177,606.50.        The fol-
lowing appropriations were made: August, 1882, $150,000; July, 1884,
$200,000; Auguit, 1886, $198,750.
    Work was commenced in 1883, and has continued since, when funds
would permit.
   The west jetty was built out continuously from the shore to a length
of a little more than 3 miles, but was only completed to mean high-tide
level for a length of 7,270 feet.
   The greater part of the foundation course of the outer mile of this jetty
has since been destroyed by the sea, in the absence of funds to properly
protect it against damage. The other, or east jetty, foundation course
is now 14,410 feet in length, measured from the shore end, and is prac-
tically completed up to high-water level for 14,100 feet of this length.
   All the work during the past year has been confined to raising and ex-
tending this jetty. The depth of water originally on the bar was 61
feet; the last survey shows the least depth to be 84 feet, which is a slight
improvement since the last report. Work under the last contract was
completed August 4, 1887, when the survey above referred to was made.
July 1, 1887, amount available                              .......................................                     $41,081.23
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.------...........-----...------......----------..------.........-------.....                  39,277.00
July 1, 1888, balance available ....................................                                               ..     1, 804.23
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888....                                          ................-----   .    250, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889---
                                                     .... ..------..........                                            251, 804.23
 (Amount required for completion of existing project .. ...--                                              ...... 2, 051, 000. 00
I Amount that can be profitably expended in the fiscal year ending June
     30,1890 .........--------------.........--------------...............................--------------.....
                                                                                                   ---       ----- 500, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix S 15.)

IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS                             AND        HARBORS IN                          THE STATE OF TEXAS.

  Officer in charge, Maj. O. H. Ernst, Corps of Engineers, having under
his immediate orders First Lieut. Geo. A. Zinn, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Entrance to Galveston Harbor, Texas.-The present project for the
improvement of this locality was adopted in 1874, modified in 1880, and
again modified in 1886, the object being to deepen the channel so as to
admit sea-going vessels of the deepest draught. The natural depth
                             RIVER          AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                    173

upon the outer bar was about 12 feet at mean low tide, and upon the
inner bar about 13 feet. The amount expended during the year was
 $243,495.99. The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, including
 $100,000 subscribed in 1883 by the city of Galveston, is $1,825,278.83.
It has resulted in deepening the channel over the outer bar to about 124
feet, and that over the inner bar to about 201 feet. It is proposed dur-
ing the coming year to build the shore branch of the south jettyto con-
nect with high ground, and to extend the finished work seaward about
1 mile. During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, it is proposed to
conmplete the south jetty now under construction to the crest of the bar,
aind to build a north jetty to the same distance.
. July 1, 1887, amount available                    --....................                       ............----   .....      $296,217.16
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
   of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ......
                                            -----...........----.                                          $223, 060. 61
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities.......................                                                 20, 435. 38
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts........                                                   49,850. 04
                                                                                                                                293, 346.03

July 1, 1888, balance available ......................................                                                           2,871.13
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888........- -........       -                                            ......     500, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889....-......--                                                 ....        502, 871.13

  (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....                                                        6, 200, 000. 00
  ( Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
     30 1890..........    .......................................------ , 000, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix T 1.)
    2. Ship-channel in Galveston Bay, Texas.-The present project for this
improvement was adopted in 1871, and modified in 1877, the object
being to excavate and maintain a channel 12 feet deep and 100 feet
wide at bottom, through Galveston Bay from Bolivar Channel to Mor-
gan's Cut, a distance of about 18.33 miles. The average natural depth
of the bay was about S2 feet, with a depth in some places of about 7
feet.- The amount expended during the year was $33,099.12. The total
amount expended to June 30, 1888, is $325,022.30. It has resulted in
the excavation of a channel having an average depth of 14.feet through
Redfish Bar, a length of about 2 miles, which has maintained itself since
1883, and more recently in the excavation of a channel 12 feet deep and
100 feet wide, for a length of 11,770 feet immediately north of Bolivar
Channel.
    The estimate, $106,500, submitted for carrying on the work during
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, is the amount required to complete
the original excavation, and to maintain it one year. The work is not
capable of permanent completion. It is estimated that an annual ex-
penditure of about $80,000 will be required to maintain it, which may
be reduced to $50,000 if the Government own the plant.
July 1, 1887, amount available.---. ---....---....----..------.........--..--...--.........                                   $154,576.82
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
                                                  --
   liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ................ -...... $26, 513. 58
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ......
                                       -----....--....----....--....--..---....................                   6,585.54
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts...........                             -                    114,199.00
                                                                                                                    --          147, 298.12

July 1, 1888, balance available .........................          ------------..............                                     7,278.70
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188 .--..----..----........                                                -----......--.100, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year elnding June 30, 1889----
                                                        ...................                                                     107,278.70
174         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

rAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project, and
   maintain one year ..---.------------------------.. ---------------.$106, 500. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 106, 500.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
l harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix T 2.)
   3. Trinity River, Texas.-The present project for the improvement of
this stream was adopted in 1873, the object being to afford a navigable
channel 5 feet deep. through the bar at the mouth and up to Liberty, a
distance of 41 miles.    The natural channel through the bar at the mouth
was narrow and had a depth of but 41 feet.        A bar about 41 miles be-
low Liberty and numerous snags obstructed navigation. There were no
expenditures during the year. The total amount expended to June 30,
1888, is $34,500. It has resulted in facilitating the entrance to the river,
though the depth over the bar has not been increased. The interior
navigation was temporarily relieved by the removal of snags and of the
bar near Liberty. It is proposed during the coming year to repair and
extend the revetments at the mouth of the river, and during the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1890, to complete that work, and to deepen the
channel to 5 feet by dredging. This will complete the project so far as
it is necessary at this time. There are numerous snags in the river be-
tween Liberty and Moss Bluff, 21 miles below, but as this l)art of the
stream is rarely used, and as a new supply of these obstructions may be
expected annually, it is proposed to defer further work here indefi-
nitely.
                                                - ...............-.....-
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ....-                                   - - . $12, 500.00

  Amount (estimated)  required for completion of existing project- .- - - - --12,500. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 12. 500. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix T 3.)
   4. Buffalo Bayou, Texas.-The present project for the improvement of
this stream was adopted in 1880, the object being to straighten, widen,
and deepen the channel to a depth of 12 feet, and a width of 100 feet
at bottom, between the city of Houston and Simms's Bayou, 11 miles be-
low, and to remove such snags, stumps, and overhanging trees as were
obstructions to navigation. The natural depth was in many places not
more than 6 feet, and the channel was narrow and tortuous. The amount
expended during the year was $16,986.17. The total amount expended
to June 30, 1888, is $117,662.20. It has resulted in clearing the channel
of the most prominent snags, stumps, and overhanging trees, in easing
some of the bends, and in removing such shoals as obstructed a 7-foot
navigation. These obstructions are renewed in greater or less degree
each year. The amount required for the completion of the original ex-
cavation is estimated at $267,000, subject to revision. The project is
not capable of permanent completion.
July 1, 1887, amount available .........................................                     $18, 073.97
July 1, 1 88, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1887 - ......                  -----                ..                 16,986.17

July 1, 1888, balance available .....----------..-- ----..-....
                                                          ..-----.......----.----..------.     1, 087. 80
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ........------.......-.....--.                  25,000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ....---.... ---......
                                                                        -....            .    26, 087. 80
                                   RIVER AND                       HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                   175
I Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project subject
       to revision ......-----......-......--......----......-......-........------.                                              $242, 000.   00
     Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                                      50, 000.00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
l     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (Appendix T 4.)
  5. Mouth of Brazos River, Texas.-The advisability of a further prose-
cution of this improvement under the project adopted in 1880, being
questionable, the subject was submitted to Congress in a special report
printed in House Ex. Doc. No. 109, Fiftieth Congress, first session.
The total amount expended to June 30, 1883, is $142,098.43. It has not
resulted in any useful effect upon the bar.
July 1, 1887, amount available........................-----...............                                                         $17, 916. 06
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year exclusive of
     liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 .........................                                                   $1, 254.49
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities.... ......-----.............---                                        ----.         10.00
                                                                                                                                     1,264.49

July 1, 1888, balance available ..                                    .............................                                 16, 651.57
  (See Appendix T 5.)
  6. Pass Cavallo, inlet to MatagordaBay, Texas.--The works heretofore
constructed for the improvement of this locality have practically disap-
peared, and if resumed, must begin anew upon a new site at a largely
increased estimate of cost.    The total amount expended to June 30,
1888, is $292,050.22.   It has not resulted in any useful effect upon the
bar.
                                    ....................................
July 1, 1887, amount available......-                                                                                              $37, 404.84
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ........................                                                       $1,950. 06
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities .........................                                                            5. 00
                                                                                                                                     1,955.06
July 1, 1888, balance available ....................                                                  ........................      35, 449. 78
     (See Appendix T 6.)
   7. Aransas Pass and Bay up to Rockport and Corpus Christi, Texas.-
The present project for the improvement of this locality was adopted
in 1879 and modified in 1887, the object being to fix the position of the
pass and to provide a navigable channel at least 20 feet deep through
the bar. In its natural state the pass was moving bodily at the rate
of about 260 feet per year, and the channel depth over the bar varied
from 7 feet to 9. feet. The amount expended during the year was
$95,449.78. The total amount expended .to June 30, 1888, including
$9,938.93 subscribed in 1883 by citizens of Rockport and Corpus Christi,
is $489,006.73. It has resulted in partially checking the southwest-
ward movement of the pass. It is proposed during the coming year to
complete the protection of the southerly shore of the pass and during
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, to begin the reconstruction of the
south jetty. The amount required for the entire completion of the
project is $1,571,293.72.
July 1, 1887, amount available ....................-- .... ..----..........                                                        $97, 631.98
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
     of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 .........-..--                                                   . $72, 758.51
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ........................                                                       22, 691.27
                                                                                                                                     95, 449.78
July 1, 1888, balance available ....................                                                   ..................             2,182.20
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.----.                                                    ..........---......          100, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .................                                                            102,182.20
176         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                                     - - -$1,471, 000. 00
    (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...-
    I Amount th+t can be profitably expended              in   fiscal year ending .lJune
(                                                                       .---.    200, 000. 00
       30, 1890--....---....--....-......----.......------.......--....................------
    I Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    i harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix T 7.)
   8. Harbor at Brazos Santiago, Texas.-The present project for the
improvement of this locality was adopted in 1881, the object being to
fix the position of the channel over the bar at the entrance and to
deepen it. In its natural state the channel was shifting, and its depth
varied from 6 feet to S feet. The amount expended during the year
was $3,386.06. It was applied to a survey, recording commercial sta-
tistics, and reports. The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, is
$188,590.23 (besides an appropriation of $6,000 in 1878, applied to re-
moving a wreck). It has resulted in no useful effect upon the bar, and
the works heretofore constructed have practically disappeared. It is
proposed during the coming year to limit operations to merely keeping
a record of commercial statistics.
   The amount required for the entire completion of the project is
$1,096,000.
July 1, 1887, amount available.... ...........-----.---.                ---.----    --.   ----   $37, 295. 83
,July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887--................-----------------...    $3,381.06
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities..- ....--......----......    -                    5.00
                                                                                                   3, 386. 06
July 1, 1888, balance available...... ...... - ............... ......----..                       33,909. 77
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.... ..................                              25, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .................                   -       58, 909.77
    SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... 1,071,000. 00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
      (See Appendix T 8.)

                                    WESTERN                RIVERS.

IMPROVEMENT OF RED RIVER AND OF CERTAIN       RIVERS IN THE
  STATES OF LOUISIANA, MISSISSIPPI, AND TENNESSEE TRIBUTARY
  TO THE MISSISSIPPI-WATER-GAUGES ON THE MISSISSIPPI AND ITS
  PRINCIPAL TRIBUTARIES.

  Officer in charge, Capt. J. H. Willard, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Red River, Louisiana and Arkansas.-The present improvement
was begun in 1872. At that time navigation above Shreveport, La.,
was almost impossible on account of the great raft. Low-water navi-
gation between Shreveport and Grand .Ecore, La., was affected seriously
by the gradual enlargement of Tone's Bayou outlet, which depleted the
main channel of the river below. The entire river from Fulton, Ark.,
to its mouth was greatly obstructed by snags, sunken logs, wrecks,
leaning trees, etc., and the channel at the falls of Alexandria, La., was
insufficient for the demands of commerce.
   The project has contemplated the removal of the great raft, the
closure of Tone's Bayou, the removal of snags and other obstructions,
opening a channel through the falls at Alexandria, increasing the depth
of channel at shoal places, and improving Alexandria Harbor.
  The work from 1872 to the end of the fiscal year 1887 consisted of the
removal of the raft, preventing its reforming, and clearing the river of
                          RIVER AND HARBOR                       IMPROVEMENTS.                                 177
obstructions.   Several ineffectual attempts had been made to close
Tone's Bayou, but nothing since 1882, when the dam then under con-
struction was destroyed. The excavation at the falls of Alexandria
was practically completed. The work for the protection of Alexandria
Harbor was completed according to the project as far as the funds
available would permit. This, in connection with the dam at the lower
falls, has been of some benefit to the river bank at Alexandria. The
field work of the survey from Fulton to the mouth of the Atchafalaya
was completed between Fulton and Caspian.a. The amount expended
to June 30, 1888, was $800,158.17.
   During the fiscal year 1888 the. snag-boats lMcigs and Florence were
employed in the low-water season, the former removing obstructions
below Shreveport in August and September,. and the latter above
Shreveport in August, September, and October. The Florence was
called out again to remove jams during the floods of March and May.
Operations were limited to the above by reason of the small amount
available.
July 1, 1887, amount available ................-- ----....---............              ....-------.... $18,245.30
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ......----------------------......             ----------------              16,403. 47

July 1, 1888, balance available ...... ............                   ..........    .............          1,841.83
Amount appropriated by act of August              183  I1,         ...-. --....        -...-.. ---.       65, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1885 ........-..-                         ....-      .   66,841 83

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June:8, 1890 100, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
  harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix U 1.)
   2. Survey of Red River.-The act of August 5, 1886, in appropriating
$75,000 for Red River, provided that $25,000, or so much thereof as
may be necessary, shall be used in making a thorough survey of the river
from Fulton, Ark., to the Atchafalaya River, and in completing the survey
of Bayou Pierre, Louisiana. Of this amount $24,665.12 was expended
to June 30, 1887 (see Report of Chief of Engineers, Appendix N, page
1450).    It was estimated in this Report that an additional sum of
$35,000 would be needed to properly complete this survey, and the act
of August 11, 1888, appropriates this amount.
July 1, 1887, amount available ------..-........--......---
                               ...                          ........--...--...... $334.88
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  onstanding July 1, 1887 ................-------------..------------.................--..-.....------       334.88
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...--..--
                                                   ..... --..--..--.....                                  35, 000. 00

  3. Cypress Bayou, Texas and Louisiana.--This improvement includes
the whole navigable channel, from Shreveport, La., to Jefferson, Tex.,
via Soda and Fairy Lakes and Cypress Bayou.
  The first project consisted in cutting and dredging a high-water chan-
nel from Jefferson to Red River, which was completed in 1880.
  The act of August 5, 1886, appropriated $18,000 " to complete the
improvement." The project for application of this amount contemplated
rebuilding the dredge formerly used on this work, and by means of this
boat to straighten and mark the present channel, remove stumps there-
from, and re-open cuts by dredging.
  During the fiscal year the work in Cypress Bayou proper, which in-
cludes the principal amount of dredging, has been completed. That
       ENG 88-     12
178         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

remaining to be dlone consists in straightening and clearing the channel
of stumps through the lakes to Shreveport.
  The balance available is not sufficient for this purpose, but it is recoim-
mended that the work be continued, at a cost of $7,500.
July 1, 1887, amount available...... ........------------------....--......-- ............--...... $12, 393. 61
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  oustanding July 1, 1887     --......................---....... . ...........                                                12, 05. 32

July 1, 1888, balance available---------......---....-----------------------..                                ....   ---..          338.29


  Amounttlhat call be profitably expenu(e(l in lisc l year ending June 30, l590                                                7, 500. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requlirlnets of sections                                      2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 180(;7.
   (See Appendix U 2.)
   4. Ouachitaand Black; iRivers, Arkansas and Louisiana.-The improve-
ment of Ouachita River was begun in 1871. Black River, the connect-
ing stream between Ouachita and Rled rivers, was added under the
same head of appropriation by act of 1884. The present project con-
templates the removal of wrecks, logs, snags, leaning trees, etc., ob-
structing navigation, and the improvement of shoal places between
Camden, Ark., and the mouth of Black River.
   The amount expended under present project to June 30, 1888, was
$193,912.13. Besides the removal of obstructions, an increased depth
of from 12 inches to over 3 feet was gained at some of the shoal places.
   No funds were available for work during the past fiscal year.
   No estimate for permanent improvement can be submitted, as ob-
structions are forming continually.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 18                         -......          ..................                      $20, 000.00
SAmount that can bep rofital)ly expnded in fiscal
                                                ycar ending June 30, 1S90                                                     20, 000. 00
   Submitted iin compliance with r]equirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1860(i al 1867.
   (See Appendix U 3.)
  5. OuachitaRiver, Arkansas, abroe Camnden.-This is a new work. To
comply with the requirements of the river and harbor act of August 5,
1886, an examination (no survey being necessary) was made of the
Ouachita River above Camden, and the report thereon is printed in the
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1887, as Appendix U 27.
  The proposed improvement consists in the removal of snags, cutting
leaning timber, and building brush-dams at the shoals, at an estimated
cost of $9,000.
  The river and harbor act of August 11, 18SS, appropriates $9,000 to
complete the work.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888--.                                 .             ..         -           .       $9,   000.00

   6. Bayou D'Arbonne, Louisiana.-The project for this improvement
was adopted in 1884, and contemplates the removal of snags, logs,
wrecks, leaning trees, etc., obstructing navigation from Stein's Bluff to
the mouth, 42, miles, at an estimated cost of $15,000.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1888, was $7,000, which resulted in
the removal of obstructions from about one-halfof that part of the stream
in which improvement is contemplated.
   The small balance availale 1at the beginning of the fiscal year was
expended in removin.g obstructions flomu about 12 miles of the bayou.
  But little work is requircl in tie 29 miles above the mouth at pres-
ent, and with the amount askd for)te fiscal year ending June 30, 1890,
                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                           179
it is proposed to continue the removal of obstructions up to Stein's
Bluff.
   The work is not permanent as new obstructions are forming contin-
ually.
July 1, 1887, amount available....---.......----........... ..- ....-----.......            $669.23
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.....--. . ..- ...... ....... ...... ............                   669. 23
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188..                ... .... ...........-   .    2, 000. 00


  Amouut that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890               4, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirem ents of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix U 4.)
  7. Little River, Louisiana.-This is a new work. To comply with the
requirements of the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, a preliminary
examination (no survey being required) was made of the above stream,
and the report thereon is printed as Appendix U 30 of the Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1887.
  The contemplated improvement consists in the removal of sunken
logs and cutting away overhanging trees from Catahoula Lake to Black
River, at an estimated cost of $2,500.
  The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $2,500 for
the work.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1885.... .....................                   $2,500.00
   8. Bayou Bartholomew, Louisiana and Arkansas.-This improvement
was begun in 1881, the project contemplating the removal of wrecks,
snags, overhanging timber, etc., obstructing navigation between Bax-
ter, Ark., and the mouth, a distance estimated to be 213 miles.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1888, was $23,000. The work had
extended nearly over the entire portion of the bayou included in the pro-
.ject, and lessened the dangers of navigation greatly. But no permanent
improvement can be effected, as new obstructions are forming continu-
ally.
   During the fiscal year about 48 miles of the bayou were worked over.
July 1, 1887, amount available--.....   ------.....--..--........--. ------..- ------      1, 883. 45
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 187--....--------------...........-------.......................
                                                                               -- _--1,883.45
Amount appropriated b)y act of August 11, 1888._ ............ _ ..........                 5, 000. 00

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                6, 500. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix U 5.)
   9. Bayou Bweuf, Louisiana.-The project for improvement of this
bayou was adopted in 1880, and contemplated the removal of snags,
logs, leaning timber, etc., obstructing navigation between Wallace's
Landing and its mouth, a distance of 280 miles. An examination of
three outlets of the bayou near Point Jefferson, La., was made in 1884,
and their closure recommended at a cost of $8,500.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1888, was $15,482.75, exclusive of
existing contracts. The removal of obstructions enabled boats to run to
Point Jefferson, 19 miles below Wallace's Landing, during high water.
   In August, 1887, an agreement was made with a planter in the vicin-
ity of Point Jefferson to close the three outlets, so far as the funds
available would permit, in connetion with levee work he was perform-
180            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

ing     near
        .         .y,    Oltet             . 1.A    a      l od          1
                                                                         ndii,     o.Legun,             brt     waS   disL

continued by bad weather in December and nothing has been done since.
  It is proposed to apply the available balance to closing the outlets.
  No permanent improvement can be secured, as new obstructions are
added from time to time.
July 1, 1887, amount available----.... ...--  --......-----..-------
                                        -.......--                   ---- --....--....
                                                                                   $4,981.41
July 1, 1888, amount expendedduring iscal1year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887_ ..-......- ...-   ......         $3,138.54
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities..------...
                                              ----------                                           325.62
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts...........                                    1,320.00
                                                                                                                 4,784.16
July 1, 1888, balance available----......----..---...--------...----....------......--.......----.-------....      197.25
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...... ...... ....                                ..........        6,000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                        6,197.25
SAmount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                     5, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
      (See Appendix U 6.)
  10. Tensas River and Bayou Macon, Louisiana.-The project for im-
provement of Tensas River was adopted in 1881, and contemplated the
removal of logs, snags, leaning timber, etc., obstructing navigation from
Dallas to its mouth, about 180 miles, at an estimated cost of $23,000.
Bayou Macon, a tributary, was added under the same head of appro-
priation by act of 1884, and the project contemplates the removal of the
same class of obstructions as in Tensas from Floyd to its mouth, about
130 miles, at an estimated cost of $17,000.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1888, was $11,000, $7,000 of which
had been applied to improvement of Tensas River and the balance to
Bayou Macon.
   Operations were continued in Bayou Macon from October 13, 1887, to
the end of the month, when the funds were exhausted. The work con-
sisted principally in destroying accumulations of drift. This placed the
bayou in good condition for high and medium stages, but navigation
can be improved by removal of sunken logs, etc., from the channel.
   The work is not permanent, as new obstructions are forming continu-
ally.
July 1, 1887, amount available...... ........----.--..........     ---.
                                                           ----.......                                            $400. 39
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.................-----           --- --....--....400. 39
                                             ....--.....--..--..--..
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888- -....
                                                 -              .....---.
                                                     --...............-- 5,000.00
                                                                         -
      Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........     24,000.00
      Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year endingJ une 30, 1890 11, 000. 00
      Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
       harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix U 7.)
  11. Bayous Rondeway and Vidal, Louisiana, by removing obstructions.-
This is a new work. To comply with the requirements of the river and
harbor act of August 5, 1886, an examination was made (a survey being
unnecessary) of the bayous above referred to, and the report thereon is
printed in the Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1887, as Appendix
U 29.
  The improvement proposed is the removal of obstructions, chiefly
leaning trees, from the canal and the part of Bayou Vidal which will
remain open from the lake to the line of the levee proposed to be erected
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                           181
by State authority north of Lake Palmyra, etc., at an estimated cost of
$1,000.
  The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $1,000 for
thei work.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...                                          ...--........
                                                                                   ---- ....                    $1, 00.00
  12. Big Black River, Mlississippi.-The project for this improvement
contemplated the removal of snags, logs, wrecks, and leaning trees
obstructing navigation between the mouth and Cox's Ferry, 130 miles
above, at an estimated cost of $32,000. Such improvement can not be
permanent, as new obstructions are added from time to time.
  The first appropriation for this work, by act of 1884, was applied to
removing obstructions in the first 75 miles above the mouth. No work
has been done since.
   The appropriation inl the act of 1886 contained the following proviso:
  No part of this appropriation shall be used until the State of Missis-
sippi shall have first caused the bridges south of the Vicksburg and
Meridian Railroad to be so constructed as not to obstruct the navigation
of said stream." This requirement has not been complied with yet.
July 1, 1887, amount available .......................................------------------------------------      $5, 000. 00
July 1, 1888, balance available .--.....-.....-..---- ......-.......------.........-....---.                     5, 000. 00

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........                                      22, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix U 8.)
   13. Yazoo River, Mississippi.-Work in this river was begun in 1873
by removing the wrecks of eleven steam-boats sunk during the war.
The project contemplates the removal of wrecks, logs, snags, leaning
trees, etc., which obstruct the channel throughout the entire length of
the stream. No permanent im.provement can be effected, as each flood
brings new obstructions into the river, and others are added by sliding
banks, etc.
    The amount expended to June 30, 1888, was $157,006.56.                                                     The large
number of wrecks and natural obstructions which limited navigation of
the stream had been removed to such an extentthat the river was naviga-
ble from its head to its mouth the entire year.
  The snag-boat Mllcigs continued work during July, 1887, and was then
transferred to Red River.                       At the close of operations the river was less
obstructed and navigation safer than ever known.       An attempt was
made in September to deepen the channel over the bar at the mouth,
but the funds available being insufficient the work was abandoned.
July 1, 1887, amount available......--...----...--....--......--..--.... ---..........                          $3, 960. 45
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887---........--- ....-......---...----......--......--..--......                         2,967. 01
July 1, 1888, balance available ......
                                  --                   ......--   .   .   ......   ....   .. .....   _......       993.44
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888- ..............                              -         ......     32, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889....................                                       32, 993.44
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                   50, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of .1-66 and 1867.
   (See Appendix U 9.)
  14. Tchula Lak e, ]Mississippi.-The project for fhis improvement was
ado)pted in 1881, and conteml)lated Ihe removal of snags, logs, leaning
timber, etc., obstructing navigation , to enable light-draught steam-boats
to enter the lake earlier in the season.
182          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The amount expended to June 30, 1886, was ~9,0.22.
  No work was done during the fiscal year.
  No permanent improvement can be effected, as new obstructions are
forming continually.
July 1, 1887, amount available ....---...---.... __                ..............                                     18
                                                                                                                 ,-$519.
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887----------------..............-----.............................                        518. 40
July 1, 1888, balance available ......               .....................................                             78
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 -..-....................                                         3,000.00
                                                                                       -3,000.
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...................------------------.                            78
   Amount that canbe profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30, 1890                                    6, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix U 10.)
   15. Tallahatchee River, Mississippi.-Tlhis improvement was begun in
1879. The project contemplated the removal of snags, sunken logs,
and leaning timber obstructing low-water navigation below mouth
of Coldwater River, a distance 165 miles, and the removal of a wreck
lying in the channel 8 miles above the mouth. The estimated cost of
such improvement was $40,000.
  The amount expended under this project to June 30,1888, was $27,500,
and there had been expended above mouth of Cold water $10,000. Be-
fore improvement the river from mouth of. Coldwater to Yazoo River
was navigable about six months of the year. Boats from the Yazoo
now run to Sharkey's Landing, 100 miles above the mouth, the entire
year.
  No work was done during the past fiscal year.
   Many dangerous obstructions remain, and others, caused by sliding
and caving banks, are forming continually.
                                                                        ....----......---------....---......
July 1, 1887, amount available.-------------.....----............------------....----                            $114. 74
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887------.....................................
                                      -------------------------......                                             114.74
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 --
                                              ........
                                                 ---                                         ---- --......     5, 000. 00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                       17, 500. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                   10, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
l harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix U 12.)
   16. Steele's Bayou, Mississippi.-The lproject for this improvement con-
templates the removal of snags, logs, stumps, leaning trees, etc., ob-
structing high-water navigation.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1888, for this purpose was $4,699.20.
   Nothing was done during the fiscal year.
July 1, 1887, amount available ...--------
                                      ......------......-------.......... ........--......                       $590. 76
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887...---------------------------------------................----                          289.98
July 1, 1888, balance available----------
                                    ....-----...............---...--...---..........---.                          300. 80
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .--..... --.... --.... ....---.......                            2, 500. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 --....--..------..-.....                                 2,800.80
I Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30,1890                                     5, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (see Appendix U 13.)
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                         183
   17. Big Sunflower River, iississippi.-The project for improving this
stream was adopted in 1879, and contemplated building wing-dams to
scour a channel of from 3 feet to 40 inches over the bar, and the re-
moval of snags, sunken logs, and leaning timber obstructing naviga-
tion, at an estimated cost of $66,000.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1888, was $47,000. Obstructions
were removed and an increased depth of channel of from 18 inches to
5 feet gained at the bars where dams had been built. When work
was begun in 1879 the stream was navigable about six months in the
year. During 1885-'86 it was navigable all the year, but in 1886-'87
for about eight months only, on account of formation of new obstruc-
tions since work was stopped in January, 1885.
   The work resumed in June, 1887, was continued until August 26, when
the funds were exhausted. Obstructions were removed, and wing-dams
built at various bars, giving increased depths of channel ranging from
12 to 30 inches. Operations extended up to Faisonia, about 144 miles
above the mouth, considered ordinarily the head of navigation.
                                                           -- ---.......----------. ---- ---- ----
July 1, 1887, amount available-----....---....--- ....---...--                                               $2, 955. 16
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ----------..........-----------                 -----------..---------             2, 955.16

Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888................                              - - -..........    5,000.00

  Amount that can be rofitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                   10, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix U 14.)
  18. Big Hatchee River, Tennessee.-This improvement was begun in
1880. The project contemplated the removal of logs, snags, leaning
timber, etc., obstructing navigation from Bolivar, Tenn., to the mouth,
about 240 miles, to render that portion of the river navigable for light-
draught boats throughout the year. The improvement will not be
permanent, as new obstructions form from time to time.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1888, was $22,000.
  No work was done during the fiscal year.
  Economy would be subserved by expending in one season an amount
sufficient to clear the river of obstructions, so as not to require further
work for several years. Five thousand dollars can be applied profitably
to this purpose during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
July 1, 1887, amount available..-------..---...--......----.....---...--................                        $64.54
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                                  .-----....--.........-----......----.....---------......--- ....----.
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ......--                                                                               64.54
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..... - -- ......
                                                          - ......                             -
                                                                                               ....-          5, 000. 00

   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending Juno 30, 1890                                 5, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and har-
    bor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix U 15.)
   19. ForkedDeerRiver, Tennessee.--This improvement was begun in 1883.
The project contemplated the removal of snags, logs, leaning timber,
etc., obstructing navigation from the mouth to Sharon, about 114 miles
above, at an estimated cost of $19,250. Operations, however, have been
extended to Jackson, the head of navigation, 81 miles above Sharon.
The work will not be permanent, as obstructions are added from time
to time,
184           REPORT OF THE CHIEF                                OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The amount expended on the South Fork to June 30, 1888, was
$10,000.
  No work was done during the fiscal year.
   The obstructed condition of the main Forked Deer River prevents
navigation of South Fork at least three months of the year.
  The sum of $10,000 can be expended profitably in one season's work
in these streams.
July 1, 1887, amount available......--......                       ......--------....-        ...............            $117.24
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887............................................--------------------------------------------..      117.24
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.-..........---............                                                9,500.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year   June30, 1890                  Hiding                        10,000. 00t
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections "2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix U 16.)
   20. Water-gauges on the Mississsippi River and its p)rincilpal tribu-
taries.-Section 5252, Revised Statutes, authorizes and directs the Sec-
retary of War to have water-gauges established and daily observations
made of the rise and fall of the Lower Mississippi River and its chief
tributaries at or in vicinity of certain points named and at such other
places as he may deem advisable.
   By the terms of the statute the sum of $5,000 was to be appropriated
annually for these gauges. This amount, however, has not been ap-
propriated regularly. In 1878 observations had to be stopped by reason
of exhaustion of funds, but many observers continued the readings with-
out compensation. In 1886, no appropriation being made for that fiscal
year, the Mississippi River Commission paid the observers and repaired
the gauges on the Mississippi to prevent the suspension of those im-
portant observations. Nearly all the permanent gauges require re-
building and the bulletin-boards repairs and painting. Bulletins should
be erected also at all stations on the tributaries.
   During the fiscal year observations were continued at all the gauges,
and inspection and repairs made as far as practicable with the funds
available. The appropriation of August 5, 1886, was exhausted practi-
cally by September 30, 1887, but observations were continued volun-
tarily, with the understanding that the observers should receive no pay
unless special appropriation was made, an estimate for which was con-
tained in Senate Ex. Doe. No. 92, Fiftieth Congress, first session.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..........................................       $1, 628. 92
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887......................... $1,618.28
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities................-..........          10.64
                                                                                                                        1, 628. 92

Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888................. ........                                                 9, 600. 00
    (See Appendix U 17.)
IMPROVEMENT OF ARKANSAS RIVER ; OF RIVERS IN THE STATE OF
    ARKANSAS, OF BLACK RIVER IN ARKANSAS AND                                                                    MISSOURI, AND
    OF ST. FRANCIS AND LITTLE RIVERS, MISSOURI.

   Officer in charge, Capt. H. S. Taber, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Red River above Fulton, Arkansas.-The appropriation available
is the first ever made for work above Fulton.
   The project contemplates high and mediumn-stage navigation only,
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                         185
and proposes to attain this by operating a hand-propelled snag-boat of
light draught between low and middle stages of water.
   Three thousand one hundred and fifty-four dollars and forty-six cents
had been expended up to June 30, 1887. During the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1888, with the small balance remaining, a good beginning
was made upon the project, nearly eight hundred dangerous snags
(low water) having been removed. The direct benefits to navigation
were very marked.
July 1, 1887, amount available.........................................                                    $3, 828. 34
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ........................                            $3, 664.84
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..............                  ............              75.00
                                                                                                            3, 739. 84
July 1, 1888, balance available .........                    ........   .................--.....               88.50
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188 ..                         ......   ..............             3, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889..-..........--                              .... .    3, 088.50
   (See Appendix V 1.)
  2. Little Red River, Arkansas.-The only improvements ever at-
tempted upon this river were made in 1872.
   Prior to this work many overhanging trees and a large number of
snags interfered with navigation in the lower reaches, and many
bowlders obstructed flat-boat and raft navigation in the reach above
the present town of Judsonia.
   Most of the overhanging trees and snags were removed as high as
J udsonia, and the bowlders remained untouched to the end of June 30,
1886.
   The act approved August 5, 1886, appropriated $3,000.                                              The amount
estimated as actually necessary was $8,400; $400 for the bowlders;
$8,000 for dredging a channel through the shoals.
   The $400 for the removal of bowlders having been expended during
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, and the balance being too small to
build and operate a light dredge-boat, nothing was done during the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, except to care for the property and
records.
July 1, 1887, amount available ......              ................                   ............         $2, 587. 10
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                                                    ---....--..---....------.........----.
  outstanding July 1, 1887-... .........--.......-...-                                                         200. 00
July 1, 1888, balance available ---..........................                      ...........              2, 387.10
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ..--.....................                                     5,400.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                   7, 787.10
   (See Appendix V 2.)
   3. Removing obstructions in Arkansas River, Arkansas.-Prior to the
first improvements in 1833, shifting sand-bars, numerous drift-piles, and
dangerous snags constituted the obstacles to navigation in the lower
reaches, and gravel and rock shoals, with a few snags and many over-
hanging trees, constituted those of the upper. Except for a few special
reaches, like the Fort Smith and Pine Bluff, the general plan of im-
provement has consisted in snagging operations, including the cutting
of overhanging trees, in building wing-dams to improve the shoals, and
in surveys looking towards plans for its permanent improvement.
   The appropriations to June 30, 1888, amount to $440,251.87. Of this
there had been expended to June 30, 1887, $365,299.61.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $2,178.28 were expended
186         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

in the care of the property and the records, and in advancing the work
on the maps of the river from Little Rock, Ark., to Wichita, Kans.
   The removal of obstructions will be continued with the amount on
hand and that asked for.
July 1, 1887, amount available..........................                .............            $2, 426. 95
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 .-----..--.................   $1,986.28
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities...      ......... ........   .    192.00
                                                                             ---                  2,178.28

July 1, 1888, balance available. ---..... -..._ ...          .... ....... ...        .-..-   .       248. 67
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888              ....      ... ....      .... .. -     25, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...... ..............                 --   25, 248.67

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                     35, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix V 3.)
   4. Arkansas River, Arkansas and Kansas.-By act of August 5, 1886,
$75,000 was appropriated for continuing the improvement of Arkansas
River. According to the plan and recommendations in Appendix V 13,
House Ex. Dec. No. 1, Forty-ninth Congress, first session, of which there
was to be expended $8,000 at Pine Bluff, $1;,000 at Fort Smith, $10,000
at Dardanelle, or so much thereof as may be necessary at these points.
   The approved project for the expenditure of this sum is as follows:
   At Pine Pluff the $8,000 to be usd in extending and repairing the
dikes, and for protecting the town front.
   At Fort Smith the $13,000 is to be expended in erecting a permeable
dike a little above the town to retain the channel along the city wharves.
   At Dardanelle the $10,000 to be expended in erecting a permeable
dike above the town to remove the sand-bar now in front of the wharves.
   From Little Rock to the mouth, the balance, and so much as may not
be required at the three places above specified, to be expended in the
erection of permeable dikes at the worst places, looking towards the
permanent improvement of the river to give at least a depth of 5 feet
at extreme low water.
   Before operations were begun at Fort Smith the old jetty at that place,
built in 1877 and 1878, had so far disappeared as to render no service.
   At Dardanelle a bad bar had formed along the town front, cutting off
all approach to either wharf at low water or medium stage.
   At Pine Bluff the condition before improvement was that at one point
in the vicinity of the town a cut-off was threatened, at another a bar
interfered with navigation at low water, and in the bend in front of the
town the river was eroding the banks with a rapidity that threatened
the town front. The works erected have, so far, produced the desired
effect of arresting this erosion.
   From Little Rock to the mouth of the river the river consists of alter-
nating bars and caving banks, with crossings more or less troublesome
at low water, a few of the latter operating to effectually close the river
to navigation at extreme low water for boats drawing 2 feet of water.
During the fiscal year ending June30, 1888, $437.29 have been expended
at Pine Bluff in the care of the property. No additional work has been
required at that point. The works have rendered excellent service.
-Extensive filling has continued all along the dangerous points of the
town front.
  At F'ort ISmith, Ark., $148.63 was expended in caring for the prop-
                         RIVER       AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                   187
erty. No rises occurred until near the close of the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1888, to test the dike erected here. These rises have been at-
tended with very satisfactory results in the way of deposits.
   At Dardanelle there were no rises after the completion of the dike of
300 feet that were sufficient to indicate what length of dike would ac-
complish the object in view and do no violence to the town front, until
just prior to the close of the fiscal year.
   At last accounts the dike described in the last annual report was doing
excellent work, and it is probable that early in the next fiscal year de-
velopments will be such that the original project may be successfully
completed.
   From Little Rock to the mouth $34,589.13 were expended according
to the approved project. The plant belonging to Pine Bluff; Fort Smith,
and Dardanelle was utilized, and three of the worst places have been.
improved.
   Good progress has been made also just above Little Rock in directing
the channel through draw of the Baring Cross Bridge and keeping it
next to the city wharves. It is believed that one or more short dikes
will be required to complete this work.
    To complete the project as set forth in Appendix V 13, House Ex.
Doc. No. 1, Forty-ninth Congress, first session, $2,494,544 will be re-
quired to obtain a channel at least 200 feet wide and 6 feet deep at low
water.
   The Board of Engineers, in reviewing this project, estimate the cost
of obtaining a depth of 4 feet at $40,000 per mile, or $8,400,000 for the
160 miles from Little Rock to White River Cut-off. The act of August
11, 1888, contains the following proviso:
   That nothing herein contained shall authorize the Secretary of War to enter upon
the project of improvement of said river, as set forth in the report of the Board of
Engineers on improvement of the Arkansas River from Wichita, Kans., to its mouth,
dated New York City, March 16, 1888, and contained in House Ex. Doc. No. 234, Fifti-
eth Congress, first session.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..................................---------....---     -      -....        $44, 868. 64
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
   of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887--            .----.............---.....    $33, 508.81
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities .-..---.-------.-------                              1, 350. 29
                                                                                                           34, 859.10

July 1, 1888, balance available ........................................                                   10,009.54
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ...-                            ... ......    ..--.         150, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.. - -.........---                             ...   160, 009.54
 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..... '2, 344, 544. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1890...--------.-----. - --------- -----.. ---                           .--
                                                              ......----...-------- 50, 000.00
      Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
  .    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix V 4.)
  5. PetitJean River, Arkansas.-Before improvement this river was ob-
structed by snags, logs, drift-piles, overhanging trees, and shoals. The
project for improvement contemplated rendering it navigable during
high and medium stages of water as high as Danville, Ark., by cutting
the overhanging trees and cutting up the snags, logs, and drift. The
only appropriation made for this river was that of August 5, 1886.
  Three thousand three hundred and six dollars and fifty-one cents had
been expended to June 30, 1887, effectively carrying out the original
project as high as Rocky Crossing, or about one-half the distance to
Danville,
188          REPORT OF THE CHIEF                          OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1.888 the entire balance of the
above appropriation was expended in caring for the property and the
records.
July 1, 1887, amount available--..----...............---------------......................                  $199.49
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887-----..--....---..........------------..---...----......--... --...---......       199. 49
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888                        ........................              2, 500. 00
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-.--- ---                                 1,000.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                              1, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections                                2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix     5.)
   6. Fourche River, Arkansas.-The improvement of this stream was
begun in 1879. Prior to any improvement its channel was choked with
snags, logs, and drift, and heavy timber overhung its banks. Several
bad shoals also impeded navigation.
   Up to June 30, 1886, $21,000 had been expended in removing the
greater part of the obstructions, though the shoals, and here and there
a snag, washed in since work was suspended in December, 1882, still
offer serious obstacles to navigation at medium stages of water.
   Fair progress had been made up to June 30, 1887, in carrying out the
project, which provided for blasting a channel 50 feet wide and 2 feet
deep through the shoals about 4 miles below Perryville, Ark. During
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, the balance was expended in com-
pleting the project. The shoals were found to be more than double the
length given from an old reconnaissance. Despite this, an effective
channel 30 feet wide has been opened the entire length of the shoal.
July 1, 1887, amount available.........................................--------------.                       809.00
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887..--....--- --....--............-.........---------..----..-------------......     809. 00
   (See Appendix V 6.)
  7. White River, Arkansas.-Prior to improvement, this river was
choked with drift-piles, logs, and snags in its lower portion, and from
Batesville up, gravel-bars, rocky shoals, channel bowlders, and over-
hanging trees impeded navigation.
  The originally a.dopted project consisted in snagging operations and
blasting of ledges and bowlders, and dam building to remove gravel-
bars or to close chutes, The first separate appropriation for this river
was made by act approved July 5, 1884. At that time the river was in
excellent navigable condition for boats drawing not to exceed 3 feet of
water, from its mouth to Newport, Ark. From Newport to Batesville
there were many troublesome snags, and from Batesville to Buffalo
Shoals there were numerous bad shoals, rendering navigation very un-
certain. From Buffalo Shoals to Forsythe, Mo., there were many fine
reaches of river, but the depth of water on Buffalo Shoals and others
prevented any navigation at ordinary stages of water.
  The appropriations for this river have been united so often with those
of the St. Francis, with the Black and St. Francis, and the Black and
Little Red, that the amount expended on the White River alone to
June 30, 1884, can not be exactly stated. The approximate amount is
not under $170,000.
  The present project provides for removing snags, bowlders, and other
obstructions to navigation, building wing-dams to improve shoals, and
a survey of the river, with a view to its permanent improvement, from
Forsythe, 1Io., to the mouth.
                            1RIVER AND 1HAR13OR                        IMPROVMENTS.                         189
   Up to June 30, 1887, $46,575.24 had been expended. This completed
Ihe field work of the survey, removed many of the most dangerous snags
from Batesville to the mouth, partially plotted the notes of the survey,
improved many of the worst shoals between Batesville and Buffalo
Shoals, rendering material though temporary aid to navigation for
very light-draught boats.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $4,784.41 were expended.
The plotting of the field notes was completed, and plans and estimates
for permanent improvement prepared, and a few snags were removed
in the lower reaches. The officer in charge reports that the cost of im-
proving this river as proposed by him will be $105,315 in addition to
the amount already expended.
July 1, 1887, amount available...................... ..........    ......                              $6, 430.76
Received from sale of fuel to officer.....................................                                   6. 00
                                                                                                        6, 436. 76
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ......................                           $4,239.91
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities.. ........................                           544.50
                                                                                                        4,784.41

July 1, 1888, balance available..........................................                               1,652. 35
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ............                                ....   ...   25,000.00
                                                                     --.
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.................-                                26, 652. 35
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                               80,315.00
I Amount (estimated) required for snagging annually ...................                                8, 000. 00
4 Amount that can be prolitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                          58, 000. 00
  I Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix V 7.)
  8. Cache River, Arkansas.-This is a new work. To comply with the
requirements of the river and harbor act approved August 5, 1886, a
preliminary examination (a survey being unnecessary) of the above-
named river was made, and the report thereon printed in Appendix V
15 of the Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1887.
  The contemplated improvement is to build and equip a hand-propelled
snag-boat, with which to remove the snags, logs, etc., which obstruct
the river, at an estimated cost of $7,000.
  The river aid harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $7,000 for
the construction of the boat and paying running expenses of the same.
Amount appropriated by act of August                         11,   1888.........................      $7, 000. 00
    9. Black River, Arkansas and Missouri.-Before any improvements
were made upon this river its channel was choked with logs and snags,
and obstructed by overhanging trees, and in many places shoals inter-
fered with its navigation at low water by any but very light-draught
boats. Its banks caved but little, and except at the shoals it had greater
depth of water than is found in streams generally in its vicinity.
    The original plan for its improvement contemplated the removal of
the obstructions and the improvement of the shoals, the latter by win g
dams. A few sloughs were to be closed so as to confine the water to
the main channel.
    Up to June 30, 1887, $55,635.51 had been expended for these purposes,
and good progress made toward connecting with some detached worik
near Poplar Bluff, Mo., i. e., only 60 miles of unworked river intervenes.
    During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $606.89 were expended
in the care of the property and the records.
190         REPORT OF -THIE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, Uf. S. ARMY.

  Eight thousand dollars will be required annually for two or three
years to maintain free navigation.
July 1, 1887, amount available---..------------......---                  ..--...--......--......
                                                         -----............----..--...                   $606. 89
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.----....---.......---................----........------                        606.89

Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.........................                                 5, 000. 00

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project annually                              8, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in the fiscal year ending Junno
     30, 1890 .----.........----.....----... ..--.--...------.......---..----..----.-       ---...     8,000. 00
I( Submitted  in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
                                                                                            and

  (See Appendix V 8.)
  10. Black River, Missouri.-The work upon the river has hitherto been
done under the appropriation for improving Black River, Arkansas and
Missouri, and is provided for in the item under that heading in the river
and harbor act of August 11, 1888.
  The above being the first appropriation made for the improvement of
Black River independently, it may be classed as a new work, and a new
project for its expenditure will be proposed accordingly
  The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $7,000 for
the improvement.
  Until a project can be prepared an estimate for the completion of this
work can not be submitted. This will be done by a special report at a
later date.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                      -        $7, 000. 00
   11. Saint FrancisRiver, Arkansas.-The first appropriation was made
March 2, 1833, prior to which this river was choked with drift-piles,
logs, snags, and its waters spread out through a great variety of sloughs,
while overhanging trees added to the difficulty of navigation.
   The originally adopted project was principally for snagging opera-
tions, and attempts have been made to close up some of the many
sloughs. Appropriations for this river having been united with the
White River, exactly how much had been expended upon the St. Fran-
cis River to June 30, 1884, can not well be stated.
   July 5, 1884, the first separate appropriation was made, amounting to
$12,000. August 5, 1886, $8,000 more followed.         Of these amounts
$19,066.93 had been expended to June 30, 1887.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $929.69 have been ex-
pended in the continuance of the original project.
July 1, 1887, amount available ----..----...-----------...............--...................
                                                                                        --              $93.07
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887......-...................... $904. 69
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..............................                  25. 00
                                                                                                          929.69
                                                                                                          ----
July 1, 1888, balance available .-..............--.....-....... ..........                                 3.38
Amount appropriated by act of August 11) 1888..... ...... ....--...... --                        .    4, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...... ....                   .... ......        4, 003.38

   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                           8, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix V 9.)
   12. St. FrancisRiver, ilMissouri, from Greenville to the Arkansas State
line.-This is a new work. To comply with the requirements of the
                   RIVER AND        IIARBIOR    IMPROVEMENTS.                                    191
river and harbor act approved August 5, 1886, a preliminary examina-
tion was made of the St. Francis River between the points named (a
survey being considered unnecessary), and the report thereon is printed
in the Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1887. (Appendix V 17.)
   The proposed improvement is the removal of the shoals below Green-
ville and the removal of snags and other obstructions to navigation
by snag-boat at an estimated cost of $7,300.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $5,000 for
this work, and a further sum of $2,300 may be profitably expended in
continuing it during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...      ......          --......
                                                                      ----......   --       $5, 000. 00

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year en ling June 30, 1890                2, 300. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   13. Little River, Missouri, from Ifornersville to its junction with the St.
FrancisRiver.-This is a new work. To comply with the requirements
of the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, a preliminary examina-
tion (a survey being unnecessary) was made of Little River, and the
report thereon is printed as Appendix V 16 of the Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1887. The proposed improvement consists in the clos-
ing of one of the chutes forming the river by a dam and the removal of
obstructions by a hand-propelled snag-boat at an estimated cost of
$8,000.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $5,000 for
the work, and a further sum of $3,000 may be profitably expended in
continuing it during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...          -........       ......    ....    $5,000.00

  Amount that can be profitably expended infiscal'year endling June 30, 1890                 3, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.

REMOVING       SNAGS     AND    WRECKS      FROM3    THE        MISSISSIPPI                AND MIS-
  SOURI RIVERS.-IMPROVEMENT                 OF THE MISSISSIPPI IBETWEEN THE
  MOUTHS OF THE ILLINOIS AND OHIO RIVERS.-IMPROVEMENT OF
  OSAGE RIVER, MISSOURI AND KANSAS, AND OF GASCONADE RIVER,
  MISSOURI.

  Officer in charge, Maj. A. M. Miller, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Removing snags and wrecks from the MississsippiandMissouri rivers.--
Mississippi River.-For the removal of these obstructions appropriations
were made as early as 1824, and the project consisted in the building of
boats suitable for pulling snags, etc., which were almost continually
employed during favorable boating stages.
  The total amount expended for'this purpose can not be definitely
given, as previous to the appropriation made by act of March 3, 1879,
a general amount was appropriated to be applied to several streams as
their needs required. From March 3, 1879, when the first specific ap-
propriation was made, up to June 30, 1887, $548,125.87 was expended
for this purpose. The navigation of the river has been very materially
improved by this method and the danger of accidents to boats lessened.
During the fiscal year eiding June 30, 1888, $17,302.29 was expended.
  No appropriation having been Inmade for carrying on this improve-
ment during the fiscal year, but little work could be done. One snag-
192           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

boat was employed between the mouth of the Missourirliver atnd Vicks
burg, Miss., removing obstructions. The boat worked two months and
a half, removing 798 snags, cutting down 348 trees, and traveling a dis-
tance of 1,792 miles. All the worst obstructions to navigation w ee re-
moved, and commerce was greatly benefited thereby.
  With the appropriation asked for the fiscal year ending June 30,
1890, it is proposed to continue the snagging operations and rebuild
one of the wooden snag-boats for wrecking purposes.
  No definite amount can be stated, as required, to complete this proj-
ect. During every high-water season new snags and other obstructions
are brought down and lodged in the channel; the banks are also contin-
ually caving in the river, and it is necessary to cut the timber where
this is threatened to prevent the trees being caved into the river and
forming new obstructions. For this reason an annual appropriation is
required to properly carry on these operations.
July 1, 1887, amount available.------..........--------------------....----......--.....---...--..........       21,   074. 76
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1 87 .... ----...             - - .-- -- --. - ---                - ---..-      -    -.    17, 302. 29

July 1, 1888, balance available--..-----......------.....-----.....----- --......-...------........--....      , 772. 47
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 --         . ...............-
                                                            --- ---                -
                                                                            -- -.... -         -- -       . 100,000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30. 1889....--.....                                  ......        103, 772.47
    (See Appendix W 1.)
   Removing obstructions Missouri River.--The necessity for the improve-
ment of this stream was first recognised in 1832, as its navigation was
rendered difficult and dangerous by numerous snags, etc., in the chan-
nel and leaning timber on the banks of the river.
   The plan adopted for its improvement was the removal of these ob-
structions by snag-boats, and they have been used to great advantage.
   The first appropriations having been made so as to cover the needs
of several streams, the total amount expended on this river for the re-
moval of obstructions can not be given. Since June 18, 1878, when the
first specific appropriation was made, up to June 30, 1887, $450,306.46
was expended in that manner, greatly improving navigation during the
low-water season.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $3,445.29 was expended
in watching and caring for the snag-boats. No appropriation having
been made for continuing this improvement, no boat was sent to the
river to remove obstructions, the balance on hand not being deemed
sufficient for that purpose.
   With the appropriation asked for fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, it
is proposed to complete the outfit of new boat and continue the snag-
ging operations, and it is expected that the worst obstructions can be
removed and navigation rendered comparatively safe.
   As new obstructions are continually brought down the river work is
required every year, so that an annual appropriation is necessary.
July 1, 1887, amount available..............................----......--......                                  $6, 193.54
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887..------ -------- --------  -..--...... -- -...--- .                                    3, 445. 29
July 1, 1888, balance available----................----........--....--......-----....--....--2, 748. 25
    (See Appendix W 1.)
   2. Mlississippi River between the Ohio and Illinois rivers.---VWork was
carried onat Pulltight, Jim Smith's, and Sulphur Springs. Owing tolack
of funds no other work could be un(lertaken. These works form parts
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                        193
of one connected whole, carried on under a general scheme of making
the improvement of the river continuous, beginning at Saint Louis and
working down-stream, reducing the river to an approximate width of
about 2,500 feet, and protecting the banks from erosion. The work
between the Illinois River and Saint Louis-consists in the maintenance
of a channel 6 feet in depth.
   Horsetail.-Cross-sections.were taken here to ascertain the amount
of fill. The results shown were as follows: Area over which fill has
taken place, 915 acres. Area above 15-foot stage, on which willows are
growing, 589 acres. Average fill over whole area, 11.86 feet. Greatest
fill, 40.5 feet. Amount of material deposited, 17,500,000 cubic yards.
   The effect of this remarkable fill has been to render this portion of
the river navigable for the largest boats during the entire year and
to remove one of the most troublesome bars, Horsetail, where trouble
was always met with at low stages. The improvement of this locality
may be considered complete, with the exception of the closing of Car-
roll's Island Chute, which still needs attention.
    Twin Hollows, west bank.-The present project for the improvement
of this locality was adopted in 1881. It consists in the building up
of contraction works in order to confine the water. A channel of not
less than 8 feet at low water has been obtained. No work was done
here during the season. Cross-sections of work taken in the spring
show the area over which fill has taken place to be 361 acres, 251 acres
above 15-foot curve. Amount of material deposited, 11,389,259 cubic
yards; average fill, 19.5 feet; greatest fill, 41.2 feet. Willows are grow-
ing over the area above the 15-foot curve.
    Pulltight.-.The project for the improvement of this locality was
adopted in 1881, the object being to afford a channel of 8 feet at low
water. The river at this point has shown a tendency to make a cross-
ing above the point originally projected, and a careful study of this local-
ity was made and works laid out in conformity with this tendency.
Two hurdles were built from the east bank. The upper one, No. 4, was
3,000 feet long, and the lower, No. 5, 2,100 feet long. The rapid rise in
the river and large run of drift damaged the first so that it is continuous
for only about 1,700 feet from the east bank. No. 5 was completed its
fulllength, and now holds. Work was discontinued on No. 4, as it was
not economical to work at so high a stage. This hurdle will be com-
pleted as soon as the stage of the river permits, and it is confidently
expected that this crossing will be greatly improved for low-water navi-
gation. The middle bar has already been partially removed and a large
deposit of silt obtained behind the hurdles. The amount expended
during the year was $81,875.34, and the total amount expended to June
30, 1888, was $205,475-74.
    Ohesley Island.-No work was done at this locality. The object of
the improvement here was to hold the head of the island and close the
chute on its west side. Considerable difficulty has been met in closing
this chute; every run out of the ice and drift during the spring rise has
damaged the work. This year, however, the work has held and caused
a large accumulation of drift in the head of the chute, and a fill in the
chute, which will cause it to be dry at about the 15-foot stage, and it
is expected that this will continue until the chute is entirely closed.
    Jim Smith's.--The project for the improvement of this locality con-
sists in construction of contraction works. The work done during the
year was the revetment of the artificial bank opposite the head of
Chesley Island; 1,775 feet were protected and held from erosion. The
channel in this locality has been good during the year. To complete
         ENG 88-13
194        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

work at this locality one hurdle is required to fill a vacancy left during
construction for the accommodation of the steam-boat landing. The
amount expended during the year was $18,824.98, and the total amount
expended to June 30, 1888, was $327,939.44.
   Sulphur Springs.--The project for improvement of this locality was
adopted in 1881, and consists of contraction works. The hurdles con-
structed during the previous year were wattled, and a new hurdle, No.
16, built at the head of Foster's Island. This hurdle was extended from
the shore of the island westward for a length of 1,620 feet, and stands
completed. This completes the work at this locality except repairs.
The ice damaged to some extent the hurdles constructed last season,
to what extent can not be definitely stated until the water reaches a
lower stage. The effect of the work has been very apparent. Large
accumulations of material have been obtained behind the hurdles, in
some places a fill of more than 20 feet, and the chute behind Foster's
Island has been almost entirely closed for a 15-foot stage of river.
   A reference to the plates, accompanying the report of the officer in
charge, will give a graphic description of the progress and effect of the
above works. The amount expended during the year was $25,246.98,
and the total amount expended to June 30, 1888, was $177,964.24.
   The original estimated cost of the work, as revised in 1883, was
$16,997,100. The aggregate amount appropriated to June 30, 1888, is
$3,739,600. The amount expended to June 30, 1887, is $3,521,508.50.
July 1, 1887, amount available ........................................               216,173. 02
Miscellaneous receipts.............................................................     1, 708. 63
                                                                                      217, 881.65
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 .................... $122, 195. 19
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities........................         28.09
                                                                                      122, 223.28
July 1, 1888, balance available........................................                95, 658. 37
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ......................                  300,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .................               395, 658. 37

( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... 12, 957, 500. 00
I Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1890...........................................................        600,000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix W 2.)
   3. Gasconade River, Missouri.-This river was greatly obstructed by
snags, logs, and leaning timber, which materially interfered with navi-
gation. Work was commenced on this stream in 1880, and the project
adopted for its improvement consisted in the removal of the snags and
logs and the cutting of leaning timber and contraction works.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $34,424.39, and at that
time the navigation was much improved. During the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1888, $3,013.64 was expended in constructing dams or
training-walls at Round Island and Bock's Bar, in order to concentrate
the water in the main channel of the river at those points. All trouble-
some obstructions were also removed.
   The original estimate for the improvement of this stream was $50,000,
of which $37,500 has already been appropriated, leaving an estimated
amount of $12,500 to complete the project. This amount will probably
be exceeded, as new obstructions are continually forming, and it will
                          .RIVER         AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                1 95
require a small amount each year to keep the channel open after the
principal work has been-done.
July 1, 1887, amount available ............       ....------....-----.....--. ...----....-------....                        $3,075 61
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887                            -
                               _....-............ ......   . ......- ..... . --..-. .                                        3, 013. 64
July 1, 1888, balance available ....----....----....------....---....----...---....-..-----..-------....                        61. 97
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                                                      5,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889                            ....---....-----..---------......           5, 061.97
   Amount that canbe profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                                 10, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix W 3.)
   4. Osage River, Missouri and Kansas.-The navigation of this stream
was greatly interfered with by obstructions in the channel and shoal
crossings. The original project, adopted in 1871, was to obtain a low-
water navigation of 2 feet by means of dams and training-walls, but
this was abandoned and no other definite project was adopted. The
improvements have consisted in the removal of overhanging trees from
the banks, and of snags from the bed of the stream, and the construc-
tion of wing-dams and training-walls. The amount expended to June
30, 1887, was $194,027.89, at which time the navigation was in a fair
condition, the worst obstructions having been removed. During the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $1,816.63 was expended in watching
and caring for plant and in reading gauge at Tuscumbia.
   An annual appropriation is required to keep this stream in navigable
condition by the removal of new obstructions that are brought down
during the floods. No stated amount can be given as required to com-
plete the improvement.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..................... ......... . ..........   .                                             $5, 972. 11
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 .................   ................  ............                                                1, 816. 63
July 1, 1888, balance available --..-...                 .....   .......          .....        ......
                                                                                            .....                    ....    4, 155. 48
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188 .......-................                                                        5, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                                    9,155.48
  SAmount that can be profitably expended in fiscal y-ar ending June 30,1890                                                10, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sectiois 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix W 4.)

EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS FOR IMPROVEMENT, TO COAiPLY WITH
  REQUIREMENTS OF THE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT OF AUGUST 5,


  The required preliminary examination of                   River at Rush      Mississippi
Island Bend and Ivy Landing, Illinois, with a view to confining and deep-
ening the channel, was made by the local engineer, Major Miller, and not
recommended for improvement at present, as this locality will, at the
proper time, be treated as part of the general plan of improvement of
the river. Report transmitted to Congress and printed in House Ex.
Doec. No. 216, Fiftieth Congress, first session. (See also Appendix W 5.)
  It appearing, after preliminary examination by the local engineer, that
the locality was worthy of improvement, Major Miller was charged with
and completed the survey of Kaskaskia River, Illinois, from New Athens
196        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

to its mouth, the results of which were transmitted to Congress and
printed in House Ex. Doe. No. 216, Fiftieth Congress, first session. (See
also Appendix W 6.)

IMPROVEMENT OF THE MISSISSIPPI RIVER BETWEEN THE DES MOINES
        RAPIDS AND THE MOUTH OF THE ILLINOIS RIVER.

   Officer in charge, Capt. E. H. Rtiffner, Corps of Engineers.
   The approved plan of operations consists in contracting the low-water
bed of the river at localities which have more than one channel, or where
there is insufficient channel depth. Island chutes are closed by brush
and stone dams, and wing-dams of the same construction are built where
it is necessary to confine the low-water width to narrower limits. The
heads of islands and many caving banks are protected by brush-mats and
rip-rap, or by the latter alone. Dredging has been resorted to where nec-
essary. The contract system is partly used in construction, and the
United States owns and operates a plant of its own. A steamer has been.
purchased and fitted up as a hydraulic dredge for the purpose of in-
creasing dredging facilities.
   During the season of 1887, contractors finished their contract at Gil-
bert's Island and Turner's Island, and the United States constructed
works near Cap au Gris and Martin's Landing, and made repairs near
Dixon's Landing. The exhaustion of the appropriation limited opera-
tions.
   With the money asked for it is intended to continue work as outlined
above.
July 1, 1887, amount available .........................................         $19, 349.94
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887........--         ....................-...... ....... 19, 022. 89
July 1, 1888, balance available .......................... --......-.....                               327. 05
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888....-..                        ....   .....            200,000. 0
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...-----......                  ....---.....   200, 327.05
  Amount that can be profitably expended infiscal year ending June 30,1890 264,000. 0(
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix X.)
IMPROVEMENT OF THE NAVIGATION OF THE MISSISSIPPI RIVER BE-
  TWEEN MINNEAPOLIS AND DES MOINES RAPIDS, INCLUDING IM-
  PROVEMENTS AT SPECIAL LOCALITIES BETWEEN THOSE POINTS-
  OPERATING AND CARE OF THE DES MOINES RAPIDS CANAL.

  Officer in charge, Maj. A. Mackenzie, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Upper Mississippi River : Operations of snag-boats and dredge-boats,
etc.-There being but $4,585.63 available from this appropriation at the
beginning of the fiscal year, an additional allotment for snagging-work
was necessarily made from the general appropriation for improvement
of the river between Saint Paul and Des Moines Rapids.
  In July and parts of August and September, 1887, the snag-boat was
employed removing snags and other obstructions and assisting inter-
ests of navigation between Saint Paul and the mouth of the Missouri
River.
  The total amount expended for snag-boat service on the Upper Mis-
sissippi River between Saint Paul and the mouth of the Missouri, to
July 1, 1888, is $522,728.66.
  As a result of the work of the snag-boat during past years, accidents
                      RIVER AND HARBOR                  IMPROVEMENTS.                          197
and damage from snags, wrecks, and other similar obstructions have be-
come exceedingly rare; while, previous to the inauguration of snagging-
work, the wrecking of boats and barges, attended by much loss, was a
common occurrence. The dangers from snags and similar obstructions
are now so slight that, as a rule, no insurance is taken out against loss
from such cause.
July 1, 1887, amount available ...------............---...................--.             $4, 588. 63
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887...--    ...................--..--......--........               2,677. 29
July 1, 1888, balance available......-------...................---......--.......          1,911.34
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.........................                    25, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889............---......                26, 911.34
   (See Appendix Y 1.)
   2. Mississippi River, from Minneapolis to Des Moines Rapids.--Under
this appropriation is carried on the improvement of through navigation.
Work has been in progress, under annually approved projects, since
1878, and very favorable results have been secured, showing that with
a continuance of the work under liberal appropriations the low-water
channel of the Mississippi between Saint Paul and the Des Moines
Rapids can be made comparatively safe, convenient, and permanent.
The interests for which the improvement is being made are very large
and important.
   During the past year work has been carried out by days' labor be-
tween Saint Paul and Hastings, in vicinity of Crooked Slough, between
Read's Landing and Winona, on Rock Island Rapids, and between
Otter Island and Nauvoo, and by contract between Homer and Queen's
Bluff, between Guttenberg and Waupeton, and between Sand Prairie
and Savanna. Temporary work of dredging was carried out at numer-
ous points.
   The records of eight years' work show that material used in the con-
struction of dams and shore protections can be purchased far more ad-
vantageously in open market than by contract, and that the carrying
out of a portion of the work by aid of Government plant has resulted
in a saving, as compared with cost of contract work, of $160,614.35, or
within $33,275.61 of the total amount expended for plant. It is a satis-
faction to know that the efficient plant now on hand has been almost
paid for by the saving it has effected in cost of work.
   There has been expended to June 30, 1888, for the permanent im-
provement of through navigation, the sum of $1,496,725.16, or $2,906.26
per mile.
July 1, 1887, amount available---...--.............................--------...         *$270, 274. 40
Received from sale of fuel......--......----......-----..........................             105.04

                                                                                         270, 379.44
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887-......        ...............   $204, 871.21
July 1,1888, outstanding liabilities ........................                282. 70
                                                                                         205,153. 91

July 1, 1888, balance available----..---..-------..............--............---.         65, 225.53
Amount appropriated by act of August 11,1888........................                     600, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30,1889.............-
                                                   --------.....                         665,225.53

  * This amount differs from the balance reported in money statement of previous
year. It includes $15,000 appropriated for Lake City, which amount at date of pre-
rious report was included under special head of " Harbors of refuge on Lake Pepin,
Lake City, Minnesota;" and it excludes $388.24, expended in Washington from al-
.otment of $15,000 for the practical test of the Adams flume, previous to June 30, 1887.
{Amount
198          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

               that can be profitably expended in fiscal year dnding June
    30, 1890----........----------- -....--..-----......------ .--...........
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                              .... $1, 000,000.00
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Y 3.)
   3. Des Moines Rapids, Mississippi River.-This work was commenced
in 1866. The adopted plan provided for the building of a closed canal
8 miles long and for cutting an open channel in the rock-bed of the river
over the remaining 4 miles of rapids. The canal was opened in August,
1877, though not fully completed, and has been in operation since that
time.   The work of the past year consisted in the continuation of the
protection of the canal embankment. The work remaining to be done
to complete the improvement in accordance with the approved project is
as follows: Completing blasting and dredging in open canal; raising
lock-walls of middle and lower locks; refilling and completing paving
of canal embankment; building a sluice in embankment for removing
sediment; building an office at lower lock, and completing lock grounds.
The approved project provides for two sluices in canal embankment, but
one of these sluices has been provided in connection with the dry-dock.
The estimated cost of the sluice was $20,000. As built, the additional
cost to dry-dock was $8,000. The arrangement, therefore, effected an
estimated saving of $12,000, which is deducted from the amount required
to complete work. The amount of $8,000 is retained in estimate, and
this amount should be expended in connection with the completion of
the dry-dock.
   There has been appropriated and allotted for this work the sum of
$4,517,950. There have been expended for work $4,492,835.09. The
net cost to the United States has been, to June 30, 1888, $4,491,690.72.
July 1, 1887, amount available-                   ..........-----..............--..---............          $29, 124.40
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887...--..-----........... .......... ............ ....                                3,884.24

July 1, 1888, balance available --------...........-----------.........------------------................    25,240. 16
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.........................                                       35,000. 00

Amount availal le for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                   60,240.16


   Amount that canbe profitably expended in fiscal year ending Juno 30, 1890                                  8, 500. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections '2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Y 4.)
   4. Operating and care of Des Moines Rapids Canal.-Duringthe past
year the Des Moines Rapids Canal was open for navigation two hun-
dred and twenty-seven days, during which time there passed through
it 595 steam-boats and 235 barges, carrying 8,330 passengers, 33,160
tons of merchandise, and 143,037 bushels of grain. There also passed
through 166,827,752 feet of lumber, 34,505,000 feet of logs, 49,848,840
shingles, and 83,642,450 laths. The lumber traffic of the year was about
the largest on record, owing to the extreme low water of 1887. During
1888 the water was high and but few boats passed through the canal.
   Less material than usual was brought into the canal during the past
year, but surveys show that a gradual filling up of canal is taking
place, and the amount of dredging must be increased.         Forty-seven
thousand three hundred and thirty-three cubic yards of material were
removed during the year. It is possible that the purchase or construc-
tion of a tow-boat for use with dredge will be necessary in the near
future.
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                       199
   A floating boom was built and placed this spring at the head of the
canal to facilitate entrance.
   The extreme high water of the past spring developed some weak
places in the embankment and extensive repair to the same must soon
be made.
   The expenses of the year have been $42,802.35, of which amount
$9,161.24 are chargeable to dredging and $1,327.32 to boom construc-
tion; $2,234 35 were expended for repair of the gates, which are getting
quite old and must be replaced in a few years.
   The estimated expenses for the coming year are $45,000.
   The expenses of operating and care of the Des Moines Rapids Canal
are provided for by an indefinite appropriation, made by act of March
3, 1881.
July 1, 1887, balance on hand.                    --.. .......
                                 . .................          --.... .... $1,849. 75
June 30, 1888, amount drawn from Treasury under indefinite appropriation 42, 000. 00
                                                                      43, 849. 75
                                                                      42, 802. 35
Jung 30, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year..... .................
June 30, 1888, balance on hand. ....     ..........................................    1,047. 40
  (See Appendix Y 5.)
  5. Dry-dock at the Des Moines Rapids Canal, Mississippi River.-The
approved project for this work provides for the building on the river side of
the Des Moines Rapids Canal, above Middle Lock, of a dry-dock 400 feet
long and 100 feet wide, with gates giving an entrance into the canal 80
feet wide. The original estimate of cost was $125,000.          There have
been expended to date $108,750. No balance remains on hand.
  All the embankment and masonry work are completed, and the con-
struction of gates is well under way. To finish the work requires the
completion of paving of embankment of the gates, of the concrete and
timber of bottom of dock, and of the draining arrangements, also the
putting up of pumping machinery and the removal of a portion of canal
embankment.                                      0
  In constructing the sluices of dock, the openings were made larger
than was originally proposed, with a view to discharging through them
the muddy water at times brought into the canal by Price's Creek. This
work has increased the cost of the dock somewhat, but has made un-
necessary one of the sluices planned for the canal embankment and esti-
mated to cost $20,000. The addi ional expenditure should be considered
as acredit from the appropriation for " Improving )Des Moines Rapids" to
the appropriation for "Dry-dock at the Des Moines Rapids Cana!," to
be drawn upon for the latter work, in case it is found to be impractica-
ble to fully complete the dry-dock without exceeding the estimate.
  The large plant owned by the United States and the entire commerce
of the Upper Mississippi River will be benefited by this improvement.
July 1, 1887,amount availahble.......................................... $27, 621.76
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 187..................----------....----.....--.......--.        27,621.76
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888....           ....             16,250. 00
                                                               ......-......-....

  (See Appendix Y 6.)
   6. Harborof Refuge on Lake Pepin, at Lake City, Minnesota.-The pro-
ject for this work proposed the building of a breakwater to protect and
facilitate the landing of steam-boats and afford safety to rafts caught in
the lake by storms.
   In May, 1887, the work of reducing depth of water and cost, by build-
ing up a foundation of gravel, was commenced.                        During the year a
200         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

breakwater, 871 fee long, of which 512 feet are crib-work, extending
into the lake below the gravel point in front of Lake City, from the
foot of Elm Street, was completed. This breakwater was given sloping
side and end, which permits the ice to slide over the pier rather than
push against it. This pier passed comparatively safely through a severe
test this spring due to a combination of very high water, heavy ice, and
severe storms. There have been expended on this work to June 30,
1888, from special appropriations, the sum of $20,000, and from an al-
lotment from general appropriation a further sum of $11,985.23.
   As the length of pier built is thought to be sufficient to properly pro-
tect the harbor at Lake City, and as the balance on hand from the allot-
ment is sufficient to make repairs now needed, no further appropriation
is asked for.
July 1, 1887, amount available .....--......                          --....-- ....
                                                                 ......             --.......... $16, 350.82
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ..............................................                         16, 350. 82
   (See Appendix Y 8.)
  7. Harborof refuge on Lake Pepin, at Stockholm, Wisconsin.--The p'roj-
ect for this work proposed the building of a breakwater to protect and
facilitate the landing of steam-boats and afford safety to rafts caught in
the lake by storms. A crib-work pier 579 feet in length was completed
in 1885. During the spring of 1888 there was a higher stage of water
in the lake than was ever before known at the time of the breaking up
of the ice, and the ice, when it did break up, was as solid as in mid-
winter. A violent storm, occurring at this time, drove the ice with
great force against the pier, carrying off about 4 feet from its top.
  The pier should be repaired as soon as possible, and in making such
repairs sloping sides and end should be provided. The amount ex-
pended on this work to June 30, 1888, is $19,070.94.
July 1, 1887, amount available -..---.. .. .................. ...... --...... $6, 209.39
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilites
   outstanding July 1, 1887           ..--........-----............-----......    ............        280.33

July 1, 1888, balance available . ...         ..................................................   5,929. 06
IAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                            15,000.00
   Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal yearending June30, 1890                         15, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirement of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Y 9.)

PRESERVATION OF THE FALLS OF SAINT ANTHONY AND IMPROVE-
  MENT OF THE MISSISSIPPI AB OVE THE FALLS-IMPROVEMENT OF
  CHIPPEWA AND SAINT CROIX    RIVERS, WISCONSIN, AND OF MIN-
  NESOTA RIVER AND RED RIVER OF THE NORTH, MINNESOTA AND
  DAKOTA-RESERVOIRS AT THE SOURCES OF THE MISSISSIPPI---IM-
  PROVEMENT OF THE MISSOURI RIVER FROM SIOUX CITY, IOWA,
  TO FORT BENTON, MONTANA, AND OF YELLOWSTONE RIVER, MON-
  TANA AND DAKOTA.

  Officer in charge, Maj. Chas. J. Allen, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Preservationof the Falls of Saint Anthony, Minnesota.-The history
and details of this improvement are given at length in the last Annual
Report.
  " This amount is $15,000 less than the balance given in the last Annual Report, the
$15,000-appropriati on of July 5, 1884-having been transferred to appropriation for
"Improving Mississippi River from Saint Paul to Des Moines Rapids" on books of
Treasury Department and considered as an allotment, rather than a special appro-
priation.
                     RIVER AND         HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                               201
   No work was done during the past fiscal year, there being no funds
for it. As there is no navigation dependent upon the preservation of
the Falls, and as Congress has made no appropriation for that purpose
since 1884, it is deemed proper to render no estimates for this work for
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
   Total expended under the present project, including outstanding lia-
:bilities, $405,000.
July 1, 1887, amount in hand..................---- .  ...............    ....  .. .     $86. 83
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities.....................................----           86. 83

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 210,000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Z 1.)
2. Constructionof lock and dam on MississippiRiver at Meeker's Island,
Mlinnesota.--The river and harbor act of March 3, 1873, appropriated-
  For construction of the lock and dam on the Mississippi River at Meeker's Island,
Milinesota, according to the surveys and plans of the War Department, twenty-five
thousand dollars: Provided, That all rights and claims in and to the land grant made
to the State of Minnesota for the above work, by act approved July twenty-third,
eighteen hundred and sixty-eight, shall be fully relinquished to the United States be-
fore any of this appropriation is expended.
  None of this appropriation has been used, the required relinquishment
not having been made, and the appropriation has been lying unused
for fifteen years.
July 1, 1887, amount available subject to conditions in act............. $25, 000.00
July 1, 1888, balance available subject to conditions in act.... ........ 25, 000. 00
SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ......    897,121.46
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of the river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Z 2.)
   3. MississippiRiver above Fallsof SaintAnthony, Minnesota.-The pres
'ent project, adopted in 1880, consists in improvement of the river mainly
between Aitken and Grand Rapids, a distance of 165 miles, by removal
of snags, bowlders, bars, and leaning trees from the channels, and con-
struction of wing-dams, when necessary, to afford 3 feet depth during
low-water stage, the cost being estimated at $54,127. The last appro-
priation for this improvement being that of $10,000, by the act of Au-
gust 2, 1882, no work was done upon the channels during the past fiscal
year for want of funds.
   The total expended under the present project to June 30, 1888, in-
cluding outstanding liabilities, is $35,000.
   Before improvement commenced in 1880 the stream between Aitken
and Grand Rapids was so obstructed that navigation was difficult and
at times almost impossible for steamers of lightest draught. There is
now a general depth in the improved channels of 3 feet at low water,
but there are many snags, leaning trees, bowlders, and gravel-bars yet
remaining to be removed, as they contract the channels and thus inter-
fere with the movement of steamers at any stage of water.
July 1, 1887, amount available, including outstanding liabilities ......                  $3.67
.July1, 1888, outstanding liabilities............................................          3.67

.Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888........................                10,000. 00
202        REPORT OF THE CHIEF                       OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project, viz, im-
  provement between Grand Rapids and Conradi's shoals..............                            $9,127.50
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                      9, 200. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Z 3.)
   4. Reservoirs at headwaters of Mississippi River.-The object of the
reservoirs is to collect surplus water, principally from the precipitation
of winter, spring, and early summer, to be systematically released so as
to benefit navigation upon the Mississippi River below the dams. The
reservoir project is the outcome of surveys and examinations made in
1869, 1874, 187-8, and 1879. From the results of these examinations, and
further examinations made in 1880, the first cost of constructing reservoir
dams in Minnesota and Wisconsin was placed at $1,809,083. The cost
of land and other damages to result from construction and operation of
the proposed dams was not included in that estimate, as they could not
be predicted with any approach to accuracy.
   The present project consists in constructing reservoir .dams at the
headwaters of the Mississippi River in Minnesota, that locality having
been selected for commencing the work in consequence of an appropria-
tion made by the river and harbor act approved June 14, 1880, for con-
struction of a reservoir dam at Lake Winnibigoshish, Minnesota, and
for other reasons given in Appendix Y to the Annual Report for 1886.
Four of the reservoirs have thus far been created.
   During the past fiscal year, surveys and examinations were made
upon which to base plans for increasing the lift of the Pokegama reser-
voir 2 feet, and from which to ascertain the feasibility and cost of creat-
ing a reservoir at Sandy Lake, Minnesota.
   The four completed reservoirs were operated in the interest of naviga-
tion during the exceedingly dry navigation season of 1887. Without
taking into consideration the liberal volume of water released from them
prior to August, the effect of a continuous discharge of the stored-up
water from them for eighty-six days in August, September, October, and
November, when the Mississippi needed water, was, as estimated by the
officer in charge, to increase the channel depth of the Mississippi River
at Saint Paul from 1 foot to 1 feet.
    Some extension was made to the apron at the Pine River dam during
the year.
   Expended during the fiscal year, $12,583.09.
   Expended upon this project to date, including expense of detailedl
surveys and examinations, hydrological measurements, land damages,
awards to Indians, and care of the completed damrns and of the Engineer
property pertaining to them, $596,800.27.
July 1, 1887, amount available ......----.........---...       ....... _.......                38, 282. 82
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ....................          $11, 617. 16
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities.................. ......                  965.93
                                                                                       --      12, 583.09

July 1, 1888, balance available...... ..........................             .......           25, 699.73
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.......................                           12,000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .........             ........           37, 699. 73

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project......                      1, 174, 600.00
j Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1890, for care and maintenance ----.................             ..                        12, 000. 00
 [ Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
 ( harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Z 4.)
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                 203
    5. Chippewa River, including Yellow Banks, Wisconsin.--This work
consists in the construction of dams and jetties to confine the low-water
volume to a practicable channel, and in revetment of caving bends be-
tween Eau Claire and the mouth of the river, a distance of 57 miles.
The project was adopted in 1877, and its cost then placed at $75,790.
Revised estimates in 1883, however, increased the estimate to $132,476.35,
including in this latter all the expenditures from the commencement of
the improvement. Further revision in 1887 showed the cost of comple-
tion to be at that date $55,522.96. The total expended to June 30, 1888,
including outstanding liabilities, is $115,712.72.
    The work for improvement performed during the past fiscal year con-
sisted in some extensions to and repairs of wing-dams, jetties, and re-
vetments.
    By the works constructed for the improvement of the river a low-water
depth of 3 to 4 feet has been maintained, where before they were under-
taken the depth seldom exceeded 18 inches. The jetties at the mouth
of the river have been of great benefit to raft and steam-boat naviga-
tion, in securing a stable channel of sufficient depth, where before im-
provement commenced there was a broad bar intersected by shallow,
shiftiig channels, passable with difficulty at times of low water by
steamers and rafts.
    A number of bars between the mouth and Eau Claire still require im-
provement.
    The object of the work at Yellow Banks is to prevent erosion of the
high sand-banks or bluffs on the Chippewa River below Eau Claire, and
thereby relieve the channels of this river and of the Mississippi below
the junction of the two streams from the masses of sand contributed
by those banks.
    The project for improvement was adopted in 1883. The estimated
cost of the work was originally placed at $61,102.50. The estimate,
however, as revised in 1883, was increased to $96,000, from experience
as the work progressed. The protection work consists of revetment of
piling and fascines. The revetment shouldbe crowned with rock.
   The total expended on the project to June 30, 1888, including outstand-
ing liabilities, is $30,000.
    Slight repairs were made to the works during-the fiscal year, but no
new protection work was undertaken, owing to want of funds.
July 1, 1887, amount available ....-                .................----               ...............---.            $5,470.04
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
   liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ................                     ........                   $4,406.21
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ....-----.....---.. ..............                                      26. 55
                                                                                                                        4, 432. 76

July 1, 1888, balance available..--.........--.-------.....--...-------........--------------...........                1,037.28
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ......................                                                   10, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ............---......                                            11,037. 28
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..-...  77, 000. 00
   Amount that can beprofitably expended in fiscal yearendingJune30, 190 30, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and   -
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix Z 5.)
  6. Saint Croix River, Wisconsin and Minnesota.--The original project,.
adopted in 1878, contemplated removal of obstructions from the chan-
nels between Taylor's Falls, Minn., and Prescott, Wis. There was ex-
pended under this project $18,000.
  The present project, adopted in 1880 and modified as to cost in 1882,
204             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

-consists,in addition to the removal of obstructions from the channel
between Taylor's Falls and Prescott, in the contraction of the low-water
channel into one of nearly uniform width, especially at the bars and
crossings, by means of jetties of brush and stone, and dams of same
materials to close island chutes and secondary channels. The estimated
-ost was $83,450.
   No work could be undertaken during the past fiscal year for want of
funds.
   The work performed since the adoption of the present project has re-i
sulted in a least depth of 3 feet on the improved bars above Stillwater,
and 4 to 5 feet on the bars below that place. At many places naviga-
tion has been made permanent where formerly it was uncertain, and in
other places it has been made practicable where before improvement
commenced it was impossible. Some bars yet require improvement and
some of the existing works are in need of small repairs.
   Expended under the present project to June 30, 1888, including out-
:standing liabilities, $64,362.32.
July 1, 1887, amount available..         .. .....................................                         $458. 49
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ........................                              $312. 49
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..........................                                8.32
                                                                                                           320.81
                                                                                                           S

July 1, 1888, balance available..........................................                                   137. 68
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 . ..........         - - - -- ---..........--------....   10, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889....................                               10,137.68
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..-......                                8, 950. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                            9, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
       harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Z 6.)
   7. Minnesota River, Minnesota.-For want of funds no work for im-
provement was done during the past fiscal year. The last appropriation
for this stream was made by the river and harbor act of June 18, 1878.
   The river and harbor act approved August 5, 1886, authorized a sur-
vey of the Minnesota River with a view to its improvement by locks
and idams. The survey was made in 1887, the report upon which is
printed in House Ex. Doc. No. 158, Fiftieth Congress, first session.
  Total expended under the last adopted project for improvement of
this stream, $29,967.
July 1, 1887, amount available, including outstanding liabilities ($9) ....                               *$42. 00
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities .........----...... ----    --......------....
                                                               ..---                                         9. 00
July 1, 1888, balance available .------.....-----.....--------------...... -----............---....----      33. 00
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                                 10, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June, 1889 ......................                               10, 033. 00
   (See Appendix Z 7.)
   8. Red River of the North, Minnesota and Dakota.-The project for the
improvement of this river from Breckenridge to the northern boundary
line, adopted in 1877, and amended as to cost in 1883, consists in the
removal of snags, leaning trees, and bowlders, and in dredging chan-
nels through the bars, at an estimated cost of $179,310. A revised esti-
mate made in 1887 placed the cost of completing the improvement at
 $79,598.37.
             SDeposited to credit of Treasurer of the United States, November 11, 1885.
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                              205
  During the past fiscal year dredging was carried on upon the lower
8 miles of Goose Rapids, at points between the rapids and Grand
Forks, and on bars to a point 62 miles by river below the latter-named
point.
  There have been expended upon the improvement to June 30, 1888,
including outstanding liabilities, $160,212.52.
  Before improvement the ruling depth upon bars between Moorhead
and Goose Rapids, at ordinarily low water, was but 1J feet; and below
Grand Forks 2 feet, while between Moorhead and Abercrombie the nav-
igation was at all times difficult. The channels for 80 miles below Moor-
head, and on the lower half of Goose Rapids, and between Frog Point
and Grand Forks, have been improved to afford, at ordinarily low water,
3 feet, and below Grand Forks for 62 miles, 4 feet of depth. The re-
moval of snags and trees between Moorhead (opposite Fargo) and Aber-
crombie, a distance of 76 miles, improved that portion of the stream for
navigation during high and medium stages of water.
July 1, 1887, amount available..----.... ----.................---................ $22, 065.61
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887....-----....-----.........------.----------..---..-....----......... 12,330. 48
July 1, 1888, balance available....... .................. .................                   9,735. 13
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888--.........................                     20,000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889--------...----..------..........       29, 735.13,


  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 30, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
                                  with
                                 requirements of sections 2 of river and

      (See Appendix Z 8.)
   9. The Missouri Riverfrom Sioux City, Iowa, to FortBenton, Montana.--
This work was in charge of Capt. C. B. Sears, Corps of Engineers, to
April 16, 1888.
   The work of improvement is at present confined to the extent of river
between Fort Benton and Carroll, Mont., and consists in the construc-
tion of wing-dams and dams to close secondary channels, so as to con-
tract the water-way where too wide and to raise the water on the rapids
and thus reduce the slope; also in dredging out the heavier gravel-bars
and in removing projecting rock and loose bowlders, where necessary,
with the expectation of ultimately securing between Fort Benton and
Carroll a navigable depth of 41 feet at low water.
   The original condition of the navigable channel between the points
named was extremely bad at low-water stages, the depth only averag-
ing 3 feet, the channel having many sharp turns and being obstructed
in many places by projecting embedded rocks and loose bowlders.
   The river from Carroll to Sioux City was, and is, bad during low-water
stages, owing to unstable banks, shifting channel, moving sand-bars,
and snags. The originally adopted project for the improvement com-
prised the removal of snags from the lower or sandy portion and on the
upper or rocky portion the contraction of the water-way so as to afford
a navigable channel of 4 feet depth at low water. On this project the
expenditure to June 30, 1886, was $202,456.87. At that date the chan-
nel for purposes of navigation was much better than at any previous
period, and vessels loaded to 31 feet draught could, by careful pilotageo
and hard rubbing on the bottom, reach Fort Benton.
  During the year ending June 30, 1888, three dams were built at
Shonkin Bar and six at Crocondunez, the former increasing the.chan
206           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

nel depth 6 inches and the latter increasing it 12 inches. Two small
dams were also built near Rowe's Ranche, a few miles below the Cro-
condunez. Total expended during the year, $30,639.17. Total ex-
pended under the project, $262,458.53.
July 1, 1887, amount available .........................................             $30, 639. 17
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887........................           $30, 359.83
July 1, 1868, outstanding liabilities ..........................              279.34
                                                                                            30, 639.17

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project* above
     Carroll ............................           ............   ...---         ......
                                                                              ----..       250, 000.00
{ Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30, 1890 100, 000. 00
SSubmitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Z 11.)
  10. Yellowstone River, Montana and Dakota.-This work was in charge
of Capt. Or B. Sears, Corps of Engineers, to April 16, 1888.
  The original condition of the navigable channel of the Yellowstone
was bad and unsafe, due to the existence of numerous swift rapids, to
crooked and shallow channel at low water, and to the presence of rocks
and loose bowlders. By removing the latter at the worst places and
by confining the water to one channel so as to increase the depth on
the rapids the river has been considerably improved for purposes of
commerce. Up to July 1, 1886, $98,306.74 had been expended upon tahe
improvement, and at that date the condition of the improved river was
much better than at present, as the dams hhve received no repairs since
that date and are broken in many places. No work for improvement
has been done since the fiscal year ending June 30, 1886, owing princi-
pally to insufficiency of funds. The engineer property pertaining to
the improvement was, however, put in repair and cared for. Total
expended to June 30, 1888, $104,489.27.
July 1, 1887, amount available ............................-.............                   16, 530. 83
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887............................                    .............      3,269. 85
July 1, 1888, balance available             ....................-.---......                 13, 260.98
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 106, 000. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 25, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix Z 12.)

EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS FOR IMPROVEMENT TO COMPLY WITH
  REQUIREMENTS OF THE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT OF AUGUST 5,
   1886.
  It appearing, after preliminary examination by the local engineer,
that the localities were worthy of improvement, Major Allen was charged
with and completed the following surveys and examinations, the results
of which were transmitted to Congress and printed in House Ex. Doc.
No. 158, Fiftieth Congress, first session.
  1. Miississippi River between Saint Paul and Saint Anthony's Falls,
Minnesota. (See also Appendix Z 13.)               *
  2. Minnesota River, with a view to its improvement by locks and dams.
(See also Appendix Z 14.)
   3. Led River of the North, Minnesota, from Moorhead to Fergus Falls.
 (See also Appendix Z 15.)
                            *No project for river below Carroll, except snagging.
                     RIVER      AND    HARBOR          IMPROVEMENTS.                                   207
IMPROVEMENT OF TENNESSEE AND CUMBERLAND RIVERS, AND                                                      OF
    CERTAIN RIVERS IN EASTERN TENNESSEE AND KENTUCKY.

   Officer in charge, Lieut. Col. J. WV. Barlow, Corps of Engineers, with
Lieut. II. E. Waterman, Corps of Engineers, under his immediate or-
ders.
   1. Tennessee River.-a. Ab ve Chattanooga.-Thepresent project is to
blast a channel through the reefs, to reduce the sand and gravel bars,
and to build riprap dams to contract the water-way, so as to obtain a
safe, navigable channel having a depth of 3 feet at low water. The
rocky bed and banks render the improvement practically permanent.
   The snag and tow boat for use on this river and its tributaries was
completed during the fiscal year, and was employed in towing stone-
barges at Half Moon Island and in the removal of snags at other points
along the river. Work was carried on atBlaker's Shoals, Russell Shoals,
and Caney Creek Shoals, constructing wing-dams and removing surface
obstructions.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, including outstanding
liabilities, is $2x3,947.70, which has resulted in giving an improved
channel by removing or reducing obstructions, and thus lengthening
the season of navigation.
July 1, 1887, amount available .$..............    ........    .... .....    ......               $5, 274.90
July 1, 1884, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 .........                     .    5, 177.49
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..... ......   ...... ..    ..          45.11
                                                                                                   5, 222. 60
July 1, 1868, balance available .-..            .
                                             .....   ......   ...... .....   ...........   .           52. 30
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188~..--............
                                                            --.......                             15, 000. 00

.Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ..........                 ....
                                                                                   ...      .
                                                                                           .15,      052. 30

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                      30, 000. 00
  Sub:Jitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1566 and 1867.
   (See Appendix A A 1.)
  b. Below Chattanooga.-The section of the river from Chattanooga,
Tenn., to Brown's Ferry, Ala., was obstructed by reefs, bars, etc., and
had about 3 feet of water in the channel for eight or nine months in each
year. From Brown's Ferry to Florence it was not navigable, the Mus-
cle Shoals forming an absolute barrier, excepting when the river was at
an unusually high stage. From Florence to mouth of the river the usual
surface obstructions were found, with many shoals, having deep water
between them.
   The present project consists in building around the Big Muscle Shoals
a canal 14J miles long, 70 to 120 feet wide, and 6 feet deep, having nine
locks, each 300 feet between gates and 60 feet wide, and an aqueduct
over Shoal Creek 900 feet long, 60 feet wide, and 5 feet deep; in con-
structing a canal around the Elk River Shoals, 1 miles long, with two
locks; and in blasting a channel through the bed-rock and building
wing-dams at Little Muscle Shoals, a modification of the original plan
for a system of lockage ; and in improving the most troublesome places
above Decatur and below Florence.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, including outstanding
liabilities, is $2,957,377.28, which has resulted in the improvement of
the river, as follows:
   The Little Muscle Shoals work, as modified, has been practically com-
pleted by cutting a channel through the bed-rock, 2k miles long, and
208        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

building wing-dams. It may, however, become necessary in the future
to make modifications of the existing dams, or to build locks, as origin-
ally projected.
   At Big Muscle Shoals and Elk River Shoals the eleven locks are built
and all the miter-gates are in position. The five lower locks are to have
drop-gates, one of which, at Lock No. 5, is already hung. The Shoal,
Creek Aqueduct is nearly finished; it sustained a severe test by the
heavy floods of March last without injury. A dredge and dump-scows
were built for service in dredging the canal-trunk and approaches.
   Straightening the upper chaunnl entrance to the Elk River Shoals
Canal and raising the walls of Lock A to the level of its upper bay are
recommended. The plans for the radical improvement of the Colbert
Shoals and Bee Tree Shoals, by the construction of two locks and dams,
have been submitted.
   It is expected that both sections of the canal can be opened for the
use of the public during the low-water season of 1889, provided that
sufficient funds are made available without delay.
   Attention is invited to the necessity of removing certain obstruc-
tions immediately below Chattanooga, and of making an instrumental
survey of the river below that city.
July   1, 1887, amount available.......................................                  $94, 883. 13
July   1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of   liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887...... ............. $90, 880. 76
July   1, 1888, outstanding liabilities........................   3, 379.65
                                                                                          94, 260. 41
July 1, 1888, balance available...................... ...............                         622.72
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.................. ....                     250, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889..................                  250, 622.72
(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... 1, 48, 000. 0
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1890 ...... .......... ............. ......... ............... .... 1,000, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix A A 1.)
   2. -FrenchBroad River, Tennessee.-After a course of about 121 miles
in Tennessee, this river joins the Holston, near Knoxville, thus forming
the Tennessee River.
   Above the mouth of Nolichuky River it is not susceptible of improve-
ment, except by building locks and dams, at a heavy cost, and the com-
merce, present and prospective, does not warrant such an expenditure.
The present plan seeks to improve the channel so as to obtain a depth
of 2 feet at low water, from the mouth of the river to Leadvale, about
90 miles, the work consisting of channel excavation, clearing away of
surface obstructions, and building wing-dams, where necessary, to con-
tract the water-way.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, including outstanding
liabilities, is $28,000, and has resulted in securing an improved channel
below Dandridge, by giving an additional depth of water over several
of the worst shoals.
July 1, 1887, amount available ...........................                ..     ......  $4, 727.40
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ........................              $4, 682. 96
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ................          .........         44.44
                                                                                          4,727. 40
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ...................              ... ...    10, 000. 00
                    RIVER AND         HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                       209
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..... ... $112, 000.00
Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal'year ending June 30, 1890 20, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix A A 2.)
  3. Little Tennessee River, Tennessee.-This river rises in the Blue
Ridge, and is an important tributary to the Upper Tennessee.
  An examination was made in 1881, upon which is based the present
plan of improvement, which is to remove surface obstructions, reduce
rock-reefs and gravel-bars, and build wing dams to contract the water-
way so as to obtain a low-water channel 40 feet wide and 2 feet deep
below the mouth of the Tellico River, a distance of about 13 miles.
  No work has been done since December, 1883.
  The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, is $5,000, which has
resulted in securing an improved channel.
SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ $18, 724.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix A A 3.)
   4. Hiawassee River, Tennessee.-This river is an affluent of the Ten-
nessee. An examination was made in 1874. The natural channel is
obstructed by rock-reefs, bowlders, snags, and overhanging trees.
   The present plan is to obtain a navigable channel 40 feet wide and 2
feet deep at average low water from the mouth of the river to head of
navigation, about 33 miles, by reducing the reefs and bars, removing
surface obstructions, building wing-dams, etc.
   No work has been done during the fiscal year.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, including outstanding
liabilities is $34,000, and has resulted in obtaining an improved chan.
nel below Charleston.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ...............     ........   $1,000. 00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-- --........1,500.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 1, 500. 00
  Submitted in compliance   with  requirements   of sections 2 of river  and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix A A 4.)
   5. Clinch River, Tennessee.-The Clinch River rises in Virginia and
enters the Tennessee near Kingston, Tenn." It is about 400 miles in
length, 230 miles of which are in Tennessee.
   The present plan of improvement consists in lengthening the season of
navigation and in securing a safe channel, having a depth at ordinary low
water of 2 feet to Clinton, 70 miles, and 1 feet from Clinton to Walker's
Ford, 75 miles. Above this point, to the Tennessee and Virginia State
line, 85 miles, the only work that can be done to advantage is to reduce the
ledges and remove surface obstructions sufficiently to assist the passage
of flat-boats and rafts on the sudden rises or " tides "caused by heavy rains.
   During the year work has been carried on principally at Cloud's
Shoals, about 113 miles from mouth of river, by reducing the rock-
ledges in channel and building wing-dams.
   The channel of river between Cloud's Shoals and Hibb's Shoals-
about 18 miles-has been cleared of snags, overhanging trees, fish-trap
dams, etc. The Engineer officer in charge urges the importance of leg-
islation or executive action in the matter of the building of fish-traps
and trap dams upon this stream, and calls attention to their character
as serious channel obstructions. These dams appear to be authorized
        ENG 88       14
210         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

under the fish law of Tennessee, as amended by the legislature of that
State in 1885.
   The total amount expended to June 30,1888, is $25,958.09, which has re-
sulted in securing an improved channel at many of the principal obstruc-
tions, and practically safe navigation for rafts and flat-boats at stages of
the river 2 or 3 feet lower than before channel-work was begun in 1880.
July 1, 1887, amount available ............         ............................             $4, 425.90
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ........................                  $4, 313. 15
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities........ ..................                      70. 84
                                                                                              4, 383.99
July 1, 1888, balance available              ............-------.........---................
                                                                                        --                       41.91
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ....-    - - -- -....-........ --
                                                - ....-....                                                  5, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889. ---.... ---.... --....-- -. -                         5, 041.91
   Amount estimated) required for completion of existing project .----.                                     19,000. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                10,000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix A A 5.)
  6. Duck River, Tennessee.-This stream flows wholly in the State of
Tennessee.     Its length is about 250 miles. An examination, below Cen-
treville, was made in 1879. Obstructions were found to nearly close
the channel in places. Work began in September, 1880, removing
snags, etc., reducing gravel-bars, and building wing dams. No chan-
nel-work has been done since December, 1882. The total amount ex-
pended to June 30, 1888, is $13,000, and has resulted in securing a fair
navigable channel, during the boating season, from Centreville to mouth
of river, about 68 miles. The character of this stream is such that
snags, fallen trees, etc., accumulate rapidly, and these obstructions should
be removed after heavy floods.
SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-..-...... $22,118. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix A A 6.)
   7. Cumberland River, Tennessee and Kentucky.-Below Nashville.-The
project for improving this section consists in deepening and widening
the channel, removing surface obstructions, and building riprap dams
to contract the water-way', to remove the bar at mouth of river, and
secure a navigable channel at low water to the deep waters of the Ohio.
   Work was carried on during the first six months of the fiscal year,
clearing away snags and other surface obstructions from Nashville to
the mouth of the river, and in channel excavation and building wing-
dams at several points.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, including outstanding
liabilities, is $254,858.35, which has resulted in securing an improved
channel at the most dangerous obstructions and a lengthened season
of navigation.
July 1, 1887, amount available ................               ......-------..................              $11, 350. 66
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887----------------------
                                      ........................                          $11, 005.58
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities .. .................-......                                203. 43
                                                                                                            11,209. 01
July 1, 1888, balance available .....................                     .................                     141.65
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 --.. ... ---...-..                       -. ----.             10, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...--....-                               --...... ...-. 10, 141. 65
{Amount                RIVER AND HARBOR                  IMPROVEMENTS.

        (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ $83,000.00
  Amountthatcanbeprofitably expended in fiscalyear ending June30, 1890 20, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                               211


     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix A A 7.)
   Above Nashville.-This section extends from Nashville to the head of
Smith's Shoals.
   The work done prior to the adoption of the present project has re-
sulted in securing an increased depth of from 6 to 8 inches over the
principal obstructions, and also in giving an improved channel and
lengthened season of navigation from Burnside, Ky., to Nashville,
Tenn.
   The present project consists of a radical improvement, by a system
of locks and dams, from Nashville to head of Smith's Shoals.
   The site of Lock No. 1, near Lower Nashville Island, has been de-
termined upon, and work of lock-pit excavation and construction of
lock-wall will be carried on under contract, provided the bids received
are reasonable and advantageous to the Government.
   From August to November, inclusive, a snagging party moved down
from Burksville to Nashville, clearing the channel of snags and over-
hanging trees, excavating rock and gravel, and extending and repair-
ing dams at various points.
   The total amount expended under the existing project to June 30,
1888, including outstanding liabilities, is $54,424.20, and has been ap-
plied to the improving of the shoals above Nashville, and in the neces-
sary surveys and observations and estimates pertaining to the projected
work of lock construction.
July 1, 1887, amount available ........................................                  $77, 611. 19
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887......--....         ........ $6,408.93
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities .........----..---...      ---
                                                                  .       626. 46
                                                                                           7, 035. 39
July 1, 1888, balance available......--.......... ..................---......
                                                                     ----                 70,575.80
                                                                      -
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .....................---..                 200,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889--..........---------..------....   270, 575. 80

 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... 3, 753, 000. 00
SAmount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
              --------.----------------------...------------------.
     30, 1890...                                                                         400,000.00
 | Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
 ( harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix A A 7.)
    8. South Fork of Cumberland River, Kentucky.--This stream is an af-
fluent of the Cumberland River, which it enters near the head of navi-
gation, at Burnside, Ky.
   An examination was made in 1881. The obstructions in the lower
section from " Devil's Jumps" to the mouth, about 44 miles, are rock-
reefs, gravel-bars, etc., while above the " Devil's Jumps" immense
bowlders are also found in the channel, which can only be removed at
great expense.
   The present project provides for improving the channel of the 44
miles of river below the " Devil's Jumps" by reducing the reefs and
bars, removing bowlders, and building riprap dams to contract the water-
way so as to secure safe navigation at a 3-foot stage above low water.
   From July to September work was carried on in the channel, reach-
ing to a point 16 miles from mouth of the river.
212          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, was $11,968.94, which
has resulted in securing an improvement of the channel for the passage
of rafts and boats.
July   1, 1887, amount available$..... ......     ..-......        -..           .......       $1,877. 36
July   1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of
July
                                                   -----------
       liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887...... ................
       1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ...................... ....
                                                                              $1, 836.33
                                                                                    9. 97
                                                                                                1, 846. 30
July 1, 1888, balance available .-----.....------...................................                31. 06
     Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......                    50, 803. 00
     Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearendingJune 30, 1890                  10, 000.00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
 (     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix A A 8.)
   9. Caney Fork River, Tennessee.-This stream flows wholly in the State
of Tennessee, and is an important tributary of the Cumberland River,
which it enters near Carthage, Tenn., about 120 miles above Nashville.
   The river has been examined to Frank's Ferry, about 92 miles from its
mouth.
   The obstructions were found to be gravel-bars, snags, and overhang-
ing trees, with a crooked channel and numerous shoals, making naviga-
tion insecure at all seasons. The present plan is to clear, deepen, and
straighten the channel by removing surface obstructions, building wing-
dams and training-walls, so as to secure safe navigation for rafts, flat-
boats, and light-draught steamers during the boating season, usually
from February to July-five months.
   Active operations were carried on during the first three months of the
fiscal year, clearing the channel and chutes of snags and brush, and in
building wing-dams at Trousdale's Ferry, James's Shoals, and other
points.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, including outstanding
liabilities, is $19,421.95, which has resulted in obtaining a greatly im-
proved channel as far up as Sligo Ford when the river is at a 3-foot
stage above low-water mark.
July 1, 1887, amount available......--...... .......................-..           . $2, 510.98
July 1. 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 -        -....-......-....  ...... $1,913.93
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ................ ...........            19.00
                                                                                           -    1,932.93

July 1, 1888, balance available...... ............----......--------   .............               578.05
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .. ...... .. ..-- --..............                2, 500. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889........ ............                      3, 078.05
     Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project......                      22, 700.00
     Amountthat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                  5, 000. 00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
       harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix A A 9.)

EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS FOR IMPROVEMENT, TO COMPLY WITH
  REQUIREMENTS OF THE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT OF AUGUST 5,
     1886.
  It appearing, after preliminary examination by the local engineer,
that the localities were worthy of improvement, Lieutenant Colonel
Barlow was charged with and completed the following surveys, the
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                      213
results of which were transmitted to Congress and printed as House
Ex. Doe. No. 84, Fiftieth Congress, first session.
   1. Obeils [Obeys] River from the point where improvements have here-
tofore been made to the mouth of the West Fork, Tennessee. (See also
Appendix A A 10.)
   2. Bear Creek, Mississippi (Big Bear Greek), Mississippi and Alabama.
(See also Appendix A A 11.)

IMPROVEMENT OF THE OHIO, MONONGAHELA, MUSKINGUM, AND AL-
  LEGHENY RIVERS-OPERATING AND CARE OF DAVIS ISLAND LOCK
  AND DAM, OHIO RIVER ; LOCK AND DAM NO. 9, MONONGAHELA
  RIVER, AND THE LOCKS AND DAMS ON THE MUSKINGUM RIVER-
  CONSTRUCTION OF ICE-HARBOR AT MOUTH OF MUSKINGUM RIVER,
  OHIO, AND OF LOCK AND DAM AT HERR'S ISLAND, ALLEGHENY
  RIVER.

   Officer in charge, Lieut. Col. William E. Merrill, Corps of Engineers,
having under his immediate orders First Lieuts. Lansing H. Beach and
Cassius E. Gillette, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Ohio River.-The general method followed in improving the navi-
gation of the Ohio River is to secure additional depths at islands
and sand-bars by the construction of low dams closing unused passages,
and by building guiding-dikes to confine the water to narrower chan-
nels. A snag-boat and two dredges, all of them having iron hulls, are
owned by the United States, and find constant employment during the
low-water season in taking out snags and wrecks, and in dredging away
gravel-bars that can not otherwise be removed.
   The first appropriation for the improvement of the Ohio River was
made in 1827. The total amount thus far appropriated is $3,770,479.25.
In addition to this there has been allotted to this river a portion of
twenty-three different combined appropriations for the Ohio, Mississippi,
Missouri, and Arkansas rivers, which aggregated $1,947,000, but the
amount thus allotted is unknown.
   The following is a summary of the work done during the fiscal year:
   Three Brothers Islands.-The dam at this locality was repaired by re-
laying paving and filling a few vacant spaces.
   Dike at middle of Grand Chain.-Three-fifths of this work is finished;
its total length will be 3,000 feet. The contract has been extended to
December 1, 1888.
   Removing rocks at Grand Chain.-A blasting plant, with diver and
dredge-boat, was employed by contract at the Grand Chain in remov-
ing submerged rocks, and during the fiscal year the total amount taken
out of the river was 11,472 tons. The Jackson Rocks were wholly re-
moved (except a small area not in the channel), and a marked reduction
was made in the sizes of the Arkansas and Grenadier rocks.
   Ice-piers.-No work on the ice-piers was done during the season, as
the whole year was expended in securing proper cessions of riparian
rights.
   Bar at mouth of the Licking.-The contract for this work was com-
pleted and closed, resulting in the excavation of a channel 135 feet long
with an average width of 65 feet. This was all that could be done with
the funds available.
   Great Miami Embankment.-This work consists in raising the track of
the Lawrenceburgh Branch of the Cincinnati, Indianapolis, Saint Louis
and Chicago Railroad, so that it will act as a levee to protect Lawrence-
214        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

burgh from floods. The contractor is the railroad company that owns
the track, and at the close of the year the work was about two-thirds
done.
   Dredging.--The United States dredges Ohio and Oswego worked on
the Ohio River from June 18 to November 21, a period of five months,
and were then transferred to the Muskingum. During this period they
dredged 680 cubic yards of shale below the Davis Island Lock, 6,607
c.ubic yards from Wheeling Creek Bar, and 140,520 cubic yards from the
channel near the Three Brothers Islands, besides doing much miscella-
neous work.
   Snagging.-The snag-boat E. A. Woodruff worked from June 17, 1887,
to November 13, 1887, a period of nearly five months, during which
time she removed 1,225 snags, 127 rocks, and 46 wrecks, besides doing
some miscellaneous work.
   Harborof Refuge near Cincinnati.-The three dikes at Four-Mile Bar
that make this harbor of refuge have been completed. Their lengths
are 2,135, 2,477, and 2,500 feet, respectively.
   For information relating to the stages of the Ohio River, the water-
gauges established, the slope and navigability of the river, the dimen-
sions of bridges, and losses incurred through collision with the same,
as well as for a historical sketch of the improvement of the river, refer-
ence is made to the report of the officer in charge.
July 1, 1887, amount available .--------            --....................................               $198, 914.37
September 12, 1887, balance of allotment for ice-harbor at
  mouth of Great Kanawha River transferred to Col. W. P.
  Craighill, Corps of Engineers ......-......-..................    $168. 44
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ........................  129, 424. 42
July 1, 1838,   outstanding liabilities      ..          ......                            422. 40
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts ..........                        52, 696. 16
                                                                                            --            182, 711. 42

July 1, 1888, balance available .-... ......-....          _....-....        ...........          ....     16, 202.95
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888. - ..-                    ......
                                                                          -... --   ...... ....           380, 000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ..........-........                                 396, 202. 95
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscalyearendingJune30, 1890 600, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix B B 1.)
  2. Operating and care of Davis Island Dam, Ohio River.-This dam
was built to test the adaptability of the system of movable dams to the
peculiar conditions of the Ohio River, and to the special character of
the commerce that navigates it. The dam was intended, if successful, to
be th3 first step in the radical improvement of the Ohio, and, being the
one nearest Pittsburgh, it has the incidental effect of giving this city a
deep and navigable harbor at all times. Its benefit was especially evi-
dent during the prolonged drought of 1887, as there was at all times a
minimum depth of 6 feet in the Monongahela Harbor.
  During the fiscal year the dam was up two hundred and one days
and 712 lockages were made, passing 1,871 vessels.
  The operations of the lock were very satisfactory. The dam, how-
ever, did not do so well, as the defective steel cross-heads continued to
give trouble, and the long continuance of low water made it almost
impossible to take out wickets for repairs.
  After remaining up six months the dam was lowered in the face of
an ice-flood, and considerable damage ensued, partly due to the direct
                       RIVER AND HARBOR                    IMPROVEMENTS.                          215
impact of fields of ice, and partly to the giving away of the defective
cross-heads, which threw abnormal strains on the other members. The
damages, however, were sufficiently repaired during the spring to per-
mit the dam to be raised on June 18, and it was still standing at the
close of the fiscal year.
   The experience of last winter shows that some changes should be
made to enable the dam to successfully encounter ice and drift. For
this purpose the officer in charge recommends the removal of the Pas-
queau hurters of the weirs and the substitution of Chanoine hurters
with trippers. This change has been authorized. The addition of a
drift-gap, for which provision is made in the last river and harbor act,
will also contribute to the same end. With these two changes it is
thought that there will be no further trouble.
   Amount expended during the year, $16,309.01; amount required for
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1889, $18,015.
   (See Appendix B B 2.)
   3. Monongahela River, West Virginia and Pennsylvania.-The object
of the locks and dams which the United States is building on the Monon-
gahela River is to extend the existing slackwater from the mouth of
Dun kards Creek, Pennsylvania, to Morgantown, W. Va., a distance of
14 miles. Two locks and dams are required for this extension; iNo. 9,
the upper, was completed in 1880; No. 8, the one next below, is in course
of construction. When completed, these locks and dams will give 6
feet in low water from Morgantown to Dunkards Creek, whence there
is already 4 feet to Pittsburgh, secured by seven locks and dams be-
longing to the Monongahela Navigation Company. The distance from
Morgantown to Pittsburgh is 102 miles. At Pittsburgh the Monon-
gahela slackwater connects with the pool of the Davis Island Dam.
   The total amount heretofore appropriated for this improvement is
$397,900, of which sum $348,038.03 have been expended to June 30,
1888.
   Work was actively carried on during the entire season of 1887, and
was resumed in the spring of 1888; during this time the masonry of
the lock was completed, except a small amount of coping, and the abut-
ment on the opposite bank of the river was about four-fifths completed.
July 1, 1887, amount available ...........................   ...... ........                 $84, 095.26
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 .......................                $32, 152. 95
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ...............        ..............     2,080. 34
                                                                                        --    34, 233.29

July 1, 1888, balance available .........................................                     49, 861. 97
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .......................--.                      35, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.... ................                    84, 861.97
   (See Appendix B B 3.)
   4. Operating and care of Lock and Damn No. 9, Monongahela River.-
During the low water of 1887 the apron below the dam, which was
built in 1884, was extended across the whole width of the river, and it
is believed that all danger of undermining has been removed. Minor
repairs were made on other parts of the work.
   The land-wall shows signs of defective construction, and it is pro-
posed to fill it with cement grout, and to raise the chamber-walls and
lower buttresses to the height of the upper buttresses, in order to make
the lock available in higher stages of the river than is now the case.
These repairs have been authorized.
216        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Amount expended during the fiscal year, $10,895.30. Amount re-
quired for year ending June 30, 1889, $6,470.
   (See Appendix B B 4.)
   5. Allegheny River, Pennsylvania.-The work hitherto done on this
river has been limited to the removal of rocks, of which there was a
vast number in and near the channel, and to the closure at two locali-
ties of duplicate channels. The benefit of such work has been very
apparent.
   The money thus far appropriated for the improvement of the river
amounts to $135,000.
   During the past season the dam at Corydon, Pa., was modified so as
to make it safe for the passage of rafts in high water. Repairs were
made on the low dams at Nicholson's Island and Six Mile Island, and
540 tons of rocks were taken out of the river.
July 1, 1887, amount available...............--------...........--.....-----......                                           $6, 850.23
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 .....------....--... , ..------....---....------.....
                                                                       ......--..---......--..                                6, 190. 90
July 1, 1888, balance available           ...-.    ................................                                             69.   33
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.......................                                                         25, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.............. ......                                                   25, 659.33
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                                  50, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix B B 5.)
  6. Damn at Herr's Island, Allegheny River.-The object of this dam is
to extend navigable water up the Allegheny from the head of the pool
of the Davis Island Dam to the city limits, thus completing the im-
provement of the harbor of Pittsburgh'and providing the means for the
cheap transfer of freights at all seasons. This dam will also be the first
step towards the radical improvement of the Allegheny River, a work
that promises most valuable results.
  The construction of this lock and dam has hitherto been prevented
by the lack of authority to purchase the necessary land. This obstacle
has lately been removed, and the work of acquiring a site is now under
way. It is hoped that the work of construction may be begun in 1889.
The money thus far appropriated for this work amounts to $37,500.
July 1, 1887, amount available ........                            .....         .............                   .--.       $37, 340. 00
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887..--.... --...... ----.... .....-- 491.55
                                                                           1.
July 1, 18;8, outstanding liabilities- .......----.................      256. 45
                                                                                                                                 748. 00
July 1, 1888, balance available ..........              ......          ....-
                                                                       -....--             ....-----....--....    ----...    36, 592. 00
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ..................-
                                                           - - -......                                                       35, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889........
                                                       --- ---.. ---.                                                        71, 592. 00


  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 100, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with iequirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix B B 6.)
   7. Ice-harbor at mouth of Muskin unt River, Ohio.-The work in hand
is the construction of a lock through Dam No. 1, Muskingum River, in
order to permit Ohio River craft to take refuge in ice times in Pool No.
1, Muskingum River. This lock is also needed to replace Lock No. 1 of
                      RIVER AND HARBOR                 IMPROVEMENTS.                          217
the Muskingum River, which has long been in a threatening condition.
The total amount thus far appropriated for this work is $237,500.
   During the past working season the coffer-dam was extended, so as
to include the whole of the lock, the new area thus protected was exca-
vated to grade, the necessary piles were driven and capped, the lock-
floor was completed, and about half of the new floor was covered with
concrete. At this stage work was stopped on account of the exhaus-
tion of funds.
July 1, 1887, amount available     -.. ---........-- .........   ...... .......... . $27, 851.73
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.---... .----........................---................. 26,689. 27
July 1, 1888, balance available ............---..---- ...........           .........      1,162. 46
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .- -.....   -- ....---- -..... ....---.
                                                                                  -   -   60, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...................                  61,162. 46
   (See Appendix B B 7.)
  8. Muskingum River, Ohio.-The act of August 5, 1886, appropriated
$20,000 for this river, which was expended in repairing the locks and
dams. In obedience to the instructions ofthe Secretary of War, estimates
were prepared by Lieut. Col. W. E. Merrill, Corps of Engineers, of the
entire cost of completing the repairs of the locks and dams in the Mus-
kingum River, and his report was transmitted to Congress by the Sec-
retary of War January 18, 1888, and printed as House Ex. Doc. No.
108, Fiftitth Congress, first session.
   The estimated cost of repairing all of the locks and dams was
$268,128, and of getting rid of the Taylorsville Canal and one lock
$102,000.
  The latter sum is appropriated by the river and harbor act of August
11, 1888.
   9. Operatingand care of the locks and dams on the Muskingum River,
Ohio.-As originally improved by the State of Ohio, the Muskingum
River contained eleven dams and twelve locks, and furnished continuous
navigation for 91 miles from the Ohio River at Marietta to Dresden,
where a connection was made with the Ohio Canal, running from the
Ohio River at Portsmouth to Lake Erie at Cleveland. The locks are
180 feet long and 36 feet in the clear, with lifts varying from 8 feet 10
inches to 12 feet 1 inch. On the 75 miles of slackwater now existing,
which terminates at Zanesville, there are 10 dams, 11 locks, and 5 lat-
eral canals, the total length of the latter being 3P miles. The original
cost of the works was about $1,500,000.
   The United States accepted these works from the State of Ohio on
the 7th of April, 1887, and found them in a state of extreme dilapida-
tion. The lock and dam at Synimes Creek, 10 miles above Zanesville,
had been abandoned, two of the other dams were broken, and the walls
of one lock were on the verge of falling down. Energetic work, aided
by a very favorable season, resulted in the repair of the broken dams
and the threatening lock; such other repairs were made as were most
necessary, and as a result the works passed through the ice and flood
of last winter without injury. Heavy repairs were made on five dams
and four locks. A contract was made for a ladder dredge-boat.
   The most important work now needed is to repair the locks at Stock-
port, McConnellsville, and Eagleport, all of which are in a dangerous
condition; to build a new lock at Taylorsville, thus permitting the
abandonment of the canal at that place, to turn two lifts into one at
218          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Zanesville, and to rebuild lock and Dam No.11, thus restoring connection
with the Ohio Canal.
July 1, 1887, amount available ......    -....... ..... ... .................                     $4,896. 92
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887..--....................---------....................                     4,896. 92

Amount expended during the fiscal year :
   From appropriation of August 5, 1886.... ...................                     $4, 896. 92
   From indefinite appropriation. ..........................                       179, 006. 21
                                                                                  ---             183, 903. 13

Amount for year ending June 30, 1889......-----..............---......--....                      177, 623. 00
   (See Appendix B B 8.)

EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS FOR IMPROVEMENT, TO COMPLY WITH
  REQUIREMENTS OF THE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT OF AUGUST 5,
   1886.
   It appearing, after preliminary examination by the local engineer,
that the localities were worthy of improvement, Lieutenant-Colonel
Merrill was charged with and completed the following survey and exam-
ination, the results of which were transmitted to Congress and printed
in House Ex. Doc. No. 88, Fiftieth Congress, first session :
   1. Ohio River near the city of Evansville, Indiana, to determine what,
if anything, will be necessary to prevent a change of the channel of the river
in front of that city.--(See also Appendix B B 9.)
   2. Big Hockhocking River from its mouth to Coolville, Ohio.-(See also
Appendix B B 10.)

IMPROVEMENT OF THE FALLS OF THE OHIO AND OPERATING AND
  CARE OF THE LOUISVILLE AND PORTLAND CANAL-IMPROVEMENT
  OF WABASH RIVER, INDIANA AND ILLINOIS, OF WHITE RIVER, IN-
  DIANA, AND OF TRADEWATER RIVER, KENTUCKY.

   Officer in charge, Maj. Amos Stickney, Corps of Engineers, having
under his immediate orders Lieut. E. J. Spencer, Corps of Engineers,
until August 19, 1887; and Lieut. W. L. Sibert, Corps of Engineers, from
July 11, 1887, to April 11, 1888.
   1. Falls of the Ohio, Louisville, Kentucky.-By the river and harbor
act approved August 5, 1886, this work, which at first consisted of the
enlargement of the upper portion of the Louisville and Portland Canal,
was made to include the enlargement of the basin of the canal just above
the locks.
   Enlargement of upper portion of Louisville and Portland Canal.-The
present project was adopted in 1883, with the object of enlarging the
upper end of the Louisville and Portland Canal, from a point about 400
feet below the railroad bridge to the upper end of the reef which extends
to a point about opposite Fourth street, which practically makes a wide
harbor from Fourth to Tenth streets, and more than doubles the width
of the canal from Tenth to Fifteenth street. The amount expended to
June 30, 1888, was $245,544.42.
   The work was done under four contracts, three for excavating and
moving materials, and one for the construction of a new canal wall along
the northern line of the improvement. One of the contracts for excava-
tion was completed in November, 1886.
   On the middle section the earth, loose rock, and old wall have been
removed, and about 77 per cent. of the rock excavation completed. On
                        RIVER AND             HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                   219
the upper section about 32 per cent. of the rock excavation has been
completed to grade.
  About one-half of the new canal wall is completed. Work was begun
about the 1st of June, and continued until the 1st of December.
  Under the contracts for excavation of material about 104,116 cubic
yards remain to be removed.
  Enlarqing basin of canal.-On this work the contractors have exca-
vated 108,795 cubic yards of earth, and 3,575 cubic yards of rock.
The amount expended to June 30, 1888, was $25,415.98.
July 1, 1887, amount available......---.......--....--...................... $280,922. 11
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ........................ $103, 189. 71
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ...........................                               19, 236. 94
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts .........                                   140, 048.41
                                                                                                               262, 475. 06
July 1, 1888, balance available............................................                                     18, 447. 05
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                                        150, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                      168, 447. 05
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project, includ-
   ing enlargement of canal basin ............    .................. ......                                    855, 000. 00

L harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                                               370,000.00


  (See Appendix C C 1.)
  2. Indiana Chute, Falls of the Ohio River.-The present project is to
remove projecting points and reefs in the Indiana Chute, to make an un-
obstructed channel, 400 feet in width, between the dam and railroad
bridge. The original chute was crooked, full of projecting rocks, and
very difficult to navigate. The work of the past season was devoted
principally to the left-hand reef, the high points on which were entirely
removed for a distance of about 1,200 feet.
  Isolated points in the channel and on the right-hand reef were also
removed. Work was vigorously prosecuted from September 27, to No-
vember 21. The dam at the head of the Falls and the guiding-dike
north of the canal were thoroughly repaired.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1888, was $115,576.06.
July 1, 1187, amount available ....              .......         -..........................                   $19, 773.96
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
     of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887               ..................                   $10, 350. 02
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ........................                                       11. 50
                                                                                                                10, 361.52

July 1, 1888, balance available .......-............ ....................                                        9, 412, 44
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..................----......                                       15, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                       24,412.44

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                    30, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (S'ee Appendix C C 2.)
   3. Operating and care of Louisville and Portland Canal.-Duringthe
fiscal year the canal was open for the passage of commerce three hun-
dred and forty-five days, having been closed eighteen days on account
of high water and two days by ice. The old locks were used to pass one
boat. During the year 5,471 vessels, representing an undertonnage of
1,315,851 tons, were passed through the canal.
220         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   Necessary repairs have been made to lock machinery and operating
plant.
   The shops and store-houses which were moved on account of the en-
enlargement of the basin above the locks are in place, wish the excep-
tion of one warehouse.
   The tow-boat was docked, and new hog-chains put on her. Proposals
have been received for paving the lower part of the high earth slopes at
the locks to prevent slides during high water. The old tow-boat
Walker Morris was sold at public auction. It is proposed during
the coming year to keep the canal in operation, build new guard-gates
for both the old and new locks, and to excavate a channel below the
new locks over a length of 300 feet and 100 feet wide at a cost of $19,200.
It is also proposed to extend the pipes of the city water-works to the
locks to supply water for the use of the employds.
   The total receipts from all sources amount to $2,494.61.
   The estimated amount required for operating and maintaining the
canal during 1888-'89 is $100,105.
July 1, 1887, amount available.......................................                                           $34, 863. 97
Allotment, year ending June 30, 1888..........................                                    .......        77, -05. 00
                                                                                                                112, 668.97
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887.---..................-------------------...... $48, 809. 25
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities................ ..                             .  4, 646. 51
July 1, 1888, dropped, not drawn...... .....................                           58, 565. 00
                                                                                             ----               112, 020. 76

July 1, 1888, balance available---------
                                   ....----......................----.....--....                                     648. 21
   (See Appendix C C 3.)
  4. Wabash River, Indiana and Illinois.-The first appropriation for
the improvement of this liver was made in 1872. The project contem-
plated the construction of a lock and dam at Grand Rapids near Mount
Carmel, and the removal of rock ledges, sand-bars, snags, and other ob-
structions, and the closing of chutes, with a view to obtaining a navi-
gable channel of 3J feet in depth from the mouth of the river to Vin-
cennes.
   The river has been separated into two portions in reference to its
improvement, with Vincennes, Ind., as the dividing point, and appro-
priations have been made for each division.
   Below Vincennes.-The principal work on this division of the river
was the procuring of stone and the building of masonry on the lock at
Grand Rapids. The site of the old lock was excavated and 695 cubic
yards of masonry laid in the new lock. The levee at Grayville was re-
paired and extended 250 feet. Repairs on the snag-boat were com-
pleted and she is nearly ready for work during the coming season. A
new hull was built for the dredge and the machinery transferred.
   The amount expended on this portion of the river to June 30, 1888,
was $155,959.38.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..........                  ..........       ...................                 $46,436.31
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ......--....-- .... ........ $22,645.58
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ...........    ...... ......    3, 726. 06
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts..... ......       10, 365. 77
                                                                                                                 36, 737. 41

July 1, 1888, balance available ...-             ....... ....      ......        ...........           ......     9, 698.90
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .-------.......................----------.                         60,000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ......---.............                                     69,698.90
                          RIVER AND HARBOR                       IMPROVEMENTS.                                       221
  SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ......
                                                                      -    $190, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 90, 00. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix C C 4.)
  Above Vincennes.-The project for the improvement for this part of
the river was the removal of obstructions and the construction of wing-
dams when necessary. No work was done on this portion of the river
during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, there being no funds avail-
able.
  The accumulation of snags and the formation of a new cut-off about
20 miles above Vincennes have made navigation very difficult.
  The amount expended on this river above Vincennes to June 30, 1888,
was $65,929.92.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..........................................  $70.08
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities.....................................  10.05

July 1, 1888, balance available .........................................                                             60.03
                                                                          ....................
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888......------------------------                                       5, 000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ....................                                       5, 060.03
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-. -      15,000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expendedinfiscal year endingJune 30,1890 10,000.00
  Submitted in compliance with    requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix C C 4.)
   5. White River, Indiana.-The present project for the improvement of
this river extends from the mouth to the railroad bridge at Hazleton,
and contemplates the obtaining of a depth of 31 feet at low water.                                                   This
is to be accomplished by a cut through the rock at Kelly's Ripple by
dikes, dredging, and by the removal of snags. The bad location of the
draw in the railroad bridge at Hazleton precludes the advisability of
any improvement above that point for the present.
   The work of the past year has been confined to dredging loose rock
from the previously blasted channel at Kelly's Ripple. About 5,190
cubic yards of rock were removed from this channel. A new hall for
the dredge was built, and the machinery transferred in April and May,
1888.
   Amount expended to June 30, 1888, was $99,764.05.
July 1, 1887, amount available ........................................                                          $4, 940. 49
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887........................                                     $2, 226. 04
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..........................                                       366. 19
                                                                                                                  2, 592. 23
July 1, 1888, balance available ......................                        ..................                  2,348.26
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.                            . --......
                                                                                 ....              ........       5, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                         7, 348.26
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .---                                           12, 500.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                     12, 500.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix C C 5.)
  6. Tradewater River, Kentucky.--This river is a tributary of the Ohio
and empties into it 79 miles below Evansville, Indiana.
  The present project, adopted in 1881, contemplates the formation of
222        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

a clear channel at least 40 feet wide, with a minimum depth of 2. feet
during eight months of the year for a distance of 41 miles.
   The work of the past year consisted in the removal of a number of
snags, tree-tops, etc., from the first 19 miles of the river. The work
was limited by the small amount of funds available, viz, about $550.
   The river is in good condition for a distance of about 24 miles from
its mouth, but a few snags remain to be removed from this part.
   Amount expended to June 30, 1888, $10,110.46.
July 1, 1887, amount available.           .......        ............----......             -----......    $549. 66
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887............ . .....       ....                          $160. 12
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ........... ............ ..... .                           18. 00
                                                                                                            178. 12

July 1, 1888, balance available ......................                    ..................                371.54
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888............                                   .........     6,000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889-...----...---..-----..--..---.                      6,371.54
   (See Appendix C C 6.)

IMPROVEMENT OF GREAT KANAWHIA AND ELK RIVERS, AND CON-
  STRUCTION OF HARBOR OF REFUGE AT MOUTH OF GREAT KAN-
  AWHA RIVER, WEST VIRGINIA; IMPROVEMENT OF NEW RIVER IN
  VIRGINIA AND WEST VIRGINIA.

   Officer in charge, Col. William P. Craighill, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Great Kanawha River, West Virginia.-This river flows through a
fertile and picturesque region, filled with mineral wealth, especially
coal and salt. It was by nature divided into a number of pools, some
of considerable length and depth, separated by shoals of gravel and
coarse sand, which were the principal obstructions to navigation in low
water, there being often on them at such seasons but a few inches of
water. In some of the pools were found shallow places, also obstruct-
ing navigation. There were also snags and loose rocks in the channel.
The navigation above Charleston was more obstructed than below.
Above it was almost suspended in summer.
   The coal and salt were generally sent out on rises, which enabled the
boats to pass safely over the obstructions that otherwise would stop
their movements entirely. The use of the river for the movement of
these valuable products was therefore unsatisfactory and intermittent.
By the agency and superintendence of a Board acting under the State,
first of Virginia and then of West Virginia, considerable improvement
in the river was from time to time effected, tolls being charged on the
commerce for payment of expenses.
   The object of the improvement begun several years ago by the United
States was to give a constant navigable depth of at least 6 feet through-
out the whole length of the Kanawha to its mouth at the Ohio River,
to be accomplished by large locks and dams. Those already built have
been about 300 by 50 feet.
   The peculiarity of most of the dams is that they can be lowered when
the stage of water in the river will suffice over the shoals. This gives
them the name of " movable dams," and enables an open river to be
had where the water is high enough.
   Dams 3 and 2, both above Paint Creek, are fixed, as the declivity of
the river in that section is too great to permit the advantageous use of
the movable system.
  Up to June 30, 1887, the amount expended was $1,844,817.86. At
that date Lock and Dam 3, 21 miles above Charleston Ferry, had been
                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                      223
completed, as also Locks and Dams 4 and 5, respectively, 15 and 9 miles
above.
   The amount expended in the year ending June 30, 1888, exclusive of
outstanding liabilities, was $96,432.19, applied at sites 2 and 6.
   Lock and Dam 6 were put in operation October 11, 1886. Lock 2 was
completed in the autumn of 1887 and the dam in December, 1887.
   Site 7 has been for several years owned by the United States, but
work could not be begun because funds were not available.
   Had funds been available, all the locks and dams needed for this im-
portant improvement could have been begun at the same time and fin-
ished in three years, with much economy to the United States and with
manifest advantage in the use of the improved water-way.
   The development of commerce on this river has been very great since
its improvement by the United States, although the project has been
only partially executed for want of money.
   A law was enacted by Congress March 3, 1887, prescribing the terms
under which bridges might be erected over the Great Kanawha River.
Taking advantage of this, the company which is building a railroad along
the left bank of the Ohio has completed a bridge over the Kanawha at
its mouth.
   By an act of February 28, 1887, authority was also granted to the
Kanawha and Ohio Railroad Company to lay its track through the
United States lock and dam property on the Great Kanawha River,
under such restrictions as the Secretary of War should prescribe.
   The completion of Lock and Dam 2 in 1887 was a most important ex-
tension of the improvement, as it enabled the pool thus formed to be
used for the shipment of coal in a section containing most extensive and
valuable mines which have hitherto been dependent entirely on the
railroads for reaching a market.
   During the long continued season of low water in 1887 the value of
the improvement was shown in a very marked manner, as free and
sufficient navigation was maintained through it over the improved part
of the river, while navigation was entirely suspended below the lowest
dam and above the upper pool.
July 1, 1887, amount available .......................................                                                 $102, 327. 81
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscaryear, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 .............---- ...... .. ............  ....                                                 96, 432. 19
July 1, 1888, balance available ................--
                                         -----..........            .........                                              5, 895. 62
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888--..----...................----.                                            350, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ....-------.. .......                                              355, 895.62

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..... 1, 320, 000. 00
j Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1890 ....--------....-- ----....----....--...--..----------...... ....------ ---------..............----------........... -500, 000.00
I Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
l    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix D D 1.)
  2. Operating and care of the locks and dams on the Great Kanawha
River, West Virginia.-Amount expended during the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1888, $14,417.62.
  (See Appendix D D 2.)
  3. Harbor of Refuge at mouth of Great Kanawha River, West Vir-
ginia.-In charge of Lieut. Col: W. E. Merrill, Corps of Engineers, until
September 12, 1887. This work consists of three ice-piers in the Great
Kanawha River, about 1 mile above its mouth. The piers were built
in order to protect water-craft from ice-floes coming down the Great
224         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Kanawha River. Two of the piers are on the right bank, at distances
of 4,200 and 6,300 feet, respectively, from the mouth of the river, and
one on the left bank at a distance of 6,600 feet. They are rectangular
in plan, and are built to a height of 291 feet above low water.
  The work contemplated having been completed no additional funds
are required.
July 1, 1887, amount available .....................                ..    .............           ..      168. 44
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
outstanding July 1, 1887............................................                                     168. 44
   (See Appendix D D 3.)
   4. Elk River, West Virginia.-The country through which this stream
flows is rich in minerals and well fitted for agriculture and grazing.
The approved project of improvement has been the removal of rocks,
snags, overhanging trees, etc., and the cutting of narrow sluices through
the rapids and shoals. The principal interests to be served are those
of lumbering and rafting, but much country produce is also carried
down stream in small boats, which return with merchandise, etc.
   The cost of the improvement was originally estimated at $100,000 to
make it complete of its kind. The first appropriation was in June, 1878.
The total expenditure prior to June 30, 1886, was $17,000. The work
done up to that time was of great benefit to the comparatively unde-
veloped section through which the river flows.
   The law of August, 1886, contained an item of $1,500 for this stream,
but the season was too far advanced for the resumption of work with
advantage and economy, which can only be done at low water.
   The available money was not spent in the fiscal year just closed, as it
was deemed better to hold so small a sum in the hope of its increase by
another appropriation, with both of which together work can be done
much more economically.
July 1, 1887, amount available .........................                     .........        ...      $1, 500.00
July 1, 1888, balance available ..................         ...............                 .......      1,500.00
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .................                              ..         3, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                              4,500. 00
  SAmountthat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                             5,000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix D D 4.)
   5. Gauley River, West Virginia.-To comply with the requirements of
the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, a preliminary examination
was made of the Gauley River, no detailed survey being needed. A
report of the results of the examination was transmitted to Congress
January 21, 1888, and printed as House Ex. Doc. No. 114, Fiftieth Con-
gress, first session.
   It is proposed to improve this river from its mouth up to the Roughs,
a distance of 12 miles, by straightening the channel and removing
obstructions, at an estimated cost of $10,000.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, contains an appropria-
tion of $3,000 for improving the river, and a further sum of $7,000 may
be profitably expended in continuing it during the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ...... .... ....                      ....   ......      $3, 000. 00

   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                           7,000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
                        RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                225
  6. iVew River, from the mouth of Wilson, in Grayson County, Virginia,
to the mouth of Greenbrier River, West Virginia.-The appropriations
have been made in such manner as to divide this portion of the river
into three sections, as follows :
                                                                                                      Miles.
Upper, or Lead Mines.....................................................------------                   62
Middle, or New River Bridge .....           --.... .... .......................----.....--...----..     43
Lower, or Greenbrier ...-----...... . ................... .... ....              ........ --     .      861
    Throughout this distance the navigable channel consisted of natural
chutes through the ledges and shoals of varying widths, rarely over 1
foot in depth, in some places so tortuous as to render navigation ex-
tremely difficult and dangerous.
    The original project adopted for the improvement of these natural
channels was to widen them to 30 or 50 feet, as might be required,
deepen them to 2 feet, and straighten such as needed it. This was for
bateau navigation; the improvement, however, to be made in such a
manner as to aid the work should a greater depth and width be required
in the future.
    A small steam-boat, draught 12 inches when light, having been built
at Hinton, in the fall of 1878, rendered it necessary to make the chan-
nel in that section 50 feet wide at all points, and in many from 75 feet
to 100 feet, the depth of 2 feet being retained. This steam-boat was not
adapted in dimensions and power to the navigation of the river, and
was withdrawn.
    The original plan of improvement has been adhered to, except that
the width of channels on the middle and upper divisions has been re-
duced to 20 feet, and on the former to 10 feet for several miles, to allow
iron to be shipped from the furnaces above.
    There was no appropriation for this river in 1883, 1884, or 1885. July
1, 1886, there was a balance remaining unexpended of $3,000 from the
appropriation of August 2, 1882. This pertained by special designation
of the law to the portion of the river above Foster's Falls, which are
not passable. The balance remained unexpended because of the im-
passability of these falls. As the disconnection with routes of trans-
portation caused by these falls would practically disappear on the com-
pletion of the railroad up Cripple Creek, and as boats could then ship
to the railroad their freight at Porter's Ferry, above the lead mines and
the falls, it was concluded to improve the condition of Williamson's
Ledges and Shoals. This work was continued as late as the season
allowed, a small balance of funds being left unexpended, but not large
enough to justify the resumption of operations in the summer of 1886.
    The navigation of the river not being continuous as yet, it is practi-
cally a feeder to the railroads which cross it and run along portions of
it. It has also been of much use in carrying materials and supplies to
the railroads while in process of construction near it. It is probable
that when the river is fully improved boats will transport one-third of
the products of the fine agricultural country through which it flows,
and seven-eighths of those of the mines, exclusive of coal.
    There was an appropriation of $10,000 in the law of Ausust 5, 1886,
applicable only to the portion of the river above the lead mines.
When the money became available it was too late to commence opera-
tions in 1886. For more than one reason it seemed inexpedient to spend
this appropriation in the year ending June 30, 1888. The portion of the
river to which it is applicable is above Foster's Falls, and these can only
be passed by one or two locks at a cost much greater than Congress is
likely to authorize. There is also strong reason for doubt whether, con-
        ENG 88-15
226         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

sidering the present development of that section of the country, the con-
struction of such locks would be justifiable even if the money were
available. The construction of railroads near this stream has for the
present diminished very much the importance of the improvement of the
portion above Foster's Falls. After a careful re-examination of the sub-
ject, and a reconnooissance of the river and its vicinity, it was decided to
postpone the expenditure of the appropriation until the will of Con-
gress could be further ascertained.
July 1, 1887, amount available....................----------------...----------..............--.        10, 222. 29
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 187...--......---...--------..-...----......--------......-            ......--
                                                                                       ...--..--             75. 00
July 1, 1888, balance available .......----....--......--------................----...                  10, 147.2
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                           20, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1l66 and 1867.
    (See Appendix D D 5.)

'EXAMIINATIONS FOR IMPROVEMENT, TO COMPLY WITII REQUIREMENTS
        OF THE RIVER AND HIARBOR ACT OF AUGUST 5, 1886.

   The required preliminary examinations of the following streams
were made by the local engineer, Colonel Craighill, and reported by
him as worthy of improvement to a limited extent, but no additional
surveys required :
   1. Gauley River, West Virginia.- (See Appendix DD 6.)
   2. Meadow River, West Virginia.-(See Appendix D D 6.)
   The results of these examinations were transmitted to Congress at
its last session and printed as House Ex. Doc. No. 114, Fiftieth Congress,
first session.

IMPROVEMENT OF KENTUCKY AND LICKING RIVERS; OPERATING ANND
  KEEPING IN REPAIR LOCKS AND DAMS ON THE KENTUCKY RIVE
  KENTUCKY; IMPROVEMENT OF BIG SANDY RIVER, WEST VIRGINIA
  AND KENTUCKY; AND OF GUYANDOTTE, LITTLE KANAWIHA, AND
  BUCKHANNON RIVERS, WEST VIRGINIA.

   Officer in charge, Capt. D. W. Lockwood, Corps of Engineers, having
under his immediate orders Lieut. W. L. Sibert, Corps of Engineers,
since April 11, 1888.
   1. Kentucky River, Kentucky.-This river was in temporary charge of
Maj. Amos Stickney, Corps of Engineers, until April 17, 1888. The
present project for the improvement of this river was adopted in 1879,
the object being to repair the five locks and dams built by the State of
Kentucky, and extend slackwater navigation for a draught of 6 feet,
by the construction of additional locks and dams, to Beattyville, a dis-
tance of 261 miles from the mouth of the river.
   During previous years the five original locks have been repaired and
three of the dams rebuilt, the fourth and fifth having also been restored
to a serviceable condition. Contracts have been entered into for the
stone for Lock No. 6, and the contractors are at work.
   The dam at Beattyville was cut down by removing the crest and two
upper steps, so as not to interfere with free navigation at the proper
stage of water, and the material taken out used in bank protection or
stored for future use. A stone quarry has been opened up 4 miles from
the dam, and stone is being takLen out to construct thile new lock at
                        RIVER        AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                           227
'Beattyville. Stone is also being taken out for the new lock at No. 6,
but the contractors are making slow progress.
July 1, 187, amount available.-...-..................................                            $158, 367. 37
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
    of liabilities outstanding JuJy 1, 1887 ..................         --         $54, 622. 66
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities...-----------..-------....--...--.....--.    7, 623.90
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts ........                       71,536.55
                                                                                                  133, 783. 11
July 1, 1888, balance available........................  ............ ....                         24, 584.26
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 --.......................                           180,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889................                             204,584.26

i(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....- 1, 854, 000. 00
  Amountthat can be profitably expended in fiscalyear ending June 30,
    1890..... ........... ... ....................      ----............. . 400, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E E 1.)
  2. Operating and keeping in repair locks and dams on the Kentucky River,
Kentucky.-In temporary charge of Maj. Amos Stickney, Corps of Engi-
neers, until April 17, 1888.
   There is at present slackwater navigation upon the Kentucky River
for a distance of 99 miles. During the year extensive repairs were made
at most of the locks and additional works such as guide-walls, bank pro-
tection walls, etc., built. The lock entrances were dredged where nec-
essary, and banks paved about the locks. One lock-keeper's house was
built and general repairs made to others where necessary. The locks
have been operated and continuous navigation maintained, with the ex-
ception of times when the locks were closed for repairs and a few days
when ice interfered.
   The amount estimated for operating and maintaining navigation for
year ending June 30, 1889, is $82,769.50. It is proposed to complete the
auxiliary works, rebuild one abutment, and make such general repairs
as may be necessary.
   (See Appendix E E 2.)
  3. Licking River, Kentucky, from Farmer's to West Liberty.-To comply
with the requirements of the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886,
a preliminary examination of the Licking River between the points
above indicated was made (a survey being unnecessary), and the report
thereon is printed in the Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1887 as
Appendix D D 12 (page 1902).
   The proposed improvement contemplates the removal of snags and
rocks obstructing the channel, at an estimated cost of $17,680.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $3,000 for
the work, and a further sum of $5,000 may be profitably expended in
continuing it during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..........................                            $3, 000.00
    Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........                        14, 680.00
    Amount that can be profitably expended in             fiscal
                                                  year ending June 30,1890                          5, 000. 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 186 and 1867.
  4. Big Sandy River, West Virginia and Kentuckay.-In temporary charge
of Lieut. Col. W. E. Merrill, Corps of Engineers, until April 13, 1888.
  The present approved project for the improvement of this river con-
templates the construction of a lock and dam at Louisa, below tihe june-
228      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

tion of the two forks, and also the improvement of open river naviga.
tion on these forks and on the main river. The object of building the,
dam is to form a pool for holding coal boats and barges, with a view to
the shipment of coal from the extensive deposits found in the valley.
It is expected that other locks and dams will be built if this experi.
mental one should prove a success. For open river navigation on the
fork it is intended to secure a channel with a minimum depth of 1 foot
and a minimum width of 50 feet during six months in the year.
   During the past year the abutment of the proposed dam at Louisa,
was completed and the river below the lock cleared of some of the
worst obstructions. Above the dam the Tug and Levisa Forks were
cleared of obstructions and chutes improved, as far as the funds on hand
would permit.
July 1, 1887, amount available .........................................---- $10,888. 01
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ........................    .................              7, 45.63

July 1, 1888, balance available ........................ .................            3,462. 38
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................              31,500.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................            34,962.38'

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 31, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E E 3.)
   5. Guyandotte River, West Virginia.--In temporary charge of Lieut.
Col. W. E. Merrill, Corps of Engineers, until April 13, 1888.
   The object of work on this river is to remove rocks and logs and other
obstructions, so as to make a smooth channel for rafts and push-boats
during the season of good water, there being no navigation at all during
low water. The channel to be cleared out will be 122 miles long, and
it is designed to give it a minimum width of 30 feet and minimum depth
of 18 inches during five months in the year.
   No work was done during the past year from lack of funds.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...........                            $2,000. 00
                                                                           ...........
SAmount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890          2,000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E E 4.)
   6. Little Kanawha River, West Virginia.-In temporary charge of
Lieut. Col. W. E. Merrill, Corps of Engineers, until April 13, 1888.
   The approved project for the improvement of this river contemplates
the construction of a lock and dam to extend slackwater for a draught
of 4 feet a distance of 12 miles, and the improvement of the natural
channel of the upper river by the removal of obstructions for a distance
of 80 miles, the object of the last-named work being to obtain a chan-
nel of a minimum width of 40 feet, containing at least 2 feet of water
during four months of the year. The navigation of the river above the
slackwater is by push-boats and rafts.
   During the past year the stone needed to complete the lock was quar-
ried by hired labor, transported to the lock site, and part of it cut for
the lock-walls.
  Owing to lack of funds, work for the benefit of open river navigation
was confined to repairing the chute at Glenville.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR                        IMPROVEMENTS.                                  229
,July 1, 1887, amount available .......--...----..--.. -- --..--
                                                           ........----....--..---- --......                $7, 784. 93
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887.-..------......--..-----...-----... $7, 420. 66
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ...---....--.........          .....      30. 00
                                                                                                             7,450. 66
July 1, 1888, balance available ..............................--------------------.....                        334.27
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ........................                                      25,000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .......--.                                -....      25, 334.27

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .----...... 26, 800. 00
   Amountthat can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30,1890 26, 800. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1886 and 1867.
   (See Appendix E E 5.)
   7. Buckhannon River, West Virginia.-In temporary charge of Lieut.
Col. W. E. Merrill, Corps of Engineers, until April 13, 1888.
   This is a tributary of the Tygerts Valley River, which itself is one of
the tributaries of the Monongahela. The improvement of this river
contemplates the formation of a rafting channel between the Three
Forks and the town of Buckhannon, a distance of 24 miles. The pro-
posed channel will have a minimum width of 30 feet and a minimum
depth of 2 feet during four months of each year.
   No work done during the past year from lack of funds.
July 1, 1887, amount available .----....--........---------..--..--...........--------.....---....--             3. 68
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1887 ....--------..-........--.......------.----..-.....--.--......-------.... ---         3.68
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ..........................                                    1, 500. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                 3, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix E E 6.)

:.EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS FOR IMPROVEMENT, TO COMPLY WITH
    REQUIREMENTS OF THE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT OF AUGUST 5,
     1886.
     It appearing, after preliminary examination by the local engineer, that
the localities were worthy of improvement, Lieutenant-Colonel Merrill
was charged with and completed the survey of the Louisa (Levisa) Fork
of Sandy River, Virginia, the results of which were transmitted to Con-
gress and printed in House Ex. Doc. No. 88, Fiftieth Congress, first
session. (See also Appendix E E 7.)
   Major Stickney was charged with and completed the survey of Salt
River, Kentucky, the results of which were transmitted to Congress and
printed in House Ex. Doc. No. 181, Fiftieth Congress, first session.
 (See also Appendix E E 8.)

                             LAKE HARBORS                        AND RIVERS.

IMPROVEMENT OF                    THE      HARBORS AT DULUTH, MINNESOTA, AND AT
   SUPERIOR BAY                    AND      SAINT LOUIS BAY, WISCONSIN-1MPROVE-
     MENT OF THE HARBORS                            AT     GRAND         MARAIS         AND       AGATE         BA.Y,
     MINNESOTA.
   Officer in charge, Capt. James B. Quinn, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Harbor at Duluth, Minnesota.-The original lroject for the im-
provement of the harbor, adopted in 1871. consisted of a breakwater in
230       REPORT OF THE CHIEF                        OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Lake Superior, outside of Minnesota Point, in continuation of a break-
water already commenced by the Northern Pacific Railroad Company.
This breakwater was destroyed by a storm in 1872 and abandoned. In
1873 Congress provided for maintaining the canal through Minnesota
Point, which had been constructed by the city of Duluth, and for dredg-

  NY
ing channels in Superior Bay to the Duluth docks.
     ork under this project was continued until 1881, at which time the
piers of the canal had been repaired and somewhat extended, a harbor
basin dredged of moderate capacity, and a narrow channel dredged in
Superior Bay from Duluth to deep water at Connor's Point. The
amount expended under this project was $270,651.81.
  The present project was adopted in 1881 and modified in 1884, the
object being to preserve the piers bordering the canal and in dredging
an inner harbor and channels to accommodate vessels drawing 16 feet
of water.
  The amount expended under present project to June 30, 1888, was
$197,848.25, and has resulted in increasing the dredged area of basin
to about 104 acres, exclusive of private dredging, a gain of 20 acres dur-
ing past fiscal year, and removing shoals from area previously dredged,
giving the whole dredged basin a minimum depth of 16 feet, deepening
the Blast Furnace Channel to a like depth, and in maintaining the
canal piers.
  Work during the past fiscal year consisted in repairing the entrance
piers and deepening and enlarging the main harbor basin to the south-
ward. The amount of material excavated was 159,940.35 cubic yards.
  The piers are in fairly good condition, but the superstructure, and
perhaps the entire work, will eventually require to be replaced with
more durable material. The ruling depths in the plortions of the har-
bor dredged by the United States are:
                                                                                           Feet.
In canal ......... ...........                                          ............
                               .............. ............... ...........
       inner basin
In the inner basin or harbor................_................
                          harbr-------    ------------------------------------
                                                                   _............     16
                                                                               .......
In Blast Furnace Channel to a point opposite Elevator E ---------------------..............
From point opposite Elevator E, through dredged               channel along east side of
  Rice's Point to the Saint Louis River .............. ....-......
                                                               -................             1-
   All the areas and channels above mentioned (canal and anchorage
area excepted) require widening.
   Since 1881 the narrow channel which was dredged from Duluth to
deep water at Connor's Point has shoaled so that it now has a mini-
mum or ruling depth of 12 feet, and large vessels can only pass throughL
light. The advance of the Rice's Point dock line absorbs this channel,
and the new channel parallel with the new dock line becomes necessary
to preserve this line of communication.
July 1, 1887, amount available..... .    ... .. ...........  . 42, 415. 06
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887..................-.....         .......                38,615. 92'
                                                                      ...............

July 1, 1888, balance available ........................................            3,799. 14
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888--- ......        .. . 80, 000.000
                                                    --- ......--...--
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...................           83, 799. 14

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890        39, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix T F 1.)
  2.Harborat Superior Bay and St. Louis Bay, Wisconsin.-Originaily
a sand-bar obstructed the natural entrance to Superior Bay, with a.
                            RIVER          AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                 231,
narrow and tortuous channel through it, having a minimum depth of
9 feet. In Superior Bay a deep natural channel, having a depth of not
less than 14 feet and a width of from 100 to 500 feet, extended from the
natural entry to Connor's Point. Nine feet was the greatest draught
that could reach the docks at Superior, one-half mile distant from the
natural channel.
   The original project, adopted in 1867 and modified in 1873, comprised
the construction of parallel piers 350 feet apart, and dredging between
the piers; dredging in Superior Bay from natural channel to Quebee
Wharf; maintenance of piers and protecting portions oflMinnesota Point
where the sea threatened to break through. The amount expended on
original project was $335,513.26.
   The present project was adopted in 1881 and modified in 1884, which
added improvement of St. Louis River channel within the bay of Supe-
rior, the object being to provide channels for vessels drawing 16 feet of
water. The act of August 5, 1886, added the improvement of St. Louis
Bay.
   The natural and dredged channels in 1881 were about 100 feet wide
with not more than 11 feet in depth at the shoalest part.
   The amount expended under present project to June 30, 1888, was
$115,100.21, and resulted in securing channels having a minimum width
of 100 feet and not less than 16 feet in depth.
   Work during the past year consisted in dredging, the amount of ma-
terial removed being as follows:
                                                                                                             Cubic yards.
Dredging in St. Louis Bay along the dock-line on the Wisconsin shore,
  between Connor's Point and Grassy Point ........................            .-- - - ....                           . 829
Deepening and enlarging channels in Superior Bay and harbor, including
  the mouth of the Nemadji River .....    ..............         .... ..............                              19, 644
                                      ......--------
         Total-----...... ...... .... ----        --......
                                                     ..--..----             ..        -......-
                                                                                  .......-----....   --- -....--....---....
                                                                                                                   32, 473
   The entry piers are in fair condition, but need extensive repairs, par-
ticularly the superstructure, to render them secure. The beach protec-
tion is still intact.
   The following are ruling depths in the channels dredged by the United
States:
                                                                                                                    Feet.
From Connor's Point to the entry ................................--..-.........                                          16
From Northern Pacific Railroad Dock to the entry .-----.........................                                         10
                            - - ---..---
In front of Quebec Dock ...........................- -- -...-                                          - -------... -
                                                                                       - - --------................      16
Throughout the entry between piers.--- -...---......----.......                 -..----...........--..........----- --   16
July 1, 1887, amount available............ ............                       ..         --............. $18, 76.        11
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1887 .............................................                                      8,497.78

July 1, 1888, balance available ....-----------..----------.............----..................                10,270.33
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.. ..                               ......-.........             50, 000. 00


{Amount
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ........--
               (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 177, 580. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 100, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                             ...--    ....    60,270.33



     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F F 2.)
   3. Harbor at Agate Bay, Minnesota.--This harbor, on the north shore
of Lake Superior, 27 miles from Duluth, is a shipping port for iron ore.
It also serves the purpose of a harbor of refuge. Its naturally deep
water renders but little dredging necessary in order for vessels to reach
the docks.
232          REPORT OF THE CHIEF                               OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The present project for improvement of this harbor, adopted in 1887,
consists in the construction of two breakwater piers, extending from
the eastern and western points of the bay, to be 1,000 and 900 feet
long, respectively, and on a line towards each other, leaving an opening
of 1,340 feet between the outer extremities and inclosing an areaof 109
acres.
   The amount expended thereon to June 30, 1888, was $20,682.94, and
has resulted in the construction of 400 linear feet of the east break-
water, giving very material protection to vessels lying at Merchandise
Dock from southerly storms. The appropriation asked is to be applied
to the completion of the east 1,000 feet of breakwater.
                                                                  ..--. ------------
July 1, 1887, amount available---- --....---......------....--....-----                                          $21, 521. 47
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.......-----....----......---- ----......--........--------   ------------              19, 704. 41

July 1, 1888, balance available...... ..................................                                           1, H17. 06
Amount appropriated by act August 11, 1888..........................                                              15, 000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889........                                          .......    16, 817. 06
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .....-.                                         175, 500. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                       50,000. UO
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of the river
   and harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix F F 3.)
  4. Harbor at GrandMarais, Minnesota.-This was originally a natural
harbor basin, but of insufficient depth for large vessels, and not wholly
protected from storms. The need of a harbor of refuge somewhere in
this locality was felt on account of the long stretch of coast-line between
existing available harbors, and led to the project for the improvement
of this harbor for that purpose.
   The present project for its improvement, adopted in 1879, consisted
of deepening the basin to 16 feet and constructing a breakwater out
from Mayhew's Point so as to partially close the natural opening and
lessen the exposure to storms.
   The amount expended to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30,
1888, was $77,577.77, and has resulted in obtaining a dredged basin
having an area of 11 acres, with a minimum depth of 16 feet, a gain of
one acre during fiscal year, and the'construction of 350 linear feet of
breakwater.. The harbor is now accessible for vessels of the largest
size and draught that come to Lake Superior, but the smallness of the
dredged basin limits its accommodation to but very few vessels at one
time, and hampers their movements when in the harbor.
   The breakwater is already of much service for the protection of ship-
ping.
July 1, 1887, amount available .........................................               $5, 643. 19
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ......-.........              ....... ......... ...........  3, 220. 96
July 1,1888, balance available-----
                              ......------------................--......-------............--.                     2, 422. 23
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888......----....                     ......---.....                    15, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                         17,422. 23

   Amountthat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                      44, 700. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of seetions 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix F F 4.)
                          RIVER        AND HARBOR                IMPROVEMENTS.                                             233
,IARBORS ON LAKE SUPERIOR (EAST OF SUPERIOR CITY), ON GREEN
   BAY AND ON THE WESTERN SHORE OF LAKE MICHIGAN, NORTH OF
   MILWAUKEE, WISCONSIN.

  Officer in charge, Maj. Charles E. L. B. Davis, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Ashland Harbor, Wisconsin.-The project for the improvement of
this harbor was adopted in 1887, and modified in 1888, and has for its
object the construction of a breakwater northeast of the town to be
about 8,000 feet long for the protection of the shipping at the wharves,
and to dredge a channel in froat of the city wharves sufficient for ves-
sels of 16-feet draught.
  No work has been done, as the amount available during the fiscal
year was insufficient to commence a work of such magnitude.
July 1, 1887, amount available...
                                --                    ..---...         --...... ....-
                                                                 --......-       ----........-       -.....
                                                                                                        --         . $21, 820. 43
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 187.....--......-- ------....--....------.....-------           -----..----.................      827. 40

July 1, 1888, balance available -..................                  ....   ....         ....     ........    --      20,993. 03
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188 ......---------....---.--...                                             60, 00. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ..................                                              80, 993. 03
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- .-----.....                                        90, 000. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending                             une 30, 1890              50, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix G G 1.)
   2. Ontonagon Harbor, MIichigan.-The present project for the improve-
ment of this harbor was adopted in 1867, the object being to afford an
entrance to the mouth of the Ontonagon River, not less than 12 feet
deep, and of a navigable width. This result was to be accomplished by
,constructing two parallel piers, 250 feet apart, from the river's mouth
lakeward to the 18-foot contour in Lake Superior, and dredging a channel
between them 12 feet in depth.
   The natural channel was but 7 feet in depth, and owing to the shift-
ing nature of the bottom was variable in position.
   The amount expended, to June 30, 1888, is $284,029.52, and has re-
sulted in the construction of 2,315 feet of east and 2,525 feet of west pier,
and the removal of 10,546 yards of sand, making a channel 100 feet wide
.and 13 feet deep between the piers with a depth of 12.1 feet on the outer
bar.
July 1, 1887, amount available .------..--...---....--....-----------   .....----.. --.......------...... $14, 747. 05
.July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 187 ............................................                                    13,205. 07
July 1, 1888, balance available ....---............. . ...........       ........                                      1,541.98
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188...... .....         ............                                         12, 500. 00


 {Amount
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................

           (estimated) required for completion of existing project.- .---.....
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yeareunding June 30, 1890
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                                                      14,041. 9

                                                                                                                      65, 700. 00
                                                                                                                      25, 000. 00

    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix G G 2.)
  3. Eagle Harbor, Michigan.-The project for the improvement of this
harbor was adopted in 1866, and modified in 1868, 1874, and 1878. Pre-
vious to the improvement, the entrance was obstructed by a rocky reef
vith S8 feet of water over the shoalest point.
234         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                     U.   S. ARMY.
  The plan as finally carried out consisted in blasting and dredging
through the rocky ledge a channel 130 feet wide and 14 feet deep, and
marking it by two guiding-cribs, one on each side of the channel, and
the removal of a number of bowlders.
  The amount expended to June 30,1888, is $94,513.67, and has resulted
in carrying out the above plan, the work being completed in 1885 and
meeting the present demands of commerce.
  No appropriation is asked for for this harbor, as the funds on hand
will probably be sufficient to cover the expenses of keeping the channel
and cribs in good condition for several years.
July 1, 1887, amount available..-                       -..---..-----...............-..-......--......
                                                                                                     $2, 886. 33
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 187...........--- ...... ............ ....--....----........                      400.00
July 1,1888, balance available..                  ... .....   ...... ........-............ ....      2, 486. 33.
   (See Appendix G G 3.)
  4. Establishmentand maintenanceof harbor lines in PortageLake, ichi-
gan/.--Congress by act of August 5, 1886, conferred upon the Secretary
of War the authority to establish harbor-lines where debris of mines
or stamp works were liable to work injury to navigation. Harbor lines
were accordingly established in Portage Lake, Michigan, to prevent the
destruction of the through routes of communication across Keweenaw
Point, and rules and regulations were prescribed for maintaining them.
Notwithstanding these regulations the stamp-mills on Portage Lake
continued to dump their tailings outside of these lines, and the United
States attorney for western Michigan was instructed by the Depart-
ment of Justice to apply for an injunction restraining the mill owners
from dumping d6bris into Portage Lake between the harbor-lines es-
tablished by the Secretary of War.
   (See Appendix G G 4.)
   5. Marquette Harbor, Mllichigan.-The present project for the improve-
ment of this harbor was adopted in 1866, and consisted in the construc-
tion of a crib breakwater 2,000 feet long and 25 to 40 feet wide, built to
a height of 6 feet above the water-surface, the estimated cost being
$385,129.58. Previous to the commencement of the work these widths
were changed to 20, 25, and 30 feet. The structure was completed
in 1875, the total length being 2,010 feet and the total cost $290,646.55.
   In its original condition this harbor afforded no protection to vessels
during the prevalence of easterly and northerly gales.
   Since the completion of the original project commerce has increased
so much that additional protection is needed and should be afforded,
and for this purpose it is recommended that the present breakwater be
extended 1,200 feet, which will increase the available anchorage over
100 per cent. and afford ample protection for the present commerce.
   Some damage having been done to the breakwater by the October
gales of 1887, repairs were made at a cost of $738.86.
   It is believed that the encroachment upon the available protected
area, heretofore complained of, will be adjusted satisfactorily.
July 1, 1887, amount available .....................................                               $10, 323.82
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887..............................................                             1, 322. 96:
July 1, 1888, balance available .........................................                            9, 000. 86
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                             25,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .................                             34,000.86
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                            235
 (Amoun t (estimated) required for completion of proposed project
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30, 1890
                                                                                 ....... $175, 000. 00
                                                                                            50,000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections ' of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix G G 5.)
  6. Harbor of Refuge, Grand Mlarais, Mlichigan.--The present project
for the improvement of this harbor was adopted in 1881, the object being
to provide a harbor of refuge for vessels navigating Lake Superior, and
consists in the formation of an artificial entrance to the natural harbor
of Grand Marais, having an available capacity of 160 acres, capable of
being increased to 240 acres hereafter in case the increased needs of
commerce demand it.
  This artificial entrance is to be formed of two parallel crib-piers 500
feet apart, with a dredged channel tetween 300 feet wide and 18 to 20
feet deep, cut through the sand-spit north of the harbor, connecting the
deep water of the lake with that of the harbor.
  The natural channel was variable and crooked, with but 6 feet of
water.
  The contract made October 25, 1886, for building 450 feet of crib-pier
was abandoned by the contractor early in the present fiscal year, and
another contract was then entered into with the next lowest bidder for
400 feet of pier extension, but owing to the season being far advanced
and the difficulty of obtaining stone, work was suspended and the time
of completion extended to July 31, 1888.
  Under this contract during the month of June, 1888, the west pier was
extended 200 feet by four cribs, each 24 feet in width. To complete the
existing contract four more cribs are to be sunk during the month oft
July, 1888.
July 1, 1887, amount available..... ........--.....              ...............             $28, 251.91
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ......................                    $9, 152. 59
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..........................                     859.77
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts............ 16, 400.00
                                                                                                     36
                                                                                              26, 412.
July 1, 1888, balance available ........................................                     1,839. 55
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188              .......................           50, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...... ......               ....       51, 839. 55

rAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 268, 750.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended infiscal year ending June 30,1890 100, 000. 00
SSubmitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix G G 6.)
  7. Manistique Harbor,Michigan.-The present project for the improve-
ment of this harbor was adopted in 1880, and consisted in dredging
between the piers built by the Chicago Lumbering Company, increas-
ing the depth of the channel to 12 feet for a width of 150 feet.
  The natural channel of entrance to the mouth of the Manistique
River was 7 feet deep. By private enterprise a slab-pier 3,000 feet
long had been built at the mouth of the river and a channel dredged to
10 feet before any appropriation had been made by the Government.
  By the acts of 1880 and 1881 the sum of $6,000 was appropriated for
this harbor in order to dredge a channel 150 feet wide and 12 feet deep
between the piers built by a local lumbering company. Dredging was
done to the amount of 11,780 cubic yards, and the work was then sus-
236         REPORT         OF    THE      CHIEF                    OF ENGINEERS,                    U. S. ARMY.

pended in consequence of the refusal of the company controlling the
harbor to rectify their pier lines when rebuilding the same.
  No work has been done during the year.
  No appropriation is asked for this harbor.
July 1, 1887, amount available ........................................---- ----.                                       $3,501.79
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1867 ....--........                              ......... -    ......- .......          ....        400. 00
July 1, 1888, balance available---..----...........                         ....--...------------..------......
                                                                                                     --..--..--..--..    3, 101. 79
   (See Appendix G G 7.)
   8. Cedar River Harbor, Michigan.-The present project for the im-
Iprovemnent of this harbor was adopted in 1882, with a modification in
the direction of the piers in 1884, the object being to afford a channel
of entrance of navigable width antl14 feet in depth.
   Previous to the improvement the mouth of the river was 175 feet wide
and 8 to 10 feet deep with a 3-foot bar in front of the mouth. Improve-
ments have been made by private parties prior to the commencement of
Government work.
   The amount expended to June 30, 188S, is $27,664.98, and has re-
sulted in the construction of two pile-piers 754 and 350 feet long, re-
spectively, in continuation of the slab-docks built by private parties,
and a channel that at last accounts, October, 1885, was 50 feet wide and
13 feet deep, and 100 feet wide for a depth of 11 feet.
   For the next fiscal year n)o appropriation is asked for the commerce
of Cedar River being entirely local.
July 1    1887, amount available          ......................                            ..............              $2, 670. 02
July 1, 18-8, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 187 ....----------......
                                          -------
                                           ......------.... .......-.......------ ---------......---                       335. 00
July 1, 1888, balance available ....                     ....        ......-......-... .............                     2, 335. 02
SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--........
                                                                     --    108,000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix G G 8.)
   9. Menomonee Harbor, Michigan and Wisconsin.-The present project
for the improvement of this harbor was adopted in 1871 and modified
in 1874, the object being to afford a channel of entrance of navigable
width and not less than 14 feet depth.
   Previous to the improvement of this harbor the depth of water at the
mouth of the Menomonee River was about 4 feet, and the river was
navigable for boats of that draught for some 2 miles above its mouth.
   Tlhe amount expended to June 30, 1888, is $200,616.80, and has re-
sulted in the construction of two piers, with a dredged channel between,
14 feet deep and 270 feet wide, this channel extending across a bar
about 350 feet beyond the south pier. The north pier consists of three
parts, 585 feet of slab-pier, 609 feet of pile-pier, and 660ifeet of cribs, or
a total of 1,854 feet. The south pier consists of 1,900 feet of pile-pier
and 810 feet of cribs, making a total of 2,710 feet.
July 1, 1887, amount available ---....-------------...................---------... -.... -                               3,100.51
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887----....------....--....--....------------------------..    -.--.                                  30.21

July 1, 1888, balance available           ......----..----..-----........----..--........--.--..--...--...               2, 370. 30
Amount appropriated by act of August 11. 1888 ............--                                     ..........             9, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ..................                                                11,370. 30
    (See Appendix G G 9.)
                           RIVER         AND       HARBOR          IMPROVEMENTS.                                 237
   10. Oconto Harbor, Wisconsin.-In its natural condition the channel-
at the entrance to Oconto River was obstructed by a bar with less than,
2 feet of water over it. Previous to 1881, when the first appropriation
was made for its improvement, the citizens had, by the construction of
a small amount of slab-pier and by dredging, increased the depth to 3J
feet.
   The project of improvement proposes to secure an 8 foot channel from
deep water in Green Bay to the city of Oconto by dredging and the
construction of piers, at an estimated cost of $150,000.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, 1,200 feet of reinforcement
piling on the channel side of the south pier was built by hired labor.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, is $47,778.86, resulting
in the building of two piers, the north pier 1,603 feet and the south one
2,151 feet in length, the latter being the full length contemplated by the
approved project, and in the removal of 207,641 cubic yards of material
by dredging.
   The navigation interests at Oconto are at present dependent upon the
business of three lumber companies located there, and the benefits to
be desired are essentially local.
July 1, 1887, amount available ...................................................                          $1, 104. 14
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 187 .................                    ......-. -......           ..-.. ...... ..    3,904. 50
July 1, 1888, balance available ...................---........------....--......                                199.64
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 183..........                             ....   ....   ......     20, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 188:- .................-..                                 20,199. 64
   Amount (estimated) recquired for completion of existing project........                                  82, 000. 00
  SAmount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1S90 20, 000. CO
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix G G 10.)
   11. Pen-saukee Harbor, Wisconsin.--The first appropriation for this
harbor was made in 1882. At that time the facilities of the natural
channel of the Pensaukee River had been increased by private enter-
prise by the construction of 1,600 linear feet of continuous slab-pier
and by dredging from a depth of 2 feet to a depth varying from 7 to 9
feet, with a width of 30 feet.
   The project of improvement of this harbor, adopted in 18S2, consists
in the construction of a single slab-pier 2,500 feet in length in continua-
tion of the pier built by private enterprise, and the dredging of a chan-
nel 10 feet deep and 100 feet wide on the south side of the pier.
   There was no work done at this harbor during the fiscal year.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, is $10,939.08, resulting
in the construction of 1,300 feet of the proposed extension of the pier
and the dredging of 5,698 cubic yards of material, making a channel 25
feet wide and 10 feet deep. The entire length of the pier is 2,900 feet,
the inshore 1,600 feet having been built by private enterprise.
   There being at present no commercial or navigation interests to be
benefited by improving the harbor, and the harbor itself not being needed
as a harbor of refuge, further operations have been suspended.
July 1, 1887, amount available ...----..----..........----...........-----..--....--........--.       $4, 446. 92
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887........................................                              .....     387. 00
July 1, 1888, balance available..........................................                                    4, 059.92
238          REPORT           OF THIE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

0 Amounted (estimated) required for completion of existing project ......
  Subml,:ittei in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                                                  25, 000.
      harbor acts of 1866Iand 18)7.
   (See Appendix G G 11.)
  12. Grcen Bay Barbor, lisconsin.- efore the improvemelnt of this
harbor was begun the channel between the mouth of Fox River and the
deep water inl Green Bay was circuitous and narrow, with but 6 feet of
water at its shoalest point.
  The project was adopted in 1800 and modified in 1872 and 1881, its
object being to secure a channel 200 feet wide, 14 feet deep, and 2 miles
long, in place of the natural channel, with a revetted cut across Grassy
Island.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 18SS, the superstructure of the
west revetment at Grassy Island has been rebuilt for the entire length
of 620 feet.
   The total expenditures since the beginning of the improvement amount
to $277,372.97, resulting in a dredged channel 10,600 feet long, 200 feet
wide, and 14 feet deep, except where occasional shoals reduce the depth
to 13 feet, and the construction of 1,325 linear feet of pile and timber
revetment on the sides of the cut through Grassy Island.
   The appropriation asked for will be applied to dredging the channel
to the dimensions called for by the present project.
July 1, 1887, amount available ...------.....--------......----.....--....-----------......-----......             5, 437.64
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887---------------------------------------..............................................    5, 229.61
July 1, 188, balance available....................................- ..-- ..                                          208. 03
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188                            ..    -.--....--......
                                                                                 -                                10, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1989 ...- -.-.---------
                                                             -                                                    10, 208. 0:

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project......----.                                      20,000. 00
   Amountthat c n be profitably cxpended in fiscal earending June30, 1890                                         20, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix G G 12.)
   13.-Harborof Refuge at eitlra(ce of Sturgcon Bay Canal, lVisconsin.
Before the construction of this harbor was undertaken the location
afforded no shelter at all from storms ranging from northeast to south-
west.
   The project of constructing a harbor of refuge at this point was
adopted in 1873 and modified in 1879 and 1880. The modified project as
carried out consists of two piers, each 1,344 feet long, 850 feet apart at
the shore-line, protecting the lake entrance of the canal, and converg-
ing so as to make the harbor entrance 335 feet wide, inclosing an area
of about 10 acres.
   No work was done during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
   The total expenditure at this harbor since the beginning of the im-
provement has been $161,354.58, resulting in the entire completion of
the piers as projected, and in the dredging of 132,344 cubic yards of
material, giving a channel 16 feet deep at the entrance and 14 feet or
more thence to the canal, making a depth of 14 feet over the greater
part of the sheltered area.
   No money is asked for during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, as
it is thought the unexpended balance will be sufficient for maintenance
and repairs.
                          RIVER         AND HARBOR               IMPROVEMENTS.                               239
July 1, 1887, amount available ....................................                               .     $4, 027. 71
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  6utstanding July 1, 187 ............--- ........................- -.....--- .                             387.29
July 1, 1888, balance available ........................                        .......---   ......       3, 640. 42
   (See Appendix G G 13.)
   14. Ahnapee Harbor, Wisconsin.-Previousto the improvement of this
harbor the depth of water at the mouth of the Wolf River was only about
2 feat.
   The project of improvement, adopted in 1875 and modified in 1884,
provided for the formation of a small artificial harbor, connected with
the lake by a channel 100 feet wide and 12 feet deep, formed by the
construction of two piers extending to the 18-foot contour, with a 200-
.foot entrance between the pier-heads.
   Owing to the proviso in the appropriation act of August 5, 1886, that
wharfage over the Government piers must be made free, no work has
been done during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, is $139,660.88, and has
resulted in the construction of two piers, the north one 902 feet long,
and the south one 1,125 feet, the outer 100 feet of the north pier and
150 feet of the south pier being without superstructure, and in the
removal of 22,233 cubic yards of rock and 82,343 cubic yards of sand.
July 1, 1187, amount available ..........                         .............................       . $15, 433. 42
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.................. ... ........... ............                                   158.80
July 1, 1888, balance available.......... .... ........ . ........ . ...... ....                         15,274. 62
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..........           ............                            5, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889............20,                                       274. 62

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......                               15, 000.00
   Amount that can he profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                            10, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with rquireuments of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix G G 14.)
   15. Ke caunee Harbor, Wisconsin.-The natural entrance to this har-
bor was via the Kewaunee River. The river mouth was not more than
20 feet wide, with a depth of about 2 feet at its shoalest point, and ob-
structed by submerged bowlders.
   The project of improvement was adopted in 1881. Its design was to
cut a channel through a neck of land between the river and the lake at
a point about 2,000 feet south of the river mouth, and to continue this
channel to deep water in the lake by the construction of two parallel
piers 2010 feet apart, extending from each side of the cut lakeward to
the 18-foot curve.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, north pier was extended
200 feet by contract, and by hired labor and open purchase 151 cords
of stone were placed at the junction of the north pier with the shore to
prevent a breach.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, has been $44,776.23, in
addition to which the local harbor commissioners have expended
$8,042.72. These expenditures have resulted in the construction of
1,000 feet of north pier and 775 feet of south pie!, and in the dredging
of a channel 100 feet wide and 10 to 12 feet deep, 9,035 cubic yards of
material having been removed by the Government dredges.
240          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1887, amount available..--...-----......------
                                                   ..--...... ....................                          $7,658. 8
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887... ---.-----.--.-.---.-                 ..             ---... -. ---              7, 469. 47

July 1, 1888, balance available ......---...------...-----......----
                                                                  ....---....----......-----.......----.        189. 37
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                                     10. 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...................                                    10, 189.37
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project -....                                -137,j300.    00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                               30, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix G G 15.)
   16. Two Rivers Hlarbor, Wisconsin.-Previousto the improvement of
this harbor the natural channel was obstructed by a bar covered by but
2 or 3 feet of water.
   The project of improvement adopted in 1870 provided for the forma-
tion of a channel of navigable width and not less than 12 feet deep.
This was to be accomplished by the construction of two piers extending
from the river mouth lakeward to the 18-foot contour in Lake Michigan
and by dredging.
   During the year ending June 30, 1888, no work has been done. The
total expenditures to June 30, 1888, are $197,864.67, resulting in the con-
struction of two parallel piers, as follows: A north pier 1,810 feet long,
the inner 1,060 linear feet of which consists of pile-pier and the outer
750 feet of crib-pier; a south pier 1,710 feet long, 960 linear feet of
which is pile-pier and the outer 750 feet crib-pier; the crib sections of
the two piers begin at points opposite, and are 230 feet apart. The pile
sections are 270 feet apart; 240,600 cubic yards of material have been
removed by dredging.
   At the close of dredging operations in 1885 there was a channel of
1.2 feet, 180 feet wide, but in May, 1887, there was only a narrow cha n-
nel about 10 feet deep.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..........................................                            ---       $135. 33
July 1, 1888, balance available...----- ............ .................-- ......           15. 3
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888---- -........-----..--..-.......-------..2, 500. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ---..................                                   2, 635. 33
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                   65, 000.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                5, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix G G 16.)
   17. Manitowoe Harbor, Wisconsin.--Previous to the improvement of
this harbor but 3 feet of water existed at the shoalest point over the bar
at the mouth of the Manitowoc River.
   The original project adopted in 1852 provided for the construction of
two parallel piers 220 feet apart and extending from the river mouth to
the 12-foot contour in Lake Michigan. This was modified in 1881 to
extending the piers to the 18k-foot contour and obtaining a channel not
less than 14 feet deep.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, under contract, the south
pier was extended 50 feet and 250 feet of the superstructure of the same
pier built.
   This completes the present project, but about 1,600 feet of super-
structure is from seventeen to twenty-one years old, is in bad condition,
and should be rebuilt at once.
                       RIVER' AND HARBOR                    IMPROVEMENTS.                                      241
  The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, is $291,383.15, and has.
resulted in the construction of two piers, 1,970 and 1,900 feet long, 228
feet apart at the shore-line, and 250 feet at the outer ends, and in the
dredging of 156,877 cubic yards of material.
July 1, 1887, amount available------ --------..                        .-------------          ------   $8, 905.00
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 -------......---....           -....-----....---.
                                         -...... ----....---....----....     ....----..----- 8, 416. 15

July 1, 1888, balance available ....................--------------......                ---- -----.         488. 85
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .-..--- -..                         --....--. ---.         8, 000. 00



{Amount
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889

             (estimated) required for completion of existing project -- -... - . -
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                          ..................             8,488. 85

                                                                                                         8, 362. 54
                                                                                                         8, 400. 00'

     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix G G 17.)
   18. Sheboygan Harbor, Wisconsin.-Previous to the improvement of
this harbor the natural channel had a depth not exceeding 4 feet on
the bar at the entrance to the river.
   The project for the improvement of this harbof was adopted in 1852
and had for its object the formation of a 12-foot channel entrance to
the mouth of the Sheboygan River. This was modified in 1873 so as
to secure a deeper channel by further pier extension and dredging.
Both projects were completed within their estimated cost and a channel
was formed 100 feet wide with a depth of 15 to 16 feet between the
piers. The existing project was adopted in 1881, its object being to
deepen the channel still further by extending the piers to the 20-foot
contour in the lake and dredging to a depth of 18 feet between their
outer ends, the depth decreasing to 14 feet at the shore-line. There is
now a navigable channel with a depth of about 13 feet.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, the north pier was ex-
tended 200 feet, the work being done by contract. By hired labor
4,410 cubic yards of material were removed from the channel.
   The total expenditures to June 30, 1888, have amounted to $287,759.36
and have resulted in the construction of two piers 2,044 and 2,260 feet
long, respectively, built of cribs (except less than 300 feet at the shore
end), of widths of from 14 to 20 feet, and in dredging 187,043 cubic yards
of material from the channel.
   The only means of securing a permanent channel is by rapid exten-
sion of the piers to deep water; hence a liberal appropriation is urged
as a matter of economy and of necessity to the commerce of this im-
portant harbor.
July 1, 1887, amount available. .-......            ...... .... .... ...... $13, 521. 79
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887        ..-.....................----.......................--------
                                                                                           ---          12,892. 44

July 1, 1888, balance available ...........----..--..........----
                                                              ...... ......                                 629. 35
Amount appropriated by Oct of August 11, 1888-.--....................                                   15, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...--..---..-----..........                        15, 629. 35


  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                            30,   000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix G G 18.)
         ENG 88--16
242      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  19. Port Washington Harbor, Wisconsin.-The present project for the
improvement of this harbor, adopted in 1869 and modified in 1870 and
1876, was for the formation by dredging of two interior basins having a
combined area of about 54 acres, with a deplth of 12 feet, and a channel
of the same depth connecting them with the lake, the channel entrance
to the basins.to be north of the mouth of the Sank River, inclosed be-
tween two piers so constructed that the flow of the river should be selI
arated from the channel, and that the debris brought down by freshets,
instead of shoaling the channel, should re-enforce the south pier.
  The natural channel at the mouth of the Sauk River was narrow, and
at the shoalest point had a depth of but 1 foot.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $681.56 were expended
in building 50 feet of superstructure on the north pier.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1888, is $168,468.53, exclusive of
outstanding liabilities, and has resulted in the construction of a north
and south pier 920 and 1,226 feet long, respectively, with 400 feet re-
vetment along the north bank of the river, extending to the inner end
of the south pier; in the formation of two interior dredged basins of 24
and 3 acres, respectively, with an average depth of about 9 feet in the
north and 8 feet in the west basin, and in making a navigable channel
between the piers of 11 feet.
                                                      ---.....--...-----... $2,216. 53
July 1, 1887, amount available ..--..--....--.--....----..........----..
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 .....................
                                              ----......              -1,
                                                  -----..--...--....---....           177. 16

                                                                      ......--.... 1, 039. 37
July 1, 1888, balance available .......----......--.........---.....-----
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ...... ..         .. ---- ......
                                                                --....             5, 000.00
&mount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...--...--........
                                                                  -                6, 039. 37

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890       7,000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix G G 19.)

CONSTRUCTION OF HARBOR OF REFUGE, MILWAUKEE BAY--IMPROVE-
  MENT OF THE HARBORS OF MILWAUKEE, RACINE, AND KENOSHA,
  WISCONSIN, AND WAUKEGAN, CHICAGO, AND CALUMET, ILLINOIS-
  IMPROVEMENT OF ILLINOIS, CALUMET, FOX, AND WISCONSIN RIV-
  ERS.

   Officer in charge, Capt. W. L. Marshall, Corps of Engineers, with
Lieut. G. D. Fitch, Corps of Engineers, under his immediate orders.
   1. Harbor of Refuge, Milwaukee Bay, Wisconsin.-The project for the
work was approved in 1881, and contemplated the formation of an ar-
tificial harbor by inclosing a portion of Lake Michigan within an outer
breakwater of crib-work upon a stone foundation. This harbor will
furnish 417 acres of safe mooring ground beyond the 18-foot curve and
about twice this area beyond the 12-foot curve. *
   Work began in 1881, and up to June 30, 1888, there had been ex-
pended $330,562.34, resulting in the completion of 3,300 linear feet of
the substructure of the breakwater, over which 3,100 linear feet of su-
perstructure has been built.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, the east arm of the break-
water was extended 100 linear feet, and superstructure built over 400
linear feet of substructure.
   The breakwater when gompleted will be 7,250 feet in length ; there
                        RIVER AND             HARBOR                      IMPROVEMENTS.                                 243
remains, then, to be constructed 3,950 linear feet of substructure and
4,150 linear feet of superstructure to complete the work.
   The balance of appropriation now available is barely sufficient to
maintain the necessary lights upon the unfinished pier during the pres-
ent season.
   The funds asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, are to be
applied to the extension southward of the east arm of the breakwater.
   The harbor is now used to a limited extent as a shelter from north-
east storms. Its value will rapidly increase as the east arm is ex-
tended.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..........................................  $39, 754.58
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887, and including $4,737.91 expended on Milwau-
  kee Harbor ....-- -----......-          ......
                                       -......--       .......................----                 --   --......   36, 116.35

July 1, 1888, balance available.......... .... .............   ......      ......                                   3,638.23
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...-------------------..---.....-.                                    70, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                          73, 638.23

IAmount      (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 418,600.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30, 1890 150, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix H H 1.)
   2. Milwaukee Harbor, Wisconsin.--The present project was adopted
in 1852, and was directed to securing 12 feet of water at the entrance
to the river and to protecting this channel by parallel piers. Since that
date a channel, 18 feet in depth and of sufficient width, has been formed
by extending the piers and dredging. The project has been completed,
and consequently the only expenditures now demanded are for the main-
tenance of the piers by timely repairs and the depth of the channel by
dredging.
   The original depth of water at the mouth of the river was not more
than 3J feet.
   The United States has expended on this harbor up to June 30, 1888,
$289,586.08, in addition to $321,355.66 by the city of Milwaukee. Of
the above expenditure $4,737.91 were expended by allotment from the
appropriation of August 5, 1886, for 1 Harbor of Refuge, Milwaukee
Bay and Harbor."
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, 336 linear feet of super-
structure over the outer section of the north pier have been cut down and
rebuilt.
   There are no funds now available for this work.
   The superstructure over the outer section of the south pier is in urgent
need of rebuilding, and repairs are necessary at the west ends of both
piers, where they have been damaged by collisions.
   The pile protection to the stone superstructure of the inner section of
the north pier is also in need of repair, and dredging is needed to main-
tain the channel, which has deteriorated to 17 feet, through a narrow
channel.
July 1, 1887, amount available..........-......-.......................... $7, 901.95
Amount allotted from act of August 5, 1886, for Milwaukee Bay and Har-
  bor--        .....    .          .................
                                . .....         ......-------------------- 4, 737.91
                                                                                                                   12, 639.86
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.............................. .... ...----                                              12, 639. 86
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ...                                    ,......... ------.....        10, 000.00
244          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.----                                   $12, 000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                             12, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix I H 2.)
  3. Racine Harbor, Wisconsin.-The entrance to this harbor originally
varied in depth from absolute closure after storms to about 6 feet.
  The present project was adopted in 1843, and contemplated originally
a channel 12 feet in depth. The piers have since been further extended
and the channel deepened to 16 feet by dredging.
  There has been expended upon this harbor up to June 30, 1888,
$231,707.02.
  There being no sufficient funds available for this harbor during the
past fiscal year no work has been done.
  The harbor is in urgent need of dredging. The channel has de.
teriorated from 16 feet in depth until it is now barely practicable for
vessels drawing 124 feet of water; nearly 40,000 cubic yards of dredg-
ing is required to restore the channel.
  The south pier should be extended also, and the present wide mouth
of the channel somewhat contracted.
July 1, 1887, amount available ............ ............................                                   $774. 04
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1887 ........................................                                .       174.56


July 1, 1888, balance available..........................................                                    599. 48
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1883 ......                        ..........   ........        10, 000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .........-.....                                    10, 599. 48


   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                             15, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix H H 3.)
   4. Kenosha Harbor, Wisconsin.-The present plan of improvement by
parallel piers and dredging was first directed to securing a channel 12
feet in depth. The depth of water in the channel at the present stage
of water in Lake Michigan is 11 feet; at ordinary low water it is only
12 feet. The original depth was 4 feet or less; sometimes it was en-
tirely closed.
   This harbor was dredged in 1875-76 to 15 feet in depth, but the
appropriations have been insufficient to maintain the work, and it had
deteriorated to 104 feet in depth at the beginning of the present fiscal
year, or nearly 5 feet in available depth.      It is now 12- feet in
depth.
   There has been expended upon this harbor up to June 30, 1888,
$221,153.64.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, 49 white-oak piles were
driven along the channel-face of the inner section of the south pier by
contract, and 7,272 cubic yards of sand excavated from the channel,
restoring the depth over a channel width of 40 feet to 14 feet in depth,
which has again deteriorated, as shown above, to 121 feet in depth.
   Twenty-eight thousand cubic yards of dredging is urgently required,
and the sections of superstructure built in 1872-'74, are now rotten and
require renewal,
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                   245
July 1, 1887, amourft available ....-----------.....-----....... -......---..----.                $5, 547. 17
                                                                                   -..-....----.........
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1887 .--........                  ............--.....-.........-....                           4,747.24

July 1, 1888, balance available..--.....----......--------------.................------ ---- --                         799.93
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...                         ---....................--.                   7,500. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...                                      ........-
                                                                                                  -     ....          8,299. 93

iAmount  (estimated) required for completion of existing project-----........
Amount thliatcan beprofitablyexpendedinfiscal year ending June30,1890
                                                                                                                     33,500.00
                                                                                                                     10, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   ( See Appendix H H 4.)
   5. Waukegan Harbor, Illinois.-The present project was adopted in
1880, and, as since modified, consists in excavating a small basin in the
low ground between the lake and the bluffs to form the harbor, and in
dredging an entrance between parallel piers from the lake to the basin.
   The harbor here is to be created upon a shallow exposed coast, and
will not begin to be available for commercial purposes until the piers
are sufficiently extended into the lake to allow the entrance to be
dredged with hope of permanency and the basin excavated.
   There has been expended upon this harbor up to the close of the
fiscal year, June 30, 1888, $89,725.20.
   During the year ending June 30, 1888, the south pier was extended
71 feet in length; stone was also placed in and around the piers where
it had become deficient from the washing out of the sand at base by
storms, and 257 piles have been purchased for the continuance of the
work, when funds are made available.
July 1, 1887, amount available ...               ......--......
                                                        --...--..-             ----      ...... .....----- ---....   $9, 318. 11
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ........................................--------                                           9, 043. 31

July 1, 1888, balance available               - -........................------------................                   274. 80
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ......................                                            .    25, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ..................------                                  .    25, 274.80

                                                                 ------ 46,000.00
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of exising project ....-
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1800                                          30, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix H H 5.)
   6. Fox and         Wisconsin
                         Rivers, Wisconsin.-The works for the improve-
ment of the Fox and Wisconsin rivers were purchased by the United
States from the Green Bay and Mississippi Canal Company in 1872.
These works were all, except one stone lock, temporary structures, all
of them in bad condition. There was no low-water navigation on the
Upper Fox, and on the Lower Fox navigation was uncertain.
   For the .ox River.-The adopted project contemplated the replacing
of the temporary structures with permanent works, the construction of
five additional stone locks on the Upper Fox, and widening and deep-
ening the channels throughout the river and canals to 6 feet depth and
100 feet width.
   For the Wisconsin River.-The method adopted has been to contract
the channel-way by wing-dams of brush and stone, to give increased
depth by' concentrating the water and by scour due to the increased
currents. The estimate, including the Wisconsin River, made in 1874
246    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

and 1876, was $3,745,663, since which time there has been appropriated
$1,780,000, leaving for completion of the adopted project $1,965,663.
   The general subject of the improvement ofthe Fox and Wisconsin rivers
was referred to the Board of Engineers, who, after systematic observa-
tions of the effect of the dams on the improved section of the Wisconsin
River, submitted a report contained in House Ex. Doc. No. 65, Forty-
ninth Congress, second session, recommending that no further work be
done on wing-dams in the Wisconsin River with a view to improve its
navigation.
   The original project, therefore, as far as it relates to the Wiscnsin
River, has been definitely condemned, and the work confined to the
Fox River, under the modified project of a Board of Engineers sub-
mitted September 17, 1884, published in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1885, approved by the Secretary of War Decem-
ber 10, 1884, as further modified by authority of the Chief of Engineers
May 14, 1886.
   The modified project applies only to the Fox River and its needs, and
contemplates the renovation of eleven old locks and the deepening and
widening the channel of the Fox River from Montello to Green Bay to
6 feet depth and 100 feet width, the estimate for which is $602,000. Of
this amount $56,250 were appropriated August 5, 1886.
   The amount expended on the improvement of the Fox and Wisconsin
Rivers from 1867 to date, including outstanding liabilities and $145,000
paid to the Green Bay and Mississippi Canal Company for works of im-
provement under act of June 10, 1872, is $2,693,003.62.
   The result of this expenditure has been:
   On the Fox River.-The construction of 14 new locks of stone; 13
dams, 4 of which are temporary ; 12 cut-offs ; 10miles of canals dredged
and deepened. Over 2,000,000 cubic yards of material have been
dredged from the Upper Fox, and all temporary structures repaired and
maintained in working order. The navigation has thus been continu-
ous throughout the season from Portage to Green Bay, there being at
an ordinary stage of water 21 feet navigation on the Upper Fox and 54
feet on the Lower Fox, except at the entrance of Lake Winnebago,
where there is only 41 feet. During the months July to November,
1887, inclusive, navigation was partially suspended from Lake Winne-
bago to Appleton, due to the mills drawing more water than the dis-
charge of the Fox River, thus lowering the levels of the Lake Winne-
bago and Little Butte des Morts pools.
   Under the modified project, there remains to be done 2,800,000 cubic
yards of dredging and rock excavation, mainly upon the Upper Fox,
and one dam at Appleton, with sluice-ways; the old works to be main-
tained under the continuous appropriation.
   On the Wisconsin River.-To date 108,512 linear feet of wing-dams
have been constructed over a distance of 50 miles, of which a section 9.2
miles in length below Portage has been completed. The result has
been an increased depth of navigation wherever the works have been
applied. There is not now, nor has there been, any regular navigation
on the Wisconsin River, due to the prevalence and shifting nature of
the sand-bars and the consequent lack of any defined channel for con-
siderable distances.
   The question of the practicability of improving the open-river navi-
gation of the Wisconsin by wing-dams in the bed of the river, to the
extent required for an effective through route of navigation, has been
decided in the negative, and the work on that stream definitely aban-
doned.
                            RIVER AND HIAROR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                          247
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, the following work has
been done:
   On the Wisconsin River.--Nothing.
   On the Upper Fox.-The work was confined to the maintenance of
the channel by dredging, and to timely repairs to locks, dams, and em-
bankments.
   On the Lower Fox.--Dredging was continued in the Menasha Chan-
nel, to connect the deep rock cut with deep water in the lake.
   The various works on the Lower Fox were maintained in serviceable
condition. The old locks, Kaukauna 5th and Appleton 3d, were prac-
tically rebuilt; a deep dredge cut was made from Menasha Lock to
deep water in Little Lake, Butte des Morts; new lock' gates built
where required, and general repairs made to locks, dams, and canal
banks.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..................    ..     .................. .. $44, 300. 28
Fuel sold to officers, deposited to credit of appropriation- ..............- .         175.00
                                                                                                               44, 475.28
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 - ------..------------ -------.......................---- .. 24, 535.67
July 1, 1888, balance available ........................................-----------------------------------.    19,939.61
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                                        100,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1859 ............                                   ......    119, 939.61

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project, Fox
    River------
         ...... ......................       ------ --......
                                          ......---......     --    .. 446, 000. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 200, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
L harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix H H 6.)
  7. Operating and care of locks and dams on the Fox and Wisconsin
rivers, Wisconsin.-Under the continuous appropriation for operating
and care of canals and other works of navigation, it is proposed to main-
tain existing navigation by timely repairs to old locks until they are re-
placed by new, and to continue the repairs of works that have already
been completed and used, injured by the extraordinary flood of 1881.
July 1,1888. amount expended during the fiscal year ....................                                       $52,204.77

Amount (estimated) for expenditure in fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ..                                       48, 900. 00
    (See Appendix H H 7.)
  8. Chicago Harbor, llinois.-In charge of Maj. Thos. H. Handbury,
Corps of Engineers, to March 31, 1888. The present project was adopted
in 1870 and modified in 1878.
  The project consists in:
   The formation of an outer harbor or basin, by inclosing a portion
of Lake Michigan just south of and adjoining the entrance to Chicago
River, for the purpose of increasing the harbor facilities of the port of
Chicago.
  The construction of an exterior breakwater of crib-work filled with
stone, outside of the outer harbor in deep water to shelter the approach
to the river and outer harbor entrances, and to form a harbor of refuge
at the southern end of Lake Michigan.
  There has been expended upon this project since 1870, $1,409,819.02
and has resulted:
  In the completion of the outer harbor, except 267,000 cubic yards of
dredging, to attain 16 feet in depth throughout the basin required.
248       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   In the completion of 4,236 linear feet of the exterior breakwater.
   During the past fiscal year the work consisted in :
   The construction of experimental permanent superstructure of con-
crete over 95 feet about midway on the easterly breakwater of the outer
harbor.
   The completion, by hired labor, of 400 linear feet of superstructure
over the outer extremity of the exterior breakwater for the harbor of
refuge.
   To complete the work of improvement upon the harbor of refuge and
outer basin requires an estimated sum of $240,000.
   The whole of the superstructure over the easterly breakwater of the
outer basin and over part of the north pier of the entrance to Chicago
River, is now in an unsafe and rotten condition and requires renewal.
One hundred and twenty thousand dollars is required to build these
superstructures.
    The dredging in the outer basin is not urgent and can be postponed
until the basin is demanded for harbor and dock purposes, when the
material will be valuable for filling. It should not be further dredged
and wasted.
    At the entrance to the Chicago River the channel has now deteriorated
to a depth in places of only 11.8 feet in depth. It is unnecessary to say
that an appropriation for this work is very urgently needed. An esti-
mate of $12,000 is submitted for this purpose to restore the depth to 16
feet. This, the greatest port on the lakes, should have its harbor deep-
ened to 18 feet. It is now in places about 12 feet, but a 15-foot channel
is found.
Estimated for completion of outer basin and harbor of refuge..........-------.                $240, 000.00
For superstructure over east and north piers............................                       120, 000. 00
For dredging Chicago River entrance ............       -.................. --                   12, 000. 00
       Total.......           ----- -.... ---...............................   ............    372,000.00
July 1, 1887, amount available .........................................                        20,974. 11
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ............................................                         18, 212. 81
July 1, 1888, balance available ..........-............ ...... ..........                        2, 761. 30
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ..............................                   200, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...............                          202, 761.30
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....                          172, 000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 172, 000. 00
  Submit ted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix H H 8.)
   9. Galumet Harbor, Illinois.--(In charge of Maj. Thos. H. Handbury,
bury, Corps of Engineers, to March 31, 1888.) This improvement is
to furnish a safe and practicable entrance to Calumet River and the
port of South Chicago, by parallel piers, 300 feet apart, extending from
shore to deep water in the lake, and by dredging between them to 16
feet in depth at low water.
   The work commenced in 1870, and at the close of the fiscal year 1888
there had been expended $391,222.30. As the result of which 3,600
linear feet of the north pier and 1,870 feet of the south pier had been
completed, and 384,376 cubic yards of material dredged, giving a chan-
nel 16 feet in depth instead of 7 feet, as found here before improvement.
   During the past year no work has been done for lack of appropria
tions.
                              RIVER SAND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                     249
  Additional dredging to secure 16 feet in depth is needed in the chan-
nel, which has deteriorated. The south pier should be extended 150 lin.
ear feet to complete the original project. The north and south piers need
additional stone, particularly the outer end of the north pier, which is
in very insecure condition, and the superstructure on portions of the
north and south piers are rotten for a length of 1,600 linear feet.
   The funds available and asked for the fiscal year ending June 30,
1890, are to be applied to the above-described works, viz:
For dredging .............                                  ...........-------..--..-    .......--.....-----..........   $21, 000.00
Rebuilding superstructure                      .....................................--                    ------....          2, 500.90
Completing original project.......................................20,400.00
        Total ........................................................                                                       63, 900. 00
   All of which can be profitably expended in one year.
July 1, 1887, amount available...... .................                                        .----.....--...........    -     $871.58
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 .................. .......... .... .... ......---...---.                                              93. 88
July 1, 1888, balance available ............................-----.....--------.....----.                                      777. 70
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888_.................. ....                                                     20, 400.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.......................                                              21, 177.70
  Amount (estimated) required for maintenance ........................------------                                        43,500.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                              43, 500.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix H H 9.)
   10. Illinois River, lllinois.-(In charge of Maj. Thos. H. Handbury,
Corps of Engineers, to March 31, 1888.) The present project contem-
plates the extension of the work heretofore done by the State of Illi-
nois, from the mouth of Copperas Creek to the Mississippi River, a
distance of 135 miles, which project includes the building of two locks,
350 feet long, 75 feet wide, and with 7 feet at low water over the miter-
sills, and dredging the channels where necessary to 7 feet deep at low
water.
   The sites selected for the two locks are, one at Kampsville, 30 miles
above the mouth of the Illinois, the other at La Grange, 45 miles above
Kampsville.
   The ultimate object of the improvement is the construction of a ship-
canal from the southern end of Lake Michigan to the Mississippi River
of sufficient capacity to accommodate large-sized Mississippi steam-
boats, and for military and naval purposes.
   The State of Illinois, aided by the United States, has executed part
of this project by the construction of two locks of the dimensions above
stated, one at Henry and one at Copperas Creek, completing that part
of the improvement between La Salle, Ill., and the mouth of Copperas
Creek.
   The La Grange Lock is now completed, with the exception of guide-
piers, and filling behind the lock. The foundation of the Kampsville
lock is completed and part of the stone cut and delivered. Both dams'
are still to be constructed, the Kampsville lock completed, and dredg-
ing done amounting to more than 2,000,000 cubic yards. In executing
this work the United States has expended up to the close of the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1888, $712,141.45, exclusive of $62,359.80 expended
on the foundation of the Copperas Creek Lock, which was afterwards
completed by the State of Illineois. An additional amount of $747,747
250       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

was expended by the State of Illinois on Henry and Copperas Creek
Locks.
   To complete the present project requires the sum (estimated) of
$587,500.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, the following work was
done:
   a. La GrangeLock.-The sediment deposited in this lock was removed;
the foundation floor planked over with 2-inch pine plank; lower miter-
still set and secured ; gates, valves, maneuvering machinery and snub-
bing posts placed, and the lower tail-bay mattressed and ballasted, and
part of the filling behind the lock-wall placed.
   b. Karpsville Lock.-Two thousand eight hundred and eighty-one and
eight-tenths cubic yards of cut stone was received and piled.
   c. Dredgingin channel.-Twenty-six thousand five hundred and sixty-
one cubic yards of material was dredged and removed from the channel
where work was most needed.
   The boats, dredges, etc., were repaired and maintained, and 121 snags
removed from the channel.
   The amount asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, can be
expended advantageously upon the locks and dams at La Grange and
Kampsville, and in dredging operations.
   Plans and estimates of cost of continuing this improvement to Joliet,
Ill., have been submitted to Congress, but no surveys or estimates have
been made for continuing the improvement from Joliet to Lake Michi-
gan. Practicable routes are known to exist. It is suggested that
$10,000 be made available for making proper surveys and preparing
plans and estimates for this continuation.
   The report of the Board of Engineer Officers constituted to examine,
in all their relations to commerce, the Illinois and Michigan Canal, and
the proposed Hennepin Canal, with their value and usefulness to navi-
gation, and to report upon the acquisition and improvement of the Illi-
nois and Michigan Canal and the construction of the fiennepin Canal,
was transmitted to Congress January 10, 1887, and printed as House
Ex. Doc. No. 79, Forty-ninth Congress, second session, also published
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers, U. S. A., for 1887, Ap-
pendix II, page 2125, et seq.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..........----------------..--...---------------..----. $41,735.38
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887          ........----....   ....----....--....---......   ---......--.....   31, 508. 03

July 1, 1888, balance available .......--...... .. .... ...... .... .........     10,227. 35
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ......................-         .. 200, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889-----------------................... 210,227.35
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.----.       387, 500.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 387,500. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix H H 10.)
S11. Calumet River, Illinois and Indiana.--In charge of Maj. Thos.
H. Handbury, Corps of Engineers, to March 31, 1888. The object of
this improvement, so far as at present projected, is to secure a chan-
nel 200 feet wide and 16 feet deep from Calumet Harbor, Illinois, to
one-half mile east of Hammond, Ind., with the view to increasing the
failities for handling the growing commerce of this region, and also to
aid in providing means for the better accommodation of much of the
commerce of Chicago, which is now very much crowded in that city.
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                251
  The river and harbor act of July 5, 1884, appropriated $50,000 for
the improvement of that section of the river from the harbor to the
outlet from Lake Calumet, with the proviso-
  That no part of said sum shall be expended until the right of way shall have been
conveyed to the United States free from expense, and the United States shall be fully
released from all liability for damage to adjacent property owners, to the satisfaction
of the Secretary of War.
   Parties directly interested have for some time been actively engaged
in securing to the United States the right of way and releases required.
The matter is now so far advanced as to be placed in the hands of the
United States district attorney for the northern district of Illinois for
examination of titles and preparation of the necessary legal papers.
   Work will be commenced on this section of the river as soon as the
requirements of the proviso shall have been complied with.
   The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, appropriated an additional
sum of $30,000 for the improvement of this river, $11,750 of which
were to be expended in improving the river " between the Forks and
one-half mile east of Hammond, Ind.," one- half of which to be expended
in Illinois and one-half in Indiana.
   The work during the year ending June 30, 188, was confined to that
indicated in the above provision of the act of August 5, 1886, i.e., to
dredging between the "Forks and one-half mile east of Hammond, Ind.,"
by contract with the lowest responsible bidder.
  Thirty-seven thousand seven hundred and forty-three cubic yards of
material were removed in Indiana at Hammond, and 39,061 cubic yards
in Illinois at Burnham.
  The amount expended by the United States upon this work up to
June 30, 1888, is $11,095.52.
                                                                        .....------ ----
July 1, 1887, amount available--.--..--...------..--........---.-- .........---...........       $79, 227. 50
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887----....--......--.....------......----- ------
                                                                   ..----..--------..--.....---.  10, 323. 02

July 1, 1888, balance available..........................--....----............ 68,904. 48
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888--                                 50, 000. 00
                                                    .....................-----...
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889............ ........ 118, 904. 48
fAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- ......295, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30, 1890 100, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix H H 11.)

IMPROVEMENT              OF     HARBORS        ON THE            EASTERN          SHORE       OF    LAKE
                                              MICHIGAN.

   Officers in charge, Capt. D. W. Lockwood, Corps of Engineers, to
March 28, 1888, since which date Maj. S. M. Mansfield, Corps of En-
gineers, having under his immediate orders since May 15, 1888, Lieut.
J. E. Kuhn, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Charlevoix.Harbor and entrance to Pine Lake, Michigan.-The aver-
age width of the original channel of entrance was 75 feet; the depth
varied from 2 to 6 feet. The present project for its improvement,
adopted in 1868 and revised in 1875 and 1876, is to dredge a channel
100 to 150 feet wide, connecting Round Lake with Lake Michigan, to a
depth of 12 feet, and to protect both sides with close piling. This was
modified in 1876 by substituting crib-work for pile-piers beyond the
252          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

shore-line in Lake Michigan. An additional modification in 1882 pro-
vided for a revetted channel between Round and Pine lakes.
   The present channel of entrance is from 160 to 105 feet wide, and the
channel between Round and Pine lakes is 83 feet wide. The available
depth for navigation is about 10 feet. The amount expended to June
30, 1887, was $70,710.82, and has resulted in obtaining a channel of
navigable width and about 10 feet depth through from Lake Michigan
to Pine Lake, and in revetting both sides of the cut between Round and
Pine lakes, the length of the revetment being on the north side 339
feet and on the south side 366 feet. The amount expended during the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, was $7,368.38, including outstanding
liabilities, and resulted in the construction of 354 feet of plank-beam re-
vetment on the north side of channel, in the removal of 4,500 cubic
yards of dredged material from the lower channel, and in the extension
of the south pier 50 feet by a crib 20 feet wide.
   The extension of the south pier is urgently needed to maintain a depth
of 12 feet in the lower channel.
July 1, 1887, amount available...---......-----..--....--..---.................-..-                      . $10,289. 18
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 187 ...............------..---
                               - - ----              ---..----..................----                         7,368. 38
July 1,1888, balance available ......---............--......------........--......                          2, 920. 80
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.........................                                      12,500. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889..                            ..............          15, 420. 80
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-........-92, 500. 06
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30.1890                               30, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix I I 1.)
   2. Frankfort Harbor. Michigan.--The natural channel of entrance to
this harbor was not more than 3 to 4 feet deep. The present project.
for its improvement, adopted in 1866, was to dredge an outlet through
a strip of land separating Lake Aux Becs Scies from Lake Michigan
and to construct two parallel piers 200 feet apart extending from 12-
feet soundings in the inner lake to the same depth in Lake Michigan.
The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $246,189.39, in securing an
entrance 195 feet wide with an available depth of 12 feet. The amount
expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, was $429.03.
including outstanding liabilities, applied to contingencies of the work
and office expenses. The amount available during the fiscal year was
too small to undertake any work of pier extension.
  The present available depth of water is 12 feet. Until the piers are
extended into deeper water shoaling of the channel will continue to
take place.
July 1, 1887, amount available ......---......--......---              ....   -----...............         $3. 748. 90
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ...........................................                                         429. 03
July 1, 1888, balance available .....-----...---..--..-------------------.....................-....--.      3. 319. 9:
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888--.... ----            ....--....---.........-....             8, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                  11. 319.93

   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                              25. 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (ee ApPendix II 2.)
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                253
  3. Harbor of Refuge at Portage Lake, Michigan.-No natural channel
existed prior to the beginning of the improvement.
   The project adopted in 1879 was to make this a harbor of refuge,
with a channel 300 feet wide and not less than 18 feet deep. The piers
as constructed, however, are 370 feet apart.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $70,239.47 in revetting
the north side of the channel, and the extension of the revetment by
pile work and cribs into Lake Michigan 625 feet beyond the shore-line;
also In building 137 feet of revetment on the south side, and in keeping
open a narrow channel, by dredging, sufficient for local commerce. The
amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, was
$11,479.60, including outstanding liabilities, in removing 11,094 cubic
yards of material with the Government dredge, and in extending the
north pier 100.4 feet by two cribs 24 feet wide.
   The present depth of water is 7.5 feet.
   Until the piers are extended to a considerable distance no hope can
be entertained of procuring a deeper channel than 8 feet.
July 1, 1887, amount available------....---.....---------  ----                     $12,260.53
                                                                       ..----..--........
                                                 .......------.....---......
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ---..-......                  -- $11,299. 95
                                                        ---- ---- --..
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities_....            .
                                                    .....     ............         179.65
                                                                                             11,479.60

July 1, 18, balance available......
                              --------....................................                       780.93
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188                ...---............-......        10, 000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...................                     10, 780.93
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 172,500. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 60, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix I 3.)
  4. Mianistee, Harbor, Michigan.-A narrow channel, not more than 8
feet in depth, was obtained at this harbor by the slab-piers built by
local enterprise. The present project for improvement, adopted in 1866
and modified in 1870 and 1874, was to afford a channel of entrance of
navigable width and not less than 12 feet deep.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $225,108.12 in securing
a channel of navigable width with an available depth of 12 feet.
  The amount expended during fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, was
$5,678.39, including outstanding liabilities, in extending the south pier
50 feet by a crib 30 feet wide.
  The depth available is 12 feet.
July 1,1887, amount available ..........................................                      $12, 8'J1.
                                                                                                       88
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ...... ................                     ................. ..... 5, 678. 39
July 1, 1888, balance available ....................................                          7, 213.49
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                      10, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                    17, 213. 49
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project           82,700. 00
                                                                       -....
  Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal year ending June 30,1890 30, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix I I 4.)
  5. Ludington Harbor, Michigan.-The channel made by local enter-
prise was narrow and not more than 7 feet deep.
254          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The project for its improvement, adopted in 1867, was to afford a chan-
nel of entrance to Pere Marquette Lake, of navigable width, and not
less than 12 feet deep.
   The present project, approved January, 1885, is to widen the.en-
trance to 400 feet by building a new south pier 400 feet south of the
present north pier, and dredging the channel to a depth of 18 feet.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $235,550.52, and has re-
sulted in a navigable channel 200 feet wide and 15 feet deep.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888,
was $1,506.67, including outstanding liabilities, in dredging a channel
to a depth of 15 feet, removing 3,780 cubic yards.
   The available depth of water is at present 15 feet.
July 1,1887, amount available ---------------     ---------------------- $56, 884.48
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 .$.........                 .............                   866. 82
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities...... ......................                                 639. 85
                                                                                                   -              1, 506. 67

July 1, 1898, balance available .... .................----------------------............----------------...      55, 377.81
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..........................                                          60, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30,1889 ....................                                       115, 377.81
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..                                             303, 000.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30, 1890 120, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix I I 5.)
  Pentwater Harbor, Michigan.-The original channel of entrance was
narrow and not more than 4 feet deep in its shoalest part.
  The present project for its improvement, adoptedin 1866, was to afford
a channel of navigable width and not less than 12 feet deep.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $209,791.74, and resulted
in procuring a navigable channel 9 feet in depth.
  The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888,
was $2,813.48, including outstanding liabilities, in extending the south
pier 53.8 feet by a crib 30 feet wide.
  The present available depth, owing to the poor condition of the north
pier at the shore end, which allows sand to enter the channel, is only 9
feet.
July 1, 1887, amount available....--....-----......----..-----....----...----...------------...                  $8, 028.26
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ....          ................................----------             ..                2, 813. 48
July 1, 1888, balance available .................... ........-.-        .........                                  5, 214.78
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.... ......................                                        -6, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ..........                                       ......    13, 214.78

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-....----... 37, 000.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 20, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix I 16.)
  7. White River Harbor, Michigan.-The old channel was narrow,
crooked, and too shoal to accommodate any but very small vessels.
  The present project for its improvement, adopted in 1866, was to
afford a channel of navigable width not less than 12 feet deep.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $237,274.96 and resulted
in obtaining a channel of navigable width between 9 and 10 fe~t deep.
   The amount expended during fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, was
                          RIVER AND              HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                           255
$7,699.98, including outstanding liabilities, in repairing the superstruct-
ure of a portion of the north pier, and in dredging 4,190 cubic yards of
sand from the channel.
  The present depth of water is 12 feet.
July 1, 1887, amount available .........................................            $10,275.04
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ........................          $5, 245.95
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities..........................                               1, 465. 71
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts............                                    988.32
                                                                                                            7, 699. 98

July 1, 1888, balance available              ..... ........       .......................                   2, 575. 06
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                                    10, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                  12, 575. 06
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                   74, 000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                25, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix II 7.)
  8. Muskegon Harbor,Michigan.-The original channel was irregularly
defined by slab-piers, and while it gave comparatively fair access a bar
at the end of the piers on which there was only 7 feet of water was an
obstruction to navigation.
  The project for improvement, adopted in 1866, was to obtain a chan-
nel of entrance of navigable width, and to extend the piers over the bar
to 17-feet soundings.
  The project was modified in 1880 so as to secure a width of entrance
of 300 feet.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $219,427.20, in securing
a width of entrance of 300 feet, the main channel inside being 186 feet
wide, with an available depth of 15 feet.
  The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888,
was $13,208.62, including outstanding liabilities, in repairing the end
of the old north pier and in extending the north detached pier 100 feet
by two cribs 30 feet wide.
   The present available depth between piers is 15 feet, and over the
bar beyond the piers it is 14 feet.
July 1, 1887, amount available.....................................              $14, 572. 80
July 1, 1858, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 .........................    $13, 194.53
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities.........................            14. 09
                                                                                                      --   13, 208. 62

July 1, 1888, balance available..........                                                                   1,364. 18
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ...............                               ..........     45, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ..................                                   46, 364. 18
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 56, 000. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 56, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix I I 8.)
  9. Grand Haven Harbor, Michigan.-The natural outlet was wide but
shoal, the water being only 9 feet deep in the best course. The present
project for improvement, adopted in 1866, was to obtain a channel of
navigable width with a minimum depth of 18 feet.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $486,434.93, in obtaining
navigable channel 400 feet wide and 18 feet deep.
256         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888,
was $27,024.05, including outstanding liabilities, and resulted in the
addition of 150.6 feet of crib-work, 30 feet wide, to the north pier, and
52.2 feet of crib-work, of the same width, to the south pier, and in the
repair of the old end crib of the south pier.
  The present available depth of water between the piers is 18 feet, and
over the bar outside 15 feet.
July 1, 1887, amount available ....            -..              ..............           ................               $37, 931. 22
July 1,   1888,   amount expended daring fiscal year, exclusive, of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887....... ....                                 ..                $------
                                                                                                     $26, 901.05
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..........................                                              123. 00
                                                                                                                         27, 024.05

July 1, 1888, balance available ....................                .................                                    10,907. 17
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ....                          ....         -- - - - -.....
                                                                                        ......      - -25,....-             000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ..................-                                                35,907. 17

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project------........ 155, 000.00
SA mount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 75, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix I I 9)
   10. Black Lake Harbor, Michigan.-The channel made by the Harbor
Board of the city of Holland was narrow, irregular, and only 5. feet
deep.
   The project for its improvement, adopted in 1866 and modified in
1873, was to obtain a channel of entrance of navigable width and not
less than 12 fret deep.
   The.amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $252,854.26, in obtaining
a channel 200 feet wide at the entrance and a depth of 10 feet.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888,
including outstanding liabilities, was $4,237.24, in repairs to the super-
structure of the north pile revetment.
   The present available depth is only 7 feet, owing to a small shoal
that has formed between the piers and the low stage of water in the
lake.
July 1, 1887, amount available............. ....----                       ......................                        $6, 761. 05
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ....-......-....-..........                                    $2, 732.20
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities.      _
                                          -....      .................                                    160. 29
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts..........--                                              1,344. 75
                                                                                                                          4, 237. 24
July 1, 1888, balance available .........---- .................... .........                                              2, 523. 81
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.................. ......                                                    5, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889----...................                                              7,523.81
  rAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                                10, 000.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                             10, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
t harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix II 10.)
   11. Saugatuck Harbor, Michigan.- The channel, originally made by
local enterprise, was narrow and not more than 7 feet deep in the best
water.
   The l>roect for its improvement, adopted in 1869, was to obtain a
channel of entrance of navigable width and an available dlepth of 10 feet.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $124,790.48, in obtaining
a narrow channel of 8 feet deep inside and 11 feet deep on the bar,
                     RIVER AND         HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                257
  The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888,
was $9,665.15, including outstanding liabilities, and resulted in renew-
ing the superstructure of 1,334 feet of the revetment on south side.
  The present available depth of water is 8.5 feet.
July 1, 1887, amount available .........................................             $10, 648.52
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ........................          $9, 651.54
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..........................              13. 61
                                                                                       9, 665. 15
July 1, 1888, balance available ...................... ..................                983. 37
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                5,000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .             .............      5, 983. 37
   (See Appendix I I 11.)
   12. South Haven Harbor, Michigan.-The channel, originally made by
private enterprise, was narrow and not more than 7 feet in depth.
   The present project for its improvement, adopted in 1866 and modi-
fied in 1879, was to obtain a channel of entrance of navigable width and
not less than 14 feet deep.
   The amount expended to June 30, 18S7, was $172,218.06, in obtaining
a channel of navigable width 11.5 feet between the piers and 14 feet on
the bar.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888,
was $9,761.99, including outstanding liabilities, and resulted in the
extension of the south pier 53 feet by a crib 30 feet wide and in the
removal of 1,750 cubic yards of material from the channel by dredging.
   The present available depth of water is 10 feet.
July 1, 1887, amount available.......................................... $9, 781.94
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ...... .................. $9, 633.07
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..........................     128.92
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts ............................        9,761. 99
July 1, 1888, balance available ......................     ........  .....                 19.95
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.........................                10, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889....................             10, 019. 95
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 67, 500.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 20,000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix I I 12.)
   13. Saint Joseph Harbor, Michigan.-The natural channel was origi-
nally about 250 feet wide and 12 feet deep at the entrance, shoaling to
9 feet in the river above.
   The present project, adopted in 1866 and modified in 1874, was to
obtain a channel of entrance of navigable width and not less than 16
feet deep.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $337,568.43, in securing
a channel of entrance 15 feet deep and a canal leading to Benton
Harbor 100 feet wide and about 11 feet deep.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888,
was $4,039.47, including outstanding liabilities, in repairs to the filling
of the north revetment and to renewal of the superstructure of 476
feet of the south revetment; also in dredging 14,850 cubic yards from
the canal and basin.
         ENG 88-         17
258          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1887, amount available--..................--......----......--..........  $4, 544. 57
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ......................         $2, 693. 52
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..........................       1, 345.95
                                                                                                 --              4,039. 47

July 1, 1888, balance available .--------....---......-------............
                                                                    ------------....-----....--......       --.... 505. 10
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ...................                                     ...... 12, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 -...................                                      12, 505. 10
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ......                                         29, 000. 00
   Amountthatcanbeprofitably expendedinfiscal yearending June30,
   Submitted in
                                                                          1890
                       compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                                                20, 000. 00

      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix I I 13.)
  14. St. Joseph'River, Michigan, from its mouth to Berrien Springs.-
This is a new work. An examination and survey of the river were
made to comply with the requirements of the river and harbor act of
March 3, 1879, and the report thereon is printed in the Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1880 as Appendix G G 20 (page 2049).
  The proposed improvement contemplated the construction of wing-
dams, dredging, and removal of snags and other obstructions, at an
estimated cost of $11,300.
  The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $2,500 for
the work, and a further sum of $5,000 may be profitably expended in
continuing it during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ---......                      ......         .........           $2, 500. 00
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......                                        8, 800. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                     5, 000. 00
  SSubmitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    Sharbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   15. Michigan City Harbor, Indiana.-Outer Harbor.-Work at this
harbor was commenced by the Government in 1836. The project of
1857 for the construction of a breakwater had been modified, and in
1870 provided for pier extensions and. dredging of channel. In 1870
provision was made for an exterior harbor, and in 1882 it was furthei
modified and an exterior breakwater west of the harbor entrance and
the construction of a pier at west end of exterior breakwater of outer
harbor added.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $830,396. With this
amount the outer harbor has been completed with the exception of some
dredging and the extension of the pier at its western extremity 350
feet. The depth of water is sufficient to admit the largest class of
vessels on the lakes.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888,
was $17,493.76, including outstanding liabilities, in rebuilding outer
end of west pier and renewing its superstructure, and in repairs to the
breakwater.
July 1, 1887, amount available..- -...--.....             ...                               ..         -       $38, 397. 59
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
   liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887----..-------...........--..--......               $17,268.05
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities..........................                                       225.71
                                                                                                                17, 493.76

July 1, 1888, balance available......-------........------..........----------.--...----......                  20, 903. 83
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888-----
                                             ......-----....---..--....                          ......         90, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889-.......-.......... 110,903. 83
                        RIVER AND HARBOR                     IMPROVEMENTS.                               259
  SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..-.----.
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 150, 000. 00
                                                                                                   $305,625.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix I I 14.)
  Inner Harbor.-The site of the present inner harbor was originally
a small creek, crooked, and with a depth insufficient for commercial pur-
poses. The first project was that of 1870 for dredging up to the rail-
road bridge. In 1878 a modified project, providing for extending the
inner harbor up Trail Creek by dredging, was adopted, the cut to be
120 feet wide and 15 feet deep, the city to revet the cut.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $93,581.75 in dredging
a navigable channel with a least depth of 13 feet.
  The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888,
was $314.68 in dredging 4,510 cubic yards from the channel.
  The least depth of water up to the lower basin at end of year was
13 feet.
July 1,1887, amount available--..---....----..----..........---...---.......----......----.           3, 293.25
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 11887-----..-....--.....---... ---........--........----..-----.-----........        314. 68
July 1, 1888, balance available......... ........................                     ........       2, 978.57
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188-....               ............           ......
                                                                                      -5,               000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.--......                   -.........          7, 978. 57
   (See appendix I I 14.)

IMPROVEMENT OF ST. MARY'S RIVER-ENLARGEMENT OF AND OPER-
  ATING ST. MARY'S FALLS CANAL-CONSTRUCTION OF HARBOR OF
  REFUGE ON LAKE HURON, AND IMPROVEMENT OF CERTAIN HAR-
  BORS ON LAKE HURON AND OF SAGINAW RIVER-PRESERVATION
  OF AND OPERATING ST. CLAIR FLATS CANAL-IMPROVEMENT OF
  GROSSE-POINT CHANNEL AND OF DETROIT RIVER.

   Officer in charge, Lieut.-Col. O. M. Poe, Corps of Engineers, with
Lieut. H. F. Hodges, Corps of Engineers, under his immediate orders.
   1. St. Mary's Falls Canal and River, Michigan.-The project for obtain-
ing a navigable channel of 16 feet in depth between Lakes Superior and
Huron had been barely completed when the demands of commerce so
enormously increased that the work of attaining a depth of 20 feet
throughout was undertaken with the full sanction of both legislative and
executive authority.
   A necessary part of the project is the construction of a new lock
upon the site of the old State locks, to have a length of 800 feet be-
tween gates, a width of 100 feet throughout, a depth of 21 feet on the
miter-sills, and a single lift approximating 18 feet. The canal is to be
deepened to correspond. The estimated cost of this enlargement of
the canal system is $4,738,865, for the details of which see pages 2220
et seq. of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1887. The
statistics of the commerce using the canal indicate more clearly each
succeeding year the urgency for rapid progress in the improvement.
It is now so great that an estimate of $1,500,000 is submitted for the
prosecution of the work during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, in
full confidence that the actual conditions now existing will justify so
large an appropriation.
260          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1887, amount available                ......................................                     $227, 909. 42
July   1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of   liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887-----------------...
                                                        ................ $112, 508. 72
July   1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ........................           24, 432.48
July   1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts......... 90,968. 22
                                                                                                           227, 909. 42

Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888......-                                   .....-.......... 1,000, 000. 00
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-...... 3,738,865. 00
I Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
     30, 1890 ...-------------------....    ......--......
                                         -----------...    --......---....------....------.... 1, 500, 000. 00
I Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
I harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix J J 1.)
   2. Operating and care of Saint Mary's Falls Canal, Michigan.- During
the fiscal year the canal was open to navigation two hundred and ten
days. It was closed for the winter December 2, 1887, and opened May
7 for the season of 1888.
   Eight thousand eight hundred and twenty-three vessels, etc., repre-
senting a registered tonnage of 4,741,976 tons, and carrying 5,581,169
tons of freight and 29,494 passengers, passed through in 3,940 lockages.
   The staple articles transported were 1,605,279 tons of coal, 31,868
tons of copper, 1,645,236 barrels of flour, 23,049,421 bushels of grain,
2,328,275 tons of iron ore, 63,571 tons of pig and manufactured iron,
201,922 barrels of salt, 1,168 tons of silver ore, 188,228,000 feet B. M.
of lumber, 20,404 tons building stone, 2,215 tons of wool, 310 tons of
hides, and 347,275 tons of unclassified freight.
   The expenditures on account of operating and care for the fiscal year
aggregated $29,898.72, and the receipts for dry-docking were $844.
The difference, $29,054, was therefore the net cost to the United States.
   The estimated amount required for the fiscal year ending June 30,
1889, is $36,000, all of which is already provided for by indefinite appro-
priation.
Amount required for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889................------------------.... $36, 000. 00
Balance remaining in hand from allotment of preceding year, exclusive of
outstanding liabilities................................................                     1, 101.28
Additional allotment required for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.......                                    34, 898. 72
   A balance ($22,173.41) remained undrawn from the allotment for the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, and $1,040 remained undrawn of the
allotment for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
   (See Appendix J J 2.)
   3. Dry-dock at Saint Mary's Falls Canal, Michigan.-There is nothing
to add to the subject-matter of preceding reports in regard to this work
beyond the fact that the construction of the coffer dam inclosing the
site of the proposed lock at Saint Mary's Falls Canal has reached that
stage which renders necessary the tearing out of the walls of the old
lower lock, and therefore all projects aiming at converting the old State
locks into a dry-dock must be considered as disposed of.
   The proposition to locate a dry-dock in immediate proximity to the
lockage system is as objectionable as ever; but if it should be decided
to do so, then the location heretofore referred to at the eastern end of
the area transferred from the Fort Brady military reservation to the
canal reservation is the least objectionable.
Amount (estimated) required for construction of a dry-dock at point indi-
cated ....--..---------......------------....----
                                              ...... -----......-----......----..--......-- ----......--....---- $323, 872
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                        150, 000
                          RIVER          AND HARBOR                 IMPROVEMENTS.                                     261
which should be added to the $65,000 (more or less) which it is under-
stood the State of Michigan holds in readiness to transfer to the United
States for the purpose of constructing a dry-dock at Saint Mary's Falls
Canal.
   (See Appendix J J 3.)
   4. Hay Lake Channel Saint Mary's River, Michigan.--The originalesti-
mates for this improvement were based upon a project for a channel
300 feet wide, 17 feet deep, leaving the present navigable channel of
Saint Mary's River at Sugar Island Rapids (about 34 miles below the
canal), through these into Hay Lake, and then, by way of the Middle
Neebish, rejoining the present navigable channel at the foot of Sugar
Island, thus saving a distance of 11 miles and obtaining a route which
it is practicable to so mark with lights as to be navigable at night-a
condition impracticable with the present route.
   The estimated cost of this project was $2,127,292. The project was
subsequently modified to increase the depth to 20 feet, the estimate of
cost being $2,659,115, subject to change, however, in case unexpected
difficulties are developed during the progress of the work.
   The amount thus far appropriated for the work is $475,000, all of
which has either been expended or is covered by existing contracts,
and has been or is to be applied to excavation in Middle Neebish, except
a comparatively small amount expended in surveys and examinations
at Sugar Island Rapids, and in surveys and excavations at Sailor's En-
campment.
    The work is progressing well, and with ample appropriations could
be pushed with great energy. The length of the route is sufficient to
admit of the use of a very extensive plant, and bearing in mind the
fact that the channel is not available until the whole is completed, the
appropriation of $500,000 for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890. is
strongly urged.
July 1, 1887, amount available.. ...................                              ......      ............   $152, 540.29
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887.......................  $72, 005. 08
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities..........................                                 6,941.77
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts...... .....                                 73, 593. 44
                                                                                                ------     152, 540.29
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888........................                                        . 500, 000.00

 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........ 1,684,115.00
 | Amount that can be profitably expended in the fiscal year ending June
    30, 1890 ..---------..----..----......----....----..-------...... ......--....--........------..------........ 500, 000.00
  SSubmitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix J J 4.)
   5. Harbor at Cheboygan, Mllichigan.--Prior to undertaking any im-
provement at this harbor only 61 to 7 feet of water could be carried
across the bar at the mouth of Cheboygan River.
   The original project for the improvement, adopted in 1871, contem-
plated dredging a channel 200 feet wide and 14 feet deep through the
bar, and revetting each side by a pile-pier. Experieice gained during
the progress of the work already done leads to the belief that the piers
can be dispensed with, with consequent reduction of cost to the extent
of about one-half the original estimate.
   Subsequent modifications of the project were made until, as it now
stands, it provides for a channel of 15 feet in depth, and generally of
200 feet in width, from the 15-foot curve in Straits of Mackinac to the
State Road Bridge.
262        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The contract in force at the date of the annual report for last year
resulted in much greater progress than had been expected, and when
the work covered by it was completed the improvement had been car-
ried so well up-stream that but about 45,000 cubic yards remain to be
removed to complete the channel to the State Road Bridge, the limit of
the existing project, and the cost was entirely paid from prior appro-
priations, leaving the appropriation of August 5, 1886, untouched.
   A contract has been made for the remainder of the required excava-
tion at a price so low that the funds available will suffice to pay for all
that is proposed at present, and therefore no further estimate is sub-
mitted at this time. It is feared, however, that the contractor may not
be able to do the work at the price of his contract, and that failure may
result. In that case it may be necessary in the future to estimate for
further appropriations.
July 1, 1887, amount available.......... ..............         ..................           $19,291.20
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ........................                  $4, 976. 08
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts ...........                   14, 315.12
                                                                                              19, 291.20
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888                       -
                                                              .... ......    ...... ......        15, 000. 00

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........                         70,000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30,1890                        15, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix J J 5.)
  6. Harborat Thunder Bay, Michigan.-The project for the improve-
ment of this harbor was adopted in 1876, the object being to obtain an
entrance channel from the bay into the river of navigable width and of
not less than 13 feet in depth. The project was subsequently modified
to such extent as to provide for a depth of 14 feet.
  This had been practically accomplished at the date of the Annual
Report for 1884.           It was then stated that the improvement was of such
a character that it would require attention from time to time, and it
was recommended that a sufficient appropriation be made to render
available the sum of $10,000 for use when it should be wanted. This
was not done, however, and the matter has remained in abeyance.
   Recent complaints of insufficiency of water arise from these causes:
   (1) Deterioration of depth (due to deposits).
   (2) A low stage of water in Lake Huron.
   (3) The general use of larger vessels.
   It is estimated that to fully restore the 14-foot channel will require
an additional appropriation of $5,489.09, thus making available the
sum of $10,000.
   The commerce of the harbor last season, as reported by the deputy
collector of customs, amounted to 750.000 tons, having a value of
$5,267,000. A demand for a 16-foot navigation has arisen in conse-
quence, and is well worthy of consideration. It is therefore recom-
mended that the additional sum of $30,000 be appropriated for the
latter purpose, thus making the entire sum available $34,510.91, all of
which can be profitably expended in one year.
July 1, 1887, amount available .................                      ........................ $4, 525. 07
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ..............................................                           14. 16
July 1, 1~88, balance available ........            ......   .............   ..........      ..    4,510. 91
                         RIVER AND HARBOR                       IMPROVEMENTS.                               2 3

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                          30, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix J J 6.)
   7. Harbor at Au Sable, Michigan.-The present project for the im-
provement of this harbor was adopted in 1866, and modified in 1879,
the object being to obtain a channel of not less than 10 feet in depth
for a width of 100 feet from the lake to the State Road Bridge at Au
Sable.
   The attempts to improve this harbor have not been as successful as
had been hoped, and it does not appear practicable to make any per-
manent improvement at a cost commensurate with the advantages to
be gained. Therefore no estimate is submitted for a further appropria-
tion at this time.
July 1, 1887, amount available....--.....--------.----...--------........-----...........---- ------...... $4,861.53
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year; exclusive of liabilities
                           ---
  outstanding July 1, 1887....       .....        ..-- ---.......----                         ---.....         15.76
                                  ......
July 1, 1888, balance available----  -----........---..------..........-----   ----.---..------.        4, 845.77
    (See Appendix J J 7.)
  8. Saginaw River, Michigan.-The present project aims to secure a
channel 200 feet wide, 14 feet deep, from Saginaw Bay to Bay City, and
12 feet deep thence to the head of navigation in Saginaw River, a total
distance of about 23 miles.
  By the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, the improvement of the
west channel of Saginaw River, along West Bay City, was added to the
original project.
  The same act appropriated the sum of $33,750 for "continuing im-
provement, * * * of which $16,875 are to be used above Bay City,
and $5,000 in improving the west channel along West Bay City."
  The works reported in progress last year were all carried as far as
practicable with the funds available.
  Above Bay City.-Repairs of beam-wall and revetment at Carrollton
for a total linear distance of 4,239 feet, involving the drawing and re-
driving of 242 old piles, driving 817 new piles, and the use of 325
cords mill edgings for filling; total expenditures during fiscal year
$10,410.29.
  Opposite and below Bay City.-Operations were confined to dredging
on the bar at the mouth of the river, resulting in the removal of 18,477
cubic yards of material at a cost of $8,222.26.
   West Channel along West Bay City.-A channel 1,830 feet long, 12 feet
deep, and 25 feet wide, was dredged along the west line of the proposed
channel below the "Cincinnati Mill" dock and in front of Davidson's
ship-yard. In addition the shoal immediately above the Portsmouth
Bridge was almost entirely removed. The total excavation amounted
to 12,520 cubic yards at a total cost of $3,756.
  The available funds are practically exhausted. The interests involved
are so large as to justify the most extensive operations, and the length
of the channel (nearly 23 miles) is such that they can be readily carried
on without interfering with each other.
  The estimate covers $157,050, which includes $20,000 for the West
Channel along West Bay City, which forms no part of the original proj-
ect. The amount of the estimate applicable to the original project is
therefore $137,050.
264,      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1887, amount available .-.......               ............               .................                     $26, 352.12
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ...............-- ..---................ ..... 25, 277. 99
July 1, i1888, balance available ..--..  .     ..        ..                                 . ....  ......                1,074. 13
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .-....--..                                    ...-..........               65, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...-                                         ...        ..          66, 074. 13

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 137, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix J J 8.)
  9. Harborof Refuge at Sand Beach, Lake Huron,Michigan.-The present
project for this improvement was -adopted in 1873. It consists of a
breakwater constructed of timber cribs filled with stone, inclosing an
area which is to be deepened by dredging where necessary.
   Its object is to afford a harbor of refuge to vessels engaged in the
navigation of the northern and northwestern lakes when caught in
heavy weather near the dangerous Pointe aux Barques, the southerly
headland of the mouth of Saginaw Bay. Prior to 1876 vessels so caught
were compelled to run a distance of 60 miles to find refuge in Saint
Clair River; after the subsidence of the gale those upward bound had
to work their way back again. Few improvements have resulted in
greater benefit to the lake commerce, as is fully shown by the infre-
quency of disasters in the vicinity since it became available.
   The estimate of the probable cost of the improvement was $1,442,500.
The sum of $1,050,000 has been appropriated for the work, but of this
amounts aggregating $75,000 have been expended for operating the
harbor and for repairs rendered necessary by extraordinary circum-
stances, etc., none of which were contemplated when the original esti-
mate was made, so that the amount actually applied in accordance with
the original project has been about $975,000.
  If sufficient in amount, the next appropriation should be expended
in beginningk the construction of a permanent superstructure, for cur-
rent repairs, for custody and control of the harbor for one year, and for
dredging in and about the harbor.
July 1, 1887, amount available       .......   .....       ......     ....        ...........            ........       $35, 575. 60
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887...
                                     .......     ............. $19, 766. 35
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities.-. ...----                             -.               .          4, 397.31
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts...........                                           .11,411, 94
                                                                                                                    -    35, 575.60

Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...                          -
                                                                        --..... ..............                           70, 000. 00
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- --. -                                                 58,000.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                             58, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix J J 9.)
   10. Mouth of Black River, Michigan.-To comply with the requirements
of the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, a preliminary examina-
tion, a survey being unnecessary, was made of the above, and the report
thereon is printed in the Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1887 as
Appendix K K 22.
  The improvement proposed is the removal by dredging of all material
at the mouth of the river above the uniform depth of 17 feet, at an
estimated cost of $59,300.
                      RIVER AND           IIARBOR       IMPROVEMENTS.

  Under previous appropriations, the last made in 1876, aggregating
$56,500, the shoal was removed to a depth of 16 feet.
  The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $10,000 for
the work, and a further sum of $20,000 may be profitably expended in
continuing it during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888--......----.------....----......------       $10, 000.00

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-------.......              59, 300.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                20, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   11. Clinton River, llichigan.-In1870 the channel over the bar at the
entrance to this river afforded a depth of only 3J feet, whilst the depth
in the river some distance above the bar was 10 feet.
   The present project for improvement was adopted in 1870 and modi-
fied in 1880. It aims to obtain an entrance channel of 8 feet. This was
practically accomplished in 1882.
   In a teport of January, 1885, of the results of a survey, made to coin-
ply with provisions of the river and harbor act of 1884, a modification
of the existing project was proposed by the officer in charge, involving
the straightening of the channel of the river at Shoemaker's Bend, and
minor improvements elsewhere, at a cost of $33,000
   This report was transmitted to Congress February 11, 1885, and the
river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, appropriated $6,000 for continu-
ing the improvement.
   This amount being too small to accomplish anything at the mouth of
the river and at Shoemaker's Bend has not been expended, and is held
to await future action of Congress.
   Meanwhile an unusually low stage of water has occurred, resulting in
great difficulty in navigating the river. Consequently, urgent demand
was made for temporary relief, and the expenditure of $2,500 in dredg-
ing for the purpose has been authorized, and the work is now in progress.
This will reduce the amount available for the existing project to $3,500,
to which adding the $10,000 appropriated by act of August 11, 1888,
leaves a balance of $19,500 yet to be provided.
July 1, 1887, amount available..----......-------..----.............---................ $6, 000. 00
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ........................                         $81. 88
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities.--.....--------......-----......----------....    610. 50
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts...... ....                        1, 807. 62
                                                                                                2, 500.00
July 1, 1888, balance available ....................- ........                                3,500. 00
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...........                      ..... ...      10, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ........-..........                    13, 500. 00
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ......                     19, 42G. 00
   Amount thatcan beprofitablyexpended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                   19, 500. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of -river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix J J 12.)
    12. Saint Clair Flats Canal, Michigan.-This canal was projected in
1866, with a view to obtaining a straight channel 13 feet deep and 300
feet wide across Saint Clair Flats, the channel being bounded on each
side by a dike 7,221 feet long, or an aggregate of 14,442 feet.
    These dikes consist of timber cribs resting upon piles driven into the
original bottom of the shoal, the crib-pockets being filled with material
dredged from the channel. To maintain a channel bank a single row
of sheet-piling was driven along the channel-face of the cribs previous
266         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

to dredging. The lake-sides of the dikes were protected from wave
action by shorter sheet-piling.
   In 1873 the channel was deepened to 16 feet by dredging for a width
of 100 feet on each side of the axis of the canal, or a width of 200 feet in
all, being thus limited by the fact that the sheet-piling, intended for a
depth of 13 feet, have not sufficient penetration to admit of dredging to
16 feet for the full width of 300 feet. Moreover, the single row of sheet-
piling is insufficient to prevent.the leakage of the dike material through
it into the channel, and it is necessary to re-enforce it with a double row,
giving them, however, sufficient penetration to admit of subsequent
dredging to a depth of 20 feet.
   The entire timber superstructure is much decayed, and should be re-
newed as soon as possible. Its condition has been duly reported in the
Annual Reports for the last four or five years, and the condition be-
comes worse with each succeeding year. It has now been in place fdr
an average of about twenty years.
   The present project for improving the canal contemplates driving a
double row of sheet-piling to a depth of 26 feet along the channel-face
of each dike, dredging the area between them to a depth of 20 feet, con-
tinuing the channel above and below the canal to the same depth in
river and lake, and rebuilding the wooden superstructure.
   The cost of the work indicated, exclusive of dredging, is estimated at
$200,000, an increase of nearly 33 per cent. upon the estimate submitted
in 1885. This increase arises from the continued increase in the price
of labor and materials, especially of timber, which forms so large a por-
tion of the latter. It is probable that, for the reason stated, this esti-
mate will have to be increased from time to time, depending upon the
extent of the delay.
   By the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, the sum of $18,750 was
appropriated for continuing the improvement. This has been expended
in the construction of 2,449 linear feet of re-enforcing sheet-piling.
July 1, 1887, amount available............-----......-----......--......----......----......            -- $18, 553. 94
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887- .------------...................-----.......----.....------....---------......  18, 414. 24
July 1, 1888, balance available--........................ --......         ------        -                   139.70
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888--------                 .... ....-- ......
                                                               ....------....-                           75, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.-------------------.                               75,139.70
  Amount (estimated)required for completion of existing project........ 181,250.00
  Amountthat can be profitablyexpended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 100, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix J J 13.)
  13. Operating and care of Saint Clair Flats Canal, Michigan.-The
canal is in immediate charge of a custodian, who also acts as inspector
whenever any work is in progress.
  During the past year operations were limited to the necessary super-
vision of the canal, and the expenditures to the custodian's salary of
$1,500, and to the repairs of the boat belonging to the work, amount-
ing to $10, or an aggregate of $1,510.
  The estimated cost of operating and care of the canal for the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1889, is as follows:
Salary of custodian .-.......--..                                         --. .       ....       .....        $1, 500
Current repairs and contingencies, which can neither be foreseen nor esti-
mated for in detail, to include a fair proportion of the office of the superin-
tending engineer at Detroit ..      ..... .........   .-...............       . 3, 500
        Total..         ................................-..-......                ....... ............ $5, 000
                        RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                267
  All of which is provided for by indefinite appropriation (section 4
of the river and harbor act of June 5, 1884).
Amount required for' fiscal year ending June 30, 1889--                   .-.....-....------..... $5, 000. 00
Balance remaining " in hand" from allotment of preceding year, exclu-
  sive of outstanding liabilities ............------------ ......-.......----....
                                                           ..------               ----.....--- .      391.93
Additional allotment required for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889..--......                      4,608.07
  A balance of $4,500 remained undrawn from the allotment for the fis-
cal year ending June 30, 1883, and $7,000 for the fiscal years ending
June 30, 1886 and 1887.
  (See Appendix J J 14.)
   14. Grosse Point Channel, Michigan.-Within the last two or three
years a good deal of trouble has occurred to vessels because of insuffi-
ciency of water in the channel off Grosse Point, Mich., at the lower
end of Lake Saint Clair (head of Detroit River). The improvement of
this channel has always formed a part of the project for the ameliora-
tion of the general navigation of the Lakes, and now that the use of
vessels of heavier draught has become so common, and the mishaps, and
consequent expense and delay to which they are almost daily subjected
at this place have become so great a burden, the work of improvement
should be no longer delayed.
   The improvement proposed for the present consists in dredging the
present channel sufficiently to give a depth of 19) feet for a width of
800 feet. This was submitted to Congress in Senate Ex. Doc. No. 82,
Fiftieth Congress, first session. The amount of material to be removed
to make such a channel is about 2,515,000 cubic yards, and the cost is
estimated at $553,300, and an estimate of $200,000 is submitted with
which to begin the work.
   The tonnage passing this point amounts to about 20,000,000 per year.
   The act of August 11, 1888, appropriated $75,000 for continuing the
improvement of Saint Clair Flats Ship Canal, with a proviso that all
or any portion of which may be expended in dredging Grosse Point
Channel.
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of proposed project..- -$553,$      300. 00
  Amountthat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 200, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix J J 15.)
  15. Detroit River, Michigan.-Originallythe channel at Lime Kiln
Crossing, Detroit River, could not be depended upon for more than 13
feet of water, the ordinary depth being much affected by the direction
of the wind.
  As originally projected in 1874, the improvement at this point was to
consist of a curved channel 300 feet wide, with a uniform depth of 20
feet, and the original estimate was based upon this project.
   In 1883 it was determined to so modify the project as to secure a
straight channel, the least width of which should be 300 feet, with a
somewhat greater width at each end, utilizing the work already done.
   In 1886 this was further modified to the end that the width of the
channel should be increased to 400 feet by removing an additional width
of 100 feet from the western (American) side.
   From the beginning of the fiscal year operations were energetically
prosecuted until September 15, 1887, when they were suspended because
of the exhaustion of the available funds.
   The progress proposed to be made with the appropriation of August
26$       REPORT        OP   'iTIl   CIIEp      O     E1tGINEERS,       t .   S. ARMY.

5, 1886, has been fully accomplished. About seven-twelfths of the ma-
terial has been removed from the additional 100 feet in width required
to make the channel 400 feet wide according to the project of 1886.
July 1, 1887, amount available.......-----...................----...---...........--.    $8,991.27
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal, year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887..--     ---------............................ ........         8, 830.75

July 1, 1888, balance available ........  ----....----........................               160.52
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 -      ....................
                                                      --                                130, 500.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.................... 130, 660.52
   (See Appendix J J 16.)
   16. Rouge River, Michigan, at its junction with Detroit River and up
the river as far as the bridge of Saint Louis and Wabash Railroad.-This
is a new work. In compliance with the requirements of the river and
harbor act of August 5, 1886, a preliminary examination and survey
were made of Rouge River, and the report thereon is printed in the Re-
port of the Chief of Engineers for 1887 as Appendix K K 21 (page
2275).
   The proposed improvement contemplates the forming of a channel 16
feet deep and 240 feet wide at mouth of the river and for a distance of
800 feet above and then decreasing to 100 feet in width to the bridge
of the Saint Louis and Wabash Railroad, at an estimated cost of
$31,690.39.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $10,000 for
the work, and $10,000 may be profitably expended in continuing it dur-
ing the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 8888.......................                    $10, 000.00
t Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........    21, 690.39
SAmount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 10, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.

IMPROVEMENT OF HARBORS ON LAKE ERIE, WEST OF ERIE, PENN-
        SYLVANIA-IMPROVEMENT OF SANDUSKY RIVER.

   Officer in charge, Maj. L. Cooper Overman, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Monroe Harbor, Michigan.-The original project for the improve-
ment of this harbor was adopted in 1835, when Monroe was a town of
considerable importance, and when the navigable waters of the River
Raisin were separated from the waters of Lake Erie by extensive shoals.
It provided for cutting a canal between the river and the lake, 4,000 feet
long and 10 feet wide, through River Raisin Point, and protecting the
entrance into the lake by parallel piers, the object being to afford a
channel of entrance of navigable width, with a depth of 10 feet. Work
was commenced in 1835 and has been continued from time to time since
that date.
   At the close of the last fiscal year there was a fair channel with a
least depth of 8 feet, up to a point below Monroe where rock bottom
exists, which is deemed sufficient for the present commerce of the port.
   During the month of July, 1887, the sum of $371.94 was expended in
repairs in accordance with terms of the appropriation, being the balance
of funds on hand. No other work was done during balance of the fiscal
year.
   The total amount appropriated for this harbor has been $215,515.27.
   If the harbor is to be kept up there is need of extensive repairs to
                   RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                 269
piers and canal revetment, in order to prevent their ultimate destruc-
tion. These are estimated to cost $20,000.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.............. ............     $5, 000. 00

  Amount(estimated)requiredfor completion of existing project and repairs    21,000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 10, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K K 1.)
   2. Toledo Harbor, Ohio.-The original project provided for making
the existing channel 200 feet wide and 12 feet deep through Maumee
Bay, and this was amended from time to time, resulting in the adoption
of the present project, which provides for a width of 200 feet at bottom
and a depth of 16 feet at low water between the city of Toledo and deep
water in Lake Erie.
   The total amount appropriated for this harbor for the several projects
for improving the natural channel, from 1866 to close of fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1888, is $714,046.71, all of which has been expended, and
has resulted in obtaining a 15k-foot channel where before there was a
narrow, intricate channel with but 11 feet depth.
   The act of August 5, 1886, appropriated for " continuing the improve-
ment of Maumee River by a straight channel along such line as may
be approved by the Secretary of War, $112,500; and the balance of
the $25,000 heretofore appropriated are hereby made available for clear-
ing the old channel."
   The balance then available amounted to $9,632.61. A contract was
made for dredging to the extent of available funds for clearing the old
channel. This was completed in May, 1887, only 45,397 cubic yards
were removed. This quantity did not restore the natural channel to its
condition as at close of 1885, as the annual fill exceeds 50,000 cubic
yards.
   The estimated cost of the present project for the natural channel was
$570,000, of which amount there has been appropriated $519,346.91.
The balance of $50,000 yet required will not complete the project as
originally estimated, owing to the time consumed in doing the work for
want of adequate appropriation; the annual removal of the deposits of
each winter and spring repeated for thirteen years, and other necessary
expenses, having absorbed at least $100,000 of the original estimate. It
will therefore require at least $100,000 to complete the deepening and
widening of the natural channel between Toledo and 16 feet of water
in Lake Erie, after which an annual expenditure of about $20,000 will
be needed to maintain the dredged channel through the open bay, or
until the straight channel improvement is completed.
    The act of July 5, 1884, appropriated $25,000 to commence the work
of making a straight channel for the Maumee River from its mouth to
Lake Erie.
    The sum of $15,367.39 was expended in dredging along a line desig-
nated by this act of Congress, but subsequently abandoned.
    To comply with the requirements of the act of August 5, 1886, addi-
tional examinations became necessary to determine the line to be recom-
mended-for approval of the Secretary of War. These were made and
the report of the officer in charge thereon was referred to a Board of
Engineer Officers for consideration. The Board adopted a line different
from all others previously selected, which was approved by the Secre-
tary of War, April 27, 1887.
    A project for the expenditure of the appropriation of 1886, in accord-
    270        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

    ance with this report of the Board of Engineers, was adopted, and con-
    tracts were made for dredging about 750,000 cubic yards along the pro-
    jected straight channel.
       Work has been carried on under these contracts during the fiscal year.
    About 428,913 cubic yards of material have been excavated and re-
    moved from along a section of the line of proposed straight channel,
    but the small amount of work done, as compared with the entire project,
    is of no avail.
       There have been two appropriations for straight channel, amounting
    to $137,500, of which $84,730.20, including outstanding liabilities, has
    been expended to June 30, 1888 (on two lines), and $9,632.61 trans-
    ferred to " old channel."
                                            Straight channel.
    July 1, 1887, amount available .........-----------                       $109, 178. 65
                                                        ..--........---....--............
    July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
      of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887-----....--...........-------------. $49, 517. 89
    July 1, 188-, outstanding liabilities...------............------------......   16,237.87
    July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts.........                    42, 400.00
                                                                                                 108, 155. 76
    July 1, 1888, balance available.....----............................                           1,022.89
    Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.-.....-.................                       150, 000. 00
    Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889------..-----------.............        151,022.89
      SAmount(estimated) required for completion of existing project...... 1,262,500.00
      Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
         1890 ......-----------------------------------------------........-------.......        250, 000. 00
     I Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     ( harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
                                                   Old channel.

    Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.......,....----.......                          $5, 000.00
     SAmount that can profitably be expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                    5, 000.00
      Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
       harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
       (See Appendix K K 2.)
       3. Port Clinton Harbor, Ohio.-In 1870 the channel at the entrance
    was narrow and intricate, with a depth of only 5 feet.
       The present project, adopted in 1875, provides for a pile revetment
    from the north shore of the Portage River, opposite the town, 967 feet
    into the lake, and two pile-piers, 200 feet apart, of an aggregate length
    of 4,100. feet, extending to the depth of 10 feet in the lake, with a view
    of maintaining a depth of 9 feet between them.
       The act of August 5, 1886, approplriated $2,000 for "repairs of exist-
    ing works," and at the close of the year 1887 had been expended in
    making the most urgent of the repairs. Considerable repairs are still
    required and dredging also is badly needed.
       The total amount appropriated for this harbor to the close of the
    fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, has been $48,000, all of which has been
    expended, and has resulted in obtaining a depth of 8 feet from the lake
    to the town. The proposed improvement is only about one-half finished.
    July 1, 1887, amount available...........------------ -.....--....---....... ...........      $1,960. 66
    July 1, 1888, amount expended (luring fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                                                  --------------------- 1,960.66
      outstanding July 1, 187......---------............------------.................
-   Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ......-..---..............                       5.000. 00
                      RIVER       AND HARBOR             IMPROVEMENTS.                       271
(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-------......           $37,000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890             10, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K K 3.)
   4. Sandusky City Harbor, Ohio.-The original depth in the channel
through the outer bar was 10 feet, and greatest depth in the bay about
12 feet.
   The project adopted in 1880 provides for a channel through the outer
bar and through the bay 200 feet wide, and parallel to the city docks
100 feet wide, the whole to be 15 feet deep.
   An increased depth of 16 feet at low water in the old channel is rec-
ommended for this harbor by the officer in charge, on account of the
increased size of vessels navigating the lakes. The estimated cost of
this extra depth is $61,000.
   A project for " a straight channel" for this harbor, extending from
the east end of the dock channel to the north end of Cedar Point, has
received the sanction of Congress. This will materially shorten and
improve the existing entrance. The estimated cost is $96,712, an in-
crease of only $46,712 over the estimate for the project of 1880 as re-
vised to give 16 feet depth.
   Under the appropriation of August 5, 1886, a contract was made                             tor
dredging to the extent of the available funds. Work was commenced
in November, 1886, and was being continued at the close of the fiscal
year with but little progress by the contractor; 17,036 cubic yards of
material were removed from the channel, which restored it to a condi-
tion similar to that at close of 1887.
   An annual removal of at least 10,000 cubic yards is necessary to
maintain the unfinished channel, after which the additional dredging
can be applied toward the completion of the channel to 200 feet in
width and 15 feet in depth.
   The appropriation asked will complete the project of 1880, but not
the revised project for increased depth.
   At the close of the fiscal year ended June 30, 1888, the sum of
$263,715.47, exclusive of outside liabilities and existing contracts, had
been expended on this harbor, resulting in a channel through the outer
bar about 150 feet wide, having a depth of about 15 feet, in which for
a width of 50 feet there was a depth of 16, feet, and through the bay
up to a point 50 feet from the line of docks a width of 150 feet and
depth of about 141 feet.
July 1, 1887, amount available     ...... .............. ...... -....... ..... $12, 337.34
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887......-.................. $5, 972. 81
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities......-
                                           --................             2, 565. 40
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts .-.--         .-....   3, 150.00
                                                                                        11, 688.21

July 1, 1888, balance available- ............-- .......................        ...          649.13
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888- ...-..........        .........          40, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889... ..............                 40, 649. 13

  Amount shat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890            45, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K K 4.)
   5. Sandusky River, Ohio.-The present project, which was based on a
survey made in compliance with the river and harbor act of 1880, pro-
272     ' REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                        U. S. ARMY.

vides for opening a channel 100 feet wide and 9 feet deep between the
town of Fremont and the depth of 9 feet in Sandusky Bay, at an esti-
mated cost of $44,000.
  During the years 1867 and 1872 the sum of $30,000 was expended in
opening a navigable channel with a depth of 8 feet from Sandusky Bay
to Fremont, a distance of 17 miles. Since 1872 the cuts then made
throagh the various bars have filled up.
  At the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1883, the sum of $21,500
had been appropriated for the present project, of which amount
$20,871.53 have been expended ; and there was at the close of the season
of 1883 a good channel, with least depth of 9 feet, from Fremont, the
head of navigation, to the lake. The last appropriation for this river
was that of August 2, 1882.
  The balance on hand, viz, $628.47, was too small to attempt any fur-
ther work last season.
   Up to the present date $51,500 has been appropriated for this river,
of which sum $50,871.53 has been expended.
July 1, 1887, amount available .-.-------.               --- -----------           ---- ---- ----     $628.47
July 1, 1888, balance available -..-..      --... .............................-                ..      628. 47

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                             22,500.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix K K 5.)
   6. Huron Harbor, Ohio.-At the close of the fiscal year ending June
30, 1887, there was a good channel through the outer bar with a depth of
16- feet, and between the piers with a depth of from 16 to 17 feet. The
superstructure of both piers, except where repaired in 1884 and 1886,
was in a decayed condition and needed immediate renewal.
  The heavy gales of the springs of 1885, 1886, 1887, and 1888 did con-
siderable damage to the piers and to the beaches, so that a breach was
made at the inner end of east pier near the shore. Extensive and im-
mediate repairs are much needed.
   Up to the end of the fiscal year the sum of $117,273.71 has been ap-
propriated for this harbor, all of which has been expended, including
the last appropriation, that of August 5, 1886.
   A good channel, with least depth of 14 feet, had been obtained, until
piers became dilapidated, where originally there was a.sand bar dry at
low water.
   The estimated cost of renewing the superstructure of the piers is
$22,000; $13,500 has been appropriated. Repairs in addition to those
contemplated when the estimate was submitted have been made neces-
sary by the storms of 1884, 1885, 1886, 1887, and 1888, and the amount
asked for to completely renew the piers has been correspondingly in-
creased.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                              $6, 000.00

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project and re-
I pairs                            ....------
                     -------------------------.---           - -----..-...   12,000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 12, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K K 6.)
   7. Vermillion Harbor, Ohio.-Before improvement the mouth of the
Vermillion River was closed by a sand-bar, upon which there was a
depth of less than 2 feet; the original project consisted of parallel piers
                           RIVER AND HARBOR                      IMPROVEMENTS.                                 273
running out into the lake from each side of the mouth of the river, in
in order to secure a depth of 10 feet. This project has been amended
from time to time, and now provides for a depth of 14 feet.
  In 1878 the channel was about 70 feet wide, with a depth of about 12
feet, and has since remained nearly permanent.
   The act of August 5, 1886, made an appropriation of $3,000 for this
harbor. Only partial repairs to the piers could be made with the small
amount of funds available, which repairs were made during the fall of
1886.
  At the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, the piers were in
fair condition; the depth in channel was about the same as at close of
the previous fiscal year. The amount appropriated to close of fiscal
year ending June 30, 1888, has been $117,942.32, all of which sum has
been expended.
July 1, 1887, amount available--....--..---...............-------..-----------....----.....-----.           $308. 18
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887...........------.......---------- ------.-----......---......---------......      308. 18
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................
                                                --                                                         1,000. 00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-------.......                            11,000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K K 7.)
   8. Black River Harbor, Ohio.-The present project for the improve-
ment of this harbor consists of parallel piers 200 feet apart, running
out to a depth of 16 feet in the lake.
   Up to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, there had
been appropriated, since 1826, the sum of $210,138.73, all of which has
been expended, and with which a channel with least depth of 16 feet
has been obtained where originally there was but 3 feet at the entrance.
   The act of August 5, 1886, appropriated $10,000 for this harbor. A
contract was at once made for the dredging necessary to remove a shoal
that had formed beyond the piers, and the 16-foot channel was restored
by the end of September, 1886. The repair of piers under contract
was begun in November, 1886, and at the end of August, 1887, were
finished and appropriation exhausted. The piers need considerable
renewal of superstructure.
   Nothing has been accomplished towards the extension of the piers,
which is the most important work when funds sufficient shall be avail-
able.
   The unexpected and extra repairs made and to be made at this har-
bor will increase the estimate for repairs, and the renewal and the pro-
longing of the piers will cost at least $12,000, so that the sum of $20,000
is still needed to complete the existing project.
July 1, 1887, amount available..- ....--..............................--            .                     $5,498. 99
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ..-----------..-----.......................... .........                       5, 498. 99
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..........................                                   10, 000. 00
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project---..----.                                10,000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                               10, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K K 8.)
   9. Rocky River, Ohio.-The project for the improvement of this river
was adopted in 1871, the object being to afford a channel of entrance
          ENG 88-.18
274      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

100 feet wide and from 6 to 12 feet deep. It required the construction
of a pier 500 feet long, and a large amount of excavation.
  With the appropriations of 1872, 1874, and 1875, amounting to $35,000,
the pier as projected was constructed, but only a small amount of exca-
vation was done.
  By the act of June 14, 1880, $4,000 was appropriated for repairs, and
during the years 1880 and 1881 portions of this amount were expended
in placing the piers in good condition. The storms of 1883 did con-
siderable damage, and it was repaired during the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1884, at a cost of $1,248.61.  At the close of that season t he
pier was in fair condition, but the storms of the springs of 1884, 1885,
1886, 1887, and 1888 have again damaged it, and very extensive repairs
are now needed. As the act of August 5, 1886, made no appropriation
for this harbor, and the balance on hand is too small to attempt any
repairs, there will be. no work practicable until further appropriation,
and the damaged pier will be still further impaired. No work was done
nor expenditure of any sort made during the fiscal year ending June
30, 1888.
July 1, 1887, amount available...              .....         .....               ....   $119. 31
July 1, 1888, balance available ...   .....-....-..    ...   ........   ...........      119. 31
   (See Appendix K K 9.)
   10. Cleveland iarbor, Ohio.-The original project for the improve-
ment of the mouth of Cuyahoga River was adopted in 1825, and has
been amended from time to time to gain increased depth. It consists
of parallel piers about 200 feet apart, running out to a depth of 16 feet
in the lake.
   When operations were commenced there was a long, low sand-bar
where the river now empties into the lake, and the entrance was through
a narrow, intricate channel with a depth of about 3 feet.
   At the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, there had been
expended about $369,500, and there was, as a result, a good, wide chan-
nel at the entrance of the harbor, with a depth of from 14 to 18 feet
between the lake and the railroad bridge at the inner end of the piers,
with a pile protection work 620 feet long at the inner end of the west
pier, constructed in 1882.
   Harbor of Refuge.-The original project provided for on outer break-
water, starting from the lake shore about 700 feet west of the upper
end of the old river-bed.
   The west breakwater runs out about due north a distance of 3,130
feet to a depth of 28 feet, and thence for 4,030 feet it runs nearly par-
allel to the shore, with a spur 100 feet long on the north side of the
lake arm, 200 feet from its eastern end, in a depth of from 28 to 30 feet.
It was originally proposed to protect the entrance to the harbor on the
east side by extending the east pier at the mouth of the river 1,400
feet.
   An amenlded project changed this plan and provided for a break-
water on the east side, which begins at a point on the prolongation of
the arm of the west breakwater and 500 feet from it, extends eastward
on the line about 1,100 feet, then inclines towards the shore in a depth
of 25 feet of water, and extends 2,400 feet, having an entrance 1,200
feet wide between the eastern end and the curve of 14 feet depth of
water, or about 2,200 feet from shore.
   The latest project enlarges, the east breakwater by extending the
lake arm 3,500 feet to the east before change of direction is made, and
then the shore-arm is continued 2 ,000 feet as before, but ends in a depth
                     RIVER AND HARBOR               IMPROVEMENTS.                         275
of 26 feet of water, having an entrance 2,300 feet wide between it and
Ihe.curve of 14 feet depth of water. For full report of this change of
plan see House Ex. Doc. No. 189, Fiftieth Congress, first session.
   For the expenditure of the appropriation of August 5, 1886, contracts
were made for the construction of about 1,200 linear feet of the east
breakwater. Operations were commenced in October, 1886, and were
continued, when weather permitted, until end of this fiscal year. By
that date the 1,200 feet of east breakwater was about uine-tenths finished,
and will be completed to the extent of available funds by July 30, 1888.
   The amount expended during.the fiscal year was $151,824.07.
   At the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, a total of about
$942,014.25 had been expended and 7,960 linear feet of breakwater had
been finished, which completes the west breakwater, and over 800 linear
feet of the east breakwater, leaving to be built to complete the harbor
of refuge about 4,700 linear feet of east breakwater.
   The total amount appropriated for the harbor of refuge to July 1,
1888, is $993,750, of which sum $977,514.25, exclusive of outstanding
liabilities, has been expended, less about $35,500 applied to repairs to
piers, dredging, etc., for Cleveland Harbor proper.
July 1, 1887, amount available.--...........----......-----.......... .......------ $165, 922.98
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887.-...- .        .... ......$149, 687.23
                                                    -..
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities     ----......--..............   10, 518.26
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts......--           . 5, 717.49
                                                                       -------      165,922.98

                                                              ........ 100, 000. 00
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...... ...... ...--
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.--...... 519, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 200, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K K 10.)
   11. FairportHarbor,Oh io.-The present project for the improvement
of this harbor consists of parallel piers, 200 feet apart, running into the
lake. It was adopted in 1825, and has been modified by prolonging the
piers from time to time so as to give increased depth, the object now
being to afford a channel of navigable width and nt less than 16 feet
in depth.
   When the work of improvement was commenced in 1826 the mouth
of the river was closed by a sand-bar 1,200 feet wide, at times so hard
and dry that teams could be driven across.
   At the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, there was a good
channel between the piers with a least depth of 16 feet at low water,
and in the lake beyond end of piers a least depth of 151 feet at ordi-
nary level of the lake.
   Contracts were made and work completed for necessary repairs to
piers and for the extension of the east pier 200 linear feet.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, an agreement was also
made in the spring of 1888 for a small amount of dredging in the
channel, and by June 6, 1888, it was restored to its required depth, but
not to full depth.
   Extensive improvements as to docks and yards for receiving cargoes
of iron ore and shipping coal have been made at Fairport Harbor by
Pittsburgh capitalists. These improvements were continued during the
fall of 1887, and it is expected that they will be further extended and
the business of this harbor thereby still further increased.
276       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1887, amount available .......................................------------
                                                                           $15, 040.41
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.                .15,                                 04t. 41
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................             10, 000.00
SAmount (estimated)   required for completion of existing project........          21,250. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890         21, 300.00
* Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of-1866 and 1867.
  (See-Appendix K K 11.)
   12. Astabula Harbor, Ohio.-The original project for the improvement
of this barbor was adopted in 1826. Rock bottom was then found at 9
feet below the surface, and there was a depth Hof only 2 feet of water on
the bar at the entrance.
   The present project contemplates the extension of the piers out to 16
feet depth of water, the removal of the decayed portions of both piers
and rebuilding with new materiial, at the same time straightening the
line of the west pier so as to afford a uniform width of 160 feet in chan-
nel.
   At the close of the year 1886 there was a good wide channel, 151 to
16 feet deep, from the lake into the harbor.
   During the year ending December 31, 1887, the previous condition of
the channel was restored by the removal of 2,954 cubic yards of soft
material by contract.
   As the excavation of the rock from the bar in lake and from the chan-
nel between the piers was the next step in the approved project, a con-
tract was made for this excavation to the extent of available funds, and
the work required under the contract was completed by end of Septem-
ber, 1887. The channel through the outer bar was excavated to 18 feet
depth and full width. The channel between the piers was excavated
to 17 feet depth and of such width as the available funds permitted,
viz, 50 feet, all in rock bottom.
   There has been appropriated for this harbor up to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, a total of $402,401.21, all of which has
been expended.
July 1, 1887, amount available..----.........--...-......--                $19, 057.58
                                                       .---..----.............------.
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 187..----        ..--------..------                --...... 19, 057. 58
                                                            --...--..--..........-
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888......---....-....- --..-
                                                                  .... 25, 000. 00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-..-......25,250. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 25, 300. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K K 12.)
  13. Conneaut Harbor, Ohio.-The original project for the improve-
ment of this harbor was adopted in 1829. 'he design was to afford a
depth of 12 feet of water through the bar at the mouth of Conneaut
Gcreek, which bar was dry at low water when work was commenced.
  The improvements have been prosecuted at this harbor with more or
less interruption and suspension. The best channel ever obtained was
11 feet, and the more usual depth has been 8 or 9 feet. At present the
mouth of harbor is closed by a sand-bar, dry at low water. The piers
are entirely destroyed, with breaches, through which the stream finds
an exit to the east.
  Up to the close of the present fiscal year the sum of $112,629.39 has
been appropriated for this harbor, all of which sum has been expended.
                       RIVER AND -HARBOR IMPROVEMFSN.TS.2                                         277
  The present project for this improvement contemplates rebuilding the
east pier and renewing the superstructure of the west pier, at an esti-
mated cost of $35,000.
  The last appropriation for this harbor was that of June 14, 1880.
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....... $35,090.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix K K 13.)

IMPROVEMENT OF ERIE HARBOR, PENNSYLVANIA, AND DUNKIRK,
  BUFFALO, WILSON, OLCOTT, OAK ORCHARD, AND TONAWANDA HAR-
  BORS, AND NIAGARA RIVER, NEW YORK.

   Officer in charge, Captain Frederick A. Mahan, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Erie Harbor, Pennsylvania.-The original survey of this harbor
was made in 1819, at which time the channel was narrow and tortuous,
with a depth of only 6 feet. In 1823 a' plan for the improvement was
adopted, and constitutes the present work at the entrance to the har-
bor, excepting some changes which have been required either on ac-
count of the age of the structures already built or other causes.
   The piers have been extended from time to time and are now in good
condition.
   The present project contemplated the extension of the piers to the
16-foot curve in the lake, and the maintenance of a channel of naviga-
ble width and 16 feet in depth from the harbor inside to the lake out-
side.
   Operations have been prosecuted with more or less interruption and
suspension (no work was done from 1838 to 1812, from 1846 to 1853,
and from 1855 to 1864), and have resulted in much benefit to the harbor
and its channel entrance. The work during the fiscal year consisted of
the repairs to the piers and breakwaters, and of a survey of the penin-
sula to determine changes in the shore-line and the direction of the
currents along the outside of the peninsula. The channel is now avail-
able to its full width for vessels drawing 16 feet of water.
  To carry out the recommendations of the Board of Engineer Officers
ot June 14, 1882, $10,000 of .the amount available bor the harbor are set
aside to provide for the prompt construction of a dike at the neck of
the peninsula in case of necessity.
   The total amount appropriated for this harbor to June 30, 1888, is
$768,867.23, of which $695,983.01 have been expended, including out-
standing liabilities.
July 1, 1887, amount available .--..........
                                         ...------..------......---------.... .....---------....
                                                                                         -- $80, 351.78
Amount deposited to balance account........... ................                   ........          . 04

                                                                                            80, 351.82
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ......-......                         $6, 937. 28
                                                                    _..-......
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ...-----.....------..........-------....
                                                                        530. 32
                                                                                              7, 467.60

July 1, 1888, balance available .7---------        .      ..----   ...----------   - --      '72,884.22
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888----......----        23, 000.00
                                                      --....--..........
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 -.................                    95,884.22

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-.....-----.24,000.00
  Amount that can be protitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 21,000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L L 1.)
278        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   2. Preservation and protection of the Peninsula of Presque Isle, Erie
Harbor, Pennsylvania.-This is a new work. In a report upon the ex-
amination of Erie Harbor made in 1.885 it was recommended that the
neck of the peninsula be protected by a breakwater, and that the move-
met of sand around the eastern end of the peninsula, which threatens
to close the harbcr entrance, be arrested by the construction of jetties
perpendicular to the shore of the peninsula, at an estimated cost of
$173,044.50.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $60,000
for the work, and a further sum of $60,000 may be profitably expended
in continuing it during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888                                   ...     ............--               ......      $60, 000. 00

( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ..-...-     113, 044. 50
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year euding June 30, 1890 60, 000. 00

    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   3. Dunkirk Harbor, New York. -A      project for the improvement of
this harbor was adopted in 1870, the object being to form an artificial
harbor by constructing a breakwater 2,860 feet long and nearly parallel
with the shore, and by excavating a channel so as to afford a depth of
13 feet into this harbor.
   The breakwater construction has been carried out in part, 1,341 feet
having been completed at a cost of $98,000. The excavated channel is
quite narrow, and presents ragged edges of unblasted rock jutting out
from either side. As it is exposed to winds and waves from any
direction from northwest to northeast it is somewhat dangerous at'
times for vessels trying to come in.
   During the fall and winter of 1886-'87 the west breakwater was badly
damaged, a breach 300 feet long having been made in it. The super-
structure was carried away, as well as much of the foundation cribs.
The east breakwater was also much injured.
   Work during the fiscal year consisted in trying to close the breach
in the west breakwater. Nine cribs were put down. Of these six were
entirely carried away by the gales of October 3 and 4 and October 23
and 24, 1887. Three of the cribs remained, and on them the super-
structure was laid and completed. A few minor but urgent repairs
were made to the east breakwater.
   This last-named work is in such bad condition that any attempt at
small repairs is a waste of money. It needs to be entirely rebuilt. This
should be done so soon as possible.
   Up to June 30, 1888, there had been appropriated for this harbor a
total sum of $479.079.38, of which $477,489.16 have been spent.
July 1, 1887, amount available ......----------....-----......--......                           ----.... $8,299. 23
                                                                       --....----....--....--------....
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.......... .....-----------------------............----......-------......------......                   6, 709.01

July 1, 1888, balance available. ......
                                    ___                  ....           .....         .................               ......        1,590. 22
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ...... ....                                                 ...... ........
                                                                                                                     ---          15, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889..........                                                       .....---. 16,590.22

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .....-
                                                                      - -.                                                        25,000.00
I Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                                                          1890    25, 000. 00
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix L L 2.)
                           RIVER AND IHARBOR                       IMPROVEMENTS.                                279
   4. Buffalo Harbor, New York.-The original project for the improve-
ment of this harbor was adopted in 1826, the date of the first appro-
priation, and, as modified at various times, provided for the construc-
tion of piers on the north and south sides of Buffalo Creek, a masonry
sea-wall running south from the inshore end of the south pier, and a
breakwater less than half a mile in front of the Buffalo light-house, its
long arm being nearly parallel with the shore.
   The present project was adopted in 1874, and provides for the con-
struction of a breakwater of crib-work 7,600 feet long, running parallel
with the shore, and a shore-arm of piles and crib-work 4,100 feet long,
running out toward the southern end of the main or detached break-
water, leaving an opening of about 150 feet between them.
   A length of 1,460 feet north of the north timber parapet of the break-
water is in a very dilapidated condition and should be rebuilt at once.
It was badly wrecked by a severe gale on October 14, 1886. Another
section about 1,500 feet long, south of the north timber parapet, is be-
coming very rotten and can not hold together much longer. It should
be replaced with masonry.
   During the past year a length of 250 feet of the superstructure, be-
ginning from the north end of the breakwater, was rebuilt with natural-
cement concrete faced with Portland-cement concrete, and an additional
length of 200 feet was partly rebuilt with concrete faced with stone.
Both new parts have stood well. The ice during the winter was excep-
tionally heavy, but no damage was done to the new superstructure.
   Very extensive minor repairs were made to the timber portion of the
work, which was badly damaged by the ice of the winter of 1886-'87,
by the gales of October 3 and 4 and 23 and 24, 1887.
   Slight repairs were made to the south pier.
   The works are all in good condition except the breakwater, much of
which is in as bad shape as it well can be.
   The total amount appropriated and allotted for this harbor up to
June 30, 1888, was $1,966,480.41, of which the sum of $1,959,920.73, in-
clusive of outstanding liabilities, has been expended, resulting in the
construction of the north and south piers, the sea-wall, 870 linear feet
of pile-pier, and 6,355 feet of main breakwater.
July 1, 1887, amount available----................----- ------.----...-..--..........-----....----..---   $6, 960. 76
Amount refunded by contractors on account of overpayment--..----....-                                         325.28
                                                                                                           87, 286. 04
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887        ..----..-----    ..--------$79, 230. 47
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..--.....---          -------        1,495. 89
                                                                                                           80, 726. 36

July 1, 1888, balance available .........................................                                   6, 559. 68
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ..---........                                 ..........    225, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .------
                                                        ..................                                231, 559.68
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-....... 892,000.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 400, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L L 3.)
  5. Tonawanda Harbor and Niagara River, New York, etc.--This is a
new work. To comply with the requirements of the river and harbor
act of August 5, 1886, a preliminary examination and survey were made
of the harbor and river referred to, and the report thereon was trans-
280        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

'mitted to Congress January 13, 1888, and printed as House Ex. Doc.
No. 83, Fiftieth Congress, first session.
   The improvement proposed is the construction of a channel for ves-
sels drawing 16 feet between the points above indicated, involving chan-
nels at Horse Shoe Reef, at head of Strawberry Island, and river front at
Tonawanda, etc., at a total estimated cost of $593,538.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $100,000
for the work, and a further sum of $100,000 may be profitably expended
in continuing it during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.......................$100, 000.00

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 100, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  6. Wilson Harbor, New York.-The project for the improvement of
this harbor was adopted in 1873 and modified in 1877, the object being
to afford a channel of navigable width and 12 feet in depth by the ex-
tension of parallel piers from the mouth of Twelve-Mile Creek to the
12-foot curve in Lake Ontario, with the formation of a protected chan-
nel between the piers. The mouth of the creek was originally obstructed
by a bar upon which there was a depth of about 1 foot.
  Before the commencement of operations by the United States the
piers had been carried about 400 feet into the lake by private enter-
prise.
  During the past year the piers were thoroughly repaired. They are
now in good order.
  The amount appropriated to June 30, 1888, is $60,000, of which
$56,799.46, including outstanding liabilities, have been expended, with
the result of extending the piers to the 8-foot curve in the lake.
July 1, 1887, amount available .................. ...........---------------------......      -- $8, 283. 83
                                                                                           ---....
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ........................                        $702. 19
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ............... ..... ....                       481. 10
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts...........                        3,900.00
                                                                                                   5,083. 29
July 1, 1888, balance available .........................................                          3,200.54
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..........................                            5, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889--...--............                           8, 200.54


  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year endingJune 30,1890                        10, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L L 5.)
  7. Olcott Harbor, Hew York.-The project for the improvement of this
harbor was adopted in 1866. It proposes to connect the deep water in
Lake Ontario with the deep water in Eighteen-.Mile Creek by the exten-
sion of two parallel piers from the mouth of the creek to the 11-foot
curve in the lake, with the addition of a dredged channel between the
piers. The project was modified in 1874 and in 1881 to provide for the
removal of rock found to exist in the channel between the piers and for
additional pier extension. The natural channel between the mouth of
the creek and the lake was obstructed by a bar upon which there was
a depth of about 1 feet.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                            281
  During the past year 368 feet of the west pier and 371 feet of the
east pier were rebuilt from below the water-line up. Minor repairs
were also made. They are both in good condition.
  Up to June 30, 1888, the sum of $128,000 had been appropriated for
this harbor, of which $125,207.66 had been spent in the extension of
the piers to the 9-foot curve in the lake and the formation between the
piers of a channel of navigable width and about 7A feet deep at low
water.
July 1, 1887, amount available........................-----.........-------....                             $5, 086. 30
Amount refunded by contractor on account of extra cost of timber pur
  chased in open market --........--------......------ ...-----..--..-......          ---......-----........ 303. 28
                                                                             -......----
                                                                                                                 5, 389. 58
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.... ..............................-------------..--...-----.                          2, 597.24

July 1, 1888, balance available .......                  ........-
                                                            --       -   ..-......     .......... .....-    .    2, 792. 34
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .....................                                              5, 00. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ........-----...........                                   7,792. 34


  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                    10, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix L L 6.)
   8. Oak OrchardHarbor, New York.-The earliest project for the im-
provement of this harbor was adopted in 1836, the date of the first ap-
propriation, and proposed the construction of an east and west break-
water approaching to within 200 feet of each other, and connecting at
the opening with two parallel piers extending into the lake.
  Subsequent modifications were extensions of the original project to
provide for the removal of rock, and to adjust the harbor to the in-
creased demand of commerce. The present project was adopted in
1881, the object being to extend the piers to the 12-foot curve in the
lake with the formation of a channel of navigable width and 12 feet
deep at low water between the piers. The natural entrance into Oak
Orchard Creek was narrow, with a depth of from 2 to 4 feet.
  During the past year the whole of the east pier was rebuilt from
below the water-line. Both piers are in good condition.
  The total amount appropriated for the harbor up to June 30, 1888, is
$194,000, of which there has been spent $192,632.40, resulting in ex-
tending the piers to the 12-foot curve in the lake and securing a chan-
nel of navigable width and 12 feet deep at low water.
July 1, 1887, amount available ....................                                  ....................       $3,213.23
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ................................                                    ......            1,845.63

July 1, 1888, balance available ........................     ...............                                     1,367. 60
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ........................                                           6, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .................                                          7, 367.60

SAmount (estimated)  required for completion of existing project........                                       86,000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                    10, 000. 00
1 Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix L L 7.)
282         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS FOR IMPROVEMENT, TO COMPLY WITH
  REQUIREMENTS OF THE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT OF AUGUST 5,
   1886.

   It appearing, after preliminary examination by the local engineer,
that the localities were worthy of improvement, Captain Mahan was
charged with and completed the survey of Tonawanda Harbor and
Niagara River, New York, between Black Rock and Tonawanda, with a
view to a 16-foot channel, the results of which were transmitted to Con-
gress and printed as Hlouse Ex. Doc. No. 83, Fiftieth Congress, first
session. (See also Appendix L L 8.)

IMPROVEMIENT              OF      HARBORS  ON LAKE ONTARIO                         EAST         OF       OAK
                                    ORCHARD, NEW YORK.

  Officer in charge, Capt. Carl F. Palfrey, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Charlotte Harbor, New York.-The original project for the improve-
ment of this harbor, adopted in 1829, proposed to connect the deep
waters in the Genesee River with the deep water in the lake by parallel
piers about 480 feet apart.
  The present p)roject, adopted in 1881, is for the extension of the piers
to the [5-foot curve in the lake, with the formation by dredging of a
channel between them of a navigable width and 15 feet in depth at low
water.
  The natural channel over the bar was tortuous, and in calm weather
would admit, at ordinary stage of the lake, vessels drawing 8 feet.
  The total amount expended from 1828 to June 30, 1888, is $394,303.25.
The amount expended from the adoption of the present project in 1881
to June 30, 1888, is $76,224.85.
  The total expenditure has resulted in extending the piers to the 13-
foot curve in the lake, securing a channel between the piers of naviga-
ble width, and of not less than 12 feet in depth at low water.
   During the year 1,400 feet of superstructure have been rebuilt and
153 sunken piles removed.
July 1, 1887, amount available .................. ........... .... ...... $20, 739. 38
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ......              ..................   $15, 084. 53
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities..........................                      901.70
                                                                                                    15, 986. 23
July 1, 1888, balance available.-- .............................                       _.........    4, 753. 15
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.............................                          45, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889..----....--.... ......                        49,753. 15

  SAmount (estimated)  required for completion of existing project........ 28, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 28, 000. 00
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   See Appendix M M 1.)
  2. Great Sodus Harbor,New York.-The earliest project for the improve-
ment of this harbor, adopted in 1828, proposed the construction of two
breakwaters from the east and west shores, approaching to within 500
feet of each other, and connecting at this opening with parallel piers
extending into the lake. Subsequent modifications were extensions of
the original project, to adjust it to the increased demands of commerce.
  The present project was adopted in 1882, the object being to extend
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                    283
the piers to the 15-foot curve in the lake and dredging a channel be-
tween the piers 15 feet deep at low water.
   The natural channel would admit vessels drawing 8 feet at ordinary
lake stage.
   The total amount expended from 1829 to June 30, 1888, is $408,567.25,
including outstanding liabilities. The amount expended from the adop-
tion of the present project in 1881 to June 30, 1888, is $51,027.13. The
total expenditure has resulted in the extension of the west pier to the
14-foot curve in the lake, and of the east to the 9-foot, with a channel
of navigable width and 10 feet deep at low water between them.
   The operations of the past fiscal year have been renewal of super-
structure on 926 feet of east breakwater, sheet-piling along 250 feet of
west pier, and a temporary improvement of the channel by pump-
dredging.
July 1, 1887, amount available-...............---             ..--
                                                                -                     .-   -     - --- --             $14, 262. 33
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887............ --....-.....----.       $9, 181. 85
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities---------...........--...-------....---------60
                                                                                                                        9, 182. 45

July 1, 1888, balance available .............       ---              ......-.....--                ............ -       5,079. 88
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888---...............----                                             ...   24, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889---.... --...............                                        29, 079. 8

  SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......                                              24, 000. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal year ending June30, 1890                                            24, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1666 and 1867.
   (See Appendix M M 3.)
   3. Little Sodus Harbor,New York.-The earliest project for the improve-
ment of this harbor was adopted in 1829, and has since been variously
modified. The first appropriation was made in 1852. The early proj-
ect proposed the partial closing of the opening between the bay and
the lake by lateral dikes connected with two parallel piers extending
into the lake.
   The present project, which is an expansion of the earlier ones, was
adopted in 1881, and is designed to afford a channel of navigable width
of not less than 15 feet depth at low water.
  The total amount expended from the date of the first appropriation
in 1852 to June 30, 1888, is $274,964.24, including outstanding liabilities.
The amount expended from the adoption of the present project in 1881
to June 30, 1888, is $40,522.47. The total expenditure has resulted in
the extension of the piers to the 12-foot curve in the lake, securing a
channel between the piers of navigable width and 12 feet in depth at
extreme low water.
   The operations of the past fiscal year have been the building of 200
feet of fascine and stake revetment in front of west breakwater, re-
newal of superstructure on 512 feet of east pier, and minor repairs.
July 1, 1887, amount available ............. ............ ................ $14, 193. 08
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
     outstanding July 1, 1887 .............................                                ..............               7. 165. 55

July 1, 1888, balance available-----
                               ................--....----......-------......----....----..                             7,027.53
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888- ......------ ---......--..----......                                   16,000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...............                                                 23, 027. 53
284        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, l.                                   S. ARMY.

(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........ $17,000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 17, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix M M 4.)
   4. Oswego Harbor, New Yor.-The earliest project for the improve-
ment of this harbor was adopted in 1827, and proposed to inclose an
area at the mouth of the river by extending jetties from the shore
into the lake, joining the outer ends by a breakwater, but leaving an
opening through which to enter the harbor.
   The project was completed in 1869, and forms the present inner harbor.
   The present project was adopted in 1870, and consists of a break-
water 5,800 feet in length, parallel to the old west breakwater, and
1,100 feet in advance of it. The estimated cost was $1,161,682. It
was subsequently modified by the proposed construction of an east
breakwater, 2,700 feet in length, the reduction of 350 feet of the open-
ing between the east end of the west breakwater and the north end of
the light-house pier, the construction of spurs along the face of the
outer west breakwater to reduce the effect of accumulated seas, and for
deepening by dredging the inner harbor at the mouth of the Oswego
River.
    The object of these improvements was to give protection to the city
docks and wharves, and to the commerce of the harbor and lake a depth
suitable for the heaviest draught vessels on the lakes.
    The natural entrance to the mouth of the river was shallow and dif-
ficult of access.
    The total amount expended from the date of the first appropriation
in 1826 to June 30, 1888, is $1,607,854.63, including outstanding liabili-
ties. The amount expended from the adoption of the present project
in 1870 to June 30, 1888, is $1,134,521.90.
    The total expenditure has resulted in the completion of the origi-
nally projected harbor, the completion of the west breakwater, with the
reduction of 350 feet of the opening between the east end of west break-
water and the north end of the light-house pier, the construction of 213
linear feet of the east breakwater, the completion of one spur-crib, and
the deepening of the river mouth to a depth of 15 feet at low water,
securing full protection to the docks and wharves west of the river
  mouth, and channels of entrance 16 feet deep and 350 feet wide each
to the inner and outer harbors and 15 feet deep at low water.
    Early in December, 1884, a severe northwest storm caused a breach
in the west breakwater 145 feet in width, and necessitating repairs for
a length of 100 feet each side of the breach. This portion of the break-
water has been repeatedly breached. To remove and rebuild the old
work the officer in charge estimates would cost $80,000.
    The operations of the past fiscal year have been renewal of super-
structure on 846.3 feet of outer west breakwater and minor repairs.
July 1, 1887, amount available                For repairs      ----------------
                                                                            $47,737.78
                                            JulyContinuing
                                                 1, 1887,amount
                                                             avai
                                                            improvement....  15, 000.00
                                                                                               $6-2, 737.78
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ....................                       34,110. 72
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities.................      ..... ...                989. 02
                                                                                                35, 099. 74

July 1, 1888, balance available .........................................                       27, 638. 04
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888........-.....-........                           100,000.00
Amount.available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889... ...--..---.... --....                 127,638. 04
                            RIVER         AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                  285
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....       60, 00. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 60, 000. 00
                                                                                                       ----
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 18i7.
   (See Appendix M M 5.)
   5. Sackett's Harbor, New York.-The project for the improvement of
this harbor was adopted in 1881, and proposed the deepening of the
harbor over an area of about 15 acres to a depth of 12 feet at low water.
The depth previously existing was less than 8 feet over a large part of
its area.
   In 1826 and 1828 the sum of $6,000 was expended in clearing and
deepening the harbor.
   The total amount expended from 1826 to June 30, 1888, is $12,752.15.
The amount expended from the adoption of the present project to June
30, 1888, is $6,752.15, and has resulted in the removal of 24,010 cubic
yards of sand, mud, and gravel. With the completion of that work
the harbor had a depth of 12 feet at low water over about 6 acres of its
area, except in a small part where the presence of rock in place limited
the depth to a little less than 12 feet.
   No work done during the year.
July 1, 1887, amount available............---------------.... ......
                                                               ----.........------------------......--....        $72. 11
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 18,7 .............................................                                           11.97

July 1, 1888, balance available..................-------...... .....    .....                          ......       60.14
Amount appropriated by act of August, 11, 1888 ........................                                         2, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889............---                         --..--.            2,060.14
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.--......                                       13, 00. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                      5, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
 ( harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix M M 6.)

IMPROVEMENT OF OGDENSBURGIIH HARBOR ON THE RIVER SAINT LAW-
  RENCE,.OF HARBORS ON LAKE CHAMPLAIN, AND OF GRASS AND TI-
  CONDEROGA RIVERS, NEW YORK, AND OF OTTER CREEK, VERMONT.

   Officer in charge, Maj. Milton B. Adams, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Ogdensburgh Harbor, New York.-The present project for the im-
provement of this harbor, which was adopted in 1882, contemplates the
deepening of the channels along the city front and the prolongation of
the lower reach of the Oswegatchie to deep water in the St. Law-
rence River, so as to afford a depth of 15 feet in the channels, and 16
feet on the outer bar at extreme low water.
   When operations were commenced at this harbor the channels
afforded depths of 5 to 12 feet only, and now there are two good chan-
nels from deep water in the St. Lawrence to the nearest docks or
wharves, in which water from 15 to 16 feet deep is afforded, and a
channel 12 feet deep and 150 feet wide has been made along the city
front and is undergoing deepening to 15 feet.
   At the close of operations, August 31, 1887, the channel along the
city front had been made 15 feet deep and 100 feet wide from its lower
end to a point opposite Hannan's Dock, a total length of 2,900 feet, and
all available funds were consumed. The total amount expended from
the date of the first appropriation in 1852 to June 30, 1888, has been
,$146,680.87, and from the adoption of the present project, $36,680.87.
286         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                             U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1887, amount available ....--------------                          ----...............................            $6, 568.44
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887..............................................                                                   6, 568. 44
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .....................                                                       15, 000. 00

i Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........
  Amount that canbe profitably expendedin fiscal year ending June 30, 1890
                                                                                                                          25. 000. 00
                                                                                                                          25, 000. 00
 , Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
 ( harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix N N 1.)
   2. Grass River (at Massena), New York.-The project for the improve-
ment of this river was adopted in 1881, and has for its object the forma-
tion of a channel with a least depth of 4 feet and a least width of 40
feet from the St. Lawrence River to the village of Massena, a distance
of about 71 miles by water.
   The natural depth of the shoal places is about 2 feet. The act of
August 2, 1882, appropriated $3,000 for this work.
July 1, 1887, amount available.---..-....................................                                                 $2, 948.60


'Amount
July 1, 1888, balance available ......--..................................                                                 2, 948. 60

          (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                                 17, 600. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix N N 2.)
   3. Breakwater at Rouse's Point,Lake Champlain, New York.-The proj-
ect for this improvement was adopted in 1885, and contemplates the
construction of a breakwater composed of rubble and large stone on a
straight line extending from Stony Point until the 18-foot curve in the
lake is reached, a total distance of about 2,000 feet.
   The estimated cost of the breakwater is $110,000. Work was com-
menced by contract September 1, 1885, and has been in progress since
that time. The first contract is completed and comprises the section,
800 feet long, extending from the shore to the 12-foot curve. The sec-
ond contract, comprising the extension of the shore section to the 14-foot
curve, 550 feet, is in progress and when completed, November 30, 1888,
will exhaust the available funds.
   There have been $47,686.73 expended on this work to June 30, 1888,
including outstanding liabilities.
   The good effects of the completed improvement are already apparent
in the increased shelter afforded at the                          (locks
                                               and wharves by the por-
tion of the breakwater which has been finished.
July 1, 1887, amount available ---..-----............--......................--.        23, 970.59
July 1, 1888, amount expended during the fiscalyear, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ...-----..---...........-         14, 402.21
                                                                  --- ....
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities......----- ..--...---......--          2, 255. 11
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts-----------.....           6, 985. 00
                                                                                        23, 642. 32
July 1, 1888, balance available ............ ......................                                              ......       328. 27
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.           ..........                 ..            .... ...                13, 500.00



{Amount
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................

              (estimated) required for completion of existing project ......-- -
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                                                          13, 828.27

                                                                                                                          41, 500. 00
                                                                                                                          25, 000. 00

    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix N N 3.)
                          RIVER AND HARBOR                     IMPROVEMENTS.                                 287
  4. Swanton Harbor, Vermont.-The project for the improvement of
this harbor was adopted in 1873, and had for its object the protection
of anticipated docks and wharves by the construction of a breakwater
in front of the place most likely to be selected as their location.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1888, is $70,188.07 and has resulted
in the construction of the existing breakwater.
  Its site was necessarily selected before the docks since built by private
parties were located, and these shipping facilities of the harbor have
been, unfortunately, so placed that very little, if any, benefit in the way
of protection is derived from the breakwater.
July 1, 1887, amount available ...--.................................                                     $326. 93
July 1, 1888, balance available ....-...........---              ---.--....--....
                                              ----............-....                                        326. 93

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....... 169, 500.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix N N 4.)
  5. Channel between the islands of North Hero and South Hero, Lake
Champlain, Vermont.-This is a new work. In compliance with a reso-
lution of the Senate of the United States, dated January 15, 1887, a
report of an examination of the above channel was submitted and printed
as Senate Ex. Doc. 38, Forty-ninth Congress, second session. (Appen-
dix O0 11 of the Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1887.)
  The proposed improvement provides for the removal of about 12,000
cubic yards (mostly bowlders) at the west end of "The Gut" channel
at an estimated cost of $14,300.
   The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $10,000
for the work, and a further sum of $4,300 may be profitably expended in
continuing it during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .-   -
                                               .......                                          .
                                                                                 ..... ......-$10,000.           00

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-.-.--                                 4, 300. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30,1890                             4, 300. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   6.Breakwater at Gordon's Landing, Lake Champlain, Vermont.-The
project for this improvement was adopted in 1887, and has for its object
the construction of a stone breakwater, composed of rubble and large
stones, extending in a straight line to the 18-foot curve in the lake, for
the purpose of increased shelter to a launding on the west shore of Grand
Isle, Lake Champlain. There was necessarily some delay attendant on
the preparation of the project for this work, as no preliminary examina-
tion of the locality had been made prior to the appropriation, conse-
quently the actual work of construction did not commence until August
11, 1887, and has been progressing under contract since then. Nearly
all the rubble stone required for the 500 feet shore section has been
placed, and it is expected that the contract which comprises the con-
struction of the above section will be completed: by the close of this
season's operations, practically consuming the available funds.
                                                                               $18, 413.9
July 1, 1887, amount available ................................-------------------
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887...--      .................. $5, 192.27
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities---..-...-....--..-.......        400.01
July 1, 1888,  amount  covered by  existing    contracts .......... 11,149.94
                                                                                                       16,742.22

July 1, 1888, balance available .---------........----...--..----..-----------................----...----. 1,671. 68
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888....................... . 10,000.00
Amount available for          fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ................... 11,671.68
288            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

r   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- ---                                       $9, 500.00
     Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                  9, 500. 00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
       harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix N N 5.)
     7. Plattsburgh Harbor, New                          York.-The first appropriation for the
improvement of this harbor was in 1836. The project adopted and its
modifications have resulted in the construction of 1,250 feet of break-
water, the protection of a portion of the beach and the dredging of shoal
areas within the harbor.
      Under the appropriation of August 5, 1886, proposals were invited
and a contract made for dredging 25,000 cubic yards from the shoal
areas within the harbor. This contract was completed and closed in
November, 1887, practically consuming 'the available funds.
  The total amount expended at this harbor to June 30, 1888, has been
$143,022.58, of which amount $57,522.58 were expended since the adop-
tion of the modified project in 1870.
July 1, 1857, amount available ....----....----------...----
                                                 ....- ....----.....---....--------....---.                    $4, 903.65
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
     outstanding July 1, 1887 .........................................                                         4, 426.23

July 1, 1888, balance available -   ---......... --................ .........                                      477. 42
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                                         7, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ....                              .....-.......      .    7, 477.42
      (See Appendix N N 6.)
  8. Burlington Harbor, Vermont.-This improvement dates from 1836.
Modifications of the original plan have been made from time, so as to
afford adequate protection to the increasing commercial and shipping
interests of the harbor. The last modification, made in 1886, provides
for further extension of the breakwater, both to the north and to the
south, with its gradual withdrawal, as it is prolonged into water about
30 feet deep instead of 38 feet, to reduce the cost of the work.
  Operations during the past year consisted in placing 4,209.2 cubic
yards of rubble-stone in the foundation of 240 feet of extension to the
southern end of the breakwater.
  The contract under which the above foundation is being constructed
also comprises the building of six cribs, the sinking of the same, and
covering them with a superstructure.
  This contract will doubtless be completed by the close of the present
season of operations, and will practically consume the available funds.
July 1, 1887, amount available........................                           .................. $20, 570.24
.July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 -----------------------.....................    $4, 655. 39
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities...                     ...     ................               1,194.95
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts ...........                                    13, 074.46
                                                                                                               18,924. 80
July 1, 1888, balaxte available...... ......--- ...... ........ ......... ......                                1,645.44
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..........................                                        35, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889..............-......                                     36, 645. 44

     Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 149, 000.00
     Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 50, 000.00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
      (See Appendix N N 7.)
                        RIVER AND HIARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                          289
  9. Otter Creek, Vermont.-The project for this improvement proposes
the formation of a channel of navigable width and a least depth of 8
feet from Vergennes, Vt., to Lake Champlain.
  No operations have been carried on since the improvement of Bull
Brook Bend and vicinity, in 1884, when this obstruction was entirely
removed, so as to afford a good channel 75 feet wide and 8 feet deep at
low water.
  There have been expended to June 30, 1888, $33,351.66.
  The channels at Steam-boat Landing, Sharkie's and Crittenden's
bends, and at the mouth are still to be widened and deepened to com-
plete the project for improvement.
July 1, 1887, amount available .--...........----.....-----....--...--....---....---....                       $648. 34
July 1, 1888, balance available ...--.................                 .... .............-----                  648. 34
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                                      2,500.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889................                                         3,148.34
T   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project. - - -
    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890
                                                                                                             37, 000. 00
                                                                                                              5, 000. 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix N N 8.)
   10. Ticonderoga River, New York.-The project for this improvement
was adopted in 1881, its object being to afford a channel of navigable
width and a least depth of 8 feet at low water from Ticonderoga Village
to Lake Champlain, a distance of about 2 miles.
   The original estimated cost of the improvement was $42,516, of which
amount $12,000 have been appropriated, and as expended have resulted
in an improved channel.
   The channel requires very general widening and deepening in order
to carry out the project of improvement.
July 1, 1887, amount available .......------............
                                                     ---......---...........---------.                       $1,864.60
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
    outstanding July 1, 1887 .---.........----       ....---...........--......-....-.              --....    1,805.89

July 1, 1888, balance available..............----........--........-----......--..                               58. 71
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 -..                       -..-
                                                                  - -.....-           -.--.....               2, 500. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.....                          .............             2, 558.71

SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--........
                                                                      -                                      28,000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix N N 9.)
   11. Narrows at Lake Champlain, New York and Vermont.-The project
for this improvement was adopted in 1885, and has for its object the
removal of such obstructions in the channel as will afford a least depth
of 12 feet and a least width of 150 feet, at low water, from Whitehall
Harbor, New York, to Benson's Landing, Vt. The entire undertaking
was estimated to cost $86,000, of which amount $30,000 have been ap-
propriated. Contracts were made for the removal of the rock-reef at
Elbow, near Whitehall, N. Y., and the dredging of Kenyon's Bay, near
Benson's Landing, Vt., and both were well under way at the close of
last fiscal year.
   The former contract was completed and closed in July, 1887, the other
is to be completed July 30, 1888, which will about, consume the avail-
able funds.
        ENG 88----19
290        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1887, amount available ...-....................----..---....--- --------..--.           $26, 858. 94
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ......----............----         ---
                                                                         ......    $16, 333.35
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities......----------
                                                    ....--......        .. -..--.. 6,264.97
                                                             ------ ------
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts ..........                         2,502. 07
                                                                                                 25,100. 39

July 1, 1888, balance available ............ ..... .... .................                         1,758. 55
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ....     ........         ..........               15, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889..................                          16, 758. 55
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project------.......--. 41,000.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30,1890 41,000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix N N 10.)

                                       PACIFIC COAST.

IMPROVEMENT             OF NAPA RIVER AND OF THE HARBORS OF OAKLAND
                            AND REDWOOD, CALIFORNIA.

  Officer in charge, Col. G. H. Mendell, Corps of Engineers.
  1. NTapa River, California.-This is a new work. In compliance with
the requirements of the river and harbor act of July 5, 1884, a prelimi-
nary examination and survey were made of Napa River from the mouth
to Napa City, Cal., and the report thereon is printed in the Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1885, Part 3, as Appendix P P 8.
  The improvement proposed was the making of a channel 4 feet deep,
75 feet wide from the mouth of the river to the bridge at the city and
50 feet above it, at an estimated cost of $27,600.
  The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $7,500 for
the work, and a further sum of $10,000 may be profitably expended in
continuing it during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..-                 ....
                                                                  .     ....   ......   ......   $7, 500. 00

                                                                           -20,100.00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- -----........
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1l90 10, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  2. Oakland Harbor, California.-The natural low-water depth at the
entrance of this harbor was about 2 feet. The present depth is 9.5 feet.
The project provides for a ship-channel of 18 to 20 feet.
  The general features of the project are:
   (1) Two high-tide stone jetties extended into San Francisco Bay to a
depth of about 13 feet.
  (2) A tidal canal, 400 feet in width, 8 feet in depth, admitting to the
head of the harbor tidal water from San Leandro Bay.
  (3) A dam at mouth of San Leandro Bay.
  (4) Increase of tidal prism by dredging a basin; and
  (5) Dredging interior channels.
  No operations, except those of supervision, were carried on during
the past year.
  The dredged channels show a slight diminution of maximum depth 1
foot or less during the year, accompanied generally with a considerable
increase of area of channel section, as compared with the condition at
the close of the last dredging in 1882.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                        291
  The jetties have undergone no noticeable change during the past
year.
The amount appropriated to June 30, 1888, is.                             ----              .. --.     $934, 600.00
The amount expended, including liabilities, is .-------.--.--                             ----.-           928, 856.05

July 1, 1887, amount available...-----......----.....----...................----.                            8, 278. 28
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887.................                      ......    $2, 174. 33
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities................--.....---.                             60. 00
                                                                                                             2, 234.33

                                     ............
July 1, 1888, balance available...-----           -----............... ..----.                               6, 043.95
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...... .................                                      350, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...--...... -......                                   356,043. 95

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project... -.  1, 241, 000. 00
I Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30
( 1890---..----...........---..
                              --------------...............
                              ..                               -------     500, 000. 00
I Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
l harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix O O 1.)
   3. Redwood Harbor, California.-The project is to dredge the portion
of Redwood Creek adjacent to Redwood Ciy for a distance of 6,000 feet,
to accommodate the vessels trading at that port.     These vessels have
a capacity of 50 to 60 tons.
  'The Government dredge was engaged in making this channel at the
beginning of the fiscal year. It had then gone over about 2,900 feet in
length. In July and to August 3, when it was withdrawn to work
elsewhere, it dredged 870 feet more, leaving about 2,300 feet untouched.
July 1, 1887, amount available....----- ---......----......----...---.............-----------...--..---.    $3, 455.76
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1887 ................................                                                 1,794.92

July 1, 1888, balance available.-------............---....-------.......-..--......                          1, Gi. 84
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188 .............             ...... ....                           7, 400.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889-........... ........                                   9, 060. 84
    (See Appendix O O 2.)
  4. Survey of San FranciscoHarbor, San Pablo and Suisun bays, Straits
of Carquinez, and mouths of Sacramento and San Joaquin rivers, Cali-
fornia.-A party took the field on August 17, 1887, and continued a
hydrographic survey of San Francisco Harbor until January 31, 1888,
when the party was withdrawn on account of bad weather. During this
interval 110.5 square miles were covered by survey, extending in lati-
tude from a parallel 1 miles south of Point Avisadero to a point one-
half mile north of Red Rock, and in longitude from the Alameda shore
to Raccoon Straits, covering most of the city fronts of San Francisco
and Oakland.
  Special examination of shoals, with samples procured by borings, was
included.
  The maps embodying this information are all completed except one,
which is well advanced.
  This survey covers rather more than half of the area that may be
rated as San Francisco Harbor, leaving the western half, including the
entrance, as yet unsurveyed.
  The estimate herewith is intended to extend the survey over the
entrance.
  The total amount appropriated is $11,000.
292           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.-S. ARMY.

   The amount expended, including liabilities, is $8,985.15.
July 1, 1887, amount available...... ....------------..--...----
                                                           ..----..                                     -- $11, 000.00
                                                                                           .--.....------.....--.
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 .. _-. .. __............                                $8, 678. 48
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities .                      .........................              306. 67
                                                                                                                  8,985. 15
July 1, 1888, balance available ....--.                         ------ ----------------------............. --    2, 014.85
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......                                         14, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal ycar ending June 30,1890                                      14,000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix OO                     3.)

IMPROVEMENT OF THE HARBORS AT SAN LUIS OBISPO,                                                          WILMINGTON,
                AND SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA.

  Officer in charge, Maj. W. 11. H. tBenyaurd, Corps of Engineers.
Supervising Engineer, Col. G. H. Mendell, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Harbor at San Luis Obispo, California,etc.--This is a new work.
In compliance with the requirements of the river and harbor act ap-
proved August 5, 1886, an examination was made of the harbor of San
Luis Obispo, California, with the view of establishing a breakwater at or
near Whaler's Point, and the report thereon is printed as Appendix R R
3 of the Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1887.
  The estimated cost of the proposed breakwater is $284,898.
  The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $25,000 for
the work, and a further sum of $50,000 may be profitably expended in
continuing it during lhe fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
Amount appropriated by act passed August 11, 1888..................... $25, 000. 00
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....... 259, 898. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year eudingJune 30,1890                                       50, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  2. Wilmington Harbor, California.-Thepresent project is intended to
secure a depth from 14 to 16 feet at mean low tide. When the improve-
ment was begun in 1871, there was a depth of about 1 foot at the en-
trance; the operations, however, have resulted in securing a greatly
increased depth and width of channel. A recent survey of the harbor
shows that a depth of 12 feet at mean low tide exists throughout the
length of the inner and outer channels. It is intended to gain the
additional increased depth required by dredging and by raising and
extending the jetties. These operations will be carried on during the
coming season and in the future under the existing project, to the ex-
tent of the funds made available for the improvement.
   The total amount appropriated for this harbor is $780,000, and the
amount expended is $735,126.60.
July 1, 1887, amount available-.---- .        ----
                                             .----.    --.-----      -.-          $..71, 714. 06
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887.........
                                              --...       ...... ..  $26, 833. 39
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities .............-..     .........        7. 27
                                                                                   26, 840. 66

July 1, 1888, balance available..........................................                                        44, 873.40
Amount appropriated by act of August 11 1888 ...... --..... ..                                  .. ..
                                                                                                --       ...     90, 000. 00
Amount aivailable for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ......--.........----....                                134,873.40
                              RIVER AND HARBOR                                IMPROVEMENTS.                                     293
{ Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........ $85,000. 00
J Amount that can be protitably expendedin fiscal year ending J ne 30, 1890 85, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix P P 1.)
  3. San Diego Harbor, California.-Theproject for this improvement was
made in 1875, and the work was completed in 1876, the object being to
prevent the filling up of the harbor by material brought down by the Sanr
Diego River during flood stages. The work consisted in cutting a new
water-way, so as to cause the river to empty into False Bay, and in
building a levee across the old channel near its entrance into the harbor.
  The amount appropriated since 1875 is $81,000, and the amount ex-
pended $80,958.09.
  The general condition of the work is good, but it is in need of cer-
tain repairs.
July 1, 1887, amount available .....................--- ...------------ ....                                                   111. 19
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 187......---..----.......................--------......-----..                                            69. 28

July 1, 1888, balance available......-......--                         ----   ---....-..--....--....          ......-...--       41. 9L
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888....                                                      ...-.......-          1, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889--..--..............
                                                                  --                                                         1, 041. 91
   (See Appendix P P 2.)
  4. Surveys of San Diego Harbor,Newport Harbor, and San Luis Obispo
Harbor, California.-These surveys were made in accordance with a
proviso in section 1 of the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, and
reports thereon submitted to Congress and printed as follows:
  Survey of San Diego Harbor in Iouse Ex. Doc. No. 177, Fiftieth Con-
gress, first session.-(See also Appendix P P 3.)
  Survey of Newport Harborin House Ex. Doc. No. 215, Fiftieth Con-
gress, first session.-(See also Appendix P P 4.)
  The report on survey of San Ltdis Obispo Harbor is printed in Senate
Ex. Doec. No. 81, Forty-ninth Congress, second session; also in Appen-
dix R I of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1887.
EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS FOR IMPROVEMENT, TO COMPLY WITH
  REQUIREMENTS OF THE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT OF AUGUST 5,
   1886.
  It appearing, after preliminary examination by the local engineer,
that the localities were worthy of improvement, Major Benyaurd, was
charged with and completed the survey of San Pedro Bay, California,
near the entrance to Wilmington Harbor, with a view to establishing an
outer harbor for the protection of deep draught vessels, the results of
which were transmitted to Congress and printed as House Ex. Dec.
No. 191, Fiftieth Congress, first session.--(See also Appendix P P 5.)
IMPROVEMENT OF ENTRANCE TO HUMBOLDT BAY ; OF SAN JOAQUIN,
  MOKELUMNE, SACRAMENTO, AND FEATHER RIVERS, AND PETALUMA
  CREEK, CALIFORNIA.
  Officers in charge, Capt. A. H. Payson, Corps of Engineers, to No-
vember 23, 1887, since which date Maj. W. I. Heuer, Corps of Engineers.
Supervising Engineer, Col. G. H. Mendell, Corps of Engineers.
  1. San Joaquin River, Stockton and Mormon sloughs, California.--
The project adopted in 1877 and slightly modified in 1881 had for its
object to secure and maintain a channel 9 feet deep and 100 feet wide
294        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U S. ARMY.

to Stockton, 4 feet deep and 80 feet wide to Miller's Warehouse in
Mormon Slough to straighten the river by cut-offs below the mouth of
Stockton Slough and to temporarily improve the low-water channel of
the Upper San Joaquin by the removal of snags, scraping bars, and
construction of wing-dams. Before work was comimenced the channel
to Stockton had at low-water stage a depth of only 6 feet. The upper
river was navigable to Hill's Ferry, for boats drawing 2 feet or less, for
six or seven months of the year.
   Up to June 30 there had been expended on the San Joaquin and
sloughs $144,880.44.      During the fiscal year just ended there was
spent in dredging at Stockton Slough and in the main river at Dutch-
man's Reach $13,073.92. About 144,975 cubic yards of dredging was
done, and the excavated material was forced ashore. In. Stockton
Slough an excavation was made 50 feet by 9 feet by 7,663 feet in
length on the south side of the slough, and one was made on the
north side the same depth and width and 2,200 feet long. In Dutch-
man's Reach a channel was made 150 feet wide, 850 feet long, and hav-
ing a depth of 9 feet at low tide. Annual dredging in the Stockton
Slough and in the main river below the slough will. be necessary to
maintain navigable channels. Wherever dredging has been done and
interrupted for any length of time in the slough, the cut has refilled.
Where cut-offs have been made in the river the channel produced has
maintained. Two more cut-offs below Stockton Slough would be bene-
ficial to navigation; they are estimated to cost $125,000. On account
of lack of funds only seven months of dredging could be done on this im-
provement. The crevasse at Paradise Cut ought to be partially closed,
and was estimated to cost $14,000. A dam may have to be built at
Laird's Slough on the upper river to prevent the river from leaving its
present bed and to prolong navigation for a few weeks in each year.
The estimated cost of the dam is $9,570.
   The act of August 11, 1888, making an appropriation for improving
this river, provides for closing Laird's Slough and the partial closure of
"' Paradise Cut." The amount estimated for the completion of the ap-
proved project is therefore increased.
July 1, 1887, amount available...........- ............... _----                       ...      _- ... $13,869.56
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887---...-------------------------..........................--.............      13,073.92
July 1, 1888, balance available.................... ......   ..............                             795. 64
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ........................                              25, 000. 00


{Amount
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ......------------------......

              (estimated) required for completion of existing project-------.124, 000.00
  Amount that can beprofitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                                    25, 795. 64


                                                                                                    40, 000. 00
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix Q Q 1.)
   2. Mokelumne River, California.-The project for improvement was
adopted in 1884, and had for its object the removal of snags and over-
hanging trees between the mouth of the river and Benson's Ferry.
  Up to June 30, 1887, there had been spent on the improvement
$10,960.58; both forks of the river were cleaned out to Benson's Ferry,
as contemplated. No work was done during the past year, owing to
lack of funds.
  A little snagging will occasionally be necessary to keep the river in a
good navigable condition; hence no estimate for final completio ncan be
made.
                        RIVER       AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                      295
July 1, 1887, amount available .--...........              ..   ........ ......-.........       $39. 42
July 1,1888, balance available ...                   ..-......-........-...-..........            39. 42
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ...... ....                ..............       2, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889--------...--..--.....------....         2, 039. 42
   (See Appendix Q Q 2.)
   3. Sacramento andFeatherrivers, California.--Theproject was adopted
in 1874 and had for its object the improvement of the low-water channel
by wing-damis, scraping of bars, and the removal of snags and trees.
   Up to June 30, 1887, there had been expended $320,799.03, including
outstanding liabilities, part of which was used in the construction of a
snag-boat, two barges, and a dredge-boat.
   During the year ending June 30, 1888, there was expended on the
river $8,813.84.    On account of lack of funds the snag-boat only
worked 29 days, removed 283 snags, built 2 wing-dams, blasted off a
projecting point of river at Hemstreet's Bend, and blasted and washed
out a bar near Walsh's Cut-off, increasing the depth of water on this
bar by 2 feet.
   Before improvement the channel of the Upper Sacramento River was
obstructed by snags, and navigation was very expensive and hazardous;
after improvement the snags were removed, depths were increased, nav-
igation was uninterrupted, freight and insurance rates were reduced,
there was a great increase in commerce, and navigation was made per-
fectly safe.
   Since 1875, when work was commenced, Congress has appropriated
for this work $445,000, of which, up to the close of the present fiscal
year, $329,612.87 have been spent; of the balance, $115,387.13, only
$1,193.26 is available for use, as the large appropriation ($250,000) made
in 1882 and that of 1884 ($40,000) were rendered non-available in conse-
quence of a clause in the act of 1884 which prohibited the expenditure
of these funds except as therein provided, and until the Secretary of
War was satisfied that hydraulic mining on the Sacramento River and
its tributaries had ceased.
   Steam-boatmen are now complaining of troublesome navigation near
Walsh's Landing, but with the small amount of money available nothing
in the way of assistance can be rendered.
   No estimate for final completion of the work can be made. Snags
will have to be removed annually or navigation must cease. It is esti-
mated that $40,000 can be advantageously spent in the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1890.
July 1, 1887, amount available      -............ ..........  .............-.... $124, 200.97
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887......... ............ ......      ...... . ........       8, 813.'84
July 1, 1888, balance available. -....................                   ...     ...        115, 387. 13
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.........................                      20, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889................... 135, 387.13
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 40, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix Q Q 3.)
  4. PetalumaCreek, California.-Theproject adopted in 1880 had for its
object to straighten the channel by cut-offs and secure, by dredging for
about 8,000 feet below Petaluma, a channel 50 feet wide and 3 feet
deep at low water. Before improvement the channel was very crooked
and bare at low water. Work was completed in 1884 at a cost of
296           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

$27,656.91, leaving a balance available of $2,343.09. Since then and
until within the past two months nothing has been done, and the chan-
nel has refilled in places, so that the bottom of the creek in places at
low tide is 2 feet out of water.       A contract has been made, and
dredging is now in progress, to be completed in about one week. About
8,000 cubic yards of material will be excavated, which will relieve the
immediate wants of navigation.
July 1, 1887, amount available......---....------ --.----......-----...........------......-----....---....----         2, 343. 09
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
   liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887...... ...---                               --..      .        $210.24
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts...........
                                                           -                                        2, 132. 85
                                                                                                          --              , 343. 09
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .............--                                      ....    ......        2, 000. 00
( Amountthat can be profitably expended in fiscalyear ending June 30,1890                                               2, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 166(i and 1867.
   (See Appendix Q Q 4.)
   5. Humboldt Harbor and Bay, California.-The project for the im-
provement of the bay was adopted in 1881. Its object was to obtain,
by dredging, a channel 13 feet deep and 200 feet wide to the upper end
of the wharves in Eureka, and to dredge channels 10 feet deep and 100
feet wide to Arcata and Hookton. This work was completed in 1884.
It has since deteriorated. In 1882 a project was submitted and adopted
to improve the entrance to Humboldt Bay by building a training-wall
to the level of low water, extending from the South Spit in a north-
westerly direction. The estimated cost of the training:wall was
$600,000.
   Before improvement began in the bay the channel to Eureka only had
a depth of 7 feet; those to Arcata and Hookton had 6-foot depths.
   The act of August 5, 1886, provided that no money should be spent
in the improvement to entrance of Humboldt Bay until the United
States had received, free of expense, a title to the land desired on the
South Spit. The deed for the land has just been received.
   There has been expended to the end of the present fiscal year
$80,884.69.
July 1, 1887, amount available....                             .-...... .-      ..-.............                      $136, 615. 31
                                                                                                                    .......
July 1, 1888, balance available .--------...........---------------------------.................-- 136,615.31
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ....--.................                              125, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889....-----------..-----.......                                    261, 615.31

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 200, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1h67.
    (See Appendix Q Q 5.)
IMPROVEMENT OF THE ENTRANCES TO COOS AND YAQUIJNA BAYS, OF
  MOUTHI OF COQUILLE RIVER, OF UMPQUA RIVER, AND OF TILLAMOOK
  BAY AND BAR, OREGON.

  Officers in charge, Capt. Chas. F. Powell, Corps of Engineers, to.
July 16, 1887, since which date Capt. Willard Young, Corps of Engi-
neers. Supervising Engineer, Col. G. I. Mendell, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Coquille River, Oregon.-At the time the work of improvement
was begun the entrance to the Coquille River was considered very dan.
                       RIVER AND IHARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                         297
gerous. It was by a long, tortuous, and narrow channel skirting the
south headland, and was studded with rocks from beyond the bar on
the outside to a distance of one-half mile inside. The depth at low
water over the bar was only about 3 feet, while the position of the bar
channel was constantly shifting. The channel sometimes, at long inter-
vals apart, broke through the North Spit and ran directly out to sea,
just south of Rackliffe Rock, but did not remain long in this position.
The entrance at such times was comparatively safe, and the channel
was at its very best. The mean rise of the tide at this place is 4.1 feet.
   The plan of the improvement is to open and maintain a channel through
the North Spit, and running directly out to sea, just south of Rackliffe
Rock, by building ajetty on the south side of the entrance, beginning
at a point on the left bank inside the entrance and running across the
North Spit at a distance of 800 feet south of Rackliffe Rock, and in a
direction nearly west.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1888, including outstanding liabil-
ities July 1, 1887, was $49,510.43. One thousand six hundred and
twenty-six feet of jetty had been built. The channel through the North
Spit was opened in 1882, after the construction of about 1,000 feet of
temporary jetty, and soon after the old channel was completely filled up
and the jetty across it covered with sand and drift. The new channel
when well opened gave a depth of 7 feet at low water over the bar.
During 1884 some of the temporary jetty was destroyed by drift, and
the adjacent fill was washed out, so that a portion of the outflow escaped
uselessly to the south among the rocks, causing a shoaling up of the
channel over the bar to a depth of 5 feet. In 1885 the jetty was
repaired and extended out to a length of 1,523 feet, giving a channel
depth of about 6 feet at low water.
   During the year ending June 30, 1888, an extension of 300 feet was
made to the jetty pile-work, in which 14,235 linear feet of piling were
used; 3,384 cubic yards of stone were quarried and placed in the jetty
as filling to the pile-work and as riprap on the channel side. Other
operations consisted simply in the storage and care of property and in
keeping vessel records.
   The jetty thus far constructed is temporary in character and will need
to be strengthened throughout most of its length. To obtain a needed
8-foot channel at low water over the bar the present jetty will have to
be extended, and probably a jetty on the north side of the entrance
will have to be added.
July 1, 1887, amount available..-
                                -..-         ...--- ....-- ......   ......       .....--........          $6, 682.40
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ........................                              $6,119.50
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities .. ......         ........             ........            73. 33
                                                                                                   ---     6, 192. 83

July 1, 1888, balance available ....-----.......... --................--..--.....--....                       489. 57
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888......----...............                  .                 25, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ---- ..............                                 25, 489. 57

(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                   94,000.00
I Amount that can be profitably expended, including $500 for snagging, in
   fiscal 3 ear ending June 30, 1890 .--.....-......-.................
                                                                .----..--...                              50, 000.00
SSubmitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
( harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix R R 1.)
   2. Entrance to Coos Bay, Oregon.-The obstructions which'existed at
the entrance to this harbor before the works of improvement were be-
gun consisted first of the outer bar, which is of sand and is shifting in
298        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

character, and, secondly, of the inner shoals formed by the sands
which accumulate in the spring, summer, and autumn, during the times
when the northwesterly winds prevail. Under the action of these winds
the spit on the north side advanced towards the south, contracting the
navigable passage under Coos Head to a very narrow width, and
usually making the outer channel follow the west side of the spit in a
long and tortuous course across the bar. The channel had at times
broken through the north spit on a line the general direction of which
is from Fossil Point to a point just to the north of Coos Head. It was
then direct, the depth of water was greatest, and vessels could enter
or go out without trouble. The mean rise of tide above the plane of
reference is 5.6 feet.
    The project for this improvement, adopted in 1879, is to construct, at
an estimated cost of $600,000, a jetty of wood and stone, or of stone, as
may be found best, from a point 250 yards below the northern extremity
of Fossil Point, on a line towards the east end of Coos Head, this line
in plan curving so as to be directed at its outer end to the Head or a
little to the north of it. The object is to prevent accretion to the south
end of the sand-spit on the north side of the entrance, and to open and
maintain a deeper and more direct channel across the outer bar.
    The amount expended to June 30, 1888, including outstanding liabili-
ties, was $134,529.10.
    July 1, 1887, the jetty had been partly built to a length of 1,761 feet,
and had caused a partial erosion of the end of the North Spit, and had
opened a channel well to the south, which was deeper, wider, and less
exposed to wind and sea than the former channel in its usual position.
The new channel was also much less shifting than the old one.
    No active operations in jetty building were conducted during the past
year.     Vessel records were kept, and a watchman was employed to
look after the Government property. A supply of water being avail-
able for quarry sluicing during the rainy season, the watchman, with a
little assistance, succeeded in washing into the bay about 7,000 cubic
yards of dirt overlying the ledge at the Fossil Point quarry.
    It is expected that the jetty will be extended about 600 feet, and that
its top throughout will be raised to 2 feet above low water. The first
work to be done, after sufficient funds become available to resume op-
erations, will be to lay a proper foundation course of stone on the line
of the proposed extension. This will be needed to prevent the bottom
from scouring out, and so to keep the cross-section of the jetty as small
as possible.
July 1, 1887, amount available .......................          ............      ...        $30,910.42
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887.........................                $1, 433. 03
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities .....   ......
                                             ..............                        256.49
                                                                                               1, 689.52
July 1. 1888, balance available ............--...---- ...........--..--.. .....----.          29, 220. 90
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...... ....................                      50. 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889............    --         ........      79, 220.90

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 386,250.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 200, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix RR 2.)
  3. Umpqua River, Oregon.-Just below Scottsburgh, the head of navi-
gation on the Umpqua River, are five sandstone bars or ledges 12 feet
                            RIVER AND HARBOR                       IMPROVEMENTS.                                 299
to 15 feet wide, and submerged from 1 foot to 2 feet at low tide on a
low-river stage. They are separated by pools about 150 feet wide and
from 5 to 10 feet deep at low water.
   The amount expended on the project to June 30, 1887, including out-
standing liabilities, was $4,715.51, and resulted in increasing the con-
trolling depths over the reefs through a channel 50 feet wide, from 1
foot at low water, which formerly existed, to 2 feet at low water.
   The total amount appropriated for this work to July 1, 1887, was
$4,685.89, and $63.86 has been received from sale of property to other
appropriations, making a total of $4,749.75.
   No work whatever was done during the past year for want of funds.
There has been no change in the channel since June 30, 1887.
   It was estimated at the time work was suspended that $2,000 would
be required to complete the present project. This amount could be
profitably expended in one season.
                                                                ...... .---.....------....--.......------.
July 1, 1887, deficiency.----......----------------..--...--....--..-----                                      $29. 62
Received from sale of property to other appropriations .................                                        63.86

                                                                                                                34. 24
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ...................---------------------------..........--....                       23.49
July 1, 1888, balancer available ---......--.. ........--.......... ..--.........---- .                         10.75
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888................. ....---.                                      2,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ......---- ....---......----....                       2, 010.75
    (See Appendix R R 3.)
    4.  -ntrance  to Yaquina Bay, Oregon.-The usual prevailing depths
over the bar at low water at this entrance before improvement were
from 7 feet to 8 feet. Three distinct channels existed, known as the
North, Middle, and South channels. The South Channel was the one
most used, but was rendered dan gerous by the presence of rocks. The
Middle Channel, though free from rocks, was usually the shoalest of
the three, and so was little used. The North Channel, besides being
long and tortuous, was so studded with rocks as to be considered un-
navigable. Owing to the shifting nature of the bar these channels
were constantly changing, both in position and in depth. The mean rise
of the tide is 7.1 feet.
    The approved p)rqject, adopted in 1881, is to run out a dike or jetty
on the south side of the entrance, so as to cause the South Channel to
shoal up and the flow to be deflected northward, with a view to open-
ing and maintaining the Central Channel with a least depth of 17 feet
at high water.
    The amount expended to June 30, 1888, including outstanding lia-                                                     -
bilities, was $234,353.64. On July 1, 1887, 2,517 feet of jetty and 450
feet of dike for shore protection had been constructed, but not completed
to full height and strength. The South Channel had been permanently
'deflected from the south rocks, and, for a part of the time, made to unite
with the Central Channel. The prevailing depths over the bar were
greater by 2 or 3 feet, and the channel was less shifting and much safer
than formerly. During the past year this jetty has been extended 460
feet.
   The present condition of the work makes it apparent that a north
jetty, closing the North Channel, must be constructed before the im-
proved channel will be of the necessary depth. An estimate for this
jetty was included in the annual report of the officer in charge for June
30, 1886 (Annual Report Chief of Engineers, 1886, page 2001). This
300            REPORT            OF THE CHIEF OF Ey{GINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

amount has been added to that heretofore reported as required for the
completion of the existing project.
  An examination of the bar was made June 9, 1888, when the channel
was found to have a depth of 11 feet at low water, and .to be straight
out on a line a little to the north of, but parallel to, the jetty.
   The part of the jetty already constructed needs raising and strength-
ening. An extension shoreward of 600 feet or more will be needed to
close the breach in the jetty tramway recently started and-now widen-
ing at the shore end of the jetty.
July 1, 1887, amount available ........ ......... ..... . .. ..-..........                                             $42, 476. 84
Amount refunded on account of errors in freight charges ................
                                                                  -                                                           0.55

                                                                                                                        42, 497. 39
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 .........                              .           ....-------.. $41, 674.98
                                         _..................
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ......                                                           :     155. 50
                                                                                                                        41, 830. 48

July 1, 1888, balance available---..-----....--. ......-------------......----......--------....---......     .....         666. 91
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ..........................                                               150, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                              150, 666.91
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- ......    318, 970. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 319, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliianco with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    (See Appendix R R 4.)
  5. Tillamook Bay and Bar, Oregon.-This is a new work. To comply
with the requirements of the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, a
I)reliminary examination and survey were made of Tillamook Bay and
Bar, and the report thereon was transmitted to Congress February 25,
1888, and printed as House Ex. Doc. No. 185, Fiftieth Congress, first
session.
  The proposed improvement contemplates dredging, removal of snags,
and closing with dams two small outlets, at an estimated cost of
$5,192.19.
  The river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, appropriates $5,200 for
the work.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188-                                     ......-----...... ....--....
                                                                                                        ----   ....     $5,200.00

EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS FOR IMPROVEMENT TO COMPLY WITH RE-
  QUIREMENTS OF THE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT OF AUGUST 5, 1886.

  It appearing, after preliminary examination by the local engineer, that
the localities were worthy of improvement, Captain Powell was charged
with and completed the survey of Tillamookl Bay and Bar, Oregon, the
results of which were transmitted to Congress and printed as House
Ex. Doc. No. 185, Fiftieth Congress, first session.
  (See also Appendix R R 5.)
IMPROVEMENT OF THE MOUTH OF THE COLUMBIA RIVER, OREGON AND
   WASHINGTON TERRITORY-CONSTRUCTION OF CASCADES CANAL,
   COLUMBIA RIVER--IMPROVEMENT OF THE CHIEHALIS RIVER; OF                                                                             ,
   THE SKAGIT, STEILAQUAMISH, NOOTSACK, SNOHOMISH, AND SNO-
   QUALMIE RIVERS, WASHINGTON TERRITORY-WATER-GAUGES ON
      COLUMBIA RIVER.
Officers in charge, Capt. Chas. F. Powell, Corps of Engineers, until
April, 1888, since which date Maj. Thos. H. Handbury, Corps of
                              RIVER AND HARBOR                     IMPROVEMENTS:                                   301

Engineers. Lieut. Edward Burr, Corps of Engineers, has been on duty
under the immediate orders of the officers in charge during the year.
Supervising Engineer, Col. G. H. Mendell, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Mouth of the Columbia River, Oregon and Washington Territory.-
The project under which this work is being carried on was adopted in
1884. It contemplates providing a channel across the Columbia River
Bar having a depth of 30 feet at mean low tide. This is to be accom-
plished by concentrating the water flowing over the bar and increasing
the resultant currents to such a degree as to procure the desired depth.
   Of late years the main-bar channel has varied from 19 to 21 feet in
depth at low water, with insufficient width; 26 feet are required in a
wide, direct, and stable channel, and 30 feet are desirable for the deep
vessels needed by the Columbia River trade on account of heavy seas
in the locality.
   The work which is now in progress is the building of a low tide jetty
from Point Adams, on the South Cape. and extending in a westerly di-
rection, with a slight curve to the south, out across Clatsop Spit. The
project calls for this to extend 4A miles or less as circumstances may
require, to a point about 3 miles south of Cape Hannock. The material
is principally stone, placed in position from a tramway resting on piles
driven along the line of the jetty.
   The jetty is now under construction for a little more than one-half a
mile; over much of this distance only a thin layer of stone has yet been
placed. The work is not sufficiently advanced to show any appreciable
effect upon the channel over the bar.
   The amount appropriated for this work is $287,500, of which there has
been expended to June 30, 1888, $247,331.75.
July 1, 18b7, amount available ......------------.....--..---..-.......-----....--------- ---- $153, 959. 31
From sale of powder to appropriation improving Chehalis River, Wash-
  ington Territory .........---------.....-------....--..----.........-------.----.........---..----.. ..---------. 78. 00
                                                                                                             154, 037. 31
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1867.......... ........ $102, 791.06
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ......................----- 11, 000. 00
                                                                                                             11:, 791. 06
                               ......--------....--....-----.......------....---......------....-.... -40,
July 1, 1888, balance available-----                                                                              246.25
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 -......................                                        500, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.........--..---                                 ..     540, 246.25

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... 2,923, 000.00
I Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
     1890-----
        ............--......--..................-----                            -------....-....------
                                                                      ..........---------..---------       1, 000, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
l harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix S S 1.)
  2. Construction of canal at the Cascades, Columbia River, Oregon.-The
general scope of the improvement which it is desired to effect at the
Cascades of the Columbia. River includes a reach of about 4, miles.
The principal obstruction to navigation occurs at the upper end of this
reach, at what is known as the Upper Cascades.
  The project contemplates that the river should be improved below
the Upper Cascades by removing bowlders and projecting points in the
bed and banks, so as to give good navigable water from its lowest up
to a 20-foot stage. The fall at the Upper Cascades is to be overcome
by digging a canal about 3,000 feet in length across the neck of a low
projecting spur, and placing in this a lock and suitable other structures
302         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

which will permit of the passage of boats up to a 20-foot stage of water
in the river. This lock to be so arranged that additional structures
may be made which will permit navigation at higher stages. So far as
is contemplated for the present the first part of the project is completed.
   Up to the present time there have been excavated from the line of the
canal in the neighborhood of 250,000 cubic yards of material of various
kinds, 'such as bowlders, gravel, sand, and bed-rock conglomerate. To
complete this with its lock structures and guard-gates, it is estimated
that about 400,000 cubic yards of material of the same general, char-
acter are yet to be moved.
   About 40,000 cubic yards of dry stone wall and slope paving have
been laid on the sides of the upper and lower entrances to the lock. A
considerable quantity of concrete and rubble work has been done which
was necessary to keep out water during process of construction. About
2,600 cubic yards of stone have been cut and prepared for use in the
further construction of the entrance-walls.
   The principal operations during the year were the excavation of about
22,645 cubic yards of material, making concrete and rubble masonry,
cutting stone for side-walls and caisson masonry, and paving side-walls.
   The amount appropriated for this work is $1,442,500, of which $1,140,-
451,06, has been expended.
July 1, 1887, amount available--...----------............... .-----------................--.$79,827.38
From sale of condemned property ..---.....       ..........--..
                                                            -----.....-----.....--. --           10. 00

                                                                                                               79. 837. 38
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.... ...... ....... ...    ...   .... ...... ..                                      77, 788. 44

July 1, 1888, balance available --...----....... ......................                                         2,048.94
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .......................                                         300, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending Juneo 30, 1889......                            ..........            302, 048.94

(Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project                                      ....   1, 550, 000.00
jAmount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
S30, 1890------......------.......................---------------------.. ...... -----....---......-------......
                                                                                                             500, 000. 00
I Submitted        in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river
 .    and harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix S S 2.)
   3. (tehalis River, Washington Territory.-The project for the improve-
ment of this river consists in removing logs, snags, and other obstruc-
tions from its bed and banks, so as to provide a navigable channel-way
during its medium and higher stages from Claquato, a small stream near
its headwaters, to Gray's Harbor, into which it empties. This distance
is between 80 and 100 miles.
   Montesano, 12 miles from its mouth, is the head of coasting naviga-
tion. Eighteen feet at high tide can be carried to this point. The head
of tide is at Elma, 16 miles above Montesano. Between these points
navigation is obstructed by snags and fallen trees. By removing these
a good all-the-year-round channel can be provided from Elma to the
mouth. Above Elma the river, during summer and fall, is practically
blockaded by snags, rafts, and shoals. These latter, in many cases, are
reported to have but from 6 to 12 inches of water on them.
   During the year 353 snags and 129 overhanging trees were removed.
Eighteen thousand dollars has been appropriated for this work of which
$7,960.83 has been expended.
                        RIVER       AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS                                                                      303
July 1, 1887, amount available .........................................                                                    $1,269.94
Received from sale of fuze and caps to appropriation, improving Skagit
  and other rivers, Washington Territory .......................--...---.                                                        15.54
                                                                                                                             1, 285.48
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887-.- .... .                 -......
                                                                    ...........                               $1,244.97
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities..........---- ----------
                                                          ......                                                   1.34
                                                                                                                             1, 246. 31
July 1, 1888, balance available             ..----..............--..--.......                        ......      ....           39. 17
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888............-----------------------.........                                   2,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889                                     ......   ......        .. - ...    2, 039. 17

SAmount that canbe profitably expended infiscal year ending June 30,1890                                                    3, 0u0. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix S S 3.)
   4. Skagit, Steilaquamish, Nootsack, Snohomish, and Snoqualnmie rivers,
Washington Territory.-The project for the improvement of these rivers
contemplates the removal of logs, snags, trees, and other obstructions
to their navigation. There is provided for this purpose a snag-boat
partially complete with an outfit of tools and appliances, which passes
from one river to the other doing services in each as far as the necessi-
ties of the commerce require and the amounts appropriated will admit.
The aggregate navigable length of the rivers is about 250 miles.
   During the year 708 snags were removed from the Snohomish and
Snoqualmie rivers.
   Fifty-seven thousand five hundred dollars has thus far been appro-
priated for these rivers, of which $42,398.67 has been expended up to
July 1, 1888.
July 1, 1887, amount available .....--- -- --..---...... ........................    $3, 829. 54
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887......................... $3, 727.39
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities..................--- ------------....--     82
                                                                                                                             3, 728.21

July 1, 1888, balance available .            --........................................                                        101.33
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...----------..---....--.....-----......---..                                  15, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889....                                                                   1..............
                                                                                                                              101. 33


  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix S S 4.)
   5. Gauging waters of Columbia River.-The object of these gaugings
is to keep a record of the fluctuations of the Columbia River which will
be used in connection with its improvement at various points. By the
gauges established at various points, the pilots, captains, and those
interested in navigation are enabled to ascertain the stage of water at
all times on the crossings and places of difficult navigation, and to reg-
ulate the movement and draught of their vessels accordingly. An
automatic self-registering gauge at Astoria has been found to be useful
in indicating, in a general way, the condition of the bar at the mouth
of the river, besides giving much data from which the tide tables are
constructed.
   To maintain these constantly a yearly appropriation of $2,000 will be
necessary.
304        REPORT OF             THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1887, amount available......-----......     ...........--..--       -----......---......           $45.20
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.....--............--   ..--......            ......      ......----....           45.20

Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .-.....-..-....                     ........-          .   2, 500. 00

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                             2, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix S S 5.)

EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO COMPLY WITH
  REQUIREMENTS OF TIIE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT OF AUGUST 5,
   1886.

  The required preliminary examinations of the following localities
were made by the local engineer in charge, Captain Powell, and reported
by him as not worthy of improvement:
  1. Wood River, Oregon.-(See Appendix S S 6.)
  2. Link River, Oregon.-(See Appendix S S 7.)
  The results of the above were transmitted to Congress and printed
in House Ex. Doc. No. 58, Fiftieth Congress, first session.

IMPROVEMENT OF COLUMBIA AND WILLAMETTE RIVERS BELOW PORT-
  LAND, OREGON; OF UPPER WILLAMETTE, UPPER COLUMBIA AND
  SNAKE, AND COWLITZ RIVERS, OREGON AND WASHINGTON TERRI-
  TORY.

   Officer in charge, Maj. W. A. Jones, Corps of Engineers ; Supervising
Engineer, Col. G. H. Mendell, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Columbia and Lower Willamette rivers, below Portland, Oregon.-The
project for this improvement was adopted in 1877, and modified subse-
quently, the object being to afford a ship-channel of 20 feet depth at
low water by contraction and shore protection works at four bars be-
tween Portland and Columbia City, Oregon, by temporary improvement
at the bars during construction of the works, by temporary improve-
ment at three shoal places below Columbia City, and by snagging opera-
tions.
   The natural depth of the channel at the shoalest places was about 9
feet, and on six other bars it was from 10 to 15, feet at low water.
   The amount expended on the project to June 30, 1888, was $44.7,040.98,
and has resulted in maintaining a channel depth of successively 17, 18,
and 19 feet at low water from Astoria over the whole reach of 100
miles.
   Operations during the year have been practically suspended. A
snag-boat has been constructed at a cost of $19,560. Minor surveys
have been made with a view to watch the development of the dike
channel at St. Helen's Bar. A channel was dredged across this bar
early in October, 1887, at the expense of the Board of Trade of the city
of Portland, Oregon; cost, $3,500.
   An examination into the subject of the salmon fisheries of the Colum-
bia and their relation to navigation was made under a resolution of
Congress, and report submitted under date of December 21, 1887.
   Sixty cubic yards of dangerous rock were removed from the Ross
Island Channel in Portland Harbor.
  Generally, the river constructions, floating property, and plant have
been watched and cared for, but at considerable expense.
                          RIVER AND             HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                             305
July 1, 187, amout available ..--....- ......-...........-.................      $24, (604.05
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
   liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887--..-__...-  ......... ..... $15, 576.79
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..- - - -      -.----              127. 67
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts --...-........     7,185.00
                                                                                  22, 889.46

                                        ---- ... ..
July 1, 1888, balance available ............          ..... .... ....                                   ......            1, 714. 59
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 - ---..--...... - -... - ..-                              ---
                                                                                                        ......          100, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.....---..                                     ........            101,714.59

  Amount (estimated) required fo' completion of existing project and
                  ----.------------
     maintenance ...                                       ---..--..                    -------..                       325, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 200, 000. 00
SSubmitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  (See Appendix TT 1.)
   2. Of Upper Willamette River, Oregon.---The project for this improve-
ment was adopted iin 1870, moditied in 1878, and extended in later years.
The object is to afford and maintain an easy, light-draught navigation
from Portland to Eugene City, Oregon, and in 12 miles of tributaries,
making in all a distance of 184 miles. The work consists in snagging
operations, bar-scraping, and for the reach between Willamette Falls
and Corvallis, in the contraction of water-way by low cut off dams and
rock removal. The natural channel from Portland to Willamette Falls,
12 miles, was generally deep and wide, above it is narrow, tortuous,
and much obstructed. The mouth of the Yamhill, 28 miles from the
Falls, was the head of an inconvenient low-water navigation in a draught
of 2 feet. Only 1 foot could be carried above.
   Present project was adopted in 1878.
   Total appropriation to date is $84,000.
   Amount expended $83,996.77, of which about $25,000 has been applied
to maintenance.
   No work has been done during the year.
                                                                                                          $2, 910. 73
July 1, 1887, amount available ....------ ------....---..--------..... ---......--..-.............----------
July 1, 1888, amount expended (luring fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887. .-..           .................. $2, 563. 36
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities...--- ...... ................                        344. 14
                                                                                                                              2, 907.50


July 1, 1888, balance available ..........---...--.                    ........----........                    --......--..       3. 23
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 -                           ..........          ....-........               29, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889... --....-..........                                                29, 003. 23
  (See Appendix T T 2.)
  3. Upper Columbia and Snake rivers, Oregon and Washington Terri-
tory.-The plan for this improvement, adopted in 1877, consists in rock
removal at a number of very swift rapids to give channel depths at low
water of 5. feet upon the Columbia and 4 feet upon the Snake; a river
length of 266 miles between Celilo, on the Columbia, and Lewiston, on
the Snake. The natural channel was narrow, tortuous, and dangerous,
with many very difficult rapids.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1888, is $126,000, and has resulted
in improvement of fifteen different localities.
   No work has been done during the year.
           ENG 88---- 20
306        REPORi      OF   THE     CHIEF OF       ENGINEERS,        U. S. ARMY

Anioiin    app:opriated by act of August 11,188 .----- ....------         ...-------. $10,
                                                                      ....---                00 00

     \Amount (estimated) required for completion of existin(g project.......16,000.00
J Amonut    that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30,1890 16, 000.00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
       harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix T T 3.)
  4. Lower Clear Water River, Idaho -The present project, adopted in
1878, is to make a channel through rock-reefs and cobble-stone bars
from Lewiston, at t he mouth of the river, to North Fork, a distance of
40 miles. to secure a low-water draught of 4 feet.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1888, is $15,000, and has resulted
in improvement, more or less compete, over the lower reach of 30 niles.
     Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....... $19, 424. 00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 ot river and
       harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix T T 4.)
   4. Cowlitz River, Washington Territory.--The project for this improve
ment, adopted in 1860, consists in wing dam construction, bar-scraping,
and snagging operations to secure a light draught navigation up to
Toledo, a lit t le more than 30 miles above the mouth.
   The original estimate for this work was $3,000 for construction in the
first year and an annual expenditure thereafter of $2,000 for mainte-
nance by snagging operations.
   The total appropriation to date is $8,000. The amount expended to
date is $8,000.
   No work was done during the year.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.3.......... ........ ......              $3,000. 00

f   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.... Indeterminato
     Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending Juno 30, 1890 6, 000. 00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
       harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
     (See Appendix T T 5.)

EXAMINATIONS, SURVEYS, AND CONTINGENCIES                            OF RIVERS AND IIAR-
                            BORS.

  For examinations and su,'veys for improvement, and for contingencies
and for incidental repairs of harbors for which there is no special ap-
propriation, an appropriation of $175,000 should be made, of which sum
$75,000 for surveys and $ 100.000 for contingencies, including incidental
repairs of harbors.

                 MISSISSIPPI             RIVER        COMMISSION.

   This Commission, organized under the provisions of the act of Cou-
gress of June 28, 1879. reports to an(l receives instructions fronm the
Secretary of War through this office.
   The Secretary of War transmitted to the House of Representatives,
January 3, 1 88, a report from the Commission showing the progress of
its operations from July 1 to November 1, 1887. This report was printed
as House Ex. Doc. No. 55, part 1, Fiftieth Congress, first session. (See
also Appendix U U 1.)
      The report of the Commission fbr the fiscal year ending June 30, 1 88.
embracing the following subijects viz. (1) Surveys and exaninations
                             BRIDGI G NAVIGABLE WATERS.                                        307
(2) Construction ; (3 Financial statement, and (4) Estimates, will be
found in Appendix U U 2.
   T'le estimate of funds requiredl for the service of the Commission for
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, is stated in the above report, as
follows:

ESTIMATE       OF FUNDS FOr)ITIE       MISISSSIPPI RIVER COMMISSION           FOR THE FISCAL YEAR
                                       ENDING    JUNE    ;ii), 18390.


                                           Sundry civil bill.

Mississippi River Comia ission.-For salaries, inspections, and traveling ex-
     penses of the Mississippi River Commission;                 for printing and tele-
     graphing; for office expenses and miscellaneous .-....................                 $35, 000

                                        River and harbor bill.

For surveys and examinations of the Mississippi River from the head of
     the Passes to its headwaters; continuing survey ......................                 150, 000
For improving the Mississippi River from the head of the Passes to the
  mouth of the Ohio River .................. ............................ 4, 000, 000
For work at-
    Columbus, Ky., continuing improvement ..-..            ................ ......           25,000
    Hicknan. Ky., continuing improvement.------... .... .... .... ........        .....     181, 750
    Greenvle Mis. continuing improvement...........................                         230, 000
    Vicksburg. Miss., continuing improvement........................                        125, 000
    New Orleans, La., continuing improvement .-....--..--.........-......                   230, 000
For rectification of Red and Atchafalaya rivers ...........................                 300,000

                         MISSOURI RIVER COMMISSION.

   'hibs Commission, organized under the provisions of the act of July 5,
188.1, reports to and receives instructions from the Secretary of War
through this office.
   The report of the Commission describing the operations in its charge
for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, will be found in Appendix V V
of this report.
   The estimate of funds required for the service of the Commission for
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, is stated in the above report, as
follows :

1.    For the improvement of Missouri River from its mouth to Sioux City.- $1, 000, 000
2.    For surveys and examinations ................       ............ .......... 120, 000
3.    For office and traveling expenses and salaries of Commissioners .......      30, 000
4.    Re-appropriation for general survey of Missouri River of the item of
     $15,000, appropriated in the act of July 5, 1884, for survey of river above
     the falls .-----------.----------.-----------------------------               15, 000
              ......---------------------------------------.----------..............
         Total----                                                                        1,16(;5,000

           BRIDGING NAVIGABLE               WATERS OF THE UNITED STATES.

   1. Report of the Board of Engineers relative to the construction of cer-
tain bridges across the Missouri, Mississippi, and Illinois rivers.-Senate
bill 275, authorizing the construction of bridges in certain parts of the
above-mentioned rivers, having been referred to this office by the Com-
mittee on Commerce of the Senate for examination, a Board of Engineer
Officers was constituted by order of the Secretary of War to report upon
its Iprovisions.
   The report was transmitted to the Senate by the War Department
March 7, 1888, and printed as Senate Ex. Doc. 120, Fiftieth Congress,
first, session.
308     REPORT    OF   THE   CHIEF OF     ENGINEERS, U. S ARMY.

  The Board, after giving the subject full and careful consideration,
prepared in detail a bill to meet the requirements of navigation and
commerce and at the same time todo justice to the bridge interests.
  (See Appendix W W 1.)
  2. Bridge across Staten Island Sound known as Arthur Kill.-To com-
ply with a resolution of the Senate Committee on Commerce of Febru-
ary 9,1888, requesting the Secretary of War to detail a Board of Engi
neers for the examination of the Arthur Kill Bridge, then in process of
construction, especially in reference to its alleged obstruction to naviga-
tion, the Board so detailed completed the duty assigned to it and sub-
mitted two reports thereon April 10, 1888, the members being divided
in opinion regarding the subject.
  These reports, with a letter of transmittal from the Secretary of War,
were transmitted to the Senate May 11, 1888, and printed as Senate Mis.
Doc. 130, Fiftieth Congress first session. (See Appendix W W 2.)
  3. Report of a Board of Engineers on Senate bill No. 1850, Fiftieth Con-
gress,first session, to authorize the construction of a bridge across the waters
of Arthur Kill at or near the town of Westfield, Staten Island.-(See Ap-
pendix W W 3.)
   4. The plans and locations of the following bridges, authorized by law,
have been approved by the Secretary of War:
   a. llighway bridgeacross that part of the waters of Lake Champlain lying
between the towns of North Hero and A lburgh, Vermont, authorized by act
of Congress of June 20, 1884, approved by the Secretary of War Jan-
uary 13, 1887.-( See Appendix W W 4.)
   b. Bridge of the Kansas City, Topeka and Western Railroad Company
across Missouri River, at Sibley, Missouri, authorized by act of Congress
ot July 3, 1884, approved by the Secretary of War April 12, 1887.-(See
Appendix W W 5.)
   c.Bridge of the Chicago, Saint Louis and New Orleans Railroad Com-
pany across the Ohio River at East Cairo, Kentucky, authorized by acts
of Congress of December 17, 1872, and February 14, 1883, authorizing
the construction of bridges across the Ohio River. Approved by the
Secretary of War April 15, 1887.-(See Appendix W W 6.)
   d. Free wagon bridge across the Cumberland River, near the city of
Nashville, Tennessee, authorized by act of Congress of March 3, 1887.
Approved by the Secretary of War May 28, 1887.-(See Appendix W
W 7.)
   e. Bridge of the Ohio River Railroad Company across Great Kanawha
River, near Point'Pleasant,W. Va., authorized by act of Congress of March
3, 1887, for the construction of bridges across the Great Kanawha River
below the Falls. Approved by the Secretary of War, June 14, 1887.-
(See Appendix W W 8.)
  f. Bridgeacrossthewest channel of the Detroit River, to connect Belle isle
Park with the main land, authorized by act Congress of July 20, 1886.
Approved by the Secretary of War June 14, 1887.-(See Appendix W
W 9.)
  g. Internationalbridge of the Sault Sainte Marie Bridge Company across
Sainte Marie River, authorized by act of Congress of July 8, 1882. Ap-
proved by the Secretary of War June 28, 1887.-(See Appendix W W
10.)
  h. Bridge of the Nebraska Railway Company across Missouri River at
Nebraska City, authorized by act of Congress of June 4, 1872. Approved
by the Secretary of War July 5, 1887.-(See Appendix W WV 11.)
                   BRIDGING    NAVIGABLE    WATERS.                  309
   i. Combined railway and wagon bridge of the Omaha and Council Bluffs
Bailway and Bridge Company across Missouri River between Omaha, Ne-
braska, and Council Bluffs, Iowa, authorized by act of Congress of March
3, 187. Approved by the Secretary of War July 19, 1887.-(See Ap-
pendix W W 12.)
  j. Bridge of the New York and Long Island Bridge Company across
the East River between the city of Yew York and Long Island, author-
ized by act' of Congress of March 3, 1887. Approved by the Secretary
of War October 3, 1887.-(See Appendix W W 13.)
   k. Bridge of the Ohio Valley Railway Company across the Tradewater
River, Kentucky, authorized by act of Congress of February 21, 1887.
Approved by the Secretary of War October 25, 18s7.-(See Appendix
W W 14.)
   1. Bridge of the Sioux City Bridge Company across the Missouri River
at Sioux City, Iowa, authorized by act of Congress of August 15, 1876.
Approved by the Secretary of War March 18, 1888.-(See Appendix
W W 15.)
   m. Highway bridge of the Central Railway and Bridge Company of New-
port, Kentucky, across the Ohio River between Cincinnati, Ohio, and New.-
port, Kentucky, authorized by acts of Congress of December 17, 1872,
and February 14, 1883. Approved by the Secretary of War April 18,
1888.--(See Appendix W V 16.)
   n. Bridge of the Georgia Pacific Railroad Company across the Sunflower
and Yazoo rivers, authorized by act of Congress of March 3, 1887. Ap-
proved by the Secretary   of  War April 28, 1888.--(See Appendix W W
17.)
   o. High bridge across the lMissisippi River at Dubuque, Iowa, author-
ized by act of Congress of February 21, 1887. Approved by the Secre-
tary of War April 30, 18S.-(See Appendix VW W 18.)
   p. Bridge of the Ohio Connecting Railway CompaLy across the Ohio
River near the mouth of Cork's_ Irun, in Allegheny County, Pennsylvania,
authorized by act of Congress of May 14,. 1888. Approved by the Sec-
retary of War June 18, 1SS.-(See Appendix W W 19.)
   q. Bridge of the Georgia Pacific Railway Company across the Tombigbee
River at Waverly, Mississippi, authorized by act of Congress of March
3, 1887. (The act of April 2, 1888, changes the name of this company
to railway instead of railroad.) Approved by the Secretary of War
June 19, 1888.-(See Appendix W V     W 20 )
   r. Bridge of the Memphis and Charleston Railroad Company across the
Tennessee River at Chattanooga, Tennessee, authorized by act of Con-
gress of February 28, 1887. Approved by the Secretary of War July
11, 1888.-(See Appendix V W 21.)
   s. Bridge of the Kansas City and Memphis Rail way and Bridge Com-
pany across the Misisspispi River at lem1,phis, Tennessee, authorized by
act of Congress of April 24, 188. Approved by the Secretary of War
August 2:3, 1888.--(See Appendix    WV   W 22.)

REPORTS    RESPECTING   INTERFERENCES  WITH  NAVIGATION                BY
          BRIDGES, CAUSEWAYS, AND OTHER STRUCTURES.

  To comply with the requiremeuts of section 2 of the river and har-
bor act of July 5, 1884, and of section 4 of the river and harbor act of
August 5, 1886, the Secretary of War transmitted to Congress Decein-
ber 18, 1885, February 24, 1887, and December 10, 1887, copies, of re-
ports from officers in charge of river and harbor districts, made under
orders from this office, ef instances where bridges, cause ways, and other
310       REPORT       OF   THE     CHIEF      OF         ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

structui es erected or iniprorces of ee-t ion Io or will interfere with free
and safe iavigantion.
   These reports were priltedi   as Senate Ex. Doe. 12, Forty-ninth (on-
                           LEx. Doc. 105, Forty-ninth Congress, second
gress, first session; Senate
session, ald House Ex. Doe. 12, Fiftieth Congress, first session.
  (See also Appendix W W 23.)

OCCUPANCY OF AND INJURY TO PUBLIC WORKS                                    BY   CORPORATIONS
                     AND INDIVIDUALS.

   To comply with the requirements of section 2 of the river and har-
bor act of July 5, 1884, and section 4 of the river and harbor act of Au-
gust 5, 1886, the Secretary of \ar   transmitted to Congress February
26, 1885, and January 3, 1888, communications Irc)m this office con-
taining reports from officers in charge of river and harbor districts of
instances in which piers, breakwaters, rother works built by the United
States in aid of commerce or navigation are used, occupied, or injured
by corporations or individuals, which reports were printed as House Ex.
Doc. 259, Forty-eighth Congress, second session, an)( House Ex. Doc. 56,
Fiftieth Congress, first session.
   (See also Appendix X X.)

                                 MISCELLANEOUS.

[Public works not provided for in acts making appropriations for the construc ion,
            repair, and preservation of works on rivers and harbors.]

MAINTENANCE AND REPAIRS OF WASHINGTON AQUEDUCT-INCRIEAS-
ING WATER SUPPLY OF THE CITY OF WASHINGTON-ERECTION  )OF
FISH-WAYS AT THE GREAT FALLS OF THE POTOMAC.

   Officer in charge, Maj. G. J. Lydecker, Corps of Engineers, with Lieut..
C. MeD. Townsend, Corps of Engineers, under his immediate orders.
   1. Washington Aqueduct.-The al)propriation of $20,000 has been ap-
plied as usual, to maintaining the aqueduct and its accessory structures
in proper repair, and to regulating the supply of Potomac water to the
cities of Washington and Georgetown.
   In addition to the ordinary minor repairs and routine work consid-
erable progress in extending the macadam roadway overllying and pro-
tecting the aqueduct was made, 4,682 cubic yards of broken stone hav-
ing been applled to this purpose; the old dam across the Maryland
Channel ot the Potomac at the Great Falls was re-enforced by a backing
of about 850 cubic yards of riprap careuiiy placed, an(d a new flooring
of 3 inch Georgia pine was placed on the bridge spanning the waste-
channel at the receiving reservoir.
July 1, 183-7, amount available..........---------....-- -------.............            20, 000. 00
July 1, 1888, amount expended (luring fiscal year .--...        -........  19,021. 94
July 1, 188,   outstanding liabilities .      ..............      ......        97. 00
                                                                                         20, 000. 00
  The sum of $20.000-being the same as that appropria ed annually
for the past tine years-is required for engineering, maintenance, and
repairs of the aqueduct for the year ending June 30, 1890.
  (See APlpeni(Idix Y Y 1.)
2. Increasing the zoater supply of the city of Wa'shin!gton. D)isfrict of
Columbia.-The approve prqject for this work eC:ra:is,,         first. lhe
                    WATER      SUPPLY     OF   WASHINGTON                         311




extension of the dam at the Great Falls of the Potomac across Conn's
Island and the Virginia Channel to the Virginia shore, and the comple-
tion of the whole to an elevation of 148 feet above meani tirh tide at
the navy-yard, this elevation -being about 15 inches above the crest of
the old dam across the Maryland Channel of the river; second, lie
extension of the aqueduct by a tunnel 20,696.3 feet long, from t lihe    ter-
minus of the conduit at Drover's Rest (distributing reservoir) to the site
of the new reservoir near Howard University; third, construction of a
new reservoir at that place capable of holding about 300,000,000 gal-
lons; fourth, making the necessary main connections for taking the
water from the new reservoir into the system of supply mains for the
city.
    Operations during the lpast fiscal year were confined to work on the
tunnel and new -eservoir,the dam having been completed in the summer
of 1886, and the new mains laid to within a few feet of the proposed
effluent gate-house at the new reservoir.
    On the tunnel work was carried on until September 30, 1887, when
the appropriation became exhausted, all work was stopped, and the
tunnel allowed to fill with water. The deficiency act, approved March
      1888, appropriated the sum of $355,000 for completiiig the tunnel,
   0;1,
anl operations were at once resumed, but it was not until the latter
pa  rt of May that work on the tunnel lining was well started. The
length of tunnel lined during the year was 3,95) feet. making, to June
30, 1888, the total length lined 10,069k feet; the lengsth of lining remain-
ing to be done is 10,626.8 feet. The act of apl)propriation requires that
thle work appropriated for shall be completedl by November 1,1888, but
it will be absolutely impossible to comply with this requirement, andt it
accordingly becomes a question whether further legislation by Congress
will not be required to legalize expenditures made from this appropria-
tion after the specified date.
     )n the reservoir the work under contract was completed by the end
ol October, 1887, the principal items of work accoml)ished during the
year being about 45,000 cubic yards of excavation, and 7.500 square yards
of slope paving. The construction of the combined influent and effluent
gate house, and the completion of the reservoir slopes in its vicinity,
remains to be done before water can be let into the reservoir, but this
can iot be undertaken until the tunnel contractors finish operations at
the inlet shaft and remove their plant from that point; this will prob-
ably be accomplished by the middle of August, 1888.
July 1, 1887, amount unexpended on all items of appropriations ........ $493, 802. '24
Amount appropriated by act of March 30, 1888..    --.....- ........ 35,000. 00
                                                 .....-

                                                                            848, 802. 24
July 1, 1388, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of outstanding liabilities...... _..... .... ......-. ....$298, 607.59
July 1,1888, outstanding liabilities........................  43, 908. 08
                                                             283,522.50
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts ..--.......
                                                                                038. 17
                                                                            3626,

Juoly 1, 1888, balance available (less $611.24 disbursed directly from the
  United States Treasury Department for advertising) ................-------222, 764.07
                                                                           2.


   At this writing it is believed that the above will suffice for the com-
pletion of the work in all its essential )parts,and therefore no estimate
is iow submitted for any additional appropriation ; it will ultimately
be necessary to provide undss for properly finishing the grounds about
the new reservoir, and for surface work at the several tunnel shafts, but
the requisite ;a ounmt c:a.not !bedeterimined acenrately at present and
312         REPORT          OF     THE       CHIEF        OF ENGINEERS,                 U. s. Aiia.

the matter will be made the subject of a special communication at some
later date.
   (See Appendix Y Y 2.)
   3. Erection of fish-ways at Great Falls of the Potomac.-No work has
been done on the fish-ways during the past fiscal year, there being no
sufficient appropriation for doing any useful work. The deficiency act
approved February 1, 1888, appropriated $23,000 for their completion,
but it has not yet been settled whether this appropriation is to be dis
bursed under the directions of the War Departmeuit or directly in the
office of the United States Commissioner of Fish and Fisheries.
   The original appropriation for the work was $50,000, of which there
had been expended prior to June 30, 1888, the sum of $44,365.18, leav-
ing $5,634.82 as the balance then available.
   The money statement for the year ending June 30, 1888, is as follows:
July 1,188, amount available ...... ..................................--------------------------------------.. $5,634. 82
Amount appropriated by act of February 1, 1888............-------......--.. '25, 000. 00
                                                                                                           30, 634. 82
July 1,1888, outstanding liabilities for surveys in May and June- 1888....                                     435. 50
July 1,1888, balance available..........----------------.....--------..----.........--......               30,199.32
   No estimate for further appropriation is submitted.
   (See Appendix Y Y 3.)
IMPROVEMENT AND CARE OF PUBLIC BUILDINGS                                                AND       GROUNDS            IN
                THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA.

   Officer in charge, Lieut. Col. John M. Wilson, Corps of Engineers,
colonel, U. S.
             S.Army.
   1. Improvement and care of public buildings and grounds in the District
of Columbia.-At the Executive Mansion the outside of the conservatory
and a portion of the outside of the main building were repainted and a
numnber of rooms and halls repainted and calcimined.
   The tile floor of the main vestibule was repaired and the fresco work
on ceiling and side walls cleaned and restored.
   New carpets were placed in the green and blue parlors, and the furni-
ture in the blue parlor, a portion of that in the east room, the green
p)arlor, the southwest bed-room, and the upper corridor, which had ihe
come worn and shabby, was repaired ; new matting was placed in trie
blue parlor and linoleum on the floors of the kitchen and pantry ; a tlew
articles of furniture were purchased and such curtains as were no long;er
fit for use were replaced with others; a storage closet was constructed(
in the attic; the ceiling over the south balcony, which was in a danger-
ous condition, was taken down and renewed.
   The sul)erstructure of one green-house, which was in poor e(:ditio ,.
was renewed and various repairs were muade to all the other green
houses. The entire sewerage of the Mansion was overhauled, and t he
chandeliers in the parlors and state dining-room were ,epired and and re-
stored, as far as possible, to their original condition.
   Extensive repairs were made to the green-houses at the nurseries aind
a new cold frame pit, 200 feet long, was constructed.
    In addition to the general work performed for maintaining in gooad
condition the improved public reservations, three heretofore partially
improved have been highly imlprove(d; and of three heretofore unima-
troved, one has been highly and two p)artially improved.
    The high iron fences have been removed fromn all the smaller trian-
                   PUBLIC BUILDINGS          AND    GROUNDS.                      313
gular reservations, except one at the northwest corner of Pennsylvania
avenue and Twentieth street, where the fence was allowed to remain
for the present at the request of citizens living in the vicinity.
   Extensive improvements were made at the grounds around new
Pension Building and at the Smithsonian grounds. At the latter, 2,983
square yards of asphalt pavement was constructed on the main road
between Seventh and Twelfth streets.
   Asphalt walks were constructed leading to and around the Garfield
statue.
   A large amount of work was done at Reservation Number Seventeen.
New roads were laid out and constructed, lawns graded and seeded, and
a number of trees and shrubs planted.
   Water was introduced into three reservations, the supply at the
green-houses largely increased, and improvements made at the spring
supplying the Capitol.
   Attention is invited to the detailed report of the officer in charge and
to his estimates and recommendations for the fiscal year ending June
30, 1890.
   His estimates are as follows:
For improvement and care of public grounds ....--...    ....   ........... $133, 788. 50
For compensation of persons employed on public buildings and grounds..       51, 100. 00
For replacing the overhead system of telegraph wires with duplicate six-
  conductor underground cable, and for care and repair of existing lines-    10, 000. 00
For contingent and incidental expenses of public buildings and grounds .         500 00

                                                                             195,388.50
   (See Appendix Z Z 1.)
   2. rUnderground Telegraph and Telephone Wires.-A resolution of the
Senate of March 26, 1888, having directed the Superintendent of Public
Buildings and Grounds to report to that body a comprehensive system
of underground wires for telegraph and telephone service to connect
the several Departments and Bureaus of the Government in Washing
ton, a report from Col. John M. Wilson, in charge of public buildings
and grounds, giv i    n detail the routes for, and extent of, such a sys-
tern as would embrace all the required points, together with an estimate
of its cost, was submitted, through this office, and printed as Senate Ex.
Doc. No. 153, Fiftieth Congress, first session.
   (See Appendix Z Z 2.)
   3. Washington Monument.- By direction of the President, as con-
tained in Special Orders No. 76, Headquarters of the Army, Adjutant
General's Office, April 3, 1888, Col. Jolhn MI. Wilson, U.    Army, Lieu-
tenant-colonel of Engineers, reported on the 4th of April, 1888, to the
Joint Commission for the constriuctioi of the Washington Monument
created by the act of Congress approved August 2, 1876, as the engineer
in charge of the construction of the Monument,, vice Col. Thos. Lincoln
Casey, Corps of Engineers, relieved at his own request. By act (o
Congress, approved October 2, 1888, known as the sundry civil bill,
the Joint Commission above referred to was dissolved at its own r,
quest, and the Secretary of War was charged with the custody, care,
and protection of the Monunent, and on October 6, 1888, the Secreta v
of War placedl under the supervision of the Chief of Engineers the
general charge of the same.
   The last report made by Colonel Casey to the Joint Commission was
dated December 1, 1887, and was submitted to Congress on December
17, 1887.
   Since December 1, 1887, about 120,000 cubic yards of earth has been
deposited in position, under contract, in constructin.2 an earthen em-
314         REPORT          OF    THE      CHIEF        OF       ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

bankment around the Monument, making in all about 205,000 cubic
yards deposited under the contract. The embankment when completed
will contain about 267,412 cubic yards. The steam machinery and the
electric-light plant have t een put in running order, and the elevator
and machinery connected therewith will be started at an early day.
    The construction of a marble lodge-house, to be erected at the ex-
pense of the Washington Monument Society at a cost of $10,720, was
commenced, under contract, early in April upon a site about 40 feet from
the Monument, but its location having been subsequently changed, by
direction of the Monument Commission, to a point about 4S0 feet east of
the Monument, at an additional expense of $930, which was allowed the
cont, actors by the Commission, work was suspended in May, but was
resumed early in June at the new site, and has been continued in a sat-
isfactory manner. At the close of September, 1888, the walls of the
building were nearly completed.
    During the present fiscal year it is proposed to continue the inmprove-
*ment of the grounds, to complete the new lodge, to insert in the walls of
the Monument the memorial stones on hand, and to maintain in good
order the machinery connected with the elevator and the electric lights.
    Attention is invited to the detailed report of the officer in charge,
and to his estimates for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
    His estimates are as follows:
For salaries of employ6s .. _.............                   ......      ....................                  $8, 160. 00
For fuel, light, contingencies, etc ........................................                                     2, 340. 00
                                                                                                                10, 500. 00

Balance on hand December 1, 1887 ........................             ...........                              74, 927. (6
Amount appropriated by act of October 2, 1888 ........................                                         27, 500. 00
                                                                                                               10-2, 427. 61
Amount expended up to September 30, 188 ................                                        $44, 853. 02
Amount covered by existing contracts .........           .........                               30, 074.59
                                                                                                                74, 927. 61

Amount available October 2, 1888 .....................................                            ........     27,500. 00.
    (See Appendix ZZ 3.)

                                                                                                                              .
CONSTRUCTION                        AND IMPROVEMENT                                             OF ROADS AND
      BRIDGES IN                 THE YELLOWSTONE                               NATIONAL PARK.

   The beginning of systematic construction of roads and bridges 'ol-
lowed an appropriation of $10,000 made by act of Congress approved
March 3, 1883, the portion of the appropriation allotted to construction
work   to be expended under the supervision and direction of an engineer
officer to be detailed by the Secretary of War. The construction of
roads and bridges has remained, since 18S3, under the supervision of tlhe
Engineer Department. '
   The condition of the roads and bridges in the Park prior to the adop-
tion in 1883 of a systematic project, which project, with such extensions
as subsequent experience called for, constitutes the present one, was
as bad as could be. The roads, few in number and short in extent,were
mere wagon trails; the grades were frequently excessive, and the roads                                                            ,
full of stumps, rocks, 'boggy places, and dangerous side-hill slants.
The few bridges were of weak and cheap construction, and the crossings
of the streams generally had to be made at fords, which, at time of
high water, were imluassable.
                              YELLO\WSTONE                   NATI       NAL      PARK.                                  :   15




   The project for this improvement consists in repairing old trails, and
in the construction of substantial roads about 18 feet in width, well
crowned, ditched, and drained, with easy grades and, where necessary,
covered with gravel or broken rock; also, the building of good bridges
over the streams; the permanent roads to cover a circuit of about 145
miles, extending from the Park line at Gardiner, Mont., to the Mamuimoth
Hot Springs, thence to Norris Geyser Basin, thence to Upper Geyser
Basin, thence to Yellowstone Lake via Shoshone Lake, across the
great continental divide of the Rocky Mountains, thence along the Yel-
lowstoneLake and Yellowstone River, via the Falls and the Grand Cation
to Yancy's, thence to the Mammoth Hot Springs. In addition, a cross-
road from the west line of the Park to the Firehole Basin, a road from
Yancy's to the east line of the Park, and a number of short branch roads
and trails from the intersection of the above-named roads to minor ob-
jects of interest off the main lines of travel; in all, about 225 miles of
new road, about twenty large and fifty small bridges, and many cul-
verts are contemplated in the project.
   The cost of completion of the project was estimated in the last Annual
Report as $250,000 Deducting from this the appropriation made by act
approved March 3, 1887, the cost of completion reduces to $230,000.
   Total expended upon the project to the close of the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1888, $109,779.42.
   The work performed under this project may be briefly stated as fol-
lows:
Miles of   new road built .... .... ......     ......  ......     ....................                       ....           58
Miles of   old roads (original wagon trails) repaired ..........................                                    .       90
Miles of   new roads repaired, about ----------.........------...           -......... -         .. -...... ....    .       45
Number     of large bridges built---- ......--........ _........_ _           ....       ......-- ......          .          6
Number     of small bridges built.............        .........               .........        ..... ... .....              13
and many culverts.
  Some ofr the new work                        was
                                     through heavy rock cutting. The sum
of $130,000 asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, is to be ex-
pended towards completing the circuit of main road from the Mammoth
Hot Springs via Upper Geyser Basin, Shoshone and Yellowstone l:kes,
the Falls and Yancy's, about 145 miles, of which 58. miles Iav'-e been
completed; in improving and completing roads already built or com-
menced; in repairing old trails where absolutely necessary ; in l)ur(!las-
ing a portable saw-mill and rock crusher; and in build ng a warehouse
for tools and supplies, a small office, a stable, and a house thr the over-
seer in summer and the watchma n in winter.
   Owing to the late date at which appl)opriations are frequently nmale
by Congress, the season when expenditures can be made to the best ad-
vantage is lost for the fiscal year; for that reason, in order that the
work may be done at the most favorable time, it is earnestly recom-
mended that future appropriations for this object be made without
limit, as in the case of each of the items of river and harbor acts.
Amoundt' appropriated by act of March 3, 1887 ----...--.. --.....
                                                             ............ 20, 0('0. 00
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887--.-..............
                                                ---...           ...----.                    $1--9,76.84
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities............ ..     ....-....                                 283. 16
                                                                                                          --   20, 0(0. 00

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......     '230, 000.00
 ) Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1e90 130, 000. 00
   Submniitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
I. harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   (See Appendix A A A.)
316       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

ANNUAL WATER-LEVELS OF THE NORTHERN AND NORTH
               WESTERN LAKES.

  A table showing the monthly means of water-levels from June 30, 1887,
to June 30, 1888, at Charlotte, Erie, Cleveland, Milwaukee, Escanaba,
Sand Beach, Marquette, and Sault Ste. Marie, being a continuation of
that published in the last annual report, and also tables and diagrams
showing yearly means of water-levels from 1860 to 1887, will be found in
Appendix B B B 1.

PRINTING AND DISTRIBUTION                           OF CHARTS OF THE               NORTH-
                   ERN AND NOR TH WESTERN LAKES.

   Under the supervision of this office additions have been made to each
of the following engraved chart plates:
       North end of Lake Michigan;
       Straits of Mackinac;
       Beaver Island Group.
  During the year 8,897 charts were issued under the supervision of
Lieut. Col. O. M. Poe, Corps of Engineers, 1,527 of which were sold at
30 cents each, and the amount, $458.10, turned into the Treasury.
  Owing to changes in channels, the discovery of previously unknown
dangers, and the extension of works of river and harbor improvement,
many of the charts require additions and corrections in order to render
them of the greatest service. In some cases limited surveys will be re-
quired to obtain the requisite data.     Considering the extensive use
made of the charts and their recognized value to the lake marine, it is
recommended that the sum of' .$10,0t)) ibe annually appropriated for the
purpose of making the necessary surveys and for correcting the en-
graved plates, in addition to the amount app)ropriated for electrotyping
the plates and for chart printing. The recommendations of last year
are repeated in this respect.
Amount appropriated by act of March 3, 1887....          .-.-..-.....               $2, 000. 00
June 30, 1888, amount expended during the fiscal year...................             1, 797.32

Amoint required for survey of the northern and northwestern
lakes for the fiscal year ending June :30, 1890, namely, fbr
su rveys, additions to and correcting engraved plates........ $10, 000. 00
For plrinting and issuing charts for use of navigators, and elec-
trotyping plates for chart printing........... . .......      .. 3, 000.00
                                                                      ---   13, 000.00
   (See Appendix B B B 2.)

                MILITARY           AND       GEOGRAPHICAL                  MAPS.

  A new edition of the map of the Department of the Columbia has
been photo-lithographed and distributed.

         RECONNAISSANCES                         AND       EXPLORATIONS.
  The following officers of the Corps of Engineers have been on duty
at the headquarters of the military divisions and departments, engaged
in preparing such maps and making such surveys as were required by
their respective commanding officers:
   Maj. Thomas H. Handbury, at headquarters Division of the Missouri,
to April 5, 188; since which date Capt. William L. Marshall.
  Lieut. Tlhomnas L. Casey, at headquarters Division of the Pacific and
Departnment of California, to September 19, 1887.
                RECt)NNAISSANCES      AND   EXPLORATIONS.              317
   Lieut. John Biddle, at headquarters Department of Dakota, to De-
cember 15, 1887.
   Lieut. William C. Langfitt, at headquarters Department of the Co-
lumbia.
   Lieut. Hiram M. Chittenden, at headquarters Department of the
Platte, from July 16, 1887.
   Also, Lieut. James E. Runcie. First U. S. Artillery, acting engineer
officer at headquarters Division of the Pacific.
   Capt. W. L. Marshall, engineer officer, Military Division of the Mis-
souri, reports that the work of his office has consisted in collecting, com-
p)iling, and platting geographical information for the improvement of
existing maps and in making copies of maps of military and Indian res-
ervations, posts, scouts, and reconnaissances for use at division head-
quarters.
   (See Appendix C C C I.)
   Lieut. William C. Langfitt, engineer officer, Department of the Co-
lumbia, reports the determination of the western boundary of the Van-
couver Military Reserve to aid the post quartermaster in removing
encroaching persons; an estimate for increased water supply for Fort
Spokane, together with a resurvey of that reservation; a resurvey of the
Fort Townsend Military Reservation. Many maps, plans, etc., have
been prepared and issued to officers of the department.
   The department map was corrected to December, 1887, and forwarded
to the Chief of Engineers, to be used in preparing a new edition. A
map of Alaska has been projected and its compilation started.
   Additions and corrections are constantly being made to the depart-
ment map to add to its efficiency and correctness.
   (See Appendix C C C 2.)
   Lieut. James E. Runcie, First U. S. Artillery, acting engineer officer,
Division of the Pacific, reports that the following have been made:
   Map of a portion of California south of Mojave Junction; drawings
of plant and machinery used in the manufacture of high explosives;
surveys for new water supply for Fort Gaston, Cal., and for a telegraph
line thence to Arcata, with report; surveys for a sewerage system at
Fort Huachuca, Ariz., with exhaustive report and drawings; that the
land-office map of California has been corrected; the projection for the
map for the Department of Arizona and the District of New Mexico
calculated, and that for a new map of the Department of California
calculated and laid out; and data collected for correcting the maps of
the division, as well as for the correction and compilation of map of
Fort McDermit, Nev., and Fort Bidwell, Cal.
    (See Appendix C C C 3.)
   Lieut. H. M. Chittenden, engineer officer, Department of the Platte,
replorts that the field work and work outside the office during the year
has consisted of--
    i. A survey, relocation, and marking of the boundaries of the Fort
Niobrara Military Reservation.
   2. A survey of the department rifle range, at Bellevue, Nebr.
   3. Copying the records in the United States land-office at Cheyenne,
Wyo., to obtain information for a department map.
   4. Suplerintending the construction of a system of water-works for
Fort Bridger, Wyo.
    The office work has consisted of-
    1. Preparation of a map) of Fort Niobrara Military Reservation.
318     REPORT OF' THE      CHIEF    OF   ENGINEERS,    U. S. ARMY.

  2. Preparation of map of i;ellevue Rifle Range.
  3. Preparation of a plat showing collectively all the military posts
and reservations in this department.
  4. Preparation of a map of the Department of the Platte.
  5. Usual routine work.
  Twenty copies of the map of the United States published in 1885
have been received from the Chief of Engineers and distributed to
posts and officers of the department. Several surveying and mathe-
matical instruments have also been received.
  (See Appendix C C C 4.)

ESTIMATE FOR AMOUNT REQUIRED FOR SURVEYS AND RECONNAIS-
       SANCES IN MILITARY DIVISIONS AND DEPARTMENTS.

   For military surveys and reconnaissances and surveys of military
reservations by the engineer officers attached to the several head-
quarters of military divisions and departments, being an average of
$5,000 for each of eight military divisions and departments west of the
Mississippi River, $40,000; for publication of maps for use of the War
Department, $10,000; total, $50,000.
   Attention is specially invited to this estimate for appropriation and
to the important uses for which it is intended.
   At the headquarters of the military departments west of the Missis-
sippi River there are stationed officers of the Corps of Engineers, or
other officers detailed to act, whose duty it is to make reconnaissances
fur military purposes, to make such surveys and prepare such maps as
may be required by their respective commanding officers. In recent
Scya! no appropriations have been made for these purposes, and, con-
sequently, these officers have been very much cramped from lack of the
necessary means, and the usefulness of their offices has been very much
reduced in consequence. The maps of these departments are constantly
in need of revisions and additions, which the officers make so far as
possible, but with no means even for the purchase of paper their 'fforts
are limited in results.
   Paragraph 464 of the Army Regulations requires that the command-
ing officer of each post where there are fixed batteries bearing upon a
channel will call upon the Engineer D)epartment for accurate charts
showing the soundings, to the extent of the ranges of the guns.
   During the last season of artillery practice at our coast fortifications
calls upon this department to perform its duty under this regulation
could not be honored from lack of means.
   Maps of certain military departments are now being prepared, and
should be published.
   Besides all this there is much information in this office relative to mili-
tary geography which could, with little expense, be made available for
the information of officers of the Army; for instance, there are on the
office files detailed maps of regions of Europe which may become at a,
early day the theaters of war, a,:d it would be of great advantage t) the
service if such information as these maps give could be made available
for the study of officers. Were the means provided this office would be
glad to compile and to disseminate the information on its tiles.
   It is the policy of this country to keep a standing army snall in uum-
bers, but it is its expectation that it should be a 1highly instructed (.ne,
and a small outlay as here referred to will be conducive to that end.
  Applications from officers of the Army have been received for maps
of certain regions of Europe, and it was witlh great regret that this
               OFFICE    OF   THE   CHIEF   OF ENGINEERS.            319

office c uld not render this assistance to officers desirous of improvi A
themselves professionally especially, when the material was on its files.

          OFFICE     OF THE         CHIEF OF ENGINEERS.

    During the fiscal year ending June ;0, 1888, the following-name
officers were in charge of the several divisions of the Office of the Chi(
of Engineers:
    FIRST DIVIsIoN.-Fortificatationsand Surveys relating thereto--Army
meat of Fortifications-Sitesfor Engineer Defenses-Boards of Engineer
for Defenses:
    SECOND DIVISION.-Battalion of Engineers-Engineer School of Ap-
plication and Engineer Depot and Post-Professional Papers and I for-

                        1ymond,
mi)ttion--Personnel-Orders-AMilitaryReservetions--Land Files.
    MIaj. Charles \V. lR           until January 27, 1888; Capt. Thomas
Turtle, temporarily, to April 18, 1888; since which date Capt. Clinton
B. Sears.
    THIRD DIvISION.-Improvement of Ricers and Harbors and Surveys
relating thereto-Bridging Navigable Waters of the United States-Pub-
lic Buildings and Grounds and Washington Aqueduct.
    Maj. James C. Post.
    FOURTHI DIVISION.-Accounts f r Dablk rseients-Contracts-iReturns
of Engineer Property and Instru~ments-Applicationsfor Remittances-
Appropriatiomns and Estimates- Blank Forms.
    FIIFTII Divisi()N.-Surrey ( the Lakes-Explorations and Surveys-
EReco ,,naissances-Maps-fIntr  aum ets- Cl i ims.
    Capt. Thomas Turtle.
          Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                            THOS.   LINCOLN CASEY,
                                        Brig. Gen., Chief of Engineers.
  Hon. WILLIAM C.       ENDICOTT,
                  Secretary of War.
STATEMENT SHOWING THE RANK AND THE DUTIES OF OFFICERS OF
THE CORPS OF ENGINEERS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE
  30,   1888.



    RANK        AND   NAME.                                DUTIES.

                              i


BRIGADIER-GENERAL
    AND CHIEF OF
     ENGINEERS.

James C. Duane........            In command of the Corps of Engineers and in charge of the
                                    Engineer Department. Charged with the supervision of
                                    such matters connected with construction of jetties and
                                    other works at South Pass, Mississippi River, as require
                                    the action of the Secretary of War. Member of Joint
                                    Commission to supervise the construction of the Wash-
                                    ington National Monument. Member of the Light-House
                                    ,Board. Retired from active service on June 30, 1888, un-
                                    der the provisions of the act of Congress approved June
                                    30, 1882.
          COLONELS.

Quincy A. Gilimore.....           In charge of Forts Wool, Va.; Caswell, N. C., Moultrie,
  Bvt. Major-General.               Sumter, and Johnson, S. C.; Oglethorpe and Pulaski, Ga.,
                                    and Clinch, Fla., and of the construction of Forts Wads-
                                    worth, Tompkins and its batteries, N. Y.; Monroe, Va.,
                                     and Castle Pinckney, S. C. In charge of the improve-
                                    ment of the harbors at Charleston, S. C., and Savannah
                                    and Brunswick, Ga. In charge of the improvement of
                                    Ashley River and Wappoo Cut, S. C. ; Cumberland Sound,
                                    Ga. and Fla.; Savannah and Altamaha rivers, and Ro-
                                    merly Marsh, Ga., and Edisto and Salkahatchie rivers,
                                     S. C. In charge of preliminary examinations of Savannah
                                    River from Doboy Island to Doboy Bar, Ga., and North
                                    Fork of the Edisto River, S. C. In charge of preliminary
                                    examinations and surveys of Savannah River from cross-
                                    tides above Savannah to the bar; of Jekyl Creek, Ga.,
                                    and of Mosquito Creek between the South Edisto and
                                    Ashepoo rivers, S. C. In charge of removal of wreck of
                                    trading boat in Cheehaw River, and of steamer Alice Clark,
                                    from the channel of inside passage below Charleston, S.
                                    C. Member of Board of Visitors for Engineer School of
                                    Application, at Willets Point, N. Y. Member of Boards
                                    of Engineer Officers on further improvement of Cape Fear
                                    River, N. C., and on improvement of the Potomac River
                                    in vicinity of Washington, D. C. Member of Board of
                                    Officers to examine into and report upon question of
                                    source and method of water-supply, sewerage, etc., at
                                    Willets Point, N. Y. Member and President of the Mis-
                                    issippi River Commission created by act of Congress ap-
                                    prod June 28, 1879. His death at Brooklyn, N. Y., April
                                    7, 1888, announced in General Orders No. 5, Headquarters
                                    Corps of Engineers, April 10, 1888.
Thos. Lincoln Casey....           Member and President of The Board of Engineers. Member
                                    of Board of Visitors for Engineer School of Application
                                    at Willets Point, N. Y. In charge of the construction of
                                    the building for the State, War, and Navy departments
                                    and of the Washington National Monument. Member
                                                                                    320
                     RANK AND DUTIES OF OFFICERS.                                              321
Statement showing rank and duties ofoficers of Corps of Engineers-Cont'd.

    RANK AND NAME.                                          DUTIES.

                           i




        COLONELS.
      (continued.)
                                 of the Light-House Board. Member of Boards of Engi-
                                 neer Officers on the construction of bridges across Staten
                                 Island Sound (known as Arthur Kill), and the Kill Von
                                 Kull, and for the examination of certain named officers
                                 of the Corps of Engineers, with view to their promotion.
John G. Parke..........        On duty in office of the Chief of Engineers. Detached; Su-
  Bvt. Major-General.            perintendent of the Military Academy. Member of Board
                                 for the purpose of considering the limits on the south of
                                 the reservation at the Post of West Point, N. Y.
George H. Mendell .....        In charge of Fort Winfield Scott, Fort on Alcatraz Island,
                                 batteries at Fort Mason, and defenses at Lime Point, and
                                 fortifications at Angel Island, San Francisco Bay, and at
                                 San Diego, Cal. Supervising Engineer over districts em-
                                 bracing works in charge of Majors Benyaurd, Jones,
                                 Heuer, and Handbury, and Captains Powell, Payson, and
                                 Young. In charge of the improvement of the harbors at
                                 Oakland   and   Redwood,   Cal.   To   investigate   causes   tend-
                                 ing to decrease depth of water and diminish the commer-
                                 cial value of San Francisco Harbor. In charge of survey
                                 of San Francisco Harbor, San Pablo and Suisun bays,
                                 Strait of Carquinez, and mouths of San Joaquin and Sac-
                                 ramento rivers, Cal. In charge of the removal of wreck
                                 of steamer Escambia from entrance to San Francisco
                                 Harbor.
Henry L. Abbot ........        Member of The Board of Engineers. In charge of certain
  Bvt. Brig. General.            experiments with torpedoes. Member of Board of Visit-
                                 ors for Engineer School of Application at Willets Point,
                                 N. Y. Member of Board of Officers and Civilians to ex-
                                 amine and report at what ports fortifications or other
                                 defenses are most urgently required, etc. In temporary
                                 charge of Forts Wool, Va.; Caswell, N. C.; Moultrie, Sum-
                                 ter, and Johnson, S. C.; Oglethorpe and Pulaski, Ga., and
                                 Clinch, Fla., and of the construction of Forts Wadsworth,
                                 Tompkins and its batteries, N. Y.; Monroe, Va., and Cas-
                                 tle Pinckney, S. C. Intemporary charge of the improve-
                                 ment of the harbors at Charleston, S. C., and Savannah
                                 and Brunswick, Ga. In temporary charge of the im-
                                 provement of Ashley River and Wappoo Cut, S. C.; Cum-
                                 berland Sound, Ga. and Fla.; Savannah and Altamaha
                                 rivers, and Romerly Marsh, Ga., and Edisto and Salka-
                                 hatchie rivers, S. C. In temporary charge of prelimi-
                                 nary examination of North Fork of the Edisto River,
                                 S. C.
                               In temporary charge of removal of wreck of trading boat
                                 in Cheehaw River, and of wreck of steamer Alice Clark
                                 from the channel of inside passage below Charleston,
                                 S. C. To examine and report upon the site of the new
                                 bride across Arthur Kill. Member of Boards of Engineer
                                 Officers to consider and report upon location and plans of
                                 bridge across the Mississippi River at Dubuque, Iowa,
                                 and for the examination of certain named officers of the
                                 Corps of Engineers, with view to their promotion.
William P. Craighill....       Member of The Board of Engineers. In charge of Fort Car-
                                 roll and the construction of Fort McHenry, Md. Supervis-
                                 ing engineer over districts embracing works in charge of
                                 Captains Hinman, Bixby, and Black, Lieutenants Abbot
                                 and Carter, and Mr. S. T. Abert. In charge of the im-
                                 provement of the harbors at Baltimore and Annapolis,
                                 Md. In charge of harbor of refuge at mouth of Great
                                 Kanawha River, West Virginia. In charge of the im-
        ENG 88-21
322      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Statement showing rank and duties of officers of Corpsof Engineers-Cont'd.


   RANK AND NAME.                                   DUTIES.




       COLONELS.
      (continued.)
                           provement of James River, Virginia, and New River,
                           Virginia and West Virginia, and Great Kanawha and Elk
                           Rivers, West Virginia, and of the work of rebuilding piers
                           at Battery Island, head of Chesapeake Bay. In charge of
                           the survey across the peninsula of Maryland and Dela-
                           ware to connect by canal the waters of the Delaware and
                           Chesapeake bays. In charge of preliminary investiga-
                           tion of Coal River, West Virginia.      In charge of pre-
                           liminary investigations and surveys of Meadow and
                           Gauley rivers, West Virginia. In charge of removal of
                           wreck of schooner Dorcas and Eliza from Pasquotank
                           River, near Elizabeth City, N. C., and of barge Harry off
                           Turkey Point light-house, Chesapeake Bay. To exercise
                           supervision of construction of bridge across Great Kana-
                           wha River at Point Pleasant, W. Va. Member of boards
                           of engineer officers on further improvement of Cape Fear
                           River, N. C.; on improvement of the Potomac River in
                           vicinity of Washington, D. C.; on subject of permanent
                           improvement of Delaware River and Bay; on construc-
                           tion of the locks at the Cascades, Columbia River, Oregon;
                           and to consider and report upon Joint Resolution (H.
                           Res. 113) in relation to the Delaware River between the
                           city of Philadelphia, Pa., and Camden, N. J. Member
                           of Advisory Board to State Harbor Commission of Nor-
                           folk, Portsmouth, and Norfolk County, Va. In tempo-
                           rary charge of the improvement of the harbor at Norfolk.
                           and the approach to Norfolk Harbor and the United
                           States Navy Yard, Va. In temporary charge of the im-
                           provement of the Blackwater, Nottoway, Archer's Hope,
                           and Appomattox rivers, Va., and Meherrin River, Curri-
                           tuck Sound, Coanjok and Edenton bays, and North River
                           Bar, N. C., and North Landing River, Va. and N. C. In
                           temporary charge of preliminary examination of Alliga-
                           tor River, N. C., and preliminary examination and survey
                           of Nansemond River, Va.
Cyrus B. Comstock .....   Member of The Board of Engineers. Member of Board of
   Bvt. Brig. General.     Visitors for Engineer School of Application at Willets
                           Point, N. Y. Member of Boards of Engineer Officers on
                           further improvement of Cape Fear River, N. C.; on im-
                           provement of the Potomac River in vicinity of Washing-
                           ton, D. C. ; on harbor at Atlantic City, N. J.; to consider
                           and report upon joint resolution (H. Res. 113) in relation
                           to the Delaware River between the city of Philadelphia,
                           Pa., and Camden, N. J. ; and for the examination of certain
                           named officers of the Corps of Engineers, with view to
                           their promotion. Member and President of the Missis-
                           sippi River Commission created by act of Congress ap-
                           proved June 28, 1879.

LIEUTENANT-COLONELS.

Orlando M. Poe ..... .    In charge of the construction of Fort Wayne, Mich. In
    Bvt. Brig. General.     charge of the improvement of the harbors at Cheboy-
                            gan and Au Sable, on Lake Huron, and Alpena, at Thunder
                            Bay, and of the construction of harbor of refuge on Lake
                            Huron; of the improvement of the St. Mary's Falls Canal
                            and River, and of the rivers Detroit, Saginaw, and Clin-
                            ton, Mich., and Hay Lake Channel of the St. Mary's
                            River; of removing bar at ice-harbor of refuge at Belle
                            River, Mich., and construction of Dry Dock. St. Mary's Falls
                       RANK AND DUTIES              OF OFFICERS.                        323
Statement showing rank and duties of oficers of Corpl of Engineers-Cont'd.

   RANK AND    NAME.                                      DUTIES.

                           I
LIEUTENANT-COLONELS.
      (continued.)
                                 Canal. In charge of St. Clair Flats Canal and St. Mary's
                                 Falls Canal, Mich. In charge of issuing charts of North-
                                 ern and Northwestern lakes, and of water-level observa-
                                 tions on Lake Huron. In charge of preliminary exami-
                                 nations of bar in St. Clair River, opposite Saint Clair
                                 City, North River between Essex and North bridges, Bid-
                                 dle's Point at Mackinac Harbor, Harbor at Forestville,
                                 Lake Huron, and Pinepog River, Mich. In charge of pre-
                                 liminary examinations and surveys of Rouge River at its
                                 junction with Detroit River, and up the river to the
                                  bridge of the Saint Louis and Wabash Railroad; and of
                                 mouth of Black River, Mich. In charge of survey of his-
                                 toric grounds, etc., referred to in the act of Congress
                                 approved May 24, 1888. To supervise and personally ex-
                                 amine the construction of bridge across the west channel
                                 of the Detroit River to connect Belle Isle Park with the
                                 mainland, and to exercise supervision of construction of
                                 bridge across Sainte Marie River, Mich. Member of Boards
                                 of Engineer Officers upon plan and estimate for a lock at
                                 or near the Lower Island at Nashville, for improving
                                 Cumberland River, Tenn., and to examine and report
                                 upon plans and location of proposed bridge across the
                                 Ohio River between Cincinnati. Ohio. and Newport, Ky.
David C. Houston......         Member of The Board of Engineers. In charge of Forts
         Bvt. Colonel.           Griswold and Hale, Conn., and Lafayette, N. Y., and of
                                 the construction of Forts Trumbull, Conn., and Columbus,
                                 Wood, Wadsworth, and Tompkins and its batteries, N. Y. ;
                                 Castle Williams, South Battery, new Barbette Battery and
                                 sea-wall at Governor's Island, N. Y., and of permanent
                                 platforms for modern cannon of large caliber. In charge
                                 of the improvement of the harbors of New London, Clin-
                                 ton, New Haven, Milford, Bridgenort, Black Rock, South-
                                 port, Stamford, and Norwalk, Conn., and Port Jefferson,
                                 Greenport, Mamaroneck, Port Chester, New Rochelle, and
                                 of Echo Harbor, N. Y., and of the construction of break-
                                 water at New Haven, Conn. In charge of the improve-
                                 ment of the rivers Housatonic and Thames, Conn., Con-
                                 necticut, Mass. and Conn., Flushing Bay, and East
                                 Chester Creek, N. Y. In charge of the manufacture and
                                 supply of mastic. In charge of preliminary examination
                                 of Peter's Neck Bay, N. Y. In charge of preliminary ex-
                                 aminations and surveys of Five Mile River and Duck Isl-
                                 and harbors, Conn., and Glen Cove Harbor, N. Y. In
                                 charge of removal of wreck of scow George C. Bloomer in
                                 Connecticut River at Hartford, Conn.; of wreck of
                                 schooner R. H. Daly in Connecticut River near Saybrook
                                 Point; of wreck of schooner Emma J. Higgins, near Pen-
                                 field's Reef, and of wreck of schooner Louise Bliss, at Corn-
                                 field Shoal, Long Island Sound. Member of Board of
                                 Visitors for Engineer School of Application at Willets
                                 Point, N. Y.
George H. Elliot. ......       On sick leave of absence.
Henry M. Robert-.......        In charge of Fort Mifflin, Pa., and mortar battery thereat;
                                 Fort Delaware, and fort and mortar battery opposite Fort
                                 Delaware, Del., battery and mortar battery at Finn's
                                 Point, and site for defenses at Red Bank, N. J. In charge
                                 of the improvement of the harbor at Delaware Break-
                                 water; ice-harbors at Marcus Hook, Pa., and the head of
                                 Delaware Bay; of the Salem, Rancocas, and Raccoon
                                 rivers, and Cohansey, Mantua, and Woodbury creeks,
                                                                               e
324      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Statementshowing rankand duties of officers of Corpsof Engineers-Cont'd.


   RANK AND NAME.                                    DUTIES.



LIEUTENANT-COLONELS.
      (continued.)
                              N. J.; Frankford Creek and Schuylkill River, Pa.; and
                              Delaware River, from Trenton, N. J., to its mouth ; and
                              of the construction of pier near Lewes, Del. In charge of
                              preliminary examinations of channel back of Brigantine
                              Beach, between Absecon and Brigantine inlets, N. J., and
                              Darby Creek, Pa. In charge of preliminary examination
                              and survey of thoroughfare running back of the ocean
                              from Cape May to the Great Bay north of Atlantic City,
                              N. J. In charge of survey of thoroughfare running back
                              of the ocean from Cape May to the Great Bay north of
                              Atlantic City, N. J. In charge of removal of wreck of
                              schooner David Lee from Delaware Bay; of wreck of
                              schooner G. H. Bent from the harbor at Delaware Break-
                              water, Del., and of wreck of steamer Blanche Henderson
                              from Delaware River, off Lombard street wharf, Phila-
                              delphia, Pa. Member and Disbursing Officer of Board of
                              Engineer Officers on harbor at Atlantic City, N. J. Mem-
                              ber of Boards of Engineer Officers on subject of perma-
                              nent improvement of Delaware River and Bay; on the
                              construction of bridges across Staten Island Sound known
                              as Arthur Kill), and the Kill Von Kull; and to consider
                              and report upon Joint Resolution (H. Res. 113) in rela-
                              tion to the Delaware River between the city of Phila-
                              delphia, Pa., and Camden, N. J. Member of Commis-
                              sion Advisory to Board of Harbor Commissioners of Phil-
                              adelphia.
William E. Merrill ......   In charge of the improvement of the Ohio River; Mononga-
    Brt. Colonel.             hela River,W.Va.; Allegheny River, Pa., and of the Mus-
                              kingum River, Ohio. In charge of the construction of
                              harbors of refuge at mouth of Muskingum River, near
                              Cincinnati, Ohio, and of a dam at Herr's Island, Pa. In
                              charge of preliminary examinations for ice-harbor at Pa-
                              ducah, and of bar at mouth of Limestone Creek, in harbor
                              of Maysville, Ky. In charge of preliminary examinations
                              and surveys of Ohio River, near Evansville, Ind., and of
                              the Big Hockhocking River, from mouth to Coolville,Ohio.
                              In charge of removal of wrecks of two barges from the
                              Ohio River, at Glasshouse Ripple, near Pittsburgh, Pa.
                              To exercise supervision over the construction of bridges
                              across the Ohio River between Covington and Cincinnati;
                              at Cairo; between Cincinnati and Newport; and near the
                              mouth of Cork's Run, in Allegheny County, Pa. To in-
                              spect the work in progress for improvement of Coosa
                              River, Ga. and Ala, In temporary charge of the improve-
                              ment of the Little Kanawha, Guyandotte, and Buckhan-
                              non rivers, W. Va., and the Big Sandy River, W. Va. and
                              Ky., and of preliminary examination and survey of Louisa
                              Fork of Sandy River, Va. Member of Boards of Engi-
                              neer Officers on plan and estimate for a lock at or near
                              Lower Island at Nashville, for improving Cumberland
                              River, Tenn.; to consider and report upon new plans for
                              the proposed bridge across the Ohio River, near Pitts-
                              burgh, Pa.; to consider and prepare general regulations
                              concerning the erection of bridges over the Muskingum
                              River, Ohio; to consider and report upon the improve-
                              ment of the Mississippi River from Des Moines Rapids to
                              the mouth of the Illinois River; to recommend a plan for
                              the improvement of the navigation at the mouth of the
                              Cumberland River; on proposed bridge across the Ohio
                              River at Louisville, Ky., and on proposed bridge across
                              the Mississippi River at Memphis, Tenn. Engineer 14th
                              Light-house District.
                       RANK AND               DUTIES OF OFFICERS.                           325
Statement showing rank and duties ofofficers of Corpsof Engineers-Cont'd.


    RANK AND NAME.                                            DUTIES.

                                 f




LIEUTENANT-COLONELS.
      (continued.)

Walter McFarland.         ....       Member of The Board of Engineers. In charge of Fort at
                                       Sandy Hook, N. J., and of the construction of Fort Ham-
                                       ilton and additional batteries, and Mortar Battery at Fort
                                       Hamilton, N. Y. In charge of the improvement of the
                                       harbors of New York, Rondout, and Saugerties, N. Y.
                                       In charge of the improvement of the Hudson and Harlem
                                       rivers and Sheepshead and Canarsie bays, N. Y.; Raritan
                                       Bay, N. J.; channel in Gow anus Bay and Buttermilk
                                       Channel; channel between Staten Island and New Jersey,
                                       and deepening Gedney's Channel, and Newtown Creek
                                       and Sumpawanus Inlet, N. Y. In charge of the removal of
                                       o structionsin East River and Hell Gate, N. Y. In charge
                                       of removal of wreck of sloop Locomotive in Hudson River,
                                       and of wreck of bark Quickstep in Main Ship Channel, New
                                       York Harbor, and of wreck of canal-boat from Harlem
                                       River at High Bridge. In charge of preliminary exami-
                                       nation of channel between Jamaica Bay and Rockaway
                                       Inlet, and of the East River, N. Y. In charge of prelimi-
                                       nary examinations and surveys of Hudson River between
                                       New Baltimore and Coxsackie, and of the mouth of Pat-
                                       chouge River, N. Y. In charge of preliminary examina-
                                       tion or survey of Spring Creek, N. Y. To exercise super-
                                       vision over construction of bridge across the East River
                                       between the city of New York and Long Island. Member
                                       of Board of Visitors for Engineer School of Application at
                                        Willets Point, N. Y. Member of Boards of Engineer Offi-
                                       cers on subject of permanent improvement of Delaware
                                       River and Bay, and on harbor at Atlantic City, N. J.    In-
                                       spected the works of river and harbor improvement in
                                       charge of Majors Ernst and Damrell and Captains Hoxie,
                                       Taber, and Black.
John M. Wilson ........              In charge of Public Buildings and Grounds in the District
   Bvt. Colonel.                       of Columbia, with the rank of Colonel. In charge of the
                                       improvements over the grave of Thomas Jefferson at
                                       Monticello, Va.; of the erection of a pedestal and statue
                                       of the late President James A. Garfield; of a monument
                                       at Washington's Headquarters, at Newburgh, N. Y.; of
                                        the erection of a monument to mark the birth-place of
                                        George Washington; of the erection of building for the
                                       Army Medical Museum and Library, and of the erection
                                       of monuments or memorial tablets for the proper mark
                                       ing of the position of each of the commands of the Regu-
                                       lar Army engaged at Gettysburg. In charge of the con-
                                        struction of the Washington Monument.     To report to the
                                        United States Senate a comprehensive system of under-
                                       ground wires, for telegraph and telephone service, to con-
                                        nect the several Departments and Bureaus of the Govern-
                                        ment in Washington City. Member of Board of Engineer
                                        Officers in connection with the Bennington Battle Monu-
                                        ment.
John W. Barlow----........           In charge of the improvement of the rivers Tennessee,
                                       Tenn., Ala., and Ky.; Cumberland above and below Nash-
                                       ville, Ky. and Tenn.; Hiawassee, Caney Fork, Duck,
                                       French Broad, Clinch, and Little Tennessee, Tenn., and
                                       South Fork of the Cumberland, Ky. In charge of prelim-
                                       inary examinations and surveys of Obey's River from the
                                       point where improvements have heretofore been made to
                                       the mouth of the West Fork, Tenn., and of Bear Creek,
                                       Miss. Member of Boards of Engineer Officers to con-
                                       sider and report upon new plans for the proposed bridge
326      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Statement showing rankand duties of oficers of Corps of Engineers-Cont'd.


   RANK AND NAME.                                   DUTIES.



LIEUTENANT-COLONELS.
      (continued.)
                            across the Ohio River near Pittsburgh, Pa., and to con-
                            sider and recommend a plan for the improvement of the
                            navigation at the mouth of the Cumberland River.
Peter C. Hains ........   In charge of Forts Foote and Washington, Md., and Wool,
                            Va., and the construction of Fort Monroe, Va. In charge
                            of the improvement of the harbors at Washington and
                            Georgetown, D. C. In charge of the improvement of the
                            Potomac River in the vicinity of Washington, D. C., the
                            establishment of the harbor lines, and the raising of the
                            river flats. In charge of the construction of a new wharf
                            at Fort Monroe, Va. In charge of the improvement of the
                            Shenandoah River, W. Va. In charge of purchase and
                            reconstruction of Aqueduct Bridge, D. C. In charge of
                            construction of bridge across the Eastern Branch of Poto-
                            mac River, D. C. In charge of survey of the low lands at
                            Washington Barracks, D. C. To test samples of cement
                            offered for use of Congressional Library Building. To
                            supervise the modifications of the Light-house Wharf at
                            Fort Monroe, Va. To report upon a new sewer system at
                            Fort Monroe, Va. Member of Board of Officers on divis-
                            ion of land at Fort Monroe, Va., with view to consoli-
                            dating, separately, the belongings of the Engineer Corps
                            and the Ordnance Departments. Member of Boards of
                            Engineer Officers in connection with the Bennington
                            Battle Monument, and on the construction of bridges
                            across Staten Island Sound (known as Arthur Kill) and
                            the Kill Von Kull.
George L. Gillespie -.... In charge of Fonts Winthrop, Standish, Andrew, Independ-
                            ence, and work on Long Island Head, and of the con-
                            struction of Fort Warren, Mass. In charge of the im-
                            provement of the harbors at Newburyport, Lynn, Boston
                            (including sea-wallA on Point Allerton, Great Brewster
                            Island, Lovell's Island, Gallop's Island, Long Island IHead,
                            Rainsford Island, and Deer Island; Malden, Mystic, and
                            Charles rivers; and channel leading to Nantasket Beach),
                            Provincetown, Plymouth, Scituate, Hingham, and Glou-
                            cester, Mass. In charge of construction of a national har-
                            bor of refuge (of the first class) at Sandy Bay, Cape Ann,
                            Mass. In charge of the improvement of the rivers Merri-
                            mac and Ipswich, Mass. In charge of preliminary exam-
                            inations and surveys of Manchester, Duxbury, Wellfleet,
                            and Winthrop Harbors, Mass. To mark the boundaries of
                            the military reservation of Fort Sewall, Mass., with suit-
                            able monuments. Member of Boards of Engineer Officers
                            on subject of permanent improvement of Delaware River
                            and Bay; on construction of the locks at the Cascades,
                            Columbia River, Oregon; and for the examination of cer-
                            tain named officers of the Corps of Engineers, with view
                            to their promotion. Member of Board of Officers to de-
                            termine upon a suitable locality for proving-ground, etc.
                            In temporary charge of the improvement of the harbors
                            of New York, Rondout, and Saugerties, N. Y. In tem-
                            porary charge of the improvement of the Hudson and
                            Harlem rivers and Sheepshead and Canarsie bays, N. Y.;
                            Raritan Bay, N. J.; channel in Gowanus Bay and Butter-
                            milk Channel; channel between Staten Island and New
                            Jersey, and deepening Gedney's Channel, and Newtown
                            Creek and Sumpawanus Inlet, N. Y. In temporary charge
                            of the removal of obstructions in East River and Hell
                            Gate, N.Y. In temporary charge of removal of wreck of
                           RANK AND DUTIES         OF OFFICERS.                       327
Statement showing rankand duties of officers of Corps of Engineers- Contd.

    RANK   AND   NAME.                                   DUTIES.



LIEUTENANT-COLONELS.
       (continued.)

                                 sloop Locomotive in Hudson River ; of wreck of bark Quick-
                                 step in Main Ship Channel, New York Harbor, and of
                                 wreck of canal-boat in Harlem River at High Bridge.
                                 In temporary charge of preliminary examination or sur-
                                 vey of Spring Creek, N. Y. In temporary charge of sur-
                                 vey of Hudson River between New Baltimore and Cox-
                                 sackie, N. Y. To temporarily exercise supervision over
                                 construction of bridge across the East River between the
                                 city of New York and Long Island.
Charles R. Suter      ......   Member of the Mississippi River Commission created by act
                                 of Congress approved June 28, 1879. Member and Presi-
                                 dent of the Missouri River Commission, created by act of
                                 Congress approved July 5, 1884. Member of Board of
                                 Engineer Officers to consider and report upon the con-
                                 struction of bridges across the Missouri River between its
                                 mouth and the mouth of Dakota or James River; across
                                 the Mississippi River between Saint Paul, Minn., and
                                 Natchez, Miss.; and across the Illinois River between its
                                 mouth and La Salle, Ill. To exercise supervision over
                                 the construction of bridges across the Missouri River at
                                 or near Sioux City, Iowa; opposite to or within the cor-
                                 porate limits of Nebraska City, Nebr., and between the
                                 cities of Omaha, Nebr., and Council Bluffs, Iowa. Engi-
                                 neer 15th and 16th Light-house districts.
Jared A. Smith .........       In charge of Forts Knox, Popham, Gorges, Scammel,
                                 McClary, and batteries at Portland Head and Gerrish's
                                 Island, Me., and Fort Constitution and battery at Jerry's
                                 Point, N. H., and of construction of Fort Preble, Me. In
                                 charge of the improvement of the harbors at Bangor, Bel-
                                 fast, Rockland, Portland, and York, Me., and Portsmouth,
                                 N. H., and harbor of refuge at Little Harbor, N. H. In
                                 charge of the improvement of the rivers Penobscot, Kenne-
                                 bunk, Saco, and Narragaugus, Me., and Cocheco, N. H.;
                                 Saco River Breakwater, Lubec Channel, Moose-a-bee Bar,
                                 and channel in Back Cove, Portland, Me. In charge of
                                 preliminary examinations of Big Rapids of St. John's
                                 River; St. George's River from Warren to Thomaston, and
                                 Matinicus Isle with view to harbor of refuge, Me. In
                                 charge of preliminary examinations and surveys of Baga-
                                 duce River between Penobscot and Brooksville; Camden
                                 and Rockport harbors; Kennebec River at Bath, and from
                                 Augusta to lower end of Perkin's Island; Penobscot River
                                 from Bangor to Bucksport Narrows; St. Croix River from
                                 Ferry Point Bridge at Calais to Breakwater Ledge, and
                                 Bar Harbor, with view to establishing breakwater, etc.,
                                 Me., and Bellamy River, N. H. In charge of surveys of
                                 Bagaduce River between Penobscot and Brooksville; Cam-
                                 den and Rockport harbors; Kennebec River at Bath, and
                                 from Augusta to lower end of Perkin's Island ; Penobscot
                                 River from Bangor to Bucksport Narrows, Me.
         MAJORS.

Samuel M. Mansfield-....       In charge of the improvement of the harbors at Charlevoix,
    Brt. Lieut. Colonel.         Frankfort, Manistee, Ludington, Pentwater, White River,
                                 Muskegon, Grand Haven, Black Lake, Saugatuck, South
                                 Haven, and Saint Joseph, and harbor of refuge at Port-
                                 age Lake, Mich., and harbor at Michigan City, Ind. Engi-
                                 neer 9th, 10th, and 11th Light-house districts.
328            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U                              S. ARMY.

Statement showing rank and duties of officers of Corps of Engineers-Cont'd.


    :ANK AND      NAME.                                         DUTIES.
      ------                     1




          MAJORS.
       (continued.)
William R. King .......              Member of The Board of Engineers. Commanding Post and
                                       Engineer School of Application at Willets Point, N. Y.,
                                        and the Battalion of Engineers. In charge of the con-
                                        struction of Fort Schuyler; of fort and engineer depot at
                                       Willets Point, N. Y.; torpedoes for harbor defense, and
                                        of experiments with torpedoes. In charge of the con-
                                        struction of officers' quarters, mess, etc., at Willets Point,
                                       N. Y., and of disbursements for same. In charge of funds
                                        pertaining to the Library of the Engineer School of Appli-
                                        cation. Member of Boards of Engineer Officers on plan
                                        and estimate for a lock at or near the Lower Island at
                                       Nashville, for improving Cumberland River, Tenn.; on
                                        construction of bridges across Staten Island Sound (known
                                        as Arthur Kill) and the Kill Von Kull; to report upon
                                       the "Auto-Mobile Controllable Torpedo" of Mr. J. N. H.
                                        Patrick, and for the examination of certain named officers
                                       of the Corps of Engineers, with view to their promotion.
                                        Member of General Courts-martial convened at Willets
                                       Point, N. Y., January 23 and February 24, 188. On tem-
                                       porary detached service at Newport. R. I.
Wm.   11. H. Benyaurd
       H.                 - --       In charge of the improvement of the harbor at San Diego,
                                        and construction of breakwater at Wilmington Harbor,
                                        Cal. In charge of examinations and surveys for channel
                                       in San Diego Harbor, and at Newport Harbor; establish-
                                        ment of breakwater at San Luis Obispo Harbor, and of
                                        San Pedro Bay near entrance to Wilmington Harbor, Cal.
                                        To examine into the condition of the navigable channel
                                       of San Diego Bay, and the wharfage frontage thereon, etc.
Garret J. Lydecker .....             In charge of the Washington Aqueduct; increasing water
                                       supply of the city of Washington, and the erection of
                                        fish-ways at Great Falls of the Potomac River. Member
                                       of Board of Engineer Officers in connection with the Ben-
                                       nington Battle Monument.
Amos Stickney ........               In charge of the Louisville and Portland Canal. In charge
                                        of the improvement of the Falls of the Ohio River, Wabash
                                       River, Ind. and Ill., and White River, Ind. In temporary
                                        charge of the improvement of the Kentucky and Trade-
                                        water rivers ; of preliminary examination of Pond River,
                                        and of preliminary examinations and surveys of Licking
                                        River from Farmers to West Liberty, and Salt River, Ky.
                                        To exercise supervision over the construction of the pro-
                                        posed road of the Carrollton or Lock No. 1 Turnpike Co.
                                        through the land of the United States at Lock No. 1,
                                        Kentucky River, and of bridge across the Tradewater.
                                        River, Ky. Member of Boards of Engineer Officers to
                                        consider and report upon new plans for the proposed
                                       ,bridge across the Ohio River near Pittsburgh, Pa.; to
                                        consider and prepare general regulations concerning the
                                        erection of bridges over the Muskingum River, Ohio; to
                                        examine and report upon plan and location of proposed
                                        bridge across the Ohio River between Cincinnati, Ohio,
                                        and Newport, Ky.; and to examine and report upon the
                                        plans of the proposed bridge across the Ohio River at
                                        Louisville, Ky.
Alexander Mackenzie...               In charge of the improvement of the Mississippi River from
                                        Saint Paul to Des Moines Rapids; the Upper Mississippi
                                        River, and Rock Island Rapids and Des Moines Rapids of
                                        the Mississippi River, and of removing bar in Mississippi
                                        River opposite Dubuque, Iowa. In charge of the con-
                                        struction of a dry-dock at the Des Moines Rapids Canal ;
                        RANK 'AND      DUTIES    OF OFFICERS.                      329
Statement showing rank andduties of oficers of Corps of Engineers-Cont'd.


   RANK AND NAME.                                     DUTIES.


        MAJORS.
      (continued.)
                               of ice-harbor at Dubuque, Iowa and of harbors of refuge
                               on Lake Pepin at Stockholm, Wis., and Lake City, Minn.
                               In charge of operating the Des Moines Rapids Canal and
                               of operating snag-boat on Upper Mississippi River. In
                               charge of the work in connection with the Adams Flume,
                               Mississippi River. To supervise the work of alteration
                               in the ponton-bridge across the Mississippi River at
                               Prairie du Chien, Wis.    Member of Boards of Engineer
                               Officers to consider and report upon location and plans of
                               bridge across the Mississippi River at Dubuque, Iowa; to
                               consider and report upon the improvement of the Missis-
                               sippi River from Des Moines Rapids to the mouth of the
                               Illinois River; to consider and report upon the construc-
                               tion of bridges across the Missouri River between its
                               mouth and the mouth of the Dakota or James River;
                               across the Mississippi River, between Saint Paul, Minn.,
                               and Natchez, Miss., and across the Illinois River between
                               its mouth and La Salle, Ill.; to examine and report upon
                               plan and location of proposed bridge across the Ohio
                               River between Cincinnati, Ohio, and Newport, Ky., and
                               t. consider and recommend a plan for the improvement
                               of the navigation at the mouth of the Cumberland River.
                               Member of the Missouri River Commission created by act
                               of Congress approved July 5, 1884.
Oswald H. Ernst      ...-    In charge of the improvement of the harbors at Galveston
                               and Brazos Santiago, Tex. In charge of the improvement
                               of ship channel in Galveston Bay, Pass Cavallo, Aransas
                               Pass and Bay up to Rqckport and Corpus Christi, mouth
                               of Brazos River, Buffalo Bayou; deepening channel at
                               mouth of Trinity River, and removal of obstructions to
                               Liberty, Tex. In charge of preliminary examination ofCe-
                               dar Bayou, Galveston Bay, Tex. Member of Board of En-
                               gineer Officers on proposed bridge across the Mississippi
                               River atMemphis, Tenn. Member of the Mississippi River
                               Commission created by act of Congress approved June 28,
                               1879. Member of the Missouri River Commission created
                               by act of Congress approved July 5, 1884.
David P. Heap ....    ....   Detached; Engineer secretary to the Light-House Board.
                               Engineer 3d and 4th Light-house districts.
William Ludlow ......        Detached; Engineer Commissioner of the District of Co-
    Bvt. Lieut. Colonel.       lumbia. Engineer 4th Light-house District.
William A. Jones.......      In charge of the improvement of the Upper and Lower Co-
                               lumbia and Snake Rivers, Oregon and Wash.; Willamette
                               River above Portland, and Lower Willamette River be-
                               low Portland, Oregon; Cowlitz River, Wash.; Yamhill
                               River, Oregon, and Lower Clearwater River, Idaho. On
                               leave of absence.
Andrew N. Damrell......      In charge of Forts Morgan and Gaines, Ala., and fort on
                                Ship Island, Miss. In charge of the improvement of the
                               harbor at Mobile, Ala. In charge of the improvement of
                               the rivers Warrior and Black Warrior, Ala. ; Pascagoula,
                               Pearl, and Noxubee, Miss.; Tombigbee, Ala. and Miss. ; the
                               roadstead leading into Back Bay of Biloxi in Mississippi
                                Sound; channel of Biloxi Bay, and Old Town Creek and
                                Horn Island Pass, Miss. In charge of preliminary exam-
                               ination of Noxubee River, Miss. In charge of preliminary
                                examination and survey of Tombigbee River from Vienna,
                               Ala., to Walker's Bridge, Miss. In charge of survey of
                                Tombigbee River from Vienna, Ala., to Walker's Bridge,
                                Miss. To exercise supervision over the construction of
                               bridge across Tombigbee River, at Waverly, Miss.
330           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Statement showing rank and duties of officers of Corps of Engineers-Cont'd.


     RANK AND- NAME.                                            DUTIES.



            MAJORS.
         (continued.)
Charles J. Allen........               In charge of the improvement of the Chippewa River, and
                                         protection of Yellow Banks on the same; of the Minne-
                                         sota and St. Croix rivers, and the Red River of the North ;
                                         of the Mississippi River above the Falls of St. Anthony;
                                         of the Falls of St. Anthony; construction of Meeker's Isl-
                                         and lock and dam, and lock and dam at Goose Rapids, on
                                         Red River of the North. In charge of the improvement
                                         of the Yellowstone River, Mont. and Dak., and the Mis-
                                         souri River from Sioux City, Iowa, to Fort Benton, Mont.
                                         In charge of construction and improvement of roads and
                                         bridges in Yellowstone National Park. In charge of
                                         the construction of reservoirs at headwaters of the Mis-
                                         sissippi River and its tributaries. In charge of examina-
                                         tion and surveys of the sources of the Mississippi, St.
                                         Croix, Chippewa, and Wisconsin rivers, with the view to
                                         ascertaining the practicability and cost of creating and
                                         maintaining reservoirs, etc. In charge of preliminary ex-
                                         aminations of Red Lake River from Grand Forks to Red
                                         Lake, Minn., and harbor at Hudson, Lake St. Croix, Wis.,
                                         and examination and report on causes of the extraordi-
                                         nary overflows of the Chippewa River, Wis., and the
                                         means to be adopted to prevent their recurrence. In
                                         charge of preliminary examinations and surveys of Red
                                         River of the North from Moorehead to Fergus Falls ; Mis-
                                         sissippi River between Saint Paul and St. Anthony's Falls,
                                         and Minnesota River with view to its improvement by
                                         locks and dams, Minn. In charge of surveys of Mis-
                                         sissippi River between Saint Paul and St. Anthony's Falls,
                                         and Minnesota River with view to its improvement by
                                         locks and dams, Minn. To exercise supervision over con-
                                         struction of bridge across Red River of the North at
                                         Grand Forks, Dak. Member of Board of Engineer Officers
                                         to investigate and report upon all matters concerning the
                                         work in progress in connection with the " practicaltest
                                         of the flume invented by M. J. Adams," etc.
Charles W. Raymond...                  In charge of the First and Second Divisions, Office of the
                                         Chief of Engineers. Detached; Engineer Commissioner
                                         of the District of Columbia.
L. C o o p e r O v er m a n . . . ..   In charge of the improvement of harbors at Monroe, Mich.,
                                         Toledo, Port Clinton, Sandusky, Vermillion, Huron, Black
                                         River, Rocky River, Cleveland, Fairport, Ashtabula, and
                                         Conneaut, Ohio. In charge of improvement of Sandusky
                                         River, Ohio. In charge of water-level observations on
                                         Lake Erie. In charge of preliminary examination of Cha-
                                         grin River at its mouth, Ohio. In charge of removal of
                                         wreck of schooner Joy from Ashtabula Harbor, Ohio. En-
                                         gineer 10th Light-house District.
Alexander M. Miller ....               In charge of the improvement of the rivers Mississippi and
                                         Missouri-removal of snags, etc., Mississippi River be-
                                         tween the mouths of the Illinois and Ohio rivers; Osage
                                         River, Mo., and Kans., and Gasconade River, Mo. In
                                         charge of resurvey of the Osage River from mouth to
                                         Osceola, with view to movable locks and dams, etc. In
                                         charge of preliminary examinations and surveys of Kas-
                                         kaskia River from New Athens to mouth, and of Missis-
                                         sippi River at Rush Island Bend and Ivy Landing, Ill. In
                                         charge of surveys of Kaskaskia River from New Athens
                                         to mouth, and of Mississippi River at Rush Island Bend
                                         and Ivy Landing, Ill. Member of Boards of Engineer
                                         Officers to consider and report upon location and plans of
                          RANK AND DUTIES           OF OFFICERS.                      331
Statement showing rank and duties of officers of Corps of Engineers-Cont'd.

   RANK AND NAME.                                        DUTIES.

               --           1




         MAJORS.
      (continued.)
                                  bridge across the Mississippi River at Dubuque, Iowa; to
                                  consider and report upon the improvement of the Missis-
                                  sippi River from Des Moines Rapids to the mouth of the
                                  Illinois River; and to consider and report upon the con-
                                  struction of bridges across the Missouri River between its
                                  mouth and the mouth of Dakota or James River; across
                                  the Mississippi River between Saint Paul, Minn., and
                                  Natchez, Miss,; and across the Illinois River between its
                                  mouth and La Salle, Ill.
Milton B. Adams .......         In charge of Fort Montgomery, N. Y. In charge of the im-
                                  provement of the harbors at Ogdensburgh, on the river St.
                                  Lawrence, and Plattsburgh, Burlington, and Swanton, and
                                  construction of breakwaters at Rouse's Point and Gordon's
                                  Landing, on Lake Champlain. In charge of the improve-
                                  ment of Ticonderoga and Grass rivers, and of narrows at
                                  Lake Champlain, N. Y., and Otter Creek, Vt. In charge
                                  of preliminary examinations of Spring Creek and Wad-
                                  dington Harbor, N. Y.
William R. Livermore ..         In temporary charge of the forts at Clark's Point, Mass.,
                                  at Dutch Island, R. I., and of the construction of Fort
                                  Adams, R. I. In temporary charge of the construction of
                                  harbor of refuge at Wood's Holl, Mass. In temporary
                                  charge of the improvement of the harbors at Nantuckett,
                                   Wood's Holl, Westport, Wareham, and Hyannis, Mass.,
                                  Newport and Block Island, R. I., and Stonington, Conn. In
                                   temporary charge of the improvement of the rivers Taun-
                                  ton, Mass., Pawtucket, Providence, Warren, and Pawca-
                                  tuck, and Narragansett Bay, R. I. and Little Narraganset
                                   Bay, R. I. and Conn., and removal of Green Jacket Shoal,
                                  Providence River, R. I. In temporary charge of prelimi-
                                  nary examinations of Falmouth and Menemsha harbors of
                                  refuge, and Cottage City Harbor, Mass., and Little Narra-
                                  gansett Bay, entrance to the wharfs at Watch Hill, R. I.
                                  In temporary charge of preliminary examinations and sur-
                                  veys of Vineyard Haven and New Bedford harbors, and
                                  Taunton River, Mass. In temporary charge of survey of
                                  Taunton River, Mass. Temporarily a member of advis-
                                  ory counsel to the Rhode Island State board of harbor
                                  commissioners.
William H. Heuer ......         In charge of Forts Jefferson and Taylor, Fla., and Jackson,
                                   St. Philip, Livingston, Pike, and Macomb, Tower Du-
                                  pr6, Battery Bienvenue, and Tower at Proctorsville, La.,
                                  In charge of the improvement of Humboldt Harbor and
                                  Bay, Cal. In charge of the improvement of the Sacra-
                                  mento, Feather, San Joaquin, and Mokelumne rivers, and
                                  Petaluma Creek, Cal. In charge of the improvement of
                                  the Amite, Tangipahoa, Tickfaw, Tchefuncte,Bogue Falia,
                                  and Calcasieu rivers, Bayous Terrebonne, Teche, Black,
                                  and Courtableau, arid Calcasieu Pass, La., Bayou Pierre,
                                  Miss., Sabine Pass, Blue Buck Bar, and Neches River,
                                  Tex., and Sabine River, La. and Tex., and of removal of
                                  obstructions in Bayou La Fourche, La. In charge of con-
                                  necting Bayou Teche with Grand Lake at Charenton, La.
                                  In charge of preliminary examinations of Bayou Rouge,
                                  Bogue Falia from present landing to Covington, bar ob-
                                  structing mouth of Calcasieu River, Bayou Terrebonne
                                  from Houma to Thibodeaux, and Bayou Teche from St.
                                  Martinsville to Fort Barre, mouth of Bayou La Fourch,
                                  with view to construction of a lock and dam, Bayou La
332        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Statement showing rank and duties of offcers of Corps of Engineers-Cont'd.


    RANK AND NAME.                                         DUTIES.

                             I
          MAJORS.
       (continued.)
                                   Fourche to secure navigation at low water, and Bayou
                                   Vermillion to secure navigation from Abbeville to the
                                   Louisiana and Texas Railroad Bridge, La. In charge of
                                   preliminary examinations and surveys of mouth of Bayou
                                   Plaquemine, Bayou Plaquemine and other connecting
                                   streams, and Calcasieu Pass, La.       To report upon the
                                   depth and width of a channel secured and maintained by
                                   jetties constructed by James B. Eads at the mouth of the
                                   Mississippi River. Member of Board of Engineer Officers
                                   on subject of permanent improvement of Delaware River
                                    and Bay. Engineer 7th, 8th, and 12th Light-house dis-
                                    tricts.
William S. Stanton----           Detached; Engineer 1st and 2d Light-house districts.
Thomas H. Handbnry-..            In charge of Fort Stevens, Oregon, and of the construction
                                    of Fort Canby, Wash. In charge of improvement of the
                                    harbors at Chicago and Calumet, Ill. In charge of the
                                    improvement of the Illinois and Calumet rivers. In charge
                                    of the improvement oftthe Columbia River at Cascades,
                                    Oregon, mouth of the Columbia River, Oregon and Wash. ;
                                    of the rivers Chehalis, Skagit, Stielaquamish, Nootsack,
                                    Snohomish, and Snoqualmie, Wash. In charge of water-
                                    gauges on the Columbia River from Astoria to the bar.
                                    In charge of survey of the Hennepin Canal. In charge of
                                    preliminary examination of Calumet River from forks of
                                    the river near its entrance into Lake Calumet to Blue Isl-
                                    and, and of Farm Creek, with view to changing its course,
                                    Ill. Member of Board of Engineer Officers to consider and
                                    report upon the construction of bridges across the Missouri
                                    River between its mouth and the mouth of Dakota or
                                    James River; across the Mississippi River between Saint
                                    Paul, Minn., and Natches, Miss.; and across the Illinois
                                    River between its mouth and La Salle, Ill. Engineer
                                    Officer, Division of the Missouri. Engineer 13th Light-
                                    house District.
James C. Post ..........         In charge of the Third Division, Office of the Chief of En-
                                   gineers. Member of Board of Engineer Officers on con-
                                   struction of the locks at the Cascades, Columbia River,
                                   Oregon.
James F. Gregory ......          Detached; Engineer 5th and 6th Light-house districts. En-
                                   gineer Secretary of the Light-house Board.
Henry M. Adams .......           On duty in Office of the Chief of Engineers. On duty un-
                                   der the direction of the Secretary of War. Member of
                                   Board of Engineer Officersito investigate and report upon
                                   all matters concerning the work in progress in connection
                                   with the " practical test of the flume invented by M. J.
                                   Adams," etc.
Charles E. L. B. DE'vis ..       In charge of the improvement of the harbors at Ashland,
                                   Wis., Ontonagon, Eagle Harbor, Marquette, Manistique,
                                   and Cedar River, Mich., Menomonee, Oconto, Pensaukee,
                                   Green Bay, Ahnepee, Kewaunee, Two Rivers, Manitowoc,
                                   Sheboygan, and Port Washington, Wis. In charge of
                                   harbors of refuge at entrance to Sturgeon Bay Canal, Lake
                                   Michigan, and Grand Marais, Mich. In charge of water-
                                   level observations on Lake Superior. In charge of the
                                   establishment and maintenance of harbor lines in Portage
                                   Lake, Mich.     In charge of preliminary examination of
                                   Torch Lake Channel, Lake Superior, Mich.
                      RANK AND        DUTIES OF OFFICERS.                            333
Statement showing rank and duties of officers of Corps of Engineers-Cont'd.

   RANK AND NAME.                                     DUTIES.

                          i



       CAPTAINS.


George M. Wheeler....       On temporary duty to supervise certain publications per-
                              taining to geograpical surveys west of the 100th merid-
                              ian. Retired from active service on June 15, 1888, in con-
                              formity with section 1251 Revised Statutes.
James  B. Quinn ........    In charge of the improvement of the harbors of Duluth,
                              Grand Marais, Agate Bay, Minn., and Superior Bay, on
                              Lake Superior, and St. Louis Bay, Wis. To exercise super-
                              vision over construction of bridge across the St. Louis
                              River between the States of Minnesota and Wisconsin.
Daniel W. Lockwood-...      In charge of the improvement of the harbors at Charlevoix,
                              Frankfort, Manistee, Ludington, Pentwater,White River,
                              Muskegon, Grand Haven, Black Lake, Saugatuck, South
                              Haven, and Saint Joseph, and harbor of refuge at Port-
                              age Lake, Mich., and harbor at Michigan City, Ind. In
                              charge of the improvement of Little Kanawha, Guyan-
                              dotte, and Buckhannon rivers, W. Va. ; Big Sandy River,
                              W. Va. and Ky., and Kentucky River, Ky. In charge
                              of preliminary examination of Grand River, Mich. In
                              charge of preliminary examinations and surveys of Pigeon
                              River; Carp River at Leland, for harbor of refuge ; Lake
                              Michigan at Empire, and Grand Traverse Bay, Mich.
                              To exercise supervision over the construction of the pro-
                              posed road of the Carrollton or Lock No. 1, Turnpike
                              Company, through the land of the United States at Lock
                              No. 1, Kentucky River, Ky. Member of Board of Engi-
                              neer Officers on proposed bridge across the OhioRiver
                              at Louisville, Ky.
Ernest H. Ruffner --- -- In charge of the improvement of the Mississippi River be-
                              tween Des Moines Rapids and the mouth of the Illinois
                              River. In charge of preliminary examination and survey
                              of bars in Hamburg Bay, Ill.
John C. Mallery ........    Detached; engineer 4th, 5th, and 6thLight-House districts.
Clinton B. Sears...      .. In charge of the improvement of the Yellowstone River,
                              Mont. and Dak.; and the Missouri Riverfrom Sioux City,
                              Iowa, to Fort Benton, Mont. In charge of preliminary
                               examination of James River, Dak. In charge of con-
                               struction and improvement of roads and bridges in Yel-
                              lowstone National Park; in charge of the 1st and 2d Di-
                               visions, Office of the Chief of Engineers.
Thomas Turtle......... In charge of the 4th and 5th Divisions, Office of the Chief
                               of Engineers.
Edward Maguire .......       Commanding Company B, Battalion of Engineers. In-
                               structor of Military Engineering at the Engineer School
                               of Application. Secretary of Board of Officers and Ci-
                               vilians to examine and report at what ports fortifications,
                               or other defenses are most urgently required, etc. Mem-
                              ber of Boards of Engineer Officers on construction of
                               bridges across Staten Island Sound (known as Arthur
                               Kill), and the Kill Von Kull, and to report upon the "Auto-
                               Mobile Controllable Torpedo," of Mr. J. N. II. Patrick.
                               Member of General Courts-martial convened at Willets
                               Point, N. Y., August 5; November 3, 1887; February 24
                              and March 29, 1888.
Frederick A. Mahan ....    In charge of the improvement of the harbors at Erie, Pa.,
                              and Buffalo, Wilson, Olcott, Oak Orchard, and Dunkirk,
                              N. Y. In charge of improvement of Niagara River, N. Y.
                              In charge of preliminary examinations and surveys of
                              Tonawanda Harbor and Niagara River between Black
                              Rock and Tonawanda, N. Y. In charge of survey of the
                              peninsula and harbor at Erie, Pa.
334      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Statement showing rank and duties of oficers of Corps of Engineers-Contd.

   RANK AND NAME.                                 DUTIES.

                       i



       CAPTAINS.
      (continued.)
Charles F. Powell.      In charge of Fort Stevens, Oregon, and of the construction of
                          Fort Canby, Wash. In charge of the improvement of the
                          Columbia River at Cascades, Oregon, mouth of the Colum-
                          bia River, Oregon and Wash., entrance to Coos Bay, and
                          entrance to Yaquina Bay, and mouth of Coquille River,
                          Oregon. In charge of the improvement of the Umpqua
                          River, Oregon, and of the rivers Chehalis, Skagit, Stiel-
                          aquamish, Nootsack, Snohomish, and Snoqualmie, Wash.
                          In charge of water-gauges on the Columbia River, from
                          Astoria to the bar. In charge of preliminary examina-
                          tions of Nehalem Bay and Bar, Wood and Link rivers,
                          and Suislaw River and Bar, Oregon. In charge of pre-
                          liminary exanlinations and surveys of Tillamook Bay and
                          Bar, and Umpqua and Coquille rivers, Oregon. In charge
                          of survey of Tillamook Bay and Bar, Oregon. Engineer
                          13th Light-house District. Detached ; Secretary and Dis-
                          bursing Officer of the Mississippi River Commission cre-
                          ated by act of Congress approved June 28, 1879. Sec-
                          retary and assistant to the Construction Committee of
                           the Mississippi River Commission and Disbursing Officer
                          for works carried on by the Commission.
Frederick A. Hinman... In charge of the improvement of the harbor at Norfolk, and
                          the approach to Norfolk Harbor and the United States
                          Navy-yard, Va. In charge of the improvement of the
                          Blackwater, Nottoway, Archer's Hope, and Appomattox
                          rivers, Va., and Meherrin River, Currituck Sound, Coan-
                          jok and Edenton bays, and North River Bar, N. C., and
                          North Landing River, Va. and N. C. In charge of pre-
                          liminary examination of Alligator River, N. C. In charge
                           of preliminary examination and survey of Nansemond
                           River, Va. On sick leave of absence.
Albert H. Payson ...-. In charge of the improvement of Humboldt Harbor and Bay,
                           Cal. In charge of the improvement of the Sacramento,
                          Feather, San Joaquin, and Mokelumne rivers, and Pe-
                          taluma Creek, Cal., and Colorado River, Nev., Cal., and
                          Ariz. In charge of preliminary examinations of mouth of
                           Smith's River, and Crescent City Harbor with view to a
                           sea-wall from Battery Point to Flat Rock, Cal. Engineer
                           12th Light-house District. Resignation accepted by the
                           President, to take effect December 1, 1887.
John G. D. Knight .....Commanding Company A, Battalion of Engineers. In
                           charge of the construction of Fort Schuyler, N. Y. H. De-
                           tached; Instructor of Engineering at the United States
                           Infantry and Cavalry School. On temporary detached
                           service with New York State National Guard near Peeks-
                           kill, N. Y. Member of General Court-martial convened at
                           Willets Point, N. Y., November 3, 1867.
Richard L. Hoxie ...... In charge of Forts Pickens and McRee, and the construction
                           of Fort Barrancas and redoubt, Fla. In charge of the
                           improvement of Pensacola Harbor, Fla. In charge of the
                           improvement of the rivers Coosa and Chattahoochee, Ga.
                           and Ala., Ocmulgee, Oconee, Oostenaula, Coosawattee,
                           and Flint, Ga., Choctawhatchee, Escambia, and Cone-
                           cuh, Fla. and Ala., Alabama, Cahawba, and Tallapoosa,
                           Ala., Apalachicola River and Bay, and La.Grange Bayou,
                           Fla. In charge of resurvey of outer and inner bars at
                           Pensacola, Fla., and of examination and survey of Flint
                           River from Montezuma to Old Agency, Ga. In charge of
                           removal of wrecks of ship Bride of Lorne and bark Laigia
                           in Pensacola Harbor, Fla.
                     RANK AND DUTIES OF OFFICERS.                                 335
Statement showing rank and duties of oficers of Corps of Engineers--Cont'd.


   RANK AND NAME.                                   DUTIES.



       CAPTAINS.
      (continued.)
William L. Marshall. :.. In charge of the improvement of the harbors at Milwaukee,
                            Racine, and Kenosha, Wis., Waukegan, Chicago, and
                             Calumet, Ill., and harbor of refuge at Milwaukee Bay,
                             Wis. In charge of the improvement of the Fox, Wiscon-
                            sin, Illinois, and Calumet rivers. In charge of water-
                            level observations on Lake Michigan. In charge of sur-
                             vey of the Hennepin Canal. Engineer Officer, Division
                             of the Missouri. Member of Board of Engineer Officers to
                            investigate and report upon all matters concerning the
                             work in progress in connection with the "practical test of
                             the flume invented by M. J. Adams," etc.
Joseph H. Willard ...... In charge of the improvement of Tensas River and Bayou
                            Macon, and Cane River, La., Ouachita and Black River,
                            and Bayou Bartholomew in La. and Ark. Bayous Bcuf and
                            D'Arbonne, Loggy Bayou, Lake Bisteneau, and the Dor-
                            cheat, La. and Cypress Bayou, La. and Tex.; Red River,
                            La. and Ark., and South Forked Deer River, Tenn.; of
                            the rivers Big Sun Flower, Yazoo, Yallabusha, Big Black,
                            and Tallahatchie, and Tchula Lake, and Steel's Bayou,
                            Miss., and the Big Hatchie River, Tenn. In charge of
                            survey of Bayou Pierre, La. In charge of the water-
                            gauges on the Lower Mississippi River and its principal
                            tributaries. In charge of preliminary examinations of
                            the lakes connecting with Red River between Shreveport,
                            La., and Fulton, Ark., Little, Dugdemona, and Cornay
                            rivers, Ouachita River from Camden to mouth, Black,
                            Red, Kelley, Cypress, Rondeway, and Vidal bayous, Clear
                            and Black lakes, La., and Cassity Bayou, Miss., North
                            Fork of the Forked Deer River, Tenn., and re-examina-
                            tion of Ouachita above Camden, Ark. To supervise the
                            construction of the bridge across Yazoo River, near Green-
                            wood, Miss., and across Sunflower River, near Johnson-
                            ville, Miss.
Philip M. Price.........- Detached; on duty at the Military Academy as Instructor
                            of Practical Military Engineering, and in command of
                            Company E, Battalion of Engineers. In charge of water-
                            works and supply line, and Acting Signal Officer at West
                            Point, N. Y. To inspect the work upon the monument at
                            Washington's Headquarters, Newburgh, N. Y.
Carl F. Palfrey ..-----.  In charge of the construction of Forts Porter, Niagara, and
                            Ontario, N. Y. In charge of the improvement of the har-
                            bors at Charlotte, Pultneyville, Great Sodus, Little Sodus,
                            Oswego, and Sacketts Harbor, N. Y. In charge of water-
                            level observations on Lake Ontario.
William H. Bixby ...... In charge of Forts Macon and Caswell, N. C. In charge of
                            the improvement of Beaufort Harbor, N. C. and George-
                            town Harbor, S. C. In charge of the improvement of
                            Cape Fear River above and belbw Wilmington, Neuse,
                            Pamlico, Tar, Yadkin, Black, Trent, and New rivers,
                            and Contentnia or Moccasin River and inland water-way
                            from New Berne to Beaufort, and inland w,, er-way be-
                            tween Beaufort Harbor and New River, N. C., and San-
                            tee, Wateree, Great Pee Dee, Waccamaw and Congaree
                            rivers, and Winyaw Bay, S. C. In charge of preliminary
              *             examinations of Catawba River, and Yadkin River from
                            South Carolina line to the Narrows, N. C. In charge of
                            preliminary examinations and surveys of the rivers Lum-
                            ber and Lockwood's Folly, N. C., and Little Pee Dee, and
                            Alligator and other waters connecting Santee River and
                            Bull's Bay, S. C., and Mingo and Clark's creeks, S. C.
336         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Statement showing rank and duties of officers of Corps of Engineers-Cont'd.

   RANK AND      NAME.                                  DUTIES.



          CAPTAINS.
         (continued.)
Henry S. Taber.               In charge of the improvement of the Arkansas River-re-
                                moval of snags, etc.; Arkansas River at Pine Bluff, and
                                of rivers White and St. Francis, L'Anguille, and Saline,
                                Red above Fulton, Little Red and Petit Jean, Ark., Black,
                                Mo. and Ark., and of removal of rock shoals in Fourche
                                River, Ark. In charge of survey of Arkansas River from
                                Little Rock to its mouth. In charge of preliminary ex-
                                amination of Saline River, and re-examination of Little
                                River, Ark. In charge of preliminary examinations and
                                surveys of Cache River, Ark., Little River from Horners-
                                ville to its junction with the St. Francis River, and St.
                                Francis River from Greenville to the Arkansas State line,
                                Mo., and examination of Red River at railroad bridge,
                                Fulton, Ark.
Eric Bergland..........       Commanding Company C, Battalion of Engineers. In-
                                structor in civil engineering at the Engineer School of
                                Application.      Member of General Courts-Martial con-
                                vened at Willets Point, N. Y., August 5, 1887, and Jan-
                                uary 23, 1888. On leave of absence.
William T. Rossell .....     In charge of 3d District of the Mississippi River, from
                                mouth of White River to Warrenton, for the purpose of
                                improvement and the construction and repair of levees,
                                to include the improvement of the harbor at Vicksburg,
                                Miss. Member of Board of Engineer Officers on building
                                and repair of levees on the Mississippi River. In tem-
                                porary charge of First District of the Mississippi River,
                                from Cairo to foot of Island No. 40, and of 2d District from
                                foot of Island No. 40 to mouth of White River, for the pur-
                                pose of improvement and the construction and repair of
                                levees.
Thomas W. Symons ....        Detached; assistant to the Engineer Commissioner of the
                                District of Columbia.
Smnith   S. Leach ........   In charge of 1st District of the Mississippi River from Cairo
                                to foot of Island No. 40, and of 2d District from foot of
                                Island No. 40 to mouth of White River, for the purpose
                                of improvement and the construction andrepair of levees.
                                Secretary and Disbursing Officer of the Mississippi River
                                Commission created by act of Congress approved June 28,
                                1879. Member of Board of Engineer Officers on building
                                and repair of levees on the Mississippi River. Detached ;
                                assistant to the Engineer Commissioner of the District
                                of Columbia.
Dan C. Kingman.......        In charge of 4th District of the Mississippi River, from War-
                                renton to Head of the Passes, forthe purpose of improve-
                                ment and the construction and repair of levees, to include
                                levees and special work on the river, the improvement of
                                the harbor at New Orleans, the Mississippi River at Nat-
                                chez and Vidalia, the mouth of Red River, and the recti-
                                fication of the Red and Atchafalaya rivers at mouth of Red
                                River. Member of Board of Engineer Officers on proposed
                                bridge across the Mississippi River at Memphis, Tenn.
                                Member of Board of Engineer Officers on building and re-
                                pair of levees on the Mississippi River.
Eugene Griffin........       Detached; assistant to the Engineer Commissioner of the
                                District of Columbia. On temporary duty in office of the
                                Chief of Engineers. On leave of absence.
Willard Young .........      In charge of the improvement of Umpqua River, mouth of
                               Coquille River, and entrances to Coos and Yaquina bays,
                               Oregon. In charge of preliminary examinations and sur-
                               veys of Umpqua and Coquille rivers, Oregon. In tempor-
                      RANK AND DUTIES OF OFFICERS.                                    337
Statement showing rank and duties of officers of Corps of Engineers-Cont'd.

   RANK AND NAME.                                       DUTIES.

                          I

       CAPTAINS.
      (continued.)
                                ary charge of the improvement of the Upper and Lower
                                Columbia and Snake rivers, Oregon and Wash.,Willamette
                                River above Portland, and Lower Willamette River below
                                Portland, Oreg., Cowlitz River, Wash., Yamhill River,
                                Oregon, and Lower Clearwater River, Idaho.
William M. Black ......       In charge of the construction of Fort Marion, Fla. In
                                charge of the improvement of the harbors at Key West,
                                Tampa Bay, and Cedar Keys, Fla. In charge of the im-
                                provement of the Saint John's River (at channel over
                                bar at mouth, and Upper Saint John's River), Volusia
                                Bar, Caloosahatchee, Manatee, Withlacoochee, and Su-
                                wanee rivers, and Pease Creek, Fla. In charge of exami-
                                nation and survey of entrance to harbor at Key West, Fla.
                                In charge of resurvey of Tampa Bay, including Hillsbor-
                                ough River up to Tampa, and ofpreliminary examinations
                                of Charlotte Harbor, including San Carlos Bay, Clear
                                Water Harbor, including Anclote and Saint Joseph's bays,
                                and narrows into Boga Ciega Bay; Wakulla River, from
                                mouth to Wakulla Springs; and of survey of channel
                                from Haul-over on Indian River to Gilbert's Bar, Fla.
                                In charge of preliminary examinations and surveys of
                                Punta Rassa Harbor, and Saint Augustine for deep-sea
                                channel on the outer bar, Fla. In charge of surveys of
                                Punta Rassa Harbor, and Saint Augustine for deep-sea
                                 channel on the outer bar, Fla. In charge of removal
                                 of wrecks of Transport, Maple Leaf, and German brig
                                from Saint John's River, between its mouth and Lake
                                George.
Walter L. Fisk ........       Detached; on duty at the Military Academy as Assistant
                                Professor of Civil and Military Engineering. On tempo-
                                rary duty in the office of the Chief of Engineers. In charge
                                of Forts Jefferson and Taylor, Fla., and Jackson, St.
                                Philip, Livingston, Pike, and Macomb, Tower Duprd,
                                Battery Bienvenue, and Tower at Proctorsville, La. In
                                charge of the improvement of the Amite, Tangipahoa,
                                Tickfaw, Tchefuncte, Bogue Falia, and Calcasieu rivers,
                                bayous Terrebonne, Teche, Black and Courtableau, and
                                 Calcasieu Pass, La.; Bayou Pierre, Miss.; Sabine Pass,
                                 Blue Buck Bar, and Neches River, Tex.; and Sabine
                                 River, La. and Tex., and of removal of obstructions in
                                 bayou La Fourche, La. In charge of connecting Bayou
                                 Teche with Grand Lake at Charenton, La. To report
                                upon the depth and width of a channel secured and main-
                                 tained by jetties constructed by James B. Eads at the
                                 mouth of the Mississippi River. Engineer 7th and 8th
                                 Light-house districts.
Solomon W. Roessler...        Adjutant and Treasurer of the Battalion of Engineers and
                                 Post of Willets Point, and Signal Officer and Recruiting
                                 Officer, Post of Willets Point. Commanding Companies
                                 A and D, Battalion of Engineers. Inspector of Rifle Prac-
                                 tice, Battalion of Engineers. In charge of the library of
                                 the Engineer School of Application. Acting Battalion Q.
                                 M., A. A. Q. M., and A. C. S., Post of Willets Point. In-
                                 structor in Submarine Mining at the Engineer School of
                                 Application. Member of Board of Engineer Officers to
                                 report upon the " Auto-Mobile Controllable Torpedo." of
                                 Mr. J. N. H. Patrick. Member of General Courts-Martial
                                 convened at Willets Point, N. Y., January 23 and March
                                 29, 1888.
         ENG 88-22
338       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Statement showing rank and duties of officers of Corps ofEngineers-Cont'd.

   RANK   AND NAME.                                  DUTIES.


       CAPTAINS.
      (continued.)
George McC. Derby ....     In charge of the improvement of Keyport Harbor.       In
                             charge of the improvement of the rivers Shewsbury,
                             Rahway, Elizabeth, Manasquan, South, Raritan, and
                             Passaic above and below Newark, and Woodbridge,
                             Cheesequakes, and Mattawan creeks, N. J. On duty under
                             the immediate orders of Lieutenant-Colonel McFarland.
  FIRST LIEUTENANTS.

James L. Lusk.........   Detached; Secretary and Disbursing Officer of the Mis-
                           sissippi River Commission created by act of Congress
                           approved June 28, 1879. Secretary and assistant to the
                           Construction Committee of the Mississippi River Commis-
                           sion and Disbursing Officer for works carried on by the
                           Commission. Detached; assistant to the Engineer Com-
                           missioner of the Disrict of Columbia,
Frederic V. Abbot ...     On duty under the immediate orders of Colonel Gillmore.
                           On duty under the immediate orders of Colonel Abbot.
                           In charge of Forts Moultrie, Sumter, and Johnson, and of
                           the construction of Castle Pinckney, S. C. In charge of
                           the improvement of the harbor at Charleston, S. C. In
                           charge of the improvement of the Ashley, Edisto, and Sal-
                           kiehatchie rivers and Wappoo Cut, S.C. In charge of
                           preliminary examination of North Fork of the Edisto
                           River, S. C. In charge of removal of wreck of trading
                           boat in Cheehaw River, and of wreck of steamer Alice
                           Clark from the channel of inside passage below Charles-
                           ton, S.C.
Thomas L. Casey .....    Detached ; Engineer Officer Division of the Pacific and De-
                           partment of California. On duty under the immediate
                           orders of Major Livermore.
Theodore A. Bingham . Detached ; Secretary and Disbursing Officer of the Missouri
                           River Commission, created by act of Congress approved
                           July 5, 1884. Recorder of Board of Engineer Officers to
                           consider and report upon the construction of bridges
                           across the Missouri River between its mouth. and the
                           mouth of Dakota or James River; across the Mississippi
                           River between St. Paul, Minn., and Natchez, Miss., and
                           across the Illinois River between its mouth and La Salle, Ill.
Curtis McD. Townsend.- On duty under the immediate orders of Major Lydecker.
                           Recorder of Board of Engineer Officers on construction of
                           locks at the Cascades, Columbia River, Oreg.
Gustav J. Fiebeger.... Detached; on duty at the Military Academy as Assistant
                           Professor of Civil and Military Engineering. Member of
                           General Court-martial convened at West Point, N. Y.,
                           September 9, 1887.
Oberlin M. Carter ...... On duty under the immediate orders of Colonel Gillmore.
                           On duty under the immediate orders of Colonel Abbot.
                           In charge of Forts Oglethorpe and Pulaski, Ga., and
                           Clinch, Fla. In charge of the improvement of the har-
                            bors at Savannah and Brunswick, Ga. In charge of the
                            improvement of Cumberland Sound, Ga. and Fla., Savai.-
                            nah and Altamaha rivers, and Romerly Marsh, Ga.
George W. Goethals. -.... Detached; on duty at the Military Academy in Department
                            of Civil and Military Engineering.
John Mi]lis .........-.. Detached; on temporary duty as Engineer of the 3d Light-
                            house District. On duty under the immediate orders of
                            Major Heal).
John Biddle ...........   Detached; Engineer Officer Department of Dakota. On
                            duty as Assistant Instructor of Practical Military Engi-
                            neering at the Military Academy, and with Company E,
                            Battalion of Engineers.     Recruiting Officer for Company
                            E, Battalion of Engineers.
                     RANK AND DUTIES          OF OFFICERS.                     339
Statement showing rank and duties of officers of Corpsof Engineers-Cont'd.

   RANK AND   NAME.                               DUTIES.



  FIRST LIEUTENANTS.
      (continued.)
Harry F. Hodges.......   On duty under the immediate orders of Lieutenant-Colonel
                           Poe.
James G. Warren ...... Detached ; on duty as Assistant Instructor of Practical Mili-
                           tary Engineering at the Military Academy,and with Com-
                          pany E, Battalion of Engineers. Officer in charge of
                          Post Schools, and Recruiting Officer for Company E, Bat-
                          talion of Engineers. Adjutant and Treasurer of the Bat-
                          talion of Engineers and Post of Willets Point. and Signal
                           Officer and Recruiting Officer, Post of Willets Point.
                          Commanding Company D, Battalion of Engineers. In-
                           spector of Rifle Practice, Battalion of Engineers. In
                           charge of property pertaining to the Library of the En-
                           gineer School of Application.
Edward Burr........... On duty under the immediate orders of Captain Powell.
                           On duty under the immediate orders of Major Handbury.
Oscar T. Crosby ........ On duty under the immediate orders of Major Heuer. On
                           leave of absence. Resignation accepted by the President,
                           to take effect October 22, 18n7.
Lansing H. Beach...... On duty under the immediate orders of Lieutenant-Colonel
                           Merrill. Member and Disbursing Officer of Commission
                           to run and mark the boundary lines between a portion of
                           the Indian Territory and the State of Texas. Member of
                           Board of Engineer Officers to consider and prepare gen-
                           eral regulations concerning the erection of bridges over
                           the Muskingum River, Ohio.
Graham D. Fitch....... On duty under the immediate orders of Captain Marshall.
Eugene J. Spencer ..... On duty under the immediete orders of Major Stickney.
                           Detached; on duty at the Military Academy in Depart-
                           ment of Chemistry, Mineralogy, and Geology. Member
                           of General Con rt-martial convened at West Point, N. Y.,
                           September 9, 1887.
George A. Zinn-......... On duty under the immediate orders of Major Ernst. On
                           leave of absence.
William C. Langfitt .... Detached; Engineer Officer Department of the Columbia.
                           Member of General Court-martial convened at Vancouver
                           Barracks, Wash., April 23, 188?.
Henry E. Waterman....-- On duty under the immediate orders of Lieutenant-Colonel
                           Barlow. Recorder of Boards of Engineer Officers upon
                           plan an estimate for a lock at or near Lower Island at
                           Nashville, for improving Cumberland River, Tenn.; and
                           to consider and recommend a plan for the improvement
                           of the navigation at the mouth of the Cumberland River.
Irving Hale ............ Quartermaster Battalion of Engineers. Acting Assistant
                           Quartermaster and Acting Commissary of Subsistence,
                           Post of Willets Point. Instructor in Military Photogra-
                           phy at the Engineer School of Application. Member of
                           Board of Engineer Officers to report upon the "Auto-Mo-
                           bile Controllable Torpedo " of Mr. J. N. H. Patrick. Mem-
                           ber of General Court-martial convened at Willets Point,
                           N. Y., February 24, 1888.
James C. Sanford....... On duty under the immediate orders of Lieutenant-Colonel
                           Houston, In temporary charge of the improvement of
                           Keyport Harbor. In temporary charge of the improve-
                           ment of the rivers Shrewsbury, Rahway, Elizabeth,
                           Manasquan, South, Raritan, and Passaic above and be-
                           low Newark, and Woodbridge, Cheesequakes, and Mat-
                           tawan creeks, N. J.
Hiram M. Chittenden-...- On duty with Company B, Battalion of Engineers. De-
                           tached; Engineer Officer Department of the Platte.
340       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Statement showing rank and duties of oficers of Corps of'Engineers-Cont'd.


    RANK AND NAME.                                       DUTIES.

                            i



  FIRST LIEUTENANTS.
       (continued.)

Cassius E. Gillette......       On duty under the immediate orders of Lieutenant-Colonel
                                  Merrill. Recorder of Boards of Engineer Officers to con-
                                  sider and prepare general regulations concerning the
                                  erection of bridges over the Muskingum River, Ohio, and
                                  on proposed bridge across the Mississippi River at Mem-
                                  phis, Tenn.
David DuB. Gaillard....         On duty under the immediate orders of Captain Black.
Harry Taylor............        On duty under the immediate orders of Captain Bixby.
William L. Sibert.......        On duty with Company C, Battalion of Engineers. On duty
                                 under the immediate orders of Major Stickney. On duty
                                 under the immediate orders of Captain Lockwood. Re-
                                 corder of Boards of Engineer Officers to examine and
                                 report upon plan and location of proposed bridge across
                                 the Ohio River between Cincinnati, Ohio, and Newport,
                                 Ky., and to examine and report upon the plans of the pro-
SECOND LIEUTENANTS.             posed bridge across the Ohio River at Louisville, Ky.
Joseph E. Kuhn ........  On duty with and in temporary command of Company B,
                           Battallion of Engineers. Ordnance Officer Post of Wil-
                           lets Point. Under instruction at the Engineer School of
                           Application. On duty under the immediate orders of
                           Major Mansfield. Recorder of Board of Engineer Officers
                           to consider and report upon location and plans of bridge
                           across the Mississippi River at Dubuque, Iowa. Judge-
                           Advocate of General Courts-martial convened at Willets
                           Point, N. Y., August 5, 1887, and March 29, 1888. Member
                           of General Court-martial convened at Willets Point, N. Y.,
                           January 23, 1888.
William E. Craighill.... On duty with Company A, Battalion of Engineers. Under
                           instruction at the Engineer School of Application. On
                           temporary detached service at Fort Niagara, N. Y. Re-
                           corder of Board of Engineer Officers to consider and re-
                           port upon the improvement of the Mississippi River from
                           Des Moines Rapids to the mouth of the Illinois River.
                           Member of General Courts-martial convened at Willets
                           Point, N. Y., August 5, November 3, 1887, and Jaunary
                           23, 1888. Judge-Advocate of General Court-martial con-
                           vened at Willets Point, N. Y., February 24, 1888.
Henry C. Newcomer ....   On duty with and in temporary command of Company C,
                           Battalion of Engineers. Under instruction at the Engi-
                           neer School of Application. Member of General Courts-
                           martial convened at Willets Point, N. Y., August 5, 1887;
                           January 23, and March 29, 1888.
Mason M. Patrick ...... On duty with Company A, Battalion of Engineers. Under
                           instruction at the Engineer School of Application. Mem-
                           ber of General Courts-martial convened at Willets Point,
                           N. Y., August 5, 1887; January 23, and March 29, 1888.
                           Judge-Advocate of General Court-martial convened at
                           Willets Point, N. Y., November 3, 1887.
Charles S. Rich6 ....    On duty with Company B, Battalion of Engineers. Under
                           instruction at the Engineer School of Application. Mem-
                           ber of General Courts-martial convened at Willets Point,
                           N. Y., August 5 and November 3, 1887, and February 24,
                           1888. Judge-Advocate of General Court-martial con-
                           vened at Willets Point, N. Y., March 29, 1888.
Thomas H. Rees........ On duty with Company A, Battalion of Engineers. Under
                           instruction at the Engineer School of Application. Mem-
                           ber of General Courts-martial convened at Willets Point,
                           N. Y., August 5, 1887, and March 29, 1888. Judge-Advo-
                           cate of General Courts-martial convened at Willets Point,
                           N. Y., January 23 and March 29, 18-8.
                          RANK AND       DUTIES OF OFFICERS.                          341
Statement showing rank and duties ofofficers of Corpsof Engineers-Cont'd.

    RANK AND NAME.                                       DUTIES.

                            i



SECOND LIEUTENANTS.
        (continued.)
Charles L. Potter......  On duty with Company C, Battalion of Engineers. Under
                          instruction at the Engineer School of Application. Mem-
                          ber of General Courts-martial convened at Willets Point,
                          N. Y., August 5, November 3, 1887, and February 24, 1888.
Francis R. Shunk ...... On duty with Company B, Battalion of Engineers. Under
                          instruction at the Engineer School of Application. Mem-
                          ber of General Courts-martial convened at Willets Point,
                          N. Y., November 3, 1887; February 24 and March 29, 1888.
James J. Meyler-........ On duty with Company C, Battalion of Engineers. Under
                          instruction at the Engineer School of Application. Mem-
                          ber of General Courts-martial convened at Willetts Point,
                          N. Y., November 3, 1887; February 24 and March 29, 1888.
Eugene W.Van C. Lucas. To report to the Commanding Officer, Battalion of Engi-
                          neers, for duty with the battalion.
       U. S. AGENTS.

S. T. Abert ...........         In charge of the improvement of the harbor at Breton Bay,
                                  Leonardtown, and at entrance of Saint Jerome Creek,
                                  Md. In charge of the improvement of the rivers Rappar
                                  hannock, Chickahominy, Mattaponi, Totusky, York, Pa-
                                  munkey, and Staunton, Va., Roanoke and French Broad,
                                  N. C., and Dan, Va. and N. C.; of channel in Potomac
                                  River through flats in front of landing at Mount Vernon,
                                  and of Neabsco, Nomini, and Urbana creeks, Va. In
                                  charge of preliminary examinations of Mattox and Hunt-
                                  er's creeks, Va. In charge of preliminary examinations
                                  and surveys of Patuxent River from Benedict to Hill's
                                  Landing, Md., and Roanoke River from Clarkesville, Va.,
                                  to Eaton Falls, N. C. In charge of survey of Patuuxent
                                  River from Benedict to HIill's Landing, Md. In charge
                                  of removal of wreck of schooner Spray in Rappahannock
                                  River below Fredericksburg, and of the removal of three
                                  wrecks from Mattaponi River, Va.
William F. Smith ......         In charge of the improvement of the habor at Wilmington,
                                  and ice-harbor at New Castle, Del. In charge of the im-
                                  provement of the Maurice River, N. J., Broadkiln, Indian,
                                  Nanticoke, and St. Jones rivers, Duck, Mispillion, and
                                  Broad creeks, Del., Susquehanna River above and below
                                  Havre de Grace; of the Chester, Wicomico, Choptank,
                                  and Pocomoke rivers, Corsica Creek, upper thoroughfare
                                  at Deil's Island, Md, and inland water-way from Chinco
                                  teague Bay, Va., to Delaware Bay at or near Lewes, Del.
                                  In charge of preliminary examinations and surveys of
                                  Duck Creek, Del.; Cambridge Harbor and Fairlee Creek,
                                  Md. In charge of removal of wreck of steamer in Broad-
                                  kiln River, Del.
U. S. CIVIL ENGINEER.

M. Meigs...............         On duty under the immediate orders of Major Mackenzie.
         APPENDIXES

                TO TIHE




REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,
       UNITED   STATES ARMY.




                               343
                        APPENDIXES
                                      TO THE




          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,
                            UNITED STATES ARMY.




                   FORTIFICATIONS, ETC.



                            APPENDIX           No.   i.




POST OF WILLETS POINT, NEW YORK-ENGINEER SCHOOL OF APPLL
       CATION-BATTALION OF ENGINEERS-ENGINEER DEPOT.




ANNUAL REPORT OF MAJ.OR WILETAM R. KING, CORPS OF ENGINEERS,
OFFICER IN COMMAND, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR EVNDIXG JUNE 30,
  1888.
                         UNITED STATES ENGINEER SCHOOL,
                           Post of Willets Point, N. 4., July 27, 1888.
  GENERAL : I have the honor to submit the following annual report
on the Post of Willets Point, N. Y., the United States Engineer School,
the Battalion of Engineers, and the Engineer )epot.

                          POST OF WILLETS POINT.

   At the close of the fiscal year the garrison consisted of 20 commis-
sioned officers and 352 enlisted men (for roster and changes during the
year see report of the battalion commander herewith), including the fol-
lowing general staff and artillery officers:
Maj. J. C. G. Happersett, surgeon, U. S. Army.
Capt. E. C. Carter, assistant surgeon, U. S. Army.
Capt. C. P. Miller. assistant quartermaster, U. S. Army.
First Lieut. John Pope, jr., First U. S. Artillery.
Second Lieut. Thomas Ridgway, Fifth U. S. Artillery.
Second Lieut. Charles F. Parker, Second U. S. Artillery.
  Captain Miller was assigned to duty as post quartermaster in Jan-
uary, 1888, and relieved July 1, 1888.
                                                                345
346     REPORT   OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The three officers of artillery were assigned to duty at the post in
November, 1887, for special instruction in the torpedo service, and re-
lieved on the 1st of July, 1888.
   The improvements referred to in my last annual report as having
been begun by the Quartermaster's Department, have been completed
as follows:
   I. The introduction of an adequate water supply; this was arranged
for by a contract with the village of Flushing, N. Y., which secured the
laying of mains to the line of the reservation and the daily supply of
60,000 gallons of water, which was tested and found to be of excellent
quality. The entire labor of laying the mains and service-pipes upon
the reservation was done by the enlisted men of the garrison. Over 2
miles of pipe was laid; also two 6-inch water meters, eight 6 inch gates.
two 4-inch gates, and fourteen fire hydrants, at a total cost for labor and
material of $ 7,037.73. (For full details see report of post quartermaster,
forwarded February 8, 1888.)*
   II. The introduction of an adequate system of sewerage. This, also-,
has been done entirely by soldier labor. Over 6,000 feet of sewer-pipe
was thus laid.
   III. The necessary plumbing for sanitary purposes in barracks and
quarters done by contract at a cost of about $7,200. This includes bath-
tubs, water-closets, etc., in fifteen buildings.
   IV. The double set of quarters for officers and the new hospital build-
ing, both of which are now in use.
   The quartermaster's department has also furnished the material for
putting down a system of brick walks. The labor is being done by en-
listed men. This is a very desirable improvement to the I)ost, as it was
difficult to keep some of the walks in a passable condition in wet
weather.
   I would again earnestly recommend the following additional improve-
ments, which are greatly needed for the proper and economical adimin-
istration of affairs at the post, viz:
   I. The new barracks recommended in last two annual reports and by
a special board of officers, and for which plans and specifications have
been submitted, are much needed. The old barracks, built of a combi-
nation of old and new materials many years ago, require more and more
repairs from year to year, and their location, which was determined by
certain unfortunate limitations, can be greatly improved. They were
built when the companies were about half their present size, and are now
overcrowded, although the number of men is still below the limit pro-
vided by law.
   The estimate for this purpose comes within the province of the Quar-
termaster's Department, and was submitted to Congress (House Ex.
Doe. 277, Fiftieth Congress, first session).
   II. As stated in last annual report, the quartermaster and commis-
sary warehouses, coal-yard, etc., are located at the extreme end of the
post, and as far as possible from the wharf on which all stores and sup-
plies must be landed. The extra cost of hauling coal, every ton of
which has to be hauled nearly a mile further than is necessary, would
alone be a sufficient reason for changing the location. Plans, specifica-
tions, and estimates for a suitable building to be located near the
quartermaster's wharf, prepared by the post quartermaster and acting
commissary of subsistence, have been sent in, and are again respect-
fully recommended for favorable consideration.
                                SOmitted.
                APPENDIX       i--REPORT      OF   MAJOR   KING.                 347
   III. " The reservation is bounded on the west by a salt marsh, with
a sluggish lagoon in the middle, and at low tide there is nothing to pre-
vent unauthorized persons from entering or leaving the post without
passing the guard-house, especially at night or in case of heavy fogs,
which often prevail. I believe it was a part of the original design for
the land defense of this place to clean out and deepen this lagoon and
extend a broad ditch as far as the main road leading past the guard-
house.    This could be done without any great expense if a small
dredging machine could be borrowed from some of the Government
works in the vicinity when not needed for other purposes. This work,
if done, would greatly improve the sanitary condition of the post, and
would, at the same time, reclaim considerable land, which is greatly
needed for post gardens and for a target-range. The present range is
too low and can not be used for skirmish-firing."
   This would also make a suitable harbor for laying up our boats in
winter where they will be protected from ice and storms.
   IV. The soldiers' laboratory destroyed by fire in November, 1886,
should be rebuilt as soon as possible. A clause appropriating money
for this purpose has been inserted in the bill making appropriations for
the support of the Army for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.
Should this become available, the work could begin at once.
   V. A suitable building should be provided for the collection of en-
gineering models referred to in last two annual reports. The present
building is an old, leaky, frame structure erected during the war, and
very inconveniently located. It is not worth repairing. A suitable
fire-proof building can be built for about $8,000.
   The sanitary condition of the post (luring the year has been quite sat-
isfactory, and with the recent improvements in the sewerage and water
supply, there should be little to complain of in the future. ,
   Only four deaths occurred at the post during the year; two from ac-
cidental drowning, one (a civilian) from consumption, and one from
acute bronchitis.   One soldier belonging to the post died of sunstroke
at Newton, L. I., while absent without leave.

                  ENGINEER          SCHOOL OF APPLICATION.

   The scope and object of the school have been fully set forth in pre-
vious reports and in the order establishing it on its present basis; the
orders issued in pursuance of the latter arranging the details of the sea-
son's work are appended, marked A, B, and C.
   Duiing the past year a class of two engineer officers coml)leted the
full course of three years, and a class of three artillery officers com-
pleted the seven-months' course in torpedo instruction and were relieved
July 1, 1888.
   The following tabular statement shows the constitution of each
class, the subjects in which they have received instruction, and their
marks in each subject for the year, the maximum in all cases being 3.
These marks are the mean of marks awarded at examinations held as
follows: January 3, February 1, March 3, April 3, and May 3, 1888.

                     Third   inter's class.                    Civil        Military
                                                            engineering.   engineering.


Second Lient. J. E Kuhn, Engineers ....-.......................
                                                           ....... 2.80      2.80
Second Lieut. W. E. Craighill. Engineers .... ..............................
                                                                   2.61      2.76
348          REPORT            OF    THE      CHIEF        OF        ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                        Second winter's class.                               Civil             Military        Military
                                                                          engineering,       engineering,    photography.


Second   Lieut.   H.   C. Newcomer, Engineers ................                       2 83            2. 80            3.0
Second   Lieut.   M.    M. Patrick, Engineers- .................                     2. 76           2. 70            3.0
Second   Lieut.   C.   S. Riche, Engineers ......................                    2.20            2. 40            2. 8
Second   Lieut.   T.   H. Rees, En iuneers .......................                   2.73            2. 75            2.9
Second   Lieut.   C.   L. Potter, Engineers ....................                     2. 65           2. 50            3. 0


                             First winter's class.                                 Torpedoes.     Essays.     Surveying.


First Lieut. John Pope, jr., First Artillery ..................                          2. 66          3. 0..
Second Lieut. Thomas Ridgway, Fifth Artillery.................                           2.76           3.0 ..
Second Lieut. C. F. Parker, Second Artillery .............          ...       ..         2.85           3.0 ..
Second Lieut. C. L. Potter, Engineers ..      .......................       .            2.93           2. 8..
Second Lieut. F. R. Shunk, Engineers ........................                            2.79           3.0          2.54
Second Lieut. J. J. Meyler, Engineers .............             ... ......... .          2.75           2.8          2.67



   I. The library of the school is under the immediate charge of the post
adjutant, and has received many valuable additions during the year in
the way of standard scientific works and periodicals.
   The appropriation asked for to keep the library up to the proper
standard during the next fiscal year is $500, which is respectfully rec-
ommended.
   II. Under authority of the Chief of Engineers it has been arranged
for the officers on duty here to visit several manufacturing establish-
ments in and around New York for the purpose of inspecting machinery
and witnessing such mechanical operations and processes as were thought
to be of professional interest.
   The Brooklyn Navy-Yard, Continental Iron Works, and the Ordnance
Proving Grsunds at Sandy Hook have already been visited, and it is
proposed to visit other works as soon as arrangements can be made for
the purpose.
   III. As post and battalion orders have been accumulating here for
the past twenty-three years, many having become obsolete or inopera-
tive from frequent amendment, the post adjutant has, under my direc-
tion, compiled and consolidated into a single post order all that appear
to be desirable for the proper regulation and administration of the post.
   IV. Attention is again invited to the fact that a much larger number
of artillery officers could be accommodated here, and the cost of instruct-
ing two or three times the number recently detailed for the torpedo
course would be hardly appreciable.
   If a sufficient number of artillery officers can not be spared, it is re-
spectfully recommended that details be made from the cavalry and in-
fantry of officers who take an interest in such matters, and preferably
of those who desire the detail. It is thought that if an opportunity was
offered them to express their preferences in this matter enough would
signify their willingness to undertake the seven-months' course to ena-
ble the War Department to select a proper number from for the detail.
   V. Although not a matter of very great importance, I would respect-
fully recommend that the official designation of this establishment be
abbreviated to ' 'United States Engineer School." This would be uni-
                   "
form with ' Artillery School," "Cavalry School," etc., and would be
much shorter than the present title, which reads "Engineer School of
Application of the Army of the United States." The word " applica-
tion" besides being unnecessary is not altogether appropriate, as there
are several theoretical branches of study included in the course.
  VI. It is thought that the comfort and convenience of enlisted men
                APPENDIX      1-REPORT        OF MAJOR KING.           349
will be greatly improved by starting what is known as a post canteen
for them, and the post council has been requested to formulate a plan
for making the experiment. There will be no expense attached to it,
as it can be accommodated in one of the old buildings not needed for
any other purpose, and the proceeds of sales and other sources of rev-
enue, which now go to the post trader and outside parties, ought to pay
all expenses and leave quite a revenue for post and company funds, ap-
plicable to the soldiers' mess allowances.

                         BATTALION      OF ENGINEERS.

    The law provides for five companies of engineer troops, having an
authorized strength of 752 enlisted men, officered by details from the
Corps of Engineers. At present only four companies, with a total
strength of 450 enlisted men, are allowed to be recruited.
    The aggregate strength of the battalion on June 30, 1888, was 15
commissioned officers and 388 enlisted men.
    During the past year Companies A, B, C have been stationed at
Willets Point. Company D exists only in name. Company E has been
'stationed at West Point to assist in the practical instruction of cadets
of the Military Academy in building military bridges, sapping, mining,
and signaling.
    The following is a roster of officers serving with the battalion on June
30, 1888, viz:
  Maj. W. R. King, Corps of Engineers, commanding.
  First Lieut. J. G. Warren, Corps of Engineers, adjutant.
  First Lieut. Irving Hale, Corps of Engineers, quartermaster.

                                    Company A.

  Capt. S. W. Roessler, Corps of Engineers, commanding company.
  Second Lieut. M. M. Patrick, Corps of Engineers, with company.
  Second Lieut. T. H. Rees, Corps of Engineers, with company.

                                    Company B.

  Capt. Edward Maguire, Corps of Engineers, commanding company.
  Second Lieut. Charles S. Rich6, Corps of Engineers, with company.
  Second Lieut. F. R. Shunk, Corps of Engineers, with company.

                                    Company C.

  Capt. Eric Bergland, Corps of Engineers, commanding company.
  Second Lieut. H. C. Newcomer, Corps of Engineers, with compaiy.
  Second Lieut. Charles L. Potter, Corps of Engineers, with company.
  Second Lieut. J. J. Meyler, Corps of Engineers, with company.

                                    Company D.

  First Lieut. J. G. Warren, Corps of Engineers, commanding company.

                                    Company E.

  Capt. P. M. Price, Corps of Engineers, commanding company.
  First Lieut. J. Biddle, Corps of Engineers, with company.
350        REPORT         OF THE CHIEF                OF ENGINEERS. U. S. ARMY.

  The following table shows the changes that have taken place in the
personnel of the officers during the year, viz :


        Rank.                   Names.              Date.        Joined
                                                                 relieved. r               Remarks.


First lieutenant .....   Chittenden, H. M ... July 6, 1887 Relieved.           S. O. 151, A. G. O., July 1, 1887.
      Do .. .....        Sibert, W. L... ..    . July 6, 1887 ... do .-...     S. O. 152, A. G. O.. July 2, 1887.
Second lieutenant....    Shunk, F. R ........     Oct.  1, 1887 Joined...      S. O. 227, A. G. O., Sept. 29, 1887.
      Do..............   Meyler, J. J.......O..    ct.  1, 1887 ... do . ..          Do.
Captain ........         Knight, J. G. D          Nov. 15, 1887 Relieved.      S. 0.262, A. G. O., Nov. 10, 1887.
First lieutenant.....    Biddle, John .......     Dec. 22, 1887 Joined...      S. 0O.272, A. G. 0., Nov. 22, 1887.
Second lieutenant...     Kuhn, J.1         ...    May 10, 1888 Relieved.       S. O. 101, A. G. O)., May 2, 1888.
      Do.............    Crai hill, W. E ...... ] June 30, 1888 ... do. .. .   S. O. 141. A. G. 0., June 19, 1888.



   Capt. S. W. Roessler, Corps of Engineers, was relieved from duty as
battalion and post adjutant and treasurer, recruiting officer, and acting
signal officer, post of Willets Point, and from command of Company D,
Battalion of Engineers, in Orders No. 253, Post of Willets Point, and
Orders No. 95, Battalion of Engineers, December 6, 1887. Relieved
from duty as inspector of rifle practice, Bal talion of Engineers, in Gen-
eral Orders No. 14, headquarters Corps of Engineers, December 17, 1887.
Assigned to command of Company A, Battalion of Engineers, in Orders
No. 86, Battalion of Engineers, November 15, 1887.
   First Lieut. J. G. Warren, Corps of Engineers, was relieved from duty
with Company E, Battalion of Engineers, on December 5, 1887, in com-
pliance with Special Orders No. 272, headquarters of the Army, Adju-
tant-General's Office, November 22, 1887, and appointed battalion adju-
tant and treasurer, in command of Company E, Engineers, in Orders No.
95, Battalion of Engineers, and post ad.jutant, treasurer, recruiting
officer, and acting signal officer, Post of Willets Point. In Orders No.
253, Post of Willets Point, December 6, 1887 ; inspector of rifle practice,
Battalion of Engineers, in General Orders No. 14, headquarters Corps
of Engineers, December 17, 1887.
   First Lieut. John Biddle, Corps of Engineers, was appointed recruit-
ing officer, Company E, Battalion of Engineers, at West Point, in
Orders No. 103, Battalion of Engineers, December 24, 1887.

                                             RECRUITING.


   During the past year the companies of the battalion have been re-
cruited, partly. by enlistments and re-enlistments at Willets Point and
West Point, and partly by assignment of recruits from principal depot,
general recruiting service at David's Island, New York Harbor.
   On February 16, 1888, application was made to the Adjutant-General
U. S. Army, through the Chief of Engineers, U. S. Army, for the assign-
ment of sixty recruits and three trumpeters. This application was re-
newed on May 25, 1888. The superintendent of the recruiting service,
in compliance with instructions from headquarters of the Army, Adju-
tant-GeneraPl's Office, dated June 1, 1888, directed on June 9, 1888,
twenty recruits to be assigned to the Engineer Battalion. The three
trumpeters joined from David's" Island and were assigned to the En-
gineer Battalion on April 26, 1888, in accordance with instructions from
headquarters recruiting service.
   The following is a summary statement of the recruiting, desertion,
                               APPENDIX                       1-REPORT                        OF       MAJOR                      KING.                            351
and other changes among the enlisted men of the Battalion of Engi-
neers during the past year, viz:
Recruits from depot...............................                                                      ................                   .. ...... ....                  89
Enlisted in the battalion... ....--..--......-- ......-- ............--................                                                                   .                 9
Re-enlisted in the battalion ....................................................                                                                                          24
By    transfer.       -           .-- --..         ..                                              ...----                ...--.----.--                                     1--.
                                                                                                                                                                            1
From desertion.........-----............                                                                                                         --
                                                                                ............---..----...-----......-----......-----....--..----....                        11
          Total..                      ..
                             ....... ...                ...   ..          ...          ..................................                                ......           134

Discharged :
    By expiration of service .........................                  ..........................         2
                                            -------......-------..--------------.....----..--
    For disability .....---------......-...........---                                        ----........ 16
       By sentence of general court-martial.....                                                     ..........................                     ....---                11
     Ry order---..-.......------....       ----     ---
                                             ........----..............-----....----------      ..------------..---....     ------..-......14
     By letter-....---.----------.. ................----..-----------          ..------------..--... ----.......... ....------....----------1
Transferred.--........----....-----.---.......................------------.....---------..........---....------.....--------.......        15
Died of disease and accident ....                                  ....     ..................---                  ....             ....   ....   ....        ....-----     4
Dropped from rolls....----.---.....----....-----......------........   ------------..------..------.......-----......                                                       1
Deserted...--------.................----------..---..----..........-------------- ---------................................                                                4---------9
Retired           -------.......................................................................                                                                            1
                          .
           Total-.---------                       -----.---..--------------------------- ---------                                                                        134

  During the year the battalion has been drilled and instructed as fol-
lows :
  1. Infantry tactics, school of the soldier, company, and battalion.
  2. In target practice, during the months of June, July, and August,
in the last target year, 152 men qualified as marksmen and 7 men as
sharpshooters.
  3. In pontoniering, during the months of August and September, in-
cluding rowing, and building canvas batteaus and trestle bridges, as
prescribed in the ponton manual.
  4. In military engineering, including field fortifications, sapping, and
military mining.
  5. Torpedo drills were had throughout the year, the winter months
being devoted to in-door drills and practice in the loading-room, and
the summer months to outdoor drills and exercises.
  6. Photography: Selected details of non-commissioned officers and
privates have been instructed in military photography. (For details
see Appendix E.)
   7. Astronomy: The officers under instruction were practiced in the
use of the sextant, transit, and zenith telescope.
  8. In April, 1888, First Lieut. John P. Wisser, First U. S. Artillery,
reported at the post under orders from the War Department, and practi-
cally demonstrated to the officers the workings of a system of instruction
in the minor operations of war. A detailed report of his work was for-
warded April 21, 1888.*
                                                                   EXPERIMENTS.

   As there has been no appropriation for torpedo experiments for the
last two years, but little has been attempted in that direction.
   Anything in the way of an extended or systematic course of experi-
ments, either in electricity, explosives, or their combination in mining
operations, involves expense, which could not be provided for without
proper appropriations.
  A few years ago the popular notion was that torpedoes would enable
us to dispense with sea-coast fortifications, but now the idea seems to
                                                                          * Omitted.
352       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

be to dispense with torpedoes also, and trust to luck or some system of
defense that will come up spontaneously when needed.
   There is no doubt but that the efficiency of torpedoes, like most things
that are suddenly brought into public notice, has been greatly overes-
timated even by military authorities, but they are now settling into
their proper relative importance as a powerful auxiliary to, not substi-
tute for, sea-coast fortifications, their value consisting very largely in
their moral effect on the enemy and the delay which they will cause
when armored ships attempt to run past shore batteries.
   To be of any use, therefore, our system must be kept albreast of the
most advanced developments of foreign nations, not only in general ar-
rangements but in all their details, and especially in the all-important
elements of simplicity and certainty of action.
   We can not afford to lag behind in anything so vital to our national
defense.
   At the close of the late war we were in advance of all other nations
in the knowledge and use of torpedoes, and although but little progress
had then been made in their development as compared with what has
since been accomplished. foreign nations were anxious to learn all they
could from is.    Now they are not only independent, but we can take
lessons from them in such matters, as well as in ordnance and armor,
ship-building, and in fact all that relates to sea-coast defense, not only
to such nations as Great Britain and Germany, but to Italy and Spain.
   With such facilities as were available a few miscellaneous experi-
ments were made during the year, as follows:
   1. Two grand groups of torpedoes were planted and tested as nearly
as practicable in the way it would be done in actual service.
   One of these groups was allowed to remain from November till May,
to test the effect of winter weather, and in both cases complete records
were kept of the time required to prepare and plant the mines, the dif-
ficulties encountered, and the conditions of the different parts at dif-
ferent times as shown by electrical tests and by careful inspection when
the groups were taken up. Some of the details of these operations and
suggestions relative to the subject are given in the report of Captain
S. W. Roessler, hereto appended, Appendix D.
   2. The electrical testing of torpedo cable; to ascertain its condition
and rate of deterioration, has been continued; and much useful but
very discouraging information relative to the condition of the cable in
store has been obtained and recorded. Some of the results obtained
are given in Captain Roessler's report just referred to, and will, I think,
justify the following conclusion from my last annual report, viz:
   Enough has been learned, however, to justify the conclusion that the greatest care
must be taken to preserve the insuiating material of the cables, whatever their style
of manufacture, or they will be found worthless when required for use, and if any
better means can be devised than either the dry or wet storage as now practiced, it
will be a valuable discovery.
   One plan that suggests itself, and might be worth investigating, would be to buy
and store the cable in tanks without the armor, and store the wire for armor in dry
warehouses until the cable is required for use, and then apply the armor as the cable
is being reeled out of the tanks for shipment. This last operation would require a
number of machines to be in readiness so as to cause no delay in getting the cable on
board, and if worst come to worst, some of the cable could be laid temporarily without
armor in the least exposed places, and aftervards replaced by armored cable when a
sufficient quantity became available. This system would require concrete tanks for
storage of the cable, but they would not require to be very large, as the unarmored
cable is very much smaller in cross-section. The number and cost of the machines
for applying the armor is a matter for investigation, but it is probable that neither of
these items would be very large. Ten machines could armor 25 miles or more of cable
in a single day, and this would secure absolutely reliable insulation at the time the
cable was needed for use. If not needed at all, the cost of armor would be saved, as
the wire could be used for other purposes.
              APPENDIX 1----REPORT      OF MAJOR     KING.           353
   3. A series of experiments was made to ascertain the form and di-
mensions of the craters produced by different charges fired at various
depths below the surface of the water.
   These experiments were in continuation of some investigation made
by me twenty-three years ago, when the first recorded attempt was
made to measure the force of submarine explosions.
   The apparatus consisted of a wooden frame 15 feet by 18 feet square,
with a thin iron ring just below the center (as shown on Plate I), this
ring being held in position by 16 radial wires, making angles of 22)-
degrees with each other and having their outer ends attached to the
wooden frame. Upon each wire was placed a small sliding block of
hard wood 2 inches in diameter at the end towards the ring and much
smaller at the outer end, the length of the blocks being 4 inches, and
their density about the same as that of water. A small piece of rubber
tubing was placed on the wire outside each block, the object being to
record the distance to which the blocks were forced outward by the ex-
plosion of the charge, which was placed in the center of the ring.
   The charges were inclosed in paper cartridges, coated with paraffine,
and were exploded with platinum fuses containing only a little granu-
lated gun cotton, instead of the usual priming of mercuric fulminate.
The charge was generally of musket powder, only a few of dynamite
having been tried.
   The frame containing the ring and charge was lowered vertically into
the water to the desired depth, and after firing the charge was raised,
and the distance to which the sliding blocks were forced back was care-
fully measured and plotted, as shown on Plates 11 and following. In
a few cases the water appears to have leaked into the charge and some-
what reduced all the indications of that round, but, on the other hand,
as nothing could have caused any excess in the result, it is safe to as-
sume that the maximum set of indications for a given charge were
very nearly correct.
    Although but few experiments have yet been made, the following
conclusions are thought to be warranted:
    (a) When a charge, of either gunpowder or dynamite, is fired under
water, a large volume of water is displaced, forming a crater or cavity,
spheroidal in general shape, and varying in size, according to the weight,
nature of charge, and depth in the water.
    (b) There appears to be a strong tendency to retain the spheroidal
form, even when the depth below the surface of the water is considera-
bly less than the line of least resistance that would give a " common
mine crater " in ordinary earth, with the same charge.
    (c) Charges exploded near the surface give larger craters and greater
depressions below the center of the charge than those fired at greater
depths.
    (d) While the surface of the cavity formed by the explosion is gener-
ally quite regular in form, there are frequent exceptions to this rule
which indicate that for some reason the expanding gas sometimes sends
out small jets to a considerable distance beyond the general surface of
the cavity. These jets are sometimes downward, but oftener in an up-
ward direction, as would be expected.
    (e) By standing on a 'wharf, nearly over the smaller charges, when
they were fired, it was noticed that the inflamed gas formed a well-de-
fined ball of fire, and by means of photography some tolerably successful
efforts have been made to catch a view of what takes place at the very
instant of explosion.
         ENG 88-      23
354     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,             U. S. ARMY.

   (f) The action of dynamite in forming a crater seems to be quite sim-
ilar to that of musket powder, though, of course, a much smaller charge
produces an equal cavity.
   4. A few experiments were made with paper discs, secured to a large
iron ring' which was used in the sane way as the crater gauge already
described for getting the form and size of the cavity formed by the ex-
plosion of small charges of powder and other explosives under water,
but no satisfactory results have been obtained, as the paper manifested
a disposition to tear out radially in such a way as to make it uncertain
how much of the effect was due directly to the explosion and how much
to the action of the water.
   5. Some explosions were made for the purpose of breaking up the
wreck of the schooner sunk near the long wharf by the steamer Idle-
wild in 1887. This wreck was in the way of navigation and was entirely
broken up by a few charges of dynamite and common powder. The frag-
ments were nearly all removed by the waves and the balance by a steam-
tug.
   6. Experiments have been begun with the electric search-light, and
it is hoped that a practical combination can be made that will be avail-
able in case of actual attack on our harbors. The plant for this pur-
pose must be simple, compact, and portable, as well as capable of throw-
ing a powerful beam of light to a great distance, and it is not unlikely
that some form of gas-engine burning liquid fuel will be found best for
driving the dynamo.
   7. The existence of two 15-inch guns, a large quantity of torpedo
cable, and a dynamo in close relation to each other suggested the pos-
sibility of making the most powerful electro-magnet in the world with
very little of expense, and the opportunity was taken to make some ex-
periments in electro-magnetism on a large scale.
   The two guns, weighing each 50,000 pounds, were placed side by side
and connected at the breech by a pile of railway bars, as shown in the
drawings, Plate III.
   About 4 miles of insulated wire was coiled around each gun, and
an armature or keeper was made of fifteen wrought-iron plates, each
111 inches wide and half an inch thick, This armature, as well as the
pile of rails forming the base of the magnet, was much too small to give
the best results, and a much greater length of wire would have been
desirable, but was not available, and the results obtained with the com-
bination, as it was arranged, were a sufficient demonstration of the pos-
sibilities of this invisible power.
    Four 320-pound shells were suspended from one .of the guns and it
required a pull of 20,600 pounds to detach the armature. The lines of
force were easily traced to a distance of 20 feet or more by suspending
pieces of soft iron wire so that they could take up the directions of
these lines. Plate IV shows the direction of the lines of force in a hori-
zontal plane through the axes of the guns and extending over 4 feet from
the plane of the muzzles.
    At a distance of 46 feet the magnet formed by one of these guns neu-
tralized the earth's magnetism, and at 20 feet pieces of wrought-iron
wire magnetized by induction so that they would hang together.
    Some interesting facts were noted in regard to the direction of the
lines of force, among which was the existence of a neutral point in the
axis of the bore of the guns and 74 inches from the plane of their muz-
zles, A spike or bit of iron placed inside of this point would be thrown
beyond it, sometimes to a distance of 25 inches from the gun, returning
suddenly to the face of the gun; but if placed on a board at the neu-
                                                                                                                                  1-\&(<.   1.




                                                        CRATER                     GAUGE.

                                                                 WILLBT          POINT,

                                                                          'I88 .




    2
Eng5O
        S1   +, i   . w.   ,   o ,               S3                   Y     S
                                                                                            t         f             IF,~
                                                                            1i



          t-#~#tt#~i
              f~t
               tt------_~
        I-~-lrti                                  i-
                                     .C;i-;"~.'i-="=i        ~----~                r9-*l
                                                                             ~-=-r------       --i
                                                                                           _-~~~iii       ------ L----tC-E====d
                                                         !




                                                                                                                                             8
                                                                                                       -Nkrr~f                      ~C

                                                                                                                     ~~~Wttt~   -



                                                                                                                                         1   -P   ____




Ck~~r       4f\%.
             7QcW                                       K~   XJh~r4A~a~3~lPPU~

                       i.'.            4L                        b)

              ~0~M
           '?T~~~~~-                     kAo
                                        \S\.\Q
              g ~ 9r          i       b~~                           ~"I            o w.'r._
          n,~~~~~h.&wVZc
            WP\                                      ot4r~       i~joi
Igl~gW   ~r~,rO                   c         T    .




EXPERIMhENT                                                  WITH         SRATER              4AU4E.
                                                 AT lWILLET$ POINI                                               w       S

         Eng50O
              2

                                                               188 .8_
                             PLATE III.




IMPROVISED ELECTRO-MAGNET.
                                                                PLATE IV.


                                                : :::\,




pjt :i ~
  -- i
           "
                                 : :;- :: :1.~
                                  :i:t . .~;:

                                            I             i4i
I:;                                                       ir.

;;
      i




               IMPROVISED ELECTRO-MAGNET.
                                     I             _ ___   _
                                                               a?   m   V.

          IMPROVIED                      ELECTRO MAMETT.




             ,to,   ,   ,,   i   i7s M   I     I




Eng50 2
                 APPENDIX       1-REPORT OF MAJOR KING.                             355
tral point it would remain there and resist any force moving it either
towards or from the gun. A similar point was noticed inside the bore
of the gun and about 51 inches from the face of the muzzle. When a
320-pound shell was placed inside the gun in was forcibly pushed out
and remained attached to the lower side of the muzzle of the gun.
(Plates III. & IV.
                                ENGINEER DEPOT.

                 PUBLIC BUILDINGS           AND CONSTRUCTIONS.

   The building for an officers' mess, library, etc., was completed and
occupied during the year, excepting the actual transfer of books to the
library, which has been delayed for want of suitable book-cases. These
are now making from such materials as could be picked up by enlisted
men, and when completed the library will be fairly well provided for.
   The observatory dome has been repainted, and water has been brought
into the officers' laboratory.
   The rebuilding of the laboratory for enlisted men has been delayed
an entire year by the failure of Congress to make an appropriation for
it, but if the item for that purpose in the pending army appropriation
bill becomes a law work should be begun at once, as the building is
urgently needed for the proper instruction of enlisted men in torpedo
service.
   Other public buildings are referred to in the post report.
   The steamer David Bushnell was hauled out on the ways last fall and
should have been repaired and launched in the spring as soon as the
ice was out of the way, but there was no appropriation for the purpose,
and the repairs needed are quite extensive.
   This steamer was designed and built several years ago for the pur-
pose of planting torpedoes, but the propelling and steering arrange-
ments, which are the Mallory type, have proved so unsatisfactory that
it is not thought advisable to repair them, but rather to replace them
by the ordinary propeller and rudder. Although she has run less than
2,000 miles since she was first launched the main-gear wheels and sev-
eral other vital parts are entirely worn out.
   Her deck needs calking, and it will be done at once by a detail of
enlisted men, but before the repairs to her machinery are begun it is
proposed to have the whole vessel thoroughly examined by an expert.
   All repairs necessary for the preservation of depot buildings and
depot property have been made.
                                 DEPOT PROPERTY.

  The surveying, astronomical, and other instruments in depot have
been properly cared for, and some additions have been made by pur-
chase of transits, levels, and other instruments likely to be called for
by officers in the field.
  Instruments have been received and issued in compliance with orders
and requisitions as follows :
   Turned into depot.-Three theodolites, 3 transits, 5 levels, 4 barometers, aneroid; 2
barometers, mercurial; 1 thermometer, 1 case drawing instruments, 1 odometer, 12
prismatic compasses, 4 silver watches, 1 leveling rod,1 transit and compass, 1 transit
and level combined, 1 protractor, 1 goniometer, 1 compass, surveyor's; 2 compasses,
pocket, round; 2 psychrometers, 1 current meter.
  Issuedfrom depot.-Two theodolites, 2 transits, 2 levels, surveyors; 3 chains, 100 feet ;
3 tapes, steel, 50 feet; 2 plane tables, 1 protractor, Abbot's; 2 prismatic compasses
3 hand-levels, reflecting; 6 odometers, 1 compass, pocket, square; 2 extra tubes for
barometers, 1 solar attachment for transit, 1 level rod, 3 rulers, metallic; 1 case
drawing instruments, 2 triangles, metallic, 2 triangles, rubber; 2 bridge rheostats.
356         REPORT                OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Most of the repairing of the instruments during the year has been
done by detailed enlisted men, and the cost has been very much less
than it would have been if the instruments had been sent out to private
shops, while the character of the work done has been satisfactory.
  The following instruments have been overhauled, cleaned, and put in
good repair durifig the year, viz:
  Two astronomical clocks, 4 boxes drawing instruments, 1 artificial horizon, 4 levels,
4 dial telegraph instruments, 2 dynamos, 2 chronometers, 1 sextant, 2 surveyor's com-
passes, 6 theodolites, 1 electric light, lens, and reflector, 1 orograph; besides a num-
ber of smaller instruments.
   A small testing machine was improvised for measuring the tensile
strength of wire, rope, etc., by using a Duckham dynamometer in
measuring, and a jack-screw for applying the strains.
   Another and more powerful machine, procured from the work recently
in charge-of the late General Gillmore, has been set up and will be used
for testing specimens of building materials.
                                                 WORK OF THE DEPOT.

   Printing, bookbinding, draughting, photographing, lithographing,
engine driving, repair of depot buildings, and the general work to keep
the property, buildings, and animals in a proper state of preservation,
have been done by engineer soldiers, at a cost of $2,172.41, paid out of
the appropriation for engineer depot at Willets Point, N. Y. Inciden-
tals, 1888: Instruments were repaired at a cost of $140.70, paid out of
the appropriation for Engineer Depot at Willets Point, N. Y. Instra-
ments, 1888: For the latter payment special authority was obtained
from the War Department.
   The work of printing General Abbot's new Manual of Torpedo Drill
has occupied most of the time of the printers.
   The printing and bookbinding has been useful to every department
here. Confidential and professional books for the officers of the corps,
reports, blank forms, orders, circulars, etc., have been made promptly
and with economy; professional periodicals were bound into volumes,
and books pertaining to the library of the Engineer School of Applica-
tion were rebound when necessary.
   The blocks of granite which have so long occupied the open ground
near and around the flag-staff and the Engineer Office were collected
and piled as closely together as possible.
   Materials required for the instruction of the Battalion of Engineers, in
their special duties of sappers, miners, and pontoniers, have been pur-
chased and issued for use here during the year, and the office work in-
cidental to this and to the new mess building, with the necessary cor-
respondence, money and property accounts, and required records, has
been performed.
                                                 STATEMENT OF FUNDS.

   Congress appropriated for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888:
For incidental expenses of depot (incidentals) .......-----....-----....---...------...............----    $3,000. 00
For instruction of battalion (materials)....       ................                     ..........          1, 000. 00
For repair and purchase of instruments (instruments) ..----........-......                                  2, 000. 00
For purchase of professional works of recent date on military and civil
engineering (library)--.................. ..-----. .....--       ..... ---------
                                                             . ----                                     ..     500.00

        Total ....................------------                                     -----................-------
                                                   .....................--------------                            6, 500.00
                           APPtINDIX 1-REPORT OF' MAJOR                                                                           RINo.                 357
   Of this there has been expended and pledged:
For incidental expenses of depot (incidentals) .....-...................... $-3, 000. 00
For instruction of battalion (materials)................................     1,000.00
For repair and purchase of instruments (instruments) ....................    2, 000.00
For purchase of professional works of recent date on military and civil
  engineering (library)                                                         ......................                                     ....        494.32

        Total          --...... --...- ............                               .........        ............................                     6,494.32
   No official notification has been received of the appropriation for the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.
   The following amounts have been assigned to me for disbursement,
under extension, for the month of July, 1888, " under public resolution
No. 20:"
Engineer depot at Willets Point, N. Y. :
   Incidentals, 1889 ................................................                                                                             .$250.00
   Materials, 1889.. ...........................                         ......                                                   .............         83.33
   Instruments, 1889 ...................................................                                                                               166. 66
   Library, 189 .........................................                                                                           ..........           41.00
        Total.             ............................                                   .. ........................................                  540.99
  Which will be applied during the month of July as contemplated by
law.
  There will be required for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, the
following, viz :
For incidental expenses of depot, including fuel, lights, chemicals, stationery,
  extra-duty pay to soldiers necessarily employed as artificers, on work in
  addition to and not strictly in the line of their military duties, such as
  carpenters, blacksmiths, draughtsmen, printers, bookbinders, lithographers,
  photographers, engine drivers, wheelwrights, teamsters, clerk hire, and for
  materials to repair public buildings, machinery, and unforeseen expenses..-- $5, 000
For purchase of materials for instruction of Engineer troops in their special
  duties as sappers. miners, for land and submarine mines. pontoniers, tor-
  pedo drill and signaling................................................                                1, 500
For purchase and repair of instruments to be issued to officers of the Corps
  of Engineers for use on public works, surveys, etc.....                  - .. -.... ......--.           2, 500
For library of the Engineer School of Application; for purchase of profes-
  sional works of recent date treating of military and civil engineering .....                               500
For a small fire-proof building to contain the collection of engineering models
  used for illustration and instruction...---------..---------..............----......-..---....--...---- 8, 000
         In    all..              --------.............................................-----.............                                              17, 500


              Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                                                                                  W. R. KING,
                                                                                                        Major of Engineers, in Charge.
    The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,
                    U. S. Army.




                             APPENDIX A.-                          COURSE OF WINTER INSTRUCTION.

                                                                 [Printed Orders No. 233.1

                                                                 ENGINEER SCHOOL OF APPLICATION, U. S. A.,
                          Post of Willets Point, New York Harbor,November , 1887.
   The recommendations of the Academic Staff for the winter course of instruction,
having been approved by the Chief of Engineers, are hereby announced. The course
will begin on December 6, 1887, and extend to April 29, 1888, a period of twenty-one
weeks.
358      REPORT       OF THE      CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S: ARMY.

                         COURSE         FOR OFFICERS.
  1. Examinations by the Academic Staff will be held at the end of January and
April, and intermediate examinations, as near monthly as practicable, will be held
by committees of the Academic Staff. Marks at examinations will be on the West
Point system, and the committees will report to the Commandant of the school the
results of the examinations. As the efficiency of the instruction can be much influ-
enced by the instructors, they will keep themselves fully advised of the progress of
the students; will give them at any time any needed aid, and when the information
on special subjects is difficult to obtain, should supplement the course by lectures.
The instructors will meet their classes weekly, and assign the lessons for the follow-
ing week.
                             FIRST WINTER'S COURSE.

   2. The course for Engineer Officers spending their first winter at the school, and
for Artillery Officers, will be submarine mining, nineteen weeks. The Engineer Of-
ficers will have in addition civil engineering, two weeks.
                                  SUBMARINE    MINING.

   3. Nineteen weeks. (1) Parts I, II, III, Abbot's Manual (omitting Chapter V),
and such parts of the following books as may be designated by the Academic Staff;
(2) Abbot's Report on Submarine Mining; (3) Gray's Absolute Measurements; (4)
Schleeman's Torpedoes, An essay is to be written between April 1 and 15, on use of
explosives for demolitions and removal of wrecks and other obstructions to naviga-
tion by blasting.
   4. Books of reference: Kempe's Electrical Testing ; Murdock's Notes on Electricity
and Magnetism ; Eissler's Modern High Explosives.
   5. The officers will be present at the electrical laboratory for six hours daily, Satur-
days and Sundays excepted, while studying Abbot's Manual and Report. They will
proceed to the laboratory at 9 a. m. Each officer will make all the electrical meas-
urements specified in Abbot's Manual, excepting those in which the electrometer is
used. Each measurement will be repeated six times independently, and the results
will be reported weekly in writing through the instructor to the Commandant. Prac-
tice will be had in the duties of the loading-room as the officer in charge may direct.
                                 CIVIL ENGINEERING.

  6. (Two weeks after April 15.) Such portions as may be designated by the Academic
Staff, of Johnson's Theory and Practice of Surveying.

                           SECOND WINTER'S COURSE.

  7. Civil engineering, five weeks; military engineering, seven weeks; photography
four weeks; submarine mining, four weeks.

                                 CIVIL ENGINEERING.

  8. (Five weeks.) Subjects: (1) Measurement of river discharge; (2) improvement
of non-tidal rivers; (3) improvement of tidal rivers.
  9. Text-books: Vernon Harcourt's Rivers and Canals; Schlichting's Improvement
of Non-tidal Rivers.
  10. Books of reference : De Bauve ; Rankine's Civil Engineering; article on hydro-
mechanics in Encyclopmedia Britannica; Cotterill's Applied Mechanics.

                                MILITARY ENGINEERING.

   11. (Seven weeks.) Subjects: (1) Modern guns, carriages, and projectiles; (2)
steel, compound, wrought and cast iron armor; (3) modern ships of war and sea-
coast defenses; (4) modern fortifications, and their attack and defense.
   12. Text-books: Such parts of the following books as may be designated by the
Academic Staff: Woolwich Text-book of Fortifications ; Maguire's Attack and Defense
of Coast Fortifications; Fortifications of To-day ; Inglis' paper in Professional Papers
Royal Engineers, 1884, and a lecture on armored defense in Ordnance Notes No. 151;
Very's Development of Armor; Naval Intelligence Papers, June, 1886; Adams' Spezia
Experiments, 1886; Baylay's Types of Modern Guns; The Protection of Heavy Guns
for Coast Defense, Sir A. Clark.
                 APPENDIX       1---RRPORT      OF MAJOR       KING.              359
  13. Books of reference: Articles on Fortification and Gunnery, Encyclopuedia
Britannica ; Ordnance Notes, No. 135, and Appendix; Volume 9, Professional Papers
Royal Engineers; Report Board on Fortifications; Text-books on Gunnery, McKinlay.

                              MILITARY PHOTOGRAPHY.

   14. (Four weeks.) Practice will be had in the following methods: Negatives by
wet and dry processes; developers and intensifiers; silver printing, and finishing
and mounting of the prints; map printing; photolithography, including the nega-
tive and transfer to stone and printing. Each officer to submit 12 printed copies of
his map. Text-books: Griffin's Notes on Photography.
                                 SUBMARINE    MINING.

  15. (Four weeks.) An officer of the second and third winter's course will be de-
tailed weekly to report to the instructor in submarine mining, as assistant for testing
core joints and instructing enlisted men on the torpedo detail.

                            THIRD WINTER'S COURSE.

16. Civil engineering, eleven weeks; military engineering, three weeks; submarine
mining, four weeks.
                                 CIVIL ENGINEERING.

   17. (Eleven weeks.) Subjects: (1) Measurement of river discharge; (2) improve-
ment of non-tidal rivers ; (3) improvement of tidal rivers; (4) wave and current ac-
tion, and improvement of harbors; (5) canals; (6) steam engines and pumps. Such
parts of the following text-books as may be designated by the Academic Staff.
   18. Text-books: Vernon Harcourt's Rivers and Canals, and Harbors and Docks;
Schlichting's Improvements of Non-tidal Rivers; Edward's Steam-engine.
   19. Books of reference: De Bauve, Manuel de l'Ingdnieur; Rankine's Civil-Engi-
neering and Steam-engine; Bixby's Pointe de Grave; articles on hydro-mechanics
and steam-engine in Encyclopaedia Britannica; Cotterill's Applied Mechanics; Jamei-
son on Steam-engine; Steam-boilers, Wilson; Modern Steam-engine, Rose.

                               MILITARY ENGINEERING.

  20. (Three weeks.)    Hamley's Operations of War.

                                   SUBMARINE MINING.

  21. (Four weeks.)     See paragraph on submarine mining in second winter's course.

                       COURSE FOR ENLISTED MEN.

                   INSTRUCTION    OF ENLISTED MEN IN TORPEDOES.

  22. Details will be for one week, and from the companies in turn, and will consist
of 1 sergeant, 1 corporal, and 12 privates.
  23. The details will spend the regular fatigue hours, Saturdays and Sundays ex-
cepted, at the old instruction building for enlisted men. Every soldier not excused
by orders will be included on this list; but the roster will be arranged specially for
the benefit of the recruits. Their instruction will be directed by the instructor in
submarine mining, who will be assisted by the lieutenant detailed.
  24. Instruction will comprise telegraphing with the dial instrument, including the
code for action; the duties of the loading-room, and, so far as practicable, of the
boat service as prescribed in the iorpedo manual, comprising preparing the plugs of
the buoyant and ground torpedoes ; charging the mines; charging the cut-off boxes,
three methods; jointing the cores; making turk's heads in the electrial cable; using
the junction boxes; attaching a cable stop ; splicing and knotting hemp rope; insert-
ing thimble in wire mooring rope. They will also receive from the instructor in sub-
marine mining or his assistant, daily lectures respecting the fuses, explosives, torpedo
material (except that of the operating-room), voltaic batteries, simple electrical test-
ing, and the use of the portable apparatus for the electrical ignition of mines. On
Saturday the instructor in submarine mining will submit a report giving the names
360       REPORT     OF THE      CHIEF OF         ENGINEERS,        U. S. ARMY.

and plrofcicilcy of the dlet:il, what verbal anyd other inst rulctionls they have received,
and will give the insulation of the core joints made by them. Printed blank forms
will be suppl)lied.

                 INSTRUCTION    OF   ENLISTED   MEN IN       PHIOTOGRAPHY.


  25. Two non-commissioned officers will be detailed each week for instruction in map
printing.
                                     INFANTRY DRILLS.

  26. Company commanders will see that their companies are kept well drilled in
the manual of arms, and that they are practiced in gallery target practice, and when
the weather is suitable in estimating distances. The hours of practice and of recruit
drill will be regulated as may be most convenient. One company drill will be had at
3 p. m. by Company A on Wednesday, by Company B on Thursday, and by Com-
pany C on Friday of each week-recall being sounded at 2.30 p. m. for that company.
The drill will be attended by all men except the foregoing details and men excused
by orders.
                                COMPANY     RECITATIONS.


   27. The non-commissioned officers of each company in turn will receive one week's
theoretical instruction. They will be excused from all duties but those necessary in
the company. Recitations will be conducted daily (Saturdays and Sundays excepted)
under the supervision of the company commanders.           Company commanders may ex-
cuse non-commissioned officers from recitations in any subljects in which they are
already proficient.
   28. Regular classes will be formed in field fortifications (including mining), pon-
toniering, infantry tactics, the theoretical and practical use of the railroad transit.
Each recitation will be marked on the West Point system, and at the close of each
week a list, showing the marks of each non-commissioned officer, in each branch,
will be forwarded to the commandant.
   29. A school for soldiers will be established, as prescribed in the regulations of the
Army. This school will be under the charge of the post adjutant. Sessions will be
held between 7.30 and 8.30 p. m. on Tuesday and Friday of each week in the upper
school-room. Weekly reports of progress will be rendered.
   30. Company recitations of non-commissioned officers will be held in one or both of the
rooms assigned to the post school for children, at the option of the company commanders;
provided, however, that such hours are selected as will not interfere with the regular
use of these rooms.
   31. The following assignment of instructors is made:
   Military engineering, Capt. E. Maguire, Corps of Engineers.
   Civil engineering, Capt. E. Bergland, Corps of Engineers.
   Submarine mining, First Lieut. S. W. Roessler, Corps of Engineers.
   Military photography, the battalion quartermaster.
   By order of Major King:
                                                                   S. W. ROESSLER,
                                         First Lieutenant of Engineers, Post Adjutant.




APPENDIX B.-PROGRAMME OF STUDY AND INSTRUCTION FOR SUMMER SEASON.

                                  [Printed Orders No. 85.]

                                        UNITED STATES ENGINEER SCHOOL,
                          Post of Willets Point, 1New York Harbor, April 20, 1888.
  The following programme of study and instruction for the ensuing summer season,
to commence May 7 and end November 17, 1888 (twenty-eight weeks), having been
recommended by the academic staff and approved by the Chief of Engineers, will be
carried into effect:
                               MILITARY    ENGINEERING.


Ist.   Instruction by the company officers in the nomenclature, dimensions, and con-
struction of modern siege batteries and saps. 2d. A full course of trestle and ponton
drill. 3d. Instruction in military mining. 4th. Military map making in accordance
with existing orders and instructions. Each lieutenant who has not already done so,
                  APPENDIX 1--REPORT               OF1 MAJOR KING.                      61
and such non-commissioned officers and privates as may be selected front each com-
pany, will make satisfactory foot reconnaissances about 4 miles long in the vicinity
of the post, the maps thereof to be submitted by company commanders to post head-
quarters on or before the termination of the season.

                                     TORPEDO DRILLS.

  The torpedo drills are separated into two divisions, viz:
  1. The weekly torpedo drill, the programme for which is given below.
  2. Planting a grand group of torpedoes as for service, using an inert substance in
place of the explosive; testing and operating the group; and experience in the use
of the electric light and in the adjustment of its machinery.

                                   Weekly torpedo drills.

   These drills will be had first, and continue until each officer has had at least two
weeks' experience in their supervision--one week as in charge of operations on the
water and one week as electrician. The weekly detail will consist of two officers,
two non-commissioned officers, and twelve privates. The detail of officers will be
made as far as practicable from the artillery officers until the first of July. The de-
tail of enlisted men will be taken from the companies in turn. In the absence of
commissioned officers the assistant instructor in torpedoes will be in general charge
of the detail without regard to rank.
   During the fatigue hours (except on Saturday and Sunday) the men will be in-
structed (1) in the duties of the boat service connected with submarine mines, and
(2) in those of tle loading-room; occasionally loaded mines will be planted and fired
as in actual service.
   The following system will be observed as closely as circumstances permit:
   1st. MONDAY.     Judgment torpedo drill. The mapping drill will first be practiced;
then the judgment firing drill. A few steamers or sailing vessels should be tracked
at every drill, and the diagrams will be neatly finished and preserved.
   2d. TUESDAY.     Placing the junction boxes. This drill will be simulated on land
until the principles are fully understood by every member of the detail. It will then
be executed on the river, using the base line between the fort and engineer wharf.
Care must be taken, by providing buoy ropes of sufficient length, to avoid the loss of
anchors.
   3d. WEDNESDAY.      Planting a group of mines. One officer will act as electrician,
and the other will command on the steam-launch; the former, on Monday or Tues-
day, will set up the apparatus completely in the mining casemate, so that every-
thing shall be in readiness. All the tests used in planting a grand group will be
made. Before the officer's detail is relieved, all the apparatus will be removed from
the mining casemate, unless otherwise ordered.
   4th. THURSDAY.     Automatic firing drill. This drill must first be practiced at the
wharf in the manner prescribed in the manual. Subsequently it may be combined
with the judgment drill on the river.
   5th. FRIDAY.    Planting a self-acting mine.
   6th. Daily instruction in rowing will be had between morning fatigue call and
8.30 a m.
   In weather unfavorable for outdoor drill the detail will be exercised in the duties
of the loading-room, in the shore duties pertaining to the boat service, and in the
use of the dial telegraph, and verbal instruction will be given respecting the fuzes,
explosives, torpedo material-except that of the operating-room-simple electrical
testing, and the practical use of the ordinary forms of apparatus for the electrical
ignition of mines.
   The officer in charge will submit the plots of the mapping drills and weekly reports
giving the names of the enlisted men ; what they have been drilled in, and their classi-
lication as to proficiency; also personal reports from each officer showing what he
has accomplished, with notes of his tests and a statement of any difficulty encountered
and any suggestion he may desire to make.
   Planting Grand Group, etc -After a proper amount of experience has been had in
the above-mentioned drills the officers will be arranged in details, as the post-com-
mander may direct, for the purpose of planting a grand group of torpedoes, testing
and operating the system, and manipulating the electric light-an inert substance
will be used instead of the explosive. The officers of the detail will frequently inter-
change duties so that each one shall have a fair amount of experience in all the details
of the work. The senior officer will be in general charge ; he will keep a daily journal of
operations, noting particularly any difficulties encountered and any suggestions that
may occur to him at the time, looking to the avoidance of similar difficulties in the future.
The group and electric light being ready for service, the fact will be reported at once
362      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

through the instructor to the post-commander, who may order an exhibition drill
illustrating the operations of the torpedo defense against an attempted passage of the
mines by an enemy's vessel under cover of night. The group will then be taken up
by the same detail, and the parts dismantled and returned to their proper places.
   Weekly reports of progress will be rendered by the senior officer of the detail, and
at the conclusion of the work each officer will submit a report on the work done by
him, mentioning difficulties encountered and any suggestions he may desire to make.
   The attendance of the officers will be from 8.30 to 11.30 a. m., and from 1 to 4 p. m.
When not actually engaged in supervision of the above-named drills, they will prac-
tice in the Morse system of telegraphy until messages are sent and received with
facility.
   The non-commissioned officers of the battalion will also receive practice in the
Morse system of telegraphy at such times as they can be spared from their other
duties.
                                 CIVIL   ENGINEERING.

  The following instrumental surveys will begin as soon as practicable, and officers
when detailed for this purpose will be excused from all other duties when actually
engaged in the field-work. Each lieutenant who has not already done so will make
and plot a careful instrumental survey of about one square mile of ground. The work
will include contours with a surveyor's level. He will be assisted in the field-work
by details of non-commissioned officers and privates from his company. The work
will be plotted on a scale of 12 inches to the mile, with contour planes 10 feet apart.
Good level bench-marks should be made and located on the map, the references being
given a column of notes. The names of the residents should be recorded. A field
azimuth of one of the lines will be determined astronomically. The finished maps
will be submitted on or before the termination of the season.
  A careful hydrographic survey of about one-quarter (1) of a square mile, including
current measurements with electric current meter and double floats, will be made, if
practicable, by the lieutenants who have not already done so.

                                  FIELD ASTRONOMY.

   All the lieutenants who have not already completed the course, and been excused
from further observations, will constitute the observers, being called upon by the
officer in charge as wanted. In addition, when officer of the day (except on Sundays),
the weather permitting, they will observe the sun for time.
   The following system will govern the observations at the observatory. The course
covers two seasons-the first including sextant work, and transit and zenith telescope
work, with the instruments in the east wing and on the outer pier; and the second
including sextant work, practice with the new combined instruments in the west wing.
Officers wishing to use the instruments for special observations or practice, must apply
for authority to do so.
   Suitable blank forms will be provided, both for observations and computation ; and
these original records, after inspection by the commanding officer, will be returned to
the officers as their personal property.
   The following allowance of time will be made for computations: Three days for a
set of latitude observations with the sextant, for a set of time observations with the
transit, for the value of a level division or for a micrometer turn with the zenith
telescope, and ten days for latitude by the zenith telescope.
   The following will be the ordinary routine of observations with the several instru-
ments :
   Sextant.--After becoming skillful in the use of this instrument upon the sun, observ-
ers will deduce at least one satisfactory latitude by observing a north and a south star,
using the time deduced from an east and a west star-each based on ten altitudes
taken on the same night. These observations for latitude and time must be made at
the observatory, and the time results must be reported for the Lukens' chronometer.
No other record will be accepted.
   Transit.--A satisfactory set of time observations will be taken by each officer on two
nights, successive if possible, the observer taking his own time.
   Zenith Telescope.-Observers will first determine the level correction by daylight,
using a distant terrestrial object, or at night using a slow circumpolar star. They will
then find the value of a turn of the micrometer by observing Polaris at elongation.
Lastly, they will observe for latitude, until they have obtained a satisfactory deter-
mination based on three nights' work upon not less than twenty pairs.
   Astronomical Azimth.-Each officer serving his second year will determine an as-
tronomical azimuth-using a large theodolite for the purpose.
   Each officer shall receive instruction in the use of the personal equation machine
and chronograph, and in comparison of chronometers.
                  APPENDIX      1-REPORT OF MAJOR KING.                               363
                               MILITARY PHOTOGRAPHY.

   The officers' laboratory will be open daily from 1.30 p m. until 4 p. m. The build-
ing, apparatus, chemicals, etc., will be under the charge of the battalion quartermas-
ter, whose duty it is to furnish any desired assistance, and who will be held responsi-
ble for the judicious use of the property. Officers are invited to avail themselves of
the advantages of the laboratory, making such arrangements with the officer in charge
as shall insure no confusion in his official duties, or in those of the men under his in-
struction. The instruction of enlisted men will be restricted to one non-commissioned
officer from each company, selected from those having special aptitude. They will
be detailed singly for one week at a time, and will receive such instruction as, in the
judgment of the officer in charge, is best suited to perfect their knowledge of the
subject.
  By order of Major King.
                                                                  J.   G.   WARREN,
                                          First Lieutenant of Engineers, Post Adjutant.



   APPENDIX    C---ASSIGNMENTS     TO CHARGE OF DEPARTMENTS OF INSTRUCTION.

                                  [Printed Orders No. 90.]
                                             UNITED STATES ENGINEER SCHOOL,
                                   Post of Willets Point, N. Y. Harbor, April 24, 1888.
  The following assignments to the charge of Departments of Instruction are an-
nounced:
   Military Engineering, the captains in turn, excepting the instructor in torpedoes.
  Astronomy, Capt. Edward Maguire.
   Civil engineering, Capt. Eric Bergland.
  Torpedoes, Capt. S. W. Roessler.
  Military Photography, First Lieut. Irving Hale.
  At the close of the season each officer will submit a report upon the work done in
his department, with any recommendations he may desire to make. Weekly reports
of progress will be rendered.
   I. Infantry Drills (school of the company) will be had on Monday, Wednesday, and
Friday of each week from May 7 until July 15, from 10.30 to 11.30 a. m. Recall from
fatigue will be sounded at 10 a. m. for this purpose. Battalion drills will be had at
such times as the post commander may order.
   Excepting the non-commissioned staff, band and field music, provost sergeant,
police sergeant, school teacher during sessions of the school, mail-carrier and ambu-
lance driver, telegraph operator, one post baker, one stable orderly, two cooks and one
barrack orderly from each company (the barrack orderly to be, if practicable, from
among those who are sick in quarters); nothing in existing orders shall be construed
as excusing any soldier whether on extra or daily duty from attending these drills.
   II. Drills in Military Engineering will be had daily, Saturdays and Sundays ex-
cepted, during the months of August, September, and October.
   The companies will be consolidated as one company under the command of officers
detailed from these headquarters; unless so detailed officers will not be required to at-
tend. The captains of companies, excepting the instructor in torpedoes, will be de-
tailed in turn to supervise these drills. The drills will commence at 1 p. m. and con-
tinue until 4 p. m., or until the completion of the particular work laid out for the
day.
   The months of August and September will be devoted to ponton exercises. Au-
gust will be mainly devoted to drills on land, including building trestle bridges, load-
ing the wagons, and putting together the canvas ponton boats. September will be
devoted to drills on the water, including the construction of bridges and boat maneu-
vers. October will be devoted to instruction and practice in field fortifications, sap-
ping, and military mining.
   Extra and daily duty men, with the exceptions heretofore noted for infantry drills,
will be required to attend an average of at least one drill per week on military en-
gineering, and officers' having charge of extra and daily duty men will send to the
companies timely lists of those who are not to attend each day.
   III. Surveys and reconnaissances as required by Orders No. 8, current series, will be
made if practicable during the months of May, June, and July.
   IV. The months of May and June having been designated as the target practice
season, practice will commence on May 1.
   V. Beginning May 1, dress parades will be had daily, Saturdays and Sundays ex-
cepted. First call will be sounded half an hour before sunset.
364      REPORT      OF   THE    CHIEF OF        ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  VI. The following are excused horn dress parades: Police sergeant; provost ser-
geant; 2 cooks and 1 barrack orderly for each company; 2 post bakers; torpedo, de-
pot, and photographic sergeants; mail-carrier; 1 post clerk; 1 stable orderly.
  The following are excused from Sunday morning inspection: Police sergeant; 2
cooks and 1 barrack orderly in each company ; driver of ice-cart ; mail-carrier; 1 stable
orderly; telegraph operator; 2 post bakers.
  VII. Company recitations will be discontinued after the first proximo.
  VIII. On and after the 30th instant, all formations under arms will be in full dress,
without blanket bags, canteens and haversacks, excepting at infantry drills, at which
undress with forage caps will be worn.
  IX. On and after the 30th instant, the triangular bayonet will be substituted for
the trowel bayonet.
  By order of Major King.
                                                                  J. G. WARREN,
                                        First Lieutenant of Engineers, Post Adjutant.




   APPENDIX D.-REPORTS OF CAPTAIN S. W. ROESSLER, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

                                          (1.)

                                WILLETS POINT, NEW YORK HARBOR, July 12, 1888.
   SIR: I have the honor to submit the following report on the torpedo department
for the year ending June 30, 1888:
   The work of the year consisted mainly in carrying out the programme of study and
instruction as announced in post orders, viz, out-door drills and exercises on the
water during the summer season, and in-door work, theoretical and laboratory studies
during the winter season. In addition, two grand groups of torpedoes without ex-
plosive charges have been planted, partly for experimental, and partly for drill pur-
poses. Their performances, which have not been entirely successful, have been sub-
jected to as close an analysis as the data would permit.

                                 FIRST GRAND GROUP.

   This group was planted in October and November, 1887, under the immediate direc-
tion of Captain Knight, and was raised in May, 1888, after an endurance test of about.
six months. It consisted of five groups of three mines each, and two groups of two
mines each. Two torpedoes were ground mines of the latest pattern; the remainder
were buoyant mines with galvanized steel cases. The explosive and charge-bag were
omitted. Circuit regulator plugs were used in all the mines, but with magnets re-
moved from some of them. Day's kerite cable, multiple and single, was used through-
out. The former (drum D) has been submerged since 1881, and frequently applied to
experimental and drill work since.
   All work required in connection with the group was done by picked men, and spe-
cial care was taken to insure good workmanship.
   During the winter season, from the beginning of December to the end of April, the
mines were tested, when practicable, every working day of the week by the officer of
the weekly detail, or by one of the officers taking the winter's course. Both the re-
sistance test and sea-cell test were applied. The results of the resistance tests are
tabulated, giving for each week the average of all the tests made during that week.
   During the raising of the mines, after the switch-box had been raised and cut out,
the mine cables were successively connected with the cable leading back to the grand
junction-box and the resistances of the mines determined separately. From these it
was easy to calculate what the resistance of each group should have been if there
were no leak in and around the mine switch. The last line in above table gives the
resistances of the groups so calculated.
   The tests of November 21 exhibit the condition of the group just after planting.
They show that all the mines were serviceable, and the mine resistance nearly normal,
excepting that of triple group No. 7, whose resistance was 1,090 ohms.
   Assuming 500 ohms as the lowest limit to which the resistance of a triple group
may safely fall in main-line firing, the tests show that within four weeks after plant-
ing, two triple groups had become unserviceable; that a third group failed within
six weeks, and a fourth within nine weeks, and a fifth within about seventeen weeks,
leaving only two groups out of the original seven in proper condition for main-line
firing. The failures were due mainly to (1) leakage through the gland stuffing-boxes
into the fuze-can and into the chambers of the mine switch, and (2) to injury to the
cable insunlation. Lieutenant Pope, who personally superintended the raising and
                  APPENDIX       1-REPORT         OF MAJOR        KING.               365

dismantling of the group, reports that "considerable leakage was shown, both in the
cut-off bones and in the plugs, the fuze-cans in three of the mines containing water,
one nearly full. In some cases the "A" wire had the insulation twisted off near the
rubber packing. The leakage appeare:l to have taken place along the wire and not
by the screw-threads of the gland." The failure of groups 1, 4, and 7, so far as their
resistances were brought below the 500-ohm limit, was due to leakage in and around
the mine switches. Group 1, at last test in April, gave a resistance of 258 ohms; the
calculated resistance of the group with the switch-box cut out was 1,490 ohms. Group
4, at last test in April, gave only 18 ohms resistance; with switch-box out the resist-
ance was 2,054. The group consisted of only two mines, so that the resistance would
have been nearly normal but for the faults in the switch-box. Group 7 gave a resist-
ance of 51 ohms with switch-box in circuit, and a resistance of 683 ohms with switch
and its faults removed. The failure of the remaining two defective groups is attrib-
utable largely to leakage into the fuze-can and injury to cable insulation. As to
the injury to the cable insulation, Lieutenant Pope reports that "the armor of the
single-conductor cable was found to have been badly twisted, in every case immedi-
ately below where it was lashed to the bales, and in some cases the insulation of the
cores injured. In one case, that of a ground mine, the armor was entirely divided,
evidently by corrosion due to some local cause, and the core separated. This damage
was in the cable leading from the grand junction-box and within 2 feet of the mine,
where the cable could not have been subjected to considerable motion or strain."
   The sea-cell tests were always made in connection with the resistance tests, and
much thought and study were given to them at first with the view of determining
from their indications the probable cause or causes of the failure of the mines. Ow-
ing, however, to the disparity of the indications no definite conclusions could be drawn,
and the tests came to be regarded by all who made them as of doubtful value. In the
drills so far carried out this season the sea-cell tests have not been applied, the resis-
tance tests being accepted as the only safe guide.
   The galvanized steel cases were found practically free from rust after their six months'
exposure to the action of sea-water.

                                SECOND    GRAND) GROU.


   The group was planted in June under the immediate supervision of the artillery
officers (Lieutenants Pope, Ridgway, and Parker). Each officer having had one week's
preliminary experience in charge of the boat parties and one week's experience as
electrician. The mines were all arranged for both judgment and automatic firing.
A 100-pound mixture of sand and sawdust was used in place of the regular charge
of dynamite. The multiple cable was that used in the winter group.            The single-
conductor cable was taken from a drum of the Silvertown purchase of 1874, which
had given an insulation resistance of over three megohms per mile at 730 F., after
two weeks' submersion. The following are the principal points of our experience with
the group :
   Considerable care had to be taken in putting together the circuit closer as the ball
is liable to stick fast in some positions of the plug if the adjustment is not made with
accuracy.
   Much difficulty was experienced in adjusting the magnet of the circuit regulator.
The adjustment is so extremely delicate that the slightest turn of the screw which
regulates the pressure of the spring against the magnet may make the pressure too
heavy or too light. In the case of one regulator, adjusted to work well one day, the
magnet proved to be out of adjustment the following day. A modification of this
mechanism to make it easier and more certain of adjustment is necessary to insure its
success in the hands of an officer of average experience.
   The fault of the untwisting of the armor of the cable below where it is lashed to the
bales of the torpedo was shown in this group, although some of thesmines remained
in position only one week. The fault does not appear to be due to chafing, but to the
motion of the mine. In the grand group now being planted the effect of a wrapping
of marlin or iron wire applied to the cable to a point from 3 to 5 feet below the moor-
ing ring will be investigated. Two wrappings of armor wire in opposite directions
would doubtless be the best solution to the difficulty.
   The presence of moisture in one of the mines was found to have a marked influence
on the mine resistance, reducing the latter to nearly one-half its normal value. The
difficulty was removed by dismantling the torpedo and drying all its parts. It is sup-
posed that the charge and charge-bag, when moist, are semi-conducting, and thus
constitute a shunt circuit between the zinc plate of the regulator and the metal of the
torpedo case. It would be of value to know the behavior of a dynamite charge under
similar conditions.
  Owing to the close fit of the mine switch between the Turk's heads in the tripple
junction-box, there is danger, when the switch-box is placed in position, of injuring
 366         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

the insulation of the wires by bending the latter sharply at the glands. An enlarge-
ment of the interior space of the junction-box or a reduction in the size of the switch-
box is desirable.
   The mine switch, when loaded with the service cut-off, containing four grains of
fulminate, has not given satisfactory results, earth being frequently made through
the box. A number of trials has been made with the mechanical cut-off fuze de-
scribed in Abbot's Manual, and in each instance with perfect success,
  I desire here to invite special attention to a few points in the present organization
of the torpedo department which, in my opinion, are open to grave objections.
  The organization is given in Abbot's New Torpedo Manual, as follows, page 99 et
seq. :
  " Upon the approach of hostilities, officers of*engineers will be selected to direct
the planting and operating of the submarine defenses at the channels to be obstructed."
  "They will be provided with specific orders and plans showing the number and
location of the mines, and will make requisition upon the Battalion of Engineers and
the Engineer Depot for instructed enlisted men and the needful material."
         *         *                         *           *             ,            *




                       DUTIES OF THE COMMANDING ENGINEER.

   " His requisitions will first demand the attention of the commanding engineer ; but
before they can be drawn up correctly he must settle one matter which has been
left undecided in the approved local projects of the Board of Engineers," viz : " The
locus of the circuit regulators," whether they should be .placed in the torpedoes
themselves or in separate buoys planted some 50 or 100 feet in rear of the torpedoes
proper for the purpose of baffling the enemy's defensive outriggers. The manual
then mentions some of the conditions that would enter in a decision of this question,
and proceeds:
   "' It will be for the officer, after considering the conditions of his special problem,
to decide what proportion, if any, of his mines shall be planted with detached cir-
cuit regulators, for which provision has been made in planning the details of the sys-
tem."
   " In one contingency, not unlikely to occur, a radical modification may be neces-
sary in the projects of the Board of Engineers, and hence in the requisitions for ma-
terial, viz, when from deterioration in store the supply of insulated cables is insuf-
ficient for the demand."   *   *   *
   First. The officer who will be charged with the torpedo defense of a harbor and be
held responsible for its success is not designated until the approach of hostilities.
   The torpedo service is technical in its requirements and a working familiarity with
all its details is necessary to insure success. The detail of an officer for this duty will
be made from among those who have taken the torpedo course at Willets Point, per-
haps many years before. Being engaged in the interim in other duties he will have
forgotten much that he has learned, and at the time of his selections will in all prob-
ability not have a working knowledge of the system, and this I do not believe he can
acquire in the short time given him. Why should his problem and the fact of his
selection be withheld from him until the last moment ? Why should not the selec-
tion be made years in advance, so that the officer may have the important advan-
tages of time and careful preparation for his work ?
   Second. The officer is required to decide the question of the locus of the circuit
regulator.
   The conditions which enter into a decision of this question can be determined in
time of peace, as well as in war. The matter should therefore be definitely settled
in peace time or left out of consideration altogether.
   Third. The officer himself is required to make up the list of material required for
his harbor.
   Many objections could be urged against this provision, but I need mention only one,
viz : There is no necessity for postponing the preparation of this list till the outbreak
of hostilities, because it can be done just as well in time of peace. The torpedo officer
should be required to plant and to operate, and not to provide. The latter duty de-
volves particularly upon the commanding officer of the engineer depot.
   A modification of the organization upon the following basis is suggested as in the
direction of a better state of preparedness for actual war service :
  I. The plans of the torpedo defense to be prepared by the Board of Engineers in
sufficient detail to permit the preparation of a complete list of material.
  II. A copy of the Board's plan should be furnished to the commanding officer of the
engineer depot, whose duty it would then be to prepare the list of material required
and to provide, as far as the appropriations would allow, the articles which do not
deteriorate in store, and especially all articles of special manufacture which can not
be readily bought in open market. The lists of material for each harbor should be
                               APPENDIX 1-REPORT                     OF MAJOR KING.                               367
separate, and in a parallel column to the amount required should be placed the amount
on hand, and in a third column could be placed the amount yet to be provided. These
lists could easily be revised from time to time, as new purchases are made or material
expended. The exact condition of the supplies for each harbor would be ascertainable
at a glance. The operations of the engineer depot would thus become, in a measure,
independent of persons, and a change in the commanding officer could be made even
during the period of the most active war preparations without detriment to the serv-
ice. The duty of the commanding officer of the engineer depot should begin with
the preparation of the lists of material required for each harbor and end with the de-
livery of the material at the harbor in question. The duties of the officer selected to
conduct the defense would commence with the receipt of the material at his station.
   Ill. Each important harbor should have at all times its officer for the torpedo de-
fense. His selection need not be made public, if it be deemed impolitic to do so. He
would be informed that in the event of a war within a certain period, say five years,
he would be depended on to conduct the torpedo defense. Copies of the plans of the
Board and of the lists of material prepared by the commanding officer of the engineer
depot would be furnished him, and he would be kept informed, from time to time, of
any changes therein. He should be informed as fully as possible of the condition of
the material in store. He would be given facilities for studying all the details of the
localities, channels, currents, etc., in which he would be required to operate. This
could be done in addition to and without materially interfering with his other duties.
He would thus acquire a thorough familiarity with his duties, and upon the outbreak
of war, on the receipt of orders to actively defend his harbor, he would approach the
problem with the conciousness of being master of it in all its details and of his ability
to make the most effective use of the material supplied to him. Every difficulty that
is likely to arise will have been considered and provided for, and every provision
made to insure dispatch, regularity, and precision in the operations of the defense.
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                                     S. W.      ROESSLER,
                                                                                           Captain of Engineers.
    The POST ADJUTANT.



Table of resistances (in ohms) of the mines of Experimental Grand Group as determined
                                    by the winter tests.

[The value given for each week is the mean of the daily tests of that week.                       Groups 1 and 4 have
                                      only two mines each. I


                                                                            Triple group number.
                      Week ending--

                                                          1.        2.       3.       4.         5.       6.      7.

November 21, 1887. (Just after planting
groups.).......................                         2, 120   1, 390    1,420    2,236      1, 460   1, 400   1, 090
December 16 1887.....            . ......                   487   1, 157    1, 367     479      1, 355   1, 335   1,089
December 23, 1887.........................                 234      884     1, 390     130      1, 368   1, 368     718
December 30, 1887.............             ...........     240      713     1,402      104      1, 312   1,387      856
January 6, 1888.........................                   111      205     1, 425      80      1,198    1, 395     828
January13, 1888.........................                   248      476     1, 434     235      1, 264   1, 278     910
January 20, 1888.....................                      290       90     1, 395      10      1, 367   1, 357     835
January 27, 1888........................                   143       97     1, 395         57   1, 394   1, 407     374
February 3, 1888........................                   275      165     1, 390         30   1, 350   1, 365        30
February 10, 1888 ........ ...................             120       74     1,415          40   1, 370   1, 414        39
February 17, 1888..........................                340      106     1, 400         62   1, 400   1, 408        46
February 24, 1888 ........................                 530       10     1, 327      28      1, 377   1,385       31
March 2, 1888............................                  436       11        983      36      1,357    1,342       79
March 9, 1888...........................                   438        9.4      848      45      3, 385   1,364      224
March 16, 1888.................................            586       22        919      62      1,387    1,349      338
March 23, 1888........................                     434       47        675     139      1,376    1,376      242
March 30,1888...........................                   471       14        477      47      1,390    1,390       97
April 6, 1888....................................          470       20       115          20   1,360    1, 360        70
April 13, 1888......................
April 21,1888..........................
                                                           414
                                                           238
                                                                     18
                                                                     12
                                                                              120          23   3.,
                                                                                                  370    1, 246        81
                                                                              135          18   1,068    1,353         51
Resistance of group with switch-box cut out              1,490       30       211    2,054...............           683
36$       REPORT       OF           THE             CHIEF     OF   ENGINEERS,                         U.   S.     ARMY.




                                                                            TORPEDO DEPARTMENT,
                                                            illets Point, NewYork Harbor, July 16, 1888.
  Sin: I have the honor to report the following tests of Henley's ozokerite multiple
cable, purchase of 1883.
  The purchase included 9 miles of cable, or 18 drums.
  One drum has been used in drills and experiments; the remaining 17 are stored in
casemate No. 2.
  The records do not show that any previous tests of them have been made.
  For convenience in making and recording the tests, the drums in the casemate have
been numbered from 1 to 17.  To facilitate an inspection of the cables the number of
each drum and its tests have been recorded on a small piece of board nailed to the
drum.
  At the beginning of the tests, the usual method with Thomson's reflecting galvanonm-
eter being found inapplicable, it was discovered, in attempting to number the op-
posite ends of the cores for the purpose of applying the fault test, that the resistance
of the insulation between the cores, wet or dry, was so low as to give an appreciable
deflection on the service detector.   The tests were therefore made without placing
the cables in the tanks.   The method used was that   of measuring the resistance of a
conductor with a bridge rheostat and Sieman's galvanometer for balancing.       Battery
used, 6-cell Leclanche testing battery.   One of the cores was taken at random, and
the resistances between it and others were successively measured.     Both ends of each
drum were uncovered and the cores separated so as to avoid contact between the
copper conductors.


                               Insulation re-                                                                   Insulation re-
                                sistance be-                                                                     sistance be-
       Description.                                   Ohms.               DU
                                                                           )escription.                          tween cores Ohms.
                               tween cores
                                    (dry).                                                                           (dry).


                                 Between-                                                                         Between-
Drum 1.-Cores num-(            1 and 2......             564                                                 1 and 2     -...... 66 64
bered and tagged from         11 and 43 .....
                                         ....            587                                                 1 and 3......      1, 184
1 to 7. One lead was           1 and ......             694    Drum 6. -Outer                    end of     1 and 4......         78B0
attached to core 1 and'                                 519             cable.                              1 and 5......         78 0
the other to cores 2 to        1 and 6......
                                                         547                                               SI and 6......          81 7
7 in succession.               1 and 7-......           520                                                                       86 4
                                                                                                           S1 and 7......
Drum 1 (continued).-                                                                                       (1     and 2......            74t0
                               1 and      2 ....         573
Lead wires then trans-        1 and      3......                                                               1 and3......          1,6770
ft red to the other end                                 580
                               1 and      4......        680    Drum 7.                                         1 and 4......            71 7
of the cable, the cores       1 and      5......        517                                               ................
                                                                                                                1 and 5......            7J '0
  being numbered to cor-       I and      6......                                                               1 and 6......            7770
                                                         550
respond with the num-
bers at the first end.        1 and      7..--          517                                               (    1 and 7......            78
                                                                                                                 1 and 2.....           613
Drum 1 (continued).- ( 1 and 2 -....                     585                                                     1 and 3......          680
One lead then attached 1 1 and 3.....                   609
                                                                DIrum 8.
                                                                                         f 1 and 4......                                644
to core 1 and the other S 1 and 4......
lead to cores 2 to 7 in ) 1 and 5......
                                                         690
                                                         510
                                                                         '----~~--~- """ ~ 11 and 5......
                                                                                              and 6......
                                                                                                                                        810
                                                                                                                                        710
succession at the other I 1 and 6......
end of cable.             1 and 7......
                                                         550
                                                         514
                                                                                         I 1 and 7......                                869

                                                                                                                 1    and   2......     910
                                1   and 2.....           400                                                     1    and   3......     620
                                1   and 3 .....          320                                                     1    and   4......     670
Drum 2.-Outer end of i
       cable.              1    1
                                1
                                1
                                1
                                    and 4.....
                                    and 5......
                                    and 6......
                                    and 7......
                                                         349
                                                         420
                                                         350
                                                                Drum 9.    ..



                                                                                       ............

                                                                                                           I
                                                                                                                 1
                                                                                                                 1
                                                                                                                 1
                                                                                                                      and
                                                                                                                      and
                                                                                                                      and
                                                                                                                            5......
                                                                                                                            6......
                                                                                                                            7......
                                                                                                                                        560
                                                                                                                                        650
                                                                                                                                        684
                                                         340
                                                                                                           I     1    and   2......     557
                                1   and   2......      1, 470                                                    1    and   3 ....      527
                                1   and   3.....       1, 240                                                    1    and   4-----.     517
Drum 3.-Outer end of            1   and   4......      1, 350   Drum 10         S...                             11   and
                                                                                                                      and   4......
                                                                                                                            5..         550
        cable.                  1   and   5......      1, 370                                                1 and 6*.....              700
                                1   and   6..--.       1, 440                                              I 1 andl 7 ....              520
                               .1   and   7......      1, 300
                                                                                                                 1 and 2*...--          750
                                1 and 2 .....           470                                                  1        and   3.....      700
Drum 4.-Inner end of       j
                                1 and 3......
                               Sand 4....
                                                        472
                                                        1,290   Drum 11    ...                               1        and   4......     740
        cable.                 1 and 5......
                                1 and 6 .....
                                                         472
                                                         510
                                                                                                           ( 1
                                                                                                           I 1
                                                                                                             1
                                                                                                                      and
                                                                                                                      and
                                                                                                                      and
                                                                                                                            5.....
                                                                                                                            6......
                                                                                                                            7......
                                                                                                                                        730
                                                                                                                                        770
                                                                                                                                        X90
                                1 and 7....              517
                                                                                                                 1    and 2* ...      1, 230
                             1 and        2 ...          834                                                     1    and 3 ....         600
                             1and         3 ....         630
Drum 5.-Outer end of         1 and        4......        ..00  Druu 12          .._                              1
                                                                                                                 1
                                                                                                                      and 4 .---...
                                                                                                                      and 5......
                                                                                                                                         640
                                                                                                                                         640
        cable.               1 and        S--.           949                                                     1    and 6......        620
                             1 and        6......        737                                                     1    and 7......        630
                           I 1 and        7......        827
                                                       * Center core.
                             APPENDIX            1-REPORT                  OF MAJOR KING.                                     369

                                      Insulation Ire-                                                       Insulation re-
        Description.                   sistanco be-      Ohms.                  Description.                 sistance be. Ohms.
                                       tween cores                              Description.                 tween cores
                                           (dry.)                                                                (dry.)


                                       Between-                                                            Betwoeen-
                                      2   and
                                            6*....        1,390                                         ( 1 and 2*.....         690
                                      2     1......
                                          and              770                                          I   1 and   3......      770
Drum 13....   ............            2   and
                                            3---......     710                                              1 and   4......   1,070
                                      2     4......
                                          and              700            rum                               1 and   5......      740
                                      2and 5......         780                                              1 and6......         630
                                      2 and 7-----....     730                                          (   1and 7......         780

                                  (    2and1*.....          810                                         (    land 2......     1, 250
                                       2 and 3......        590                                         I      and3......     1, 260
Drum14.................                2and4 ......         530                                              1 and4......     1, 230

                                  S2   2 and 5......
                                         and 6......
                                       2 and 7......
                                                            570
                                                            540
                                                            590
                                                                     Drum 17.....              ..
                                                                                                        I
                                                                                                             1 and 5......
                                                                                                             land6 ......
                                                                                                             1 and 7......
                                                                                                                              1, 300
                                                                                                                              1,240
                                                                                                                              1, 330
                                     2 and 1*.....        1,190
                                     2 and 3......          740
.Drum 15...._....         .....   ,  2 and 4......          650
                                  S2   and 5......          690
                                   S2 and 6......            710
                                   S2 and 7......           700


                                                         *Center core.

   It is recommended that the above lot of cable be submitted to the action of an
inspector.
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                                                 S.    W.     ROESSLER,
                                                                                                      Captain of Engineers.
   TILE POST ADJUTANT.


                                                                   (3.)

                                                              MWILLETS           POINT, NEW YORK HARBOR,
                                                                           July 17, 1888.
    SIR: I have the honor to submit the following list of cables whose insulation re-
sistances have fallen below one-tenth of a megohm per mile at 750 Fahr. It is rec-
ommended that they be submitted to the action of an inspector.
    Ten drums or 5 miles Silvertown multiple, purchase of 1874. Drum numbers and
tests are as follows:
    Drum No. 893: Date of test, October 25, 1877; observer, General Abbot. Rang
numbers freely, i. e., totally bad.
    Drum No. 904: Date of test, October 25, 1877; observer, General Abbot. Rang
bell freely.
    Drum No. 965: Date of test, October 29, 1886; observer, Lieutenant Hale. High-
est resistance of any core, 3,060 ohms per mile; lowest, 780 ohms.
    Drum No. 985: Date of test, December 21, 1877; observer, General Abbot. Defects
42 ° with all cores on. No wetting since October 26, 1877.
    Drum No. 1024: Date of test, August 2, 1876; observer, General Abbot. Resist-
ance of cores from 9,000 to 30,000 ohms.
    Drum No. 1025: Date of test, October 30, 1875; observer, General Abbot. Insula-
  tion resistance varied from .05 to .11 megohms.
    Drum No. 1026: Date of test, June 2, 1b86; observer, Lieutenant Langfitt. Insu-
  lation resistance of cores per mile at 75 ° Fahr., 7,212 to 12,588 ohms.
     Drum No. 1035: Date of test, November 9, 1886; observer, Lieutenant IIale. Insu-
  lation resistance per mile at 750 varied from 20 to 325 ohms.
     Drum No. 1043: Date of test, August 2, 1876; observer, General Abbot. Resist-
  ance (mean) of cores, about 3,000 ohms.
     Drum number washed off: Date of test, not known; observer, Captain Knight.
  Highest resistance of any core, 2,240 ohms.
     Henley ozonite, purchase of 1883. One drum or one-half mile.
     No. 18: Insulation resistance so low as to give a sensible deflection on service de-
  tector.
     Four drums or 8 miles Silvertown single conductor cable, purchase of 1874. Drum
  numbers and tests are as follows:
     Drum No. 151: Date of test, April 24, 1888* observer, Captain Roessler Insuli,
  tion resistance (rough), 5,540 ohms,
            ENG 88-24
370     REPORT OF THE CHIEF              OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   Drum No. 153: Date of test, April 26, 1888; observer, Captain Roessler. Insula
tion resistance, 31,338 ohms at 410 Fahr.
   Drum No. 164: Date of test, November 9, 1886; observer, Lieutenant Hale. Insu-
lation resistance, 9,500 ohms per mile at 750 Fahr.
   Drum No. 192: Date of test, October 26, 1877; observer, General Abbot. Insula-
tion resistance, 6,000 ohms.
   Siemen's single conductor, sample mile, one drum, purchase of 1874: Date of test,
October 19, 1874; observer, General Abbot. Insulation resistance, 11,422 ohms.
   To the above list should be added the 17 drums of Henley's ozokerite multiple
cable which I reported upon in my letter of the 16th instant.
   This letter should form an appendix to my letter of the 16th.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                            S.   WV. ROESSLER,
                                                                 Captain of Engineers
  The POST ADJUTANT.



  APPENDIX E.--REPORT OF LIEUTENANT IRVING HALE, CORPS OF ENGINEERS.

                                        WILLETS PoINT, NEW YORK HARBOR,
                                                                           July 7, 1888.
   SIR: I have the honor to submit the following report of work in the photographic
laboratory during the year ending June 30, 1888.
   During February, March, and April, 1888, each of the five second-year officers took
a four weeks' course in photography. During the time devoted to the regular winter
course of study (December 6, 1887, to April 29, 1888), two non-commissioned officers
were detailed each week for instruction in map-printing, and in addition were given
as much instruction and practice in the other branches of the subject as the time per-
mitted. During he greater part of the year three non-commissioned officers (Sergeant
Wunder, Company A; Sergeant Helling, Company B; Corporal Burtner, Company C)
alternated on duty in the laboratory, and received instruction and practice in all
branches of the subject, with a view to the selection of a successor to Sergeant Von
Sothen at the end of his enlistment, which expires in August, 1888.
   The officers' course comprised the subjects laid down in Post Orders No. 233, 1887,
and also as much practice as the limited time permitted, with the "American film"
negative and bromide paper, which will probably play an important part in military
photography in the future, inasmuch as the film negatives can be carried in a roll in
the camera, admitting of two dozen exposures without removing roll, and the bro-
mide paper enables prints to be made very rapidly at night by the light of a lamp,
rendering the operator independent of daylight.
   In previous years the course in photography has covered two seasons, and consisted
of four weeks in each of the first and second years, these weeks not, however, being
consecutive. The reduction of the course to one season is an improvement, and the
making of the work continuous is a great advantage, and is, in fact, essential to good
results, but it was found that four weeks is a little too short a time to accomplish the
work laid out. Every officer was obliged to spend at least one additional week at the
laboratory, and some more, to do the work presented in the order. If photolithography
were omitted, the time would be reduced by one or two weeks, but as the making of
a good map negative requires considerable skill and practice, and involves different
operations from the ordinary negative, and as an officer ought to understand the trans-
fer to the stone and printing, even though he may not expect to have occasion to do
this work himself, it would not seem advisable to omit this part of the course if it
can be avoided.
   In view of these facts, the following recommendations are submitted :
   First. That the course consist of at least five, and if practicable of six weeks, and
that these weeks be consecutive.
   Second. That not more than two officers be allowed to work at the laboratory at the
same time, and if the class is small enough it would be better to have only one officer
on the duty at a time. It is impossible for a person to do good work unless he can
keep apparatus and chemicals in perfect order, know just what each bottle contains
and how many times the solution has been used, and in general have entire control
over all the material, and this can not be done when two or more are working with
the sgmp things; moreover, with two or three officers and as many non-commissioned
Sfficers in the I~boratory at a time, and all wanting, almpst continually, instruction
pr assistance or material, the sergeant in charge is uinable to do justice to his work.
   Third. That considerable atteyti(n ho giveIq t the makig of (pla pegftivye 4
t]euseof bromide i~pey                                             o   n
                APPENDIX 1-REPORT              OF MAJOR KING.                   -371
  Fourth. That more instruction be given than heretofore in the use of the alkaline
developer; this developer is only mentioned in the text-book, but since the latter was
written the alkaline developer has grown much in favor with photographers, and
when skillfully handled possesses advantages over the oxalate developer.
  During the past few years considerable progress and numerous changes have been
made in photographic practice, notably in the perfection of the film negative and
rapid-printing bromide paper and in the introduction of the new developers.
  I have therefore directed Sergeant Von Sothen to prepare a paper on these subjects,
giving also any other changes or improvements that have been made since the text-
book was written.
  This will be forwarded when completed.
  Respectfully submitted.
                                                             IRVING HALE,
                                      First Lieutenantof Engineers, Instructor in
                                       Military Photography, U. S. Engineer School.
The ADJUTANT,
      Post of Willets Point.
               RIVERS AND HARBORS, ETC.



                               APPENDIX A.




IMPROVEMENTS OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE STATES OF MAINE
                     AND NEW HAMPSHIRE.




REPORT OF LIEUTENANT-COLONEL JARED A. SMITH, CORPS OF ENGI-
NEERS, OFFICER IN CHARGE, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE
30, 1888, WITH OTHER DOCUMENTS RELATING TO THE WORKS.

                               IMPROVEMENTS.

1.   Lubec Channel, Maine.                 9. Breakwater at mouth of Saco River,
2.   Moose-a-bee Bar, Maine..                   Maine.
3.   Narraguagus River, Maine.            10. Saco River, Maine.
4.   Bangor Harbor and Penobscot River,   11. Kennebunk River, Maine.
      Maine.                              12. York Harbor, Maine.
5.   Belfast Harbor, Maine.               13. Portsmouth Harbor, New Hampshire.
6.   Rockland Harbor, Maine.              14. Cocheco River, New Hampshire.
7.   Portland Harbor, Maine.              15. Harbor of Refuge, at Little Harbor,
8.   Channel in Back Cove, Portland,            New Hampshire.
      Maine.

                        EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS.

16. Bayoduce [Bagaduce] River, Maine,     19. Kennebec River, Maine, at Bath, and
      between the towns of Penobscot and        from Augusta to lower end of Per-
      Brooksville.                              kin's Island.
17. Camden Harlor, Maine.                .20. Penobscot River, Maine, from Bangor
18. Rockport Harbor, Maine.                     to Bucksport Narrows.




                            UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                          Portland, Me., July 9, 1888.
     SIR: I forward herewith annual reports for river and harbor works
in my charge for fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
      Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                   JARED A. SMITH,
                                           Lieut. Col., Corps of Engineers.

     The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. A.
                                                                        373
374      REPORT OF THE CHIEF            OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                       Ai.

                IMPROVEMENT OF LUBEC CHANNEL, MAINE.

   At the beginning of the fiscal year the contractors, Messrs. Moore &
Wright, were engaged upon the work of widening the channel by dredg-
ing.
   About the middle of August work under the contract was completed,
the amount being limited by the available funds.
  Under this contract 24,172 cubic yards of material were removed in
the fiscal year, making a total of 25,153 under the entire contract.
  As a result the widening has been completed for about one-half the
length of the channel from the south or Quoddy Roads end.
  There remains to be dredged to complete the widening of channel to
275 feet, and to 300 feet in the bends, about 45,000 cubic yards, at an
estimated cost of 50 cents per cubic yard, including all contingent ex-
penses.
  The following remarks in the Annual Report of 1886 are considered
worthy of repetition here:
  While the channel now gives a depth of 12 feet at mean low water, the variations
are so great that a minimum depth of 8 feet occurs at extreme low tides. No vessel
can pass through drawing the. extreme depth of water, and in such rapid currents as
here obtain in a narrow channel even the best steamers must have 2 or more feet of
water under their keels to permit their handling with safety.
  The benefits to navigation and to commerce from the improvement are not local.
The channel forms a part of a thoroughfare to and from the St. Croix River and
the waters of the Passamaquoddy Bay, and is not only the shortest route and the
only channel not exposed to the open sea, but is the only one in American waters
through which vessels can reach many points on our eastern border.
  During heavy gales many vessels find refuge and anchorage in the lower part of
Quoddy Roads; in such cases when the wind changes to the eastward there is no
longer any protection and no escape, save by the Lubec Channel, which must afford
a sufficient draught of water at all times to make it effective. Before the improve-
ment was undertaken many vessels were thus hemmed in and wrecked. (See "Report
of Chief of Engineers, 1879, Appendix A, page 281.)
  Save for use in the fisheries, the smaller vessels are gradually disap-
pearing from the coast, as they can not compete in the carrying of
freights with vessels of larger capacity so that deeper channels will be
required in future than those heretofore necessary.
  The recommendations previously made to dredge the channel to a
depth of 15 feet are therefore renewed.
  This work will not be injured by a few years' delay, and it would, in
my opinion, be better to leave it until a sufficient appropriation to do
the work effectively can be made in one sum.
  Lubec is in the collection district of Passamaquoddy. The nearest port of entry is
Eastport, Me. The nearest light-house in the United States is on West Quoddy Head,
about 4 miles below.
  There is a Canadian light-house on Mulholland's Point, at the narrows opposite
Lubec.
  The channel is a thoroughfare to various points on our eastern coast,
as well as a factor of safety for the anchorage in Quoddy Roads when
the wind changes to easterly points. Local statistics are, therefore,
very incomplete, and there is no means of ascertaining the exact num-
ber of passing vessels. In 1882 a record was kept of about 10,000 ves-
sels passing Quoddy Head-light-house.   N o subsequent record has been
kept. A record of vessels seen to pass the life-saving station at Lubec
in 1887, in day-time and clear weather, shows the number to be 8,683.
                     APPENDIX             A--REPORT                                OF LIEUT.                                 COL. SMITH.             375
The following appropriations have been made for improving Lubec
Channel.
By act of March 3, 1879----..-........---..----......--... --                                                                  ....... .--.    $44,000.00
By act of June 14, 1880......                               ..         .....------.........................--..                                 20, 000. 00
By    act    of   March 3, 1881............----------------
                                                      ...................................                                                       45, 000.00
By    act    of                               --....
                  August 2, 1882..---.... --.....-..                 ........--..-----......----------------.                                   20, 000. 00
By    act    of   July 5, 1884....................------------------------..-----..........------..---                                          10, 000. 00
By    act    of   August 5, 1886....---.........--          ........................                 ...-     .                                 10,000.00
          Total ............---           --............---..............---------......                                         .....         149, 000.00

Expenditures to June 30, 1887................--        ....--... .... .............                                                            139,932.04
Expenditures in last fiscal year      ........................----..---.........                                                                 9,057.93
          Total expenditures to June 30, 1888 ..............................                                                                   148, 989.97
   It is proposed to expend such funds as may be available for the en-
suing year in widening the channel, so that it shall have a clear width
of 275 feet, and 25 feet additional at the bends. After this is completed,
it is recommended that any additional amounts which may be appro-
priated shall be expended in deepening the channel to 15 feet in accord-
ance with the project of 1884.
   The additional cost of deepening the channel to 15 feet is estimated
at $135,000.
                                                         Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available .......................................                                                                          $9, 067,96
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstayding July 1, 1887 ..............................-----------------------------------...........                                          9, 057.93
July 1, 1888, balance available .........................................                                                                            10.03
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .-.... ...- .. ............                                                                       20, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...................                                                                        20, 010.03
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......                                                                        2,500. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                                                     2, 500.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                         COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR 1887.

Number of steam-boat lines at Eastport---------------------............... ...............                                                                4
Arrivals of steam-boats at Eastport.... ............ .....................                                                                           1,000
Arrivals of sailing vessels at Eastport and Lubec -....... ................                                                                             650
Greatest draught of vessels ....-...................................                  feet..                                                             16
Number of vessels owned at Eastport and Lubec ........................                                                                                  252
    Tonnage ..........................................................                                                                              25, 722

                                EXPORTS OF EASTPORT,                                       LUBEC, AND CALAIS.

Sardines--..       .............................................------                          -- .. cases..     350,000
Smoked herring .........................                          ---- ....................          boxes.. 1,000,000
Pickled herring.... ..............................--                                 ....-...... barrels ..        12,000
Potatoes ........................................................                                      do....      25,000
Lumber ........................................................                                        feet.. 40, 000, 000
Dry fish.................                   ....      .. ....        ..........                                   ........        quintals..        11,650
Fresh fish ..................................................                                                                       pounds.. 20,250, 000

                                                                         IMPORTS.
Coal- ............            .............                  ----          ..-- --..--.......-- ..... .. tons..
                                                                       ...--                                                                        55, 600
Lime ..          .... ............-......-..............--..                  ....... ........ casks..                                               7,350
Corn ...................-...-                    ..... ...........................                   bushels..                                     273,000
Kerosine oil. ..............................................                                          barrels. -                                    38, 000
376              REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Iron--..------------------------------------------------.........................................................               -tons..                     373
Plaster----..........---                 ----........------.....-----....---....-----............---.... .....--...------             do..               13, 000
Flour ....          ....................................................                                                      barrels..                  93,000
                                      ...............------....-------..............-------..----..
Sardine oil----.....----...----..--...--                                                                                           do...                  7, 000
Tin and pig-lead-...---...-----------............------......--------........-----.-----....---..-.......- tons..                    7, 000
Tin-plate.......... ......---- ................                  .... ..............---- ---........            do..               13, 569
Coke for sardine factories ...                                                                                   do..                    800
                                                                                                           -....................................

  The following commercial statistics for the Passamaquoddy district for the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1888, were received from the collector of customs:

                                                          Shipping.          .                                                        Number. Tonnage.


Arrivals from foreign ports.......................................................                                                               761     197, 762
Clearances for foreign ports.......................................................                                                              841     205, 519

Amount of revenue collected ..........................                                       ........            ...  .................                  $93, 315
Value of importations .........          ....-...         -......                .........          ..   ..     .. ..    ...         .. ....             860, 809
Value of exportations ........................         ..         .                           ...             ..       ...         ...........           645, 277




                                                                            A 2.

                            IMPROVEMENT OF MOOSE-A-BEC BAR, MAINE.

   This bar, at the eastern terminus of Moose-a-bec Reach, is near the
town of Jonesport, Me., about 30 miles east of Mount Desert. The
a Reach " is a thoroughfare of about 12 miles in length, which is trav-
ersed by thousands of vessels annually; in addition to this it forms an
admirable harbor of refuge, and is used as such by many vessels, espe-
cially in the winter months.
   The project for improving the channel contemplated dredging the bar
to a depth of 14 feet and width of 200 feet, and removing the rock known
as Steam-boat Ledge" to a depth of 15 feet at mean low water. The es-
timated cost of the improvement as amended was $40,000. The dredg-
ing then projected was completed in 1885.
   The following appropriations have been made for this work :
March 3, 1881 .-----.-                     ...        ..-..      .         . ..--. .               ..-.--.-           .. .                        $10,   000.00
Augost '2, 1882 ....------..-                                            ------------------......................
                                                            ------........................-----                                                    10,   000.00
July 5, 1884 ..........-------....--- ....-------....------....--------....----..........-----......-----....--....----.....                       10,   000. 00
August 5, 1886-----......-----......----------....---....----......--......--....----....---....---.......--.. ------                              10,   000. 00
            Total.... ....-----------..... -----..- ....-------....----......----....--..------....
                                                                                    40, 000. 00
                                                                          ---......--------......
            Expenditures to June 30, 1888 ....................................                                                                      31, 841. 77
   The balance now available is sufficient to complete the improvement
as originally planned.
   In August, 1887, a contract was concluded for removing the rock from
"' Steam-boat Ledge" to a depth of 15 feet at mean low water. It was
near the 1st of September before the necessary formalities could be com-
pleted, and the time was therefore insufficient to complete the work be-
fore the autumn months, when it could not be done without great expense
and exposure. Only about 50 cubic yards were removed.
   The contract has therefore been extended to September 29, 1888, at
which time it is expected the presentproject will be completed.
   Moose-a-bee Reach having the bar at its eastern extremity is a thorough-
fare for thousands of sail-vessels and many steamers annually. The
reach is nearly straight and is thoroughly protected from the sea by
islanms and shoals, so that it is very much used as a harbor of refuge.
               APPENDIX           A-REPORT               OF LIEUT.          COL.     SMITHII.              377
   It is earnestly desired by the owners and masters of vessels navigat-
ing the thoroughfare that the channel over the bar be increased to 300
feet in width, and that the small ledges in the reach be removed. The
ledges should be removed to a depth of not less than 16 feet. The work
completed and the additional work desired are shown upon map oppo-
site page 534, Annual Report of Chief of Engineers for 1886.
   The estimate for this work is repeated from last Annual Report, de-
ducting amount of ledge to be removed under present contract:
Removing 3,064 cubic yards of ledge, at $22..--..........................--. $67, 408
Widening channel to 300 feet, 65,000 cubic yards, scow measurement, at 35
  cents .------.....---......-----......----.....-------....----....------....--....-----......-----           22,750
                                                                                           ......----....----....--....
Constructing small breakwater to divert cross-currents .---................... 6,000
Contingencies, about 10 per cent..----..............................
                                                       -....--......           8, 842

                                                                                                        105, 000
  The work can not be done with economy on very small appropriations.
  The improvement is in the collection district of Machias, Me.                         The nearest port of
entry is Machias, Me. The nearest light-house is Moose Peak.
  With the available means it has been found impossible to obtain
exact statistics for this work. The commerce of the nearest town is
small, but the amount of commerce benefited by the improvement is
very large and bears little or no relation to the merely local wants.
  Moose-a-bec Reach is a thoroughfare for a large number of vessels and
steamers plying between the Dominion of Canada and ports in the
United States, and does not depend for its usefulness upon any local
commerce.     It is estimated that the number of vessels using this
thoroughfare and receiving benefit from the improvements is as great
as twenty-five thousand annually. Before this improvement was made
the route was used by comparatively few vessels.

                                            Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..........----....-----....---......----.......--------.       --   $9, 606.89
July 1, 1888, amount (xpended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887-............--              ....-- ......          $569. 81
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities --------....-----..-----.......--.........--------.  87. 85
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts..-.......... 1,621.00
                                                                                                    3, 069.66
July 1, 1888, balance available ......-..........                     ..................... 6,537.23
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888......-
                                                 -..---.........-
                                                              -..                             - -. 15, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                             21,537.23



Abstract of proposals for removing ledge from Moose-a-bee Bar, Maine, received July
                                       23, 1887.


                                                                                                 Price per cubic
No.                             Names and address of bidders.                                     yard measured
                                                                                                  in place.

  1   George W. Townsend, Boston Mass. ---...........
                                                  .................                          .              $24. 83
  2   John F. Hamilton, Portland,          ..............................................                    26.00
  3   Louis E. Lunt, Portland, Me..................................................                          16.20


  A contract was made with Louis E. Lunt, of Portland, Me., August 12, 1887..
378             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                      COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The following commercial statistics for the Machias district for the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1888, were furnished by the collector of customs :

                                                      Shipping.                          INumber. Tonnage.


Vessels arrived from foreign ports............................................._..             19     2, 279
Vessels cleared for foreign ports...................................................          196    31, 341
Vessels built in the district..--.....................................................          2         74

Amount of revenue collected .......     .......................   ............................     $155.87
Value of importations .............................................. ...........     ...- ..      3,329.75
Value of exportations..               ------                     ---------....-                . 43, 330.59




                                                                        A 3.
                        IMPROVEMENT OF NARRAGUAGUS RIVER, MAINE.

   At the beginning of the fiscal year a contract was outstanding with
Messrs. Moore & Wright, of Portland, Me., for commencing the im-
provement of this channel by dredging.
   Work under the contract was commenced on the 16th of August and
completed October 10. There were removed from the channel and
dumped in deep water outside, 55,450 cubic yards of material measured
in scows.
   The result is a practicable channel 114 feet deep and 5,000 feet long
to the lower steam-boat wharf, the width being 50 feet on the bottom
for about 3,600 feet from deep water and the remainder 75 feet wide on
the bottom.
   This is already a great improvement to the navigation, but as it is not
wide enough to permit steam-boats to turn within its limits, it is but lit-
tle used by large steamers, which therefore wait outside and are light-
ered of their freight and passengers by a small steamer which runs to
the wharf in town.
   As soon as the channel can be widened so that the steamers may turn,
much delay and expense will be avoided.
   The town of Mil bridge, at the head of the present navigation, is a
shipping point to and from a considerable section of country which has
no other convenient connection with commercial points.
   The mouth of the river, in addition to its facilities for navigation, is
used as a refuge and anchorage for steamers and other vessels in storms;
the completion of the channel will therefore add an element of safety as
well as convenience.
   Previous to June 30, 1887, no expenditures had been made for this
improvement save in necessary preparatory work, costing $257. During
the last fiscal year there has been expended $9,743; total expenditure,
$10,000. The total expense of the work thus far has been approximately
18k cents per cubic yard. The amount (estimated) required to complete
the improvement is $40,000.
   The improvement is in the collection district of Machias. The nearest port of entry
is Machias. The nearest light-house is Narraguagus light-house on Pond Island.
  The steamers of the Portland, Bangor and MVachias Steam-boat Com-
pany touch at Millbridge four times each week. Other irregular lines
touch at the same place.
               APPENDIX           A--REPORT             OF LIEUT.     COL. SMITH.             379
                                           Mlioney statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available......................................----                 $9,743.00
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ......-----------...............       .......                 9,743.00

Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                  10,000.00
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project           --------      30,000.00
                                                                                         30, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30,1890
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                       COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

Arrivals and departures of steamers.--------------------------------------                      185
Arrivals and departures of sailing vessels ................................                     350
Number of vessels owned in Millbridge..............................               ....           50
     Tonnage ...... ...-----......................------    -----...
                                        -----------....--.............--       tons.          3, 000
Number of vessels now building ........................................                                       5
   Average tonnage                                                                            tons..
                                                          ............-------.---........-------........    200
Receipts :
   Stock for manufacture of canned goods, and supplies, and general mer-
      chandise for consumption of 5,000 people.
Exports:
   Lumber............                                        ...................... .feet..
                                                      ............                                   5,000, 000
   Canned goods .........................................                                    cases..    20, 000
   Eggs ....------....--.....----------....------....                        --------....----
                                                                                    ..         do...
                                                          ---......----..........--....---....--         3,000



                                                     A 4.
IMPROVEMENT OF BANGOR HARBOR AND PENOBSCOT RIVER, MAINE.

  The project heretofore adopted for improving the Penobscot River
contemplates widening the channel in the harbor of Bangor so as to
give a width of not less than 300 feet and a depth of 11 feet at extreme
low water, and to increase the width at Crosby's Narrows, 3 miles
below.
  The cost of the work was originally estimated at $75,000.
  The following appropriations have been made for the work:
By act of July 5, 1884 ........................ .-......-................              $20, 000. 00
By act of August 5, 1886............................................                    15,000.00
        Total.....----------------..............----..-----------------------..
                                                                   35,000.00
                                                                   24,795.07
        Expenditures to June 30, 1888..-------------------------------.............
  As a result, the channel between Bangor and Brewer has been
widened an average amount of 100 feet, giving at. least 300 feet in full
width, with a depth of 11 feet for a distance of about 2,750 feet.
   At the beginning of the fiscal year a contract had been made with
Messrs. Moore and Wright for dredging and removing large rocks, to
continue the widening of channel.
   The contractors were very dilatory in commencing the work, urging
various reasons for delay, none of which were satisfactory to this office.
The contract had, however, been taken at exceptionally low rates for
that location, and if it were to be annulled no practical gain to the work
would result either in time or price. It seemed an object to avoid pos-
sible litigation and trouble so long as a prospect remained that the work
would ultimately be completed. The contract has therefore been twice
extended, the last time to October 15, 1888.
380              REPORT OF TIIE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The entire amount accomplished under the contract until June 30,
1888, consisted in dredging 14,102 cubic yards and removing 9p cubic
yards of large stone from the channel.
     The contract will probably be completed on or before the date to
which it has been extended.
     The amount estimated to complete the improvement as projected is
$40,000, and it would result in great economy to the work if it could be
made available in a single sum.
   The funds available for the ensuing year and the appropriation asked
for year ending June 30, 1890, are to be expended in pushing the im-
p)rovement toward completion, as indicated.
  Under the requirements of the river and harbor act of August 5,
1886, a survey of the river between Bangor and Bucksport Narrows
was made in the autumn of 1887. A report and estimate for the im-
provements which are considered necessary to accomplish what is re-
quired was submitted January 11, 1888, and was printed in Ex. Dec.
No. 133, House of Representatives, Fiftieth Congress, first session. A
copy of this report is appended hereto.
  Should the work be authorized by Congress, annual appropriations
as great as $50,000 are recommended, in order that the improvement
may be prosecuted with economy and dispatch.
  The commerce of the Penobscot River is very large. The navigable
part of the river reaches the interior of the State at a very central and
important point, where it touches the line of railroad which connects
the United States with the provinces of New Brunswick and Nova
Scotia.
  Bangor, near which the improvements are located, is a port of entry.                                                       Fort Knox
the nearest fort, is at the narrows, opposite Bucksport.

                                   Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available--- ....--............--.....----........-......----     $14,596.03
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 187-................. ........ $3, 868. 35
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities _..........................              522. 75
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts ............             9, 822. 92
                                                                                                                                  14, 214. 02

July 1, 1888, balance available -                                   .-.-....... ------------...
                                                                                          .....                  ..      .           382. 01
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ......                                                .. ......    ..
                                                                                                                 -.....        50, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 18895 ................                                                           50, 382. 01

    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                                     40, 000.00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                                        COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The following commercial statistics for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, were
furnished by the collector of customs for the Bangor district :

                                                       Shipping.                                                      Number. Tonnage.

Arrivals from foreign ports .......................................................                                          17      3,166
Clearances for foreign ports......................................................                                           37     14, 013
Vessels built (steamers)....................................                           -----------------------                1         203. 21

Amount of duties collected on imports ...-...................... ..............- ..- ...........   $147,103
Value of dutiable importations .-.-                    -------              ---------            .---446, 825
Value of free importations ................................. ..............................          456, 975
Value of exportations ................................. ...................................... 149, 367
                    APPENDIX                 A---REPORT OF LIEUT.                                 COL. SMITH.                           381

                                                                        A 5.
                          IMPROVEMENT OF BELFAST HARBOR, MAINE.

  A small balance of former appropriations remains to the credit of this
improvement, but the amount has not been sufficient to materially affect
the condition of the harbor, so that no work has been undertaken.
  The following-named appropriations have been made for this improve-
ment:
August 14, 1676 .---..-----..--...--------...... ..-----..--..---......-----..-----......-............----.-----                   $5, 000. 00
June 18, 1878 ............-----------.........----------..           ----..................----....-------.............----        12, 000.00
March 3, 1879 .--------.....---......-------....     ------....------..... ....   ......   ................-...-              -.    5, 000. 00
June 14, 1880.......................-----------------------......------......---------............---------..........               3, 000. 00
          Total......  - - - --......  - -
                               - -............            - -- -......
                                                       ..........       .................       - - 25, 000.00
          Expenditures to June 30, 1887 ............--       ....................------             22,193.20
          Expenditures last fiscal year......--............                --........----..--......      20. 64
    Upon the request of Hon. S. L. Milliken, M. C., representing a neces-
sity for further improvement of Belfast Harbor, the Chief of Engineers
directed that an examination be made and a report, with estimate, sub-
mitted.
   The officer in charge made a personal examination, supplemented by
careful inquiries.                     A report was submitted, of which the following is a
copy:
                                                                             UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                                       Portland,Me., February 2, 1888.
   SIR: In compliance with instructions from the Chief of Engineers in indorsement
of January 16, 1888, upon letter of Hon. S. L. Milliken, I have the honor to submit
the following report regarding the necessity for further improvement in the harbor of
Belfast, Me., and an estimate of cost.
   The harbor is situated on the west shore of Penobscot Bay and near its northern
extremity. I forward in a separate package a tracing from the map of the harbor to
accompany and explain this report.
   The harbor lies entirely within the town of Belfast, though the principal part of
the city proper is on the southwest side. The place has between 5,000 and 6,000 in-
habitants and is the natural shipping and receiving point for the surrounding country
within about 20 miles.
   Some years ago the harbor was improved by dredging to the depth of 12 feet and
10 feet in front of the principal wharves. The improvement was completed in 1879,
leaving a small balance of funds still available.
   Recommendations have been submitted in the annual reports for 1886 and 1887 that
the available balance should be used to deepen the water on the northeast side, but
the amount is too small to accomplish much save when taken in connection with ad-
ditional funds.
   On Tuesday of this week, January 31, I was in Belfast and as far as possible ascer-
tained the conditions which seemed to require a greater depth of water.
   Belfast is the terminal point of a branch line of the Maine Central Railroad, and the
harbor is therefore used in bringing in and carrying out coal and other freights which
are distributed or delivered by rail. I am assured by the railroad officials that the
depth of water is sufficient for all purposes at present required by them. So far as I
can ascertain, the prospect of an ocean terminus for any extensive railroad system at
Belfast is not at all promising; in fact I did not find anybody at Belfast who even
mentioned the subject; upon inquiry of persons who are interested in the railroads of
the State, they intimated that such a result was not probable.
   It is my judgment, therefore, that this contingency may be safely left to be provided
for when the occasion arises.
   The channel in the upper portion of the harbor is quite deep, giving more than 20
feet to a point above Lewis's Wharf; at the wharf, however, the depth is somewhat
less.
   Heavily-loaded sailing vessels sometimes enter the harbor drawing as much as 18
feet, but the majority of the vessels draw much less.
   The channel which passes through the middle of the harbor and leads to the upper
wharves affords a clear depth of a little more than 13 feet at mean low water, which i
probably as great as can be obtainel clQse to the wharves,
382       REPORT OF - THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The slight delay of the large sailing vessels which might be compelled to wait a
short time for the tide would not in any way affect the rates of freight or insurance.
  The regular steamers between Boston and Bangor which touch at Belfast rarely
draw more than 10 feet, and their landing is in a part of the harbor improved previous
to 1880.
  Another line of steamers running to New York has been making its landings at
Lewis's Wharf, and inquiry developed the fact that the steamers of this line had some-
times been delayed by getting aground while going to or from the wharf.
  The agent at Belfast informed me that the New York steamers draw from 10 to 11
feet of water, the latter depth being only when heavily loaded.
  As nearly as I could ascertain by inquiry the steamer was aground where the map
shows but 10 feet of water, though the pilot doubtless thought he was in the channel.
  The channel is not marked by any buoys, and in the absence of ranges or definite
marks to locate the course it is very difficult to take a vessel up the harbor in the
deepest water.
  Had the channel been twice as deep the steamer would have gone aground just the
same, because it was not in the right place.
  I can not resist the conclusion that the main channel in the harbor is deep enough
for all present requirements, but it should be buoyed so that vessels can find it.
   It would be an excellent plan to establish upon the bridge and the high land a short
distance above beacons, to form a range in day-time marking the axis of the channel.
  It is possible that the channel may have filled slightly since the last survey, but
the character of the inflowing streams is such that any perceptible diminution of
depth in ten years is hardly probable.
   It would be well to take a few soundings next summer to determine this point with
certainty.
  There is another feature of this harbor which seems worthy of attention.
   Some of the purest ice in the country is harvested in the small stream flowing into
the harbor opposite to the Boston steamer's wharf, and that side of the harbor has
also other commercial interests.
   The large vessels which bring in coal and other freights generally leave without a
return freight because the water on the northeast side is not deep enough to permit
them to load the ice.
   The ice, of which a large quantity is annually shipped, must therefore be either
lightered or shipped in small vessels at a higher rate of freight.
   The incoming freights are also greater than they would be if the vessels could carry
freight in both directions. This is a valuable industry which would be increased with
better facilities.
   The harbor room for turning the steamers, save at extreme low water, and for anch-
orage of small vessels at all times, would be much improved by making a depth of
8 feet on the northeast side of the harbor, as shown on the map. This would also per-
mit the shipment of ice in large vessels, and would affect the rates of freight in both
directions. I therefore recommend that this be done.
   The statistics for this harbor have been difficult to obtain, and they are very in-
complete. As far as received they were embodied in my annual report for year end-
ing June 30, 1887.
   The estimate for improvement here recommended is as follows:
Dredging 52,000 cubic yards, situ measurement, at 30 cents     ......................
                                                                                    $15, 600
Deduct probable balance available .................... ........     ....              2, 750
                                                                          __..............
       Amount required ......................         . ...................... 12, 850
  If this amount be made available in one sum the work can be completed in a single
season at the minimum of expense, otherwise it is probable that the estimate should
be increased.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                  JARED A.       SMITH,
                                                                      Major of Engineers.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. A.

   Itis   recommended that $13,000 be appropriated for the additional
improvements described.
  The harbor is in the collection district of Belfast. The nearest port of entry is
Belfast. The nearest light-houses are Dice's Head, Castine, Fort Point, Mouth of
Penobscot River, Gilkey's Harbor, and Penobscot Bay, almost equally distant.
  Lines of steamers to New York and Boston touch regularly at Belfast
throughout the year, 80stu steamers make two landings per day, New
                    APPENDIX                 A-REPORT                                OF LIEUT.                 COL. SMITH.                   383
York steamers make two landings per week throughout the year.                                                                              Other
smaller steamers make four landings per day in the summer.

                                                            Money statement.

July 1, 1887, amount available .. ............                  ...... ..       ........                                                 $2,806. 80
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.........            .........-----......--....................                                                    20. 64
July 1, 1888, balance available ...                                      ...................................                              2, 786.16




                                                      COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

Arrivals and departures of vessels .....................................                                                                     1,250
Foreign arrivals '.....................................................                                                                          5
                              ----........------- ................................
Foreign clearances ............                                                                                                                  16
Vessels built during the year............................................                                                                         1
    Tonnage..----....---......--.........-----................                                                   ..........     tons..         643

                                                                          EXPORTS.

Hay ..........................................................                                                            tons..            11,000
Granite (rough and finished) ................                                        ...........              .......      do..             14, 000
Ice ......................                  ..........................................                                     do...            15,000
General merchandise..............................................do...                                                                      25, 000
Sheep skins and leather ...........................                                              ..............            do...                400
Leather board...--------.........................................                                                     ... do...                 175
Manufactured clothing ............                              ......           .......       .............               do...                200
Shoes ..............              ...........                 .......... ......                 ............... . cases..                   15, 000
Potatoes ................                     ........           ...... .......................                        bushels..            48, 000
Apples ........................................................                                                           bbls..            11,000
Eggs                   -..............----
                                   ....        .........................................                                         doz..     800,000
Bricks...... ..........       ....................................          200, 000
Doors, frames, sash and blinds, manufactured from lumber.......... feet.. 1,200,000
  Large amount of horses, cattle, sheep, lambs, poultry, and dressed meats, shipped
by steam-boats.

                                                                          IMPORTS.

Grain ...........--..                        .... ...................--                 ..........   .... bushels..                        370, 000
Flour............................................................bbls..                                                                     14,500
Fish .............................................................                                            do...                          2, 000
Fish .............................................................                                           tons..                             700
Coal ...........           .........................                               .......................... do...                         14,000
Iron ...........                    ................................................                          do...                          5,000
Nails and hardware                  ......             ................................                                ......    do...      15, 000
Merchandise .........................................--..                                                      ......... do...     170, 000
Machinery ..........                         ................                         .....................                do...     2,500
Iron water-pipes ...................................................                                                       do...    11,000
Drain-pipes...............                          ....            ..................................                     do...        300
Paper stock for leather boards ..................................                                                          do...        200
Hides and leather .................................................... do...                                                            600
Sheeps-skins, to be tanned...........................................do...                                                              300
Grindstones .......................................................                                                        do...         15
Phosphates ...........                  ...................................                                             .do...          500
Lime and plaster ........................................                                                                casks..    17,000
Salt ............................                                           .......................                    bushels..    20, 000
Lumber.................                          ...............................                                          feet.. 4,000,000
Lath ..................................                                                    ....-----..................           1,000,000
Shingles...........................---                                             ----------------...........                   1,800,000
   The foregoipg statistics have been kindly furnished by Mr HE.].                                                              peiroe, pf Spf4
ag<} are pyeg ps 4 close approgypation only,
3$4         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The following statistics for the Belfast district for the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1888, were furnished by the collector of customs:
                                             Shipping.                                                        Number. Tonnage.


Aprivals from foreign ports........................................--------------                                   119          9, 044
Clearances for foreign ports ----..-.. -       ...- ..---.---------------------.  --                   _             -129       12, 641
Vessels built in the district ...   ----------------------------------------                                           3         3,065


Amount of revenue collected ..............................................-----------------..............                    $1,255.88
Value of importations ......--------------------------------------------------------                                         14, 324.00
Value of exportations......----.........---------------------------------. ----------.........                      ----     33, 505.00




                                                            A 6.
             IMPROVEMENT OF THE HARBOR AT ROCKLAND, MAINE.

   The project for improving this harbor, adopted in 1881 and revised in
1882, consists in constructing a breakwater 1,900 feet long from Jame-
son's Point, and a second breakwater, detached, with a length of 2,640
feet. See map opposite page 464, Report of Chief of Engineers, 1881.
   It has been found necessary to raise the first breakwater to the level
of mean high water, instead of to 5 feet above mean low water as origi-
nally planned.
   June 30, 1887, the first breakwater had been practically finished as
originally planned.
   A contract was then outstanding with Messrs. Hamilton & Soule for
delivering stone upon the breakwater to raise it to the level of high
water as far as funds permitted.
   The delivery of stone was continued until the middle of December,
when the weather became so severe that operations were suspended.
    The balance of funds on hand being very small the contract was con-
sidered as completed.
   The amount of stone delivered from July 1 to December 15, was 17,823
tons.
    The breakwater was raised to high-water level a distance of 271 feet
from the outer end, and was given a width of 20 feet on top.
   The stone beacon was taken down and re-erected upon the outer end
of the breakwater.
   The beacon is now marked by a light at night maintained under the
direction of the Light-House Board.
    The result of the increased height is to prevent the sea from breaking
over to a sufficient extent to cause a sea and undertow inside the break-
water. It is therefore proposed to continue the increase in height as
far towards the land as it may be found necessary to produce the result
required.
   The entire estimated cost of the improvement as now being carried on
was $650,000.
   The following appropriations have been made for this work:
Act of June 14, 1880..........................----------......................                                             $20,000.00
Act of August 2, 1882 ......-        ......-----------...-...................                                               40,000.00
Act of July 4, 1884 ....................-.-------........----......                                  ......
                                                                                                       ----                40,000.00
Act of August 5, 1886---------------.............                             ..................                    ,      22,500.00
         Total...----                            -------                          ................-                        122,500.00
         Total expende4 to June 30 188,,......,.                            .......                 - -~-,- :, --          120, 16,40
                        APPENDIX A--REPORT                                             OF LIEUT. COL. SMITH.               385
  Funds which may be appropriated for the ensuing year will be ex-
pended in giving the increased section to the breakwater.
   The appropriation asked for year ending June 30, 1890, is to be ap-
plied to continuing the construction of the breakwaters in accordance
with the approved plans.
   It has been urged by parties interested in the navigation and com-
merce of the place that instead of separating the breakwaters the second
should be made as an extension of the first. No recommendations are
however, at present made, it being left for future consideration.
   Rockland is a port of considerable commercial importance, and its
harbor forms an excellent refuge, for which it is largely used.
   Local statistics indicate but a small part of the benefits received.
   The barbor of Rockland is a port of delivery in the collection district of Waldo-
borough, of which Waldoborough is the nearest port of entry. The nearest light-house
is Owl's Head, 2 miles distant.

                                                                    Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available.....................................                                      ...       $16,868.24
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.............................................                                                14,684.84
July 1, 1888, balance available ......---------........ ....................                                              2,183.40
Amount appropriatad by act of August 11, 1888 .............                                              .....................
                                                                                                                        30,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ..................                                               32,183.40

    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                         75, 000.00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                                              COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The following commercial statistics for the district of Waldoborough for the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1888, are furnished by the collector:

                                                                 Shipping.                                Number. Tonnage.


Arrivals from foreign ports......................................................                                662        49,540
Clearances for foreign ports.....................................................                                691        55,677
No record
        builtisinkept
Vessels               of arrivals and departures coastwise.
                  the district ......................................................                              5         2,439

Arrivals and departures of steamers at port of Rockland, upwards of fifty weekly.
Revenue collected (duties) ..............................................................                                $1,227.53
  Importations mainly Canadian and non-dutiable.
Value of importations...................................................................                                 75,387.00
Value of exportations......................................................................                                 651.00




                                                                                   A 7.
                   IMPROVEMENT OF THE HARBOR AT PORTLAND, MAINE.

  The project adopted in 1886 for this improvement consists-in dredging
a channel 500 feet wide and 29 feet deep at mean low water from deep
water of the outer channel to the front where the largest steamers re-
ceive and discharge their cargoes. The plan is indicated upon a map
opposite page 450, Report of Chief of Engineers for 1887.
       ENG 88----25
 388 6        REPORT OF THE CHIEF                              OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

    The estimated cost of dredging the channel above-described was
 $135,000.
    In a harbor like that of Portland small points occasionally require
attention which have not been definitely outlined in reports previously
submitted to Congress. A letter has been recently received from the
agent of the International Steam-ship Company asking that a small
shoal near the steamers' landing may be removed. An examination of
the place will be made as soon as practicable, and such recommendation
will be made as the case may seem to require.
    For the project indicated there has been appropriated the following
amount:
By act of August 5, 1886...............................................              .      $30,000
   At the beginning of the fiscal year dredging was in progress under a
contract with the National Dredging Company, of Wilmington, Del.
   Work under the contract was completed December 28, 1887. Much
of the material had been harder than was anticipated, and a large part
of it was of such a kind that the most tedious part of the work was to
dump the material from scows after it had been dredged. Notwith-
standing the difficulty the contractor pushed the work forward vigor-
ously and to the entire satisfaction of this office.
   The amount of material removed under the contract was 198,872 cubic
yards, measured in situ.
   The entire expenditure during the fiscal year has been $27,951.75.
   The total expenditure upon the project has been $29,992.34.
   As a result, the portion of the new channel lying along the front of the
wharves an average length of about 1,600 feet and width of 400 feet has
been deepened from 21 feet to 29 feet depth at mean low water in ad-
dition to the slopes on the outer edges of the cuts.
   The improvements thus far are only partial, as the new channel does
not yet extend outside, but it permits the movement of the largest ves-
sels about the wharves at all stages.
   The prices obtained were exceptionally low. It is not prudent to
estimate the cost of completing the improvement otherwise than by
deducting the amount appropriated from the amount of original esti-
mate.
   This leaves the balance estimated to complete the deep channel
$105,000.
   It would result in great advantage to the work if this amount could
be made available in a single sum.
  Portland is the most important port east of Boston both in a com-
mercial and military point of view.
  The harbor is defended by Forts Preble, Gorges, Scammel, and a battery at Port.
land Head.
  There is a light-house on the breakwater, and a second at Portland HIead, 3 miles
distant from the city.
  The harbor is in the collection district of Portland and Falmouth, Maine, of which
Portland is the port of entry.

                                                 Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available..........................................                 $27, 959.41
,July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1887...........................................                     27,951.75
July 1, 1888, balance available ..-.. .....................................                      7.66
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ........................                     40, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889....................                  40, 007.66
  {                     APPENDIX A-REPORT

    Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project, ..... $65, 000.00
    Amount that can beprofitablyexpended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 65, 000, 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                   OF LIEUT. COL.                     bMITH.

                                                                                                                         -
                                                                                                                                            387


     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
                                                           COMMERCIAL                 STATISTICS.

Arrivals of sailing vessels ........                                  2,885           Lines of steamers, foreign and coast-
Arrivals of steamers ......----                                         736             wise ...........................                        11
                                                                          IMPORTS.

By transatlantic steamers                                                             Value of other imports by
  (85,000 tons) ......... ....                              $6,905, 716I               water ....................                  $1,751,318
                              PRINCIPAL ARTICLES IMPORTED IN SAILING VESSELS.

Molasses, 24,425 hogsheads..                                   $739,875               Coal, 400,000 tons ......................
Sugar, 29,090,000 pounds....                                  1,360,000           I
                                       LANDED ON THE WHARVES OF BACK COVE.

Coal .......................                            tons.. 3, 000                 Building brick .............               tons.. 1,000
Pipe-cla .................                               do... 8,000                  Granite ....................                do...    2, 000
Fire-brick ..............                                do... 1, 000                 Castings .................                  do...    1, 300
                                                                          EXPORTS.

Value of exports by sea ....                               $4,503, 061               Oats .............              bushels..         49, 750
By ocean steamers.... tons..                                    100.000              Peas .. ...........                do....        522,290
Wheat............bushels..                                   1, 272,910

  The following statistics for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, are furnished by
the collector of customs:

                                                       Shipping.                                                        Number.      Tonnage.


Arrivals from foreign ports..................................................                                                291           89, 54
Clearances for foreign ports............................................                                                     412          142, 567
Vessels built within the district                   ..............................................                             3              219


Amount of revenue collected................................................................                                            $509, 332
Value of importations    ..................................................................                                           2, 292, 875
Value of exportations ......................................................................                                          3,152, 441




                                                                             A 8.
        IMPROVEMENT OF CHANNEL IN BACK COVE, PORTLAND, MAINE.

   The project for this improvement, adopted in 1886, consists in deepen-
ing and straightening the chaunel so that it shall have a depth of not
less than 12 feet at mean low water and a width of 300 feet, following
the harbor commissioner's line.
   A map is submitted, to accompany this report, showing the location
as finally adopted and the progress made to June 30, 1887.
   The original estimated expense of the improvement was $181,000.
A trifling modification in the original location has slightly reduced the
amount of material to be removed, so that the revised estimate is
$180,000.
   By act of August 5, 1886, there was appropriated for the work the
sum of $26,250.
   At the beginning of the last fiscal year the necessary surveys and
maps and other preliminary work had been completed and a contract
had been made for dredging as far as the available funds will permit.
388      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

The last annual report explained the reasons for delay in entering upon
the contract.
   Dredging was commenced August 29, 1887, and continued until De-
cember 14, when work was suspended for the winter.
   On the application of the contractor the time of completion of the
                                                                             ,
contract has been extended, first to June 30, 1888, and subsequently to
September 30, 1888.
   The entire amount of material taken from areas which have been
dredged to grade has been 49,602 cubic yards, situ measurement.
   In addition to this, a considerable portion of adjacent cut has been
removed, but is not included in reports nor payments, as the contract
requires completion to grade before payments can be made.
   As a result a part of the channel, over 2,000 feet long and 72 feet wide,
has been dredged to give a least depth of 12 feet at mean low water,
and an additional distance of 930 feet has been dredged to the same-
depth, with a width of 24 feet.
   The funds now available of the first appropriation are expected to
cover expense of completing the first three cuts from the point of start-
ing to the end of the channel, as shown upon the map.
   The amount expended in the fiscal year is $9,281.02.
   Total expended to June 30, 1888, $10,728.39.
   The progress made by the contractor thus far has not been satisfac-
tory, though there have been many causes of delay, which the contractor
could not foresee nor prevent. His requests for extension of time have
therefore been approved in this office, and the extension has been author-
ized by the Chief of Engineers.
   The completion of the channel is expected to add to the convenience
of receiving and shipping large amounts of coal, lumber, potter's clay,
and miscellaneous articles, and it will cause greatly reduced freights,
especially in the interest of suburban villages, towards which the growth
of the city is tending.
   With the appropriations which may be made available for the pur-
pose, it is proposed to continue the improvement by completing the first
cuts the entire length, and then to widen the channel by successive cuts
until the entire width is obtained.
   Back Cove is a part of Portland Harbor, and is therefore in the same collection
district, and is defended by the same forts, and is near the same light-houses as are
given for Portland Harbor.
  The commercial statistics can not at present be separated from those
of the principal harbor, with which they are therefore included.

                                 Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available. ......................................       $24, 802. 63
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887.......................... $6, 880. 35
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities.................... ....... 2,400.67
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts............ 14, 950. 00
                                                                              24,231.02
July 1, 1888, balance available........................................            571.61
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888....................2......        5, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889..................        25, 571.61
fAmount (estimated)
Amount that         required for completion
             can be profitablyexpeuded        of year
                                       in fiscal existing project
                                                             June....
                                                      ending                50, 750.00
                                                                  30, 1890 128, 000. 00'
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
                     NO TE :                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   IMPROVEMENTS                            :

  T.h   s"oundereyw gistdepth        he/erthe     at
                                                   plane                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             .....? ,.4 8. dm4,4,.,,,a
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     TI,                           Is a/,i4da e30,-trn a it,, arpth. of 2 -Petef'           '.. .,,
    me     loJw water;   n.tor witA =.'pe*w/ited pair, l.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   alowr      waer
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          is sr/eaded,       nt     \\wr \r \
  .levat'io, of 6otten a     .lo aGrt pregAr S oatS4tAt )                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     The periwse    completed sa I.o ret O9 2688 is a/unIrd fAtes : Th UIa
     Ontly a l&w eharaenfie* seaetnearrsaodr.O tuak.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           7%<perfion remaining             . hcor     /rolted    tesuer*t/e     contrael atled April      I6"
  en du,,-ig th. survey       e SeCeve        Y',.
                                             mae in,.  0-44 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                1887, v# chaded       thuta
     86,a a e s,,wn .,'s i ptan.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Area.A"wea drrdged          before        te  ertnge in lration ,t (t'/onel       worae fleate
Alleaser    re and   ia/oftider .9.2 fart.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Are.   dredged overs Aut enot y-et                   eted is      ompln
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              shaded  tns:V;




                                                                                                                                                           V                                                                                                                                                                                                                         t
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   0
                                                                                                                                                                    &                                                                                  C                                                                                                                                               -4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     -1.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      ' Q9                                                                             "-21
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            - +
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     -1 3.5S4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           .2d
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        -2.y
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              -1.6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   -t3
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   -             -Go
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              1f'                             -3...1,

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          -1.                                                                                                                            i                                     -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          Q,          /                                                                                                                                                                                                 -i               -a
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              e     r
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  -        R.      /        1 4
                                                                                                                                                           0                b                                             -                        -1       b
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      -83               -.


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          -03


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               rs


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  -                                                       /              .+04-0;
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  -i-                   -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              -1-1
                                                                                                                                                                                        -"   t         -          -           0 e            -a
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      3                                           /              *a                        -        .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             ,                        a-S              l                   o




                                                                                                                                                                                                             -a-
                                                                                                                                                      2.1                                                                                          -

                                                                                                                                                  -                                  .   1r                   -  .-
                                                                                                                                                                                     _ - - .3.              -I.e    -                             o,

                                                                                                                                                       3.                                    -14           -34 .              --                                +Eo               -'/-17s~o            ~        o                                 3€ o                                   a                     &                 a              -a L

                                                                                                                                          -kIT1                                 -                      -a


                                                                                                                                                                                                              ar;-0                     _,.             -~
                                                                                                                                                                                                       -      a.                                                                  0"4"                       -a                -:-,                                                                                    s,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              As--

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                '-
                                                                                                                                                                                                             ,        '                 1r                                    3
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   - 04.                                                   Q3   - z-                  a                        "   -l
                                                                                                                                                                                     -Qr

                                                                                                                                                                                                                          -                            -0.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          %
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    -Q3
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               ... ..                             .....3                                  ,,.           .-                              _y                   4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      a        --                          j.                    - - -           - s4,-..e..                          .4.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                      -        -a             -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          10




                                                                                      -4rt-all-24    0         -4           3             4                    --               --                                                                                                    -    0;e-.       r




                             SAL I                                XL         -a,*

                                                                                      _L
                                                                                       r~i     7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   -o
                                                                                                               L       z                          r




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          "           ,l       -z -t       0.   -' . -s-,                                _ .M4r                  =                                                                               P.
                                       3--s
                                -'     g-   N~   -114      r---~-,-r=~ - WCI'0
                                                                        -1
                                                                              44
                                                                                    ;>
                                                                                    & Cn
                                                                                                   29, awr
                                                                                                          ~ Cr Wr-F* 1&45r
                                                                                                         -z'xCs'                     4*
                                                                                                                                     rr       ,       ay                -       s                'fi
                                                                                                                                                                                                           04C
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         -mo''~



                                                                                                                                                                                                                              -Ire's.i
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           0                               E'         -%
                                                                                                                       - o
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      SI[AP                0OF
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       A                  .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ,               BACK                           C O)VE
                                                                                                                                -,

                                                                                              ,-           3       ,       ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     'B                                                                                                                                                        s                  "-s
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           v                        "-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  -_
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  PORTLAND HARBO R ,MAINE,                                                                                     /
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    As
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         S'           HOWING                     LOCATION                       OFHANNEL.                                                                                                I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   -4.       -3
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Semi.        in Feet        :                                                                             I,    I

                                                                                                                                                                                                              -               s
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 ,                     -                      s-               _.,                             .e                  o
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     -1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   -44                                                                                                                                                       /                                                                            ng/ner Office
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       u B.                                                '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            PortlandMane,                                 .rely J#, 1888                                                            ": "sp "
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   a. ccompan                                    annual report for the efiscalt
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      -       ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        year               endig               J asne 3           18 ./
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              ,.




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       Lieut.         Colonels. Corpeiagineer,                             V.A



        Eng5O 2
                 APPENDIX A-REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. SMITH.                                       389

                                 A 9.
          BREAKWATER AT MOUTH OF SACO RIVER, MAINE.
  The present project for this improvement consists in repairing and
completing the old breakwater so that it shall have a height of 15 feet
above low water and a width of 12 feet on top. It has been recom-
mended that after completing the work thus far the breakwater be ex-
tended to Sharp's Ledge.
  The following appropriations have been made for the work:

2By
By act of July 5, 1884.......              .................................
     act of August 5, 1886...............................................
      Total.................................................. .............
                                                                               ......    $15, 000. 00
                                                                                         12, 500. 00
                                                                                          27,500.00
Total expenditure to June 30, 1887 .....................................                -0,024.04
   At the beginning of the fiscal year work was in progress under a con-
tract with George Willett Andrews, of Biddeford, Me., for placing stone
upon the breakwater and rectifying the beacon.
    Work under the contract was completed October 6, 1887.           The
amount of stone delivered in the fiscal year was 6,484 tons, and the
entire amount under the contract was 10,964 tons.
    The beacon has been placed in an erect position, and has been se-
.cured by heavy stone placed at the end of the breakwater.
    A length of 1,310 feet of the breakwater has been completed from
the outer end, and an additional distance of 292 feet has been made
nearly ready to receive the capping stones.
    In the first year after commencing the work the amount of stone re-
quired to complete a given length was largely in excess of the estimate,
owing to displacement and sinking in the sand. It was therefore
thought necessary to increase the estimate submitted in reports for 1886
;and 1887. The stone delivered under the last contract has, however,
gone further than was expected, so that the average for the whole work
done is about the same as the original estimate.
    The estimated amount required to complete the old breakwater is
therefore the original estimate reduced by the amount appropriated.
Balance required June 30, 1888, $42,500.
    Any funds which may be made available for the ensuing year will be
applied to the completion of the breakwater.
    It is recommended that the amount necessary to complete the old
breakwater be appropriated for fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
    The Saco River Breakwater is a part of the work for improving Saco
River, Maine; but its completion will not benefit the bar at mouth of
the river to any appreciable extent until other work for improving the
river can be constructed on the opposite side of the channel, as recom-
mended in the last annual report for Saco River.
   The breakwater is in the collection district of Saco. The nearest port of entry is
;Saco. The nearest light-house is Wood Island light-station.
    Commercial statistics are included with those for Saco River.
                                                     Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available...... ....................................                $7, 475.96
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1887 .............................................                  7,474.48
,July 1, 1888, balance available ...............................  ..... -     1.48
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.......................... 12,500.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.................                   12,501.48
  (Amount
   JAmount (estimated)           for completion
                        required expended
           that can beprofitably                   existing project....-...
                                                of yearending
                                          infiscal            June 30, 1890               30,
                                                                                          30, 000.00
                                                                                              000.00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
390     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                  A io.
                IMPROVEMENT OF SACO RIVER, MAINE.

   The project for improving the Saco River was adopted in 1886, its
object being to obtain a depth of 6 feet at mean low water to the cities
of Saco and Biddeford.
   The points requiring improvement to obtain the results indicated were
the following:
   The bar at the mouth of the river.
   Ledge and shoals at Little Islands (the latter requiring one or more
submerged jetties).
   Shoal from Pier 2 to wharves.
   Closing channel between Cow Island and mainland.
   See Report of Chief of Engineers, 1884, page 484, and 1886, page 555.
   At the beginning of the fiscal year contracts had been made with
Thomas Symonds, of Leominster, Mass., for removing the ledge at Little
Islands, and with Robert Hamilton, of Chebeague, Me., to dredge the
shoals near the same place.
   The removal of the ledge was commenced in September, 1887, and was
completed November 18. Two hundred and fourteen cubic yards of rock
were removed from the ledge, so that the channel between the islands
has been given a width of 110 feet, with a depth of 6 feet at mean low
water.
   The dredging of the adjacent shoals was commenced August 29, and
was completed October 31. The amount of material removed from the
channel by dredging was 19,4071 cubic yards, measured in scow.
   As a result there is a good channel of 6 feet depth at low water,
though somewhat crooked, past Little Islands, the width-save at the
point between the islands, where it is narrow-being 200 feet or more.
   A further work, consisting of a stone jetty and training-wall, will be
required to concentrate and direct the flow so that the channel may be
maintained by the scour of the current.
   Upon the representation of parties in Saco and Biddeford that dredg-
ing near the coal wharves was greatly needed, authority was received
from the Chief of Engineers to expend a balance of $4,000 for that pur-
pose.
   The work was commenced November 1 and was completed December
5 by Mr. Robert Hamilton, who had dredged the shoal at Little Islands.
As the time did not permit of making a formal contract after public
advertisement, and it was not probable that any advantage would be
obtained even had there been time, Mr. Hamilton was employed to do
the work at the same price as on the other work for which he had been
the lowest bidder.
   The amount of material removed under this agreement was 16,987
cubic yards, and it resulted in giving a clear channel along the front
of the wharves to the full depth of 6 feet at mean low water. The
average width dredged was 100 feet, and the average length 750 feet.
This gave a great temporary relief to the shipping interests of the place,
which would otherwise have been greatly embarrassed in receiving coal
and other articles before the closing of the river by ice.
   Observations have been made to obtain the direction and velocity of
the current in the ordinary tides near Little Islands, and these have
been extended to the time of freshets over the principal places where
improvements are required except over the bar at the mouth.
   The changes which occur in the channel are almost exclusively due
to the scouring action and the deposition of drift at times of freshets.
                  APPENDIX                 A-REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. SMITH.                                           391
  The only appropriation thus far made for this improvement was by
act of August 5, 1886, $12,500.
   Amount expended to June 30, 1888, $12,436.32.
  The work considered necessary to give the required depth was origi-
nally planned to consist largely of dredging.
   It is believed, however, that a channel dredged in the broader places
of the sandy bottom will not remain for any great length of time unless
the current be restricted to a width which is found sufficient to maintain
a good depth in the narrower parts of the river. It is also considered
desirable to construct the works for contracting the space in which the
current flows before doing any dredging, as it is probable that by this
means the scour will reduce the amount of material to be otherwise
removed.
  The general features of a project for this purpose were indicated in
last Annual Report (pages 457 and 458, Report of Chief of Engineers,
1887), and a map and plans of the work were quite fully shown. It is
probable that certain details of the plan may require modification, but
the principle employed is considered so essential to the maintenance of
a good channel that the project is recommended, and the estimate is
here repeated:
Jetty at mouth of river, 65,000 tons stone, at $1 ............................                $65, 000
Improvement at Little Islands..............................................                    15, 000
For pier-head, coal-wharf channel.. .....................................                      10,000
Revetment to coal-wharf channel......................................                           4,500
For wing dams, 20,000 tons stone, at $1..................................                      20, 000
Revetment   of shoal,  2,500      tons,      at   $1......................................      2, 500
Dredging channel.......................................................                        10, 000
Contingencies of engineering, etc...................................                       .. 13,000
        Total .......................................................                               .......      140,000
  The bar at the mouth of the river is the most serious obstacle to the
navigation.
  The depth over the bar frequently changes, but it is much of the time
as small as the depth over the shoals above.
  Vessels which arrive off the bar at low stages of water must wait
outside in all kinds of weather, until high water, and even then large
vessels are likely to have difficulty in passing.
  The breakwater, for which a separate appropriation is made, and
which is therefore made the subject of a separate report, is filling its
office fairly well, but it merely prevents, to a greater or less degree,
the drifting of sand across the mouth of the river, and can not confine
the current so as to maintain a channel of good depth.
   It is therefore recommended as of prime importance that works for
producing and maintaining a good channel over the bar should be un-
dertaken as soon as the funds therefor may permit.
  The estimate for completion of present project does not include the
removal of the bar at the mouth of the river.
Saco River isin the collection district of Saco, Me., of which Saco is the port of entry.
Nearest light-house, Wood Island.
                                                       Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available -.--...---...-------.....--......-----....------....--....----....---....          $11,935.24
July 1, 188, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887..........................................-----------------------------------------....  11,871.56
July 1, 1888, balance available .................--------------------.....................                          63.68
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..........................10,                                         000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ..................                                      10, 063.68
392           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 25, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
                                                               STATISTICS.

  The following commercial statistics for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, were
furnished by the collector of customs:
Number of clearances for foreign ports .......................                                           ................          4
   Tonnage---------------.........-..............                               .................-....                           596



                                                                    AuI.

                       IMPROVEMENT OF KENNEBUNK RIVER, MAINE.

    No appropriation has been made for this work since 1881.
    Improvements at the mouth of the river were begun in 1798 by the
State of Massachusetts with the approval of Congress.
   The work subsequently built has consisted of crib-work, forming a
jetty and protection near the mouth of the river, a wooden pier or wharf
about 1,000 feet above the mouth, and two granite piers or jetties across
the bar at the mbuth of the river. The channel has also been dredged,
and two small ledges of rock have been removed to give a depth of 4
feet at mean low water.
  The appropriations for the work have been-
By act of March 2,1829....................................................                                                   $5,000
By act of March 2,1831..................................................                                                       1, 175
By act of July 3, 1832....................................................                                                     1,700
By act of June 28, 1834 ....................................................                                                  10,300
By act of July 2, 1836................................................                                                         7,500
By act of March 3, 1837        .         ................................     .....       ...........                         3,000
By act of July 7, 1838.............................................................                                           8,000
By act of August 30, 1852.....................                              .     .......     ........ .                      7,500
By act of July 11, 1870 ...................................................                                                   5,000
By act of March 3, 1871...............................................                                                        5, 000
By act of August 14, 1876..................................................                                                    5,000
By act of March 3, 1879....................................................                                                   2,000
By act of June 14, 1880.................................................                                                      2,000
By act of March 3, 1881.........................................                                                  ........    2,000
         Total...............................................................                                                 65,175
  On the 30th of June, 1887, there remained on hand a balance of $336.34.
  The improvements have maintained a good channel over the bar and
to the bridge and wharves, about 1) miles above.
  In the month of June, 1888, the top of the wooden pier was repaired
and re-covered with gravel.
  No other work has been done, and no work is proposed for the ensu-
ing year, save such minor repairs as may be paid for by the small re-
maining balance.
  The river is in the collection district of Kennebunk; nearest port of entry is Kenne-
bunk; nearest light-house is on Goat Island, near Cape Porpoise.

                                      Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available.......................................                                                        $336.34
July 1, 1888, amount expendell during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887..............................................                                                      236. 92
July 1, 1888, balance available.........................................                                                       99. 42
                    APPENDIX                   A-REPORT            OF     LIEUT.        COL.         SMITH.                          393
                                                      COMMERCIAL      STATISTICS.


  The following commercial statistics for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, were
'furnished by the collector of customs :
Arrivals and departures coastwise ............-...........................---....                                               --     75
' essels built in the district.....................................................                                                     3
     Tonnage............................................                                       ----.........-..............            75




                                                             A 12.

                     IMPROVEMENT OF THE HARBOR AT YORK, MAINE.

   The project for this work consists in widening the channel in three
rplaces to obtain a depth of 10 feet at mean low water, with room for the
movement of vessels.
  There has been appropriated for this improvement the following
amount:
By act of August 5, 1886................................................                                                      $15,000.00
Total expenditures to June 30, 1888 ....................................                                                       12, 928. 11
   At the end of the fiscal year work was progressing under a contract
for removing gravel and rock from the point at Stage Neck, and from
the second point above, at prices of 65 cents and 35 cents per cubic
yard, respectively.
   Work was continued until August 26, when there had been removed
4,059 cubic yards in situ from the upper shoal, and 15,283 cubic yards
from Stage Neck Point.
   At the latter place numerous borings had previously been made to as-
certain the kind of material to be removed. Nothing worse than coarse
rocks and gravel had been discovered.
   In dredging it was discovered that a considerable point of ledge pro-
jected into the part to be removed at the point of Stage Neck. This is
the important part of the entire improvement, and it was therefore
thought best to suspend further operations until the ledge can be re-
moved.
   A careful survey of the ledge, which had been exposed by dredging,
was made in November, 1887, and the quantities to be removed were
ascertained.
   The project can not be completed and no benefit can obtain from the
channel from the work already done at that place until the ledge is re-
moved. This makes it necessary to revise the original estimate for the
entire work as follows :
903 cubic yards of ledge, at $15 ..................-.......................                                                   $13,545.0
21,167 cubic yards of gravel and rock, at 65 cents........................                                                    13, 758.55
36,168 cubic yards of sand and gravel, at 35 cents........................                                                    12,658.80
Contingencies of engineering, etc.......................................                                                       4,037. 65
         Total for depth of 10 feet....                      ......     ..... ......   .................                       44,000.00
    In this narrow part of the channel the tidal current is exceedingly
strong, and but for the rock it would no doubt scour the place to a
greater width and depth.
    The proportion of vessels carrying coal, ice, and other freights which
draw more than 10 feet is very large, and a jagged bottom at that depth
is very dangerous. If the rock is to be removed at all, I am of the
opinion that a depth of 12 feet at mean low water is the minimum which
394          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

is advisable. This will increase the quantity of ledge to be removed to
1,700 cubic yards, and will add $13,500 to the estimated expense.
   As the original project only contemplated a depth of 10 feet the esti-
mate for completion of project is for 10 feet only.
   York Harbor is in the collection district of York, Me., of which York is the port
of entry.      The nearest light-house is at Cape Neddick.

                                                Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available .......................................                                              $14,319.35
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887..............................................   12,247.46
July 1, 1888, balance available              ........................................                                 2,071.89
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.........................                                               10,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...................                                             12, 071.89

   Amount that can beprofitablyexpendedin fiscalyear endingJune30,1890 19, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




                                                                    A 13.

         IMPROVEMENT OF PORTSMOUTH HARBOR, NEW HAMPSHIRE.

   The project for improving this harbor comprises the following:
   (1) Constructing a breakwater across the side channel between Greai;
Island and Goat Island. This was completed in 1880, but has since
been re-inforced by receiving the stone excavated from Gangway Rock.
  (2) Removing Gangway Rock to a depth of 20 feet at mean low water.
The depth was restricted to 20 feet, owing to the expense attending a
greater depth.
  (3) Removing to 10 feet depth at mean low water the ledge on the
point at Badger's Island.
  The original estimate of cost submitted in 1879 was $150,000.
  The following appropriations have been made for the work, viz:
By act of March 3, 1879................................................                                            $10,000.00
By act of June 14, 1880.........................................................                                    25,000.00
By act of March 3,1 881................................................                                             20,000.00
By act of August 2, 1882 .......                        ....................................                         17,000. 00
By act of July 5, 1884..........................                                               ...............   .20,000.    00
By act of August 5, 1886 ...............................................                                             15,000.00
        Total.....................................             ......................                              107,000.00
        Total expended to June 30, 1888 .................................                                          106,604.94
   At the beginning of the fiscal year work was in progress under a con-
tract with Mr. George W. Townsend, of Boston, Mass., for completing
the removal of Gangway Rock.
   The time for completing the contract was November 30, 1887, but
work was somewhat delayed by unavoidable causes, so that an exten-
sion to June 30, 1888, was asked by the contractor and was authorized
by the Chief of Engineers.
   The work was, however, pushed forward with all possible rapidity,
even into the extreme cold of winter, and was finished January 11, 1888.
   The amount of ledge removed was 632 cubic yards, all of which has
                   APPENDIX A-REPORT                                      OF LIEUT.                   COL. SMITH.         395
been deposited upon the breakwater between Great Island and Goat
Island, to give it additional thickness and stability.
   This completes the removal of Gangway Rock, and completes all the
improvements originally projected, except a portion of the ledge pro-
jecting from the point of Badger's Island.
  The amount of ledge remaining to be removed is 590 cubic yards.
The average of four bids for removing the first part of this ledge was
$34.594 per yard; but prices are now somewhat lower, and the estimate
may safely be made as follows:
590 cubic yards ledge, at $30 ...................                                                                     $17, 700
Contingencies of engineering and superintendence ........................                                               2,300
                                                                                                                        20,000
   The rock is very hard and is exposed to very rapid tidal currents,
both flood and ebb, and is upon the slope of the point, so that its re-
moval is expensive. The cross-section through which the current flows
will be so little increased by the removal, being but a little more than
1 per cent., that it is not probable that any perceptible effect to the
tidal currents will result. On the other hand, the proposed depth of 10
feet over the point is less than the draught of a large proportion of the
vessels which pass. The currents are peculiar in their action at this
place, and at low water they run nearly as rapidly as at any other
stage. Vessels will be more likely to be driven near or over the point
after the ledge is removed than before, so that the liability of injury
by striking the ledge is increased rather than diminished by the re-
moval.
   It is therefore recommended that no further work be done unless it
be considered desirable to remove the rock to a depth of not less than 18
feet.
   The expense of removing the point ledge to 18 feet depth to the same
line which limits the former project is as follows, the price per yard be-
ing estimated lower than for the 10-feet depth because it can be done
cheaper:
3,442 cubic yards submerged ledge, at $25..................................                                           $86, 050
Contingencies, 10 per cent .................................................                                            8,605
                                                           ....--
        Total.........----------.-----.................. -....-----....---................--.......                    94,655

  For such an expenditure the area of the cross-section of the river at
low water would be increased but a trifle over 4 per cent. on the side
where the currents are least rapid.
  The point is in a bend of the river, and the most rapid currents are
on the opposite side. It is hardly possible that these strong currents
can be radically affected by the removal of the ledge even to 18 feet, as
indicated, so that, although I consider it decidedly better than the
smaller depth, I do not recommend any further work at present, be.
cause the benefits are not commensurate with the expense.
                                                        Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available.... ...............................---         $12,269.64
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.................................           . .. ..  11,874.58
July 1, 1888, balance available ........-..-.............-..............-- .                                           395.06
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.......................-----------------------..                       15,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year'ending June 30, 1889. ..-......-.......                                            15, 395. 06
  {Amount
396             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

           (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....... $5, 000.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                             5, 000.00

    harbor acts of 1566 and 1867.


                                                        COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

Number of arrivals of sailing vessels ............................................                                                 805
Number of arrivals of steamers......--.............---------------................----------......--....                            42

                                                                           IMPORTS.

Coal ......................                       tons.. 237,000                Lumber ....-...........-feet.. 62,902,000
Railroad-ties .-..................                       141,049                Laths .......................      70,000
Cement................barrels..                                   36,000        Lime ...............           barrels..        34,000
Salt .......           -......-....boxes.. 10, 000 Plaster .......--........ do....                                              5,000
Salt ...............        hogsheads..               1,000 Molding-sand.......... tons..                                        1,300
Iron    .            -          -0....................
                                     tons..              750 Ashes ................  do....                                        100
                                                                                                                                   800
Potatoes ..............         bushels..              3,722 Phosphates ..........  do....
Oysters ..................          do....             1,875 Stone.................do....                                          500
Wood ...................           cords..               150 Concrete.............do....                                           100
Miscellaneous merchandise ....................................                      .tons..                                      1,650

                                                                           EXPORTS.

Brick..................................................................                                                    15, 000, 000
Number of steam-boat lines..............................................                                                             4
Number of tug-boat lines ......................................................                                                      4
Number of irregular tow-boats arriving for tows ................................                                                    50
Number of vessels owned ......................................................                                                      63
       Tonnage..........................................................                                                    10,198.87
  The above statistics have been courteously furnished by Col. William H. Sise,
president of the Portsmouth Board of Trade.




                                                                            A 14.

            IMPROVEMENT OF THE COCHECO RIVER, NEW HAMPSHIRE.

   A full description of this river, and its connection with the Piscata-
-qua, was submitted in the last Annual Report. The present project for
improving the Cocheco River contemplates cutting a channel through
the ledge and other material a short distance below the city of Dover,
N. HII., so as to give a width of 50 feet, and depth of 5 feet at low water.
For the same purpose bowlders are to be removed from the channel
below the narrows. The original estimate for cost of this improvement
was $47,000.
   The following appropriations have been made for this work, viz:
By act of July 5, 1884 ...............................................                                                     $28,000.00
By act of August 5, 1886...............................................                                                     10,000.00
           Total ...................................                                     ...................                38, 000. 00
           Total expended to June 30, 1888................................
                                                                37.682.11
  At the date of the last Annual Report a contract was outstanding with
Mr. Thomas Symonds, of Leominster, Mass., for removing ledge and
bowlders from the channel.
  Work under the contract was completed September 30, 1887; 738
cubic yards of solid ledge and 350 cubic 'yards of bowlders were re-
moved under the terms of the contract.
                   APPENDIX               A-REPORT OF LIEUT. COL.                      SMITH.          397
  The ledge was the worst portion of the obstruction, and the result
thus far has been of great benefit to the navigation of the river, and
the completion of the project will be a still further benefit.
  While a draught of 5 feet at mean low water is of vast benefit to the
place, and has made the channel navigable nearly to Dover for vessels
of 600 tons, or even more, at extreme high water, yet the time for such
navigation is limited to very short intervals near the highest stages.
  The narrow channel not being straight, is very difficult to navigate
with a tug having large vessels in tow, and the interests involved indi-
cate that it will need to be made both wider and deeper.
  The commercial interests of Dover were quite fully given in my re-
port for 1886, to which I refer. (See page 550, Report of Chief of En
gineers, 1886.)
                             Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available......................................$....9,502.64
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.............................................     9,184.75
July 1, 1888, balance available ......................................                                317. 89
Amount appropriated by act of August 11,1888..........................                             9. 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ..................                            9.317.89



                                        COMMERCIAL              STATISTICS FOR 1887.

   Arrival of sailing vessels, 90.
   Vessels built during the year, 1 sailing vessel, 1 steam tug.

                                                     RECEIPTS BY WATER.

Coal...           ......                ....   ...         ........................       tons..      25, 000
Lumber.....................................................feet..                                  5,000,000
Lime and cement ..........................................                               casks..      12, 000.




                                                                A       15.

          HARBOR OF REFUGE AT LITTLE HARBOR, NEW HAMPSHIRE.

  The project for this improvement, adopted in 1886, was based upon a
recommendation by Col. George Thom, Corps of Engineers (Report of
Chief of Engineers, 1882, page 507.) It consisted in dredging a chan-
nel 100 feet wide and 9 feet deep across the bar a distance approx-
imately 3,000 feet; widening the anchorage basin to 300 feet for a
distance of 700 feet, and constructing a small breakwater on the ledge
at Jerry's Point. The estimated cost was $33,000.
  The object of the work is to make a harbor in which vessels may take
refuge at such times as they are unable to make a harbor in the mouth
of the Piscataqua River owing to the great rapidity of the ebb tides.
  The act of Congress approved August 5, 1886, appropriated $10,000
for this improvement.
  Amount expended to June 30, 1888, $9,907.76.
  At the beginning of the fiscal year a contract had been made with
Messrs. Moore & Wright, of Portland, Me., for dredging in the channel.
  Work was commenced early in July and was completed as far as funds
permitted on the 22d of September.
398          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS U. 8. ARMY.

  There were removed from the channel 36,021 cubic yards of material,
resulting in a cut 75 feet wide and 2,400 feet long, to the depth of 9
feet.
  The cut does not reach to the inner anchorage, so that no benefits to
navigation are yet obtained.
   It will be readily seen that a channel of 3,600 feet long, nearly all of
which is but 100 feet wide, and has but 9 feet in depth at mean low
water, and but little more than 6 feet at extreme low water, will serve
but little purpose for sailing vessels, especially as the winds, at times
when it would be needed, would blow across the channel for its entire
length, and at low-water stages nothing larger than a small fishing
smack could venture to enter.
  An enlarged project has therefore been recommended, at an ultimate
probable cost of $225,000.
  For a description and plan I refer to my last annual report. (See Re-
port of Chief of Engineers, 1887, page 470, with map.)
  There are at present no commercial statistics to report for this place
save as they have been given in previous reports, giving wrecks, etc.,
and the statistics for Portsmouth and Dover. All vessels for these
points pass Little Harbor.
                                                 Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available .........................................                   $9,650.29
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1887 ..............................................                  9,558.05

July 1, 1888, balance available ..................          .... ............       ....       92.24
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..........................                    20,000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...................                   20, 092.24

   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 23, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                           A. i6.
PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION OF BAYODUCE [BAGADUCE] RIVER, MAINE,
     BETWEEN THE TOWNS OF PENOBSCOT AND BROOKSVILLE.

                                                UNITED           STATES ENGINEER   OFFICE,
                                      Portland, Me., December -, 1886.
   GENERAL : The river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, required an
examination or survey of the " Bayoduce River between the towns of
Penobscot and Brooksville, Maine."
   By letter of September 27, 1886, from office of the Chief of Engineers,
the duty was assigned to me.
   Coast Survey chart No. 311 of the Penobscot River and Belfast Bay,
Maine, and Coast Survey chart Penobscot Bay, Maine, contain very
complete maps, though on a small scale, of the river in question.
Upon these charts the name of the river is given as " Bagaduce," and
I find through inquiry in the locality that the name indicated by the
Coast Survey is correct.

   For maps to explain this report I refer to the charts already men-
tioned. It will be seen that the Bagaduce River is a tidal water open.
          APPENDIX A---REPORT        OF LIEUT. COL. SMITH.            399
ing into Penobscot Bay at Castine. The lower part or mouth of the
river forms the harbor of Castine, where the mean rise of the tide is
9.3 feet.
   About 5 miles above the mouth of the river is a place known as the
" narrows," though even here the banks are at least 700 feet apart, and
the channel for the largest vessels is more than half that width.
   Immediately above the " narrows" the river is much broader and di-
vides into the North and South Forks. The tidal portion of the North
Fork terminates in the Northern Bay, while that of the South Fork
passes through the " South Bay" and thence in a tortuous channel
through various "narrows" and broad places to the town, or rather
village, of Brooksville, a distance of about 8 miles. The river between
Penobscot and Brooksville consists of the two forks mentioned, a total
distance by the channel of about 11 miles.
   From the " narrows" to Penobscot the North Fork is broad and has
a good channel, though somewhat indirect, as far as Bridge's Point.
This point is on the east shore where the river widens into Northern
Bay, about 3 miles from the " narrows," and a little more than three-
fourths of a mile below the head of the channel at Penobscot.

   The town has two villages, known, respectively, as 1 Penobscot " and
"South Penobscot." The latter is at the head of the tidal channel of
the river on the southeast shore of the bay, while the former is 1 mile
further north.
   Owing to the very crooked channel in the broad waters of the two
forks, and of the very rapid tidal current through the " narrows," there
is a great desire expressed to have the shallow places suitably marked
by buoys, and it would seem that the necessity is not exaggerated.
   Although the question of buoyage does not properly form a part of
this report, it is here mentioned for the reason that this examination
seems to have been asked by the people, partly to secure the proper
marking of the channel, which is one of the greatest needs of the navi-
gation.
   Above Bridge's Point, in the Northern Bay, the channel is narrow and
at low water has not sufficient depth for even the smaller coasting ves-
sels which carry freights to distant points. Even this small channel is
greatly obstructed by points of ledge and by bowlders where it passes
between Winslow's Island and the mainland.
   The ledge and bowlders mentioned form such an obstruction that ves-
sels are compelled to leave the channel entirely and pass over the flats
on the other side of the island; this can only be done at high water
and with vessels of comparatively small draught. Any regular or reli-
able communication by water are, therefore, at present impracticable,
though the shipments by water from this point are sufficient to make
freights for 210 vessels, many of them so large that they have to be
loaded below Bridge's Point, at great additional expense.
   At the time of my examination of the river, an order for a large ship-
ment of bricks was received from a sea-port town in Massachusetts, but
after a long search no vessel could be found with sufficient size and light
draught of water. This is mentioned to illustrate the situation.
   To fulfill the requirements, the channel should be straightened and
deepened so as to give a width of 150 feet from Bridge's Point to Wins-
low's Island, and thence a width of 100 feet to the village of South Pe-
nobscot, with a depth of 6 feet at low water throughout.
   The Coast Survey chart is not sufficiently in detail to furnish the in-
400        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

formation needed for a definite estimate of the expense; it may, how-
ever, be approximated very closely, as-follows:
Dredging, 90,000 cubic yards, at 25 cents per yard .......................        $22, 500
Removing 500 cubic yards of ledge and bowlders, at $10....................5,000
Contingent expenses .....................................................           2,500
       Total ................    .............................................     30,000
   To ascertain whether the present and prospective commerce of the
place is such as to make the river worthy of improvements by the Gene
eral Government, I made careful inquiry and obtained the following
statistics and information.
   There is an extensive industry of brick-making carried on in Penob-
scot, which is only awaiting better communication to be very largely
increased. A large part of the bricks have to be lightered, and it is
difficult to obtain the larger class of vessels for freight, so that the ex-
pense is increased about 50 cents per thousand for freight, lighterage,
breakage, and delay.
   The 50 cents per thousand thus lost represents a large part of the en-
ti e profit, so that the production is restricted. About 5,000,000 bricks
is the present annual average of manufacture on the North Fork, and
a good channel would probably result in doubling that number.
   About 2,500 cords of wood are shipped from Penobscot annually; also
about 3,000 bushels of potatoes and various other agricultural products.
   Winston's Creek, which flows into the Northern Bay at South Penob-
scot Village, furnishes power for two stave-mills, two single-mills, one
saw-mill and lath-mill, and one mill for grinding corn meal. There is
also in the village a knitting factory.
   All these industries would be enabled to ship their products at reduced
prices were the freights by water regular and reliable.
   The number of freighting vessels arriving on the North Fork of the
Bagaduce annually is given as 210, and about an equal number of yachts
and small craft in addition.
   There is a fine granite quarry which can not now be operated, owing
to cost of transporting stone, which may figure among the prospective
business of the place.
   Penobscot is the natural outlet of quite a large section of country re-
mote from any direct line of railroad, 10 miles over a hilly road from
Castine Harbor, and 14 miles to the nearest point of the branch railroad
from Bangor to Bucksport.
   A regular line of steamers from points on Penobscot Bay is only
awaiting a time when the channel above Bridge's Point shall be im-
proved, to make daily trips to South Penobscot village.
   On the south fork of the river the freight vessels arriving are given
as numbering ninety, with an equal number of smaller craft. There are
500,000 bricks shipped annually, and the number would be increased
were the channel freed from obstruction so that large vessels could be
employed. Over 2,000 cords of wood are annually shipped in small
vessels of from 30 to 40 tons each.
   Navigation on this fork at present extends only a short distance from
the South Bay, and its only serious obstacle is in Johnson's Narrows, at
which point the channel is very narrow and obstructed by ledges of
rock. Some years ago the worst parts of the obstruction were removed
by individual enterprise, but still only small vessels can pass, and then
only when the water is at a high stage.
   In my opinion the character of the Bagaduce River when considered
with its present and prospective commercial interests, renders it worthy
of improvement by the General Government in the places indicated.
          APPENDIX     A-REPORT      OF   LIEUT.   COL.   SMITH.      401
  An approximate estimate of the expense on the north fork is submit-
ted above, but I have no data upon which to estimate the expense of
work in Johnson's Narrows. The latter will probably not be large.
  I recommend that a survey be made of the places requiring improve-
ment. The expense of such a survey, including the platting and com-
pleting of maps and estimates, will be $400.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                JARED A.     SMITH,
                                                     Major of Engineers.
  Brig. Gen. JAMES C. DUANE,
             Chief of Engineers, U. S .A.



SURVEY    OF BAYODUCE [BAGADUCE] RIVER, MAINE, BETWEEN                THE
             TOWNS OF PENOBSCOT AND BROOKSVILLE.

                            UNITED   STATES ENGINEER        OFFICE,
                                        Portland, Me., February 2, 1888.
   SIR: I have the honor to submit the following report upon a survey of
the Bagaduce River, Maine (incorrectly printed "Bayoduce" in river
and harbor act of August 5,1886).
   The instructions and allotment of funds for this and several other
surveys were received in a letter from the Chief of Engineers, dated
March 16, 1887.
   The large amount of work which has been required to complete the
surveys, maps, and estimates for several improvements, some of them
extensive, has made it impracticable with the small amount of funds
which could be allotted for the purpose to submit this report at an ear-
lier day. The map of the survey is still incomplete, though far enough
advanced to furnish a basis for the plan of improvement and an esti-
mate of its cost.
   A tracing of the map will be forwarded, as soon as completed, to ac-
company this report. The commercial features of this river were ex-
plained in my preliminary report.
   I inclose herewith, to form part of this report, the report of Mr. F. S.
Burrowes, assistant engineer, to which I invite attention for the details
of the survey.
   The plan devised for improvement is essentially the same as was out-
lined in the preliminary report, but it has not been considered necessary
to make any part of the channel more than 100 feet wide, so that the
quantity to be dredged is somewhat reduced.
   On the other hand, the survey indicates that the rock to be removed
to make a clear channel, full width, is more than was estimated from
mere observation.
   The estimate given in Mr. Burrowes's report, $45,000, for this improve-
ment, will doubtless be ample, provided appropriations are large enough
to complete the dredging and the broken ledge, each by itself, in a single
contract. The removal of the rock is the more important, and it is there-
fore recommended that the first appropriation should be $25,000, to in-
sure its complete removal in one season, otherwise the expense will be
made greater, and but little benefit would result from removing only a
part of the rock.
   Johnson's Narrows is of less importance than the channel to South
Penobscot, and its improvement may properly be left until the other
        ENG 88      26
40 2           REPORT OF             THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                        U. S. ARMY.

work is completed. The estimate in Mr. Burrowes's report ($1,875)
covers all that is considered necessary for any immediate requirements
in this locality.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                                                               JARED A. SMITH,
                                                                                                                 Major of Engineers.
   The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. A.



                  REPORT OF MR. F. S. BURROWES, ASSISTANT ENGINEER.


                                                                                  UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                                                                       PORTLAND, ME., February 1, 1888.
  MAJOR : I have the honor to submit the following report upon the survey of the
Bagaduce River, Maine, between the towns of Penobscot and Brooksville, made under
your direction in August, 1887.
  As explained in your preliminary report, the portion of the river between the points
named includes two branches, the one through the Northern Bay to South Penobscot,
and the other through Johnson's Narrows and Southern Bay to Brooksville.
  In accordance with your verbal instructions the survey was restricted to an examni-
nation of the channel through Northern Bay, and of Johnson's Narrows. Both sur-
veys have been plotted on one chart to a scale of 1: 2,000.
  An azimuth line carefully measured with a steel tape was run down one shore, the
deflection points being marked by drill-holes in the ledge. The soundings were lo-
cated by intersection with two transits and the depths measured with a graduated
rod.
  The plane of reference to which the soundings have been referred is that of the low-
est tide observed during the survey.
  The difference in level between mean high water and mean low water is about 9.5
feet.
  A bench-mark was established near wharf at South Penobscot, as shown on the
chart, being a drill-hole in large bowlder. It is 19.44 feet above the plane of refer-
ence.
  A bench-mark was established at Johnson's Narrows, as shown on the chart, being
a drill-hole in ledge. It is 14.12 feet above plane of reference.

                                 CHANNEL THROUGH                                       NORTHERN BAY.

  The survey of the upper branch included the portion of the channel through
Northern Bay from head of tide-water at South Penobscot to Bridge's Point. At
present the channel is very narrow, crooked, and shallow, and so obstructed by rock
opposite Winslow's Island as to make it hazardous to navigate at all stages of tide,
and vessels are compelled to wait for extreme high water so as to be able to pass over
the shallower but safer flats to the north of the island.
  The plan of improvement upon which the following estimate is based is to obtain
by dredging and blasting a nearly straight channel, 100 feet wide and 6 feet deep at
low water, from the wharf at South Penobscot to deep water at Bridge's Point, and
passing to the south of Winslow's Island, a total distance of 4,000 feet. Most of the
material, from an examination made by driving down an iron rod in a number of
places, seems to be soft mud and clay, with some gravel, and could be dredged without
great difficulty. The loose rock at Winslow's Island could, with proper machinery,
be thrown outside of the proposed channel, and only the larger pieces would require
blasting.
                                                                   ESTIMATE.

80,000 cubic yards dredging, at 25 cents ..................................                                                       $20, 000
3,417 cubic yards rock to be removed, at $6...............................                                                         20,502
Engineering and contingencies...................... .......                                                          ..........     4,498
       Total         -   - ----......------............--..................--.....................----......                      45,000


                                                    JOHNSON'S NARROWS.

The lower or southern channel is contracted at Johnson's Narrows to a low-water
width at one point of 150 feet, both banks being ledge. There is an available depth
                 APPENDIX            A--REPORT              OF     LIEUT.       COL.      SMITH               403

of 4.5 feet at low water through the narrows, and no general improvement, such as
the widening of the channel by the removal of large quantities of rock, could be ob-
tained except at a cost greatly in excess of the benefits to be derived therefrom.
   Two small rocks immediately below the narrowest part, which project 1.50 feet
above low water, are so located as to be a source of danger, and their removal would
be a benefit to navigation. The following is an estimate of the cost of their removal
to a depth of 6 feet below low water :
Removing 125 cubic yards of rock, at $15 ...............................-------------------------------...   $1, 875
  Your preliminary report shows the commercial importance of a portion at least of
this river, and as it is the only outlet except by wagon road for a large section of
country, its improvement would be a great benefit.
  Before closing this report I wish to acknowledge the willing and intelligent assist-
ance rendered by Mr. William B. Bennett during the past season, both in the field
work of the surveys and in the preparation of the maps.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                             F. S. BURnOWES,
                                                                 Assistant Engineer.

  Maj. JARED A.           SMITH,
        Corps of Engineers, U. S. A.




                                                        A    17.

          PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION OF CAMDEN HARBOR, MAINE.

                                             UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                                              Portland.Me., January 18, 1887.
   GENERAL : I have the honor to submit the following report of a pre-
liminary examination of Camden Harbor, Maine. in compliance with
requirements in the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, and with
instructions received from the Chief of Engineers.
   On the 1st and 2d days of December, 1886, I visited Camden, and
obtained the following points bearing upon the commercial interests
and statistics of the place:
   In a walk around the harbor I observed various vessels which were
noted as follows: Three large schooners, heavily loaded, one of three
masts, were lying at anchor, preparing to depart, and a fourth was al-
ready under way; two schooners of fair size and one small one were re-
ceiving cargoes at wharves; another was lying idle at the wharf, and
a small unloaded schooner was at anchor. Of small fishing vessels,
yachts, and other sailing craft of various sizes which were estimated as
ranging from 5 tons to 25 tons burden, I counted twenty which had been
taken into winter quarters.
   Three ship-yards figure among the industries of the place. From one
of these a small steamer had been launched the day before my arrival,
and another had been launched in October last; in the last year a
small yacht was built at the same yard at the head of tide-waterin the
harbor.
   Two of the three ship-yards are more especially adapted and used for
building small vessels; a list was, however, furnished me of seven
large vessels built at one of these yards in the last eleven years, the
average capacity of which was over 500 tons each. The third ship-yard
is close by the steamboat wharf, and is one of the very few in the State
where ship.building has been continued without interruption. From
this yard a four-masted schooner has very recently been launched, hav-
ing a capacity of 1,165 tons. In the nine last years but one year has
404               REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

passed in which no vessels were launched from this yard, and the aver-
age has been slightly over two per annum, twenty vessels having been
launched in the time mentioned.
   The total tonnage of the twenty vessels was 10,177 tons, an average of
over 500 tons to each, and only one vessel of the entire list was as
small as 350 tons.
   Camden is an enterprising village of about 3,000 inhabitants, and is
the principal inlet and outlet for freights and passengers by steamer
for a considerable section of country. The nearest railroad is at Rock-
land, habout 8 miles distant. Most of the articles which are especially
required for the ship-building industry are manufactured at Camden.
   Prominent among the manufactories is an establishment for forging
anchors, for which about 1,500 tons of iron are brought in annually as
crude materials. Other establishments turn out oakum, wood-work,
carvings, blocks, capstans, plugs and wedges, pumps, and windlasses;
there are also a shop for the manufacture of machinery, a woolen-mill
for felts and cloths, a powder mill, a large bakery with water-power,
and two grist-mills In addition to productions of these manufactories
there are shipped from Camden annually from 50,000 to 60,000 barrels
of lime, 150 tons of hay, 25 tons of bran and flour, over 60 tons of meal,
and a vast amount of miscellaneous small articles going by the regular
steamers, of which it is difficult to obtain definite statistics.
   The steamers between Boston and Bangor touch regularly at Cam-
den eight times each week during the year, and during the summer sea-
son there are daily steamers each way for between three and four
months; these will make nearly five hundred arrivals of steamers an-
nually. The amount of freight received and shipped by these steamers
is very large, besides many passengers.
   Complete statistics of articles brought to Camden by water could not
be obtained, but the following are given as a partial statement:
Corn ......--------......-------------......---------....---......--......-------........-----.
                                                                                   ......---......-.... bushels..                                        50,000
Bran and flour                  -----............--....                 ----..................---....                  ----................     tons..      100
Coal ......................                                    .     ........... .              ....................                             do...   4,500
Salt .........................................-----------------------------------------...-.............                                      pounds.. 125,000
Wood ......--------....---......-------......--------......--.-----....---......---....---....--------....---....-----....------..            -- cords.. 2,500
   Coal costs from 10 to 15 cents per ton more than would be required
with a fair depth of water to near the wharves; and all other shipments
and receipts are similarly affected. Add to this the great inconven-
ience to ship-building, and to steamers in their numerous landings,
and the necessity for improvement can not be questioned.
   I believe that the facts mentioned fully show that the harbor is
worthy of improvement by the General Government.
   A survey of Camden Harbor was made in 1872, and two small chan-
nels, each 80 feet wide, were subsequently dredged to the upper part
of the basin under appropriations made in 1873, 1874, and 1875, $10,000
in each year. The channels were planned for depth of 7 feet at low
water, but the work by contract was so imperfectly done that the clear
depth throughout did not exceed 6 feet. The channels being narrow
and the adjacent banks soft, some filling has since obtained, so that the
present depth is entirely inadequate to accommodate vessels of the size
necessary to conduct business with fair economy.
   The maps in this office are believed to be sufficiently accurate for the
purpose of making a plan and estimating approximately the cost of im-
provement. It will, however, be desirable to ascertain more accurately
the present depth of water and the changes which have taken place
since the survey of 1872 before the final adoption of any plan.
          APPENDIX A-REPORT         OF LIEUT.    COL. SMITH.          405
The estimated cost of the hydrographic survey and correcting the
maps, including transportation, boats, etc., is $300.
      Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                JARED   A.   SMITH,
                                                  Major of Engineers.
  Brig. Gen. JAMES C. DUANE,
             Chief of Engineers, U. S. A.



                SURVEY OF CAMDEN HARBOR, MAINE.

                           UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                       Portland, Me., January 28, 1888.
   SIR: In compliance with instructions from the Chief of Engineers,
dated March 16, 1887, I have the honor to submit the following report
of a survey of Camden Harbor, 1Maine, with a plan for its improvement
and an estimate of the probable expense.
   In connection with several other surveys required in the river and
harbor act of August 5, 1886, the field work and platting of maps was
assigned to Mr. F. S. Burrowes, assistant engineer. For the details of
the survey I invite attention to Mr. Burrowes's report which is inclosed
herewith.
   A comparison of the soundings obtained with those taken in a sur-
vey made fifteen years ago shows that any filling which may have taken
place in the harbor has been too small to cause any perceptible change
in the general depths of water; the channels have probably changed
slightly by wash of material from the edges of the middle ground in the
upper part of the harbor.
   The only method by which greater depths can be obtained is by
dredging.
   A tracing from a map of the survey is forwarded in a separate pack-
age to accompany this report; upon the tracing the areas which should
be dredged are fully shown.
   The areas to be dredged are as follows:
   First. A small area, marked A upon the map, should be deepened to 12
feet at mean low water, that depth being required to enable the regular
lines of steamers to effect a landing at all stages of the tide.
   Second. The area marked B should be deepened to 10 feet at mean
low water, to form the approach to the upper harbor, where most of the
business and shipping points are located.
   Third. A channel 100 feet wide, marked C, and a second channel 50
feet wide, marked D, should be given the same depth of 10 feet as in
the approach.
   The small channels marked E, F, and G do not require as great a
depth as that further down the harbor, because the vessels from the
small ship-yards at the upper end can always be launched at high
water, and are, of course, not loaded. The other business in the upper
end of the harbor is small, so that a depth of 5 feet at mean low water
will be sufficient.
   After the portions mentioned have been dredged, it would be advisa-
ble to dredge the middle ground to the same depths of 10 and 5 feet as
the channels between which it lies. The benefits from this would be,
first, the greater permanence of the channels, because they would not
be filled by wash from the middle ground, and the slight amount of
406                REPORT OF TIHE CHIEF OF                                                       ENGINEERS, U. S ARMY.

drift from the inflowing streams would" be more uniformly distributed
over the entire area instead of being principally in the channels.
  The second benefit would be the safe anchorage for numerous small
vessels and the greater facility of moving to and from the wharves.
  The currents in the harbor from tides and streams are not sufficient
to be considered as a factor in maintaining the depths.
  For measurements in situ the expense, including all contingencies of
supervision, etc., is estimated at 35 cents per cubic yard, making the
probable expense as follows, viz:
                                                                                                                                     Cubic yards.
Area A....................................................................                                .3,300
Area B...................................................................                                                        32,400
Channel C ......--.......................................................                                                        19,700
Channel D...........---------.---------......--......---....----....--......--------....----......---------....---......-......
                                                                                                                           ----- 7,700
Channels E, F, and G .....................................................                                                       10,100
      Total measurement..................................................                                                                 73, 200
   Expense, at 35 cents per yard, $25,520.
  This covers the essential part of the improvement. On its completion,
should further appropriations be made they should be applied to remov-
ing the middle ground, for which the estimate is as follows:
                                                                                                                                 Cubic yards.
Area II----H
          ....-----....--....--..--...-------------......--......------....--------....--......---.............------......---....        74,600
Area I---------
        .........................-----------------......---------....----....-----....---......------......--......----......             24, 000
           Total       ...----...--......----..................--   ------..........--....--....--...........                             98, 600
   Expense, at 35 cents per yard, $34,410.
   The removal of the middle ground, though desirable, is not essential,
and it should not be undertaken until the other parts are completed.
   It seems proper to add that to make this improvement with any re-
gard to economy the channels and approach covered in the first estimate
should be done by contract at a single time.
   For small amounts at points distant from commercial centers, compe-
tition by contract is nearly, if not entirely, eliminated, so that the prices
to be paid are greatly increased, and by prolonging the time the con-
tingent expenses are made much greater.
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                   JARED A. SMITH,
                                                      Major of Engineers.
   The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. A.


                            REPORT                OF MR. F.         S. BURROWES,                       ASSISTANT   ENGINEER.


                                                                                       UNITED STATES ENGINEER                  OFFICE,
                                                      Portland,Ale., January 27, 1888.
  MAJOR: I have the honor to submit the following report upon the survey of Cam-
den Harbor, Maine, made under your direction in September, 1887.
  The same methods were adopted as in the survey of Rockport Harbor; that is, a sys-
tem of triangles was used as the basis of measurement, and topography filled in with
the stadia. The depths were measured with a graduated rod and the positions of
soundings located by intersection with two transits.
  The survey has been plotted on one sheet to a scale of 1: 1000.
  The plane of reference to which the soundings are referred is mean low water as
established during a survey of the harbor made in 1872.
  The bench-mark used was also established during that survey and is 14.86 feet above
the plane of reference. It is a drill-hole in ledge, 18 feet southerly from the southeast
corner of Adams & Stetson's upper salt store; its location being indicated on the map.
  The survey of 1872 was made with a view to an improvement of the harbor, which
was afterwards carried out. It consisted in dredging an approach to the harbor and
           APPENDIX       A-REPORT       OF LIEUT.      COL.    SMITH.         407
channels along the wharves. A careful comparison of the present survey with that
of 1872 shows that there has been no appreciable filling on the undisturbed middle
ground in the harbor. There has been some slight filling in the dredged channels,
caused doubtless by gradual washing in from the sides, and not by the deposition of
material brought into the harbor by the small streams flowing into it.
  The areas proposed to be dredged in carrying out the project for the further im-
provement of the harbor are indicated on the chart and lettered from A to I.
      Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                           F.   S. BURROWES,
                                                                Assistant Engineer.
Maj. JARED A. SMITH.
        Corps of Engineers, U. S. A.




                                       A 18.
     PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION OF ROCKPORT HARBOR, MAINE.

                                UNITED    STATES ENGINEER         OFFICE,
                                       Portland, Me., December 24, 1886.
   GENERAL : I have the honor to submit the following report of a pre-
liminary examination of Rockport Harbor, Maine, made in compliance
with requirement in the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, and in-
structions from the Chief of Engineers.
   The earliest opportunity for making this examination was on the 2d
of December, on which day I visited the place and obtained such in-
formation as seemed necessary for the purpose of this report.
   Rockport Harbor is on the west shore of Penobscot Bay and about 6
miles north of Rockland Harbor; it is at the northern extremity of a
small bay having a broad entrance on the south, but entirely sheltered
from storms in all other directions. The water is quite deep south of
the portion in which wharves have been constructed.
   For a more full understanding of the situation, I refer to Coast Sur-
vey Chart No. 321, harbors of Camden and Rockport, Me., and to
Coast Chart No. 4, Penobscot Bay, Maine.
   The mean rise of tide is 9.8 feet, and in most places inside the harbor
the water is deep enough to meet the ordinary requirements of com-
merce. There are a few points, however, where some embarrassment
is caused by shallow water and bowlders, which could be remedied by
a comparatively small amount of work.
   So far as I could ascertain, the principal obstruction to the harbor is
the rock shown on the chart as Harbor Ledge, upon which there is
erected a stone beacon.
   The top of the ledge is submerged but about 3 feet at mean low
water; it forms a ridge of about 150 feet in length, and a greatest width
of about 40 feet, lying obliquely across the west side of the harbor en-
trance in a northwesterly direction from the beacon.
   A large part of the shipments from this harbor are in the winter, and
the retention of the ice about the wharves is a most serious obstruction.
   The beacon and the ledge hold the ice which gathers in the harbor
and prevent its going out with each receding tide, and thus place a seri-
ous embargo upon the winter traffic.
   It was represented to me that the revenue cutters have frequently
assisted vessels, which would otherwise have been unable to move, by
breaking the ice in the harbor.
   On the day of my visit there were five large and heavily-loaded
schooners lying at anchor near the lower wharveswaiting for a favora-
408      REPORT     OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

ble wind to depart; two schooners were unloading lumber at one of
the wharves; three large unloaded schooners and one small one were
at anchor awaiting room at the wharves to take in a shipment; three
large schooners were lying at wharves taking in cargoes of lime, and
three were discharging cargoes of wood-seventeen vessels, most of them
of more than average size, engaged in the business of the place in a sin-
gle day. In the pastyear there have been shipped from the harbor of
Rockport 300,000 barrels of lime, 40,000 tons of ice, 100,000 cases of fish,
clams, and lobsters, besides miscellaneous smaller items for which no
statistics were procured. The manufacture and shipment of lime has
increased more than one-third in the past two years, and new facilities
just introduced for transporting limestone by railroad instead of wag-
ons give promise of a continued increase for some succeeding years.
   Close by the village is a large fresh-water pond which furnishes an
excellent supply of ice. This industry is one which receives great in-
jury from the insufficient depth and a large bowlder near the wharves,
as well as from the difficulties of winter shipments from causes already
mentioned.
   There is reason to believe that a considerable increase in the ice ship-
ments would result from a removal of the obstructions. Among the
heavy articles brought into the harbor are coal and wood; of the latter,
there is now an annual consumption of 15,000 cords in the manufacture
of lime alone.
   Rockport and Camden are among the few places on the coast from
which the ship-building interest has not entirely departed. Ship-build-
ing has been continued regularly at Rockport, though no vessels have
been built there since August, 1885. Since 1882 three vessels of 2,200,
2,400, and 2,600 tons, respectively, have been built and launched in this
harbor, and it is expected soon to commence another. From the office of
the deputy collector of customs at Rockport, I have been furnished
with a list of thirty-nine vessels, owned in that place. The largest of
these has a gross tonnage of 2,628.93 tons; three have a tonnage of
over 2,000 tons each; eight have over 1,000 tons each, and fourteen
have over 600 tons each.
   The vessels carrying ice draw from 15 to 18 feet of water, and some
of the vessels entering the harbor draw 20 feet.
   The deputy collector of customs has also furnished the following in-
formation regarding arrivals and departures of vessels:
  From January 1 to December 1, 1886, there were 279 foreign entrances and clear-
ances of vessels which delivered or received their cargoes at said Rockport. * * *
I think I am safe in saying that the number of vessels arriving at the port of Rock-
port will average very close to 100 per month.
  It may be observed that the number of foreign vessels is in excess of
twenty-five per month, or about one for every working day in the year;
and many of the heaviest shipments from the place are made in the
winter.
  In my opinion the condition and commerce of the harbor of Rock-
port are such that it is worthy of improvement by the General Govern-
ment.
  The Coast Survey charts, though giving a very good map of the har-
bor on a small scale, are insufficient in detail to furnish information on
which to base an accurate estimate of the expense of necessary im-
provement.
  It is, therefore, recommended that a survey of the harbor be made as
soon as it can be done with advantage and economy in the coming
spring.
           APPENDIX    A--REPORT      OF   LIEUT.   COL.   SMITH.       409
The expense of such a survey, including the platting of maps and
making of plans, is estimated at $350.
     Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                            JARED A. SMITII,
Brig. Gen. J. C. DUANE,                       Major of Engineers.
      Chief of Engineers, U. S. A.


                SURVEY    OF ROCKPORT      HARBOR, MAINE.

                            UNITED STATES ENGINEER           OFFICE,
                                         Portland, Me., January 18, 1888.
    SIR: I have the honor to submit the following report of a survey of
Rockport Harbor, Maine, made in accordance with instructions from the
Chief of Engineers, dated March 16, 1887.
    The field-work and platting of maps for this survey were put in charge
of Mr. F. S. Burrowes, assistant engineer, and the survey was made in
connection with several others in such succession as would cause the
least loss of time and least distance to travel.
    Mr. Burrowes's report, which I inclose herewith as part of my own,
furnishes all necessary details of the field and office work. A tracing of
the map of the harbor is forwarded in a separate package to accom-
pany this report. In my report of a preliminary examination of this
harbor, submitted December 24, 1886, I mentioned such points as I was
enabled to ascertain by a personal examination and inquiry.
    The statistics then submitted are considered sufficient to show the
importance of the harbor and the propriety of its improvement, provided
the expense be not incommensurate with the probable benefit.
    The difficulties pointed out to me in my preliminary examination were
the retention of ice by the " harbor ledge," which greatly increases the
difficulty of shipping in winter, and the insufficient depths near the
wharves.
    Since the map of the survey has been platted I have given the subject a
more careful consideration than was possible before. This study has been
made by Mr. Burrowes and myself in mutual consultation, and the gen-
eral conclusions and estimtates of cost have been embodied in Mr. Bur-
rowes' s report.
    There being no reservoirs beyond the harbor to be filled and emptied
by fipw of tides, there are no tidal currents of sufficient strength to be
considered as factors in clearing the harbor of ice.
    The harbor proper is very small in area and the land is sufficiently high
to protect it from the force of winds which might assist in driving out
the ice.
    I have reached the conclusion that it is undoubtedly true that the
ice is a great injury to the harbor in winter, and that the beacon, stand-
ing as it does about midway between the shores near a point which
may be fairly called the harbor entrance, would naturally be regarded as
the cause of the trouble; but that it may not necessarily follow that the
removal of the beacon and the ledge upon which it stands will result in
the clear water which seems to be expected.
    The harbor, being very small and shallow near the wharves, has the
water somewhat freshened by the inflow of the small streams, so that the
  bformation of ice during the succession of tides which rise and fall almost
without perceptible current wll take place between and around the
wharves, with lodgments even upon the bottom, so that it is not easy to
see what force will operate to remove the ice, protected from wind ex-
410     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

cept on the side which makes it enter the harbor, even were the "harbor
ledge" removed.
   Should the ledge be removed to a depth barely sufficient to be beyond
the reach of " anchor ice," a depth of say 12 feet, it would, in my opin-
ion, become a serious danger to vessels drawing more than that depth
of water, for they wquld be more likely to strike upon the ragged bot-
tom than upon the ledge, which is now smooth and well marked. If
removed at all it should therefore be to a depth great enough to clear
the keels of large vessels, or say 20 feet. This would require the blast-
ing and removal of 9,800 cubic yards, most of which is solid ledge, at
an estimated price, including contingent expenses, of $15 per cubic yard,
making a total of $147,000.
   The harbor is entirely protected from all winds except from the south,
and at such time the removal of the ledge would have a tendency to
permit an increase " undertow "' near the wharves, from the sea setting
into the harbor. This part of the subject may, therefore, be summar-
ized as follows:
    (1) There is no certainty nor even strong probability that the removal
of the ledge will entirely remedy the evil or very greatly reduce it. The
evil of ice in the harbor is one of latitude and longitude combined with
its local features, of which the ledge forms but one.
    (2) It is not improbable that the removal of the ledge will increase
the difficulty of vessels lying at the wharves during southerly storms.
   (3) The estimated expense is too large to be recommended without a
greater probability of large resulting benefits. The water at the upper
end of the harbor is very shallow, so that access tb the wharves in that
part can only be had at high stages, and even then only by vessels of
comparatively small draught.
   1 believe that ai increase of the depth to 12 feet over the small area
shown upon the map will result in a very great benefit to the facilities
for shipping lime and ice at all times of the year, as well as for ship-
ping and receiving any other articles of freight.
   It also seems probable that such increase of depth will decrease the
lodgment of ice upon the bottom, and to some small extent make the
movement of vessels through the ice in that part of the harbor less dif-
ficult.
   Should ledges of rock be found to underlie the earthy material above
the grade indicated, the expense of their removal would probably not
be justified.
   The amount of funds which could be allotted to this survey wa; not
sufficient to cover the expense of complete borings; these, however,
can be readily made before a contract for dredging is completed.
   I recommend that the dredging indicated be done as far as practi-
cable. The estimate of $14,000 for the purpose is included in Mr. Bur-
rowes's report, to which I invite attention.
         Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                 0Major               JARED A. SMITH,
                                                                  of Engineers.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. A.


             REPORT OF MIR. F.   S. BUJRROWES,   ASSISTANT   ENGINEER.

                                        UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                                 Portland, Me., January 16, 1888.
  MAJOR: I have the honor to submit the following report upon the survey of Rock-
port Harbor, Mine, made under your direction during the past summer.
  The survey was commenced August 26, 1887, and completed September 1.
            APPENDIX       A-REPORT             OF LIEUT.   COL.   SMITH.          411
  A system of triangles carefully measured and computed was used as the basis of
the survey. The triangulation! stations were marked either by drill holes in ledge
or nails in the wharves. Shore-lines, wharves, buildings, and other adjacent topo-
graphical features were located by stadia measurement from triangulation points.
The survey was mapped on one chart to a scale of 1: 1000, which is herewith sub-
mitted.
  The soundings were measured with lead and brass sounding-chain, the positions
being located by intersection with two transit instruments.
  The soundings cn the chart are reduced to the plane of mean low water. This plane
was established by three comparisons at slackwater with the plane of mean low water
at Camden as determined and referred to a bench-mark in 1872 by Mr. A. C. Both, as-
sistant engineer.
  A bench-mark was established, being a drill hole in ledge 20 feet east of the south-
east corner of Barrett's fish-house. It is 19.90 feet above the assumed plane of mean
low water. Its location is indicated on the chart. The difference in level between
mean high water and mean low water, as given on the charts of the U. S. Coast and
Geodetic Survey, is 9.8 feet.
  Rockport Harbor is an arm of Penobscot Bay, and is well protected on all sides ex-
cept to the southward, in which direction it opens unobstructedly to the bay. Its
shores are composed ahlmost entirely of rocks. The entrance to the harbor is very deep,
and there is a good channel 36 feet deep as far up as the lower wharves. There is an
available depth of 12 feet to within 350 feet of the head of the harbor, and extending
over two-thirds of its width.
                                       HARBOR   LEDGE.


   Almost in mid-harbor, and about 300 feet below the lower wharf, is a rock known
as Harbor Ledge, the top of which is but 4.4 feet below mean low water. It is at pres-
ent marked by a masonry beacon 11.5 feet square and extending 24 feet above mean
low water. From its general formation and location it is apparently an upheaval of
the same ledge, which juts out from the shore to the northwest of the beacon. As at
present marked it can not be regarded as an obstacle to the free entrance of the har-
bor, as to the east of it there is a straight channel 24 feet deep and 300 feet wide.
   It is perhaps a benefit in partially protecting the upper part of the harbor from the
heavy seas caused by the winds blowing from the direction in which it is most ex-
posed.
   The principal cause of complaint appears to be that the ledge and beacon cause the
ice to anchor and jam around them, thus preventing the ice in the upper portion of
the harbor from moving out as freely as it otherwise would. If this interference
with navigation in the harbor should be regarded as of sufficient importance to jus-
tify the removal of the ledge, it should be taken out to a depth of 20 feet at mean low
water and back to the general line of the 20-foot curve above and below it, in order
to give safe and unobstructed passage to both vessels and ice. To obtain such depth
would require the removal of 9,800 cubic yards of material in situ, at least 75 per cent.
of which would be solid ledge. To obtain a depth of 18 feet over the same area would
require the removal of 6,500 cubic yards in situ of the same material. The beacon on
the ledge contains 155 cubic yards of masonry. Its removal, without the removal of
the ledge also, would add hazard to navigation by leaving a dangerous obstacle, not
definitely marked, close to the channel, without a corresponding benefit, as the ice
would still be partially held by the ledge itself.

                          SHOAL   IN    UPPER END   OF HARBOR.


     From the 12-foot curve to the upper wharves the water shoals very rapidly, having
.anshoaling
      available depth of only 4.25 feet at mean low water along the wharves. This
            is presumably caused by the material washed down from the hills by Rock-
port Brook and another small drain at the head of the harbor. Nothing more, how-
ever, than a superficial examination was made of the character of the material, which
could only be definitely determined by a thorough set of borings
   If the whole upper part of the harbor bounded by the lines of the prominent
wharves were dredged to a depth of 12 feet at mean low water an improvement
would be obtained which would greatly facilitate the present and cause an increase
in the future traffic of the place.
   The following estimate gives the amount of material to be removed within the lines
and to the depth mentioned. The areas proposed to be dredged are marked on the
chart with black shade lines.
   A small rock close to the eastern line of the area proposed to be dredged and oppo-
site the upper ice-house should also be removed to a depth of 12 feet.
412     REPORT OF TIE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                     ESTIMATE.

Dredging in upper end of harbor, 40,640 cubic yards in situ, at 30 cents-..... $12, 192
Removing small rock opposite upper ice-house, 35 cubic yards in situ, at $20        700
Engineering and contingencies .....................-----------...... ......      1, 108
     Total-------                                                       14,000
           ....----............-------------....--------......----......-----
  Rockport is a place of considerable commercial importance. It ships annually
large amounts of ice and lime.   Within the past year a narrow-guago railroad 2 miles
long has been constructed, connecting the quarries with the kilns at Rockport. For
the detailed commercial statistics of the place I would refer to your report upon the
preliminary examination of the harbor.
      Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                              F.   S. BURROWES,
                                                                   Assistant Engineer.
  Maj. JARILED A. SMITH,
      Corps of Engineers, U. S. A.




                                        A ig9.

PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION OF KENNEBEC RIVER, MAINE, AT BATH,
     AND FROM AUGUSTA TO LOWER END OF PERKIN'S ISLAND.

                                 UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                      Portland,Me., December 27, 1886.
  GENERAL: I have the honor to submit the following report of a pre-
liminary examination of the Kennebec River, Maine, at Bath, and from
Augusta to lower end of Perkin's Island, in compliance with a require-
ment in the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, and instructions re-
ceived from the Chief of Engineers.
  On the 7th of December I visited Bath, and proceeded down the river
as far as Perkin's Island on a tug, in company with several pilots and
other parties who are acquainted with the river and its commerce.
  There are a few points in the river below Bath where small ledges in
the river bottom make shallow places in the channel, but as they are
marked by buoys and have plenty of water on either hand, they are not
considered as obstructions, and do not require any present attention.
   "The Coast Survey chart of the Kennebec and Sheepscot rivers,
Maine," numbered 314, to which I refer, shows a small island in the
river about 3 miles above its mouth, the name on the chart being "Per-
kin's Island." This is the only island on the river shown on the charts
by that name, but as there are at present no improvements required
below Bath, and from Augusta to the island in question would include
Bath, for which a separate examination is required, I conclude that the
limitations were intended to be at Bath, and from Augusta to the south
end of the large island ,ear Richmond, upon which the town of Per-
kins is situated, but which is shown upon the unpublished Coast Survey
chart as " Swan Island." Upon such an interpretation this report is
submitted.
  The obstructions in the river at Bath consist of a few small points of
ledge projecting above the general level of the bottom; they are in the
channel, but near the wharves, and so situated as to cause much incon-
venience and some hazard.
   Some of these ledges are of sufficient size to be indicated upon the
larger-scale charts of the river at Bath. One of the ledges shown on the
chart without a name is now locally known as the " Steam Mill Rock,"
and is about 600 feet north of the buoy on Trufant's Ledges; a second
           APPENDIX A--REPORT        OF LIEUT. COL. SMITH.           413
ledge is known as Houghton's Rock, and a third is adjacent to the
wharf of the railroad ferry. Apparently the same general line of up-
heaval is shown at Trufant's Ledges, Lincoln's Ledges, and at Hospital
Point.
   The last-named ledge seems to be but little in the way of navigation,
and will probably require no attention. How far the others may need
removal can only be determined after a careful survey; but of the ne-
cessity for removing some, if not all, of the ledges mentioned to such a
depth that the keels of large vessels can no longer reach them there
can be no doubt.
   From Bath to the south end of Swan Island (Perkin's Island) there
are no obstructions which are at present considered worthy of attention.
From this point to the dam at Augusta I went over the large scale
charts very carefully with some of the best pilots on the river, and on
December 18 I visited Augusta, and by inquiries there and at Hallo-
well added further points to my information on the subject.
    So far as I have been able to ascertain the greatest embarrassment
to the river navigation is caused by the narrow channel and shallow
water over the rocks in the sharp bend at Lovejoy's Narrows. This
place is in the channel east of Swan Island and at the head of Little
Swan Island.
   I forward, to accompany this report, a tracing, giving an outline
sketch, which shows the location of the narrows, and a second sketch on
the same sheet indicating on a large scale the parts of ledge which
should be removed. The present condition is such that the channel is
confined between rough ledges so near to each other that two large ves-
sels have not room to pass each other. The situation is rendered worse
because of the bend at this point, which tends to conceal from each
other vessels which are approaching from opposite directions. The ad-
jacent land is high and the current is rapid. Most of the vessels are
towed up and down the river. Should a tug, going in the direction of
the tide or river current with a tow, meet other vessels at this point, it
must go ahead at whatever risk of collision or incur the certainty of
injury to vessels in tow, which would be driven into the narrows by the
force of the tide.
   At low water the place is entirely impassable for vessels of any con-
siderable draught.
   Some portions of the ledge have been removed at different times
under former appropriations for that purpose; the last work being com-
pleted in September, 1877.
   The work then done gave a narrow channel of but 10 feet at mean
low water and 15± feet at mean high water, of summer stages. (Report
of Chief of Engineers, 1878, Part I, page 38.)
    Shipping in large vessels has been found so advantageous, that at
present the most economical size is only limited by the depth of water in
the channel. This is especially true for the shipment of ice, of which an
immense amount is annually cut at points above Swan Island. A large
part of the vessels now employed in such shipping can only pass these
rocky narrows and other shallow points at the high-water stage, so that
delay and expense are added to the danger of injury, and much larger
vessels could be used with great resulting economy would the depth of
water permit.
    The surveys heretofore made of Lovejoy's Narrows are sufficient to
afford a fair degree of accuracy in the computation of quantities of
stone which should be removed. The channel must, of necessity, be
limited by the situation, but it should be straightened as far as prac.
414            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

ticable, made sufficiently wide for vessels to meet without special dan-
ger, and be as deep as 18 feet. In improving such a channel it is rec-
ommended that points of ledge should be removed to a depth below
the shallower parts of the river bottom in their vicinity, because a hull
resting upon an earthy bottom receives little or no injury, but if it
touch the rocks it can not fail to receive damage causing more or less
serious results.
   I am enabled to submit the following estimate of improving the chan-
nel at Lovejoy's Narrows, to give a width of 170 feet and a depth of 18
feet at mean low water:
                                                                                                                               Cubic yards
Ledge formerly known as Dry Rock ........................................                                                               3,626
                         ......-------......-------------......----......------......---------....----......---------......----......
Rock No. 4 (near ditto)------                                                                                                             241
                      ......-------......-----....------....-----....------....---....---....---............---...... ---
Half Tide Rock Point-----                                                                                                               3,078
Spaulding's Island Point--  .----------....---......-----------......----......--------......----......-......----......-....           1,063
              ................................................................
          Total--------------------------------------------------------                                                                 8,008
   It is believed that the ledge can be removed for $12.50 per cubic
yard, if the appropriations therefor be not extended over a long period.
The estimated expense is thus made $100,100; this sum would be most
economically expended in two years.
   In addition to the above, there are numerous places between the
south end of Swan Island and the dam at Augusta where small im-
provements are required, and for which no general plan or estimate
can be submitted until the points have been carefully surveyed in de-
tail.
   Some deepening of the west channel is required nearly opposite the
lower end of Swan Island.
   In the east channel the first obstruction reached is locally known as
Coxsackie Shoal. The river at this place is broad at high water, so that
the current is too sluggish to cause a scour over the bar, defended at its
head by a small ledge known as Beef Rock, which is only submerged at
high water. This is perhaps the most extensive shoal in the main chan-
nel below Gardiner.
   At the head of Swan Island is the Richmond Breakwater. It is a
serious question among those interested in the river navigation and in-
dustries, and one which can only be answered by a survey and further
observation, whether this breakwater by causing ice-jams in freshets
is not injuring the channel it was intended to benefit, as well as causing
loss in the ice crops above. The question is worthy of attention, though
I am not at present able to give any definite information on the subject.
   A bout half a mile above Swan Island opposite Lincoln ice-houses, there
is said to be a rock in the channel on which several vessels have been
injured; it has but 9 feet of water over it, though it is not shown upon
the map obtained from the office of the Coast Survey.
   A similar rock is in the channel about 3 miles above Swan Island,
opposite the middle one of Berry's ice-houses; this rock has but 5 feet
of water over its top at low water.
   Following up the channel we come to what is known as the Upper
Sand Bar, where some dredging and probably a small jetty is required.
In 1871 a channel 100 feet wide and 10 feet deep at mean low water was
dredged through this bar, but this is entirely insufficient for the present
necessities. A short distance above is Nehumkeg Rock in mid-chan-
nel, which was removed to 12 feet at mean low water in 1871.
   In very nearly mid-channel, 2( miles below the bridge at Gardiner, is
a reef known as Green's Ledge, over which the chart shows a depth of
but 4 feet.
           APPENDIX    A--REPORT      OF LIEUT.    COL.   SMITH.       415
   A short distance below the bridge at Gardiner the river is wide, and
a spit known as Tarbox's Shoal requires some attention.
   The draw of the bridge from Gardiner to Pittston is difficult and
somewhat dangerous to pass, owing to the lack of suitable piers as
guides to the current and guards for the passing vessel. I give this upon
the statement of pilots and others without personal knowledge obtained
from observation.
   The bridge seems to have had an effect in forming a shoal in front of
the wharves immediately above, and the shoal has extended downward
until it has injured the channel through the draw; opposite the railroad
wharf the shallow water causes great inconvenience and expense in
getting vessels to and from the landing.
   About 1. miles above the Gardiner Bridge is Brown's Island, a small
formation in mid-channel where the river is wide. In the eastern and
principal channel is " Brown's Island Shoal."
   From the last named point to the bridge at Augusta, a distance of 5
miles, are Hinkley's, Shepard's Point, Hallowell, Britt's, and Gage's
shoals, where, from 1867 to 1871, channels 100 feet wide and 6 feet
deep were cut by dredging.
   On the 20th of February, 1870, thedam at Augusta was carried away,
letting loose into the river below an immense accumulation of gravel,
sand,and mill refuse. Aportion of the refuse was subsequently removed
from the channels which had been previously dredged, but the great
mass remained in the river-bed and by degrees drifted into the chan.
nels and upon the shoals.
   Most of the trouble now experienced above Gardiner is above the
south end of Shepard's Point Shoal Cut, but to devise a complete plan
for improvement soundings should be taken and platted on the maps
covering the entire distance. A draught of 10 feet at high water is now
the extreme amount which can be carried to Augusta, and even that
depth is subject to great inconvenience and delay. The tidal range in
this part of the river is about 5 feet.
  The same freshet carried away the toll-bridge at Hallowell,leaving the
piers in the river. The remains of the bridge piers are now submerged
at high water and form a dangerous obstacle on which many vessels
have been injured.
  I am informed that a channel on the east shore at Augusta was greatly
obstructed by ddbris, which was deposited in the water many years ago
during the construction of the United States Arsenal, and that private
enterprise has incurred considerable expense to remedy its worst feat-
ures.
   As before remarked, it is not now practicable to devise a definite proj.-
ect and estimate of cost of improvements which may be found neces-
sary at these various places, but that the river is worthy of improvement
by the General Government there is, in my opinion, no doubt.
   The river forms one of the principal water communications from the
sea-board to the interior of the State. Perhaps no other equal area in
the country has so extensive a business in the cutting and shipment of
ice; this is a grand annual crop, which practically costs nothing save
labor to produce, so that the total receipts are a net benefit to the State,
and it decreases the cost of this luxury in nearly every State on our
Atlantic and Gulf coast.
  Exports of granite and lumber figure to a considerable extent, as well
as numerous other articles of smaller merchandise.
  From Augusta alone there is shipped an annual average of 7,500,000
feet of lumber, requiring, with the present, draught of water, fifty yes
416         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

sels to transport it. Freight on lumber is increased 45 cents per 1,000
feet, owing to the shoals at and above Gardiner; this is equivalent to a
tax of $3,375 on this single interest in one town.
   Large quantities of lumber from the valley of the Kennebec are car-
ried by rail at greater expense than for water transportation to points
further down the river in order that larger vessels and consequent
cheaper freights may be obtained.
   At Hallowell there are shipped by water from 10,000 to 15,000 tons
of granite per year, on which the extra cost of freight due to shoals in
less than 3 miles of the river below is given as 15 cents per ton.
   From a member of the " I ce Exchange" I have obtained the storage
capacity of ice-houses on the Kennebec River as closely approximating
1,200,000 tons. The amount of ice cut and shipped annually is, of course,
less than the total capacity, and varies from year to year.
   In the winter of 1885-'86 a large part of the best ice-fields were in-
jured or ruined by freshets, so that nearly half the companies cut no
ice at all, and others cut less than usual. The amount of ice cut and
stored during the winter mentioned was 433,000 tons.
   It is estimated that the average capacity of the vessels carrying ice
will not exceed 700 tons, and upon this basis it would require over 600
vessels to carry the small crop harvested in this exceptional season.
   The ice shipments above Gardiner, and probably granite also, would
be largely increased were it possible to employ vessels having a greater
draught of water. Articles of import are less numerous than those
going out of the river; but they are sufficient to form in the aggregate
an item of much importance. Over one hundred vessels per annum are
required to bring to Augusta and Hallowell the coal alone which comes
by water. There are also large receipts of lime, cement, bricks, etc.
All of these freights are considerably increased in cost, owing to the
obstructions and the smaller class of vessels which are necessarily em-
ployed. Freights on coal above Gardiner are increased 25 cents per
ton by the obstructions above that place. The cities of Hallowell and
Augusta thus pay annually $5,500 more for their coal than would other-
wise be required.
    Two regular lines of steamers ply upon the river as far as Augusta,
one line running from Boston. The latter, however, is compelled to
transfer its passengers and freights to a smaller steamer at Gardiner.
With a good channel steamers would without doubt run direct from
Augusta to Boston.
    The Kennebec Steam-boat Line also has to make transfers at Gardiner
to smaller craft when the stage of water is low.
    I recommend that a survey be made of all the locations mentioned,
in order that a complete project and estimate may be prepared.
    A surveying party under charge of a competent assistant will cost
 $20 per day, and it is estimated that six weeks will be required to do
the field work properly. Not less than one month's time of assistants
will be required to plat the maps.
    The following estimate for costs of survey, etc., is therefore submitted:
Expense of field work, 36 days, at $20 .-..----------....------....--......---....-----....-...... $720
                                   ...------------............
Reducing maps and projects in office---------------------                                       ----    200
Transportation of party, hire of boats, etc ..................................                           80

        Total-................................................................                         1,000
          Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                                 JARED A. SMITH,
   Brig. Gen. JAMES C. DUANE,                                                      Major of Engineers.
             Chief of Engineers, U. S. A.
          APPENDIX    A--REPORT     OF   LIEUT.   COL.   SMITH.     417
SURVEY OF KENNEBEC RIVER, MAINE, AT BATH, AND FROM AUGUSTA
              TO LOWER END OF PERKIN'S ISLAND.
                            UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                        Portland,Me., January 9, 1888.
   SIR : In accordance with instructions contained in Department letter
of March 16, 1887, I have the honor to submit the following report of
a survey of the Kennebec River, Maine, at Bath, and from Augusta to
lower end of Perkin's Island.
   In my preliminary report I explained that the island known and
shown on the charts as Perkin's Island is below Bath, and that the
island indicated for the termination of the survey contains the town of
Perkin's, but is known as Swan Island. Swan Island is about 5 miles
long, and the two channels by which it is inclosed are used for naviga-
tion, and both require improvement.
    The entire length of the channel to be passed over by the survey was
thus about 27 milds, besides what was required in the harbor of Bath.
    The situation and character of a channel forming the approaches to
an obstruction is often nearly as important an element as the obstruc-
tion itself in determining the location and extent of improvement which
may be required.
    The funds which could be allotted for this survey were insufficient to
make it complete, with borings to ascertain the character of the bottom,
and to cover the expense of making the maps.
    I was therefore compelled to limit the work to a hydrographic sur-
vey of the river from Augusta to Gaidiner and to such detached loca-
tions below as seemed to require improvement.
    The survey was thus not only very much abridged, but even in that
form every expedient was used to save expense. It has therefore been
impossible to obtain all the information necessary to devise a project
covering the complete and permanent improvement of the river.
    The project for the improvement of the river navigation has been
made as complete as possible with the information which could be thus
obtained.
    The field and office work have been under the immediate charge of
1lr. F. S. Burrowes, assistant engineer, who, though only temporarily
employed for the purpose, has pushed the work forward very rapidly
and with a good judgment which is worthy of special commendation.
    Mr. Burrowes's report is appended, to form part of my own, and thir-
teen tracings* from completed maps are forwarded in a separate pack-
age, to accompany my report.
    The discussion of the commerce of the river was made so full in my
preliminary report that no further statistics seem to be here required.
    It is apparent, however, that as there are various shipping points for
ice, lumber, stone, and merchandise, most of w hich is taken out in sea-
going vessels, and at the same points receive return freights of coal,
grain, provisions, articles of manufacture, etc., the number passing the
channel at any one point diminishes as the river is ascended, and at the
head of navigation only those vessels will appear which carry freights
the entire distance.
    It is therefore evident that the necessity for a deep channel which
may be navigated at all stages of the tide diminishes towards the head
of navigation; it is also true that vessels may arrive at and leave the
  upper terminus of navigation at high water, but to do this without de-
lay en route points further c[own the river must be passed at low stages.
                                  SOmitted.
418             REPORT OF THF CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The requirements thus bear a relation to the volume of water in the
river which passes a given point through the action of tides and trib-
utaries, the channel hecoming larger and deeper as the river is de-
scended.
   Augusta, the capital of the State, at the head of tide-water and of
navigation, is a shipping point of considerable lumber and other mer-
chandise, and a distributing point for coal and other articles brought
in by sail vessels and regular steam-boat lines.
   From Augusta to a point midway between Hallowell and Gardiner
a depth of 8 feet at low water is all that can be maintained without in-
curring great expense.
   The shoals are mainly of hard sand and gravel, with some bowlders,
all of a kind not easily moved by the current. At the points where
these shoals occur the river is too wide to obtain a good channel by the
scouring action of the water, so that jetties to contract the width would
be desirable; but it is believed that at present the additional expense
would be disproportionate to the benefit, as the channels when dredged
will be maintained without concentration of the current, at least for a
long time.
   It is therefore recommended that through Gage's Shoal and Britt's
Shoal the channel be dredged, so as to give a depth of 8 feet at low
water and a width of 100 feet. It would be well, also, to dredge the
east channel at Augusta to a depth of 7 feet and a width of 50 feet.
   Between HIallowell and Gardiner are four shoals.          The channel
through them should have a width as great as 125 feet. For the first two
and upper part of the third a depth of 8 feet is all that can be readily
obtained. For the lower part of the third shoal and for the fourth a
depth of 10 feet is desirable, more especially for the reason that they
reach points where heavy shipments of ice are made.
   Immediately above the bridge at Gardiner is a small shoal which
should be removed, and also a very small one, known as Steamboat
Shoal, at a short distance below the bridge.
   The amount of dredging required to complete the channel as indi.
cated, from Gardiner to Augusta, is as follows:

                                                     SITU MEASUREMENT.
                                                                                                                          Cubic yards.
Gage's Shoal------------......---------....---......-----------....----......------......-----....--........------.................. 45, 500
East Channel ......--------------......---........---------.........---------.------....---.........---..--......---..-....           5,500
Britt's Shoal ..------...----------------------......--......-----.....---..........-----....---......---......--....-...... -70,        000
Hallowell and Shepard's Point shoals....-............................ .....                                          ---
IHinckley's Shoal........-----------------....----....-----....---....--......----....------....--....----....--....---........
                                                                                                                                     41,000
                                                                                                                                     18, 000
Brown's Island Shoal------.......-------......---------....---....--....---....-.......-------....-----....---....--......           33, 000
Gardiner and Steamboat shoals............................................                                                             8, 000
          Total..----------------------------------------                                              ------------            '221,000
   One of the greatest difficulties to be experienced in this work is the
dumping of the material in suitable places. The dumping must gener-
ally be near the shore, where the water is shallow and where the mate-
rial will not be washed back into the channel, so that the distance of
towing is often great and delay is caused by the necessity for waiting
for high water. It is, therefore, not prudent to estimate the contract
price of this work at less than 35 cents per cubic yard in situ.
   At Hallowell the remains of the piers of a former bridge are still in
the river, and two of them next the draw are not only inconvenient, but
dangerous; both should be removed. For their removal the estimate
is as follows, viz: 350 cubic yards of stone, etc., at $2.50 per yard, $875.
           APPENDIX A-REPORT         OF LIEUT. COL. SMITH.            419
   The shbal below Nehumkeg Island, known as the "Upper Sand Bar'
is situated in a wide part of the river, where an obstruction is naturally
formed by the shifting sands.
   The survey and the time for maturing plans of improvement have
been so much restricted, that the plan of improvement which has been
devised for this and perhaps for other places may be found to require
some modification.
   It seems probable that a properly located wing-dam and dike or
training-wall will be sufficient to cause a scour which shall obtain and
preserve a good channel through the shoal. It is possible .that some
dredging may be found necessary to assist the scour.
   The wing-dam joining the dike with the shore must be very strong to
resist the force of ice, and its top should be a little higher than the top
of the dike. A footing of brush should be provided, to prevent under-
mining by scour, and most of the work should be of heavy stone.
   The estimate is for a wing-dam 20 feet wide on top and 5 feet high,
and for a dike 10 feet wide on top and 4 feet high, both having slopes
of 45 degrees.
   A dredged channel is represented upon the map, but I feel so confi-
dent that the dike and wing-dam will accomplish all that is required,
that no estimate for dredging is considered necessary.
   The obstruction made by Berry's Rock will probably require atten-
tion at some future time, but in view of the fact that numerous other
points exist where the channel demands immediate attention, this place
may very properly be passed over without an estimate for improvement
at present.
   Some years ago a jetty of stone was constructed at the head of Swan
Island for the purpose of diverting the current and causing a scour in
the west or Richmond Channel. It is quite apparent that the jetty has
not accomplished all that was expected or hoped; but, on the other
hand, it is very urgently claimed that it has been a means of injury to
the ice crop by causing a jam in time of winter freshets.
   Be this as it may, my judgment is that the channel would be im-
proved by removing the outer end of the jetty for at least a third of its
length, and to place the stone on a line from the end of the jetty thus
shortened toward the point of rocks a short distance below, on the Swan
Island side of the Richmond Channel. To do this will require the
shifting of 6,000 tons of stone, at an estimated cost of 50 cents per ton.
   At Swan Island the eastern channel is by far the more important, as
it is the main thoroughfare for most of the heavy shipping.
   The steamers and some other vessels, however, use the west channel,
owing to the necessity for touching at Richmond, which is a thriving
town.
   In my preliminary report I referred to the obstruction by ledges of
rock at Lovejoy's Narrows, in the east channel of Swan Island.
   As a survey of this work had been made some years ago, I forwarded
in the same report a map of the narrows, and an estimate of the cost of
its improvement by removing the ledge to a depth of 18 feet and a
width of 175 feet.
   This is probably the most important improvement upon the river,
with the possible exception of Beef Rock Shoal, which is further down-
stream in the same channel.
   The estimate for removal of this ledge was made $100,100.
   Toward the south end of Swan Island the east channel becomes very
wide, and has a sandy bottom; a long bar is thus formed, with its upper
end protected by a ledge known as Beef Rock.
420     REPORT OF THE CHIEF         OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  No channel that can be made through this shoal will have any degree
of permanence until the current of the river has been concentrated
within similar bounds to those which maintain a sufficient depth at
other places.
  The removal of the ledge at Reef Rock would be expensive, and as a
good channel on either hand may be maintained by a dike or long wing-
dam from the east shore shortly above Beef Rock, and extending down-
stream parallel to a line joining the projecting points of the island, it is
considered best not to remove the rock, but to mark its location by a
beacon.
  At present the tow-boat company maintains three small lights along
the banks near this shoal; and a single light upon this beacon would
furnish a sufficient mark, and one which could be seen more than a mile
and a half above and nearly twice that distance below.
  The tracing sufficiently indicates the plan of improvement at this
place. It is probable that no dredging will be required.
   The design for a dike places its top 4 feet above mean low water and
gives it slopes of 45 degrees on each side. The top has a width of 15
feet where the old channel is crossed, and a width of 10 feet the remain-
ing distance.
   It may be also found necessary to construct a wing-dam across the
small bay on the island nearly opposite the middle of the dike, and a
second wing-dam opposite the lower end of the dike to direct the cur-
rent into the deep water below, so that the deep channel may be unin-
terrupted.
   To build the dike and wing-dams will require 80,000 tons of stone, at
an estimated contract price of $1 per ton in place.
   To protect the foundation in places where it is likely to be under-
mined by scouring, will require 8,000 cords of brush, at an estimated
cost of $3 per cord in place.
   The beacon upon Beef Rock must be strongly built to resist the pres-
sure of ice which will come upon it.
   It will require 152 cubic yards of good masonry, at estimated cost
of $10 per yard by contract.
   As before explained, it is not probable that any dredging will be re-
quired, and although a cut is indicated upon the map there is scarcely
a doubt that all needed depth will be obtained by the scour of the cur-
rent, so that no estimate for dredging is considered necessary.
   The west channel at Swan Island has but one obstruction which is
considered worthy of notice at present; this is known as Hatch's Rock
Shoal. The stream at this place is so wide that no channel of good
depth can be maintained without wing-dams and training-walls to re-
duce the width and secure a scouring effect by the current.
   The channel dredged some years ago was filled again in a short time,
and a repetition of the experiment is not advisable.
   Three wing-dams of stone and brush are recommended essentially as
indicated on the map. (Sheet No. 11.)
   These works will require 15,000 tons of stone and 1,200 cords of brush.
   I believe that the wing-dams will accomplish all that is necessary,
without any resort to dredging, but in any event the contraction works
are indispensable to maintain a channel.
   While there are other points between Augusta and the foot of Swan
(Perkin's) island, which might be improved, those here discussed in-
clude all that seem to demand any immediate attention.
  In the river at Bath are several ledges which are annoying, but with
one exception they do not seem to be in the way of general navigation
                 APPENDIl A-l1EPORT                              OF LIEUT. COL. SMITH.                                      4"1

of the river, and I do not even regard this one as of vital importance.
The ledge is locally known as Houghton's Rock. If removed at all, the
depth should be made at least 20 ifeet; otherwise it would be as likely
to do damage as it is at present.
   The shoal, above 20 feet depth, contains 343 cubic yards, about three
fourths of which is ledge.      It is estimated that its removal will cost $20
per cubic yard for the entire amount.
   The following is a condensed estimate of the improvements here pro-
posed, and the various )laces are arranged, with the exception of Bath,
in the order of their distance above the foot of Swan Island, and this
indicates in a general way the order in which I consider it advisable to
carry on the work :
Beef Rock Shoal: Stone and brush dike and wing-dams ..................                                $104, 000
Beef Rock Beacon ..---..--------------------------------------------                                     1, 520
Hatch's Rock Shoal: Three wing dams...._...........................--------------------------------..   18, 600
Lovejoy's Narrows: Removing 8,008 cubic yards ledge, at $12.50 ....                                ..  100, 100
Modification of jetty at head of Swan Island .......-----------                                                             3, 000
Upper sand-bar, wing-dam, and dike:
    51,000 tons of stone, at $1...-----------------------------------------51                         000
    3,350 cords of brush, at $3...----------------------------------------10,050
Removing bridge-piers at Hallowell...-------------------------------------                            875
Removing shoals from Gardiner to Augusta---------------------------............................... 77,350
For superintendence, surveys, and engineering, contingencies, add about 10
            ...--------------......
  per cent----------------------                         -----------------......                   36,505
       Total-------......------....---------....----....----......---......--                               403, 000
   Houghton's Rock being at Bath and separated from the other improvements, its re-
moval is estimated separately, viz:
343 cubic yards, at $20 .......................................................                             $6, 860
                                 ....-----......-......----......-----......---...--...-.......------......
Engineering contingencies--------                                                                               640
         Total-----......-------......-----....--...... ......                                                                 7,500
                                                                 .--.....-------......-----...--..------....-----....------....--....
   For a more detailed description of the survey and discussion of the
subject, I invite attention to the report of Mr. F. S. Burrowes.
    In   closing this report it seems proper to ask attention to the fact
that the amount of navigation on the river is very large, and the com-
merce is of a kind which makes the rate of freights a matter of interest
to a large section of country, especially along our Atlantic coast.
   Upon many other rivers in the country the importance of small and
inexpensive lights to mark bends or crossings in the channel has been
fully recognized, and the want has been supplied.
   A few such lights judiciously located upon the Kennebec River would
be of great advantage, and I recommend that the subject of such lights
be considered as an important factor in improving the navigation.
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                                     JARED A. SMITH,
                                                                                        Major of Engineers.
    The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                   S. A.



                      REPORT OF MR. F.                 S.   BURROWES, ASSISTANT ENGINEER.

                                                                 UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                                  Portland, Me., December 20, 1887.
   MAJOR: I have the honor to submit the following report upon a survey of the Ken-
nebec River, Maine, at Bath and from Augusta to the lower end of Perkin's (Swan)
Island, made under your direction in accordance with river and harbor act of August
5, 1886. As shown in your preliminary report, the Perkin's Island of the act is the
one locally known as Swan Island, and will be referred to by that name throughout
this report.
422       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The survey was commenced at Augusta, July 5, 1887, the party consisting of one as-
sistant engineer, one instrument-man, two recorders, one rodman, one leadsman, two
boatmen, and a cook. In order to expedite the work two small flat-boats with rough
cabins on them were hired, in which the party lived and which were dropped down
the river as the work progressed. The field work was completed at Bath, August 13,
and the party disbanded.
   As with the funds available it was not possible to make a continuous detailed sur-
vey of the river between the points named (a channel length of 27 miles), it was de-
termined to make close examinations at those points only where navigation was
known to be obstructed, and to entirely omit the parts in good navigable condition as
shown by the charts of previous surveys as well as by the testimony of those con-
stantly using the river. In accordance with this decision, the following general plan
was pursued:
   Between Augusta and Gardiner, a distance of 6¢ miles, there are six shoals, locally
known-beginning at Augusta-as Gage's, Britt's, Hallowell, Shepard's Point, Hink-
ley's, and Brown's Island shoals, the latter 1 miles above the bridge at Gardiner. A
continuous survey was made of the portion of the river including these shoals, as the
pools between them are short and as a definite knowledge of their depth would be
necessary in determining the depths to be made through the shoals. Four charts
made to a scale of 1: 2000 show this portion of the river, and a fifth to the same scale
shows the channel in the vicinity of the bridge at Gardiner.
   Between Gardiner and the foot of Swan Island in the main (that is eastern) channel
the localities surveyed and mapped are as follows: Green's Ledge, Chart No. 6, scale
1:1000; Upper Sand Bar at South Gardiner, Chart No. 7. scale 1 : 2000; rock at Ber-
ry's ice-houses, Chart No. 8, scale 1 : 1000; and Beef Rock Shoal, in eastern channel
of Swan Island, Chart No. 9, scale 1 : 2000. These are the only points in this portion
of the main channel at which improvements could be made with signal benefit to
navigation, except Lovejoy's Narrows, also in eastern channel at Swan Island, where
some work has already been done, and of which sufficiently detailed surveys have
been made on which to base estimates for further improvement.
  In the western channel at Swan Island surveys were made of breakwater and shoal
at head of Swan Island. Chart No. 10, scale 1 : 2000 of Hatch's Rock Shoal; Chart
No. 11, scale 1: 3000, and of shoal at foot of Swan Island, Chart No. 12, scale 1: 2000.
  At Bath surveys were made of three ledges near the wharves and mapped on one
chart, No. 13, scale 1: 1000.

                             MANNER OF MAKING SURVEY.

  The same question of economy influenced largely the methods of making the survey
adopted, so that as much time as passible could be given to the location and deter-
mination of the soundings.
  On the continuous portions of the survey a measured azimuth line was run down
the river and points on opposite shore located by triangulation, buildings, wharves,
points on high-water line, and other topographical features being located by stadia
measurement.
  On the shorter shoals a system of triangles was used, the topography being filled in
with the stadia. Wherever practicable the stations were marked by drill-holes in the
ledge, or established with reference to prominent landmarks, such as corners of
wharves, buildings, etc. No attempt was made to make a close topographical survey
of the banks above high-water line.

                                      SOUNDINGS.

  All soundings were located by intersection, either with two instruments, or on one
instrument and an established range. The depths were measured either with a sound-
ing lead and graduated brass chain or with a graduated rod, the latter being used
for depths less than 20 feet.
                                          TIDES.

    As it was not feasible during the survey to make a continuous series of observa-
tions at one point for the determination of the rise and fall of tides, the planes of ref-
erence of mean high water, mean low water, and lowest water were taken from
charts and bench-marks of previous surveys. The mean oscillation of tides from
these data is about 5 feet throughout the whole length of the river from Augusta to
'foot of Swan Island. The tide-gauges on which observations were made for reduction
of soundings were connected with each other by simultaneous observations at slack-
water. A bench-mark was established for each gauge, the locations and elevations
being indicated on the charts, and, wherever possible, were connected with bench-
marks of previous surveys.
            APPENDIX       A-'-IREPORT OF LItEUT. COL. SMITH.                     423
                               AUGUSTA TO GARDINER.

   All the shoals in this reach of river, that is Gage's, Britt's, Hallowell, Shepard's
Point, Hinkley's, and Brown's Island, with the exception of the last named, have been
improved by the General Government, the improvements consisting in dredged chan-
nels 100 feet in width and 6j feet in depth on the first two, and 7 feet in depth on the
last three shoals. The plane of reference used was the lowest water observed in the
summer of 1867. For convenience of comparison the same plane of reference for
soundings was adopted in this portion of the present survey, connection being made
by means of the bench-mark at the lower tide-gauge at Hallowell, as it was the only
one which remained undisturbed or could be definitely located. This plane, being
that of an exceedingly low run of summer tides, is at least 2 feet below usual low
tides, so that any improvement made with it as a datum would ordinarily yield 2
feet more depth than that indicated.
   Gage's Shoal begins 1,200 feet below the bridge at Augusta, is 2,800 feet long be-
tween the 8-foot curves, and has a least depth of 5j feet. Through a large part of
the dredged channel, however, the depth of 64 feet has remained and the partial
shoaling may have been caused by the freshet, which carried away the dam at Au-
gusta, bringing with it much silt and heavy d6bris, which it was unable to carry far.
The material of which it is composed is coarse gravel and large bowlders.
   Britt's Shoal ends a short distance above the old bridge site at Hallowell; it is
3,700 feet in length between 8-foot curves, and has a least available depth of 4.7 feet.
Throughout most of its length, however, the dredged channel has maintained its depth
of 6 feet. The material of which it is composed is coarse gravel and sand. At both
Gage's and Britt's shoals several large bowlders close to the edge of the channel add
hazard to navigation. The depth to be obtained by improvement should be the
same for both shoals, as they are close together and there is no shipping point be-
tween them.
   At Hallowell the piers of the bridge carried away by a freshet remain standing and
obstruct navigation to some extent; the piers which caught the ends of the draw
being especially hazardous, as their tops are nearly in the plane of low water.
   Hallowell and Shepard's Point shoals are practically continuous, and beginning just
below the wharves at Hallowell have a combined length of 4,700 feet between 10 feet
curves. The dredged channels have maintained their depths of 7 feet, but have been
somewhat narrowed.
   Both of these shoals are in excessively wide portions of the river. The cuts were
made in nearly straight lines through the fiats, the crooked natural channels which
followed the shores being abandoned.      The material appears to be mostly sand, with
some gravel.
   Hinkley's Shoal, 21 miles above Gardiner, is also in a wide part of the river. Its
length, between 10-foot curves,is 2,200 feet, and least depth 6.5 feet. The material of
which it is composed is sand, coarse gravel, and possibly some ledge.
   Brown's Island Shoal is at the head of and opposite Brown's Island, which here
divides a very wide part of the river, the western part being shallow and the eastern
and navigable channel being narrow and crooked, withaleast depth of 6.5 feet. The
material of which this shoal is composed is apparently sand and loose gravel.
   About midway between Brown's Island and Hinkley's shoals the channel, although
maintaining a depth of 10 feet, becomes very narrow, and should be widened in order
to make this depth available for navigation.
   Between Brown's Island and Gardiner there is a least depth of 10 feet, and this ap-
pears to be the limit which could be obtained above that point without excessive
cost. This depth could be made through Brown's Island and Hinkley's shoals, and
perhaps through Shepard's Point and Hallowell shoals. Above Hallowell a depth
of 8 feet would be sufficient for present navigation, and is perhaps all that could be
obtained without outlay disproportionate to the benefits derived therefrom.
    Immediately above the bridge at Gardiner the water has shoaled in front of the
wharves, the cause being presumably the checking and deflection of the current by
the piers of the bridge. Below the bridge, and just off the lower end of the Boston
steamer wharf, is a shoal composed of logs and sawdust, with bowlders on top, which
are only 6 feet below low water. It is known as the Steam-boat Shoal, and is in such
a position as to be a source of danger to boats loading at the wharf. One-half mile
below the bridge at Gardiner the river widens and the channel becomes shoal and
crooked. It maintains, however, a least depth of 11 feet at lowest water.

                             GARDINER TO     SWAN ISLAND.


   The portion of the river from Gardiner to the head of Swan, a distance of 10 miles,
is remarkably free from serious obstructions and has throughout almost its entire
length an available channel depth of 13 or 14 feet at mean low water. Along this
424      REPORT      OF THE     .CHIEF     OF ENGINEERS, 11.          S. ARMY.

part of the river are most of the large ice-houses, the shipments from which consti-
tute the great bulk of the commerce of the river. The obstructions, of which sur-
veys were made, are Green's Ledge, Upper Sand-bar, and rock at Berry's Ice-house.
   Green's Ledge, 2J miles below Gardiner, is a ledge of rock nearly in mid-river It is
about 150 feet long and 50 feet wide, and has a least depth on it at mean low water of
3 feet. To the west of it there is a channel 175 feet wide and 14 feet deep. As the
river here is nearly straight, the ledge, if well buoyed, would not greatly interfere
with navigation. Its removal so as to widen the channel would, however, be a benefit.
   The Upper Sand-bar is opposite the lower end of South Gardiner, and just below
Nehuminkeg Island. It is a sand-shoal, which reaches entirely across an excessively
wide section of the river. A channel 100 feet wide and 10 feet deep at low water was
dredged through the bar in 1871. This channel has been partly filled in by the shift-
ing sand, and it would seem that in order to maintain a channel some auxiliary works
would have to be constructed to reduce the width of the cross-section. The present
length of the shoal, between 14-foot curves, is 2, 500 feet, and there is a least available
depth through the old cut of 9J feet at mean low water.
  Berry's Bock is a ledge in front of Berry's Ice-houses and about 1 miles above Ice-
boro. It is about 90 feet long and 60 feet wide, and has a least depth on it of 5 feet
at mean low water. It is nearly in mid-river, but there is a clear channel to the east-
ward of it 200 feet wide and 16 feet deep at mean low water. If well buoyed it is
not a serious obstacle to navigation, but, as in the case of Green's Ledge, its removal
would allow of the handling of large tows with greater safety.

                               SWAN ISLAND CHANNELS.

   Swan Island divides the river into two channels for a distance of 5 miles, beginning
about a mile above the landing at Richmond. The easterly channel has the greater
depth of water through it, and is consequently always used by the deep-draught ves-
sels. It is obstructed at only two points, Lovejoy's Narrows and Beef Rock Shoal.
The former, as previously stated, has been improved by the removal of rocks from the
channel, and an estimate submitted for its further improvement The plane of ref-
erence for the soundings used in present surveys of the Swan Island channels is mean
low water, as established by the United States Coast and Geodetic Survey, and is same
as the one used for the various improvements made in the vicinity.
  At Beef Bock Shoal the river is very wide, and is divided at low water by a middle
bar into two channels, in each of which there are shoals having a depth of only 10
feet at mean low water. The formation of this bar is caused by the ledge at its head
known as Beef Rock, and which projects 4.5 feet above mean low water. The concen-
tration of the water in one channel would doubtless cause scouring action sufficient
to yield a good navigable depth through the shoal; it would at least be a necessary
part of a plan to maintain a channel however obtained. The easterly channel is the
one at present most used, the shoal being shorter, and it would seem to be the most
available for improvement, as the material of which it is composed appears to be all
sand, and there would be less likelihood of encountering ledge than in the westerly
channel, which follows close along the rocky shore of Swan Island. The depth to be
obtained at this shoal should be at least as great as the draught of the largest vessels
navigating the river, as tows start from points above at high tide, and reaching this
point at or near low water are often delayed until the next high water. The draught
of vessels at present using the river seldom exceeds 15 feet.
   Swan Island, western channel.-The western channel is used almost exclusively by
the steamers plying between points up the river and Boston, Portland, and the mouth
of the river, being compelled to take this route in order to land at the town of Rich-
mond, about a mile below the head of the island. The greatest draught of any of
these boats is 9J feet, and as for a distance of 21 miles the available depth of the
channel is barely 10 feet, it would be useless to attempt to obtain a greater depth than
that through the shoals.
   At Head of Swan Island a breakwater has been constructed, extending from the head
of the island 550 feet up-stream, with the evident intention of diverting a greater
proportion of the water down the west channel. At the same time a channel was
dredged through the shoal opposite the breakwater to a depth of 10 feet at mean low
water. This channel has shoaled somewhat, but there remains now an available
depth of 9 feet over the shoal. It is doubtful if the breakwater has been efficacious
either in scouring or maintaining the channel. It is claimed by some of the parties
engaged in the ice traffic that it causes the ice to break up and jam, and prevents the
formation of smooth ice-fields suitable for cutting in its vicinity.
   Hatch's Rock Shoal, 1 mile below Richmond, is a sand-bar in a wide part of the
river, through which a channel was at one time dredged to a depth of 10 feet at mean
low water. There is a barely perceptible trace of this channel now to be found, the
depths through it varying from 7.5 to 8 feet.
            APPENDIX      A-REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. SMITH.                         425
  In order to maintain at channel here it would seem to be necessary to reduce the
river to a width normal for the depth required. The present length of the shoal be-
tween 10-feet curves is 2,000 feet.
  At shoal at foot of Swan Island a channel was also dredged to a depth of 11 feet at
mean low water, and has shoaled but slightly since.
  Bath.-At Bath three rocks lying close to the wharves were sounded. The lower
one is 50 feet off the Steam Mill Wharf, and is about in the middle of the small chan-
nel between this wharf and the large ledge known as Steam Mill Rock. Its top is
only 2.5 feet below mean low water and is in the way of vessels being dropped against
this wharf.
  The second rock is 185 feet off Haughton's Wharf, its top being 13 feet below mean
low water and 7 or 8 feet above the general level of the surrounding bottom. One or
two heavily laden vessels have been known to hang on the rock for a short time at
low tide. It is the only one of the three rocks surveyed which could be regarded as
at all interfering with the free navigation of the river.
  The third is close into the railroad wharf, its top being 12.5 feet below mean low
water. It is small and unimportant, and entirely out of the way of navigation.

                                         RESUME.

  The foregoing detailed descriptions are held to include all the points at which im-
provements could be made with reasonable economy and without altering the regi-
men of the river.
   First in order of importance to the principal commerce of the river, that is, the
deep-draught vessels carrying ice, is the improvement of the Beef Rock Shoal, which
would prevent the delay of twelve hours to the large tows. The upper sand-bar is
also a fruitful source of annoyance and delay, as the channel being narrow as well as
shoal large tows can not be taken through it unbroken.
   The improvement of Brown's Island and Hinckley's Shoals would carry the channel
to the present head of the heaviest ice traffic. Further up lighter vessels are, of
necessity, used for bringing ice, stone, and lumber from points above.
   The principal immediate advantage of the improvement of this upper portion of
the river would be the prevention of vexations and costly delays to the steam-boats,
and as they are also compelled to navigate the western channel at Swan Island the
improvement of Hatche's Rock Shoal is of vital importance to them.
   The removal of Green's Ledge and Berry's Rock would be a benefit to navigation,
but is of less importance than the improvements at the other points named.
   I was unable to obtain any statistics of importance touching the commerce of the
river other than those given in your preliminary report, which, however, show con-
clusively the importance of the river as an artery of trade and the necessity for its
improvement.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                             F.   S. BURROWES,
                                                                  Assistant Engineer.
  Maj. JARED A. SMITH,
          Corps of Engineers, U. S. A.




                                          A   20.

PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION OF PENOBSCOT RIVER, MAINE, FROM BAN-
                SGOR TO BUCKSPORT NARROWS.

                                UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                        Portland,Me., January 11, 1887.
  GENERAL : I have the honor to submit the following report of a pre-
liminary examination of the Penobscot River, Maine, from Bangor to
Bucksport Narrows, in accordance with instructions from the Chief of
Engineers dated September 27, and October 28, 1886.
  On the 14th and 15th of )ecember, 1886, I visited Bangor and Bucks-
port, and also went in a tug over the portion of the river where im-
provements seem to be required.
426     REPORT OF      ITHE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   From the facts gathered by observation and inquiry, it is my opinion
that the portion of the river indicated is well worthy of improvement
by the General Government.
   This opinion is based upon the following points:
   The head of navigation of the river at Bangor is, by the ch'annel, 19J
miles above the " Narrows" at Bucksport, 27 miles above the mouth of
the river at Fort Point Ledge, on Penobscot Bay, and 62 miles above
the headlands of the coast.
   Navigation at Bangor includes regular lines of steamers and many
sailing vessels, affording communication with the interior of the State,
and intersecting the lines of railroads which reach across the State into
the provinces of New Brunswick and Nova Scotia.
   During about three months in the winter at Bangor, and over a dis-
tance of several miles below, the river is closed by ice, so that the steam-
ers and sail vessels make their landings at Winterport, about 14 miles
below Bangor.
   From April to December, 1886, inclusive, 1,798 sailing vessels were
taken up the river to the wharves at Bangor and returned; the average
tonnage of these vessels is estimated as not less than 300 tons each.
Most of them carry freights. in both directions, though the outward
freights are much the larger. In addition to the above there are about
300 vessels of less than 50 tons each, of which no regular reports are
made by the harbor-master.
   During the year, and especially from December to March, inclusive, a
large number of vessels receive and discharge cargoes at Winterport;
the number of these amount to several hundred in all, but I have not
been able to obtain the exact figures.
   At Bucksport, above the "Narrows," there were 150 arrivals and 137
departures during the year 1886.
   Sixty-three vessels are owned in Bucksport alone.
   The Boston and Bangor Steamship Company ran a steamer six times
per week during the summer season, and four times per week during
the remainder of the year.
   The Bangor and Bar Harbor Steam-boat Company run a steamer
twice weekly during the summer and early autumn months.
   The regular steamers, added to the tugs employed upon the river,
make a large total for the amount of navigation and the value of inter-
ests involved.
   The obstructions to navigation are all included between Bangor and
Bucksport Narrows. They are not numerous nor of a character difficult
to remedy; they consist almost entirely of bars in the wide part of the
river between Bucksport and Winterport, though it is probable that
some minor points above may require attention.
   A project for improvement of the river from Bangor to Crosby's Nar-
rows is still incomplete. Surveys above that point have been already
made.
   Many of the vessels plying on the river to Bangor draw from 15 to
18 feet of water, and in one instance.a vessel drawing 22 feet and 7
inches was towed down the river at high water. The greatest depth
over the bar below Winterport is not more than 11 feet at mean low
water. This causes great detention and some danger to vessels in tow
of a tug.
   As the Coast Survey charts are not in sufficient detail for the purpose
required, I recommend that a survey of the river be made from Crosby's
Narrows to the narrows at Bucksport, a distance of 16 miles. For the
part above Winterport soundings may be made at wide intervals; be-
               APPENDIX             A--REPORT                O'      LIEUT.        COL.       SMITH.              427

low that place, a distance of 5 miles, the survey should be made care-
fully in detail. The expense of such a survey is estimated as follows:
Field work of surveying party in charge or assistant engineer, fifty days, at
  $20..-----------.-   ---..-..  . . --...----------- --          -----       _....
                                                                                 $1,000
Incidental expenses of transportation, hireof boats, purchase of hunber, nails,
  etc ......-.----------------------------------------------------------        200
Salary of assistant engineer and for office expenses, platting maps, and con-
  pleting a project for necessary improvements...------------------------------300

      Total........-----------------....---.......-----..--...---...--..-----------........--......----........   1,500
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                                JARED A.             SMITIIh,
                                                                                       Major of Engineers.
  Brig. Gen. JAMES C. DUANE,
          Chief of Engineers, U. S. A.



SURVEY OF PENOBSCOT RIVER, MAINE, FROM BANGOR TO BUCKSPORT
                         NARROWS.

                                             UNITED STATES ENGINEER                                OFFICE,
                                       Portland, Me., January 11, 1888.
   SIR: In compliance with instructions from the Chief of Engineers,
dated March 16, 1887, I have the honor to submit the following report
of a survey upon the Penobscot River, Maine, between Bangor and
Bucksport Narrows, and to include in the report an estimate of the cost
of works of improvement.
   The amount of funds allotted for this survey was very small, so that
it was impracticable to make a general survey between the limits indi
cared, and I was compelled to limit the work to the portion included
between Winterport and Bucksport.
   The surveys, projects, and estimates hitherto made and laid before
Congress cover the part from Bangor to Crosby's Narrows, and below
the latter point there is no obstruction worthy of present consideration
save in the portion which has been included in this survey.
   Below Winterport the river makes a bend, so that the direction of the
current is changed to about a right angle from its former course.
   At this place the river becomes nearly three times as wide as it will
average at points above, and it is fully twice as wide as at any place in
the river where a good channel is maintained by natural conditions.
   The place is known as Frankfort Flats. Being in a bend, the great
width is less prejudicial than it would be in a straight reach, because
the strongest current follows the outer part of the bend, and is thus
more rapid than if it were uniformly diffused.
   Opposite the middle of the flats is a tidal arm and tributary of the
Penobscot known as Marsh River. The ebb tide from this river sets
out very strongly, and assists in producing effects in the current below
its mouth, which cause great irregularity in the channel.
   These irregularities are continued some distance below the flats to a
point known as High Head.
   Owing to the limitations in the survey I found it impracticable to ob-
tain a competent and reliable man to do the work, and was, therefore,
under the necessity of assigning it to Mr. A. C. Both, assistant engi-
neer, whose duties upon other works of importance made it impossible
to give his time until nearly the 1st of October.
428       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OP ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   I was compelled to close the field work on the 1st of November from
lack of funds, though the current observations were incomplete and no
borings had been made.
   The map has been made in the office by Mr. Both, and the studies for
the improvement have been made by him and myself in mutual discus-
sion and consultation. The resulting plans and estimates of cost are
discussed in Mr. Both's report, which I inclose as part of my own, and
to which I invite attention.
   A tracing of the map covering the survey and plan of improvement
is forwarded in a separate package.
   It is very apparent to me that a good channel can not be made per-
manent at this place without constructing works to concentrate the flow
of water within bounds similar in extent to those where a good channel
is found in other places.
   Having constructed the jetties which are indicated, with any changes
or modifications which may be found advisable, it is probable that the
amount of dredging for which an estimate is submitted will be greatly
reduced, if not eliminated entirely, by the increased scour of the river.
   This effect depends upon the character of the bottom, which I have
not been able to examine with sufficient care to predict the effect of in-
creased current velocity with any certainty.    Should it accomplish what
is hoped and what seems probable, the total estimate of $365,000 will
be decreased by more than $1 00,000.
   For a further discussion of the subject, I refer to my preliminary re-
port and to the very complete report of Mr. Both.
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                 JAR ED A. SlMITH,
                                                     Major of Engineers.
   The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. A.



                 REPORT OF    IR.   A.   C.   BOTH,   ASSISTANT ENGINEER.


                                                UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                                        Portland, Me., January 3, 1888.
   MAJOR: I have the honor to submit the following report upon a survey of the Pe-
nobscot River, Maine, between Bangor and Bucksport, required by river and harbor
act of August 5, 1886.
   In compliance with your orders I proceeded to Winterport, Me., on September 27,
1887, and commenced the survey the following day.
   The depth now available in this part of the river for safe navigation is about 16
feet at mean low water. By using great care single vessels drawing 18 feet may be
taken through this channel. Nearly all the vessels bound for or sailing from Bangor
avail themselves of the fine tow-boat service maintained between Bangor and the
mouth of the river (Fort Point), 25 miles below, and as most of the tows consist of from
six to twelve and more vessels, the tortuous courses which are necessary to be followed
by deep-laden vessels can not be made with that accuracy required for their safe pas-
sage over the existing bars. All the tows bound up-river start at its mouth (Fort
Point) at or before low water, passing through the channels between Bucksport and
Winterport at the low stages of the tide, in order to arrive at Bangor at time of high
water. On the other hand, all tows leaving Bangor start at high water, and pass the
channel between Winterport and Bucksport at time of low water. The improve-
ments made and contemplated in Bangor Harbor provide for a depth of about 14 feet
at average low-water stage of the river (or 11 feet at extreme low water).
   The mean rise and fall of the tide here being 131 feet (from United States Coast
Survey records), the high-water depth would be about 27 feet. The draught of the
largest class of vessels loading at Bangor for foreign ports is from 20 to 22 feet, and
it is, therefore, desired to obtain a low-water depth for the channel between Winter-
port and Bucksport, of not less than 22 feet, or, if possible, 24 feet, so that these ves-
sels arriving here at time of low water may be able to pass with safety and without
delay.
             APPENDIX       A-REPORT         OF LIEUT.      COL.    SMITH.          429
                          TRIANGULATION     AND TOPOGRAPHY.


   The straight and level stretch of the east shore of the river, about a mile below the
steam-boat wharf at Winterport, was selected for measuring a "base-line."              The
distance between the north and south base, carefully measured with a steel tape, is
3,727.05 feet. The northerly end of this line is marked by a hole, five-eighths inch
in diameter, drilled into an embedded granite bowlder located at the high-water
mark. The southerly end is marked by a similar° hole drilled into the flat top of a
solid ledge. The direction of this line is about 29 30' west of the magnetic meridian.
   All the triangulation stations are marked by holes drilled into either large bowl-
ders, not likely to be disturbed by ice or freshets, or into solid ledge, and in such
places where neither a bowlder nor ledge was available, suitable rocks were selected
and set into the ground level with its surface.
   For signals over these numerous stations new broom-handles were used with good
advantage; they are quickly fitted and driven into these holes, easily removed and
replaced before and after occupation of stations by the instrument, are always avail-
able for obsers ation, and will stand plumb in any weather or wind without bracing,
and thus save a great deal of valuable time. Small red and white cotton flags, 10
inches square, single and in pairs, are nailed to these sticks for ready identification.
   The prom lent features of the shore-lines between the triangulation stations were
determined by telemetric measurements. The triangulation stations on the west side
of the river are marked I, II, III1 to XXII, and those on the east shore A, B, C, to W.
The survey of Bucksport Harbor, made by me in May, 1875, was connected trigono-
metrically with this survey, and has been reduced and copied on the accompanying
platn.
                                       SOUNDINGS.

  All the soundings shown on this plan were taken on ranges established for that
purpose, and were located by intersection angles taken with transit instrument from
suitable stations on shore. For each sounding the boat from which they were made
was brought to a stand-still to insure plumb soundings. At times when the tidal cur-
rents were too strong to obtain plumb soundings in this way, the boat was pulled
above the ranges and then dropped down, the leadsman being in readiness to catch a
plumb reading on crossing the range. A brass chain and 10-pound lead were used for
taking soundings.
                               TIDE AND BENCH-MARKS.

   Tide-gauges were established at Colby's Wharf in Bucksport, and at Boston and
Bangor Steamer's Wharf in Winterport. The gauge at Bucksport was nailed to the
outer face of Colby's Wharf and referred to a bench-mark at Fort Knox Wharf, estab-
lished by me while making a survey of Bucksport Harbor in 1875. The reference of
this bench-mark is 13.3 feet above mean low water. It was obtained from a tide-gauge
which I found at Colby's Wharf, and which had been used the year previous (1874)
by the United States Coast Survey. The record of that office gives the following
data:
                                                                                 Feet.
Mean rise and fall of tides-. .  -..-.................                           10. 3
Highest observed high water above plane of mean low water.................. 12. 1
Lowest observed low water below plane of mean low water................... 2.7
  The reference for the gauge at the Boston and Bangor Steamune Wharf in Winter-
port was obtained by a careful transfer of the reading at the Bucksport gauge at
high-water slack, which occurs very nearly at the same time at both places. The
reference of the Winterport gauge was transferred by level to a large, partly embedded
granite bowlder, the highest point of which is 15.75 feet above the zero of that gauge.
The location of this bowlder is given on the map.

                               CURRENT    OBSERVATIONS.


   A few observations only could be made to determine the directions and velocities
of the ebb currents. One set was made October 31 in the wide portion of river below
Winterport and one set on November 1 above High Head. The result of these ob-
servations are shown on the map and give the exact course taken by the float, and the
velocities in statute miles per hour. The float used was made of dry pine, 4 inches
diameter and 12 feet long, weighted at one end with iron, so that the other end would
protrude a few inches only above the surface of the water. This end carried a small
flag on a wire rod. At intervals of one minute angles were taken simultaneously by
two observers on shore to a signal held vertically above the float by one of the men fol-
lowing the float in a boat. The locations of the float and the velocities of the current
430      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

(between these locations), however, are given on the map for intervals of five minutes.
The rise of the tide on October 31 was 11.2 feet, and on November 1 it was 11.3 feet,
occurring at 9h. 55m. and 10h. 35m. a. min.,respectively, and may be considered aver-
age high waters. I would here state, however, that the currents at the high runs of
the tides have considerable higher velocities, and that during the time of the yearly
spring freshets the velocities are certainly twice as high as those shown on the map.
  As far as is known extensive changes of the river bottom take place mostly during
freshets. Should it be decided to improve the channel in these parts of the river by
contraction works, which seems to be the only sure method to procure permanency to
any contemplated improvement, the currents of these freshets will aid materially in
removing, by scour, the shoals now obstructing navigation, while the velocities of
the current at other times will be ample to prevent the lodgment of any sediment,
especially the sawdust which the waters of this river carry.

                                        BORINGS.

  In order to investigate the nature of the shoals at the different places, it was the
intention to make careful borings. The apparatus being in readiness for commenc-
ing these borings on November 2, on the evening of November 1 1 received from you
a telegram ordering me to suspend all operations for want of necessary funds.
  I therefore at once discharged the party, and returned to this office the following
day.
  From observations made during the survey I feel inclined to believe that these
shoals consist mostly of slabs, edgings, and sawdust deposited here by favorable eddies
and accumulated during many years.
  I would recommend, however, that before actual work is commenced a thorough
examination of these shoals be made to determine without doubt if a continuous
channel of 22 or 24 feet depth can be obtained by the scouring action produced by
contraction works alone, or if it will be found necessary to dredge a certain portion
of the proposed channels and thereby hasten the availability of these channels for
navigation.
  Since returning to the office the survey has been plotted to a scale of 1 :5000, and a
copy of samle is herewith submitted. The frequent interruptions caused by other
duties which I had to attend to have delayed an earlier completion of the map and
report.
                  PROJECTED IMPROVEMENTS AND ESTIMATED COST.

  Since completing the map, works for improving the channel have been projected
in frequent consultation with yourself. They consist mainly of a system of jetties
and some dredging, should it be found necessary. The work which the jetties are
intended to perform is twofold and closely dependent upon each other.
  First. A contraction of the cross-section of the river at the different places to such
an extent that the currents resulting therefrom shall tend to scour the material and
carry the same to deep water to procure a continuous channel of at least 800 feet
width and 22 feet depth through these shoals.
  Second. To direct the currentsin such a manner that the resulting channel shall pre-
sent easy curves; whether obtained by scouring or dredging, or both combined, the
channels once obtained will be permanently preserved by the current as then directed.
  Should future examination of the shoals reveal the fact that dredging has to be
resorted to in order to assist the scouring action it is proposed to cut a width of 400
feet and a depth of 22 feet at mean low water and to leave the remaining shoal ground
to be scoured by the currents.
  In view of the scarcity of brush in the vicinity of the work, and the very close
proximity of granite quarries, it is proposed to build the jetties of granite grout, which
can be had in large quantities and at reasonable cost.
   The design of the jetties gives the tops an elevation of 6 feet above mean low water,
so as not to obstruct the river too much at times of heavy freshets and ice, which
would endanger the stability of these jetties, unless built very massive.
   In view of the fact also that the strongest currents of the ebb tide fall between the
time of half-tide and low water, the height ofjetties is believed to be ample.
  The jetties are proposed to be 10 feet wide on top, with slopes of 1 on 1, constructed
by systematicallydumping the stone in place and above the level of low water, laying
it carefully, the top to be finished with heavy split stone of about 2 feet rise and
10 feet length.
  The ends of the jetties should be protected by strong headings to resist the cur-
rents and ice and to form the base for beacons to indicate the channel. These head-
ings or piers are planned as frustrutus of pyramids, the tops at high-water level and
the slopes being 1 on 14.
                   APPENDIX                    A-REPORT                                 OF LIEUT.                  COL. SMITH.                      431
  Surmounting these are stone beacons 12+ feet high. They are proposed to be built
of split dimension stone, set in cement mortar, in five courses of 21 feet rise each,
lower course 12 feet square and upper course (top 224 feet above mean low water) 8
feet square.
                                                                       Estinmated cost.


                                                            Quantity                                Quantity     Total
                   located at-
                 Jetties                         Length in of stone in                             of stone in quantity of Priceper               Cost
                  located
                  Jetties  at-                     feet.    jetty, in                              heading, in stone, in      ton.                Cost.
                                                               tons.                                  tons.       tons.


                                                                                                                                      Cents.
A...............................  .....       920                                 51,753                  5,700      57,453                75   $43,089.75
B ...............................       ..    980                                 34, 914                 5, 700     40, 614               75    30, 460. 50
C ............................             2, 650                                 91, 719                 5, 700     97, 419               75    73, 064. 25
D...............................           1, 530                                 38, 755                 5, 700     44, 455               75    33, 341.25
E ..............................           1, 850                                 24, 128                 1, 690     25, 818               75    19, 363. 50
                                                                                                                    265, 759               75   199, 319. 25

Five beacons, each containing 47 cubic yards of split dimension stone, set in fine cement
concrete, 235 cubic yards, at $12.75 per cubic yard.......................................                                                       2, 996.25

       Total cost of jetties            ......................                        ......          .........      ..............             202, 315.50
Dredging channel near Jetty C, 400 feet wide, 22 feet deep at mean low water,
will require the removal of 263,482 cubic yards, measured in situ, at 25 cents
per cubic yard...................             ......................................... $65, 870. 50
Dredging-channel between Jetties A and B, 400 feet wide, 22 feet deep at mean
low water, will require the removal of 238,480 cubic yards, measured in situ,
at 25 cents per cubic yard...................................................59,             620.00

      Total cost for dredging ...........................................                                                     .............     125, 490. 50
     Total cost forjetties and dredging ...............................................                                                         327, 806.00
Add for contingencies and engineering expenses ..................................                                                                37, 194. 00
      Grand total cost                  .......................................................-                                                365, 000. CO



        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                                                                       A. C. BOTH,
                                                                                                                              Assistant Engineer.
  Maj. JARED A. SMITH,
            Corps of Engineers, U. S. A.
                                 APPENDIX B.



     IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN MASSACHUSETTS.




REPORT OF LIEUTENANT-COLONEL GEORGE L. GILLESPIE, CORPS OF
ENGINEERS, OFFICER IN   CHARGE, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING
JUNE 30, 1888, WITH OTHER DOCUMENTS RELATING TO THE WORKS.

                                 IMPROVEMENTS.

1. Newburyport Harbor, Massachusetts.          7. Boston Harbor, Massachusetts.
2. Merrimac River, Massachusetts.              8. Malden River, Massachusetts.
3. Ipswich River, Massachusetts.            9. Hingharm Harbor, Massachusetts.
4. Harbor of Refuge, Sandy Bay, Cape       10. Scituate Harbor, Massachusetts.
     Ann, Massachusetts.                   11. Plymouth HIarbor, Massachusetts.
5. Gloucester Harbor, Massachusetts.       12. Provincetown Harbor, Massachusetts.
6. Lynn Harbor, Massachusetts.

                       EXAtMINATIONS       AND SURVEYS.

13.' Manchester Harbor, Massachusetts.     15. Duxbary Harbor, Massachusetts.
14. Winthrop Harbor, Massachusetts.        16. Wellfleet Harbor, Massachusetts.



                             UNITED      STATES ENGINEER'S          OFFICE,
                                        Boston, M1ass., July 10, 1888.
  GENERAL: I have the honor to transmit herewith annual reports of.
the works of river and harbor improvement in my charge for the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1888.
      Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                           G.   L. GILLESPIE,
                                                        Lieut. Col. of Engineers.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. A.



                                         Bi.

   IMPROVEMENT OF HARBOR AT NEWBURYPORT, MASSACHUSETTS.

   Newburyport is situated on the south bank, 24 miles approximately
from the mouth of the Merrimac River. The river empties into the
Atlantic Ocean midway between Cape Ann and Portsmouth, or about
30 miles a little east of north from Boston in a direct line.
   The outlet of the river between Plum Island and Salisbury Point is
1,000 feet wide and 30 feet deep at mean low water. At a distance of
nearly a mile outside lies a sandy bar thrown up by wave-action, through
                                                                            433
       ENG 88--28
434     REPORT. OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

which, previous to the improvement, a channel variable in position,
direction, and depth was maintained by the current of the river, increased
by the tidal prism in a large interior basin due to a range of tides equal-
ing 7.7 feet. For 1,000 feet outward from the gorge towards the crest of
the bar the current was able to maintain a channel of navigable width
and 18 feet deep at mean low water, and for a further distance of 1,500
feet a channel 12 feet deep. From the 18-foot contour on the inside to
the same on the outside the distance was 4,000 feet, and between the 12-
foot contours the distance was 3,000 feet. The depth on the crest of the
bar was generally less than 7 feet at mean low water.
   The object of the improvement is to create through the outer bar a
channel 1,000 feet wide and at least 17 feet deep at mean low water,
so that vessels may cross the bar and find a harbor at any stage of the
tide, with as great draught as can reach Newburyport by the river at
high tide.
   The p)roject submitted September 16, 1880, proposed two converging
rubble-stone jetties, their outer ends parallel for 1,000 feet, and about
the same distance apart; and the protection of the beach in their vi-
cinity.
   This was modified in 1882 so as to provide for the partial closing of
Plum Island Basin with a timber dike about 800 feet long and 51 feet
above mean low water.
   The direction of the south jetty, and the character of the shore pro-
jection were modified in 1883. The north jetty from Salisbury Beach is
to be 4,000 feet long approximately, and the south jetty from Plum Isl-
and is to be 2,400 feet long approximately. Both are 15 feet wide on
top, which is in a plane 12 feet above mean low water. The two jetties
have slopes of 1 on 2 on the sea side, and of 1 on 1 on the harbor side.
   A map showing the location of the jetties is published in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1885. Their form and dimensions
are shown in the Report for 1881. The location and details of construc-
tion of the dike are given in the Report for 1883. The estimated cost
of the improvement was $375,000.
   The total appropriations for this work to date have been $207,500.
The amount expended to June 30, 1888, was $207,498.27.
    During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, 3,443 tons of rubble-
stone were deposited in the north jetty, under the contract of October
25, 1886, with Mr. Charles II. Edwards, at a cost of $2.23 per ton of
2,000 plounds. This contract was for 15,000 tons, more or less, and
und(ler it a total of 14,991 tons was deposited, thereby extending the
full section of that jetty 390 feet. The contract was satisfactorily com-
pleted October 20, 1887.
   A survey of the bar was made in August, 1887. The result indicated
no material change of channel-depths on the bar; there was assuredly
no deterioration, but rather a tendency to improvement.
   The channel had straightened and moved southward slightly.
   A survey was made in June, 1888. It showed a very decided advance
in the condition of the improvement. The 12-foot channel had extended
seaward 600 feet since the survey of 1887, and between the 12-foot con-
tour inside and outside, embracing the bar, the distance had been re-
duced to 250 feet. The 9-foot contours crossed the bar and formed a
channel of at least that depth 750 feet wide, with the exception of two
small spots, whose depths were 8.5 and 7.6 feet, respectively.
   Within this 9-foot channel three deeper channels cross the bar.
   The two most southerly are direct and navigable. Each has a least
depth of 10.7 feet ; the most southerly is at least 150 feet wide ; the othev
                     *      )   CNTOURSf5-1 ND
       ---      c      ---   SOUND/A'05   OPF
             172;.._5_.1-5SU          VEY   JUNE                       l6'8'\                              \



----
             .-..--
              (9---
                         -           CONTOURS AND
                                     SOUNDINGS OF                                                                                                                                           x                          NEWBURYPORT                                                  HARBBOR
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         , MASS.
       -.       -(.m)        -       SURVEY JUNE 18s                                                                                                                                        fl                        PLAN           SHOWING              CONDITION             OF       IMPROVEMENT
                                                                                                                                                                                            W
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     TO    ACCOMPANY            ANNUAL              REPORT OF
                                                                                                                                                  N                 \
                                                                                                               \\                        \                                                  W
                                                                                                                                                                                                                        LT.     COL. GEO. L. GILLESPIE, CORPS OF ENGRS. U.S.A.
                                                                                                                                      ,,\"\'.
                                                                                                                                                                                            h                                                      1888.
                                                                                                                                                      ; "..
                                                      !/7
                                                                                                                                                                        .

                                                      /                                                                     s                                                                                               .   o   s500
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  SCALE
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   0ooo
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           OF    MAP
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  s15o0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          110000.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    oo               so30
                                                                                                                            \             \\
                                                                                                          -1                             *l\      \ :"" \ \                                                                             UA.S. ENo/nEER OF/CC
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       .REqPECrFULLY FORWARDED
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              , BOSrO/V , MASS.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   WITH LETTER
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 JuY   10. 1888.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  OF TH.s DATE
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        TO T H C l/(/i  OF ENOI/NEERS,    WAS INGTOND, D.C.



f-                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        LT. COL.   OF   EN/GINEERS
                                                                                                 .,   /    'I.         "

                                                                                                                                                                                       \\
                                                                                                                                                                                                 W/HIJTLING   U/OY



                                                          -.-.             -*                                       7.7,.
                        *'                     't ,                -            -     9 "ST5                                                                            \.x        "



                                 /   F(tS/V    BAR 2OY           -9?                      0'-1


                 NN~                                                                                  4                4~\Ni1J


C           Ni1 - A   --               "     'D                       v                         >    .9A2.;'<                        "\.j            ..




                                                                                    I
                                                                                    44/                                                      /             A

                                                                                    soi!                                        .,!




                                                                            I             \}                                                     1
                                                                                                                                                 1'        >l:h Y           l -4
                                                                                    i ! \             "-        "



                                                                                                                                             /                                                      0                2000           000             3000               4000               5000                   000




Eng50 2
              APPENDIX              B -REPORT                OF LIEUT.             COL. GILLESPIE.                      435
is at least 200 feet wide; the third or northern deep-water channel has
a least depth of 11.2 feet, but it is crooked and not over 100 feet wide.
   The high-water line on the Salisbury Beach side of the entrance shows
no essential change; on the Plum Island side, inside of the south jetty, it
has advanced on an average 150 feet northward. This advance is ap-
parently due to the increased shelter given by the extended north jetty,
and to a straightening of the channel.
   The spring freshet in the river, as shown by notes furnished by Mr.
Hiram F. Mills, engineer of the Essex Company atLawrence, Mass., was
not of an average height, but was of an unusual duration; the river
was " high" for more than three months, and to this is probably due
the very large increase of scour on the bar. A comparative chart that
shows the condition of the bar, June, 1887, and June, 1888, accompa-
nies this report.
   The condition of the improvement on June 30, 1888, was as follows:
The north jetty had been completed for a length of 1,930 feet, and in
addition.745 feet was partly comlleted;         south jetty had been com-  the
pleted 1,077 feet, and partly completed for an additional distance of 223
feet, and its shore end protected by a durable sand catch.
   The dike was completed as far as was prudent at that time for its
safety. It was 817 feet long, and 5- feet high above mean low water,
except that near its center, a weir was left 150 feet long and 2 feet deep
at mean low water.
   The channel through the bar was at least 200 feet wide and 10.7 feet
deep at mean low water.
   No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending Jane 30, 1888.
The river and harbor bill for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1889, con-
tains an item of $25,000 for continuing this improvement, and if this
amount should be appropriated it will provide for the delivery of 10,000
tons of stone towards the extension of the two jetties. Estimating that
the appropriation of $25,000 will be made very soon after the close of the
present fiscal year, there will be required in addition for the completion
of the project the sum of $142,500, all of which it is recommended should
be appropriated for the fiscal year ending June 30,1890, for application
in extending the two jetties to the full projected length. The improve-
ment is in a very encouraging condition, and should be pushed to com-
pletion with the least delay practicable. The advantages to be derived
from the completion of the project are the deepening and widening of
the channel across the bar, thereby affbrding a harbor of refuge on the
inside of Salisbury Beach, and also affording easy access at high stage
to the wharves at Newburyport for vessels drawing 17 feet approxi-
mately.
  This work is located in the collection district of Newburyport, Mass., of which
Newburyport is the port of entry. The nearest light-house is on Plum Island, at the
entrance of the harbor.
  The accompanying commercial statistics for the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1888, have been furnished by the collector of customs for New-
buryport, Mass.
                           Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available .......--------.-----------......--......--------....---......------......-......   $17, 623.80
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887..............................................                                            17,622.07
July 1,1888, balance available..........................................                                                  1.73
Amount appropriated by act of Aggnst 11, 1888 ......---....-....---....---......--.                                 25, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                           25.001.73
436         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

{Amount   (estimated) required for completion of existing project.-.....-$142,  500.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30,1890 142, 500.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                          COMMERCIAL           STATISTICS.


                   Commercial statistics for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.


                                          Shipping.                                                Vessels.    Tonnage..


Foreign arrivals.................................................. ..............    209   3, 481
Foreign clearances-----------------                                                        6, 604
                       .............................--.----------------------------....................
                                                                                     46
                                                                          ---------
Coastwise arrivals................................................................  342   89, 382



Received from customs--..........................---..----. .... -...- ..--                         ........$2, 782.03
Received from tonnage tax .........................- .................-....                       ... ....       93.51

      Total ................................................................................. 2,875. 54

                                                      IMPORTS.

Coal......            -..........................................................                                        to s..      5,098
Lumber------
           .......---------....-......------.........-----------...----..---......--......                                feet.. 265,000
Shingles ..---------------......................-----......---....-.---------........--                                            352, 000
Potatoes----.......--------....---......----....------....------....----....---....----....--......----....--..--...--bushels..      7,346
Vegetables ............................................                                                    .........     do --.... 300
Eggs ....--------------......-----....--......----------....-----......--......--..---                                  dozen.. -300
Coal received by coastwise arrivals..................................tons.. 175,000




                                                         B    2.

              IMPROVEMEN T OF MERRIMAC RIVER, MASSACHUSETTS.

  The mouth of the Merrimac River is 15 miles northwest from Cape
Ann, Massachusetts. Tide-water extends up it a distance of 19 miles,
or to foot of the " Upper Falls," 1I miles above Haverhill, Mass.
   Seven incorp)orated cities and the largest mills in New England are
directly interested in its improvement. Before improvement the chan-
nel was narrow and crooked, and much obstructed by ledges, bowlders,
and shoals. At mean low water vessels drawing not to exceed 7 feet
could enter the river and proceed to South Amesbury, 9 miles from the
mouth. The sea bar at the mouth of the river has been improved
under specific appropriations for improvement of Newburyport Harbor,
while many sunken rocks and wrecks of piers and vessels lying inside
the bar have been removed by general appropriations for thle improve-
ment of tile river.
   The object of the Merrimac River improvement is to straighten, widen,
and deepen the natural channel from the bar to the head of tide-water
of the upper falls of a group known as Mitchell's Falls.
   The rise or fall of the tide at the mouth is 7.7 feet, at Haverhill Bridge,
4 feet.
   No plan of the river above Newburyport has been published in the
Reports of the Chief of Engineers.
   The project originally adopted in 1870 proposed to remove obstruc-
tions from the Upper and Lower Mitchell's Falls, and to remove the
Gangway rock and the " Boilers" inNewburyport Harbor. The cost
was estimated to be $69,025. This )roject~ was modified in 1874 so as
to include the removal of rocks in and near the draw of the bridge at
           APPENDIX B-REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. GILLESPIE.                                           437
Deer Island, 2 miles above Newb uryport, and Rock'; Bridge, and at
Little Currier's shoal, East Haverhill, so that the channel should have
the following depths at ordinary high-water stages of the river: From
the mouth to Deer Island Bridge (5 miles), 16* feet; from Deer Islanl
Bridge to Haverhill Bridge (12- miles), 12 feet; thence to the foot of
MitchelPl's Falls, Hazeltine Rapids (1*miles), 10 feet; through Mitchell'Ps
Falls to the head of the Upper Falls (21 miles), not less than 41 feet,
when the mill-water at Lawrence is running.
   This revised project was estimated to cost $147,000.
   The total appropriations to date have been $170,500.
   The total expenditures to June 30, 1888, were $170,498.43.
   During the fiscal year gauges to establish high-water plane wereestab-
lished at Haverhill Bridge and at Newburyport Bridge, and the height
of the water recorded hourly during the spring freshet of 1888. These
records, with similar data furnished by Mr. Hiram F. Mills, hydraulic
engineer of the Essex Company, at Lawrence, Mass., will fix the high-
water-grade line of the river from the dam at Lawrence to its mouth, in
accordance with circular letter of the Engineer Department, dated April
25, 1888.
   No other operations were in progress. The condition of the improve-
ment on June 30, 1888, was as follows:
   The river channel had been improved in accordance with the modi-
fied project of 1874, with the exception of the removal of the " Boilers,"
upon which no work had been done.
   The excess of expenditure over the estimate is due to the removal of
rocks and other obstructions that were unknown, or whose removal
were not contemplated when the estimate was made, and by the expense
of necessary surveys and examinations not provided for in the estimate.
   The project, as modified in 1874, has been completed with the excep-
tion of the removal of the "Boilers."      But from 1883-'86, additional
iml)rovements were recommended, as follows:
   For that part of the river below head of Mitchell's Falls:
1. To remove sunken rocks and shoals from Mitchell's Falls................                      $1, 500
2. To remove "The Boilers" to a depth of 5 feet at meau low water, 350
     cubic yards, at $25--...----......---........----------..-------......-----...
                                                                      8,750
                                                                         1,250
   Contingencies ......---..........----....---------......-----........----..........--

                                                                 11,500
       Total ........---------------.......------...------......--------.......
  To extend the improvement so that the same depth of water as is
now obtained through MitchelPl's Falls can be carried to Lawrence (a
distance of 5 miles from the head of the Falls) was, in 1882, estimated
to cost for dredging through Gage's Shoal and Andover Bar, and remov-
ing bowlders and ledges, $11,000.
  The improved channel is in good order, and meets all existing de-
mands of commerce. No appropriation is recommended for the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1890.
  This work is located in the collection district of Newburyport, Mass., of which
Newburyport is the nearest port of entry. The nearest light-house is the Plum Island
Lights and the Newburyport Upper Harbor Lights.
Commercial statistics are included in statement for Newburyport
Harbor.
                         Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available------............................---....---....--......
                                                                                  -$290.04
July 1, 1888. amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887............................ $282. 47
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities.............................               6. 00
                                         *                                     --               288. 47

July 1, 1888, balance available ....-..........         -.....-.....    -...        -........     1.57
438    REPORT OF THE CHIEF 'OF ENGINEERS, IT. S. ARMY.


                                  B   3-

         IMPROVEMENT OF IPSWICH RIVER, MASSACHUSETTS.

    Ipswich River empties into Plum Island Sound, 9 miles south of New-
buryport, Mass., and at the same distance west of Cape Ann. The bead
of navigation is 3 miles above the mouth.
    The entrance of Plum Island Sound is 2 miles east of the mouth of
the river. Six feet depth at mean low water can be carried over the bar
at the entrance to the sound, and between the bar and the mouth of the
river there is a good anchorage, with from 3 to 5 fathoms of water.
    Before improvement the channel of the river from its mouth to
 " Barras Turn," a distance of 2 miles, was at least 60 feet wide and 4
feet deep at mean low water. From " Barras Turn" to the town wharves,

                  ,feet
a distance of 1 mile, the channel was narrow and crooked, and had at
some places but 1
of the tide is 8o feet.
                           depth at mean low water. The mean rise or fall

    The original project for improvement was submitted December 6,1875.
It proposed a channel 60 feet wide and 4 feet deep, mean low water,
from " Barras Turn" to the town wharves, at an estimated cost of
$25,000.
    On November 5, 1883, the original project was divided into three par-
tial projects:
    1. The removal of the ledges at Heard's Point, and opposite Nabby's
Point, to a depth of 2 feet at mean low water, to open a navigable chan-
nel of that depth, at a cost of $15,900.
    2. To dredge the shoals at "Labor in Vain" and " The Shoals," so as
to open a channel 4 feet deep, at mean low wadter, and 60 feet wide, at a
cost of $2,200.
    3. To straighten the channel by making a cut across "Barras Turns,"
and to build a jetty to close the old channel at a cost of $6,900. In the
Annual Report of 1887 it was recommended that the general project be
modified, by limiting the present improvement to opening a channel, 60
feet wide and 4 feet deep through "The Shoals" and " Labor in Vain"
and extending it to the "Deep Hole," opposite the town wharves.
    A chart showing this limited project was published in the Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1887.
     The amount which has been appropriated for this improvement tb
date is $2,500 by the act of August 5, 1886.
     The amount expended to June 30, 1888, was $2,500.
     No active operations have been in progress during the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1888, from want of funds. The condition of the improve-
ments June 30, 1888, was as follows: A channel 4 feet deep at mean
low water had been dredged 60 feet wide at " Labor in Vain," and 40
feet wide at " The Shoals."
     The full projected width of the channel at " The Shoals" had not been
obtained for the reason that logs and bowlders were uncovered by the
dredging, and the increased expense of their removal proportionally
reduced the amount applicable to dredging.
     No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
     The river and harbor bill for the year ending June 30, 1889, contains
an item of $2,500 for continuing the improvement, and if appropriated
that sum will be applied towards enlarging the cut through "1The
  Shoals" and connecting the "Deep Hole," opposite Glover's Wharf, with
  the improved channel below Heard's Point, by a cut 250 feet long, 60
  feet wide, and 4 feet deep. When this work is done the amount re-
             APPENDIX           B -REPORT              OF     LIEUT.   COL.   GILLESPIE.             439

quired to complete the original project will be $20,000; but it is not con-
sidered necessary to make recommendations for additional improve-
ments until the commerce of the river has increased beyoud its present
volume. No recommendation is therefore made for continuing the irm-
provement for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
   Ispwich River is in the collection district of Newburyport, Mass. The nearest
light-house is the Ipswich Light, on Castle Neck, about 1l miles southeast from the
mouth of the river.
   Commercial statistics included in Newburyport Harbor.
                                              Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available .................................                           ..      $246. 79
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887......-----------------......------......--......--......-----...--.      246.79

Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.....................                          .     2,500.00

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........                        20, 000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                      2,500. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                       B 4.

       HARBOR OF REFUGE, SANDY BAY, CAPE ANN, MASSACHUSETTS.

   Sandy Bay is situated at the northeastern extremity of the promon-
tory of Cape Ann, which forms the northern limit of Massachusetts
Bay. The shore-lines of the bay form a little less than a right angle,
and their directions are nearly north and south and east and west. The
rocky island of Straitsmouth forms the eastern extremity of one shore-
line, and the steep headland of Andrew's Point the northern end of
the other. Following the line of tmhe proposed breakwater, the bay is
24 miles wide, and it has a depth of 2 miles approximately.
   The bay on the land side is perfectly protected by steep high hills,
but it fronts the northeast, and is open to the full force of the violeit
northerly and easterly gales of this coast. The great seas of the ocean
are broken, however, in a degree by the sunken rocky ledges called
Avery's ledge, the Dry and Little Salvages, the Flat Ground and
Abner's ledge, which are directly at the mouth of the bay. Inside
these entrance ledges the bay is entirely unobstructed, and has an
average depth of 50 feet at mean low water.
   A plan of the bay showing the proposed breakwater was published
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1886, page 582.
   The project for improvement was submitted in 1884. It proposes a
continuous breakwater 9,000 feet long, divided into two branches; one
starts at Avery's ledge and runs in a direction a little west of north to
Abner's ledge, a distance of 3,600 feet; the other extends 5,420 feet
from Abner's ledge, in a northeasterly direction, and terminates at the
83 feet contour off Andrew's Point. The axis of the proposed break-
water is approximately at the inner edge of the ledges at the entrance
of the bay, and about a mile inside the Salvages. and Flat Ground,
which will receive the first shock of easterly storm waves.
   The southern entrance to the harbor lies between Straitsmouth
Island and Avery's ledge, and is 1,800 feet wide, and at least 30 feet
deep.
440    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The northern entrance, near Andrew's Point, is 2,700 feet wide, and
80 feet deep. They are so located with reference to each other that
vessels can enter and leave the harbor without any wind.
   The harbor formed by the breakwater covers an anchorage of 1 377
acres, in which the depth exceeds 24 feet at mean low stage. The theo-
retical anchorage capacity is fifty-five hundred vessels.
   The breakwater will be formed to the level of 22 feet below low water,
of a mound of broken stone, 40 feet wide at top, above which a masonry
wall has been suggested, whose crest shall be 15 feet wide and 8 feet
above extreme high water. The detailed plan for the construction of
the masonry wall has not been definitely adopted, and operations have
been confined to the construction of the rubble-stone mound, or sub-
structure of the breakwater. This is effected by dropping stone from
vessels and self-dumping scows along the axis of the breakwater, ex-
tending to the eastward and westward, a distance of 20 feet approx-
imately. The axis is indicated by an iron spindle on Avery's ledge,
when in range with the south light-house on Thatcher's Island; cross-
ranges are established by iron pipes let into the rocks on the Dry and
Little Salvages, which mark points at intervals of 100 feet from the
spindle (initial point) on Avery's ledge. The estimated cost of the im-
provement is $5,000,000, to which must be added $2,500,000 for buoy-
age, lighting, and defense of the harbor.
   These estimates are based upon consecutive annual al)propriations of
not less than 10 per cent. of the original estimates of cost. Should
operations be suspended at any time from want of funds, or annual ap-
propriations be reduced to small sums for a series of years, the expenses
for the final construction will be proportionally increased.
   The amount which has been appropriated to date is $200,000.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, inclusive of outstand-
ing liabilities, was $194,125.24.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, 83,935 tons of rubble-
stone, at 71 cents per ton of 2,000 pounds, were deposited under a con-
tract dated October 21, 1886, with the Rockport and Pigeon Hill Gran-
ite companies. Operations under this contract were commenced March
21, 1887, and were satisfactorily completed June 23, 1888, 114,931 tons
having been deposited by the contractors. This stone was dumped be-
tween cross-ranges 1540 and 2340, or at corresponding feet from the in-
itial point. From the nature of the work, the top of the mound is some,
what irregular, and the depth of water over it at low tide varies from
18 to 23 feet. A careful survey of the mound is now in progress, and
the results will be compared with previous surveys by which deductions
may be drawn as to settlement and wave action, if any such changes
have taken place. The spindle marking the initial point on Avery's
ledge was broken off by a vessel drifting over it in June, 1887. Every
possible method was adopted to remove the stump of the spindle from
the hole in the ledge, but unsuccessfully, and the attempt was abandoned.
   In July, 1887, the drilling of a new spindle hole was begun on Avery's
ledge, and was satisfactorily completed early in September, 1887, in
time to receive a new spindle which had been ordered. This new spin-
dle in turn was prostrated during an easterly gale in March, 1888, the
fracture occurring inside the hole near the surface of the rock.
   The stump was extracted, and the frustum reforged and replaced
March 26, 1888. The destruction of this important spindle is liable to
occur at any time, and a spare hole in the ledge and a duplicate spindle
should always be available while operations are in progress to pre-
vent serious delays, at least until some more efficient method of mark-
      TO ACCOMPANY              ANNUAL           REPORT                                                           DRY
      FOR THE FISCAL           YEAR       ENOING                                                             SALVAGEo
      JUNE        30,   1888.                                                                               ..                          HARBOR                        OF REFUGE
                               LT. COL.     OF    ENGI/NEERS.                                         V                             SANDY                  BAY,              APE            ANN


                                                                                                                                                  MASSACH USETTS
                                                                        FLAT GROUND
                                                                        FLAT. GRPWV                                                         SCHEME                    OF   RANGES

                                                                                                                                                FOR   CONSTRUCTION                     OF
                                                                                                                                   THE SUBMERGED                           ENROCKMENT
                                                                                T4OF                                                            THE PROPOSED BREAKWATER
                                                                                                                                                       SCALE          130000.
                                                                                       SPI DL   .INITIAL    POINT
                                                                                        AVqRWS             LEDE        ,0                             ONE.    STATUTE      MILE

                                                                                                                                            a         vv                        ++10
     !W'S   PT.                                          o




                                                                                                 LIGHT                 STRAITStQkTH
                                                                                                                                   D,

                                                                                                                              N
                                                                                                                         I1S77/A
                                                     SANDY
                                                     H                  BAY                                       ,N
                                                                S'9 -   \'GAP                      HEAD                                                           N



                               'con

                                                                                                                                                                           TH AT CH~              GHTUlr

                                      PIGEON HILL
                           /    /         GfRANITE   CO$"7                                                                                                                        LA




Eng5O 2
            APPENDIX          B3-REPORT O                    LIEUT'.    COL. GILLESPIE.             441
ing the initial point has been adopted. The pipes on the Salvages, indi-
cating the cross-ranges, are frequently swept away; buat the cost and
trouble of replacing them are slight, and the loss causes no important
delay to the work.
   Sealed proposals were invited by public advertisement, according to
law, on December 2, 1887, for the hire of a steam-launch to be used by
the inspector in overseeing the dumpings. One bid, presented by Mr.
F. Scripture, was received and opened January 2, 1888, and the price
bid of $125 per month was accepted and a formal written contract, dated
.January 13, 1888, was executed for this service. This contract was
closed June 30, 1888.
   The condition of the improvement on June 30, 1888, is as follows :
   A total of 242,934 tons of rubble-stone had been deposited between
cross ranges 140 and 2340, thus essentially completing 2,200 running
feet of the substructure of the breakwater. The ranges used in the
work were in position and in good order.
   The funds available July 1, 1888, will be expended in completing the
survey of the mound now in progress, and in preparing drawings, esti-
mates, etc., therefrom.
   No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
   The river and harbor bill for the fiscal year ending June 30,1889, con-
tains an item of $100,000 for continuing the improvement, and if this
amount should be appropriated by the present session of Congress, it
willbe applied towards extending the rubble mound 800 feet towards
Abner's ledge, the drilling of a new spindle hole on Avery's ledge, and
in the purchase of a duplicate spindle. On completion of this work the
amount required to complete the project will be $4,700,000, approxi-
mately. An appropriation of $200,000 is recommended for the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1890, and if appropriated will be applied towards
the further extension of the substructure of the breakwater in the direc-
tion of Abner's ledge.
   The prospective benefits to commerce and navigation by the con-
struction of this harbor of refuge are increased safety to life and prop-
erty, and a consequent reduction in freights and insurance.
  Sandy Bay is situated in the collection district of Gloucester, Mass.
  The nearest light-house is Straits-mouth Light, situated on Straits-mouth island, at
the southern entrance of the bay.
  The accompanying commercial statistics for the fiscal year ending
June 30,1888, have been furnished by the collector of customs at Glou-
cester, Mass.
                          Money statement.

July 1, 1887, amount available....-............... .....  ...... .......                       $75,916.09
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1,         187 ....................         $58. 571.09
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities .......................                  11,470.24
                                                                                      --        70,041.33

July 1, 1888, balance available.......................................                           5,874.76
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.....................----------------------..     100,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 188- .................                       105,874.76

  SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-......
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
                                                                                             4,700,000.00
    30, 1890------........-----------------........--------.-------------------....... --- 200,000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections '2of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
442               REPORT OF                         THE CHIEF                    OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Abstract of proposalsfor removing remains of iron spindlefrom Avery Ledge, Sandy Bay,
Mass., and enlargingpresent hole to 8 inches in diameter, opened July 13, 1887, by Lieut.
  Col. G. L. Gillespie, Corps of Engineers.


                                                                                                                          Amount
                                                                                                                          bid for re-
                                                                                                                           moving
No.                                                   Names and residence of bidders.                                      the spin-
                                                                                                                            dle and
                                                                                                                          enlarging
                                                                                                                             hole.


   1 George W. Townsend, Boston, Mass..............................................                                 ...        $1,500
   2    George F. Runyan, Boston, Mass...............................................                             .....         1, 600
   3    W. D. Duncan & Nickerson, Boston, Mass....... .....................................                                     2, 500
   4 Boynton Bros., Boston, Mass...........................................................                                      *650

                                                        * Lowest bid for drilling a new hole.

   Contract was awarded to Boynton Bros., with the approval of the Chief of Engineers.



Abstract of proposals for furnishing a steam-launch during the year 1888 for service at
   Sandy Bay, Mass., opened January 2, 1888, by Lieut. Col. G. L. Gillespie, Corps of En-
   gineers.


No.                                 Name and residence of bidder.                                 Price bid       Remarks.
                                                                                                 per  month.

   1     Frank Scripture, Rockport, Mass ...............................                                $125   Only bid received.


   Contract was awarded to Mr. Frank Scripture, with the approval of the Chief of
Engineers.
                                                             COMMERCIAL            STATISTICS.

                          Commercial statistics for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.

Vessels hailing from Rockport, Mass-....-----....---.---......--------......---.......-------......---....                         48
Tonnage.... ----........................-............................-........                                            ..   1,950
  Five vessels entered the port with cargoes consisting of fire-wood and eggs; value,
$650; no duties collected.



                                                                                 B 5.
               IMPROVEMENT OF GLOUCESTER HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

   This is the most important harbor between Boston and Portland,
and is the principal resort for all New England fishing vessels. It is
situated at the southeastern extremity of Cape Ann, 20 miles northeast
from Boston. It is easily entered when the dangerous easterly storms
of this coast occur, and provides a secure ample shelter for all classes
of vessels except from south winds, and from these a moderate extent
of protected anchorage is afforded in the inner harbor.
   It contains in the outer roadstead the inner harbor, and in the chan-
nel connecting them sufficient deep water for the most liberal demands
of commerce; but the inner harbor and channel are obstructed by
bowlders, ledges, and shoals dangerous and inconvenient to shipping,
and the outer harbor or roadstead is open to the action of all southerly
winds.
        APPENDIX Bl-REPORT          OF LIEUt. COL.     GILLESPIE.      443
   A plan of the harbor was published in the Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1887, page 506.
   The first project formed for improvement was submitted by the local
engineer January 20, 1871, and was based on the survey ordered by the
act of July 11, 1870. (Report of the Chief of Engineers, 1871, page 869.)
   This project proposed the removal of certain bowlders from the inner
harbor at a cost of $10,606.20, and the construction of a breakwater
from Eastern Point over Dog Bar to Round Rock Shoal, at an estimated
cost of $494,148.65.
   On November 19, 1884, Major Raymond, Corps of Engineers, by or-
der of the special Board of Engineers that was considering the sub-
ject of the Sandy Bay breakwater, submitted a project for two break-
waters at the entrance of Gloucester Harbor, one to cost $752,000, on
essentially the same site as that proposed in 1871, and a supplementary
one through Norman's Woe Rock, to cost $607,000. This project and
estimate are published in the Chief of Engineer's Report for 1885, page
534.
   On January 20, 1885, it was recommended, in accordance with act of
July 5, 1884, that a survey of the inner harbor and of the reef off Mus-
cle Point be made, and that Babson's Ledge be removed to 21 feet at
mean low water. (Report Chief of Engineers, 1885, page 541.)
   In the annual report for this harbor for 1887 a general project for its
improvement was submitted, based on the survey ordered by act of
Congress approved August 5, 1886. (Chief of Engineer Report, 1887,
page 500.)
   This project provided for the removal from the inner harbor of 101
cubic yards of rock known to exist, and of 216,000 cubic yards, scow
measurement, of material, at an estimated cost of $65,000, and for the
construction of the breakwater, recommended in the project of 1884,
that extends from Eastern Point to Round Rock Shoal, at an estimated
cost of $752,000.
   The total appropriations for this harbor to dlate have been $15,000.
    The amount expended to June 30, 1888, was $15,000.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, the chart of the survey
provided for in the act of August 5, 1886, was completed, and the oper-
ations under that part of the act requiring the partial removal of Bab-
son's Ledge were as follows:
   The survey showed that the ledge was very much more extensive than
had been supposed; that instead of a few hundred cubic yards, it con-
tained 5,000 to the plane of 21 feet below mean low water. The funds
specifically appropriated would only suffice to reduce the ledge to 14 feet
below mean low water. This work was recommended July 27, and ap-
proved July 30, 1887. Specifications were prepared, and sealed propo-
sals invited, according to law, by public advertisement dated July 27,
1887. Three bids were received and opened August 30, 1887; the high-
est was $59, the lowest $14.75 per cubic yard. A contract approved by
the Chief of Engineers was entered into with Messrs. Duncan & Nick-
erson, the lowest bidders, and the ledge was succesfully reduced as pro-
posed, during the months of September, October, and November, 1887,
to the depth of 14 feet mean low water by the removal of 149.94 cubic
yards of rock.
   The condition of the improvement June 30, 1888, was as follows:
    Clam Rock had been reduced from 1 foot to 9, feet at mean low
water; Pinnacle Rock from 8) feet to 16) feet, mean low water; rock off
Pew's Wharf from 2 to 5 feet mean low water; rocks off of J. Friend's
Wharf, from 13 to 17 feet mean low water. All the above were reduced
444          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

to the level of the surrounding bottoms. Babson's Ledge from 11 to 14
feet mean low water, or as far as the funds provided sufficed, and it is
now believed to be no further obstruction to commerce if kept properly
bouyed.
    No work had been done on the breakwater.
    No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
    The river and harbor bill for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1889,
contains an item of $10,000 for the improvement of Gloucester Harbor,
in partial execution of the project of 1887 (Annual Report Chief of
Engineers, 1887, pages 500-504), and if appropriated will be applied in
dredging Harbor Cove and removing ledges and bowlders obstructing
the approach to the wharves between Harbor Cove and Pew's Wharf.
    The value of this harbor in its relation to the general commerce of
the coast, and especially to the fishing industry, is given in detail in
the Annual Report for 1887, to which reference is invited.
    For the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, an appropriation of $305,000
is recommended, in partial execution of the project of 1887; $55,000 to
be applied to the completion of the dredging of Harbor Cove, and of the
removal of ledges and, bowlders between that basin and Pew's Wharf.
and $250,000 for beginning the breakwater proposed to be built from
Eastern Point over Dog Bar to Round Rock Shoal, for the purpose of
protecting the Outer harbor against southeasterly storms.
    The vested interests at this harbor represent directly and indirectly
the large sum of $143,875,800. It is stated authentically that seven
thousand vessels of all classes visit the port annually.
    The prospective advantages to commerce by the completion of the
improvement are greater facilities and safety in the movement of vessels
in the harbor, and a more secure anchorage for vessels seeking protec-
tion from southerly gales.
   Gloucester Harbor is in the collection district of Gloucester, Mass., of which Glou-
cester is the port of entry.            The nearest light-houses are Ten Pound Island light, in
the harbor, and Eastern Point light, at the entrance                        'of the harbor.
  The accompanying commercial statistics for the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1888, have been furnished by the collector of customs at
Gloucester, Mass.
                         Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available .......................................-------------------------------------.. $3, 003.29
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887-------
                           .......-------------......----......-----------......---......-......-----....-.... 3, 00:1. 29
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ........................                                       10,000.00
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....... 807, 000. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30,1890 305. 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
 ( harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.

Abstract of proposals for removing Babson's Ledge, Gloucester Harbor, Mass., opened
          August 30, 1887, by Lieut. Col. G. L. Gillespie, Corps of Engineers.

                                                                                                           Price  bid for
                                                                                                            removal of
No.                                        Names of bidders.                                               rock per Cu-
                                                                                                             bic yard.


  1   William David Duncan and James Ephraim Nickerson--------....--.                                             *$14. 75
  2   Thomas Symonds ...---------------------------------------------...                                            21.00
  3   Charles H. Edwards......................................................--                 .......            59. 00

                                                      Lowest bid.
                  APPENDIX                          B-REPORT                                   OF LIEUT.                            COL.     GILLESPIE.              445
  Award of contract was made to Messrs. Duncan & Nickerson, with the approval of
the Chief of Engineers.


                                                                     COMMERCIAL                           STATISTICS.

                           Commercial statisticsfor the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.

Fishing vessels-----     ......--------......--......--..------......-----......------....-....-......------......-----.... -414
Coasting---.......------......---------......--......------......------......-------....---....-----....--......------....----....                                      47
Foreign        trade........         ----..........--......---............................-------------......                                                             9
Yachts---------------------------------------..........................................---------------------.....................                                         3

          Total         .----.....                 --....        --......----....................................                                   ---........        473
Tonnage ....--------..----..-....------......-----.............---------......----......------....--......--....-- tons..                                           31,194
Domestic arrivals--   .----..........---......-----....--......--....------------------..-....--.....--.....--..--....                                                  91
Domestic clearances ....--.           ..............................................                                                                                    99
                    ......---------......--------......-------......--......-......--------......-----....---......---..--..
Foreign arrivals-----                                                                                                                                                   68
Foreign clearances------....----------....----....--......-......-------.....--......-----....---....----....-----...----....                                           53
Coastwise arrivals- ........----------------------....----------........---------....--........................-----......                                              29
Coastwise clearances ...                                    ....--......                      ---------............................--..-..            ---....           60
Value of imports------....----......------......-----......----- ....-......-------------....---......---..---..........                                .         $140, 322
Duty on imports collected...............................................                                                                                            12,912




                                                                                                B 6.
                      IMPROVEMENT OF LYNN HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

    Lynn Harbor is situated 9 miles northeast from Boston. It is 1 by 2
miles, approximately, in extent, the greater part of which is dry at low
water. It is protected 6n the north and west by the main land, and on
the east by Nahant Beach, and its entrance 2 miles wide into Massa-
chusetts Bay is on the south side.
    Before improvement three narrow and crooked channels of approach
to the wharves existed, in each of which there was about 6 feet depth
at mean low water. The mean rise or fall of the tide is 90 feet.
    The western channel leads to the "Point of Pines" and the mouth of
Saugus River. The main ship-channel is entered between "White" and
 "Lobster" rocks, and connects about 3,600 feet northward with the
 " Black Rock" channel, which is the most eastern near Nahant Beach.
    The project for improvement was adopted in 1884. It provides for
the excavation of a channel 200 feet wide and 10 feet deep at mean low
water, from a point near and east of the " White Rocks" to deep water
opposite Little Nahant, a distance of 3,610 feet. This is called the
 "outer" improved channel, and is merely a rectification and deepening
of the Main Ship-channel. The combined Main Ship and Black Rock
channels are sufficient for the purposes of commerce for the next 2,500
feet. Then commences the "inner" improved channel, which is pro-
jected 6,450 feet long, 200 feet wide, and 10 feet deep at mean low water.
It extends from deep water opposite '" Sand Point" to the harbor com-
missioners" line, and follows very closely in direction the extension of
the united Main Ship and Black Rock channels.
    It is supposed that the inner channel will need to be dredged occa-
sionally to maintain its width and depth; but a training-wall about 6,000
feet long has been I)roposed to ai(d minkeeping the outer channel open,
if experience shall show it to be necessary.
    This wall is to start from the shore at ' Little Nahant," and is to cross
the Black Rock Chuannel; its outer )ortiol is to be parallel to the outer
improved channel,
446      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The cost of this project was originally estimated to be $145,000. This
estimate was revised in 1885, and then made $157,000. This excess of
$12,000 was caused by an increased amount of dredging found to be nec-
essary during the progress of the work, to round off the corners of the
natural channel at its junctions with the dredged channel; to provide
flatter slopes to the sides of the cut than was originally designed; and
also to provide funds for the necessary surveys during the progress of
the work.
   A plan of the harbor, showing the projected improvement, was pub-
lished in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1881, Part I,
page 532. The amount expended to June 30, 1888, was $65,962.60.
   At this date the outer channel had been completed, as proposed,
3,610 feet long, 200 feet wide, 10 feet deep, and the inner channel had
been improved 6,450 feet long and 10 feet deep, with a width limited
to 150 feet, or 50 feet less than the project calls for.
   A survey of the improved channels was made during the latter part of
June, 1888, and it was found that the improvement showed no serious
deterioration, and was essentially as at the date of the last Annual Report.
   No other operations were in progress during the fiscal year.
   No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
The river and harbor bill for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1889, con-
tains an item of $10,000 for the improvement of this harbor, and if this
sum should be appropriated part of it may be applied in the channel lead-
ing to the Point of Pines, and the residue in extending the improved
inner channel westward 50 feet wide, to the basin, inclosed by the
wharves of the city of Lynn, beyond the line established by the dock
commissioners. This extension will be 1,200 feet long, and iC it should
be made of the same width and depth as thQ project provides for the
inner channel, 100,000 cubic yards of material will have to be excavated,
in addition to the original estimate, at .a cost of $25,000, making the
total estimate of cost for the proposed improvement $182,000 (inclusive
of training-wall, estimated to cost $66,500).
   The total amount appropriated for this work to date is $66,000. It is
not necessary at this time to enter upon the construction of the training-
wall for the outer channel. The inner channel should be first widened
50 feet to give it the full projected width, 200 feet, and then extendled
with this full width to the inner basin. To effect this will require the
removal of 210,000 cubic yards of material, at an estimated cost of $49,500.
   An appropriation of $30,000 is recommended for the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1890, of which $24,000 will be applied in widening the in-
ner channel 50 feet, and $6,000 in widening the northward extension
50 feet, so that the channel leading to the inner basin may be improved
to a width of 100 feet, with 10 feet depth at mean low water.
   Lynn is a port of entry in the collection district of Marblehead, Mass.                 The nearest
light-house is Egg Rock (Nahant) Light, 3 miles distant.
  The accompanying commercial statistics for the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1888, have been furnished by the collector of customs for the
port of Marblehead, Mass.:
                                   Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available------                                    $566.86
                              ......------......---------........-------......-----......
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887- ...-
                               -     _----------------------"------------529.46

July 1, 1888, balance available....-.... .....-...                 -....-........-....
                                                                                  ......         37. 40
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188 .........................                       10,000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...................                     10,037.40
                   APPENDIX                B-REPORT                           OF LIEUT. COL. GILLESPIE.                                         447
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-........-$172, 000. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearendingJune 30, 1890 '30, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                        LETTER FROM MR.                        TRANCIS         E.   PEDRICK.


                                                                              CUSTOM-HOUSE,              COLLECTOR'S OFFICE,
                                                      Marblehead, Mass., July 9, 1888.
  I inclose herewith information as per request of yours of the 26th instant. There
has been a marked increase in the commerce of Lynn during the past year, and masters
of vessels express great satisfaction at the recent improvements; but the work should
be continued in order that the commerce may increase with the demands of the above
growing city..
       Very respectfully, yours, etc.,
                                                                                                                 FRANCIS E. PEDRICK.
   Lieutenant-Colonel GILLESPIE, U. S. A.




                                                        COMMERCIAL                STATISTICS.

                              Commercial statistics for the fiscal year ending ,June 30, 1888.
   Revenue collected during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $6,789.52.

                                                       Shipping.                                                              Vessels.       Tonnage.

Foreign entrances.............................................................-                                                         41        4, 92
Foreign clearances ............................................................-                                                        49        6, (88
Coastwise .................................................................... .                                                       556       90, 813


   Total value of merchandise, $851,950, including the following articles:
Coal.       -. -......                     ..........-----....------                                 -             -----.--                  $649, 000
L um ber..                         -   ."......-.-....-.....--  - - - .. . 99, 000
Lime and cement     _---...................---
Stone and sand--------------------------------
                                                                       ----
              ....................................-----------------------  16,500
                                                                                                -         ----                   ---           39,600

Fire-wood                -----..                     ..--                ..-         ..-----                                                     3
                                                                                                                                                :3
                                                                                                                                                 3.- 00--------------..
Hay, tiles, pipes, stone, potatoes and other vegetables, etc---------...                                                  ---------            44, 000

            Total---------------------------------...................................----------------------------...................          851,950




                                                                              B 7.

                     IMPROVEMENT OF BOSTON HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

   Boston Harbor consists essentially of an inner and an outer harbor,
united by a deep water-way, and each accessible from the sea by a dis-
tinct channel, widening into a deep and spacious roadstead.
   1. Inner harbor.-This harbor lies to the north and westward of Long
Island, and has deep water and a good anchorage in the President
Roads, seaward of Lower Middle Bar, and also near the city westward
of Upper Middle Bar.
  Four rivers discharge their waters into this basin: the Charles, Mystic,
and Chelsea rivers from the north, and the Neponset from the south.
The direct eutrance from the sea is by Broad Sound,
448     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   2. Outer harbor.-This harbor lies to the southward of Long Island
and has a fine anchorage in Nantasket Roads, as well as in Hingham
SBay, a well-sheltered harbor southeast of Paddock Island. It connects
with the inner harbor by the main ship-channel through the "Narrows,"
and by secondary channels east and west of Long Island.
    It is reached from the sea by Nantasket Roads, which lie south of
George's and Great Brewster islands, and is marked at the sea entrance
by Boston Light.
    Both the inner and outer harbors are subdivided into several minor
harbors, and contain many islands, which shelter the anchorages from
winds-and storm waves.
    The range of tides at the navy-yard is 9.8 feet, and at the entrance
to the outer harbor 9.4 feet.
    A sketch of the harbor was printed in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for the year 1883, page 454.
    The object of the improvement is, first, to preserve the harbor by pro-
tecting the islands and headlands, and, second, to improve it by widen-
ing, deepening, and straightening the channels.
    The projects adopted for this purpose since 1866 have been mainly in
accordance with the recommendations of the United States commis-
sioners, whose labors terminated during that year.
    The works of preservation consist of sea-walls, aprons, jetties, etc.,
which protect the shores of the islands and headlands, prevent addi-
Sional wash into the channels, control the tidal scour, and preserve the
full height of anchorage shelter for vessels in the roadsteads.
    The works of improvement have been by dredging and blasting.
    The amount which has been appropriated for this improvement to
date is $1,663,750.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1888, was $1,654,020.74 (inclu-
sive outstanding liabilities).

                       WORKS OF PRESERVATION.

   Point Allerton.-This headland, at the southeasterly entrance of the
harbor, is protected by a granite sea-wall 1,202 feet in length. It was
completed in 1873. Its concrete foundation, for a distance of 1,(;05 feet,
is protected by an apron and eight short jetties of granite rubble-stone.
N*o work was done on it during the fiscal year. Its condition June 30,
1888, is as follows: The wall is generally in good order, although some
of its joints should be repointed. The bluff protected by this wall is
not fully covered from storm action, and the sea-wall should be extended
westward for a distance of at least 150 feet, and the foundation of this
extension should be protected with rip-rap.
   This is estimated to cost $15,000.
   Great Brewster Island.-This island is on the north side of the Main
Ship-channel, near the entrance. It is protected by a granite sea-wall
2,840 feet long, which was completed in 1869. During the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, 617 running feet of the coping course were reset
by hired labor at a cost of $2,167.06. On June 30, 1888, the wall was
in good order, although many of the joints should be repointed.
   George's Island.-Its northern and eastern shores are protected by a
granite sea-wall 2,150 feet long. West of this wall a riprap improve-
ment extends for 450 feet, and south of it another 600 feet long. The
sea-wall and southern riprap were built about 1835. The western rip-
rap was built in 1884-'85. No work was done during the fiscal year.
Its condition on June 30, 1888, was as follows; One coping stone of the
           APPENDIX   B--REPORT     OF LIEUT     COL.   GILLESPIE.     449

sea-wall was thrown from the wall and eight others were loosened by
storm action; they will require resetting. This work is estimated to cost
$300. The unprotected western shore line of the island, in front of the
Government buildings, was considerably abraded; the high-water line
had been moved back in places nearly 25 feet. This shore-line should
be p)rotected by a light sea-wall, 1,400 feet long, at a cost of $35,000, or
at least by a stone apron, at a cost of $10,000.
   Lovell's 1sland.-The western shore of this island is protected by a
rubble-stone apron 975 feet long, built in 1873 and repaired and extended
in 1884; the northern shore is covered by a granite sea-wall 750 feet
long, built in 1843, and the eastern shore is protected by a gra..te sea-
wall 800 teet long, built in 1869 and repaired in 1879 and in 1886, and by
two rubble-stone aprons, one between the northern andl eastern sea-walls
1,440 feet long and the other south of the east sea-wall 1,330 feet long.
No operations were in progress during the fiscal year. The condition
of the works June 30, 1888, was as follows: The sea-walls and the rip-
raps on the eastern shore were in good order; the western-shore riprap
had been undermined in places, and had fallen down, but it needed no
innediate repairs.
   Gallop's lsland.-The western, northern, and eastern shores of this
ish ind are protected by a granite sea-wall 1,785, feet long, completed in
1871, and by a rubble-stone apron completed in 1881, 3,050 feet long,
which also covers the foundation of the sea-wall. No operations were
in progress during the fiscal year, and at its close, June 30, 1888, the
wall and riprap were in good order. To more completely protect the
northwestern bluff of this island, which has been very seriously abraded
by storms, especially during the past winter, the sea-wall should be ex-
tended about 300 feet to the southward. This it is estimated will cost
$15,000.
    Deer Island.-The three prominent bluffs of this island are protected by
granite sea-walls originally built about 1827. The north head wall is
1,740 feet long; the middle head wall is 840 feet, and the south head
wall is 380 feet long. In 1865 and 1869 these walls were partly rebuilt,
and in the weakest places were backed with concrete. They were all
originally built dry, and from time to time have required repairs. Dur-
ing the fiscal year some of the joints of the south and middle head wall
were repainted, at a cost of $426.45.
   On June 30, 1888, the south and middle head walls were in fair order;
some repairs to the north head wall were needed, a few feet of the cop.
ing course have been loosened, and part of the paving in rear of the
walls needs resetting.
    Long Island. The north head of this island is protected by a granite
sea-wall 2,081a feet long, completed in 1874. Part of the foundation of
the sea-wall, and of the beach at both of its ends are protected by a
rubble-stone apron, aggregating 1,375 feet in length. This apron was
built in 1874 and extended in 1884. No operations were in progress
during the fiscal year. On June 30, 1888, the wall needed to be re-
pointed in places, the riprap was in fair order and should be extended
about 250 feet to more fully protect the southeastern shore; these repairs
and extensions are estimated to cost $3,000.
   Rainsford Island.-The north head of this island is protected by a
dry granite sea-wall 1,500 feet long, originally built about 1840, and
extensively repaired in 1884-'85.
   No work was done during the year, and on June 30, 1888, the wall was
in good order and needed no repairs.
   CastleIsland.-The    north and part of the east and west shores of this
        ENG 88       29
450    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

island are protected by a dry granite sea-wall 3,300 feet long, built in
1835. A light riprap extends along the east shore 300 feet from the
end of the sea-wall; this was built in 1865.
   No work was done during the fiscal year, and on June 30, 1888, the
riprap was in good order; the sea-wall needed repairs on the north
face, a short distance west of the wharf, where the foundation has been
undermined and the wall has settled. About 100 running feet of the
wall has been thus injured, and this length of wall needs to be taken
down and rebuilt, at a cost of about $1,000.
   Governor's Island.-The shore-line of this island has never been pro-
tected. The east and south bluffs, however, should be covered by sea-
walls to prevent any additional abrasion, not only to secure the sites of
the important heavy batteries occupying these bluffs, but also to pre-
vent injury to the Main Ship-channel. The east bluff wall should be
500 feet long, and is estinlated to cost $30,000; the south bluff wall
should be 1,800 feet long, and will cost $50,000.
                      WORKS OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The 111ain Ship-channel.-Before improvement it had a least width of
100 feet, and a least depth of 18 feet at mean low water. The general
project for its improvement was submitted in 1867; it proposed to
dredge the channel 23 feet deep at mean low water, 1,000 feet wide at
the " Upper" and Lower Middles" and 685 feet wide at the " Narrows."
In 1870 the proposed width at the "Narrows" was reduced to 625 feet,
and increased to 1,100 at Anchorage Shoal in the inner harbor. In
1887 it was proposed to straighten the passage through the "Narrows"
by cutting off a spur that projected from Lovells Island, and was esti.
mated to contain 20,000 cubic yards.
  During the fiscal year' ending June 30, 1888, operations have been in
progress under a contract with Mr. J. E. Chapman, dated March 19,
1887, to dredge from the 1 Lower," "Middle," and "1Narrows" 44,000
cubic yards. This contract on January 2, 1888, was extended and en-
larged to cover the removal of a total of 914,000 yards. Operations un-
der this contract were commenced October 25, 1887, and during the
year 65,576 yards were dredged from the " Lower Middle" and 3,430
yards from the "Narrows," or a total of 69,006 cubic yards dredged
under the contract. The contract was closed before completion by
mutual consent, June 6, 1888, which was approved by the Secretary of
War, June 13, 1888, in order that funds might be available to immedi-
ately remove three small ledges which had been developed by the
dredging at the "Lower Middle." The existence of these ledges by
their position in the channel almost completely nullified the advantages
which had been gained by the dredging. The ledges contain 300 cubic
yards, approximately, above the plane of 23. feet below mean low water,
and the least depth on them is 17 feet.
  On June 22, 1888, a contract was entered into with Mr. G. W. Town-
send, of Boston, Mass., for the removal of these ledges, at $22 per cubic
yard. This contract was approved by the Chief of Engineers June 26,
1888, and operations under it will be commenced by the contractor early
in July, 1888.
   On June 30, 1888, the condition of the Main Ship-channel was as fol-
lows: It was 23 feet deep at mean low water, 1,100 feet wide west of
the " Upper Middle," 600 feet wide at the " Upper Middle," 1,000 feet
wide at the " Lower Middle," 625 feet wide at the " Narrows."
   From the " Narrows" to the entrance of the harbor no detailed sur-
vey of the channel has been made, but it is known that it is obstructed
by ledges and shoals, especially off Nash's Rock, where the available
         APPENDIX    B-REPORT OF LIEUT.          COL. GILLESPIE.       451
-width (full 23 feet deep) is less than 500 feet. In effecting this improve-
ment, dredging and blasting were done at the following places:
   At Nash's Rock Shoal during the years 1876-1878, 365 cubic yards of
ledge were removed.
   At Kelly's Rock and Shoal during the years 1869-1879, 222 cubic yards
of ledge were removed.
    Tower Corwin and Channel Rocks were removed during the years
1867-1875. They aggregated 608( cubic yards.
   From the west end of the Brewster Spit, during the years 1874-1876
29,226 cubic yards of sand and gravel were dredged and 935 cubic yards
of ledge were removed.
   At Lovell's Island, from the southeast and southwest points, 267,294k
cubic yards were dredged during the years 1867-1877; and from a spur
between these points 3,430 cubic yards were dredged in 1888.
   At Castle Island Bar and Shoal, opposite the Lower Middle, during
the years 1880-1883, 36,957 cubic yards were dredged and 20 tons of
rock were removed.
   At the Lower Middle, in 1874-1875, State and Palmyra rocks were re-
moved. They aggregated 62 cubic yards. In 1887-1888, 65,576 cubic
yards were dredged from this shoal.
   At the Upper Middle, during the years 1870-1876, 268,278k cubic yards
were dredged and 1181 cubic yards of ledge were removed.
   At Anchorage Shoal, during the years 1879-1882, 65,327 cubic yards
were dredged.
   At Man-of-War Shoal, 85,917 cubic yards were dredged in the years
1878-1880.
   At Mystic River Shoal, during the years 1879-1882, 82,082 cubic yards
were dredged. To complete the present project for the improvement of
the Main Ship-channel, 687,500 cubic yards must be dredged from the
Upper Middle, in the inner harbor, at an estimated cost of $250,000, and
17,000 ebic yards from the Narrows, in the lower harbor, at an esti-
mated cost of $5,000. A detailed survey of the lower harbor from Long
Island to the sea should be made, the bottom carefully examined to
reveal all obstructive ledges, and current observations taken. This
survey will demand three or four months field work, and will cost, it is
estimated, not less than $6,000.
   The improvements by dredging both in the inner and outer harbor
have been remarkably well maintained and show no essential deteriora-
tion, with the exception of the dredging done at the western end of Great
Brewster Spit, or the eastern entrance of the "Narrows."            Here, as
shown by the latest surveys, the condition of the entrance is almost ex-
actly what it was previous to the dredging. To propose a project for
the further improvement of this outer part of the Main Ship-channel
will require continued study, and the collection by surveys of additional
information. It may involve a radical change in the location of the
channel to the south and west of George's Island, or at least indicate
how a new channel may be opened to the westward at comparatively
small expense for the relief of the existing over-crowded channel through
the Narrows.
   In addition to these improvement of the Main Ship-channel through
the inner and outer harbor, dredging and blasting have been done in
the following tributary channels:
                           I.-CHARLES RIVER.

  This river enters the inner harbor near the navy-yard at CharlestoIn.
Before improvement the natural channel had, as far up as We-tern
452    REPORT   OF   THE   CHIEF   OF ENGINEERS,   U. S. ARMY.

Avenue Bridge, 4@ miles from its mouth, 7 feet depth at mean low watery
except in several places covering about 11 miles in extent below
Brookline Street Bridge, where the depth varied from 4) to 7 feet.
From Western Avenue Bridge up to Arsenal Street Bridge (2- miles),
there was a depth of 4 feet, mean low water; thence to Market Street
Bridge (g mile) 2- feet at mean low water, and thence to the dam at
the head of tide-water (1( miles), a depth varying from 0 to 9. feet
above mean low water. The mean rise or fall of the tide is 10 feet. A
sketch showing the river was published in the Chief of Engineer's Re-
port for 1884, page 512.
   The project for the improvement of this river consists in straighten-
ing, widening, and deepening the natural channel, so that it should be,.
from its mouth to Western Avenue Bridge, 7 feet deep at mean low
water and 200 feet wide; from Western Avenue Bridge to Market
Street Bridge, 6 feet deep at mean low water and 80 feet wide, and
thence to the dam at head of tide-water 60 feet wide and 2 feet deep at
mean low water.
   The estimated cost of this improvement was originally $85,000. But
a revised estimate was submitted in 188L of $125,000.
   The total appropriations for this improvement to date have been
$57,500. The total expenditures to June 30, 1888, were $57,378.99.
   No operations were in progress during the fiscal year, and the condi-
tion of the improvement June 30, .1888, is as follows: The projected
channel had been completed from the mouth of the river to Arsenal
Street Bridge (74 miles); work was stopped at this point for the reason
that the draws and piers of this bridge do not conform to the projected
channel above it. In effecting this improvement 127,971 cubic yards
Were dredged during the years 1880-1884.
   This improvement, even if the project were completed, is not regarded
as an important benefit to commerce, for the conditions which exist on
the lower reach of the river between Boston, Cambridge, and Charles-
town make navigation of most any kind extremely expensive, slow, and
difficult. Seven railroad and municipal bridges now exist on this lower
part of the river, and an eighth is being built on the extension of West
Chester Park street, under authority of a State act. No recommienda-
tion is made for the continuation of the improvement. The funds avail-
able July 1, 1888, will be expended in surveys and examinations of the
work.
                       II.-FORT POINT CHANNEL.

   This channel is situated between the eastern shore of Boston lproper
on the one side, and the reclaimed and improved flats of South Boston
and South Boston o the other side. It connects the tidal basin of
South Bay, which has an area of 250 acres, with Boston inner harbor;
is fast becomning the center of the city's most extensive shipping trade
and is the most important branch of the Main Ship-channel. Fort Point
Channel is 14 miles long. Before improvement the least depth at mean
low water was 12 feet at its entrance and 17 feet above Congress Street
Bridge. That part of it which it is proposed to improve is spanned by
bridges at Congress street, Mt. Washington avenue, and at an inter-
mediate point. These bridges have conveniently located draw open-
ings, but the draw-piers of the railroad bridge must be strengthened or
reconstructed before the improvement can be extended past them, and
the width of the draw increased to that of the other bridges above and
below it. The project for this improvement was submitted January 27,
1885, Annual Report Chief of Engineers, 1885, page 545. It proposed.
        APPENDIX    B -REPORT     OF LIEUT.    COL.   GILLESPIE.    453
the excavation of a channel 175 wide and 23 feet deep at mean low
water from the entrance to near Federal Street Bridge, a distance of
4,100 feet and was estimated to cost $100,000; the railroad bridge to
be constructed at the expense of the owners.
   By the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886, the sum of $18,750
was appropriated for the improvement of that part of the channel lying
below Congress Street Bridge.
   The total expenditures to June 30, 1888, were $17,439.50.
   No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
No operations were in progress during the fiscal year, and the condition
of the improvement on June 30, 1888, was as follows: The channel had
been dredged as proposed from its entrance to Congress Street Bridge,
a distance of 1,900 feet; 94,211 cubic yards were removed effecting this
improvement dpring the year 1897.
   The funds available July 1, 1888, will be expended in examinations
of the work. To complete the improvement as proposed to Federal
Street Bridge will cost $60,000, and an appropriation for this purpose
is recommended applicable only after the railroad-bridge draw shall
have been properly reconstructed.

                         III.-HINGHAM HARBOR.

  See separate report.

                   IV.-NANTASKET BEACH CHANNEL.

   This is a small channel along the east side of Hingham or Hull basin.
It leads to a wharf on the west side of the heel of Nantasket Beach,
about 12 miles from Boston.
   Before improvement it was approximately 100 feet wide and had a
depth of at least 11 feet, except at the eastern end, 1,500 feet from the
wharf, where the width was reduced to 40 to 50 feet, and the depth to
less than 8 feet. It was circuitous, and obstructed by bowlders at the
mouth of Weir River, and by a ledge near the wharf. The project adopt-
ed in 1880 was to widen and deepen the channel from the mouth of
Weir River to the steam-boat wharf, so that it would be 100 feet wide
and 9) feet deep, mean low water; to remove a few bowlders at the
mouth of Weir River, and to remove the ledge near the wharf.
   The total appropriations and allotments for this work to date have
been $11,750.
   The total expenditures to June 30, 1888, were $11,750.
   No operations were in progress during the fiscal year, and the condi-
'tion of the improvement June 30, 1888, was as follows: The projected
channel had been completed by the removal of 41,922 cubic yards of
material dredged, and 51 cubic yards of ledge blasted, during the years
1881-1883. The improvement meets the present demands of commerce,
and no further appropriation is required at this time.

        V.--CHkNNEL BETWEEN NIX'S MATE AND LONG ISLAND.

   This is a channel through the bar which extends from the north head
of Long Island to Nix's Mate Shoal. Previous to the improvement
there was 41 feet depth of water on the bar at mean low tide. The
project for the improvement was adopted in 1883. It was to dredge a
channel 200 feet wide, 12 feet deep at mean low water, and about 550
feet long. In 1887 it was recommended that thle axis of the cut be
454         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

shifted 300 to the westward, and that it be widened to 300 feet, 15 feet-
deep at mean low water.
   The original project was estimated to cost $9,000. The project of
1887 was estimated to cost $25,000.
   No specific appropriation has been made for this work.
   The expenditures on it to June 30, 1888, from the appropriation for
the improvement of Boston Harbor, have been for dredging $9,551.76.
   No operations were in progress during the fiscal year, and the condi-
tion of the improvement June 30, 1888, was as follows:
   The original project had been completed by the removal of 19,899-
cubic yards of material during the fiscal year 1884.
   The latest survey shows that this channel has retained its full width
and deepened throughout 1 foot approximately.
   The channel has been of the greatest service to the vessels and boats
which ply to the wharves of the lower harbor, and has conferred a great
lbenefit upon commerce by diminishing the number of passages of me-
dium craft through the '"Narrows," where the channel is narrow and
overburdened and the currents transverse and irregular.                                                    These ad-
vantages will be largely increased so soon as the modified project of
1887 shall have been completed, and an appropriation or allotment is
recommended for this purpose.

                                            VI.-BROAD SOUND.

   An obstruction called Barrel Rock, lying on the north side of the
Broad Sound Channel, was removed in 1869. It contained 116 cubic
yards.
   The balance available July 1, 1888, $8,297.75, will be expended in re-
moving the group of three ledges which obstruct the main ship channel
at the eastern end of the Lower Middle Bar. No appropriation was
made for this harbor for the fiscal year en(ling June 30, 1888. The
river and harbor bill for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1889, contains
at item for Boston Harbor of $125,000. Should this sum be appropri-
ated by the Fiftieth Congress, first session, it will be mainly applied
towards widening the channel at the Upper Middle Bar, and towards
extending and repairing sea-walls, and by so much will reduce the
amount, $449,000, estimated in this report as required for the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1889.

            RECAPITULATION                  OF APPROPRIATIONS                        RECOMMENDED.

  The amount recommended for exl)enditure for impl)rovements in Bos-
ton Harbor, Mass., during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 are as
follows:
Extension of sea-water at George's Island..-............................                                     .    $10,000
Extension of sea-wall at Gallop's Island.................................---------------------------------..       15, 000
Extension, etc., of sea-wall at Long Island................................                                         3, 000
Sea-walls at South and East Bluffs of Governor's Island...................                                        80,000
Widening Main Ship-Channel at the " Upper Middle 1'------...--..................
Completing Fort Point Channel ...........................-..---.........
                                                                                                                 250, 000
                                                                                                                   60,000
Widening and deepening Nix's Mate Channel .......................                   ....     25, 000
Survey of Main Ship-Channel east of Long Island Head------------------................... -6,0004
        Total........                       ".     ......                             ..---- .........
                                                                                 ...--------
                                                                             ............                ....    $449,000,
  The several works completed and projected for improvement of this harbor are
located in the collection district of Boston and Charlestown, Mass. Boston is the port,
of entry.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           -.   ..   .        .             :               .;,_                                                                               ,,, ir.


                                                                                     . ;.II:                                    FLATS.


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      1'
                                                                              ;    "." "
                                                                                   .:"'                   .     .     .         .       .        BEACON.                                       4
                                                                                                                                                                        22            12
                                                                     69                                                         116              1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  ;Y   "•
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       ""          '.    .   -   . ,        .   , , .-                                 -.-     31
                3O                                                            13
                     34                                                                                                                                                 20

                                                                    18                         14,                                                                                                  12
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 ''~ !,..,.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        !. ,        '
                30                                                                                                                                                                 C.                                                                    .,       : lb..         .          71$
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              -.                                        - "829              ,,                AA'.:.!
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             18
                          37                                                  15                                                                                        22.        .O                                                                                      z27
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           15                                                              --
          28                                                                                                                                                                       16.1        19
                               25                                        20                1
                                     25        24                                                                                                                                                                           29
                     28                                                                                                                                    29
                                29
                                          24                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        26
                      28
                                                                                                                                                                                                                            40
                                                    27                                                                                                                                                                           26        28
                                                              27
                                                                                                                                                                        is5




                                                                              19a                                                                                is
                                                                    19                         19                                                    .19                      12           2                                                                                                                                                                                             36
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      18                                                                                                                              34,
                                                                   I H                                    .     .         . .       .   .    .         .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    2C        26


               20
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                6                12              16

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              19
                                                                                                          BOSTON                                                              HARBOR                                                                                                                                                              12


                                                                                                                                                     ass achus etf                         s                                                                                                                                                                     'i


                                                                                                      THE MAIN                                             SHIP                       CHANNEL                                                                                                                                                         14,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       10
                                                                                                               ABOVE                                 LOWEII                             MIDDLE
           ~   12
                                                                                                                          Showin                      proposed improvements

                                                                                                                          TO    ACCOMPANY                            ANNUAL           REPORT          OF
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      NOTE   THESOUNDINGS , IN FEET, REFER TO MEAN LOW WATERS
                                                                                                    IT. COL. GEO. L. GILLESPIE , CORPS OF EYGRS. U.SA.                                                                                ADD .9. "    ' ORMEAN          WATER.                             H/6H
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      AREAS    SHADED    THUS             HAVE BEEN DREDGEI)
                                                                                                                                                                     1888.                                                             TO 23 FT ) THOSE CROSS LINED THUS                ARE

                                                                                                                                                                      MAP     1:15,000
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      PROPOSED TO      ,E DREDGED   TO 23 F7 (MN. L.                                                                   W.)
                                                                                                                                            SCALE               OF
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      DREDGED AREAS MARED         WITH M HAVE BEEN EXCAVATED
                                                                                                    100         500         0                          10(0
                                                                                                                                                          it
                                                                                                                                                                               2000                 300           400'Fet
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      BY THE STATE.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       THREE    LEDGES AT THE LOWER MIDDLE, UNCOVERED BY
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      DREDGING, ARE I/ PROCESS OP REMOVAL          UNDER CON-
                                                         %%
                                                                                                              U. S. NGIA9EE!?                OFFICE, BOSTON, MASS. JULY 20. 1888.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      TRACT   DATED   JU/VE 22 ,.2888.
                                                                                                              RESPECTFULLY                  FORWARDED     WITH LETTER OF THIS DATE
                                                                                                              TO THE CHIEF                  OF AWGINEERS., WASHINGTON , D.C.

    x/
                                                                                                                                                                                           LT. CO. .0,-    ENI   EERS .



Eng50 2
1r
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              --
                                                                                                                   _.T~~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           G

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 li                                                                                                  1                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          t

                       B OSTON                                                  HARBOR                                                  MASS.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  Suandtrf c
                                              PLAN
          WORKS OF PRESERVATION AND IMPROVEMENT
                                                                   SHOWING LOCATION                                                   OF
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 U. S. EMS/VNEER                                                      OrrICt
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Me'a r'e
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  fall  of" ide
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          are in feet aizd refer to mean low wate,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           or
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          is
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  {9.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   4 ft. in
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 9.8        .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              LoLwer
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Jper
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      Harbor
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      Sea wal
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      Bip - rap
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ar' indicatod
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         .hore potec     t z'ns
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  thus :
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ,, :....
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    40
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              3"
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              *w            THE BRA hVES
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  Areas shaded t hu              arxe beens dredged                                                                                                                                                   Rocks and                           Iz'dyw removed                                                                   .           " +                                                                                                                          57                                        .0.1




     MADE AND PROPOSED BY THE TJNITED STATES GOVERNMENT                                                                                                                                                                                          RESPECrru/LLY FOWARDEo
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       sosTON,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           WITH  ETrn
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             MASS.                   JULY           10           1888.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       OF              HIS
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  -.o a. depth of 23 feet at
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  those nzrked with
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             mcan low water;
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           M Iave Aeeir excavated                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               55
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       26   UD1


                    FROM                 1825         TO           DATE ,AND                           OF IMPROVEMENTS                                                      BY                                                                   DATE 7" rt  CHIEF oF ENGINEERS, WAS/Hl                                                                                   TO
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        D.    C.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  6y zte State .                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             42
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            68
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  Areas shaded     thus   VE         [it A proposed to                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    49
                       STATE                  HARBOR AND LAND COMMISSIONERS                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               LT. COL.                 OF EN/NEERS.                                                   dredye                       to          a    depth               of          23         f   ,        at         mean                    low         water                                                                                                                                                                                                                     I                  54                                       49
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   6O
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        ,m ,./

                                                                              SINCE           1866.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        45/                                                                       50
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               4-1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       46
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         4.5                  4-7                                                                            .9                                                                                         1
                                                                                         1888,,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                56




             A
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    29
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              41                                                    40                                                                      69



I                                  1"   --      -'
                                                                    SCALE
                                                                    2"
                                                                                    0F    PLAN
                                                                                         4 -..
                                                                                                        1o000.
                                                                                                                    - .     .             9                u,0.oo,.F.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                38




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   2.16T
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 S4                                                        4t

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       27
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                t6                            32




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  /7.3729
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             I442
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           40
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        36


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           4    f
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              49
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    5                  47



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   r



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    31                                                                                                           61
                                                                                                          Zi.,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   S                                                                                                                                                                                                                     £9
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        57                                                    +7                                                                 $ I t          I*RS                                                                                                                                                              1 54.           -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            i 64,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           102                                                                                                                                                                                  t                             23'7                                                 SDGAS
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     . ,.                        .     .       .. '.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             .v ,Y.4: ..-                                                                                            ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           947
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      2-.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       6                                                     s"5     'f                                    \                                  -                                            /
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    27
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   -=
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    .

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  -                                                              TUWKSBURY
                                                                                                                                                                                                                   d,041                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         N             S44 4,9                     46                                          5,              ROO


                                                          , N.                                                                                                                                                      ..-t4              '..toy          :                                     .'.;.-:.-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        N' o        w-                                                            5                          So


                                                                                                                                                                            . • ,               -
                                                                                                                                                                                                    ..
                                                                                                                                                                                                              ...:..-.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                            $          .I:t."
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            :     .     .-. C.-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       0o                                                        .   4:                                       '"                                                           ......                                                                                                                  S                        r.t".',4/                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                tGb4?3so55
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           119
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    / 40                                                                              44
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      46
                                                                                                        ,M                                                     "        ". ..                                 . ._....
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ,,.....                                                                                                   ..     -                                    "".\.t-.:-" .-                                                                                              A It.,4                                                                                                    2±            C,                                                 22.(                                       pg                                        /
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         .t1+                                                                                                                                                                                                                       1..t1)                                          4        20                                                                          27
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             15                  -                         V18                                                                                                     6                                  N,(.il
                                                                                                                                                                                                ...            "     :      .' .       9     :" '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            ':         "       "       •    .            . . ...                          •.       .-.       ,       -. 9" .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   "
                                                                         ,    N\"                                                                              :,,.                                            .    "      • • • •-":             ..   "                   - •" ••: " ••t o"                                                       " " '.
                                                                          \                Q                                     IlIT                           , \ \\ \ '                     . .
                                                                                                                                                                                            " t-i                        .,',,,''':.              -    ."''                 .-   "•        ..                             .         .            .1.4• '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               .;_.,                                                                                                                          in                                    -              5                                                                3"4.Z2
                                                                                                                                                           \   't •ff "                    ..            ":'tir,                        ::::.I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        I.. .  " ."                                                                                                                                    ..            17                                                4                                                                                                                                                                                            19L                                                            21%i /


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       ". ..                                                              __ __       .                                                                                     1                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          49                                           -    .                 5
                                                                                                                            N1sr                           ,it-s..                                                                      k!~%A                                   .                              1 , . . .....
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              ,:. s,,.;. ...:....                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         9     S.427'3 .:4                                                                                       _'
                                                                                                             1                                   r",,:::                •-           .. ..,...,,,., ..
                                                                                                                                                                                                     36,                                   .,y..,,,.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            ,,                               ,, ;...:.7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ;.W"..::.G, .0 .,.;...                                   0                 r22                                    EE                                                                        2b                      -',                                                      ti36 o                       7            ~/           6.        ~             B*                  274/                                                                                                          4



                                                                                                                                        2.7           ,.                                           ..
                                                                                                                                                                                 may ... _ -: . - :-.
                                                                                                                                                                                                    1...2:
                                                                                                                                                                                                    .  : r -'
                                                                                                                                                                                                      .:t                                                                      . .,,..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            > /o                        .    .        "I "     10,           .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             _:....
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         .....  OS                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          '£6                  1         5             20
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          2
                                                                                                                                                                                      "                                     27 . "         _ "" ); :;;"'" 7 -;.15              " " :.'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               . ,,, ,I: . . ":..-   .'.. ,-                                                 . .t      "'.-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      7 ::'
                                                                                                                                                                                                           ":'      -.      :'[;
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        321
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          10;f             m                                                                                35                           5421,                   lo                                  58               79 150/ 18.3-16
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               / /A , G                                                            ;      , -           ." "              4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   4-                 'S
                                                                                           366 4AT                                                                                                                                                             05                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         11                                                         2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    42                      /20/L7"                                                                           0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      4

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         '"tal       .ta       4-                     .        OSW           LiT.33
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     28                                                     2,                "R                                                                                   55         ,=,67                                                            87                                             7.           ..             . .           s                     "               ,            1
                                                                                                          2825-±
                                                                                                            N.,                                 \_"
                                                                                                                                                           0,4                                  °
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               PAR":y ;):
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  D                        r               g                               9_
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                44-        27o524-S            73                       ?             ./
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     L(
                                                                                                                                              \/"                           . ::''.::..'.".
                                                                                                                                                                                       ' #,                                       r.:                  ,...
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          P                                                 -1                 ,.i                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                5
                                                                                                                                is24-                                                      L~&~                                  42
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      2                                                                    17             '/        2'9                7           DE                       -2:"..-"                                                                                                                       .:.                ..                                                                                 ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              l :.....           ":                  ..       .,     10                                :8           4t- 28                          Q                   34"

                                                                                                                                                      •                     ,,       .-.                       .                                                   .    .       .                  .    i                                        -

     Eg                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               ,.-5S4                                          3.....0                                    ,...,.                                ^'."                                                                                                                                   os,                                            &
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             "                               .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         40343
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             _ ,
                             C:                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    434

                                                                       rER"..
                                                                    Wq.:::...                    LOW                                                  "'by".,,-,                      -MEAN                                                                                         .-        '        -. S1          ,,-. "1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 _,.                             26                     16         1                                                        3S                          54                 2    8 3        6,$0                                                       ,         ...                               >                                                       -       8        /27l                               .4.4                                   1- Q4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    it                   -"             ,,Z.54'3241

                                                                  0.
                                                                  t         rosr                                   PLUG
                                                                                                          COPPER'.""-                                                   -                                                  '            ....it         :.::oron.e           .a,,.i
                                                                                                                                                  "movE-- MEAN"             LOW".'                                                                              .. w. .;• ,. ' :',,,, 'qrre..•.                                                      8,¢      ,i , ,1 .v           28.;;,..,t,.                ,
                                                              .         LEDGE.
                                                                   (U.&c.S..).CtyctE.
                                                                     I.A:.'..,        cur:                                                                                                                                                             ,"n                  .                         3*4 .-.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    .. ..v ,., " ".'::':"   ':?%                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     YS     415              25                                        ,27.%                          ,.1 1
                                                                    ABOVE'                                                        air"/,1,:;,... ..",,,.
                                                                                                                           25;.o.a'"-                                                                         ". .S .'                                         8" . .                 . .-,                                   "E"                    . .. :t                                                     24,4-            2G3                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                441l.                                                   tGbg4~
                                                                  .-.
                                                              E,-..R                                                                                                         . . -,
                                                                                                                                                                                 •    .    -' '          •"
                                                                                                                                                                                                              ,.." . ',:. . , .'''.,, : " . • " . • ' i-: ; "
                                                                                                                                                                                                               ".    "      ',    --    -,".    ..-        -       -. ".:',          . "          ".
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       2         -e ?:
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            : .. " -,,,';'               .   4.0-..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               :-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               •* ....       •    "
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             3                                                                                                         6                                             z
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    8
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     ]-$            o
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    J                                                                                     '4:4"                '       0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          "M7,b.4"28.8                              ,-b

                         '                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           39
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             31 2               7                 2                    2202


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          ,.2.                                                                                                                                        -.    .           o.52,.                                                                                                                                                                     l
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     (ft%''                                                                                    47                                             a"                                                                                                                                     413l

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         9
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         2                                     a74           o                     -'::"
     Elg                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            .0..                                                                                                      a29               335                                                                                "7s1                                                                                                         34        so %1                                                                2      _ .,       :-" ""

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    2b.                                    ..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Nor2h.ea-- o-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             29                 7            OSP/          44          +                2+                                                                                                                                                                                     to... bou"da"                              lieid.t
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            .,.:-                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   -              9                                                                 0
             BENCHMARKS.
              1n CNARL(7SOwn
             IS   14.69 FErT    A
                                 . 7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     17,17                   "",\                           .'.       " -49

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      28
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                2,8.                         3IN                     $

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  4..11.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           14                                                     17
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      t
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Ceorqer                            '            --.              }"en-tir
             AT LOVELL'S /SLAJ/
             /    17.  ,yFEETA
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          -V.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                43:                    f            :-         -
             A 7 " B OS T
                           O N L t 16 HT3o f
                                             T    W S '   4
             340 r. wre      Or A                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       ..                    -V                      .                      2i                                                    41S
            MWEAN    LOW     W/AT
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               -                                                                              .- .    ,/.42-',"                                                                                                                                      2        1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             walls.
           502                      t
                                                                                                                            \g
                                                                                                                                ./.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               ,::c.o
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  _       _     _
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      ._
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       _        _
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      _______
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ~~~21    :J      1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     r    -    QrNb .A? .-    _
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               46                                     n
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           -a                                                  and
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    .. . ..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 the            s 6 '[.s               at   fthe.tea



     Eng50 2                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             -



                                                                                                                                                      1
                 APPENDIX B-REPORT                                        OF LIEUT.               COL. GILLESPIE.                     455
  The accompanying commercial statistics for the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1888, have been furnished by the collector of customs at Bos-
ton, Mass.
                                                              Money statement.

July     1, 1887, amount available.........-......-......-......-...                    ........    $34,712.42
July     1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of    liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887-----------------...................--... $23,396.04
July     1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..-.....................                      1,587.12
July     1,1888, amount covered by existing contracts...........                        6,600.00
                                                                                                 --  31,583.16

July 1, 1888, balance available..- -.......-........................-----------....
                                             -....                                                                               3, 129.26
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.........................                                                         125,000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...................                                                       128, 129.26

  SAmount  (estimated) required for completion of existing project-....... 325, 000. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 325, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




Abstract of proposalsfor the renmoral of rock from the main ship channel,Boston Harbor,
  Massachusetts, opened May 12, 1888, by Lieut. Col. G. L. Gillespie, Corps of Engineers.


                                                                                                               Price bid
                                                                                                               per cubic
No.                                              Names of bidders.                                            yard, meas.-     Remarks.
                                                                                                                ured in
                                                                                                                 situ.

  1     George W. Townsend .............................................                                            $22 00     Lowest bid.
  2     Thomas A. Rowe .................................................                                             23.75
  3     W. I). Duncan & Nickerson. N. E. Gordon .......................                                             31.00
  4     IHiramW. Phillips.................................................                                          50. 00
  5     Thomas Symonds..                   .   ............     ...............................                     25. 50



The contract was awarded to Mr. George W. Townsend, with the approval of the
Chief of Engineers.




Transaction of conm'nerce and navigation at the port of Boston during the fiscal year ending
                                      June 30, 1888.
Importations :
    Merchandise...............................................$63,                                                                 897, 778
    Coin and bullion ..............................................                                                                $47,375
Domestic exportations:
    Merchandise......................................                                                 ...........             $55, 515,863
    Coin and bullion .............................................                                                             .     none.
Foreign exportations (returned exports):
    Merchandise................ ........                           ..........................                                   . $974, 720
    Coin and bullion ..............................................                                                                  none.
Vessels entered from foreign ports:
    Number .....................................................                                                                      2, 467
    Tonnage .......................................                                           ............                       1, 321,167
Vessels cleared for foreign ports:
       Number ....................................................                                                                   2, 379
    Tonnage ................        .................................                                                            1,099,899
Total customs collections from all sources ..........................                                                       $21,396,776.15
456     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                       B 8.
          IMPROVEMENT OF MALDEN RIVER, MASSACHUSETTS.

   Malden River is tributary to Mystic River, into which it empties, 3
miles from the mouth, at the navy-yard in Boston Harbor, Massa-
chusetts.
   Previous to its improvement there was a navigable depth of barely 7
feet at mean high water, and the mean rise or fall of the tide is 9.8 feet.
   The object of the improvement is to increase the width and depth of
the river channel from its mouth to the second bridge in Malden, a dis-
tance of 2 miles.
   The project was originally proposed in 1880. It was to excavate a
channel 100 feet wide and 12 feet deep at mean high water, up to the
second bridge in Malden, with two cut-offs, one east of the island near
the mouth of the river and one through the marsh, about one-half mile
above.
   The project was modified in 1882, when it was proposed to make the
natural channel of the river 100 feet wide, 12 feet deep at mean high
water, to the first bridge in Malden, thence to the second bridge, 75 feet
wide, with the same depth. The cost of the original project was esti-
mated to be $40,000.
   The total appropriations for the work to date are $10,000.
   The total expenditures to June 30, 1888, were $ 10,000.
   The condition of the improvement June 30, 1888, was as follows:
    The channel had a least width of 50 feet (it was 70 feet wide at turns)
and had a depth of 12 feet at mean high water from its mouth to the
first bridge in Malden, a distance of 14 miles.
    No work was done during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
    The improved channel is in good order and meets all the existing de-
mands of commerce.
    No appropriation is recommended for the year ending June 30, 1890.
    There is no balance available July 1, 1888.
  Malden River is in the collection district of Boston, Mass. The nearest port of
entry is Boston, Mass. The nearest light4ouse is Long Island head-light in Boston
Harbor, Massachusetts, about 7 miles distant.
  (Commercial statistics included in Boston Harbor, Massachusetts.)


                                        B g.
         IMPROVEMENT OF HINGHAM HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

   Hingham Harbor is situated in the southern part of Hingham or Hull
Basin, which comprises all that part of Boston Lower Harbor south of
Nantasket Roads. It is distant about 12 miles from Boston in a south-
easterly direction.
   The harbor covers an area of 1 square mile, with extensive mud fiats
bare at low tide. The mean rise or fall of the tide is 9.4 feet.
   The channel leading to Hingham south of Ragged and Sailor's isl-
ands was, before improvement, very narrow and crooked and ob-
structed by sunken rocks and shoals. Its least width was 30 feet, and
least depth 4 feet at mean low water.
   The of ject of its improvement is to widen and deepen the natural
b nnel from deep water near the head of the harbor to the steam-boat
wh arf, a distance of about 2,500 feet.
          HINGHAM HARBOR,MASS.
            TO   ACCOMPANY          ANNUAL    REPORT         OF


          LT. COL. GEO. L.                   GILLESPIE
                  CORPS       OF ENGINEERS, U.S.A.
                                  1888




                                NOTE  THE SOUNDINGS IN FEET REFER
                               TO MEAN LOW WATER, WHCH IS ,9. 4
                             FT BELOW THE BEACH, A COPPER BOLT IN
                         THE LEDGE NEAR STEAMBOAT        WHARF.
                        THE MEAN RISE OR FALL OF TIDE     /S 9. SFT
                     THE AREA SHADED          THUS           WAS EXCAV.
             /     ATED TO     'FT.M.L. W. I/N 1874 -75, &   SS.
                  THE AREA SHADED THUS                WAS    BLASTED
                THROUGH       THE LEDGE     TO A DEPTH       OF IOFT
               AM. L.W.    IN  188,0.


                 1U.
                S. ENGINEER OFFICE, BOSTON, /'ASS .
                                         JULY 10. 1888.
              RESPECTFULLY FORWARDED   WITH LETTER OF
              THIS DATE   TO THE CHIEF OF ENIV/NEERS,
              WASHINGTON,         D.C.

                                              L T COL. OF ENGINEERS




Eng50 2
              APPENDIX              B-REPORT                     OF       LIEUT.           COL.         GILLESPIE.                     45   7
   The original project for improvement was submitted December 23,
1874. It I)rovided for an improved channel on the east side of Sailor's
Island, past the west side of Beacon to the Hingham wharf, 100 feet
wide and 8 feet deep at mean low water, at an estimated cost of $11,000.
This project was modified January 20, 1885, when it was proposed to
deepen the improved channel to 10 feet at mean low water, and to re-
move a mid-channel ledge lying between Chandler's and Ragged islands,
measuring 128 cubic yards, at a total cost of $18,700.
    A plan of the harbor is submitted herewith. The channels A D and
13 D are described in Annual Report for 1875.
    The total amount appropriated to date for this harbor is $16,000.
    The total expenditures to June 30, 1888, were $16,000.
    By this expenditure up to June 30, 1888, the original project had
been completed, and the modified prqject of 1885 had been partly tom-
pleted by dredging and blasting the channel tO feet deep and 50 feet
wide through the ledge, which extends for 280 feet in length in the im-
proved channel, about 1,600 feet northeast of the steam-boat wharf.
    During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, no active operations
were in progress from want of funds. The balance of $76.74, available
July 1, 1887, was expended for office expenses.
    To complete the present project will require an appropriation of
$13,000.
    The following is a tabular statement of the items included in the esti-
mate for $13,000.
Removal of 128 cubic yards from ledge between Ragged and Chandler's
  islands, at $25 ..........................................................                                                         $3,200
Removal of 200 cubic yards from ledge opposite Samuel Burr's, at $25 .......                                                          5, 000
Dredging 20,000 cubic yards of material from the bend near Samuel Burr's to
the steam-boat wharf at Hingham, to give a channel 100 feet wide and 10
feet deep at mean low water, at 20 cents................................                                                              4,000
Contingencies ---------------------------------------.-----------------                                                                  600
         Total..-....                                    --......---.....---....---...------.. ......
                              --------.... ---....-----....                                             ......----......--- --..     13,000
     No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
The river and harbor bill for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1889, con-
tains an item of $5,000 for continuing this improvement, and if appro-
priated this sum will be applied in widening and deepening the chan-
nel near Samuel Burr's.
   This work done, there will be still required the sum of $8,000 to coinm-
plete the project. A recommendation for an appropriation of $8,000 is
made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
     The benefit to be expected from the completion of this improvement
is a more convenient and safe navigation of the improved channel.
  Hingham Harbor is in the collection district of Boston, Mass. The nearest light-
house is the Narrows light on the Main Ship-channel in Boaton Harbor, distant about
5 miles.
     (Commercial statistics included in Boston Harbor.)
                                                    Money           statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available-------  ....-------......--------......--......------......--......----......--.                      $76. 74
Jniy 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1687..............................................                                                              76.74

Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.........................                                                             5,000.00

J   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 190
                                                                                                                                   8, 000.00
                                                                                                                                   8, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
I, harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
  I
458    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                 B.   io.
        IMPROVEMENT OF SCITUATE HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

   Scituate Harbor t on the west shore of Massachusetts Bay, 14 miles
from either Boston or Plymouth light-houses, and just southwest of the
direct sailing course of all ocean-going vessels entering Boston Harbor.
    Before improvement the harbor had a low-water area of 57 acres ap-
proximately, more than 6 acres of which had a depth of at least 3 feet
at mean low water. It was entirely open to the action of easterly
winds, and the entrance was obstructed by many detached bowlders.
The depth on the bar was about 2) feet at mean low water, and the-
mear rise or fall of the tide is 8-a feet.
    A plan of the harbor, showing the proposed improvement, was pub-
lished in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1881, Part I,
page 522.
    The object of the improvement is to create a harbor of refuge for ves-
sels bound. to Boston that are too far south of their true course to clear
the dangerous ledges near Minot's light-house.
    The project for the improvement adopted in 1881 is to build two rub-
ble-stone jetties converging towards each other from opposite banks,,
and to dredge an anchorage basin with channels connecting with the
sea and the town wharves. The north jetty from Cedar Point to be
800 feet long, and the south jetty from the point of the " First Cliff" to
be 730 feet long.
    Both jetties are to be 20 feet wide on top, and 4 feet above mean high
water, except at their outer ends, which are to be built 6 feet higher to
serve as sites for entrance beacons.
    The anchorage basin to be 30 acres in area, approximately. The en-
trance channel to be 2,700 feet in length, and 300 feet average width.
The estimated amount of dredging (including the entrance channel)>
was 500,000 cubic yards, to give a depth of 15 feet at mean low water in
the entrance channel; 12 to 15 feet between the jetties; 12 feet imme-
diately in rear of the south jetty, and 10 feet for the anchorage ba-
sin. The estimated cost of the jetties was $100,000, and of the dredging
 $190,000, a total of $290,000. The total amount appropriated for this
work to date is $47,500.
    The amount expended to June 30, 1888, was $47,500.
    By this expenditure the north jetty had been essentially completed-
it was 720 feet long, of full width and height. The entrance channel
was made 100 feet wide, 1,600 feet long, and 5 feet deep at mean low
water. The anchorage basin was made 400 by 350 feet in area, 7 feet
deep. Nothing had been done on the south jetty.
    A portion of the beach between Cedar Point and the mainland had
been protected by a brush and stone bulkhead 450 feet long, in front
of which was a stone apron 10 feet wide and 385 feet long, and all known
bowlders obstructing the entrance had been removed.
    No operations were in progress during the year ending June 30,1888,.
from want of funds.
    No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
The river and harbor bill for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1889, con-
tains an item of $5,000 for continuing this improvement. If this amount
should be appropriated at the present session of Congress, it might be
judiciously applied toward opening a channel 25 feet wide and 3 feet
deep, to connect the basin with the town wharf. On the completion of
this work the amount required to complete the project will be $237,500.
               APPENDIX               B-REPORT                     OF         LIEUT.              COL.         GILLESPIE.               459

Of this amount $50,000 could be profitably expended during the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1890, and, if appropriated could be judiciously ex-
pended as follows:
Build south jetty 400 feet long, 10,000 tons rubble-stone at $2.15 ...........                                                  $21, 500
Enlarge anchorage basin to four acres, 10 feet deep, and the channel to the
town wharf to 150 feet wide, with same depth; 70,000 cubic yards dredging
at 33 cents ..........---------............----......----......------......---..........-------....-------....---....           23, 10,
Contingencies ......------......--------......---------....-----.....--......-------....------....---....------....--..........   5, 400
       Total..................     ............... ...... ..... ,-.... .....-...... 50, 000
   Scituate is in the collection district of Plymouth, Mass. The nearest port of entry
is Plymouth, Mass. The nearest light-house is Minot's light, about 5 miles distant.
  The accompanying commercial statistics have been furnished by the
collector of customs at Plymouth, Mass.
                                                       Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available- .........................................                               - ---                        $474.72
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1687 ...............-..-....                       ..........-------....-----....----..---.                     474.72

Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                                                           5,000. 00
 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                                       237,500.00
   Amount that can beprotitably expendedin fiscalyearendingJune 30, 1890                                                         50, 000 00
   Submitted in compliance with requiremenuts of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                                 COMMERCIAL                STATISTICS.

                      Commnercial statisticsfor the fi cal year ending June 30, 1888.

Foreign arrivals (74 tons) .........................................                                                             1
Domestic arrivals...................... ...........................                                                             12
Foreign clearances-----....
                                                                                                                           --              1;
                                        ---.....-----........      ............................                                  1
Domestic clearances....                       -............................                        ..      .............        12
Four cargoes of coal.......-........................................tons..                                                               60
Eight cargoes of lumber................--                              ....-....-..-...           ".............-feet..              550, 000
  In addition to the above a number of small boats are principally engaged in gath-
eriug moss.


                                                                   BII.

             IMPROVEMENT OF PLYMOUTH HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.
  Plymouth Harbor is situated 30 miles south of Boston. Its outer
anchorage, the " Cow-Yard," is common to Plymouth, Kingston, and
Duxbury, and is the only refuge for sea-going vessels from northeast-
erly gales when caught between Boston and Provincetown, a distance
of about 75 miles, following the coast-line. The entrance to this outer
anchorage is direct, unobstructed, of ample width, and sufficiently deep
for the wants of commerce. The anchorage is capacious, and has good
"holding ground," but the extensive tidal basins inside of it give rise
to strong variable currents across it.
  The inner or harbor proper is formed by Long Beach, a narrow low
sand-spit 3 miles long, which runs generally parallel to the mainland
and about a mile from it.
  The harbor contains 2,000 acres, almost all of which is dry at low tide.
A few narrow, crooked, shallow channels traverse these flats. These
460           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

channels join about the center of the harbor, opposite the town wharves,
and form the main ship-channel, 150 feet wide approximately and 10
feet deep at mean low water, which runs directly behind the northern
half of Long Beach to the outer anchorage.
   The maintenance of this inner harbor and channel depends on the
preservation of Long Beach.
 * Before improvement about 6 inches depth only of water could be car-
ried to the town wharves at low tide.
   Previous to 1875 the project was a general one, and had for its object
the preservatiou only of Long Beach. From the nature of the work it
can at no time be considered completed, and small annual appropria-
tions are necessary to repair any damage done by storms. The various
devices employed for this purpose are described in the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1877, all of which have been remarkably
successful.
   The project for the improvement of the harbor was first adopted in
1875. It provided for dredging a channel from the town wharves to
the main ship-channel, 2,286 feet long, 100 feet wide, and 6 feet deep
at mean low water. This project was modified in 1877 so as to include
the dredging of a basin 866 feet long, 150 feet wide, and 8 feet deep,
directly in front of the town wharves.
   In 1884 and 1885 it was proposed to deepen the improved channel and
basin to 9 feet at mean low water, and to make their approaches more
easy.
   The modified project of 1884 required the excavation of 81,000 cubic
yards (scow measurement), and was originally estimated to cost $27, 000.
   This estimate was revised in 1885, in accordance with the low prices
then current for dredging, and the cost was then estimated to be$22,500.
From 1866 to date the amount appropriated for this improvement was
 $114,800, of which there had been expended to June 30, 1888:
For beach protection...................................................                                                   $72,587. 56
For dredging, etc------
                    ......---------......--------......--......--------....--....--------....---....---......--........    42, 212.44

  During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, 8,312 cubic yards of
material were removed from the improved channel and basin under a
contract with the New England Dredging Company, dated October 22,
1886. This contract was satisfactorily completed in July, 1887, and a
total of 23,124 cubic yards were dredged at a contract price of 24 cents
per yard. A small bowlder developed by the dredging was removed by
hired labor in August, 1887.
  During the latter part of the fiscial year a survey of the dredged basin
and channel was made, and lines of soundings wefe also run over the
main ship-channel to its junction with the outer anchorage. This sur-
vey shows that the basin and improved channel have not deteriorated
since dredging was suspended in July, 1887, though it is noticed that ex-
tensive changes have taken place in the shoals surrounding the main
ship-channel, especially between Plymouth Beacon and Duxbury Pier
Light, since the survey of 1870. The channel is, however, essentially
uninjured, and at least 9 feet depth at low water can be carried to the
town wharves. A chart showing the results of the survey accompanies
this report.
  The condition of the improvement on June 30, 1888, is as follows:
The improved channel was 115 feet in width, 9 feet in depth for 90 feet
of its width nearest the town wharves, and the remainder averaged 5
feet depth. Long Beach was in good order throughout arid the works
of preservation on it required no repairs or extensions.
                    PLYM0 UTH                                                   HARBOR, MASS.
                               PLAN SHOWING CONDITION OF     CHANNEL                                                   THE                                                                                          U.S.EGMIEEOR    FF/I1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       , BOSTON, MAISS.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           JULY .10. 1888
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    RESPECTFULLY FORWARDED WITH LETTER                    OF
                                 FROM THE "COW YARD" TO THE WHARVES                                                                                                                                                 MIkS DATE TO THE CHIEF OF EGIIVEE,,

                                                   TO   ACCOMPANY                 ANNUAL                       REPORT                     OF
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       LT. COL. Or EN/NEERS'8
                                LT.COL. GEO. L. GILLESPIE , CORPS OFiENGRS.U.S.A.
                                                                     JUNE 30, 1888.                                                                                                                                                                                                                          l.5

                                                              SCALE        OF        PLAN       19,000.

                               I990                 0            1                    1500                        2000
                                                                                                                   .000                           259                     3000 fr.


                                                  NOTE.     THE SOUNDINgS, IN FEET AND TENTHS, REFER
                                                  TO MEAN LOW WATER;            THEY ARE SELECTED PROM THE
                                                   NUMEROUS 804/ND/NGO          TAKEN IN THE SURVEY OF MAY
                                                  1888.     T.      ,SOUNDINGS IN FEET ALONE ARE FROM THE
                                                  U.,S. C. S.    MANUSCRIPT MAP OP 1870.
                                                   THE MEAN RISE OR         FLL     OF TIDE IS ABOUT 10 FT.                                                                                                                                                                                              1
                                                  *ENCHMARX. THE SILL OF CANOPY OVER PLYMOUTH
                                                   IOCK       ,S  17.2.4 FEET ABOVE MEAN LOW WATER-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   4.   N.   ~   4,No~




                                                                                                                                          .COI

                                                                                                                  V/                                                                                                                                               /          '    L4'
                      63        '

                                                                                                                                          L                                                                                         y /     4"   tis     r         t...                                 v,


                                                                                07

                          0.          crJ                                                                                 V                   N                 Ul        f      N7*~           '
                           0J
               c0     (0        4y

                                            co0
                    720




                                                                                      0                   40                                                                             q~.4       -oo,

                                                                                              lee(                        ~                       O.
                                                                                                                              20.                                          -s

                                                                           ".             A          l¢           16                '.2                '   2    c    ''    c                                           j        '                                 ,"-                    ,   ;:    o   .';

          42




                                                                     4..                             fit.:     3.1.             :\"F.                      '"                        .      .              ......                            .               \"           .       ...             ".                                     1   3




Eng50 2
                APPENDIX                  D-REPORT                      OF       LIEUT.                COL.            GILLESPIE.                         461

  No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
The river and harbor bill (not yet passed) for the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1889, contains an item of $3,000 for continuing the improve-
ment, and if this sum should be appropriated it will be applied towards
completing the project by widening and deepening the basin. This work
done, there will still be required the sum of $9,500 to complete the pro-
ject. An appropriation of $9,500 is recommended for continuing the im-
provement for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
  The prospective benefits to commerce are increased facilities and safety
in navigating the improved channel.
   Plymouth Harbor is located in the collection district of Plymouth, Mass., of which
Plymouth is the port of entry. The nearest light-houses are the Plymouth (Gurnet)
lights, about 5 miles from Plymouth, and Duxbury Pier Light, about 2 miles distant.
     The accompanying commercial statistics for the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1888, have been furnished by the collector of customs at Ply-
mouth, Mass.
                                      Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available--...... ......-------......-......--..............-.... $-2,957. 39
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887----....---....----......----------------------............-----......----....----......--------.... --                      2,957,   :9
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188                                               .........................                                   6, 000.00

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                                                              9, 500, 00
   Amount that can be protitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                                                           9, 500. 0)
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1863 and 1807.



                                                       COMMERCIAL                STATISTICS.

                        Commercial statistics for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.

Revenue collected during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1883............                                                                          $91, 919. 97

Derived from the folloving sources, namely:
    Duties on imports from hemp----------------------------------.......................................                                            42,205.42
    Duties on imports from sisal-grass ......-....-..........-....-........                                                                         1;, 504. 50
    Duties on imports from rivet-wire rods-..............................                                                                           18, 711.80
    Duties on imports from wool........-------------------....----......----......--......... - ---......-                                          10, 710. 80
    Duties on imports from bar iron------ .............--------.-----....----....---....-----....--......                                             7,745. 84
    Duties on imports from steel bars...................................                            ----                                              3,944.70
    Duties on imports from salt and lumber..-...........................                                                                                 96. 85

           Total------......-------......-------....------....---....--......-----.....-             ---------...--....---......--..........        91,919.97


                                                          Shipping.                                                                             No. ofTonnage.
                                                                                                                                               vessels.

Foreign entrances..............--------------------------------------.-...---                                                                      3        1,327
Foreign clearances---                           ...------------------------------------------------...                                             5        1, 648


  Coastwise entrances were 114 in number, namely:
78 cargoes of coal................................------------------------------------------................tons..   27,300
25 cargoes of lumber ...........................................---------------------------------------.. feet.. 2, 700, 000
3 cargoes of granite..........--------------.......                    ...............-              ... tons..         300
3 cargoes of cement and lime ......................................                                         do.. .      600
2 cargoes of brick-------------------------
                          ................................................---                                do...       240
2 cargoes of hay ...............................................-----------------------------... do....                 120
1 cargo of tar ....................................................                                        bbls..    1,775
  The above items do not include ordinary packet running, and in addition thereto a,
steamer runs regularly during the summer months.
462     REPORT   OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                  B   12.

      IMPROVEMENT OF PROVINCETOWN HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

    Provincetown Harbor is situated at the extremity of Cape Cod, about
40 miles southeast from Boston Light. It is one of the most valuable
harbors of refuge on the Atlantic coast. The entire commerce of New
England and a very large local fishing interest are directly benefited
by its maintenance, which depends entirely on the preservation of the
sandy beaches which inclose it.
    Since 1826 the project has been a general one, and provides for the
preservationoftheharbor by building dikes, bulkheads, andsand-catches,
and extensive planting of beach grass, to repair or prevent storm dam-
ages to the beaches. From the nature of the work it can at no time be
considered completed. A full history of these improvements will be
found in the Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers for the years
1876, 1879, and 1886. A special dike across House Point Island Flats,
to be built contingently, was recommended in the Annaal Report for
1880.
    A plan of the harbor was published in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1886.
    The total appropriations or allotments for this work up to date have
been $139,478.44.
    The amount expended up to June 30, 1888, was $139,328.09.
    The condition of the improvement June 30, 1888, was as follows:
    Long Point. This long, narrow, low point forms the southeastern
limit of the harbor. It had been protected on the east or outside by
bulkheads, groins, and aprons built of rubble-stone. These were all
generally in good order, except that 600 tons of additional large stone
were required to level up the bulkhead near the northern end; and it
required to be repaired and backed with brush and small stone to pre-
vent the sea making through it to the injury of the beach behind it.
For this purpose an appropriation is recommended. At the narrowest
part of the point, 3,000 feet west of Wood End Light, a gap in the beach
had been worn by the portage of fishermen's boats, etc.
    This was closed during the fiscal year by wood and brush sand-catches
with five jetties, aggregating 232 feet in length, and 5 acres of beach
grass were planted on the inside opposite this gap.
     Abel Hill Dike.-This dike was built to p)revent the rush of water
from Lancy's Harbor over House Point Island Flats into the main har-
bor.
     The rapid wearing away of the southern sand-spit that forms Lancy's
  Harbor had threatened to make a breach through the beach south of the
dike. To guard against this, brush and wooden sand-catches had been
  built on the outer beach opposite the west end of the d(like. These sand-
catches were repaired and extended during the fiscal year by building
an additional length of 257h feet.
     House Point Island Flats.-These flats remained essentially unaltered
  from the condition shown by the last survey and stated in last annual
  report. It still appears unnecessary to commence the dike projected to
  be built across these flats.
     Beach Point, High Head Dike, and Cove Section.-These works were
  all in good order, and have required no extensions or repairs during the
  year.
     At the date of this report the several works of preservation are in
  good order, and serve the purpose for which they were built.
                APPENDIX                       B-REPORT             OF       LIEUT.          COL.   GILLESPIE.             463

  No appropriation was made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
The river and harbor bill now pending, for the fiscal year ending June
30, 1889, contains an item of $7,000 for improving Provincetown Har-
bor, and if this sum should be appropriated, it will be applied in level-
ing up and backing the Long Point Breakwater, and in repairing prob-
able storm damages to other points of the covering beaches. This work
completed, an appropriation of $2,500 is recommended for the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1890, for application towards the repair of probable
storm damages to the beaches.
  The prospective benefit to commerce is the preservation of an impor-
tant harbor of refuge.
  Provincetown is a port of entry in the collection district of Barnstable, Mass.                                             The
nearest light-houses are Wood End and Long Point lights.
  The accompanying commercial statistics have been furnished by the
deputy collector at the port of Provincetown, Mass.
                                                         Money statement.
                                 ......-----------......---......-------------......-......----.......--....
July 1, 1887, amount available-----                                                                          $2, 144.04
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 187....-..        --........................................                             1,993.69
July 1, 1838, balance available-----------..........................................
                                                   ----------------------                                             150.35
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 18883...-...................                                               7,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889....................                                           7,150.35
  SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project... ....                                           '2,500.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                        2,   500. 00
SSubmitted    in compliance with requirements of sections '2 of river and
   . harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                                    C)MSIERCIAL            STATISTICS.

                       Cometercial sta1diti~csfor tie iscal ycar endig ,Ju
                                                                         se 30, 175$8.


                                                   Shipping.                                              No. of          nnage.
                                                                                                                         cunage.
                                                                                                         vessels.


Foreign arrivals......---------------------------------------------------------                                23           3, 425
Foreign cleaiances .....-------------------------------------------------------                                32           4, 244

Amount collected for           imp   o
                                         rts                                                                             $...................................
                                                                                                                         $210.68
Amount collected for tonnago tax .............................................................                               91.64
Amount collected for immigrant fund .........................................................                                30. 50

   The total number of vessels which have entered the harbor at Provincetown, Mass.,
for shelter and other purposes during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is five
thousand; estimated value, at the rate of $10,000 each, $50,000,000.




                                                                   B 13.
PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION OF MANCHESTER HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

                                                      UNITED STATES ENGINEER                            OFFICE,
                                   Boston, Mass., Novemniber 20, 1886.
   GENERAL: In compliance with in*structions contained in your letter
of September 27, 1886, I have the honor to submit the report of a pre-
liminary examination of Manchester Harbor, Massachusetts, provided
464    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

for in the river and harbor act approved August 5, 1886. Manchester
Harbor is situated on the eastern shore of Massachusetts, Ul)On Massa-
chusetts Bay, 5 miles northeastward of the entrance to Salem Harbor.
At the entrance there is a small sheltered roadstead, containing 300
acres or more, with 5 fathoms water, formed by Great Misery Island,
House Island, and the mainland terminating in Gale's Point, which is
much used by fishing-vessels during northeasterly, easterly, and south-
erly storms. The entrance is marked by a light-house on Baker's Isl-
and, andl the channels east and west of Great Misery Island are buoyed
by the Light-House D)epartment. The roadstead shoals gradually to-
wards the entrance to Manchester Harbor, and opposite Glass Head; at
the immediate entrance the depth is 3 feet mean low water. At a dis-
tance of 2,500 feet farther inland, at the Narrows, the width of the wa-
ter-way is contracted to less than 1,000 feet, and the depth reduced to
1 foot, approximately, mean low water. Thence to the wharves at the
upper end of the bay, where the town of Manchester is located, is prac-
tically no water at low stage. The bed of the harbor is composed of
loam and sand, with a few bowlders visible close inshore. At a con-
ference which I had with the selectmen of the town on November 10,
1886, I was informed that the Government expended about $5,000 thirty
years ago in blasting and removing rocks alongside the channel at the
Narrows. The printed records contain no statement of such appropri-
ation or improvement. I have not been able to learn that it was an
improvement by the State or by private individuals.
   The harbor is divided into ihe upper and lower harbor by the con-
tractioniat the Narrows, and the distance from the 3-foot curve at the
entrance to the town wharves is 1mile. No hlydrographic survey of the
harbor has ever been made, but the citizens claim that there was for-
merly a depth of 3 feet mean low water into the upper harbor, and
that the decline in shipping and the present disuse of the harbor are
due to the decline in the navigable depths, which are now such        as to
practically close the harbor at low tide.
   The improvement desired is the restoration of the channel to its for
mer depth of 3 to 4 feet mean low water, This will require the (irewt I-
ing of a channel 5,000 feet long, 60 feet wide, and 2± to 3 feet deep, with
an estimated excavation of 100,009 cubic yards of material.
   The inclosed paper l)repared by the selectmen of Manchester gives an
exhibit of the interest represented in the harbor and the country ad-
jacent. The sheltered roadstead at the entrance, the faicility with which
it may be entered from the main ship channel leading to Salem Harbor,
and the additional shelter which may be gained by excavating a channel
into Manchester Harbor, make this an important harbor of the third
class.
   The citizens are fully justified in asking relief from the Government.
It will be practicable at small cost to open a narrow channel to the lower
wharves for the use of vessels in transporting at reduced rates to the
town and adjacent country those supplies now carried by rail, which
most generally enter into home consumption, such as coal, lumber, prod-
ucts of iron and mercantile articles.
   The harbor is worthy of improvement, and I respectfully recommend
an allotment of $1,000 for making a complete hydrographic survey of
the harbor from the 6-foot curve of the roadstead to the lower wharves.
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                  G. L. GILLESPIE,
                                                Lieut. Col. of Engineers.
   The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. A.
          APPENDIX      B -REPORT        OF LIEUT.     COL. GILLESPIE.            465
COMMUNICATION FROM THE SELECTMEN, MERCHANTS, ETC., OF MANCHESTER, MASSA-
               *               CHUSETTS.
                                                  MANCHESTER,      November 17, 1886.
   DEAR SIR: We, the undersigned selectmen, merchants, and residents of the town
of Manchester, Essex County, Mass., respectfully submit that the improvement oTf our
harbor is necessary and expedient for the following reasons, among others, viz:
   (1) That our commercial and manufacturing interests have been injured by the
gradual filling up of our harbor. There was formerly a good channel, which has been
obstructed by the accumulations of years. Within twenty-five years vessels loaded
with coal and drawing 11 feet of water could enter the harbor and unload. At the
present time it is necessary to bring the coal to Salem by vessel and from there it
must be brought down by rail 9 miles and carted to mills, thus making an extra cost
for transportation, to be borne by the consumers.
   The consumption of coal has increased within the past twelve years from 800 to
2,800 tons, and a continued increase is anticipated. While this coal could formerly be
sunloaded at the dock, it is necessary now to bring it in by lighters when it comes by
sea, or else by rail as above stated.
  In former years vessels ran between Manchester and Boston, carrying our manu-
factures of furniture, etc., and bringing articles of home consumption in return.
Now it is necessary to send everything of this kind by rail.
Formerly a large part of the hay produced here was sent away to be sold. The
product of hay is now greater than ever before, but it is all consumed here, and fully
.as much more brought in from Maine and other places. If the channel was improved
this hay could be brought by coasters at less expense to consumers than it is now
brought by rail.
  The consumption of lumber amounts to at least 1,500,000 feet, nearly all of which
must be brought by rail or teamed in, unless the channel is deepened.
  The consumption of granite in Manchester since May, 1886, exceeds 600 tons, nearly
all of which came from Rockport, and, with the exception of about 60 tons, all was
brought by rail or teamed in at much greater cost than would be necessary if the
depth of channel would allow it to be brought by water.
   This is also true as regards other building material. The consumption of brick,
lime, and cement has increased within a few years at least threefold. This material
could be brought by water at reduced cost if depth of channel would allow.
  (2) The business and commerce of Manchester would be benefited by the improve-
ment of our harbor. Notwithstanding the injury caused by the filling up of the
channel and harbor, which forced the fifty fishing-vessels, formerly engaged in this
pursuit, to other ports having a greater depth of water, our town valuation has
steadily increased from $1,746,222 in 1877, to $4,826,888 in 1886, and we have reason
to believe will continue to increase, especially if the harbor be improved and channel
deepened.
   We believe that the desired improvement will be of great benefit to the neighbor-
ing districts of Magnolia and Beverly Farms, as these towns are obliged to draw
their supplies, to a great extent, from distant places, and depend for transportation
upon a railroad corporation which can exact its own terms for carrying goods and
freight, as it has no competitor in the carrying trade. Supplies could be brought by
Manchester Harbor if improved and deepened.
   Some years ago our channel had at least 4 feet of water at low tide. Now there is
less than 1 foot, and we respectfully suggest that the channel be dredged to a depth
of at least 5 feet at low water, and to a width of 100 feet clear.
   The rock known as Bow Bell presents a dangerous obstacle to the navigation of
our harbor, as it lies directly in the channel, and we suggest that it be removed.
   We also respectfully suggest that it would be an advantage to the harbor if a por-
tion of the flats be dredged out, so that there may be an anchorage for boats at all
tides. These flats have filled up to a great extent within a few years, and the depth
of the harbor gained by a removal of part of them would be greatly to its benefit.
   We desire that the harbor be improved as much as possible, and remain, sir,
       Yours, respectfully,
                                                        JOHN H. CHEEVER,
                                                        HENRY T. BINGHAM,
                                                        WM. A. STONE,
                                                            Selectmen of Manchester.
                              T. JEFFERSON COOLIDGE.         A.   E.   Low.
                              SAMUEL KNIGHT.                 F. K. HOOPER.
                              DANIEL LEACH.                  JOHN ALLEN.
                              JOHN W. CARTER.                HENRY P. KITFIELD.
                              THEO. W. SLADE.                GEORGE A. KITFIELD.
                              C. H. SHELDON.                 GEO. C. LEACH.
Col. GEO. L.   GILLESPIE.
       ENG 88-        30
466     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


        SURVEY            OF MIANCHESTER HARBOR,                             MIASSACHUSETTS.

                                       UNITED STATES                     ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                                  Boston, Mass., November 28, 1887.
   GENERAL: In compliance with instructions contained in your letter
of March 16, 1887, I have the honor to transmit 'herewith a report of
Mr. Sophus Haagensen on the survey of Manchester Harbor, Massa-
chusetts, made to comply with provisions of river and harbor act ap-
proved August 5, 1886.
   A tracing is also transmitted showing the limits of the improvement
proposed for this harbor determined by the survey.
   My preliminary report on this harbor, dated November 20, 1886, gives
all the material facts relating to this harbor and the reasons which in-
fluenced mein recommending the survey. The only new facts are those
which have been revealed by the accompanying chart, which has been
prepared from the survey.
   The channel from the roadstead to Proctor's Point is everywhere 100
feet wide, with a least depth of 6. feet mean low water, is unobstructed,
and is adequate to the commercial necessities of the port. At Proctor's
Point the first important obstruction is met with, which consists of a
submerged ledge of rock projecting westward from the west side of Proc-
tor's Point and extending well into the deep-water channel. Another
ledge, called the Bow Bell, crops out on the opposite side of the chan-
nel a little to the northward and westward of the first ledge. From
Proctor's Point to the "Narrows," a distance of 1,400 feet, the channel
rapidly shoals to 1 feet depth mean low water. It is but slightly de-
fined by a few deep and disconnected pools in which the depth varies
from 4 to  5. feet mean low water. From the "Narrows" to the town
wharves, a further distance of 2,500 feet, approximately, the bottom of
the harbor is practically bare at average low tide. The high-water
channel in this last reach is crossed near the town by the Boston and
Maine Railroad (eastern division) on a bridge which is provided with a
draw opening 28 feet wide in the clear.
   It is recommended that a channel be opened from Proctor's Point to
the town wharves, which shall be 60 feet wide on bottom and 4 feet deep,
mean low water. Its direction is given on the accompanying chart.
   In order to take advantage of the pools exterior to the " Narrows,"
which indicate the direction of the proper channel, an excavation will
be required to be made through a portion of Proctor's ledge, leaving
the Bow Bell ledge untouched on the west side.
   The following is the estimate of the cost of the improvement:
Excavating 46,000 cubic yards of material, sand and loam, in a channel 60
  feet wide on bottom, slope 1 on 4, and 4 feet deep mean low water, from
  Proctor's Point to the town wharves, at 25 cents per cubic yard .....-.... $11,500
Blasting and removing 150 cubic yards of rock from the west side of Proctor's
ledge, at $10 per cubic yard ........................................                                 1,500
Contingencies for engineering, etc     ....        ...                                         .       1,300

      Total   ......................        ....................................                   .   14,300

  An appropriation of $14,300 is recommended for the improvement
indicated in the foregoing report.
  The commerce of Manchester at present is nominal.
  Attention is invited to the report of Mr. Haagensen for the details of
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   I
                                           .. ..
                    . . . . '
                                                    .
                                                           .
                                                               +.   .




                                                                                  " , ,. . * e                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                o0
                                                                                          "" .                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            -3



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   -a---




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    . '           2             U

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           e9


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      Q




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                -(I.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               -. 1 -"

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               _ '.             -S.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 -         7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      -C
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      I   4           -            == -      -    _          '5   8

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              -a    -                                                                                                  1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   7-:x1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   ..-                                                      1   9
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          ..                      -                        ..
                                                                                                                                              3k
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      1L,
                                                                                                                                                                     2.,
                                                                                                                                                                               3.2
                                                                                                                                                                                           1.                                                                                                                      --?
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 ."

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               r",,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               _      ..     . ..                 _    .r
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ~4. 7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      ,S
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           J~.L
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     -0.9                                                      _Ui.,                                                                                                                    ..6~ '       "*                                                         -Q*~            -4'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      I       -1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               -2.'~2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 .412                                                                                                                                          s % DVc
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            -


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  -. 9
                                                               8.,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              02 .9
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               --                                                                t              I                   -~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         *1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ~                              '3
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     0-"'           0"   T*                                       -0.¢. -2.         o
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      -1 '7                                                                                         IB                                     may.--r                                                    te-.-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         07c
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       :0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         -L~                                                              -2. S
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     :JI.                 ~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                '

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 .                                                                              '
                                                                                                                                                                   3.6     o                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     2
                                                                                                                                                                                     1.9        L
                                                                                                                                                                                                     0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    .I                                                                                                                                                                                       ~Wp                               -3                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  -Sb-'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             '1~ ~ j*. '*                                                                                                    -2




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          / /             c                                                      _
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          -   -        -                          -                         _




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      -=J7                .F3._.//.

                                                                        6.s                                    2.6      1.9         3.     73     8                              S36       10                 0.'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  I.                       /
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             _I.     "   -.   -8.1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              -0.7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    #ageo't
                                                                                                                                                                                                    14               0.8                                                                                                                       .7         -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         -0
                                                                                                                                              S          3.                                                                                                                                                                                           _1.41
                                                                                                      I.        9                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              //
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 -    "8    _.9                               _1 "'0



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                azg
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                :-2.t
                                                          Z71
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      11
                                                                                                                                                                                                    I.5             .6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 ih                                                             ._Si
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       f
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           JIG              I

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       2d&

                                                                                                                        0.0              0.        1.4        1.

                                                                                                  0-c
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              _



                                9.j.           8.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    -    -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            --                            4-

                                                                                                                     0..
                                                    7/                                           04
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                '*0 -5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              -1.
                                                                                  1.4                                                                                                                     1.2
                                                                                                                                                                     0.6                                                   t
                                                                                                                                                                                                                               1.,          0.5
                                   7 0                                                                                     _1                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ////////////////
                                                                                                                 -o'9                                                                                    1.
                                                                                                                                                                                                              S     I.
                                       7                                                                _0.7                                                                           0.9
                                                                                                                                                                           0.a
                                                                              I
                                                                                                                                                         -. 9
                                                                                                                                         -- 2.
                                                                                                                              -l3

                                                                                                   --   1 .b
                                                                                                                 -+t                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 MANCHESTER                                                                                                                            HARBOR, MASS.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  SURVEYED IN ACCODDANCE WITH

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   N       "ot. The sowtdtr ,rp ',                    ew        cand.s
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ACT OF CONGRESS APPROVED AUGUST 5.1                                                                                                                                             86
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       refer    IS meanlow
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      resec .ivfe
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    r and           WO
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   sdectal         frm     are                                                                                  SHOWING PROPOSED IMPROVEMENTS
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          owenunter                 ~ et kot A wsurrey.                                                                                                                 To accompany report of
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        oztS v0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          Themeanr's8 orfall      of fide is         feet.                  9.o                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           U.S.A.
                                                    '4g                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Ji orwa,,crkc The -4ewof fketzil of Mer                                                                                                          LT. COI. GEtO. L . GILLESPIE , CORPS OF ENORS.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       Xa'citerw, Railroadf
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          feee bove mea         tlow,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           drawtidg
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        a.ter .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              atre
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            .qs Al
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                1 :4000
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         ,&r /4 w'aer line
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               X1won
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              is expreSSedL t rS:tZ
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        war linze.            .. .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 KQ
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       ..................
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              SCALE                            OF        MAP
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         L50       w
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  O.                                                                                                                                  wwooM
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              so, o                                                                      500                                                          1e0                                              1W       aQ-

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           4 ft.             eon       -tour        ,,             ,,            .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         6                SIo
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         The areawsuried. tus                                                    prpos .                                                                                                                                               rSE                     ng eerO2fhte                                         .. z'.      ltm ber           1at
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Je redged to a'xofepikfof                                                  at mnr                                                                                                                                                                                 to dChi efWir"wMn Waskhgtn.C.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       oFSr)teers.
I   Surveyed and dram y Sophue Hawenseni

    Eng5O 2
                                    I                                                                                                                                                                                                                    II
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       1u;Co.
              APPENDIX            B-REPORT                OF LIEUT.            COL. GILLESPIE.                      467
the survey, the description of the harbor, and the obstructions to navi-
gation.
  Manchester Harbor is in the collection district of Gloucester, Mass., of which Glou-
cester is the port of entry. The nearest light-house is situated upon Baker's Island,
at the entrance to the roadstead, 21 miles from Proctor's Point.
           Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                                   G. L. GILLESPIE,
                                                                               Lieut. Col. of Engineers.
   The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. A.


                 REPORT OF MR.            SOPHUS HAAGENSEN,               ASSISTANT       ENGINEER.

                                                              UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                                    Boston, Mass., October 31, 1887.
  COLONEL: I have the honor to report upon the survey of Manchester Harbor, Mas-
sachusetts, made in July, 1b87, in pursuance of your instructions; also to submit a
map of the survey drawn to a scale of 1: 3,000.

                                                    TOPOGRAPHY.

  The shore-lines shown on the map are, with a few additions of wharves and piers
built since 1851, those of the U. S. Coast Survey manuscript map. A copy of this on
a scale of 1: 10,000 was obtained and enlarged to a scale of 1 : 3,000. This sheet, used
in the field on the plane table, enabled us to orient stations, and to establish a system
of ranges for the soundings, so as to correspond with the high-water line.

                                                  HYDROGRAPHY.

  The area covered by the soundings extends from the 8-foot contour of the outer
roadstead up to head of tide-water at Knight's Wharf, and is about 230 acres. Seventy-
one lines were run, aggregating in length 8.8 miles, upon which 2,655 soundings were
taken. Of this number about one-third were located by plane-table intersections from
suitable shore stations. One hundred and forty-four borings were made, principally
on the ledge off Proctor's Point and the Bow Bell, of which a special map was made
on a scale of 1:500.
  The soundings and borings all refer to mean low water.

                                                         TIDES.

  The range of tide (mean rise or fall) was assumed to be the same as for Gloucester
Harbor (8 miles distant), where a full lunation had previously been observed with
the following result:
                                                                                                                      Feet.
Mean rise or fall of tide------
                         ......-----------......---......---------......--------......--......----......--...--......   9.0
Extreme low water observed----------
                                  ....------------....-----......--......-----....---..........--....----...........    1.8
Extreme high water observed--..........-----....--------..--------------------------..........................         11.0

   To determine the plane of mean low water, eight consecutive high and low waters
were observed on a tide-staff set in the channel near Glass Head. The mean was
taken of every two consecutive high and low waters, giving seven values of mean
ocean level. From the average of these seven values, 4.5 feet, or half of the mean
rise or fall, was deducted to find the plane of mean low water adopted for the survey.
   The bench-mark established is shown on the plan; it is the top of the rail of the
Eastern Railroad at the draw-bridge, and is 15 feet above mean low water.

             DESCRIPTION OF THE CHANNEL                      AS DEVELOPED BY THE SURVEY.

   The entrance to Manchester Harbor is from Massachusetts Bay through the main
ship-channel leading to Salem Harbor, which it leaves one-fourth mile west of Baker's
Island lights; +hence 1 mile almost due north to the center of the roadstead, where
there is an anchorage three-fourths of a mile square with a greatest depth of 6 fathoms
at mean low water. This roadstead is protected on the south by Great Misery Island,
on the west and north by the mainland, and on the east by Gale's Point, Ram Island,
and House Islands To the southeast it is exposed.
468      REPORT     OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  One-half mile northeast of the center of the roadstead, in 8 feet depth at mean low
water, commences the tidal channel leading to the wharves. It preserves this depth
for 3,200 feet. or opposite Proctor's Point; on the 4-foot contour its width is from 200
to 80 feet. Beyond Proctor's Point no navigable channel exists; there are, however,
" pot holes" with not to exceed 5 feet in depth. Three thousand feet above Proctor's
Point the Eastern Railroad (Gloucester Branch) crosses the harbor on an earthen em-
bankment, with a draw opening 27.9 feet in the clear.
  Nine hundred feet beyond the draw is the head of tide-water near the Town Land-
ing. The remainder of the harbor consists of mud fiats, mostly in an elevation 2 feet
above mean low water. Ledge in and near the channel was only found off Proctor's
Point, and at the Bow Bell, which some fifty years ago, it is said, was reduced by
blasting to its present level about mean low water.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                             Sonus      HAAGENSEN,
                                                                     Assistant Engineer.
  Lieut. Col. GEO. L. GILLESPIE.
          Corps of Engineers, U. S. A.




                                         B   i4.

PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION OF WINTHROP HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

                                   UNITED      STATES ENGINEER            OFFICE,
                                       Boston, Mass., November 20, 1886.
   GENERAL: In compliance with instructions contained in your letter
of September 27, 1886, I have the honor to submit the following report
of a preliminary examination of Winthrop Harbor, Massachusetts, pro-
vided for in the river and harbor act, approved August 5, 1886.
   The harbor is situated in the northeastern part of Boston Harbor,
immediately westward of Winthrop Head. It contains 200 acres, ap-
proximately, and is dry at low tide, except in a very narrow slough
which penetrates the low land to the northward of Snake Island. The
mean range of tides is 91 feet, approximately. There are several wharves
along the south shore of the town of Winthrop, from Pulling Point to
Winthrop Brook, which at high tide may be reached by vessels draw-
ing not more than 8 to 9 feet. The bed of the harbor is composed
chiefly of loam and sand, with occasional bowlders outcropping near
Snake Island, but not in the vicinity of the channel. No hydrographic
survey has ever been made of the harbor and no money has been spent
by any authority for improvement. The inclosed paper, prepared by
the selectmen of the town, is an exhibit of the valuation of property of
the town, the condition of the harbor, and the character of the improve-
ment solicited by the citizens. The narrow-gauge railroad, which runs
through Winthrop to Point Shirley, carries no freight, and all the town
supplies, consisting of coal, lumber, brick, and mercantile articles, when
not transported by barges, are carted over dirt roads from East Boston
or Chelsea.
   The population interested in the improvement numbers 5,000 souls,
approximately, and the real and personal property is estimated at
$2,250,000. The back channel between Point Shirley and East Boston
has from 9 to 16 feet at low water, and by opening a narrow channel
with 6 feet at low water through Winthrop Harbor to the northward of
Snake Island, it will be practicable for small vessels or scows to pass,
at all stages of the tide, from Winthrop wharves to Boston wharves by
following the cross channel north of Apple Island and entering the
main ship-channel by the Bird Island Channel.
              APPENDIX                     B-REPORT           OF        LIEUT.               COL.              GILLESPIE.          469

   As Winthrop Harbor forms part of Boston inner harbor, and is only
2 miles distant from the main ship-chapnel by a navigable channel
having 15 feet at low water, I am of the opinion that the citizens of Win-
throp are entitled to relief, and that, therefore, the harbor of Winthrop
is worthy of improvement.
   I recommend a survey of the harbor at an expense not exceeding $600,
and an allotment to that extent is asked, provided the project is ap-
proved.
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                              G. L. GILLESPIE,
                                                 Lieut. Col. of E ngineers.
   The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                     S. A.


                                WINTHROP          AND   ITS    WATER COMMUNICATIONS.


  The town of Winthrop is in the county of Suffolk, State of Massachusetts, upon
whose shores a large and flourish=ng business might be maintained, which would
have a vital relation to the prosperity and growth of the country. It is a subject of
national as well as local interest.   The many advantages of a sea-port town lie in the
saving effected in the transportation of materials such as are used for manufacturing
purposes, and would be particularly so in the case of Winthrop, as we have no com-
munication whatever, except one, a narrow-gauge railroad for passengers only. The
town has a frontage upon the sea of 7 miles, which, if it could be made available by
a channel sufficient to take in light-draught vessels, would greatly lessen the cost of
all materials that are used in manufacture or building. The excavation of the chan-
nel, it is believed, could be done at a trifling cost compared with the benefits to be
derived.
  This harbor is free from rocks and obstructions of every kind; its bottom is a bed
of mud some 5 feet deep, resting upon sandy soil.
  The harbor is well sheltered on all sides, and is a safe place for anchorage while
waiting for favorable winds or tide.
  The project asked for is the making of a channel, so as to have a depth of 5 feet at
mean low water, with a width of 75 feet.
  Winthrop, at the present time, is growing more rapidly than any other town in the
State. The following will show the increase in population and buildings in Winthrop
alone during the past years:
Population in June-
   1880------
        ......-----------......---......-------......-......------....---......-------                                         2,050
   1885 (over)------
               ......-------....--------....---......----....----....--............-----......------......-----....-...... --- 5,000

Number of dwellings in-
   1880 ..............................                           ...... ........................... ....                             213
     1885 ......-............................... ...........                                      ..........          ........       558


                ....--------......--......-------......---......-----......---...----...---........------..........
        Increase---------                                                                                                            345
  This does not include stables, stores, hotels, two public halls, and other buildings
erected for manufacturing purposes.
  In 1874-twelve years ago-there were 430 parcels of land in the town of Winthrop,
and at the present time there are 2,509 parcels. There were at that time 168 owners;
now there are 664. The number of public streets were 9; now there are 29. The
number of private ways then were 16; now there are 89. At that time there were 131
houses; now there are 619.
  The following is the increase in valuation within the last two years:
Personal estate in-
     1883 .        .....................                                                                                         $46 685
     18853 ----- ---- ---- ----------------------- "-- ---- "----------- ----- 59,9308
     1885 ....--....----.....------......--------....--....---------....----....-----......------......---------......--......---....
                                                                                                                                  59, 950

       Increase ...............................                                  ........         .". .........    ._......       13, 265

Real estate in-
    1883 ...............................................................                                                      1,784,595
    1885 ....-- ..........................................................                                                    2, 193.500

       Increase ...................                           .................................                                  408, 905
470      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The above will show a wonderful progress, and all with a very insufficient railroad
communication. The present narrow-gauge runs on the north side of the town, and
those persons living on the south side have to resort to barges. Three thousand tons
of coal are consumed annually, every pound of which has to be carted from East
Boston. The same may be said of the building material that is used in the town,
such as lime, timber, bricks, and granite. All this heavy material has to be carted
over the road, which very naturally increases the cost at least 10 per cent.
   A few reasons why this channel should be constructed:
   Because it is a public necessity and will prove of great advantage to the town and
country.
   Because the industry of the town demands it, which is composed at the present
time of curriers, torpedo manufacturers, boat-builders, carpenters and builders, wheel-
wrights, carriage painters, etc.
   Because with water communication it is safe to predict that the population and
taxation would be doubled inside two years.
   Because, in a sanitary point of view, if a channel was cut through the flats it would
prove a natural drain, and carry off the refuse matter which is brought in by the
tide and left to rot on the flats to the detriment of the health of the inhabitants.
   In addition to the before-mentioned reasons why we hope Winthrop Harbor will be
deemed worthy of the improvement asked for, we will add that the town of Revere,
which adjoins and is tributary to Winthrop for its water communication, contains a
population much greater than the latter town, and is joined in Winthrop in the peti-
tion to have Winthrop Harbor channel made available for commercial purposes.
                                                              EDMUND S. READ,
                                                              STEPHEN S. SMITH,
                                                              SAMUEL G.   IRVIN,
                                        Board of Selectmen, Town of Winthrop, Mass.




            SURVEY OF WINTHROP HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

                         UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                 Boston, Mass., November 28, 1887.
  GENERAL: In compliance with instructions contained in your letter
of March 16, 1887, I have the honor to transmit herewith a report of
Mr. Sophus Haagensen, assistant engineer, on the survey of Winthrop
Harbor, Massachusetts, made to comply with the provisions of the river
and harbor act approved August 5, 1886.
  A tracing of the survey is also transmitted, upon which has been in-
dicated the proposed project for improvement.
  The preliminary report on this harbor, dated November 20, 1886, to
which attention is respectfully invited, gives the essential features of
the harbor, and my reasons for recommending the survey. It will not
be out of place to repeat that the southern side of the flats constituting
the harbor is skirted by a back channel having 9 to 16 feet, mean low
water, which extends from Point Shirley to East Boston, and which has
two navigable connections with the main ship-channel through Boston
Harbor.
   The harbor, so called, measures 350 acres of tidal flats, which are
generally 2 feet above mean low water, over which are scattered a few
bowlders, lying chiefly near Snake Island. It is traversed by two small
tidal depressions or channels, in which the depth of water varies from
6 feet to 0, mean low water. The greater of these depressions lies on
the east side of Snake Island, adjacent to Point Shirley, and the project
for the improvement proposes to convert this depression into a naviga-
ble channel to connect Rice's Wharf with the back channel, so that ves-
sels of small draught may conveniently reach the town of Winthrop, at
all stages of the tide, by way of the Bird Island Channel.
   The proposed channel will be 3,900 feet long, 50 feet wide, and 6 feet
                                                                                                                002.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        ,uo
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       2
                                                                                                                                                 c--2                                                                                                                                                                         -                     i        -        i4l i              i                    _           n        --                                   "CI                                     _        -




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          -"                        9    -              O.          -             0-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           74-5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              -25                      _22'+
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        4         -      . .-      -3        _o ,                              '        o                                     "

                                                                                                                                                                                                             2.0
                                                                                                                     41,                         <            .       r                                                     - .'""                                     -14j-                                   "a3.               _2,
                                                                                                                                                                                           W
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        --"                                                      4,,0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        /.                          15
                                                                                                                ,          x-z                                                    0.                                                      - 'a",_18                    .                                                                        . "g -0.                  - 'olg                                                                                                  /91
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   2                                                                                                                                                         5




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        -'            -o                              "_              _".
                                                                                                                                                                                                              '                                                    -
                                     Jij;4                                                                      '           12                                             2:14                 -o                                    ' -t           " 2                   ..             _8-       '          -2        .,       7        -f
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                10 -. +_                           . n           ,,                                                                                               . . ."-


                                                                                                                                                          -           ""2                            "

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 , ' .u j.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   "a[
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   .-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      {                           .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      115                                                   :


                                          ......--       ""Z                H A .ii:CHANNC-L) ....                                                                    7-                        xl       "
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  W                      isij'--j.4'                                                     Q".p-'"                  -.        -1.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             F ' -'k                                                                                             N.."
                          2 2                " -                                                                       ,      "-"-'                               "                    "   -1                                   -u                                                                      ""
                                                                                                                                           171


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                4              0 4,1,j.1-]
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        _7., .1:5-        ,                                                                                                                      '.
       .. $2            E..    N:                  i    "-
                                                                                                                                                          "                        ...
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              -               ,.",                       ,: -.                    _? _"                          4' -           _21 . z '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          414'

                                                                                                                                          -] "                                                                                       "
                                                                       -.       .         \      €I _
                                                                                          "".-',Z"               ;"] z                                   - "s           "          "      - "                                   -                    //                                           - "           -           -i .
                                                                                    "''      "-' '  -,,
                                                                                                     '"-    _ o -'%
                                                                                                                 -"q"             q'             ]                     -".             -2 .-                               o.                                  Z './ ?)                       - ...           -z         152 :
                   )"
               (.""U          -.      7      -                              1                              i r .l            3        "              4                 s.         2 +-                             .                                 ,-7                                                     a          -                 16-
                                                                            %14111
                                                                               -,                  t
                                                                                                                                                         _.,.                                            .                                                                                                              o l,
                                                                                              "- "g]8"                     .] .. --.             •                           ,                  _1                                                                                      - -     F
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          /                =:                                 - .                 3
                                                                 "-\        -- ". •                v -                     "%                                                "-.                                                 S.       .                                     '0                                       lb . "
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        13b

                                                                                                             "'"                                                  1                                                    ,                      I !.             '                                                         .1."6_




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 97                    17-'")


,l             WINTHROP
                 A
                                                                             HARBOR,MASS.
                                          BM                                         S.SURYED INACCORDANCE
                                                                                                     WITH                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             ""                                   "43..                                                     ', .:..                     .
               ACT      OF           CONGRESS                      APPROVED                              'AUGUST                      5.11186.i6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                1.52
                        SHOWING                        PROPOSED                                    IMPROVEMENTS                                                                                                                 -                                                                                                                       SAS                                             ,                     •                              I\-                         ////
                                                   To accompany                           Yeport           of                                                                                                                                                                   '
            LT.COL. GEO.L. GILLESPIE                                                       , CORPS OFENGBS. U.S.A.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             -_-                                        q.                                       .. "            .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           1          6                                     1"
                                                     SCALE         OF        MAP            I 1.8000
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                d                                       22                 /                   /.                ..
                  o            300                     1011300                                             t2ad2$003000                                                Fr                                .Ao4r. The sounigepesdi                                                                                         etar
                                                                                                                                                                                                 refer to mian                                low              wr                             a ndi          are         seleete Sfrom
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             ,/
                                                                                                                                                                                                t.           ,>u fne,'ou soundaken                                                                       in the surrq
                                                                                                                                                 2
                                                             I.Sn in-rr    i' Oce.Boston,)fas.jlrember                                       867.                                                iS         a'587nd quartenr  at                                                              trn the US                          mquir
                                                                 7
                                                                                     to
                                                                   es e etFulty forwarded with
                                                                             the C nef otfnyineers.
                                                                                                                                 letter of hie da
                                                                                                                                      Wasknynort.D .C.
                                                                                                                                                                                                 surVey of
                                                                                                                                                                                                    ihte mean
                                                                                                                                                                                                                Aeson Harbor.

                                                                                                                                                                                                Bench wa an    v
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  r
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    oo
                                                                                                                                                                                                                       or fall o                                                         tid,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        pu
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         is
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               n asre
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        9.e. feet
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            -       post,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ralatd                                  co;  7         area   .Iadted
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      be dredged
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             thus
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            to   a
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            fpruposed
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        depth of' 6'fC'at
                                                                                                                                                                                                350 ft. B . of U~laa                                                                                            oel
                                                                                                                    .Le.Col. of Engineers,                                                       and               i                 17.0     flet              aborc                            mean                    Jon"              n, ct             r.                              rn       zn          low         nea uter.


     Survyedy and drawn            by ,Sop/c           laagense-                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   Yoo




     Eng50 2
            APPENDIX B-REPORT                                       OF LIEUT.                 COL. GILLESPIE.                       471
deep, mean low water, and its excavation will require the removal of
64,000 cubic yards of sand and soft clay, at an estimated cost as follows:
Dredging 64,000 cubic yards sand and clay, at 25 cents per cubic yard........ $16, 000
Contingencies of engineering, etc..........................................     1,600
      Total ......---------....----......---------....-------....--....------....---.....----..--..---......--....-----.........   17,600
   An appropriation of $17,600 is recommended for the proposed im-
provement. The population interested in the improvement is 5,000souls,
and the estimated value of the real and personal property represented
is estimated at $2,250,000.
   I respectfully invite attention to the accompanying report of Mr. S.
Haagensen, assistant engineer, for the details of the survey and the gen-
eral description of the harbor and its approaches.
   The existing commerce of the harbor is nominal.
  Winthrop Harbor, Massachusetts, is in the collection district of Boston, Mass., of
which Boston is the port of entry, and the nearest light-house is situated upon Long
Island Head, Boston Harbor, Massachusetts.
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                               G. L. GILLESPIE,
                                              Lieut. Gol. of Engineers.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. A.



                 REPORT OF MR.                  SOPHUS HAAGENSEN,                      ASSISTANT ENGINEER.

                                                                         UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                                                                        Boston, Mass., November 2, 1887.
  COLONEL: I have the honor to report upon the survey of Winthrop Harbor, Massa-
chusetts, made in April, 1887, in pursuance of your instructions.                                                     Also to submit a
map of the survey, drawn to a scale of 1:6000.

                                                            TOPOGRAPHY.

  The accompanying map is reduced from the original plot of the survey, which was
drawn to a scale of 1 : 3000. A base-line 2,150 feet long was measured on the beach
connecting Point Shirley with Great Head. Eight triangulation points were located
and occupied, and from these the details of the survey were developed. The point K
of this survey is the same as the United States Engineer station at Great Head (also
U. S. Coast Survey A point); it is marked by a square stone post. By sights from
this point to the A point at Governor's Island the survey was connected with the gen-
eral survey of Boston Harbor.
  The high-water and wharf lines from Bartlett's Pier to Rice's Wharf, Snake Island,
and part of Point Shirley, were located by us; the rest of the high-water line shown
on the map is drawn in by enlarging U. S. Coast Survey manuscript map.

                                                          HYDROGRAPHY.


   The area covered by our soundings extends from the 18-foot contour of the channel
south of the harbor up to the Pile Bridge at Ocean Spray, and is about 350 acres. A
fan of twenty lines was laid out, and an aggregate length of 13.1 miles of these lines
were run, upon which 2,948 soundings were taken. Of this number 505 were located
by transit intersections from shore stations. Nine borings were made in the channel
east of Snake Island.
   The soundings on the map, selected from the above, refer to mean low water, and
are expressed in feet and tenths; those expressed in feet and quarters are taken from
the United States Commissioner's survey of Boston Harbor (A. Boschke, 1861), and
also refer to mean low water. Two of the lines of the present survey were extended
across the channel to Apple Island Flats, to compare with United States Commission-
er's map.
472           REPORT OF THE CHIEF                               OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                             TIDES.

   The tides are the same as for Boston lower harbor, viz:
                                                                                                                              Feet
                           --
Mean rise or fall of tide .---..........................................--                                    ........         9. 4
Extreme low water observed------   ......---..........................................                                   --    2.5
Extreme high water observed--        .------......---------......------............-............----......-----....           12. 2
  The tide-staff used in the survey was placed on the United States Wharf at Lovell's
Island.
  The bench-mark is a copper plug in a stone post 350 feet east of the United States
Wharf at Lovell's Island, and is 17 feet above mnean low water.

                        DESCRIPTION OF THE HARBOR AND ITS APPROACHES.


  Winthrop Harbor is a tidal harbor, mostly flats in elevation 2 feet above mean low
water, inclosed by the high hills of the town on the north and by Great Head and
Point Shirley on the east. This triangular area contains about 350 acres south of the
Pile Bridge; north of this there is about 110 acres of flats and salt marshes draining
into the harbor.
  The greatest depression in the flats follows the easterly shore, becomes a low-water
channel 1,500 feet below the bridge, and continues to deepen for a length of 2,800 feet
to the edge of the flats passing between nake Island and Point Shirley. For the
last 1,600 feet the 2-foot channel is continuous, deepening to 6 feet at the junction
with the channel limiting the harbor on the south.
  To the west of Snake Island there is another lesser gully. Borings show the flats
to consist of sand, mud, and soft clay, to a depth of 8 feet below mean low water.
West of Snake Island are many scattered bowlders.
  The flats slope abruptly from low water to 18 feet depth, and from the northerly
edge of the 1,500-feet-wide channel between Winthrop Harbor and Apple Island Flats.
This is the principal water-way for the large tidal basin known as East Boston Flats,
with many branching channels and gullies.
   It is entered directly from Broad Sound through Shirley Gut with 15 feet at mean
low water, and connects with the main ship-channel of Boston Harbor by channels
east and west of Apple Island; the former with 15 feet at mean low water to President
Roads, 1 mile distant, and the latter with 17 feet at mean low water to upper middle
channel, 2 miles distant, via Apple Island and Bird Island channels.
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                                          SOPHUS        HAAGENSEN,
                                                                                                      Assistant Engineers
    Lieut. Col. GEO. L. GILLESPIE,
                 Corps of Engineers, U. S. A.




                                                              B I5.

PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION OF DUXBURY HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

                                                  UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                      Boston, Mass., November 8, 1886.
     GENERAL:   In compliance with instructions contained in your letter
of September 27, 1886, I have the honor to transmit herewith the follow-
ing report of a preliminary examination of the harbor at Duxbury,
Mass., provided for in the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886:
    Duxbury Bay is one of the three divisions into which Plymouth Har-
bor is divided, viz: Plymouth Bay, Kingston Bay, and Duxbury Bay.
The first two have previously been improved by Government appropria-
tions, but no money has ever been expended upon the channels leading
into and through Duxbury Bay.
    By resolution of House of Representatives March 9, 1871, an examina-
tion or survey of the harbor of Duxbury, Mass., was called for, 'a with
a view to dredging and improving the same, so as to afford greater pro-
        APPENDIX     B--REPORT OF LIEUT.            COL. GILLESPIE.   473
tection and facilities to commerce," etc. (Report Chief of Engineers,
1872, page 963.)
    The town of Duxbury covers part of the Kingston Bay, so called, and
it is stated in the report of the local engineer, December 1, 1871, that
the petitioners of Duxbury, in asking for the improvement of their har-
bor, had in vi<w the enlargement, at Splitting-Knife Bar, of the Miles
or South Channel, extending westward from the Cow Yard by the south
point of Captain's Hill. Owing to the small amount of commerce at
the wharves located on Duxbury Bay proper, to which access was given
by the channel on the east side of Captain's Hill, and the small draught
of the vessels, chiefly in the fishing trade, which entered that part of
the harbor, and for other reasons, the local engineer dlid not recommend
the improvement of the channel leading into Duxbury Bay, which was
estimated to cost $66,000.
    The appropriation of June 10, 1872, of $10,000, and that of March 3,
1873, of $10,000, were applied in the South Channel. No other appro-
priations have been made except for the improvement of Plymouth Bay.
Duxbury Bay is not so important commercially as the other bays; still
it has a good, wide channel, affording 12 feet depth mean low water to
within 1 mile of the principal wharf, and affords a respectable anchor-
age for vessels when the Cow Yard is full. If the channel were extended
with 6 feet depth mean low water, so that the principal wharf of the
town could be reached, it is believed that all the trade of the town would
be concentrated there, to the benefit and advantages of the citizens, and
that many vessels would use it, by which freight charges would be re-
duced on coal, lumber, and other supplies, which form the principal
  bforeign articles of consumption in the town.
    The harbor "is worthy of improvement" as one of the tributaries of
the main harbor of Plymouth, Mass.
    The channel improvement, for which an estimate was given in 1871,
extended from the wharf on the south side of Duxbury Point, in the
northern part of the harbor, to the 6-foot curve. It was 2,000 feet,
long, 150 feet wide, and 6'feet deep, mean low water. As sixteen years
have elapsed since the survey of 1871, and since it is probable many
changes have occurred in the upper harbor of Duxbury, I would recom-
mend that an examination be made of the existing channel inside the
6-foot curve to determine the direction to be given to the improved
channel.
    The allotment recommended for this purpose is $400.
          Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                          G.   L.    GILLESPIE,
                                                Lieut. Gol. of Engineers.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. A.



          SURVEY OF DUXBURY        HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

                            UNITED   STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                     Boston, Mass., November 28, 1887.
  GENERAL: In compliance with instructions contained in your letter
of March 16, 1887, I have the honor to transmit herewith a report by
Mr. Sophus Haagensen, assistant engineer, on the survey of Duxbury
Harbor, Massachusetts, made to comply with the provisions of river and
harbor act approved August 5, 1886.
474       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The accompanying tracing gives the details of the authorized exam -
ination of the existing channel through the inner harbor of Duxbury,
inside or north of the 6-foot curve, upon which is located the direction
to be given to an improved channel to a selected wharf at Duxbury.
   An outline tracing of Plymouth, Kingston, and Duxbury bays, com-
bined, is also transmitted, to render intelligible the report of the local
engineer, December 1, 1871. (Report Chief of Engineers, 1872, page
963.)
   The Cow Yard, inside and near the sea entrance to these bays, is the
anchorage common to all. It is marked by the Duxbury Pier Light and
day beacon, and has in places a depth of 12 fathoms at mean low stage.
Starting from this common ground, the improvements mad3 by the Gov-
ernment in past years have been to the southward in the direction of
Plymouth, or northward in the direction of Kingston.
    The channel leading to the northward through Duxbury Bay has
never been improved, though the conditions of protection afforded by
an outer beach are as favorable as in the case of the Plymouth Harbor
improvement.
    Abreast and westward of Clark's Island the Duxbury Channel sepa-
rates into two channels. The Beach Channel is broad and deep, follows
close to the beach, and has its depth maintained by the tidal scour from
Back River. This channel is remote from the town, and has no wharves
which could be conveniently converted into commercial use.
    The westward channel is also amply wide and deep for vessels draw-
ing 18 feet to within one-half mile of the southern end of the town, when
it separates into two branches, the eastern branch terminating in the
6-foot curve below Knapp's Wharf, and the western terminating in the
same curve below the town wharf. In the Report of 1871 an estimate
was submitted for connecting this eastern branch with Knapp's Wharf
at a cost of $66,000. It was this improvement which I had in my mind
when the preliminary report of Niovember 8, 1886, was submitted. But
inasmuch as the property upon which Knapp's Wharf is located has
lately changed hands, and that shore will no longer be used for com-
mercial purposes, I have during the survey examined the shore upon
which the town is built, and now present a project for a channel which
  will communicate with its principal wharf.
    I have chosen the western branch of the Duxbury Channel for im-
provement, for the reason that the excavation will be less on that side,
and also because the axis of the improved channel will be more nearly
in the direction of the ebb currents than in the case of a channel exca-
  vated to connect the town wharf with the eastern branch.
    The proposed channel will be 3,600 feet long, 60 feet wide, and 6 feet
  deep, mean low water, and its improvement will require the excavation
of 48,000 cubic yards of material, scow measure, at an estimated cost as
follows:
Dredging 48,000 cubic yards of material, scow measurement, at 25 cents per
  cubic yard..        .       ......     .............................................                       .       ...   $12,000
Contingencies for engineering, etc.. -                                  ......-.....................   .   .......           1,200

      Total .............................................................                                                   13,200
  A comparison of the surveys of 1871, 1875, and 1887 indicates that
the channel, when once opened, will probably not deteriorate more
rapidly than similar tidal channels.
  An appropriation of $13,200 is recommended for the improvement.
  Duxbury is not an important commercial point; but it is believed
that the proposed channel will give great relief to the town by reduc-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           Sheet No.I


                                                                                                                                                                      DUXBURY HARBOR
                                                                                                                                                                                             MASSACHUSETTS
                                                                                                                                                                                                 OUTLINE                 MAP      OF

                                                                                                                                                         .- :"DUXBUTY , KINGSTON

                                                                                                                                           ID'.-                                         .PLYMOUTH                               BAYS
                                                                                              ,       ,.    '                                                                FROM            U.S.COAST                   SURVEY          CHARTS

                                                                                                                                                                                          TO ACCOMPANY REPORT OF
                                                                                                  ,..: :-..,                            ,..;::                        "LT.               COL                 L .GILLESPIE
                                                                                                                                                                                                           GEO.
                                                                                                                                              er'¢a                  ,       ... CORPS                                     OF ENGINEERS,      U.S.A.

                                                                                      8 ,             ( r!_ -,                                                                                                  1887
                                                                                                                                                                                          \SCALE           OF     MAP        1: 60,000




                                   Ii;ii

   Eng50
       2.                      '                       ..                       /

                           •               '/     ,,                                          :       ::." :>..                                                                                                                  hi-
                                                                                                                                                                             I   f                          U   JI   .    (1Nr    ore      ssov        iMs.


            ;I       ,     , .: ' " """::;,                   iJ t1 "          1 '   t/                                         ;y. ,1: " % U y

            .    .          :::.-,v.'..
                         .......                               e    --X1




                                                                                                                               rI
                                                                                                      S17.'                                                                                                                             CO$-:..OFENGINEER




                                                                   .....                                          N                       'MA'
                                                            iI9j                                                                0             l                                      /


                                                                               36s
                                                ;.,-.,+.                   ,                                                                            i ! " \                      f                 .        N..CR
                                                                                                                                                                                                            N..G."...
                                                                                                                                                                                                               VO'o      OF.C
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    48L# i~      6   Tg
                                                                                                                                                                                                                            28. c1887"
                                                                                          -                           \       *''~'I,.,.Y f       .,,                                     RA:.    PICTFLLLY              FORWARDZD          W/7N   LE.TrER
                                                                                                                          \         C    iK             :;       r       \       I          OF THI'         DATA: TO         TNT        CHEiL OFN/NEEITI
                                                                                                                                                   \         46i,"/                            WASH/       0BT(      D.C


                                                                                          -\;                                                                                                                                    L.."    C0..OF" E NGINEERS

                                                                                                      ,//




                                                                                                  '




Eng5O 2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      /r
     #
          77777 77,,77777 177zz77"777z777.7711-z"77zz""zzzz7777777zz,-7,77z7777777zzzzzz..--zzlzly                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         11




                                                                                                                                                                                                                BsD UXBURY                                                                                                                HARBOR, MASS.
                                -       2   -0           ..   ?

                                                                                                                                                                                   7"2.                                             3        oSHOWING                                                     PROPOSED                                                           IMPROVEMENTS
                                                          : s
                                                   _.. o,...
                                                                       1o-                             s                                                                                                                                                   SURVEYED IN ACCORDANCE WITH
                                        .2.7                                                                                                                                                                    7 'ACT                                   OF CONGRESS APPROVED AUGTJST 5. 1886
                      4 ,-2.4
                -'2. 2.    .:.2.,;-7.                                7 -2.a
                                                                   -3.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            2.G ;.' To accompa&ry- report of

                                                                                  , 1....
                                                                                                                                                                                               00L_'IT.                                 COL.                 GEO". L . GILLESPIE , CORPS OF ENGBS. U.S.A.
                                                              2

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    -           p9.oj''SCALE                                                                    OF MAP 1:80

                                                                            .;:"_1.                                                                                                                                       o's
                                                                                                                                                                                                                          0                                                                        S00       1000                                 o    1500         ,o                            .o.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   2000                                  2500  ,o             3000   FT.




                             01                               .-       2.
                                                                                                  .                    -                  -                                                     _         ,2*S0       - 26                                                                                         & n ei'w er Office.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                3ee
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       Boston,Jas.N vember 2&187                  x    e



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             . ., espectfJ                                            fornrarded withle(er of/ i dat~
                                                                                                                                   S 0 -1. - "o                                     -2.                                                                                                                                                   f~e                                          (rtzef of £nfei ers, Was.hrz'qto,,


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                S ".o. -.2 0.                                    -                                                                                                   . Col. of       mE~ngners
                                                                                              . .               .'                 -1"                         0     .                         - 3.s                                         .2.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             1.


                                                                                                                     0.3
                                                                                                                " " -.                                -0.                         - -                                               _1.s
                                                                                                  27                                                                           0,9                                                                                                        ..

                                                                                         - .g                         Io                          O".. 03s. - 3                8 . 0' . . 7I. 0 .
                                                                                                                                                                               -...0"                                                             3*
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        **"04,00.3-                     -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  -1.3                                                                                          0


                                                                                          -1                   -l.5            '" 2"",                                                         0                                                     _0.                    . -1.3"...                                                                               0                     ..
                                                                                                                                                       o..,,4....


                                                                                                      -8                       -                         o                                                                                   .                                                                           .1                                                                                                                          0.   8

                                                                                                                                0.5                           3.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                '-"...*.--1-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     1.8
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               x       :1c3


                                                                                                                           -       2              -0.2                                                                                           1.                             o.-                                                                                                                         0.z


                                                                   O             5 Q                       '0
                                                                                                                      .0.5                    .
                                                                                                                                                                     -. s
                                                                                                                                                                       .o
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    0s-os5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    *.   0-0.s                                                                    0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              . ....
                                                                                                                      .4.."                             O.S               .                1 _1.                      0                      ..      e                          .                  9o                        .                                   O0




                                                         2-
                                                                   -        10.          2•0               .
                                                                                                               $ 0   ... Y-
                                                                                                                         21
                                                                                                                       .....                      0.O0.oO
                                                                                                                       '9 .-s ' -O".f 0. 9 4. '' 2 12 a0. s
                                                                                                                      0.0.11-o o0 '2  a'2 .93 1. ..   1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              0 "- '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    :
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            2 0-Al"
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         oa-.   ..."2-s
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          52 ' 3 " "s"
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             - ,3
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    -   oo -O
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             s                  s "
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       0.7"
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   '.10 o
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                1.0. O1.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              .     9_ .                   - s
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          o-1 5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 . . o0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 0.  0 .,5                                                   5..Ld   o.-0 ,     7K




I
                                                         4                              0-0$11                                                        S1.0n <Z"               1.0     .$
                                                                                                                                                                                          2,        0.7    o.5 .,                       .7                                  0.2-"Lo
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          "              '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ".
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     .2    1       .        1   .4           0.       04        14.Lo       s   .-       U7s         1-21013-




                                                                                                                                       (1..                                                                                                  0.


                                                                                    02 .                                                                 1
                                                                       2.  0" 0." 1. 1.                                               z                             2      1. .7 1.a                                                    2~ o                                                                                                                                                   a.4.0.                                2   O-
                                                                        --           1                                                                 2,                 ..3     1..                                         o.'
                                                                   -             .5'
                                                                            07111'*

                                                                                                                                                                              o"'."                                                                         1.                         1




                                                                                                                  .                                                                                                       20. 1. 0                   1                                              2
                                                                                                  s                                           .              .1.                                    0 l'                   1"1"2
                                                                                                                                                              1.0               0 2.2                           0 .7                                                                                    61.          2   0.9                   ;        .        .
    ool
    10
                                                                                                                                                                                               oo .                                                                              o.                                                                             o"
    00


    00
    10
                                                                                        1.    L                  .
                                                                                                                           7.M.*


                                                                                                                               3
                                                                                                                                              . 0.6     .5
                                                                                                                                                                    -..                    . ....~                d
                                                                                                                                                                                                                      o
                                                                                                                                                                                                                           -8

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                O 0.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          O             ...
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        0...                     .                                                         .            01:/
                                                                                                                                                        *9....            .                                   ... 4::                                          .,                     0                                                                                                                     :23              /                  2.

                                                                                    0o                1.       o.....8                                                                                                          .                                                                  1'                                              _        ._. 2/                                                   .                    2.

                                                                                                                                                                                      .                       o -02s                                                                                                                                   .-Ls.s
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          1 .72 ;.                                                       2       a              a
                                                                       1.       7
                                                                                O         .           .1o*               °'o..1                                                ,               .2
                                                              1.                                                      0.                                                                                                                                                        0.                           0                      .                                                                                       2o

                                                                   7            1.a.21                                                                                              2.(                    3_         .             O            T .5                            _                       _.1.        1                                   "                    .
    00

                                                                                          ,                    .j'2o                                                      0-:" 0                                                             1                                                                      -,,..
    10
    10




                                                                                              0.                                       ............                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                +
                                                                            5       '
                                                                                                                                             --. 0                              0
                                                                                                                                                                                                    ".5         . .. . . .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                           _l.                        ..0      _._
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             "o.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              .8                                   'S4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    1 5- ',-- .,.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               ' "



                                                  .0..
                                                    2
                                                                                              5.."2
                                                                                                                                          -.
                                                                                                                                                                   .2-0             .-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         X017.°                  8".

                                                                                0c...                                                             0           o                 a2         2              4       -0o               .                 0.




                           in..0ecopin              stone     and
                                                 _0nhrcrc-o.Krzaps      9.&fee
                                                                   ..s har"5                                                                           aoe
                                                                                                                                                      0"5di lo' mean
                                                                                                                                                                 l2"                                 .e.                   O        s                                                     ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       dredged
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              "
                                                        w-er.                                                                                                                                                   "ow                 .Area                                   h                      "dedhus                           /
                                    T
                  N o d , 7 he . s o un                        ed     i         - o. ,-' o7
                                                                                    ~_s-a re e . res                                                                                                                                                     - (')...                                                                                                        .

                   feet an-d1                           envt h s a nd refer -to meearn , *                                                                                                                                               - ..                                                  9                  19
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            o                  :
                    wader; tihey are selecded from.nt1u -h n umnerous
                   soun-dinz96 -e ako, in the s u rvey.
                  lerch         E.no.g...
                                a0rk. on,                   Wharf 2(
                                                                   Ai" a.                                                                                 -
                                                                                                                                                         drilliwo                                                               ... " .napps
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         -~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      /1/.               f: 4                        1.                          pr                    o6               d

                   wr vohye'ard          draw re by Soples ca  rmennee




            Eng50 2
          APPENDIX        B-REPORT       OF LIEUT. COL. GILLESPIE.                 475
ing the cost of transportation of such articles as coal, lumber, lime, and
building materials, which enter into daily consumption.
   I respectfully invite attention to the report of Mr. Haagensen, assist-
ant engineer, for the details of the survey and for the general descrip-
tion of the harbor.
  Duxbury is in the collection district of Plymouth, Mass., of which Plymouth is the
port of entry. The nearest light-house is the Duxbury Pier Light, situated in the
Cow Yard anchorage.
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                         G.. L. GILLESPIE,
                                                        Lieut. Col. of Engineers.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                S. A.



            REPORT   OF   MR.   SOPHUS HAAGENSEN,    ASSISTANT ENGINEER.


                                          UNITED STATES ENGINEER'S       OFFICE,
                                                   Boston, Mass., November 4, 1887.
   COLONEL: I have the honor to report upon the survey of Duxbury Harbor, Massa-
chusetts, made in August and September,1887, in pursuance of your instructions; also
to submit a map of the survey drawn to a scale of 1: 6000.
                                     TOPOGRAPHY.

   The accompanying map is reduced from the original plot of the survey, which was
drawn to a scale of 1: 3000. A base line 2,200 feet long vas measured from Knapp's
Wharf eastward along the shore of Powder Point.
   Fourteen triangulation points were located and occupied, and from these the details
-of the survey were developed. The point Duxbury Belfry is the same as in United
             3
States Engineer's Survey of 1871 (and of the U. S. Coast Survey map); by sights from
this station t South Gurnet Light the present survey was connected with former sur-
veys.
   The high-water line, shown on the map, is essentially that of the U. S. Coast Sur-
vey map, the only change being a dike built across Blue River, which, with Knapp's
Wharf and some scattered points of the high-water line, were located by us.
                                    HYDROGRAPHY.

  The area covered by our sounding is the upper northwest corner of the harbor, and
amounts to 750 acres, or about 11 miles from north to south by nearly a mile from east
to west, so as to include the main channel with its branches. Sixty ranges were es-
tablished and an aggregate length of 28.6 miles of these lines run, upon which '6,663
soundings were taken; of this number 1,102 were located by transit intersections
from shore stations. Below the area covered by the soundings the channel as far as
the Cow Yard was "swept; " no obstructions were found. The soundings, expressed
in feet and tenths, refer to mean low water.
                                         TIDES.

  A tide-staff was set in the main channel, and by eight consecutive high and low
water observations seven values found for mean ocean level. From the average of
these were deducted 4.65 feet (or one-half of mean rise or fall, 9.3 feet), giving menu
low-water level.
  A bench-mark was established on Knapp's Wharf (shown on map) and is a drill
hole in the coping stone in elevation 9.85 feet above mean low water.
                                CURRENT OBSERVATIONS.

   The tracks of free floats set adrift near the wharves were followed both on ebb and
flood tide. The velocity of current is almost imperceptible in this part of the har-
bor, the maximum observed being .4 foot per second on half and three-quarter ebb,
and .3 foot per second on three-quarter flood. Most of the floats on the ebb tide
drifted towards the main channel, although some, during the latter part of the ebb,
turned the projecting point opposite Knapp's Wharf and followed the shore southward.
476        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                DESCRIPTION OF CHANNEL.

  The entrance to Duxbury Harbor is from Cape Cod Bay through the " Main Ship--
channel" leading from Gurnet Lights for a distance of 3 miles to Duxbury Pier
Light in the Cow Yard, which is the roadsteads common to Plymouth, Kingston, and
Duxbury Harbors; this channel runs due west, is straight, almost one-half mile wide,
and passable for vessels of the deepest draught. The Cow Yard is circular, about
three-fourths of a mile in diameter, and the greatest depth is 12 fathoms at low water.
From Duxbury Pier Light the main channel of Duxbury Harbor runs in a northerly
direction, tapering from a width of 600 feet to 200 feet on the 18-foot curve at the
point where the present survey began, distant 21 miles from Duxbury Pier Light, or
51 miles from the Gurnet. About midway in this reach, or abreast of Clark's Island,
is the junction with the Beach Channel, which carries off the water of Back River,
the drain from the extensive marshes north of Powder Point.
   From the initial point of the survey the 18-foot channel is continuous for 3,600 feet;
the 12-foot (from 300 to 200 feet wide) for a distance of 5,000 feet; the 6-foot channel
extends to 6,500 feet, where the channel through the flats becomes very circuitous
and shallow, and practically ends at 9,000 feet, or opposite Knapp's Wharf. Five
hundred feet north of the initial point a 10-foot channel branches off to the west and
north to a distance of 3,500 feet. At 3,800 feet the 6-foot channel stops, although
there are many "pot-holes" with 6 feet depth between this point and the Town
Landing, 7,400 feet distant.
   Outside of the above-described channel the surveyed area is mud-flats in an aver-
age elevation of mean low water, running almost entirely dry at an extreme low
water.
  Borings made in 1871 show these flats to consist of sand and mud overlying hard
clay, which latter was struck in the following
61                                                     depths:
                                                         51 feet, 111 feet, 21 feet, and
   feet below mean low water in four representative sections of this part of the har-
bor.
  The survey shows no change in the channels or flats, as developed by survey of 1871
and by U. S. Coast Survey of 1867 and lai.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                 SOPIIUs HIIAAGENSEN,
                                                                       Assistant Engineer.
     Lieut. Col. GEO. L.   GILLESPIE,
                  Corips of E.giners, U. S. A.




                                          B      I6.

PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION OF WELLFLEET HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

                             UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                       Boston, Mass., November 8, 1886.
   GENERAL: In compliance with instructions contained in your letter
of September 27, 1886, I have the honor to transmit herewith the fol-
lowing report of a preliminary examination of the harbor at Wellfleet,
Mass., provided for in the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886.
   This harbor is situated near the northern extremity of Cape Cod, and
is the best and most sheltered harbor on the cape, except that of Prov-
incetown. It is especially frequented by mackerel fishermen, whose
fleet numbers over one hundred vessels, but this number is largely in-
creased by other vessels which come irregularly. The draught of some
of the vessels is 10 feet and over, and under present conditions they can
only make the harbor at half-tide.
   The value of the annual fish yield exceeds $500,000.
   By act of Congress January 31, 1871, a survey of this harbor was
made June, 1871, and a report submitted November 3, 1871 (Report
Chief of Engineers, 1872, page 969). The report embodied a project for
excavating a channel to give access to Central and Commercial wharves
at Wellfleet 2,060 feet long, 150 feet wide, and 4 feet deep, at an esti
mated cost of $30,000.
        APPENDIX B--REPORT        OF LIEUT. COL. GILLESPIE.            477
   By act June 10, 1872, an appropriation of $5,000 was made for the
improvement, which sum was expended in 1872-'73 in the complete re-
moval of Channel, Mayo, Bay, Lobster, and Lumpfish rocks.
   The survey of 1871 only covered that portion of the upper bay which
extends north Gf "Deep Hole," about 1 mile from the town wharves.
The obstructions of which mariners now complain, in addition to those
mentioned in report of 1871, are the sand-shoals in the lower bay (all
the known bowlders near the channel have been removed) at the en-
trace and inside, opposite Billingsgate light-house.
   I think the harbor " worthy of improvement," and respectfully recom-
mend that the portion of the harbor surveyed in 1871 be re-examined
with the view of ascertaining the changes which have taken place since
that survey, and that special surveys be made of the two shoals between
Billingsgate light-house and the deep water of the outer bay. The ob-
ject of the first is to make an estimate for a channel with 6 feet depth,
mean low water, to the town wharves, and of the second for providing
an entrance 12 feet deep, mean low water, for the mackerel fleet, to a
secure harbor of refuge in the inner harbor at all stages of the tide.
   The cost of the survey is estimated at $1,500. An allotment of that
sum for the purpose indicated is respectfully recommended.
   A sketch* plan of Wellfleet Harbor is inclosed herewith.
        Very respectfully. your obedient servant,
                                                G.   L.   GILLESPIE,
                                             Lieut. Col. of Engineers.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. A.


         SURVEY OF WELLFLEET         HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

                           UNITED    STATES ENGINEER        OFFICE,
                                      Boston, Mass., November 28, 1887.
   GENERAL: In compliance with instructions contained in your letter
dated March 16, 18S7, I have the honor to transmit herewith a report
of Mr. Sophus Haagensen, assistant engineer, on the survey of Wellfleet
Harbor, Massachusetts, made to comply with the provisions of the river
and harbor act approved August 5, 1886.
   A tracing of the chart prepared from the survey is also transmitted,
upon which are drawn the limits of the improvement proposed for the
harbor.
   Wellfleet is situated on Cape Cod Bay, on the south shore of the
peninsula of Cape Cod, 12 miles southeast of Provincetown Harbor. It
is the best and most sheltered harbor on the cape, except that of Prov-
incetown, and is the resort of the principal mackerel fleet of the coast,
which fleet numbers over one hundred vessels, besides of other fisher-
men whose sail vary in number and kind.
   The catch of fish, one year with another, averages 20,000 barrels, at
an estimated valuation of $100,000.
   The harbor is divided, practically, into two parts:
   First. The inner harbor, which includes the part north of Smalley's
Bar, and is known as the Deep Hole anchorage, from which the car-
goes are lightered to the wharves of the town. This anchorage is com-
pletely protected and safe, as the bounding shores are all above the
highest water level. The area included within the 6 foot curve is 900
acres, and is distant 3,700 feet, at the nearest point, from the town
                                * Omitted.
478           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

wharves. The 12-foot channel, which traverses nearly the whole of this
basin, is 400 feet wide, and practically terminates in the Deep Hole.
  Second. The outer harbor, which includes the outer anchorage and the
approach over Stony Bar. At very high stages of the tide this anchor-
age becomes a wide estuary of Cape Cod Bay, as the shoals on the
west side, including Billingsgate Island, are wholly submerged. Safe
anchorage at such times can only be secured by going into the inner
harbor. Billingsgate Island and Lieutenant Shoal divide the outer har-
bor into two basins; the outer one is wide and shoal, having a width
between the 12-foot curves of 3,000 feet and a maximum depth of 21 feet;
while the inner one is narrow and deep, having a width between the 12-
foot curves of 1,000 feet and a maximum depth of 34 feet. The connect-
ing passage of these two basins, where the width is only 300 feet and
the depth 14 feet, is regarded by mariners as the part of the channel
which affords the most difficult navigation. A proper location of the
buoys will make the access easy and convenient.
  The outer bar, known as Stony Bar, offers no obstruction; it has 15J
feet at mean low water, and the channel over it, between the 12-foot
curves, has a width of 1,400 feet.
   It has been before stated that the anchorage of the inner harbor is
good and sheltered; but it must be nrioted that it does not meet all the
commercial necessities of the harbor, inasmuch as it has no connection
for vessels with the town wharves at low tide. From the margin of the
Deep Hole the bottom rises gradually until it becomes exposed at the
wharves at low tide. This fact very much impairs the anchorage com-
mercially. It is proposed to ameliorate the conditions in a degree by
excavating a channel 4,200 feet long, 100 feet wide at bottom, and 6 feet
deep, mean low water, from the Deep Hole to the wharves.
  The estimate of the cost is as follows:
Dredging 86,000 cubic yards of material, scow measurement, at 25 cents per
cubic yard..........---------------......----......------......--------....---....-----......--....------....--............ $21,500
Contingencies for engineering, etc ........................................                                                               2, 500

         Total------                                                                                                             -----
               ......-----------....----......---......-----------....---....--....-----....--......---------......----......-......     24, 000
   Au appropriation of $24,000 is recommended for this improvement.
   When this new channel is opened and the buoys in the outer harbor
are properly located, the inner harbor will be equal to every demand
upon it for depth of water and ease of access.
   I invite attention to the accompanying report of Mr. Haagensen, as-
sistant engineer, for the details of the survey and the description of the
harbor.
   I also invite attention to my preliminary report on the harbor, dated
November 8, 1886.
 * My thanks are due to Mr. Simeon Atwood, deputy collector of cus-
toms, for the accompanying statement giving the commercial statistics
of the harbor, viz:
  The following is a report for the harbor of Wellfleet, showing the amount of revenue
collected during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, the number of entrances and
clearances, the tonnage and character of the same, and other items showing the
amount of commerce and navigation, both foreign and domestic, to be benefited by
the completion of each particular work :
Foreign clearances--------
                    ....-----..........-----....------....--......--....----....---....---.........----------- 3
Coastwise entries of foreign salt ........................................                                                                    11
Revenue collected..........-------------------......-------......---......--------....--....--....-------.... ......-..                $166.40
Salt received in bond (998,900 pounds)........-..........................                                                           $1,012. 00
Lumber landed (240,000 feet) ...........................................                                                            $3, 500.00
Coal landed (1,'221 tons) ..........-....                            -.............................                     .           $6, 105. 00
Cured mackerel landed (3,105 barrels) ..............................                                                              $41,704.27
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          I
 _




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            00.0

                              WELLFLEET HARBOR
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              .00
                                                          Mass achus etfs                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 ....

            SURV  EYE                                         D       IN                           C E W IT58H
                                                                                      ACC O R D A NAUGUST                                                                                                            .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              '"'                                ...   ;:'...."
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      ".   .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                .. i- ..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                $
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      .
          ACT OF CONGRESS APPROVED                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                .... 1...:t--+.                                                                                                                               .....
                                                                                                                                                                                               "                                                                                                   '         .- sEt                  ,4 P.                                .                  .-..              0-...                    LI                  t                 .   5    ' '-i +'
                                                                    SHO.iNGPROPOSED.IMPROVEMENTS"                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     .                                       >1"                                                                      -                         -0.5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            t0         c'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   _00
                                                                                          SHOWIG                                                                                                                                                                                                                   '                         .                    -..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    p,"';€.                                   L                       2,     a &                              0j..         5                     3

                                                    To accompany report of                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     . A7 o"

                            LT. COL. GEO. L . GILLESPIE                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 .                 L             s                       ,               -g                              "

                                         Corps of IEnineers, U.S.A.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             .J,                                           6.",'                                    11,041ff.+                                 '       a        &a                  '.a
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 '    tj,
                                                    SCALE                      OF             MAP            1:30,0007
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   -


                            wog        am      p
                                                                      £ S-"       3
                                                                                IMI                                                             7
                                                                                                                                              L r7.g                Io oo Pr.                                                                                                                                                                      8.       $"   ! 7.7,.z           .            :        .        .       7.s7.!z.                                                            .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       0                                                     8""             $ "               7"s                   " 7        q..                     s.           r                ,       8        '2.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         8
                                                                                                                                                                                                             ";/                                                                                                                              'a            q.                     s. ,                   s.,          .           7                 1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            _                                                         , ,of .                             ,                8 . . '7                                                                               2                           22..                                               ..   /

                            oe
                            Tite soun
                     expressed in Pee
                                                                    9 .s ref r
                                                                   'n
                                                                           tt sare
                                                                                   i-to
                                                                                       %
                                                                                           ow
                                                                                          ee
                                                                                                                           rat1;tos
                                                                                                                             from tea                           mm-                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  10 .                  9.       '                I                8                                                                                                                                       00,

                                ine                                        Ctiu     e om.,e                                Iron    ma.-                                                                                                                                                .I'e.et'.U.

                     .Th.moan
                          re nmark.
                                                     fall    of
                                                              or   tide
                                                  T . p of Stone an. 8, near
                                                                                22.2 feet'
                                                                                                                                         1cayois"
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   ,rise                                                                                               .

                                   IXea&tJ Xgh6"is 14.76 feet           c/ove       "ta-                                            ow        water                                                                               LITTLE BEACH HrLL                                                                            2                                                                 +.                               _              4          ho.                                                                        .l
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              °"



                                    wa6er    line     is  rg    rresse&       tucs:                                                  /           /ow'.soars\                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      (>f'.                              &
                     higy
                                                                                      .                                                                                                                     :e..o....                                                                               "I                     j1                                                               ..                 -                  ,'12.a                 i""
                            6'f.       curve                                                                               _                     _,

                     12                       4P                      4                                                     -4 .. -                   -                                                                                                                                                                                                           3


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             ".o

                 dredlto                            a     depth'               of     6'       t.atmeant                        lo w ir'.34k                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             >ts44)1                               1
                     Pro'epl          aces markced     :
                      a,           CWhanne
                                        Rock                                                                                                                                                                                                                     5                    6        5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       2
                                       Lose     .were     reo~ved-
                             c, L pI Lu SW k    ( in- 1872-    '73.                                                                                                                       """:.
                            , Mayo's       -  /     ..   ..                                                                                                                         ;.,.". .    -:                       +                          +77                                                                                                                                                  20./f
                      e ,.B ay                                 .           )                                                                                                    : '..'"4./                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    5.2
                                                                                                                                                                                                             '           :                                   5                                         /         $8                                                   .

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      4                                                                 j:M                             ,                 6,           8.5                                                                 2



                                                        ,~s        .Efne f4e                  o~         4.fs.7oec                                    28.)8                                                 .. ,             -                           4                             +                                                 ,                       2-+ /'D


                                                    v.               .,          ,- .o+ + o+                  .          ctK,+,           c           C 4Las                                                         ".".                                                                                        .."                                .'.                                                                                                                                            2,-.:./ °

                                                                                                             •                      •%                                                                                           .,                                                                                                 D,                      "                 10




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 2                        2            2       1            "

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   1                            @'*"

                                                                                                                                                                                                   . "t              '                '" : .20                                                               ' "                                                                                                                                                                                                                      I

                                                                                                                                                                         ,;j)                                            '                      '.                           ,!                \ fl" 9                         ,9 __ _'n                              ,,                li,.\                                                                                                                       2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             aD$ BACN ROcA                                         .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  12;                ;1                0u         7-                                              65       +.           3
                                                                                                                                               $+""                                                          '                                           "..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         --                  , +' .C', . ;\ ,,1 o..                                          ,13..                                                                                               v                                                               3            3             2               :/
                                                                                                                                                                    $%                                                                                                                                                                       .94   1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          2
                                                                                                                                                                            +,                                                                                                                 '4 •                                          14
                                                                                                                                               ('r.1440                                                                                                                                                      4,:                         2.! <K                       " -. 4                                                                                                                                            2                              /                                                      E




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  30_                                             9!                                    4
                                                                                                                                                                      V             .                                                                         ..                  2-+          6.                          '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      %              G                                         2           4"s         \1.                          1j.18                          14

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             7                                 2":..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            7~                                                   ' ",.
                                                                                          ]                                                                                                                                                                   j6             2                                         1              'x' I7                              15                                  5ltZ1                          4SN                tC
                                                                                                             "2t                                            2                                      r                                                         "           ."                3       "1            5 o                   0" ' . _.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     117.,5                               31                                                                                              1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  4
                                                                                                                                                                                              12                 .                            N                              10                                 , "                          a"             151 17                                       A
                                                                                                                                                      2,,i4                                                                                                                       5 4                              6                0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    16                   1 2 15. )                                   2   :1/$y                                                                             01
                                                                                                                                                                                                   .... "                                                    ,, .'iS                                                                                                                                                                                                  0 '= .                                 ,
                                                                                                                                     "                .a'                                 N1.0                                            1'                                                                     25
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          "s                                                                                        0 '1.

                                                                     -,16"                                                                            .             7"l6+:..                                                                                     /               N                                         )                            15.,                                                                                             N,                                        o
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   9           8 4                          2      2        1R
                                                                                                                                                                          ~12
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              -                      9                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             1                  5                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           }    J
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              1+n          6.-i
     10        f,.                 .    .      'I                     .             "".            "16               16 '" 17 16                          1s 1\1                    1         1         1            "                1"'".-./-(z                        , .                               16""-15                                          J'.,              ;     . ..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           159
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     'x..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                \iii.                  17                     1 15
                                                                                                                                                1                                                  10                                                    l9        2                                       71    12                                                                                                                                                                                                               10-                                  21         +/




     "27 7                                                                                          2>< "4                     ,-                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           32                          r
                                                                                                                                                                     14 ,.;"413 -:                                                                                                                                                                                 --                                    y,
                                                                                                                            271;27"
                                                                                                                                                 15                                 11/
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          $                                           49                                            "         .--                                                              1]961J"                                                                                                      11)                            4                       2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  1
          27                                                               43.                                                           "-.          ,                             .                   /                                      23t                                         9       2 sid               19                                   2.I:§§7......                                                                                                                  12




J.                                                                                                                                                                              '             -"                                          27                             _                                                                                                                       21                                                         . "                        -
                                                                                                                                                                                          i
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             18".,                                                                    10
                                                                               '                                                         .'                         ,0 _i2++.                                                                            ,                                     .....                                                                                         '.+:1 " 1 2 /                                                  4'1 -"/                                     17"
     3o                                                                                                  C           /                                          1           15                              *"                        2                                                                    16                                                                                                                     .                                                                      1
                                                                      24                                                                  18                    16 4                                         7                            4                                      14,                                                                                                                                            " /
                                                                                                                               "              ,-,16
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       l3                                   xd
                                       257/                                                                                                                                         12                                                               .                                                                              1%'



Ywry                                          1816:1dr"yo                        and           drawn by Sophus                       161aa                                                                               7                                                        313 o',                                                                                                                              7

                                                         r                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          :14A-%                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                :-
Lngb0 2
              APPENDIX              B-REPORT           OF   LIEUT. COL.                        GILLESPIE.              479


                                    Tonnage employed.                                                   Gross.       Net.

W holly in coasting ..............................--..--. ....-----.....-.....  3, 053. 00                           2, 900. 39
Coasting and fishing........................................................... 2, 595.65                            2,465.82:
       Total tonnage----
                    ......-..                                      -  5, 648. 65
                          -.......................... ...................                                            5, 366. 21

  Vessels licensed for coasting; vessels licensed for fishing, 44.
      Respectfully submitted.
                                                                                              SIMEON ATWOOD,
                                                                                                      Deputy Collector.
  P. S.-I   most respectfully suggest that the year ending June 30, 1886, was an off
year so far as the fishing interests and products are concerned. To show the products
for years previous I append the following :

                                                Catch of mackerel.

                                          Years.                                                     Barrels.     Values.

1881.........................................................................                           31,365    $171,039.00
1882 .........................................................................                          30,133     177,173.27
1883......................................... ............................                              14,175     123,845.10
1884 ...................................................................... .                           32,168     155,187.19
1885.......................................................................                             19,676     102, 377.23
1886..-------------------------------------------------------------------------3,105                     3,105      41,704.27
                                                                                                                    41.....................
1887(estimate) .................            .       .........     ................................       6, 000       000.
                                                                                                                    90,  00,

  Consequently the amount of salt received would be correspondingly large.
     Respectfully,
                                                                                              SIMEON ATWOOD,
                                                                   Deputy Collector.
  Wellfleet is in the collection district of Barnstable, Mass., and the nearest light-
house is located upon Billingsgate Island.
           Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                               G.L. GILLESPIE,
                                                                             Lieut. Col. of Engineers.
   The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                           S. A.



                 REPORT        OF   MR.   SOPHUS HAAGENSEN,           ASSISTANT ENGINEER.

                                                            UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                                 Bosto n, Mass., November 11, 1887.
  COLONEL : I have the honor to report upon thq survey of Wellfleet Harbor, Massa-
chusetts, made in September and October, 1887, in pursuance of your instructions;
also to submit a map of the survey drawn to a scale of 1: 20,000.

                                                    TOPOGRAPHY.

   The accompanying map is reduced from the original plot of the sirvey, which was
drawn to a scale of 1 : 5,000. A base-line, 5,580.66 feet long was, measured from Mer-
cautile Wharf westward along the beach toward Herring River. Twenty-two trian-
gulation points were located, of which nine were occupied, and from these two
hundred and fourteen triangulation angles were measured; the most important were
repeated not less than four times.
   The high-water line is essentially that of the U. S. Coast Survey map, 1851, with
exception of the wharves in Wellfleet and the shore-line of Billingsgate Island. The
present island is much reduced in size, and has been beaten to the eastward since 1851
about 800 feet. The outer Billingsgate Island (former site of the light-house) has now
disappeared, and the highest part of the remains, dry at half-tide (Sunken Island),
is 600 feet east of its position in 1851.

                                                   HYDROGRAPHY.

The area of Wellfleet Harbor is about 5 miles north to south by 3 miles from east to
west, and amounts to 9,811 acres. Of this area about 2,240 acres were covered by our
480          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

soundings, so as to develop the channel. In the southerly part of the harbor the
channel through Stony Bar and that between Billingsgate Island and Lieutenant
Island Shoal were specially examined by closer soundings; in the northerly part, from
Smalley's Bar to the town wharves, most of the area was covered by close soundings.
One hundred and thirteen lines of soundings were established. An aggregate length
of 60 miles of these were run, upon which 11,717 sounding were taken; of this num-
ber 1,867 were located by observations from or upon shore stations with transit or
sextant. The soundings expressed in feet and tenths, are selected from the above;
those in feet are taken from the U. S. Coast Survey manuscript map; they all refer
to mean low water.
                                                           TIDES.

  Two tide-staves were established, one at Central Wharf, for the upper harbor, and
one in the channel off Billingsgate Island, for the survey of the lower harbor; they
both had their zero at mean low water, as determined in 1871, and which is marked
by the top of stone monument N. 8, 14.76 feet above mean low water. When set in
1871, monument 8 was 55 feet southeast of Mayo's Beach Light; since then the light
has been moved north about 100 feet.
                                                                                  Feet.
Mean rise or fall of tide ..................................................      11.2
Meau rise or fall of spring-tide .............................................    13.3
Mean rise or fall of neap-tide ................................................    9.4

                            DESCRIPTION OF HARBOR AND SHIP-CHANNEL.

   The harbor may be divided into the upper and lower harbor by a line through
Smalley's Bar and Lieutenant Island.
   The upper harbor is well sheltered on the east and north by the high hills of the
mainland, and on the west by Great Island, Great and Little Beach hills.
   The lower harbor is well protected against east winds by the high land of Eastham,
but in the other directions much exposed, especially at high water of spring-tides,
when even Billingsgate Island is overflowed.
   The lower harbor has two basins: Basin 1, between Stony Bar and Lieutenant
 .Island Shoal; basin 2, between Lieutenant Island Shoal and Smalley's Bar.
   The upper harbor has two basins: Basin 3, between Smalley's Bar and Quahaug
Ground; basin 4, or Deep Hole, between Quahaug Ground and the flats, gradually
shoaling towards the wharves.
   The channel from Cape Cod Bay through Stony Bar to Basin 1 is 4,000 feet long
from the 18-foot curve on the outside, to the 18-foot hole inside of the bar. The black
buoy on the bar is half-way between the 18-foot depths, and its distance from the
wharves in town is 6 miles, measured on the axis of the ship-channel. There is a 15-
foot channel through Stony Bar of a least width of 700 feet; the 12-foot channel is
not less than 1,400 feet wide. Basin 1 is on the 12-foot curve, 3,000 feet in width by
4,000 feet in length. The greatest depth found is 21 feet, and the average depth is
15 feet at mean low water. From this basin three dangerous rocks were removed in
1872-'73, viz :
   Channel Rock, having only 1.8 feet water over it at mean low water; Lobster Rock
having only 4.5 feet water over it at mean low water, and Lumpfish Rock having
only 3.5 feet water over it at mean low water.
   The channel between Basin l and 2 is the one most complained of by the pilots. It
runs in a northwesterly direction to a line between Billi ngsgate Island Light and the
red buoy at the extremity of Lieutenant Island Shoal; this buoy is 41 miles from the
wharves; 2,000 febt below the buoy is the most difficult place; there is a least width
of 300 feet on the 12-foot contours, and 14 feet depth can be carried through the chan-
nel, which deepens rapidly above; half-way to the buoy the 18-foot channel com-
mences; off the red buoy the depth is 27 feet at mean low water.
   Basin 2 is the deepest part of the harbor. From the red buoy at Lieutenant Island
Shoal to the black buoy off Smalley's Bar (21 miles from the wharves) there is a
straight 18-foot channel, averaging 1,000 feet in width, and having from 4 to 51 fath-
oms of water in it at mean low water.
   Basin 3 joins Basin 2 at the black buoy off Smalley's Bar. The 18-foot channel at
this junction is not less than 400 feet wide. Basin 3 measures on the 12-foot contour
2,000 by 3,000 feet. The greatest depth is 21 feet, while the average is 16 feet at
mean low water. From this basin two dangerous rocks were removed in 1872-'73,
viz :
   Mayo's Rock, having only 2.7 feet over it at mean low water, and Bay Rock, the top
of which was 3.4 feet above mean low water.
   The Quahaug Ground separates Basin 3 from Basin 4 (Deep Hole); the channel con-
necting the two begins one-half mile northwest of Smalley's Bar Buoy, and runs due
         APPENDIX B-REPORT                 OF LIEUT. COL,     GILLESPIE.         481
north for about 1 mile, where the continuous 12-foot curve ends, distant about 1 mile
from the wharves. The lower half of the 12-foot channel averages 500 feet in width,
the upper half 300 feet.
  The greatest depth in Deep Hole is 13 feet, and the 6-foot contour extends to within
3,600 feet from Central Wharf. With exception of one " pot hole" one-half mile from
the wharves, with not to exceed 7 feet at mean low water, the flats shoal gradually
to the town.
   Herring River on the west, and Town Creek on the east, empty into the head of
the harbor, draining large areas of salt marshes in the town.
   With the exception of the development of details by more numerous soundings, no
material change in the upper harbor can be seen by comparison with former surveys;
but the present detailed surveys of the bars in the lower harbor (not surveyed in
1871), shows practicable channels through them of such widths and depths as are
stated above.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                          SOPHUS HAAGENSEN,
                                                                 Assistant Engineer.
  Lieut. Col. GEO. L. GILLESPIE,
            Corps of Engineers, U. S. A.
        ENG 88----31
478
                              APPENDIX C.



IMPROVEMENT OF HARBORS AND RIVERS ON THE SOUTHERN COAST OF
    MASSACHUSETTS AND IN RHODE ISLAND AND CONNECTICUT.




REPORT OF MAJOR WILLIAM R. LIVERMORE, CORPS OF EXGINEERS,
OFFICER IN TEMPORARY CHARGE, FOR TILE FISCAL YEAR ENDING
JUNE 30, 188, 1, WITH OTIHER DOCUMENTS BELATING TO THIE WORKS.

                              IMPROVEMEN TS.

1. Harbor of Refuge at Hyannis, Mas-         10. Removal of Green Jacket Shoal, Prov-
      sachusetts.                                  idence River, Rhode Island.
2. Harbor of Refuge at Nantucket, Mas-       11. Newport Harbor, Rhode Island.
      sachusetts.                            12. Harbor of Refuge at Block Island,
3. Wood's Hell Harbor, Massachusetts.              Rhode Island.
4. Wareham Harbor, Massachusetts.            13. Little Narragansett     Bay, Rhode
5. Westport Harbor, Massachusetts.                Island and Connect icut.
6. Taunton River, Massachusetts.            14. Pawcatuck River, Rhode Island and
7. Warren River, Rhode Island.                     Connecticut.
F. Pawtucket River, Rhode Island.            15. Harbor of Refuge at Stonington, Con-
9. Providence River, and Narragansett:             necticut.
      Bay, Rhode Island.

                        EXAMINATIONS         AND SURVEYS.

16. New Bedford Harbor, Massachusetts.   j   17. Taunton River, Massachusetts.




                                     ENGINEER OFFICE, U.             S.   ARMY,
                                      Newport, R. I., July 2, 1888.
  SIR: I have the honor to submit herewith annual reports for the
year ending June 30, 1888, for river and harbor works temporarily in
my charge.
This office was assisted during the year by Assistant Engineer Ed-
ward Parrish; by Assistant Engineer Frank I. Angell from July 21 to
August 5, 1887, and by Assistant Engineer John H. Rostock from
August 6, 1887, to June 30, 1888.
     Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                             W. R1. LIVERMORE,
                                               Major of Engineers.
  The CHIEF     OF ENGINEERS,       U.   S. A.
                 t483
484      REPORT   OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                  C   I.


          HARBOR OF REFUGE AT HYANNIS, MASSACHUSETTS.

   The harbor of Hyannis lies on the south shore of the peninsula of
Cape Cod, about 15 miles to the westward of the heel of the cape, and
is an important harbor of refuge.
   The mean rise and fall of the tide is about 3( feet.

                         ORIGINAL CONDITION.

   Before improvement it was an open roadstead, exposed to southerly
storms.
                      PLANS OF IMPROVEMENT.

   In the years 1827-1S38 a breakwater of riprap granite 1,170 feet long
was constructed, covering an anchorage of about 175 acres, the entrance
to which has a depth of about 15) feet. In the years 1852-1882 exten-
sive repairs were made in increasing the width of its base and the size of
the stone forming its sides and top.
  The depth of water inside the breakwater is insufficient for many
vessels that seek the harbor for refuge, and Colonel Elliot's project for
the improvement of the harbor, published in the Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1885, volume 1, pages 560 and 619-621, contemplated dredg-
ing the area protected by the breakwater to a depth of 15) feet at mean
low water.

         AMOUNT EXPENDED AND RESULTS TO JUNE            30, 1887.
  The amount expended on this work up to June 30,1887, was $124,163.18.
The breakwater had been completed according to the original project
and the subsequent plans for strengthening it, and the 15-foot anchor-
age area had been increased by about two acres.

           OPERATIONS DURING       THE LAST FISCAL YEAR.

  At the beginning of the last fiscal year the work was in progress,
under the project for the expenditure of the appropriation of $10,000 of
August 5, 1886, approved by the Chief of Engineers, which consisted
in beginning the work of dredging at the eastern side of the area to be
deepened, and continuing it as far to the westward as the funds avail-
able would permit. The work was continued up to September 30, 1887,
when it was suspended on account of the weather.
   The contractor has failed to resume operations, and the time for the
completion of the contract expired on June 30.
   Mr. Thomas A. Churbuck was the local inspector of the work of
dredging.

AMOUNT EXPENDED       DURING THE LAST FISCAL        YEAR AND RESULTS
                           TO JUNE 30, 1888.

  The amount expended during the last fiscal year, including liabilities
outstanding June 30, 1888, was $3,7424.19. The result has been the ex-
cavation of 21,389 cubic yar(1ds of mud and sand and the increase of
the 15).foot anchorage area protected by the breakwater by about 4.9
acres.
                     APPENDIX C-REPORT                                     OF MAJOR LIVERMORE.                                   485

          WORK REQUIRED TO COMPLETE THE EXISTING PROJECT.

   The work required to complete the existing project is the completion
of the dredging to a depth of 154 feet in the area limited on the west
by a line running due north from the western end of the breakwater and
on the north by a line running parallel to the breakwater and dis-
tant 1,500 feet from it, leaving a berm of 100 feet along its northern
side.

OPERATIONS CONTEMPLATED FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE
                        30, 1889.

   The execution of the project above referred to, of deepening the
anchorage area inside the breakwater, will be continued.
Hyannis Harbor is in the Barnstable collection district, and Barnstable is the nearest
port of entry. The amount of revenue collected at Barnstable in the last fiscal year
was $570.02.
  The main value of the harbor is for a harbor of refuge. The nearest light-house is
Hyannis Light; the nearest fortification is the fort at Clark's Point, New Bedford,
Mass.
                                                         Money statement.

July 1, 1887, amount available .........................................                   $9,194.40
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ........................               $3, 369. 11
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities...........                .............      355. 08
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts...........                  5,449.39
                                                                                --          9, 173. 58
July 1, 1888, balance available ........................................                                                      20. 82
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888........................                                                     10,000.00



{Amount
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889..--...............

                  (estimated) required for completion of existing project........
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                                                           10, 020.82

                                                                                                                          25, 662.00
                                                                                                                          25,662.00
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




                                                    COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.


                                    [Furnished by Mr. A. F. Lothrop, Hyannis, Mass.

                                                                   IMPORTS.

Coal............                     .........................                    .....................                tons..       8,071
Grain ..........................                                        ...............                     ....... bushels..     125,000
Brick...... ...............................                                                        ................   .......      25, 000
Lumber........           ......  ----....     ......------......--...----.......--.............                         feet.. 1, 250,000
Lumbe-------           -------- ---- ---- ---- -- ---- ---- ---- -- ---- ------barrels..
Lime ...............................................                                                                 arets.. 1 300300

                                                                  EXPORTS.

         ................................----------------------.......................
Iced fish-------------------------                                                                         barrels..                 800

                                      VESSELS IN HARBOR DURING THE YEAR.

Sailing.................................................................                                                         1,400
Steam ................................................................                                                              225
486     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                         C 2.

        HARBOR OF REFUGE AT NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS.

   Nantucket Harbor is the only one between the harbors of Martha's
Vineyard (Vineyard Haven and Edglirtown) and Provincetown, a dis-
tance of about 100 miles, except the small harbor of Hyannis, on the
other (the north) side of Nantucket Sound, the navigation of which is
intricate and dangerous by reason of numerous shoals. Nantucket
Harbor has deep water inside, and the object of the improvement is to
make it a harbor of refuge for vessels plying between ports north and
south of Cape Cod, estimated to be 30,000 annually. In the memorial
to Congress, on which the first appropriation for this harbor of refuge
was based, it was stated that more than 500 vessels had been wrecked
in the vicinity of the island.
   The mean rise and fall of the tide is about 3 feet.

                               ORIGINAL CONDITION.

  Before the commencement of the present work there was a shoal
about l1 miles in width outside the entrance, through which shoal the
channel or line of best water was only about 6 feet deep and very
crooked and subject to changes in location.

                            PLANS OF TIlE WORKS.

  The present approved project is to construct jetties of riprap stone
nroijecting from   either   side   of the pre   ent   ntr/an(   to th   hab
                                                                         ihor,   o

the purpose of concentrating the strength of the tidal currents, and ex-
cavating a channel of 15 feet depth by scour, and at the places where
the full depth required will not be reached by this means to complete
the work by dredging. A plan of the works may be found in the Re-
port of the Chief of Engineers for 1885, volume 1, page 578.

       AMOUNT EXPENDED              AND RESULTS TO JUNE 30,             1887.

  The amount expended on this project up to the close of the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1887, including liabilities outstanding at that date,
was $111,531.77, and the result was the construction of the west jetty
to a point 3,955 feet from the shore and the east jetty to a distance of
330 feet from the initial point on the shore, which is the outer end of
the middle of the three northwest spurs built on Coatue Beach some
years ago, and the foundation was laid and the jetty partially com-
pleted for an additional distance of 56 feet.

           OPERATIONS DURING TIHE LAST FISCAL YEAR.

   At the beginning of the last fiscal year the work of the construction
of the east jetty under the approved project was in progress, and was
continued until October 1, 1887. The contractor has failed to resume
operations as required by his contract.
   Soundings were taken over the area between the east jetty and Brant
Point, but show no material change in the depth of water beyond that
already reported.
   Until the two jetties are completed and a light-house erected on one
of them the end of the west jetty will be a source of danger to vessels
                      APPENDIX                         C-REPORT                                    OF   MAJOR     LIVERMORE.            487

entering and leaving the port at night. In order to avoid this danger
as far as possible, a temporary light has been established at the end of
that jetty, which has been faithfully maintained during the year.
  Mr. C. O. Abell was local inspector of fhe work of the construction
of the east jetty.
AMOUNT              EXPENDED DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR AND RESULTS
                                 TO JUNE 30, 1888.

    The amount expended d(luring the last iscal year, including liabili-
ties outstanding June 30, 1888, was $7,618.92. The construction of the
east jetty was continued and fully completed to a distance of about 385
feet from the initial point on the shore, and the foundation was laid
and the jetty partially completed for an additional distance of 200 feet.
During the fiscal year 2,941.5 tons of stone were placed in the jetty.
           WORK REQUIRED TO COMPLETE                                                                    THE EXISTING PROJECT.

  The work required to complete the existing project is the completion
of the east and west jetties, and the excavation by dredging of so much
pf the channel as may not be excavated by tidal scour.
OPERATIONS                   CONTEMPLATED                                          FOR             THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING              JUNE
                                                                                    30, 1889.
  It is proposed to continue the construction of the east jetty as far as
the available funds will permit.
  Nantucket is in the Nantucket collection district, and is a port of entry. The
amount of revenue collected at Nantucket in the last fiscal year was $40.15. The
value of the harbor is mainly as a harbor of refuge. The nearest light-houses are
Nantucket Cliff and Brant Point lights. The nearest fortification is the fort at Clark's
Point, New Bedford, Mass.
                                                                        Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available --......
                                  -................................--- --------....                                            -$13,468.23
July 1, 188, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 .......................                                                        $6, 926.68
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..........................                                                          692. 24
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts............                                                         5, 849.31
                                                                                                                               --   13,468.23

Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188_..........................                                                             20, 000.00

   Amount          (estimated)
                        required for completion of existing project.-.----230,000.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                                        50,000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                                                 COMMERCIAL                         STATISTICS.

                (Furnished          by Mr. Albert A. Gardner, collector of customs, Nantucket, Mass.]
                                                                                      IMIPORTS.

Coal......---------......---------....---......--------.....---......-----......---------......--......----....--......   tons.. 6,830
Grain ......---               ---..........--------....--...........---.........................                       bushels..15,000
        ......----......------......----....--.-------------...---....-....--......------.....---......----....
Flour----                                                                                                         barrels..      4,500
Hay ------.........------------............-----------------------------------........                               tons..        180
Lumber..--------------------------------......................-----...----........................feet.                     2,000,500
Brick ....................                             ..............................................                          320,000
Lime ..........................                            --...........................                          barrels..      1,050
Cement -----------------------------------......................................................                    do...-         320
W ood .....-------.......... .. ................................. cords..                                                          680
Salt ......................................................                                                    .. bushels..      1,000
General merchandise............................................                                                     tons..      4, 006
488      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                              C3.
   IMPROVEMENT OF HARBOR OF WOOD'S HOLL, MASSACHUSETTS.

   This harbor is on the north side of Vineyard Sound and is divided
into Great Harbor and Little Harbor. The name Wood's Holl is also
.applied to the adjoining strait, which connects Vineyard Sound with
Buzzard's Bay. The site of the works is Great Harbor, Wood's Holl.
The mean rise and fall of the tide is about 2 feet.
                        ORIGINAL CONDITION.

Before the improvement the site of the present works was a sub-
merged point of land extending from the shore of the harbor.
                      PLANS OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The adopted project for the improvement of Great Harbor, Wood's
Holl, was for the construction of retaining-walls on the shore, a hol-
low pier and wharves for the use of the United States Fish Commission,
and to serve also as a coaling station for vessels of the Revenue Marine.
and other branches of the public service, and as a harbor of refuge.
A plan of the works may be found in the Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1884, vol. 1, page 598. Also, for the removal of a dangerous
rock in the strait of Wood's Holl.
          AMOUNT EXPENDED    AND RESULTS TO JUNE 30,       1887.
   The amount expended on these works to June 30, 1887, was $91,955.50.
The retaining and pier walls and the dredging of the interior of the
hollow pier and the berths for public vessels had been completed, and
all the wharves as projected had been completed, except a small amount
of planking on the coal-wharf extension. The dangerous rocks in the
strait had been removed, and the small amount of dredging in the rear
of the coal-wharf extension had been completed.
            OPERATIONS DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR.

  At the beginning of the fiscal year the work under the approved
project for the improvement of the harbor at Wood's Holl was in prog-
ress, and was completed July 20, 1887.
  Mr. Frank I. Angell was the local inspector of the work at Wood's
Hoil.
AMOUNT     EXPENDED DURING THE LAST FISCAL         YEAR AND RESULTS
                        TO JUNE 30, 1888.

  The amount expended during the last fiscal year, including liabilities
oustanding June 30, 1888, was $451.16. The pier and retaining-walls
have been constructed, the basin and berths for vessels have been
dredged, and all the wharves as projected have been completed, the dan-
gerous rocks in the straight have been removed, and the small amount
9f dredging in the rear of the coal-wharf extension has been completed.

        WORK REQUIRED   TO COMIPLETE    THE   EXISTIiNG PROJECT.
  The completion of the work under the contract with William M. Mol-
throp & Co., dated September 27, 1886, and the supplemental contract,
Elated November 12, 1886, finished the improvement as far as projected.
                    APPENDIX                C-REPORT                   OF      MAJOR          LIVERMORE.                   .489
OPERATIONS                 CONTEMPLATED                       FOR THE FISCAL YEAR                               ENDING JUNE
                                                              30, 1889.
   No work is proposed for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.
  Wood's Holl is in the Barnstable collection district. New Bedford is the nearest
port of entry. The amount of revenue collected in the last fiscal year was, at Barn-
stable, $570.02, and at New Bedford, $58,865.60. The nearest light-house is Nobska
Light; the nearest fortification is the fort at Clark's Point, New Bedford, Mass.

                                                      Money statement.
July 1, 1687, amount available---------......-------....--------....--......-....----..........--....----.... --           451. 16
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887............................................                                                     451.16



                                                   COMMERCIAL            STATISTICS.

                                 [Furnished by A. F. Shriverick. Wood's Holl, Mass.]

   The receipts and shipments by vessels have been about as follows during the past
year :
                                                                        -25
Cargoes of coal aggregating 6,000 toins ..............--------..........--------......---......                             to 30
Cargoes of spiles, wharf material, etc .--------......-------......-------......-----......-------......--......                4
Cargoes of lumber--------......-------....--......---.....-------....---..----......--......------....--....--.....--.          4
                  ....--------------....----....--....---......-......--------......---......-----.....----....---......
Cargoes of barrels------                                                                                                        4
Cargoes of completed fertilizer, phosphate, rock, brimstone, nitrate of soda,
  fish scraps, and other materials used in the manufacture of fertilizers, ag-
  gregating about 25,000 tons .............................        ............                                                75




                                                                  C 4.
              IMPROVEMENT OF WAREHAM HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

   This harbor is an estuary at the head of Buzzard's Bay. The object of
the improvement is to deepen and widen the channel leading from Buz.
zard's Bay to Wareham, the industries of which, and of several towns
in the vicinity with which it is connected by rail, are chiefly the manu-
factures of iron, and depend largely on transportation by water of the
material used therein. The commerce of Wareham is carried on in sail-
ing vessels, and the channel is to be made a beating channel for such
vessels.
   Another object of the improvement is the raising of Long Beach, over
which the sands from the bay were washed into the harbor. The mean
rise and fall of the tide is 4 feet.

                                                ORIGINAL CONDITION.

   Before improvement the ruling depth in the harbor was about 7 feet
at mean low water, in a narrow and very crooked channel. Long Beach,
a narrow sand spit at the mouth of the harbor, was washed and abraded
by the waves and currents at high water, and the material was carried
into and shoaled the channel inside.

                                            PLANS OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The original approved project of 1871 for the improvement, and its
subsequent modifications, provides for a channel 250 feet wide and 10
490   *   REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

feet deep at mean low water from Barney's Point down to the entrance
to the harbor. Ab..      Barney's Point the width of the channe is to be
350 feet, with the same depth, 10 feet, as below that point. The plan
includes, also, the raising and strengthening of Long Beach, of which a
large portion was submerged at low water, to carry it above the storm
waves and currents and to hold it there in order to prevent the filling
of the improved channel above by material abraded from the beach.
   A plat of Wareham Harbor, showing the lines of the channel now
being excavated, may be found in the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1885, vol. 1, page 586.

          AMOUNT EXPENDED AND RESULTS TO JUNE 30, 1887.

   The total amount expended on the improvement up to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, including liabilities outstanding at that
date, was $69,704.14, and the result was that the channel in the upper
part of the harbor in front of the wharves was carried to its full width
and completed, and the eastern half of the second and third reaches
below the wharves and about one-fourth of the fourth reach, which ex-
tends to Barney's Point, were excavated to the full depth of 10 feet below
mean low water. Long Beach had been raised above high-water storm
tides, so that the wash of sand into the improved channel inside the
beach had been stopped.
   A ruling depth of the approaches to Wareham had been increased
from 7 to 9 feet, and the channel greatly widened in all the reaches.
   Vessels of larger draught can be carried to Wareham than formerly.
The increase in width of channel was a great help to all vessels in beat-
ing in and out of the harbor.

             OPERATIONS DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR.

  At the beginning of the last fiscal year the work of dredging had
been temporarily discontinued, as the contractor, who is also the con-
tractor for the dredging at Hyannis Harbor, Massachusetts, desired to
remove the plant to the latter place, which is considerably exposed to
the sea, and utilize the summer months in dredging there. It was re-
sumed October 23, 1887, and suspended December 3 on account of ice.
The amount of material removed uip to the end of the fiscal year was
10,680.2 cubic yards.
  The contractor has failed to resume operations and the time for the
completion of the contract expired on June 15.
  Mr. Thomas A. Churbuck was local inspector of the work.

AMOUNT EXPENDED DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR                AND RESULTS
                          TO   JUNE   30,   1888.

  The amount expended during the last fiscal year was $2,320.49. The
eastern half of the second and third reaches below the wharves and
about t wo-thirds of the eastern half of the fourth reach, which ex-
tends to Barney's Point, were deepened to 10 feet at mean low water.
The channel for about one-half its width from Barney's Point to Ware-
ham has been deepened to 10 feet.

      WORK REQUIRED     TO COMPLETE         THE EXISTING   PROJECT.

   The work required to complete the existing project is the excavation
of the channel to its full width and depth down to the deep water above
            APPENDIX       C-REPORT          OF- MAJOR LIVERMORE.                       491

Long Beach, and the further building up of Long Beach by the con-
struction of sand fences.

OPERATIONS      CONTEMPLATED           FOR    THE     FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE
                                        30, 1889.

  it is proposed to devote the remainder on hand July 1, 1888, to the
completion of the channel for one-half its proposed width as far as the
funds available will permit and to the building up of Long Beach.
  Wareham is in the New Bedford collection district. New Bedford is the nearest
port of entry. The amount of revenue collected at New Bedford in the last fiscal
year was $58,865.60. The nearest light-houses are Bird's Island and Wing's Neck
lights. The nearest fortification is the fort at Clark's Point, New Bedford, Mass.

                                  Money statement.
                                                                   -$10,295.96
July 1, 1887, amount available .-------......------......--------.....-----......-----...
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1. 1887 ...      ..           .    -. $1, 816.50
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities-..........................         503.99
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts-...........         7,975. 47
                                                                                   10,295.96

Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188 -.......................              4, 000. 00

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- .......          12,236.00
  Amountthat canbeprofitably expended infiscal year ending June 30,1890            12, 236. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




                               COMMERCIAL      STATISTICS.


                   [Furnished by Mr. G. C. Tobey, Wareham, Mass., 1887.]

Arrivals and departures of vessels annually ......-......-......-..............      400
Merchandise received and shipped, tons--  ....-...........                 ---   65, 000
                                                                   --......-----....----.....




                                           C 5.
        IMPROVEMENT         OF WESTPORT          HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

  Westport Harbor is an estuary of a bay lying between Narragansett
Bay, Rhode Island, and Buzzard's Bay, Massachusetts. The site of the
work is on Horse Neck Point (the north side of the entrance to the
harbor).
                               ORIGINAL CONDITION.

   Before the commencement of the improvement the site of the present
work was a point of sand forming the northern and eastern boundary
of the entrance to the harbor, and subject to erosion by the sea and tides.

                            PLANS OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The project for the improvement of Westport Harbor, approved by the
Secretary of War February 23, 1887, i~ to construct wooden jetties, filled
492           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

with stone, at the end of Horse Neck Point, to stop the wearing of this
point; the number and spacing of the jetties to depend on the price at
which the work is let.

                     OPERATIONS DURING                         THE LAST FISCAL YEAR.

  The available funds were sufficient to construct but one jetty.
  The work of the construction of the jetty on Horse Neck Point, which
was commenced June 22, 1887, was completed July 28. Mr. David
Hamilton was the local inspector of the work.

           WORK REQUIRED TO COMPLETE THE EXISTING PROJECT.

  The completion of the jetty referred to above finished the work as far
as projected.

OPERATIONS                CONTEMPLATED FOR THE                                FISCAL YEAR                 ENDING JUNE
                                                          30, 1889.
    No work is proposed for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.
   Westport Harbor is in the New Bedford collection district. New Bedford is the
nearest port of entry. The amount of revenue collected at New Bedford in the last
fiscal year was $58,865.60. The nearest light-house is West Island Light. The near-
est fortification is the fort at Clark's Point, New Bedford, Mass.

                                                  Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available........-------------------....----......--......-------......-......-......            $890.66
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887...........................................-------------------------------------------...    890. 66



                                                              C 6.
                IMPROVEMENT OF TAUNTON RIVER, MASSACHUSETTS.

   This river rises in Norfolk County, Mass., and empties into Mount
Hope Bay, a name given to the northeastern part of Narragansett Bay.
It is about 44 miles in length, measured along its course.
   The object of the improvement is to deepen and widen the channel
leading to the city of Taunton, at the head of navigation, which requires
large quantities of coal, iron, clay, moldings, sand, and other heavy ar-
ticles for its extensive manufactures dependent largely on water trans-
portation, so that vessels of 11 feet draught can reach the city at high
water. The rise and fall of the tide before improvement was 5) feet at
Dighton and 3.4 feet at Taunton.

                                             ORIGINAL CONDITION.

   In its original condition the channel was narrow and obstructed by
bowlders, and from Berkley Bridge to Taunton the depth was not, in
places, more than 5 feet at mean high water. A vessel of 30 tons bur-
den was as large as could go up to Taunton.

                                         PLANS OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The approved project of 1871 and its subsequent modifications pro-
vides for a channel 60 feet wide and 11 feet deelp from Weir Bri.lge to
          APPENDIX     C-REPORT      OF   MAJOR   LIVERMORE          493
the ship-yard; a channel 80 feet wide (100 feet at the bends) and 11
feet deep from the ship-yard down to and through the Needles and
Brigg's Shoal; thence to Berkley Bridge a channel of the same width
and 12 feet deep. From Berkley Bridge to the deep water at Dighton
the channel was to be 100 feet wide and 12 feet deep. The depths are
estimated from high water. The ledge which crosses the bottom of the
river at Peter's Point and the numerous bow]ders which lay on the bot-
tom and sides of the channel from Taunton to Dighton were to be re-
moved.
  A plat of the river showing the improved channel was published in
the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1884, page 606.

        AMOUNT EXPENDED AND RESULTS TO JUNE 30,              1887.

   The amount expended on the improvement of the river up to the close
of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, including liabilities outstanding
at that date, was $153,618.35.
   With the exception that but 40 feet of the 60 feet of width could be
dredged between the bridge at Weir and the ship-yard on account of in-
terfering with private property, and that on account of the hardness
and depth of material at the sides the 80-foot channel was not in all
cases dredged to its full width, the channel down to Berkley Bridge
had been completed. The channel as proposed between Berkley Bridge
and Dighton had been completed with the exception of a small amount
of dredging and the removal of the bowlders. The channel had been
cleared of bowlders from Taunton down to Berkley Bridge. The work
of removal of the ledge at Peter's Point had been completed. The ma-
terial blasted in the channel had been dredged and deposited in the
form of a half-tide dam running from Reuben's Island to the west shore
of the river, with the view of accelerating the current in the dredged
channel off and above Dighton, and preventing deposits in this part of
the channel.

           OPERATIONS     DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR.

  At the beginning of the last fiscal year work was in progress under
a contract with J. H. Fenner, of Jersey City, N. J., described in the
Annual Report of 1885, for cutting a channel 12 feet deep and 100 feet
wide through the ledge at Peter's Point, and excavating by dredging a
channel of the same dimensions between the upper part of " The Nook"
and Dighton.
  The immediate locality of the work at the beginning of the fiscal year
was between Peter's Point and Dighton, where the channel was com-
pleted August 6, 1887, with the exception of the removal of a small
amount of ledge rock uncovered in dredging. The removal of the bowl-
ders in the channel from the upper part of "The Nook" to Dighton
was completed October 12.
  Mr. L. F. Pendleton was local inspector of the work.

AMOUNT EXPENDED DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR AND RESULTS TO
                              JUNE 30, 1888.

  The amount expended during the last fiscal year, including liabilities
outstanding June 30, 1888, was $3,317.59.
  The results were the completion of the channel as proposed between
Berkley Bridge and Dighton, with the exception of a small amount of
494           REPORT           OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

ledge rock uncovered in dredging below Peter'sPoint, leaving the han-
nel above Berkley Bridge as at the beginning of the fiscal year as stated
above. Vessels of 11 feet draught can now reach Taunton, at the head
of navigation.

          WORK REQUIRED TO COMIPLETE THE EXISTING PROJECT.

  There remains to complete the existing project the widening and
deepening at a few points above the bridge, and the removal of a small
amount of ledge rock uncovered in dredging below Peter's Point. This
ledge projects about 30 feet into the eastern side of the channel, dimin-
ishing its depth by a few inches, while there is ample width and depth
beyond the channel line on the western side.
   In compliance with the provisions of the river and harbor act of Au-
gust 5, 1886, a survey of portions of Taunton River, made in October,
1887, and the map and report thereon were submitted to the Chief of
Engineers November 21, 1887, for which see Appendix.
OPERATIONS               CONTEMPLATED                     FOR THE             FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE
                                                          30, 1889.
   No work is contemplated for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.
   Taunton is in the Fall River collection district. Fall River is the nearest port of
entry. The amount of revenue collected at Fall River in the last fiscal year was
$40,805.75. The nearest light-house is the Borden Flat light-house. The nearest for-
tification is Fort Adams, Newport Harbor, Rhode Island.

                                                  Money statement.
July i, 1887, amount available---------......---......------....------....-----....------....---....--..........
                                                               -3,                                                     381.65
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887--...... ......---......- --......----......------................
                                                                             3, 317. 59

                                                                                    64. 00
July 1, 1888, balance available .------...........----............--....--......----....----....
                                                                       ----

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project                                    ------13, 986. 94
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 13890                                      13, 986.94
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                              COMMERCIAL            STATISTICS.

                       [Furnished by Messrs. Staples & Phillips, Taunton, Mass., 1885.
Lumber-------------
      ............... feet.. 11, 000, 000                           Metalof all kinds-......tons..-                    39, 000
Grain ..............bushels.-                    1,228, 000         Cotton--------
                                                                           .........-----......
                                                                                           bales..                    25,500
Flour .............. barrels.                       40, 000         Molding sand ....... ..-tons..                    22,000
                           240, 000 Clay ................ do.. .
Coal ..---......-----....---......
                   tons .                                                                                             28,000
All other kinds of merchan-
dise. ................ tons..                       20, 000




                                                              C 7.
                 IMPROVEMENT OF WARREN RIVER, RHODE ISLAND.

   Warren River is an arm of Narragansett Bay north of the harbor of
Bristol. This is a new work, and no appropriation had been made for
it until, by act approved August 5, 1886, Congress appropriated $5,000
for the improvement of the river. In his report, January 12, 1885, of
the survey made in accordance with the act of July 5, 1884, Colonel
                 APPENDIX             C-REPORT               OF     MAJOR         LIVERMORE.           495
Elliott stated that the obstructions to navigation were a rocky reef be-
low Little Island and a submerged bowlder known as Bushworth Rock
near mid-channel, opposite the lower wharf of the town of Warren, and
recommended that this bowlder and the reef referred to be removed as
far as it could be done with an expenditure of $5,000 for both purposes.

                                      PLANS OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The work of improvement is one that can not be well carried on by
contract, and the approved project is first to remove Bushworth Rock,
and afterwards to remove the bowlders which lie submerged on the
western side of the narrowest portion of the channel at Little Island,
and also the projecting portions of the ledge beneath the bowlders,
widening the channel as much as the funds available will allow; it also
includes the hiring in open market of a vessel with working crew, sub-
marine diver, firing battery, and steam-hoisting apparatus, and pur-
chase of the explosives also in open market.
  A plat of the river showing the proposed improvement near Little
Island, was published in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1885, page 630.

                   OPERATIONS DURING                       THE LAST FISCAL YEAR.

  The work of the removal of bowlders and ledge rock, under the ap-
proved project, was commenced August 1, and continued until Novem-
ber 23, when the limit of the appropriation was reached. During this
time 811 tons of bowlders, ledge rock, and gravel, were removed and
placed on the shore.
  Mr. Theo. Topham was the local inspector of the work.

AMOUNT EXPENDED                       DURING TIHE LAST FISCAL YEAR AND                            RESULTS
                                          TO JUNE 30, 1888.

  The amount expended during the last fiscal year, including liabilities
outstanding June 30, 1888, was $4,699.39. The result was the removal
of Bushworth Rock to the depth of the surrounding water, and the re-
moval of the bowlders and points of ledge rock over an area of about
1.8 acres, in the vicinity of Little Island, extending 550 feet along the
narrowest part of the channel.

WORK REQUIRED                    TO     BE     DONE       TO COMPLETE                 THE EXISTING     PRO-
                                                         JECT.

  The work carried on from August to November, 1887, finished the
improvement as far as projected:
  Warren River is in the Bristol-Warren collection district, which is a port of entry.
There was no revenue collected in the last fiscal year. The nearest light house is the
light-house on Conimrnicut Point, Providence River.                            The nearest fortifications are
fort on Dutch Island, and Fort Adams, R. I.

                                                Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available .........................................                           $4,969.50
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 --......................-------------------.....................         4,699. 39

July 1, 1888, balance available ..-..--..-........................----...... --------------           270.11
496    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                   C8.

       IMPROVEMENT OF PAWTUCKET RIVER, RHODE ISLAND.

   The navigable part of the Pawtucket (or Seekonk) River, an arm of
Providence River, extends from Providenc, to Pawtucket, a city which
has a population of about 23,000, and extensive manufactures, depend-
ing largely on water transportation. The object of the improvement is
to widen and deepen the channel leading to Pawtucket, so that vessels
of 12 feet draught can reach that city at mean low water. The mean
rise and fall of the tide is about 5 feet.

                        ORIGINAL    CONDITION.

  Before improvement the channel in the river had a ruling depth of
about 5 feet at mean low water.

                      PLANS OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The original project, as modified in 1883, provides for the excavation
by dredging of a channel 100 feet wide and 12 feet deep at mean low
water from the deep water above Red Bridge to the ledge opposite
Grant & Company's Wharf at Pawtucket; thence the deepening by
blasting of the channel through the ledge to Pawtucket Bridge to the
same depth and 40 feet wide.
  A plat of the river showing the lines of the proposed channel was
published in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1884,
page 608.
       AMOUNT EXPENDED       AND RESULTS TO JUNE 30,        1887.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1887, was $110,969.70.      The chan-
nel had been excavated under the original project to a width of 75 feet
and a ruling depth of 7 feet at mean low water, and under the project
as modified in 1883 a new channel 12 feet deep and 100 feet wide, with
wide enlargements at the bends, had been carried from its mouth at the
deep water just above Red Bridge, a distance of about 9,940 feet, or to
a point about 2,200 feet above a line drawn from Bucklin Island to Swan
Point Wharf.
           OPERATIONS    DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR.

   At the beginning of the last fiscal year the work of dredging under
the project for the expenditure of the appropriation of $30,000 of August
5, 1886, approved by the Chief of Engineers, was in progress and was
continued until October 6, when the limit of the appropriation was
reached. This project contemplated the continuation of the enlarged
channel as far towards Pawtucket as the funds would allow, affording
at the same time such relief as the commerce may require at the shoal-
est places above the main work.
   The amount of material dredged was 72,248.58 cubic yards. Capt. M.
S. Persons was the local inspector of the work.

AMOUNT EXPENDED DURING         THE LAST FISCAL YEAR AND RESULTS
                          TO JUNE 30, 1888.
  The amount expended during the last fiscal year, including liabilities
outstanding June 30, 1888, was $20,160.29, and the result is the excava-
                    APPENDIX C-REPORT OF MAJOR LIVERMORE.                                                                          497
tion of the channel about 2,800 feet up the river. There is now a chan-
nel 100 feet wide and 12 feet deep at mean low water from the deep
water above Red Bridge to Bass Rock, or to within about 11 miles of
the head of navigation.
   This completed portion of the channel is already a great benefit to
the commerce of the river. A ruling depth of about 6 feet can be car-
ried from the upper end of our present work to Pawtucket.

          WORK REQUIRED TO COMPLETE THE EXISTING PROJECT.

   The work yet to be done is to excavate, by dredging, the channel 12
feet deep and 100 feet wide, from Bass Rock to a point opposite Grant
& Company's Wharf and thence to Pawtucket Bridge, to deepen the
channel through the ledge to the same depth with a width of 40 feet.

OPERATIONS CONTEMPLATED                                         FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE
                                                                30, 1889.

  Should an appropriation be made for this work it is proposed to ex-
tend the channel toward Pawtucket.
  Pawtucket is in the collection district of Providence, and that port is the nearest
port of entry. The amount of revenue collected at Providence in the last fiscal year
was $240,197.75. The nearest light-house is Sassafras Point Light. The nearest
fortifications are Fort Adams, Newport, R. I., and the fort on Dutch Island, Rhode
Island.
                                                      Money statement.
July 1,1887, amount available                      .-....   -        ......-...................                               $21,036.26
July 1,1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887...-. ..    ..    .------.........              20,160.29
July 1,1888, balance available..........................................                                                           875.97
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.........................                                                         35, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.................... 35,875.97
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 367,478.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 50, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                   COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                              [Furnished by Business Men's Association, Pawtucket, R. I.]

                                                                RECEIPTS.

Coal...................................                                         ........................            tons..       150,000
Cement ....          ......     ......    ......   ......       ......        ....      ......    ......   ...... barrels..        9,657
Lime      ........---.........--------------------...---........   do...       5, 628
                                                                           5,000,000
Long lumber (about)......---.................-----------------...............
Short lumber ..... ................ _...._..........................do.. . 1,000,000
Spool wood ........................................................do..-.                                                        270,000
  Together with large quantities of brick, iron, gravel, cotton, and various kinds of
other merchandise which are used by this community.
  There passed through the draw of the Washington Bridge, Pawtucket River, dur-
ing the year 1887:
Steamers .........................                                684          Tow-boats...... .................. 2,356
Schooners ...... .......                                          334           Sail-boats ................... ....                   486
Barges ....-...-....-......-....                                  492           Miscellaneous craft ............... 1,470
       ENG 88-32
498    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                       C   9   .

IMPROVEMENT OF PROVIDENCE RIVER AND NARRAGANSETT BAY, RHODE
                          ISLAND.

   Providence River is an estuary of Narragansett Bay. The object of
its improvement is to furnish a wide and deep channel for European
and coastwise commerce from the ocean to Providence, a city of about
125,000 inhabitants, largely engaged in manufactures, and a port of
entry for an extensive region of country with which it is connected by
railroads. The mean rise and fall of the tide is 4.7 feet.

                             ORIGINAL      CONDITION.

  Before the improvement of the river was commenced, in 1853, many
shoals obstructed navigation, and at one point in the channel, a place
called " The Crook," the available low-water depth was but 41 feet.

                          PLANS OF IMPROVEMENT.

  There was expended between 1852 and the 30th of June, 1882, $290,
459.34 in deepening the channel; first to 9 feet, then to 12 feet, then to
14 feet, and again to 23 feet, as the increasing sizes of vessels and the
growing commerce of Providence demanded. Bulkhead Rock was also
removed during this period to a depth of 20 feet below mean low water.
  The approved project of 1878, modified in 1882, under which we are
now working, provides for a channel 25 feet deep and 300 feet wide suit-
able for large ocean vessels, extending from Fox Point, in the city of
Providence, to the deep water of Narragansett Bay, and for an anchor-
age-basin between Fox and Fields points of the following dimensions
in cross-section, viz:

       300 feet wide, 25 feet deep.
       600 feet wide, 20 feet deep.
       725 feet wide, 18 feet deep.
       940 feet wide, 12 feet deep.
       1,060 feet wide, 6 feet deep.

   The 25-foot channel has been laid out in straight reaches (with en-
largements at the angles), with a view to lighting them by range or
leading lights, such as are used in similar cases in Chesapeake Bay,
Delaware River, and other localities, if it should be found necessary.
   A plat of Providence River, showing the improved channel, was pub-
lished in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1884, page
622.
        AMOUNT EXPENDED AND RESULTS TO JUNE 30, 1887.

   The amount expended on the present project up to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, including liabilities outstanding at
that date, was $222,836.68. At that date about one-half of the excava-
tion required for the anchorage-basin above Field's Point had been done.
Bulkhead Rock had been removed, and the 25-foot channel, 300 feet
wide, from Providence to the deep water of Narragansett Bay, had been
completed.
               APPENDIX         C-REPORT             OF MAJOR          LIVERMORE.                  499
                OPERATIONS DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR.

  At the beginning of the fiscal year the work of dredging, in that por-
tion of the anchorage-area between Fox Point and Field's Point to be
deepened to 20 feet at mean low water, was in progress and continued
until October 12, when the contract was completed; up to this date
199,580 cubic yards of material had been dredged during the fiscal
year.
   Mr. W. C. Simmons was the local inspector of the work.

AMOUNT EXPENDED DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR AND RESULTS
                   TO JUNE 30, 1888.

  The amount expended during the last fiscal year, including liabilities
outstanding June 30, 1888, tvas $19,762.92.   The result was the com-
pletion of the excavation of the 20-foot anchorage-area in the Fox Point
Reach, and about one-fourth of the same area in the Sassafras Point
Reach. The 25-foot channel, 300 feet wide, from Fox Point in the city
of Providence to the deep water of Narragansett Bay, has been com-
pleted.

        WORK REQUIRED TO COMPLETE THE EXISTING PROJECT.

   There is required for the completion of the existing project the re-
mainder of the excavation of the anchorage-basin between Fox and
Field's points.

OPERATIONS CONTEMPLATED FORI THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE
                         30, 1889.

  Should an appropriation be made it                        is proposed to continue the ex-
cavation of the anchorage-area.
  Providence River is in the collection district of Providence, which is a port of en-
try. The amount of revenue collected at Providence in the last fiscal year was $240,-
197.75. The nearest light-houses are the six light-houses in Providence River. The
nearest fortifications are fort on Dutch Island and Fort Adams, R. I.

                                         Money statement.

July 1, 1887, amount available........................................------------------------------------.. $20, 763.95
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887-----------------........................---.--.......                              19,762.92

July 1, 1884, balance available.................---.            -1,001.03
                                               ..........-------........--......
                                                                      40,000.00
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.. ...... - -...............

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.................... 41,001.03


  Amount that can be profitably expendedinfiscal yearending June 30.1890 100, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and1867.
500                  REPORT OF THE CHIEF                                  OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                      COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                [Furnished by Providence Board of Trade.]

                                                                  RECEIPTS.


                            Articles.                    Quantity.                                    Articles.                              Quantity.


Lumber........................feet..                      3, 736, 000G       Shingles ....         - - -- -...............- - - - - -.....    3,132,000
Laths.................................                    7, 974, 000        Pickets ...........................                                   9, 080
Piling .......................          pieces..                  150        Wood .......................                       cords..            3,921
Salt ..............                    pounds..           7, 350, 749        Logwood ......................                       tons..           4, 082
Brimstone.....................tons..                              630        Potatoes ................                      bushels..             36, 950
Starch .....................                   casks..            738        Clapboards ...............                                            5,400
Cliff stone.....................tons..                         1, 050        Brandy......                  ........   gallons.                     4,597
Champagne ..........                         baskets..            328        Beer .........................             do....                        919
Cotton ........                    ........    bales..       200, 607        Beef.........................tons..                                   8, 349
Wool..........................do....                          61, 207        Flour.......................barrels.                                244, 381
    Do .......              ................. sacks..         39, 516        Corn .....................              bushels..                1,614, 291
    Do ...................                   pounds..     5, 103, 371        Oats ... ...................               do....                1, 278, 738
Coal..........................tons..                         887, 424        Dry goods....................cases.                                  59, 766
Iron and steel .................                do...         26, 308        Paper .........................             tons..                    3 341
Lumber.........................feet..                    49, 088, 910        Chemicals ........                     packages..                    71,666
Oil .........................                barrels..       155, 844        Hardware. ...................               tons..                    2, 438
Waste......................pounds.                       11, 039, 881        Liquor .....................             barrels..                   20, 276



                                                                   TONNAGE.


                                                         Vessels.                                                                     No.    Tonnage.


Sail.................................................................................
                      ------------------------------------------------------------------                                                87    15,254.48
Steam ....................................                  ..........           .   ..............          ..............             35    16,   884. 95



                                                                         C I0.

RE\OVAL OF                                   GREEN JACKET             SHOAL, PROVIDENCE                                       RIVER,         RHODE
                                                                     ISLAND.

      Green Jacket Shoal is in that part of Providence River which con-
stitutes the harbor of Providence.
   It lies off the wharves on the south front of the city, and occupies a
part of the harbor that is required for anchorage purposes.

                                                     ORIGINAL               CONDITION.


      That part of the harbor in which the shoal is located is about 2,000
feet long, by from 600 to 1,200 feet wide; and of this area the shoal, or
rather that part of it which was included between the 15-foot curves,
takes up about 18 acres. There were channels on either side of the
shoal, between it and the harbor lines, having, the one on the north side
a width of 300 feet and a depth of 20 feet, and the one on the south
side a width varying from 50 to 100 feet and a depth of about 15 feet
at mean low water. The water on the summit of the shoal was 1 foot
deep.
                                                  PLANS      OF IMPROVEMENT.


   The general project is the removal of the entire shoal to a depth of
25 feet at mean low water, limiting the work by lines drawn 200 feet
from the harbor lines.
   A plat of Green Jacket Shoal, with report of survey, was published
               APPENDIX           C-REPORT OF MAJOR LIVERMORE.                                  501
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1885, vol. 1, pages
598-602.

             AMOUNT EXPENDED AND RESULTS TO JUNE 30,                                   1887.
   The amount expended, including outstanding liabilities to June .30,
1887, was $767.47. At the close of the last fiscal year the work of
dredging had not commenced.

                 OPERATIONS DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR.

   The work of dredging under the approved project was commenced
July 11, and continued until November 5, when the contract was com-
pleted. Two hundred and six thousand four hundred and thirty.one
cubic pards of material were excavated.
  Mr. W. C. Simmons was the local inspector of the work.

AMOUNT EXPENDED DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR AND RESULTS
                    TO JUNE 30, 1888.

   The amount expended, including outstanding liabilities, to June 30,
1888, was $24,388.13.    The result was the excavation to a depth of 25
feet at mean low water of an area of about 91 acres, extending along
the western side of the shoal, making an important addition to the an-
chorage facilities of the harbor.  On a portion of this area the depth of
water before the completion of the contract was from 3 to 4 feet.

OPERATIONS CONTEMPLATED FOR THE FISCAL                                           YEAR ENDING JUNE
                        30, 1889.

   Should an appropriation be made for this work it is proposed to con-
tinue the removal of the shoal according to the general project.
  Green Jacket Shoal is in the collection district of Providence, which is a port of
entry. The amount of revenue collected at Providence during the last fiscal year was
$240,197.75. The nearest light-houses are the six light-houses in Providence River.
The nearest fortifications are fort on Dutch Island and Fort Adams, R. I.

                                      COMMERCIAL      STATISTICS.

  For the commercial statistics, see report of the improvement of Providence River
and Narragansett Bay, Rhode Island.



                                        Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available.........................................    $25,482.53
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 .....................................            24,388.13
July 1, 1888, balance available ...................         .......................         1,094.40
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888........................                      28, 000.00
Amount    available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.................                  29,094.40

SAmount   (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 58, 096.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 50,000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
502    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                  C   I.


       IMPROVEMENT OF NEWPORT HARBOR, RHODE ISLAND.

   This harbor is at the main entrance to Narragansett Bay. These
waters during summer and winter constitute a harbor of refuge for our
European and coastwise commerce quite equal in every respect to that
of New York Harbor, and are even more accessible. The objects of the
improvement are to widen and deepen the southern (the main) entrance
to the harbor, and to enlarge its capacity for vessels seeking refuge in
storms, by increasing the area and depth of the anchorage within it.
The mean rise and fall of the tide is about 34 feet.

                         ORIGINAL CONDITION.

  Before improvement the capacity of the inner harbor was limited by
shoals, and it was not adequate to the number and size of vessels seek-
ing it for refuge. The southern (the main) entrance was obstructed by
a bar which stretched out from Goat Island, and the general business
wharves of the city could not be reached at low tide by vessels draw-
ing more than 8 feet.

                       PLANS OF IMPROVEMENT.

   The original project and its -modifications under which we are now
working are substantially as follows:
   Deepening the southern entrance to 15 feet at mean low water and
widening it by dredging Goat Island Spit northward to a line drawn from
the dolphin which marks the spit to clear the permanent dock at Fort
Adams by 100 feet; the excavation of a channel 750 feet wide and 15 feet
deep at mean low water around and to the eastward of this dolphin; ex-
cavating to 13 feet at mean low water the area included between the 13-
foot curve on the west, a line drawn from the southwest corner of Perry
Mill Wharf to Lime Rock on the south, the harbor line on the east, and a
line drawn parallel to and 50 feet from the city wharf on the north; ex-
cavating to 10 feet at mean low water the area northwest of a line drawn,
from Lime Rock through the spindle, which is in the southeast part of
the harbor; the excavation of a channel 10 feet deep at mean low water
along and outside the harbor line south to a point opposite the gas com-
pany's wharf, and the construction of jetties on the western shore of
Goat Island to arrest the drift of littoral sand and gravel into the south-
ern entrance.
   A plat of Newport Harbor, showing the plans of the work, was pub-
lished in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1885, vol. 1,
page 604.

        AMOUNT EXPENDED       AND RESULTS TO JUNE        30, 1887.

  SThe amount expended up to the close of the fiscal year ending June
30, 1887, including liabilities outstanding at that date, was $107,563.87,
with the following results:
  Of the area to be dredged to 13 feet within the harbor, about nine-
tenths had been completed, except at a few places in the northern part
of the harbor, where the material was found too hard for the dredge in
use at the time. The channel along and outside the harbor line south
            APPENDIX      C-REPORT OF MAJOR LIVERMORE.                          503

to a point opposite the gas company's wharf, and the 15-foot channel
750 feet wide around and to the eastward of the dolphin on Goat Island
Spit, had been completed, with the exception of a strip along the west-
ern edge and to the north of the dolphin. The increase of width to be
made between the 15-foot curves at the southern entrance, by dredging
the spit south of Goat Island, had been completed. The berth for ves-
sels at the Quartermaster's wharf at Fort Adams had been deepened to
10 feet at mean low water, and the littoral sand from the outside of
Goat Island had been stopped from washing into the channel at the
southern entrance of the harbor by the construction of a jetty on the west
side of the island.

             OPERATIONS       DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR.

  At the beginning of the last fiscal year the work of dredging in the
13-foot anchorage area under the contract with the Hartford Dredging
Company, described in the last Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers,
was in progress and was completed July 8.
  Mr. Theo. Topham was the local inspector of the work.

AMOUNT     EXPENDED DURING THE LAST               FISCAL YEAR AND RESULTS
                               TO JUNE 30, 1888.

   The amount expended during the last fiscal year, including liabilities
outstanding June 30, 1888, was $560.36, and the result was the comple-
tion of the excavation of about nine-tenths of the 13-foot anchorage area.
Of the total area to be dredged within the harbor (about 90 acres)
about two-thirds have been completed. The berths for vessels at the
quartermaster's wharf at Fort Adams was deepened to 10 feet at mean
low water, and the effectual stopping for the present of the supply of
littoral sand and gravel from the outsideof Goat Island into the southern
entrance by the jetty on the southwest shore of the island. The south-
ern entrance is completed for vessels of 15 feet draught.

      WORK REQUIRED           TO COMPLETE THE EXISTING PROJECT.

   The work required to complete the existing project is the dredging
of a narrow strip along the western edge of the 750-foot channel around
and to the eastward of the dolphin on the Goat Island spit; the re-
mainder of the excavation within the harbor of the anchorage area of
13 feet depth, and the excavation also within the harbor of the anchor-
age area of 10 feet depth; also the building of additional jetties outside
of Goat Island whenever they may be required to arrest the drift of
littoral sand and gravel into the harbor entrance.

OPERATIONS      CONTEMPLATED          FOR THE      FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE
                                      30, 1889.

   Should any appropriation be made for this work it is proposed to
complete the 15-foot channel as projected and extend the anchorage
area as far as possible to the east and south.
  Newport is in the collection district of Newport and is a port of entry. The amount
of revenue collected at Newport in the last fiscal year was $4,774.26. The nearest
light-houses are Lime Rock and Newport (Goat Island) lights.    The nearestfortifica-
tion is Fort Adams, Newport, R. I.
504                REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                          Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available                            ....---------------------------------------                           $638.16
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 .................................-......--......-------------                                         560. 36
July 1, 1888, balance available -----------------------------------------
                                .....................                          77.80
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ........................    12, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.................                                                        12,077.80

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                                     40,000. 00
SAmount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,189a 30,000. 00
  SSubmitted in compliance with requirements
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
                                                                                of sections 2 of river and




                                                       COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                        [Furnished by Mr. J. H. Cozzens, collector of customs, 1887.]

                                                     RECEIPTS OF MERCHANDISE.


                           Articles.                       Quantity.                                   Articles.              Quantity.

Coal...........................tons..                           50,000    Cement ...................               barrels.          9, 000
Shingles.............................                       5, 000, 000   Brick      ...........................                5, 000, 000
Laths................................                      8, 500, 000    Lumber.......................feet.                   12, 500, 000
Lime.......................barrels..                           13, 000    Hay ........................... tons..                     1, 000
Potatoes ...................                   bushels.         2, 600    Grain .....................              bushels.       350, 000




                                                                    C 12.

                   HARBOR OF REFUGE AT BLOCK ISLAND, RHODE ISLAND.

   This island is a part of the State of Rhode Island. It is 14 miles east
of Montauk Point, the eastern end of Long Island, and its nearest point
is about 10 miles from the mainland. Besides the wants of the mack-
erel.fishing fleet and the general coast navigation, the island is an im-
portant point on our shores for ocean navigation. It has a signal sta-
tion connected by submarine telegraph with the mainland. Vessels
are passing the island at all times and on all sides of it, and its posi-
tion renders it of national importance. The object of the improvement
is to furnish a harbor of refuge for vessels engaged in foreign and coast-
wise commerce. The mean rise and fall of the tide is about 3 feet.
                                                       ORIGINAL CONDITION.

  Before the construction of the present harbor of refuge Block Island
had no harbor which afforded protection for decked vessels. The only
ones used were open boats, which, on the approach of storms, were
hauled up on the beach by oxen. The largest of these boats were of
about 10 tons burden.
                                                     PLANS OF THE WORKS.

   The original project and its subsequent modifications provided for a
harbor of refuge on the eastern side of the island, consisting of an inner
liarbor or basin for small vessels and an exterior harbor for large ones.
           APPENDIX    C--REPORT     OP MAJOR LIVtRMORE.               505
The basin was to be about 250 by 300 feet in area, and inclosed with
the exception of an opening 80 feet in width. The exterior harbor was
to be formed by a riprap breakwater, which has been built. About
300 feet from the sea end of this breakwater, which is 1,900 feet long, a
gap 200 feet long was left for the convenience of vessels. The present
project contemplates the filling of this gap and the enlargement of the
inner harbor. A plat of Block Island, showing the position of the har-
bor of refuge and a plan of the works, may be found in the Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1885, vol. 1, pages 612, 613.

        AMOUNT    EXPENDED AND RESULTS TO JUNE             30, 1887.

   The total expenditure up to June 30, 1887, including liabilities out
standing at that date, was $325,024.17. The inner harbor and the main
breakwater, built in prolongation of the eastern side of the inner harbor
and extending 1,900 feet from the shore, were constructed in the years
1870 to 1879, inclusive. The utility of the work at once became ap-
parent. In the stormy weather the inner harbor especially was filled
with fishermen and coasters, and it soon became necessary to increase
its depth from 7 feet, to which it had been dredged in the first instance,
to 9 feet at mean low water. In 1883 a strong jetty was built out from
the cliff to the eastward of the inner harbor, and a masonry wall was
constructed on the inside of the crib-work, forming the eastern side of
the inner harbor. The filling in the gap in the main breakwater was
carried to the height of about 1 feet above mean high water, and at
the close of the work under the last contract about one-half of the total
amount of stone required for the completion of this work had been de-
livered and placed in the gap. The sea, which formerly came into the
outer harbor through the gap in the main breakwater in easterly storms,
had been stopped by this partial filling. A contract for the commence-
ment of the enlargement of the inner harbor and filling the gap in the
main breakwater was made.

           OPERATIONS     DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR.

  The work of the commencement of the enlargement of the inner harbor
and filling the gap in the main breakwater, provided for in the appro-
priation of August 5, 1886, was commenced July 11, 1887, and continued
until November 30, when it was suspended for the winter; it was re-
sumed April 17, 1888, and continued to the end of the fiscal year. There
were 4,258 tons of riprap granite placed in the gap of the main break-
water, which carried that portion of the work as far as the funds availa-
ble would allow. The timber jetty filled with stone, to form the shore
end of the west wall of the proposed enlarged harbor, was built from
high water to low water of spring tides a distance of 138 feet, and a
substantial enrockment placed at its outer end to protect it from the
action of the sea until the west wall is built.
   The work of the construction of the north wall of the inner harbor
was commenced near the breakwater, from whence it will be carried to
the westward as far as the available funds will permit. At the close
of the fiscal year the work was still in progress. Mr. Frank I. Angell
was the local inspector of the work.
   In response to a resolution of the Senate of the United States, passed
April 17, 1888, calling for an estimate of the cost of the removal of a
shoal obstructing navigation at the entrance to the harbor of Block
506       REPORT OF THE CHIEP OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Island, the following report was submitted to the Chief of Engineers
on May 4:
                                              ENGINEER     OFFICE, U.    S.   ARMY,
                                                        Newport, B. I., May 4, 1888.
   SIR: Referring to the letter of the Chief of Engineers of April 18, 1888, inclosing a
copy of a resolution of the Senate asking for an estimate of the cost of removing a
sand-bar which has recently formed, obstructing navigation, at the entrance of the
harbor at Block Island, I have the honor to report that a gradual shoaling along the
western side of the breakwater has taken place for a number of years; this reaches
its maximum width at the point where the north wall of the proposed enlarged harbor
joins the main breakwater, and since the survey of 1884 the 9-foot curve has advanced
to the westward about 70 feet, reducing the distance between the 9-foot curves in the
harbor by that amount. This distance at that time was 445 feet.
  At the entrance to the present basin the 6-foot curve has advanced slightly to the
westward since 1884, and this shoaling may interfere somewhat with beating out of
the basin, and the extension of the shoal to the westward of the breakwater renders
the landing of the steamers of the Fall River and Providence Steam-boat Company at
their wharf outside of the basin difficult and uncertain.
  It is estimated that the removal of the whole shoal to a depth of 9 feet to a line 20
feet from the breakwater would cost $5,000.
  The removal of that portion of it opposite the entrance to the basin and extending
to the end of the Fall River and Providence Steam-boat Company's wharf would cost
$1,000.
  The inclosed tracing shows the relative positions of the 9 and 6-foot curves of 1884
and 1888.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                             W.   R.   LIVERMORE,
                                                                  Major of Engineers.
                  ENGINEERS,   U.   S.   A.
  The   CHIEFOF


  The formation of this shoal is probably due in a great measure to
the lowering of the top of the main breakwater, caused by its settle-
ment. The sea, coming up the eastern side of the island, holds in sus-
pension a large amount of sand, and, breaking over the top of the break-
water, deposits it in the harbor. Cross-sections of the breakwater will
be taken with a view to Estimating the cost of restoring its original
section. When this is accomplished and the harbor inclosed on the
western side by a riprap wall the accumulation of sand within the har-
bor can be checked.

AIOUNT EXPENDED DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR AND RESULTS
                    TO JUNE 30, 1888.

  The amount expended during the last fiscal year, including liabilities
outstanding June 30, 1888, was $13,983.95.      The result was the filling
of the gap to within about one-seventh of the total estimated amount,
the construction of the timber jetty filled with stone forming the shore
end of the western wall of the proposed enlarged inner harbor, and the
commencement of the construction of its north wall.

                       THE WHARF AT BLOCK ISLAND.

  In his annual report for the year 1886 Colonel Elliot recommended
that the Government wharf on the land side of the inner harbor of
refuge at Block Island should be turned over to the town of New Shore-
ham, the corporate name of Block Island, and that the following pro-
visions be attached to the item for Block Island in the next river and
harbor bill:
  Provided, That the wharf on the land side of the inner harbor may be turned over
to the town of New Shoreham for the public use of said town; but no tolls or charges
shall ever be exacted for the use of said wharf by public vessels of the United States,
or freight carried in such vessels.
                 ...........        6i
  ,,        ~,




        I
        I
   /
.4-4*       9.
                           a
                           b3                   4


                                                                               wW
                               $3        $3$3       5
                                                                               7AY
                                $3ti




   $.                                                                          7w
                                                        MA3A     REAK     T

                                                               'BEAK    WAT7
                                                                                     4.




                 100 1. tolin.
                 APPENDIX            C---REPORT              OF MAJOR LIVERMORE.                                  507
  And I would respectfully renew the recommendation.
  The location of this wharf may be seen in the plat published at page
613 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1885.

         WORK REQUIRED TO COMPLETE TUE EXISTING PROJECT.

  The work required to complete the existing project is the completion
of the filling of the gap in the main breakwater, the restoring of the
breakwater to its original dimensions, and the enlargement of the inner
harbor.

OPERATIONS             CONTEMPLATED FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE
                                    30, 1889.

   It is proposed to apply the amount available July 1, 1888, to the ex-
tension to the westward of the north wall of the inner harbor.
  Block Island is in the Newport collection district, and Newport is the nearest port
of entry. The revenue collected at Newport in the last fiscal year was $4,774.26.
There is no duty collected at the island. The value of the harbor is mainly as a har-
bor of refuge. There are four lights at the island, the north and south lights and
the breakwater lights. The nearest fortification is Fort Adams, Newport, R. I.

                                              Money statement.

July 1, 1887, amount available -......................---....----..........---.     $19, 975.83
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 .....................            10,049.21
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities...... ...................           3, 934.74
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts...........             5, 215.09
                                                                                                             19,199. 04

July 1, 1888, balance available:
  ' Breakwater .............      ......----............ ..............                            197.31
    Inner harbor .........-- ............       ......   .............. --                         579. 48
                                                                                               ,                 776.79
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ....                              ..........      ......       15, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .................                                      15,776. 79
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.... ....                                    40, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                 40, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                           COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                               [Furnished by lion. Nicholas Ball, Block Island.]

  Report on the arrival and departure of steam and sail vessels, together with imports
and exports, to and from Block Island for the year ending December 31, 1887:
Coal received (about)............... ............................                                      tons..       5,300
Iron received (about)...... .....-            -...........  .........................- --          -- do...            250
Grain received (about) ......................                        ................            bushels..         15, 000
Lumber received (about).... ...... ...............................                                      feet.. 4, 200,000
General merchandise, not included in the above, imported and exported,
  tons ....................................................                              .............             15,000

                             ARRIVALS AND DEPARTURES FOR THE YEAR.

Steamers from 50 to 1,000 tons, drawing from 3 to 10 feet of water.........                                       2,100
Sailing vessels, from 10 to 200 tons, from 2 to 6 feet draught (about)....                                      116,000
508      REPORT OF THE CHIEF-OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                       C 13.

IMPROVEMENT        OF LITTLE NARRAGANSETT              BAY, RHODE ISLAND AND
                             CONNECTICUT.

   Little Narragansett Bay lies on the north side of the eastern entrance
from the ocean into Long Island Sound; Pawcatuck River, upon which
is situated the important commercial and manufacturing town of West-
erly, R. I., empties into the eastern side of the bay, and has been im-
proved by the United States. The object of the improvement of Little
Narragansett Bay was to deepen the approach from Long Island Sound
to Westerly.
   The mean rise and fall of the tide is 2.63 feet.
                             ORIGINAL CONDITION.

  The navigable draught of water through the bay before improvement
was about 41 feet at mean low water.
                           PLAN OF IMPROVEMENT.

   The project of 1878 for the improvement of the bay provided for a
channel 200 feet wide and 71 feet deep at mean low water from the en-
trance to the bay to the mouth of the Pawcatuck, and the removal of
the bowlders which then obstructed navigation, and any others which
the excavation of the channel might develop. Subsequently it was
determined to clear away some large bowlders which interfered with
steam-boat navigation between this channel and Watch Hill Landing.
The estimated cost of the improvement was $51,000.
   A plat of Narragansett Bay, showing the improved channel, was pub-
lished in the Annual Report.of the Chief of Engineers for 1879, page
314.
                    AMOUNT      EXPENDED AND RESULTS.

   The project was completed in the fiscal year 1883-'84. The main chan-
nel as projected was excavated to its full width and depth, and many
bowlders were removed from the Watch Hill Channel. Vessels draw-
ing 10 feet of water can now reach the mouth of the Pawcatuck River
at high water, but the full benefit of the improvement can not be util-
ized until further deepening of that river, which is now in progress, to
enable vessels of the same draught to reach Westerly.
   The remainder of the last appropriation for Little Narragansett Bay
is reserved for comparative surveys of Sandy Point, at the entrance of
the bay, which seems to be affected by the construction of the break-
water in Stonington Harbor, and for range-marks on Pawcatuck Point
to guide through the new channel. The total cost of the completed im-
provement was $35,856.96.
  Little Narragansett Bay is in the collection district of Providence and Stonington,
the dividing line passing through the bay. Providence and Stonington are the near-
est ports of entry. The revenue collected in the last fiscal year was: Providence,
$240,197.75; Stonington, $1,659.18. The nearest light-houses are the Stonington and
Watch Hill Lights. The nearest fortification is Fort Trnumbull, New London, Conn.

                                Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available........... .. ..-----    -..
                                                          ----......
                                                                  ......  $143.04
July 1, 1888, balance available ......... -----                            143, 04
                                                            -----....................
          APPENDIX     C--REPORT      OF MAJOR LIVERMORE.              509

                                   C 14.

IMPROVEMENT OF PAWCATUCK RIVER, RHODE ISLAND AND CONNECTI-
                          CUT.

   The navigable part of Pawcatuck River extends from the manufact-
uring town of Westerly to Little Narragansett Bay, into which it emp-
ties. The approach to the river is though Stonington Outer Harbor and
Little Narragansett Bay, and the object of the improvement is to deepen
and widen the river channel leading from this bay to Westerly.
   The mean rise and fall of the tide is 2.60 feet at the mouth of the river
and 2.30 feet at Westerly.
                          ORIGINAL CONDITION.

Before improvement the channel was crooked and obstructed by nu-
merous shoals, on some of which there was but 1l feet at mean low water.
                        PLANS OF IMPROVEMENT.

   By means of appropriations made in the years 1871-'75 the river was
improved by the United States by the excavation of a channel 51 feet
deep at mean low water and 75 feet wide below the wharves and from
35 to 40 feet wide between the lower and upper wharves. The present
project contemplates the widening of the channel to 100 feet below the
wharves and by an additional width of two cuts of an ordinary dredg-
ing-machine, or about 40 feet, between the lower and the upper wharves;
also the deepening of the entire channel to 8 feet at mean low water.
   A plat of Pawcatuck River, showing the channel lines under the
present project, was published in the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1885, part 1, pages 623-625.
        AMOUNT    EXPENDED     AND   RESULTS TO JUNE 30, 1887.

  The amount expended on the present project to June 30, 1887, includ-
ing outstanding liabilities, was $3,535.12, and the result was the com-
pletion of the channel to its full width and depth from the deep water
opposite the village of Lottery to Certain Draw Point.
            OPERATIONS     DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR.

  At the beginning of the fiscal year the work of dredging under the
project for the expenditure of the appropriation of August 5, 1886,
which contemplated the beginning of the channel at the deep water op-
posite the village of Lottery and extending it as far towards Westerly
as the funds would allow, was in progress and was continued until No-
vember 19, when it was suspended for the winter ; it was resumed April
24 and continued until the close of the fiscal year, when it was still in
progress.
  During the fiscal year 48,938.8 cubic yards of sand and mud and 8.32
cubic yards of bowlders over 2 tons weight were excavated from the
channel.
  Mr. A. H. Dickens was the local inspector of the work.
AMOUNT EXPENDED       DURING    THE LAST FISCAL YEAR AND          RESULTS
                            TO JUNE 30, 1888.
  The amount expended during the last fiscal year, including liabilities
outstanding June 30, 1838, was $6,928.50, and the result was the com-
510         REPORT OF THE CHIEF                                OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

pletion of the channel to its full width and depth from the deep water
opposite the village of Lottery to a point near the lower end of Major's
Island, with the exception of a small amount of ledge rock which ex-
tends into the channel near Certain Draw Point and at Pawcatuck
Rock.
         WORK REQUIRED TO COMPLETE THE EXISTING PROJECT.

  The work required to complete the existing project is the dredging of
the channel to a depth of 8 feet at mean low water, and width of 100
feet from the upper end of the present work to Westerly, and a width
of 40 feet between the upper and lower wharves of that town; also the
removal of the ledge rock near Certain Draw Point and Pawcatuck
Rock.

OPERATIONS CONTEMPLATED FOR THE FISCAL YEAR                                                                  ENDING JUNE
                                                         30, 1889.
  It is proposed to continue the work of widening and deepening the
channel according to the new project as far toward Westerly as the funds
will admit, and also to afford such relief as the commerce of the river
may require at the shoalest places in advance of the main work, and to
remove the points of ledge rock referred to above.
  Pawcatuck River is in the collection districts of Providence and Stonington, the
dividing line passing through the river. Providence and Stonington are the nearest
ports of entry. The revenue collected in the last fiscal year was: Providence,
$240,197.75; Stonington, $1,659.18. The nearest light-houses are the Stonington and
Watch Hill lights. The nearest fortification is Fort Trumbull, New London, Conn.

                                                 Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available .........................       ....     ....    $8,464.88
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding Jily 1, 1887.                             $5, 184. 13
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities.....            .              1,744.37
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing. contracts.... ......       1,137. 38
                                                                                 8, 065. 88
July 1, 1888, balance available.....................................                                       .
                                                                                                         ........        399.00
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.                                                                        10,000. 00
                                                                      ..
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...................                                              10, 399.00

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                          16, 637. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of section, 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                              COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                               [Furnished by Messrs. Maxon & Co., Westerly, R. I.]

                                     RECEIPTS AT WESTERLY                     BY WATER.

Coal........... ..................... ............................                                           tons..     18, 540
Molding sand....................................................do...                                                       547
Lumber.......................... .................................                                          feet.. 5, 309,790
Bricks ....................                          .... ..........  . ................         ..    ....     .... . 359, 000
Grain ..........................................................                                       bushels..        94, 000

                                                         SHIPMENTS.
Stone.... .......................                   .........-..........              ...........            tons..        2,350
Number of passengers carried by steamers                             ......     ..-    -.   ..        ....                54, 400
           APPENDIX    C-REPORT OF MAJOR LIVERMORE.                 511

                                  C 15.
         HARBOR OF REFUGE AT STONINGTON, CONNECTICUT.

   Stonington Harbor lies on the north side of the eastern entrance
from the ocean into Long Island Sound, and the main object of the im-
provement is to furnish a harbor of refuge for vessels entering and
leaving this entrance to the sound. The mean rise and fall of the tide
is about 21 feet.
                         ORIGINAL CONDITION.

  Originally it was an open bay, unprotected from southerly storms and
obstructed by a shoal, having a low-water depth of but 6 feet at the
shoalest part. This shoal nearly filled the inner harbor and left but a
narrow channel on either side of a depth insufficient to permit vessels
of 12 feet draught to reach the upper wharves at low water.

                         PLANS OF THE WORK.

   A short breakwater was constructed in the years 1828-'31 at a cost of
 $34,766.65 for the protection of the commerce of the town of Stonington.
The enlarged project of 1871 for the improvement of Stonington Harbor
and its subsequent modification, under which work is now carried on,
embraced dredging in the upper harbor and the construction of two
breakwaters in the outer harbor. One of these-the western-was to
be built out from Wamphassuck Point, the southwestern limit of the
harbor, and to extend about 2,000 feet, and the other-the eastern-was
to extend from the vicinity of Bartlett's Reef to the Middle Ground.
The western breakwater was completed in 1880 at a cost of $103,190.
The amount expended in dredging in the upper harbor was about
 $45,000. The position of the western end of the eastern breakwater
has not been determined, but it will probably be found necessary, in
order to afford all the protection desired, to extend the breakwater at
*least until it intersects a range from Stonington Light to the middle of
Wicopessit Island. It may then be found desirable to carry it still fur-
ther, possibly to the range from Stonington Light to the eastern end of
Fisher's Island.
   A plat of this harbor, showing the position of the breakwaters, was
published in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1884,
page 632.

        AMOUNT EXPENDED       AND   RESULTS TO JUNE 30, 1887.

  The amount expended upon the eastern breakwater up to the close
of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, including liabilities outstand-
ing at that date, was $105,115.19, and its length at that date was 2,150
feet.
            OPERATIONS DURING       THE LAST FISCAL YEAR.

   At the beginning of the last fiscal year the work of extending the
eastern breakwater to the westward, under the project for the expendi-
ture of the appropriation of August 5, 1886, was in progress, and con-
tinued until October 27, 1887, when the limit of the appropriation was
512       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

reached. -During the fiscal year 3,550 tons of riprap stone were placed
in the breakwater.
  Mr. Charles C. Livermore was the local inspector of the work.
AMOUNT EXPENDED DURING THE LAST FISCAL YEAR, AND RESULTS,
                                   TO JUNE 30, 1888.
  The amount expended during the last fiscal year, including liabilities
outstanding June 30, 1888, was $4,433.71, and the result was the ex-
tension of the eastern breakwater to a point about 2,210 feet from its
eastern extremity, or about .86 of the shorter of the alternative lengths
projected.
       WORK REQUIRED TO COMPLETE                      THE EXISTING PROJECT.

   The work required to complete the existing project is to finish the
construction of the eastern breakwater. In case it be found that suf-
ficient protection to the harbor of refuge has been afforded when the
range from Stonington Light to the middle of Wicopessit Island is
reached, the length of the breakwater yet to be built is about 360 feet.
Should it be decided to extend it to the middle ground it will require
about 150 feet more.
   By reason of the great danger to the large passenger steamers of
the Stonington Line (New York and Boston), caused by the western
end of the breakwater, especially in foggy and thick weather, and
which will continue to exist until it is completed and a light-house and
fog-signal are erected upon it, it is very desirable that the whole amount
necessary to finish the breakwater should be included in one appropria-
tion.
   The completion of this work will afford a thoroughly protected anch-
orage for vessels drawing 18 feet of water, and a harbor of refuge for
the commerce which daily passes between Long Island Sound and the
the eastward.
OPERATIONS CONTEMPLATED                  FOR THE FISCAL YEAR            ENDING JUNE
                                         30, 1889.
  Should an appropriation be made for this work, it is proposed to extend
the eastern breakwater further to the westwards
  Stonington Harbor is in the Stonington collection district, and is a port of entry.
The amount of revenue collected at Stonington in the last fiscal year was $1,659.18.
The principal value of the harbor is as a harbor of refuge. The nearest lights are
Stonington Light and Latimer's Reef Light. The nearest fortification is Fort Trum-
bull, New London Harbor, Connecticut.

                                    Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available ......................................... $4, 884. 51
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1,1887........................................................ 4,433.71
July 1, 1888, balance available ................ ........................          450. 80
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..........................          8,000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889................            8, 450. 80

  Amount that can be profitably expended infiscal year ending Jun 30, 1890      25, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
                APPENDIX           C--REPORT OF MAJOR LIVERMORE.                                       513
                                        COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                            [Furnished by Mr. H. G. Palmer, deputy collector.]

Number of vessels entered from foreign ports .......................                                 10
Number of vessels cleared for foreign ports .........................                                10
Value of merchandise imported---         ................            ..........
                                .---------------------------------....          .....       $8, 247. 66
Amount of duties collected - - ---- ----.------    .            .- ---- - -- .- -
                                                            ------                          $1, 659. 18
Estimated value of cargoes coastwise ...............................                  $37, 400, 000. 00
Estimated value of cargoes shipped coastwise .......................                         $35,000, 000.00
                                        ..---....-- ....
Value of product of fisheries ....----------                    -....------............
                                                           -..-..--                             $135, 000.00
Number of vessels seeking harbor for refuge .. .....................                                   2, 400
Number of vessels registered in district. ...........................                                     104
Tonnage .................    .... ...      ....... ....... . ..        --.................          8,744.39




                                                      C i6.

PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION OF NEW BEDFORD HARBOR, MASSACHU-
                          SETTS.

                                                 ENGINEER           OFFICE, U.          S.   ARMY,
                                                         Newport, R. 1., November 26, 1886.
   GENERAL: In compliance with the instructions contained in Depart-
ment letter of the 28th October last, I have the honor to submit the
following report of the preliminary examination of New Bedford Har-
bor, Massachusetts, provided for in the river and harbor act of Con-
gress of August 5, 1886, and made by me on the 13th instant.
   In the years 1875-'76 there was appropriated for the improvement of
New Bedford Harbor the sum of $20,000, which was expended in ex-
cavating a channel 15 feet deep from the vicinity of the wharves to the
deep water just above Palmer's Island.
   Since that time the draught of the steamers plying between New Bed-
ford and New York has increased, and I am informed that they not only
now touch the bottom in this channel, but that in the channel below
Palmer's Island, which was not included in the former improvement,
there is not sufficient water at low tide for the commerce of the port.
   New Bedford is an important port of entry. It is largely interested
in manufactures and has an extensive commerce in addition to its
whale fisheries.
   In a petition from citizens of New Bedford, which was published in
the Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1875, 1 find the statement that
in the six months from April to October of 1874, 1,777 steamers, 56 ships,
13 brigs, 2,545 schooners, 1,025 sloops, in all, 5,416 vessels, passed Pal-
mer's Island light-house in New Bedford Harbor, and that there were
engaged in the whaling business 88 vessels requiring a depth of about
16 feet of water. I have no later information respecting the commerce
of New Bedford, but it has doubtless largely increased, especially in
respect of steamers.
   I am inclined to the belief that the deepening of the channel desired
can be done at comparatively small cost, and in view of the interests
involved I am of the opinion that the harbor is worthy of further im-
provement.
   I estimate the expense of the necessary surveys at $600, if authority
to make them can be issued in time for completing them before Christ-
      JNG 88- 33
514       REPORT      OF THE      CIIEF    OF   ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

mas, but if later the expense will be much increased by reason of de-
lays by bad weather and ice.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                       GEORGE II.         ELLIOT,
                                                          Lieut. Col. of Engineers.
Brig. Gen. J. C. DUANE,
      Chief of Engineers, U. S. A.



          SURVEY OF NEW BEDFORD HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

                                       ENGINEER       OFFICE, U.     S.    ARMIY,
                                        Newport, R. I., October 17, 1887.
   SIR: I have the honor to submit the following report on the survey
of New Bedford Harbor, together with an estimate of the cost of its
improvement.
   This harbor is an estuary of Buzzard's Bay, forming the port of the
cities of New Bedford and Fairhaven, Mass.
   The survey was made on the 5th, 6th, and 7th of October.
   Soundings were carefully tak;en from the deep water off Clark's
Point to the wharves of New Bedford near the bridge. These sound-
ings were reduced to mean low-water level, determined by observations
for one month of tide-gauge at New Bedford. Borings were also taken
throughout the entire length of the proposed channel to a depth of 20
feet at mean low water.
   It will be seen from the accompanying sketch* that vessels drawing
over 15 feet of water can not enter the harbor at mean low water.
    It is proposed to excavate a channel 200 feet wide and 18 feet deep).
The general position of this channel and of the areas to be excavated
are shown on the sketch. The borings show that the material to be
dredged consists of mud, sand, and gravel.
    As it appears from the following estimate that the total cost of this
channel will amount to less than $35,000, I have the honor to recom-
mend that this amount, all of which can be profitably expended during
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1889, be appropriated.
   The lower part of the channel has been laid out in one straight reach,
the axis of which passes through Palmer's Island light-house, so that
vessels entering the harbor can run directly for it. The two upper
reaches are so laid out as to involve the least amount of excavation.
    In the years 1875-'76 there was appropriated for the improvement of
New Bedford Harbor the sum of $20,000, which was expended in exca-
vating a channel 15 feet deep from the vicinity of the wharves to the
deep water just above Palmer's Island. Since that time the draught of
the steamers plying between New Bedford and New York has increased,
and vessels of 15 feet draught not only now touch the bottom in this
channel, but in the channel below Palmer's Island, which was not in-
cluded in the former improvement; there is not sufficient water at low
tide for the commerce of the port.
    Many vessels and barges of much greater draught than 15 feet are
unable to carry their full cargoes.
    New Bedford is adapted by its situation to become a commercial
city of great importance.          It was once the great center of the whaling
  *   Omitted.   Printed in House Ex. Doc. No. 86t, Fiftieth Congress, first session.
                     APPENDIX C-REPORT                                     OF MAJOR LIVERMORE.             515
industry in America, and is still one of the largest and most flourishing
cities i  ew England, both in respect to its commerce and manufact-
ures.
  New Bedford is a port of entry. The amount of revenue collected at New Bedford
for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, was $29,023.98.

                                   ESTIMATE OF TILE COST OF THE IMPROVEMENT.

One hundred and seventeen thousand cubic yards, measured in place, of mate-
rial to be dredged and dumped south of Egg Island, at 27 cents.......... $31,590
Add 10 per cent. for contingencies...... ..... ...............     ...... . 3, 159
      Total ..........-......-......-...............................                                  _   34,   749

         Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                                   W.   R . LIVERMORE,
                                                                                         Major of Engineers.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                               S. A.



                      COMMERCIAL STATISTICS,                           NEW BEDFORD, MASSACHUSETTS.

  The harbor-master of New Bedford reports the arrival of eight sailing-vessels of
over 100 tons burden per day throughout the year, 2,920, about 200 of which draw
over 15 feet of water.
  Mr. Charles W. Agard, agent of the Philadelphia and Reading Coal and Iron Com-
pany, reports vessels carrying coal, 180.
   Old Colony Railroad and Steamboat Company's steamers make tri-weekly trips to
New York.
   New Bedford, Martha's Vineyard and Nantucket Steamboat Company make 600
trips annually with 5 steamers between the points named.
  The following freight is reported as being received annually by vessels by the firms
named.
   Charles W. Agard, agent Philadelphia and Reading Coal and Iron Company, re-
ports total coal received, 273,200 tons.
   Charles S. Paisler and William A. Tillinghast report lumber received in 47 vessels
of 160 tons, 8,000,000 feet.
   William B. Fisher, agent for Old Colony Railroad and Steamboat Companies, report
from New York line of steamers, cotton, over 35,000 bales; miscellaneous freight,
60,000 tons.
   William F. Nye reports oil by schooners, 3,000 barrels; cases of bottled oil by
steamers, 14,000.
   Mr. Charles S. Kelley, vice-president of board of trade, states that New Bedford has
inhabitants about 40,000; banking capital, $4,500,000; manufacturing capital (em-
ployed in 120 manufactories), $11,500,000; whalers of a tonnage of 28,291 tons, 75.
   It is the third city in the United States in point of cotton manufactures.




                                                                       C   17.


  PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION OF TAUNTON RIVER, MASSACHUSETTS.

                           ENGINEER OFFICE, U. S. ARMY,
                               Newport, R. I., November 26, 1886.
   GENERAL: In compliance with the instructions contained in Depart-
ment letter of the 28th October last, I have the honor to submit the
following report of the preliminary examination of Taunton River,
Massachusetts, provided for in the river and harbor act of Congress of
August 5, 1886, and made by me on the 19th instant.
Taunton River rises in Norfolk County, Mass., and empties into Mount
516     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Hope Bay, a name given to that part of Narragansett Bay which lies
mainly in Massachusetts. It is 44 miles in length, measured         ng its
course.
    It has been improved by the United States under appropriations made
in the years 1852-1884, amounting to $160,000.
    The object of the improvement is to deepen and widen the channel
leading to the city of Taunton, at the head of navigation, which re-
quires large quantities of coal, iron, clay, moldings, sand, and other
heavy articles for its manufactures, depending largely on water trans-
portation, so that vessels of 11 feet draught can reach the city at high
  water.
     In its original condition the channel was narrow and obstructed by
bowlders, and from Berkley Bridge to Taunton the depth was not, in
places, more than 5 feet at mean high water. A vessel of 30 tons bur-
den was as large as could go up to Taunton.
     The project under which the work is being carried on provides for a
channel 60 feet wide and 11 feet deep from Weir Bridge to the ship-
yard; a channel 80 feet wide (100 feet at the bends) and 11. feet deep
from the ship-yard down to, and through the Needles and Brigg's
  Shoal; thence to Berkley Bridge, a channel of the same width and 12
feet deep, and from Berkley Bridge, to the deep water at Dighton the
  channel was to be 100 feet wide and 12 feet deep. The depths are esti-
  mated from high water. The ledge which crosses the bottom of the
river at Peter's Point and the numerous bowlders which lay on the bot-
-tom and sides of the channel from Taunton to Dighton were to be re-
  moved.
     A plat of the river, showing the improved channel, was published in
  the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1884, page 606.
     With the exception that but 40 feet of the 60 feet of width could be
  dredged between the bridge at Weir and the ship-yard, on account of
interfering with private property, and that, on account of the hardness
  and depth of the material at the sides, the 80-foot channel was not in
  all cases dredged to its full width, the channel down to Berkley Bridge
  has been completed.
     The major part of the dredging below the bridge has been done, but
  this part of the channel still lacks in width at some places.
     The last appropriation for this work, $26,500, made by the act of July
5, 1884, is not yet expended. The entire work from Berkley Bridge
down, contemplated to be done, is now under contract, and the major
part of it, including the excavation of a channel through the ledge at
Peter's Point, to a depth of 12 feet at mean high water with a width of
100 feet, has been completed.
     There remains to be done under this contract the completion of the
deepening and widening of the channel below Berkley Bridge, by
dredging. The work is to be paid for by the cubic yard, measured in
  scows, and just how much of the funds available will remain after the
completion of the current contract can not now be stated with accuracy,
but unless the filling in of the channel since our last survey, especially
by the freshet of February, 1886, which broke the embankment of the
Old Colony Railroad opposite Wikamount, and shoaled the water there,
is greater than I anticipate, there will remain between $3,000 and $4,000
for additional work above the bridge.
     The following is the work which the safe navigation of the river re-
quires to be done above the bridge, and between it and Taunton :
   (1) The removal of Pioneer Rock,a large bowlder estimated to contain
from 60 to 70 tons.
             APPENDIX       C--REPORT OF MAJOR LIVERMORE.                          517
  (2) The further deepening and widening of the channel at several
points from just below Pioneer Rock to a point just below Three Mile
River, especially at Brigg's Shoal.
  (3) The cutting off of a sharp bend and enlargements of the channel
at the mouth of Three Mile River.
  (4) The enlargement of the channel at Burt's Turn and at the Fish
Place.
  (5) The removal of a deposit of sand in the channel at Weir,.the head
of navigation, caused by the freshet before referred to.
  (6) The removal of a few other bowlders in and near the channel be-
tween Berkley Bridge and Weir.
  My judgment is that the river is worthy of the further improvement
above referred to, and that the remainder of the current appropriation
that will be available at the completion of the present contract will
suffice to pay for it, but this can not be determined until a survey is
made, which I estimate will cost $300.
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                      GEORGE H.          ELLIOT,
                                                         Lieut. Col. of Engineers.
  Brig. Gen. J. C. DUANE,
       Chief of Engineers, U. S. A.



              SURVEY      OF TAUNTON RIVER, MASSACHUSETTS.

                                      ENGINEER OFFICE, U.           S.    ARMY,
                                     Newport, R. I., November 21, 1887.
   SIR: I have the honor to submit the following report on the survey
and further improvement of Taunton River, Massachusetts, together
with map of survey just completed and estimate of the cost of improve-
ment.
   This river rises in Norfolk County, Mass., and empties into Mount
Hope Bay, a name given to the northeast part of Narragansett Bay.
It is 44 miles in length, measured along its course.
   The survey was made between the 15th and 30th of October. Sound -
ings were carefully taken over the areas mentioned in Colonel Elliot's
report of the preliminary examination of the river.
   These soundings are referred to mean high water, the plane of refer-
ence used on the Taunton River.
   Borings were also taken over the areas surveyed.
   The map* of the survey herewith submitted shows the areas over
which the soundings and borings were taken, with the channel, as con-
templated in the approved project, in a broken and dotted line, and the
11-foot contour in a broken line. On figure 4, at the head of naviga-
tion, the 10-foot contour is also shown in a dotted line.
   The areas in which it is proposed to dredge are shaded, and are em-
braced between the 11-foot contour and the channel lines.
   There is also on the same sheet, on a smaller scale, a map of the river
from Weir to Somerset, on which the location of those portions of the
river surveyed are indicated.
   The river has been improved by the United States under appropri-
ations made in the years 1852-1884 amounting to $160,000.
   *   Omitted.   Printed in House Ex. Dec. No. 86, Fiftieth Congress, first session.
518     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The object of the improvement is to deepen and widen the channel
leading to the city of Taunton, at the head of navigation, which requires
large quanties of coal, iron, clay, molding-sand, and other heavy arti-
cles for its manufactures, depending largely on water transportation, so
that vessels of 11 feet draught can reach the city at high water.
   In its original condition the channel was narrow and obstructed by
bowlders, and from Berkley Bridge to Taunton the depth in places was
not more than 5 feet at high water. A vessel of 30 tons was as large as
could go up to Taunton.
   The project under which the work is being carried on provides for a
channel 60 feet wide and 11 feet deep from Weir Bridge to the ship-yard;
a channel 80 feet wide (100 feet at the bends) and 11 feet deep from
the ship-yard down to and through the Needles and Brigg's Shoal;
thence to Berkley Bridge a channel of the same width and 12 feet
deep, and from Berkley Bridge to the deep water at Dighton the chan-
nel was to be 100 feet wide and 12 feet deep. The depths are estimated
from high water.
   The ledge which crosses the bottom of the river at Peter's Point, and
the numerous bowlders which lay on the bottom and sides of the chan-
nel from Taunton to Dighton, were to be removed.
   A plat of the river showing the improved channel was published in
the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1884, page 606.
   Colonel Elliot states in his report of the preliminary examination of
this river November 26, 1886, as follows:
   With the exception that but 40 feet of the 60 feet of width could be dredged be-
tween the bridge at Weir and the ship-yard, on account of interfering with private
property, and that, on account of the hardness and depth of the material at the
sides, the 80-foot channel was not in all cases dredged to its full width, the chan-
nel down to Berkley Bridge has been completed.
   During the past season a small amount of ledge rock above the plane
of the bottom of the channel was uncovered by the dredging below
Peter's Point. After the removal of this the channel below Berkley
Bridge will be completed.
   The object of the further improvement of the river is the widening
of the 80-foot channel to its full dimensions where it is too narrow, the
removal of the bowlders obstructing the channel between Berkley
Bridge and Taunton, and the removal of the small amount of ledge rock
in the channel below Peter's Point.
    The greas in which it is proposed to dredge are shaded on the accom-
panying map, and are in the following localities:
    (1) At the points indicated from just below Piouieer Rock to about
300 feet above the mouth of Three-Mile River.
    (2) At Burt's Turn.
    (3) At Pond Rock's Shoal.*
    (4) In the upper part of the channel at Weir Village.
    (5) It is also proposed to remove the small amount of ledge rock un-
covered in dredging between Peter's Point and Dighton, and to remove
the bowlders in and near the channel between Berkley Bridge and
Weir.
    The estimated cost of completing the approved project is $14,051.
    The channel as projected is shown on the map by a broken and dotted
line. There is also shown, in the localities referred to above, a full line,
indicating a channel 60 feet wide in the narrowest places and 90 feet
wide at the bends, which it is estimated could be completed for $4,500.
                     APPENDIX                  C-REPORT                  OF MAJOR LIVERMORE.                                           519

    ESTIMATE           FOR FURTHER                 IMPROVEMENT              OF TAUNTON                      RIVER,   MASSACHUSETTS.

Dredging 12,534 cubic yards of material, including the removal of bowlders,
  at $1 per cubic yard -------------------------------                                  ----              ------ $12, 534
Removing ledge below Peter's Point, six days of vessel and crew, at $40 per
  day ...-------...--- ------......-----....----
                                  ......------..........--.-------...... ----..........------------........-.....     240
                                                                                                                                      12,774
Add 10 per cent. for contingencies, etc ....                              ...............................                              1, 277

          Total----------....------...... ......                             ....----....-----....--.............
                                                           ------....---......---------....------                        --........
                                                                                                                       -----          14, 051
                                                     COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

        Receipts at Taunton, Mass., via Taunton River, for year ending March 1, 1887.

                     Articles.                             Quantity.                                Articles.                     Quantity.


Flour.....       ..... .......         ....... barrels..       38. 500     Iron...... .....      ..   ........         tons.           31, 000
Grain ......................                   bushels..   1, 300, 000     Molding-sand..................do ..                         22, 000
Lumber .........              ............---     feet..   8, 700, 000     Clay......       ..-.. ......       ........ do ..          27, 000
Coal .... .-         .... .... ...........     tons..         228, 000     Other merchandise .............              do -.          23, 000
Cotton ....--..................... bales..                     26, 000


             Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                                               W.           R. LIVERMORE,
                                                                                                             Major of Engineers.
The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                          S. A.
                              APPENDIX             D.


IMPROVEMENT OF CONNECTICUT RIVER, MASSACHUSETTS AND CON-
  NECTICUT, AND OF RIVERS AND HARBORS ON LONG ISLAND SOUND,
  CONNECTICUT AND NEW YORK.



REPORT OF LIEUTENANT-COLONEL D. C. HOUSTON, CORPS OF ENGI-
NEERS, B3VT. COL., U. S. A., OFFICER IN CHARGE, FOR THE FISCAL
YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1J88, WITH OTHER DOCUMENTS RELATING
TO THE WORKS.
                           IMPROVEMENTS.

1. Thames River, Connecticut.             13.   Stamford Harbor, Connecticut.
2. New London Harbor, Connecticut.        14.   Port Chester Harbor, New York.
3. Connecticut River, Massachusetts and   15.   Mamaroneck Harbor, New York.
      Connecticut.                         16.   Echo Harbor, New Rochelle, New
4. Clinton Harbor, Connecticut.                   York.
5. New Haven Harbor, Connecticut.         17.   New Rochelle Harbor, New York.
6. Breakwater at New Haven, Connecti-     18.   East Chester Creek, New York.
      cut.                                 19.   Greenport Harbor, New York.
7. Milford Harbor, Connecticut.           20.   Port Jefferson Harbor, New York.
8. Housatonio River, Connecticut.         21.   Flushing Bay, New York.
9. Bridgeport Harbor, Connecticut.        22.   Removing sunken vessels or craft ob-
10. Black Rock Harbor, Connecticut.                structing or endangering naviga-
11. Southport Harbor, Connecticut.                 tion.
12. Norwalk Harbor, Connecticut.



                                           NEER OFFICE, U. S. ARMY,
                                                   New York, July 9, 1888.
  SIR: I have the honor to transmit herewith my annual reports upon
river and harbor works in my charge for the fiscal year ending June
30, 1888.
  For illustrations of these works I would respectfully refer to Annual
Reports for 1885, 1886, and 1887.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                          I). C. HOUSTON,
                                                        Lieut. Col. of Engineers.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS. U. S. A.




                                       D I.
            IMPROVEMENT OF THAMES RIVER, CONNECTICUT.
  This river is formed by the confluence of the Yantic and Shetucket
rivers at Norwich, Conn., and extends southward as a tidal stream 15
miles, to Long Island Sound. For 11 miles above its mouth the channel
is from 13 to 80 feet deep, averaging over 30 feet for the first 4 miles.
                                                                 521
522      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

For 3 miles below Norwich the available depth in 1829 was but 6 feet
at mean low water, where now there is over 10 feet. The work of im-
provement has been confined to a stretch of 34 miles below Norwich.
Histories of the improvements may be found in the Annual Reports of
the-Chief of Engineers, 1873, page 981, and 1879, Part I, page 331.
                         PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

    Prior to 1830 various attempts had been made by private parties or
corporations to deepen the channel of this river near Norwich; the
first ones were by excavation only, but subsequently stone piers were
constructed perpendicular to the channel at shoal spots.
    By act of March 2, 1829, $150 were appropriated "for making a
survey of the river Thames with a view to improve the navigation of
the same and the cost of such improvements."
    The survey was made in 1829 by Capt. Hartman Bache, Corps of
Engineers; at that time there were four old piers standing. In his
report pn the survey, dated February 20, 1830, and printed in House of
Representatives War Department Document, Nio. 125, Twenty-first
Congress, first session, Captain Bache submitted a project for making
a channel 60 feet wide, to be either 12 or 14 feet deep at high water (9
or 11 feet at low water) by excavation, by rebuilding one of the existing
piers, by adding to the other three wings extending up and down stream
converting them into T-walls and by building ten new piers extending
down-stream in curves. The piers were to be of riprap 3 feet wide on
top, with side slopes of 45 degrees; they were to be built to heights of
from 1a to ±3.  feet above highest tide, those farthest up stream being
the highest. The piers were estimated to require 43,436 cubic yards of
riprap, and the excavation for a 12-foot channel was placed at 27,895
cubic yards, for a 14-foot channel at 69,251 cubic yards. The cost of
whole work was estimated at $72,650. The project was adopted, and
under appropriations of 1836, 1837, and 1838-$40,000 in all-the piers
were built nearly as designed, with exception of two of the new piers
and one wing-wall, which were not constructed ; considerable dredging
was done, but no complete record of amount appears to have been kept.
At this time $500 were annually expended in river improvements by
the Merchants' Bank of Norwich, Conn., being a bonus required by
their charter. Work was stopped in 1839 by exhaustion of appropria-
tions.
   In 1866 a petition of citizens of Norwich, asking for an appropriation
for removing obstructions in the river Thames, was referred to the Chief
of Engineers and returned by him to the Secretary of War, with a re-
port describing the work done upon the river, recommending no further
work on the piers until their efficiency could be investigated satisfac-
torily, and stating :
   In conclusion it is considered that should the sum of $8,000 be appropriated for the
improvement of this river, to be applied during the next fiscal year, all will be ac-
complished that can be justifiably undertaken until a commission decides upon other
efficacious methods or systems of improvement.
  June 23, 1866, an appropriation of $10,000 was made for improving
the river, under which a survey was made and a project for dredging
to obtain a depth of 11 feet at low water (14 feet at high water) was
adopted. Under this and succeeding appropriations, up to 1878, this
channel was dredged and as far as possible maintained with a width of
100 feet. March 3, 1879, $12,000 was appropriated" for the improve-
ment of the Thames River to secure a 14-foot channel," and in accordance
therewith the project was modified to provide for a channel of that
depth. In 1882, upon recommendation of Major Barlow, approved by
             APPENDIX D--REPORT OF LIEUT.                                   COL. HOUSTON.                          52

the Board of Engineers, the project was further modified by providing
for the construction of five dikes or training-walls along the outer sides
of the channel curves, with the addition of low walls on the inner sides
should they be found necessary, the width of water-way between them
increasing from 300 feet (about the full width of the river) at Thames.
ville, 1 mile below Norwich, to 480 feet at the lower dike.
  The object of the training-walls was to utilize the effect of the tides
in keeping the channel open; they were to be built up to high-water
level, and to have an eggregate length of 13,800 feet. In the same year
the projected channel was increased to 200 feet. The improvement was
designed to extend over the first 3 miles below Norwich, and the esti-
mated cost was:
For the five dikes or training-walls.... .....................................                                 $82, 800
For dredging 200 feet wide and 14 feet deep ................................                                   125.280
        Total..--..--..........--    ..   .......----- .---.....    .....     ..... ..   ....     .........    208, 080
   Under this project, up to July 1, 1887, the three dikes farthest down-
stream had been built, and a fourth one about one-third completed;
132,969 cubic yards of dredging had been done.
   OPERATIONS           DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1888.
  The contract with John A. Bouker, of New York City, for delivering
riprap and building extension of the Rolling-Mill Dike, which was in
progress at the close of the last fiscal year, was completed December
21, 1887. Since July 1, 1887, 6,542 tons of stone were delivered, build-
ing 1,513 linear feet of the dike, besides slight repairs on the three lower
dikes. Under this contract, the total amount of stone delivered was
11,021 tons, and 1,883 linear feet of dike were built.
   June 29, 1887, a contract was entered into with the Hartford Dredg
ing Company, of Hartford, Conn., to dredge in the river at the rate of
12 cents per cubic yard. Work under this contract was begun July 18,
1887, and was completed October 6, 1887, channels 12 feet deep and 100
feet wide being made through the shoals just above and below the
Thamesville Rolling-Mills; 37,953 cubic yards of sand and gravel were
removed.
   A letter from Hon. Charles Russell, M. C., to the Secretary of War,
asking the " approximate cost of completing the 16 feet deep channel to
Allyn's Point and the 14 feet deep channel to Norwich," was referred to
the officer in charge for report, and the estimates asked for were sub-
mitted in May, 1888.
   Proposals for dredging were received May 29, 1888, and a contract
dated June 12, 1888, was entered into with the Hartford Dredging Com-
pany, of Hartford, Conn., at the rate of 19 cents per cubic yard. Work
under this contract will be begun early in July, 1888.
                   PRESENT CONDITION OF THE IMPROVEMENT.

  Of the five dikes provided for in the project, the three furthest down-
stream have been constructed at cost, as follows:
                                                                   Date of                                    Cost,   ex-
                                                                          of Length
                                                                   Location.Date                    oftons    elusive of
                         Location.                                 comple      Length.          of riprap.     supervi-
                                                                     tion.                                       sion.


                                                                                    Feet.
Mohegan 34 miles below Norwich. - --...... ............                1883         2,988       Pile-dike.     $23, 686. 00
Tradingiove, 24 miles below Norwich..................                  1882         2,370           17,207      21,113.05
Long Rock, 2 miles below Norwich......................                 1885         2, 800          11, 945     12, 781. 15
524               1EPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The next in order, the Rolling-Mill Dike, designed to be 4,350 feet long,
was begun in 1885. Up to date, 3,093 feet of the south end of this dike
have been built, leaving a gap of 390 feet at the sand-pier," and extend-
ing to about 250 feet south of the lower Rolling-Mill embankment. These
                                                                                                       1"
spaces are covered by old piers, which it is designed to dredge out and
throw over into the line of the Rolling-Mill Dike. The project contem-
plated extending the Rolling-Mill Dike about 600 feet north of the lower
Rolling-Mill embankment. Since its adoption the Lower Rolling-Mill
Company has dredged a channel in towards shore on the north side of
the embankment, which is now used as a landing. An opening of at
least 100 feet ought to be left for this channel, and it probably will not
be found expedient to continue the dike at all to the northward of the
embankment. The upper dike, one-half mile below Norwich, to be 1,050
feet long, has not been begun.
   The Trading Cove Dike has settled an average of about 1I feet over
its whole length, and the Mohegan Dike nearly a foot. Both ought to
be built up to high-water level.
   The channel is in nearly the same condition as at the time of the last
annual report. Mean low-water depth on the shoalest places is about
10.5 feet. Pending the completion of the dikes only enough dredging
has been done to maintain a navigable channel.
                                                 PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

  Under the contract now in force the Middle Ground at Norwich will be
dredged out as far as possible, and work will be done on the shoals where
necessary to maintain a navigable channel of 11 to 12 feet depth at low
water. With future appropriations it is proposed to complete the sys-
tem of dikes and to dredge the channel 200 feet wide and 14 feet deep, as
provided for in the project.
  To the estimates of cost of the projected improvements, $4,000 per
year should be added as necessary for maintenance of the channel.
  Appropriations for the improvement of the Thames River have been
made as follows :

      Date.                                                            Application.                                                            Amount.


Mar. 3,1821 Removal of obstructions placed during war of 1812...                                               ......       ..............            $150
Mar. 2,1829 Survey ..                 ------------------------------------------......                           .............                         150
July 4,1836    Piers and dredging ........................................................---                                              .       10, 000
Mar. 3,1857 ......--do ....................................................---------------------------------------------------............         20, 000
July 7, 1838 .....  do ..---------..-...--....----.................--------------------....-----------..............--................             10, 000
June 23, 1866 Dredging and survey. --..--.-                              ..--.....-      .....---           ....-.............                    *510,000
Mar. 3,1867 Dredging --...........                          ...      ............................................                                  72, 000
Mar. 3,1871 ....     o..........----------------------...-------------.-........-----------......--.......                                         15, 000
June 10,1872 ...... do ......--------------------------------------------....................................................-------               10, 000
June 18,1878 ...    do...---...------------------------------------------------------.                                                             10, 000
Mar. 3,1879 ...... do.             ..          ..------------------------------------------............                                            12, 000
June 14,1880 --     do---- ------------                         ----------------------------------                                              -- 22, 00..00
Mar. 3,1881 Dredging and training-walls................................................                                                           30, 000
Aug. 2,1882 Training-walls ..............................................................                                                        *35,000
July 5,1884 .-- _.-do .---                                                                                                                        25, 000
                                                                                                                                                 *.....................
Aug. 5,1886 Training-walls and dredging........................................---........--                                                     *22, 500
                               Total ...--................................---------------------------------------------------                   $304, 300

 *Appropriated for present project : These with $20,000 from previous appropriation (see Annual
Report for 1882, Part I, page 603), make total of $102,500 for present project.

  The Thames River is in the collection district of Now London. The nearest light-
house is at the mouth of the river, on the west shore. Forts Trumbull and Griswold
overlook the mouth of the river from either shore.
              APPENDIXI D---REPORT                                OF LIEUT. COL. HOUSTON.                                        525
                                                    Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available ........................         ...... ..........    $21,137.76
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ........................       $13, 136. 87
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts...........             6, 650, 00
                                                                                              S            -              19, 786. 87

July 1, 1888, balance available .....---..........   .... .....          ...........                                       1,350. 89
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ..........................                                                  50, 000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.............................                                        51, 350. 89
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..--------......                                          79, 600, 00
  Amount that can be profitable expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                               79, 600. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



Abstract of contracts for improving Thames River, Connecticut, in force during the fiscal
                               year ending June 30, 1888.


N ame and address of centractor.                     Date.                 Subject.               Price.            RImarks.


Joh n A. Bouker, Neow York City .. I Oct. 23, 1886                   Building        riprap       * $0. 98     Completed D ece m-
                                                                        dike.                                    ber 21, 1887.
The/ Hartford Dredging Company,                  June 29,1887        Dredging.                     t 0. 12     Completed     October
Dlartford, Conn.                                                                                                6, 1887.

                    * Per ton.                                                                t Per cubic yard.

Abstract of bids for dredging in Thames River, Connecticut, opened at Engineer Office, U. S.
                           Army, New York City, May '29, 1888.


                                                                                                                            Rate per
No.                                        Name and address of bidders.                                                      cubic
                                                                                                                             yard.


                                                                                                                             Cents.
  1   The Hartford Dredging Company, Hartford, Conn ............                           ............................            19
  2   Morris F. Brainard, New York City ...............................................                                            24
  3   W. H. Beard, Brooklyn, N. Y ......................................................                                           20

                            * Entered inte contract June 12, 1888; work not yet begun.




                     COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR THE CALENDAR YEAR 1886.

  From the best obtainable estimates the amount of freight received at Norwich was
250,000 tons, valued at $3,250,000; rather more than half the tonnage is coal, the rest
iron, lumber, and general merchandise. It is carried in vessels drawing 7 to 13 feet.




                                                                  D 2.

             IMPROVEMENT OF NEW LONDON HARBOR, CONNECTICUT.

   New London Harbor is that part of the Thames River which lies in
front of the city of New London, extending from Winthrop's Point to
Long Island Sound, a distance of about 3 miles. It has good anchor-
age-ground and a channel from 30 to 50 feet deep and a quarter of a
526      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

mile wide, extending up to Winthrop's Point. It is one of the best
harbors on the Atlantic Coast. No improvements of general importance
have ever been needed, and none were undertaken until 1880.

                           PROJECT FOR IMPROVEMENT.

   In the annual report for 1878 upon the improvement of Thames River
(see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1878, Part I, page
397), shortly after the completion of the New London Northern Railroad
Wharf, a petition of certain citizens of New London and Norwich was
presented, asking that the United States undertake the removal of a
shoal east of that wharf. The desired work was estimated to cost $6,800,
and it was recommended that it be included in the general project for
the improvement of the Thames River. The estimate was as follows:
To remove the shoal and bowlders to a depth of 16 feet at mean low water will
require the excavation of-
    125 cubic yards of bowlders, at $5 per yard ...... ...... ... ............ $625
   37,000 cubic yards of gravel and mud, at 15 cents per cubic yard -.......... 5,550
   Add for contingencies .....................................................................     25

                                                                                                 6, 00
   This shoal extended from the shore out about as far as the end of
the wharf. The part whose removal was contemplated was that part
lying south of a line running east from a point on the railroad wharf
500 feet from its outer end.
   The river and harbor act approved June 14, 1880, appropriated ":fo
the improvement of the Thames River, of which sum $2,500 shall be
expended in the removal of rocks and sand from New London Harbor,
$25,000." In 1881 and subsequently appropriations were made for im-
proving New London Harbor.
   The first work under this project, so inaugurated, was done in 1880.
It was found that the presence of bowlders made the dredging much
more expensive than had been counted on, and in the annual report fbr
1881 (see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1881, Part 1,
page 586) a new estimate was submitted, placing the cost from the be-
ginning at $24,000.
   In 1882 the project was modified so that the area to be dredged should
be that part of the shoal lying southwest of a line running about south-
east from a point on the wharf 600 feet from its outer end; the object
of this modification was to avoid as far as possible the large bowlders
that were found near the crest of the shoal and to keep the cost of the
work within the last estimate, while affording no less accommodation
to vessels using the wharf. The depth over this part of the shoal was
from 5 to 15 feet at mean low water.
   Nineteen thousand eight hundred dollars have been appropriated for
this work; 22,902 cubic yards of sand and stones and 564 cubic yards
of bowlders have been removed. The proportion of bowlders to mud
and gravel in the original estimate was about 1 to 300; the proportion
actually found has been about 1 to 41. The actual cost of dredging mud
and gravel has averaged 54,1 cents per cubic yard, and of removing
bowlders $8.51 per cubic yard. The bowlders have ranged in size from
one-fourth cubic yard to 5 cubic yards, many of them having to be
blasted.
  OPERATIONS DURING TIIE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1888.

  No work was done, the project being substantially completed,
                  APPENDIX D--REPORT                                          OF LIEUT.                   COL. HOUSTON.              527
   Appropriations for improving New London Harbor have been made
as follows, viz :


    Date.                                                                 Application.                                            Amount.


June    14,   1880 Dredging shoal east of railroad wharf .................................                                          *$2, 500
M ar.    3,   1881 ...... do ....................................................................                                     4, 300
Aug.     2,   1882 ...... do ..................................................................                                       9,000
July     5,                                     .........................................
              1884 ..... do ........................                                                                                  2, 000
Aug.     5,   1886 ..... do ...............................................................                                           2, 000

                             Total .................................                                 ..........................      19, 800

                                  * Part of appropriation for Thames River improvement.

  New London, tA port of entry for the collection district of New London, is situated
on the west bank of the Thames River, about 2i miles from Long Island So und; the
harbor is hoe mouth of the Thames River.
  New London light-house is located at the entrance to the harbor, on the west shore.
Forts Trumbull and Griswold command the harbor from either side.

                                                               Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available...                                 -........       ............................                     $204.33
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887... ............                                           .............................                    2.94

July 1, 1888, balance available..........................................                                                           201.39



                     COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR THE CALENDAR YEAR OF 1886.

  The freight received on the east side of the New London Northern Railroad Wharf,
the only landing benefited by the improvement, was 131,225 tons; shipped, 27,955
tons; total, 159,180 tons. It was carried as 359 cargoes in 9 steamers of aggregate
registered tonnage of 7,887.05; the maximum draught of these steamers was 15 feet.
  The general commerce of the harbor amounted to about 500,000 tons additional.




                                                                              D 3-

IMPROVEMENT OF THE CONNECTICUT RIVER, MASSACHUSETTS AND CON-
                         NECTICUT,

  This river rises in the northern part of New Hampshire, flows in a
general southerly course between the States of New Hampshire and
Vermont, crosses the States of Massachusetts and Connecticut, and
empties into Long Island Sound at Saybrook Point, Conn. It is divided
naturally into two parts, Hartford, Conn., at the head of navigation,
being the point of division, and appropriations by Congress have gen-
erally specified in which part the money appropriated was to be ex-
pended.
  The divisions are as follows:
  1. Above Hartford, Connecticut.-Embracing a length of about 66
miles, from Hartford, Conn., to Miller's Falls, Mass.
  2. Below Hartford, Connecticut.-Embracing a length of about 50
miles, from Hartford to Long Island Sound.
  By the river and harbor act of 1882 an examination or survey of the
Connecticut River, from Bellows Falls, Vt., to Pittsburgh, N. H., was
authorized. Bellows Falls is about 105 miles above Hartford, and Pitts-
528       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

burgh is 180 miles above Bellows Falls. A preliminary examination
was made, the report on which, printed in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1884, Part I, page 659, recommended no survey
and proposed no plan of improvement.
                     (1) ABOVE HARTFORD, CONNECTICUT.
   Miller's Falls, Mass., is at the head of possible navigation of the
Connecticut River. From this point down to flolyoke, Mass., a dis-
tance of about 32 miles, the river is susceptible of improvement, but
it can not be used by vessels now, on account of a dam and falls at
Holyoke, which entirely obstruct navigation. The lockage required to
lift boats from the lower to the upper levels at Holyoke is about 60 feet.
From Holyoke, Mass., to Enfield Falls, Conn., a distance of 18 miles,
there is a fair channel 4 to 5 feet deep at low water, which could be
made 8 feet deep. Enfield Falls, or Rapids, cover a stretch of river
about 5 miles long, having a fall of about 32 feet at low water. The
bed is rocky and very uneven, and the slope is not uniform, but consists
of a succession of long shallow reaches separated by rapids. From the
foot of Enfield Falls to Hartford, a distance of 11 miles, the river has a
broad sandy bed with a depth of 2 to 5 feet at low water. Under a
charter from the State of Connecticut granted in May, 1824, the Con-
necticut River Company has constructed a canal with locks around En-
field Falls. The locks are 80 feet long, 18 feet wide, and 41 feet deep.
The canal is chiefly used for water-power; the company collects toll
from vessels using it.
   Following is a list of places in this part of the river where work has
been done by the United States, with distances above the wagon-bridge
at Hartford:
                                         Miles.                                         Miles.
Barber's Landing.. ...............              4 j Strong's Island.....................    6
Farmington River.... ....--------..........---- 5   Scantic River   -...          .......   7
                                                                                            7....

                           PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

   No general project for the improvement of this part of the river is on
record as approved and adopted. All the work done has been under
special projects for expenditure of the several appropriations. It con-
sists of dredging at Barber's Landing in 1873, and construction of dikes
or wing-dams at Scantic River, Strong's Island, and Farmington River
in 1871, at Farmington River and Barber's Landing in 1878, and again
in 1880 and 1881.
   Plans and estimates for a larger canal around Enfield Falls were sub-
mitted in 1878 and modified in 1880 (see Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1881, Part I, page 566). They proposed a canal on the
east bank of the river, extending from above Enfield Falls down to the
mouth of the Hockanum River, opposite and just below Hartford, as the
best means of gaining an available depth of 8 feet from Hartford to and
around the falls. The canal levels were to be 10 feet deep at low water
and 120 feet wide at the water-line; the locks 200 feet long, 55 feet wide,
with 8 feet depth over the miter-sills at low water. The cost of the work
was estimated at $1,332,805. It was considered not advisable to begin
construction with a less sum than $450,000.
  OPERATIONS DURING              THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1888.

  No work was done. The available money is insufficient to begin any
general improvement in this part of the river.
               APPENDIX          D-REPORT                 OF       LIEUT.          COL.            HOUSTON.                       529

                            PRESENT CONDITION                  OF IMPROVEMENT.
  The wing-dams are all in fair condition; they are as follows:
  One at Scantic River, one at Strong's Island, one at the mouth of
Faimington River, two nearly opposite the mouth of Farmington River,
and two on the east bank opposite Barber's Landing.
  The available channel depth from Hartford to Scantific River is about
2 feet at ordinary summer stage of water; this part of the river is navi-
gable for freighting only when in freshet. No work has been done
above Scantic River; the depth from there up to the foot of Enfield
Falls is greater than from there down to Hartford.
                                       PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

  No work in the river above Hartford is contemplated during the en-
suing year. Should any injury to the wing-dams occur, the money avail-
able will be sufficient for repairs.
  Appropriations for improving the Connecticut River above Hartford
have been made as follows, viz :

               Date.                                           Application.                                                    Amount.


                               1
July 11, 1870..--..-----------............                                             (1                                        $20, 00
March 3, 1871.............I Dams at Scantic River, Strong's Island, Farmington I                                                  20, 000
June 10, 1872 ...    ............
                                - River, and Barber's Landing; repair of dams ; dredg-                                            25, 000
March 3, 1873................-    ing at Barber's Landing; surveys.                    I                                          20, 000
June 14, 1880 .................                                                                                                   15, 000
                                         Total .......----------...................
                                                                                  .............                                  100, 000



   Of these amounts the following balance is yet unexpended :
From appropriation of June 14, 1880, for "improving Connecticut River
   between Hartford and Holyoke"                                       .......                    ....    .                $9,133. 20
                                                                                                                           $........-.....-

                                               Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available .............--..                               ..-..--....-....
                                                                              _..                                 --   _- . $9, 133.20
July 1, 1888, balance available                  ..........                   ...........
                                                               .................                                               9, 133.20



                    COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR THE CALENDAR                                   YEAR             1886.
                                                  Beceipts by water.

                                              Articles.                                                                 Tons.    Value.

Coal.........   ................................   ...     ............................... 4, 000                                $22,000
Paper and paper stock.............--
                               -- - -..  .............................. . ...... ...          300                                 12,000
       Total... ..........--..         ---.......-...........                           4,300
                                                            ....--.....--.................                                        34,000


                                       Vessels employed in this traffic.

                                       Vessels.                                                          No. Tonnage. Draught.

                                                                                                                                 Feet.
Steam-tugs...............        ...      ...........          .      ................                        2           30             4
Scows...............----               ...
                                         .....
                            .. ..........-          .................
                                           ..............                                                     4          300             3

   In its present condition this part of the river is navigable only during freshets.
The amount of freight in 1886 was unusually small, owing to the river current break-
ing through behind one of the dikes and leaving the main channel shoal; the dike
has since been repaired.
            ENG 88-----4
530              REPORT OF THE CHIEF                              OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                   (2)      BELOW HARTFORD,                  CONNECTICUT.

   The Connecticut River below Hartford is a large stream, for the first
21 miles flowing in a winding course, mostly through alluvial meadows,
which are overflowed at high water, and which consist of a light, sandy
soil, easily undermined. For the remaining 29 miles to Long Island
Sound, at Saybrook Point, the course is straighter, the banks more per-
manent and generally harder.
   A gauge has been established at Hartford, whose zero is the lowest
stage that the water is known to have reached from natural causes;
closing the gates at the Holyoke Dam in time of drought has caused
the water to fall lower. The usual low-water stage of the river in sum-
mer is about 1 foot on this gauge. Spring freshets ordinarily rise to 20
feet; the highest recorded stage of water is 29 feet.
   The average tide at Saybrook is 3N feet ; at Hartford it is about 1 foot,
though when the water stands above 5 feet on the Hartford gauge the
tide there is not perceptible. The slope of the river from Hartford to
Saybrook averages .0458 foot per mile. The bed of the river, through
the alluvial meadows within 10 miles of Hartford, is constantly chang-
ing, from the undermining of the banks. It is said that in places it has
changed its position a half mile. The bars in this part of the river,
after being dredged, form again during freshets and ice-jams, so that
some of them require dredging annually; others less frequently. This
part of the river was worked upon by corporations and private parties
at various times between 1800 and 1870. Several small stone piers, to
deepen the channel at shoal places, were built in this way. Some of
these are covered by new banks, the channel has shifted to the opposite
side of others, and others still have been dredged out, because they had
come to be obstructions. The depth sought by these works was 6 feet
feet at low water.
   The following list gives the names of the several places on the river
below Hartford where work has been done by the United States, with
their distances by course of channel below the Hartford Wagon Bridge:

                         Locality.                       Miles.                        Locality.                     Miles.

Hartford Bar.............................                             Pistol Point Bar .........................          15
Clay Banks Bar..................       .....                 2    I   Mouse Island Bar .......................            20
Pratt's Ferry or Naubuc Bar --...---....... I                5        Haddam Island Bar ................         .        30
Press Barn Bar..............-.......                         6        Cluster Rock.............--...........   ..         38
Glastenbury  Bar.--....
       Dividen
            ar-.......................          --   ]     1
                                                             9        Saybrook
                                                                      S-brook
                                                                               Bar (at
                                                                                     -r
                                                                                        mouth)...-..-.........
                                                                                   (atmout.~...1..    ....                 50
                                                                                                               _......-.-- 50
Dividend Bar.............................                  12



                                            PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

   By act of July 4, 1836, Congress appropriated $20,000 " for improve-
ing the harbor at Saybrook, by removing the bar at the mouth of the
Connecticut River." Under this appropriation a survey was made by
Capt. W. H. Swift, U. S. Engineer Corps. In his report on this survey,
dated January 31, 1837, and printed in House Ex. Doc. No. 252, Twenty-
fifth Congress, Captain Swift submits a project for deepening the west
chanuel over Saybrook Bar, dredging a cut 500 feet wide and 12 feet
f0epp at nean low water, at an estimated cost of $54,380.50 the esti-
inmted cost per cnlbig yard for dredging ard upning was SG ce ts.
The available depth over the bar before dvedging was 7 feet at meni
l0w wate. 8 CPta,4 Swift's project way apnrg~Y, arid work was beggy
                APPENDIX               D-REPORT               OF LIEUT.                    COL. HOUSTON.                                 531

in May, 1838, under contract with Randall, Haskell & Holmes, at the
rate of 624 cents per cubic yard, measured in scows; dredging was con-
tinued until the fall of 1840, when the appropriation was exhausted;
26,984 cubic yards of sand and stones had been removed, making a
channel 1,500 feet long, 50 feet wide and from 11 to 12 feet deep. This
channel was nearly destroyed by storms and freshets in the following
winter and spring. March 1, 1843, $3,471.57 was appropriated to pay
a balance due the contractors.
   No further work was done upon the river until 1867. By act of Con-
gress, approved March 2, 1867, a survey of the river was ordered, which
was made in the following season, and which embraced all the princi-
pal bars and obstructions between Hartford and Long Island Sound.
With the report on this survey, dated January 11, 1868, and printed on
page 754 et seq. of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1868, was presented a project for improving this part of the river; it
proposed dredging at Hartford, Clay Banks, Pratt's Ferry, Glastenbury,
and Pistol Point, to make channels 8 feet deep at low water and 100 feet
wide, dredging at Saybrook Barfto make a channel 81 feet deep and 200
feet wide, piling for shore protection at Hartford and Wethersfield, and
the romoval of Chester Rock, at a total estimated cost of $70,000; an
estimate of $10,000 for annual maintenance was submitted. All the
dredging done up to 1880 was in accordance with this project, estimated
to make 9 to 94 feet depth instead of 8 feet, and also to include Press
Barn, Dividend, and Mouse Island bars ; the piling at Hartford was built
in 1871, and the removal of Chester Rock was begun in the same year,
but abandoned by the contractor soon after beginning.
   January 22, 1873, a project for building three jetties at Saybrook and
for dredging was approved by the Secretary of War; the jetties were
to be of a double row of piles 20 feet apart, filled with stone to a height
of 8 feet above low water; the dredging was to be 9 feet deep and 400
feet wide; the estimated cost was-
Dredging ..............--....--......-----------..       ......------------...-- --.......-------........--------....---.....--.      $17, 850
Jetties.-----..---............ ..........---..        ......------------.-----.......----....-...------......------......-----....    318, 760
              ...... ------..........------------
         Total------                 ....---......-                         ---...--- ---------......-----......----....--            336, 610
   Before work on the jetties was begun the plan of construction was
modified to one for building them of riprap stone, triangular cross-sec-
tion, rising to level of highest water i. e., about 5 feet above mean low
water, this plan being much more economical than the previous one.
   The jetties were begun in 1873, and two of them were completed in
1881; the third has not been built and may not be needed; the west
jetty has since been extended, and both have been repaired and strength-
ened.
   In 1880 a project was adopted for permanent works of improvement
at six of the worst bars (see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1880, Part I, page 396 et. seq.).
   This project provided for riprap wing-dams, mattress shore-protection
and rectification of the banks at the following places, viz:

                     Locality.                       Amount.                                 Locality.                                Amount.

Hartford Bar ......... .....       ..........        $33, 464        Glastonbury Bar-...............---                       .....    $114, 922
Clay Banks Bar -...-..-      .................        69,116         I)ividend Bar ..........................                             7,110
Pratt's Ferry or Naubuc Bar ...........                64, 735
Press Barn Bar ........................                41, 140                   .........................
                                                                             Total--                                                    330, 487
532     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

With dredging, to make and maintain a permanent channel. The proj-
ect did not provide for extension and repair of the Saybrook jetties,
nor did the estimate include any amount for annual dredging to main-
tain channels, nor for dredging between the jetties at Saybrook, nor for
any work whatever at Pistol Point, Mouse Island, and Haddam Island
bars, where dredging has since been required; all of these have con-
sumed a large part of the appropriations made since. It is evident,
therefore, that the contemplated works could not now be completed
with the unappropriated balance of the estimate.
   Under this project, extended as above, up to the close of the last
fiscal year, a training-wall of riprap, 3,689 feet long, has been built at
Hartford Bar (instead of the proposed wing-dam), and a riprap wing-
dam, 5,300 feet long, had been built at Glastonbury Bar, both to the
height of 3 feet above low water; part of the Hartford training-wall
was subsequently built to 4 feet above low water; the west jetty at Say-
brook had been extended to the 16-foot curve, the east jetty to the 12-
foot curve, and a channel 120 feet wide and 12 feet deep at mean low
water had been dredged between them, besides maintaining the required
depth in the upper half of this part of the river by annual dredging at
a cost of from $5,000 to $10,000 each year.
   Since the project of 1880 was adopted, $161,250 have been appro-
priated for this part of the river, including $5,000 ordered by the ap-
propriation act to be expended in Salmon River, a tributary 33 miles
below Hartford. Of this amount only $40,715 have been applied to
that part of the improvement provided for in the partial estimate of
$330,487.
   In a letter to the Chief of Engineers, dated December 21, 1887, it was
recommended that ' future operations be confined to completing the
jetties at the mouth of the river to a height of 5 feet above high
water and a top width of 6 feet; widening the channel between the
jetties to 400 feet width with a depth of 12 feet at mean low water, and
annual dredging to maintain the channel from Hartford to Long Island
Sound," at an estimated cost as follows :
For completing jetties- ....-.. -.. --...
                                      --......
                                           .. ..         ...... ......... $60, 000
                                                        _...
                                                       .....
For dredging between jetties.. .............................. ........... 20,000
                                                                       80,000
For average annual maintenance of channel from Hartford to Long Island
                                                       - ---------.    10, 000
  Sound.....---............................--------------------------.......
  The seasons for this change of project are fully given in the letter
referred to, a copy of which is appended to this report. The recommen-
dations made therein were approved by the Chief of Engineers, Decem-
ber 22, 1887.
  OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE                      30, 1888.
   The contract with James V. Luce, of Niantic, Conn., for building up
the jetties at Saybrook, which was in progress at the time of the last
Annual Report, was extended to August 31, 1887, and was completed
August 27; 1,080 tons of granite were delivered in the west jetty after
July 1, and during the previous fiscal year 6,289 tons had been placed
in the east jetty and 540 tons in the west jetty, making a total of 7,909
tons delivered under the contract. The east jetty was built up to ap-
proximately 2 feet above high water and several weak places in the
west jetty were repaired.
   The contract with the Frank Pidgeon Dredging Company, of New
York City, for dredging on the bars between Hartford and Haddam
Island, which was in progress at the beginning of the fiscal year, was
                        APPENDIX D-REPORT                                                          OF LIEUT. COL. HOUSTON.                                                       533
completed August 27, 1887, 26,254 cubic yards of sand having been
dredged from the channels since July 1; the contract price was 11.7
cents per cubic yard. In September a small shoal had formed again in
Hartford Bar, and with the approval of the Chief of Engineers this
was dredged out in October by Mr. C. C. Goodrich, of Hartford, Conn.,
5,220 cubic yards being removed,.at the same price as the contract work
preceding.
  Following is a statement of the dredging done in the Connecticut
River below Hartford during the calendar year of 1887:
                                                                                                    S_
                                                                                                     o
                                                                                                              &°By
                                                                                                              a
                                                                                                                  Frank Pidgeon
                                                                                                                 Dredging
                                                                                                                                                                 "
                                                                                                                                              Com-          C


                                                                                                      cr      a              pany.                          C 44C
                                          Bar at-                                                                     -                                               a         Total.
                                                                                                              o0       Before             After             O         u
                                                                                                              Co      June 30.           June 30.


Hartford..........................................                                                           5, 588          11, 240        10,056           5,220                32,104
Clay Banks .....................                                              ..................                              3, 852         1, 848              ..                5,700
Naubuc ............                             .........................................                                                    3, 461 ..........                     3, 461
Press Barn .                      ...         .         ..................                 ...............                                    2, 449 ...........                   2,449
Glastonbury ........................                                                 ...-. .---.
                                                                              .........                                --        -            5, 079    .       ...               5, 079
Dividend..... .....................                                          ............... .                        ...     3,625              780            ....              4,405
Pistol Point..............          ...........                                 ...   .      ......                                           2, 581   ..........                 4, 717

           Total ...........               .......               ................
                                                              .......                                      7, 724            18,717         26, 254             5, 220            57, 915


   In September, 1887, an examination of the river from Hartford to
Dividend Bar was made, which showed that on the whole the condi-
tion of the bars is slightly better now than at the time of the last sur-
vey, 1879, and that since 1879 the erosion of the caving banks has aver-
aged from 18 to 30 feet per year-about the same as the rate between
1867 and 1879.
   February 4, 1888, Mr. C. C. Goodrich, of Hartford, Conn., submitted
an offer for dredging in the river below Hartford during the season of
1888, at the rate of 10 cents per cubic yard for river work and for work
on Saybrook Bar at a rate per day equal to the average per diem earn-
ing in the river. This offer, being lower than any contract prices ever
obtained for the same work, was forwarded with recommendation to
the Chief of Engineers, and approved by him February 15, 1888, the
work to be done as an open market transaction, that method being
most economical and advantageous to the Govrrnment. Work under
this arrangement began June 13, and up to the close of the fiscal year
the following amounts had been dredged:
                                                                                                                                                                          Cubic yards.
Clay Banks Bar...... .........................                                                                                --....................                  ....---    3, 310
Hartford Bar .............................................................                                                                                                      10,995
Glastonbury Bar ........................                          ..... .... .                                              ..... .      .... .. ....... ...
                                                                                                                                        .....                                       825
               Total.....................                                                ...                    ............
                                                                                                              ....
                                                                                                             .......                                         15,130
                                                                                                                                             .... ................
Making channels of 9 feet depth through those bars. Work is still in
progress at Hartford and Glastonbury.
  The total amount of dredging done during the past fiscal year is
46,604 cubic yards.
                                          PRESENT                       CONDITION OF IMPROVEMENT.
  At the close of the fiscal year dredging upon the shoals formed dur-
ing winter and spring had been begun. The spring freshets of 1888,
though not unusually high, were of long duration, and left the bars
with depths of 5 to 8 feet at low water. Under an arrangement now
in force a channel 9 feet deep has been cut through Clay Banks Bar
and partly through Hartford and Glastonbury bars.
534         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, UI. S. ARMY.

  The channel between the Saybrook jetties, dredged in 1884, has
shoaled about a foot at either end and has narrowed slightly.
   The Hartford Dike is in good condition. It may be expedient in the
future to build it higher, in order to increase the scour on the bar. The
Glastonbury Dike, built on a convex bank, is now nearly covered by
the advance of the bank.
  Both jetties at Saybrook are in fair condition. They should be built
up to the dimensions provided for in the project to make them perma-
nent.
  The lengths of the dikes and jetties are as follows:
                                                                                                                                  Feet.
Hartford Dike ...............................................----- ---...............                      ------ 3, 968
Glastonbury Dike ......----....................--....-------..--------......------..------....----.... --- ...---. 5,300
Saybrook:
    West jetty.... ......         ...... ......      ...     ... ..........        ......         .... .... .... 2,550
    East jetty ..................          ...... ...... ...... ......-        -      .... ......      .... ......2,316
                                          PROPOSED               OPERATIONS.

  With the money now available, the channels which filled during the
spring freshets will be dredged out, and if the funds are sufficient the
channel between the Saybrook jetties will be widened.
  The object of first importance in the improvement of this river is the
maintenance of a depth of at least 9 feet at low water through such
shoals as form in spring freshets, and so much of future appropriations
as is necessary should be applied to this work.                                               It is proposed to con-
fine future operations to such annual dredging, to building up the jet-
ties at Saybrook, and to dredging between them, in accordance with the
approved project. The estimated cost of this work is:
                                                                                          $80, 000
                                                 -----........ ---....----...... .----..---....
Jetties and channel at Saybrook-.....---......----......
Annual maintenance of channels ...... ..            ...... .... ...... .......... ....     10, 000
  Ninety thousand dollars can be profitably expended upon this work
during the next fiscal year.
  Appropriations for the improvement of the Connecticut River below
Hartford have been made as follows:
    Date.                                                  Application.                                                    Amount.


July   4,1836    Dredging at Saybrook Bar....----------------------------------------                                         $20, 000. 00
Mar.   3, 1839   Dredging at Saybrook Bar (the unexpended balance of 1836 was re-appro-
                  priated).
Mar. 1,1843      Balance due contractors under previous appropriation.----...........----.....-------..----.                    3, 471. 57
Mar. 2, 1867     Survey ...- ....       ..................                  ................            .............-          3, 995. 22
July 11,1870     Dredging at Pratt's Ferry, Pistol Point, Mouse Island ; piling at Hartford.                                   20, 000.00
Mar. 3,1871      Dredging at Hartford, Clay Banks, Pier I, Pier J, Pratt's Ferry, Glaston-
                   bury, Pistol Point, and Chester Rock..---.-----------.---..-----------.                                     35, 000.00
June 10, 1872    Dredging at Pratt's.Ferry and Pistol Point; Saybrook Jetty..............                                      40, 000. 00
Mar. 3,18:3      Dredging at Hartford, Pratt's Ferry, Glastonbury; Saybrook Jetty .......                                      20, 000. 00
June 23, 1874    Dredging at Hartford, Pratt's Ferry, Saybrook; Saybrook jetties .........                                     20, 000. 00
Mar. 3, 1875     Dredging at Hartford, Pratt's Ferry, Glastonbury; Saybrook jetties .....                                      20, 000. 00
Aug. 14, 1876    Dredging at Hartford, Pratt's Ferry, Glastonbury; Saybrook jetties; Sal-
                  mon River dredging .................................-----------------------------------..---.......--......  20, 000.00
         1878    Compensation for previous dredging--               .--......---------............................              4, 203.00
June 18, 1878    Saybrook jetties; survey from Hartford to Rocky Hill ....................                                     30, 000. 00
Mar. 3,1879      Dredging at Hartford, Press Barn, Glastonbury _..........................                                     10, 000.00
June 14, 1880    Dredging at Hartford and Glastonbury ; Saybrook jetties ................                                      10. 000. 00
Mar. 3,1881      Dredging at Hartford, Pratt's Ferry, Glastonbury; Glastonbury wing-dam
                  and Saybrook jetties ......                   ...........                  ..........                .....   30, 000. 00
Aug.   2,1882    Dredging at Hartford, Clay Banks, Pratt's Ferry, Press Barn Glaston-
                  bury, Dividend, Pistol Point, and Salmon River; Hartford Dike ......                                         45, 000. 00
July   5,1884    Dredging at Hartford, Clay Banks, Pratt's Ferry, Press Barn, Glaston-
                  bury, Dividend, Pistol Point, Mouse Island, and between Saybrook jet-
                  ties; extending west jetty at Saybrook ...                                                                   35, 000.03
Aug.   5, 1886   Dredging at Hartford, Clay Banks, Naubuc, Press Barn Glastonbury,
                  Dividend, Pistol Point, and Haddam Island; repair of Hartford Dike
                  and Saybrook jetties --- ... ........    ...    ... -. . .. . ..........                                   26, 250. 00
Aug. 5,1887      Compensation for previous dredging--.............-.......................                                    4, 745. 43
                       Total .....--...............             ........................         ............      ....     397, 665.22
                    APPENDIX                       D-REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. HOUSTON.                                                                                          535
  The Connecticut River is in the collection district of Hartford. By course of river,
the distance from Holyoke, Mass., to Hartford, Conn., is about 34 miles, and from
Hartford to Long Island Sound about 50 miles. There is a light-house on Saybrook
Point, on the west shore of the river at its mouth, and another at the end of the'west
jetty, besides which there are three small beacon lights in the lower part of the river
which are maintained by the United States.
  Fort Trumbull, New London Harbor, Connecticut, about 16 miles east from Say-
brook.Point, is the nearest work of defense.

                                   Money statement.
                                     ----
July 1, 1887, amount available ----............       .       ..-- -- . ......-      ..--.   $21, 222. 80
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887-...... ....-...- ........                 $7, 311. 76
                                       ..................-------
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities----                             ...---....  1,679.67
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts- ...........                   8, 487. 00
                                                                                                                                                           -         17,478. 43

July 1, 1888, balance available.. ........................................                                                                                            3,744.37
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                                                                                              10, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...................----                                                                                         13, 744. 37
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project------....... 80,000.00
  Amount required for annual maintenance of channels..............            10, 000. 00
  SAmountthat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 90, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.

Abstracts of contracts for improving the Connecticut River, in force during the fiscal year
                                 ending June 30, 1888.

Name and address of
    contractors.                                 Date.                                 Subject.                     .           Price.                 Remarks.


James V. Luce, Nian-                        Oct. 27,1886.              Increasing height of Say-                                 $1.14       Contract completed under
  tic, Conn.                                                             brook jetties with rip-                                              extension, August 27,
                                                          rap granite.                                                              11        1887.
The Frank P id-g eo n                      Apr. 23,1887. Dredging between Hart-I t                                                      i/   Contract completed Au
Dredging Company,                                        ford and Haddam Island.J                                                            gust 27, 1887.
New York City.                                     I I                           i

   * Per ton.                                                                                                                                     t Per cubic yard.


                       COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR THE CALENDAR YEAR OF 1886.
                                                                   Receipts and shipments.

                                                                                                                                                    Tons.                 Value.


Coal .....................................                                                                                                           275, 000            $1, 375, 000
Stone -...--..-          ......            ........                      ................................                                            365, 000             2, 337, 000
Miscellaneous                         .................................................                                                              355, 214            60, 827, 740
          Total....................                            .....                ..........                      ...............                  995, 214            64, 539, 740
                                                                                                                                              i                 i




                                                          Vessels employed in above traic.
                                                                       [Draught, 6 to 11 feet.]

                                                                                                                                                   Number.               Tonnage.

Owned in district:
    Steamers -----...        -------------......                                                                                                      18                       3,887
    Sail vessels .            .           .. .............................                                              ............                  56                       6, 068
    Barges... -----------------------------------------......                                                                          ...            21                       4, 133
Not owned in district: Vessels of all kinds ................................                                                                          95                      14, 088
          Total......             .       .---------                   ...                .        .        . ...       ..     ...........           190                      28,176
                                                                  -                           -~ -I                                                                 i-
536           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

LETTER OF                LIEUTENANT-COLONEL D. C. HOUSTON,                                            CORPS OF ENGI-
                                        NEERS.

                                                    ENGINEER             OFFICE, U.                   S.   ARMY,
                                       New York, December 21, 1887.
  SIR: In my last annual report on the improvement of the Connecti-
cut River below Hartford I state that-
   It seems evident from experience that the completion of the works proposed in
1880 for the improvement of the river from Hartford to Middletown will not obviate
the necessity for annual dredging, and it is not therefore considered advisable to con-
tinue that project, except perhaps by shore protection, which may reduce the amount
of dredging needed. It is proposed to confine future operations to annual dredging,
strengthening the jetties at the mouth of the river, and shore protection between
Hartford and Middletown. An estimate for completing the jetties and shore protec-
tion will be submitted as soon as practicable. Until that is done the estimate for
completion of existing project will be the same as in the last annual report.
   In 1867 a survey of the Connecticut River below Hartford was made
by Mr. Theo. G. Ellis, civil engineer, under my direction, and I sub-
mitted a report on this survey, dated January 11, 1868. (Annual Re-
port of the Chief of Engineers for 1868, page 754.)
   This report contained an estimate of $70,000 for improving the river
between Hartford and Middletown, and including $9,000 for deepening
the bar at the mouth of the river. This was principally for dredging
and removing obstructions. An estimate of $10,000 for annual main-
tenaince was also submitted. The results of work done in the river be-
tween Hartford and Middletown since work was commenced, in 1871,
confirm the views I expressed in my report, that the most satisfactory
and economical method of maintaining the channel in this part of the
rive is by periodical dredging.
   There has actually been expended in dredging between Hartford and
Middletown from 1871 to 1887, including $2,606.80 expended by private
parties--
In   1871 -...                 .........--..                                               --
                                        ----.............----..................--------...............        $23,588.59
For the sixteen years following.. ----                    . ..       .          -----.            93, 407.50

         Total ..---..........--          ......   ......---....--............   ............--....           116,996.09

   The average annual expenditure since 1871 being $5,838.
   In 1878 and 1879 a survey was made, under direction of General G.
K. Warren, of the river from Hartford to Rocky Hill, with a view of
planning a system of permanent improvement. The system proposed
(Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1880, page 396) consisted
of bank protection and wing-dams at an estimated cost of $330,487, as
follows :
Hartford Bar.... ............... $33, 464                       Glastonbury Bar................ 114, 922
Clay Banks Bar .---...----.......-------- 69, 116               Dividend Bar...................   7,110
Pratt's Ferry (or Naubuc) Bar ..                   64, 735
Press Barn Bar----------------.................    41,140              Total .....................                 330,487
  No dredging is included.
  The only work done under this project is a wing-dam at Glastonbury
near the convex bank, 4,950 feet in length, at a cost of $11,374.60, and
a dike at Hartford near the concave bank, 3,698 feet long, at a cost of
$27,018.20. The location of these works is shown in sketch, page 636,
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1885. The project at Glas-
tonbury contemplated in addition protection on the opposite bank, with-
out which no benefit could be expected, but at Hartford the project has
been completed and extended, and the work appears to be as well
located as possible to produce the effects anticipated. It is near the
concave bank, and the channel is close to it. Favorable results are to
                        APPENDIX                           D--REPORT                        OF LIEUT.                    COL. HOUSTON.                        537
be expected here, if at any point. This work was commenced in the
fall of 1882 and completed in 1883 to 3 feet above low water; it was
raised to 4 feet above low water for about two-thirds of its length in
1886.
   The annual quantity and cost of dredging in the past four years at this
locality has been as follows:

                                                                                                                                             Number of
                                                                                                                                            cubic yards     Cost.
                                                                                                                                              dredged.


1884. ................................                                   .....     .          ...
                                                                                           .....         ............                ....       30,028     $3,002.80
1885..........................................................................                                                                  17, 742     1, 774. 20
1886...............                            .........                  .....   .....        .... ........            ..........              22,225      2,222.50
1887.............................................................                                                     ............              32,104      3, 756.17

            Average per annum ................                                    ..........................................                                2, 688. 92


  The annual average amount and cost of dredging actually done at this
locality for eleven years previous to 1884 was as follows:
Average annual amount ....                                            .........        ...............                   ......       cubic yards..           8, 248
Average annual cost .--.........----------..----.--..---..------...--..
                                                                ........--.......---..--..--....                                                          $1,515. 28
   While this increased amount is not caused by the dike, the result
shows that a large amount of dredging is still necessary every year to
meet the requirements of navigation. Similar results are to be expected
at the other points when wing-dams and shore protections have been
designed.
   During 1887 dredging was done three different times at Hartford,
owing to frequent freshets.
   I feel satisfied that no system of perrmanent improvements can be
constructed at a reasonable cost which would entirely obviate the neces-
sity of annual dredging or reduce the amount sufficiently to warrant
the expenditure. The reasons for this may be found in the followipg
facts:
   The portion of the river under consideration winds through bottom
lands from Hartford to Rocky Hill, a distance of 11 miles by river and
73 miles in a straight line. The bed is continually changing by erosion
of the concave banks and accretions on the convex banks. The extreme
variation in the water level at Hartford is about 30 feet, with correspond-
ing variation in discharge from 5,000 cubic feet per second to 211,000
cubic feet per second. The water falls rapidly after freshets, and the
low water discharge is not sufficient to cut out such a channel as is
needed for purposes of navigation. At present prices for dredging the
channel can be maintained at a moderate cost.
   I would therefore recommend that future operations be confined to
completing the jetties at the mouth of the river to a height of 5 feet
above high water and a top width of 6 feet; widening the channel be-
tween the jetties to 400 feet, with a depth of 12 feet at mean low water,
and annual dredging to maintain the channel from Hartford to Long
Island Sound.
   The channel between the jetties was excavated in 1884 and 1885 to a
depth of 12 feet below mean low water for a width of 120 feet, increas-
ing the navigable depth about 5 feet. A slight shoaling has since oc-
curred.
   The amount required for this work is estimated as follows :
Completing jetties......-....    ......... .................................                   $60, 000
Dredging channel between them.... ................                            .--.--      ..    20, 000
      Total .......................... ..........              ......        ............. ... 80,000
538    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Average annual amount for maintenance of channel from Hartford to
Long Island Sound, $10,000.
  Should these recommendations be approved, it is proposed to modify
the project accordingly.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                D. C. HousToN,
                                             Lieut. Col. of Engineers.
The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.          S.   A.



                           [First indorsement. ]

                            OFFICE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,
                                                         U. S. ARMY,
                                                        December 22, 1887.
  Respectfully returned, approved.
  After such record as may be necessary has been made this paper will
be returned to this office.
  By command of Brigadier-General Duane.
                                                          JAS. C. POST,
                                                       Major of Engineers.

                          [Second indorsement.]

                               ENGINEER OFFICE, U.          S. ARMY,
                                        New Yhork, December 27, 1887.
  Respectfully returned to the Chief of Engineers, the necessary record
having been made.
                                                      D. C. HOUsTON,
                                                   Lieut. Col. of Engineers.


                                   D 4.
         IMPROVEMENT OF CLINTON HARBOR, CONNECTICUT.

   Clinton Harbor is on the north shore of Long Island Sound, about 10
miles west of the mouth of the Connecticut River. It consists of an
open, shallow bay, and of the mouth of the Hammonasset River, a small
stream which flows easterly in front of the town wharves and empties
into the bay. For three-fourths of a mile above its mouth the river is
separated from the bay by a narrow strip of sand and marsh. About
1840 a breach was made through this strip a half mile above the mouth
of the river, which diverted a considerable part of the tidal flow, and
since then two shoals have formed, one just inside the river's mouth,
with 4.5 feet of water, and one out in the bay, shortly before reaching
deep water in the sound, with a depth of 4 feet. It is said that for-
merly there were depths of from 8 to 12 feet on both these bars, and that
shoaling occurred soon after the breach was made.
                    PROJECT FOR IMPROVEMENT.

  By act approved March 3, 1881, Congress authorized a survey of the
harbor, which was made the same year. In his report on the survey,
              APPENDIX               D-REPORT OF LIEUT.                                         COL. HOUSTON.             539
dated January 17, 1882, and printed in the Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1882, Part                             1,
                                page 630, Colonel Barlow, U. S. Engi-
neers, submitted a project for restoring the original condition of the
channel by closing the breach, and by subsequently, should the in-
creased tidal current not produce the deepening desired, dredging
through the shoals, making a channel 100 feet wide and 6 feet deep at
mean low water.
  The cost of a dike to close the breach was estimated at $3,000, and
the cost of the whole project, including the dredging, at $10,000.

  OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1888.

  Nothing was done; the available funds were not sufficient for con-
tinuing the improvement.
                          PRESENT CONDITION OF IMPROVEMENT.

   The dike was built in 1883, using 1,574 tons of riprap granite, and
costing, exclusive of superintendence, $2,219.34.   An examination made
in 1885 showed that it had settled about 2 feet and would require 500
tons of stone to build it up to full height; also that no material change
in the channel had taken place since the dike was built. It seems es-
tablished that the increase of tidal flow will not of itself deepen the
channel as desired.
                                          PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

  It is proposed to complete the project by dredging channels 100 feet
wide and 6 feet deep at mean low water through the two shoals in the
harbor when the estimated funds, $7,000, are appropriated.
  The only appropriation made for improvement of this harbor is the
one of $3,000 in 1882, expended in construction of the dike.
  Clinton IIarbor is in the collection district of Hartford. The nearest light-house is
in Falkner's Island, 8 miles southwest. Fort Hale, New Haven Harbor, 22 miles
west, is the nearest work of defense.

                                                  Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available.........................................----.                                             $2. 73
July 1, 1888, balance available .-....     .......---....   .............-......                                          252. 73
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project -.......                                                  7, 000
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                                7,000
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                    COMMERCIAL            STATISTICS FOR THE CALENDAR YEAR 1886.

Arrivals and departures of vessels ................................---..-                                          .    90 to 100
Shipments :
    Wood and lumber ...----...--......--......---.......---                  -----......---......
                                                                           ..----------....                    tons..      2, 000
    Hay and straw ................------------..................-----------------..........---------            do...         500
                ......------....--....-----
      Total-------                                                                     ------...... do...
                                          .....----.......----....-----.....----....--.....                                2, 500
Receipts :
                                           ...........--.....---...
    Coal......---------- ---......------..------..--... ----              --------...---..--...... tons..                  1,200
      Lumber--
             ......---......-...--    .    .   ..-........                 ..................        ....   M feet..         108
      Oysters....................-.                     ...............................                      bushels..     10,000
D)raught of vessels using the barbor. ........ ............                                         ..-...... feet.. 41 to 71
Tonnage of vessels using the harbor................
                                               ---................                                                      30 to 150
                                                                                                               t-----ons.-
540     REPORT     OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                       D 5.
        IMPROVEMENT OF NEW HAVEN HARBOR, CONNECTICUT.

   New Haven Harbor is a bay on the north shore of Long Island Sound,
extending about 4 miles inland and from 1 to 2 miles wide. The Mill
and Quinnipiac rivers empty into the head of the harbor; these rivers
are of no commercial importance except for tidal navigation at and near
their mouths. The harbor channel is from 400 feet to a mile wide, with
mud and sand flats on either side. When the Government began work
in this harbor in 1867, the available low-water depth above Crane's Bar,
about a third way down the harbor, was 9 feet; thence to Fort Hale,
which is about half way down, it was 16 feet or over; a short distance
below Fort Hale was a bar of very soft mud extending across the har-
bor, with 13 feet available depth at mean low water. The entrance to
the harbor was partly obstructed by several sunken rocks.
                      PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

   Several plans for removal of certain of the rocks at the harbor en-
trance have been proposed and undertaken, but not completed. The
removal of the harbor light-house to southwest ledge and the comple-
tion of the present plan for breakwaters will obviate the necessity for
further work upon these rocks.
    The work of deepening the channel in this harbor has for the most
part been done in accordance with plans presented in annual or special
reports to the Chief of Engineers, the projects being adopted to comply
with subsequent appropriations and not based upon examinations or
surveys ordered by Congress.
    In a letter dated January 20, 1871, printed as house Ex. Doc. No.
95, Forty-first Congress, third session, and also on page 771 of the An-
nual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1871, General Warren says
that " the business of New Haven requires that there should be a chan-
nel dredged 200 feet wide and to a depth of 14 feet at mean low water
up to the wharves," and that this is " in many respects more important
to New Haven than the removal of the rocks at the entrance to the
harbor." It was estimated to cost $64,815. March 3, 1871, $40,000 was
appropriated and expended in the same year in making a channel 13
feet deep, 200 feet wide up to Long Wharf, 350 feet wide at the bend at
Long Wharf, and 100 feet wide from there to the Steam-boat Wharf.
    In a letter of December 23, 1871, printed in House Ex. Doc. No. 137,
Fort~i-second Congress, first session, General Warren submitted an esti-
mate of $26,250 for dredging 16 feet deep and 200 feet wide across Fort
Hale Bar, adding that there was some doubt as to the permanence of such
a channel. June 10, 1872, $15,000 was appropriated for the removal of
rocks, and $20,000 for harbor improvement; the former amount was
expended upon Luddington rock; the latter, with part of an appropria-
tion of $?5,000 made March 3, 1873, was expended in dredging on the
Fort Hale Bar, and at the close of the season of 1873 the channel had
been made 16 feet deep and 200 feet wide, as proposed; it soon filled to
nearly its former condition. The 13-foot channel above Long Wharf
was also widened to 110 feet.
    In the Annual Report for 1873, General Warren says:
  It is thought that no improvement here beyond what can be accomplished with the
funds now available is called for on the part of the United States and no further ap-
propriation is asked for.
            APPENDIX            D-REPORT                OF        LIEUT.      COL.      HOUSTON.                  541
   No appropriation for this harbor was made in 1874, and none was rec-
ommended in the Annual Report for that year.
   In a report dated January 27, 1875, in reply to the first part of a res-
olution of the House of Representatives, January 21, 1875, asking " for
a report from surveys already made, in regard to the expediency of
widening and deepening the main channel of New Haven Harbor, Con-
necticut, to a depth not exceeding 20 feet, and also the expediency and
estimate of cost of a breakwater,"                            *
                                         * * Colonel Barlow, United
States Engineers, then in charge, presented estimates (see Annual Re-
port for 1875, Part II, page 250).
For   channel   400   feet   wide   and   20   feet   deep   ................................                   $416,490
For   channel   400   feet   wide   and   18   feet   deep   ...........--            ....    .............      276, 990
For   channel   300   feet   wide   and   20   feet   deep   ..............                     -............... 329, 925
For   channel   300   feet   wide   and   18   feet   deep   ..--.................... ..........                 208, 890
   Also, February 8,1875, in reply to request from the Chief of Engineers,
he estimated $10,000 as the cost of widening to 200 feet the 13-foot
channel above Long Wharf, already 110 feet wide. In submitting these
reports the Chief of Engineers recommended the latter work " as being
of immediate importance, and whatever action may be taken upon the
project of making a 20-foot channel, this at least should be done." In
a subsequent report on the same matter, February 9, 1875, Colonel Bar-
low presents an estimate of $35,000 for widening the channel above
Long Wharf to 400 feet; this was transmitted to the House of Repre-
sentives by the Secretary of War, February 13, 1875, with favorable
indorsement of the Chief of Engineers. This latter plan was carried
out under the appropriation of $10,000 made March 3, 1875, with a bal-
ance of about $6,000 from previous appropriations, and the 13-foot chan-
nel was made 415 feet wide above Long Wharf, the price of work being
much lower than had been estimated.
   Nothing was appropriated for this harbor in 1876 or 1877.
   In the Annual Report for 1877, Colonel Barlow refers to the estimates
submitted in letter of January 25, 1875, and recommends that the chan-
nel below Long Wharf be made 400 feet wide and 16 feet deep, its then
dimensions, 200 feet wide and 13 feet deep, not affording " sufficient space
for convenient navigation;" the estimated cost was $40,000. In 1878,
under an appropriation of $25,000, made June 14, 1878, the channel was
dredged to length and depth as proposed, with width of 300 feet.
   In a letter, February 4, 1879, transmitting map of harbor examina-
tion made in December, 1878 (letter printed in Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1879, Part I, page 336), Colonel Barlow recom-
mends deepening the channel above Long Wharf and widening that
below, to secure 400 feet width with 16 feet depth from the Steam-boat
Wharf down to Fort Hale; also dredging a channel 500 feet wide and
16 feet deep through Fort Hale Bar; the work above Fort Hale was
estimated to cost $65,000, that below $35,000. The proposed depth and
slightly greater width above Fort Hale were obtained by October, 1881,
under three successive appropriations of $15,000 each, in 1879, 1880, and
1881; nothing had been done on the Fort Hale Bar.
   In the Annual Report for 1879, a dike at Sandy Point (opposite Fort
Hale) was suggested as a means of increasing the depth on Fort Hale
Bar, but on account of its expensiveness was not recommended to be
undertaken until dredging had been tried again.
   In the Annual Report for 1880 (Part I, page 445), Colonel Barlow
renews his recommendation for dredging a channel through Fort Hale
Bar 500 feet wide and 16 feet deep.
  In the Annual Report for 1881 (Part I, page 592), after current ob-
542     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

servations and borings had been made, a dike from Sandy Point is
recommended, the length to be determined experimentally as construc-
tion progresses, but to be at least 4,400 feet, which length was estimated
to cqst $60,000.
   Under appropriation of $30,000, made August 2, 1882, a plan for this
dike was submitted and referred to the Board of Engineers, by whom
it was slightly modified and approved October 2, 1882. The project as
approved consisted of a dike connected with Sandy Point by a shore-
arm about 2,160 feet long, and extending southward as a channel-arm
about 3,200 feet, the channel-arm and part of the shore-arm to be built of
creosoted piling in double rows filled in with stone. In 1883, the loca-
tion of the shore-arm was modified, upon the request of oyster-growers
in the vicinity, and in 1886 the method of construction was modified in
order to use riprap instead of creosoted piling, the latter being found
more expensive both to construct and to keep in repair.
   The appropriations of 1882 and 1886 were expended upon the dike,
building rather more than one-half of the work. The appropriation of
1884 was expended in dredging under a special project for widening the
channel above Long Wharf with depths of 8 and 12 feet, and for re-
moving part of the piers and abutments of Tomlinson's Bridge, just
above the steam-boat wharf, which bridge was at that time being re-
built.
   The present project for making a 16-foot channel across Fort Hale
Bar includes the completion of the dike at an estimated cost of $46,000
and dredging a channel 16 feet deep through the bar, which, for 400 feet
width, is estimated to cost $47,000; total cost, $93,000 (see revised es-
timates, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1887, Part I, pages
599 and 600.)

  OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE               30,   1888.

   The contract for extending the dike from Sandy Point, which in June,
1887, was awarded to Owen J. Conley, of Guilford, Conn., was executed
under date of July 1, 1887. The contract provided for building about
450 linear feet of dike extension, using riprap, to be furnished and de-
livered in place at a cost of $1.03 per gross ton. Work under this con-
tract was begun August 27, 1887, and the contract, being twice ex-
tended, was completed January 28, 1888. The total amount of stone de-
livered in the dike was 4,951 tons, and the length of work built was
570 feet.

               PRESENT CONDITION OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The available depth over Fort Hale Bar is about 13 feet at mean low
water. Above this bar there is a 16-foot channel up to Tomlinson's
Bridge, at the head of the harbor, with from 400 to 600 feet width. Just
below the Sewer Dock, on the west side of the channel, is an anchorage
basin of about 2 acres area and 8 feet depth, and on the east side of the
channel above Long Wharf an additional width of about 100 feet has
been dredged 12 feet deep or over.
  Of the Sandy Point Dike, the shore-arm, 2,140 feet long and 1,359
feet of the channel-arm (including an ice-breaker 20 feet long) has been
built; 1,294 feet of the inner end of the shore-arm are of riprap; the
outer part of the shore-arm, 846 feet long and 254 feet at the north end
of the chape-arm2 is bit    of two rows of creosoted piling, 8 feet apart
                  APPENDIX              D-REPORT                         OF LIEUT.                    COL.         HOUSTON.                 543

from out to out, and filled in with stone; 1,085 feet of the channel-arm
south of the pile-work are built of riprap, of which the north 273 feet
are on a log foundation ; the ice-breaker at the north end of the channel-
arm is also of heavy riprap on log foundation.

                                               PROPOSED                   OPERATIONS.


   With future appropriations the dike will be completed and the chan-
nel dredged through Fort Hale Bar. The estimated cost of this is
$93,000, to which should be added an estimate of $5,000 annually re-
quired for maintenance of channels and for repair of dike.
  Appropriations for the improvement of New Haven Harbor have been
made as follows, viz:

     Date.                                                           Application.                                                        Amount.


Aug.   30, 1852     Removal of Middle Rock, not expended until 1867 ..........................                                              $6, 000
July   11,1870      Removal of rocks.--...-...----------------------------...............................--.................                15, 00,
Mar.    3, 1871     Dredging (13 feet) above Fort Hale ............-----------------------                                                  40, 000
June   10, 1872     Dredging (16 feet) Fort Hale Bar; removal of rocks ....-.---------------                                                35, 000
Mar.    3, 1873     Dredging (16 feet) Fort Halo Bar...........................................                                             2, 000
Mar.    3,1875      Dredging (13 feet) above Long Wharf ..-----....---.............-..........                                              10, 000
June   18, 1878     Dredging (16 feet) Long Wharf to Fort Hale.---..-.........                          . ...     ..- ...- .                25, 000
Mar.    3, 1879     Dredging (16 feet) above Long Wharf .---...---------.....................---........                                    15, 000
June   14, 1880    ....--.. do ------   -----                    ---------------------------------.....                                     15, 000
Mar.    3, 1881     Dredging (16 feet) Long Wharf to Fort Hale................................                                              15, 000
Aug.    2, 1882     Sandy Point Dike.--..------------ -------------------------......                                ------                 30, 00)
July    5, 1881     Dredging (18, 12, and feet) above Long Wharf............................                                                10, 000
Aug.    5, 1886     Sandy Point Dike ............................................................                                           20, 000
                          Total..-..--....---------------------------.                                             -----------------       261, 000


  New Haven, the port of entry forthe collection district of New Haven, is situated
at the head of New Haven Harbor, about 31 miles from Long Island Sound.                                                                  There is
a light-house on Southwest Ledge, at the mouth of the harbor.                                                            Fort Hale, 2 miles
below the city, commands the channel.


                                                         Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available .................................---                                                          ....   $7, 818. 93
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 --.......... --.............. ...........--........
                                                          --                                                                         6, 488. 95
July 1, 1888, balance available -------...--------.....                      ....------................-----....                     1,329. 98
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .. ............                                                          ........     15, 000. 00
                                                                   -16,
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889..... ..........-..                                                                  329. 98
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--------. 78, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 78, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




4bstract of contractfor                improving New Haven Harbor, Connecticut, in                                          force during the
                                          fiscal year ending ,June30, 1888.


Name and address of con-                 Date.                           S   ect.                        Price
       tractor.                                                          Subject.                       per ton.             Remarks.


Owen J. (Iquley, Quilford,           Jply    1, 1887        Delivery of riprap and                           $1. 03   Contract completed Jan.
  Coun.                                                        extension of dike.                                       uary 28, 1888.
544                REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                            COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR THE CALENDAR                                          YEAR 1886.

                                                                   FOREIGN COMMERCE.
Value of imports .............--....--                       ........................                              ......           $580, 054.16
Value of exports ...............................----------------..                                         ..-----........
                                                                                                                 ---              $1,349, 655.06
Rovenue receipts............ ........................................                                                               $257, 811.64
Vessels entered from foreign ports-...........-..-....-..................                                                                     35
Vessels cleared for foreign ports ......                   ................                   ..........           ......                     20

                                                                  DOMESTIC COMMERCE.


                                                                                                                     Tons.                    Value.




Receipts....................................................................                                       1, 553, 700           $8, 787, 300
Shipments ..................................................................                                          549, 000          Not known.



                                                    VESSELS ARRIVING AND DEPARTING.

                                               [Draught, 8 to 20 feet; tonnage, 100 to 1, 400 tons.
                                                                                                                                               Number.
Steamers ........ ..........................                                  ................             ............                ....        6,930
Sail-vessels ....             ...................................................                                                                  9,000
Barges. .....................                                         ....................................                                         6, 540
             Total ............................................                                                             ........             22, 470




                                                                                 D 6.
      CONSTRUCTION OF BREAKWATER AT NEW HAVEN, CONNECTICUT.

   New Haven Harbor is the only accessible natural harbor of any con-
siderable area and depth in Long Island Sound between New London
Harbor, 45 miles east, and Huntington Bay, 32 miles southwest. At
this point Long Island Sound is at its widest, and the broad, open
mouth of the harbor left the anchorage ground exposed to storms from
a southerly quarter, so that vessels driven in by stress of weather were
frequently obliged to cross Fort Hale Bar, going from 2 to 4 miles up
the harbor, and to anchor in the dredged channel in order to reach se-
cure shelter.
                                                                               PROJECT.

   December 15, 1874, the harbor commissioners of New Haven ad-
dressed a memorial to the members of Congress from Connecticut ask-
ing that measures be taken "to procure appropriations by Congress for
deepening the main ship-channel of the harbor to 20 feet, and for con-
structing a breakwater from the light-house" (then on Five-Mile Point)
"'to Southwest Ledge." The memorial, printed in House Ex. Doc. No.
162, Forty-third Congress, second session, stated that the breakwater
contemplated would add greatly to the value of the harbor as a harbor
of refuge.
   January 21, 1875, a resolution was passed by the House of Represen-
tatives asking "for a report from surveys already made, in regard to
the expediency of widening and deepening the main channel of New
Haven Harbor, Connecticut, to a depth not exceeding 20 feet; and also
the expediency and estimate of expense of a breakwater between the
eastern shoe of the entrance of said. harbor and Southwest Ledge, so
           APPENDIX        D-REPORT            OF LIEUT.            COL.       HOUSTON.        545
called, or such part of said distance as may be found most expedient or
necessary for the protection of said harbor." In reply to this resolution
a report was made by Col. J. W. Barlow, Corps of Engineers, dated
January 27, 1875, printed in House Ex. Doc. above mentioned and also
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1875, Part II,page
251, suggesting three locations for a breakwater, viz:
   1. That indicated in the resolution and terminating at Southwest
Ledge.
   2. A line running nearly east and west, its middle point resting upon
Adam's Fall Rock, about one-half mile north of Southwest Ledge.
   3. A line 400 yards further north, running nearly west from Five-
Mile Point.
   Estimates of cost ranging from $248,000 to $465,330 were suiblmitt(d,
and with the report were also presented letters and( coIn iercial statis-
tics bearing upon the subject. The question of a westerly breakwater
does not appear to have been considered at that time.
   This report is referred to by Colonel Barlow in the succeeding Annual
Reports for 1876, 1877, and 1878, and in the latter year additional sta-
tistics were submitted, but no action was taken until 1879, when an
appropriation of $30,000 was made "for the construction of breakwater
at New Haven, Conn." In August of the same year an examination
of part of the mouth of the harbor was made, and a map transmitted
to the Chief of Engineers with several projects for breakwaters, which
were referred to the Board of Engineers for report. The report of
the Board, dated November 24, 1879, and printed in the Annual Re-
port of the Chief of Engineers for 1880, Part I, pages 449-452, recom-
mended a breakwater from Southwest Ledge to Quipes Ledge as con-
templated in the resolution of the House of Representatives of January
21, 1875, but as the anchorage ground would still be exposed to south-
westerly gales, the Board stated as its opinion that a breakwater ex.
tending northwest from Luddington Rock would be necessary. Their
plan provided for two riprap breakwaters, 12 feet wide on toln,   rising 6
feet above high water, with exterior slopes of one-third and interior
slopes of two thirds with estimates as follows:
     ESTIMATE FOR BREAKWATER FROM LIGHT-HOUSE LEDGE TO QUIXES LEDGE.


                             --- ...... ...
Length of construction ......-                        . . .
                                                .. - -...     ...          -   .   ._yards..   1, 100
Average height of work.---. ---....----         ------
                                    ................----.       --..        feet-....
                                                                  --.......-----..           32
Average cross-section ......----...........----..      ........              yards..
                                                                 ............--             299
                                    --------.... ------- ---- ---........
Cost per cubic yard .-----........----...                                                $2.
                                                                        ---..-...----...... 00
                                                                   ---......
328, 900 cubic yards, at $2-- ....----......---.....---.                              $657, 800
                                                        ----- ----..........--.........--.
                                                      ....--

         ESTIMATE FOR BREAKWATER          IN   THE VICINITY OF LUDDINGTON LOCK.


Length ............------  --......---------
                     ..------.....--........---.....-......   1,400
                                              yards .----......--.
Average height-------------------------
                     ..............................----.........--  -- feet ---....--...     28
                                                  --.....------.
Cross-section.-----..... --....---...................--..----....      square yards..       233
326,667 cubic yards, at $2............----------             ------             ----  $653, 334
                                           --------.........---............----......--..----.
  This plan locates the easterly breakwater so as to lie between Light-
house Ledge (or Southwest Ledge) and Quixes Ledge, and the westerly
one to extend in a northwest and southeast direction overlying Ludding-
ton Rock. This report was transmitted to the Secretary of War by the
Chief of Engineers, with suggestion that the appropriation ($30,000) be
applied toward the construction of the easterly breakwater, and( was
approved by him January 31, 1880. Before work had been begun the
details of cross-section were modified with approval of the Chief of En-
gineers, so that the exterior slope should be & and the interior --.
       ErNG 88---- 35
546    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The first load of stone was delivered April 22, 1880, beginning the
east breakwater at the end resting upon Southwest Lodge; under sub-
sequent appropriations it has been extended northeasterly, and up to
July 1, 1837, 2,412 lineal feet of this breakwater has been built, using
212,541 tons of granite.

  OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1888.

   The contract dated October 22, 1886, with T. J. Allen, of New York
City, for delivering about 57,000 tons of granite in the breakwater at
the rate of $1.12 per ton, which was in progress at the beginning of the
fiscal year, was extended to December 31, 1887, under which extension
it was completed, 55,822 tons of granite having been delivered and 656
lineal feet of the breakwater built under the contract. Of these
amounts 33,179 tons of stone were delivered and 391 lineal feet of
breakwater constructed since July 1, 1887.
   Under the unexpended balance of the last appropriation, proposals
for further extension of the east breakwater were received April 21,
1888, and a contract dated May 11, 1888, was entered into with John
Beattie, of Leete's Island, Connecticut, for delivering about 6,000 tons
of granite. Work under this contract began May 22, and is now in
progress, the contract expiring September 28, 1888; up to June 30,
1888, 1,251 tons of granite were delivered and 15 lineal feet of the break-
water built.
   During the past fiscal year the total amount of stone received is
34,430 tons, and the total length of breakwater built is 406 feet.

                   PRESENT CONDITION       OF WORK.

  The east breakwater is now 2,818 feet long, being nearly seven-eighths
of its projected length of 3,300 feet. It contains 246,971 tons of stone,
and has cost (supervision, etc., included) about $100 per linear foot.
The part first built has settled somewhat and ne eds repairing.

                        PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

   With future appropriations it is proposed, first, to complete the east
breakwater, and then to build the west one. About $40,000 will be re-
quired to finish the east breakwater. Should sufficient appropriation
be made work on both could be prosecuted. at the same time.
   In its report of November 24, 1879, the Board of Engineers states as
its opinion " that after the completion of a certain portion of the eastt
erly breakwater the westerly one should be promptly commenced."
Appropriations have not heretofore been sufficiently large to justify
working in both places, but the easterly breakwater will soon be com-
pleted, when work upon the westerly one will be begun. The question
now is as to its location. In reference to this the Board says: "If it be
built in a northwest and southeast direction it would cover not only the
deep-water anchorage, but to some extent the harbor above." As the
object of the westerly breakwater was to protect the anchorage from
southwesterly gales and the length was fixed at 4,200 feet, it is evident
that it should have a northwesterly direction from Luddington Rock; a
breakwater of that length in a southwesterly direction would afford no
protection from southeasterly gales.
  The harbor commissioners of New Haven have expressed a desire that
the location of the westerly breakwater be changed so as to extend in
                  APPENDIX                    D-REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. HOUSTON.                                                                           547
a southwesterly direction from Luddington Rock, and that its length
be increased, on the ground that the harbor of refuge under the present
project is not of sufficient capacity. A supplementary report will be
submitted as to the necessity of thus increasing the capacity of the
harbor.
  During the ensuing year $500,000 could be profitably expended in
completing the easterly breakwater and in beginning the westerly one,
whether the location and length of the latter be modified or not.
   Appropriations for the New Haven Breakwater have been made as
follows, viz :

       Date.                                                               Application.                                                                Amount.


Mar.     3,1879 East breakwater..................                                                 ................................                      $30, 000
June    14, 1880 ...... do ....................................                                  .............................                           30, 000
Mar.     3, 1881 ...... do ..............                                 .60,                                                                               000
Aug.    2, 1882 ...... do .....................................................................                                                   I     60, 000
July     5, 1884 ...... do . .....           . ...... ..... .....                     ........     .....................................                 40, 000
Aug.     5, 1886 East breakwater (partially expended) .........                                                       ............... ..........         75, 000
                               Total ................................------------.....---.....................                                          295, 000



  New Haven, the port of entry for the collection district of New Haven, is situated
at the head of New Haven Harbor, about 4 miles north of the breakwater. There is
a light-house on Southwest Ledge, at the west terminus of the east breakwater. Fort
Hale, 2 miles north of the breakwater, commands the channel.

                                                               Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available ................................................. $47, 977. 49
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, excusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ................. .......      $39, 786.28
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..........................         1,688.85
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts...--.......          6,411.15
                                                                                                                                                   47, 886.28

July 1, 1888, balance available ............-------------....-----------...................----------------..                                            91.21
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .-..............
                                                           -   ...- -                                                               ..- - .        75,000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ..........--------......                                                                     75,091.21

   SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........   941, 134. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 500, 000. 00
   Submitted in comphiance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




Abstract of bids for extending the breakwater at New laren,   Conn., opened at Engineer
                    Office, U. S. Army, New York City, April 21, 188.


                                                                                 Rate      Total
No.            Name and address of bidders.                                    per gross for 6.500                                  Remarks.
                                                                                 ton.      tons.


  *1    John Beartie, Leete's Island, Conn........                                  $1. 35          $8, 775      Granite.
   2    Chas. H. Edwards, Quincy, Mass .........                                     1.59           10, 335
  t3    S. & E. S. Belden, Rocky Hill, Conn .......                                  1.16            7, 540      Sandstone from Portland, Conn.
   4    A. M. Newton, New York City.........                                         1. 60          10, 400

 *Entered into contract May 11, 1888; in progress.
t Lowest bid rejected, with approval of the Secretary of War, May-2. 1888; granite being a better
material for the work, and worth the difference in price.
548          REPORT OF THE CHIEF                                 OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Abstract of contractsfor xtending ' ew Havcen Breakwater, in force during the                                               fiscal   year
                                 ending June 30, 188g.


Name and address of                Date.                   Subject.                    Priceark
    contractors.                    Dte.                    ubject.                    per ton.                     emarks.


T. F. Allen. New York Oct. 22, 1886 Delivering riprap and ex-                             $1.12       Contract completed               De-
  City,                                 tending breakwater.                                             cember 31, 1887.
                                                ..---..--------.
John Beattie, Leete'si May 11, 1888 .... do .----                                          1. 35     In progress.
  Island, Conn.



                     COMMIERCIAL              STATISTICS   FORI TIE        CALENDAR              YEAR 1S6.


                                     Vessels passing Xew               aliecn B, calwcater.


                      Vessels.                         No.                                 Vessels.                                 No.


Men-of-war .---....- ....-......... .......                28     Schooners and sloops .- --- . -.. ----    .                       15, 346
Steam-ships ......----.. ............. ......          1,910      Barges in tow...---------..  --------------                       1, 620
Steamers of all kinds .... ..................         15, 276
Ships, barks, and brigs ...................                412             Total ....---..---.......-----------....-----...--. --   52, 592



  These figures are not complete, as many vessels would pass unobserved in night or
in thick weather.
  The value of the cargoes of these vessels can not be ascertained; it is undoubtedly
very great.



                                                             D    7.


                 IMPROVEMENT OF MILFORD HARBOR, CONNECTICUT.

   This harbor is on the north shore of Long Island Sound, about 9
miles southwest of New Haven, Conn. It consists of a broad, open bay,
from the head of which the Wepauwog River, a small tidal stream, ex-
tends three-quarters of a mile north to the Milford wharves, and the
Indian River, another small inlet, extends northeasterly. The mouth of
the latter stream is partly closed by a (lam, formerly used to create
power for a tide-mill.
   The original depth on the bar just outside the mouth of the rivers
was less than 2 feet at mean low water, and in some places between
there and the upper wharves low tide left the channel nearly bare.
   The mean rise of tide is 6.2 feet.

                                    PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

  A survey of breakwater at Milford, Conn., was ordered by Congress
in the river and harbor act of 187.   There being no breakwater, a sur-
vey of the harbor for a breakwater was made, and in his report dated
December 24, 1874 (printed as part of Ex. Doc. No. 1.07, Forty-second
Congress, third session, and also on page 1041 of the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1873), General Warren, U. S. Engineers,
submitted the following plan of improvement:
1. A riprap breakwater from Welch's Point, on the east side of the mouth of
    the harbor............ ...........................                              . . ....  . ..
                                                                                             ....  . $7,000
2. Protecting the bluffs on the east shore from erosion by means of small
    stone jetties .... ..............
                          -                ........................................                    5, 500
3. Dredging 4 feet deep and 100 feet wide across the bar at the mouth of the
    river . .... ..... .. ............... ..... ... .. ..... .. .......... ..                                                       6,250
           APPENDIX         D--REPORT          OF    LIEUT.     COL.    HOUSTON.              549
4. A jetty on the east side of the channel, to prevent the dredged area from
    filling and to confine the action of the tide------                                             $5, 000
                                                                         ....................--------------------.
Superintendence.-----.....---.....                                ----.--..---..---....
                                   ---.............------------..----                                 1, 250
                                                                                        ---....---...........----

       Total....... ............................................. ..........                85,000
    In 1874 $5,000 was appropriated for this harbor, and work under the
above project was begun, building the small jetties to protect the east
shore. Twelve such jetties were built, 100 to 130 feet long, and rising to
9 feet above mean low-water level. The appropriation of 1875 ($13,000)
was applied to repair of these jetties, to construction of a jetty frdm
the east shore, at the mouth of Indian River (Long Jetty), and to
dredging across the bar.
    In the annual report for 1876 (see Annual Report of the Chief of En-
,gineers for 1876, PartI, page 225) Colonel Barlow, U. S. Engineers, rec-
ommended that the dredged channel be carried up to the Town Wharf,
about half a mile farther up, at an additional estimated cost of $9,000.
This recommendation was renewed in 1877, and was included in the pro-
ject for expenditure of the appropriation of $10,000 made in 1878; in that
and the following year the 4-foot channel across the bar was completed
to 100 feet width as originally projected, and was extended to Town
Wharf with width from 60 to 75 feet, and Long Jetty was repaired; also
under the same appropriation, in 1879 and 1880, an additional jetty,
authorized by Department letter of October 16, 1879, was built on the
west side of the channel extending southward from Burns's Point. This
appropriation completed the original project except the breakwater;
sufficient money for beginning that had not been appropriated.
   June 14, 1880, $5,000 was applropriated, and in accordance with a pro-
ject for its expenditure submitted and approved, the 4-foot harbor chan-
nel was extended from Town Wharf to the Straw Works Wharf, at the
upper end of the harbor,with a width of 40 feet. This was completed before
the appropriation was exhausted and, 'at the eaInestsolicitation of those
most interestedin the works of improvementthere, an experimental chan-
nel 25 feet wide and 8 feet deep was cut through the bar at the entrance,
lying within and on the west side of the 4-foot channel already made.
This is now of great use to the steam-vessels employed in the fish-oil
works at that place, and it is claimed that the increase of shipping in the
harbor, particularly in the oyster business, for which those waters seem
very well adapted, will soon require an 8-foot channel of fully 100 feet
width. Such a channel would involve the removal of about 45,000 cubic
yards more of material, principally sand and gravel, which, at ruling
prices, would cost, including superintendence and incidental expenses,
about $11,000." (Extract from Colonel Barlow's annual report of 1881.
See Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1881, Part I,pages
598 and 599.)
    Under the appropriation of $5,000 made August 2, 1882, the project
above suggested was adopted and the 8-foot channel was widened to 65
feet from the bay up to Merwin's AWharf, with 100 feet width around
the bend at Burns's Point. No appropriation has since been made.
    By act of Congress approved March 3, 1871, a survey for a break-
water and harbor of refuge at Milford Harbor was authorized. The
survey was imade, and a report with estimates was suinitted January
20, 1882. This report is )printedin the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1882, Part I, page 632.
   OPERATIONS         DURING TIIE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30. 1888.

The available funds were not snuficient to continue the improve.
ment.
550           REPORT OF THE CHIEF                                        OF ENGINEERS,                                         U.       S.       ARMY.

                              PRESENT CONDITION OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The channel, dredged 4 feet deep, with width of 60 feet for about two-
thirds the distance from the mouth of the river to the Straw Works Wharf,
and width of 40 feet the rest of the distance, is understood to be in
good condition, having filled but little. The channel across the bar, 8
feet deep and 65 feet wide, has shoaled in places, especially near the
outer end, so that the available depth at low water is now less than 7
fe'et.
  Long Jetty, on the east bank of the mouth of Indian River, needs
considerable repair; the other jetties slight repairs.

                                                PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

   Future appropriations should be applied to repairing the jetties and
to completing the 8-foot channel through the bar to 100 feet width;
$6,000, the remainder of the estimate, could be profitably expended dur-
ing the next fiscal year to complete the project.
  Appropriations for improving Milford Harbor have been made as
follows, viz:

    Date.                                                             Appropriation.                                                                              Amount.


June 10,1872         Survey-------........---........-- .............                        .....--------........................--.                  --             $1,500
June 23, 1874        Jetties on east shore....-----------------       -----.........---....-----------------------...                                                  5,   000
Mar. 3, 1875         Long Jetty and dredging at mouth of river..-------- -----------------------                                                                      13,   000
June 18, 1878        Dredging to Town Wharf _ ------.....------......------....--...------ ------..--..--.......------..                                              10,   000
June 14, 1880        Dredging above Town Wharf and (8 feet) below Merwin's Wharf, on bar...                                                                            5,   000
Mar.      3, 1881    Survey for breakwater- ..                                                                                                                              1---0..0..-..---.--00....-..--.
                                                                                                                                                                            100
Aug.      2, 1882    Dredging (8 feet) on bar.                                                                                                                      , 000
                                                                                                                 .....----------------------------------------------------.....

                            Total ...---------------------------------........---------------------....-----------............                                        39, 60

  Milford Harbor is in the collection district of New Haven ; it is about 9 miles west
from Fort Hale, New Haven.     arbor. The nearest light-house is on Stratford Point,
4 miles to the westward.
                                                          Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available. --                                         -       ---.                  -.------ ---                    --. ----                  $241. 02

July 1, 1888, balance available............------------......----- ------......------......----...------......                                                      241. 02
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188 ....-......          --             .......-.--....--.                                                               5,000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June                                         30, 1889.. -..-.............                                                 5,241. 02

                                                                      - - -...
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing p)roject- - ...                                                                                          1,000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                                                                       1, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance   with  requirements  of  sections 2 of river   and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
                                                       COMMIERCIAL STATISTICS.

  No recent statement of commerce has ben received; the present amount is prob-
ably not very different from that of 1884, when the following figures were submitted.
                                      ARRIVALS           AND         DEPARTURES                    OF VESSELS.



                                                       Vessels.                                                                                  Number. Tonnage


Steamers---...--..      --............-- ....    ..------..------      --...          -------               - ...                ....                         0       23, 52
Sail-vessels .....       .......          ---.----..            -.
                                                         --. ---..         -----          -------..          -            -.. ...            .              318       12, 72(
         Total .-.-----------------------... ..                     ............                                                             .,-----        87-       :3, 240
                  APPENDIX                    D-REPORT                            OF        LIEUT.       COL.             HOUSTON.                  551
   The chief articles of commerce are:
Coal--..----...... --------............---....-----...... ..-----..........--.......-----...--...........                              tons..      10,000
Building materials-------.. .........------....              ------.----...------------..............---.....--..                       do...       2,500
Oysters........        -------..---......--..--...--......--..---........---....---..                                              -value..       $78, 750
                                                                                              ...--.. not known.
                                                                             ------......-... ----..
Fish-oil and fertilizers--.....--....-- ---..........----....------......---....
  The value of the oyster business is supposed to have increased somewhat, and that
of the fish-oil and fertilizer factories to have diminished since 1884.




                                                                                  D 8.

             IMPROVEMENT OF THE HOUSATONIC                                                         RIVER, CONNECTICUT.

   The Housatonic is a long, shallow river, running southward through
Massachusetts and Connecticut and emptying into Long Island Sound
just east of Stratford Point, about 15 miles southwest from New Haven.
At Derby, 13 miles above its mouth, it receives the discharge of the
Naugatuck, a small rapid river. This point, which has been regarded
as the head of navigation, is nearly the head of tide-water; about"a
mile above there is a dam across the Housatonic River, furnishing large
water-power. For at least 5 miles below Derby the water is always
fresh.
   The original depth on the worst bars in the river (six in number) was
from 3.5 to 4.5 feet at mean low water; there was also a bar across the
river's mouth, with about 4 feet, low-water depth.
                                              PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

   In pursuance of a resolution of the House of Representatives, dated
December 20, 1869, authorizing a survey of the Housatonic River below
Derby, which resolution was referred by the Secretary of War to the
Chief of En'gineers for report as to " the necessity for the survey," an
examination of the river from Derby to Long Island Sound was made
by Col. D. C. Houston, Corps of Engineers, who reported January 8,
1870, recommending a detailed survey of all that part of the river, at
an estimated cost of $5,000. This report was printed in House Ex.
Doc. No. 62, Forty-first Congress, second session.
   By act of Congress, approved July 11, 1870, a survey of the Housa-
tonic River below Derby, Conn., was directed, and an allotment of $2,700
was made for a survey "sufficient to determine the prominent obstruc-
tions to navigation." In his report on this survey, dated January 23;
18'1, and printed in House Ex. Doc. No. 95, Forty-first; Congress, third
session, also in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1871,
page 781, General G. K. Warren, Corps of Engineers, submits the
following estimates for making a channel 7 feet deep at mean low water,
to be 200 feet wide over the bar at the mouth of the river, and 150 feet
wide in the river, the channel at the river's mouth to be protected on
the east side by a breakwater from Milford Beach:
Jetty at Sow and Pigs Reef..............................................                                                                           $4, 000
Removing Drew's Rock, 357 cubic yards ....................................-
                                                                    --                                                                              2,000
Dredging inside the bar at the mouth ....................................--                                          .                             18,486
Dredging in the bar at the mouth ................          ....-------------------------...............------------.                               12, 000
Construction of breakwater at mo th...........                                                            __
                                                                                               ........................                       .    6, 475

       Total ...--------..                       ---...         .             ...........                          .. ..............              404, 961
  The breakxvater was to be built of riprap up to 1I feet abdve mean
low water and of dimension stone above; it was to be 6 feet wide on top,
552        REPORT          OF      THE    CHIEF      OF    ENGIEE:RS,       U. S. ARMY.

rising to 11 feet above low water, and was to extend to the 6-foot curve,
an estimated length of 4,2Q0 feet.
    March 3, 1871, the first appropriation for improvement of the river
was made and work in accordance with the project was begun. In
/1872 the project was modified to admit of a jetty connecting Drew's
Rock with the west bank, instead of removal of the rock ; this was done
on the ground of economy, and the jetty was built in 1872. The result
has been to form a bar below the jetty, which required such frequent
dredging that it has been found expedient to remove the rock, as origi-
  nally projected.
    Appropriations were not made in sufficient amount to warrant be.
  ginning the breakwater as originally designed, and in 1879 Colonel
  Barlow proposed to substitute for it a riprap jetty at an estimated cost
of $12,000; in 1882 the estimate was changed to $20,250, the contemrn
plated jetty being 6,000feet long and rising only to low-water level. Such
aletty could subsequently be built higher if necessary, and there seems
no doubt that this would have to be done before any useful effect could
  be realized; therefore, in my Annual Report for 1887 (see Annual Re-
port of the Chief of Engineers for 1887, Part I, page 607), I presented
  rev sed estimates for a breakwater, modifying the originally proposed
  me hod of construction to one for using riprap only, experience at
  harbors on Long Island Sound having, shown this construction to be as
durable as dimension stone-work and more economical. At the same
  time estimates, based on recent surveys, were submitted for the dredg-
ing necessary to make the channel 7 feet deep, with width of 200 feet at
  the mouth of the river and 100 feet above ; the latter width was adopted
in 1883, because up to that time the originally proposed width of 150
  feet had never been obtained.
    Following are the estimates for the breakwater and for dredging, sub-
  mitted in 1887:
For a breakwater 5,750 feet long, extending from Milford Beach 3,250 iet
   in a course about south-southeast: thence parallel with and S00feet from
   the channel, 2,500 feet furtherto the 12-foot curve; inside the bend to be
   built up l o 3 feet above mean low water, top width 6 feet, side slopes 1
   on 1; outside the bend to be built up to 6 feet above high water, top
   width 12 feet, outer slope I on 2, and inner slope 1 on 1 --.............                $175, 000
For dredging at the mouth of the river and at six bars in the river, 146,000
   cubic yards, at 16 cents, with about 15 per cent. added for contingent
   expenses..--------------------..------.........-----...--....---------------
                                      .....---------.........................                  7,000

       Total-.... -----....---.-    ---   ---....   -- -----..-   ----...       -........    202,000
 " To which should be added about .4,000 annually, required for main-
tenance of the channels.
   January 27, 1887, a letter further explaining the reasons for the new
estimate for the breakwater was submitted to the Chief of Engineers,
and was subsequently printed as Senate Ex. Doc. No. 103, Fiftieth Con-
gress, first session, a copy of which paper is attached to this report.
    OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING- JUNE 30, 1888.

   The contract for removal of 1)rew's Rock and Jetty, which was in
progress at the time of the last annual report, was extended to June
30, 1888, under which extension it was completed early in June. A
depth of 7 feet at mean low water was made over the rock.
   A series of tidal observations were made in the river in May and
June, 1888, to correct old tide-levels and establish new ones. This was
especially important at the mouth of the river, where mean low-water
levels vary 12 feet in a distance of less thanm 2I miiles.
                   APPENDIX                      D--REPORT                         OF         LIEUT.              COL.           HOUSTON.                            553
                                   PRESENT                    CONDITION* OF IMPROVEMIENT.

  The available depth on the several bars in the river is from 5 to 6 feet
at mean low water; on the inner bar, at the mouth of the river, the
present depth is about the same.
  Drew's Rock and Jetty have been removed.
                                                        PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

  With future appropriations it is proposed to construct the break-
water at the mouth of the river to widen and deepen the channel there,
and to restore and maintain a depth of 7 feet at mean low water on the
bars in the river.
  The estimated cost of this work is $202,000, to which should be added
about $4,000 annually required for maintenance of channels.
  Appropriations for the Housatonic River have been made as follows,
viz :

   Date.                                                                       Application.                                                                    Anmount.


Mar.    2,   1867 Examination...--------------------------------------------------------------                                                                               $42
July   11,   1870   Survey ---------------------------------------------------------------------                                                                          2, 700
Mar.    3,   1871   Sow-and-Pigs Jetty; dredging..----..------------------------------------
                                                                                  .
                                                                                                                                                                         15, 000
June   10,   1872   Drew's Rock Jetty; dredging- .............................................                                                                           15,000
Mar.    3,   1873   Dredging ..................................................                                                                              ......      10,000
June   23,   1874 .-..... do ---------------------------.-----------------------------------------                                                                       10, 000
Mar.    3,   1875 ...-       do --..------.......---....................----------------------...----..----....------------------------------...........................  5, 000
June   18,   1878 ...---. do----................------------------..------------..............--....---...---...............----------------------5. 000
June   14,   1880 ......--- do ......-------------...............--.....---------------..........---..--.......--..-......--.-----.............   ---------------         2,000
Mar.    3,   1881 ......------do .......--------..............-----------------......-.......------...............................--------------------------              2,000
Aug.    2,   1882 1     Removing       Drew's Rock and Jetty, 1887..-----------------------------------                                                                   2,000
July    5,   1884 ...... do ...--------------------------------------------------------------                                                                             2. 500
Aug.    5,   1886 ...... do .....----......--------.......------------...----..--...-...----..-..----..--...........----------------------                                5,0

                                Total--..----.......--..-----------..---------------------..---------------------...........76,                                           242


  The Housatonic River is the boundary between the collection districts of New Haven
and Fairfield. The nearest light-house is on Stratford Point, at the mouth of"the river,
and the nearest work of defense is Fort Hale, N ew Haven Harbor. about 15 miles east,

                                                                   Money statement.
July 1, 18S7, amount available ......................................                                                                                       $6, 975. 37
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887.................--..                                                                             $825. 96
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities .........................                                                                        4, 444. 00
                                                                                                                                                               5,269.96

July 1, 1888, balance available .-................. ..................---
                                                                       ..  1, 705. 41
Amount apprnopriated by act of August 11, 188 .......................     35,000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ......................                                                                                36,,705.41

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.. ......    167,00. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 100, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1L66 and 1867.



Abstract of contractfor removal of Drew's Rock atd Jettl, Iousaton ic River, Connecticu t, in
                    force during the fiscal year ending June 30, 188.


Name and address of con-    Date.                                                   SPriect                       fo        le                   Remarks.
                      tractor                                                                                          work.


Francis I. Smith,                  ew        Oct. 26, 1886 Removal of Drew's Rock                                      $4, 444       Contract completed                     in
  York City.                                                 and Jetty.                                                               Tune, 1888.
554           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                            Commercial statistics for the calendar year of 1886.

                                                                             iAt Stratford           At Derby.
                                                                                    ra              head of navi-             Total.
                                                                              near mouth.              gation.


Arrivals and departures of vessels ........................-.                1         -     575                 460                1, 035
Tons of cargo received and shipped.......................                                25, 000             44, 301               69, 301
Value of cargo received and shipped .....................                             $350, 000         $3, 250, 600          $3, 600, 600



SPECIAL           REPORT            OF LIEUTENANT-COLONEL                                 D. C.         HOUSTON,               CORPS
                                           OF ENGINEERS.

                                          OFFICE, U. S. ARMY,
                                                       ENGINEER
                                         New York, January 27, 1888.
   SIR: I would respectfully call your attention to the estimate in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1887, "for completion of
existing project, $25,000," Housatonic River, Connecticut.
  The original project for this improvement is based on a survey made
in pursuance of the river and harbor act of July 11, 1870. (Annual Re-
port of the Chief of Engineers for 1871, page 781.) The estimate was
as follows:
Breakwater at mouth of river...-----..--.....--....-----..-----..---------                                   ......-------. $368, 475
                                                                                                           ..---
Dredging at mouth............----------- ............----------......----......--- ---..............----------        ....    12,000
Dredging on bars above mouth .......--------.----------......--...... -- ---....--....- ----....---....-      ....---...-.    24,486
         Total ..--....     ..-----....------......----
                                             ......--------....--....--......--....     -----------....----................
                                                                                                                     ---       404, 961
   No estimate for completion of project appears in the annual reports
until 1884, when an estimate of $30,000 is given for completion. This in-
cludes $20,000 for a riprap jetty 6,000 feet long, rising only to low water,
as a substitute for the original plan of breakwater. The sum of $5,000
having been since appropriated (1886) reduces this estimate to $25,000,
of which $20,000 is for breakwater and $5,000 for dredging. As ex-
plained in my annual report for 1887, I consider this project and esti-
mate inadequate, and for this reason the estimate for completion should
be increased before any breakwater is commenced.
   The amount given for this purpose in my annual report fbr 1887 is
$202,000, of which $175,000 is for a breakwater at the mouth of the
river, and $27,000 for dredging on bars from the mouth up to Derby.
I inclose an extract from my annual report explaining .this estimate.*
   The reason why my estimate for a breakwater is so much less than
the original is due.to the method of construction. There is a drawing
on page 782, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1871, show-
ing the original design. From experience at New Haven and other
locations, I think a riprap structure will answer the purpose at much
less cost. General Warren and other officers in charge of the work have
also arrived at this conclusion.
   No dredging has been done at the mouth of the river except by pri-
vate parties with whom contracts have been made to do the work under
direction of the officer in charge, the compensation being the material
excavated, which was valuable for oyster beds. The channel thus
deepened has tilled, to some extent with sand, so that this arrangement
can not be continued. The necessary depth on the bar could be main-
tained by annual dredging, but the estimate now presented to Congress
provides only $5,000 for dredging in the entire river.                                                        This would not
                                                      * Omitted here.
         APPENDIX D--REPORT        OF LIEUT.   COL. HOUSTON.        555
be sufficient to do the work required above the mouth, which is of the
first importance.
   Unless the estimate for completion is increased the project for a
breakwater should be abandoned. This was practically the case up to
1882, when the estimate of $20,000 was made, as the amounts appropri-
ated were not sufficient to warrant the commencement of the breakwater
in the original estimate.
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                  D. C. HOUSTON,
                                               Lieut. Col. of Engineers.
   the CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. A.



                                  D 9.
       IMPROVEMENT     OF BRIDGEPORT HARBOR, CONNECTICUT.

   This harbor extends nearly 3 miles inland from the north shore of
Long Island Sound, its width of about 1 mile at the mouth decreasing
to 200 feet between opposite wharves at its upper end. The channel,
even in the widest part of the harbor, is comparatively narrow.
   Before the first workb)ythe United States was done at this harbor
the depth over the bars was about 5 feet at low water, equivalent to 11l
feet ;t high water.
                    PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.
   In 1833 a petition of citizens of Bridgeport was presented tO Con-
gress asking an appropriation of $10,000 to improve the harbor; this
was granted in 1836, and the agent in charge was instructed by the
Engineer Department to dredge a, channel 8 feet deep, making it 200
feet wide through the outer bar and 100 feet wide through the inner
bar, or as much as the appropriation would admit of; the work was
done by contract in 1837 ; the rate was high (understood to be 72.8 cents
per cubic yard) and the funds were exhausted when the channel through
the outer bar had been made 60 feet wide.
   In 1838 Captain Swift, U. S. Engineers, reported that the channel
had been sounded. and was found to be 12 feet deep, or 4 feet deeper
than when left by the dredger.
   Nothing further was done until 1852, when a second appropriation
of $10,000 was made ; Captain Dutton, U. S. Engineers, found that the
channel on the outer bar was then 6 feet deep and 90 feet wide, and on
the inner bar but 5 feet deep, and he submitted a project for dredging
through both bars to a depth of 8 feet and width of 200 feet, at a total
estimated cost of $32,000; this project was approved by the Secretary
of War February 5, 1853, and with the $10,000 then available channels
8 to 13 feet deep were dredged 100 feet wide through the inner bar and
60 feet wide through the outer bar.
    By act of Congress approved June 23, 1866, a survey of the harbor
was ordered, which was made in that year. The object of the survey
was to ascertain " the present state of the harbor and the character
and extent of the encroachments upon it by the action of the tides," it
being feared that Long Beach on the east side of the harbor's mouth was
making northwestward l)y reason of sand drifting along the shore in
such a way as to contract and ultimately fill up the channel above the
inner bar. This work was at that time in my charge, and in my report
on the survey, dated January 12, 1867, I stated that it had been 1pro-
posed to construct a breakwater extending out from Long Beach to
556    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

arrest the sand, but the danger feared did not seem imminent and I
recommended a series of observations for the purpose of ascertaining
the nature and amount of changes taking place.
    In 1867 a survey of the shore-line of Long Beach was made.
    In' 1868 1 was directed by the Chief of Engineers to make " such re-
survey of Bridgeport Harbor Connecticut, as may be found necessary
to ascertain what changes have occurred since the survey of 1866." In
my report on this survey I said that the channel remained the same and
that no appropriation was needed until "1the channel is found to be in-
adequate to the necessities of commerce, and then dredging must be
resorted to."
     In 1870 a petition of citizens of Bridgeport was presented to Con-
gress asking that an appropriation " be made to remove said sand-bar"
 (the outer bar) " and to widen and deepen said channel and harbor in
order that vessels drawing 12 feet of water may be enabled to enter
without being grounded and without the aid of lighters," and a sur-
vey or examination of the harbor was ordered. The work was then in
charge of General Warren, U. S. Engineers ; he made an examination
of the harbor and found it unnecessary to make further surveys. In
his report, dated January 12, 1871, General Warren submits a project
for dredging a channel 100 feet wide and 12 feet deep at extreme low
water (or 14 feet at mean low water), and for building a pier 3,000 feet
  long extending out from Long Beach, to be partly of riprap, partly of
dolphins; the estimated cost of the project was $124,000. After an ap
propriation of $20,000 was made in 1871, work under this project was
  begun. dredging to depths of 12 and 13 feet at mean low water, and
substituting a riprap jetty for the riprap and dolphins ; the jetty was
completed as far as deemed necessary in 1873. In 1875 the dimensions
  of the projected channel were modAfied, so as to make it 12 feet deep at
mean low water and from 200 to 300 feet wide; this was accomplished in
  1882.
      In 18,78, in compliance with the terms of the appropriation act of
  that year, a channel 100 feet wide and 9 feet deep was dredged from the
  Lower Bridge to to  the Horse-railroad Bridge, a distance of about 3,000
  feet.
      After the appropriation of 1882, a project for widening to 600 feet
  the channel between the inner beacon and the Naugatuck Railroad
  Wharf was adopted, to prevent overcrowding of the main channel by
  vessels entering to seek refuge during storms ; the estimated cost was
  $60,000. This is nearly completed, a small area near the inner beacon
  remainining to be dredged.
   OPERATIONS    DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1888.
   Under the unexpended balance of the last appropriation, proposals
were received for dredging to remove a shoal point on the west side of
the channel near the Inner Beacon, and a contract, dated May 16, 1888,
was entered into with Messrs. Henry DuBois Sons, of New York City,
to dredge about 14,000 cubic yards at the rate of 14 cents per yard.
  Work under this contract was begun June 19, and completed June 30,
14,000 cubic yards being removed from the southeast part of the shoal
point, making 12 feet depth at mean low water when the depth had been
from 5 to 12 feet.
                PRESENT CONDITION OF       IMPROVEMENT.
   The 12-foot channel is 75 feet wide on the outer bar, but for 200 feet
width there is a depth of 11 feet or over; thence across the inner bar
and up to the inner beacon the 12-foot channel is about 300 feet wide;
               APPENDIX                      D-REPORT                              OF           LIEUT.              COL. HOUSTON.                                          557
thence up to the Naugatuck Railroad Wharf it is 600 feet wide; above
that wharf it has shoaled so that the present depth is from 10 to 11 feet.
   The breatkwater out from Long Beach has settled since it was built;
it still serves the purpose for which it was designed and no repairs are
now needed.
   The prject of 188. for making 600 feet width of channel between the
Inner Beacon and the Naugatuk Railroad Wharf was reported in the
last annual report as completed. The inner beacon has been rebuilt
and its location slightly changed, which mades it desirable to cut off a
shoal point outside the new position of that beacon; this has been
nearly finished under a contract just completed.
                                                     PROPOSED OPERATIONS.
   The channel from the Naugatuck Railroad Wharf up to the Lower
Bridge has shoaled about 2 feet. With future appropriations it is pro-
posed to remove the shoals and to widen the channel eastward to the
harbor line an additional width of about 200 feet. The estimated cost
of this work is $17,000 (for details of estimate see Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1887, Part I, page 611); it could de done to ad-
vantage in a single year.
   The annual cost of maintaining the dredged channel in this harbor
is estimated at $2,000.
   Appropriations for the improvement of Bridgeport Harbor have been
made as follows, viz:

      Date.                                                                  Application.                                                                          Amount.


July    4, 1836     Dredging outer bar ..................                                            ..........................                          ......        $10, 000.00
Aug.   30, 1852     Dredging outer and inner bars.....--...........................                                                               ._.     .....          10, 000. 00
June   23, 1866     Survey .------.-----------------------------------------------------------.........................................................                   1, 985. 38
July   11, 1870    ......o .---.....---..........-------------.............................................---------------------------------------------.                       00.00
Mar.    3, 1871     Dredging and 521 feet of breakwater.....................----------------------............----------------.                                         20, 000.00
June   10, 1872     Dredging and 859 feet of breakwater. .-------------.--------.. ----..-..                                                                         .  40, 000.00
Mar.    3,1873      Dredging inner bar and upper harbor..................                                                                ...............                30, 0       00
June   23, 18-4     Dredging, bridge to Long Island Sound (9 feet)....... ................                                                                       ...    20, 000.00
Mar.    3, 1875     Dredging, bridge to Long Island Sound (12 feet) ...........................                                                                         15, 000.00
Aug.   14,1876      Dredginu upper harbor (9 feet) ............................................                                                                         10, 000.00
June   18, 1878     Dredging above bridge and outer bar (9 and 12 feet) . ............                                                                    ..... .!10,         000. 00
Mar.    3, 1879     Dredging, bridge to Long Island Sound (12 feet) ...................                                                                         ......  10, 000.00
June   14, 1880    ....    o.......                                                                                                                      ........             0..0....0.00................
                                                                                                                                                                          0.....
                                                                                                                                                                        10,000.00
Mar.    3, 1881     Dredging above inner beacon (12 feet)......                                                              ....     ..........          .. ...        10, 000. 00
Aug.    2, 1882     Dredging between inner beacon and railroad wharf (12 feet)......... ......                                                                          10, 000. 00
July    5,1884     ...... do ...................................................................                                                                          5,000.00
Aug.    5, 188ij   ....    o .................................................................                                                                       .   20, 000. 00

                             Total .................---------..................                                                        .....    ..........           232, 485. 38


     Bridgeport, the port of entry for the collection district of Fairfield, is situated about
2 miles from Long Island Sound, at the head of Bridgeport Harbor. There is a light-
house at the entrance to the harbor.                                               Fort Hale, New Haven Harbor, the nearest
work of defense, is 18 miles east.
                                                                  Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available... .....                                                  ......      ..........            .............            __.           $2, 47. 07
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
     liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887..............                                                        .... ......                      $321.01
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities....                                               .....          .....        ..       ....              1,960. 00
                                                                                                                                                         -          2, 281.01

July 1, 1888, balance available .... ........ ............   ..                                                                     .....        ......                  197. 06
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .... ............                                                                                 .......           10,    000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 18-9 .................                                                                                           10, 197.006
     Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project......     .7, 000. 00
     Amountthat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 180    7,000. 00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
t     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
558               REPORT                    OF       THE CHIEF                                OF             ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY,

Abstract of bids for dredging in Bridgeport Harbor, Connecticut, opened at Engineer Office,
                          U.                            S.
                               .Army, .New York, April 21, 1888.


                                                                                              Rate     Total for
No.               Names and address of bidders.                                             per cubic 30,000 cubic                                          Remarks.
                                                                                              yard.      yards.


                                                                                                 Cents.
  1     Townsend & Fennell, Boston, Mass.......                                                     19                $5,700. 00           But one bid received.
  2     AlonzoJ. Beardsley and George D. Beards-                                                    141                4, 387. 50          Date of beginning work was
         ley, West Stratford, Conn.                                                                                                         changed by bidders to " on
                                                                                                                                            or before June 15, 1888."
 *3     Charles DuBois and Henry N. DuBois,                                                               14            4, 200. 00
            New York City.
  4     Hartford Dredging Company, Hartford, i                                                            16            4, 800. 00
         Conn.

                           * Entered into contract May 16, 1888; contract completed June 30, 1888.

                                      Commercial statistics for the calendar year of 1888.


                                                                                                                                                               No.             Tonnage.


Foreign commerce:
      Arrivals ................................................................                                                                                       10             1, 365
      Departures........... ....                                ............................ .............                   ................                              8         1, 605
Domestic commerce: Arrivals and departures                                                ....................................... ....                         15, 939          1, 195, 760


                                                         ESTIMATED                      VALUE                    OF CARGOES.

Receipts.-. ----- ------.---------..-..------ ------ ------...------ ------. $39, 000, 000
Shipments......-----....--------....---......---....--- ----....---....-----------....---....--------....--............... 38, 000, 000

                                                     VESSELS              ARRIVING                        AND         DEPARTING.


                                                (Draught, 6 to 18 feet ; tonnage, 50 to 1,200 tons.)
                                                                                                                                                                                Number.
Steamers......-             -......----........---                ...................................---......                                                                     4,911
Sailing vessels ....----------......---......---................       .-----------------......------
                                                                                      ......----......---------....--                                                              5, 509
Barges----- --........---..... ..----
                                  ................---..          ............     .... ...----..........                                                                           5,519
             Total ......------....--....---................-------...-------                                     ......----..-- ....-------....------------....----....
                                                                                                                 ---                                                              15,939

      Vessels carrying 212,000 tons of coal entered the harbor for refuge during 1886.




                                                                                           D Io.
                   IMPROVEMENT OF BLACK ROCK HARBOR, CONNECTICUT.

   This harbor, 1 miles long from northeast to southwest, and from 300
to 2,500 feet wide, lies between the mainland on the west and Fair-
weather Island on the east, and includes the navigable part of Cedar
Creek, a small tidal inlet which extends up into the western part of the
city of Bridgeport, and affords water communication of great value to
several large manufactories in its immediate neighborhood. It is in the
interest of the city of Bridgeport that the improvement of Black Rock
Harbor is desired.
   The depth in the lower part of the harbor is from 6 to 12 feet at mean
low water; this part of the harbor was formerly much used as a refuge
for vessels overtaken by storms, but it is not deep enough for most ves-
sels now engaged in commerce through the Sound. Before work was
               APPENDIX                  D-REPORT                     OF       LIEUT.            COL. HOUSTON.                     559
done in Cedar Creek the depth there was from 2 to 4 feet, and the chan-
nel was narrow and crooketd.
  The head of the harbor was separated from Long Island Sound on the
southeast by a broad, flat sand-bar, which was bare at about half-tide,
and which joined Fairweather Island with the main shore.
                                       PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENTS.

   Between 1836 and 1838 $21,500 were expended in building a sea-wall
across a breach in the southern part of Fairweather Island to preserve
the light-house reservation at the south end of the island, and to pre-
vent shoaling on the anchorage-ground.
   In 1882 a survey of the harbor was ordered by Congress, which was
made in 1883. In his report on this survey, dated December 12, 1883,
and printed in Senate Ex. Doc. No. 50, Forty-eighth Congress, first ses-
sion, also in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1884 (Part
I, page 666), Colonel McFarland, U. S. Engineers, submitted a project
providing-
   (i) For protecting the upper part of the harbor from the sea by building
a breakwater over the bar northeast of Fairweather Island, to be about
a half mile long and 6 feet wide at the top, which was to be 3 feet above
mean high water or 10 feet above low water.
   (2) For making a channel 80 feet wide and 6 feet deep at mean low
water, extending up Cedar Creek.
   The estimated cost was-
Breakwater------..---....------.....-----------------......----....--......        --..-----.............--------- $58, 000.00
                                                                            -------........---..--..
Dredging------------------ ----.---.----------------------------                           ...                      22,000. 00
         Total-....---------------.......-----...............---------.------..---.................--..---......----   ------ SO, 000. 00
   Work under this project was begun in 1885, and up to July 1, 1887,
the breakwater had been built to its full length in order to prevent the
currents from cutting a channel across the bar, but its cross-section was
less than designed, both in height and width; also a channel had been
dredged as far up Cedar Creek as the Forge Company's Wharf, with a
width of 57 feet and a depth which was originally made 6 feet at mean
low-water, but which had shoaled on the southeast side to from 4 to 6 feet.
   OPERATIONS                   DURING              THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1888.

  The contract of October 22, 1886, with Elijah Brainard, of New York
City, for dredging in Cedar Creek, which was in progress at the date of
the last annual report, was completed October 14, 1887, 24,868 cubic
yards being dredged since July 1, 1887. The total amount of material
removed under this contract was 46,368 cubic yards, and the channel
was made 60 feet wide and 6 feet deep from the 6-foot curve in the har-
bor to a point opposite the Forge Company's Wharf, and was extended
with a less width about 430 feet farther. During the first part of the work
dredged material was mostly pumped up and deposited on the marsh
lands for filling, and in order to get more material the contractor fre-
quently dredged deeper than required; the amount thus dredged from
below the required depth- during the whole contract is estimated at
11,240 cubic yards, which amount was not accepted nor paid for, and is
not included in the amount above reported.
                              PRESENT CONDITION OF IMPROVEMENT.

   The sea-wall built in 1836-1838 across a breach in Fairweather Island
is still effective in preserving the island and in preventing the sea from
washing over into the harbor.                                      It needs some repair.
560         REPORT               OF THE                CHIEF              OF       ENGINEERS,                      U. S. ARMY.

   The breakwater between Fairweather Island and the mainland is built
to its full length, 2,744 feet, with diminished cross-section.
  The 6-foot channel has been dredged to the full width projected-80
feet-but that part dredged in 1884 has shoaled nearly 2 feet, so that
the present available width of channel is but 60 feet; it extends up
the harbor to a point opposite the Forge Company's Wharf.
                                               PROPOSED                      OPERATIONS.

   With future alpropriations it is proposed to complete the channel to
its projected widih of 80 feet, to extend it up the harbor, and to build
up the breakwater to the dimensions projected ; $20,000 could be profit-
ably expended on the work during the next fiscal year.
   Appropriations for the improvement ot Black Rock Harbor have been
made as follows, viz:

    Date.                                                            Application.                                                                  Amount.

1836-1838 ....   Building sea wall in Fairweather Island .--..--......------..-----------............------------..........                          $21, 500
Aug. 2,1882.I    Survey---..--------.......--------------.....--...-----..........----------.........--..-----------------...................             350
July 5, 1884.    Building breakwater and dredging....----------------...----------............--...---...--..--.                              --      20, 000
Aug. 5,1886.     Dredging--------------------..                           --------------------------------------
                                                                      .....               ..                  ....                                     5, 000
                        Total--------------.................---.............----------------------------------------                                  46, 850


  Black Rock Harbor is in the Fairfield collection district, of which Bridgeport is the
port of entry.  There is a light-house at the harbor entrance.        Fort Hale, New
Haven Harbor, the nearest work of defense is, 20 miles east.

                                     Money stalttefent.
July 1, 1887, amount available ......----------......-- ---------......-----------
                                                                      ......----......--...........                                            $2, 531. 59
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ......----......-----......---------......----....      ...---......... ---
                                                                              ..--------                                                           2,391. 29

July 1, 1888, balance available ...---------..---.... ---------.....----......
                                                                           ------.......------...---......            140. 30
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188                                           -........-------..-----..
                                                                                                    ..----------. 10, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .........                                                            ......--..          10, 140.30

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project -....                                                                       45, 000. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30,1890                                                                   20, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



Abstract of contract for inproring Black Rock Harbor, Con necticut, in force during the
                            fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.


   Name and address of con-                         Date.                S                Price per                             Remarks.
          tractor.                                                                       cubic yard.

Elijah Brainard, New York                      Oct. 22, 1E86          Dredging                     $0.09       Contract completed October
  City.                                                                                                         14, 1887.


                     COMMERCIAL STATISTICS                            FOR TtE             CALENDAR YEAR                      1886.


  In 1886 there were 13 manufacturing firms located near the head of the harbor,
using coal and raw materials amounting to about 40,000 tons annually, of which
23,500 tons were received by water; the rest was carted from Bridgeport or received
by rail. The amount of material received by water has nearly doubled since the im-
provement of the harbor began in 1884.
         APPENDIX    D-REPORT       OF    LIEUT.    COL. HOUSTON.     561

                                   DII.

        IMPROVEMENT OF SOUTHPORT HARBOR, CONNECTICUT.
  This harbor consists of the mouth of a small stream called Mill River
and of a broad, shallow bay on the north shore of Long Island Sound,
about 6 miles west of Bridgeport. Before any Government work was
done in this harbor the navigable low-water depth was less than 2 feet,
and the channel was in danger of being quite filled by drift-sand from
the beach to the east.
  The mean rise of tide is 6.6 feet.
                     PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

   In 1827 a survey of Mill River (Southport Harbor) was made by
Lieut. Col. John Anderson, U. S. Engineers, in order to ascertain " the
expediency of removing the obstructions to navigation thereof and of
protecting the same." With the report on this survey, dated February
19, 1827, was submitted a project for a stone breakwater on the east
side of the channel from high water to low-water line, for a dike of earth
and sod extending up-stream along the edge of the marsh, and for chan-
nel dredging to make 2 feet depth at low water, at an estimated cost of
$6,096.18.
   By act of Congress approved March 2, 1829, $6,097 was appropriated,
and the work was carried out substantially as projected, the breakwater
being 1,320 feet long, 8 feet wide at top, which was 8, feet above com-
mon low water, and the dike being 1,350 feet long, 5 feet wide at top,
which was 1 foot above high water of spring-tides.
   In 1832 $4,490.23 were appropriated " for completing the breakwater
and dike, and deepening the channel," and in 1836 and 1837 $2,500
were appropriated for " securing the public works of the harbor of
Southport; " these sums, it is understood, were applied to repairing the
breakwater, to building storm revetments on either side of the dike, to
building beacons, and probably to dredging.
   By act of Congress approved July 11, 1870, a survey or examination
of Southport Harbor was authorized. General Warren, U. S. Engineers,
made an examination of the harbor, and in his report, dated January
14, 1871, and printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1871, page 823, submitted a plan for repairing and increasing the
height of the breakwater and dike, at an estimated cost of $12,225.
   March 3, 1875, $5,000 were appropriated " for the repair of the break-
water and piers at the harbor of Southport," which sum was applied to
raising the breakwater about 2 feet higher. With an appropriation of
$5,000, made in 1876, the dike was repaired and a channel 4 feet deep
and 60 feet wide was dredged through the bar at the harbor's mouth.
   In his Annual Report for 1878, Colonel Barlow, U. S. Engineers, rec-
ommended making the channel 4 feet deep and 100 feet wide, which
project was adopted, and under successive appropriations up to 1882
the channel was dredged 95 feet wide up to the south end of the break-
water, thence 80 feet wide up to White Rock, above which point it was
prolonged in a Y instead of widening it, in order better to accommodate
the harbor commerce. This substantially completed the project and
afforded all the harbor facilities that were then desired.
  OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR                ENDING JUNE 30, 1888.

  No work was done. The project for improvement is completed, and
the money appropriated is nearly all expended.
      ENGf88-   36
562           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY

                           PRESENT CONDITION OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The breakwater and dike are in fair condition, with no urgent need
of repairs. An examination in the fall of 1885 showed no material
changes in the channel; it had then an available depth of 4 feet at
mean low.water as far as dredged.
                                                  PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

The approved project is completed, and no repairs or further improve-
ments are required at present.
Appropriations for improving Southport Harbor have been made as
follows, viz :


     Date.                                                          Application.                                                      Amount.

Mar.    2, 1829    Breakwater, dike, and dredging..................                                .............    ...............    $6, 097. 00
July    3,1832      Completing breakwater and dike, building beacons, and a small amount                                                4, 0. 43
July    4,1836        of dredging.                                                                                                      1,500 00
Mar.    3,1837           dredging.                                                                                                      1,0000
July   11, 1870    Examination and report..................                         ...........................                       ,    500. 00
Mar.    3,1875     Repairs on breakwater .......                        .....................................                           5, 000.00
Aug.   14, 1876    RefTairs on dike and dredging .......................................                                                5, 000.00
June   14, 1880    Dredging upper harbor ................................................                                               2, 500.00
Mar.    3,1881     Dredging on bar..................             ........          ................................                     2, 500.00
Aug. 2, 1882 Dredging upper harbor..................................................                                                   3,000.00
                          Total.............................                        ..............................                    31,587.43



  Southport Harbor is in the Fairfield collection district, about 6 miles west of
Bridgeport, which is the port of entry. The nearest light-house ison Penfield's Reef,
31 miles east of the harbor. Fort Hale, New Haven Harbor, 24 miles east, is the
nearest work of defense.
                                                               Money Statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available..-........................................                                                               $79.60
July 1, 1888, balance available ....--..---------....---- --....--....-----.............----------..--...... .                           79. 60



                                                         COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  No statement of commerce has been received since 1883; it has not materially
changed since then, when the following estimates were presented:
Vessels arriving and departing.......... .......                               ......................
                                                                            ------....                                        175
Tonnage------......- --....--....--............................---------..-----
                                                         ----...----------                       ..--..-------....----.   10, 500
Average draught--......---......----...... .--..........-------..............----------------....               feet..          7
Receipts ;coal, lumber, miscellaneous .............                       .................                    tons..      6, 000
Shipments; chiefly farm produce, valued at.... .................                                          ........      $190, 000




                                                                   D   12.

               IMPROVEMENT OF NORWALK HARBOR, CONNECTICUT.

  Norwalk Harbor, or River, is a tidal estuary, with a narrow channel
extending about 3 miles north from Long Island Sound to the town
of Norwalk. Above Norwalk the river is a small fresh-water stream.
South Norwalk is on the west bank of the river, 1 miles below Norwalk.
At this point the river is crossed by two bridges; the lower one awagon
          APPENDIX D-REPORT              OF LIEUT. COL. HOUSTON.                563
bridge, and the other, 450 feet' above, the bridge of the New York, New
Haven and Hartford Railroad.
  In 1867 a company was incorporated under the laws of the State of
Connecticut for the improvement of this river. Little work was done,
and when the improvement was begun by the United States the low-
water depth to South Norwalk was 5 feet and to Norwalk but 1 foot.

                        PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.


  By act of March 2, 1829, Congress appropriated . $80 " for making
a survey of the harbor of -Norwalk, Conn., with a view to its im-
provement." The survey was made by Capt. Hartman Bache, U. S.
Engineers, who, in his report on the same, dated May 10, 1830, recom-
mended excavating the channel, proposing to build a steam-dredge for
the purpose, to cost-
For a channel 12 feet deep at ordinary high water....................... $15, 668.95
For a channel 10 feet deep at ordinary high water......................... 12, 286. 45
   No money was appropriated for carrying out this plan, and in 1871
another survey was ordered by Congress, which was made in the
same year. In his report upon the latter survey, dated December 16,
1871, and printed in Senate Ex. Doc. No. 23, Forty-second Congress,
second session, also in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1872, page 900, General Warren, U. S. Engineers, submitted a project
for dredging a channel 6 feet deep and 100 feet wide, from Long Island
Sound up to Norwalk, at an estimated cost of $34,000. In 1880 the
terms of the river and harbor act provided that " so much of said ap-
propriation ($5,000) as shall be necessary therefor shall be so expended
as to have a channel 6 feet deep at low water between the steam-boat
landing in said Norwalk and Long Island Sound." As a channel of the
projected width (100 feet) and depth of 6 feet at mean low water already
existed, this was interpreted to require a depth of six feet at extreme
low water (see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1881, Part
I, page 609), which would be 8 feet at mean low water, and the project
was accordingly modified to provide for obtaining that depth up to
South Norwalk.
   The latest estimate, made to include the cost of this modification and
of a large amount of dredging already required to maintain the depths,
places the total cost from the time of beginning work at $84,000.
  OPERATIONS        DURING THE       FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 188S.

  No work was done.
                  PRESENT CONDITION OF IMPROVEMENT.

   The channel below South Norwalk, which has been dredged 100 feet
wide and 8 feet deep at mean low water, has its full depth, with theo
width diminished by caving in of the banks, principally on the northeast
side of the cut. Above South Norwalk the channel is from 60 to 10()
feet wide and 6 feet deep at mean low water.
                            PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

  The estimated amount required to complete the existing project i.:
$7,000, which could be advantageously expended in a single year i7
564           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. h. ARMY.

widening and straightening the channel, and in deepening the parts
which have filled in since dredging.
  Smaller appropriations will be required from time to time to maintain
the channel after completion.
  Appropriations for improving Norwalk Harbor have been made as
follows, viz :

   Date.                                                                       Application.                                                                   Amount.

Mar.    2,1829        Survey ..............................................................................                                                         $80.00
Mar.    3,1871        .... do .           .......................... .................                      ...........................                          1,166. 66
June   10, 1872       Dredging (6 feet) above South Norwalk..............................                                                                       10, 000. 00
Mar.    3, 1873       .... do ..........................................................................                                                        10, 000.00
June   23, 1874       .-... do . ........-- ..          ...............................                            ...................---       ....            10, 000. 00
Mar.    3, 1875       Dredging (6 feet) below South Norwalk....................                                                          ........                7, 000. 00
June   18, 1878       .... do--..---.....--- ..--                        ---...............--------...............................                               6, 000. 00
Mar. 3,1879           Dredging (6 feet) above and below South Norwalk..--..----......------------............--.                                                10, 000. 00
June 14, 1880         Dredging (6 feet) below South Norwalk. .................           ................                                                        5, 000. 00
Mar.    3, 1881       Dredging (8 feet) below and (6 feet) above South Norwalk ...............                                                                   5, 000. 00
Aug. 2, 1882          Dredging (6 feet) above South Norwalk...................................                                                                   5, 000.00
July    5,1884        Dredging (8 feet) below South Norwalk                                    ..................-....                     ............          5, 000. 00
Aug. 5,1886           Dredging (6 feet) above South Norwalk ....................                                                  ..................             3, 000.00
                                Total ..........................                                        .        .. ......   ..       ....... .......     .     77, 246.66



   Norwalk is in the Fairfield collection district, and is about 11 miles west of Bridge-
port, the port of entry. Norwalk light-house is on Sheffield's Island, at the harbor en-
trance. The nearest work of defense is Fort Schuyler, at the head of Long Island
Sound, 29 miles southwest.
                                   Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available ......--..--...  ---.............. ....--..--......      $560. 04
July 1,'1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1887................-----...............----------......--......   56.94
July 1, 1888, balance available.... ........ ............................                                                                                         503. 10
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.... .... .................                                                                                      28, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.                                                            ...................                         28,503. 10
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project---. ..                                                                                       31, 900. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                                                                  31, 900. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                     COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR THE CALENDAR YEAR OF 1886.
Receipts................................... . . . . ...    _........... tons..                                                                                  297, 000
Shipments.----..-.................................................do...                                                                                         141,600
Vessels arriving and departing ; draught 9 to 10 feet :
    Steamers ..............                ... ..................     .....                                              .......... number..                       1,269
    Sail-vessels...... .....................................                                                                      ........ do....                    634
    Barges ..........................................................                                                                      do ....                   467
         Total..............................................................                                                                                       2,370




                                                                                 D 13.
                  IMPROVEMENT OF STAMFORD HARBOR, CONNECTICUT.
   This is a small harbor on the north shore of Long Island Sound, about
6 miles east of the New York State line. The harbor consists of a bay
about a mile long and a mile broad and of the mouth of Mill River, a
small stream which is dammed at Oliver Street Bridge, at the head of the
              APPENDIX            D--REPORT OF LIEUT.                       COL. HOUSTON.                     565
harbor. The original low-water depth for a mile below the bridge was
from 1 to 3 feet in a crooked channel, and the 6-foot curve in the bay was
about 6,600 feet below the bridge; the wharves are all in the upper half
of this distance.
   The mean rise of tides is 7.9 feet.
                                  PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

  By act of March 2, 1829, Congress appropriated $100 for " making a
survey of the harbor of Stamford, Conn., with a view to its improvement."
The survey was made by Capt. Hartman Bache, U. S. Engineers, in 1829;
in his report on the same, dated May 10, 1830, Captain Bache recom-
mends excavating the channel, proposing to build a steam-dredge for
the purpose, to cost-
For a channel 12 feet deep at ordinary high water (about 4 feet at mean
  low water)---------------............................... ............................ $13, 250.00
For a channel 10 feet deep at ordinary high water.......................                 11, 035.20

        Total................. .......................................                                   24,285.20
  No money was appropriated for carrying out this plan.
  The river and harbor bill of 1882 authorized a survey of this harbor,
which was made in the following year. In his report on this survey,
dated December 12, 1883, printed in Senate Ex. Doc. No. 50, Forty-
eighth Congress, first session, also in the Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1884, Part I, page 672, Colonel McFarland, U. S. Engi.
neers, submitted a project for dredging a channel 80 feet wide and 5
feet deep at mean low water from deep water in the bay up to Oliver
Street Bridge, estimated to cost as follows:
Dredging 80,000 cubic yards of mud, at 20 cents.............                  ---   ....        .....       . $16, 000
Contingencies ....--------------.----........-...---...... -----..---......--     ---.........--.......--..--...
                                                                                                       ...---. 4,000
        Total-. ......     --......- ......-...............           ..   ....-......---......-......       20,000
  It was not intended to include the removal of the ledge under and
just below the bridge.
  The beginning of work under this project was approved by the Sec-
retary of War, August 30, 1886, after the first appropriation for im
proving the harbor had been made.
   OPERATIONS             DURING THE FISCAL                     YEAR ENDING              JUNE 30, 1888.

   The contract with the Hartford Dredging Company, of Hartford,
Conn., dated January 18, 1887, which was in progress at the date of my
last annual report, was completed October 14, 1887. Since July 1,
1887, 30,846 cubic yards were dredged, which, with 23,616 cubic yards
previously dredged, makes a total of 54,462 cubic yards under the
contract.
   The 5-foot channel was made 75 feet wide for more than one-half its
projected length, and 50 feet wide the rest of the distance, except that at
its lower end, where the mud is very soft and the depth but a few inches
scant, it was dredged only 25 feet wide.
                         PRESENT CONDITION OF IMPROVEMENT.

   The condition of the channel July 1, 188S, is as described above; this
is the first public work of improvement done in Stamford Harbor.
                                         PROPOSED OPERATIONS.
   Future appropriations will be expended in accordance with the ap-
proved project; $10,000, the remainder of the total estimate, could be
566                REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

profitably expended during the next fiscal year in completing the proj-
ect.
  Appropriations for improving Stamford Harbor have been made as
follows, viz :

        Date.                                                                      Application.                                               Amount.

Mar. 2,
Marug.   1829
      2, 1829              Survey
                           Survey        .---..-..- .
                                             ------------------------..._..-------..--------------- $100
                            do.....................................................................35$100
                                                                                                      350
Aug. 2, 1882  do.
Aug. 5, 1886 Dredging ..............                                      .......
                                                                                ........
                                                                                       .....
                                                                                          ...........                       ............... 10, 000
                                                                                                                        .......

                                     Total .........
                                                   ......
                                                       ........
                                                            ...
                                                              .....
                                                                  .. .. . ......--..        10, 450
                                                                                ..............

  Stamford Harbor is in the Fairfield collection district, of which Bridgeport is the port
of entry. There is a light-house on the middle ground at the harbor entrance. The
nearest work ofdefense is Fort Schuyler, Throg's Neck, N. Y., 20 miles to the southwest.

                                                                     Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available ........................ ............ ......$5,693.74
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ............................ .............--.... 5,469.66

July 1, 1888, balance available......-....................................                                                                      224.08
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ...... ..................                                                                       5,000. 00


 {Amount
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.---................
                                                                      -----
            (estimated) required for completion of existing project -...
    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30,1890
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                                                                              5,224.08
                                                                                                                                             5,000.00
                                                                                                                                             5, 000. 00
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


Abstract of contractfor improving Stamford Harbor, Connecticut, in force during the fiscal
                               year ending June 30, 1888.

                             Name and address of contractor.                                              Date of contract.     onbject of   Price per
                                                                                                                               contract.     cubic yard.

                                                                                                                                               Cents.
The Hartford Dredging Company, Hartford, Conn.*........ January 18,1887                                                        Dredging .          15. 7

                                                         *Contract completed October 14, 1887.

             COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1887.


                                                                                                                       No. Tonnage of        Value of
                                                                                                                            cargoes.         cargoes.


Vessels arrived                        ..............................................                                  126        22,171 $162, 559. 50
Vessels departed..............................                                          ....................            20         1,100   35, 000. 00


                                                                                 RECEIPTS.


                                                                                                                     No. of       Tons.       Value.
                                                                                                                    cargoes.

tioal. ......     ......................................................           . 64                                           14, 485    $74, 957. 50
Lumber ..................           ..........   ........... .....................   15                                            3,927      56,250.00
Miscellaneous .....................            ................................. 47                                                3,759      31, 352.00

   Maximum draft of vessels entering, 12 feet.

   The above is only commerce by water and does not include what comes into town
Via "the canal"'-a private channel; the latter is said to be twice as much as the
above amounts. Probably much of it will come by way of Mill River when the chan-
nelis fairly opened.
              APPENDIX D-REPORT OF LIEUT.                                  COL. HOUSTON.            567

                                                  D 14.

            IMPROVEMENT OF PORT CHESTER HARBOR, NEW YORK.

   This harbor consists of the lower part of the Byram River, and a bay
at its mouth opening into Long Island Sound. This river, for about 1l
miles from its mouth, forms the dividing line between the State of New
York and Connecticut. It was formerly navigable to a point within a
few hundred feet of the bridge at Port Chester, a little more than 1 mile
from the mouth.
  Before improvement, the depth below the wharves was in some
places as little as 1 foot at mean low water. The mean rise of tide is
74 feet.
                                    PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

  A survey of this harbor was made in 1871, and a project based on
this was submitted and adopted. It provides for the removal of two
rocks: Sunken Rock at the entrance to the bay, with 57 feet low-water
depth, to be removed to 11 feet depth, and Salt Rock, about 1,000 feet
above the mouth of the river, partly bare at low water, to be removed
to 9 feet depth, also a breakwater 400 feet long at Byram Point. The
estimated cost of the whole was as follows, viz:
Sunken Rock, 1,474.5 cubic yards, at $40.......... ......................                         $58,980
Salt Rock, 316.3 cubic yards, at $40 ........................................                      12, 652
Breakwater at Byram Point ....................                     .......... ......   .......     25, 000
       Total ..........................           ..      ....................             ....   96,632
  Under this project Salt Rock was removed in 1873. No further work
was d.one until 1884, when a survey of the channel was made under the
appropriation of August 2, 1882, and a project for expending the funds
available in 1884 (about $16,000) based on this survey was submitted
and approved. It provided for making a channel from 60 to 100 feet
wide and 21 feet deep at mean low water from the bay to the vicinity of
the bridge at Port Chester. This modification was made in deference
to the wishes of the business men of Port Chester. The channel was
completed to within 150 feet of the bridge in May, 1885. A contract
was entered into, May 15, 1886, with M. K. Pidgeon for the hire of the
necessary plant for straightening and leveling the channel, and remov-
ing lumps left by the previous contractor both in the river and bay.
This contract was completed July 22, 1886, 9,232 cubic yards of sand
and gravel having been removed.
   OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1888.

   No work has been done.
                          PRESENT CONDITION             OF IMPROVEMENT.

  Salt Rock has been effectually removed. No work has yet been done
upon Sunken Rock, nor upon the breakwater at Byran Point.
  An available channel 2 feet deep at mean low water, and from 60 to
100 feet wide to a point 150 feet below the bridge, and 25 feet wide to
the bridge, has been made, and the bottom in front of the wharves,
where vessels have to lie at low tide, has been made as nearly level as
possible.
 568               REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                    PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

   Future appropriations will be applied to a continuation of the project.
Appropriations for the improvement of Port Chester Harbor, New York,
have been made as follows, viz:

       Date.                                                                 Application.                                                                  Amount.


June 10, 1872           Removing Salt Rock.........................................................                                                           $12, 000
Aug. 2, 1882            Dredging in Byram RIiver and Bay ..........            .......
                                                                               -      ....--...                                                   ..--.        15, 000
                               Total--..--...---..-..--.....----------------------........-----------......-..---.......                                       27, 000


  Port Chester Harbor is in the collection district of New York. The nearest light-
house is on Great Captain's Island, 11 miles east of the mouth of the harbor. The
nearest work of defense is at Throg's Neck, about 15 miles southwest.

                                                            Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..........................                                                                   .....   ..... ......             $24.77
July 1, 1888, balance available ............ . ..  .     .............                                                                                         24.77
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..........................                                                                                    5, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889..........                                                                     .........              5,024. 77
    SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... -.
    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890
                                                                                                                                                          64, 632. 00
                                                                                                                                                          20, 000. 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of the river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




                                                          COMMERCIAL                     STATISTICS.


                                                Arrivals and departures of vessels.


                                                           Kind.                                                                           Number. Tonnage.

Steamers ...    .....................               .......       ..............................---             ........                            314        54.170
Sailing-vessels .---...........                 ... .. .............................................                                                320        17, 600
Barges, etc ...................................                                     ............................----                                590       118, 250
          Total..--....--------------------------------...                          ..                ------------.......                        1,224        190,020


  The draught of vessels trading at Port Chester ranges from 5 to 8 feet.                                                                               Their ton-
nate ranges from 25 to 275 tons.
                                                                           Cargoes.

                                                                                                                                                Tons.       Value.

Shipments ....................................................                                                                                   4, 530     $283, 050
Receipts.............                     .-       ....          .............................
                                                                                    .                                                           43, 870      842, 920
          Total ..................................                         ....          ..........                                             48, 400    1, 125, 970


The principal articles of commerce are manufactured goods, coal, iron, building
materials, and general merchandise.
           APPENDIX                  D--REPORT OF LIEUT.                                           COL. HOUSTON.                             569

                                                                   D 15.

           IMPROVEMENT OF MAMARONECK HARBOR, NEW YORK.

  Mamaroneck Harbor, on the north shore of Long Island Sound, about
5 miles west of the Connecticut State line, consists of an open, shallow
bay and a narrow tidal inlet about a mile long.
  The channel to the old Steam-boat Wharf (about l1alf-way up the inlet)
had a depth of 5 feet at mean low water; from there to the upper
wharves the depths gradually decreased to 1 foot. Near its mouth the
inlet was obstructed by several rocks. The mean rise of tide at Mama-
roneck is about 8 feet.

                                     PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

  A survey of the harbor was made in 1881, and a project for improve-
ment based on this survey was submitted and adopted, providing for
the removal of Round Rock to a depth of 4 feet at mean low water,
and five other rocks to a depth of 7 feet; for dredging a channel 7 feet
deep and 100 feet wide from the Sound to the old Steam-boat Wharf, and
thence 4 feet deep and 80 feet wide to the upper wharves, and for clos-
ing the small channel east of Grassy Knoll, at an estimated cost of
$43,000. In 1881 Round Rock was removed to a depth of 4 feet, and
Bush Rock and Inner Steam-boat Rock to 7 feet at mean low water, *t
a cost of $13,000, not including supervision and contingencies.

  OPERATIONS               DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING                                                             JUNE           30, 1888.

  The available funds were not sufficient to continue work under the
project.
                        PRESENT CONDITION OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The available depth of channel has not changed since the original
survey. The removal of three rocks has made the upper harbor much
safer of access.
                                             PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

  It is proposed, when funds are appropriated for that purpose, to com-
plete the existing project by removing the other dangerous rocks and
by dredging in the channel. This could be completed to advantage in
a single year.
  Appropriations for improving Mamaroneck Harbor have been made
as follows, viz:

   Date.                                                           Application.                                                            Amount.

Mar. 3, 1881   Survey.............--------------.............--------------....-----....--------.............--.......---............          $500
Aug. 2,1882    Removal of rocks.......................                              .......... ...................               .......     15, 000

                      Total ...............................................-----........--------...........                                  15, 500


Mamaroneck Harbor is in the collection district of New York; its commerce s
mainly of local importance. The nearest light-house is on Execution Rock, about 4
miles south; the fortifications at Throg's Neck, 9 miles southwest, are the nearest
works of defense.
570                  REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                             Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available..........................................                                                                                $220.55
July 1, 1888, balance available. .......                                                        .-----...      .........    - - -.......                 220. 55

   (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....
    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890
                                                                                                                                           ....         28, 000
                                                                                                                                                        28, 000
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                                                    COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                            Arrivals and departures of vessels.

                                                                Description.                                                               Number. Tonnage,

Steamers .....................                        ............................              ...... ..................                          92     13, 800
Sailing-vessels...................................................................                                                                142     11, 720
Barges, etc ......................................................................                                                                124     21, 700
           Total......................................................... ............                                                            358     47,220


  The draught of vessels trading at Mamaroneck ranges from 41 to 61 feet.                                                                                Their
tonnage ranges from 30 to 175 tons.
                                    Cargoes.

                                                                                                                                            Tons.       Value.


Shipments......................................................................                                                              1, 151      $23, 087
Receipts............                       ..........................................                                                       23, 835      304, 305

          Total .....................................................................                                                       24, 986      327, 392


  The principal articles of commerce are coal, building materials, farm produce, and
general merchandise.



                                                                                        D i6.

         IMPROVEMENT OF ECHO HARBOR, NEW ROCHELLE, NEW YORK.

  Echo Harbor is a bay on the north shore of Long Island Sound,
distant about 22 miles by water from the Battery at New York. It is
land-locked except toward the southeast, and has a good anchorage.
Nearly all of the water transportation of the town of New Rochelle is
carried on through this harbor.
  The depth in the bay varies from 6 to 15 feet at mean low water,
though the low-water channel up to the wharves is only from 1 to 2
feet deep.
     The mean rise of tide is 7.3 feet.
                      PROJECT FOR IMPROVEMENT.

  A survey was made in 1875, and a project based on it was submitted
December 20, 1875, and subsequently adopted, providing for the
removal of two rocky reefs from the channel, viz:
(1) Sheepshead Reef, lying midway between Echo                                                   Island and DuckPoint,
   which had 1.6 feet of water upon it at low tide.                                              This wasto be removed
  to a depth of 9 feet at low water, which required                                              the excavation of 872. 5
  cubic yards of rock, costing.....    .... .......                                               ....................    $21,201. 75
               APPENDIX D-REPORT                                          OF LIEUT.                COL. HOUSTON.                                   571.
(2) Start Rock, which projected about 2 feet above low water, and lay in
   the channel 120 feet from Beaufort Point. This was to be removed to
   7* feet below low water, requiring the excavation of 370 cubic yards of
   rock, costing ........................................................-------------- $12, 672.50
Contingencies.................                .....................................       5, 081. 13
        Total---...        --.......-           ---................           ...............------...                      .....     .       38, 955. 38
  A depth of 7 feet over Start Rock was obtained in January, 1880, and
in 1881-'83, 506 cubic yards were removed from the southern part of
Sheepshead Reef, making 9 feet depth.

  OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1888.

   The money available was not enough to continue the projected work,
and nothing was done.

                            PRESENT CONDITION OF IMPROVEMENT.

  Start Rock has been removed to the required depth, 7 feet at mean
low water, and about one-half of Sheepshead Reef has been removed to
9 feet depth. The condition of the channel is otherwise about the
same as before the improvement, no other work having been done.

                                               PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

  With future appropriations the removal of Sheepshead eef will be
completed. Twenty-two thousand dollars have been appropriated for
this project ; with the balance of the estimate, $17,000, the project could
be advantageously completed in a single year.
  Appropriations for improving Echo Harbor, New Rochelle, N. Y.,
have been made as follows, viz:


     Date.                                                           Application.                                                              Amount.

June 18,1878       Removal of Start rock ................................................................                                         $10, 000
Mar. 3, 1879 ...... do ..................................                   ....                     ........         .... ..............           3, 000
June 14, 1880 Removal of Sheepshead rock.............................................                                                               3,000
Mar. 3,1881 ......  do ................................                                             .....................                           3, 000
Aug. 2,1882 .-..... do ...........................................                                                          ...     .......         3, 000

                          Total ................................................................                                                   22, 000


  Echo Harbor is in the collection district of Now York. The nearest light-house is
on Execution Rock. The fortifications at Throg's Neck, 7 miles to the westward, are
nearest works of defense.

                                                           Money statement.

July 1, 1887, amount available ........................                                                  ........... ....                     $3, 043. 97
July 1, 1888, balance available ...................................                                                                            3,043.97

 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......         17, 000
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890      17,000
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
I harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
   * A mistake in printing the original report made this depth 6 feet.    This error has
been copied in subsequent reports.
572            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                      COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                  Arrivals and departures of vessels.

                                                     Description.                                                      Number. Tonnage.

Steamers .--------.... --....-------            ---------- ------------           --------------------                      276
                                                                                                                            27      22 080
Sailing vessels..---........---......................---..----................-------.------..............                  154     10, 500
Barges, etc .-------------.--------------------......----....--.....----------------..............                          196     29,400

        Total- .........          ............-         ..     ..      .....         ....   .     ..................        626     61, 980


                                                                      Cargoes.

                                                                                                                        Tons.     Value.


Shipments .........................................................................
Shipments...                                                                        " 8, 900 "$744, 075
Receipts          ------------------------------------------------------------        38, 900  $744, 075
        Total----------.....-------......................-----------------------------------------................       38,900    744,075


   The principal articles of commerce are coal, building materials, and general mer-
chandise.



                                                                        D I7 .

              IMPROVEMENT OF NEW ROCIELLE HARBOR, NEW YORK.

   New Rochelle Harbor is situated at the western end of Long Island
Sound, on its north shore, about 10 miles west of the boundary line be-
tween the States of New York and Connecticut. The harbor lies off
the southerly part of the town of New Rochelle, and Echo Harbor is off
the northerly part.
   New Rochelle Harbor consists of rather narrow and circuitous passages
bletween several rocky islands and reefs, which shelter it from rough
weather. It had originally an available depth of 8 to 9 feet at mean
low water; there were two rocks near the channel-way whose removal
was desired, and the narrowness of the deep-water channel made it dif-
ficult for vessels to turn.
                                             PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.

  A survey of New Rochelle Harbor was ordered by the act approved
June 14, 1880, and made in the same year. In the report of this survey,
January 28, 1881, a project for improvemept was submitted, contem-
plating the removal of Corning Rock to 12 feet depth at mean low water,
of Rock C to 9 feet depth, the dredging of a channel 100 feet wide and
8 feet deep around the south end of Glen Island to connect with the
channel around the north end of that island, and the removal of a reef
that obstructed the entrance to this dredged channel, the whole being
estimated to cost $40,825. The object of this dredging and rock removal
was to allow vessels to pass around the island, instead of having to turn
in the narrow channel.
  In 1881 the channel around Glen Island was dredged 100 feet wide
and 6 feet deep, and work was begun under a contract to remove the
reef at the channel entrance to 8 feet depth.
            APPENDIX            D--REPORT OF LIEUT.                              COL. HOUSTON.                      573
   The contract was extended, and in 1883 work. was abandoned by the
contractor while parts of the rock were still from 1 to 1I feet above the
plane of removal.
   In 1883 Corning Rock was removed to 11 feet depth by hired labor,
at a cost of about $34 per cubic yard; a large bowlder was removed
from near David's Island Wharf , and 10.6 cubic yards of loose rock were
removed from the reef at the entrance to the dredged channel, making
a depth of 7.5 feet there.
   An examination of the dredged channel and the rocks at the entrance
was made in April, 1887. By this examination, a reef was discovered,
not shown on the original survey, projecting about 40 feet into the pro-
posed channel, with a least depth of 6 feet; also a rock, known as Rock'
B, projecting about 10 feet into the proposed channel, with a least depth
of 29 feet. Authority was obtained, under date of April 30, 1887, to
complete the removal of the rocks at the entrance by hired labor,
and' to deepen the dredged channel to 8 feet at mean low water by
contract.
  OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1888.

  Under authority from the Chief of Engineers, dated July 13, 18S7,
the steam drilling-plant belonging to the improvement of the Raritan
River, New Jersey, was put in repair, the expense being borne equally by
the appropriation for improving the Raritan River and that for New Ro-
chelle Harbor. With this plant, the removal of the rocks at the entrance
to New Rochelle Harbor by hired labor was begun September 27, 1887,
and continued until November 30, 1887, when the work was closed for
the season. The work was resumed May 2, 1888, and completed May
31, 1888. Thirty-seven and ninety-two hundredths cubic yards of rock,
measured in place, were removed from Rock B, making 8 feet depth at
mean low water: 180.63 cubic yards of rock were removed from the
large rock discovered by the above-mentioned examination, giving a
minimum depth of 75 feet.
                       PRESENT           CONDITION OF IMPROVEMENT.

  A channel 100 feet wide, and with a mimimum depth of 7.5 at mean
low water, has been made through the rocks at the entrance. The
dredged channel has nearly retained its depth of 6 feet at mean low
water. No work has yet been done on Rock C.
                                     PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

  It is proposed to expend the funds now available in widening and
deepening the channel between Glen Island and the main land by
dredging.
  Appropriations for the improvement of New Rochelle Harbor have
been made as follows, viz:

   Date.                                                Application.                                             Amount.


Mar.   3,1881    Dredging and partial removal of rock at mouth of Glen Island Channel....                           $20,000
Aug.   2, 1882   Removing Corning Rock.................................................                              l, 000
                    Total..--.....   .    .... ......    ... ....... ........   ........   ...   ..-... ......      35, 000

  New Rochelle Harbor is in the collection district of New York. The nearest light-
house is on Execution Rock. The fortications at Throg's Neck, 7 miles west, are the
nearest works of defense.
574              REPORT OP THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                              Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available .....----------..--- -....
                                                       - -- - ------ -- .-----.    $6, 843.66
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ..--..........     ............ $7, 518. 69
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities......                                                               ..........                 190. 00
                                                                                                                                     19.......
                                                                                                                                                       7,708, 69
July 1, 1888, balance available ....                                        ..........................                              .....      . -     9, 134.97




                                                          COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                  Arrivals and departures of vessels.

                                                          Kind.                                                                             Number. Tonnage.

Steamers .--......................................----.........--...........--------------------.......                                       3, 358    1, 265, 400
Sailing vessels...................................................................................8                                                          1, 250
Barges, etc ..........--..                    .......................                    ............ ...... ..............--.                   580       443,900
         Total ..        .     ...............     ....        ......           ..--..       ..          --....................--             3,946     1,710, 550



    The draught of vessels trading at New Rochelle Harbor ranges from 5 to 9 feet.
Their tonnage ranges from 25 to 950 tons.
  Cargoes.--Receipts: tons, 10,850; value, $98,040. The principal articles of com-
merce are building materials and general merchandise. Over 700,000 passengers
were brought into the harbor during the year.




                                                                          D i8.
                   IMPROVEMENT OF EAST CHESTER CREEK, NEW YORK.
  East Chester Creek is a small tidal stream emptying into East Chester
or Pelham Bay. The bay is on the north side of Long Island Sound,
at its western end, being just east of Throg's Neck, and 20 miles by water
from the Battery at New York.
  The mean rise of tide is 7.1 feet.
  A reef of bowlders close to the course of vessels passing through the
draw of Pelham Bridge (near the mouth of the creek), made the entrance
dangerous.
  The available depth of Town Dock, 1 miles from the mouth, was, at
high water, rather over 7 feet. About the same depth could be carried
to Lockwood's, 24 miles from the mouth.
                                                 PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENT.
    The amount heretofore reported in the annual reports as the original
estimates, viz, $136,500, was for a partial project for an improvement
from Town Dock to a point 3,000 feet above Lockwood's, submitted in
1872. (Annual Report of Chief of Engineers for 1881, page 640.)
    In 1875, the project was modified by changing the location of the cut
from Lockwood's to Town Dock, involving rock excavation, at an addi-
tional cost of $10,000. (Letters from General Newton, dated September
24, 1875, and letter from the Chief of Engineers, dated September 28,
1875.)
    Since then, up to 1884, additional projects have been made and par-
tially carried out for improvement below Town Dock at an actual cost
of $22,600, and an additional estimated cost of $52,000. The original
         APPENDIX    D-REPORT OF LIEUT.         COL. HOUSTON.         575
estimate and the amounts required for completion of existing project
should, therefore, be increased by $84,600.
    The entire project thus far adopted consists of excavating a channel
9 feet deep at mean high water from Pelham Bridge to a point about
3,000 feet above Lockwood's,by removing bowlders and gravel from near
the draw of Pelham Bridge; by dredging a channel west of Goose
Island, 125 feet wide and 1,500 feet long ; and by dredging a cut 100 feet
wide and about 3,000 feet long, from Pell Point to the first bend above
Town Dock, and thence extending it by an easy curve through a marsh
and some rock cutting to Lockwood's, a stretch in which the natural
bed of the stream was very winding; a cut 3,000 feet long, 100 feet wide,
and 9 feet deep, was to be made above Lockwood's to serve both as a
'channel and tidal basin; the channel was also to be confined in certain
parts by timber dikes having an aggregate length of 5,800 feet. The
estimated cost of the whole is $221,100.
    The first work under this project was done in 1877. Since that time
the channel through the marsh and rock just below Lockwood's has
been made 100 feet wide and 9 feet deep at mean high water; the chan-
nel west of Goose Island has been dredged 125 feet wide and 9 feet deep
at mean high water; the bowlders in the vicinity of Pelham Bridge
draw have been removed; the channel just above and under the new
draw-bridge on the Boston road at Lockwood's has been dredged out; a
channel about 2,000 feet long and 9 feet deep at mean high water has
been dredged from Pell Point up to Town Dock, the width being 40 to
45 feet, gradually increasing to 90 feet at Town Dock, and 1,235 linear
feet of diking have been built.

  OPERATIONS     DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1888.

   A contract was entered into, July 11, 1887, with the Frank Pidgeon
Dredging Company of New York, for the removal ot about 30,000 cubic
yards of mud measured in scows, the work to be applied to widening
the channel and removing shoal spots. This contract was annulled by
authority of the Chief of Engineers, dated August 18, 1887, on account
of the contractor's failure to begin work within the time required. An
examination of the channel made in September, 1887, showed the exist-
ence of a channel 100 feet wide and 9 feet deep at mean high water
from the bay to Town Dock ; from Town Dock to Lockwood's there was
an available depth of about 8 feet at mean high water, in a narrow chan-
nel. Advertisement was made, proposals opened April 21, 1888, and a
contract entered into May 11, 1888, with the Hartford Dredging Com-'
pany, of Hartford, Conn., for the removal of 1,700 cubic yards of mud
measured in scows. Work was begun under this contract June 7, 1888,
and up to June 30, 1888, 1,772 cubic yards had been removed near Town
Dock.
               PRESENT CONDITION OF IMPROVEMENTS.

   There is a channel, 100 feet wide and 9 feet deep at mean high water,
from the bay to Town Dock; and a narrow channel, 8 feet deep at mean
high water, from Town Dock to Lockwood's. Above that no work has
been done.
                        PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

  Work will be continued under the contract with the Hartford Dredg-
ing Company. Future appropriations will be applied to completing
and maintaining the channel as projected.
576              REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   Appropriations for improving East Chester Creek have been made as
follows, viz:

       Date.                                                             Application.                                                Amount.

Mar.      3, 1873      Cutting through marsh and rock, and diking (in 1877) .....................                                        $25, 000
Mar.      3,1875       Dredging under Boston Road Bridge and at Goose Island ..----.................                                      12,000
,June 18,1878 Dredging near Lockwood's, Goose Island, and Pelham Bridge..............                                                     10, 000
Mar. 3, 1879 1 Dredging 40 to 90 feet wide from Pell'Point to Town Dock .. ...........                                                     3 500
                                                                                                                                           3,
June 14,1880                                                                                                                               3,500
Aug.      5,1886       Dredging above Town Dock (not yet expended)                              ........                        .         10,000
                              Total...............................................................................................        64, 000


  East Chester Creek is in the collection district of New York. The nearest light-
house is on the Stepping Stones, 3 miles southeast of the mouth of the creek. The near-
est work of defense is Fort Schuyler, Throg's Neck, about 3 miles south.

                                                             Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available................. ...             ... ... ...........     $9, 673.78
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ......-......-......                $1, 256. 18
Jly 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..........................                  797.40
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts ..........                6,852.60
                                                                                   -- _  8, 906. 18

July 1, 1888, balance available.......... ...............................                                                              767.60
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                                                              5,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889..................                                                              5,767. 60
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....... 152, 100. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 30, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.

Abstract of bids for dredging in East Chester Creek, New York, opened at Engineer Ofice,
                          U. S. Army, New York, April 21, 1888.

                                                                                                          Rate
No.                           Name and address of bidder.                                               per cubic             Remarks.
                                                                                                          yard.


                                                                                                            Cents.
  1     James McSpirit, Jersey City, N. J...........................                                           47%       Only one guarantor.
 *3     Hartford Dredging Company, Hartford, Conn ................                                             45
  a     Michael H. Flannery, New York City .........................                                           45

                                  * Contract awarded to the Hartford Dredging Company.



                                                       COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                Arrivals and departures of vessels.

                                                           Kind.                                                          Number.    Tonnage.

Sailing vessels.......... ..........                  ..      ....... ......... .......   ..............        ......           8           360
Barges, etc ..........................................                        --              ...........                       90        15,750
        Total          ..............................................                            ..............                 98        16, 110


  The draught of vessels trading in East Chester Creek ranges from 5 to 74 feet.
Their tonnage ranges from 30 to 200 tons.
  Cargoes.-Receipts,10,625 tons; value $61,075.
  The principal articles of commerce are coal and building materials.
               APPENDIX                D-REPORT                         OF      LIEUT.                 COL.            HOUSTON.                     577

                                                                       D I9.

               IMPROVEMENT OF GREENPORT HARBOR, NEW YORK.
   This harbor is a roadstead near the east end of the north fork of
Long Island, lying between this north fork on the northwest and north
and Shelter Island on the southeast and south. The anchorage-ground
is exposed to storms from the northeast and east.
   A sand-spit called Joshua's Point, formerly protected the little bay
at Greenport from easterly storms, but in the few years prior to 1883
this had worn away rapidly, and the sand had been carried out into the
bay.
   The mean rise of the tide is 2.4 feet.
                                       PROJECT FOR IMPROVEMENT.

  In 1881 a survey was made, and, with the report, a plan and estimates
based upon the survey were submitted, and subsequently adopted, for
a breakwater extending southeasterly from Joshua's Point. This
project consisted of a riprap breakwater about 1,700 feet long extend-
ing from high-water mark to the 18 foot curve, to be built 3 feet above
mean high-water level with a top width of 5 feet, and side slopes of 1
on 1, to contain about 23,000 tons of stone. Its estimated cost was
$46,000. Work under this project was begun in 1883, and in that and
the two following years 1,233 linear feet of the breakwater were built.
Under the appropriation of August 5, 1886, a contract was entered into
with James V. Luce, of Niantic, Conn., on October 27, 1886, for deliver-
ing 3,400 tons of stone on the breakwater. Work was begun May 18,
1887, and, up to June 30 of that year, 1,596 tons of stone had been de-
livered, extending the breakwater 92 feet.
  OPERATIONS DURING                                    THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1888.

  Work under the above contract was continued and completed, ex-
tending the breakwater 204 feet, giving it a total length of 1,437 feet,
and carrying it into 15.4 feet depth at mean low water; 14,7751 tons of
riprap granite have thus far been used in its construction.
                          PRESENT CONDITION OF IMPROVEMENT.

  The breakwater is in good condition as far as completed. No material
changes of depth in the harbor have occurred since the original survey.
                                                PROPOSED OPERATIONS.
   With further appropriations the breakwater will be completed as pro-
jected to the 18-foot curve. Twenty-five thousand dollars have been
appropriated for this work. The remainder of the estimate, $21,000,
could be profitably expended in completing the breakwater in one year.
   Appropriations for improving Greenport Harbor have been made as
follows, viz :

   Date.                                                               Application.                                                               Amount.


MIar. 3,1881
Mar.2,18812      Survey . ..-...breakwater
                 SExpended--"on  -- ....       ....      ...      ....     ..   ..    ....
                                               ---------------------------------------------  .   .                                                   $500
July   5,188     ...... do ......      ..... ...............................................                                                        10,000
Augy   5, 1886    -    o---------------------            ----------------          -----------------
                                                                                 ---.....                                                           1, 000
Aug    5,1886    ...... do      ..-.....        ....     ...........           ...    ....       --.     ...      ..    .....                        5, 000
                        Total................                           .    ......----------------------............           ..... .........     25,500

           ENG 88-                 37
578           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Greenport is a port of delivery in the collection district of Sag Iarbor. The near
est light-house is on Long Beach Point, 3 miles to the eastward. The nearest work
of defense is Fort Trumbull, New London Harbor, Connecticut, 21 miles distant in a
straight line.
                                 Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..---..--..--..                                                         .--        ----..        --............        $2, 957. 93
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.----------...------...--.......-----....--......---...-------....--------......                                                2,917.83
                                                   ----.....
                                                     ....
July 1, 1888, balance available.............. ......--       ....--......                                                                                     40.10
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888...................-......                                                                                   5, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889......-                                                               - -..........                  5, 040. 10


   Amount that canbe profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                                                           16, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                                         COMMERCIAL                      STATISTICS.

                                                Arrivals and departures of ressels.

                                                      Description.                                                                         Number.          Tons.


Steamers....-------------------------------------------------------------...                                                                     2,240       421,000
Sailing vessels....--.-- ---.--------------------------------------------                                                                        1,680       195, 750
Barges, etc....... -------..---..----             ..       ..................................                                                        16        7, 200

       Total .............................-------------------------------------------------------.                                               3, 936      623, 950


                                                                           Cargoes.

                                                                                                                                            Tons.           Value.


Shipments...........               ............                    --......... --...................................               ..       10, 500         $300, 500
Receipts..................         .    ...................                ....................................                             33, 00         1, 138, 500

       Total .....--.................                         ..........                 .............-------............                   43, 570        1, 439 000



  The principal articles of commerce are coal, building materials, farm produce, and
general merchandise.



                                                                              D 20.

             IMPROVEMENT OF PORT JEFFERSON HARBOR, NEW YORK.

    This harbor is a large landlocked bay on the north side of Long Isl-
and, abbut 60 miles east of New York in a direct line, and nearly oppo-
site Bridgeport, Conn. Its high-water area, with that of its shallow
tributaries, Setauket Harbor and Conscience Bay, is about 21 square
miles, and the width of the outlet is but 450 feet. Port Jefferson lies
at the head of the harbor, nearly 2 miles from the outlet, and there is a
depth of 12 feet or more at low water to within 300 feet of the wharves
over nearly the whole width of the harbor. Originally there was a bar
just outside the outlet, with a depth of 3 feet at mean low water, over
which the tide ebbed and flowed very rapidly,
              APPENDIX            D-REPORT                OF LIEUr.           COL.      HOUSTON.             579

                                 PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENTS.

   A survey of the harbor was made in 1853 by Lieutenant Harrison,
U. S. Engineers. In 1870 an examination was ordered by Congress.
The first project for improvement was submitted by General Warren,
January 16, 1871, after an examination, and provided for building
a jetty on the east side of the entrance, extending out to the 9-foot
curve, and rising to 11 feet above mean low water, to be built partly of
dimension stone; also for dredging a channel 200 feet wide and 7 feet
deep at mean low water through the bar. The estimated cost was as
follows, viz:
Construction of jetty ...............-----------......--................-------------....---....       -$150,125
Dredging .-----.....----.........---------.....----.------------..-----------... ---------..........       15, 000

        Total -----         -------------- -----. ----------.. - -----------------.                       165,125
   When the project was adopted, under the appropriation of March 3,
1871, it was provided that the jetty should be of riprap, rising only to
the level of mean high water, except between the high and low water
marks on the beach, where it was to be carried to the level of the
highest tides; but no change was made in the estimates. Under this
appropriation 600 feet of the jetty were built; and under the appro-
priation of June 10, 1872, it was extended to 1,052 feet. An estimate
made in 1873 of the cost of completion ($35,000) makes the estimate
for the whole project $65,000. In 1875 a modification of the project,
based on the observed effect of the jetty, was made, providing for a jetty
on the west side of the entrance, about 1,075 feet long, and rising 4 feet
above mean high water, designed to increase the force of the tidal cur-
rents; the width of the channel was also reduced to 100 feet. No inev
estimate was submitted at the time ; but in 1877, after about $8,000 had
been expended on the west jetty, it was estimated that $12,250 would
be required to complete it, or $20,250 in all. A revised estimate, made
in the same year, for the whole improvement, contemplated extending the
east jetty to the 9-foot curve, extending the west jetty 600 feet farther,
and dredging a channel 100 feet wide and 8 feet deep (this increase of
depth on account of increased draught of vessels using the harbor), at
an estimated cost of $34,000; $45,000 had then been appropriated and
nearly expended, making the total estimate from the beginning $79,000
 (including $6,000 appropriated in 1876, and then unexpended). This
estimate was incorrectly reported in 1878, but reverted to in 1879, and
repeated in each subsequent annual report. In 1877 one cut 25 feet
wide and 8 feet deep was dredged through the bar. The channel was
dredged to a width of 100 feet under the appropriation of March 3,
1879. In 1877 the east jetty was raised to a height of 5 feet above
mean high water, and extended 50 feet. In 1878 the west jetty was
extended 450 feet, but the height was made oly 2 feet above mean low
water, except the outer end and an intermediate point, which were
raised to 4 feet above mean high water, to serve as guides.
   Between 1879 and 1883 both jetties were extended and repaired,
making their respective lengths 1,390 feet for the east jetty and 940
feet for the west.

    OPERATIONS             DURING TIHE FISCAL YEAR                          ENDING JUNE 30, 1888.

   No work was done.
580               REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                             PRESENT                  CONDITION                       OF        THE           IMPROVEMENT.

The east jetty is 1,390 feet long, terminating in 10 feet of water. The
westjetty is 940 feet long, terminating in 6.5 feet of water. The dredged
channel retains nearly its depth of 8 feet at mean low water.
                                                        PROPOSED                      OPERATIONS.

  The amount estimated for the completion of the project was reached
by the appropriation made August 2, 1882, and the project itself is com-
pleted. Whether the depth gained will be permanent or not can only
be told by time. No further operations are proposed at present.
  Appropriations for improving Port Jefferson Harbor, New York, have
been made as follows, viz:

      Date.                                                                      Application.                                                                       Amount.


Mar. 3, 1871 East jetty .......--                 ....      .... ....       ....     ............         .......            ............----                          $15, 000
June 10, 1872 .-..... do ----------------.-----...-------------------..                                            ----       ------------                              15, 000
Mar. 3,1875 East and west jetties .--.........--....---..---..---....--..---...--.....-..............------...----...                                                   15, 000
Aug. 14,1876 East jetty and dredging ...                             .....          ...........       .......     ..........       ..     -........----.                 6, 000
June 18, 1878 East and west jetties --..                                  .....----------------------------------------------                                            8, 000
Mar. 3,1879 Dredging ..                                                                                                                                                     000
                                                                                                                                                                         5,-------------..-----------
June 14, 1880 East and west jetties------------       ..-----....--..---....--.                   - ---                                                                  3, 000
Mar. 3,1881 East jetty....--------------------------------------------------------4,000
Aug. 2,1882 ...... do............................................-----------.......................                                                                       8,000

                                Total ...          ..............          ...           ..       ...     ..-........         ..   ................-----                79, 000


   Port Jefferson is a port of delivery in the collection district of New York. There is
a light-house on Old Field Point, 1i miles west of the harbor entrance. Fort Hale,
New HIaven Harbor, Connecticut, 23 nmiles distant, is the nearest work of defense.


                                                                    Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available.......... ............                                                           ....         ---....--...----....                    $374. 76
July 1, 1888, balance available- .......................................                                                                                              374.76




                                                             COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                     Arrivals and departures of ressels.


                                                            Description.                                                                              Number.           Tons.


Steamers     ......                          ...................---------------.--------                                                                      786      106, 100
Sailing vessels.........                 ....         ... ......................                        ..................   . . ...      ...                 556       35,870
Barges, etc....... .....                 ....... ......................................................                                              ...

          Total ..             -
                            -........ ............. .....................                                                                                    1,342      141, 970


   The draught of vessels trading at Port Jefferson ranges from 5                                                                                to   14 feet.          Their
tonnage ranges from 25 to 500 tons.
                                                                                  Cargoes.

                                                                                                                                                            Tons.      Value.


Shipments-------------...............---.........................................-------------------------------------......--..........                    3, 235     $49, 350
Receipts ......................................................                                           .....................                            23,260      373, 650
           Total         ..................                    ......            ..........          ..                  .................. 26, 49                      423, 000

    The principal articles of commerce are coal, building materials, farm produce, and
  general merchandise.
                APPENDIX               D----REPORT                OF- LIEUT. COL.- HOUSTON.                                         581

                                                                D     21.

                       IMPROVEMENT OF FLUSHING BAY, NEW YORK.

  Flushing Bay is on the north shore of Long Island, about 14 miles by
water from the Battery at New York. The town of Flushing is on the
east bank of Flushing Creek, a quarter of a mile from the head of the
bay. The bay is about 1 mile wide and 2 miles long; the bottom is of
soft mud, nearly level, the depth in the original channel befng not much
greater than elsewhere. In 1861 there was a depth of 5 feet at low
water in the channel leading up to Flushing, and in 1879 but 3.9 feet.
  The mean rise of tide is 7.1 feet.

                                       PROJECT              FOR IMPROVEMENT.

  A survey of Flushing Bay was made in 1878, and a project for im-
provement, based on it, was proposed and adopted, providing for the
construction of a dike extending across the westerly part of the mouth
of the bay and upon the west side of the channel to the head of the bay
near Flushing, and a dike extending from a point near the middle of
the east shore in a northerly direction to the 6-foot curve and almost
parallel to the first, in order to form a large tidal basin whose waters
should ebb and flow through a narrow channel, with dredging to main-
tain a channel 6 feet deep at mean low water. The estimated cost for
carrying out this project was as follows:
Constructing          4,400 linear feet of pile-dike, at $10 per foot -------- ......                                             $44, 000
Constructing          7,800 linear feet of pile-dike, at $9 per foot_...--.............                                            70,200
Constructing          900 linear feet of pile-dike, at $7.50 per foot---.. ------------                                             6,750
Constructing          3, 600 linear feet of single piling, at $3.70 per foot ...-......                                            13, 320
For 83,000 cubic yards of dredging, at 20 cents per cubic yard ......-
                                                                 ---....--....                                             ----    16, 600
Contingencies..---.--..-------....................----...----....---..-----..------..--------....------..---..........             22, 630
         Total--..-------....------.....------........-......----...--....      ..............----------------.......------....   173,500
  All the timber work of the dikes was to be creosoted. Up to June 30,
1880, 3,057 linear feet of pile-dike were constructed on the west side of
the channel from the head of the bay. Subsequent appropriations have
been expended in dredging.
   Under the appropriation of August 5, 1886, a contract was entered
into, October 23, 1886, with P. Sanford Ross, of Jersey City, N. J., for the
removal of 45,000 cubic yards of mud measured in scows. The dredg-
ing was to be applied to widening the channel and removing shoal
places in the channel already dredged. Work was begun under this
contract May 16, 1887, and up to June 30, 1887, 23,630 cubic yards of
mud had been removed.

    OPERATIONS DURING                           THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1888.

  Work was continued under the contract with P. Sanford Ross and
completed July 28, 1887. All shoal spots in the channel were removed,
the 6-foot channel widened to 170 feet both along and northward of the
dike and along the wharves at Flushing, and to 200 feet from deep water
in the bay to a point 500 feet south of the north end of the dike a dis-
tance of 2,400 feet. A branch channel 1,450 feet long and 55 feet wide
was also dug from near the south end of the dike to the steam-boat land-
ing on the south end of the bay, and a turning basin 90 feet square at
the steam-boat landing. An examination of the dredged channel was
582             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

made in June, 1888. It showed that the main channel had still an avail-
able depth of nearly 6 feet, but that the branch channel had shoaled con-
siderably.
                                    PRESENT CONDITION OF IMPROVEMENT.

  Of the proposed 16,700 linear feet of dike 3,057 have been built. The
channel leading up the bay to the wharves has been three times dredged.
The examination of June, 1888, shows that it has an available depth of
nearly 6 feet.
                                                          PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

    Until the dikes are completed dredging will be needed frequently,
probably annually, to maintain the channel.                                                                              If appropriations are made
more than is urgently needed for dredging it is proposed to continue
the construction of dikes as provided for in the project.
    Appropriations for improving Flushing Bay, New York, have been
made as follows :

      Date.                                                                          Application.                                                                       Amount.


Mar. 3, 1879              Construction of dike ...                      - - .....................                   ............           ........ ........               $20, 00
June 14, 1880            Dredging .-..- ..........                  ...          ...                  .  ........................                   .......                 15, 000
Mar. 3,1881             ...... do .......--........--                     ..----                  ..----    ...............................----                             10, 000
Aug. 2,1882             ...... d......-----...--.................................                                       ......----.................                          5, 000
July 5,1884             ...... do ......-----....................--..............                               ............................                                10, 000
Aug. 5, 1886            .    ..........................................................................................                                                     10, 000
                                  Total .-..          . ..........                      ..          .........          .........................                   ..       70, 000



  Flushing Bay is in the collection district of New York. The nearest light-house is
on North Brother Island. Fort Schuyler, New York Harbor, is the nearest work of
defense.
                                                                      Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available............--.............................                                                                                               5, 201. 38
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887..---...------..-
                                        ......---------------..............--..---...----..-----........----.                                                           4,181.12
July 1, 1888, balance available........................................--------------------------------------. 1, 020. 26
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888----....-.-------                                   ........      15,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                                                                           16,020.26
T  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....--.
    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890
                                                                                                                                                                    88, 500.00
                                                                                                                                                                    35, 000. 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                                               COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                       Arricals and departures of vessels.

                                                                    Kind.                                                                                  Number. Tonnage.


Steamers ......              ......           .... ... ......... ....                ................              --......................                       755       15,600
Sailing vessels................          .......          ......     .....................                                  ..................     .   .          864       43, 200
Barges, etc ............................                                      ......       .....................................                           . ..   732      182, 600

         Total. .................................................                                                                                      .2,351              341,400



  The draught of vessels trading at Flushing ranges from 5 to 9 feet.                                                                                         Their tonnage
ranges from 20 to 300 tons.
                   APPENDIX              D-REPORT                        OF         LIEUT.                   COL.        HOUSTON.                 583
                                                                     Cargoes.

                                                                                                                                    Tons.       Value.

Shipments.......................---...---.            .....................--.....--................                               135 475 $3,152, 400
Receipts.--...   ...-    .........     ..--......   ....... ........                .............................                   93, 760 2, 502,425

        Total ..................             ...      ......................                       ..................               229, 235   5, 654, 825


The princinpal articles of commerce are manufactured goods, coal, grain, building
materials, and general merchandise.




                                                                    D 22.

REMOVING SUJNKEN VESSELS OR CRAFT OBSTRUCTION                                                                                  OR ENDANGER-
                       ING NAVIGATION.

WRECK IN                 THE CONNECTICUT RIVER AT                                                   HARTFORD,                  CONNECTICUT.

   The sloop scow George C. Bloomer, owned by Elizur Smith, of Hart-
ford, Conn., sunk about five years ago on the east side of the channel
opposite Hartford. In 1886 she was reported as an obstruction to nav-
igation; her deck and cabin had been carried away by ice, her hull had
filled with sand, and a bar was forming below the wreck with from 1 to
3 feet of water where the depth had been 6 feet.
   The contract with William E. Chapman, of Brooklyn, N. Y., to re-
move this wreck, which was in force at the date of the last Annual Re-
port, was completed August 16, 1887. Work was done by pumping out
sand and placing chains under the wreck to remove it bodily; while lift-
ing on the chains the wreck broke, and subsequently the greater part
of it was removed by grappling; the pieces left were splinters too small
to injure vessels if struck by them. A report to the Chief of Engineers,
dated October 10, 1887, gives details of the removal.

Abstract of contractfor removing wreck in the Connecticut River, at Hartford, Conn., in
                                   force during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.

                           Name and address of contractor.                                                                  Date.              Price.

William E. Chapman, Brooklyn, N. Y* ...............................                                                  November 6, 1886.....         $589

                                           * Contract completed August 16, 1887.




WRECK IN                THE CONNECTICUT RIVER AT SAYBROOK POINT, CONNEC-
                                        TICUT.

   February 8, 1887, the schooner R. If. Daly, -  Crowley, captain and
owner, employed by the contractor for delivering stone on the Saybrook
jetties, sunk while loaded, and lay in about 30 feet of water near the
west side of the channel at the mouth of South Cove, and about 3,000
feet north of the light-house on Lyndis Point. In April, 1887, the owner
made an unsuccessful attempt to raise her; he removed such of her
spars as could easily be detached, and abanloucd her,
584        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   Authority for her removal was granted, and the notice to owners, as
required by law, was published May 13, 1887.
   July 13, 1887, Mr. C. C. Goodrich, of Hartford, Conn., made an offer
to remove this wreck for the sum of $500; it was considered most
economical and advantageous to the Government to accept this offer,
which was done with approval of the Chief of Engineers. Mr. Good-
rich completed the removal of this wreck December 16, 1887 ; 230 pounds
of dynamite were exploded under her, completely shattering her hull,
so that a final examination by sweeping discovered no part of the wreak
above the surrounding bottom.



WRECK ON THE WEST                 END     OF   LONG     SAND       SHOAL, LONG               ISLAND
                                            SOUND.

  In November, 1885, the Louise Bliss, a three-masted schooner, said to
be about 120 feet long, was wrecked and sunk near the west end of Long
Sand (or Cornfield) Shoal, about 6 miles southwest from the mouth of
the Connecticut River, and on the south side of the shoal. When
wrecked, she was bound east with a cargo of about 700 tons of coal;
most of the coal was removed from her within a few months.
   This wreck was first reported as endangering navigation in the sum-
mer of 1887, and August 8, 1887, a petition for its removal, signed by
several transportation companies doing business in Long Island Sound,
was forwarded to the Chief of Engineers, with a letter from the inspector
of the third light-house district, advising such removal; authority for
such action was granted by the Secretary of War, August 15, 1887.
  At this time the wreck lay in about 3 fathoms of water, and her hull
stood 9 feet above the bottom; one timber, supposed to be the stem,
was just visible at low water.
  The notice to owners, as required by law, was published August 22,
1887, and proposals for removal of wreck were opened November 23,
1887 ; under date of December 7, 1887, a contract for doing the work for'
the sum of $1,745 was entered into with Johnston & MIaull, of Lewes,
Del. Work was begun at once, and completed December 15; 365
pounds of dynamite were exploded under and upon the wreck, which
shattered it completely, and a final examination showed no part of it
remaining above or upon the bottom.




Abstract of proposalsJforremoving wreck at Cornfield Shoal, opened at Engineer Office, U. S.
                        Army, New2 York City, November 23, 1887.


No.              Names and addresses of bidders.               Amount             Remarks.
                                                               of bid.


1    George W. Townsend, Boston, Mass .--....-...-.....        $2, 479   By blasting.
      Chas. W. Johnston and Franklin C. Manll, Lewes, Del ..     1, 745   By blasting.
3    Atlantic Dredging Company, Brooklyn, N. Y.---   -..        1, 880   By blasting and grappling.
4    William E. Chapman, New York City....................      2, 289   By blasting and use of
                                                                            steam-derrick.

 *Entered into contract December 7, 1887; contract completed December 15, 1887.
         APPENDIX D--REPORT         OF LIEUT. COL. HOUSTON.           585
WRECK IN LONG ISLAND SOUND, SOUTHWEST FRO]M BLACK ROCK HAR-
                     BOR, CONNECTICUT.

   In a letter dated July 30, 1887, the collector of port at Bridgeport,
Conn., reported to the Secretary of War that a wreck lying southwest
from Black Rock Harbor, Connecticut, was in a very dangerous position.
This was referred to me, and August 8, 1887, it was returned with in-
dorsement and three inclosures showing that the wreck was the schooner
Emma J. Higgins, sunk by collision, April 14, 1887, and then lying in
about 11 fathoms of water; that her spars were standing at or near the
surface and were obstructions dangerous to navigation, such as contem-
plated by section 4 of the river and harbor act of June 14,1880.
   Her removal was authorized by the Secretary of War, August 12,
1887, and under date of August 20 the required notice to owners was
published. About this time the spars were broken off at about low-water
level, and as the wreck lay between 3 and 4 miles from shore it was dif-
ficult to fix its precise location ; this was determined early in December,
1887, and an offer of Capt. John McNeil, of the Bridgeport Towing Line,
to remove so much of the spars and rigging as was necessary to make,
a clear depth of 25 feet at low water for the sum of $200 was recom-
mended for acceptance as being most economical and advantageous to
the Government. The recommendation was approved by the Secretary
of War, December 17, 1887.
   January 4, 1888, the work was done, a spar 58 feet long with part of
the hull attached being pulled out by a tug-boat. Unfavorable weather
delayed making an examination sufficient to determine with certainty
whether the work was completed until April 17, 1888, when the wreck
was carefully swept and sounded, and nothing discovered at less than
39 feet depth below low water.
                               APPENDIX E.



IMPROVEMENT OF HUDSON RIVER AND OF HARBORS OF RONDOUT AND
  SAUGERTIES, NEW YORK-REMOVING OBSTRUCTIONS IN EAST RIVERi
  AND HELL GATE-IMPROVEMENT OF ENTRANCE TO NEW YORK HIAR-
  BOR-IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE VICINITY OF
  NEW YORK AND IN NORTHERN NEW JERSEY.




REPORT OF LIE UTENANT-COLONEL WALTER McFARLAND, CORPS OF
ENGINEERS, OFFICER IN CHARGE, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING
JUNE 30, 1888, WITH OTIHER DOCUMENTS RELATING TO TiE WORKS.

                                 IMPROVEMENTS.

1.   Hudson River, New York.               10. Sheepshead Bay, New York.
2.   Harbor of Saugerties, New York.       11. Canarsie Bay, New York.
3.   Harbor at Rondout, New York.          12. Sumpawanus Inlet, New York.
4.   Harlem River, New York.               13. Channel between Staten Island and
5.   Removing obstructions in the East           New Jersey.
       River and at Hell Gate, New York.   14. Raritan Bay, New Jersey.
6:   Newtown Creek, New York.              15. Removing sunken vessels or craft ob-
7.   Buttermilk Channel, New York.              structing or endangering naviga-
8.   Gowanus Bay, New York.                      tion.
9.   New York Harbor.

                        EXAMINATIONS       AND SURVEY.

16. Spring Creek, New York.                17. Hudson River, New York, between
                                                New Baltimore and Coxsackie.




                                   ENGINEER OFFICE, U. S. ARMY,
                                         New York, N. Y., July 24, 1888.
   GENERAL : I have the honor to transmit herewith annual reports for
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, upon the works of river and harbor
improvement under the charge of the late Lieut. Col. Walter McFar.
land, Corps of Engineers.
   These reports were completed and revised by Colonel McFarland per-
sonally, within a few days of his death.
   The works were in temporary charge of Lieut. Col. G. L. Gillespie
from January 1, 1888, to June 29, 1888.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                           GEO. MCC. I)ERBY,
                            Captain of Engineers, in temporary charge.
   The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U, S, A
588    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                  E i.

         IMPROVEMENT OF THE HUDSON RIVER, NEW YORK.
  My annual report for 1885 contained a history of this improvement,
accompanied by original reports and two sketches showing its condition
at that time. This may be found in the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1885, Part I, page 677.
  The only part of the Hudson River which has been improved by the
General Government is the stretch about 20 miles long, beginning at
the head of navigation at Troy, N. Y., about 6 miles above Albany, and
extending down the river to New Baltimore, about 14 miles below Al-
bany.
  While there has always beenl enough water below New Baltimore for
navigation this upper section of the river, so far as its history is known
to us, has always been obstructed by bars and shoals due to the exist-
ence of numerous islands and sloughs, and the consequent diversion of
the river water through too many channels.
  Prior to 1831, when the jurisdiction of the Federal Government over
these waters was confirmed by judicial decision, the State of New York
had made efforts to improve the navigation of this part of the river.
Since 1831 the improvement of the Hudson River has been conducted
both by the State of New York and by the General Government, both
building and repairing dikes and doing such dredging as seemed neces-
sary. In the last few years, however, the dike work has been left al-
most exclusively to the General Government, while the State of New
York has done most of the dredging required.
  The general system of improvement has been the same throughout,
viz, the contraction of the channels by the construction of jetties and
dikes intended to deepen them by means of the scour so produced, and
also deepening by dredging where it could not be dispensed with.
  But up to 1831 the work, which had consisted-almost entirely of the
construction of spur-dikes and of dredging, had produced very little
permanent improvement.
  After 1831, however, the United States began the present general
system of improvement, which consists of contracting the channel by
means of longitudinal dikes, intended to aid in scouring the bars and
shoals, instead of using spur jetties, as had been done previously.
   Under this system the United States constructed two dikes in 1835,
1836, 1837, and 1838.
  Then followed a long interval of time in which nothing was done by
the United States, except in 1852; but in 1863 the State of New York
took up the improvement on the general plan adopted by the United
States in 1831, viz, substituting a system of longitudinal dikes instead
of the jetty system, and between 1863 and 1867, built six important
longitudinal dikes of this kind. (Annual Report of 1885, page 678.)
  The work was taken up again by the United States in 1864, when,
out of the general sum appropriated for river and harbor improve-
ments, $33,000 were allotted for the Hudson River improvement, and
this was followed by the act of June 23, 1866, which appropriated
$50,000 for the same work. Lieutenant-Colonel, now General, John
Newton, Corps of Engineers, was placed in charge of this improvement,
and remained in charge of it eighteen years; that is, until April 1,
1884.
  In November, 1866, General Newton submitted a project for the im-
provement of the 20 miles of river between New Baltimore and Troy,
which may be found in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
        APPENDIX E-REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. McFARLAND.                  589
1885, part 1, page 678; and based upon this report a systematic im-
provement of the river was begun and has been continued up to the
present time.
    His project was to secure a navigable channel 11 feet deep at mean
low water from New Baltimore up to Albany, and 9 feet deep at mean
low water from Albany up to Troy.
    The estimated cost of this improvement was $862,297.75; but after
more reliable data had been obtained in 1866 and 1867, a second esti-
mate was made, increasing the estimate $122,006.72, making the total
estimated cost $984,304.47.
    This estimate was again increased in 1882 by $78,000 for the comple-
tion of existing works, a large amount of the appropriation intended for
construction having been spent on repairs; and again in 1884 by $16,000,
for the removal of a hitherto unknown rock in the Overslaugh Channel
at Van Wie's Point, which brought the total estimate up to $1,078,304.47,
although the amounts given in the Annual Reports as the estimated cost
of the improvement, from 1868 to 1881, have been erroneously printed
 $984,304.47, and from 1882 to 1886 as $1,062,304.47.
    Of this amount $1,027,288 had been appropriated up to June 30, 1885,
when the available channel depth between New Baltimore and Albany
was 10 feet, except at one point, Beacon Island, where there was a depth
of 8.8 feet; and 8 feet could be carried from Albany to Troy, except at
Coville's Folly and Patroon's Island, where there were 7.8 and 7.5 feet,
respectively, at low water.
    These bars were subsequently dredged by the State of New York, but
others have since been formed yearly by ice gorges.
    The gradual and steady increase in the navigable depths obtained
during the improvement of the Hudson River are very marked.
    In 1819 the available channel between New Baltimore and Albany
was 4 feet at mean low water; in 1867 it was 7J feet; in 1878 and 1879
it was 81; in 1885, 10 feet, except at the spot mentioned, which was
subsequently dredged by the State. A table showing the depths from
1819 to 1879 may be found on page 691, Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1885.
   The act of Congress approved August 5, 1886, appropriated $26,250
for this improvement, making, with the old balance on hand, $54,768.40
available at that date.
   The condition of the dikes was so bad that it was found necessary to
apply all this to repairs and not to the construction of further perma-
nent works.
   The permanent works remaining to be built, in order to complete the
improvement as originally projected, are:
    1. Completion of dike from Staat's Island to Campbell's Island Dike.
    2. Completion of dike from Schermerhorn to Shad Island.
    3. The proposed improvement between Shad Island and Mull's Plaat.
    4. The improvement at Willow Island.
    5. The construction of a new dike below Nine Mile Tree.
    6. The extension of the dike at Mull's Plaat.
    7. The removal of the Overslaugh Rock at Van Wie's Point.
    The first of these six items were, under the estimate of 1882, to cost
 $78,000, and the seventh item, under the estimate of 1884, was to cost
 $16,000; making the total amount needed for completing the original
project $94,000.
  The actual cost, however, will exceed this amount, as the cost for
completing the dike from Staat's to Campbell's Island will exceed the
estimate, since the three detacbed sections of this dike, which were
built along the proposed line in 1870, have been completely broken by
590            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

the action of the ice, and an entirely new and stronger dike, consisting
of two rows of piles filled in with stone, will have to be built.
  This work will require about 6,000 linear feet of pile-dike, which, at
$8 per foot, will cost $48,000, and will therefore largely increase the
estimate of 1884.                   This will probably bring up the amount required for
the completion of the present project from $94,000 to $120,000.
      Out of the amounts appropriated up to June 30, 1886, more than
$35,000 have been expended on repairs.
      A careful examination of the dikes between New Baltimore and Al-
bany, made in 1886 by Assistant Engineer R. H. Tallcott, showed them
to be in very bad condition, and his estimate for repairs needed on them
was as follows:
1.    West Dike at New Baltimore, completed last year ..................                                                                               $12,165
2.    Mull's Dike, half dike (single pile) ...........................                            -.......... .. .                                       5, 000
3.    Barren Island Dike ...... .... ..........                    ...........            ..............                                                 1,500
4.    Coeymans Dike .................................................                                                                                       300
5.    Middle dike at Coeymans, completed last year ...............................                                                                      12, 366
6.    Roah Hook Dike, completed last year .... ..........                               ....       ..... ..... ..                                        2,877
7.    Mull's Plaat, half dike ...................                          .........................                                                         50
8.    Mull's Single Pile Dike .... .... .............                   .......................                                                         23,400
9.    Scodach Island Dike ..................                              ....      ............    -          ..-      ....          ... -                 300
10. Shad Island Dike ..........              ........................                        ...... .......           ....                                   450
11. Castleton Dike ...................................................                                                                                     1,300
12. Cedar Hill Dike...... ..............                       ................                 ................                                         11,000
13. Cow Island Dike ......................                                     .
                                                                         ....................                    ......                                   9,500
14. Campbell Island Dike .............................................                                                                             --
                                                                                                                                                             300
                                                                                                                                                             500
                                                                                                                                               -

  . Campbell Island Dike (single pile) ..............................
15.15                                                        -   ---   "      --   _--    --   "_-       __--    -__--          "---




16. Winnie's Landing, lower dike (single pile)........................                                                                                       600
      -(Staat's Island Pile Dike, aL entirely new structure will have to be
         built.)
17. Winnie's Dike ................... ....-........                             ...... ................                           4, 500
18. Bear Island (single pile-dike) ........                          ....-..........................                              6, 000
19. Extension of Overslaugh Dike.. --                                                                                                150
                                                                                 ----..................-------------......--------......--......
20. Overslaugh Dike, repairs---          ....................----------.......                     ..----............             9, 000
21. Beacon Island Dike (single pile) ....................................                                                            250
      Papscanee Dikes:
22. Section No. 3................------......-- ---------------............................-------------......                    1, 000
                    ......------......--------............----....-----......------......-- ---......------......---....
23. Section No. 2-----                                                                                                                900
24. Section No. 1....-----..--..-----------......---..---...       --......-----..----...--............----..---......----        4,500
25. Bogart's Island (single pile-dike) ......-........---- ---------...                                                    ---    1, 500
26. Douw's Point Extension (single pile-dike)-..- -..... ..---                                -              ..--..              -. 800
27. Douw's Point Extension (double pile-dike) .....                                           -.. -.. ............                   250
28. Douw's Point Dike ...------------------------------------------------                                                         1,340
29. Small Island Dike .-..-------------------....--..                                 ...-.                    .       ..-.-..    1,350

                                                                                                                                                         85, 390
To which should be added 20 per cent. for contingent expenses and deterio-
rations ........-----------... ----------------..---------------------------                                                                            17,160
Total estimated cost of repairs required to dikes between New Baltimore
and Albany-----..-------...........--------......--........               ---- --------
                                                             ..--------------                                                                           10:3,000
   Of these repairs those at the west dike, New Baltimore, and at the
Roah Hook Dike have been completed during the past year by J. B.
Marshall & Co., under their contract, and those at the middle dike at
Coeymans by William D. Fuller, under his contract for that work.
   Both contracts were dated October 7, 188C.
   The cost of the materials as put into the work was as follows:
1. West dike at New Baltimore:
      Piles, 40,507 linear feet, at 13 cents per foot ..............                   ... .. . $5, 274. 10
      Yellow pine timber, 33,454 feet, B. M., at $45 per 1,000 feet-........... 1,505. 43
     "Iron, 1,518 pounds, at 6 cents per pound -------......... ............              .....     919. 08
      Stone filling, 3,275.9 cubic yards, at 75 cents.....-            ...-...........           2, 456.92
                 Total ..........           .....................................                                                        ...... 10, 155, 53
          APPENDIX              E-REPORT         OF LIEUT.                  COL. McFARLAND.                          591
2. Roah Hook Dike :
     Piles, 14,495 linear feet, at 13 cents per foot--..----...................-------... $1,884.33
      Yellow pine timber, 7,915 feet, B. M., at $45 per 1,000 feet...........                356.17
      Iron, 5,163 pounds, at 6 cents per pound-...-....          ..... ..-.........          310. 08
      Stone filling, 566 cubic yards, at 75 cents----...... -- ------ --- ----------
                                                                                  .          424.50
            Total---------------
                 ..............----.................------...                   ---..---------........           2,975.10
3. Middle dike at Coeymans:
      Piles, 53, 949.5 linear feet, at 12} cents per foot...----- -----                        .....             6, 878.56
       Yellow pine timber, 28,878 feet, B. M., at $45 per 1,000 feet ..........                                  1,212. 88
       Stone filling, 1,537.75 cubic yards, at 75 cents .... ...... ...-                   -.........            1, 153. 31
       Iron, 24,986.4 pounds, at 6 cents per pound...... .... .......                         ......             1,499. 18
            Total............          ...   --..... ....................           .....----......
                                                                                       --                    10,202.76
  After the contract for the repair of the middle dike at Coeymans had
been formed, it was found necessary to rebuild a part of its upper end
70 feet in length. Under authority from the Chief of Engineers, dated
September 5, 1887, this work was done by hired labor at a cost of
$988.20, the small cost involved not justifying advertising.
  The cost of the material built into the work was as follows :
                                                       ------ -.....-...
Piles, 3,015 linear feet, at 121 cents per foot ..-------                                              --.        $384. 41
Yellow pine timber, 3,613 feet, B. M., at $42 per 1,000 feet. .............    .... 151.75
Tie-rods, drift and screw bolts, 1,459 pounds, at 6 cents--..               .-----. 87.54
                                                                          .---
Sheet-iron and chains to protect the breaker, 370 pounds, at 9 cents per pound.                                     33.30
Stone filling, 441.6 cubic yards, at 75 cents ----..-----........--.....                 ......              -     331.20
                                                                                                                   988.20
   The dikes between Albany and Troy are equally in bad condition.
Base Island Crib Dike on the east side of the river opposite Cuyler's
Island, built in 1870, will have to be rebuilt for 2,000 feet.
   The single pile-dike, built in 1879, extending up-stream from the
lower end of Lower Patroon's Island is practically carried away, and
should be rebuilt and extended up-stream so as to connect with the
lower dike of Patroon's Island, built in 1870. This would require 2,600
feet of diking. Two breaks, one 550 feet long and the other 350 feet
long, Patroon's Lower Dike should be closed.
   There has been so much filling behind those dikes since they were built,
that probably a cheaper form of construction than that formerly used
could be used there safely now.
   The water averages only a foot in depth at mean low water along the
line of the dikes.
   A dike outside of the old line and consisting of two rows of piles 14
feet long cut off 1 foot above high water, and suitably braced, would
probably, at present prices, not cost more than $5 per running foot of
dike; and with the backing it would have from the remnants of the
old dike and from the ground which has filled in behind it, it would be
stronger than the original dikes.
    The revetments along the face of Patroon's and Hillhouse islands are
wearing away, but not sufficiently so to make their repair necessary for
the present.
    There are two breaks in the Port Schuyler Dike, one 200 and the
other 100 feet in length. These should be repaired without delay as a
large amount of water is at ebb tide deflected from the main channel
through them, and twice during freshets a large amount of material
has been washed down the back channel past Hillhouse and Cuyler's
islands into the main channel below. The cost of repairing these two
breaks by a pile-dike 8 feet wide would be about $10 per linear foot.
592            REPORT OF THE CHIEF                                      OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The total cost of repairing the dikes above Albany would be then as
follows :
1. Base Island Dike, 2,000 feet, at $5 per linear foot ..........---.......--.                                                      $10, 000
2. Rebuilding Lower Patroon's Single Pile Dike and connecting it with
  Lower Patroon's Crib Dike, 2,600 feet, at $5 ..........................                                                      -     13, 000
3. Repairing breaks in Lower Patroon's Dike, 900 feet, at $5----     ...                                           --......           4,500
4. Repairing breaks in Port Schuyler Dike 300 feet, at $10 .. ........                                             ...                3, 000
Contingencies, 20 per cent ....-- .... .. .... ..... ... ... - -....
                                                               ..        .. .                                       .- . .            6, 500
       Total repairs required from Albany.--...............---                        ..           ..--         ....           .     37, 000
  This estimate was not included in the last Annual Report.
  The whole amount needed therefore for the repair and completion of
the works on the Upper Hudson is as follows:
For the repair of dikes below Albany_-.........---.-...-.-...                                             .---.                    $103, 000
                                      - -..........
For the repair of dikes above Albany ....-                                         .........                                         37,000
For the construction of the permanent works needed to complete the proj-
ect now under execution (estimate given above) .......... .............---                                                         120, 000
       Total     .----......   ......................................                          ....----....-------------....        260, 000

   The whole of this amount could be profitably expended in one season,
and the work would be more economically done were the whole amount
needed appropriated in one sum.
   The channels remain in about the same condition as last spring.
Nine feet can easily be carried at ordinary low water to Albany, and 7
feet to Troy.
   The usual bars have formed this spring at Mull's Cross-over through
the action of ice-jams and freshets, although dredged last fall by the
State of New York. It was originally intended that the channel should
follow the west bank of the river at this point, but, as rock was found
at a depth. of 9 feet, or less, below mean low water, it became necessary
for economical reasons, to throw the current of the river towards the
east side by the construction of a pile-dike from Shad Island to Mull's.
   The pile-dike is in a very dilapidated condition and should be rebuilt
entirely and extended by crib-work down-stream.
   The usual shoal has also formed this spring at the Overslaugh and
Bogart's Island, and, as stated in my last annual report, is due probably
to the condition of the Papscanee dikes, which are in such bad repair
that they do not effect their purpose, which was to contract the channel
width and throw the current along Bogart's Island and the Overslaugh.
  Two shoals have been found this spring between the railroad bridges
at Albany.
   The State of New York has dredges now at work on Mull's Crossover
and the shoals between the bridges and Albany; and it is understood
contracts for dredging were to be let about the 29th of June.
   This annual dredging does no permanent good. The old dumping
places behind the dikes are filled up, and the present system appears to
be to dump the dredged material along the channel-face of the nearest
dike, and after the dredging of the channel is completed to move the
dredge to the dike and lift the dumped material over or upon the dike,
as may be most convenient. When the material is left on top of the
dike the waves of every steam-boat passing at high water wash it back
again into the channels below.
   It is more than probable that the filling in of the channel this year op-
posite Patroon's Island is caused by the material dredged from that bar
by the State last year and deposited on the upper end of the dike; and
that the shoals formed at the Albany bridges are caused by the wash
of the material which has been deposited upon the Bath Dike. Both of
             APPENDIX                E--REPORT OF LIEUT.                                 COL. MCFARLAND.                                 593
these dikes last year were covered up with material from 6 to 10 feet
high, and now scarcely a trace of it is left.
   The same may be said of the shoal at the Overslaugh, as the material
was deposited on the Douw's Point Dike, which has entirely disappeared
since last fall.
   Most of the material dredged last fall from Mull's Crossover was
dumped behind Schermerhorn and Shad islands; but this year it is be-
ing dumped in front of the State Dike built between Scodach Island and
Mull's Plaat, with the intention of finally lifting it over or upon the dike.
   It is certain that 50 per cent., if not more, of the material dredged
finds its way back into the channels by being washed down from the top
of the dikes.
   This system of work ought to be changed and some method adopted
for transferring the material dredged to the places where it can not
possibly get back again into the channel.
   A full statement of t.e commerce of the river was given in my last
annual report.
                                               AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED.
By act of Congress approved-
   June 30, 1834 ..--. ...----                     -----                       ..-----------------......   ............               $70, 000
                  ........------..-...----.........---------------.........
      July 2.1836------                                                                ------........................                 100,000
      March 3, 1837-----......----....-------              --....---
                                                 ....----....----.....      ......---......------......--........                     100, 000
      July7, 1838--.-------------------------------------.......................................--------...............               100,000
      August 30, 1852 ........................                         .....................                   .........               50,000
                                                                                                                                      420, 000
                            AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED                        FOR PRESENT PROJECT.
By act of Congress approved--
   June28, 1864,allotment               ...---------------.......---------- ---................................                $33, 000. 00
   June 3,1866-- -.. -....------....--......--   ----....----....---..........-- --.....---------------..........----....       50, 000. 00
   March 3, 1867 ....-------....----....---......-----     ....------......---....--......-----------......        -----...... 305, 188. 00
      July 25,1868 .......--....----.........----------.............................                                                85,000.00
      April 10, 1869 .....----....---......--
                                    ----------......--......-----......--- ...... ......------------          ------....--.... 89, 100. 00
      July 11, 1870 ...--... -- ----------------........--.... -----....---......---.......---....               .....-----.   40, 000. 00
      March 3, 1871----.......................---....---------------------------.....................                          40, 000. 00
      June 10,1872---------------......-----------......------.........................................
                                                                                                 ------------- 40,000.00
                        -----------------------.................................
      March 3, 1873 .....--..........                                                                                          40, 000. 00
      June 23,1874-------------------------------------------------......................................................      40,000.00
      March 3,1875 ..----..----..---......---........-- .........------......                                     .------. 40, 000. 00
                                                                                                ....-------..--..---
      August 14,1876 ...----..------------..................................-----....    -----------....                       50,000.00
                                   ---------......---......---....----..--......------..---------......---....
      June 18,1878 ........-----....                                                                                           70, 000. 00
      March 3, 1879 ...------------------................             -- ---........................--------.......            30, 000.00
      June 14, 1880------.... -----....---..............----..............-----------------....--....-------..---. 20, 000. 00
                       .-------....---....
      March 3, 1881 ----               ......--......-------....---......----------....--....--- ----....--......---....       15, 000. 00
By act of Congress passed August 2, 1882..................                                           .     ........                 10, 000. 00
By act of Congress approved July 5, 1884 ......................                                         ......                      30, 000.00
    August 5, 1886 ....---.........................---------------------------......----------.....--..-----....                    26, 250. 00
            Total .--------...----...----........--....--...........---.. ....--.....---......... 1, 053,538. 00
      Received from other sources. ......----......--- ----....---......-..............                  792.57

                                                                                                                                 1,054, 330. 57
                                                            ---......---....---- 1, 032,137.59
      Amount expended to June 30, 1888 . --............-- ......
                                    Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available ....------------........... ....................... $23, 018. 50
July 1, 1888, amount expended during the fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887........................................--------------     1,560. 22
July 1, 1888, balance available ........................        ......                                       .....        ...... 21,458. 28
Amount appropriated by act of August 11,1888...................-...--                                                         . 75,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30,1889.-..... ........                                                      ....      96,458. 28

            EIG 88                38
594              REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 185, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


COMMERCIAL                 STATISTICS      OF THE PORT                        OF        ALBANY,                 NEW         YORK,     FOl1      THIE    FISCAL
                                             YEAR ENDING JUNE ;0, 1888.

                                      [From A. D. Cole,                 esq.,      surveyor of the port.
Value of imports..............................-------------------------------..........---------------....                             ---      $945, 381.00
Duties collected thereon.............................................                                                                            152,916.10
  The following are extracts from the report of the Hon. John Shanahan, superin-
tendent public works, State of New York, for.the year 1887, on trade and tonnage of
canals :


                                                                                                                                     Tons.             Value.

Arriving at tide-water of the Hudson River at Albany and Troy.....-........                                                         3, 158, 923 $71,755,221
Merchandise that went to New York..-.       .........- ...... .. ......---........                                                  2, 252, 943I t0, 075, 597




                                                                          E 2.
                  ,IMPROVEMENT OF SAUGERTIES HARBOR, NEW YORK.

   The harbor of Saugerties is the name applied to the mouth of Esopus
Creek, which empties into the Hudson River, on the west shore, about
100 miles above the city of New York. "With the exception of some
slight works undertaken by the inhabitants, giving no permanent re-
sults, nothing had been done toward the improvement of this harbor
until it was undertaken by the United States Government in 1887. In
1883- a survey of the harbor was made under the direction of General
John Newton, Corps of Engineers, who suggested two plans of improve-
ment, both providing for the construction of parallel dikes and for
dredging the channel between them. See Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1884, Part I, page 716.)
   A re-examination of the harbor, made in 1887, after the State had
done some dredging in the anannel, resulted in the submission of a
third project, differing but slightly from those previously submitted, the
main difference being in the location. This project was approved and
its execution was begun the same year.
   Its estimated cost was as follows:
North dike, 2,300 feet long:
   Pile-work, 2,160 running feet, at $7 per foot--   ----
                                                 ...................                                                                 ........           15, 120i
   Crib-work, 140 running feet, at $30 per foot..........................                                                                                4,200
South dike, 2,300 feet long:
      Pile-work, 2,200 running feet, at $7 per foot...........................                                                                          15, 400
      Crib-work, 100 running feet, at $30 per foot.                                                         . ...................                        3, 000
      Dredging 30,000 cubic yards, at 25 cents ......                                                  .......................                           7, 500
      Contingencies, about 15 per cent ...............                                                      .....................                        6, 780

          Total..........---            ...--------........---------................................                                                    52,000

  As the $20,000 which had been appropriated for this improvement in
1884 and 1886 was only sufficient to build one of the proposed dikes, it
was decided to apply it to the south dike only, leaving the other to be
provided for by subsequent appropriations.
            APPENDIX E -REPORT                                   OF LIEUT.                  COL. McFARLAND.                           595

   Bids for its construction were therefore invited by public advertise-
ment, and the work being awarded to Messrs. Henry Du Bois's Sons, at
$6.79 a linear foot of dike, a contract, dated July 28, 1887, was entered
into with them accordingly.
   The construction was begun nAugust 18 and was continued until the
1st of December, 1887, when work closed for the season, and as the con-
tract had been delayed by reason of bad weather, the time for its conm-
pletion was extended to June 15, 1888.
   Upon the resumption of the work in the spring of 1883, it was found
that the dike had been somewhat injured by the ice during the winter.
For 50 feet from the inner end the piles had been broken off, and at
about 1,000 feet from the shore end the dike had been lifted slightly
for a distance of about 100 feet and pushed over towards the south,
but not enough to impair its strength or efficiency.
   The broken piles have been replaced by the contractor. The dike is
now completed. It is 2,363k feet in length and consists of a double row
of piles driven 6 feet apart from center to center, the tops of piles being
cut off 2 feet above mean high water. Two courses of timber 6 by 12
inches are bolted along the inner and outer faces of the dike, and the
space between the piles is filled in with stone. The rows of piles are
tied together at intervals of 12 feet with timber cross-ties 12 by 12
inches, and with two iron tie rods between the timber cross-ties.
   For the completion of the work in accordance with the approved plan,
ho
I sum of $32,000 is required.
   A full statement of the commerce of Saugerties may be found in my
last annual report. No additional information concerning it has been
received.
  Saugerties is the collection district of Albany, N. Y., which is the nearest port of
entry.     The nearest light-house is at the mouth of Esopus Creek.

                                              AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED.

July 5, 1884--------------                                .
                                                        ------------                ..----- ..--..--.-------                  $5, 000, 00
August 5, 1886 , .....        ------......................--..            ....---........-....--- .....         ....----.     15, 000. 00


         Total...... .-----...........----......----......-----....-------....----.......---....------......
                                                                                                         20,000. 00

Amount expended to June 30, 1888-                            .-..... .. .....            -- . --...          ...- .--.        13,303.14


                                                   M3loney statement.
July 1, 1887, amount availablc..........- ......
                                  -- -----....-..........                                                             .   .$19,      939. 95
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887........ ..............                                           $13, 303. 09
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities .....................                                                  3,938. 17
                                                                                                                 --               17, 241.26

July 1, 1888, balance available ...-...-                         ......   ..............................                           2, 698.69
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.... ............-....-....                                                      12, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                                         14, 698.69)

fAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........
  Amountthat can beprofitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30,1890
                                                                                                                              20, 000. 00
                                                                                                                              20, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
596             REPORT OF THE CHIIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Jbstract of bids for building a pile-dike at Saug.erties  r, New   orkI, oened at th              T
  United States Engineer Office, Army Building, New York, July 20, 1887, at 12 o'clock
  m., under advertisement of June 27, 1887.


                                                                                                                                  2,300 feet of dike.

No.                                              Names of bidders.                                                           Rate per
                                                                                                                              linear              Amount.
                                                                                                                               foot.


  1    Joseph L. Powley, Rondout, N. Y ...              ...........                   .................                              $7. 93       $18, 239. 00
  2    Alexander Sturgeon, Rondout, N. Y ...................................                                                          8. 85        20, 335. 00
  3    John Satterlee, Inglewood, N. J       .......................................                                                   8.20        18, 860.00
  4    Stephen A. Kelly, Brooklyn, N. Y ..........................................                                                        3        22, 195. 00
  5    Ross & Sanford, Jersey City, N. J.................................                                                                40
                                                                                                                                     10:~0         22,920.00
  6    Henry Du Bois's Sons, New York, N. Y ................................-.                                                         6.79        15, 617. 00
  7    Richard Parrott, Newburgh, N. Y ....................                          ........... .... ..........                     (*)


  * The price entered in this bid of Mr. Parrott had been altered by erasure and interlineation in so
careless a manner that it was impossible to determine what amount was intended, although the bidder
said it was $7.

           Abstract of contract entered into during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.

                                                                                                                             Price per
                           Name.                                          Date.                     Purpose.                  linear              Amount.
                                                                                                                                    foot.

Henry Du Bois's Sons .....................                          July 28, 1887           Building 2,300 feet                      $6. 79       $15, 617.00
                                                                                                of pile-dike.



                                                                         E 3.

            IMPROVEMENT OF THE HARBOR AT RONDOUT, NEW YORK.

   Rondout Harbor is formed by the mouth of Rondout Creek, which
empties into the Hudson River on its west side, about 90 miles above
the city of New York. The creek is a tidal stream for 3 miles above
its mouth. Prior to 1871 improvements had been made by private per-
sons and corporations, but no permanent benefit had been derived from
them. In 1869 a survey of the harbor was made by the Government,
with a view to its permanent improvement, and it was then found that
the available depth of water in the channel was about 7 feet.
   The project of improvement based upon this survey provided for the
formation and maintenance of a channel 100 feet wide and 14 feet deep
at the mouth of the creek, to be obtained by means of dredging and
diking. Two parallel channel-dikes were to be built outward toward
and into the Hudson River, their outer ends curving gently down-
stream, while a branch dike running up-stream along the Hudson from
the outer end of the north dike was to protect that dike from destruc-
tion by running ice. The estimated cost of this work was as follows :
Building the north dike, 748 yards long......                                              ..     ....       ..................                    $41, 600
Building the branch dike, 640 yards long ...                                          -- - --------..
                                                                                              -                              ....             .      34, 400
Building the south dike, 1,27'                          yards lonbg... ......--                                              ----                    59,600
Dredging a channel 3,000 feet long, 100 feet wide, and 14 feet deep at low                         4
                                                                                      -------- 14, 400
water, 48,000 cubic yards, at 30 cents...-..--...---..---.------....-------.........--......
Contingencies ............................. ..  ............................                   22, 500

           Total.... ....               ..... ....          ...                                          ....... ...........
                                                                                        - -....................                               . 172,      500
   The final length of the north and south dikes was, however, to be de-
termined after observing the effects which they might produce in the
            APPENDIX E--REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. McFARLAND.                                                               597
removal of the bar as they were gradually extended outward. The work
was begun in 1872 and was completed in 1880. It was found by expe-
rience that the dikes might be shortened so much below the lengths
originally deemed necessary for them; that the total cost of the work
was reduced to $90,000, a little more than one-half the original estimate.
   On the completion of the work the north dike was about 2,200 feet
long; the branch dike, running up the Hudson, was about 1,000 feet
long; the south dike was about 2,800 feet long, with a spur to the light-
house 330 feet long, while a channel wide enough for existing coin-
merce and 13) feet deep had been obtained along the north dike. A
history of the improvement may be found in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1881, Part I, page 494.
   The appropriations for this harbor made since the completion of the
works in 1880 have been applied exclusively to the repair of the dikes,
the channel being in a very satisfactory condition, it having a depth of
about 14 feet at mean low water. The appropriation of $2,500 made by
act of Congress approved August 5, 1886, has been applied during the
past year to their further repair, and to protect them with fenuder-piles.
   Bids for this work were called for by circular letter dated August 8,
1887, and a contract was formed accordingly with J. L. Powley under
date of August 31, 1887. He did not begin work, however, until Octo-
ber 28, but as his contract was nearly finished at the designated time,
it was thought best to extend it to December 31,when it was completed.
   The work consisted in driving fender-piles along the channel side of
the north dike at intervals varying from 4 feet near the outer end to 50
feet at the inner end; and a cluster of piles was driven to protect the
outer end of the south dike against damage by collision.
   Two small breaks in the north dike were repaired.
   This work cost $2,296.02, and the following materials were made use
of:
   Oak piles, 42 feet long; aggregate length, 6,977 feet ; white-pine tim-
ber, 11,427 feet, board measure; iron and chain, 6,080 pounds.
   The channel is in excellent condition, and there is no reason to ex-
pect any deterioration in it unless the dikes are carried away. They
are now in very bad condition from age and decay, and should be re-
placed as speedily as possible. Ten thousand dollars could be well ap.
plied in this way during the next fiscal year.
   The commerce of Rondout Creek is very large, amounting in 18S7 to
a tonnage of 2,109,716 tons, with a value of $14,326,615. It consists
principally of coal, lime, and cement and bluestone, and is carried on
in vessels of from 6 to 15 feet draught.
  Rondout is in the collection district of New York. The nearest works of defense
are those of New York Harbor. A statement of the amount of its commerce will be
found in my last annual report. No late information concerning it has been received.

                                                 Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available-----------..........................................                                2, 560. 36
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal, exclusive of liabilities out-
  standing July 1, 1887 ............................................--------------------------------------------   2,409. 14
July 1, 1888, balance available - ......                   ................          .........         ..   _...     151. 22
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ...                              -..................                 5, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 -- ..--.............                                         5, 151.22

  Amount that can be proitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1800                                        5, 000, 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections ' of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867,
598             REPORT               OF    THE         CHIEF        OF ENGINEERS,                           U. S. ARMY.

Jbhstract of bids for repairing the dikes at                       -RondoutHarbor,
                                                          New York, opened t the ,United
  States Engineer Office, Army Building, New York, August 18, 1887, at 12 o'clock mn., under
  circular letter of August 8, 1887.


                                                         White-oak                Yellow-pine              Iron,                 Stone,
No.                Name of bidders.                    piles, 7,000 lin-          timber, 15.000         5,000                  40 cubic   Amount.
                                                          ear feet.                 feet B. M.         pounds.                   yards.


                                                            Cents.                                        Cents.
  1 J. L. Powley .....................                                22                        $40                         5         $1     $2, 430
  2 Thomas Sturgeon ................                                  20                         45                         8          1      2, 515


          Abstract of contract entered into during the.fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.

               Name.                          D)ate.                 Purpose.                                     Price.                   Amount.


J. L. Powley..............                 Aug. 31, 1887     7,000 linear feet piles             22 cents linear foot ...                    $1, 540
                                                             15,000 feet, B. M., yel-            $40 per 1,000 feet......                        600
                                                                low-pine timber.
                                                             5,000 pounds iron .....              5 cents per pound.....                        250
                                                              40 cubic yards stone .. $1 per cubic yard ....                                     40

        Total ..........................                   i....      .........       .     .    .    ...................                     2, 430




                                                                   E 4.

                   IMPROVEMENT OF THE HARLEM RIVER, NEW YORK.

   The streams included in this improvement are the Harlem River and
Spuyten Duyvil Creek. The former empties into the East River near
Hell Gate, and the latter into the Hudson River, and together separate
Manhattan Island from the mainland. The two streams interchange
waters at Kingsbridge, but two bridges, with only short spans of from
10 to 15 feet, form dams and prevent a free interchange. The Harlem
River is navigable as far as Morris Dock for vessels of from 12 to 15
feet draught, and that is practically the head of navigation at present,
though light-draught boats can go as far as Fordham Landing, 1 mile
farther. Spuyten Duyvil Creek is navigable at high water as far as
Kingsbridge for vessels drawing 8 feet. The range of the tides in Har-
lem River varies from 5.2 feet at Third Avenue Bridge to 6 feet at the
mouth of Dyckman's Creek, near the head of navigation. The tides in
Spuyten Duyvil Creek have a range of about 4 feet. A full history of
this improvement, and the legal proceedings for the acquirement of
the land needed for it, is to be found in the Report of the Chief of En-
gineers for 1887, Part 1, page 665.
   The present project for the improvement was adopted in 1879. The
route selected being the one recommended by General Newton in his
report in 1875, a change being made in the width of the proposed chan-
nel from 350 to 400 feet, except in the rock cut through Dyckman's
Meadow. The depth of the channel to be excavated is 15 feet at mean
low water except in the rock cut, when 18 feet will be the depth.
   The original estimate for the cost of the work was in round numbers
 $2,700,000.
   The field and office work necessary for the establishment of the lines
of the improvement between the Hudson and Harlem rivers and the
borings for the determination of the material through which the canal
prism was to be excavated which were in progress at the end of the
last fiscal year were continued, and the latter were finished August 20.
       APPENDIX E--REPORT OF LIEUT.           COL. McFARLAND.        599
The total number of borings made was 141. with a total length of 6,278
feet, and ranging in depth from 9 to 112 feet.
   As soon as the triangulation was completed a series of cross-sections
for the accurate determination of the quantity of material to be removed
from the cut through Dyckman's Meadow was begun, and the necessary
field work and calculations were completed the latter part of October.
   Though it would have been more economical to carry on the work
through the marsh south of the foundry and rolling mill at the same
time that the excavation of the rock cut through Dyckman's Meadow
was in progress, and to make use of the rock excavated in structures
for the protection of the sides and bottom of the new channel through
the marsh, the amount of the appropriation would not admit of such a
division, and it was therefore decided to apply the appropriation to the
excavation of the rock cut through Dyckman's Meadow, and to store
the rock from the cut on leased land adjoining the work until the oppor-
tunity for using it in the work should occur. With this in view a strip
of land of about 7j acres was leased from Mr. Isaac M. Dyckman at the
rate of $1,000 per year, the lease to begin on December 1, 1887.
   Bids for excavating 150,000 cubic yards of material, more or less, from
the cut through Dyckman's Meadow were advertised for October 13,
and were opened November 9, 1887. Mr. John Satterlee's bid was the
lowest, at 93 cents for excavation above mean low water and $1.13 for
excavation below mean low water, all expenses of dams and pumping
to be borne by the contractor. Owing to doubts of Mr. Satterlee's abil-
ity to do the work, the contract was not awarded for some weeks. On
December 15, Mr. Satterlee having furnished the required bonds, the
work was awarded to him and the contract signed. The price bid for
the excavation was so 'much less than had been anticipated, that the
quantity to be excavated under this contract was increased to 300,000
cubic yards, more or less; and, as laid out on the ground, it will include
about 60,000 cubic yards of earth and loose rock and about 250,000 cubic
yards of solid rock, which at the prices for excavation above and below
the plane of mean low water will cost about $315,000.
   The contractor began preparations for work as soon as the contract
was signed, but did not begin excavation until January 9, 1888, and
then only with a few teams, stripping the rock. The rock excavation
was begun January 19 with a few hand drills, and two steam drills were
started January 24. Until March 19 all the material excavated was
hauled away on wagons or drags, but on that date the tracks leading
from the rock-cut to a trestle with a steep incline for raising the rock,
and making a high dump on the ground leased for storage, were put
in operation, and have worked fairly well ever since. The earth strip-
ping, except on the marsh, is still hauled away on wagons and carts and
used for filling up lots belonging to private individuals.
   The weather, which up to the middle of December had been quite
mild and dry, at that time became very cold and stormy, and during
the months of January, February, and most of March continued to be
very unfavorable for the work. On March 12 an unprecedented storm
of wind and snow visited this section of the country, and for a week no
work was done. For three days communication with the lower part of
the city was entirely cut off by heavy snow-drifts both on the railroads
and streets. The location of the work is very much exposed, and the
cold northwesterly winds sweeping through the valley of the Spuyten
Duyvil and the gap through which the cut is being excavated made it
impossible at times for the men to work without risk of freezing their
600                  REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

hands and feet. During the month of April the weather was more fa-
vorable, but the month of May was very wet and much time was lost.
The progress of the work was very slow, and on March 31 only 10,921
cubic yards had been removed from the cut, which was about one-fifth
of the amount called for by the contract. The last three months the
progress has been better, but so far has not reached the contract stip-
ulation of 20,000 cubic yards per month.
  A short dam built entirely of earth has been made across Dyckman's
Creek, near the Kingsbridge road, to keep out the Harlem River water,
and a long dam on the marsh composed of a double row of piles with
wooden braces and iron tie rods, and a continuous row of tongued and
grooved sheet-piling on the outside, and banked over for a width of
about 6 feet on top with the marsh sod, has been completed on the side
of the cut toward Spuyten Duyvil Creek.
   Since the completion of the dams a large pump has been put in op-
eration and an attempt made to lift the mud overlying the rock on
the westerly end of the work under contract, and to deposit it on the
adjoining marsh. At first, o wing to the roots, which extended to a
depth of from 8 to 10 feet, the experiment was not very successful, but
by using a larger pump the difficulties have been overcome and the
pump is now lifting the material very well. The water needed is sup
plied and controlled by a flood-gate in the large dam.
  The following table shows the progress of the work to June 30 and
the amount excavated in each month :

                                                 During-                                                  Above mean Below mean                       Total.
                                                                                                          low water.  low water.


                                                                                                          Cubic yards. Cubic yards.                 Cubic yards.
January.........                          .......................            ...             ..........          2, 266. ..............                    2, 266
February...                                                                                                      4, 678 .               -.--.....             4, 678
March ......................................                                             ..........              3,977             -----                      3,   977
April.......................................................                                                     7, 715 ............                     -    7,   715
May.....................................................                                                        10, 930       ..             _               10,   930
June .........................             ............             ..................                          12, 450                 1, 472               13,   922

           Total ................................................                                               42, 016              1, 472                  43, 488



   The material through which a part of the canal prism must be exca-
vated is so nearly semi-fluid that it necessitates some sort of protection
to the sides, and probably to the bottom of the cut, to prevent abrasfon
by the currents, which will be quite strong at certain times of the tides
after the channel is opened. In order to arrive at some idea of what
would be required, and the probable cost of such protection, it was de-
cided to experiment with a crib of round timber, and a mattress of the
same, to be framed and sunk alongside of each other in a trench dredged
for their reception in the marsh, their load to be put on gradually to
permit compacting the substrata, if possible.
   A point near the mouth of Spuyten Duyvil Creek was selected for
this purpose, which was far enough away from the present channel to
prevent these operations from being any obstruction to it. On April
13 bids for furnishing timber and drift-bolts for this work were adver-
tised for and May 3 they were opened. Mr. Enoch L. Richardson was
the lowest bidder for the timber, at $25 per 1,000 feet B. M. for square
timber, and 51 cents per linear foot for the round timber, and Mr. John
Timmes, was the lowest bidder for the drift-bolts at 2.4 cents per pound.
IVr, George E, Richardson was engaged to (lo the work of framing and
            APPENDIX E---RVPORT                                OF LIEUT. COL. MCFARLAND.                                         601
sinking the crib at 17 cents per cubic foot for the timber work, and 75
cents per cubic yard for the stone delivered in the cribs. A dredge was
hired from the Morris & Cumings Dredging Company at $90 per day,
and a trench 200 feet long, 13 feet deep at mean low water, and 40 feet
wide at the bottom was dredged for the reception of the crib-work and
timber mattress. The amount of material dredged from the trench was
6,335 cubic yards, and it was removed at a cost of about 27.9 cents per
cubic yard. The crib-work has been framed to a depth of about 174
feet, and will be settled in its place and sunk as soon as the neces-
sary stone can be obtained. In order to get the stone from that stored
from the cut through Dyckman's Meadow, a new front with other re-
pairs was required to an old dock. That work has been begun and will
be completed in a few days. As soon as the crib is filled with stone
the experiment of a mattress will be undertaken. It is also proposed
to try an experiment with loose stone, to test the penetration of the
stones into the mud, with a view to using riprap should it be found prac-
ticable to do so.
   The amount that can be profitably expended upon the work during
the next fiscal year is $1,000,000, as it can not be well or economically
conducted unless the appropriations are large.
   The work has been under the personal supervision of Civil Assistant
1. H. Talcott, C. E., by whom the original surveys under General New-
ton were made in 1874; and it has been conducted with ability and
good judgment.
  Harlem River is in the collection district of New York. The nearest light-house is
on Blackwell's Island.
  A full statement of the commerce likely to be benefited by the improvement is given
in my last annual report. See Report of Chief of Engineers for 1887, Part I, page 665.

                                                      APPROPRIATIONS.


June 23, 1874, allotment from appropriation for East and Harlem rivers -.... $11, 000
By act of Congress approved March 3, 1875. ................................   10, 000
June 18, 1875          ...............----------------......------.......------.............--------.......-----.........      300, 000
March 3, 1879 ------.----...--------.---                           .--- .----...------------ ----------.                       100, 000
        Total......----------......-------....--......------------....---........----......--------.................           421,000
   Amount expended to June 30, 1888, $62,179.68.

                                                   Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available---
                               .......-..---..                                      ....................                 $399, 012.23
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ....................   41, 179. 68
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities..............---.......... 18,288.07
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts......... 268,261.76
                                                                                                                            327, 729.51

July 1, 1885, balance available ...............                               ................             ..   . ....       71,282. 72
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888---....................                                                         70,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889- .-..............                                                     141,282.72

IAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... 2,230, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
      1890 .............................................-----------...------...........
                                                                                     ----                                1,000, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     halboyr acts of 1 66 and 1867,
602           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                              U. S. ARMY.

Abstract of bids for improving Harlem River, New York, by excavating 150,000 cubic yards
  of material, more or less, from the cut through Dycknan's Meadow, opened at United
  States Engineer Office, Army Building, New York, November 9, 1887, at 12 o'clock m.,
  under advertisement of October 13, 1887.


                                               Above mean low water                 Below mean low water
                                                75, 000 cubic yards.                 75,000 cubic yards.
No.              Name of bidder.                                                                                    Total.
                                               Rate per                            Rate per
                                                cubic         Amount.               cubic          Amount.
                                                yard.                               yard.

  1   Bernard Mahon, New York .........          $2. 00          $150, 000             $5. 00         $375, 000     $525, 000
  2   A. M. Newton, New York............          1. 34           100, 500              1.34           100, 500      201, 000
  3   P. Sanford Ross, Jersey City, N. J ....     1. 35           101, 250              1. 95          146, 250      247, 500
  4   John Cox & Co., New York....                1.19             89, 250              1.19            89,250       178, 500
  5   Edward Moore, Portland, Me .....        ..      00          225, 000              4. 00          300, 000      525, C00
  6   George G. Turner, Yonkers, N. Y....         1. 40           105, 000              1. 55          116, 250      221,255
  7   John Satterlee, Englewood, N. J ...           . 93           69,750               1. 13           84, 750      154, 500
  8   O'Brien & Clark, New York .........         1.75            131, 250              1. 75          131, 250      262, 500
  9   Evans & Ackerman, Binghamton,N.Y            1. 00            75, 000              1.40           105, 000      180,000
10   John Sullivan, Catskill, N. Y ...           1. 00            75, 000              1. 50          112, 5(0      187, 500
11   Thos. F. Maney & Co., Boston, Mass -.       1. 50           112, 500              2. 00          150, 000      262, 500
12   John A. Bonker, New York.........   .       1.90            142, 500              1.90           142, 500      285, 000
13   Ripley, Smith & Brown, New York..           1. 24            93, 000              1.49           111, 750      204, 750
14   William E. Dean, New York...... ..          1.35            101, 250              1.45           108, 750      210, 000



Abstract of bids for improving Harlem River, New York, for construction materialfor crib
revetment in Spuyten.Duyvil Creek, opened at the United States Engineer Office, Army
building, New York, May 3, 1888, at 12 o'clock m., under advertisementof April 13, 1888.


                                                                Timber.


                                                   Round timber.                      Square
                                                                                     timber.         20,000
                                                                                                    pounds
                                                                                                   driftbolts.
No.              Name of bidder.                  40,000
                                               linear feet
                                                                   4,600               8,000
                                                              linear feet           feet B. M.                    Amount.
                                               spruce or        s                    Georgia"
                                                hemlock.        spruce.               pine.


                                               Price per                           Price per        Price per
                                              linear foot.    linear foot.              . 'M         pound.


  1 George Karr & Co., New York, N. Y.             $0. 06              $0. 06              $24.00 ..        ..      2,   868. 00
  2 EnochL. Richardson,New York, N.Y                 . 05$                . 05$             25. 00 ....             2,   597. 25
  3 James D. Leary, New York, N. Y ...               . 05$                . 05$             29. 00..                2,   852. 25
  4 James DuBois, New York, N. Y.....                . 06                 . 06j             25. 00      $0.03       3,   587. 50
  5 Rowland A. Robbins,New York, N.Y                         ............                                  02            488. 00
  6 John Temines, Brooklyn, N. Y ......                                                                    02U%          480.00


  James DuBois also bid 71 cents per linear foot for round white pine.

Abstract of contracts entered into during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, for                                improv-
                                    ing Harlem River, New York.

      Date.             Name.                      Purpose.                       Price.        Quantity.         Amount.


Dec. 15,1887..   John Satterlee ....... Excavation above mean                     $0. 93      122,475 cu.yds.     113, 901.75
                                          low water.
                                        Excavation below mean                      1. 13      178,191 cu.yds.     201, 355. 83
                                            low water.
May 16, 1888 . Enoch L. Richardson.      Round timber ............                  .05-      44,600 lin. ft..      2, 397. 25
                                         Square timber..........                      00
                                                                                  25. 02      8,000 ft.B. M            200. 00
May 16,1888 . John Temines.......)rift bolts...............                                &a 20,0001bs....              480.00
        APPENDIX    E-REPORT       OF LIEUT. COL. McFARLAND.            603

                                    E 5.

    REMOVING OBSTRUCTIONS IN THE EAST RIVER AND HELL GATE.

    A description of this channel and of previous work in it is given in
my last annual report, which will be found in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1887, Part I, page 689.
    The East River is crooked and narrowin places, and much obstructed
by rocks and affected by violent currents.
    The worst of these obstructions is that known as Hell Gate, lying at
the mouth of Harlem River, between Blackwell's and Ward's islands,
about opposite Ninety-sixth street, New York.
     Here the river turns at right angles around Hallet's Point, divides
into several channels and runs with a velocity varying at different
stages of the tide from 3 to 10 miles an hour, over or around Hallet's
Point, Negro Point, Way's Reef, Shell Drake, Pot Rock, Frying Pan,
Heel Tap, Holmes's Rock, Hog's Back, Flood Rock, Hen and Chickens,
Gridiron, The Negro Heads. Mill Rocks, Rhinelander's Reef, and Bread
and Cheese.
     On account of the violence and irregularity of the currents and the
  crowded condition of this passage, wrecks at Hell Gate have been num-
  erous for many years, though they have greatly decreased in number
  since the improvement of the channel was begun in 1867 under plans
  prepared by General Newton. At that time some of these rocks pro-
jected above the water level, while the least depths over the others at
  mean low water varied from nothing to 1i feet. General Newton's plan
  was to cut away the rocks and reefs that lay directly in the channel to
  a depth of 26 feet at mean low water, and to build sea-walls or dikes on
  some of the others which lay near the edges of the channel in order to
  guide the currents and prevent them from rushing over, the rodks and
  carrying upon them the vessel which might come within their reach.
     Such a wall has been built by the United States between Great and
  Little Mill Rocks, and the city authorities have built a similar protect-
  ing wall on the reef known as Bread and Cheese, at the head of Black-
  well's Island.
     The project of improvement provided for the removal at Hell Gate to
  a depth of 26 feet at mean low water of the reef at Hallet's Point, Way's
  Reef, and Shell Drake, Pot Rock, Frying Pan, Heel Tap, Negro Point,
  and Flood Rock, including the Gridiron, Hen and Chicken, and Negro
  Heads, and the construction of sea-walls on the Mill Rocks, Hog's Back.
  and Holmes's Rock, and in other parts of the East River for the removal
  of Diamond Reef and North Brother's Island Reef to a depth of 26 feet,
  Coenties Reef to a depth of 25 feet, and the small rocks known as
  Scaly Rock, Blackwell's Rock, Pilgrim Rock, and the rock off Woolsey's
  Bath-house.
     At the close of the last fiscal year the following parts of this project
  had been executed:
     Hallet's Point, covering 3 acres, Way's Reef, Shell Drake, Diamond
  Reef, North Brother's Island Reef, Coenties Reef, Scaly Rock, and Pilgrim
  Rock had been removed to the depth contemplated in the project ; Heel
  Tap had been broken to 26 feet, and dredged to 22.5 feet; and the least
  depths on Frying Pan and Pot Rock were 18 feet, and 22.8 feet at mean
, low water respectively; Flood Rock and connecting reefs covering 9
   acres had been broken to 30 feet, and their removal was in progress,
   the Negro Heads and Hen and Chickens having been reduced to 18 feet
604                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                          U. S. ARMY.

mean low water, and a new 18-foot channel 320 feet wide opened across
the reef. The total cost of this work was $3,571,613.
  These results have been of the greatest value to navigation.
  Under their contract of November 16, 1886, the Atlantic Dredging
Company continued work upon the removal at Flood Rock, working
their largest dredge day and night until December 1, 1887, after which
date the work proceeded by daylight only. November 23, 1887, the
contract was extended by the Chief of Engineers until April 15, 1888,
and it was completed on that date.
  The following table shows in detail the work done under the contract:




  fiscal year : No. 6.........._
     Packard's                                         74       130   2, 357   128   12,150    19, 548, 324   58
                                                                                                              .             $0.13
                                                                                                                            s53


Total work done under con-
tract dated November 16, I
  1886:
    Packard's               No.     6.........        200       196   4, 396   258   26, 500   41, 712, 65    70. 46        $0.133
    Packard's                        hino.
                                    5..........   .   123   ......      901'    42    3, 300    7,805,088     63.45         0.088

          Total..................                       3       196   5 297    300   29, 800   4,517,723      .......   .     126


Cost ofnedurynamitefor surface blasting, 21 cents per pond.
The dredge broke her boom December 3, 1887, and lost ive d0               it.
                                                                  replacin548,
                                                                          9ays
Total removed since the explosion and up to June 30, 1888, 83,685 ton.


   The
tion   ofprogress  of the
          small stone      work
                       on the    has
                              reef    been
                                   after it much delayed
                                            has been     by the
                                                     worked  overaccumula-
                                                                  a consid-
   orable time, which fills utethe spaces between the larger blocks, pre-

venting the grapple from taking hold of them, and is too fine itself to
remain in the grapple while it is being hoisted through the swift cur-
rent. No practical method of coping with this difficulty has as yet been
found. Some delay and difficulty also occurred, during the absence
of the engineers in charge of the work, from inadvertently setting the
dredge at work on a part of the rock that had not been mined. In
other respects the progress of the work has been highly satisfactory,
excellent results being obtained with the dredge so long as the surface
of the reef remains moderately clear.
   The work done under the last contract has added about 60 feet to the
width of the new 18-foot channel.
   The machinery and other plant stored at Astoria, as well as the drill-
scow and other vessels moored at Mill Rock, have been kept in order
during the year. The expense of taking care of this property is con-
siderable; it deteriorates to some extent with age, and much of it will
be out of date if kept much longer. On the other hand, if sold at auc-
tion it would bring very little in proportion to what it would cost to
replace it. The drill-scow has begun to leak considerably, though it
was hauled out and put in order in 1884, since the last time it was
used.
   It is apparent that a considerable saving to the United States would
result from making the appropriations for this work large enough to
admit of putting all this machinery at work before it ceases to be
Sserviceable, without interrupting the work on Flood Rock, the removal
of which is an immediate necessity.
           - APPENDIX E-REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. McFARLAND.                                                                                            605
   Hell Gate is the worst of the obstructions which are found in the East
River; but there are many other rocks and reefs in other parts of this
crowded water-way which are constant sources of danger to passing
vessels, which have been often complained of and which ought to be
removed. There is a long line of reefs and isolated rocks in mid-stream,
extending a mile and a half downward from the foot of Blackwell's
Island, which have always been troublesome to vessels beating up
against the wind or crossing from one channel to the other, as the winds
and tides often compel them to do, and which, with the continually in-
creasing size of vessels and the increasing commerce of the river, are
becoming still more dangerous. The worst of these ought to be re-
moved now.
   The expenses incurred on account of the improvement during the year
amount to $49,460.34, of which $383 remained outstanding at the close
of the fiscal year. Tbey are distributed as follows:
Dredging 19,548.32 tons of rock ...... -..-...........................---       ----.                                                         $38, 901.50
Inspection and surveying ......        -             ---..--..........-----......---....                                                        1,779. 49
Care and preservation of mining plant at Astoria .--..--............                   ..                                                       2, 747.85
Care and preservation of drill-scow and floating plant .................                                                                        2,369.26
Administration ------......----------......................................
               ......                                                                                                                           3, 662. 24

          Total .----.....----......- ......---------......       .........                  ..................                  ....          49, 460. 34

   The amount that can be profitably expended in the removal of ob-
structions in East River and Hell Gate during the next fiscal year is
$500,000, to be applied to the removal of Flood Rock chiefly, and also to
continuing operations with the steam drill-scow on the other obstructions
in the East River and at Hell Gate, before mentioned.
   It is especially desirable that the appropriation for this work should
be liberal, not only in order that the extensive plant on hand may be
kept at work, but because there is but one dredging company in the
United States that has dredges that can do the work on Flood Rock
efficiently; and as there is, therefore, no competition, reasonable bids
for contract work can only be secured by the appropriations being suf.
ficiently large to make it possible to reject unreasonable bids and pur-
chase the necessary machinery to do the work by day labor.
   Nothing further has been heard of the suit begun last year to dis-
possess the United States of its occupancy of the dike built by it be-
tween Great and Little Mill rocks.
  The work is in the collection district of New York. The nearest port of entry is
New York City. The nearest light-house is Blackwell's Island Light.
  A full statement of the commerce making use of Hell Gate was published with my
last annual report, which will be found in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1887, Part I, page 689.
                                                  AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED.

By acts of Congress approved-
    July 25,1868 -.. -- -----------...-----....--..........  ..----..-.....--.- ........--..--                                  ----......    $85,000.00
    April 10, 1869 .... ................                       ..... --.               ---..........                                  ....
                                                                                                                                    -......   178, 300. 00
    July 11, 1870 ..----..----------------------.................................-----.....----.                                              250, 000.00
    March 3,1871 .............                  ........        .....................-                                          ...     ...   250, 000. 00
    June 10,1872.---...-- ----........--....-------....--.............................--------                                                225, 000. 0
      March 3, 1873 --------.... ---........--...--..--..--------........-----...                ,----.. ---....--.------........             225, 000. 00
      June 23, 1874 .....................................                                                     ..............                  225, 000.00
      March 3, 1875 ...--....                    --............--       --.........
                                                        ----- ................--                                                              250, 000.00
      August 14,1876 ............................................----------------------------------------------                               250,000.00
      June 18, 1878 ..--.................                               . ...         .               .....             ..       ..---- .     350, 000.00
      March 3, 1879 ................                          ..............              ........            ...            ...    .. .      250, 000. 00
      June 14,1880 ...              ....-...................                        ......             .............- ..                      200,000.00
      March3,1881 ................--                            ................                     ..       ..      - --............----200,000.00
      May 4, 1882 .......-                   .....          .......           .... ...... ......              ..............                   50, 000. 00
806             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

By act of Congress passed August 2, 1882.. ....   .-...  ... ...... ........$200, 000.00
By act of Congress approved--
   July 5, 1884---- ----....----....  ---..--..---......------......
                        ......------......
                                ----....-                          --..--..--
                                                                ----...-..   360,000.00
   August 5,1886 ......--........--.                                  --     112, 500. 00
                                     .---..........----....---...........--.....
   Received from other sources ......... .       ............ ...--........    3, 719. 62
                                                                                                                                             3,664,519.62
De.duct amount reverted to U. S. Treasury .....                                                         ..--..   $3,158.55
Deduct amount allotted to Harlem River- -...                                                            ...--- . 11, 000. 00
                                                                                                                                                    14, 158. 55

                                                                     3,650,361. 07
Amount expended to June 30, 1888.................................... 3, 633,892.91

                                                               -   Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available ----.....................................                                                                           $24, 717. 62
Received from sales of fuel to officers ..........              ......                                       ...............                             52. 49

                                                                                                                                                    24,770. 11
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ....-.... -............                                                          $8, 301.95
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ._.........--    .       .......                                                         :383. 00
                                                                                                                                                     8, 684.95

July 1, 1888, balance availabl......-----....----...----.----..----......--------......--------....                                                 16, 085. 16
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 _........ ...............             _250,                                                               000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ..............                                                                               263, 05. 1

 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ...... 1, 238, 840.67
  Amountthat canbe profitablyexpended in fiscal year ending June 30,
        -----..............................................------------------....-----....
   1890.......
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
                                                                                 river and
                                                                                           500, 000.00
                                                                                                                    2of
   Commercial statistics of the port of New York for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.

Amount of revenue collected ...-         ...... ....       .. ......... .-...........               $145, 300, 544. 35
                                                           ..
Value of all imports.-------- ------ -.............- -. - -----------------        .. .....--..       470,426,724. 00
Value of all exports......................        - ---   -- ---...-                                  34,9, 956. 00
                                                                          ..-..--..... .....--------------
                                                                                                 -



                                                                                                                                       Number. Registered
                                                                                                                                                tonnage.

Foreign vessels entered ....................................................                                                              3, 815      4,754,927
Foreign vessels cleared. ...        ..........                   ................................                                         3, 803      4, 783, 448
American vessels from foreign ports .........                                                                   .     ..                  1, 514         882, 105
American vessels cleared     for  foreign        ports       -  -.......     - -......         ..............--            - -......      1, 021         744, 848
Coastwise vessels entered ......................................................                                                          2, 182
Coastwise vesselp cleared........              ........................................................                                   3, 093



                                                                               E 6.

                         IMPROVEMENT OF NEWTOWN CREEK, NEW YORK.

   Newtown Creek is a sluggish stream, about 4 miles long, running
through the eastern part of Brooklyn and emptying into the East River
opposite Thirty-fourth street, New York.
   In 1.857 it had a depth of about 17 feet, which had decreased in 1880
to about 121 feet at low water from its mouth up to the Vernon Avenue
Bridge, a distance of 1,100 feet, its width for this distance being about
240 feet; thence it gradually decreased in width and depth until at the
head of navigation, where the Metropolitan Avenue crosses it, there
was a low-water depth of about 4 feet and a width of about 100 feet.
            APPENDIX E--REPORT                            OF LIEUT. COL. McFARLAND.                                      607

  A survey of this creek with a view to its improvement was ordered
by act of Congress approved March 3, 1879, and was made under Gen-
eral Newton's directions, and was reported upon by him January 31,
1880. The project which he presented provided for dredging a channel
from the mouth of the creek to Vernon Avenue Bridge, 200 feet wide
and from 18 to 21 feet deep at low water, requiring the removal of
145,000 cubic yards of material, chiefly mud, the cost of which was es-
timated at $36,250.
  Work under this project was begun in 1880, but by reason of in-
creased cost of dredging the estimated cost was increased to $44,050.
   Under the act of Congress passed August 2, 1882, another survey
was made under the direction of Major Gillespie, whose report is dated
December 26, 1.883. His project provided for carrying the improve-
ment from the Vernon Avenue Bridge up to the head of navigation in
both branches of the creek. The estimated cost of executing this proj-
ect was as followh:
To excavate a channel 18 feet deep and 175 feet wide, from Vernon Avenue
Bridge to the Central Oil Works, 143,500 cubic yards excavation, at 30 cents
per cubic yard ...----   ----  ------------                                       - 050
                                                     ---- ---------- -----. ..---$$43,
Thence 15 feet deep and from 125 to 150 feet wide, to Queens County Oil
  Works, 101,600 cubic yards excavation, at 35 cents per cubio yard ........ .35, 560
Thence 12 feet deep and 125 to 150 feet wide to Nichol's Chemical Works,
52,600 cubic yards excavation, at 40 cents per cubic yard .................       21,040
Thence 10 feet deep and from 100 to 125 feet wide, to the head of navigation
on both branches, 231,600 cubic yards excavation, at 40 cents per cubic yard 92. 640
C ontingencies..       ..................        ................................-                     ......           19, 229
To which must be added the revised estimate for work below Vernon Avenue
                      -----.-------.....------ --.....-..-----.....---......--------....--........--...----.
  Bridge, before given.....                                                                                             44, 050

Total estimated cost of improving Newtown Creek ...- ......                           ....   -- ....            ....   255, 569

   Up to June 30, 1886, $45,000 of this amount had been appropriated,
.depth
and with it the channel below Vernon Avenue Bridge had been given a
       of 18 feet, with a width varying from 75 feet at the bridge to 150
feet at the mouth of the creek; and channels 10 feet deep and from 50
to 200 feet in width had been dredged from Covert's Dock up to the
bridge at Metropolitan avenue and Grand street, on the west branch,
and to Grand Street Bridge on the east branch, the distance being about
3,000 and 1,000 feet, respectively.
   The act of Congress approved August 5, 1886, appropriated $37,500
for the improvement, but directed that $9,375 should be expended on the
west branch, between Maspeth avenue (Covert's Dock) and what is
called the Dual Bridge, at Grand street and Metropolitan avenue, $9,375
on the main branch between Easterly Grand Street Bridge and Metro-
politan avenue, and the balance on the lower end from Maspeth avenue
to the mouth.
   Proposals were accordingly invited March 2, 1887, by public adver-
tisement, for dredging 70,000 cubic yards of material from the lower
part of the creek between its mouth and the Vernon Avenue Bridge,
and 35,000 cubic yards from the west branch above Easterly Grand
Street Bridge, and 25,000 cubic yards from the west branch at the upper
end of the creek.
   The depths to be obtained were to be respectively 21 feet at mean low
water in the lower part of the creek and 10 feet in the upper part.
   The bids were opened April 6, 1887, but as they were all too high they
were rejected, and other bids were asked for by circular letter dated
April 22.
  By this circular letter the depth to be secured in the lower part of the
608     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY

creek was fixed at 18 feet at mean low water instead of 21 feet, as pre-
viously advertised.
   These bids were opened April 29, 1887.
   Morris & Cumings were the lowest bidders, and a contract was en-
tered into with them May 10, 1887, to dredge 70,000 cubic yards of
material from below Maspeth avenue, at 32 cents per cubic yard, and
50,000 cubic yards of material from above Maspeth avenue, at 34. cents
per cubic yard.
   Work under this contract was begun May 24, on the lower part of
the creek between the mouth and the Vernon Avenue Bridge.
   Just below Vernon Avenue Bridge it was found a number of te!e-
graph and telephone wires and oil-pipes crossed the stream at depths
varying from 15 to 17 feet below mean low water. The owners were
communicated with, and were requested to remove them temporarily
in order that the dredging might go on, and this was readily agreed to.
   The work continued till September 12, 1887, during which time 70,000
cubic yards of material were excavated, giving a channel 18 feet deep
and 200 feet wide from the 18-foot curve in the East River up the creek
for 1,100 feet: thence for the next 800 feet up the creek 18 feet deep and
175 feet wide; thence up to Vernon Avenue Bridge, a distance of 500
feet, 18 feet deep and 140 to 150 feet wide. The material removed con-
sisted of mud, clay, and a few large bowlders, but principally of mate-
rial which had evidently been dredged and dumped in the channel by
private parties. This was especially noticeable at the mouth of the
creek, where it has been the custom to bring dump-scows down the
creek with a small tug and mooring them to a buoy, so that they might
be taken out to sea at night by a large tug and dumped.
   It is a significant fact that the worst shoaling was found just around
this mooring buoy, showing either that the scows leaked badly or that
the material was willfully dumped there to save 40 miles towing. There
is no doubt at all that the latter is the true cause of the formation of
this shoal.
   On the 28th of June, 1887, work under the same contract was begun
on the upper easterly branch of the creek, above Maspeth avenue, and
was continued up to September 12; when on this branch, between the
Easterly Grand Street Bridge and the Metropolitan Avenue Bridge, a
channel from 100 to 125 feet wide and from S. to 10 feet deep at mean
low water had been dredged.
   The amount of material removed here was 25,175 cubic yards.
   On the western branch of the creek, between Maspeth avenue and
the Dual Bridge work was begun August 6 and was completed Sep-
tember 10, 1887, during which time 25,071 cubic yards of material were
excavated.
   Besides this a cut from 35 to 50 feet wide and 10 feet deep was exca-
vated from Maspeth avenue to the Dual Bridge on the western side of
the channel, a small cut 50 feet wide was made around the bend, and a
cut varing from 25 to 35 feet wide was made on the east side of the
channel from the second bend up to Dual Bridge.
   The rise and fall of the tide in the creek is about 4.5 feet, but the
bed of the creek has no natural slope.
   The creek itself is a receptacle for all the refuse from the sewers, fac-
tories, and slaughter-houses of the east of Brooklyn. Constant deposits
are therefore forming in it, especially at the upper end, from these
causes and from the caving in of the unprotected banks, which consist
of marsh mud. To remedy this difficulty, annual dredging will be
             APPENDIX E-REPORT                         OF LIEUT.             COL. MCFARLAND.                      609
needed until the banks are protected by bulkheads throughout their
whole length.
   The commerce of the creek is so large that this improvement should
be pushed at least 3 miles up from the mouth as soon as possible.
Many of the ships going above Vernon Avenue Bridge ought to load to
a draught of from 20 to 23 feet; but at present they can only take on
a part of their load in the creek, through which they can carry perhaps
only 16 or 17 feet, and must then finish loading at the wharves in
deeper water in the East River.
   It is recommended that $100,000 be appropriated for continuing this
improvement, which should be carried up-stream continuously.
   The wording of the appropriation of Xugust, 1886, prevented the ap-
plication of any part of it to that part of the creek lying between the
forks and the Easterly Grand Street Bridge, up to which point, under
the unexpended balance of the appropriation of July, 1854, it was only
possible to make a channel 50 feet wide.
   It would have been better for the work had the appropriation been
made in such a way that the improvement above the bridge could have
been made as an extension of the improvement below it, since these
improvements are now separated by a narrow cut to which, under the
wording of the law, no part of the last appropriation could be applied.
  This work is in the collection district of New York. Nearest port of entry, New
York City; nearest light-house, Blackwell's Island Light; nearest fort, Fort Co-
lumbus.
                                            Amounts appropriated.


     Date.                                            Application.                                             Amount.


June 14, 1880    Dredging below Vernon Avenue Bridge....................................                        $10, 000
Aug. 2, 1882     Dredging below Vernon Avenue Bridge .....        ..............--------..........               15, 000
July 5, 1884     Part applied above Vernon Avenue Bridge .--.........----................                        20, 000
Aug. 5,1886      Below and above Vernon Avenue Bridge--..    -...........................                        37, 500
                       Total..................            ...........
                                      --------------------------------------------------------                    82,000


Amount expended to June 30, 1888 ..............................                                      ....   $80, 957.17

  A full statement of the commerce of Newtown Creek will be found in
the last annual report.

                                              Money statement.

July 1, 1887, amount available ....-...------- ------............--....------..--------------........ $2, 577.23
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887..............................................                               1,034.40

July 1, 1888, balance available--.. ...........--......----...............                                    1, 542.83
Akmount appropriated by act of August                  11, 1888....            ...................          25, 000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                    26, 542.83

IAmount         (estimated) required for completion of existing project..---.                               148, 000.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                 100, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 to 1867.
          ENG 88 -           39
610     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                   E 7.
        IMPROVEMENT OF BUTTERMILK CHANNEL, NEW YORK.
  Buttermilk Channel is the name given to the channel which separates
Governor's Island, at the mouth of the East River, New York Harbor,
from the city of Brooklyn, which lies east of it.
  The channel on the northwest side of Governor's Island, which sepa-
rates it from the lower end of the city of New York, is the wider and
the deeper of the two, and is the channel most used by vessels passing
between the East River and the other parts of New York Harbor.
   Buttermilk Channel is obstructed by three shoals:
   1. A shoal lying above and northeast of Governor's Island, projecting
into Buttermilk Channel, and extending over to the main channel on
the other side, which originally had a least depth over it of 9) feet at
mean low water.
  2. A shoal, putting out from Red Hook Point, on the Brooklyn side,
and extending up to the eastern side of the channel to the entrance of
the Atlantic Basin, with a least depth on it of about 5 feet at mean low
water.
  3. A shoal putting out from the southern side of Governor's Island and
extending towards the Red Hook Point Shoal, which is partly dry at
mean low water.
  A narrow and crooked channel about 30 feet deep lies between the
two latter shoals.
   Between the first-mentioned shoal and Governor's Island is a narrow
channel with 20 feet of water in it, and between this shoal and the Brook-
lyn shore there is a channel of the same depth, also originally narrow,
but widened now to about 900 feet.
   The line of docks and wharves from the Brooklyn Bridge down to the
mouth of the Atlantic Basin, on the Brooklyn side, is one of the most
important in New York Harbor; and this part of the river, extending
from the Brooklyn Bridge to Governor's Island, is regarded by pilots
and masters of vessels as one of the most difficult places in New York
waters to carry a vessel through safely, on account of this shoal, the
rapid current, and the enormous traffic passing, not only up and down,
but across the stream.
  Tows, tugs, small steamers, and small craft generally, in passing up
and down this part of the East River, keep to the New York side,
forcing the larger class of sound steamers, ocean steamers, and sea-
going ships in tow of tugs, to keel) over towards the shoal at the upper
point of Governor's Island, and if, as is often the case, these vessels are
obliged to stop in order to avoid collision with ferry-boats, sloops, and
canal-boat tows, they are liable to drift upon this shoal.
   Upon a statement of these difficulties, made by shipping merchants
and others whose business lay along the Brooklyn wharves between
Wall Street Ferry and the Atlantic Basin, a survey of this shoal was
ordered in 1872. and a project for its improvement was adopted in 1880.
  This provided for the removal, to a depth of 26 feet at mean low
water, of such parts of this shoal as lay within 850 feet of the line of
the Brooklyn wharves.
  The estimated cost of this improvement was $140,000, which provided
for the removal of 570,000 cubic yards of material, at the rate of 23
cents per cubic yard, with 12 per cent. added for contingencies.
  The first appropriation for this work was made June 14, 1880, since
which time other appropriations have been made, under which the work
        APPENDIX E--REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. McFARLAND.                     611
was carried on up to November 3,1884; but, owing to the distance from
the place of excavation to the place where the dredged material had to
be dumped, which is outside of Sandy Hook, a distance of about 20
  miles, the prices bid for the work were more than 50 per cent. greater
'than had been anticipated, and the estimated cost of the improvement
  had to be increased, therefore, to $210,000, of which $190,000 had been
  appropriated up to June 30, 1886.
     Under these appropriations 466,276 cubic yards of material were re-
  moved from the shoal, deepening the water over the part removed cer-
  tainly to 24 feet and probably to 26 feet at mean low water, with some
  shallower spots. It was too late in the season when the work closed,
  however, to determined this by a survey. The part removed included
  the original crest of the shoal, leaving no part of it on which there
  should have been a less depth than 17 feet.
     But it is probable that this least depth was not attained, since a sur-
  vey, made in June, 1884, showed that a material shoaling had taken
  place on undredged parts of the shoal since the first work had been done,
  amounting at that time to about 37,000 cubic yards, which, if distributed,
  would have reduced the depths on the undredged parts of the shoal to
  13 feet at mean low water, instead of 17, as it should have been had no
  such deposit been made.
     This shoaling is probably due to the fact that the city authorities
  have a scow anchored on the shoal, to which tugs, steam-lighters, and
  small steamers transfer their ashes, and during this transfer a part of the
  ashes probably falls overboard between the steam-boat and the scow.
     The recommendation was made in my annual report for 1885 that the
  width of this channel should be increased from 850 to 1,150 feet, unless
  it should be decided to remove the whole shoal to a depth of 26 feet at
  mean low water; and $50,000 was recommended for beginning the
  further widening of the channel.
     When the last detailed survey of the shoal was made in June, 1884,
  it appeared that the excavation of about 336,057 cubic yards of mate-
  rial would be required for the removal of the whole shoal; of this
  amount 30,097 cubic yards were taken out under the contract, which
  was terminated in November, 1884.
     This left 305,960 cubic yards yet to be taken out in order to complete
  the removal, which, at 50 cents per cubic yard, would cost about $150,000.
     In view, however, of the shoaling which is known to have occurred
  during the progress of the work, it seemed advisable to increase this
  estimate by $20,000, making a total of $170,000 required forthe removal
  of the whole shoal.
     The large and increasing traffic of this part of the river certainly war-
  rants the removal of the whole shoal.
     This recommendation that the whole shoal should be removed was
  tacitly accepted by Congress in the appropriation of $56,250 for the
  work, made by act of Congress approved August 5, 1886, since this
  appropriation was larger than the amount recommended for widening
  the channel only.
     In the application of this appropriation it would be more advanta-
   geous to commerce to remove the whole shoal down to a depth of 22
  feet at mean low water rather than to remove a part of it only to the
   proposed eventual depth of 26 feet, leaving other parts with 16 or 18
   feet of water above them. Bids for the work were therefore invited by
public advertisement, dated October 29, 1886, and a contract was
formed accordingly with the United States Dredging Company, who
were to do the dredging at 23k cents per cubic yard. As they failed to
612         REPORT OF THE CHIEF' OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

comply, however, with any of the terms of their contract, it was an-
nulled, and an agreement was made with Henry DuBois' Sons to do the
work at 25 cents per cubic yard. (See the last annual report on But-
termilk Channel for details.)
   Work under DuBois' contract was begun in March and finished in
October, 1887, during which time 186,638 cubic yards of material were
removed, and a depth of 22 feet at mean low water had been secured
over the entire shoal.
  To remove the remainder of the shoal down to the desired depth of
26 feet below mean low water will require, according to the survey of
1884, and taking into consideration the filling which is going on there,
the removal of 165,000 cubic yards of material, which, at 50 cents per
cubic yard, will cost $82,500; add for contingencies, $12,500; total,
$95,000.
   A reef or shoal in this part of the river lying only about 350 feet from
Diamond Reef, which was removed in 1879-'80, is an obstruction to
navigation, since there is a depth of about 20 feet over it at mean low
water. This may be removed, as Diamond Reef was under the appro-
priation for East River and Hell Gate, should that title of appropria-
tion be restored.
   The commerce of this part of New York Harbor is very large, con-
sisting of all the East Indian, West Indian, South American, and most
of the Continental European trade.         This is carried principally in
steamers drawing from 19 to 23 feet of water.
   The number of sea-going vessels using the wharves adjacent to But-
termilk Channel for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, was 4,150,
with a tonnage of 3,058,504 tons, and the value of the merchandise
which they carried was $154,829,062. This, however, does not take into
consideration the coastwise and passing trade; it appears, therefore, of
importance that this improvement should be carried out.
  This work is in the collection district of New York. The nearest port of entry is
New York City, and the nearest work of defense Fort Columbus, New York Harbor.
The amount of revenues from customs collected is the amount collected at the port of
New York.
                                Amounts appropriated.

    Date.                                                               Application.                                                                          Amount.


June   14,1880      Dredging ............--..............----------------............----................-----------------------------....                       $60, 000
Mar.    3, 1881    ...... do .............................-------------------------------........--------------------------.....................                  60, 000
Aug.    2, 1882-   ..... do ...........--------....................------------------......--------------------------------.........                              60, 000
July    5,1884     ......-- do ...---...--------------------------------------------------...                                        .........                    10, 000
Aug.    5,1886     ...... do ......----..----..--------..--..-----.--......--.........---------.......................-------.                                    56, 250
                            Total.------         ---.. ----..-------              -----------.....              --...     ........       ..........              246, 250
                            Received from other sources.........                               .-..-...                    ...-..---..-               .   .          100
                                                                                                                                                                 246, 350


  Amount expended to June 30, 1888, $240, 492.84.
  A full statement of the commerce of Buttermilk Channel accompanied the last an-
nual report upon it.
                                                              Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available...............                                                        ......       ...........        ......               $9, 461.94
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887                            ..--.         .......                 ...-              ....-                  .           _.._         3, 604. 78

July 1, 1888, balance available ... .... ...... . . ................... .... 5, 857. 16
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888................ .......... 100, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 .................                                                                                   101,857. 16
          APPENDIX E-REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. MCFARLAND.                                                       618

                                                    E 8.

                    IMPROVEMENT OF GOWANUS BAY, NEW YORK.

  Gowanus Bay is a part of New York Harbor, lying at the mouth of
Gowanus Creek, in the southwestern part of the city of Brooklyn: The
depth of water in the channel was formerly from 7 to 12 feet at mean
low water, which was wholly insufficient for the passage of the vesse s
employed in the commerce of the district. A survey of Gowanus Bay
and Creek was made in 1880, and a project for their improvement was
submitted in January, 1881.
   This project provided for dredging a channel between the pier lines
established by the commissioners appointed by the State of New York
in 1875, beginning at the bay and extending up the creek to Hamilton
Avenue Bridge, 18 feet deep at mean low water and 200 feet wide, ex-
cept for the upper few hundred feet near the bridge, where the widt                                             It
was to be gradually reduced from 200 feet to 100 feet. The total length
of the proposed channel was about 9,000 feet.
   The estimated cost of this improvement was as follows :
530,000 cubic yards of dredging, at 30 cents per cnbic yard.............                                $159, 000
Contingencies.................
                          .   .    ........  ....    .. ...... ..............                             23, 850
       Total...................................                ............           .............       182, 850
  The proposed channel, however, did not follow the old channel at the
mouth of the creek, since the pier line established by the commission
crossed the old channel at that point, and the land under water inside
of it, including the bed of the old channel, had become private property.
   The owners of this property, Messrs. Beard and Robinson, were
anxious, nevertheless, to have the old channel improved, instead of
having the new one formed, as proposed, outside of the established pier
line; but, as this could not be done unless they surrendered their right
to build out to the pier line, they signed a paper relinquishing their right
to build piers which should obstruct the old channel so long as that chan-
nel should be permitted to exist; and the Maritime Association of New
York at the same time petitioned that the old channel should be kept
open. As the improvement of this channel would, however, help only
the land near it on the north side, and not at all that which lay on the
opposite or southerly side of the creek, General Newton recommended
that the conflict of interests be settled by dredging the natural channel
from the Hamilton Avenue Bridge down to the southwest corner of the
Erie Basin; and that from that point two channels should be dredged,
one running northerly along the west side of the Erie Basin to deep
water near Red Hook, and the other running southerly along the
wharves on the south side of the bay, toward Bay Ridge.
   Both of these channels were to be 200 feet wide and 18 feet deep at
mean low water. This project required for its execution a larger amount
of work than the original scheme called for, namely:
The excavation of 583,530 cubic yards of material, which, at 30 cents per
  cubic yard, would cost.....................................$175,059.00
Contingencies, 10 per cent.....................                 .. ... ... ................ ....         17, 505.90
        Total...... ....................                      ........          ..
                                                                              .....            ......   192,564.90
  The legal measures necessary for securing the right of way across
Beard and Robinson's property, at the mouth of the creek, were not
614     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

completed satisfactorily until May, 1883, but under appropriations of
1881, 1882, and 1884 the proposed Red Hook branch of the channel was
dredgid 100 feet wide for a length of 2,000 feet, measured from Red
Hook, and the southern channel, running towards Bay Ridge, was begun
at the southern end, and carried northward for a distance of 1,900 feet,
with depths in it varying from 21 to 17 feet, except for a few hundred
feet at the upper end on the eastern side where the last cut was left
unfinished.
   The act of Congress approved August 5, 1886, appropriated $7,500 for
the continuance of this work. This amount was too small either to
benefit the improvement much, or to secure low rates for the work. It
was advertised, however, and bids were opened on the 23d of October,
1886, for extending the channel up the creek for about 1,500 feet above
the end of the old dredged channel, or to within 600 feet of the Ham-
ilton Avenue Bridge. The depth to be obtained was 18 feet, and the
width was to depend upon the price bid.
   All the bids received were high, but it was nevertheless recommended
that the lowest bid be accepted, "as no economy would probably result
from re-advertising."
   The recommendation was approved, and a contract was entered into
December 22, 1886, with Elijah Brainard, the lowest bidder, who was
to do the dredging at 32 cents per cubic yard.
   Work under this contract was begun February 4, 1887, and was con-
tinued until March 12, 1887, when it was stopped. During this time
21,497 cubic yards of material were removed from the channel.
   Two parallel cuts, each about 20 feet wide at the bottom and 18 feet
deep, were made along the northern channel line of the creek from a
point opposite the foot of Twenty-third street to one opposite the foot
of Sixteenth street, Brooklyn, a distance of about 1,500 feet.
   The material varied very much in character, from hard compact yel-
low clay to soft black mud; the mud overlies the clay, as a rule, to the
depth of 2 feet.
   Although a depth of 18 feet was obtained by the dredge, the soft ma-
terial filled into the cut again so rapidly that, at the close of the dredg-
ing, sounding showed a depth of only 15 feet, and that the cut was about
40 feet wide at bottom, with a top width varying from 55 to 75 feet;
but it is not likely that even this depth will be maintained in so nar-
row a cut.
   At the close of the work, March 12, 1887, the condition of the.chan-
nel in Gowanus Bay and Creek was as follows :
   What may be called the Red Hook Channel, running round the Erie
Basin to the mouth of the creek, had been practically completed for
its full width and depth, and the channel leading from it up the creek
had been completted to within 2,100 feet of Hamilton Avenue Bridge,
with a further extension 15 feet deep and 40' feet wide at bottom for
1,500 further up the creek.
    What may be termed the Bay Ridge Channel, south of the mouth of
the creek, had been begun at its outer or southern end, and had been
carried up with nearly full depth and width to a point 2,00:) feet south
of the mouth of the creek.
    The following work yet remains to be done under the original project:
    The completion of the channel up the creek, 2,100 feet to the Hamil-
ton Avenue Bridge, and the extension of the southern or Bay Ridge
Channel northward so as to connect with the Red Hook Channel at the
mouth of the creek.
            APPENDIX E--REPORT OF LIEUT. COL.                                  McFARLAND.           615

   A sketch of the condition of this improvement June 30, 1885, may be
found in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1885, Part I,
page 672.
   Under the present estimate of $192,564.90, only $72,500 have been ap-
propriated to June 30, 1887.
   The project should be completed as soon as possible.
   Large manufacturing and shipping interests are growing up along
the banks of the creek, for which the present depth of 18 feet at the
mouth and 8 feet at the upper end of the creek are wholly inadequate.
   In 1871, when the first project for its improvement was adopted, 18
feet was the depth of water which the commercial men interested in the
improvement asked for; now owners of the water-fronts are petitioning
for 21 feet, and yet only half of the original project has been completed.
   Apart from the creek, the Red Hook and Bay Ridge channels in the
bay, as stated in my annual report for 1886 (page 723), are very impor-
tant to passing commerce, and would be used when completed by ves-
sels of a large class.
   A letter from one of the leading merchants of New York and Brook-
lyn, published on page 713 of my annual report for 1887, inclosing a
petition signed by many firms interested in the improvement of both
Gowanus Bay and Buttermilk Channel, gives a fair idea of the growing
necessities of the commerce of the port of New York which seems to
indicate the need of the early completion of this improvement.
   From this letter it appears that there is not now enough wharf-room
in the harbor, vessels frequently having to pay a bonus of $75 or $100
a day for the privilege of using wharves for which there is a constant
demand, and that the improvement of Buttermilk Channel and the
Gowanus Bay channels, which constitute a very large part of the water
front of Brooklyn, and which are included in the East River district, of
which 63.7 per cent. of the commerce of the port of New York make
use, would give very great relief, especially if the low-water channel
depth were increased to 21 feet instead of 18 feet, as was proposed last
year, since it would permit the construction of many more wharves.
   To complete the Gowanus Iay channels, as originally proposed, mak-
ing them 200 feet wide and 18 feet deep at low water, would require,
under previous estimates, the expenditure of $120,000. The work could
be much better and more cheaply executed were this whole amount
made available in one appropriation.
   But there can be no doubt that these dimensions are too small in
view of the great increase in length and draught which has taken place
recently in the construction of sea-going vessels, especially steamers.
The depth of these channels ought to be increased now to 21 feet at low
water and their width to 400 feet, while to facilitate the handling of
vessels in the contracted space near the mouth of Gowanus Creek, more
room should be gained by cutting away the angle on the south side.
   To make these changes in the channels would involve the removal of
1,345,000 cubic yards of material in place as follows:
Red Hook Channel-
   To deepen it to 21 feet .....................                    ..   ....... cubic yards..     70, 000
   To widen it to 400 feet ........................................                     do..-..   100, 000

                                                                                                  170,000
Bay Ridge Channel-
   To deepen it to 21 feet .................................  cubic yards..                       250, 000
     To widen it to 400 feet............ ............................ do -....                    275, 000
                                                                                                  525, 000
 616                   REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Gowanus Ceeek Channel-
           To deepen it to 21 feet .---...........--....           ..... .......-             cubic yards..                                                                      350, 000
           To cut away the angle---- -----................----....             -----......----.... ---.... do ....
                                                                            --....--..                                                                                           300, 000
                                                                                                                                                                                 650,000
                Total in place ................................................                                                                                   ....         1,345,;000
Which, at 40 cents per cubic yard, would cost . - ......
                                                    -                                                                                --...............
                                                                                                                                            --                         ...      $538, 000
Contingencies ...............................................-----                                                                                                               62,000
               Total...                    .........................................                                                              ............                  $600,000
   Gowanus Bay is in the collection district of New York City. Nearest light, Rob-
bin's Reef.
   Nearest work of defense, the fort on Governor's Island, 1 mile to the northward.
                                                                           ORIGINAL ESTIMATE.

Dredging 583,530 cubic yards, at 30 cents................... ..........                                                                                                     $175, 059.00
Contingencies, 10 per cent .....-................  ....-....-..........                                                                                                       17, 505.90
               Total...--.... ......-......                                 ......-....................                                     ..........             .          192,564. 90
                                                                           Amounts appropriated.

         Date.                                                                              Application.                                                                        Amount.


Mar. 30, 1881 Dredging ------............................................................--....                                                                                   $40, 000
Aug. 2, 1882 ..... do ....................................................................                                                                                         20, 000
July .5, 1884 ...... do ...-- ......            ............................................                                                          ....      ...                 5, 000
Aug.          5, 1886 ...... do .........................................................                                                                        ........            7, 500
                                         Total ..............................................................                                                                       72, 500


Amount expended to June 30, 1888 ........                                                              ..........     ....-..               ..........                       $72, 436. 69
Estimate for channels 400 feet wide and 21 feet deep at low water-......                                                                                                      600, 000. 00

                                                                      COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

The following statement concerning the commerce of Gowanus Bay, New York
Harbor, was given in my last annual report:
                                                                         Receipts and shipments.

                                                               Articles.                                                                           Quantity.                   Values.

Coal ............................                                                     .................................. tons..                          170, 000                 $595, 000
Brick ...................................................                                                             .......                     160, 000, 000                  1, 120, 000
Lumber ..........              .          .....................................                                      feet, B. 1..                  75, 000, 000                  1, 500, 000
Lime, etc ...              ....... ....            .........................................                             barrels.                      370, 000                     555, 000
Grain ..........                       .........          ...                .....................                      bushels..                  11, 000, 000                  7, 700, 000
Ice .......                     ......                                         ......................                            tons..                  100, 000                  300, 000
Roofing tar ...     ...         ..      ............................                 barrels..              100, 000                                                               200, 000
Building stone, etc...............................................................................................                                                                 350, 000

           Total .......................................................                                               ........................                                 12,320,000


                                                                 Vessels arriving and departing.

                                                                       Articles.                                                                              Quantity. Tonnage.

Steamers. .....              ......            ....................................................                                                                       25        17, 840
Ships...                                                                                                                                                                  65        8, 179
Barks                          .................................................................                                                                         311       605, 371
Brigs .............................................................................                                                                                       72        25, 381
Schooners..........................................                                                              .................                       ..              296        64, 256
           Total-.....................................                                                          . .....................                                  769       793, 027
              APPENDIX E-REPORT                                  OF LIEUT. COL. McFARLAND.                                     617
  Many steam-tugs, canal-boats, and lighters pass in and out of the bay every day,
varSing in draught from 6 to 12 feet, but no record is kept of these vessels unless
they pass through the draw-bridge at Hamilton avenue. The record of those so pass-
ing is as follows:


                                                                       Number of       Number of                              Daily
                               Year.                                   times opened                        Tonnage.         average
                                                                        and closed,     passed
                                                                                       through.                             of times
                                                                                                                             opened.

1881 ...............................................                          5,740           4,126             573,949               15
1886     . ..- -.... .. .... .................         .......   ...          7, 632          6, 071            98,431                21




                                    Money statement.
July 1,1887, amount available--- .---........... ..-----....---...............                   .                             64. 31
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887----
                          .--------.....----......----------......----......-...------...------.                                1.00
July 1, 1888, balance available......----......-------......------......------......-------....----......----..               63.31
Amount appropriated by act of August 11,1888..........................                                                    60,000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889-                                            -.................      60, 063. 31


   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 60, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                                  E g9.

                                IMPROVEMENT OF NEW YORK HARBOR.

    A description of this harbor and a history of the work already done
in the improvement of its Sandy Hook entrance was given in my last
annual report, and will be found in the Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1887, part 1, page 717.
   The main or Sandy Hook entrance to New York Harbor is one of the
best in the world, the channel being about 24 feet deep at mean low
water and nearly 29 feet at mean high water, with abundant breadth,
and no need for deepening it was ever felt until within the last few
years, when the great increase in the length, tonnage, and draught of
the transatlantic passenger steamers made further deepening necessary
in order to prevent the delays to which they have been subjected by
having to wait for high water in order to pass either in or out.
   Before the improvement of the main entrance into New York Harbor
was undertaken by the United States it was obstructed by four shoals,
as follows:
    1. The outer bar, about 4,000 feet wide, the channel across which is
known as Gedney's Channel, where there wered epths of 23.7 feet in mid-
channel and 22.3 feet in the southern half.
    2. The shoal at the mouth of the Swash Channel, about 4,000 feet wide,
where the depth was 24.3 feet.
The channel across this shoal has been named the Bayside Channel
for the following sufficient reason given me in a letter from Captain
Derby:
  Early in the spring when the first surveys had been made and the work done in
the main ship-channel during the winter had been found to be sufficient to admit to
618      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

the upper harbor vessels that could cross the bar, it was decided to have the new
channels buoyed so that vessels could use them.
   In publishing the notice to mariners describing the new buoys, Commander Mac-
kenzie, U. S. Navy, thought it necessary to give a name to the channel across the
shoal west of Gedney's Channel at mouth of the Swash Channel, because considerable
confusion had already arisen and some rather unpleasant newspaper correspondence
been caused by uncertainty as to the proper name of this spot.
   In the published notice he named the channel after the Bayside range which marks
its center line-the range of the Bayside Beacon and Waackaack Beacon. The new
buoys are numbered B 1, B 2, etc.; and in Gedney's Channel they are numbered G 1,
G 2, etc.
   3. The shoal northwest of Sandy Hook, about 2,000 feet wide, on which
the least depth was 26.2 feet.
   4. The shoal in the main ship-channel in the lower bay, nearly 3 miles
long, on the crest of which the depth was only 23.9 in mid-channel,
with depths of 22.6 within a few hundred feet of the mid-channel range.
   A large proportion of the vast commerce of the port which is carried
on in vessels of great draught could only cross these shoals at or near
high water.
   The project for the improvement of Gedney's Channel was approved
by the Secretary of War in December, 1884, and its extension to cover
the whole of the main entrance to the harbor received his approval
December 27, 1886.
   It provides for dredging a channel 1,000 feet wide and 30 feet deep at
mean low water, from deep water below the Narrows through the main
ship-channel and Gedney's Channel to deep water outside the bar;
maintaining this channel, should it be necessary., either by periodical
dredging, or by contracting the entrance by the construction of a dike
running across the shoals from the Coney Island side with suitable
protection for the head of Sandy Hook to prevent its being scoured
away by the increased current.
   The estimated cost of obtaining the dredged channel is $1,490,000, and
the entire cost of the improvement should the contraction works prove
to be necessary, is estimated at between $5,000,000 and $6,000,000.
   Under this project an extended survey of the lower bay had been
made on which the method of improvement was based, and 303,869
cubic yards of sand had been dredged from Gedney's Channel at the
close of the last fiscal year.
  This had resulted in producing a channel of good, navigable width
across the bar 25 feet deep at mean low water, but no practical benefit
to navigation had resulted since no increase in depth had been ob-
tained on the shoals inside the bar, the application of the funds hav-
ing been restricted by the language of the appropriation act to Ged-
ney's Channel only.
   At the beginning of the fiscal year the Joseph Edwards Dredging
Company had not yet begun work under their contracts of April 21 and
May 19, 1887, for dredging 2,200,000 cubic yard at 28. cents per cubic
yard from the four shoals in the channel, and owing to the delay of the
builders in delivering the dredges, the first of these machines, the Ad-
vance, originally called the Bolivar, did not begin work until August 1,
1887, one month behind time, the Mount Waldo did not begin until Oc-
tober 14, two months and a half behind time, and the Reliance only
started November 26, nearly three months behind time. The season of
1887 was therefore nearly entirely lost, only 180,830 cubic yards having
been dredged to January 1, at which time 700,000 cubic yards were to
have been removed from Gedney's Channel alone.
  All three dredges worked upon Gedney's Channel until December 3,
       APPENDIX E--REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. McFARLAND.                    619

when they were transferred to the shoal in the main ship-channel west
of Flynn's Knoll.
   The largest vessels frequenting the port of New York draw, as ordi-
narily loaded, about 27 feet in leaving port, but in arriving here they
rarely draw over 24 feet, having lightened themselves by consuming
from 1,500 to 2,000 tons of coal during the passage. While it is of
course desirable that vessels should be able to leave port at all hours,
it is much more important that they should be able to enter without
regard to the stage of the tide, for the time of departure can be reg-
ulated to suit the tide, but the time of, arrival can not. The working
of the dredges during the year has therefore been so directed as to
secure as early as practicable a channel across all the shoals 500 feet
wide and sufficiently deep to admit the largest steamers at low water,
leaving for later operations the deepening of this 500-foot channel to 30
feet at mean low water, and its widening to 1,000 feet the full dimen-
sions required by the project. All three of the dredges were accord-
ingly kept on a section of the main ship-channel about 3,000 feet long
including the crest of the shoal west of Flynn's Knoll, from December
3 to May 10; the Reliance and Advance were then transferred to the
Bayside Channel until June 11, when the Reliance was ordered to Ged-
ney's Channel.
   The entire quantity dredged during the fiscal year is 580,405 cubic
yards, which, with the 303,869 cubic yards dredged from Gedney's Chan-
nel during 1885 and 1886, has produced a channel not less than 500 feet
wide, in which the least depths between the steamer wharves and the
ocean is 26 feet on the bar and 25.4 feet on the shoal west of Flynn's
Knoll in the lower bay.
   These dimensions are sufficient to enable the largest steamers arriving
off the bar as now loaded to reach their wharves without delay at aver-
age low tide, and they also permit any of the large steamers leaving
the port at high water, as is usual, to go to sea loaded fully 2 feet deeper
than was ever practicable before.
   The dredged channels have been thoroughly buoyed, and as soon as
the pilots have become familiar with the new channels the port of New
York will reap the full benefit of the results.
   To test the permanency of the work accomplished a survey of Ged-
ney's Channel by Captain Derby's method was made last December on
completion of operations for the season; all soundings were taken with
a rod graduated to feet and tenths, and were located by angles read
with the transit from triangulation stations established on the shoals
near by. This survey was repeated May 30, before dredging on the bar
was resumed. A careful comparison of the two surveys shows that no
shoaling whatever had taken place in the dredged channel during the
six months of boisterous weather that had elapsed since operations were
suspended. As a like comparison was made a year ago with precisely
the same result, it may be said that the prospect that the dredged chan-
nel across the bar will maintain its new dimensions by the action of the
currents alone, is most encouraging.
   It having been reported in the newspapers that new shoals had formed
in the Bayside Channel during the winter, a new survey was made of
it in April for comparison with the one made last season. No evidence
of shoaling was found; but on the contrary, the agreement between
the two surveys was so marked as to give grounds for hoping that this
locality may prove as favorable for the maintenance of a dredged chan-
nel as the outer bay, which was hardly to be expected as the ebb cur-
rent of the Swash Channel flows across the Bayside Channel nearly at
right angles.
620       REPORP OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The work done during the winter on the shoal in the main ship-
channel was surveyed April 16, and 177,937 cubic yards measured in
place were found to have been removed from the shoal. The quantity
removed by the dredges amounted, however, to only 128,453 cubic
yards measured in scows, which would not correspond ordinarily to
more than 102,762 cubic yards measured in place. It is apparent
therefore that the work of the dredges has been materially supple-
mented by the currents, in fact to the extent of about 73 per cent. It
is not known whether the currents are actually attacking the bottom
of the channel, or whether this increase in the place measurement is
due entirely to the fact that the material is composed of sand mixed
with mud, and that the greater part of the latter does not lodge in
the bins of the dredges, but is carried overboard by the overflow
from the bins and drifted off by the currents in the channel before it
has time to settle to the bottom again. The surface currents of the bay
at this point run transverse to the channel instead of along its axis, and
the tendency is therefore to carry overflow material upon the adjacent
shoals. A survey made in June to ascertain whether this material
found a lodgment in the channel at some point farther down-stream in-
dicates, on the contrary, that the channel has slightly deepened from
natural causes alone, both in the prolongation of the dredged area, where
no work has been done, and in the dredged area itself, where work had
been suspended for six weeks. These changes, however, though very
noticeable, are believed to be too slight, considering the difficulties in
the way of exact measurement, to warrant drawing the conclusion that
the currents are actually attacking the bottom ; but they are highly sat-
isfactory as far as they go, both as regards the prospects of permanency
in the dredged channel and as regards the great saving that will result
in the cost of carrying out the project, if through the assistance of the
currents, the place measurement continues to exceed the scow measure-
ment.
   The following table shows the performance of the dredges through
out the year :

                                    Gedney's Channel. Bayside Channel. Main ship.channel.




                       In. Inche.                   .t.




do........14   278   215   12x18    39   36, 320         5        ..     76      ,669   6   75,989




eliance ...    87    2 20 5   20     20 46, 240                        9 79      ,642       183,581

Mount Wal-
Mount Wal-




The pumps are of the Edwards patern (Andrews patent).                         The dredge Mount

Waldo isfitted to pump into bins on board or into scows alongside.
yards.
       APPENDIX E-REPORT OF LIEUT. COL, McFARLAND.                   621

   The great difference in the performance of these dredges in the
main ship-channel as compared with their work on the outside shoals
is due in part to the greater distance from the shoal to the dumping-
ground, but mainly to the great difference in the character of the
material, which is chiefly a coarse, clean sand in the Bayside and Ged-
ney's channels, and a very fine sand mixed with mud in the main
ship-channel.
   This latter material is much the more difficult to dredge not only on
account of the large percentage of mud too fine to be caught in the bins,
but also on account of its lying very compactly on the bottom and be-
ing consequently much more difficult to raise with the pump.
   The plant put on the work by the contractors does all that was ex-
pected of it in Gedney's and Bayside channels, and the dredges Reli-
ance and Advance will readily complete the work in the time specified
in the contract for the Gedney's Channel division. But owing to the
difficult character of the material in the main ship-channel, and also
to the delays in getting started last season, it is apparent that the con-
tractors can not possibly unaided remove the 1,500,000 cubic yards
specified in the main ship-channel contract by December 1, 1888, at
which date the contract expires.
   It would appear, in fact, that 500,000 cubic yards would be a liberal
estimate of the amount that they are likely to accomplish by that date.
This fact became apparent as early as November, 1887, and efforts were
then made to secure additional plant to assist with the work; but
dredge owners objected to putting their plant to work in such an ex-
posed locality so late in the season. These efforts were, however, re-
sumed in the spring, while Colonel Gillespie was in temporary charge
of the work, with more success, resulting in agreements being made
with Messrs. Brainard Brothers, and with Joseph Cumings, providing
for placing on the main ship-channel at the earliest practicable date two
more dredges having an estimated daily working capacity of 1,500 and
6,000 cubic yards, respectively. The work is to be done under the
specifications of the contract with the Joseph Edwards Dredging Com-
pany and to be paid for at the contract price, 281 cents per cubic
yard, scow measurement.
   These agreements were approved by the Secretary of War May 16 and
May 15, respectively.
   Messrs. Brainard Brothers began work June 18, using the dredge Leo,
formerly employed on the Gedney's Channel work, and described in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1886, page 732. They had
removed at the close of the fiscal year 3,950 cubic yards of material, but
had not got their plant in thorough running order.
   Joseph Cumings expects to begin work about July 15. He has char-
tered the steamship State of Alabama, a vessel of 6,500 tons displace-
ment, belonging to the State Line Steamship Company, running be-
tween New York and Glasgow, and is fitting her with a large vacuum
pump with two 32-inch suctions.
   If these new dredges succeed in accomplishing the amount of work
that their owners expect of them, the plant now provided for the work
will readily complete the removal of the 2,200,000 cubic yards specified
in the contracts with the Joseph Edwards Dredging Company by
December 1, 1888.
   The illegal dumping of refuse and dredged material spoken of in my
last annual report has continued throughout the year, greatly to the
detriment of the harbor, and at considerable loss to the Government,
which in several instances has been obliged to dredge up and remove the
material dumped in the channels.
622          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   It is hoped, however, that this vicious practice will be entirely done
away with under the provisions of Senate bill No. 1241, which received
the approval of the President June 29. This bill, a copy of which is
annexed, contains the best provisions of the bill recommended by the
Board of Commissioners of Pilots, referred to in my last annual report,
since it provides for the fine or imprisonment, or both, of any one aid-
ing or abetting such illegal dumping, half the fine to go to the informer,
the taking away of the license of the master or engineer who may engage
in it, the libelling of any vessel employed in such work, and lastly fining
the owners of the property from which such material is taken as well as
the owner of the dredge who does the work, at the rate of $5 for each
and every cubic yard of material illegally dumped.
   This act applies only to New York Harbor and the waters connected
with it. It would be in the interests of navigation and of economy if
its provisions were extended to all the navigable waters of the United
States which are subject to improvement.
   The expenses incurred on account of the improvement during the year
amount to $198,182.32, of which $60,467.95 remained outstanding at the
close of the fiscal year. They are distributed as follows:
           -----..................-----..----......--...-----------. --..----......------....
Dredging ......                                                                            ......-----...... $165, 413. 73
Inspection ...................                      ....           ....... ...........    ...................   3.470. 39
Surveying ............................................................                                         20,164.16
                     .
Administration -----................-------...------      ---....-----......-----......---....
                                                          -....             --..------------...------           9, 134. 04
               ......----......---......----...--......--..........-----...----.........--.........
        Total----                                                                                          198, 182. 32
  The amount needed outside of the present appropriation to widen
these channels to 1,000 feet and to deepen them to 30 feet at mean low
water, as required by the plan of improvement, is $540,000; and this
amount could be well expended in the next fiscal year.
  A full statement of commercial statistics relating to the port of New
York was given in my last annual report, and will be found on page
928 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1887.
  At this port two-thirds of the merchandise imported into the United
States is received and two-thirds of the import duties are collected.
From this port are sent out one-half of the domestic products of the
country which are exported, and here one-half of the foreign tonnage
trading with the United States enters. Three-quarters of the passen-
gers traveling between the United States and foreign countries come
and go by way of New York, and three-fifths of all immigrants land at
Castle Garden.
   From January 1 to June 29, 1888, during my absence, this improve-
ment was in temporary charge of Lieut. Col. G. L. Gillespie, Corps of
Engineers, U. S. Army.
   The work, has been under the immediate personal supervision of Capt.
George McC. Derby, Corps of Engineers, and the successful results which
have been attained are in a very large measure due to his intelligence
and his untiring energy and zeal.
                                              AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED.
For Gedney's Channel:
    By act of Congress approved July 5, 1884 ........................                                    $200, 000. 00
For New York Harbor:
    By act of Congress approved August 5, 1886........................                                     750,000.00
         Total............---   ..---   ---   , ..............             ....----------.........         950,000.00
Amount expended to June 30, 1887, Gedney's Channel. ..............                                         200, 000. 00
Amount expended to June 30, 1888, New York Harbor....... .                                     .....       145,421.10
         Total---..--..-.....           -..-... -......-. ......   -....-..........        .........       345, 421. 10
                  APPENDIX                     E-REPORT                         OF LIEUT.                       COL. MCFARLAND.                              623
                                                                  Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available ...............................--...--------....... $742, 293.27
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ......................              $137, 714.37
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities-.................-------.----.......   60, 467.95
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts .......... 461, 586. 27
                                                                                        659, 768. 59

July 1, 1888, balance available .---....                                          ...........................                             ......      82,524.68
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                                                                             380, 000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ..                                                                 ........--......           462, 524.68

  ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project unless it
     should become necessary to resort to contraction works, which would
      cost between $4,000,000 and $5,000,000 ..........................--    . 160,000. 00
    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 160, 000.00
  I Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
  ( harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
Commercial statistics of the port of New York for the fi8cal year ending June 30, 1888.
Amount of revenue collected                                      ..      ..........................-                            ....-..      $145, 300,344.35
Value of all imports .................                ......................                                                                   470, 426, 724. 00
Value of all exports........... ....................................                                                                           334,929, 956.00


                                                                                                                                       Number. Registered
                                                                                                                                                tonnage.


Foreign vessels entered ..................                                   ............................                                     3, 815     4, 754, 927
Foreign vessels cleared ........                        ........          ...       ..........................                                3, 803     4, 783, 448
American vessels from foreign ports ..-....................                                                     ....... ....- ---...          1, 514        882, 105
American vessels cleared for foreign ports . -.                                 ...............................                               1, 021        744, 848
Coaswise vessels entered ...-------------------------------------------                                                                       2, 182 ...
Coastwise vessels cleared........................................................                                                             3,093..........



                                                                      PUBLIC-No. 155.

AN ACT to prevent obstructive and injurious deposits within the harbor and adjacent waters of New
         York City, by dumping or otherwise, and to punish and prevent such offenses.
   Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America
in Congress assembled, That the placing, discharging, or depositing, by any process or
in any manner, of refuse, dirt, ashes, cinders, mud, sand, dredgings, sludge, acid, or
any other matter of any kind, other than that flowing from streets, sewers, and pass-
ing therefrom in a liquid state, in the tidal waters of the harbor of New York, or its
adjacent or tributary waters, or in those of Long Island Sound, within the limits
which shall be prescribed by the supervisor of the harbor, is hereby strictly forbid-
den, and every such act is made a misdemeanor, and every person engaged in or who
shall aid, abet, authorize, or instigate a violation of this section, shall, upon convic-
tion, be punishable by fine or imprisonment, or both, such fine to be not less than two
hundred and fifty dollars nor more than two thousand five hundred dollars, and the
imprisonment to be not less than thirty days nor more than one year, either or both
united, as the judge before whom conviction is obtained shall decide, one-half of said
fine to be paid to the person or persons giving information which shall lead to con-
viction of this misdemeanor.
   SEC. 2. That any and every master, and engineer, or person or persons acting in such
capacity, respectively, on board of any boat or vessel, who shall knowingly engage
in towing any scow, boat, or vessel loaded with any such prohibited matter to any
point or place of deposit, or discharge in the waters of the harbor of New York, or in
its adjacent, or tributary waters, or in those of Long Island Sound, or to any point or
place elsewhere than within the limits defined and permitted by the supervisor of
the harbor hereinafter mentioned, shall be deemed guilty of a violation of this act,
and shall, upon conviction, be punishable as hereinbefore provided for offenses in
violation of section 1 of this act, and shall also have his license revoked or suspended
for a term to be fixed by the judge before whom tried and convicted.
   SEC. 3. That in all cases of receiving on board of any scows or boats such forbidden
matter or substance as herein described, it shall be the duty or the owner or master, or
624      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS. U. S. ARMY.

person acting in such capacity, on board of such scows or boats, before proceeding to
take or tow the same to the place of deposit, to apply for and obtain from the super-
visor of the harbor appointed hereunder a permit defining the precise limits within
which the discharge of such scows or boats may be made; and any deviation from
such dumping or discharging place specified in such permit shall be a misdemeanor
within the meaning of this act; and the master and engineer, or person or persons
acting in such capacity, on board of any tow-boat, towing such scows or boats, shall
be equally guilty of such offense with the master or person acting in the capacity of
master of the scow, and be liable to equal punishment.
  SEC. 4. That all mud, dirt, sand, dredgings, and material of every kind and descrip-
tion whatever taken, dredged, or excavated from any slip, basin, or shoal in the har-
bor of New York, or the waters adjacent or tributary thereto, and placed on any boat,
scow, or vessel for the purpose of being taken or towed upon the waters of the harbor
of New York to a place of deposit, shall be deposited and discharged at such place or
within such limits as shall be defined and specified by the supervisor of the harbor, as
in the third section of this act prescribed, and not otherwise. Every person, firm, or
corporation being the owner of any slip, basin, or shoal, from which such mud, dirt,
sand, dredgings, and material shall be taken, dredged, or excavated, and every per-
son, firm, or corporation in any manner engaged in the work of dredging or excavat-
ing any such slip, basin, or shoal, or of removing such mud, dirt, sand, or dredgings
therefrom, shall severally be responsible for the deposit and discharge of all such mud,
dirt, sand, or dredgings at such place or within such limits so defined and prescribed
by said supervisor of the harbor ; and for every violation of the provisions of this sec-
tion the person offending shall be guilty of an offense against this act, and shall be
punished by a fine equal to the sum of five dollars for every cubic yard of mud, dirt,
sand, dredgings, or material not deposited or discharged as required by this section.
Any boat or vessel used or employed in violating any provision of this act, shall be
liable to the pecuniary penalties imposed thereby, and may be proceeded against,
summarily by way of libel in any district court of the United States, having jurisdic-
tion thereof.
   SEC. 5. That a line officer of the Navy shall be designated by the President of the
United States as supervisor of the harbor, to act under the direction of the Secretary
of War in enforcing the provisions of this act, and in detecting offenders against the
same. This officer shall receive the sea-pay of his grade, and shall have personal
charge and supervision under the Secretary of War, and shall direct the patrol boats
and other means to detect and bring to punishment offenders against the provisions
of this act.
   SEC. 6. That the sum of thirty thousand dollars, or so much thereof as may be
necessary, is hereby appropriated to carry out the provisions of this act ; and the
Secretary of the Treasury is hereby authorized to pay that sum from moneys in the
Treasury not otherwise appropriated.
  Approved, June 29, 1888.



                                         E Io.

             IMPROVEMENT OF SHEEPSHEAD BAY, NEW YORK.

  Sheepshead Bay, Long Island, is a small tidal bay about 2 miles long,
lying inside of Coney Island, New York, and extending easterly from
the village of Gravesend to Rockaway Inlet, into which it empties. Its
width varies from 100 to 1,000 feet, and its depth from 2 to 10 feet at
mean low water.
  Its natural mouth, where it connects with Rockaway Inlet, is subject
to material frequent changes, from the making and cutting away of the
beach and from the changes in the location of the shoals outside caused
by storms.
  The first survey, with a view to its improvement, of which we have
any record, was made in 1879 by General Newton, whose report, dated
February 7, 1879, may be found in the Annual Report of the Chief of En-
gineers for 1879, page 400.
  The plan of improvement proposed provided for diking the channel
and connecting it with Rockaway Inlet, the estimated cost being
$100,000 (incorrectly printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of En-
         APPENDIX        E-REPORT          OF LIEUT. COL. MCFARLAND,                   625
gineers as $10,000). Subsequently, as a route less likely to be obstructed
by changes in the shoals, it was proposed to connect Sheepshead Bay
with Dead Horse Inlet, which flows into Rockaway Inlet some distance
higher up.
  The first appropriation ($3,000) for this improvement was made June
14, 1880, but General Newton objected to its expenditure for the follow-
ing reasons:
  The position and even existence of this outlet will depend upon the advance of
Rockaway Inlet, which is now advancing westerly at the rate of 264 feet per year.
  The total estimate for this improvement is about $100,000, and for this reason and
the one cited above I would respectfully recommend awaiting developments and
further appropriations.     (See Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1880, page
515.)
   A second appropriation, of $5;000, was made by act of Congress ap-
proved March 3, 1881. For the reasons given before, this appropria-
tion also was not applied to the work.
   In 1882 a survey of the mouth of Rockaway Inlet was made which
developed great changes in the shoals westward of it, and, based upon
this, General Newton suggested making the outlet from Sheepshead Bay
into Dead Horse Inlet, instead of directly into Rockaway Inlet as at
first proposed.
   Two plans with estimates of the cost of doing this were furnished, the
first providing for diking as well as dredging; the second omitting the
diking. They were as follows:
(1) Cut to connect Sheepshead Bay with Dead Horse Inlet, 100 feet wide, 6
   feet deep at mean low water, 52,000 cubic yards, at 35 cents per cubic yard. $18, 200
1,200 feet of creosoted diking to sustain bend in cut, at $6 per linear foot....   7, 200
7,500 feet of creosoted diking for interior channel, at $5 per linear foot ...... 37. 500
        Total of first estimate....-  ..... --........... ..... ....... .... .... ... 62, 900
(2) Cut to connect Sheepshead Bay with Dead Horse Inlet, 100 feet wide, 6
   feet deep at mean low water, 52,000 cubic yards, at 35 cents per cubic yard.. $18, 200
Dredging interior channel, 40,000 cubic yards, at 40 cents per cubic yard.... 16, 000
      Total of second estimate.....-        .   .    - -...   .          ..     .     34,200
   The second plan, which omits the diking, is the one that was adopted
for the work.
   By act of Congress approved August 2, 1882, an additional sum of
$3,000 was appropriated for this work, making the total amount avail-
able $11,000, less about $650 paid for the surveys. The work was ac-
cordingly advertised and let to H. N. and A. J. Beardsley, at 45 cents a
cubic yard, for which they were to dredge a cut from Sheepshead Bay
into Dead Horse Inlet 40 feet wide and 5 feet deep at mean low water.
This contract was begun in November and completed in December, 1883,
the dredged material being placed behind a bulkhead built on the north
side of the cut by private individuals.
   Under the appropriation of $5,000 made by the act of July 5, 1884,
the cut was further dredged to a width of 100 feet and a depth of 6 feet
at mean low water. This work was done under contract with the At-
lantic Dredging Company, at 131 cents per cubic yard, between August,
1885, and January, 1886.
   Under the'act of Congress approved August 5, 1886, the sum of $5,000
was appropriated for the further improvement of this bay. But, as
there appeared to be no way in which this money could be usefully ap-
plied to the work, it was not expended, the place having no commerce
and the channel being good enough for the sail-boats that use it.
       ENG 88-     40
626            REPORT L OF -THE                          CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   Upon the petition of some of the inhabitants of Gravesend, however,
it was ordered early in 1888 that this appropriation should be applied
to the improvement, and accordingly bids were invited by public adver-
tisement for dredging a channel 60 feet wide and 51 feet deep at mean
low water from the cut in Dead Horse Inlet up to Gravesend.
   The lowest bid received, asking 50 cents a cubic yard, was rejected
as being too high, and further bids were invited by circular letter. A
bid of 39 cents would have been accepted, but in the mean time a sec-
ond petition had been sent to the Secretary of War asking that the
dredging might be deferred until September, as there was some fear
that its execution during the summer months might endanger the health
of the neighborhood, and it has been deferred accordingly.
   Further details of the improvement of Sheepshead Bay may be found
in my last annual report.
   The actual water commerce through the bay only amounts to $50,000
as given in a statement which was carefully prepared by this office last
year.
   Sheepshead Bay is not a harbor in any sense of the word, and never
will be. The bay is only used for pleasure boats of small draught, be-
longing to Gravesend and the larger hotels on Coney Island.
   The business of the place is done by rail from Brooklyn or by boats
which land at the piers on the outer beach, or in Gravesend Bay, and
do not come through Sheepshead Bay at all.
   There appears, therefore, to be no necessity for making further ap-
propriations for it at present.
  This work is in the collection district of New York, which is the nearest port of
entry. Nearest light-house, Fort Tompkins Light. Nearest fort, Fort Hamilton.
                                                                      ESTIMATE.

Original estimate of 1879---- ...--..-----                                          --........               .......            y......... $100, 000
Revised estimate of 1882 ................                                         .......      .......................                       34,200

                                                          Amounts appropriated.


                                                      Date.                                                              Application. Amount.

June 14, 1880......--..----...................................................-------------                              Dredging...         $, 000
March 3, 1881---..-..........................--------------.                -..---------..- ..................             do .....           5, 000
August 2, 1882 ..................................................................---------                     - -.        do .......         3, 000
July 5, 1884-- ------                   ----             ------------------------------------                              do                 5, 000
August 5, 1886-.---..--...--------....--.--                       -     --.----       .------------------.
                                                                                                       - -                   do .......       5, 000
        Total----------------------------...............--..........------------------------......................------------.......        21,000


  Amount expended to June 30, 1888, $15,882.44.

                                                             Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available ......................................                 $5,283.73
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887----......--..........--...------...--.....................    166.17

July 1, 1888, balance available .-..... .........
                                         _                                                    .....    ..........          .....         5, 117. 56
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ......-.....                                                               .......
                                                                                                                             -...        5,000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889                                             -----..............--------------.    10,117.56
  SAmount   (estimated) required for completion of existing project.... ...
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                                                                         8,200.00
     .harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
           APPENDIX E--REPORT                            OF LIEUT.       COL. McFARLAND.                 627
Abstract of bids for dredging in Sheepshead Bay, New York, opened at the U. S. En-
  gineers Ofice, Army Building, New York, March 29, 1888, at 12 o'clock m., under adver-
  tisement of February29, 1888.

                                                                                         18,000 cubic yards.
No.                      Name of bidder.                             Residence.
                                                                                         Rate per     Amount.
                                                                                        cubic yard.


   1    Michael I.   Flannery.........................           New York City.......   50 cents         $9, 000


  Proposals incomplete, certificate to justification of guarantors not being furnished.
  This bid was rejected as being too high.



                                                         E z1.
       IMPROVEMENT OF THE HARBOR AT CANARSIE BAY, NEW YORK.

   Canarsie Bay is the name given to a shoal tidal bay forming the
northwestern part of Jamaica Bay, on the south side of Long Island,
whose waters flow into the Atlantic Ocean through Rockaway Inlet.
  The first survey of this bay with a view to its improvement of which
we have any knowledge was made under the direction of General New-
ton, Corps of Engineers, in 1879.
  The scheme of improvement proposed was to obtain a channel 6 feet
deep at mean low water extending from the shore at Canarsie Landing
to the navigable channel in Jamaica Bay, a distance of about 3,500
feet. This channel was to be obtained by the construction of two pile-
dikes, forming a tidal basin, and by dredging them, if necessary, as it
was not believed that an unprotected dredged channel would remain
permanently open. The estimated cost of this project was $88,000.
  The rise and fall of the tide here is 4.7 feet, and the low-water depth
is 5 feet.
  Between 1880 and 1885 various appropriations have been made for
this improvement, amounting altogether to $23,000. With this money
the channel has been kept open by dredging, its depth varying from
5 to 6 feet at mean low water and its width from 50 to 125 feet, and the
outer part of the north dike, 1,150 feet long, has been built.
   A detailed history of the work will be found in the Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1887, part 1, page 637.
   By act of Congress, approved August 5, 1886, the sum of $10,000
was appropriated for this improvement. As any attempt to dredge the
channel during the summer of 1887 would interfere with the movements
of the steamers plying to Canarsie, dredging was deferred for the sea-
son.
  In January bids were invited by public advertisement for construct-
ing 1,000 feet of the south dike, and a contract was formed accordingly
February 25, 1888, with Stephen A. Kelly, for the construction of 850
feet of this dike at $9.87 per linear foot, it being necessary to reduce the
total length somewhat in order to leave money enough on hand to do
the necessary dredging in the spring.
  An examination of the channel made in May, 1888, showed that there
were two bars needing dredging, one at the inner end of the north dike
and the other near the steam-boat wharf. Under an agreement ap.
proved by the Chief of Engineers, a cut 60 feet wide and 6± feet deep
was made through the first-named obstruction, and a cut of the same
628           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

depth and from 60 to 90 feet wide was made through the second one.
The channel was also widened about 30 feet at the bend between these
obstructions. The total amount removed was 2,946 cubic yards, cost-
ing 35 cents per cubic yard, and the work was completed June 18.
   Work on the construction of the dike was begun early in May. At
the close of the fiscal year the piling had been carried a distance of 590
feet, and 30 feet of the dike had been timbered and prepared to receive
the stone filling.
   Canarsie, apart from being the terminus of the Brooklyn, Rockaway
and Jamaica Bay Railroad, from which people transship by steamer
to Rockaway Beach, has a large fishing industry.
   Jamaica Bay is most favorable for oyster culture, and most of the
oysters are sent to New York by boat or by wagon from Canarsie.
   Two steamers make six trips a day from Canarsie to Rockaway dur-
ing the summer, each drawing about 4 feet of water; and the Edith
Peck makes four or five trips a day the year round to Barren Island, her
draught being 4.8 feet.
   As a northwesterly wind often reduces the level of the bay from 1 to
1.5 feet below mean low water, it is apparent that a depth of 6 feet at
least, at mean low water, should be maintained in the improved chan-
nel.
   Judging from the price bid for this year's work, the dike will cost $10
per linear foot instead of $7, as estimated last year, so that the remain-
ing 2,550 feet will cost $22,500.
   While the construction of even 850 feet of the south dike will benefit
the channel by creating an increased scour, the improved channel can
not be considered secure until the whole dike is completed.
   Twenty-seven thousand dollars is therefore asked for the completion
of the south dike and for such dredging as may become necessary next
year.
  This work is in the collection district of New York, which is the nearest port of
entry. Nearest light-house, Fort rTompkins Light. Nearest fort, Fort Hamilton,
                                                       Amounts appropriated.

    Date.                                                            Application.                                                             Amount.

June   14, 1880 Diking .. ....................................                                           ............          ............    $10, 000
Mar.    3,1881 Dredging ...... .............................................-----------------------------------------------------                5, 000
Aug.    2,1882         o ...................................-----------------------------------------------------                                3,000
July    5,1884 Dredging and diking...................                                           ..............................                   5, 000
Aug.    5,1886 ...... do ......................................................................                                                 10,000
                            Total............................----------------.......................................                            33, 000


  Amount expended to June 30, 1888, $24,663.63.
  A statement of the commerce of Canarsie Bay will be found in the last annual re-
port upon it.
                                                          Money statement.
July 1, 1887,        amount available .................................----........ $10,066.75
July 1, 1888,        amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities        outstanding July 1, 1887 .......................      $1,630.38
July 1, 1888,        amount covered by existing contracts ............      8, 389. 50
                                                                                                                   --                     10, 019. 88

July 1,1888, balance available ----......---------------------.........................                                                        46.87
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ..-......-...............                                                                   10, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30,1889...                                                .......            ......          10,046. 87
              APPENDIX E--REPORT OF LIEUT: COL. McFARLAND.                                                                                629
   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-. . $45, 000.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                                         27, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


Abstract of bids for improving Canarsie Bay, New York, by building a pile-dike, opened
                                                           February 15, 1888.

                                                                                                                         1,000 feet of dike.
No.                                  Name and address of bidders.
                                                                                                                       Rate per      Amount.
                                                                                                                      linear foot.

  1   O'Connell & Coffee, Brooklyn, N. Y.....................................                                             $19. 75        $19, 750
  2   Stephen A. Kelly, Brooklyn, N. Y......................................                                                9.87           9, 870
  3   John D. Walsh, Brooklyn, N. Y        --..........--              ................          .....      .......        11.17          11, 170
  4   P. Sanford Ross, Jersey City, N. J ....................                        .................                     12. 35         12, 350
  5   Moses Engle, Brooklyn, N. Y..............................................                                            14. 50         14, 500
  6   George E. Richardson, Brooklyn, N. Y....................                     ....       ............                 13.45          13, 450
  7   Fearon & Jenks, New York City ...................                              ................                      11. 85         11, 850
  8   Charles H. Edwards, Quincy. Mass.................                           .....................                    12.96          12, 960
  9   Henry DuBois's Sons, New York City ..................................                                                13.90          13, 900
10   Thomas Murray, New Brunswick, N. J....................                               ..................              12. 38         12, 380
11   Theodore F. Holmes, New York City ...............................                                                    13.05          13, 050
12   Francis H. Smith, New York City.......................................                                               15.89          15, 890



         Abstract of contracts entered into during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.

                Name.                              Date.                            Purpose.                          linear ot.     Amount.

Stephen A. Kelly ..............                Feb. 25, 1888        Building 850 feet of pile-dike..                       $9.87       $8, 389.50



                                                                    E 12.

                 IMPROVEMENT OF SUMPAWANUS INLET, NEW YORK.

   Sumpawanus Inlet, known in the neighborhood and on the Coast
Survey charts as Sumpwams Creek, is a small creek on the south side
of Long Island, emptying into Great South Bay, near Babylon.
   It lies about 36 miles east of New York City, 15 miles east of the west-
ern end of the Great South Bay, and nearly twice as far from its east-
ern end.
   Fire Island Inlet, through which most of the waters of Great South
Bay pass into the Atlantic Ocean, lies south-southeast of Sumpwams
Creek, distant about 6 miles in a direct line, but 11 miles by the chan-
nel.
   The inlet is a tidal stream from 100 to 200 feet wide, running up to
the town of Babylon, Long Island, which lies less than a mile north of
its mouth. It is crossed there by a dam, which forms a reservoir for
the fresh water of a small creek, which supplies the town with water.
   The mean rise and fall of tides at the mouth of the inlet is only 1.3
feet, and the bottom of the bay and of the inlet is soft mud.
   The first survey of Sumpwams Creek of which we have any record
was ordered by act of Congress approved June 14, 1880, and was made
during the fall of 1888 under the direction of General (then Colonel)
John Newton, Corps of Engineers.
  His report may be found in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1881, Part 1, page 653.
  The project of improvement based upon this survey provided for
630     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

dredging a channel 150 feet wide and 5 feet deep at mean low water
from the 5-foot curve in the bay to the steam-boat dock at the mouth of
the creek, a distance of about 1,500 feet, and thence 5 feet deep and 100
feet wide up the inlet to the town of Babylon, a distance of about 3,500
feet further. The. estimated cost of making this improvement was
$23,115.
   The mean range of tides at the mouth of the inlet being only 1.3 feet,
there was practically no current swift enough to produce, scour. The
depth of water in the proposed channel at the time of the survey was
from 1 to 3 feet in the creek, and from 3 to 5 feet outside.
   It was not believed that diking would assist in improving this en-
trance, and inquiry showed that the depth of water both outside and
inside the inlet had materially diminished in late years.
   Under acts of Congress approved March 3, 1881, and August 2, 1882,
the sum of $7,000 was appropriated for the improvement of this inlet,
and was expended under a contract made with John McDermott for
dredging at 69 cents per cubic yard, which was 39 cents per cubic yard
more than the estimated cost. The dredging was begun in April and
was finished in May, 1883, giving a channel 75 feet wide and 5 feet deep
from the steam-boat wharf to a point 750 feet below it, besides two cuts,
each 25 feet wide, alongside the wharf. In attempting to secure these
depths the contractor was compelled to dig to a depth of 5 or 6 feet
below mean low water.
   Outside of the cuts so made and extending to the 5-foot curve in the
bay a shoal was left, on which the depth was only about 44 feet.
   An examination made in 1886 showed that since the last dredging
was done, in 1883, both the cuiand the flat outside had shoaled from 6
inches to a foot, the depth in the Cut being about 5 feet, while on the
flat it was from 4 to 41 feet. 'This was to have been anticipated, as ap-
pears by the preliminary report made by General Newton. The 5-foot
curve in the bay was 1,500 feet from the steam-boat wharf, but inside
this curve, for about 750 feet towards the wharf, lay the flat.
   The commerce of Sumpwams Creek is essentially that of Babylon, a
small town of from 3,000 to 5,000 inhabitants, 1 mile above the mouth
of the creek, depending almost entirely upon the summer trade of the
hotels and cottages along the.north shore of Great South Bay and on
Fire Island Beach.
   The commerce of .Babylon by water has been decreasing, apparently
because the Long Island Railroad.has taken away the sea-going busi-
ness. Babylon itself has improved, and has become a fashionable sum-
mer resort. At present its coimerce by sea is carried on by three pas-
senger steam-boats, drawing from 4 to 5 feet, running in summer to Fire
Island Beach ; three schooners, drawing from 5 to 5) feet, carrying brick,
lime, lumber, and other heavy freight to Babylon the year round ; 100
sloops and pleasure-boats, drawing from 1 to 2 feet of water, taking out
sailing and fishing parties during the summer, of which seven or eight
remain in use during the winter, fishing and taking oysters and clams
to Patchogue, Sayville, and New York.
   No oysters are brought to Babylon from the bay, and only a few clams
in the summer for home consumption.
   The commerce of the creek, in my judgment, does not warrant the for-
mation of a channel more than 5 feet deep from the 5-foot curve in the
bay to the steam-boat wharf, for the convenience of the few steamers and
schooners which make use of the creek.
   It is stated that the shoals in the bay kill the sea so entirely that
pleasure-boats can now lie in the mnouth of the creek in all weathers.
           APPENDIX             E-REPORT       OF LIEUT. COL. McFARLAND.                     631
  So far as the extension of the improvement from the steam-boat dock
up to the inlet is concerned, there appears to be no reason why the Gov-
ernment of the United States should undertake it.
  The original estimate of the cost of the work was $23,115. Seven
thousand dollars have been appropriated.
  Ten thousand dollars can be expended in giving a 5-foot channel out
into the bay for the use of steam-boats, but I think that the work is more
a matter of local than public interest.
  This work is in the collection district of New York, which is the nearest port of
entry. Nearest light-house, Fire Island Light; nearest fort, Fort Hamilton.
  For statement of commerce, see my last annual report.

                                     AMOUNT    APPROPRIATED.

March 3, 1881, dredging ....-----....----
                                   .. _
                                  ...                                                $5,000. 00
                                                                                ......
                                                              ........ ....--..---....
August 2, 1882, dredging ....................                    .----..............     2.000.00

       Total ................      ......   ....   ...          -............          7, 000.00
                                                                        ...........----.........
Amount expended to June 30, 1888............................................              6, 928.12

                                        Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available                  ..     ..     . ...          ....-- --      81.88
                                                                                            $......
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 187....------------......--------......---------------....--....       10. 00

July 1, 1888, balance available .... ..........           ........................--..       71.88


  Amount that canbe profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890              10, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of the river
   and harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




                                               E    13.


IMPROVEMENT OF THE CHANNEL BETWEEN STATEN ISLAND AND NEW
                         JERSEY.

  A description of this channel and a complete history of the work done
towards its improvement may be found in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1887, Part I, page 743.
  So far, the improvement has been confined to that part of the channel,
about 1 miles long, which lies east of Elizabethport, N. J., and at the
mouth of Newark Bay. This originally had a depth of only 9J feet in it at
mean low water, while the rest of the channel lying between the shores
of Staten Island and New Jersey had a depth of from 14 to 40 feet at
mean low water.
  The first project for the improvement of this channal was made in
1873. This provided for dredging it to a depth of 16 feet for a width
of 150 feet at its shallowest part, and protecting the cut by parallel
dikes built along each side of it. The estimated cost of this was
$443,210. Fifty thousand dollars of this amount, appropriated in 1874,
was spent in 1874-'75 in the construction of 2,237 feet of the south dike
opposite Elizabethport.
  So much oppositionto this plan was exhibited by oystermen and tow-
boat men, on the groond that its execution would interfere with their
business, that it was decided to modify it, although the orginal plan
632          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

was undoubtedly the best from an engineering point of view. It was
decided, therefore, in 1880, to dredge a channel 400 feet wide and only
13 feet deep over the middle 200 feet of its width, leaving it but 12 feet
deep over the remaining widths of 100 feet on each side. The estimated
cost of this work was $125,705. In addition to this, it was proposed,
should it be found necessary, to build four detached dikes along the
line of the channel, two on the south and two on the north side, whose
estimated cost was $60,000, bringing the total estimated cost of the pro-
posed improvement up to $185,705.
   By May, 1883, the channel had been dredged to nearly the proposed
width and depth, except at the bend near the Stake Light. But ow-
ing to the growing demands of commerce it was subsequently decided
to give the channel a low-water depth of 13 feet for its full width of
400 feet, the estimated cost of which was $25,000. This made the total
estimated cost of this work $210,000. This deepening and widening
was carried on in 1884,1885, and 1887, until at present there is a channel
not less than 400 feet wide and 13 feet deep, or over, east of Shooter's
Island, a channel 400 feet wide with the same depth round the Stake
Light, and, connecting them, a channel from 300 to 350 feet wide and
from 13 to 14 feet deep.
    The dredging in progress at the close of the last fiscal year under
contract with Mr. Thomas H. Bonton, dated April 15, 1887, was con-
tinued up to July 26, 1887, when the contract was closed.
    The total amount of material removed under this contract was:
From east of Shooter's Island-.--.. ---
                                     .-    ......---..... cubic yards-..                           22, 603
From the bend at the Stake Light -----..--..--. -.               do ....
                                                         ..........---                             22, 475
        Total .....-------... .....
                                 ........
                                       ......................................                      45, 078
   The commerce of this channel, which is known as the Kills, is so large
that the narrow part near the Stake Light constitutes a serious obstruc-
tion to it. This part should be widened to 400 feet as proposed, the
depth of the widened part to be 13 feet as in the other parts of the chan-
nel, and it is recommended that $30,000 be appropriated for this pur-
pose.
   There appears to be no present necessity for beginning the construc-
tion of the dikes.
   From statistics compiled last year, the commerce passing the Stake
Light is shown to have a tonnage of 8,442,439 tons, with a value of
$67,539,512.
  This work is in the collection district of New York, which is the nearest port of
entry. Nearest light-house, Bergen Point Light; nearest fort, Fort Tompkins.

                                            Amounts appropriated.


     Date.                                            Application.                               Amount.


June 23, 1874     Diking, first project........................................._.............     $50, 000
Aug. 14, 1876 Dredging, second project ..................................................           10,000
June 18, 1878 .... do .------------.....-----------------------------------...........              15,000
June 14, 1880 -_do---------------------------------------------------------                         29, 000
Aug. 2, 1882 -- do.------"--------------------------------------------------                        40000
Jug. 5, 1886       .do     .--......................................................---..           15,-----------000
Aug. 5, 1886-do----------------------------------------------15,000
                         Total...............................
                                                   ..............................                  119,000


Amount expended to June 30, 1888                     ...............................       $168, 189. 40
            APPENDIX E--REPORT                        OF LIEUt.            COL. MPcFARLAND.                  603

                                             Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available .........................................                                $1, 926. 25
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ....----....... ..-----     ............      ... ...........                 1,115.65
July 1, 1888, balance available ....................................                             .. -       810.60
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888                        ......-......   .........          15, 000.00
                                                                  -
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889...............                                    15,810.60

   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                           30, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                       E 14.

                    IMPROVEMENT OF RARITAN BAY, NEW JERSEY.

   Raritan Bay forms the western part of the large triangular bay in-
closed between Sandy Hook, the New Jersey shore, and Staten Island,
the eastern part of which is commonly known to New Yorkers as the
Lower Bay, as it lies just outside of, or below, N ew York Harbor, which
is the name usually applied to the inner body of water on which the
city of New York is situated.
   The Raritan River flows into Raritan Bay at its extreme western end,
passing between Perth Amboy and South Amboy, and Newark Bay is
connected with both the Raritan River and Bay by the Arthur Kill and
Staten Island Sound, which, separating Staten Island, belonging to the
State of New York, from the New Jersey shore, enters Raritan Bay at
Perth Amboy.
   The depth of the bay varies from 5 to 30 feet, decreasing gradually
towards its western and southern shores.
   The natural channel leading out of it, after passing the Great Beds
Light at the junction of Staten Island Sound and the Raritan River,
does not follow the middle of the bay, but hugs the Staten Island shore
for nearly 4 miles to Seguine's Point, situated about half a mils east of
Prince's Bay Light; thence it runs southeastwardly towards the inner
point of Sandy Hook for about 2 miles, crossing a shoal which puts out
towards the southward from the Staten Island shore.
   In 1880, before any improvement had been made here by the Govern-
ment, 18 feet at mean low water could be carried through the channel
from Perth Amboy to Great Beds Light, while there was not less than
21 feet of water from Great Beds Light to Seguine's Point; but from
Seguine's Point to deep water in the outer bay only 144 feet of water
could be carried across the shoal.
   The width of this shoal between the 21-foot curves was about 8,000
feet.
   Through the middle of the bay, south of this channel, from Great
Beds Light directly towards Sandy Hook, only 11 feet of water could
be carried over the shoals.
   The above depths all refer to mean low water.
   A survey of this bay was ordered in 1880, with the view of ascertain-
ing the practicability of securing a greater depth of water from the
main ship-channel in the lower bay to the wharves at Perth Anboy, as
vessels were often much delayed in crossing the shoal east of Seguine's
Point.
634       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  This survey was made under direction of Lieutenant-Colonel Michler,
Corps of Engineers, whose report will be found in the Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1881, Part I, pages 717 to 719.
  This report recommended dredging a channel 300 feet wide and 21
feet deep at mean low water from Seguine's Point southeastward to the
deeper waters of the bay outside, which would require the removal of-
460,000 cubic yards of materials, which at 25 cents per cubic yard, would
                                 --------
  cost --.------...............-----
                       ...................--------.........  ........------------.
                                                                        --....----.-..--- $115,000
Contingencies, 10 per cent.............. ............       ........... ......------   .    11,500
       Total estimated cost ..................... ...                       ... 126, 500
                                                    ...... .....-------......
  The mean rise and- fall of the tide in Raritan Bay is the same as at
Sandy Hook, nearly 4.8 feet.
   Owing to the reduced scour of the ebb current after leaving Seguine's
Point, due to its unfavorable direction, since it crosses the proposed
channel at an angle of about 45 degrees, it was not expected that the
dredged channel would remain permanently open; but as no other
means of obtaining a permanent channel was deemed practicable, the
project was accepted and approved.
  The first appropriation made for its execution was that of March 3,
1881, $50,000.
   Under it the work of dredging was let to the Atlantic Dredging
Company, at 28 cents per cubic yard, and operations were begun in
October, 1881, and were continued to June 17, 1882, by which time
166,346 cubic yards of material had been excavated, giving a channel
through the shoal 21 feet deep and 105 feet wide.
   Under date of August 2, 1882, a further appropriation of $50,000 was
made.
  The contract was again awarded to the Atlantic Dredging Company,
at 22 cents- per cubic yard, who carried on the work until October 31,
1883, by which time 202,226 cubic yards had been excavated, increas-
ing the width of the channel to 240 feet, except at the western end,
where, for 2,000 feet, it had a width of only 200 feet.
   By act of July 5, 1884, $20,000 more was appropriated for this work.
The Atlantic Dredging Company was again the successful bidder, and
a contract was entered into with it, at 16 cents per cubic yard. This
contract was closed December 13, 1884. Under it 112,657 cubic yards
of material were excavated, of which 2,403 cubic yards were not dumped
where required, and were therefore not paid for.
   With the appropriations thus far nmde, 481,329 cubic yards of mate-
rial had been excavated from the channel.
   It was believed, when dredging was closed for the season, that a
channel 300 feet wide and 21 feet deep had been obtained across the
shoal; but it was not possible to make the survey necessary for deter-
mining the actual condition of the work until May, 1885, when it was
found that the sides of the cut had run into the channel, giving a depth
of 21 feet for most of its length, with lumps in it here and there with
but 18 or 20 feet of water over them, the average width being 250 feet.
   The latest Coast Survey chart, though not giving soundings so much
in detail as our own charts, seems to indicate that there has been a good
deal of shoaling where this cut was made, and it is probably true that
we have not now the depth there which we gained by dredging.
   It is not possible without another detailed survey to state what this
amount of shoaling is, but it is probably not less than 100,000 cubic
yards.
  The original project of 1881 contemplated the excavating of this chan-
       APPENDIX E-REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. McFARLAND.                   635
nel only, but Colonel Gillespie in his annual reports of 1883,1884, and
1885, calls attention to two other shoals in the bay west of Great Beds
Light ; one in the channel leading up to South Amboy, on the Raritan,
and the other leading up to Perth Amboy on Staten Island Sound.
   The shoal in the channel leading up to Perth Amboy is a middle
ground, having a channel on each side of it, the eastern one being the
best; but only from 17 to 19 feet of water can be carried through it at
low water. It is also narrow in places and crooked.
   Colonel Gillespie recommended, therefore, that a straight channel 300
feet wide and 21 feet deep should be dredged from deep water near Great
Beds Light through the east end of this shoal to deep water at Ward's
Point, opposite Perth Amboy. This would require the removal of about
150,000 cubic yards of material. (See Report of the Chief of Engineers,
1885, Part I, page 758.)
   This, with the 21-foot channel dredged outside of Seguine's Point,
would give a continuous 21-foot channel from the main ship-channel in
New York Bay to the wharves at Perth Amboy.
   In the same report he calls attention to a shoal lying between South
Amboy and Great Beds Light, on which there is only 12A feet of water,
and in order to give the large tow-boats running from New York up the
Raritan sufficient water he recommends the cutting of a channel through
this shoal 4,500 feet long, 300 feet wide, and 15 feet deep. The amount
of excavation required to dredge this channel he estimates at 150,000
cubic yards.
   The cost of dredging these two channels and restoring the original
width in the cut east of Seguine's Point he estimated at $114,000. But
as the filling at the latter point is probably much greater than was ex-
pected, this estimate will have to be increased, and may be placed at
400,000 cubic yards, which, at 30 cents per cubic yard, would cost
 $120,000.
    Under the appropriation of $37,500 made by act of Congress approved
August 5, 1886, proposals were asked for dredging a channel 300 feet
wide and 21 feet deep from the 21-foot curve near Ward's Point, past
Great Beds Light, towards the 21-foot curve near Seguine's Point, the
amount of material to be excavated being 150,000 cubic yards, more or
less, depending upon the price bid.
   The Atlantic Dredging Company were the lowest bidders at 233
cents per cubic yard, and a contract for the work was entered into with
them August 2, 1887.
    The time set for its completion was November 30, 1887, but owing
to bad weather the contract was extended first to May 1, and then to
June 15, 1888.
    The work was completed in June, when 163,756 cubic yards of
material had been excavated, of which 138,451 cubic yards were re-
moved from the channel from Ward's Point to Great Beds Light and
25,305 cubic yards from the channel from Great Beds Light towards
Seguine's Point. But 20,000 cubic yards were deducted from the total
amount dredged on account of the contractor having dredged below the
required depth, leaving the amount actually paid for 143,756 cubic
yards.
    This gave a channel 300 feet wide and 21 feet deep from the wharves
at Perth Amboy to the bend at Great Beds Light and a channel 21 feet
deep, 315 feet wide, across the crest of the shoal in the channel leading
from the bend towards Seguine's Point, but the funds were not suffi-
cient to complete the work.
66             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                          1.S.   ARMY.

  The great shoaling in the channels in Raritan Bay is only partly due
to natural causes. The most of it is due to dredged material being
willfully and illegally dumped there to save the expense of towing it out
to sea. This is a crime against the public welfare that ought to be met
with heavy punishment.
      The material excavated by the dredges was mostly mud, and in one
place compact sand, but in a number of spots the mud brought up was
evidently old dredged material which had been deliberately dumped
illegally in the channel. It is safe to say that no material privately
dredged from the wharves and slips in Raritan Bay is ever dumped
anywhere except in the bay. None of it ever passes Sandy Hook.
   It is recommended that the entire balance of the amount of money
estimated as necessary for the completion of this work, namely, $82,500,
                during the coming year.
be applied to it,
  This work is in the collection district of Perth Amboy, which is the nearest port of
entry. Nearest light-house, Prince's Bay; nearest fort, fort at Sandy Hook.
                                                     Amounts appropriated.

      Date.                                                     Application.                                                     Amount.

Mar. 3,1881 Dredging ...............................                 ...............................                                $50,000
Aug. 2,1882 .      do ..............       ..........             .          ......................                                  50,000
July 5,1884 ...... do ....................      .............................................                                        20, 000
                do .......
Aug. 5,1886 ......                           .............
                                                         ..........................................                                  37, 500
                            Total ..............................................................                      ..            157, 500

  Amount expended to June 30, 1888, $153,557.15.
  A statement of commerce will be found in my last annual report upon this im-
provement.
                                                        Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available.... ................             ................          $37, 579.03
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887 ......................              $33, 636. 18
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities .........................                  ,935. 13
                                                                                           36, 571. 31

July 1, 1888, balance available ........ ......   ...............                                                ......          1,007.72
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .......................                                                           25, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                                       26,007. 72
( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ......
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890
                                                                                                                                57,500.  00
                                                                                                                                57, 500. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


Abstract of bids for dredging Raritan Bay, New Jersey, opened at .the U. S. Engineer
  Office, Army Building, New York, July 20, 1887, at 12 o'clock m., under advertisement
  of June 23, 1887.

                                                                                                                 150,000 cubic yards.
No.                                 Name and residence of bidders.
                                                                                                               Rate per Amount.
                                                                                                              cubic yard.


                                                                                                                  Gents.
  1    Morris Cumings Dredging Company, New York,                               . Y....................               241           $36. 750
  2    American Dredging Company, Philadelphia Pa .........................                                               26         39, 000
  3    Thomas Potter, Jersey City, N. J..                   ..                  .                         .               26         39, 000
  4    Atlantic Dredging Company, Brooklyn, N. Y .............................                                            23j        35, 625
  5    P. Sanford Ross, Jersey City, N. J......................................                                           24k        36, 750
         APPENDIX E-REPORT                      OF LIEUT. COL. McFARLAND.                                        637
       Abstract of contract entered into during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.


       Name of bidder.             Date.                         Purpose.                       cubice per     Amount.


                                                                                                   Cents.
Atlantic Dredging Company..    Aug. 2,1887      Dredging 150,000 cubic yards ...                       231      $35, 625



                                                E I5.

REMOVING SUNKEN VESSELS OR CRAFT OBSTRUCTING OR ENDANGER-
                     ING NAVIGATION.

             SLOOP LOCOMOTIVE,                  HUDSON RIVER, NEW YORK.

  This sloop, of about 90 tons burden, sunk in the Hudson River off
Tivoli, opposite Saugerties, N. Y., August 5, 1887, in about 43 feet of
water, but as her mast and boom were above water it was a dangerous
obstruction to navigation.
  By authority of the Chief of Engineers it was removed by hired labor
October 28, at a cost of $317.94.

                    BARK QUICKSTEP, NEW YORK HARBOR.

   This bark, of about 800 tons burden, sugar laden, was wrecked in the
summer of 1887 on the west bank of the main ship-channel, New York
Harbor, near Buoy 11.
   Under authority from the Chief of Engineers, circular letters were
issued for its removal October 15, 1887. and were opened October 26.
   Only one bid was received, that of W. E. Chapman; who offered to
remove the wreck for $3,200. This offer was accepted and a contract
was entered into with him November 5, 1887.
   Owing to bad weather, the time for the completion of the contract
had to be extended and the work was not satisfactorily completed till
May 28, 1888, when the contract was closed.

Abstract of bids for removing the wreck of the bark Quickstep, lying on the edge of the
  west bank, New York Harbor, opened at the U. S. Engineer Ofice, Army Building, New
  York, October 26, 1887, at 12 o'clock, m., under circular letter of October 15, 1887.

No.                            Name and residence of bidder.                                                  Amount.

   1   William E. Chapman, New York City ..        ........................................                      $3, 200


       Abstract of contracts entered into during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.

          Name.                Date.                                     Purpose.                              Amount.

William E. Chapman ......   Nov. 5, 1887   I Removing wreck of bark                  Quickstep .............     $3, 200


WRECK OF A CANAL-BOAT                      IN   HARLEM RIVER, NEAR HIGH BRIDGE.

   Under authority of the Chief of Engineers, circular letters were is-
sued, asking bids for its removal, on November 29, and opened December
8, 1887.
638          REPORT OF THE                       CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The lowest bidder was the Baxter Wrecking Company, and a con-
tract for its removal was entered into with them December 23, 1887.
  Work commenced in December, 1887, and was completed January 20,
1888.
Abstract of bids for removing the wreck of a canal-boat lying in the Harlem River near the
  High Bridge, opened at the U. S. Engineer Office, Army Building, New York, December
  8, 1887, under circular of November 29, 1887.


No.                                               Name of bidders.                                         Amount.

1    Baxter Wrecking Company, New York City..........................................                         $175
2    W illiam E. Chapman, New York City .................................................                      190
3    Edward R. Lowe, New York City ...................................................                         449


        Abstract of contracts entered into during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.


             Name.                         Date.                                  Purpose.                 Amount.

Baxter Wrecking Company..              Dec. 23, 1887     Removing wreck of canal-boat................          $175



                                                              E   l6.
         PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION OF SPRING CREEK, NEW YORK.

                                   OFFICE OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,
                                                   UNITED STATES ARMY,
                                   Washington, ID. C., January 5, 1888.
   SIR: I have the honor to submit herewith a copy of a report to this
office from Lieut. Col. Walter McFarland, Corps of Engineers, of the
results of the preliminary examination of Spring Creek, New York,
made to comply with the requirements of section 6 of the river and har-
bor act of August 5, 1886.
   The imperfect description in the act of the locality of this stream,
which has but recently been ascertained, has delayed this examination.
   Concurring in the opinion of the local engineer, that Spring Creek is
not worthy of improvement by the General Government, I have not
directed an additional survey to be made.
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                    J. C. DUANE,
                                        Brig. Gen., Chief of Engineers.
      Hon.    WILLIAM C. ENDICOTT,
                                           Secretary of War.



REPORT OF               LIEUTENANT-COLONEL WALTER                                        M'FARLAND,   CORPS OF
                                     ENGINEERS.

                                                       ENGINEER               OFFICE, U.      S.   ARMY,
                               New York, N. Y., December 30, 1887.
  GENERAL : I have the honor to submit the following report upon the
preliminary examination of Spring Creek, New York, made under the
instructions of your letter of the 17th instant.
   Spring Creek, New York, is a narrow, crooked, and shallow tidal
stream, 3 or 4 miles long, flowing from the vicinity of East NLew York
         APPENDIX E---REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. McFARLAND.                            639
and the twenty-sixth ward of Brooklyn southerly into Jamaica Bay on
the south shore of Long Island. It is called Old Mill Creek on the
Coast Survey chart.
  Its navigation is closed about a mile above its mouth by a dam.                   Its
channel is about 40 feet wide, and it is claimed that it is 3 feet deep at
low water, but the depth in the bay at the mouth of the creek at low
water is less than a foot.
  The rise of the tide is about 5 feet, and vessels of this draught can
at high water run up to the dam and the bulkhead near it built by the
city of Brooklyn.
   It is desired that the creek shall be straightened and the channel
deepened to 4 feet at mean low water, when, it is believed by those in-
terested in its improvement, nearly all of the coal and building mate-
rials needed by this large and rapidly growing part of the city of Brook-
lyn, which now is brought by drays and rail from the East River, from
7 to 9 miles distant, would be brought by this water-route.
  At present the creek has no commerce, with the exception of an oc-
casional sloop-load of manure or coal brought in, and nothing is sent out.
  Under the circumstances, while it is doubtless very desirable, on ac-
count of local interest, that this water-way to the twenty-sixth ward of
Brooklyn should be opened, it appears to me that this is the duty of the
city or of the county concerned, rather than that of the General Gov-
ernment, since no public necessity or convenience of commerce would
be subserved by it.
  I have to report, therefore, that I do not consider Spring Creek, New
York, worthy of being improved by the General Goverment.
  I transmit herewith a copy of the report of G. W. Kuehnle, who was
detailed to make the examination.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                    WALTER MCFARLAND,
                                                       Lieut. Col. of Engineers.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                S. A.




                          REPORT OF MR. G. W. KUEHNLE.

                                                     NEW YORK, Deeember 23, 1887.
   SIR: I have the honor to submit the following report of an examination of Spring
Creek, New York, made December 22, in compliance with your verbal orders of De-
cember 21, 1887.
   Spring Creek (called Old Mill Creek on Coast Survey chart of Jamaica Bay) is a
tributary of Jamaica Bay and it is the nearest approach by water to East New York
and the twenty-sixth ward, Brooklyn. The course of the creek is through salt marsh,
and has several very sharp bends in it. At the head of navigation there are an old
dam and tide mill (built in 1810) owned by J. L. Van Wicklen, a small hotel owned
by D. L. Van Wicklen, and an old bulkhead owned by the city of Brooklyn. The
distance from the head of navigation to the mouth of the creek is less than a mile, and
the least depth about 1 foot at low water. The depth in the bay near the mouth of
the creek as shown on the Coast Survey chart, 1879, is three-fourths foot, but Mr.
Van Wicklen claims that vessels can carry 3 feet to the mouth. The improvement
desired is to have the creek straightened by cutting off two of the bends (which ap-
pear to hinder navigation as much as the want of depth), the channel widened to 60
feet (the present width being about 40 feet for part of the creek), and a channel
dredged to 4 feet at low water from the Old Mill Landing to deep water in Jamaica
Bay.
   The present commerce of the creek is practically nothing, consisting of an occa-
sional sloop-load of manure or coal for the neighboring truck farmers. At the time
of the building of the Brooklyn water-works most of the material used on two sec-
tions of the work was brought to the Old Mill Landing. There are quite a number
640      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

of small boats at the head of the creek that are nearly all used by pleasure-seekers
in the summer.
  It is evident from the numerous new buildings in the course of erection and other
visible signs of improvement that this section of Brooklyn is rapidly developing.
  It is claimed, by those interested, that by improving the creek all the coal and
building material used in the vicinity and coal used by the Brooklyn and Long
Island Water-works would be shipped by water to Old Mill Landing. The present
means of getting these supplies is by trucking from Brooklyn (a distance of 7 miles)
and by Long Island Railroad in a round-about manner from Hunter's Point via Ja-
maica. It seems to me that the effect of the improvement is greatly overestimated
by the promoters, since, if the route were a profitable one, the present depth at high
water (about 6 feet) would be sufficient for light-draught vessels and canal-boats, and
there is no evidence that any such vessels use the creek, excepting the very occa-
sional ones loaded with manure or cdal for a near-by truck farmer. There is no out-
going freight, as there are no factories or mills in the vicinity.
  I was not able to find any one that could give me any figures in regard to the
amount of material that would be expected to come by way of the creek, but have
been promised that such statistics will be forwarded to you in a few days.
  Taking into consideration the fact that the benefit, if any, would be a purely local
one, and not to the advantage of general commerce, and that it is extremely doubt-
ful if an improvement of the channel would increase the traffic, I can not report that
Spring Creek is worthy of improvement.
  The cost of a survey and map would not exceed $150.
  The cost of the improvement can not be given with any accuracy without a sur-
vey, but ought to be less than $10,000.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                  G. W.   KUEIHNLE.
Lieut. Col. WALTER MCFARLAND,
              Corps of Engineers, U. S. A.



                                       E iz.

PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION OF HUDSON RIVER, NEW YORK, BETWEEN
               NEW BALTIMORE AND COXSACKIE.

                         ENGINEER OFFICE, U. S. ARMY,
                             New York, N. Y., February 28, 1887.
  GENERAL: I have the honor to submit the following report upon the
preliminary examination of the " Hudson River between New Balti-
more and Coxsackie," authorized by act of Congress approved August
5, 1886.
   The only map of this part of the Hudson River which we have among
our records is one made by the Coast Survey about thirty years ago.
Several surveys of the upper part of the river have been made by the
War Department under authority of law, but these extend only from
Troy, at the head of navigation, down to New Baltimore. The part of
the river included in the examination now under discussion extends
from New Baltimore down-stream to Coxsackie, a distance of 6 miles,
and the greatest changes which have been discovered are in the lower
third of this stretch.
  Above Coxsackie, and within 2 miles of it, are two islands, one below
the other, which separate the river here into two channels, the eastcrly
one being the widest, deepest, and the most used.
  The upper one of these islands is known as Rattlesnake or Light-
house Island, and has on it the Coxsackie light-house, and a large ice-
house with its necessary quarters and stables. The lower island is
called Coxsackie Island, and has on it three large ice-houses. - Both of
these islands are overflowed during freshets.
  The present examination shows that the shore and channel lines as
given in the Coast Survey chart before referred to have very much al-
       APPENDIX E-REPORT          OF LIEUT.    COL.   MCFARLAND.      641
tered. The eastern side of Rattlesnake Island and the head of Cox-
sackie Island have been largely washed away, while the lower end of
Coxsackie Island has been built up and now extends several hundred
feet farther down-stream than it did formerly.
   The channel has shifted its position and has shoaled in places. This
deterioration of the channel will continue until it is stopped by some
such works as those which have been built between Troy and New Bal-
timore for the purpose of regulating the channel; but before any such
works can be undertaken a thorough survey of this part of the river
must be made, and this should extend from Stone House Bar, just be-
low New Baltimore, down to Fordham Point, a little below Coxsackie.
Such a survey would cost about $2,500.
   In my judgment the survey and improvement of this part of the
Hudson River are quite as important as the survey and improvement
of the part which lies above it-between New Baltimore and Troy-
upon which hundreds of thousands of dollars have been expended, and
by which the whole commerce of the Hudson River and of the Erie
Canal are affected.
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                             WALTER MCFARLAND,
                                                Lieut. Col. of Engineers.
  Brig. Gen. JAMES C. DUANE,
              Chief of Engineers, U. S. A.

SURVEY OF HUDSON RIVER, NEW YORK, BETWEEN NEW BALTIMORE
                     AND COXSACKIE.

                                ENGINEER OFFICE, U.       S. ARMY,
                                       New York, N. Y., March 29, 1888.
   GENERAL: I have the honor to submit the following report, with
illustrative chart, upon the survey of, the Hudson River, between
"New Baltimore and Coxsackie," authorized by act of Congress, ap-
proved August 5, 1886, and made under the direction of Lieut. Col.
Walter McFarland, Corps of Engineers, in local charge of the improve-
ment of the Hudson River, in accordance with Department instructions
dated March 16, 1887.
   A preliminary report was made by that officer February 28, 1887, to
which I respectfully invite attention.
   The accompanying report of Mr. Maurice Kingsley, assistant engi-
neer, who personally conducted the survey, gives the details of the extent
of the survey, and a general comparison of the present condition of
this reach of the river with that existing at the time of the survey by
the Coast Survey in 1856. During the thirty years which have elapsed
since the survey of 1856, only a few changes have occurred in the chan-
nel-way along the reach under consideration, and these have been so
slight as not to affect the convenience of its navigation. The upper
ends of Light-House and Coxsackie islands have been wasted partially
by the currents, and the shoal at the lower end of the latter island has
made to the southward, though its extension in that direction is re-
stricted by the frequent passage of the boats to the Coxsackie Landing.
The survey indicates that the channel over Stone-House Bar, adjacent
to New Baltimore, has 12 feet depth of water, where only 11 feet existed
in 1856. This increase is due probably to the dredging operations
which were conducted at this point by the State in 1883-'84(page 696,
Annual Report Chief of Engineers, 1884, part 1).
       ENG 88-41
642        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The office of the State engineer contains no records of this work, so
that it is impossible to give the condition of the bar at the time work
began, and the degree to which it was improved by the State.
  The project approved by the War Department, 1867, for the improve-
ment of the Hudson River, provides for a navigable channel 11 feet
deep between Albany and New Baltimore. An inspection of the ac-
companying map shows that more than this depth exists everywhere
from New Baltimore to Coxsackie in a wide and convenient channel
following the east bank, and since the navigation between these two
points is easier and more convenient than it is above, I concur with Mr.
Kingsley in the statement that it does not appear to be necessary to
make any improvement at the present time between New Baltimore and
Coxsackie. If it is discovered later that material washed from the
heads of Light-House and Coxsackie islands is transported by the cur-
rents to the bar at the lower end of Coxsackie Island, causing the
channel depths to be diminished there to the obstruction of commerce,
it may be expedient to revet the heads of those islands in a permanent
way.
   This part of the Hudson River is in the collection district of New
York, and the nearest light-houses are located at Stuyvesant and Cox-
sackie.     The nearest port of entry is New York.
          Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                  G. L. GILLESPIE,
                                     Lieut. Col. of Engineers,
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. A.           it temiorary charge.


             REPORT OF MR.   MIAURICE   KINGSLEY, ASSISTANT ENGINEER.

                                              ENGINEER OFFICE, U.     S.   ARMY,
                                                  New York, N. Y., March 28, 1888.
  COLONEL:: I respectfully submit the following report, with a map, upon the survey
of the Hudson River between New Baltimore and Coxsackie, N. Y., ordered by letter
of the Chief of Engineers dated March 16, 1887, and made in accordance with river
and harbor act of August 5, 1886, after a preliminary examination had been reported
upon.
  The survey was made from September 19 to November 30, 1887, and embraced 6
miles of the river, from Fordham Point, 1 mile below Coxsackie Landing, up to the
lower part of New Baltimore, and connecting there with Assistant Engineer R. H.
Talcott's survey of 1884, made under direction of Capt. James Mercur and Lieut. Col.
Walter McFarland, Corps of Engineers.
  The primary triangulation points occupied were those permanently located by the
State of New York in 1880, and which checked out accurately; from these the sound-
ing points used in the survey were located. The shore-lines were run in by an ordi-
nary transit line, checked at all important points with the primary triangulation
stations and sounding points.
  Soundings were taken with an 11-foot rod, marked in feet and tenths, to which a
7-fathom sounding-line was attached, similar to those in use on the Mississippi; as,
on account of the sudden changes in depths and heavy currents, the ordinary rod or
lead-line could not be used to advantage. Each sounding was located by two transits
on shore.
  The soundings from Coxsackie to Stuyvesant Light were referred to a gauge set
up on the light-house crib at Coxsackie, the zero of which was referred to a Coast
Survey bench-mark established in 1856 directly across the river at Stuyvesant, and
on which Assistant Engineer R. H. Talcott checked in running his levels from Albany
in 1876 and 1884.
  There are no records to show that the Coast Survey plane of 1856 was accurate.
Assistant Talcott has at various times gone extensively into this question and in-
forms me that it was impossible to compare the two planes; but that, in his opinion,
they were nearly coincident.
  The soundings taken from Stuyvesant Light to New Baltimore during the present
survey were referred to a bench-mark at New Baltimore, also established by the Coast
Survey, and connected with Assistant Talcott's lines of levels; and for which no Coast
Survey data can be procured.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          -42                                                                                                                 22'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          J. 199'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                            4Y' 25'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                            4Z ZZ1                                                                                                                                                                                                                      4h14..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  24i
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      4       140




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        H v/414V/                                                          4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        '%//                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            C,YR '7i
                   ,fl-.&.                                                    .
                                                                                                                                                                                                           \N
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Csirt                                      . "c1v;i
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   -
7R°46                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    --    --        - ---     - --          --     -       ---    --
                                                                                                                                                                          VAt W



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      ~ .cL~~S Rb~Grol~o~ru~0e
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    mdlc
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        i;
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    "                    h
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        .r
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 .,.. a                        ""          .                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           -Ste                                        t                             9Zo.                                     3O     '             188S.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          ~II.-"                        7.: r                          5         LIGH -           "-               '



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          eo .. .                        'DGi     is        i,'.:..      .' '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            (zb
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      - iqr19a
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   -..-.Iay                                            ~sa_                                            , ""            "ai:.t','.                    :. .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  $a.C                                  ,000
                                                                                                                                             86        41       33             l
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        0124                                                                             "                                    2           , '
                                                                                  :.ti;:                                      .75.
                                                                                                                              2.7            *-- .,S
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        __                                      "
                      Houghtalling                     I.                                             7.9                              £8 10.590                                                                                1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            209           ZN9             21"Z
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ~   C               167
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     20.5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       22.9'........._.--_...~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                __ _"                               9.                                                                       p __                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  1      . 46 n4s.,~~~~4t
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          G.d        "        ,ll z.                                                                  4Iee-od
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           .I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     ..   '.   _           H"I - 9 3 -                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                            1a0                           ... _                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        Q{.vls ;! P 0. ... , ,        , bc                                             ce             . aa4..
                                                                                                                                                            165..5006                  8.                         ,        e~- -"           ..    -
                                                                       Irs n               0            la                 81               85^                                                     s       71
                             ...   9                        n          tab                 we                "L. S8        g8                                       892                             -.     "_           .. 2:
                                               *.vim                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    l.,   Casrkr s O k.
                                                                         10.1
                                                                                           12421*
                                                                                                       1      *I.    S        r       19s
                                                                                                                                           957              T5NT 7i                                             .01A.                                                                                                                                             14;
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  ST-J,'labS
                                                        8       ;4d'      2                             .a"               1       -         1               3          34 0                                                             E A-164.mp                                             .1                                                              pI"                 77
                                                                                               15.6                                          -5                                                 35
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               .16\

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            ..

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       17                         4-Z                     6n
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         11                                                                       -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           I
                             HortI n   DO.ek                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ._..1."1__
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            146                         57            &657                                                                                                    :^............ -                                                          1 1 -                                                         I                                                                    -.-r -                -.                                                       -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               1,)          hR         2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     69       I ' wa                   t     .            9        .0            26 1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Nutteit                            Hook
                                       NEW1BALT T T-OE                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           2'4.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               d   4                       F            P
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   ..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        '0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     *4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          4 ::.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       ~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            R ,.+" ,                  r    1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                c~ Z i
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                d
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            95
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              s t6         0.7. 'k                                                                                                  -7 y
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               ..   p5:t^               r              s.   =                                                        "e.: f14..c .:"y ''iq+
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     :       rs vr4"       ..        ^ -                                                                                                      23 'k.'...._                       09                     1.   o                                                                                                                                                                                                      P9   A;6 11.0,

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      e       4=eco6-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                3:'                                                                                                       .A1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               -

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         S6'           1             1.'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      2            1 ..                                          .                                                                                                                                                       12         Z.7              .                                             ra
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         "+i            +6.                                                                            "'                     ' 2:               " ' '"-        ''                                                                                                                                                                 .             2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    5i 4     tJ   ieuT-                                                                                                                                                                                                               ISv                         6h.cttOr"                               :                   b2             .,       259.       %.7                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                16.2        11"°-'.                  1"d
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          '  " 7-       -.   "ZS ,       241   ""     <t.+ '-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            L   ~~              ~~~~~--                        '         :-~'~-v~i~.~             --.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                'a   ws' e y           46                      1        {               , w:       .b     ...         . .     -        .-   -     .    ,S    X1 2    4-   d -           9 .6                 R       14    4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           S8                                                                                              0\16            .6    .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               --                              1

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 a                              1        2          1         b
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          "': ".                   '            .f'pDn     :7 j        '"t 3                                                                                                                                                                                         _                  -                                         a.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                D.as Lr         " lt"..              .,     '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       rE :bs,

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          y
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        a                                           ui '5                   "
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                _"1.0       -r   ... 113"" ..         ..        . .   5       .   .".. ....   ::                                      9       0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ..  ~....p.,:....          k                        h r        bt ?rv"., C ':                       .4F
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     ;c,",,Z¢ '                          ,             1"              /                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    3S            65        .   0.2ark's Dock
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   3u1 51.3
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               COXSACKIE
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      LIGHT
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       4                293                     2&724
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  9.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 ..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           9t3o~~k                                             J2'-i            2O 10.         -*   2                                                  *2         #34      I                ,    Is

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       r..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           "'                                                                    24                     s0.                                                                                                                                        20.20
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         2.4                                                              *%3                  %1                t

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     .0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               ILZ'             20.0                    --                    u-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                -          222 130        ~24~2,s'           b4-4                    _
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  x-f--sss          -eerxr,.5ly     s,.-       ;   "   '        zj

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     X00
                                                                           9C0..
                                                                         a;&,,                  V                     on ;t.          ,e                        .     .    .       .   .    .   .                                   3:zo
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Jce Nlo. O.                   ..
1748                                                                                                                                                                                                06.,    46..                      , 28 .;r'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    66.oo444q

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        ( (1444 Li st
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         ta.td. how                     bs
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          au          to p
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     .a
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       Lwub i WfM c (Atf.74 b 6P9 1C- b J j
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      wf     f                           'p
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              r                                                                                                                                                                                                             I_                                                               .,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             .CAIIVtPccC .ALi*I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        c tow      V,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            w,k£,OI4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  AjfOt.C14.           4..,Nw..........ate...
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                i ,40so'           ..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       4 .,.., ..... I..    .....  I.....
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   .        .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         ... _............:..6
                                                                o,,tlw             ,of '                               * 9a*-
                                                                                                                    amam                          of CPS
                                                                                                                                                  nup                        CX ;
                                                                                                                                                                             eb
                                                                                                                                                             t*,b~nC*VC C$uLU/Z                            r Pax o4
                                                                                                                                                                                                           of                                                                                                                                                                 6             ro,

                                                            t.tedo H+. 4876:.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       :.; ,.                                                                                            ~9A
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 S,.oae'P.ai
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  -~;                                                                           L~eL3~ii-                                                                                                                                   .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                _.*
                                                                MV1$i-A,.                  Qooa~ £ ii.                   h., l        ob0.




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        °
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                4r"25                                                                                                                                                                                                                       J24                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       42122

         Eng5I22
        EngSO                                                                                                                 -.                                                                                                                                                                                            I                                                                                                                                                                                           ],                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 I                                                                                  ,I
          APPENDIX E--REPORT             OF LIEUT.      COL. MCFARLAND.             643
    However, at Castleton, 5.7 miles above New Baltimore, Assistant Talcott was able
to make a direct comparison with his levels of 1876 and the Coast Survey plane, which
showed his plane to be 0.117 feet below the Coast Survey plane, so that it is not likely
that the planes on the river below Castleton vary very much.
    The results of two and a half months' gauge-readings at Coxsackie Light during
the survey of 1887 give a mean rise and fall of 3.7 feet.
    Mr. Talcott's records from June 19 to November 14, 1876, give a mean rise and fall
of 3.66 feet; while the Coast Survey records from August 13, 1i56, for the remainder
of the season give a mean rise and fall of 3.8 feet.
   It is well to notice, however, that, owing to extreme low water during the survey,
mean low water was 0.6 foot below the plane of reference used.
   The highest tide recorded above the plane of reference during the survey was 4.50
feet and the lowest 2 feet below ; both of these were due to heavy winds.
    The channel to the westward of Bronx Island is so shoal that only cross-sections
were taken at intervals across it. No commerce goes up and down this channel.
    A comparison between the last Coast Survey chart of this part of the river, dated
1856, and the present survey show that very slight changes have taken place in the
channel, assuming that there is only 0.1 foot difference in the two planes, as at Cas-
tleton.
    For the first mile below New Baltimore across Stone House Bar the channel shows
a slight improvement, there being at present a narrow 12-foot channel about 100 feet
wide as against an 11-foot channel in 1856. The Coast Survey chart is on too small
a scale to make an accurate comparison of the 11-foot curves, but they appear to be
about the same, 250 feet apart in the narrowest place.
   It is probable that the 12-foot channel is due to dredging done by the State of New
York in 1883-'84, when 23,238 cubic yards of material were removed from the chan-
nel, according to the annual report of Capt. James Mercur, Corps of Engineers.
There are no records on file in the State engineer's office at Albany of this dredging,
and it is not known what depth or width of channel was obtained.
   Below Stone House Bar the channel is wide for 3 miles and varies from 17+ to 40
feet in depth down to a shoal putting out from the east side of Coxsackie Island. Over
this there is a good 13-foot channel, as against a 12-foot channel in 1856. Below this
there is a good channel, with an average depth of 24 feet of water down to the south-
ernmost point of the survey. The bar on the east of Coxsackie Island has made out-
ward, and it is more than probable that this contraction of the channel has created
scour enough to increase the depth.
   The only trouble with this bar is that it occurs at a sharp bend in the channel and
any stranger is liable to run too close to it, especially as the black buoy marking its
eastern extremity was during the survey placed too far to the westward.
   The shoal at the lower end of Coxsackie Island is making southward, but a chan-
nel is kept open by the steamboat companies running to Cocksackie, so that the
southern extremity of the shoal is no further south than in 1856.
   The main channel, therefore, between New Baltimore and Cocksackie may be said
to be in better condition than in 1856.
   The project approved in 1867 for the improvement of the Hudson River between
Albany and New Baltimore proposed to give a navigable channel 1I feet deep between
those two points. This depth has been obtained in 1885, with a few exceptions.
   The commerce between Albany and New Baltimore is precisely the same as that
between New Baltimore and Coxsackie, and navigation between the two latter points
is very much easier than between the two former, owing to the greater widths of
channel and greater depth of water ; it, therefore, does not appear necessary to make
any improvement between New Baltimore and Coxsackie at present.
   The heads of Light-House and Coxsackie islands are wearing away, and also their
eastern sides about half way down from the heads; but these islands are private
property, and it does not appear that the d6bris carried away from them affects the
channels at present.
   It may become necessary to improve Stone House Bar from time to time by dredg-
ing, as I lea-ned that ice gorges formed there sometimes in the spring. A permanent
improvement of this bar could be made by building a dike on the western side from
near Horton's ice-house.
   This would be about 3,000 feet long ; but there appears no present necessity for it.
   A full statement of the commerce of the Hudson River over the improved portion
may be found in Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1887, page 657. This
shows the commerce to be 6,671,875 tons, valued at $250,213,049 in 1886, and the com-
merce of the Hudson between New Baltimore and Coxsackie will vary very little from
this.
   Respectfully submitted.
                                                             MAURICE    KINGSLY,
                                                                   Assistant Enginccr.
  Lieut. Col. G. L. GILLESPIE,
                   Corps of Engineers.
                               APPENDIX F.



IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN NORTHERIN NEW JERSEY
              AND OF THE HARBOR OF KEYPORT.



REPORT OF CAPTAIN GEORGE McC. DERBY, CORPS OF ENGINEERS,
     OFFICER IN CHARGE, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1888,
     WITH OTHER DOCUMENTS RELATING TO THE WORKS.

                                   IMPROVE MENT S.

1.   Passaic River, New Jersey.              7.   Cheesequakes Creek, New Jersey.
2.   Elizabeth River, New Jersey.            6.   Keyport Harbor, New Jersey.
3.   Rahway River, New Jersey.               9.   Mas:tawan Creek, New Jersey.
4.   Woodbridge Creek, New Jersey.          10.   Shrewsbury River, New Jersey.
5.   Raritan River, New Jersey.             11.   Manasquan River, New Jersey.
6.   South River, New Jersey.




                                     ENGINEER       OFFICE, U.    S.. ARMY,
                                               New York, July 9, 1888.
   GENERAL: I have the honor to transmit herewith my annual reports
on the works of river and harbor improvement in my charge for the'
fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                              GEO. MCC. DERBY,
                                                  Captain of Engineers.
     The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.          S. A.




                                         F I.

              IMPROVEMENT OF PASSAIC RIVER, NEW JERSEY.

  The Passaic River is being improved under two separate projects,
the first applying to the river above Centre Street Bridge, Newark, as
far as Passaic, a distance of 8 miles; the second to the lower course of
the river, from the Centre Street Bridge to beyond the shoals in Newark
Bay, a distance of 71 miles.

                              1.    ABOVE NEWARK.

   Before its improvement was undertaken the upper part of the river
had a navigable 6-foot channel except at Middle Belleville, Rutherford
                                                                645
646           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                    U. S. ARMY.

Park, and Holzman's bars, where the depths were 4.5 feet, 3.9 feet, 3
feet, and 3.5 feet respectively.
   The project of improvement was adopted in 1872, and provided for a
channel across the above shoals from 7- to 6 feet deep at mean low water,
and from 200 to 50 feet wide, to be obtained by dredging and diking,
at a cost of $123,924. It was modified in 1885 by extending the chan-
nel below Middle Bar 1,500 feet to the Erie Railroad Bridge, increasing
the estimate to $129,000.
   Under this project $123,762.04 had been expended to June 30, 1887,
and channels of the required depth had been dredged from 60 to 75
feet wide, excepting for a distance of 1,500 feet above the Erie Railroad
Bridge.
   There has been no work done on the upper river during the fiscal
year, no efficient means of applying the small allotment of $2,250, made
by the act of August 5, 1886, having been found. The condition of the
river remains unchanged.
   The population of the townships on the Passaic above Newark, in-
cluding the city of Paterson, was returned in 1885 as 114,726, and the
commerce of the upper iiver was valued in 1884 at $1,032,000.      Returns
representing less than one-half the firms along the river show for the
year 1887 commerce of 53,000 tons, valued at $721,119. The number
of vessels passing the Centre Street Draw-bridge during the year 1887,
has been 10,040, compared with 9,485 in 1886, and 6,271 in 1879.
   The expenditures for the fiscal year amount to $345.50 for draught-
ing (old records) and administration.
   The balance of the estimate, $7,512, can be expended profitably, as re-
gards the efficient prosecution of the work, during the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1890; and, if appropriated, will be expended in dredging the
channels to the dimensions required by the project.
   The estimated amount required for completion of the existing project
is $7,512.
  Passaic River is in the collection district of Newark, which is the nearest port of
entry. Nearest light-house, Passaic Light, at the lower end of the dike in Newark
Bay. Fort Tompkins is the nearest fort.
  Amount of revenue collected during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $2,613.62.
Original estimate (1872) ................................................                                              123, 924. 00
Revised estimate (1886) .....................      ........                ...........            ...........          133, 762. 00
Amount appropriated ....................                 ....       .... ............                    ...... ....   126, 250. 00
Amount expended ..........        ...              . .....              ..
                                                                       _....         ....-...........                  124, 107. 54

                                                    Money stqterent.
July 1, 1887, amount available.....-------....----------                                  ------.----.                  $2, 487.96
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ....... ........    ............ ..............                                                 345.50
July 1, 1888, balance available ...............----- ..  -..---                                  -............           2, 142. 46
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .-...........                                      -. ....    ..           7. 500. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30,1889 .------------..............-----                                    9,642. 46

                                2. PASSAIC RIVER B3ELOW NEWARK.

  The lower portion of the river, from the Centre Street Bridge to New-
ark Bay, was first surveyed by the Engineer Department in 1879. The
greatest depth in the channel at a point above the Elbow Beacon was
only 7.1 feet, and in many places the greatest depth was 7.5 feet at mean
low water.
               APPENDIX F-REPORT                                 OF CAPTAIN McC.                    DERBY.                647
   A project was adopted, based on this survey, providing for obtaining,
by diking and dredging, a channel 200 feet wide and 10 feet deep at
mean low water, from the Centre Street Bridge to Newark Bay, at a
cost of $232,875.
   This project was modified in 1884, pursuant to the river and harbor
act of that year, providing for extending the dike at the mouth of the
river into the bay, a distance of 8,000 feet, and for dredging a channel
across the shoal in Newark Bay 200 feat wide and 10 feet deep at mean
low water, increasing the original estimate to $353,875.
   June 30, 1887, $149,223.60 had been expended under this project; the
dike at the mouth had been extended about 1,700 feet, making a total
length of 5,705 feet; the channel through the shoal in the bay had been
dredged to the required dimensions, as also the channel up the river as
far as the Newark and New York Railroad Bridge. The remainder of
the distance to the Centre Street Bridge the 10-foot channel had only
been dredged from 130 to 100 feet in width. These results had been of
very great benefit to the large commerce of the river, which was esti-
mated in 1884 at 1,200,000 tons, valued at $30,000,000.
   The contract of October 25, 1886, with P. Sanford Ross, for the con-
struction of about 1,500 feet of dike, in prolongation of the dike at the
mouth of the river, had been extended ninety days at the close of the
last fiscal year. The contractor continued work until September 7,
1887, when the contract was closed ; 500.3 feet of dike were constructed
during the fiscal year, making the total length constructed under the
contract 1,500.3 linear feet, and the entire length of the dike 6,205 feet;
its projected length is 12,000.
   As the survey of 1887, a map of which will be found in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers, 1887, page 766, shows that the chan-
nel dredged across the shoal in the bay in 1884 is maintaining itself
well, it will not be advisable to extend the dike beyond the length now
constructed until positive evidence is obtained that it is necessary for
the maintenance of the channel, as the dike will set in motion large
quantities of material above the shoal, which may give trouble before
reaching another suitable resting place.
   Should some contraction ultimately be required at this point, it is
probable that it could more advantageously be obtained by preventing
the scattering of the current of the Hackensack, by a training-dike on
the easterly side of the channel, as the long straight bank of the fiat
on the west side already in a measure serves the purpose of the dike
on that side.
   Considerable shoaling has taken place in the dredged channel above
the curve in the dike, where there is no longer a 10-foot channel for a
distance of about 3,500 feet ; at the shoalest point the depth is 9.4 feet;
there are also three short breaks in the channel farther up, with least
depths of 9.6, 9.6, and 9.2 feet. No complaints from navigators have,
however, been received as yet of any of these points, or of the lower
shoal in the bay.
   The expenditures for the fiscal year amount to $19,484.25, as follows:
Dike construction and inspection..                          --......-    - --.-.. - - - ----                ..--..   $17, 405.45
Survey of 1887...-----...------.........----....------------............--------......--- ...............              1,153.37
Draughting (old records and new work) ....-----....................                                         ....        411.05
Administration ......-----......---- ....----......-------...------..---                                         -514.38
                                                                         -..-----........--------.....----....---......
         Total...... ........--------..........-------------------------....................................
                                                                                      --------                        19, 484.25
There has been no material change in the commerce of the river,
which is estimated at 1,000,000 tons annually; 22,742 vessels passed the
648         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

draw-bridge at the mouth during 1887, as compared with 21,234 in 1886.
  Newark has a population of over 150,000, and is one of the principal
manufacturing cities in the United States.
  The amount that can be expended profitably as regards the efficient
prosecution of the work during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, is
$100,000, and, if appropriated, it will be applied to widening the chan-
nel to the dimensions provided by the project, and to the construction
of the dikes required in the river.
  The estimated amount required for the completion of the existing
project is $181,875.
  Passaic River is in the collection district of Newark, which is the nearest port of
entry. Nearest light-house, Passaic Light, at the lower end of the dike in Newark
Bay. Fort Tompkins is the nearest fort.
  Amount of revenue collected during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $2,613.62.
Original estimate (1879) .....-...........              .........................        ....           $232, 875. 00
Revised estimate (1884) ......      ...          ---......--- ......................   .....             353, 875.00
Amount appropriated...... .................. ..............       .......... . 172,000.00
Amount expended, including outstanding liabilities July 1, 1888........ 168, 886. 85

                                          MIoney statement.
July   1, 1887, amount available ..................               ...................         ....  $4, 895. 40
July   1,1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of   liabilities outstanding Juily 1, 1887 .... ..................                  $160, 325. 00
July   1, 1888, outstanding liabilities         __........_.... ....          ......        179. 00
                                                                                                     1,782. 25
July 1,1887, balance available .......... ..........................                                   .    3,113.15
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ..             .       .............              ....       27, 500.00



{Amount
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ....-..............

          (estimated) required for completion of existing project....... 154, 375. 00
  Amount that canbe profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 100, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of the river and
                                                                                                           30, 613.15



   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




                                                     F 2.

               IMPROVEMENT OF ELIZABETH RIVER, NEW JERSEY.

   This stream, which is 28 'miles from its mouth to the head of naviga-
tion, at Broad street, Elizabeth, has a width of from 50 to 90 feet, and
before its improvement the wharves in the city could only be reached
at high water by vessels drawing less than 4 feet. Its commerce was
estimated at 45,000 tons annually. The range of the tide was about
4.7 feet at its mouth and 3.4 feet at Bridge street.
   The project for the improvement was adopted in 1878, and provides
for obtaining by dredging a channel 60 feet wide and 7 feet deep at high
water, from the mouth of the river to the head of navigation, at an
estimated cost of $25,530.
   The amount expended under this project to June 30, 1887, was
$26,708.6, and a channel has been dredged to the required depth to
within 1,000 feet of the Broad Street Bridge. A slight increase in the
commerce of the stream had been observed.
   There has been no appropriation for this work since 1882, and the
expenditures during the last fiscal year have been $13.08 for office ex-
penses.
               APPENDIX             F-REPORT               OF CAPTAIN McC.                  DERBY.            649
   The condition of the river has deteriorated since work was suspended.
When last examined, vessels drawing 5 feet could ascend the river to
the head of the dredged channel at high tide. The commerce of the
river is about 30,000 tons, but no substantial increase can be expected
while the river remains in its present condition. A coal-yard estab-
lished last year has done a business of about 6,000 tons.,
   The city of Elizabeth has a population of about 33,000, and does an
active commerce over two important lines of railroad, a considerable
portion of which would take the water route to great advantage if ade-
quate facilties existed. It is stated that the establishment of the coal
yard on the river has reduced the retail price of coal 50 cents per ton.
   If it is the intention of Congress to complete this improvement the
balance of the estimate, $16,160, could be expended profitably as regards
the efficient prosecution of the work during the fiscal year ending June
30, 1890, and would be applied to dredging the channel to the full di-
mensions required by the project.
   The estimated amount required for the completion of the improve-
ment is $16,160.
Elizabeth is in the collection district of Newark, N. J. ; nearest light-house, Newark
Bay; nearest fort, Fort Tomkins.
Amount of revenue collected at the port of Newark, N. J., during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, $2,613.62.
Original estimate (1878) ...............................                              ................ $25, 530. 00
Revised estimate (1882) ......               .... ...... ..........
                                         ......                              ..........          ...... 43, 160. 00
Amount appropriated .....................                    .................        ..........        27, 000.00
Amount expended.... ...... ......                        ........
                                                       ......                  ................. 26,721.74

                                              Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available...........--..----..--....----------------.........-----....---..........   $291.34
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 .................................................                                 13. 08
July 1, 1888, balance available----
                                ......------......------......-----....--.............                      278. 26
   SAmount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ..--.     16, 160.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 16,160. 00
1Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
 ,   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                         F 3.
                   IMPROVEMENT OF RAHWAY RIVER, NEW JERSEY.

  In its original condition the Rahway River had a depth of 8 feet and
more at mean high water from its mouth to Bricktown, 3J miles; 7 feet
to Edgar's Dock, 4- miles; 4.4 feet to Milton Avenue Bridge, 44 miles;
and 4 feet to Main Street Bridge, 5 miles, in the town of Rahway. Its
commerce was estimated at 120,000 tons, and three attempts had been
made to establish a line of steam-boats on the river, but had failed on
account of the bad condition of the stream.
  The original project for its improvement was adopted in 1878, and
provided for dredging a channel 125 feet wide and 8 feet deep at high
water from Bricktown to Milton Avenue Bridge, and 100 feet wide from
that point to Main Street Bridge. The tide rises about 5 feet at the
mouth and 4 feet at the head of navigation.
  June 3, 1887, $36,918.13 had been expended under this project, which
had resulted in the formation of a channel 7 feet deep at high water,
650           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

and from 100 to 50 feet in width to within 550 feet of the head of navi-
gation; it has not, however, proved permanent.
   The commerce of the river had not increased, though freight rates to
Rahway had been materially reduced as a result of the improvement
of the river.
   There has been no appropriation for this work since 1882, and the
expenditures during the last fiscal year amounted to $14.20 for office
expenses.
   The condition of the river has deteriorated since work was suspended
and its commerce has decreased, the shoaling of the river having obliged
one of the principal shippers to transfer his business to the railroad.
   The town of Rahway has a population of about 7,500 people, has a
number of manufactories, and ships and receives by rail large quantities
of freight annually. The river reaches the center of the town, and it
it were in good navigable condition would carry a large trade.
   If it is the intention of Congress to complete this improvement, the
balance of the estimate, $29,250, could be expended profitably as re-
gards the efficient prosecution of the work during the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1890, and would be applied to deepening and widening the
channel by dredging.
   The estimated amount required for the completion of the improvement
in accordance with the approved project is $29,250.
This work is in the collection district of Perth Amboy, N. J., which is the nearest
port of entry. The nearest light-house is Prince's Bay Light, and Fort Tompkins is
the nearest fort.
  Amount of revenue collected during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $56,727.64.
Original estimate (1878)....-----..---....---..........----..-------.....----....--......----------........... $36, 653. 00
Revised estimate (1882) .....--....--...---..      ......---...----.-----
                                                                     ..-----..---.---....----.....------....    66, 250.00
Amount appropriated .-...--..--         ...... -..-- --       -......-
                                                                     ---.... --..........- -..- ---..........       37, 000. 00
Amount expended--.-..------.....------......----..........-----......----------- ..---.....----....----..-.         36, 932. 33
                                                 Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available. ........-              -...........--   ------..           ---           ---    .      $81. 87
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fical year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887...---------.....-----.....---......---......---..----------...--....---......                14. 20
July 1, 1888, balance available                                     ------....------...--........-----......
                                                  ....----..--...--......                                                67.67
  Amount (estimated) required for the completion of existing project.... 29, 250. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 29, 250. 00
  ,Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                                              F 4.
               IMPROVEMENT OF WOODBRIDGE CREEK, NEW JERSEY.

   In its original condition this stream was obstructed at its mouth by
a bar having a depth of 9.8 feet on its crest at high water, and by two
shoals just inside the mouth; from these shoals a good 12-foot channel
existed to above Anderson's Brick Works, seven-eighths of a mile from
the mouth, above which point, however, many shoals occurred, though
a narrow 8-foot channel existed as far as Salamander Dock, 1 miles
from the mouth.
   The town of Woodbridge, and numerous fire-brick, tile, and drain-
pipe works, situated on the creek, did a considerable trade, estimated
at 126,000 tons annually. The range of the tide is about 5 feet.
  The project for improving the creek was adopted in 1878, and pro-
vides for obtaining by dredging and diking a channel 80 feet wide and
                       APPENDIX F--REPORT OF CAPTAIN MCC. DERBY.                                                                                                         651

12 feet deep at mean high water from the mouth to Salamander Dock,
at an estimated cost of $13,800, increased in 1884 to $29,000.
   The amount expended under this project to June 30, 1887, was $19,000,
with which the required dike had been constructed, and a 12-foot chan-
nel, from 80 to 25 feet wide, had been obtained as far as Valentine's
Dock, 1- miles, and a 9-foot channel 80 feet wide thence to Town Dock,
1,200 feet'further up; and the creek was also widened 20 feet at the
elbow opposite Salamander Dock.
   No increase in the commerce of the creek had been observed.
   There has been no appropriation for this work since 1882 ; there were
no funds available during the last fiscal year, and no expenditures.
The condition of the channel has deteriorated since work was suspended,
and shoals are complained of both above and below Valentine's Dock.
   There has been no increase in the amount of commerce reported
above, which is already very large in proportion to the size of the
stream.
   If it is the intention of Congress to complete this improvement, the
balance of the estimate, $10,000, can be expended profitably as regards
the efficient prosecution of the work during the fiscal year ending June
30, 1890, and would be applied to dredging the channel to the dimen-
sions required by the project, which would add materially to existing
facilities. The estimated amount required for the completion of the im-
provement is $10,000.
  This work is in the collection district of Perth Amboy, N. J., which is the nearest
port of entry. Nearest light-house, Great Beds Light, in Raritan Bay. Nearest fort,
fort at Sandy Hook, N. J.
  Amount of revenue collected at the port of Perth Amboy during the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1888, $57,727.64.
Original estimate (1878)                          .....--       ......................                                  ..................                     $13,    809. 14
Revised estimate (1884)---..........-----                                    ..-----......-------------------.........................
                                                                         -..----                                                                                  29,000.00
Amount appropriated .----                             --..---                                             --..     --           ......--
                                                                                                                               ---                                19,000. 00
Amount expended ....-------......-------....-----......-......- ---....---....-----....---......----                                       ....----....---.       19, 000. 00
                                                                Money statement.
 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project......-------..                                                                               $10,000. 00
) Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                                                                      10, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
                                                         COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The following statistics relative to commerce of Woodbridge Creek, N. J., during
the calendar year 1887, were compiled in this office by Mr. C. S. Kelsey, surveyor:

                                                           Articles.                                                                                     Tons.         Value.


                                                            Exports.
Clay and sand ...-----------------------------------------------------------------                                                                       68, 140       $167, 436
                                   --------------------------.-.....
Fire-brick, hollow brick, tile, etc...                    .         ..    -----                                                                          35, 950        291, 362

         Total............---------.........                              ......                                                   -........           1............
                                                                                                                                                       104,090          458,798

                                                            Imports.
Clay....-------..------------..--..--------------------------------------.                                                                               20,000          25,000
Coal, building material, etc.....                      .............                .................................                                     2, 552         10, 600
         Total------................................--------------------------------------------------------------                                       22, 552          5, 600
         Total commerce .....                  -....-. .          ...............         ...... --...................                                  126, 642        494, 398


  There is no material increase in the traffic by water, the increase in manufactures
and the clay output being deflected by better railroad facilities. The shipments by
rail of brick, tile, and clay during 1887 amounted to 86,240 tons, valued at $321,015,
being two-thirds that shipped by water.
652    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                  F 5.

       .   IMPROVEMENT OF RARITAN RIVER, NEW JERSEY.

  Before its improvement by the United States, the Raritan River had
a depth of 8.5 feet at " The Stakes," 3 miles; of 6.5 feet at the " Middle
Grounds," 4. miles; of 7.5 feet at Whitehead's Sand Dock, 8N miles;
and between this point and New Brunswick, 124 miles above the mouth,
the channel was obstructed by a number of rocky shoals with depths
of from 8.4 feet to 6.9 feet at mean low water. The city of New Bruns-
wick and the Delaware and Raritan Canal which terminates here, to-
gether with extensive brick-yards on the South River, did a large com-
merce on the stream, estimated in 1871 at 3,053.857 tons per annum.
   The present project was adopted in 1874, and provides for obtaining by
diking and dredging, and, where necessary, by drilling and blasting rock,
a channel 200 feet wide and 10 feet deep at mean low water from the
mouth to New Brunswick, at a cost of $2,093,662.05. It was modified
in 1881, pursuant to the river and harbor act of March 3 of that year,
by adding to it the dredging of the South Channel, about 13,000 feet
long, 100 feet wide, and 5. feet deep at mean low water from Kearney's
Dock to Crab Island.
   Under this project $447,638.57 bad been expended June 30, 1887, in
constructing the dikes required by the project at " The Stakes" and
" Middle Grounds," in dredging channels 200 feet wide and 12 feet deep
at mean low water at these points, and in drilling, blasting, and dredg-
ing a channel of the same dimensions across the rocky shoals at White-
head's Sand Dock. Under the two special allotments made for it in the
acts of March 3, 1881, and August 2, 1882, the South Channel was
dredged to the required depth for a distance of 4,000 feet. These im-
provements had been of great benefit to navigation, permitting the large
tows in use on the river to reach a point 4 miles below New Brunswick
at all stages of the tide. The commerce of the river was reported in
1887 at 1,675,355 tons, valued at $28,119,173.
   At the close of the last fiscal year surveys of the defective portions
of the river had just been completed, the results of which were reported
in the last annual report. On July 27, 1887, a report was submitted to
the Chief of Engineers, recommending that no work be done at White-
head's Sand Dock with the existing appropriation, in view of the fact
that the channel at that point was already in better condition than either
above or below, but that $15,000 be expended in dredging a channel 100
feet wide and 10 feet deep across the three shoals between Whitehead's
Sand Dock and Martin's Dock, the best depth on the crests of these
shoals being 8.4, 8.0, and 6.9 feet respectively. This work would bring
the improved channel to within 1 miles of the city of New Brunswick.
This project was approved by the Chief of Engineers August 6, 1887.
Specifications were prepared and advertised twenty-five days. Sealed
proposals were opened September 7, 1887. The lowest bid was that of
M. K. Pidgeon, who proposed to dredge the loose material from the 700
feet of the lower shoal where the rock crops out above the contract
depth, for $14 per cubic yard, and the remaining 4,100 feet of the chan-
nel across the shoals for 47 cents per cubic yard, scow measurement; the
material to be dumped in the lower course of South River, which the
original project for the improvement of that stream contemplates clos-
ing. These bids were considered unreasonable, and the work was re-
advertised.
         APPENDIX F--REPORT OF CAPTAIN McC.               DERBY.       653
    At the second opening of proposals, September 22, 1887, M.'R. Pid-
geon was again the lowest bidder (abstract of bids herewith), propos-
ing to dredge the rocky section for $2.83, and the remainder for 43 cents
per cubic yard, scow measurement. The bids were again rejected and
authority obtained to hire the necessary plant and do the work by the
day. While negotiations to this end were in progress, it became appar-
ent that it would not be advisable to close the lower course of South
River at present, if at all, so that the proposed dumping-ground could
not be used. It was then decided to dump the material along the face
of dikes A and 1, Raritan River, and use a second dredge to pick it up
again and throw it over the dike.
    Dredging began November 21, and was discontinued December 22
on account of the freezing of the river,
    A dipper dredge, 3 scows, and tug-boat were hired at $8.40 per hour;
and a clam-shell dredge, 3 scows, and tug-boat at $78 per day. The first
was put to work on the rocky section, and the latter mainly on the re-
mainder of the shoal, though partly on the rocky section also.
    The cost of digging and dumping 3,695 cubic yards was 55.6 cents
per cubic yard for the dipper dredge on the rocky section, and 37.3
cents per cubic yard for 3,935 cubic yards for the clam shell, a favor-
able exhibit as compared with the lowest bid.
    A second clam-shell dredge was hired at $50 per day, and used to
lift the dredged material over the dike, and for a short time also in
working on the shoal. The lifting over the dike cost 10.6 cents per cu-
bic yard, making the total cost of dredging and disposing of the ma-
terial 56.8 cents per cubic yard, scow measurement.
    When work was suspended a survey of the shoal showed that 4,990
cubic yards measured in place had been removed, making a channel 10
feet deep at mean low water across the shoal, 25 feet wide at its nar-
rowest point, though in most places 75 feet wide. The rocky section
was nearly completed.
    Operations this season have not yet been resumed. The only propo-
sition received for hiring plant by the day has been $168 per day for
dredge, tug-boat, and scows, which is extravagant. Three propositions
were received for doing the work by the yard: Brainard Bros., at 59
cents per cubic yard; H. Du Bois' Sons, at 55 cents; and M. H. Flan-
nery, at 50 cents. These propositions were allrejected, but the work was
  subsequently offered to M. IH. Flannery at 40 cents per cubic yard, sub-
ject to approval of the Chief of Engineers; this offer Mr. Flannery ac-
  cepted, and it has since been approved by the Chief of Engineers by
indorsement of June 12 1888, on my report of June 2. The dredged
  material is to be used by the contractor in building an earthen dike or
  embankment on the left bank of the river at the Middle Grounds, it be-
  ing believed that the material, which is mainly coarse gravel, is suffi-
  ciently heavy not to be removed by the currents, though, if necessary,
  the face of the dike can be protected with stone at small expense. The
  construction of this dike was recommended in my report of June 2, and
  was approved by the Chief of Engineers June 11.
     The channel dredged at the Middle Grounds in 1884, to a depth of 12
  feet and width of 130, has not maintained itself well, but has shoaled
  opposite the site of the proposed dike, till there is barely a continuous
  10-foot channel not over 50 feet wide. The shoaling is believed to be
  due to the fact that the width of the river is excessive at this point.
  The dike is to be about 3,260 feet long, and is to be built to the level of
  high water, contracting the river to the width of 600 feet, which is its
  width just above and below. This dike will also serve the purpose of
654            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

making available a small dumping-ground between it and shore, which
is badly needed.
   Work is to be begun on the dike and the dredging under agreement
with M. H. Flannery July 1.
   The price at which the work is to be done, 40 cents per cubic yard, scow
measurement, is considered reasonable in view of the fact that nearly
all of the material will have to be handled twice; but this price was only
obtained by bargaining, and it is now a well-known fact that owners of
dredging plant in the vicinity of New York have so combined that there
is no longer any competition for Government work, so that prices have
been raised beyond a reasonable limit. A great saving to the Govern-
ment would result from its owning at least one complete dredging plant
in this neighborhood, as the working of that plant would set a stand-
ard that the prices bid on other works could be compared with.
   Much office work has been done during the year at considerable ex-
pense, in posting up the maps and records of the improvement since its
beginning.
   The drill-scow and launch Raritan, which were in an entirely unserv-
iceable condition at the beginning of the year, have been put in good
repair, one-half of the expense being borne by the improvement of New
Rochelle Harbor, in charge of Lieutenant-Colonel Houston, Corps of
Engineers, who has since used the plant on that improvement during the
fall and spring. An opportunity offering to exchange the launch Rar-
itan with the commanding officer at Willets Point, for the tug boat Star,
which is much more suitable for the work on the Raritan River, the ex-
change was made with the approval of the Chief of Engineers, and she
has been put in good running order.
   The expenditures during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, amount
to $9,036.01, as follows:
Dredging and dumping 7,630 cubic yards ..............-------..............                                                                       $4, 331. 13
Inspection .--.....---- -----..... -----......----....----......---....-----..... ..-------.......----...                 ------....--.... --        429.74
Advertising.           -...........--...---                 ---..................-..........--......--                 .......----.        --        49. 70
Survey of shoals below Martin's Dock .......---                                           ......................-                          ..       306.42
Examination after dredging- .-----------------------.........................-------------------...................                                   38.30
Draughting (old records and new work)- ...............................                                                                               364.35
Care and storage of rock-drilling plant ..................................                                                                           175.00
Repairs of launch and drill-scow ...................                            ............--              ......                                1,733.78
Fitting out tug-boat Star................................................                                                                            499. 32
Administration.-     -.. ..................                    ..............         .. . ......-.....--           .                             1, 108. 27

      Total ....--.-------..........                  ......-----.....-------------....--..........------------..----------.....--......          9, 036. 01
  The commerce of the Raritan River is very large; the city of New
Brunswick has a population of about 20,000 people, and is the terminus
of the Delaware and Raritan Canal.
  The amount that can be expended profitably, as regards the efficient
prosecution of the work during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, is
$100,000, and if appropriated, will be expended in carrying the im-
proved channel further up the river toward New Brunswick.
  The estimated amount required for the completion of the improve-
ment is $1,622,412.05.
  This work is in the collection district of Perth Amboy, N. J., which is the nearest
port of entry; nearest light-house, Great Beds Light, in Raritan Bay ; nearest fort,
fort at Sandy Hook, N. J.
  Amount of revenue collected at Perth Amboy, during the fiscal year ending June
30, 1888, $57,727,64.
Original estimate.. .---.----...
                           .....              ------....         .......       $2, 093, 662. 05
Amount appropriated.......-------..--.........-----...........................     471,250.00
Amount received from sales of fuel (A. R. C. E., 1882-'83) ..............                                                                           180. 00
Amount received from sale of fuel to Captain Derby....................                                                                                  .00
Amount expended (including outstanding liabilities) .................                                                                           456, 860. 14
                  APPENDIX           F--REPORT               OF      CAPTAIN              McC.             DERBY.                      655
                                                 AMoney statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available...........................-------------------------..- ----------........ -$23,                       651.91
Amount received from Captain Derby for sale of fuel (March 31 and June
29, 1888)--....--------.----------- ----- -----  ----    ------  --------..                                                            2. 00

                                                                                                                                  23, 653. 91
July 1, 1883, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
   of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887...... .......--...                                        $, 896.49
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ...            --------------- -------                               185.5'i
                                                                                                           V9,
                                                                                                                                     082. 05

July 1, 1888, balance available........-----..----..---......                   ..............---....                          14,571.86
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188..                                   .....            ------                       50, 000. 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889....                                   ......         .....     .            64, 571. 86


 (Amount (estimated) required for cQmpletion of existing project-.,...                                                    1, 572, 412. 05
   Amount that can be profitably expended in the fiscal ending June 30,1890                                                    100, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
           harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




Abstract of bids for dredging in RaritanRiver, New Jersey, opened at the U. S. Engineer
  Office, Army Building, New York City, N. Y., at 12 o'clock, m., on September 7, 1887,
  under advertisement dated August 13, 1887.


                                                                                                                   Bid per cubic yard,
                                                                                                                        in scow.

No.         Name and residence of bidder.                Name and residence of sureties.
                                                                                                                   700 feet         Remain-
                                                                                                                   rocky sec- ing 4,100
                                                                                                                    tion of    feet of
                                                                                                                    channel. channel.


 *1        M. K. Pidgeon, 60 South street, New        John P. Hawkins, C. C. Ellis, New                              $14. 00            $0.47    T


             York City.                                 York, N. Y.
   2       Hartford Dredging Company, Hart-           Charles J. Hills, Edward G. Lasbury,                               25.00             .60
             ford, Conn.                                Hartford, Conn.
t3        Elijah Brainard, 24 State street,          Theodore Smith, Henry Smith, Jersey                                15. 20            .49
             New York.                                  City, N. J.

   * Commence according to specifications and finish according to same.
   t Commence on or before October 1.d887.

Abstract of bids for dredging in Raritan River, New Jersey, opened at the U. S. Engineer
  Office, Army Building, New York City, N. IY., at 12 o'clock, in., on September 22, 1887, un-
der circulardated September 12, 1887.


                                                                                                                   Price per cubic yard,
                                                                                                                   measured in scow.

No.         Name and residence of bidder.                Name and residence of sureties.
                                                                                                                    700 feet Remain-
                                                                                                                   rocky sec- ing 4,10:
                                                                                                                    tion of          feet of
                                                                                                                    channel.        channel.


   1       W. H. Beard, 302 Hamilton avenue,           C. N. Kingsland, M. D. Lawrence,                              * $3. 50          $0. 48
             Brooklyn, N. Y.                             Brooklyn, N. Y.
   2       Elijah Brainard, 24 State street, New       Joseph Laughlin, New York, N. Y. ;                                t3.   0O        . 46
             York City, N. Y.                            George W. Rogers, Elizabeth, N. J.
   3       Hartford Dredging Company, Hart-            Charles J. Hills, Edward G. Lasbury,                              18. 00          . 55
             ford, Conn.                                 Hartford, Conn.
   4       M. K.Pidgeon, 60 South street, New          John P. Hawkins, A. J. Atwater,                                    2. 83          . 43
             York City, N. Y.                            New York, N. Y.
       r




   *For all material that can be dredged without blasting.
   4 Rock-work not included.
656          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                            COIMMERCIAL              STATISTICS.

  The following statistics relative to commerce of the Raritan River during the cal-
endar year 1887, were compiled in this office by Mr. C. 8. Kelsey, surveyor:
Population of Middlesea County in 1885 ......................-----......              56, 180
Assessed valuation of real estate in 1880, Middlesea County .--....-----...... $15, 974, 111
Assessed valuation of personal property in 1880, Middlesea County-.....           3, 898, 358
Total value of productions of farms in 1879, Middlesea County......--.            1,486,147
Total value of materials of manufacture in 1879, Midlesea County....             5, 391, 913
Total value of products  of manufacture   in 1879, Middlesea County              9,  587,832                                             9...
                                                       EXPORTS.

                                  From South            From Delaware Below New Bruns-                                               Total.
                                     River.            and Raritan Canal.   wick.
          Articles.

                                  Tons.     Value.     Tons.          Value.                    Tons.         Value.        Tons.           Value.


Products of forests ....... 5, 500 $23, 700 117, 116                  $136, 928                     100        $1,000       122, 716         $161, 628
Products of mines:
   Coal ......................             I"......
                                            472, 690 2, 033, 044 ...............          _.                                472, 690        2, 033, 044
    Clay, ores, etc -....... 6, 354 16, 801 28, 445     850, 070 90,309             149,658                                 125,108         1,016,529
Agricultural products .--..  --              12, 480    936,000 .......          ...                                            12, 480       936, 000
Products of manufacture. 182, 500 513, 000              9     ... 163,840           538, 224                                346, 340        1 056,   224
Miscellaneous merchan-
  dise, etc................  1,000 50,000   218, 438 12,192,600     7,334           325,000                                 226, 772 i12, 567, 600

       Total ...............
                        195, 354 608, 591 849, 169 16,148, 642 261, 583 1, 013, 882 1, 306, 106 17, 771, 025


                                                        IMPORTS.

Products of forests----......       350      $1, 125   18, 546        $463, 650........                                         18, 896      $464, 775
Products of mines:
   Coal ..................    I 14, 515      66, 652   47, 380         204, 207 22, 800                       $95, 000          84,695         365, 859
   Clay, ores, etc ....... .............               52, 387      1,002, 555     ...                                          52, 387     1, 002, 555
Agricultural products ...      ....            ....    22, 660      1, 699, 500.....                                            22, 660     1, 699, 500
Manufactured products...            500      51, 000                                                                                500         51,000
Merchandise and miscel-
  laneous................. 18, 460 145, 500 165,651                 6, 368, 959                  6, 000       250, 000      190,111         6, 764, 459
       Total......--........ 38, 823 264, 277 306, 624              9, 738,871              28,800            345, 000      369, 249 10, 348, 14'


  The commerce of South Amboy is not included in the above. During the year
36,600 tons of clay and sand, valued at $85,000, were exported by rail from the vicinity
of the river.
  Three brick-yards have been completed since 1887, with a combined capacity of
22,000,000 brick, having a value of $271,000.
   Enumeration of craft passing through the draw-bridge at the mouth of Raritan River.



                 Years.                      Steam- Propel-                                                Schoon- Sloops.         kiffsand Total.
                                             boats.   lers.           Tugs.ers.                                                    and     t.
                                                                                                              i"yachts.

Calendar year 1880 ............                                            ......                 ...--.             .---
                                                                                                             .---..--.--.            .          13,405
Calendar year 1886 .......      .....            712     1,724          1,883             2, 241            3,772      2, 088      1, 007       13,427
Year ending June 30, 1887........                818     1,636          1,850             2,563             4,080      2,035          963       13,945

Of the above number 7,257 loaded boats passed in and out of the Delaware and
Raritan Canal, at New Brunswick Lock, during the year 1887.


                                             COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

Commercial statistics of the port of Perth Amboy, N. J., for the fiscal year ending June
                                                         30, 1888.
Amount of revenue collected ......................................                                                                   $57,727. 64
Value of all imports ...............................                                            .................                    204, 761. 00
Value of all exports .............                          .................................                                     1,499, 371.00
                     APPENDIX                         F-REPORT               OF       CAPTAIN                     McC.       DERBY.           657


                                                                                                                             Number.    Registered
                                                       Shipping.                                                                         tonnage.


Foreign vessels entered from foreign countries .........................                  20
                                                                                          9...  24, 313
Foreign vessels cleared for foreign countries.--.--.-.-......-.          ...--.. ..-....  9     68, 678
&merican vessels from foreign port-..---------.------...-...........---.-         ..        5    1, 553
American vessels for foreign ports....--------------------------------------              17     7, 485
Coastwise vessels entered- ..----------------..-----------------------------             206   119, 379
Coastwise vessels cleared.-               ---
                               ----..-..-...      -                                             52, 337
                                                        ---.............--...--.....................--..
                                                                                          72


    Am(ong -coastwise                             vessels entered" are included thirteen foreign vessels 18,485
tons, which came here with foreign cargo, having firstldischarged other foreign cargo
at New York. Among "coastwise vessels cleared" are included seven foreign vessels
(3,780 tons) and five American vessels (4,103 tons) which loaded at this port cargo
for a foreign port, but went to New York for additional cargo.
Nunmber arnd tonnage of all vessels belonging to the port of Perth Amboy, N. J., June
                                                                         .0,1888.

                                                                                                                             Number.    Registered
                                                                                                                                         tonnage.


Steam vessels......................             ........................................                                           44       7,242.60
Sailing vessels.......... ........... ........................................                                                    307      15, 841.71
Barges     ....................................                                                                                    62      20, 355. 95
Canal boats and scows... -....--...................-                                       ..           ........- ........          2          246.40

         Total.....................................                                             .........            .....        415     43, 686. 66


  Including vessels belonging here, but temporarily documennted elsewhere, June 30.
1888, not including vessels belonging at other ports yet documented here on that
date.


                                                                             F 6.
                             IMPROVEMENT OF SOUTH RIVER, NEW JERSEY.
   Before the improvement of this stream was undertaken by the United
States the navigation of the lower 2 miles of its course had been
abandoned, and a canal dredged at private expense from a short dis-
tance below Washington to Sayreville, on the Raritan River. In 1880,
when the present project for improving the river was adopted, the mouth
of this canal, on account of its faulty location, had shoaled to a depth
of 4.6 feet at mean low water, and the best depth in the canal, some
distance above, had decreased to 3.3 feet. Above Washington a depth
of 2.7 feet existed to Bissett's, 3a miles, and of 2.5 feet to Old Bridge,
the head of navigation, 61 miles above the mouth of the canal at Sayre-
ville. The range of the tide was 5.3 feet at Sayreville. The town of
Washington and numerous brick-yards did a commerce on the river
valued at $1,249,000.
   The present project, adopted in 1880, provides for closing the river
below the head of the canal, correcting the direction of the mouth of the
latter, and obtaining, by diking and dredging, a depth of 8 feet mean low
water to Washington, 6 feet to Bissett's, and 4 feet to Old Bridge,
straightening the channel at two points by cutting across the meadow.
It was estimated to cost $194,695.
   The amount expended under this project to June 30 1887, $55,863.31,
with which the direction of the mouth of the canal had been changed, the
dikes below Washington completed, and a small amount of dredging
done on a shoal above Washington.                                                   No increase in the commerce of the
river had been observed.
               ENG 88-42
658        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   At the close of the fiscal year $5,111.75 was available for this improve-
ment; a survey of the river and canal from Washington to Sayreville
was completed in June, 1887, and reported on in the last annual re-
port. It was determined to expend the available funds in dredging a
channel 8 feet deep through the canal and river, from the mouth of the
canal to the town of Washington. Specifications were prepared and
the work advertised August 12,.1887, at the same time as the dredging
on the Raritan River. Bids were opened September 7, 1887 (abstract
herewith). The lowest bidder was the Hartford Dredging Company, at
30 cents per cubic yard, scow measurement, which was considered un-
reasonable. The -bids were rejectel, and the work readvertised. At
the second opening the Hartford Dredging Company was again the
lowest bidder, at 29 cents (abstract of bids herewith). The bids were
again rejected, and authority obtained to hire the necessary plant and
do the work by the day.
   A dipper dredge was hired with three small scows and tug-boat at $8.40
per hour. Work was begun October 17, 1887, cutting away the shoal
on the right bank at the mouth of the canal, and dumping the material
in the lower course of South River below Pettit's brick-yard, the exist-
ing project approved in 1880 providing for entirely closing this channel.
The fact was shortly developed, however, that residents on the banks
of this portion of the stream strongly objected to the channel being
closed or obstructed, notwithstanding the fact that a better water-way
exists from their property to the Raritan River via the canal than via
the lower course of the river, and that no vessel ever uses the latter
channel except on the rarest occasions.        A petition was submitted
signed by forty residents and boat owners of the neighborhood requesting
that no obstruction be placed in this portion of the river, alleging that
said channel is of value to commerce and navigation, and will be of
value even when a depth of 8 feet at mean low water has been obtained
through the canal.
   In my judgment, closing the lower course of the river is not an es-
sential feature of the existing project, as I feel no uncertainty about
the volume of water that flows naturally through the canal being quite
ample to maintain a depth of 8 feet at mean low water. It was there-
fore thought advisable to defer to the wishes of the residents of the
neighborhood and find some other means of disposing of the material
dredged from the canal, even though this involved the additional ex-
pense of handling all the dredged material twice in placing it behind
the dikes in the canal.
   In addition to the dipper dredge already at work, two clam-shell
dredges with two 300-yard scows were hired at $100 per day, and were
employed excavating a channel across the shoal between Dikes D and
E in the canal, and across the shoal in the river abreast of Dike F, just
below Washington. The dredged material was placed behind the dikes
adjacent to the cuts made, with the exception of 441 cubic yards dumped
in the lower course of South River. Work was continued until Decem-
ber 8, when the available funds were exhausted. A survey was then
made and the work measured in place, showing the following results:

                                                                                      Measured     Measured
                                                                                      in scows.    in place.


Dredged from shoal at the mouth ............- ......      ........ cubic yards..         4,518          3, 163
Dredged from channel between Dikes D and E ......----..............       do....       i10, 802         8, 390
Dredged from shoal at Dike F---                ...............        .   do...           1, 495           776
      Total...............---......-          ...   --.              ...-....   ---      16, 815       12,329
              APPENDIX                 F-REPORT OF CAPTAIN MCC. DERBY.                                                              659
  The entire quantity dredged from between Dikes D and E, as meas-
ured in place, is 11,074 cubic yards, indicating that in putting the dredged
material behind the dikes the dredge removed somewhat more than had
been dumped.
Total number of cubic yards dredged this season .-..-                                          -- --..-
                                                                                        ...... ......                             . 16,815

Cost of dredging and dumping, per cubic yard -. -----                                        $0. 165
                                                        -.............--................-----------
Cost of lifting dredged material over dike, per cubic yard ................                     .079

       Total cost, per cubic yard .......----............                               ......           ..... .......                . 244

   The lowest bid received for the.above work by contract was 29 cents,
which did not include lifting the dredged material over the dike.
   Vessels drawing 6 feet can reach Washington at mean low water; the
6-foot channel is 50 feet wide at Dike F, and 60 feet in the canal, where
it is likely to be improved by the currents.
   Messrs. Sayre and Fisher, the owners of the brick-yards at the mouth
of the canal, have made the claim that it was one of the conditions on
which they deeded certain lands to the United States in 1881 for the
use of the improvement of South River that the United States should
build Dike A continuously from the meadow bank, where it now starts,
to the corner of their dock at the mouth of the canal; and they accord-
ingly made application (luring the year to have the dike extended down-
stream to the corner of their dock, a distance of about 230 feet, they
being anxious to use the dike as a dock front. A map showing the lo-
cality will be found, page 764 of the Annual Report of the Chief of En-
gineers for 1885. The records of this office indicate that the construc-
tion of this dike was not a part of the consideration for which the land
was deeded, and it does not form part of the existing project; the ap-
plication of Messrs. Sayre and Fisher was therefore not granted. It
was, however, finally settled, that in consideration of all claim against
the United States being abandoned by Messrs. Sayre and Fisher, and
their proceeding to close the gap betweeq their dock and the end of the
dike by the construction of a suitable bulkhead, that the shoal along
this front on the right bank of the mouth of the canal, which had re-
formed since it was dredged by the United States in 1882, would be
dredged again by the United States to a depth of 6 feet mean low water;
and these arrangements have been carried out, greatly improving the
entrance to the canal.
   The steamer running to Washington having been seriously damaged
by running onto Dike B during an extraordinarily high tide, fender-
piles were driven along the dike at small expense, to prevent the recur-
rence of such an accident.
    The expenditures for the last fiscal year amount to $4,875.09, as fol-
lows :
Dredging 16,815 cubic yards..............                           ...... ......
                                                                              -   ...             ....        ..-. .      .. $4, 106. 94
Inspection of above ... -..................    ............... .... .        ........                                               484. 44
Examination after dredging........... .. . ............---......      ...........                                             .      20. 63
Placing fender-piles along face of Dike B.... ............................                                                           32.50
Draughting (old records and new ones)..............---                                 ........         ............                101.40
Administration ........-  ............   ...............                             .     ....... ........          ...            129. 18
        Total...-..............----...........--------------   ......-- ...................                              ..       4,875.09
   The commerce of the stream is steadily increasing.        The largest
brick-yards in the world are situated on its banks, and the number of
brick made during the past year is greater than ever before. The ma-
jority of the vessels engaged in this trade can only reach their destina-
tion by waiting for the tide. A larger steam-boat making daily trips
to New York has been put on this year.
660           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S                                                                ARMY.

   The sum of $30,000 can be expended profitably as regards the effi-
cient prosecution of the work during the fiscal year ending June 30,
1890. It would be applied to giving the channel the full dimensions
required by the project below Washington, and in extending the im-
provement to the brick-yards above; this would add greatly to the
shipping facilities of the stream and would stimulate its increasing
con merce.
The estimated amount required for the completion of the improve-
ment is $133,695.
This work is in the collection district of A boy. The nearest port of entry, Perth
Amboy, N. J.; nearest light-house, Great Beds Light, in Raritan Bay, N. J.; nearest
for, at Sandy Hook, N. J.
  Amount of revenue collected at the port of Perth Amboy during the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1888, $57,727.64.
Original    estimate ............       ....  .......               ..................                 ....-....-      $194, 695. 00
Amount      appropriated ..........--             ...............................                                         61, 000. 00
Amount      received from sales of coal (A. R. C. E. 1883) ....--                      _..............                         30. 06
Amount      expended. . ........-......      ......................                      ............                     60, 738. 40

                                                     Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available ......-   ----......--...........          ............---......                          $5, 111. 75
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 .............      ..........         ............                   . ........                  4, 820. 09

July 1, 1888, balance available ....---..-- ...............................                                                   291.66
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ............-..........                                                       5,000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ......                                       ............             5, 291. 66


   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                            30, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


Abstract of bids .for dredging in South River, New Jersey, opened at the U. S. Engineer
  Office, Army Building, New York City, Y. Y., at 12 o'clock, m., on September 7, 1887,
under circular letter dated August 12, 1887.


                                                                                                                         Price per
No.          Name and residence of bidder.                               Name and residence of sureties.                 cubic yard
                                                                                                                          measured
                                                                                                                          in scows.


                                                                                                                             Gents.
 *1   M. K. Pidgeon, 60 Soauth street, New York                    John P. Hawkins, C. C. Ellis, New York                             40
        City.                                                        City.
  2   James McSpirit, 330 Third street, Jersey                     Thomas Potter, Joseph M. Potter, Jer-                              35
        City, N. J.                                                  sey City, N. J.
  3   Hartford Dredging Company, Hartford,                         Charles J. Hills, Edward G. Lasbury,                               30
        Conn.                                                        Hartford, Conn.

                           * Will commence within ten days from notification of award.

Abstract of bids for dredging in South River, New Jersey, opened at the U. S. Engineer
  Office, Army Building, New York City, N. Y., at 12 o'clock, mn., on September 22, 1887,
undercirculardated September 12, 1887.


  1   P. Sanford Ross, 113 Hudson street, Jersey                   Freeman A. Smith, Theodore Smith,                               291
        City, N. J.                                                  Jersey City, N. J.
  2   M. K. Pidgeon, 60 South street, New York                     John P. Hawkins, A. J. Atwater, New                             32
        City, N. Y.                                                  York City.
  3   W. H. Beard, 302 Hamilton avenue, Brook-                     C. N. Kingsland, M. D. Lawrence,                                35
        lyn, N. Y.                                                   Brooklyn, N. Y.
  4   James McSpirit, 330 Third street, Jersey                     Joseph MI. Potter, Rahway, N. J.;                               34
        City, N. J.                                                  Thomas Potter, Jersey City, N. J.
  5   Hartford Dredging Company, Hartford,                         Charles J. Hills, Edward G. Lasbury,                            29
        Conn.                                                        Hartford, Conn.
  6    Richard M. Payn, 63 Quay street, Albany,                    Edear M. Payn, Dominick Fitzpatrick,                            29)
        N. Y.                                                       Albany, N. Y.
             APPENDIX          F---REPORT               OF    CAPTAIN         MCC.     DERBY.            661

                                         COMMERCIAL          STATISTICS.


  The following statistics relative to the commerce of South River, New Jersey, dur-
ing the calendar year 1887, were compiled in this office by Mr. C. S. Kelsey, surveyor.
The population of East Brunswick in 1855 was .                      .........       ..........          3,697
Assessed valuation of real estate in 1A80, East Brunswick township ....... $789, 170
Assessed valuation of personal property in 1880, East Brunswick town-
  ship----                   ...---
       ....-----................                    ..---..--..-----------..--....
                                  ...----...------....---...----.......----  41, 400
Total (estimated) value of farm products --......                    ......                     14,000
                                                                                 --......--..........


                                          Articles.    .                                    Tons.     Value.


                                          Exports.

Common brick...--......---....................................-----..-----.--.--............        181, 00 $418, 000
Clay and sand .----.. ..-----------------....--------------.............                              6, 354  16, 801
Cord wood, posts, poles, piles, etc .......                 --..
                                                              ........   .............................5, 500  23, 700
Manufactures.--.   .....-------------...............---.....---------......--...--.-......----..----..1, 0)0 100, 000
Farm products and general merchandise...............................-- ......... 1, 000                       50, 000
      Total ....................   ..........                              ......... ....   193, 35..4 608, 501
                                         Imports.
Coal .....--......---     ...-- .....---- ... ...... ..................................       14, 515  66, 652
Building material ..............................................................                  460  10, 500
W ood ..... ....................................................................                  350   1. 125
Fertilizers.........---- ....--...----..-...  ..... .....--                              ..--
                                                                          ..--...........--   17, 000  35, 000
Manufactures and general merchandise-....-.          ... ...-.. ..------..................     1,500  151, 000

      Total.....................-------
                                 ..     --....---............................--
                                                                     .__ 33,825                        264, 277

      Total commerce......................                                            229, 179
                                                      ..................................               872, 778


  Two new brick-yards have been recently established with a capacity of 15,000,000
per year, valued at $75,000. The entire product of the brick-yards is exported by
water, and has steadily increased in amount since 1880, having more than doubled
since that date.




                                                       F 7.
          IMPROVEMANT OF CHEESFQUAKES CREEK, NEW JERSEY.

   In its original condition the stream was obstructed at its mouth by
a sand-bar, on which the best depth was 1 foot at mean low water; for
about a mile of its length the channel had a depth of 6 feet, but the re-
mainder had generally a depth of 3 teet and less. The range of the
tide is 5.1 feet. Five hundred and forty-six small vessels passed the
draw at the mouth of the creek in 1878.
   The project for the improvement was adopted in 1879, and provides
for obtaining by dredging and diking a channel 5 feet deep at mean
low water, and 200 feet wide at the mouth of the creek, and 4 feet deep
with a width of from 100 to 50 feet to the head of navigation at White-
head's Dock, 3 miles from the mouth. The amount expended under this
project to June 30, 1887, was $40,000: the least depth in the improved
channel at the mouth was 4.5 feet at mean low water; no work had been
done on the shoals above; and no increase in the commerce of the creek
had been observed.
   There have been no funds available during the year ending June 30,
1888, and no expenditures. The condition of the creek and its traffic
remains substantially unchanged. The works at the mouth of the creek
were examined )bythe engineer in charge, June 26. Thile beach has been
cut away to a considerable extent at the inS!lcr
                                              els o0 the                                     jetties, andt
662       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

for a distance of 50 feet on the west jetty and 100 feet on the east jetty;
the waves, breaking on the beach at high tide, flow over the inner ends
of the jetties, carrying large quantities of sand into the dredged channel
between them. Just above the bridge abutment, for a distance of 50
feet, the sheet-pile revetment, in prolongation of the sheet-pile dam
across the old channel, has given way and will shortly fall entirely.
  The maintenance of the works themselves and the channel between
the jetties requires that repairs should be made forthwith, both on the
revetment and on the jetties, raising their inner ends to the height of
the rest of the structure. These repairs would cost about $1,000.
  If it is the intention of Congress to complete this improvement, the
sum of $25,000 can be expended profitably as regards the efficient prose-
cution of the work during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, and it
would be expended in dredging; a slight increase in the commerce of
creek might be expected.
  The estimated amount required for the completion of the improve.
ment is $50,000.
  This work is in the collection district of Perth Amboy, N. J. Nearest light-house,
Great-Beds Light, in Raritan Bay; nearest fort, fort at Sandy Hook, N. J.
  Amount of revenue collected at the port of Perth Amboy, during the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1888, $57,727.64.
Original estimate (revised, 1885) ........................           ............ ...... $90, 000
Amount appropriated --...----. ---. ------------.          -..-..-----             --.    40,000
Amount expended...................................... ................                    40,000

                                     Money statement.
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ......     $50, 000. 00
  Amount that can beprofitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 25, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance   with  requirements of  sections 2 of river  and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                             F 8.

             IMPROVEMENT OF KEYPORT HARBOR, NEW JERSEY.

   Keyport Harbor was originally accessible at low water only to vessels
drawing less than 4 feet. Before its improvement was undertaken by
the United States a 6-foot channel had been dredged at private expense,
which had shoaled in 1872 to 51 feet, and in 1882 to 5 feet, the range of
the tide being 4.7 feet. A large commerce was carried on, however,
valued at $ -,932,000.
   The project for the improvement was adopted in 1873, and provided
for dredging a channel 4,700 feet long, 8 feet deep at mean low-water,
and 200 feet wide from the steam-boat dock to the 8-foot contour in Rar-
itan Bay, at an estimated cost of $30,475.
   The amount expended under this project to June 30, 1887, was $30,-
020.51, with which a channel had been dredged from the 8 foot depth in
Raritan Bay to Keyport Wharf, a distance of 5,000 feet, with a width of
200 feet for the first 4,200 feet and 160 feet for the remainder.
   The commerce of the harbor had increased greatly, being estimated
at $5,000,000, besides 150,000 passengers carried annually.
   There has been no appropriation for this work since 1882, and the
expenditures for the last fiscal year have amounted to $22.38 for office
expenses.
  The dredged channel is stated to have shoaled in places to about 6
             APPENDIX F--REPORT OF CAPTAIN McC. DERBY.                                                       663

feet mean low water, but it is reported that the commerce as yet shows
no falling off.
   If it is the intention of Congress to complete this improvement, the
balance of the estimate, $10,000, can be expended profitably as regards
the efficient prosecution of the work during the fiscal year ending June
30, .1890, and would be applied to dredging the channel to the dimensions
required by the project, which would add materially to existing facili-
ties.
   The estimated amount required for the completion of the improve-
ment is $10,000.
  This work is in the collection district of Perth Amboy, N. J., which is the nearest
port of entry. Nearest light-house, Great Beds Light, in Raritan Bay; nearest fort,
fort at Sandy Hook, N. J.
  Amount of revenue collected at the port of Perth Amboy, during the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1888, $57,727.64.
Original estimate (1873) ....................                .......         .............- ....       $30,475. 00
Revised estimate (1884)        .....---............    ....---....------...............         ....    40, 475. 00
Amount appropriated ......-----......----....--.... ..........---...............                       30,475. 00
Amount expended, including outstanding liabilities July 1, 1888.........                               30,047.89

                                          Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available .---.........-----..........---...--........--....--..                     $454.49
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
                                           -----......------......--.....
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887....----
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities................... ....
                                                                  - --..
                                                              5. 00
                                                                                $22. 38

                                                                                                             27. 38

July 1, 1888, balance available ....................                   ...........        .........        427. 11

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.- .... -.                              10, 000. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 10, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                      F 9.
              IMPROVEMENT OF MATTAWAN CREEK, NEW JERSEY.

  Before its improvement by the Government this small stream was
obstructed at its entrance to Keyport Harbor by a mud fiat, on which
the best depth at the worst section was 3.1 feet at mean low water,
though the 3-foot channel was too narrow and tortuous for use. Above
this flat a good 4-foot channel existed to 1J miles above the mouth, and
thence to the steam-boat dock at Mattawan 3.5 feet, shoaling to 1.8 feet
at the freight dock, 600 feet above, and 1J miles from the mouth. The
range of the tide is 4.7 feet. Notwithstanding the above difficulties it
carried commerce valued in 1880 at $800,000.
   The project for the improvement was adopted in 1881, and provides
for dredging a channel 4 feet deep at mean low water, and 100 feet wide
from the mouth to Winkson Creek, and thence 75 feet wide to the rail-
road bridge at Mattawan, 250 feet above the freight dock, at an esti-
mated cost of $33,120.
   To June 30, 1887, the amount expended under this project was
$21,000, with which a channel had been dredged, giving the required
depth, from the mouth to the freight dock at Mattawan, with width
varying from 100 to 30 feet.
664             REPORT OF THE CHIEF                                   OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The estimated value of the commerce of the creek had increased to
over $2,000,000, in 1855, amounting to 130.000 tons.
  There has been no appropriation for this stream since 1882; there
were no funds available for the past fiscal year, and there have been no
expenditures. The condition of the stream has deteriorated since work
was suspended, and complaints are made of shoaling at the mouth. of
the river. There has been no increase in the amount of commerce re-
ported above, which is already very large in proportion to the facilities
offered by the stream.
   If it is the intention of Congress to (omplete this imp rovement, the
balance of the estimate, $12,120, can be expended profitably. as regards
the efficient prosecution of the work, during the fiscal year ending June
30, 1890, and would be applied to dredging the channel to the dimnen-
sions required by the project, which would add materially to existing
facilities.
   The estimated amount required for the completion of the improve-
ment is $12,120.
  This work is in the collection district of Perth Amboy, N. J., which is the nearest
port of entry. Nearest light-house Great Beds Light, in Raritan Bay. Nearest fort,
fort at Sandy Hook, N. J.
  Amount of revenue collected at the port of Perth Amboy during the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1888, $57,727.64.

Original estimate......---------...... -------....---......    --..-------......----............-------------......--...--...  $33, 120. 00
Amount appropriated----------------.....                                  -----......---......
                                                            ----......------..........                                           21, 000. 00
                                                                                                           -....------....----........
Amount expended--..-----..-------...------............--............       --......--------.....-----....-----..                 21 000. 00

                                                            Money statement.
 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....... $12, 120. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 12, 120. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
       harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




                                                       COMMERCIAL         STATISTIOS.


  The following statistics, relative to commerce of Mattawan Creek, N. J., during
the calendar year 1887, were compiled in this office by Mr. C. S. Keisey, surveyor,
mainly from statements furnished by Mr. J. H. Hornor, of Mattawan :

                                                             Articles.                                                             Value.


                                                             Exports.

Common brick .----....---------........-.....-----......---------.- -. ----------------.----.-------...............                 $96, 000
Farm produce and garden truck (estimated from Census Report) ..-.......... ..-...........                                           100, 004

        Total---..-----...-....--------------------------                                ---------------------------                196, 000

                                                             Imports.

Lumber and building material .------.....-------............--------.........----................----------------------..-.-   .     28, 500
Flour, feed, and grain..--..-----------------------------------                                        ------.------------           26, 000
Fertilizers ...----...--..-----                   -----------------------------------------------------...                           55, 000
Coal.......--------...................------- -----------------------------------------                                              1-----------
                                                                                                                                     10,000
Hardware--.......-----...--..---------------..---------------------.......--..-------------------....................                15,500
Groceries and general merchandise.....--                          -----........ ..--....................... ..... --....             46, Ou0
        Total..................................................----................................                                 181, 000
        Total commerce....---.--------------------------------------..--..-..                                   --...----            77,000
         APPENDIX     F-REPORT       OF        CAPTAIN   McC.   DERBY.   665

                                     F   Io.

         IMPROVEMENT OF SHREWSBURY RIVER, NEW JERSEY.

   The project for this improvement was adopted in 1879, and contem-
plates the formation of a channel 6 feet deep at mean low water, and from
300 to 150 feet in width, frion the mouth of the river to Red Bank, on
the North Branch, 8 miles, and to Branchport, on the South Branch, 9
miles.
   111 its original condition the river was much obstructed by sand-bars
on which the best depths at mean low water were, at the mouth, 3.9
feet; below Highland's Bridge, 5.4 feet; at Lower Rocky Point, 3.6 feet;
at Barley Point, 3.3 feet; at Chalmers, 5 feet; at Oceanic, 5.5 feet; be.
                 L
low Bellevue, 3. feet; at Seabright Bridge, 4.2 feet; at Jumping Point,
2.6 leet; at Sedge Island, 2.8 feet. A survey completed in April, 1887,
shows the depths at these points to be 5.9 feet, 5.9 feet, 7.7 feet, 3.6 feet,
7.8 feet, 7.2 feet, 4.5 feet, 7.2 feet, 5.9 feet, 4.4 feet, respectively. No
changes are known to have taken place since.
   The estimated cost of the existing project is $254,562, of which
$200,128.58 had been expended June 30, 1888.
   A project recommending the construction of stone dikes C3, C4, and M
was approved by the Chief of Engineers July 13, 1887, and sealed pro-
posals were invited by circular letter, and opened August 10, 1887 (ab-
stract of bids herewith). A map showing the proposed work will be
found in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1887, page 780.
A contract was made August 20, with F.. P. Ea tman, the lowest bid-
der, to construct the dikes at 98 cents per cubic yard of stone; measured
on scows and delivered in the dikes; the work was to be completed by
November 1, 1887. The facilities of the contractor for doing the work
proved to be inadequate; the contract was extended to December 1,
and again to May 15, 1888, when the contractor reported his inability
to complete the work, having delivered 1,813 cubic yards of stone which
had been placed in dikes C3 and C4.
    This delay caused considerable loss to the United States, increasing
the cost of inspection while work was in progress, and causing the
loss of the bunches of piles driven to mark the line of the dikes, nearly
all of which were carried away by the ice during the winter.
    On May 17 the work was again advertised, and sealed proposals were
opened May 26 (abstract herewith). The lowest bidder was A. J. Howell,
with whom a contract was make June 7, to deliver 2,000 cubic yards of
stone at $1.45 per cubic yard. The contractor began the delivery of
the stone June 2, and has carried on the work steadily until the close
of the fiscal year, when all the stone, 2,011 cubic yards, had been re-
ceived on the work, and all had been placed in the (likes with the ex-
ception of one load of 333 cubic yards.
   Dike C4, 1,260 feet long, has been built to the height of extreme low
water, and 4 feet wide on top, except for a distance of 30 feet at its junc-
tion with C, where it was only raised to 2 feet below mean low water
to permit the passage of row-boats. Dike C has been built to the
height of 1 foot above mean low water, and from 4 to 6 feet wide on top.
This completes the dike for the present, though it willIrequire more
stone later, when the current in the river has scoured along its face
and caused the stone to settle.
   It may also be necessary to protect the top of the dike and its outer
face above low water with large blocks of stone, if it is found that ice
666               REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

injures the present structure.                                                   This dike is 1,304 feet long, and has cost
$2,685.02, as follows:
1,104 cubic yards of stone, at 98 cents.-----------.......--------------------........................                                                       $1, 081.92
891 cubic yards of stone, at $1.45----..---.........--..--..---..-..........--....                                                                            1,291.95
Piles marking line of dike ........---                                           ----.---                ------...--------- ------                               145.82
Inspection           ...---.....................                 ---------.---                       -....---            ---........          ------...          165. 33

             Total .....                 ..----....            ......
                                                            .....                    .......... ....-                    ......--
                                                                                                                          --....           --.......---.      2,685.02
   This makes the cost of the dike $2.06 per linear foot, or $1.93, deduct-
ing the cost of inspection for comparison with the pile-dikes C1 and C2 ,
which cost $4.75 per linear foot. It is believed that the cost of main
tenance will in the long run also be much less for the stone-dikes than
for the pile-dikes. Nearly all of the latter on the river are now in need
of repair; the crib at the end of C1 has been injured by the ice, and
dikes B and C2 require refilling with stone, the current having scoured
away the bottom outside of them, allowing the sand under the stone to
run out, so that the latter has settled several feet.
   A complete series of tidal observations was made during the year, 8
stations being occupied with self-registering gauges. "1he records are
nearly all reduced, and most of the stations have been connected with
lines of levels.
   The expenditures during the fiscal year amount to $3,195.08, as
follows:
Driving guide-piles....................................................................                                                                         $401. 00
Constructing stone-dikes (contract of August 20, 1887)...... .............                                                                                     1, 625. 52
Inspection of above...... ...--...... ......                                                ......              ......        ...
                                                                                                                             .......---       ........           223. 67
Draughting (old records and new work)---...---...........---......... ....                                                                                       103. 75
Tidal observations......................................................                                                                                         451. 64
Administration .........                              .................                       .................                        .   .............         389. 50

             Total.............................................................                                                                               3,195. 08
   Whatever appropriation may be made by the next Congress will be
expended in completing the dikes and dredging the shoals. The most
economical results in the prosecution of the work can be obtained if the
full amount required to complete the project be appropriated at once.
   The Shrewsbury River is susceptible of being made a valuable navi-
gable river at moderate expense. Its commerce is very considerable,
its shores are thickly settled throughout its length, the country is very
rich, and during the season of navigation the population served is very
large. Six steam-boats make regular daily trips-to and from New York,
carrying large quantities of freight of all descriptions, and doing a large
passenger traffic. Every improvement made by the Government has
been promptly put to use, and on two occasions, when no appropriations
were made for the river by the General Government, improvements have
been made in the stream by private citizens at considerable expense.
   In addition to the steamers mentioned a large number of small sail-
ing vessels are engaged in the shipment of coal, lumber, sand, fish, and
oysters. The tender of the draw-bridge at Highlands states that he is
obliged to open the draw for the passage of vessels upwards of one
hundred and twenty-five times daily, during the season.
  This river is in the collection district of Perth Amboy, which is the nearest port of
entry; nearest light-house, Navesink Light, and the nearest fort is the fort at Sandy
Hook.
  Amount of revenue collected during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $57,727.64.
Original estimate (revised 1887) ............                                                           ......................                             $254, 562. 00
Amount appropriated......-....-......-............................                                                                                    ..    204,500. 00
Amount expended (including outstanding liabilities and amount covered
by existing contracts, July 1, 188) -----.---... -.................. 203, 145. 88
              APPENDIX F--REPORT OF CAPTAIN MCC. DERBY.                                                      667
                                              Money statement.
July 1, 1887 amount available---..--....................................------..    $7, 456. 50
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
  liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887......... ... .--......--      . $3, 085.08
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities ..........................            101, 35
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts ............          2, 915.95
                                                                                                         6,102. 38

July 1, 1888, balance available ...............................                        ..............    1,354. 12
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ...............                            ..........     10, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889............... ....                               11, 354. 12

  Amount that can beprofitably expended in fiscal yearending June 30,1890                               40, 062.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


Abstract of proposals for constructing stone-dikes in the Shrewsbury River, N. J., opened
at the U. S. Engineer Office, Army Building, .New York City, N. Y., at 12 o'clock m. on
August 10, 1887, under circular-letterof July 26, 1887.

                                                                                                         Price per
                                                                                                        cubic yard
No.                                   Name and address of bidder.                                         of stone
                                                                                                         delivered
                                                                                                         in place.

  1 F. P. Eastman, foot of East 39th street, New York City ..............................                     $0.98
  2   John A. Bouker, 110 Wall street. New York City ...................................                       1.35


  A contract was made August 20, 1887, with F. P. Eastman, the lowest bidder, for
furnishing 5,000 cubic yards, more or less, of stone, and constructing about 3,700 feet
of stone-dike.

Abstract of proposalsfor constructing stone-dikes in theShrewsbury River, N. J., opened at
the U. S. Engineer Office, Army Building, New York City, N. Y., at 12 a'clock noon, on
May 26, 1888, under circular of May 17, 1188.

                                                                                                         Price per
                                                                                                        cubic yard
No.                                   Name and address of bidder.                                         of stone
                                                                                                         delivered
                                                                                                         in place.
  1   John A. Bonker, 110 Wall street, New York City ....-.............................                       $1.50
  2   Alex. J. Howell, 336 West Nineteenth street, New York City ..--... ..................                    1. 45


  A contract was made June 7, 1888, with Alex. J. Howell, the lowest bidder, for
furnishing 2,000 cubic yards, more or less, of stone, and constructing about 2,500 feet
of stone-dike.



                                                       F ii.
              IMPROVEMENT OF MANASQUAN RIVER, NEW JERSEY.

  In its original condition this stream had a depth of from 6 to 4 feet
at mean low water for several miles above its mouth, and was obstructed
at its outlet into the ocean by a sand-spit, which had deflected the
stream into a channel parallel with the beach, communicating with the
ocean across shifting sand-bars, on which the best depth did not ex-
ceed 1 feet at mean low water; mean range of tide 2.4 feet. In severe
668         REPORT OF            TIIE     CHIEF       OF      ENGINEERS,           U. S. ARMY.

storms this channel was sometimes entirely closed by the sand, remain-
ing so until the fresh water in the river had accumulated sufficientiy to
force a new outlet. Under these conditions the river could not be used
by commerce.
   The project for its improvement was adopted in 1879, and contem-
plated dredging the lower river, and obtaining by means of jetties a
permanent outlet nearly at right angles to the beach, with a depth of 6
feet at mean low water, at an estimated cost of $52,120.
   The amount expended under this project to June 30, 1887, was $39,000,
with which two jetties had been constructed, but neither to its full
length, appropriations having ceased in 1882. No permanent improve-
ment had been effected.
   There were no expenditures on account of this work during the year
ending June 30, 1888, there being no funds available.
   Manasquan Inlet was examined in August, 1887. High-water mark
north of the inlet had not changed in position, remaining a few feet in-
side of the outer end of the jetty, but south of the inlet the beach had
made out several hundred feet, and a sand-spit, similar to the one that
existed in 1879, masked the channel between the jetties, much as that
of 1879 then masked the gorge of the natural inlet. A heavy storm had
lately occurred, like those which formerly closed the inlet periodicall!;
at long intervals, producing the same result as formerly. When the
waters of the river broke through the beach again they scoured a chan-
nel behind the south jetty, leaving it without connection with the shore;
a result which had been imminent for some years. The inner end of
this jetty was in the deepest water of the inlet, and it had begun to go
to pieces. If it were intended to carry out the original project, or any
other project for improving the mouth of the Manasquan, it would be
advisable to spend at once about $',000 to put this dilke in such condi-
tion as to prevent its entire destruction ; but as there is no commerce
on the river now, and no population or interests sufficient to support a
trade at all commensurate with the cost of making the river available,
it does not seem likely that it is the intention of Congress to complete
this work, particularly as no appropriation has been made for it in sev-
eral years. As the south jetty serves no useful purpose in its present
condition, there would seem to be no reason for going to any expense to
delay its destruction.
   If it is the intention of Congress to complete this improvement, the
balance of the estimate, $33,0('0, could be expended profitably, as re-
gards the efficient prosecution of the work, during the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1890.
   The estimated amount required for the completion of the improve-
ment is $33,000.
  This work is in the collection district of Perth Amboy, N. J., which is the nearest
port of entry. Nearest light-house, Great Beds Light in Raritan Bay.                         Nearest fort,
fort at Sandy Hook, t. J.
  Amount of revenue collected at the port of Perth Amboy during the fiscal year end-
ing June :0, 1888, $57,727.64.
Original estimate (1879) ------------
                         ......                                                 $,
                                         --------......---......----.....------......120. 00
                                                              ------......-----............
Revised estimate (182) .---......---  ....---
                                      --   ------ ----     .......-.             7, 000. 00
Amount appropriated ------------------- --- ------                                 --------..-...-
                                                                                                 39, 000.00
Amount expended........----------......----....--   ----------------....--....--               39, 000. 00
                                                                                   ---....--......----..--..


{Amount                                    Money statement.
              (estimated) required for completion of existing proect .---.--
  Amountthat can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                               $33, 000. 00
                                                                                                 33, 000. 00
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
                               APPENDIX G.



IMPROVEMENT OF DELAWARE AND SCHUYLKILL RIVERS, AND OF
  RIVERS IN NEW JERSEY-HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS IN DELAWARE
  RIVER AND BAY-CONSTRUCTION OF PIER AT LEWES-DELAWARE
  BREAKWATER.



REPORT OF LIEUTENANT-COLONEL HENRY M. ROBERT, CORPS OF
ENGINEERS, OFFICER IN CHARGE, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING
JUNE 30, 1888, WITH OTHER DOCUMENTS RELATING TO THE WORKS.

                                 IMPROVEMENTS.

1. Delaware River, Pennsylvania and         10. Mantua Creek, New Jersey.
     Jersey.                                11. Raccoon River, New Jersey.
2. Frankford Creek, Pennsylvania.           12. Salem River, New Jersey.
3. Schuylkill River, Pennsylvania.          13. Cohansey Creek, New Jersey.
4. Ice-harbor at Marcus Hook, Pennsyl-      14. Removal of wrecks from Delaware
     vania.                                       Bay and River.
5. Ice-harbor at the head of Delaware       15. Removing sunken vessels or craft ob-
     Bay, Delaware.                               structing or endangering naviga-
6. Construction of iron pier, in Delaware         tion.
     Bay, near Lewes, Delaware.             16. Survey of harbor at Atlantic City,
7. Harbor at Delaware Breakwater, Dela-           New Jersey.
      ware.                                 17. United States Commission advisory to
8. Rancocas River, New Jersey.                    the Board of Harbor Commissioners
9. Woodbury Creek, New Jersey.                    of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
                        EXAMINATIONS        AND SURVEY.
18. Thoroughfare from Cape May to the Great Bay north of Atlantic City, New Jersey.



                        UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                   Philadelphia,Pa., July 6, 1888.
  SIR: I have the honor to transmit herewith annual reports for the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, of the river and harbor works under
my charge.
      Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                           HENRY M. ROBERT,
                                            Lieut. Col. of Engineers.
The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. A.



                                        G i.
IMPROVEMENT OF DELAWARE RIVER, PENNSYLVANIA AND NEW JERSEY.
  The river and harbor act approved August 5, 1886, contained an ap-
propriation of $210,000 for improving Delaware River, Pennsylvania
and New Jersey, of which $30,000 was to be applied to improving the
channel between Camden, N. J., and Philadelphia, Pa., and $7,500, or
                                                                           669
670        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. AAMY.

so much thereof as may be needed, was to be expended on said river
and its tidal tributaries above Bridesburgh.
  The expenditure of this appropriation and that of July 5, 1884, has
been in accordance with approved projects based upon the recommen-
dations of the Board of Engineers of 1884 for " the permanent improve-
ment of Delaware River and Bay."
  During the past fiscal year the following operations have been in
progress:
   (1) Examinations at points between the upper end of Petty's Island
and Delaware Bay, to determine the duration, direction, and velocity of
the flood and ebb tides, and the running of a line of levels between Tren-
ton, N. J., and Cape Henlope, Delaware.
   (2) Examinations at Five Mile Bar.
   (3) Construction of a brush and stone dike near Mifflin Bar, between
Hog and Maiden islands.
   (4) Construction of a brush and stone dike below Reedy Island.
   (5) Improvement of channel across Smith's Island Bar, between Cam-
den and Philadelphia.

      1.   TIDAL OBSERVATIONS   AND LEVELS BELOW BRIDESBURGH.

   The Board of Engineers of 1884 recommended that examinations be
made at special points requiring improvement between Philadelphia
and the bay to determine by means of borings and probings the charac-
ter of the bottom of the river both in the channels to be improved and
over the sites of proposed dikes; also that tidal observations be made
to determine the duration, direction, and velocity of tidal currents; and
that a line of levels be run between Cape Henlopen and Trenton.
   A large part of this work had been accomplished at the close of the
previous fiscal year. During the past fiscal year the field work of the
tidal observations was completed, and the necessary work done to con-
nect the lines of levels previously run. The study and discussion of the
results obtained from the tidal observations and the levels are still in
progress.
                   2.   EXAMINATIONS   AT FIVE MILE   BAR.

   A dike had been built for a distance of 3,000 feet, and to the height
of mean low water, from Fisher's Point towards Petty's Island at the
close of the fiscal year of 1886. The object of this dike was the im-
provement of the channel across Five MIile Bar, which obstructs the
main channel just above Petty's Island. During the two past fiscal
years, since operations ceased upon the dike, frequent examinations
and local surveys have been made of Five Mile Bar to determine the
extent of the dike's action toward the improvement of the bar. From
these comparative examinations the following conclusions are reached:
(1) The effect of the dikb has been to lower the crest of the bar about
4 feet throughout a distance of about 2,000 feet. (2) The - maximum
effect of the dike was reached in 1886, shortly after its completion to
its present extension. (3) The forces operating on the bar tending to
reduce its height along the crest reached a condition of equilibrium at
least a year ago, since which time no appreciable change of depth has
taken place on the bar crest.
   The best channel across the bar now carries, as it did last year, 6)
to 7 feet at mean low water. The distance from the head of the dike
to the upper end of Petty's Island is 6,500 feet, of which distance 3,000
feet are covered by the dike, whose crest was originally at the level of
6   270 ~S6       25'      .        7                           . .         0"0   20"0204              ..       16"         50            42         1-0        '-     ..        9 _ 09 -.-.                            '25 27 /".                         70 7      7        6   .--               10.4          .                 ./.           ..


          224._-'              " ' . .i:4                 " 7   i.11 .6.0 .          40            '26'"627...                       ........                               026-         270            0
                                                                                                                                                                                                  27-6"26.2                  . 20740-'                                     - -y
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         15.9.."'0.0,. 15                                  /."             • s3          .
                        . . .       •.                                            .. .        -          0                .0.                  .-.          .                    0.0                                    -,          .            .    . • 99. . -.                             .                      9"     .. .         -,




                                                                                                                                                                                                           152     G            -           0-        0*     -




                                                                                                                           14-5                      1'1             16.0                  y0108                         o10            9   8g.       I8                                                                         8!!

                                            _ % ..-                   .           2,2     .                                                                     . 8 29.
                                                                                                                                                                    ...               14 212 5
                                                                                                                                                                                   .<.20                   "5'--60. .. 1'0510.2                                   9.5

                                                                                                                                 .,,_ " - " -•                              ..     ._           O..   0 bi-51           - 7 .       .        11.7           11 8106


                        280< 9          -    2        9
                                                                                                                          2 2.1o 04                                              9      15 17         01040                         0       2018           SS310
    Q :.-- .s-                 2.        . /~' 7.o .'.:...,..s.: -"+                                                            --                                      ,          .a      -          -e      .o        -                    -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    .52 .15 17                     ,                       :,'
                                                          °:'-"' :'  9                             -        '    '--...               -         - ,6                   50        1.4      17          0    15           17      i                                12
                                                                                              KE TCH                       OF THE/.
    _'        8            .87                                                                                                                                                           2 1-     7           s    7;           -       s 2          2 s    20 1-         5       12 .1            16    /

                                                                  N THE VICINITY OF FIVE MILE BAR.
                                               From               surveys mnade under tlie direction of
                                                                          ILiut           .Col.        Hen                ryl.                  ob er t                                                                                                            T"o        a.com pay ,nacz.e.ar/.o,                                                 88s.




    Eng50 2
                                                                Eng5 2
                                                                 Sale~
                                                                  Scale
                                                                           Corps ofSEn
                                                                                                   f38
                                                                                                  loo
                                                                                                  1ooo
                                                                                                                 - 8zoo     eel
                                                                                                                    SI ~os~eQ,
                                                                                                                                ooo
                                                                                                                                                     rs U. S-.A.,
                                                                                                                                                           soooFeet          .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            CO~ ofngr', UXu,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         L~i~ZI~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        iet.            Co.  o
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           .a-- zo.?
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  9 r's,       US.A.
           APPENDIX       G----REPORT     OF LIEUT.      COL.   ROBERT.          671
low water, but is now about 2 feet lower. From the action already ob-
tained it seems highly probable that to simply extend the work as a
low-water dike would result in increasing the length of depression of
the bar crest without materially increasing the depth over the bar be-
yond about 6 feet at mean low water. The general direction of the bar
is nearly parallel with the dike; therefore the action of the latter is dif-
fused over nearly the whole length of the bar, instead of being concen-
trated upon a particular point.
    The results already obtained do not warrant the conclusion that a
sufficiently deep channel can be obtained by the dike if left at its pres-
ent height, even though it be considerably extended, which will con-
nect the deep water at Fisher's Point with the deep-water channel on
the lower side of the bar. The deep water on the upper side of the bar
is evidently the result of ebb tide action, while the deep water on the
lower side of the bar is due to flood tide action. The axes of these
channels are nearly parallel but about 1,400 feet apart, and between
them lies the bar. It can not be expected that a limited extension of
the dike will materially modify the character and tendency of its pres-
ent action.
    The diverting tendency which the dike has already exerted upon the
flood tide suggests the possibility of valuable results to be obtained
close to the Pennsylvania shore by a still greater diversion of the flood
tide into the Pennsylvania channel past Petty's Island, and consequent-
ly across the bar. This would be obtained by the ultimate extension
 (f the dike, both as to length and height. The passage of the result-
ing increased tidal volume through the Pennsylvania channel past Pet-
ty's Island would be greatly facilitated and its efficiency greatly in-
creased by widening the river opposite the lower half of the island, as
already recommended in the report of the Board of Engineers of 1888,
upon the removal of the island and shoals between Philadelphia and
Camden.
   During the season of 1887, Prof. Lewis M. Haupt made a trial on
Five Mile Bar ot the value of his system of current deflectors to pro-
duce a deepened channel across the bar. The experiment was under-
taken with the distinct understanding that the department had no
power to grant or withhold the privilege which he had asked for as long
as the river channels were not injured, and the Government was
involved in no expense in connection with the experiment; that the ex-
periment was to be made entirely at the risk and responsibility of the
inventor.
   The current reflectors consisted of a series of swinging wooden pan-
els, hinged at their tops between pairs of piles placed about 20 feet
apart; the tops of the panels were placed slightly above the plane of
mean low water and their lower edges when hanging vertically quite
near the surface of the bar. The panels were arranged on two lines
with lengths respectively of 100 and 140 feet, with a clear opening be-
tween the two lines of 135 feet. In the words of Professor Haupt:
  The method embodies the principle of the utilization of the surface currents, either
by a vertical deflection or by reaction, in combination with a lateral compression
and concentration of a portion of the ebb and dispersion of the flood, thus producing
a greater difference in the amount of the flood and ebb movements of the particles
than exists in a natural or unimproved condition.
   The deflectors were placed on the bar near its midlength and in water
from 6 to 9 feet deep at mean low water. They remained in place from
July to November, 1887, and just before their removal a detailed sur-
vey was made of the bar and a special survey of the locality occupied
672      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

by the deflectors. This survey showed that their action had been con-
fined to the formation of a trench from 4 to 10 feet deep along the line
of the deflectors, and the deposition of the excavated material in a ridge
parallel with and just below the lines of the trenches. The formation
of the trenches and their parallel ridges was caused by the increased
scour of the tidal currents in passing under the lower edges of the panels.
The deflectors did not seem to have the effect of training the currents
upon the bar between the ends of the deflectors with any valuable re-
sults, and'no perceptible deepening of the bar occurred over the area
which it was proposed to improve by the use of the deflectors.
   In connection with the improvement of this part of the river atten-
tion should be drawn to the value of the improvement of the main ship
channel west of Petty's Island, which has been in progress under late
alppropriations, as fully attested by the commercial development which
has followed close upon the work already done. The increasing devel-
opment of Port Richmond and the terminal railroad facilities thereat
strongly urge the importance of a further extension of the deep water
channel beyond its present upper limits.

   3.   DIKE BETWEEN HOG AND MAIDEN          ISLANDS (MIFFLIN BAR).

   The work in progress at this locality is the construction of a random
stone dike about 7,200 feet in length, extending between Hog and
Maiden islands. The object of this dike is the improvement of the chan-
nel over Mifflin Bar.
   During the past fiscal year 23,107.42 cubic yards of stone have been
placed in the dike under two contracts with Joseph H. Ward. The
first contract, dated October 5, 1886, was completed September 30, 1887,
by the aggregate delivery of 40,016.42 cubic yards of stone. The sec-
ond contract, dated May 3, 1888, for the delivery of 12,000 cubic yards
of stone, is now in progress, and has resulted in the delivery, up to the
close of the fiscal year, of 6,869 cubic yards of stone.
   In its present condition the dike is 7,200 feet in length, of which 5,300
feet has been brought to the surface of mean low water and 1,900 feet
to a height 4 feet below that plane. With the completion of the work
to be done under the existing contract the top of the dike will have
been brought to tohe plane of low water, except for a length of 400 feet,
where an opening carrying 12 feet at mean low water has been left
across the dike into the basin behind it. This basin is used as a dump-
ing ground for material dredged from the river in the vicinity of Phila-
delphia.
   Frequent examinations have been made of Mifflin Bar and the river
in the vicinity, to determine the action of the dike as already built.
During the past fiscal year the dike has been raised for about 5,300
feet, or three-fourths of its length, from 4 feet below to the plane of
mean low water. A comparison of the present depths of water over
the bar with those of a year ago does not show any material change.
The traces of the channel dredged in 1885 have not been obliterated.
the distance between the 24-foot curves above and below the bar is
about 1,500 feet, while the least depth between these limits and within
a channel 250 feet wide is from 221 to 23 feet at mean low water. No
marked changes have taken place in the vicinity of the dike at points
where undue scour had been apprehended. To produce the desired
effect upon the bar, which is to maintain a 26-foot channel 600 feet wide,
it seems probable that the dike will ultimately have to be raised to the
plane of high water.
                                                                                                                                                                                 E                  o accomrp a n                     r     ialReporfor                  /888.

                                                                  DELAWARE RIVER
                                                                                                                      OF THE
                                                                                                                                       AT          MIFFLIN BAR                                                  'il      L        i'w-e .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          2.odnr
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   C       ol / p &'r-'. " .S.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     A
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    A.
                                                                       From Surveys made                                                   runder the direction

                                                                                     Liert.Col. Henry M.Robert
                                                                                          Corps of Enrgineers,T.S.A.
                                                                                                       6s7o.                                                                              SCALE   0                              00   o    1500     2000         2500           300




                                     so           6        4.3             1536075                        0s a1       20                                                     7       483
                                                                                                                                                                                       a-6=                                      05               35 0                    2za         3-2o


                                                      _-                                      .,__                                                 .           ..       .        "   ..-.                                        ......,,-

                                                           S     138 143 o0               17-3        6                   s8I.             193 03              03 194                23    2        1. .3           1    5       2.1.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          '.-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           Ba -240       a0          2.     20       19 0     185
                                                                                                                                                                                                      Mifflin
                       0.            201 69     176    153        30   1s        3   0    1   40 13           131          140             I       62               .    .       .8  20.005       21330                 23            200      204       20504                 2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            21-0
  _.     _6.               .                o0 3 so         ~oo .
                                                                       2
                                                                           - .       3. .         4         a0        0     10-0 '034 4                                 1 0.          6    1 80 3
                                                                                                                                                                                                        2
                                                                                                                                                                                                            2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                3
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                             6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 4462.       21-          02.5223                o    8      00   soi    s
                   ,....                                                   ....                       -
  400 39'0 387       5 3937               147                  5.-..40350.                                                                                 '            s        0   t8 40595      35       044                        .7.    302305
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                -38 0            6                   15

  47-    0   435     423 46      4                3 . -6         400       35        38   3   0   1        3.0        3.6                      2O          4            2 "629            214 220      02       6 19             4                  0                0      0 40 1 9



               ,           6_.                                                                    00.2                                         .... ...


                                                                                                      1.          3                    .           \                                                                                                     -o o-..

.Eng50         263               3              .6     0 -         .                  -                      L--                 ---           -       .                                                                              5 ,    70 9-0                  5a-.




Eng5O 2
         APPENDIX        G-REPORT    OF   LIEUT.   COL.   ROBERT.      67 3
  The cost of the dike, as estimated by the Board of Engineers of 1884,
was $150,000. The amount already expended in the construction of
the dike, together with the amount covered by the existing contract, is
about $112,000.
                    4.   DIKE BELOW REEDY ISLAND.

   The ultimate object of the work in progress at this locality is the im-
provement of the main ship-channel just below Reedy Island, where it
is obstructed by Dan Baker Shoal, which carries a depth of only 20
feet at mean low water. The improvement in this locality, as proposed
by the Board of Engineers of 1884, is to be accomplished by a dike
nearly 5 miles in length, extending from the lower end of Reedy Island
to a point on the right bank of the river below the mouth of Blackbird
Creek.
   During the past fiscal year 2,200 cubic yards of brush-mattress and
18,299 cubic yards of stone have been placed in the work, resulting in
the construction to the plane of mean low water of 2,000 linear feet of dike
extending southward from the lower end of Reedy Island, and the placing
of the brush-mattress foundation for an additional distance of 350 feet in
extension of the 2,000 feet named. This work has been accomplished
under two contracts, as follows : Under a contract, dated April 16, 1887,
with Milo W. Locke for the construction of the 2,000 linear feet of dike
extending south from Reedy Island, 14,980 cubic yards of stone and
2,013 cubic yards of brush-mattress foundation were placed in the work,
completing the contract on April 30, 1888. Under a contract, dated
May 3, 1888, with the Brandywine Granite Company for the construc-
tion of about 2,000 linear feet of dike, in extension of the work done
under the previous contract, 187 cubic yards of brush-mattress founda-
tion and 3,319 cubic yards of stone have been placed during the fiscal
year. The dike so far built, and that contemplated under the existing
contract, consists of a brush mattress foundation about 1 foot in thick-
ness, with a width equal to the width of the base of the dike, upon which
random stone are deposited until the top of the dike is brought to the
surface of mean low water.
   The preliminary borings which were made along the line of the pro-
posed dike indicated that the bottom of the river consists of quite soft
clay to a depth of over 60 feet. On account of the yielding qualities of
the foundation, an uncertainty existed as to the sustaining power of
this soft bottom under the weights which would be imposed upon it,
and an apprehension was felt that undue scour might occur along the
toe of the dike. To guard against undue settlement a continuous mat-
tress was made to cover the entire width of the base of the dike in sec-
tions 50 feet long; and to provide against scour and the consequent
undermining of the foundation, the main mattress was provided with
wings or curtains, hinged to it and projecting from 10 to 12 feet outside
of the toe of the dike on each side. These curtain mattresses were loaded
with only stone enough to cause them to sink with the main mattress
and to follow with their outer edge any depression which might be pro-
duced by scour. The action of both the main and curtain mattresses
was highly satisfactory in accomplishing the desired objects, and the
same method will be continued during the work of this season. The
limited extension of 2,000 linear feet of dike already made is too slight
to yet produce any valuable effect on the shoal which it is proposed to
ultimately improve through the agency of the dike.
   The dike above referred to commences at the lower end of Reedy
Island and extends therefrom southward. The island extends from the
      EGT 88-43
674    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

north end of the dike about 1- miles up the river on the line of the ex-
tension of the dike, and consequently the preservation of the island forms
an essential part of the plan for the improvement of Dan Baker Shoal.
An examination of the island made last fall indicated that a rapid and
dangerous erosion of its shore-lines was in progress near its lowver end,
or just above the upper end of the dike, which threatened a breach
across this part of the island. To avert such a contingency, and to hold
intact the remaining narrow strip of island at this point, an inexpensive
arrangement of brush was applied as a temporary shore protection at
the weakened point.
   To obtain the definite information necessary for a comparison between
the past and present condition of the island a survey was made in De.
cember, 1887, which carefully located the existing high and low water
shore-lines of the island. A comparison between this survey and those
of earlier date indicates that a serious erosion has occurred along both
the east and west shore-lines of the lower one-third of the island, re-
sulting in a loss in width of about 200 feet from the former and 125 feet
from the latter side of the island, and reducing the width of the fast
land from over 325 feet to that of 15 feet near the lower end of the
island.
   The urgent necessity for preventiing further erosion and giving as-
sured permanency to the shore-lines of the lower part of the island is
so apparent that a project will be submitted for the protection of this
part of the island as soon as another appropriation shall render funds
available therefor.

              5. CHANNEL ACROSS S MITH'S ISLAND BAR.

   The formation of this channele was undertaken during the previous
fiscal year, in compliance with the river and harbor act of August 5,1886,
which provided that, from the appropriation of $210,000 for improving
Delaware Iliver from Trenton. N,.J., to its mouth, $30,000 was to be
applied " to improving the channel between Camden, N. J., and Phila-
delphia, Pa. "
   The necessity for an, improved channel bet-ween Camden and Phila-
delphia, and the general plan suggested for obtaining such a channel,
is stated in the Replort of the Chief of Engineers for 1886, pages 800 and
826. The details of the plan as carried into effect are fully stated in the
Report of the Chief of Engineers for .1887, pages 7'.-794.
   During the past fiscal year, under anl ar~ ,en( ,it ith the American
Dredging Company, 20,000 cubic yards :f'II;lt ei,l      ,c,re
                                                      \ii   rmoved, at the
rate of 12 cents per yard, from the eastern halt'of the channel in the
formation of a cut 120 feet wide and from 10 to 12 feet deep at mean
low water. This work was done in the month of August, 1887, and dur-
ing the balance of the season this deepened channel was maintained
without shoaling. An examination just completed shows that a chan-
nel of the following dimensions now exists: Six feet deep at mean low
water, with a minimum width of 120 feet; 8 feet deepl, with a width of
70 feet; and 10 feet deep, with a width of 50 feet. The channel as it
exists is maintained by the ebb-tide, and lies with its axis about par-
allel to and 100 feet north of the lower line of revetment.
   As stated in previous reports on this work, it is considered that
annual dredging may have to be resorted to in order to maintain the
channel at a depth of 10 feet at mean low water.
  The object of the revetment is to diminish the annual cost of main-
taining this channel. Its gross cost, including superintendence and
               APPENDIX              G-REPORT                        OF LIEUT.   COL. ROBERT.                675
office expenses, was in round numbers $17,000 and it is believed that
it will prove of that amount of service to commerce.
   In connection with the improvement of the channel across Smith's
Island Bar, attention is called to the subject of the removal of the islands
and adjacent shoals lying between Philadelphia and Camden as set
forth in the report on " the Delaware River between Philadelphia, Pa.,
and Camden, N. J.
   Should the improvement of this part of the river be specially under-
taken by the acts of Congress, no further appropriation would be
required for the improvement of the channel across Smith's Island Bar.
   In the best interests of the work and of commerce it is recommended
that all funds for the improvement of the main channel of the Delaware
River should be hereafter appropriated under the general title of " Im-
provement of Delaware River, Pennsylvania and New Jersey." The
improvement recommended by the Board of 1884 is the formation of a
channel from a point in the river near the upper part of Philadelphia to
deep water in the Delaware Bay, with a least width of 600 feet, and
having a depth of 26 feet at mean low water. This is to be accom-
plished, except at Schooner Ledge, where solid rock is to be removed,
by means of regulating and contracting works, aided where necessary
by dredging. The estimated cost of the work recommended is about
$2,425,000. This estimate is exclusive of the cost of any improvement
of that part of the river between Bridesburg and Trenton, for which a
project and estimate are yet to be submitted. It is also exclusive of
any expenditures for the formation of an improved cross-river channel
between Philadelphia and Camden.
   An appropriation of $600,000 towards carrying into effect the project
of 1884 is recommended for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, to be
applied to dredging and dike construction, together with any necessary
surveys and observations, all in accordance with the projects for the
permanent improvement of Delaware River and Bay.
  The Delaware River is tributary to the following collection districts: Trenton,
Philadelphia, Delaware, and Bridgeton.
  The amount of revenue collected in these districts during the year ending Decem-
ber 31, 1887, was $ 17,880,673.80.
Total amount appropriated for improvement of Delaware River from
  1836 to June 30, 1888 ......              ............................                       -- $1, 762, 000. 00
                                                                                     --....----....----....
Total expenditures to June 30, 1888.................................                                1, 691, 564. 89
Total amount appropriated on present project to June 30, 1888......---.                                410, 000.00
Total expenditures on present project to June 30, 1888-----------------...............                 339. 564. 89
                                                  Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available...... --.. ..............                             -94,             $............
                                                                                                             594. 64
July 1, 1887, covered by existing contracts ...................                         .....-.         43, 581. 98

                                                                                                       138, 176. 62
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive
  of liabilities outstanding July 1, 1887...... ---....----..... ......                7, 71. 1
July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities.....................                             8, 197. 58
July 1, 1888, amount covered by existing contracts .........                          36, 205.04
                                                                                                       112, 142. 13
July 1, 1888, balance available.........-------------------......--...........-----....----....--....----26, 034. 49
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888........          --               ..-......      ....      250. 000, 00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 -..--..--......                                 276, 034. 49
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ......
                                                                  -                                 1, 965,000.00
I Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
     1890    -------------------------------------------------------                                   ;00, 000. 00
I Submitted in compliance wi th requirements of sections 2 of river and
  Sharbor  acts of li;6 aunl 1867.
676              REPORT               OF          THE       CHIEF                     OF             ENGINEERS,                 U.     S. ARMY.


Abstract of proposalsfor furnishing and depositing stone in constructing a dike in Dela-
  ware River near Miflin Bar, opened April 27, 1888, by Lieut. Col. Henry M. Robert,
  Corps of Engineers.

                                                                                                                                                               Price per

No.                                               Names and addresses of bidders.                                                                              cubic yard.


  1     John Satterlee, Englewood, N. J                      ..................................-----...                                                              $1.93
  2     Brandywine Granite Company. Wilmington, Del--              ...-..             .-- -.-..   .......     --....         .                                         1.75
  3     George R. Stephenson, Lapidum, Md. --.............................................--..                                                                         2.10
  4     Joseph E. Spencer and W. W. Virdin, Lapidum, Md...---- - -..... .......                                 .............                                          2. 05
  5     Joseph II. Ward, Ridley Park, Pa -...................                      ..........................
                                                                                            -         -----                                                            1.19
  6     John A. Bouker, New York, N. Y....................                        ...         ....-.........- ...... .......                                           1. 65



   Contract (dated May 3, 1888) awarded to Joseph H. Ward.                                                                         In progress.




Abstract of proposalsfor constructing a dike in Delaware River fromn the lower end of RBeed
  Island, opened April 27, 1888, by Lieut. Col. Henry M. Robert, Corps of Engineers.


                                                                                                                   Approximate quantities.

No.                           Names and addresses of bidders.                                                          Brush mat-             Stone,             Amount.
                                                                                                                    tress, 4,000 20,000 cubic
                                                                                                                   cubic yards.     yards.


                                                                                                                       Per   cu.    yd.     Per   cu.yd.
   1    John Satterlee, Englewood, N. J ...                     ......................                                        $1. 84              $1.79            $43, 160
   2    John A. Bouker, New York, N. Y.............................                                                            1.70                1.75             41, 800
   3    John C. Churchill, jr., Burlington, Vt .........................                                                       1. 89               1.74             42, 360
   4    Ira Lunt, New Castle, Del..................................I                                                           1. 74               1.54             37, 760
   5    Brandywine Granite Company, Wilmington, D)el.............                                                              1. 55                1.45            35, 200



  Contract (dated May 3, 1888) awarded to the Brandywine Granite Company.                                                                                                 In
progress.



                                                         COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                             PORT OF PHILADELPHIA.

                                 Domestic and foreign entrances and clearances, 1887.


                                                             Entered from foreign ports.                                      Cleared for foreign ports.
                       Class.
                                                        { With cargoes.                              In ballast.          With cargoes.                    In ballast.


                                                          No.            Tons.                   No.        Tons.         No.        Tons.           No.           Tons.
American steam-vessels                .........
                                         ..                15             23, 742                  2          2, 577       13         23, 869          4             1,197
American sail-vessels..............                       308            146, 005                  5          6, 779      205        125, 025          6             2, 513
Foreign steam-vessels ........       ....                 531            706, 761                 13         17, 028      247        358, 131         47            33, 236
Foreign sail-vessels.....      .... ....                  490            384, 801                 13         14, 313      55         424, 551         18             6, 575


Value of exports ..........................                         ............................................                                               $33, 813, 024
Value of imports:
   Free of duty....        ...........................................                                                 ..................                  .     5, 708, 871
   Subject to duty. ................................................                                                                                            33, 863, 527

                                                                                                                                                                39, 572, 398
                        APPENDIX                      G-REPORT                           OF          LIEUT.                  COL.               ROBERT.                      677

                                                           Statement of revenue collections.



                                                           Year.                                                                         Amount re-               Increase for
                                                                                                                                           ceived.                   year.


1884......           ......    ........................................................                            $12, 530,451. 86                                    $279,141.34
1885...........................................................................                                     13, 915, 553.66                                   1,385, 101.80
1886..............                      ...............-------                  --................................  16, 303, 918.77                                   2, 388, 365.11
1887.---.--....            --         ........---..                .............                                    17, 950, 235.10                                   1, 646, 316. 33



                                                         Coastwise entrances and clearances.


                                                          Class of vessels.                                                                                Entered.      Cleared.


Steamers......--.......----..-...----.....------..-----------------...........................-----------------................                               1, 539          1, 819
Ships ...----..--       ---------------------                     ----...---.--------------------------                                                           19               8
Barks ...           -----------------------------------------------------------------                                                                             77              89
Brigs .-----........----....-----...........------....--------.........-----------..--..--.............---------------------.................                     52              69
Schooners..----..-..................--------.......---...................-------------------....----..----..-----------...----...                             2, 727          2, 820

          Total ------               --------------------------------------------...                                                              ---         4, 414          4, 805



Statenment of vessel movement to and from Port Richmond Piers, Delaware River front, for
                            the year ending December 31, 1867.


                                                                              Class.                                                                                     Number.


Steamer ......................................................................------------------------------------------------------------....---........                        864
Sailing vessels ....                ......      .....       ..          ----............----........  ....  .. .. ..          .. ..................                           1,967
Canal-boats and barges --........-.....                                                  ..............                 ...........------...........-----.                    3, 367
          Total ............-----------------...............----------------------------------------------                                                                    6,198


                                                                         Freight statement.
Received :
   Foreign iron-ore --.. ...--..-                                    ..----....         ................................                                     tons..        415, 000
Shipped :
   Coal.-----..-.............                               --          --....--..                ..............................                            do...        1,919,350
   Grain .................      ...                              ........     .. .. .              ..............              .............            bushels..        3, 382, 647

Vessels arriving at                      and departing from the Delaware and Raritan Canal at Bordentown
                                            during the year ending December 31, 1887.


                                               Description.                                                                      Arrivals.                     Departures.


                                                                                                                            No.                 Tons.         No.          Tons.
Steamers... ...............................................                                                                    720               74, 898         660         68, 640
Sailing vessels ..................................................                                                             117               19, 824           6             246
Barges ...........................................................                                                          2, 763             450, 474       1, 546        180,945
Rafts ... --.---..-.....-            ..          .... ...          .................. _..._                                     83                6, 807          35          8, 925
          Total ......................                           ...................                ........                3, 683             552, 003       2, 247        258, 756


  A total of 5,930 loaded vessels carrying 810,759 gross tons freight. The estimated
value of shipments arriving, 552,003 tons, was $12,171,666, and that of departing,
258,756 tons, at $8,320,593, a total of $20,492,259.
  The canal collector at Bordentown estimates the tonnage by water to and from
Bordentown during the year not entering the canal and therefore not included in the
above statement, as follows :
                                                                                                                                                                          Tons.
Steamers ..---- ----.-            ........             .. ..............-..............                 .. 30,000
Sailing vessels ......- - ........ .....              ........................            ...... ......     2, 000
Barges............. ........     ....................                     ......       .............. 210,000
            Total......                      ..............................
                                              ......                                                           ..........................                               242,000
   7378           REPORT                      OF            THE     CHIEF              OF           ENGINEERS,               U. S. ARMY.

Statement of vessels passing through the Chesapeake and Delaware Canal to and from Dela-
                   ware River during the year ending December 31, 1887.


                                                            Description.                                                      Arrivals.       Departures.

Steamers .......................................                         ...........    ..............                                 878              891
Canal-boats and bares.... --...............                      ......-     ..--..- ...-----
Sailin vessels .-..- ..---..---------............-..--...------..--..---..---...-                    . ....---- .
                                                                                              ........------.
                                                                                         -......------                              1. 611
                                                                                                                                   2,  051           1,71
                                                                                                                                                     2, 03
Ranafts     and-----ar--es
Rafts...............            ----------------------------------------------
                                 .. ......          ....      ..... ....... ..................                                     2,1.712,4
                                                                                                                                       171                4
           Total.................................                               --........--.......          ....------- .         4, 711            4, 631


                                                                         Freigh slatemen t.


                                                             Articles.                                                        Received.        Shipped.

Coal.........         ...................................                                   ..........            tons_          208,   793        100, 127
Generai         merchandise........--                                            .......
                                                                         ....................... ...     .... .       .
                                                                                                                   do44,                01         119, 134
                                                                                --------------
           Total-------------...........................---------------------------......                                        552, 80           219, 26


  The foregoing int'ornation was furnished by the Philadelphia Board of Trade, Mr.
F. W. Taylor, of the Philadelphia Grain Elevator Company, Mr. George M Taylor,
auditor freight receipts, Pennsylvania Railroad Company, and Mr. C. L. Nicholson,
secretary Chesapeake and Delaware Canal Company.
  In obtaining reliable information of the coastwise commerce of the Delaware River
the difficulties are much greater than with the foreign commerce, owing to the fact that
no official public record is required of the cargoes of coastwise vessels, and the in-
formation can only be obtained from the private records of those interested in such
commerce. Apart from the objection nmany might have to the work of furnishing in-
formation covering a commerce probably exceeding in value $100,000,000, I find there
is objection to making public information of a private character showing to rival
interests the amount of business carried on between particular points by certain
steam-ship companies.

THE DELAWARE                                       RIVER BETWEEN PHILADELPHIA,                                                  PENNSYLVANIA,
                                                     AND CAMDEN, NEW JERSEY.

   By the joint resolution of Congress dated February 17, 1888, the Sec-
retary of War was authorized to appoint a board of three engineers
from the United States Army, whose duty should be to examine, in all
their relations to commerce, the islands known as Smith's Island, Wind-
mill Island, and Petty's Island, in the Delaware River, between the
cities of Philadelphia and Camden, to determine whether these islands
or any shoal in the river between or adjacent to the islands constitute
an obstruction to the commerce of the Delaware River between the States
of Pennsylvania and New Jersey; and with a view to their removal to
report a plan with the estimate of cost for such removal in whole or in
part, including the )robable cost to the Government of said islands.
   To carry this resolution into effect $5,()00) was appropriated.
   As covering the reqluiremelnts of this resolutionl the following report
of the Board of Engineers was made under (late of March 30, 1888:

                                                                      Money statement.

Amount appropriated by joint resolution of Congress dated February 27,
  188 ...-.
      1888------------                                 ----           ---
                                                                               000.0(
                                                                          . $5,000.00
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
     outstanding July 1, 187 ....------.--------------------------........                                                                         534.72
July 1, 1888, balance available .........                                                 .....-------. .----.............                       4,465.28
             APPENDIX       G----REPORT        OF LIEUT.        COL.   ROBERT.             679
                       REPORT OF BOARD             OF ENGINEERS.

                                PHILADELPHIA, PA., March 30, 1888.
  SIn: The Board of Engineers constituted by your order of March 10
has the honor to submit the following report:
  The instructions to the Board are contained in the joint resolution of
Congress, which is quoted in full below:
JOINT RESOLUTION authorizing the Secretary of War to appoint a Board of three engineers to
  examine and report in relation to the Delaware River between the city of Philadelphia, Pennsyl-
  vania, and Camden, New Jersey, and for other purposes.
  Resolved by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in
Congress assembled, That the Secretary of War be, and he is hereby, authorized to
immediately appoint a Board of three engi(neers from the United States Army, whose
duty it shall be to examine, in all their relation's to commerce, the islands known as
Smith's Island, Windmill Island, and Petty's Island, in the Delaware River, between
the city of Philadelphia, in the State of Pennsylvania, and the city of Camden, in
the State of New Jersey, which Board shall forthwith report to the Secretary of War
as to whether said islands or any shoal in the said river between or adjacent to the
said islands, or any of them, constitute an obstruction to the commerce of the Dela-
ware River or to the passage of vessels between the said States; and with a view to
removing said islands and shoals, to report a plan with the estimate of cost for their
removal in whole or in part, and for the improvement of the harbor of the port of
Philadelphia, including the probable cost to the Government of said islands so as to
secure free and uninterrupted commerce upon the said Delaware River, and the un-
obstructed passage of vessels to and from and between the said States; and the sum
of five thousand dollars, or so much thereof as shall be necessary, is hereby appro-
priated, to be paid out of any money in the Treasury not otherwise appropriated, to
defray the expenses of such survey and report.
  Passed the House of Representatives February 17, 1888.
  Attest:                                                        JNo. B. CLARK,
                                                                                Clerk.

   The Board met in Philadelphia at 11.30 a. in., March 21, and in the
afternoon made a personal examination of the river from the head of
Petty's Island to Gloucester, covering about 7 miles of the city front,
in company with a number of gentlemen representing the various mer-
cantile bodies and corporations most interested in developing the com-
merce of the port of Philadelphia.
   The Board continued in session the next day, listening to statements
made by various parties interested in the proposed improvement and
examining the maps of the harbor of Philadelphia.
   The Board requested the Philadelphia Board of Trade to furnish it
with a statement of the commercial requirements that demand the re-
moval of the islands in front of the city, and also with an estimate of
the probable cost of these islands, or so much of them as should be re-
moved.
   To enable these papers to be prepared, the Board adjourned to the
28th instant, when it continued its consideration of the subject referred
to it, completing its labors on the 30th of March.
   The Delaware River in front of the city of Philadelphia was thor-
oughly surveyed in 1878 for the city, by the United States Coast and
Geodetic Survey, and since then the bars or portions of them have been
several times surveyed by the United States Engineer Department.
Forty-three borings were made in the Delaware River between Coop-
er's and Kaighn's points in 1874, by Mr. Samuel Melvin, for a bridge
company. All of these borings appear to have struck rock at a depth
nowhere less than 39 feet below low water, while on the bar just above
Smith's Island Rlock was only reached at a depth of over 100 feet.
  Thirty-three holes were bored in 1883, under the direction of General
We;.tzel, United States Engineers, on Smith's, Windmill, and Petty's
680     REPORT   OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

islands, to ascertain if at any point on these islands an excavation to a
depth of 24 feet below mean low water would reach rock. The conclu-
sion, from the best evidence attainable, is that no removal of rock will
be needed to carry out the plan reported by the Board, and the esti-
mates submitted are on that basis. I or absolute certainty on this point
some further examinations may be required, but the Board does not feel
at liberty, considering the urgency of its instructions, to delay making
a report for that purpose.
SMITH'S   AND    WINDMILL    ISLANDS AND      THE   SHOALS    ADJACENT
                               THERETO.

   Smith's and Windmill islands lie in the Delaware liver, between
Philadelphia and Camden, opposite the centers of those cities, and
about 800feet from the ends of the Philadelphia Wharves,which are very
short here, in no case exceeding 260 feet in length. The two islands
are in the State of Pennsylvania, and are separated by a narrow cut
about 130 feet wide, maintained by a ferry company. They only slightly
exceed a half mile in length; but there are shoals above and below, the
the upper one extending 1 mile to Cooper's Point, the upper limit of
Camden, having on it less than 6 feet at mean low water. The shoal be-
low the islands is not so long, but for a distance of a half mile below
Windmill Island there is less than 12 feet depth upon it at mean low
water.
   These two islands, with the adjacent shoals, thus practically form a
continuous obstruction in the river opposite the centers of the water
fronts in both Philadelphia and Camden, extending 1 miles, if we con-
sider only the portions of the shoals having less than 6 feet of water,
   2
or miles if we include all of the shoals covered with less than 1.: feet.
The width of even the 12-foot channel between this obstruction and the
heads of the Philadelphia Wharves, for 14 miles, is from 750 to 1,000
feet, and the wharves can only be extended by diminishing this width,
already too small. The greatest length of these docks is but 21(0 feet,
as stated above, while, as is well known, the larger ocean steam-ships
are much longer. The lpart of the river on the Camden side of the isl-
ands is almost useless as a portion of the harbor, as it is thus so thor-
oughly cut oft from the Philadelphia side.
   To avoid misapprehension it is proper here to state that there is a
depth of over 26 feet at low water in a narrow channel as far up as the
wharves of the Reading Railroad.
   Near the wharves on the Philadelphia side the depth is much greater
than necessary, in some places exceeding 50 feet, and adds greatly to
the cost of wharf extension on that important front.
   These islands, with their dependent shoals, are to be considered from
two points of view. They are certainly a hindrance to the cross- river
navigation between Phladelphia and Camden. This, however, is a
matter rather of ferriage between the two cities, which could be pro-
vided for at a comparatively small cost by one or more revetted cuts.
Besides, however, being obstructions as just stated to the cross traffic
between Philadelphia and Camden, these islands and shoals )practically
reduce the width of the Delaware opposite them on the Ph'liladelphia
side to about 750 feet.
   This channel might be wide enough to accommodate the vessels pass-
ing through it were it not for the tact that it is lined with docks, out
of and into which vessels must pass, which requires them to swing
across the channel. The up and down navigation is also interfered
         APPENDIX     G-REPORT      OF LIEUT.    COL.   ROBERT.       681
with by the cross-river boats. The current on this concave shore is
rapid and increases the difficulties of the situation. The heads of the
wharves are occupied by boats, and vessels over 260 feet in length in
these docks must project into the channel, thus further contracting its
narrow limits.
  In time of freshets, and especially when the river is filled with run-
ning ice, the difficulties are further increased. For the reasons thus
given the Board concludes, in the language of the joint resolution, that
these islands and shoals do " constitute an obstruction to the commerce
of the Delaware River and to the passage of vessels between the States
of Pennsylvania and New Jersey."

                            PETTY'S ISLAND.

   Petty's Island, in the State of New Jersey, lies about 2 miles above
the head of Smith's Island, the two being almost connected by shoals.
It is about 2 miles long and has an area of about 360 acres above low
water. The channel between the island and Philadelphia is about 2,400
feet wide at its upper end, gradually diminishing to 1,120 feet at the
lower end, where it can legally be further reduced to 1,000 feet when-
ever the riparian owners choose to extend the wharves on the island.
   While this island can not properly be said to be itself a great ob-
atruction to navigation, its existence complicates the situation. Behind
it is a channel carrying nearly half the water of the river, which on the
ebb tide comes around the island at a great angle with the other chan-
nel, forcing the current still more against the concave shore on the
Philadelphia side. The effect of this is to increase the velocity of the
ebb current where it strikes the Philadelphia shore and to diminish it
towards the Camden side. where it is already too small.
   Petty's Island, with its present shape and size, is also an obstruction
to the navigation of the Delaware to the extent of diminishing the
Philadelphia channel at its lower end to about one-half the width at its
apper end.
               SHOALS    ADJACENT    TO PETTY'S ISLAND.

   The shoal at the lower end of Petty's Island can hardly be deemed
an obstruction to navigation so long as Petty's Island remains as at
present. If the channel between the lower end of the island and the
Philadelphia shore is widened, then it Nwould be necessary also to widen
it past this shoal.
   Near the upper end of Petty's Island is a large shoal, known as Five
Mile Bar, which extends diagonally up and across the river to the Penn-
sylvania shore. This shoal has less than 6 feet of water on it for more
than a mile of its length, and the deepest channel across it, which is
very narrow and near Petty's Island, carries less than 10 feet at mean
low water. Immediately above it is a deep channel for       several miles
up the river, a 26-foot channel, at least 200 feet wide, extending up
some 3 miles, or more than a mile above the Frankford Arsenal, and an
18-foot channel extending to the upper limits of Philadelphia, S miles
above the head of Petty's Island, which can be readily increased to a
depth of 24 feet by improving one bar.
   This shoal is a serious obstruction to the commerce of the Delaware
River, cutting off the upper part of Pliladelphia, including the Frank-
ford Arsenal, from the advantages of deep-water navigation.
682     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                   WHARF OR PORT-WARDEN          LINES.

  Any plan for the improvement of the harbor of Philadelphia must
embrace both shores. If the United States undertakes the improve-
ment of this harbor, it should be on condition that the wharf-lines on
both sides of the river be controlled by the Secretary of War. They
are at present controlled by two different States, either one of which
can change its own at pleasure.
   As long as this condition of affairs exists, it is useless to attempt any
general scheme of improving this harbor. Only last year the New
Jersey Riparian Commissioners advanced their wharf-line 300 feet in
front of Camden, and if the islands were removed they might advance
it 300 feet farther and prevent the extension of tlie Philadelphia
wharves. At the same time they advanced the wharf-line around
Cool)er's Point 250 feet, thereby damaging' the river if the wharves are
ever built out to this line. The present exterior wharf line at Cooper's
Point, established last year, is S00 feet beyond the shore-line of 1843.
   This Board is of opinion that the law making the first appropriation
for improving the harbor of the port of Philadelphia should place under
the Secretary of War the establishment of the wharf-lines on both sides
of the Delaware River, from the lower to the upper limit of the city of
Philadelphia, giving him power to alter these lines if he deems it nec-
essary, and no money should be expended until he has both present and
future control.
                        PLAN OF IMPROVEMENT.

   The obstructions to commerce at Philadelphia, of which complaints
are made, have now been stated. Briefly they are: First, the narrow-
ness of the deep-water channel in front of Philadelphia, which renders
it difficult for vessels to enter and leave the docks, and makes them at
that time obstructions to passing vessels; second, the impossibility of
extending the wharves, which are too short, in so narrow a channel;
third, the shoals between Camden and Philadelphia, which interfere
with free-water communication, this last point, however, being of sec-
ondary importance.
   The river is able to maintain a single channel with ample depth and
about 2,000 feet in width, with a cross-section not far from 55,000 square
feet at mean tide.
   The best solution of the difficulties complained of would be obtained
by forming such a channel along the Philadelphia shore, from Kaighn's
Point to Fisher's Point, at a distance far enough from the present wharf
line, not exceeding anywhere about 300 feet, to permit the extension of
the wharves and the widening of Delaware avenue at their shore ends.
   In executing such a plan the present tidal flow must be maintained,
and as the thorough improvemnt of the Five-Mile Bar will ultimately
require the closure of the New Jersey Channel south of Petty's Island,
it involves the ultimate widening of the Pennsylvania Channel so as to
carry all the present tidal flow. It also includes the removal of Smith's
and Windmill islands and their shoals.
   Smith's and Windmill islands and the adjacent shoals should be re-
moved, so as to give a 26-foot channel, about 1,000 feet wide, alongside
the revised Philadelphia wharf-line from Kaighn's Point to the foot of
Petty's Island. If in the progress of the work it is found a wider deep
channel can be maintained, it may ultimately be advisable to increase
the 26-foot channel to 1,500 feet width.
                                                                   pILADE LPHI;A
    Note -
     THE LOCATION Of rHE EXTERIOR LINES OF THE                          ~              .                   I

     MODIFriD HARBOR is SHOWN THUS ------                                                                 ii
     WHERE    THE
     THE PRESENT ADOPTED
                         LINE DIFFERS FROM
                     MODIrIED
                             LINE THE LATTER
                                                                               I                   JLJLLJLJ                  L.LJ                                        o
                                                                                                                                         Jl
     1, SHOVYN THUS --     - -  -  -.                                                                           ..           _                '.,           /.   -   /




       c   hPointM                                             ,e-n.W                                                            Coo                    0



                                                                               CAMDEN

                                                        SSKETCH                                    OF THE                                           :

GOU~es erHARBOR                                                            OF PHILADELPHIA                                                    ,
                                                                        D)elaware -River
                                              SO   MODIIED AS  TO RENDER    FEASIBLE THE ADVANCE OF
                                        THE    PORT WARDENS   LINE                 ~300
                                                                      FT. IN THE CENTRE OF THE CITY FRONT.

                                                                               Prepared                   by
                                          Lieut. Col. H .M.Robert, Corps of Engineers. U.S.A
                                   U. S.Commission Advisory to the Harbor Commnisoners of Phladelphiao
                                                                                   2
                                                   -C    ale        0   1000           000   300   4000        5000   6000       Fet.\


             e       .olof'r, 1U...A.
  Eng50 2
         APPENDIX     G-REPORT      OF LIEUT.    COL.   ROBERT.        683

   The estimates are based on a slope of 1 on 25 rising from the eastern
edge of this 26-foot channel andl on the removal of all of Windmill and
Smith's islands and their shoals lying above 12 feet below mean low
water.
   The ultimate improvement of the Pennsylvania Channel at Petty's
Island so as to carry the whole tidal flow will require a water cross-sec-
tion of about 55,000 square feet at mean tide, and can be obtained by
giving it a width of 1,000 feet with 26 feet depth, the channel sloping
from this depth to 12 feet in a further width of about 1,000 feet, thus
making the final channel width about 2,000 feet.          The estimates are
based on these dimensions and on the supposition that the dredging re-
quired will be equivalent to full dimensions of channel up to the head of
Petty's Island. A cons derable amelioration of the Five-Mile Bar could
be obtained without the complete closure of the channel south of Petty's
Island, and until tihis complete closure the enlargement of the north
channel to its ult imate dimensions propos&d above would not be neces-
sary, the only indispensable condition being to leave a combined water-
way through the two channels which would not decrease the tidal prism
above.
    While the estimate of the Board includes the expense of dredging
away a portion of Petty's Island and the shoal below it, it is altogether
probable that the simple removal of the existing bulkheads on that por-
tion of the island and the extension of the F'isher's Point Dike, as sug-
gested, would enable the river itself to do much of the needed widening.
In this connection it is proper to remark that the enlargement of Pet-
ty's Island on the Philadelphia side, as now authorized by the riparian
commissioners of New Jersey should not be permitted.
    The removal of Smith's and Windmill islands should not begin or be
carried on without the simultaneous regulation of the port warden's
lines of both shores of the river, so as to maintain the assigned section
of the new channel, as a failure in this resp)ect would only be followed by
the reformation of these islands in whole or in part by the river. More-
over, it is not sufficient that these lines should simply be laid down on
paper, but their existence as actual constructions should be a part of the
progressive scheme for the proper improvement of this portion of the
river.
    It has been represented that the extension of the wharves on the Phil.
adelphia side could not be effected by many of their owners on account
of the large expense thereof; due to the great depth of the water. If
this can not be done at private expense it should be in some other way
than by the United States.
    When the control of the wharf lines is in the hands of the Secretary
of War, they should be revised on both sides of the river, keeping them
about 2,000 feet apart, and allowing the Philadelphia wharves in the
center of the city to be extended about 300 feet.
    The Board does not consider that it is required by its instructions to
submit a detailed plan of wharf lines, especially as this would require a
  greater delay than is consistent with those instructions.
    The material to be removed should be placed where it will not be an
injury to the river. League Island, the site of the navy-yard, contains'
  abi:ut 400 acres of land within the dikes which is about 3 feet below or-
  dinary high tides. Its value would be enhanced by its being raised sev-
  eral feet above high water.
    At Howell's Cove, in the Horse Shoe, a large amount of the material
  could be deposited with advantage to the river, by protecting the front
  with a bulkhead.
684      REPORT      OF   THE    CHIEF     OF   ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The riparian owners of the Camden shore would doubtless be glad to
get a portion of the material for filling up the large space between the
present shore line and the authorized line of solid wharf filling.
   The Board has not had the means in so short a time, from its own in-
vestigations, to reach a conclusion as to " the probable cost to the Gov-
ernment of said islands," and, in view of the urgency of the instructions
requiring prompt report, does not feel at liberty to delay its renditions
further.
   Should the city of Philadelphia, whose local interests are so intimately
and specially connected with the matter, purchase the islands as a pre-
liminary to their removal, the cost of acquiring them would( to the United
States be nothing.
   It is probable the sum that it would be necessary to pay for those
islands would not be less than the amount ($600,000), estinmated therefor
in the letter of March 23, from the Board of Trade, hereto appended.
   This Board does not feel called upon to make any recommendation as
to the process to be followed in obtaining possession of the islands in
question, as the details of such business will doubtless be managed under
proper legal direction.
   The estimated cost of dredging to be ultimately done to carry out the
plan of the Board is $3,500,000.
   The papers mentioned below are sent herewith.
(1) Communication from the Board of Trade of Philadelphia, dated March 23, 1888,
      and inclosing a number of resolutions from representative bodies.
(2) Letter of Board of Trade dated March 29, 1888, referring to No. 1.
(3) Letter from Board of Trade dated March 28, 1888, inclosing letter of Hon. W. J.
      Sewell, who incloses certain resolutions of the State of New Jersey and coun-
      cil of Camden, N. J.
(4) Letter from Board of Trade dated March 29, 1888, inclosing description of a pub-
      lic meeting held in Philadelphia in November, 1887.
(5) Letter of March 28, 1888, from Hon. Leonard Myers, attorney for Mr. William
      Longstreth.
                                                    WM. P. CRAIGHILL,
                                                        Colonel of Engineers.
                                                   C. B. COMST3OCK,
                                    Lieut. Col. of Engineers. Bvt. Brig. Gen.
                                                      HENRY      M.   ROBERT,
                                                         Lieut. Col. of .Egineers.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                S. A.



       STATEMENT OF BOARD       OF TRADE    OF PHILADELPHIA,     PENNSYLVANIA.

                                       OFFICE OF TIHE BOARD OF TRADE,
                                             MERCANTILE LIBRARY         BUILDING,
                                                         Philadelphia,March 23, 1888.
   SIR: The Board of Trade is in receipt of your communication of March 20, 1888, ask-
ing a statement of the facts that demand the removal of Smith's. Windmill, and Petty's
islands and the advantage to commerce resulting therefirom, and also a statement of the
probable cost to the Government of the islands or such portion as it may be necessary
to remove.
  In reply I would state in behalf of the Board of Trade that repfesenting the commer-
bial interests of the city and port of Philadelphia, and in obedience to a strong demon-
stration of public sentiment on the subject, the board early in 1887 started the move-
ment for the removal of the islands. In this it has been ably seconded and supported
by all the commercial and maritime organizations of the city and port, to wit, the
Commercial Exchange, the Maritime Exchange, the Drug Exchange, the Grocers and
Importers' Exchange, and the Vessel-Owners and Captains' Association.         It has also
been supported by the board of wardens for the port of Philadelphia representing the
State of Pennsylvainia as custodians of its interests in the water-ways in front of Phila-
               APPENDIX    G-REPORT          OF LIEUT.       COL.    ROBERT.            685

delphia, and finally by the city councils of Philadelphia, and their board of harbor
commissioners representing the municipality.
   All of these bodies have adopted resolutions favoring the improvement of the harbor
by the removal of the islands, under the supervision and authority of the General Gov-
ernment, and have appointed committees to further the purposes of their resolutions,
copies of which are hereto annexed. A meeting of wharf-owners, merchants, and
others interested, was held on November 29, 1887, at which a strong expression of pub-
lie sentiment was obtained in advocacy of the removal.
   The press of Philadelphia has also been uniform in its earnest expression of the ne-
cessity of removing these islands in order to improve the commerce and maritime in-
terests of the port.
   We will premise briefly a statement of the geographical location of Philadelphia.
The city stands upon a navigable river of large dimensions, and is the terminus of
three great railways leading from the interior to the sea-board, and having together
some 15,000 miles of line, besides a vast amount of additional lines connecting with
them. These railroads extend to the remotest part of the great West and Southwest,
and pour out millions of traffic to be shipped from our wharves. The foreign trade
last year alone amounted to upwards of $66,000,000, besides a vast coastwise commerce
in coal, lumber, grain, wool, and domestic products, this being one of the largest coal-
shipping ports of the country. The amount of duties paid on imports for 1887 was
$17,640,944.
  The channel of the Delaware River between Philadelphia and the sea has been ex-
tensively improved by the Government by dredging and a thorough system of light-
ing, so that it is now capable of accommodating the largest ships of modern commerce
safely and expeditiously. With these facilities of egress and ingress it would seem
unfortunate to have the immediate harbor of the city so cramped and restricted as to
imperil and curtail the facilities of handling the commerce for which so much trouble
has been taken to provide a channel. The advantages of Philadelphia as the leading
fresh-water port on the Atlantic sea-board are well known as one of the attractions
that make it a favorite haven with ship-masters.
  The city of Philadelphia is shaped like an hour-glass, the narrowest portion being
at Market street. The Delaware River flows by a crescent-shaped channel past its
wharves, giving the business section of the city a concave front, opposite to the cen-
ter of which and in the midst of the river are located Smith's and Windmill islands,
with the adjacent shoals stretching to Petty's Island about a mile above, which by
its location unfavorably influences the entire river chauntel. The main mercantile
business portion of Philadelphia is situated between Vine and South streets, and the
great stores and warehouses are in or near this section. Wi-h the sharp competition
prevailing in all classes of business it is absolutely necessary that the cost of handling
should be reduced to a minimum by reducing the distance of hauling, and that the
freight forming cargoes should be moved between warehouse and vessels at the small-
est possible expense.
  Philadelphia being the leading manufacturing city of the United States, an enor-
mous traffic grows out of the imports of raw materials and the export of unmanufact-
ured goods. The commerce naturally concentrates in front of the central portions of
the city, because the extreme upper end is not readily accessible on account of the
shallowness of the water, while the lower end is mainly a marshy region that can only
be used for such wharves as are made railway terminals for through traffic, and are
unavailable for the business originating in or designed for the city itself.
   The public wharves of Philadelphia available for the use of vessels bringing dry
cargoes are limited to four in number, viz, Piers 34, 35, 38, and 39, South Wharves,
and even these are below the business section above described. These wharves are
all extended out to the port warden's line, but are nevertheless insufficient in length
to allow enough platform space on which to place even an ordinary cargo at once,
and vessels are therefore compelled to stop in their unloading until such room is made
on the wharf by consignees removing their merchandise as will admit continuing the
work of discharge.
   As an instance of this loss of time to vessels, take a steamer coming here with a
cargo of fruit, general merchandise, or sugar. It seldom happens that she is unloaded
in less than eight days after arrival, whereas in New York, Boston, or Baltimore she
would be unloaded in two or three days, for the reason that in those cities wharves are
sufficiently long, large, and properly protected from the weather, whereas the public
wharves of Philadelphia can lay claim to none of these important features-impor-
tant not only for the above reasons, but because a ship-owner can save money by re-
ducing wharfage charges and securing dispatch, and would therefore naturally send
his vessel to the port where advantages such as these can be secured.
  The average length of steamers that now visit Philadelphia is from 290 to 325 feet;
the dock length of Pier 34 is '284 feet ; of Pier 35, 295 feet ; of Pier 38, 2 .2 feet, and of
Pier 39, 310 feet, from which it will be seen that the damage dlone sfteamers by floating
ice and vessels moving up and down the river in a fog can be aseri ied to the inability
686       REPORT OF THE              CHIEF      OF ENGINEERS,           U. S. ARMY.

of long vessels to go into these short docks far enough to be protected from these dan-
gers.
   The piling and bed work of these wharves are too old and decayed to admit of the
docks being dredged to sufficient depth to allow of vessels remaining afloat at all stages
of the tide, and it is fair to assume that the depth of water in these docks during the
year does not exceed an average of 17 feet at low water, or 22 feet at high water, whereas
vessels that now come here require 18 to 24 feet of water to keep them afloat and free
from hard substance at the bottom of docks, making grounding dangerous, and in vio-
lation of all terms of charter-party or agreement as to freighting, insurance, etc., which
stipulate a vessel must remain afloat at all hours of the tide. It likewise often happens
that steamers are unable to unload and load their cargoes through being aground and
the consequent inability to secure water for their engines to make steam.
   At the end of these docks, outside of the port warden's line, may be found 40 to 60
feet of water in the channel.
   The width of the channel at this point is only 500 feet, and it has happened that ves-
sels of 275 to 325 feet length coming out of these docks have been unable to turn in
this width of channel,and have touched the bar on the eastern side. With the exception
of the four wharves above mentioned, all the others in front of the business section
(and they are all of less length) are controlled by sugar refineries, steam-ship compa-
nies, railroads, ferries, etc., for their individual use.
   In front of the business section, where these short piers now exist, the location of
Smith's and Windmill islands entirely prevents their being lengthened, as the channel
is now so narrowed as to but inadequately accommodate existing commerce. On the
contrary, were the islands removed and the thread of the river changed the piers could
be extended, and Delaware avenue, which leads to them, widened,thus accommodating
the larger vessels which are now compelled to berth themselves at a greater distance
from the business centers, subjecting the traffic to a much increased expense and the
vessel to great delays. The widening of the avenue and the lengthening of the piers,
we understand, will be provided independently of the Federal Government, both the
city and wharf-owners being anxious for the improvement.                 In large part it is already
available for much of the improvement through the liberality of one of Philadelphia's
most noted citizens aud merchants, the late Stephen Girard.
   The islands referred to are a great obstruction to the cross-river traffic between Phila -
delphia and New Jersey, which the Governmen t has by repeated expedients endeavored
to remedy, though with but partial success. Not only is there a large freight traffic
transferred, which in 1887 reached 1,000,000 tons by the various railroads and ferries,
but also an euormous passenger traffic on the ferry-boats, which in 1887 exceeded
42,000,000 of peope. All of thes are seriously inconvenienced by the delays and im-
pediments of crossing the river under the present disabilities. All this vast trade, as
well as that moving up and down the river, has to be cared for in a chaniel so blocked
up by the islands and shoals that its proper handling is seriously interfered with and
the commerce of the city discouraged and retarded. The islands are declared in resolu-
tions adopted by this board to " stand as permanent barriers to the future improve-
ment of our valuable river frontage, and threaten most seriously the commercial wel-
fare of our great city."
   We annex a letter of the harbor master of the port of Philadelphia, an officer of the
State of Pennsylvania and practical navigator, describing this subject, which tersely
recites the difficulties alluded to, and suggests a imilar remedy.
   The improvement of the Philadelphia Ha rblo r,       :is    universally desired by all the inter-
ested parties, is a removal of the islandsudl         sho:ls  Iow    obstructing the river and the
establishment of a new wharf line 1)v   by t :             i,
                                                        i :of     your Board for both sides of the
river. It is desired that the Philadel phia v; harlvccs may be extended to a proper length
so that the increasing commerce of the city may be adequately accommodated and
the existing difficulties may be remedied, and also that the traffic between the two
States be made easy and direct across a river entirely free from obstructions.
   The network of railways ramifying through the New Jersey peninsula and terminat-
ing opposite the city of Philadelphia will be vitalized by larger, more efficieot, and
economical terminals, and the cross-river transit could then be made possible in a
shorter time by more capacious ferry-boats than can now be used. An extensive water-
front could also be reclaimed on the New Jersey shore and made available for con-
mercial purposes.
                                      '
    In reference to your request for " a statement of theprobable cost to the Government"
of the islands in question, we find this difficult to answer, for the reason that they are a
species of property, and, as they at present exist, of entirely different character from any
other property inor near Philadelphia.        It is therefore almhnost impossible to get compe-
tent estimates of value from any but directly interested parties, although the amount
stated below is the result of careful investigation and examination assisted by the
opinions of leading real-estate experts in Philadelphia.
  Petty's Island is in the jurisdiction of the State of New Jersey, and the part that
would probably be wanted is owned by several interests, a portion not being improved
             APPENDIX G-REPORT              OF LIEUT. COL.       ROBERT.             6 7
and the remainder having some improvements. A map showing the property owner-
ship is hereto annexed.
   Smith's Island is mainly occupied as a summer resort for public recreation, having
been purchased a few years ago, it is understood, for $55,000, after which a large sum
was spent for improvements. The present owner is understood to have heretofore
made a considerable annual profit from his ferry, admission fees, and the sales of
liquor, privileges, etc. ; but the fact of the liquor license being already refused from
and after June 1, next, may curtail this profit for the approaching season, and reduce
materially his idea of the value of the investment. A portion of Smith's Island, ex-
ceeding 1 acre, is the property of the Pennsylvania Railroad.
   Windmill Island is largely owned and controlled by Messrs. Tatham & Bros. and the
Philadelphia and Reading Railroad, and is mainly unoccupied. Upon a part of it are
some manufacturing establishments. We make the following estimates of value from
the best information obtainable:
   Petty's Island (about 20 acres), Smith's and Windmill islands, estimated total cost
about $600,000.
   All of which isrespectfully submitted.
       I have the honor to.be, yours truly,
                                                                FRED. FRALEY,
                                             Presidentthe PhiladelphiaBoard of Trade.
                                                                W.   R.   TUCKER,
                                                                              Secretary.
Col.   WILLIAM P.    CRAIGHILL,
                    Corps of Engineers,
                          Chairman of Board of Engineers.



RESOLUTIONS    OF    BOARD OF   DIRECTORS OF THE VESSEL-OWNERS        AND   CAPTAINS' AS-
                                       SOCIATION.


                                   VESSEL-OWNERS AND CAPTAINS'       ASSOCIATION,
                                                     Philadelphia, Decenmbcer
                                                                            7, 187.
At the regular monthly meeting of the board of directors of the Vessel-owners and
Captains' Association, held on the above (late, the follox ing resolution was unani-
mously adopted:
   "Resolved, That the board of directors of the Vessel-owners and Captaains' Asso-
ciation hereby cordially indorse the movement for the improvmcnent of the harbor
of Philadelphia by the removal of Smith's and Windmill island s from the channel of
the Delaware Rtiver.
   " :Resolved, That a committee of five members of this Board be appointed.to co-op-
erate with similar conmlittees from different commercial and maritime bodies, should
the harbor commission and its board of scientific advisers determine upon a feasible
plan of removal."
  The chair appointed committee, Messrs. Colton, Cook, Parker, Baymore, and Henry
D. May.
  Extract from the minutes.
  Attest.
   [SEAL.]                                                      J.   F.   WALLACE,
                                                                              Secretary.


EXTRACTS FROM        THE MINUTES   OF THE BOARD     OF WARDENS FOR THE PORT OF       PHIL-
                                        ADELPHIA.


                            OFFICE OF   TIIE BOARD   OF WARDENS FOR THE
                                                       PORT OF PILADELPIIA,
                                                          PJhiladelphia, March 21, 1888.
  Regular stated meeting, December 5, 1887.
  Mr. Cook offered the following:
  "Whereas there has been a strong expression of opinion by commercial and maritime
interests of Philadelphia in favor of improving the harbor by the removal of Smith's and
Windmill islands from the Delaware River and the extension of the piers in front of the
city, so that they will adequately accommodate the larger vessels now employed in
conmnerce.
   ' Resolved, That the board of wardens for the port of Philadelphia hereby expresses
its opinion as in favor of such action shiould the board of harbor conunissioners and
the advisory board of scientific men decide that it is feasible, and agree upon and
recommend a satisfactory plan.
688      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                      U. S. ARMY.

   "IResolvd, That this board further expresses the opinion that said plan should not
overlook the legal rights of the wharf-owners on the D)evaware River front, which it
isthe duty of the wardns to supervise, and should recognize the ovneorship by the
State of Fennsylvania of all the riparian rights not given to private owners, under
the laws of the State, and that it should also include a comprehensive system of im-
provement of the Delaware front of the city by the aid, in whole or in pl)rt, of the
city government, supplementing the work by private owners a, well as the removal
of the islands referred to and the adjacent shoals.
   " Resolved, That a copy of these resolutions be transmittedl to the board of harbor
commissioners."
   Unanimously adopted.
  Special meeting, January 9, 1888.
  The following was offered by Mr. Cook:
  Resolved, That a special committee of five be appointed to report to the board, under
the resolution passed at the December meeting, in the matter relating to the proposed
removal of Smith's and Windmill islands."
  Adopted.
  On motion, the secretary was instructed to forward copies of the resolution to the
Board of Trade, Harbor Commissioners, Maritime Exchange, Commercial Exchange,
and the Vessel-owners and Captains' Association.
  The committee was appointed as follows :
  Messrs. Cook, Ferguson, Wilson, Norman, and Halyburton.
  True copy.
  Attest :
                                                            GEORGE A.    COTTON,
                                                                             President.
  [SEAL.]                                                   JONA GILLINGHAiM,
                                                                             Secretary.


        LETTER FROM HARBOR MASTER OF PHIILADELPHIA,            PENNSYLVANIA.

                                  COMMONWEALTH         OF PENNSYLVANIA,
                         OFFICE OF THE H ARBOR      1MASTER OF PHILADELPIHIA,
                                                         Philadelphia, March 22, 1888.
   DEAR SIR: The port of Philadelphia is seriously crippled by reason of the limited
lengths of the wharves and the crowded condition of Delaware avenue.
   Neither of these troubles could )beremedied without the removal of the islands.
The channel between them and the ends of the wharves is so narrow that the wharves
could not be extended, and the only practical way to widen Delaware avenue would
be to bulkhead the heads of the docks and fill in to the width required.
   If the islands were removed and the port warden's line extended, say, about 300
feet at Market street, the wharves could be run out to that point, and after widening
the avenue as suggested we could have docks about 450 feet in length and be able to
accommodate any and all kinds of vessels that might visit our port.
   The wharves were built years ago to suit the vessels of that day, and while they
answered the purpose then, they must be altered now.
   Itgoes without saying that vessels like those of the present day, ranging from 300
feet to 450 feet in length, can not be afforded the proper facilities for loading or dis-
charging or be safely moored to a wharf but 200 feet or 250 feet long.
   During the past year numbers of large steam-vessels were anchored at all times in
the vicinity of Gloucester, N. J., waiting their turns to haul into the few wharves at
the lower part of the city that could receive them to discharge their cargoes. That
should not be so in a port like this. All delays add to the expense of transportation,
and vessels would not be chartered to come here at the same rates as they would be
if the proper accommodations were at their disposal.
   If the islands were removed so that the wharf owners could extend, the commerce
would be largely increased, and the large amount paid in the way of duties, etc., would
be proportionately enlarged.
   The people of Philadelphia are anxious to have the needed improvmnuts, and ready
to do their share.
        Yours, very truly,
                                                           CHARLES    LAWRENCE,
                                                                       Harbor Master.
  WILLIAM R. TUCKER, Esq.,
            Secretary Board of Trade.
             APPENDIX      G--REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. ROBERT.                             689
      LETTER FROM THIE SECRETARY OF THE PHILADELPIHIA                  DRUG EXCHANGE.

                                                   PHILADELPIIA DRUG EXCHANGE,
                                                        Philadelphia, March 23, 1888.
  DEAR SIR: In reply to your request, I herewith submit the following extracts from
the minutes of the board of directors of this association, regarding the subject of the
proposed removal of Smith's and Windmill islands from the Delaware River, viz :

                       [Extract from the minutes, December 14, 1887.]

  " A communication from the Philadelphia Maritime Exchange under date of Novem-
ber 25 was read, regarding the removal of Smith's and Windmill islands from the
Delaware, and requesting the appointment of a committee to join in a conference with
similar committees from other trade associations to consider the matter.
  " The president announced that said committee should consist of Messrs. John Fer-
gusson, Edward H. Hance, and Richard M. Shoemaker."

                           [Extract from minutes, February 8, 1888.]

   "Mr. John Fergusson, from committee on navigation of the Delaware River, re-
ported that, in company with Mr. Shoemaker, he had met the committee on com-
merce of the select councils on January 30, and had expressed the views of the drug
exchange in the matter ' as being in hearty accord with the other mercantile bodies,"
after which it was resolved that the chairman be authorized to proceed to Washing-
ton, should occasion require, and represent the association before the Congressional
committee."
   On March 14 the joint report of the several committees, bearing date February 17,
Swas received, of which you already have a copy. This (the drug exchange) com-
.mittee was then discharged from the further consideration of the subject.
  [SEAL. ]                                                         WILLIAM GULAGER,
                                                                                 Secretary.
  Mr. W. R. TUCKER,
      Secretary of the Board of Trade.



       PREAMBLE AND RESOLUTIONS OF TIIE PHILADELPHIA BOARD OF TRADE.

                                                  OFFICE OF THE BOARD OF TRADE,
                                                         Philadelphia, March 23, 1888.
   The board at its meeting held January 17, 1887, unanimously adopted the follow-
ing preamble and resolutions:
   Whereas the increasing commerce of Philadelphia demands enlarged wharf facili-
ties for vessels of the great capacity now engaged in our coastwise and foreign trade ;
and
   Whereas it is a notorious fact that there are few but piers with length enough to
accommodate safely the large vessels now trading to this port, and if it be desired to
retain our commerce some speedy and radical measure must be adopted to secure the
extension of our wharves to meet the demands of the day; and
   Whereas the further extension of the port warden's line under the existing con-
dition has been declared by recognized authorities unwise and dangerous, thus re-
stricting the length of our wharves to their present inadequate dimensions; and
   Whereas Smith's and Windmill islands stand as permanent barriers to the future
improvement of our valuable river frontage and threaten most seriously the commer-
cial welfare of our great city: Therefore,
   Be it resolved, That the president of the board be requestedto appoint a committee
of five members to take into consideration the feasibility of the removal of Smith's
and Windmill islands and the adjacent shoals.
   Resolved, That the said committee on the "'removal of Smith's and Windmill
islands" be authorized to confer with committees of the Commercial and Maritime Ex-
changes and such other organizations as it may deem wise and proper.
   The following committee was appointed by the president: Messrs. John Price
Wetherill, Henry Winsor, Benjamin S. Janney, jr., E. K. Stevenson, and William
Brokie.
   True copy.
                                                                        W. R. TUCKER,
                                                                                 Secretary.
        ENG 88-       44
690      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

MEMORIAL TO CONGRESS FROM DIFFERENT TRADE ORGANIZATIONS                      OF   PHILADEL-
                         PHIA, PENNSYLVANIA.

                           OFFICE OF THE PHILADELPHIA BOARD OF TRADE,
                                                       Philadelphia, -              , 18-.

Copy of memorial adopted at a meeting of representatives of the Board of Trade, Com-
  mercial Exchange, Maritime Exchange, Drug Exchange, Grocers and Importers' Ex-
  change, Vessel-owners and Captains' Association, and the wardens of the port of
  Philadelphia, held at the Board of Trade rooms February 10, 1888, at the call of Mr.
  John Price Wetherill, chairman of the special committee of the Board of Trade
  on the removal of Smith's and Windmill islands.

To the honorable the Senate and House of Representatives in Congress assembled :
   This joint memorial of the Board of Trade, the Commercial Exchange, the Maritime
Exchange, the Drug Exchange, the Grocers and Importers' Exchange, the Vessel-own-
                                                                       oif
ers and Captains' Association, and the wardens of the port of Philadelphia, represent-
ing in their membership the various mercantile and trade interests       the city of Phil-
adelphia, respectfully represent that they are thoroughly impressed with the great
importance of furnishing to the coastwise and foreign commerce of Philadelphia the
greatest facilities for the economical handling of vessels and their cargoes.
   That by reason of the existence of the present conditions of the Delaware River the
further lengthening of the piers on that river in front of our city can not be undertaken
without offering an obstruction to the navigation of said river. Thisis a matter deserv-
ing the most serious attention when we consider the limited number of piers that are
of sufficient length to accommodate the enlarged vessels of the present day.
   That the subject of the improvement of our harbor has been ably considered and re-
ported on by the United States Advisory Commission to the harbor commission of
Philadelphia, which commission will not advise the greater extension of the piers be-
tween Washington avenue and Willow street until Smith's and Windmill islands and
the shoals above and below them are removed; and further report that any project for
the extension of wharves and the removal of the islands should be comprehensive
enough to include the improvement of the harbor from the head of Petty's Island to
the lower end of the shoals, and also the control of the wharf lines on both sides of
the river.
   That the city councils of Philadelphia have accepted and adopted the report of the
harbor commissioners, with the recommendations of the United States Advisory Com-
mission.
   That we, representing our merchants and tradesmen, firmly believe the conclusions
of the United States Advisory Commission to be wise, and that we can only hope for
ample harbor facilities by the removal of the islands in question, which stand alike
in the way of harbor improvements and as obstructions to the free intercourse between
the States of Pennsylvania and New Jersey; therefore your memorialists, the Board
of Trade, the Commercial Exchange, the Drug Exchange, the Grocers' and Importers'
Exchange, the Vessel-owners' and Captains' Association, and the wardens of the
Port of Philadelphia most earnestly petition your honorable bodies for the enactment
of such a law as will early permit, under the direction of the proper authority, the
removal of the islands now obstructing the navigation and commerce of our river
Delaware and retarding the improvement of the harbor of the port of Philadelphia.
   And your memorialists will ever pray, etc.
   True copy.
                                                                  W.    R.   TUCKER,
                                                                                  Secretary.
  PHILADELPHIA, March 23, 1888.

PREAMBLE AND RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF THIE PHILADELDHIA
                           MARITIME EXCHANGE.

                                THE PHILADELPHIA MARITIME EXCHANGE,
                                                OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY,
                                                    Philadelphia, Pa., March 23, 1888.
           PROPOSED REMOVAL OF SMITH'S AND WINDMILL ISLANDS, ETC.

   On January 17, 1887, the board of directors of this exchange unanimously adopted
the following preamble and resolution:
   "Whereas there is an urgent necessity for better wharfage accommodation on the
Delaware River front in the neighborhood of the business portion of the city; and
   "Whereas the warden's line as laid down by the Advisory Board of the Harbor
             APPENDIX      G-REPORT          OF LIEUT. COL. ROBERT.                  691
Commission prevents any extension of piers at these points, and in some cases recom-
mends their being contracted:
   " Resolved, That this exchange appoints its pilotage and navigation committee to
confer with committees named by the Board of Trade, Commercial Exchange, and other
bodies, to consider the feasibility of the removal of Smith's and Windmill islands,
with the shoals connected therewith, which now obstruct navigation in the harbor
and prevent improvements on the river front."
                                                             EDW. R. SHARWOOD,
                                                                             Secretary.


RESOLUTION ADOPTED BY THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF THE COMMERCIAL EXCHANGE
                             OF PHILADELPHIA.

                              TILE COMMERCIAL EXCHANGE OF PHILADELPHIA,
                                                       PhiladelphiaMarch 26, 1888.
  At a meeting of the board ofdirectors of the Commercial Exchange of Philadelphia,
held October 27, 1887, the following resolution was unanimously adopted:
  'R esolved, That the president of the Commercial Exchange be authorized and re-
quested to appoint a committee of five to act in conjunction with the Board of Trade
and such other committees as may be appointed by other commercial or trade bodies of
our city in carrying out the removal of Smith's and Windmill islands in the Delaware
River."
   [SEAL.]                                                HARVEY   K.   IIINCHMAN,
                                                                             President.
   C. Ross SMITH,
            Secretary.


     APPENDIX TO THE JOURNAL OF SELECT COUNCIL, CITY OF PHILADELPHIA.

                                    [Appendix No. 112.]

                                                      PILADELPHIA, January30, 1888.
To the Select and Common Councils of the City of Philadelpha:
    GENTLEMEN : The committee on commerce and navigation, to which was referred a
communication from the board of harbor commissioners, submitting for the consider-
ation of your honorable bodies a comprehensive and handsomely indorsed report and
plan for the improvement of the harbor and port of Philadelphia, which it is proposed
to be accomplished by the purchase of Smith's and Windmill islands and a portion of
Petty's Island, and the removal of the two first-named bodies of land in their entirety,
and a portion of the latter, together with the shoals adjacent thereto, which is amply
and ably set forth by the board of harbor commissioners in their report above alluded
to and submitted to councils on the 5th day of January, 1888, and to be found in the
appendix of Common Council (No. 185) on said date, respectfully submit that the com-
mittee met in select council chamber on the 30th day of January, 1888 ; to this meeting
the harbor commission, Commercial Exchange, Maritime Exchange, Board of Trade,
Drug Exchange, the Vessel-Owners and Captains' Association were invited, as well as
officers of the Pennsylvania and Reading Railroad companies. The several commercial
and maritime bodies and the corporations were represented by gentlemen who made able
and exhaustive arguments in support of the report of the harbor commissioners. At the
conclusion thereof your committee agreed to submit for your consideration and ap-
proval-
   First. The resolution approving and indorsing the report of the board of harbor
commissioners as submitted by the United States Advisory Commission, recommending
the removal of Smith's and Windmill islands and part of Petty's Island and the adja-
cent shoals, thereby permitting the extension of the wharves of the city, and memorial-
izing Congress to make the improvements as suggested by appropriating moneys to pur-
chase the islands and do the work.
   Second. A resolution requesting the commercial and maritime bodies and corpora-
tions interested to co-operate with councils and this committee in urging the matter of
the improvement of the harbor by the removal of the islands.
    JAMES A. FREEMAN, Chairman.                    JOHN E. HANIFEN.
    WILLIAM MCMULLEN.                              THOMAS J. RYAN.
    J. B. VAN DUSEN.                               JOHN B. DALLAS.
    EDwIN S. STUART.                               GEO. L. PFOUTS.
    SAMUEL HART.                                   HAROLD MANN.
    GEO. L. HORN.                                  JAMES P. PARK.
    A. E. JONES.                                   A. C. PATTERSON.
692      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Resolution indorsing and approving the report of the board of harbor commissioners in the
matter of the improvement of the harbor of Philadelphia, and memorializing Congress to
  authorize the improvements suggested in said report.
  Resolved, That the select and common councils of the city of Philadelphia hereby ap-
prove and indorse the report of the board of harbor commissioners, recommending a
plan for the improvement of the harbor of Philadelphia, as submitted by the United
States Advisory Commission, by the removal of Smith's and Windmill islands and part
of Petty's Island and the adjacent shoals, thereby permitting the extension of the
wharves in front of the city; and
  That the following memorial be presented to Congress upon the subject:
To the honorable the Senate and House of Representatives in Congress assembled:
  This memorial of the select and common councils of the city of Philadelphia respect-
fully represents-
   That there is demanded at the port of Philadelphia enlarged wharf facilities for the
larger vessels of greater capacity now engaged in the transportation of freight, both for-
eign and coastwise.
  That there are now but few piers with sufficient length to safely accommodate the
large vessels of the class above mentioned, this being a matter of serious consideration
and one vitally affecting the future commercial prosperity of our city and State.
   That the city councils, through their board of harbor commissioners, have had under
consideration the report of the United States Advisory Commission to the said Commis-
sioners, which Advisory Commission has made a careful and thorough study of the sub-
ject of the improvement of the harbor, and submit as their conclusions that an extension
of the piers between Washington avenue and Willow street, without injury to the har-
bor, can only be made by the removal of Smith's and Windmill islands and the shoals
above and below them ; and also that any plan for the removal of these islands and the
extensions of the piers should be comprehensive enough to include the improvement of
the harbor from the head of Petty's Island to the lower end of the shoals, and the con.
trol of the wharf lines on both sides of the Delaware River.
   That the city councils are satisfied that the conclusions arrived at by such an able
commission are wise, and that they receive the indorsement of those most deeply inter.
ested in the commercial prosperity and advancement of the port of Philadelphia : There.
fore,
  Your memorialists, the select and common councils of the city of Philadelphia, most"
earnestly petition your honorable bodies to enact Auch a law as will authorize the Sec-
retary of War, through the United States Corps of Engineers, to early commence the
improvement of the harbor of Philadelphia in manner as set forth in this memorial.



Resolution requesting and authorizing the committee on commerce and navigation, in con-
junction with the harbor commissioners and other bodies, to urge upon Congress the mat-
  ter of the improvement of the harbor andport of Philadelphia.
   Resolved by select and common councils of the city of Philadelphia, That the commit-
tee on commerce and navigation, in conjunction with the board of harbor commis-
sioners, board of port wardens, the several commercial and maritime organizations
of the city, and representatives of the Pennsylvania and Reading Railroad companies
be, and are hereby, requested and authorized to urge upon the Senate and House of
Representatives of the United States the importance of the adoption of such legisla-
tion as will assist in carrying out the suggestions relative to the improvement of the
harbor and port of Philadelphia, as set forth in the report of the Board of Harbor
Commissioners, submitted to councils on January 5, 1888, and printed in the ap-
pendix of that day.


       LETTER OF THE SECRETARY       OF TILE PIHILADELPIIIA   BOARD OF TRADE.

                                             OFFICE OF THE BOARD OF TRADE.
                                                         Philadelphia, March 29, 1888.
  SIR: In reply to your request that the Board of Trade should revise its estimate of
the probable cost to the Government of the islands to be removed in the improvement
pf our harbor, by reason of the error made in submitting the acreage of the part of
Petty's Island required, I would state that I find the parties furnishing the Board
with the estimated value of that portion of Petty's Island made their calculations on
the basis of the value of the property contained outside of the line drawn by the
United States Advisory Commission to the board of harbor commissioners, and not
           APPENDIX        CG-REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. ROBERT.                                  693
on the basis of the number of acres submitted in your communication of the 20th
instant.
  The Board therefore finds it unnecessary to amend its original estimate as presented
to you in its communication under date of the 23d instant.
      I remain, sir, your obedient servant,
                                                                         W.   R.   TUCKER,
                                                                                      Secretary.
  Col. WILLIAM P.    CRAIGHILL,
        Corps of Engineers, Chairman, etc.



      LETTER OF THE SECRETARY OF TIHE PHILADELPHIA BOARD OF TRADE,

                                               OFFICE OF THE BOARD OF TRADE.
                                                        Philadelphia, March 28, 1888.
  SIR: I again address you, in order to forward a letter of the Hon. William J. Sewell
accompanying copies of resolutions passed by the legislature of the State of New
Jersey and the city council of Camden, in the State of New Jersey, relative to the
necessity of the removal of the islands now obstructing the harbor of the port of
Philadelphia.
  This, and the inclosures, I would be pleased to have you consider as a supplement
to the communication addressed to you by this Board of Trade under date of the
23d instant.
      I have the honor to remain, sir, your most obedient servant,
                                                                         W.   R.   TUCKER,
                                                                                      Secretary.
  Col. WM. P.   CRAIGHILL,
        Corps of Engineers, Chairman, etc.



                         LETTER    OF   TIIE HION.   W.   J.   SEWELL.


                                                               CAMDEN, N. J., March 27, 1888.
   MY DEAR SIR : I beg to inclose you, at the request of Mr. Geo. B. Roberts, a certi-
fied copy of resolution, relative to removal of obstructions in the Delaware River,
which passed the legislature of the State of New Jersey; also one on this subject
which passed the city council of Camden.
   I would further state that the riparian commission of New Jersey, some months
ago, in view of the proposed removal of these obstructions, changed the riparian line
in front of Camden, advancing the same 300 feet.
       Very respectfully, yours,
                                                                               W. J. SEWELL.
  Mr. WM. R. TUCKER,
        Secretary Board of Trade, Philadelphia.



     JOINT RESOLUTION OF THE LEGISLATURE              OF TIHE STATE OF NEW JERSEY.

STATE OF   NEW JERSEY:


Joint resolution requesting Congress to make an approproiationfor the removal of Smith's or
                         Windmill Islandfrom the Delaware River.

   Whereas the navigation of the Delaware River between the cities of Camden, in the
State of New Jersey, and Philadelphia, in the State of Pennsylvania, is impeded and
obstructed by the island known as Smith's Island, or Windmill Island, located near
the center of said river, to the great loss, inconvenience, and damage to the citizens of
this State, and of the State of Pennsylvania: Therefore,
   1. Be it resolved by the senate and general assembly of the State of New Jersey, That the
Senators and Representatives in Congress from this State are earnestly requested to
sulpport and use their influence with the present Congress for an appropriation of suf-
ficient money to defray the expense of an examination of the island in the Delaware
River between the cities of Philadelphia and Camden, with a view to the removal of
694      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

said islands, which not only impede and obstruct the navigation of said river, but are
the occasion of great loss, inconvenience, and damage to the citizens of this State and
of the State of Pennsylvania.
  2. And be it resolved, That copies of this resolution be forwarded to the Senators and
Representatives in Congress from New Jersey by the secretary of state.
  Approved February 15, 1888.
STATE   OV'NEW JERSEY,
         Department of State :
  I, Henry C. Kelsey, secretary of state of the State of New Jersey, do hereby certify
that the foregoing is a true copy of joint resolution No. 3, passed by the legislature
of this State and approved by the governor the 15th day of February, A. D. 1888, as
taken from and compared with the original now on file in my office.
  In testimony whereof I have hereunto set my hand and affixed my official seal, at
Trenton, this twenty-seventh day of March, eighteen hundred and eighty-eight.
  [SEAL. ]                                                    HENRY C. KELSEY,
                                                                     Secretary of State.


             RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF CAMDEN, NEW JERSEY.

 - The following is an abstract of the minutes of a special meeting of the city council,
held February 14, 1888.
   Whereas the interest of Camden being identified with that of our sister city Phila-
delphia, we join in the request for the removal of the islands opposite this city, deem-
ing them an obstruction to navigation and impeding the progress of a great commer-
cial city, causing a formation of a bar at its head which is and has been a continual
source of expense to the Government to remove the same, whereby a channel may be
opened for the free passage of ferriage, the only means of communication between the
two cities; and
   Whereas in view of the growing demands of a rapidly increasing population for a
more rapid transit, aside from the demands commercially, we urge upon the members
of Congress that their influence be extended towards the accomplishment of the re-
quest;
   Whereas the bill 5978, introduced in the Congress of the United States by the Hon.
Samuel J. Randall, to ascertain the relations to commerce of Smith's and Windmill
islands in the river Delaware, between Philadelphia and Camden, and to improve the
navigation of the Delaware River, embodies the only means whereby the removal of
such obstructions can be accomplished: Therefore,
   Be it resolved by the city council of Camden, in meeting assembled, That a committee of
three members of city council, together with the president thereof, be appointed to
appear before the Committee on Rivers and Harbors of the House of Representatives
of the United States and urge the passage of House bill No. 5978.
   I, D. Cooper Carman, clerk of the city of Camden, do hereby certify that the forego-
ing is a true copy of the resolution adopted by the city council of the city of Camden.
   In witness whereof I hereunto set my hand and cause the corporate seal of the city
of Camden to be hereunto affixed this 27th day of March, A. D. 1888.
  [SEAL.]                                                    D. COOPER CARMAN,
                                                           Clerk of the City of Camden.
LETTER OF THE SECRETARY         OF   THE PHILADELPHIA     BOARD    OF HARBOR     COMMIS-
                                        SIONERS.

                                           OFFICE OF HARBOR COMMISSIONERS,
                                                         Philadelphia, March 29, 1888.
  SIR: I inclose you herewith a clipping from the Public Ledger of November 30 last,
giving an account of a meeting held at the office of the board of port wardens, in con-
formity with the following newspaper notice which was published in several of our
daily papers:
"Notice.
                                     "OFFICE OF THE HARBOR COMMISSIONERS,
                                                               " November 26, 1887.
  "In considering the question of the removal of Smith's and Windmill Islands, the
harbor commissioners will hold a meeting at the office of the board of port wardens
(Commercial Exchange Building) on Tuesday next, the 29th instant, at 12 o'clock noon.
All persons interested in wharves and the further extension of piers on the Delaware
River are invited to be present.
                                                       " WILLIAM R. TUCKER,
                                                                       'S ecretary."
           APPENDIX G---REPORT OF LIEUT.                     COL. ROBERT.                  695
  In addition to the above notice about seventy-five postal cards were sent out con-
veying invitations to those known to be interested in the ownership of piers and in the
question generally.
       Yours truly,
                                                                       W.   R.   TUCKER,
                                              Secretary Board of Harbor Commissioners.
  Col. WM. P. CRAIGHILL,
         Corps of Engineers, Chairman, etc.



                        [From the Public Ledger, November 30, 1887.]

LOCAL AFFAIRS-HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS-VIEWS OF CITIZENS AS TO THEIR IMME-
  DIATE NEED-AN IMPORTANT CONFERENCE BETWEEN THE HARBOR COMMISSION,
  ADVISORY BOARD OF ENGINEERS, AND REPRESENTATIVES OF THE CITY'S COM-
  MERCIAL INTERESTS.

   A conference was held in the office of the board of port wardens at the Chamber of
Commerce at noon yesterday, between a large number of representatives of the com-
mercial interests of the city on the one hand and the authorities who have under con-
sideration the measures for the improvement of the harbor of Philadelphia. The meet-
ing was called by the harbor commission. in order that the advisory board of Govern-
ment officials (appointed by the President of the United States) might obtain "the
views and wishes of those persons interested in the commercial prosperity" of Phila-
delphia, the particular project under consideration being that for the removal of Smith's
and Windmill islands, and the changes which would be necessary in event of that
work being done.
   There were present : Capt. George B. White, U. S. N. ; Lieut. Col. Henry M. Robert,
Engineer Corps, U. S. A.; Prof. Henry Mitchell, U. S. Coast and Geodetic Survey, and
H. L. Merendin, secretary, constituting the Advisory Board; Henry Windsor, Edwin A.
Gaskill, Charles S. Lewis, Chief Engineer and Surveyor Samuel L. Smedley and Wm.
R. Tucker, of the harbor commission; Joel Cook, George A. Cotton, Edw. K. Stev-
enson, and N. McKinley Wilson, of the board of port wardens; Master Warden Chris-
tian K. Ross, Harbor Master Charles Lawrence, president of common council; Presi-
dent George B. Roberts, of the Pennsylvania Railroad; Superintendent Sweigard, of
the Philadelphia and Reading Railroad; John H. Weeks, agent of the Baltimore and
Ohio Railroad in this city; W. W. Frazier, jr., of Harrison, Frazier, & Co.; Benjamin
S. Janney, of Janney & Andrews; Francis and Alfred Cope, John Price Wetherill,
F. A. Churchman, president of the Tug-Boat Owners' Association; L. G. Schermer-
horn, of the U. S. Engineer Office; Pay Director A. W. Russell, U. S. N.: Spencer C.
McCorkle of the U. S. Coast Survey; Prof. Lewis M. Haupt, University of Pennsyl-
vania; Philip Fitzpatrick, General W. L. James, F. R. Pemberton, president of the
Pennsylvania Warehousing and Storage Company; William and Frederick W. Taylor,
Charles A. McGinley, .Samuel T. McDonnell, W. T. Hager, Hon. Charles O'Neill,
William Harkness, J. K. Wheeler, and Edward R. Sharwood.
   The meeting was. organized by the election of Benjamin S. Janney as chairman and
Jonathan Gillingham secretary; after which Mr. Windsor stated the objects of the
meeting. He said the Harbor Commission's first work was in connection with the
proservation of the harbor. It would be useless to expend money for improvements
before the needed steps are taken to prevent injury from the encroachments con-
stantly being made. Heretofore all of the money provided by the National Govern-
ment has been used to improve the approaches to the harbor, the engineers having
charge of the work taking the ground, very properly, that a good harbor would be
of no value unless the vessels can get to it. Mr. Windsor then went on to say that
the Advisory Board, having now come to the question of the harbor itself, as to how
far the city wharves can be extended in order to afford facilities for the vessels now
used, and what new changes may be necessary, they want to know what the citizens
of Philadelphia desire in the matter before they go on with their consideration of their
plans.
                             OPINIONS OF WHARF-OWNERS.

  Philip Fitzpatrick, speaking as a wharf and ship-owner, stated that at the present
day very few steamers are built which are under 400 feet, and it ought to be well un-
derstood that if Philadelphia wants vessels of large tonnage to come to her harbor
her wharves must be at least 500 feet long; yet none of them are over 400, and the
majority of them are much less.
  GeoI'ge W. Burton, speaking of the proposed extension of the wardens' line, in
order to permit of the lengthening of the piers, said the line was now out as far as it
696      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

can go on the immediate city front. To extend the present 250-foot piers would be a
very expensive business, and he did not know of any wharf-owners who could do it
and expect to get any revenue from their property. The gross income now is very
small, and 50 per cent. of it is eaten up in taxation, cost for dredging out material
deposited in the docks by the city's sewers (for which the city makes an utterly in-
adequate appropriation), and in other ways. He thought the removal of the islands
would be to take away a barrier against the northeast winds; that if it was not for
the islands Delaware avenue would be frequently flooded, and that the wharves
would have to be raised 4 or 5 feet, and the " taxation and expense would be some-
thing fearful." lie thought the jetties built above Smith's Island had resulted in the
filling up of the docks; that the Pennsylvania Railroad trains on Delaware avenue
were injuring the wharf properties. lie asked who would pay the expenses of im-
provements in which the whole city was to share the benefits. He did not think the
wharf-owners ought to bear it all. He also questioned the practicability of the plan.
   Mr. Windsor remarked that the possibility of the proposition was not under con-
sideration then. "We are here to find out what the city wanted. The engineers who
have studied the question can tell us whether it is feasible."
   Colonel Robert said there was no practical difficulty in extending the wharves,
though the deep water and rapid current would increase the cost. It was merely a
question of dollars and cent s.
   Mr. Burton thought the cheapest and best way to secure deeper and longer docks
was for the city to buy the properties, widen Delaware avenue, and extend the docks
to the west.
                            WHAT THE CITY SHOULD DO.

  Joel Cook said that Mr. Burton was a representative of the wharf-owners of Phila-
delphia, and that what he had said about the difficulties to owners of the short
wharves was a subject for serious consideration. Here are one hundred separate
wharf-owners, every one of whom has a direct pecuniary interest in the matter; and
yet a majority of them can not really afford to make the improvements necessary. If
this plan of removing Smith's and Windmill islands and extending the piers is de-
cided to be feasible, then it becomes the duty of the city to give some attention to
the matter, and to do something to demonstrate the desire of the city to foster its
commerce. Mr. Cook thought that if the Government agreed to pay the expense of
clearing the channel, the city's duty was to adopt some broad and comprehensive
scheme to take the river front and improve it in accordance with these plans. This
was a thing, he said, we have a right to call upon the city to do. He did not think
any encouragement could be gotten from Washington unless the city and State give
some earnest that they will contribute toward the improvement.
  All the diverse interests are looking at the plans from their respective individual
stand-points, and he believed that the city would have to get possession of the wharves
or she will never have the commerce. Mr. Cook said also that thus far the city au-
thorities had done nothing for the commercial interests at stake, and they want to be
awakened to the importance of attending to something else than celebrations. He
believed the city would respond if called upon. She has a splendid river, magnifi-
cently lighted (mainly through the efforts of Captain White), but that what was
lacking was suitable wharfage. He cited the case of the Clyde to show what had
been done in the way of stimulating commerce under the most difficult conditions.
  Edward K. Stevenson, who was the next speaker, thought there was no force in the
objection urged by Mr. Burton to the effect that the islands formed a barrier to the
northeast winds, the removal of which would be disastrous. He found that while
wharf-owners complained about low profits, it is most difficult to buy any wharf prop-
erty at any reasonable price. The owners are getting no adequate revenue because
the property is not in a condition to earn more.

                              NEW JERSEY'S ATTITUDE.

  Mr. Windsor at this point remarked that injury had been to wharf property in this
city because of the attitude of New Jersey. He believed it would be of little use to
spend money on improvements unless the harbor can be protected, and he thought it
was the imperative duty of councils to apply to the General Government to take
charge of the matter, as has been done in cases where two States do not agree upon
what shall be done. "Our harbor is in great danger from a power over which we
have no control."
   John Price Wetherill thought the riparian commissions of New Jersey had done all
that could be required of them. They are ready to extend their line 700 feet ; and
New Jersey, instead of being a laggard, seems likely to be a little ahead of Philadel-
phia in improving the channel. He thought the unanimous action of the three bodies
representing the commercial interests of the city-the Commercial and Maritime Ex-
             APPENDIX G--REPORT              OF LIEUT. COL. ROBERT.                   697
changes and the Board of Trade-was sufficient to show that the improvements were
wanted. The widening of Delaware avenue would be a proper city expense ; and he
thought with proper co-operation between the corporate and private interests the im-
provements could be brought about.
   " We improve the property for the benefit of the city at large," said Mr. Burton,
" and we lose by it."
   Harbor-master Lawrence said the city wanted to be informed as to what her people
want, and he claimed that the corporation was never slow in the matter of public im-
provements. He added that great public improvements for the public good were not
stopped because of individual inconveniences.
   "I am in favor of extending the wharves," said Mr. Fitzpatrick, "no matter who
pays for it. I have had an experience as a ship and wharf owner for over thirty years,
and I know the necessity of encouraging commerce. Every vessel which comes here
distributes from $500 to $10,000 among the people who most need it, and we can not
expect to do a large business unless we show that we appreciate it by providing the
proper facilities."
   Hyman L. Lipman, speaking " merely as a citizen and as one who had no knowl-
edge of the engineering features of the proposition," expressed the belief that unless
efforts are made to bring trade here it will be diverted elsewhere. The great mistake
Philadelphia made, he thought, was in giving League Island to the Government. If
that is not to be used as a naval station or a gun foundry steps should be taken to get
it back, when it could be used greatly to the benefit of the commerce of the port.

                                PRESIDENT ROBERTS TALKS.

    President George B. Roberts, of the Pennsylvania Railroad Company, was then
called upon to give his views in the matter, particularly with reference to the atti-
tude of the New Jersey authorities. Mr. Roberts said that, with the engineers of the
company, he had looked into the subject and had reached the conclusion that nothing
but the removal of Smith's Island would afford the facilities needed, and that that
would be of no use unless the New Jersey authorities agreed to extend the riparian
line at least half the distance, which, he believed, ought to be done to produce the
best effect.    The commissioners indicated a willingness to do what the engineers
deemed right in reference to moving out the line so as to make the channel clear
when the island is removed. "As an engineer," continued Mr. Roberts, " I believe
that if this is done the difficulties in reference to the wharves will be largely remedied.
Our experience is in the line indicated by the gentleman who has complained of the
cost of maintaining them, but the cause is more due to the presence of Windmill Island
'than anything else. The island makes a deep and narrow channel on this side, and
it will have to be removed, and the water, being allowed to distribute more widely,
would have a proper depth.
    "In this matter it will not do to consider what is the interest of the individual. The
Pennsylvania Railroad will have to expend a very large sum, but it will be benefited
by it. If we are to bring our ferry up to what the future will require we must have
a different Warden's line. If the islands were removed there would then be an op-
portunity to improve the wharf properties and make them suited to the commerce of
the day. That they are not suitable is hardly worth arguing here to-day. Philadel-
phia gets nominally nothing for her piers, because they are nominally worth nothing.
Our duty now is to ascertain what is best for the city, and if any individual does not
see fit to improve, his property must remain unproductive, and those who do improve
will reap the benefit. It is absolutely necessary that the islands should be removed,
and the work is a trifling one in comparison with what it means for this city."

                        A SUGGESTION FROM PROFESSOR HAUPT.

  After Superintendent Sweigard had stated briefly that the Reading Railroad Com-
pany would join in the movement, Professor Haupt said he wanted to suggest one or
two thoughts which had not been touched upon. He said: " Suppose the changes
are made and the great ocean steam-ships can come to the piers along the city front
proper to load and discharge. This would necessitate enormous transportation of
freight and an engorgement would result. Then perhaps Philadelphia will not always
depend upon ferry connection with Camden, and in the event of the construction of
a bridge the island would be found to be an advantage." He suggested a division of
the commerce, the foreign vessels being received, say, at the mouth of the Schuylkill,
while the upper wharves could be used for domestic commerce.
  Francis Cope thought that wharf-owners generally would be glad to take advan-
tage of any chance to extend.
  Mr. Stevenson read a letter from General Manager McLeod stating that the Reading
Company would assist in any movement for the improvement of the port, and would
698      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

extend their pier at Willow street as nearly as possible simultaneously with the re-
moval of the island.
  Finally, upon motion of Mr. Winsor, a resolution was passed urging the carrying
out of the plan, and Mr. Cook suggested that with a view of furthering the project
the meeting had better adjourn, subject to the call of the chair, which was agreed to.
  After a few remarks by Congressman O'Neill, in which he expressed his cordial ap-
proval of the conclusion reached and promised his hearty co-operation, the meeting
adjourned.


       LETTER FROM LEONARD MYERS, ATTORNEY FOR WILLIAM LONGSTRETIT.

                                                      PHILADELPHIA, March 28, 1888.
   DEAR SIR: By a recent act of Congress you are authorized to report upon the con-
dition of Smith's, Windmill, and other islands and shoals or bars in the river Delaware
opposite to Philadelphia, which it is proposed to remove in the interest of commerce,
and also the probable cost of such removal.
   To the north and east of Smith's Island, and separated from it by a narrow channel
only, is an island of 10 acres and 91 perches, which, upon survey, was granted by the
State of Pennsylvania to Joseph Fox and Moses Preston by patent dated December
30, 1831.
   This patent and the mesne conveyances by which the title vested in the present
owner, William Longstreth, are recorded in the office of the recorder of deeds of Phila-
delphia County, and the taxes upon said island have been regularly paid.
   The Engineer's Department of the Army has for the past eight years been endeav-
oring to dredge and keep open a channel through Mr. Longstreth's island, treating it
as a bar (and calling it Smith's Island Bar), because, as they state, it is slightly below
mean low water. It is well known, however, that this has not always been the case,
and your yearly official report shows that the constant accretions and filling up have
caused considerable expense to keep the channel open. In fact, a comparatively small.
expenditure would fill up Mr. Longstreth's island and make it very valuable.
   He has always deemed the channel to be in the interest of commerce, but very prop-
erly the War Department was notified of his rights to the island, now owned in his
family for thirty-five years.
   So careful of these rights has the State of Pennsylvania been that many years ago
when it was proposed to cut a channel through this island an act of the legislature
granting the authority provided that " the consent of the owners be first obtained."
   Mr. Longstreth believes that the removal of these islands in the Delaware will be of
great benefit to our national commerce.
   Congress having inquired the probable cost of such removal, he authorizes you to
report that he will accept from the Government for his said property and all loss of
its removal the sum of $5,000.
       I am, very respectfully, yours,
                                                                LEONARD MYERS,
                                                      Attorney for William Longstreth.
  Col. WILLIAM P.    CRAIGHILL,
                   Corps of Engineers,
           President Board of Engineers, U. S. A.




                                          G 2.

          IMPROVEMENT OF FRANKFORD CREEK, PENNSYLVANIA.

   No work was done on Frankford Creek during the last fiscal year,
and no appropriation for its improvement has been made since that of
August 2, 1882, appropriating $10,000. This amount was practically
expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1883, in the forma-
tion of a dredged channel 7 feet deep at mean low water, and extend-
ing from the mouth of the creek to above Bridge Street Bridge, Brides-
burgh.
   This creek is entirely within the corporate limits of Philadelphia,
and it is understood to be regulated by the municipal authorities. It
                        APPENDIX G--REPORT                                            OF LIEUT.                         COL. ROBERT.                            699
is not considered in the interest of commerce and navigation to recom-
mend further appropriations.
  Frankford Creek lies wholly within the port of entry of Philadelphia, at which
the revenue collected during the year ending December 31, 1887, amounted to
$17,878,424.46. The nearest fort and light-houses are, respectively, Fort Mifflin and
Horseshoe Range Lights.
Total appropriations to June 30, 1888 ........................ .... ......                   $10, 000. 00
Total expenditures to June 30, 1888 ...------............. --......---......------.....----.   9,735. 50

                                                                    Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available -------..----......----......-------....-----...............------- ....----                                                  $264. 50
July 1, 1888, balance available .----............----       . ...---- ..........--..---...---.                                                                264. 50
    Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.-...30,000.00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.

                                                                COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.


             Arrivals and departures of vessels during the year ending December 31, 1887.

                                                         Class.                                                             Arrivals.                  Departures.


                                                                                                                           No.        Tons.            No.    Tons.
Sailing vessels.......................................................                                                     110        10, 500          110     10, 500
Barges .-------------------------------------------------------                                                             25         5, 000           25      5, 000

          Total ............................................                                                    .....      135        15, 500          135      15, 500



                                                                                Imports.

                                                               Articles.                                                                   Quantity.          Value.


Wood--.....-----....--.--..---.....--.-----...........----------.....----------------....................--...-------......----cords..          1,000        $4,250.00
Coal----.........            ---............            ...........       .................................-----                 tons .         5,000        15,000.00
Lumber.--...-------........--.....---------.........---.--..-------------------.-----.---................----....---....          feet..   2, 500, 000       20, 000.00
Sand .--..----..----..................------........-------.-----.--.--.......-----...-------..-----------.........----.... tons.               3, 000        4, 500.00
Soda-ash     ......----......---------..-------..........-----.......----------.....---...-----.....--.......------..--.........  do...         1, 000       30, 000.00
fBay --..........----.......................------------.....-------.............--------.--------------------..............       do..            500        2,500.00

          Total ............................                             .............           .......................                    ........         76, 250.00


The above information was furnished by the Mason Fruit Jar Company, of Brides-
burg.



                                                                                  G 3.

                   IMPROVEMENT OF SCHUYLKILL RIVER, PENNSYLVANIA.

     No operations have been in progress during the past fiscal year since
the appropriation of $18,750, approved August 5, 1886, was practically
exhausted, in the year ending June 30, 1887.
  The present project proposes the formation of a channel 400 feet wide
and 24 feet deep at mean low water from the mouthof the river to Girard
Point, adistance of about 1 mile; from thence to Gibson's Point, a further
distance of about 3 miles, a channel 20 feet deep, and 200 feet wide; from
thence to Chestnut Street Bridge, Philadelphia, a distance of about 3
miles, a channel of navigable width and 18 feet deep at mean low water.
This latter reach of river has required no other improvement than the
700,    REPORT OF THE CItIEF OF              ENGINEERS,       U. 8. ARMY.

removal of about 1,000 cubic yards of rock near Locust and South
streets. The channels proposed are to be obtained by dredging, at an
estimated cost of $485,000, of which amount $368,750 has been appro-
priated.
   The present demands of commerce limit the requirement of an im-
proved condition of river channel to that part of the river lying between
the mouth and Gibson's Point, or the lower 4 miles of the river. At
Girard Point are located large grain elevators and wharves. At Gib-
son's Point and Point Breeze, which are near each other and closely
related as to commercial requirements, are the large storage tanks and
shipping wharves of the petroleum oil refineries. The large interests
assembled at these three points cover mainly the commerce of the
Schuylkill River, and both the grain and oil trade require deep-draft
vessels for the proper and economical transaction of their business.
Channel depths should exist which would permit the passage of vessels
at all stages of the tide between the mouth of the river and Gibson's
Point drawing 24 feet of water. As it now is, deep-draft vessels are
permitted to move only at high water, or else are obliged to lighter
part of their cargoes.
    The work which has been applied to the river between the mouth and
Gibson's Point has resulted in producing a channel from 150 to 200 feet
wide and 20 feet deep at mean low water. Between Gibson's Point and
Girard Point the deepened channel has been permanent, but between
Girard Point and deep water in the Delaware River the maintenance
of the dredged channel has not been satisfactory.
    As previously stated the project proposes a depth of 24 feet at mean
low water between Girard Point and the Delaware River. Between
1875 and 1878 this part of the river was deepened to 24 feet by the
removal of 242,000 cubic yards of material; in 1880 it had shoaled to
about 20 feet. Between 1881 and 1884 it was again deepened to 24 feet
  by the removal of 266,000 cubic yards of material; in 1887 a survey was
made of this part of the river and it was found that the channel had
again shoaled to 20 feet. To redredge the channel to a depth of 24 feet
for a width of 300 feet would require the removal of about 250,000 cubic
yards of material, or about the quantity which has been twice removed
since 1875.
    The shoaling principally occurs over a portion of the channel about
1,500 feet in length and situated directly at the river mouth. The
shoaling is mainly due to the abrupt angle at which the tidal currents
of the Schuylkill meet those of the Delaware River, and also to the
  abnormal width of the former river at this point. From the experience
  of the past it seems highly probably that, instead of attempting to
maintain the desired depth of 24 feet in this part of the river by dredg-
  ing, it would be more assuredly and economically accomplished by the
aid of a dike so placed as to produce tidal concentration upon the shoal
area.
  The work which has been done is of great benefit to commerce, and
the further improvement of the river would be of great advantage. If
funds become available for continuing the improvement of the river a
project will be submitted covering the improvement of the bar at the
river's mouth by means of a (like in connection with dredging.
  An appropriation of $75,000 is recommended for the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1890, and if an appropriation is made it will be applied in
furtherance of the approved project.
  This work lies in the collection district of Philadelphia, at which, as a port of en-
try, there was collected during the year endilig I)ecember 31, 1887, revenue to the
          F''                            U                       /                     / --
  1      1...0   2-          121 .        2.      25    2            22     17


",---                           .    .    .       ..                         -*                                                                                          "_                       -_                _


                                                                                   2           "21 .                                                                                                           ---

                                                                                                 -7-=                         r.-.,., _             -":,
                                                                                                                                                      . :                                              = _:




                            SKETCH164262I


                                                                                               S T-                      -- -- .- ." "i t                                62        0'




Girar d Point                                  to the Mouth,:-.:7..                                                                    6 2             .                                                     r
                 From                    a survoy                                          _              .                        si-                      "

   made          under                   the direction                                 of                         I       .                                                   ____-_
          Scal                                0                            toooFee
  Lieut.Col.Henry M.Robert                                                                                                         Wo       ,3.W,7 i                           ____


        (orps of Engineers,U.S.A                                               (ol,_1           of
                                                                                                                                                                     o~"       s
                                                                                                                                                                                            ___
                                                                                                                                                                                                       s




                                                                                                                               5
                                                                                                                              .14"                                                                           -"-


                                                                               -                                         /                                          2"
                                                                                    :..
                                                                           -rd.nt---Ma--=" /.s / /                       :.        I/           "                                                 tII-


                                                            U..r1-5
                                                            . -.    2
                                                                  5 i9                            /6
                                                                                                 51               2       61  2.       13
                                                                                                                                     051
                                                                                                                                      12
                                                                                                                                       25                           . -2 1- 5                - 1 9 -2         2
                                                             S-----                                  9.       /           .             "                                               -     9




                                                            2-1-5----4 - 22
                                                                            !::i:          5
                                                                                               --
                                                                                                 1-/2.  tiI f,1'
                                                                                                /5",./9"7 .2
                                                                                                        15/ 7"-."1
                                                                                                   2.-%---2
                                                                                                      25 /5"-
                                                                                                           2./                     25~          to              5         7 ..
                                                                                                                                                                            5      ""4 2
                                                                                                                                                                                   215 21              y'3
                                                                                                                                                                                                              21- 2 .'




                                              -- '"3.5               3.5./Q/           15-.5          26.5                    19." 1                        20           21        24."'24.5


                              537'                                     /                   /                                                2       .           6""255 28"                    265            29"




                 5     .A5     11        ..3.                1       2 .    27" 26.3                 2    8 .6.t              6    28 29 " S30                           30 .5          30   . S0            285


            a.   to1    1     17      ,i'2             265       27.27       27        .   27        28.1         28.5             o30          29                  o.        29.5          29"     28-5             28.
                  APPENDIX "G--REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. ROBERT.                                                                                  701

amount of $17,878,424.46. Tle nearest fort and light-houses are, respectively, Fort
Mifflin and Schuylkill River range-lights.
Total appropriations to June 30, 1888...... .........                                             .............                       $368, 750.00
Total expenditures to June 30, 1888--------... ...-.........                                                      _..-.....            368, 519. 13

                                                     Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available.----..-------------..........------........................-----------------..                               434.87
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887..---..        -......-...           ..............                   .....--.                                    204.00

July 1, 1888, balance available............ .. .....   ........                                                                             230.87
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.........................                                                                  25, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.......                                                         -........--.       25,230.87
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project------.......                                                           91, 250. 00
J Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                                            75,000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                 COMMERCIAL              STATISTICS.

          Arrivals and departures of vessels during the year ending December 31, 1887.
Steamers (not including tugs)----.                          ..............              ......--....              --...............              83
Sailing vessels-----------....---....-- ----......--------....----...--------.. ----..........---.......---............-- 501
Barges ---.. ----....-------...............----...---...       ----....--..........---....---..---..--....------....----. 260
         Total----.... -----......---......---........                            --------------
                                              ------...................----------...--....--........                                             44

                                                     Freight statement.
Received:
   Iron ore .....................................................                                 tons..                                    1, 022
    Barrels (empty) ......--......--..--..............-------....----........------------....-----........                                887, 341
      Miscellaneous merchandise ............                             ............             ........          .... tons..             25, 978
Shipped :
    Grain .....................--------..--.............-------------....--...---......                      bushels..                  4,967,497
    Flour-----------
          ............---------------....                                                      ---....---......
                                                                     ------....--............--......--...... barrels-..                     45, 000
    Petroleum (crude and refined) ..................................                                              do...
                                                                                                                     -                  1, 236, 235
                                                                                 ------.....------- cases..
          Do ...............------------....----.................--------------.......                                                  4,809, 960
          Do ---------..................-----........-------------......-.....------.----.----.
                   .                                                                                         gallons..                  6, 707, 935
    Miscellaneous merchandise......--                        ..--...... ...............                    .... tons..                       13,975
  The above information was furnished by five different firms most largely interested
in the improvement of the Schuylkill River.




                                                                 G 4.

   IMPROVEMENT OF ICE-HARBOR AT MARCUS HOOK, PENNSYLVANIA.

   The river and harbor act approved August 5, 1886, appropriated
$15,000 for improving ice-harbor at Marcus Hook, Pa.                                                                           Under date
of August 17, 1886, a project was submitted and approved August
25, wherein it was proposed to apply so much of this appropriation as
might be necessary to removing the stone superstructure of Pier No.
6, and rebuilding it at the lower end of the harbor on the line of Pier
No. 7 and the shore pier upon a timber crib foundation. The stone
superstructure of Pier No. 6 was built in 1881 upon a pile foundation and
had given evidences of weakness by settling towards the channel of the
702     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

river. Pier No. 5, the companion to No. 6, careened in 1882, shortly
after its completion, and was subsequently rebuilt on a crib foundation.
   Under date of March 24, 1887, a contract was made with Mr. Ira
Lunt for the construction and placing of the timber crib foundation at
the point before named, and for removing the stone superstructure
from Pier No. 6 and replacing it upon the new foundation.
   During the past fiscal year the proposed new pier has been com-
pleted and the pile foundation of Pier No. 6 removed, two groups of
mooring piles placed between existing piers, and the available deep-
water area of the harbor increased to 10 acres by dredging 58,000 cubic •
yards from the previous shoal area at the lower end of the harbor.
   At the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1887, the construction
of the timber crib which was to form the substructure for the new pier
was in progress. Under the above named contract with Mr. Ira Lunt.
the crib foundation has been completed, sunk in position, and the super-
structure removed from Pier No. 6 and placed upon the crib foundation
thus prepared for it.
    Influenced by borings on file in the office, which indicated hard bottom
suitable for the crib foundation at the proposed site of the new pier at
a depth of 25 feet below mean low water, the timber crib foundation
was built 25 feet high. Before placing the crib additional boring.s
developed the fact that the character of the bottom at the site of the
proposed pier was such as to require the foundation to be carried to a
depth of 30 feet below mean low water before a substratum was reached
which was sufficiently unyielding to bear the weight which would be
imposed upon it by the proposed pier. To accomplish this the trench
to receive the crib foundation was excavated to a depth of 30 feet be-
low mean low water and then filled to a height of 25 feet below mean
low water with random stone carefully leveled to receive the timber
crib substructure.
   The stone required to form this foundation amounted to 559 cubic
yards, and being outside of the contract with Mr. Ira Lunt for the con-
struction of the pier, was furnished by Messrs. Lieper & Lewis under
informal proposals at the rate of $1.08 per cubic yard.
   The entire cost of the pier, including the additional foundation, was
$8,289.79. The cost for a similar pier built tvo years previous was
$15,600.
   The low price at which the contract was made for building the pier
left a balance available for further work of about $5,400 from the
$15,000 on hand. Under date of August 10, 1887, a modified project
for the expenditure of this balance of $5,400 was submitted to the Chief
of Engineers, recommending its application for the removal of the piles
which formed the previous foundation for Pier No. 6, the placing of two
groups of mooring piles between the inner row of ice-piers, and the
dredging of about 60,000 cubic yards of material from the shoal area at
the lower end of the ice-harbor. This recommendation was approved
August 17, 1887, and under an agreement with the American Dredging
Company, derived from informal proposals, the pile foundation of Pier
No. 6 was removed for $200, two groups of mooring piles were placed
for $200, and 58,000 cubic yards of material dredged at the rate of 71
cents per cubic yard.
   This dredging increased the area of that part of the ice-harbor which
is under the protection of the piers from 6 to 10 acres. The depth at
low water which now covers this area is from 20 to 24 feet.
  As previously stated, Piers Nos. 5 and 6 were originally built in 1881
upon a, pile foundation. Pier No. 5 careened in 1882, and was subse-
-                                                                                                                                                                                                              --                                    --
                                                                                                                                                                           o accompany ,,            nhI42pu~zZ oret or1888 .

                                                                                                          SKET CH
                                                                                                                   OF                                                                           ,.LGG.c.            OJ .oRnI                ",.      U/.0   a.
    26,'                                                         za.ICE-HARBOR AT MARCUS HOOK,                                                                                                                                                          I
                                                                                                       5.PENN SLVANIA.
                 25.7                                                         From a          Survey          mnacle     under       lthe direction                                                                 26.0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          26 2

    259                       25.    4                                                                             Or                                                                                     25.7                            267
                  35'2                          5.3                                   Lieut. Col. Henry M. Robert ,                                                                        6                        257                    (.
                                                                                                              18                               7                                                6.        25.7
    261            25          2                 5.3                  Scale: 0          200         400           600o         00    1000       120 Fee                                   66                                                 2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    2626
                   24.8                                                                                                                                                                                   z26.                              2
    24.4.64.6
                   25.1
                                                 25.
                                                 z5                               .                                       20.
                                                                                                                                                                                  3       26. 2            5.7           -                  2.95 2.7
                                      5.         25.3                           25, 6                                                                        26   9                                       257            5
                24'Cu6v                                                                                24.9   2                         26.        ~26.9                                                                     .              25.5
                                                                                               e

                                                  24,8
                                                ....        2.    2...
                                                                 425.0.'26.                                               7                                                 ...           24                                                225
                     22.  2         3-230                                                                                                                                                                        28 .            ..                         ...
      .4             z'.&                                                      69 30...
                                                                                     . 7, .2....
                                                                                              , .. 2.3                                  2
    2124                                                                                                                 221,,2760
                                                                                                                                              -----
                                                                                                                                              23    .2....    ..
                                                                                                                                                               ".o              ; 3   4     .        25    "            250
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         2 .          .          6

                                                                       .01.c3..5..4...
                                                                       "      . .    ..   28.3....
                          2   ,     21.4              22   .3        ... .... •......33.o..                                                            .......        ..   ..




       E-               2--                                      .      i     .---.                I              ..      .I   7I._..               : ,'-..'
                                                                                                                                                       --    ."            ."




       Eng50 2

                                            -
         APPENDIX     G--REPORT     OF LIEUT. COL. ROBERT.           703
quently rebuilt on a crib foundation. Pier No. 6 had also given evi-
dences of the instability of its foundation, which threatened it with the
fate of No. 5. To avert such disaster the stone superstructure was
removed and placed upon a crib foundation at the lower end of the
harbor.
    The specifications under which the two piers were built in 1881 re-
quired the piles forming the foundations to be driven to a depth of 36
feet below mean low water; at this depth hard bottom would have been
reached. In removing the piles from the foundation of No. 6 it was
found that they had only been driven to a depth of from 291 to 311 feet
below mean low water, or from 6J to 4. feet less than the depth required
by the specifications and the character of the bottom. The piles were
driven therefore into a very soft clay without passing through it and
leaching a h'ard bottom, and the fair inference is that the principal
cause for the failure of the foundations of Piers Nos. 5 and 6 was the
improper character of the work done by the contractor. The contract
for this work was with the Mount Waldo Granite Company, and the
work was done for that company by Ira Lunt.
    The harbor is of considerable value to the commerce of the river
during the winter season. Its utility will continue even when the pro-
posed ice-harbor at the head of Delaware Bay is built, since the ice-
harbor at Marcus Hook will always be valuable as a refuge for vessels
in the upper part of the river. The value of the harbor to vessels seek-
ing temporary refuge from ice is somewhat reduced from the practice of
vessel owners utilizing the harbor as a place in which their vessels are
permanently placed during the winter season.
    In 1880 and 1881 the project for the improvement of this harbor was
amended by providing for the construction of a bulkhead about 1,800
feet in length parallel with the shore-line and about 150 feet outside of
high-water line, together with the deepening by dredging of the area
in front of the bulkhead to a depth of 15 feet at the present low-water
line, and decreasing to 10 feet depth alongside of the bulkhead. (See
Report Chief of Engineers, 1882, pages 751-755.)
    In subsequent action towards carrying into effect this amendment of
the project an obstacle arose from the unwillingness of certain riparian
owners to voluntarily authorize the construction of the bulkhead along
their property frontage. This difficulty has not yet been removed, and
even if it could be it is doubtful whether in the light of past experience
the advantages of the bulkhead would not be neutralized by its being
largely used by vessel owners as a place of safety and free wharfage
for their vessels during the winter season of disuse. This has been the
practice of the past at the landing piers, and while it enables the
owners of such vessels to escape dock and wharf charges, it encumbers
  the harbor unnecessarily. Against such improper use of a harbor there
  seems to be no present protective legislation or authority.
     It is highly probable that the area directly in front of the bulkhead,
  lying as it does under the lee of the landing piers, would rapidly shoal
  from the deposition of river sediment, and would therefore require fre-
  quent dredging in order to maintain the proposed depths along the
  bulkhead. The present harbor has a protected area of about 10 acres,
  carrying a depth of from 18 to 24 feet at mean low water. This area,
  with a slight addition to be obtained by dredging along the inner line
  of the harbor, will be fairly commensurate with the present require-
  ments of commerce, and is probably as large as would be actually avail-
  able to commerce if the bulkhead were built.
704         REPORT OF            THE CHIEF             OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  For the foregoing reasons I would recommend that the hitherto pro-
posed increase of harbor area and facilities by the construction of the
bulkhead, and the subsequent dredging of the area immediately in front
thereof, be abandoned for the present, and that such funds as may be-
come available be applied to the full development of the present harbor.
   The two landing or shore piers built by the United States in 1867-'68
are in immediate need of rebuilding above the water-line on account of
the decay of their timber supeistructures, and both the substructure
and superstructure of the oldest ice-piers require repair. The exten-
sion of the deep-water areas of the harbor should also be accomplished
by additional dredging.
   The work accomplished during the past fiscal year exhausted avail-
able funds.
   An appropriation of $30,000 is recommended for the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1890, to be expended in repairs and dredging.
  This work is located in the collection district of Philadelphia.                         This is the nearest
port of entry, the collections during the year ending December 31, 1887, amounting
to $17,878,424.46.  The nearest fort and light-house are, respectively, Fort Mifflin and
Christiana Light.
Total appropriations from 1866 to June 30, 1888...-------...--..--..--...-......                      $194,000.00
Total expenditures from 1866 to June 30, 1888 .................                            ........    193, 919. 29

                                            Money statement.
                                                                            .....
July 1, 1887, amount available.......----...... ......---------......---------             6,586.54
July 1, 1887, covered by existing contracts........--...--... ......                       7, 621.60
                                                                                       -----             $14, 208. 14
July 1, 1888, amount expended        during     fiscal     year,      exclusive   of     liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.......------.....---   ------...------..--......... ---..-......---------....  14,127.43
July 1, 1888, balance available......-----......       ---........-..
                                         -----......---....--         --.                                    80.71
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.........................                                  15, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889.................- .                               15, 080. 71

 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....... 20, 000. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890 20, 000.00
 ) Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
 ( harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.


                                                       G 5.
            ICE-HARBOR AT HEAD OF DELAWARE BAY, DELAWARE.

    The act of August 2, 1882, contained an appropriation of $25,000 for
" ice-harbor at head of Delaware Bay, and for removal of sunken piers
in channel back of Reedy Island, Delaware." The sum of $3,700 was
expended in 1883, in removing the sunken piers at Reedy Island, and
$5,023.07 has since been expended in surveys, examinations, and office
expenses.
  The importance of this ice-harbor has been fully set forth in previous
reports, but the difficulties connected with it are so great that I do not
think there has yet'been any satisfactory solution proposed. From all
the information I have obtained, the inclosing of the area by a barrier
that will prevent the ingress and egress of ice will be no improvement
upon the plan of detached ice-breakers as heretofore used in this river.
But the question of the most economical eonstruction for the ice-break-
              APPENDIX           G---REPORT OF LJEUT. COL. ROBERT.                                     705
ers, whether they should be stone piers, pile piers, or floating pontons,
requires more study than has yet been given to the subject.
Total appropriations to June 30, 1888 -----.......              --........................ $25, 00.00
Total expenditures to June 30, 1888 ..................                 ..................    8, 723. 07

                                          Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available------.......------......------------..........--.................. $17, 493. 30
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887--......--...... ....... .-....           ..........        ..      . .   1,216. 37
July 1, 1888, balance available.........----------.........---------......-------.............    16,276.93




                                                    G 6.

CONSTRUCTION OF IRON PIER IN DELAWARE BAY, NEAR LEWES, DEL-
                           AWARE.
   No work has been done during the past fiscal year. The last appro-
priation made was that of $13,000 on August 2, 1882, which was ex-
pended between that date and the close of the fiscal year ending June
30, 1884, in repairs to the wooden superstructure of the pier.
   The design of the pier provided for a substructure of wrought-iron
screw-piles surmounted with a timber superstructure or platform.
   The decay of the timber superstructure is very rapid, and to make
the pier of value the superstructure must be maintained with unim-
paired strength. Parts weakened by decay must be removed early in
their deterioration and be replaced by sound material. This renders
the life of the timber of short duration, and consequently the cost of
maintenance large. To add to the quantity of perishable material in a
wooden superstructure would be only to increase largely the cost of its
maintenance.
   By the act of July 15, 1870, the railroad having its terminus in the
vicinity of the pier was granted the privilege " to extend their railroad
upon and over said pier and to freely use said pier in connection with
their said road, subject to such regulations and charges for maintenance
and repairs as the Secretary of War may adopt." The railroad com-
pany have not yet exercised this privilege. The present wooden super-
structure was designed several years ago before the adoption of the
present heavier weights of engines and rolling stock. These increased
weights render the present plan of wooden superstructure entirely too
light for the increased loads which would be brought upon the pier in
its use by the railroad company. On account of the perishable charac-
ter and inadequate strength of the timber superstructure there seems
to be a call for a modification of the hitherto proposed plan so as to
adjust it to tbe demands of modern railroad construction. In accord.
ance with the requirements of-the Senate resolution of March 12, 1886,
a special report was submitted by the officer in charge, under date of
April 2, 1886 (see Rieport of the Chief of Engineers for 1886, pages
837-839), providing for a modification in the hitherto proposed timber
superstructure.
   The plan as therein described proposes an iron superstructure with
paved surfaces outside of the areas occupied by the railroad tracks upon
the pier-head, and an iron superstructure carrying the track upon the
approach to the pier-head, combined with the use of timber for the
       ENG 88-      45
    706           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

    deck-covering over that part of the area of the approach not occupied
    by the railroad tracks. Such an iron superstructure, with a strength
    fully equal to the requirements of railroad traffic, could be built for
    about $93,000, and maintained at a trifling cost for repairs, rendering
    available the permanent iron superstructure, which has been built at a
    cost of over $300,000.
       A wooden superstructure, giving the same strength when new as the
    proposed iron superstructure, would cost at first probably $40,000, and
    would practically have to be entirely removed each ten years, so that
    its aggregate cost would in the end exceed that of an iron superstructure.
    Even with the above expenditure for repairs the wooden superstructure
    would frequently be in a condition of impaired strength.
       The pier at present is used as a landing place by those who desire to
    communicate with the shore from vessels entering Delaware Breakwater
    Harbor; by the Light-house Establishment for the temporary storing of
    material, and by the Quarantine service in connection with the marine
    hospital located at Cape Henlopen.
       During the gale of March 12, 1888, twenty-seven vessels were wrecked
    in Delaware Breakwater Harbor, and at that time the schooner E. V.
    Mason, becoming unmanageable, was blown against the north side of the
    pier near its shore end. Five of the wrought-iron screw-piles of the outer
    row were injured by the collision to the extent of two being broken and
    the other three bent over. The lateral bracing of these piles was also
    displaced, and with it the timber superstructure covering the half width
    of the pier at the place of injury for about 125 linear feet of the pier.
    A passage-way about 10 feet wide connects the uninjured parts of the
    pier.
       To properly repair the pier the five injured piles and their connecting
-   brace-rods will require to be removed; the two broken piles will have
    to be repaired or replaced by new ones, as may be deemed best after
    their removal, and the three bent piles straightened, after which the
    piles can be replaced in their original positions and the superstructure
    restored. The timber required to repair the superstructure could be
    obtained from material on'hand. The cost of restoring the injured
    part of the pier to its original condition would probably reach $6,000,
    which is required at once.
       If the project for an iron superstructure, previously referred to, should
    be approved, an appropriation of the entire amount estimated, namely,
    $93,000, is recommended for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, as
    when the change of superstructure is begun the pier will be useless until
    the new superstructure is completed. This is in addition to the $6,000
    required for repairs.
       The pier is in the collection district of Delaware, the nearest port of entry being
    Wilmington, where the amount of revenue collected during the year ending December
    31, 1887, was $2,053.06. The nearest fort and light-house are, respectively, Fort Dela-
    ware and the Delaware Breakwater light.
    Total appropriations to June 30, 1888 ..................                               .............               $.
                                                                                                                       $368, 500. 00
    Total expenditures to June ^30, 1888 .............................                                     ___......     368, 375. 06

                                                      Money statement.
    July 1, 1887, amount available ..........................................                                               $124. 94
    July 1, 1888, balance available ..................                        ......------- __......--......------..
                                                                                                                --           124.94

       Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........                                           15, 000.00
       Submitted in coumpliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
          harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
         APPENDIX    G--REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. ROBERT.               707

                                  G 7.

IMPROVEMENT OF HARBOR AT DELAWARE            BREAKWATER, DELAWARE.

   No operations have been in progress during the past fiscal year,
available funds from the appropriation of $56,250 by act approved
August 5, 1886, having been practically exhausted at the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1887.
   The work which has been in progress since the adoption of the exist-
ing project in 1882 has had for its object the closing of the gap be-
tween the breakwater and the ice-breaker by the deposition of the
random stone which is to form the substructure of the work. It was
estimated in the project upon which the present work is based, that
the net volume of the random stone foundation would be about 87,500
cubic yards. From the experience gained in the construction of the
breakwater and ice breaker it is found that each cubic yard of those
structures represents li gross tons of random stone. From this data
the 87,500 cubic yards of foundation would require about 131,000 gross
tons of stone.
   There have been 60,762 tons of stone already placed in the gap, leav-
ing about 70,000 tons yet to be placed to supply the volume of the orig-
inal estimate, provided no allowance is made for the mattresses used
in the foundation.
    At the prices which have been paid under the three contracts in force
since the work of closing the gap was commenced in 1885, and allowing
for superintendence, the cost of completing the foundation would be
about $175,000. This work could be accomplished in two seasons if the
funds therefor were available.
    The completion of the foundation would be followed by the construc-
tion of the concrete superstructure, which was estimated at about
$370,000, including the necessary plant. From this it will be seen that
it will probably require more than the $418,750estimated in the money
statement to complete the work. But it is better to postpone a re-
vision of the estimate until after the commencement of the concrete
superstructure, or at least until the foundation is about completed.
    The importance of this work to both the commerce of the Delaware
River and the Atlantic coast is such as to justify sufficient appropria-
tions to complete the breakwater by closing the gap at the earliest date
possible.
    The Maritime Exchange of Philadelphia has established a station on
the breakwater and through telegraph-cables connecting the mainland
with their stations are in connection with the shipping of the harbor.
The reports of the Maritime Exchange state that during the year 1887,
5,751 vessels, exclusive of tugs, fishing, and small coasting craft, an-
chored under the protection of the breakwater.
    On March 12, 1888, the harbor was visited by a gale of almost un-
precedented violence, whereby 27 vessels lying in the harbor were
wrecked; most of the vessels were driven ashore, and so far as known
none of the wrecks have become obstructions or dangerous to naviga-
tion. The breakwater sustained no injury from the gale.
    During the present season, should funds become available, it is pro-
posed to continue the work of closing the gap between the breakwater
and ice-breaker by continuing the placing of stone in the substructure
of the work.
    An appropriation of $300,000 is recommended for the fiscal year end-
708              REPORT                    OF THE CHIEF           OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

ing June 30, 1890, and if an appropriation is made it will be applied
in furtherance of the approved project for closing the gap.
  This work is situated in the collection district of Delaware. Wilmington is the
nearest port of entry, at which the revenue collected during the year ending Decem-
ber 31, 1887, was $2,053.06. Fort Delaware is the nearest fort, and the Breakwater
Light the nearest light-house.
Total appropriations to June 30, 1888-----...........................-----------------------.. $2, 448, 353. 70
Total expenditures to June 30, 1888..--. ._.                     . ......-
                                                                        --....                  2, 447, 823. 61
Total appropriations under present project to June 30, 1888 -.... --......                         256, 250. 00
Total expenditures under present project to June 30, 188...----.....-..--                     .    255, 719.91

                                                          Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available ...........------------..------------------....................-----......--              $2, 685.97
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
   outstanding July 1, 1887 .---..............................
                                                      ----....                      ----.....-----.                       2, 155.88

July 1, 1888, balance available ................                  --    .   ..-............              .......            530. 09
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.... ...................                                                   100, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889-.---. .-...----..                                            . 100, 530. 09

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- ...... 318, 750.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended infiscalyearending June 30, 1890 300, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                        COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

Statement showing number of vessels calling at the Breakwater during the year ending De-
                                    cember 31, 1887.


                                        Class.                         For orders. For harbor. In distress.                Total.

Steamers...   .....................                .................      16     71 • 4      91
Ships .............................................                       12     33    2     47
Barks----------....-.....-----.......-----------------------------....    86    250    5    341
Brigs--...---..-......------..--...--......--........--------------..---------------....
                                                                          34     79    3    116
Schooners..................         ..-- .......... ......--         .... 41 5, 079   36 5, 156

      Total..........................................                         189               5, 512             50          5,751


   The above information was furnished by the Philadelphia Maritime Exchange.




                                                                G 8.
                       IMPROVEMENT OF RANCOCAS RIVER, NEW JERSEY.

   During the past fiscal year no work has been done on this river.                                                           The
last appropriation ($10,000) was made August 2, 1882, and available
funds were practically exhausted during the fiscal year ending June 30,
1883.
  The Rancocas River enters the Delaware at a point opposite Torres-
dale, or about 12 miles above the foot of Market street, in the port of
Philadelphia.
  The act of March 3, 1879, provided for a survey of the river from its
confluence with the Delaware to Pemberton, N. J.
                        APPENDIX                       G-REPORT OF LIEUT.                                              COL. ROBERT.                         709
  In 1881 the project was adopted for the formation by dredging of a
channel from 150 to 200 feet wide and 6 feet deep at mean low water from
the mouth to Centreton, a distance of 71 miles, and from thence a chan-
nel 5 feet deep to Mount Holly, 54 miles above Centreton. The esti-
mated cost of the work was $82,000.
  By act of March 3, 1881, $10,000 was appropriated for the work.
During the fiscal year 1881-'82 this amount was applied to the formation
of a channel 85 feet wide and 6, feet deep through the worst obstruction
on the lower river, known as Coates' Bar, which is about 4 miles above
the river's mouth. The work was accomplished by dredging and the
formation of a dike parallel with the channel and extending from the
north bank and the upper end of Hlamill's Island.
  By act of A ugust 2, 1882, $10,000 was appropriated to continue the
improvement. During the fiscal year 1882-'83 this amount was ex-
pended in widening to 150 feet the.channel through Coates' Bar.
  No operations are contemplated during the present season, as no
funds are available.
  In furtherance of the approved project, a channel with a low-water
depth of 6 feet should be dredged through the shoals between Coates'
Bar and Centreton at a cost which has been estimated at $22,000. This
amount could be profitably expended during the fiscal year ending June
30, 1890.
   Rancocas River is in the collection district of Trenton, N. J., which is the nearest
port of entry, at which no revenue was collected during the year ending December 31,
1887. The nearest fort is Fort Mifflin, and the Horseshoe Lights are the nearest light-
houses.
Total appropriations to June 30, 188.- - -.....................                                                                       ...........     $20, 000.00
Total,expenditures to June 30, 1888 .....................................                                                                              19,899.91

                                                                        Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available.........................................                                                                                   $100.09
July 1, 1888, balance available .........................................                                                                                  100. 09

    Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .. .... ....- 62, 000. 00
    Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal year ending June 30,1890 22, 000. 00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of the river
        and harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




                                                                  COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

              Arrivals and departures of vessels during the year ending December 31, 1887.


                                                Description.                                                              Arrivals.                 Departures.

                                                                                                                       No.      Tons.           No.        Tons.
Steamers (not including tugs) --..--......                                         ....................            .      385    52, 400          385        62, 000
Sailing vessels................................                                           -...-       .. ... ..        1, 490    73, 000        1,490        91, 600
Barges............................................----------------------------------------------..------........          610    80,000           610       124,000
Canal-boats.....--                     ........................ ........--..                           .........-- .   1, 450    78, 000        1,450        94, 000
           Total ..................                        .................................                           3, 935   283, 400        3, 935      371, 600
710                REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                                            Freight statcment.


                                                                 Articles.                                                       Quantity.           Value.

                                                                RECEIVED.

Lumber.................................                           ..      ...... .........         --......... feet..              2,800,000          $52, 000
Timber.........--...                   ..... .. ..... ..... ---.... ---.....---........... ..............          do.-..            700, 000           7, 000
Coal ............-----------------------.------------------------------- tons..-                                                      10, 200          40, 800
Machinery..............-----------                                                                            .........                    --..        10, 000
Lime..... .. .-..                  ...- ............   ...    .--...------- .. ..              ..    . bushels.-                       120,000         19, 600
Saltpeter, potash, etc........--..--..                                                ..... ..-----.. ......---_.. tons..                      500     20, 000
Brimstone................................................                                                               do...                860       17, 200
Manure ..           ..........       . ..............                 ........   .....    .............   ...... cart-loads..            12, 000       10, 800
Miscellaneous merchandise .....                                      ........        ..     -     . .......-..-..--....          ..........           120, 000

          Total .............................................................                                         ....      ............          297, 400

                                                                 SHIPPED.

Sand (molding)..........................................................tons..                                                         154, 000       462, 000
Fertilizers...............................................................                       do...                                   8, 500       250, 000
Fruit.                     -.............................................. ...... .......... baskets..                                  28, 000        12, 000
Vegetables ......................        .. .. .......... ..............           ......... do...                                     50, 000         25, 000
Canned goods ...-..        - -..... .. .... ...-.... ..... ....   ............-...... pounds.-                                     1, 800, 000         45, 000
          Total ...................................                              ........      .....      ......        ..--
                                                                                                                    .. ---       .......              794, 000


    The above information was furnished by Messrs. J. J. Allen's Sons, of Philadelphia,
Pa.




                                                                                       G g.

                       IMPROVEMENT OF WOODBURY CREEK, NEW JERSEY.

    No work of improvement has yet been done on this creek. The only
appropriation made therefor was $5,000, on August 2, 1882. With the
exception of $450.31 expended in 1882 for a survey of the creek, this
amount is yet available.
    Woodbury Creek discharges into the Delaware River about 8 miles
below Philadelphia, at a point opposite Fort Mifflin. Its confluence
forms the southern boundary of the Government reservation for site of
defenses at Red Bank, N. J.
    The plan of improvement based upon the survey of 1882 proposed the
formation, by dredging, of a temporary channel, 8 feet deep at high
water and 40 feet wide, between the mouth of the creek and the village
of Woodbury, a distance of about 4 miles, at an estimated cost of $15,000.
From the impossibility of the permanence of a dredged channel the im-
provement would be of little value unless provision is made for its main-
tenance. While citizens directly interested have expressed themselves
as willing to contribute a reasonable sum towards the maintenance of
the channel, there is no guaranty that a channel once formed by the
United States would be maintained by private effort. Since the forma-
  tion of a dredged channel to any point short of Woodbury would be of
no commercial value, and since any channel formed would not be perma-
  nent, the expenditure of available funds should be withheld, if the im-
  provement is to be made, until the funds available will permit the
  formation of the proposed channel in a single season. The additional
  sum of $10,500 could be profitablyexpended during the fiscal year end-
  ing June 30, 1890.
               APPENDIX           G-REPORT OF LIEUT.                             COL. ROBERT.                       711
   This work is in the collection district of Philadelphia, Pa., which is also the near-
est port of entry, at which the revenue collected during the year ending December
31, 1887, was $17,878,424.46.
   Fort Mifflin is the nearest fort, and the Schuylkill range-lights are the nearest light-
houses.
Total appropriations to June 30, 1888 ..................................                                       $5, 000. 00
Total expenditures to June 30, 1888 ....................................                                           450. 31

                                        COMMERCIAL         STATISTICS.


  No statistics could be obtained from parties interested in this improvement.

                                            Money statement.
                                                  ---..-
July 1, 1887, amount available---..- ....--..----....               ------ --... ---
                                                                    -..-..                       . ---.        $4, 549. 69
July 1, 1888, balance available.........................................                                        4,549.69

  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                       10,500.00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                    10,500.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




                                                      G 0o.
                 IMPROVEMENT OF MANTUA CREEK, NEW JERSEY.

  No work of improvement has yet been done oun this creek. The only
appropriation made therefor was $3,000, on August 2, 1882, the ex-
penditure of which was withheld, by order of the Secretary of War in
1883, until further appropriations should be made.
  Mantua Creek discharges into the Delaware River about 10 miles
below Philadelphia at a point abreast of Mifflin Bar. The stream in its
natural condition has a low-water depth of about 9 feet for a distance
of between 5 and 4 miles from its mouth. Above this the channel depth
slowly decreases until at Mantua, about 11 miles above the mouth,
there is a low-water depth of only 2 feet. The opinion of officers pre-
viously in charge was that there seems to be no necessity at present
for further appropriations, and none are recommended.
  This work is in the collection district of Philadelphia, Pa., which is also the near-
est port of entry, at which the revenue collected during the year ending December
31, 1887, was $17,878,424.46.
  Fort Mifflin is the nearest fort, and Tinicum and Fort Mifflin Bar range-lights are
the nearest light-houses.
Total appropriations to June 30, 1888..--..$---                                              ...-------------       3, 000

                                         COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

   No statistics could be obtained from parties interested in this improvement.

                                             Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available.....................                                          ....... ....--.   $3, 000. 00
July 1, 1888, balance available ..............                ............................                      3,000. 00

   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                      32, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 166 and 1867.
712          REPORT OF            'tIE      CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                                       G   Ii.

                 IMPROVEMENT OF RACCOON RIVER, NEW JERSEY.

   No work of improvement has yet been done on this river. The only
appropriation made therefor was $3,000, on August 2, 1882. With the
exception of a part expended in 1882 upon a survey of the river this
amount is yet available.
   The Raccoon River discharges into the Delaware about 20 miles be-
low Philadelphia, at a point opposite Marcus Hook Harbor.
   The proposed plan of improvement, based upon the survey of 1882,
proposes to make by dredging the navigation of the river safer and
less difficult up to Swedesborough, at an estimated cost of about $18,000.
By previous recommendation the appropriation of 1882 was withheld
from expenditure until additional appropriations are made.
   If the improvement is to be made, the sum of $16,000, in addition to
what has already been appropriated, could be expended in dredging
during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890.
   This work is in the collection district of Philadelphia, Pa., at which the revenue
collected during the year ending December 31, 1887, was $17,878,424.46.
   Fort Miffln is the nearest fort, and the Tinicum Island and Fort Mifflin Bar range-
lights the nearest light-houses.
Total appropriations to June 30, 1888 -................................----------   $3, 000.00
Total expenditures to June 30, 1888 ...................................           .     757.23

                                         COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  Mr. John Ford and Mr. J. L. Clark, of Swedesborough, N. J., report that there has
been no material change in the commerce of Raccoon River since the last statistics
furnished by them and published in my last annual report. (Report of Chief of
Engineers, 1887, page 811.)
                                             Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..........................................               $2, 242.77
July 1, 1888, balance available ...............................             .........    2, 242.77

   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890           16, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                       G    12.


                   IMPROVEMENT OF SALEM RIVER, NEW JERSEY.

  No work has been done on Salem River during the past fiscal year.
  Salem River discharges into the Delaware River by its natural mouth
at a point about 4 miles below Fort Delaware. At a point in the Dela-
ware River about 10 miles above the natural mouth of the Salem River
a canal was constructed by private enterprise, which connects with the
Salem River at the point of its nearest approach to the Delaware. Just
below the junction of this canal with Salem River a dam has been built
across the latter stream which essentially divides the river into two
parts, viz, from the natural mouth to the dam, and from the mouth of
the canal to the headwaters of the river.
  Under the act of July 11, 1870, a survey of the mouth of Salem IRiver
was ordered, which developed the existence of an obstruction consist-
         APPENDIX GQ-REPORT         OF LIEUT. COL. ROBERT.           713
ing of loose rock and gravel and bowlders embedded in tenacious clay,
which reduced the depth of water to about 6 feet at mean low water.
   The appropriation of March 3, 1871, of $4,000 was applied in 1871 to
the formation of a channel through this obstruction 200 feet wide and
9 feet deep at mean low water.
   The next appropriation was that made by act of June 18, 1878, of
$3,000 for continuing the work at the mouth of the river. The act also
provided for the survey of the river between Sharptown and the canal.
   On October 14, 1878, a contract was entered into with M. F. Brainard
for dredging, at the rate of 22 cents per cubic yard, a channel 8 feet
deep at mean low water and to as great a width as the funds would per-
mit. After removing 1,400 cubic yards the contract was annulled, on
account of the small progress made and the unsatisfactory character of
the plant.
   During the fiscal year 1879-'80, the balance on hand of the appropri-
ation of 1878 was applied in removing 6,034 cubic yards and the con-
sequent formation of a channel from 65 to 70 feet wide and 8 feet deep
through that part of the bar where previous dredging had been in
progress.
   On June 14, 1880, $3,000 was appropriated for continuing the im-
provement at the mouth, and applied in 1880-'81 to widening to 110 feet
the channel previously dredged.
   On March 3, 1881, $3,000 was appropriated for the improvement of
the river above the inner end of the canal, and during the fiscal year
1881-'82 this amount was expended in dredging a channel from 6 to 7
feet deep at low water and 60 feet wide from the head of the canal to a
point near Biddle's Landing.
   On August 2, 1882, $1,500 was appropriated for continuing the im-
provement, but the smallness of the amount to be expended rendered
theproposals for dredging excessive, and, further work being postponed,
the appropriation of August 2, 1882, has remained on hand since that
date.
   At the point where the creek most nearly approached the Delaware
River, in the vicinity of Deep Water Point, a canal was opened in 1872,
for the better drainage of the meadows bordering the upper part of the
creek and to secure a more direct water outlet for the products of that
region. In furtherance of this design a dam was also built across the
creek below the canal, thus separating the stream into two independ-
ent water-courses, one having its head at the dam and discharging past
Salem into the cove, the other with its head of navigation at Course's
Landing, 3 miles below Sharptown and 9 miles from the Delaware, into
which it discharges via the canal, which forms the lower 2 miles of its
length. The mouths of the two streams are now, therefore, about 10
miles apart, and the drainage of each is entirely distinct.
   The canal has, to a great extent, failed to accomplish its purpose by
reason of its originally insufficient capacity, whereby the tidal rise,
which is about 6 feet in the Delaware, is reduced to about 1 foot at the
confluence of the canal and creek.
   The natural mouth of the stream is obstructed by extensive sand-bars,
to which dredging has afforded but temporary relief, and would continue
to do so unless supplemented by quite expensive dike construction, ex-
tending across these shoals and into the Delaware River, while the bed
of the upper part of the river is obstructed with shoals, or reduced, from
lack of tidal flow, to the dimensions of a meadow brook.
   It would seem that the comprehensive improvement of the Salem
River might be deferred until the commerce of the vicinity should ren-
714                  REPORT OF .THE                                       CHIEF               OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

der its improvement more urgeht than it seems to be at present.                                                                                                            Should
Congress consider it desirable to continue the improvement, the deep-
ened channel on the upper river might be completed to Hoxie's Bridge,
which has been estimated to cost $4,000.
  Salem River is in the collection district of Bridgeton, N. J., which is the nearest
port of entry, at which the revenue collected during the year ending December 31,
1887, was $196.28. The nearest fort and light-houses are, respectively, Fort Delaware
and Finn's Point range-lights.
Total appropriations to June.30, 1888 ......................  ............    $14,500. 00
Total expenditures to June 30, 1888...... .... .............      ...........  13,009. 34

                                                                          Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available ........                                                       .... .............................                                           $1, 490. 66
July 1, 1888, balance available . ....                                            .............                                .
                                                                                                                          ....---                          .......          1,490. 66



                                                                   COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

               Arrivals and departures of vessels during the year ending December 31, 1887.

                                                 Description.                                                                       Arrivals.                        Departures.

                                                                                                                               No.               Tons.           No.          Tons.
Steamers (not including tugs) ............................           .280                                                                         21, 000            280        21,000
Sailing vessels .---...    --- -----------------------------------      140                                                                        5,600             140         5,600
Barges.---.........--.......--....--....--.....-----................      50                                                                       4, 000             50         4, 000
                   ..........--.....-..
           Total-----                                            ..               ---..---...--                 ..-..          -470               30,600             470        30, 600


                                                                            Freight statement.

                                                                 Articles.                                                                                  Quantity.         Value.

                                                                RECEIVED.

Coal ..........- ..........                        ...
                                                   .....-             .   .................................--                              tons..                    500       $20, 000
Lime--------...............................-- ---..--     ..     ......           ...........       ..........    bushels..                                    20, 000           2,000
Manure .---....................-----------------..............------.....----..---      ...--..-----------......cart -loads..                                  35,000           24, 500

                                 .....
          Total.-..................                                ....                ....                      ...........       .....................                        46, 500
                                                                  SHIPPED.

Grain ............................................................                                                                  bushels..                  60, 000          35,000
Apples..............................................                                             .................                  baskets..                  10, 000           3, 000
Watermelons ......................................................                                                                  number..                  40, 000           32, 000
Sweet-potatoes..........................................baskets..                                                                                             200, 000          80, 000
W hite potatoes..                               .........................................                                           bushels.                   10, 000           5, 000

           Total ......................                                          ........................................                                                      155, 000

    The above information was furnished by Mr. E. E. Kiger, of Sharptown, N. J.                                                                                                        *



                                                                                        G 13.

                          IMPROVEMENT OF COHANSEY CREEK, NEW JERSEY.

  No work has been done on Cohansey Creek during the past fiscal
year, and no appropriation for its improvement has been made since
that of August 2, 1882, appropriating $5,000.
  Cohansey Creek discharges into the Delaware River at a point about
22 miles below Fort Delaware, or nearly opposite Bombay Hook Point.
               APPENDIX G-REPORT OF LIEUT.                        COL. ROBERT.               715
   The act of June 10, 1872, provided for a survey of the creek. Based
upon, the survey a project was adopted which provided for the forma-
tion of a dredged channel at Bridgeton 130 feet wide and-4 feet deep at
low water from the lower steam-boat landing to Broad street, and
thence a 3-foot channel to the Nail Works Bridge. The estimated cost
of the work was $30,000.
   In 1879 the project was modified by reducing the width of the chan-
nel to 80 feet and increasing the depth to 7 feet between the steam-boat
landing and Broad Street Bridge; above that point the channel to be
5 feet deep. In 1880 the project was further modified by extending the
proposed 7-foot channel to Commerce Street Bridge and the 6-foot
channel to the Nail Works Bridge, increasing the estimated cost to
$41,000. Of this amount $36,000 has been appropriated.
   By act of March 3, 1873, $10,000 was appropriated for the work,
which was expended in 1873-'74 in dredging a channel 80 feet wide and
3 feet deep at low water along the city wharves and for a distance of
one-half mile below Broad Street Bridge.
   The act of June 18, 1878, appropriated $5,000 and that of March 3,
1879, $4,500 for continuing the work. These amounts were expended
during the fiscal year 1879-'80 in dredging, which extended the 7-foot
channel 65 feet wide to Broad Street Bridge and thence 45 feet wide to
Commerce. Street Bridge, except at the former, where the city gas and
water piprs reduced the available depth to between 3 and 4 feet.
   The act of June 14, 1880, appropriated $4,500 and that of March 3,
1881, $7,000. In 1880-'81 the channel below Broad Street Bridge was
widened to 80 feet, and between Commerce Street Bridge and the Nail
Works Bridge a shoal was deepened to 4 feet at low water. On this
work about $4,500 was expended.
   In 1881-'82 operations were suspended pending the action of the city
of Bridgeton in relation to lowering the gas and water pipes at the
Broad street crossing.
   The act of August 2, 1882, appropriated $5,000.
   During the fiscal year 1882-'83 the available balance, about $12,000,
from the appropriations of 1881 and 1882, was expended in widening
the channel below Broad Street Bridge to a uniform width of 90 feet
between the upper and lower steam-boat wharves. No appropriations
have been made since 1882.
   The attention of the city authorities has been officially called in the
past to the obstructing gas and water pipes at Broad Street Bridge, and
they have had the question of lowering these pipes under consideration
for several years, but no action thereon has yet been taken. The im-
provement of the creek above this point would be without value until
the pipes are lowered to a proper depth by the municipal authorities of
Bridgeton, and until this is done no appropriation is recommended.
  This work is in the collection district of Bridgeton, N. J., which is the nearest port
of entry, at which the revenue collected during the year ending December 31, 1887,
was $196.28.
  The nearest fort and light-house are, respectively, Fort Delaware and Maurice
River Light.
Total amount appropriated to June 30, 1888......... ................              .....   $36, 000
Total amount expended to June 30, 1888--..-----......----....------ ..................    36,000
                                   COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  No statistics could be obtained from parties interested in this improvement.
                                      Money statement.
  Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....... $5, 500. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
716             REPORT OF THE                          CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                                                      G 14.

            REMOVAL OF WRECKS FROM DELAWARE BAY AND RIVER.

   During the past fiscal year but one wreck has been removed under
the above appropriation.*
   In February, 1886, the schooner David Lee was sunk about 14 miles
from Fourteen-Foot Bank Light, in Delaware Bay. The vessel having
been abandoned by its owners and being considered a danger to naviga-
tion, the required notice to owners was published and proposals invited
for the removal of the wreck.
   Under date of December 13, 1887, a contract was entered into with
Charles W. Johnston for its removal for the sum of $1,000. The work
was accomplished April 27, 1888.

                                                        Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available ....--  ................           ...........      ..........                                               $2, 290.60
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887...... ............           ..........................                                                          1, 531. 98

July 1, 1888, balance available............ ...............                                                         .........        ....      758. 62



Abstract of proposalsfor removal of the wreck of the schooner David Lee, lying off Four-
  teen-Foot Bank Light, Delaware Bay, opened November 18, 1887, by Lieut. Col. Henry
  M. Robert, Corps of Engineers.

No.                                          Names and addresses of bidders.                                                                   Price.

  1   F.   C.    anll,   Lewes,   Del ------.....................-------------------------------------...............----------...              $1, 749
  2   Edward T. Veasey and Thomas Poynter, Lewes, Del ...................................                                                        2, 375
  3   American Dredging Company, Philadelphia, Pa.........................................                                                       4, 300


  All bids rejected, being considered too high.




                                                                      G 15.
REMOVING SUNKEN VESSELS OR CRAFT OBSTRUCTING OR ENDANGERING
                         NAVIGATION.

  During the past fiscal year two wrecks have been removed under the
authority of the act of Congress approved June 14, 1880.
  In December, 1887, the schooner G. H. Bent was sunk in Delaware
Breakwater Harbor, near the western end of the ice-breaker. Under
date of March 8, 1888, a contract was entered into with Joseph D.
Truxton for the removal of the wreck for the sum of $794. The work
was accomplished April 27, 1888.
  In February, 1888, the steamer Blanche Henderson was sunk in the
Delaware River, near the foot of Lombard Street, in the port of Phila-
delphia. Under date of April 17, 1888, a contract was entered into
with John F. Baxter, for the sum of $3,750, to remove the wreck from
its site by means of sling-chains and pontoons, and after pumping out
   * See also " Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering naviga-
tion."
                APPENDIX             G--REPORT               OF LIEUT.             COL.      ROBERT.            717
the vessel and temporarily repairing the leaks to deliver it to the United
States afloat near Fort Mifflin.
  The wreck was removed from its site on May 7, and on May 20 was
taken afloat, without the aid of pontoons, to a designated point behind
the Government dike between Hog and Maiden islands.
  On May 31, in accordance with previous advertisement, the vessel
and all property therein contained was sold by the Government to the
highest bidder, John Schrader, of Philadelphia, for the sum of $570,
which amount was turned into the Treasury of the United States.



Abstract of proposalsfor removal of the wreck of the schooner G. H. Bent, lying in Dela-
ware Breakwater Harbor, opened March , 1888, by Lieut. Col. Henry M. Robert, Corps
of Engineers.


No.                                    Names and addresses of bidders.                                         Price.


1    Elihu J. Morris and Charles W. Johnston, Lewes, Del ...................................                     $824
2    Joseph D. Truxton, Lewes, Del ..........................................................                     794


  Contract (dated March 8, 1888) awarded to Joseph D. Truxton.



Abstract of proposalsfor removal of the wreck of the steamer Blanche Henderson, lying in
  the Delaware River at Philadelphia, Pa., opened April 12, 1888, by Lieut. Col. Henry M.
  Robert, Corps of Engineers.


No.                                     Names and addresses of bidders.                                        Price.


1    Elihu J. Morris and Charles W. Johnston, Lewes, Del- .                .............    .........          $5, 949
2    Tohn F. Baxter, New York, N. Y........     --........................               ..  ........   ...     3, 750
*3    William S. Mason & Co., Philadelphia, Pa. ..........................................                       3, 000

                                                      * Informal.

  Contract (dated April 17, 1888) awarded to John F. Baxter.




                                                          G i6.

             SURVEY OF HARBOR AT ATLANTIC CITY, NEW JERSEY.

  The river and harbor act approved August 5, 1886, contained an ap-
propriation of $5,000 for a survey, by a Board of three United States
Engineers, of the harbor at Atlantic City, N. J., with a view to making
a harbor of refuge at that point.
  By Special Orders No. 141, Headquarters Corps of Engineers, Sep-
tember 25, 1886, a Board consisting of Lieut. Cols. Cyrus B. Comstock,
Henry M. Robert, and Walter McFarland was appointed to make the
survey and examination.
  The report of the Board was submitted under date of May 31, 1887,
and is to be found in the Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1887, pages
815-819.
During the fiscal year the maps and data of tlhe survey and report
were assembled and placed on the office files.
718         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                           Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available...... ................................                              -.   $, 798.332
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887.----..-----......---......----......---...-- ..--................------.      1,217.93
July 1,    1888, balance available .......          ...........          ..---................--         1,580. 39




                                                    G 17.

UNITED STATES COMMISSION ADVISORY TO THE BOARD OF HARBOR
        COMMISSIONERS OF PHILADELPHIA, PENNSYLVANIA.

   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, the personnel of the
United States Commission Advisory to the Board of Harbor Commis-
sioners of the Port of Philadelphia has remained unchanged. It is
constituted as follows:
   Capt. G. B. White, United States Navy, chairman; Prof. Henry Mitch-
ell, United States Coast Survey, and Lieut. Col. Henry M. Robert,
United States Engineer Corps, members, and Mr. H. L. Marindin, United
States Coast Survey, secretary.
   The port warden's line from Bridesburgh to the upper limits of the
city, on the Delaware front, as fixed by this commission, has been
adopted by the harbor commission and approved by the city councils.
   Port warden's lines have now been established around the entire
water-front of the city, except from the mouth of the Schuylkill south,
and around Smith's and Windmill islands. This does not include the
New Jersey side of the harbor, which is not under the control of the
city of Philadelphia.
   The harbor commission having requested this commission to report
upon the problem of the removal of Smith's and Windmill islands, and
the adjacent shoals, for the purpose of extending the wharves on the
Pennsylvania side of the river, this commission made a careful study
of the subject and submitted its conclusions in the report hereto an-
nexed.
   The subject of establishing lines around Smith's and Windmill isl-
ands will not be considered until the question as to their removal is
decided.
   It is important that the turning points of the port warden's line on
the Delaware River should be referred to fixed p)oints on shore, and this
commission has called the attention of the harbor commission thereto.


                        THE ADVISORY              COMMISSION'S REPORT.

                                                    PHILADELPHIA, Decenmber 16, 1887.
To the Board of Harbor Commissioners of the City of Philadelphia:
  GENTLEMEN: The Advisory Commission to the Board of Harbor
Commissioners of Philadelphia has carefully studied the problem sub-
mitted to it in the following resolution adopted by your commission:
  Resolved, That the advisory council of the harbor commissioners be requested to
examine and report concerning the physical relations of Smith's and Windmill islands,
and the shoals adjacent thereto, to the inmlprovement of the harbor,
and respectfully report as follows:
  At our request, Prof. Henry Mitchell, United States Coast and Geo-
         APPENDIX     G--REPORT     OF -LIEUT. COL. ROBERT.          719

detic Survey, a member of this Board, prepared a paper on the physical
relations of Smith's and Windmill islands to the Delaware River. It is
attached hereunto and made a part of this report. Col. Henry M. Rob-
ert, United States Corps of Engineers, in charge of the improvement
of the Delaware River, and a member of this Board, at its request, pre-
pared a diagram showing the movements of the shoals in front of the
city of Philadelphia, with a paper discussing these changes, and a design
for a harbor between Camden and Philadelphia which would permit the
extension of the wharves on the Philadelphia front between Washing-
ton avenue and Willow street. This paper, with inclosures, are here-
unto attached, and form part of this report.
   The statement of principles and of facts as set forth in the papers
referred to were adopted by this Board as its views on the subject.
   A meeting of the citizens of Philadelphia was held at the port war-
dens' office on November 29, when this commission carefully listened
to statements made for and against the proposed removal of Smith's
and Windmill islands and the adjacent shoals, for the purpose of extend-
ing the wharves in front of the city of Philadelphia.
   We have carefully studied the subject by an examination of the sur-
veys, charts, and diagrams kindly furnished us by the United States
Coast and Geodetic Survey and the United States Engineer Corps.
After a full discussion of all the data before us, this commission has
reached the following conclusions, viz:
   (1) Assuming that the commercial prosperity of Philadelphia demands
an extension of the wharves on the Delaware front of that city, between
Washington avenue and Willow street, such reasonable extension can
be made, without injury to the harbor, by the skillful execution of a
properly prepared project.
   (2) No such extension should be made without the removal of Smith's
and Windmill islands and the shoals above and below them.
   (3) That the ebb current should be deflected as much as possible away
from the Pennsylvania shore towards the middle of the stream, to relieve
the pressure on the pier-heads.
   (4) The removal of the islands and shoals without any auxiliary works
will not to any extent relieve this pressure.
   (5) That the proper place to change the direction of the ebb current
to the course desired is at and in the vicinity of Petty's Island.
   (6) Any project for the extension of the wharves and the removal of
the islands and shoals should be comprehensive enough to include the
improvement of the harbor from the head of Petty's Island to the lower
end of the shoals, and also the control of the wharf-lines on both sides
of the river.
   We desire to call attention to the discussion of the movement of the
shoals in front of the city referred to by Colonel Robert.
   This commission, in 1883, advised the cutting away of part of Petty's
Island nearly identical with that proposed in the design for a harbor.
It was then the opinion of the commission that the place to stop the
movement of the shoal above Smith's Island towards the Philadelphia
shore was at Petty's Island, by inducing the greater volume of water
to pass down the Pennsylvania channel, around that island.
   The conclusion reached by Colonel Robert, that the change of the
crest of the shoal off Race-street Wharf 250 feet back from the Penn-
sylvania shore since the construction of the dike at Fisher's Point, seems
to be a practical demonstration of the soundness of the theory then
advanced.
  An important point is demonstrated by the plotting of the present
720       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

wharf-lines of the chart of 1843, which shows that since that date
wharves have been extended 250 feet; at and above Arch street the
line of deepest water was crossed, and at Arch street the wharves were
extended in 57 feet of water.
   The design presented by Colonel Robert contemplates carrying out the
port-wardens' line about 300 feet beyond the present line, and provides
an unobstructed water-way between Camden and Philadelphia 2,000
feet wide, with the west half of this width carrying at least 26 feet at
low water, and the east half gradually decreasing from this depth to
not less than 12 feet on the New Jersey shore.
   The amount of material to be removed, including the work at Petty's
Island, will be about 10,000,000 cubic yards, and the cost of such re-
moval should not exceed $2,000,000, which does not include the cost of
Smith's and Windmill islands and the part to be cut away from Petty's
Island.
   The wording of the resolution of your commission, under which we
are acting, might not seem to have called for the comprehensive study
that we have made, but the views expressed at the citizens' meeting
and the action of various maritime bodies in the city have given to the
inquiry more latitude perhaps than had been anticipated.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servants,
                                              G. B. WHITE,
                                        Captain U. S. Navy, Chairman.
                                              HENRY MITCHELL,
                                       U. S. Coast and Geodetic Survey.
                                              HENRY M. ROBERT,
                                  Lieut. Col. of Engineers, U. S. Army.
   HENRY L. MARINDIN,
        Coast and Geodetic Survey, Secretary.



                      PROFESSOR MITCHELL'S REPORT.

THE PHYSICAL    RELATIONS OF   SMITH'S AND WINDMILL ISLANDS TO DELAWARE RIVER.


    When the advisory commission was first appointed by order of President Iayes, in
1880, it learned with much concern that the harbor commissioners, whom it was to
advise, had no jurisdiction beyond the water front of Philadelphia ; that counsel was
required in the location of restrictive port-warden lines upon one bank of the river
without any control over structures upon the opposite shore.
    In this anomalous position the advisory commission shrank from a task so obviously
beyond its abilities, and on the 16th of December, 1880, passed the following resolu-
tion unanimously:
    "Resolved, That in the opinion of this commission the proper adjustment of the
port-warden lines upon the Pennsylvania side of the Delaware River is impracticable
without an equal consideration of those upon the New Jersey side."
    To this resolution the commission adhered until May, 1883, when it received an
official plotting of the harbor lines adopted on the New Jersey shore, and a vote from
the harbor commission requesting that a scheme of harbor lines be prepared for the
city front.
    After much discussion the commission agreed to accept the harbor lines adopted by
New Jersey as accomplished facts in the case, and voted to proceed to the location of
lines as desired.
    In November, 1884, the commission, through its chairman, reported a system of
sport-warden lines covering the city front, from League Island to Bridesburg, in which
no change was recommended between Dickinson and Ann streets. This excluded
portion was believed to have been advanced already as far as could safely be ad-
mitted-the pier-heads being at some points within 200 feet of the thread of the ebb
current and the deepest water of the channel, so that any considerable advance might
involve no less an act than turning the Delaware.
           APPENDIX          G--REPORT     OF   LIEUT.    COL.   ROBERT.          721
g   It should be remarked here that a physical survey of the harbor, from League Island
   o Five-Mile Point, had been made and published before the advisory commission was
created."    From this data any one could ascertain the depth, velocity, and volume to
be turned by any proposed wharf extension, and the commission based the scheme of
lines which it recommended largely upon this strictly physical data.
    The question of the removal of Windmill and Smith's islands has been very much
discussed, not only by the aid of the physical survey just mentioned, but with further
examinations of the neighborhood, and we believe that nothing but good can be ex-
pected from taking out these obstructions, if the work is done without spilling. That
,there may be a tendency to deposit again must certainly be admitted, but the Dela-
ware is not a heavily loaded stream at any time, and the banks of sand that travel
down along its bed are limited, so that the running expense of keeping the harbor
free will be small.
    The advanitages to commerce from the removal of these obstructions to navigation,
anchorage, winding-room, and transit are too obvious to need more than the men-
tion; but the popular belief that this removal will greatly relieve the pressure of
the ebb current along the city front and make an advance of the wharves in this
part of the city easy and of useful effect is not warranted by our studies.
    Regarding this neighborhood our secretary, Mr. Ienry L. Marindin, in a report
dated March 30, 1885, makes the following statement: " From cross-sections 4 to 9 we
have the comparison of both the Windmill Island channels. We may continue to notice
the advance of the wharf-line more marked, however, between the years 1843 and 1878.
This advance has in most cases been followedtby an increase of channel depth, which,
is an improvement only where the depth is insufficient; but here the depth exceeds
the wants of commerce, so that a questionable improvement was obtained at the ex-
pense of width of water-way where navigable room was already restricted. The
depth along the island front has remained without change. In the eastern channel
the marked advance of the Jersey shore, by its occupation by wharves, has also been
followed by increase of channel depth." t
    But while the scour induced by the advance of wharves on the Philadelphia side
has been mostly executed very near the ends of the wharves, the deepening in the
eastern channel, consequent upon the advance of structures from the Camden shore
has been more general across the whole water-way or disposed to abrade the island
shore.
    We see, then, that no favorable change in the channel (already 50 or 60 feet deep)
blong the western shore has been effected by the advance of wharves; and the cur-
Tent    turned off from this shore does not seem disposed to wear u)pon the shore of
Windmill Island, although the channel is scarcely more than 1,000 feet wide. From
which we might properly argue that the digging away of Windmill Island would not
relieve the pressure upon the opposite wharves of Philadelphia.          Moreover, trhe
advancement of the wharves of Philadelphia in this neighborhood would touch 1he
very body and life of the river, since it would reach the deepest water and the
swiftest flow.
    From our observation of 1878 and 1879, it appears that at that time each foot of
advance from the occupied frontage on the Philadelphia shore involved the displace-
ment of sixteen times the volume of water at the strength of the ebb that a similar
advance from the New Jersey wharves would have done, or five times as much as an
equal advance beyond the Camden port warden's line of that date. Since that date,
however, the port wardens' line on the Camden shore has been moved out, it is said,
300 feet, so that from this new position (without assuming any increase of velocity),
each foot would have only 40 per cent. of the value here that it has on the Philadel-
phia shore.
    In assuming that the removal of Windmill Island might offset in part the exten-
  sion from the New Jersey shore, we have reflected our experience in such studies. It
  appears that uniform extension from the convex side does not cause a race along the
front as happens on the concave side-as one might have very well argued from con-
  sidering the direction of the particles and the angle of impact. But we may expeat
that the advance of the Camden shore will augment the pressure along the Philadel-
phia front somewhat.
    Windmill and Smith's islands belong to that class of dry shoals known upon our
western rivers as tow-heads. They lie sometimes at the points of inflection between
reverse bends andsometimes on the slackwater side of the bend itself. In this latter
case the channel on the convex side of the river is a sort of waste-way or cut-off.
    In the Delaware the presence of a 'flood current alternating with the ebb in the
dry season complicates the formation a little; but, on the whole, we may conclude
that Windmill Island does not yet resist any will of the river, however changed
              *   Appendix 9, Ann. Rep. Coast and Geodetic Survey, 1878.
              t Appendix No. 12, Ann. Report Coast Surxey, 1865.
        ENG 88       -- 46
722      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

from its natural disposition. If the river had been given a tendency to leave the
bend as the wharves were advanced this tow-head would have melted away.
    [Colonel Robert in his subsequent paper has shown that the shoal above yielded
as the wharves were advanced.]
    Of course the Delaware became the site of a great city because of its natural facil-
ities for commerce, its deep channels, bold shores, etc., and these must be preserved
as far as possible even where not utilized. But the wants of commerce may come to
exceed the natural resources, and necessitate some artificial control of the river, in
which case it would be well to thwartas little as possible the natural order, because
it involves a running expense. It not only requires a great outlay to acquire the
control,but a perpetual tax to hold it.
    Any act so serious as turning a river, however slightly, involves excavations and
deposits elsewhere that no one can foresee; and, although many of theklistant con-
sequences may not be evil, all that does go wrong will be charged to the same account.
    It must be borne in mind that the harbor of Philadelphia is the pathway of a river
and the drain-way of great tidal basins, and the extreme demand of river flood and
rare tides must be provided for. Nature, however, always leaves a margin for arti-
ficial improvement.
    To look for a moment at one of the strictly economic aspects of the question, let us
inquire whether the harbor of Philadelphia can spare the water space. If we take
the two miles reach from Cooper's Point to Old Navy-Yard, containing Smith and
Windmill islands as central features, we find that the average width of clear water-
way in 1883 outside of lines connecting'ends of wharves was 2,460 feet-the Smith
Island section being little short of 2,000 feet open water and the Windmill Island sec-
tion about 2,300 feet. With these islands removed the width would have been in
this neighborhood 2,700 feet, or 240 feet more than the average. If,however we meas-
ure between the port-warden lines of Philadelphia and Camden shores, we find that in
1883 the width, with the islands removed, would have been 2.600 feet; since which
it is said that the Camden line has been moved out 300 feet, reducing the width to
2,300 feet, or 160 feet below the average.
    It is proper to count superficial width, because the time will probably come when shoals
will be removed ; and 2,300 feet is little enough for any harbor, especially as all the com-
  merce for eleven miles of city frontage above this must make this a thoroughfare.
  One foresees the pack of vessels that may some day stop the way in this place and
  prevent the development of excellent frontage further up the river.
     Nevertheless 2,300 feet of an unobstructed channel-way, everywhere of hmple depth,
  is much more than the harbor now enjoys-more perhaps in effect than it had in
  1819, when the water spaces on the two sides of Windmill Island summed up over
  3,000 feet.
                                                                 HENRY MITCHELL,
   DECEMBER 10, 1887.                                    U. S. Coast and Geodetic b'urrey.



                           COLONEL ROBERT'S REPORT.

A study of the problem, " How can the wharves on the Delaware front of the central
        part of Philadelphia be extended without serious injury to the river ?"
    The wharves in the locality referred to have been already extended far beyond the
original shore-line, this extension being so great as to cross the line of the deepest
water at Arch and Race streets. The existing Port Wardens' line is about 250 feet in
advance of the head of the pier at Arch street in 1843, and from 150 to 200 feet in ad-
vance of the piers at the same date at Vine, Race, Market, and Chestnut streets.
This extension of the wharves, which was made between the surveys of 1843 and 1878,
did not produce a corresponding cutting from the islands and bars in the middle of
the river, although off Race and Arch streets, where the piers crossed the deepest
water-line, one-half the reduction of width was compensated for by a cutting away
of 100 feet from Smith's Island Shoal. Since 1878 the portion of this shoal between
Vine and Arch streets has been practically stationary below the 20-foot curve, while
above that depth it moved to the west between 1878 and 1883, the crest of the shoal
moving in that time about 300 feet.
    At Callowhill street the extension of the wharves was much less, and did not come
near to the deepest water-line, so that apparently the only effect was a deepening of
  the channel just beyond the pier line. But the upper end of the bar was approaching
the Philadelphia shore, the movement of the crest of the bar in this direction being
about 600 feet at Callowhill street between 1843 and 1878, while between 1878 and
  1883 the crest remained stationary and the body of the bar moved westerly, the 18-foot
curve, for instance, moving 250 feet towards Philadelphia in the five years.
            APPENDIX       G-REPORT OF LIEUT.              COL. ROBERT.             723
    Since 1883 we have two surveys of Smith's Island Bar, one made by the United
States Coast and Geodetic Survey in 1886, and the other by the United States Engi-
neer Department in November, 1887. These surveys show no change in the shoal be-
tween these latter dates, but they show a remarkable change since the survey of 1883,
the crest of the shoal having swung to the cast a distance of 450 to 500 feet at Callow-
hill and Vine streets, and 250 feet at Race street, practically placing it where it was
in 1843. [The piers across the shoal just above Smith's Island, and the gravel depos-
ited just above them for their protection, have prevented any change opposite Arch
street.]
    This shifting of the shoal westerly between 1843 and 1883, and then easterly between
1883 and 1887, seems to be accounted for by the two facts (1) that between the first
dates, when the shoal shifted westerly, the channel between Philadelphia and the
lower end of Petty's Island was greatly contracted by the extension of piers on both
sides of the river, and the reduction of the width between 1843 and 1878 being about
470 feet at low water and about 800 feet at high water; and (2) that between the
latter dates, 1883 and 1887, when the shoal shifted easterly, a dike 3,000 feet long had
been built from Fisher's Point towards the head of Petty's Island, thus increasing the
flow of water through the channel between Philadelphia and Petty's Island, and par-
tially counteracting the bad effects of the contraction of the Philadelphia channel at
the foot of Petty's Island. It should be noticed that while the narrowest part of this
channel is 1,120 feet wide at low water, the shortest distance between the legal har-
  bor-lines bounding this channel is only 1,000 feet, so that at anytime it may be far-
ther contracted to the injury of the harbor.
    The depth of water on the upper part of Smith's Island Shoal was from 6 to 8 feet
greater in 1843 than in 1878, when the channel at the lower end of Petty's Island had
  been so contracted. Since the construction of Fisher's Point Dike the bar has low-
ered to within 2 feet of its depth in 1843.
    A study of the various surveys of this harbor made by the United States Coast and
Geodetic Survey in 1843, 1878, and 1886, and by the United States Engineer Depart-
nient in 1883 and 1887, of which some of the results have been just stated, lead to the
opinion that no serious injury to the river would result from the extension of the
wharves on the Delaware front of the central part of Philadelphia, provided the har-
bor-lines are made to conform approximately to those laid clown in the sketch here-
with. This plan involves-
    (1) The widening of the channel between Philadelphia and the lower half of Petty's
Island to a least width of about 1,700 feet, with such an increase of width at the lower
end as is required to adapt it to the lines on the New Jersey shore, as shown on the
sketch.
    (2) The removal of Smith's and Windmill islands, and the shoals above and below
to a suitable depth.
    (3) The extension of the wharves on the Philadelphia front, from about Hanover
street to about Washington avenue, approximately, as follows: Starting at Hanover
street, on the present Port Wardens' line, the proposed Port Wardens' line would be
advanced 175 feet at Shackamaxon street and 300 feet at Green street, continuing at
about that distance in advance of the present line to Lombard street, whence the ad-
vance would diminish until the two lines would coincide near Washington avenue.
    (4) The modification of the exterior wharf line on the New Jersey shore, as estab-
lished by the riparian commissioners, so as to keep it about 2,000 feet distant from
the proposed Philadelphia Port Wardens' line until near Cooper's Point, where it
  should hug the shore, so as not to divert the current from the New Jersey shore.
    (5) A slight modification of the adopted wharf-lines at the lower end of the channel
to the south of Petty's Island, so as to make these proposed lines approximately par-
allel to the present deepest water-line near the mouth of this channel.
    The dredging of about 10,000,000 cubic yards of material (scow measurement) would
remove the islands and shoals, including a portion of Petty's Island, so as to give a
harbor 2,000 feet wide below Petty's Island, the western half of which would have a
least depth of 26 feet at mean low water, and the eastern half a depth gradually less-
ening from 26 feet in the middle of the river to at least 12 feet at the shore. It would
at the same time allow of the advance of about 2 miles of the Port Wardens' line in
the center of the city, permitting the construction of docks about 500 feet in length,
without increasing the currents, so as to cause any material engineering difficulties
in their construction and maintenance.
    Since the preparation of this paper and accompanying sketch of a modified harbor
for the port of Philadelphia I find that practically all the modifications proposed on
the New Jersey shore at Cooper's Point and Petty's Island have been approved in Ithe
past by the Advisory Commission.
    Accompanying this paper are the following:
  (1) * Sketch of the harbor of Philadelphia on the Delaware River, so modified as to
render feasible the advance of the Port Wardes' line 300 feet in the center of the
city front.
724       REPORT     OF   TIIE   CHIEF       OF     ENGINEERS,     U. S. ARMY.

  (2) * Cross-sections of Smith's Island Bar and the Philadelplra Channel in 1843, 1878
1883, 1886, and 1887.
  (3)   Chart of the Philadelphia Iarbor from the survey of 1843, showing the en-
croachmnents on the river since that date.
                                                              HENRY M.     ROBERT,
                                                       Lieut. Col. of Engineers, U. S. A.
  U.   S. ENGINEER OFFICE,
         Philadelphia, Pa., December 11, 1887.




                                            G i8.
PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION OF THE THOROUGHFARE RUNNING BACK
OF itHE OCE XN FROM CAPE MAY TO THE GREAT BAY NORTH OF AT-
LANTIC CITY, NEW JERSEY.

                                 UNITED        STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                    Philadelphia,Pa., December 24, 1886.
    SIR: In compliance with instructions contained in your letter of Oc-
tober 28, 1886, I have the honor to submit the following report on a
preliminary examination of the Thoroughfare running hack of the ocean
from Cape May to the Great Bay, north of Atlantis City, N. J.:
    This Thoroughfare is about 63 miles long and consists of some ten
bays or sounds, and of connecting channels varying in width from 100
to 1,000 feet.
    I made a personal examination of the route from Ludlam's Bay to
Peck's Bay, including the intermediate thoroughfares and Corson's
Sound, and the entire route from Cape May to Great Bay was gone
over by Assistant Engineer L. Y. Schermerhorn between November 1
and 6, under the guidance of Capt. George H. Dare, an old resident
and experienced navigator of these waters. Soundings were occasion-
ally made, and the shallow reaches connecting the deep water were lo-
cated at the time on the maps of the State geological survey. The ex-
amination was based upon the idea of getting a channel 6 feet deep at
mean low water, as, from all I coull learn, this depth would meet all the
demands of commerce for several years. In fact, whatever may be the
future development of this region, the first thing to do is to open the
entire route to a depth of not over 6 feet, and if appropriations were small
it might be better to limit the depth to even 4 feet at first.
    The distance from Cape May to Great Bay in an air-line is about 47
miles, while by the best channel through the bays and thoroughfares
back of the ocean beach it is about 63 miles. Of this 63 miles, about 53
miles have a least depth of 6 feet at mean low water, while the remaining
10 miles appear to have less than 1 foot, portions being entirely out of
water. This distance of 10 miles, divided into eight shoals or divides,
must be considered as requiring an excavation 6 feet deep to insure a
6-foot channel. The channel should have a mean width of 75 feet, so
that the excavation can be roughly estimated at upwards of 1,000,000
cubic yards, scow measurement. An accurate survey might increase
this estimate.
    Judging from ten years' experience with running dredges owned by
the United States, and having built two, I believe that $100,000 will
cover the cost of building suitable plant and excavating and removing
the 1,000,000 yards of material estimated as required by the above plan,
but I doubt the safety of an estimate for doing this work by contract
biasedl on anything lower than 25 cents a cubic yard, or $250,000 for the
entire improvement. The plant would have to come from the vicinity
                                        *   Omitted.
           APPENDIX      G-REPORT          OF LIEUT.     COL.     ROBERT.       725
of New York or Philad liphia, and would not, pro'.ably, be specially
adapted to such shallow work. Contractors would, probably, hesitate
to build plant suitable for such work, because there would be great risk
in building the plant before they were awarded a contract, and then it
would be too late.
   Furthermore, it might not pay to build special lant for only one sea-
son's contract, and they would not be sure ot any more.
   This question of how such a shallow channel is to be excavated in a
region where there is no similar work being done, so that special plant
should be constructed for the purpose, is a very serious one, affecting
the cost of the work, I think, as much as 100 per cent.
   At )resent the commerce through this thoroughfare consists mainly
of oysters and garden produce, the latter having for a market the
neighboring sea-side resorts, principally Atlantic City.
   The vessels used are small sail-boats whose draught does not exceed
2 feet, and they can not cross the divides at low water. A 6-foot chan-
nel 75 feet wide would allow small steamers to be placed on the route,
which doubtless would greatly increase the commerce seeking th's
route, and especially would it be used by pleasure steamers during the
summer. The oyster trade would probably be greatly developed.
   The question as to whether this route is worthy of improvement is
rendered difficult of solution. by the doubt overhanging the question of
its cost. It seems to me that the benefits to be derived from the im-
provement to the extent of a 6-foot channel 75 feet wide would justify
the expenditure of $100,000, but I am not p    arpared at present to say that
they would justify the expenditure of $250,000. In other words, with
my present knowledge of the subject, I am of opinion that the improve-
ment is worthy to be made if it can be done for $100.000, but that it is
not worthy to be made if its cost amounts to $250,000.
   I would estimate the cost of a survey of the route, including a project
with estimate of cost of the improvement, at not less than $2,000.
   There are forwarded herewith the following documents:
  1. A tracing showing the location of the proposed improvements.
  2. Assistant Engineer L. Y. Schermerhorn's report of his examination of the route
(without the maps).
  3. A communication from C. K. Lan~is, esq., founder of Sea Isle City, showing the
importance of the proposed improvement.
  4. Copy of a letter from Isaac A. Braddock, esq., on the same subject.
  So far I have been unable to get any commercial statistics; should
any be received they will be forwarded.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                      HENRY       3[. ROBERT,
                                                        Lieut. Col. of Engineers.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. A.


           REPORT OF MR.    L.   Y.   SCHERMERHORN,   ASSISTANT   ENGINEER.


                                           UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                               Philadelplhia, Pa., December 7, 1886.
  SIR : I have the honor to submit the following report on the examination made be-
tween November 1 and 6. 1886, of the " Thoroughfare running back of the ocean from
Cape May to the Great Bay north of Atlantic City, N. J.," required by the act of Con-
gress approved August 5, 1886.
  The examination was made by passing over the route in a sail-boat under the guid-
ance of Capt. George H. Dare, an experienced pilot long resident in the vicinity and
thoroughly familiar with the best water to be obtained on the route. As a further
726          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

aid use was made of the Coast Survey charts of the vicinity, and especially of the
maps of the Topographical Survey of the State of New Jersey just completed under
the direction of George H. Cook, State geologist. Soundings were also made along
the line of examination to verify the general information obtained as to the depth of
water.
  Two sheet of the Topographical Survey of the State of New Jersey, entitled "Topo-
graphical map of the peninsula of Cape May" (Atlas Sheet No. 17) and "Topo-
graphical map of Egg Harbor and vicinity " (Atlas Sheet No. 16), are submitted here-
with, to which reference is made in the subjoined report.
   Between Cape May and Great Bny, the limits of the present examination, the coast
frontage consists of a salt-marsh meadow from 2 to 6 miles wide, lying between the
mainland and the coast line. This marsh area is traversed by numerous connecting
water-ways, ramifying from the ocean inlets. The water areas consist of passages
from 100 to 1,i00 feet in width, called channels and thoroughfares, and in expansive
areas frequently covering several square miles, called bays and sounds.
   The surface of the marsh is from 4 to 5 feet above mean low water, and is covered
by the high water of storm tides. Between Cape May and Great Bay there are nine
ocean inlets, named as follows: Cold Spring, Turtle Gut, Hereford, Townsend's, Cor-
son's, Egg Harbor, Absecon, Brigantine, and New Inlet. These inlets are from one
quarter to one mile in width, and carry from 6 to 10 feet of water over the bars at
their months.
   The mean range of the tides along this part of the coast is about 4 feet, and the ebb
and flood through these inlets produce a corresponding change in the height of water
in the inland water areas. As the flood tide enters the inlets it passes inland by the
various connecting water-ways to the right and left. As a result, there is a point of
meeting in these inland water-ways of the flood coming from adjacent inlets, and, con-
sequently, at such points of meeting of the tide there exists only a vertical move-
ment of the tidal-wave. The exact point of mneet'g of the titles depends upon the
direction of the wind.                 On account of the absence of tidarl nrents                                    at     he    teetiag
the tides there ensues a slow deposition of the material held in suspension, and, as
would naturally be expected, the water is very shallow over the area covered by these
points of meeting. Such a shallow area in the inland waters exists between each sue-
cessive pair of inlets, with but one modification, viz, between Corson's and Egg Har-
bor  inlets, where two shoal areas occur, one in Crook Horn Thoroughfare and the
other in Peck's Bay. This may be only an apparent departure from the rule, since
present indications make it very possible that at some time in the past an inlet ex-
isted; but subsequently closed, between Corsou's and Egg Harbor inlets.
   The cross-section of the inlets is such as to allow of the passage of large quantities
of water into the inland areas at flood tide, and the escape of this volume at the ebb
results in considerable concentration of currents at special localities, and a conse-
quent deepening of the inland passages at suchnell  points of concentration. The depth
of water in the thoroughfares, channels, bay, and sounds is very variable in different
localities, but in general terms it may be saidt that by selecting the deepest connecting
water-ways over 6 feet can be covered at mean low water from Cape May to Great
Bay, except at the divides or shallow areas jfst described; over these shallow areas
the depth at mean low tide would average less than 1 foot.
   The air-line distance between Cape May City and Great Bay is about 47 miles, but
this distance would be increased to about 63 miles if the line of best water is followed.
Such a line is shown on the accompanying maps by a dotted black and red line, the
black line indicating the water having a present navigable depth of 6 feet and over,
and the red line indicating the water having a depth at mean low water of less than
1 foot. In the present condition of the inland passages the small boats which navi-
gate them must pass these divides at high water. These boats ordinarily draw from
1 to 2 feet of water.
   The following summary shows the location and approximate length of these divides
or shoal areas :

                 Between inlets of-                                               Location of divide.                                ,Length.


                                                                                                                                         Yards.
Cold Spring-Turtle Gut .....................         Jarvis Sound ..---------           --.............................                       , 400
Turtle Gut--Hereford..        ..... ..............   Grassy Sound .....................                                                      ,
                                                                                                                                            1,200
Hereford-Townsend's ..--....---............          Great Sound ..-.                                                                       1, 500
Townsend's-Corson's --------------------........................
                                                     Ludlam Thoroughfare and Bay ........                        -2,                            0002
Corson's-Egg Harbor......................            Crook orn Thoroughfre...                       .- - .... - -                           3, 000
                                                     Peck's Bay ....       . . ....        ..      ...         .       ...                   170a
Egg Harbor-Absecon.......................          - Beach Thoroughfare.......................                                               1, 800
Absecon-Brigantine ..--..... .........                .....   Grassy Bay ...........                 .......... ......           .. i       2, 300
Brigantine-New (Grtat) Bay ............                       Little Bay ..--------..--......          ..............---...--.              2, 000
        Total ..-----           ---...---       .---
                                                  ..    .-...- .--...........-.         .-.........                                      -   16, 900
            APPENDIX      G----REPORT       OF LIEUT.      COL. ROBERT.             727
   The land areas immediately along the coast line and at the inlets are composed of
drifting sand and the detailed configuration of the high and low water lines change
with each storm. Directly behind the sand border of the coast are the salt marshes,
which are entirely free from sand, consisting of a tough black soil, apparently the re-
sult of slow deposits and vegetable growth, closely knit together with the roots of the
marsh grass. The beds of the thoroughfares and channels seem to consist of the
same material. The same description would generally cover the bottoms of the bays
and sounds, although here are sometimes to be found gravel and sand bars. Oysters
thrive in these inland waters, which is a further confirmation of the statement that
moving sand does not generally exist in the bars of these inland waters. The water
away from the inlets both at flood and ebb seemed very free from transported or
suspended matter, and all indications suggest the extreme s ability of present
depths.
  As shown by the previous summary, about 17,1)00 linear yards, or 9,. miles, of water-
way would require to be improved so as to give a navigable channel at low water
between Cape May and Great Bay. If such a channel was improved to a width of
25 yards there would have to be removed about 150,000 cubic yards of material, meas-
ured in place, for each foot in depth of channel excavated, or to obtain a channel (i
feet deep at mean low water about 1,000,000 cubic yards would require to be dredged.
This I consider a minimum quantity, for the reason t hat a detailed survey might show
a still greater extent of shoal water, but would not probably show less than that
above stated.
  Although the character of the material which would require to be excavated is such
                             Le
as to make the cost of lifting it comparatively small, still the difficulty of disposing
of dredged material would
least'25                          such as to probably make the cost of excavation at
          cents, and possibly 30 cents, per cubic yard. The channels which would re-
quire improvement are, as will be seen from the maps, long, and in many cases very
tortuous. An improved channel of a width within the limits of reasonable economy
would, under such conditions of length and crookedness, be too narrow for sailing
vessels; consequently, to utilize such imiproved channels at all stages of wind and
tide, steam-vessels of light draught would have to be generally employed as the mo-
tive power.
   As bearing upon the utility of an improvement of the thoroughfare between Cape
May and Great Bay the following statement may be of interest. The coast line
between these limits is broken by the inlets into the following-named beaches: (1)
Poverty; (2) Two Mile; (3) Five Mile; (4) Seven Mile; (5) Ludlam; (6) Peck's; (7)
Absecon; (d) Brigantine; and (9) Island. Of these the second, fourth, eighth, and
ninth have no railroad connection with the mainland. These beaches, on account of
their facilities for summer bathing, have developed a number of siummer resorts, such
as Cape May, Sewell's Point, Sea Isle City, Ocean City, Somers Point, and Atlantic
City. These have already attained considerable development, while several others,
stich as Holly Beach, Anglesea, Longport, South Atlantic, Brigantine, and Island
Beach, are in their early stages of development. The impetus which of late years
has been given to sea-side resorts has given great value to the beaches already de-
veloped, and a large speculative value to the beach partially, or even totally, unim-
proved. To develop these beaches it is of the first importance that they be made very
accessible to the public. Such beaches as already have railroad connection with the
mainland have a great advantage over beaches lacking such facilities.
   If the thoroughfares, bay, and sounds were made navigable for steam-vessels of
light draught, then the beaches with present railroad connection could be made avail-
able as points for still further distribution and expansion, thereby opening to the
sea-side resorting public new advantages, and to the owners of the beaches rich re-
mnuneration. These inland waters are well adapted to the growth of oysters, and
considerable enterprise seems to have already been applied in this direction. With
increased facilities for reaching the market this industry could be indefinitely ex-
panded. In this connection it might be worthy to note, in passing, that the existing
privileges of occupation of these waters fcr the oyster fisheries are obtained from the
State of New Jersey simply )bypre-emption, the right holding good as long as the
fisheries are properly cared for. In case an improvement was made of the channels it
would probably be found that owners of fisheries would claim indemnity for the
injury or destruction to oyster fi sherics that might result from local interference with
the beds of the water areas.
   The development of the beaches would for several months of each year add a large
population to this district, for the subsistence of which the adjacent mainland offers
excellent facilities, and an improved water communication through these inland wa-
ters would still further develoap the immediate mainland and add something of value
to producers, anld 1posibly to con sm.ners. These prospective advanttages are contin-
gent upon conditions whichs it is Iossible to anticipate with slufficient probability to
make themni assurances, and althoughl perhaps bearing upon the question of whether
72$8     REPORT OF THE CHIEF                 OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

tCe work is worthy of improvement, still leaves the necessity for such ii~provement
fir s:hort of one of national importance.
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                           L.    Y. SCHERMEIRTIORN,

  Lieut. Col. HENRY M. ROBERT,
            Corps of I;ngine'., U. S. A.



STATEMENT OF    C. K.   LANDIS   ABOUT THE   TIItOROUGHFARIE      IMPIiOVEIENT   DIETWEEN
        CAPE MAY AND GREAT BAY, NORTH OF ATLANTIC               CITY, NEW JERSEY.


                                                    SEA ISLE CITY, .Novenber 11, 1S83.
   Six: I beg leave to call your attention to the following reasons which make it just,
proper, necessary, and profitable fir the Government of the United States to perform
the work for improving the navigation of the thoroughfare between the Great Bay,
north of Atlantic City, and Cape May, which has been so largely petitioned for by peti-
tions signed by many hundreds, if not thousands, of people. The length of this
thoroughfare, including sinuosities, is about 60 miles. At Great Bay it reaches Barne-
gat Bay, which extends the navigation 40 miles farther north, to Point Pleasant.
Practically, this improvement will make an inside navigable stream for steamers and
sailing vessels drawing not over 8 feet of water for a distance of 100) mniles. The nat-
ural formation of land and water in this district makes it peculiarly important that
the waters should be made navigable, in order that the population of the place, and
also the population of t he neighboring States, should have the advantage and benefit
of the natural resources and riches of this district. The land on the western side of
the thoroughfare consists of meadow land, filled with bays and sounds, now occupied
as oyster-beds, and an alluvial deposit, making the most productive farm land in the
State of New Jersey, which farm land is continuous for the whole distance and in a
high state of improvement, divided up into small farms, and embracing a large popu-
lation. These farm-houses in summer-time are most all boarding-houses.
   The entire distance of 100 miles is lined with numerous villages, boroughs, and sev-
eral cities. The district is only reached at several points by railroa!s, which run at
right angles with it, and not parallel, to accommodate the commerce; and in fact the
products of this district can better be accommodated by navigation than by railroad.
   In this immediate district, commencing at the Great Bay and near by and adjacent
to the proposed improvement, are the following villages, boroughs, and cities: Brig-
antine, Leedspoint, Oceanville, Summerville, Conoverville, Absecon, Atlantic City
South Atlantic City, Longport, Pleasantville, Smith Landing, Bakersville, Leedsville,
Sea View, Somer's Point, Ocean City, Beesley's Point, Palmero, Ocean View, Sea Isle
City, Seaville, Clermont, Swain, Oceanville, Cape May Court Hlouse, Anglesea, Holly
Beach, Rio Grande, Sewell's Point, Bennett's, Cape May City.
   These places have all, more or less, a numerous population, permanent for the entire
year, and visited during the year by people from New York, Philadelphia, Baltimore,
Washington, and the Far West by fully 1,000,000 of people, and which within the next
ten years will probably reach 3,000,000, if the increase of the future compares with
the increase of the past ten years. This population requires a constant supply of the
produce to be obtained from the farms, bays, and sounds adjacent to the proposed im-
provement, and which commerce is almost entirely obstructed by the alluvial deposits
in the track of navigation, which all can be removed for comparatively a small sum
w hen the benefits are to be taken into consideration.
   These benefits are not of a local character, but in their nature are general, and for
the supply of farm produce; also oysters and other prcducts of salt water. Philadel-
phia, New York, Boston, and other places will come in for a direct share of the benefits;
which cities will also be able to have delivered building materials along the entire
thoroughfare when made navigable. The waters, planted with oysters, and also
abounding in clams, crabs, fish, etc., besides the thoroughfare itself, when of a proper
width, may be said to be the following: Great Bay, Little Shad Bay, Reed's Bay,
4Grass Bay, Absecon Bay, Lake's Bay, Great Egg Harbor Bay, Peck's Bay, Ludlam's
iDay, Great Sound, Jenkin's Sound, and Jarvin's Sound.
    These waters are now planted with oysters, but the commerce is now largely crip-
pled and limited by the want of navigation, and the value of all this product, with
proper navigation, will amount to millions per annum, which value is now largely
lost or locked up by these alluvial deposits in the line of navigation, which interfere
with commerce. The improvements of this thoroughfare will also be a vast protec-
4 ion to the coasting trade. Vessels now drawing over 1 foot of water are compelled
  ,o po outside, andl then go into the thoroughfare by one of the different inlets, in order
            APPENDIX G-REPORT               OF LIEUT. COL. ROBERT.                  729
to get from one point to the other. This improvement will also be a protection to out-
side commerce, because, if made, in case of storm, vessels that do not draw too much
water can run into different inlets and find a secure harbor, or keep on their course
north or south by the proposed water-way.
   To show that there is ample opportunity for this, attention is called to the fact that
the following inlets exist, commencing at Great Bay and extending to Cape May :
Little Egg Harbor Inlet, Brigantine Inlet, Absecon, Great Egg Harbor, Corsin's,
Townsend's, Hereford's, Turtle Gut, and Cold Spring inlets. To give an estimate of
the probable commerce which would develop in case this improvement is made is
difficult. This whole district, to a certain extent, has been locked up from commerce
for the want of navigation. To afford it navigation, and, owing to the peculiarity of
its products and the proximity of millions of people, to now give it navigable facili-
ties will be like the unlocking of a mine.
   The benefits to be derived are such as to reach the population of a wide scope, and
without exaggeration we may say millions of people. As soon as the work is finished
steamers and sailing vessels will be navigating the waters, carrying the products to
adjacent watering-places and to the large cities of the Atlantic sea-board. The re-
sults of so great an improvement are self-evident, considering the great extent of
population and number of villages and cities interested in this commerce.
       Most respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                   CHAS. K.   LANDIS.

  Lieut. Col. HENRY M. ROBERT.




                         LETTER OF MR. ISAAC A. BRADDOCK.

                                             HADDONFIELD, N. J., Norember 17, 1886.
   SIR: I have been shown a statement to you regarding the proposed improvement
of the inside coast-line of New Jersey, clearing the mud-bars, etc., at the head of the
thoroughfares, and making them continuously navigable from Cape May to Great
Bay, which amounts to opening navigation inside from near Long Branch to Cape
May. I thoroughly indorse the feasibility of the undertaking, and add to the testi-
mony of C. K. Landis that this is a matter of interest to nearly a fourth of the popu-
lation of the country, as this ocean border of New Jersey is the sanitarium and sum-
mner recruiting-ground of people from at least a dozen States. If this improvement
was made, numerous small steamers would be put on to furnish cheap and pleasant
communication between the different summer resorts on this coast that are so crowded
in the season with people desirous of enjoyment and spending their money liberally
in the pursuit of health. To wait on these people, who are from many different States,
there is a numerous, industrious, and hardy set of fishermen and farmers, who, for want
of this convenience, are frequently compelled to spend a night fast in the mud with
their load of oysters, hay, fish, or farm produce, or to brave an angry sea in a small
vessel to get from inlet to inlet outside.
   The United States Government are about to order a survey for a ship-canal from
Philadelphia to Great Bay, which, if constructed (and it is possible to do it), would
then strike this 100 miles of improved navigation nearly central, and enable steam-
yachts to steam and sailing vessels of all sizes to take an inland passage from North
Carolina, Virginia, Maryland, Delaware, Pennsylvania, New York, Connecticut, and
Rhode Island, and reach this point without getting more than a distant view of the
sea and its dangers. The cost of this improvement, as you would see on examina-
tion, need not be large, as the excavations are either in mud or sand, and could all be
done by steam-dredges of the cheapest construction, and easily afterward maintained,
as the bars to be removed are not opposite or adjacent to the inlets (as there as a
rule is the deepest water), but at about the middle of the coast-lying beaches, where
the tides meet, and have probably been hundreds of years, if not thousands, in slowly
depositing a rich, fine mud, that in many cases would pay largely for removal as a
fertilizer, as it is very rich in phosphatic deposits. I believe if this navigation was
opened there would be numerous parties engaged in the business of preparing ferti-
lizers of fish and phosphatic deposits, which, with cheap and easy navigation, could
be distributed to the States mentioned above to the advantage of their agriculture.
  These are a few of the points which I desire to suggest, and if it were necessary
many others could be indicated which call for this cheap and necessary improvement.
        Very respectfully,
                                                                ISAAC A.   BRADDOCK.

Lieut. Col. H. M. ROBERT.
730    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

SURVEY OF THE THOROUGHFARE RUNNING BACK OF THE OCEAN
  FROM CAPE MAY TO THE GREAT BAY NORTH OF ATLANTIC CITY,
  NEW JERSEY.

                           UNITED    STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                       Philadelphia,Pa., April 25, 1888.
   SIn: I have the honor to submit the following report on the survey
of the thoroughfare running back of the ocean from Cape May to the
Great Bay north of Atlantic City, N. J.
   This survey was made during August, September, and October, 1887
and since then has been plotted by Mr. Feodor Sylvester, under the
supervision of Asssistant Engineer L. Y. Schermerhorn. As the thor-
oughfares are at places less than 100 feet wide, it was necessary to plot
the survey on a scale of 200 feet to the inch, and as the length of the
route surveyed is 65 miles, the map of the survey covers thirty-four
sheets. The actual length of water-way surveyed was 70 miles.
   A copy of Assistant Engineer L. Y. Schermerhorn's full report of the
survey, together with thirty-five sheets of tracings (one index sheet
and thirty four sheets of detail) are forwarded herewith as a part of this
report.
   The survey shows that to obtain a 6-foot channel at least 50 feet wide
at the bottom it is necessary to improve about 20 miles of the route by
dredging some 1,310,000 cubic yards of material, scow measurement.
Of this amount 430,000 cubic yards are north of Atlantic City, within 5
miles of Great Bay, leaving about 880,000 cubic yards to be dredged in
the 55 miles between Atlantic City and Cape May. The dredging of
114,000 cubic yards from 2 miles of channel would connect the Tuckahoe
liver with Atlantic City by a good 6-foot channel at low water, which
would prove a great benefit to those living on that river.
   In estimating the amount of dredging I have taken 6 feet as the
depth to be maintained at low water, and have had the calculations all
made to 7 feet depth, in order to insure the proper depth. The width
at this depth of 7 feet is taken at 50 feet, and the side slopes at 1 ver-
tical to 3 horizontal, so that the width at 3 feet below low water would:
be 74 feet, or about the same as the 6-foot channel, with a mean width
of 75 feet, recommended in my preliminary report dated December 24,
1886.
   The quantity of material has been reduced to scow measurement by
adding 20 per cent. to place measurement, because in practice it proba-
bly would be measured either in the dipper or in scows.
   It does not seem to me that a greater width than 50 feet at 6 feet be-
low low water is necessary in the dredged channel. A channel of this
width can be dredged economically by making two cuts with a dredge
and throwing the material to the sides, thus saving the expense of
scowing it away or procuring the plant for placing it on the shores.
   By adopting this method I think that contracts could be made at
much lower rates than estimated in my preliminary report. Assuming
appropriations commensurate with the work, I think $200,000 ought to
suffice to complete the work by contract.
   But a work of this nature should never be done by contract. There
are no dredges along the whole line of the improvement and no private
business requiring them. Even after the work is comrnleted it is not to
be expected that 20 miles of dredged channel will take care of itself.
Allowing only 5 per cent. of the original amount for the annual dredg-
ing to preserve the channel, and there will be C5,000 cubic yards of
                                               (l
dredging to be (lone each year, which could be doe    by a Governvmentl
          APPENDIX       G--REPORT            OF   LIEUT.     COL.   ROBERT.           731
dredge on the ground for one-half what it would cost to have the work
done by contract.
  The entire cost of the plant would be much more than saved( in doing
the original dredging, as the 1,310,000 cubic yards could be dredged
with a Government dredge at a cost not to exceed $130,000, including
the cost of plant. At the close of the work the Government would, in
my judgment, have saved at least $70,000, besides having a good plant
on hand, which would be needed for preserving and enlarging the
channel.
  In case this work were undertaken it could be utilized long before its
completion. As before stated, it requires the dredging of only 114,000
cubic yards to connect the Tuckahoe River and Great Egg Harbor with
Atlantic City by a 6-foot channel. After that work is done it would
probably be best to cut a 4-foot channel first and afterwards deepen it
to 6 feet.
                                         ESTIMATE.

  I would estimate the amount of material to be dredged to make a
channel 6 feet deep at mean low water and 50 feet wide at bottom at
1,310,000 cubic yards and the cost at $200,000, if done by contract, or
$ 130,000 if the Government builds its own plant and does the work by
hired labor.
   If an appropriation is made for this work it should not be less than
$40,000 to begin with. Afterwards smaller appropriations would an-
swer.
   I have been unable to procure any commercial statistics, and nothing
further has been obtained relating to the commercial importance, pres-
ent and prospective, of the improvement contemplated than is con-
tained in my preliminary report.
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                          HENRY 31. ROBERT,
                                                            Lieut. Col. of Engineers.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. A.



          REPORT OF    MIR.   L.   Y.   SCHERMIERHORN,   ASSISTANT    ENGINEER..


                                               UNITED    STATES ETNGINEER OFFICE,
                                                         Philadelphia, Pa., April 17, 1888.
   SIR : I have the honor to submit the following report upon the survey of the Thor-
oughfare running back of the ocean from Cape May to the Great Bay north of Atlan-
tic City, N. J.
   In November, 1886, an examination was made of this route and a report thereon
submitted to the Department under date of December 24, 1886. From the results of
this examination a survey was recommended and authorized under an allotment of
$1,885. The field work of the survey was commenced August 12 and completed Oc-
tober 21, 1887. This work was personally conducted by Mr. Feodore Sylvester, and
covered 70 linear miles of water-way, with about 25,000 soundings.
   The topography of the maps was mainly reproduced from the latest plane-table
sheets of the U. S. Coast and Geodetic Survey, corrected for changes which have taken
place since that survey was made. The results of the present survey are shown on
thirty-four sheets upon a scale of 200 feet to 1 inch.
   The following description of the physical characteristics of the route is derived
from my report dated December 7, 1886, on the examination made in November of that
year:
   "Between Cape May and Great Bay the coast frontage consists of a salt-marsh
meadow from 2 to 6 miles wide, lying between the mainland and the coast line.
732      REPORT OF TIIE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

This marsh area is traversed by numerous connecting water-ways, ramifying from the
ocean inlets. The water areas consist of passages from 100 to 1,000 feet in width,
called channels and thoroughfares, and inll expansive areas frequently covering several
square miles, called bays and sounds.
    " The surface of the marsh is from 4 to 5 feet above mean low water, and is covered
by the high water of storm tides. Between Cape May and Great Bay there are nine
ocean inlets, named as follows:
    "Cold Spring, T'urtle Gut, Hereford, Townsend's, Corson's, Egg Harbor, Absecon,
Brigantine, and New Inlet. These inlets are from one-fourth to I mile in width, and
carry from 4 to 10 feet of water over the bars at their mouths.
    " The mean range of the tides along this part of the coast is about 4 feet, and the
ebb and flood through these inlets produce a corresponding change in lhe heights
of water in the inland water areas. As the flood tide enters the inlets it passes inland
by the various connecting water-ways to the right and left. As a result, there is a
point of meeting in these inland water-ways of the flood coming from adjacent inlets,
and consequently at such points of meeting of the tide there exists only a vertical
movement of the tidal wave. The exact point of meeting of the tides depends upon
the direction of the wind. On account of the absence of tidal currents at the meeting
of the tides, there ensues a slow deposition of the material held in suspension, and, as
would naturally be expected, the water is very shallow over the area covered by these
points of meeting. Such a shallow area in the inland waters exists between each suc-
cessive pair of inlets, with but one modification, viz:
    "Between Corson's and Egg IHarbor inlets, where two shoal areas occur, one in
Crook Horn Thoroughfare and the other in Peck's Bay. This may be only an appar-
ent departure from the rule, since present indications make it very possible that at
some time in the past an inlet existed, but subsequently closed, between Corson's and
Egg Harbor inlets.
    "The cross-section of the inlets is such as to allow of the passage of large quantities
of water into the inland areas at flood tide, and the escape of this volume at the ebb
results in considerable concentration of currents at special localities and a consequent
deepening of the inland passages at such points of concentration."
    The depth of water in the thoroughfares, channels, bays, and sounds is very vari-
able in different localities. In the narrower water-ways depths of from 30 to 40 feet
frequently occur, while in the broad areas of the bays and sounds the ruling depth is
 .about 1 foot.
    The land areas immediately along the coast-line and at the inlets are composed of
drifting sand, and the configuration of the bars at the months of the inlets materially
change with each violent gale. Directly behind the sand border of the coast lie the
salt marshes traversed by the water-ways under consideration. The land areas of
these marshes consist of a tough, black soil, apparently the result of slow deposit and
vegetable growth, closely knit together with the roots of the marsh grass.
     The shore-lines of the water-ways rise with nearly a vertical face from 1 to 2 feet
above mean high water, and present surfaces quite easily eroded by the action of cur-
rents and storms. The banks are thickly perforated with the holes of sand-fiddlers
and craw-fish, and through their action a slow disintegration of the banks is con-
stantly in progress.
     The beds of the water areas consist of mud, except in the vicinity of the inlets,
where sand is found. Occasionally sand and gravel bars, bare at low water, occur
  away from the inlets, but such material forms only in exceptional cases any part of
  the beds of the thoroughfares and sounds. The character of the mud covering the
  bottom suggests that its source of supply is derived from the decaying banks. The
  water away from the inlets is very clear and free from suspended matter, which in-
  dicates that the process of deposition must be exceeding slow.
     The bays and sounds are universally shoal, carrying about 1 foot depth at low water,
  except in narrow and tortuous drains, which are very unstable in position, with a
  tendency to shift under the varying influences of storm tides. The unstable condi-
  tion of the forces which seem to operate in these bays and sounds will militate seri-
  ously against the improvement of the proposed line of water communication, since a
  large part of the water-way requiring improvement lies through these shallow bays
  and sounds.
     Upon the accompanying maps the 6-foot curve of depth is shown in blue and the
  line of best depth in dotted red. Along the line in red the distance from the point of
  beginning at Schellinger's Landing, Cape May, is marked by numbered stations 500
  feet apart ; the distances from Cape May, in miles, is also noted on this line. The d is-
  tance in an air line between the initial point at Cape May and deep water in Great
  Bay is about 47 miles. By the line of best water this distance is increased to 65 miles.
     The following statement shows the amount of excavation in cubic yards, scow
  measurement, which would require to be removed to form channels, respectively 4
   anld i feet deep, with widths of 50, 75, and 100 feet. All excavation has been calcu-
                APPENDIX               G-REPORT                 OF LIEUT.            COL. ROBERT.                         733
lated to 1 foot below the depth named, and in reducing the quantity of material to
scow measurement 20 per cent. has been added to the quantity in situ.
   The first column, marked " miles," indicates the mile, numbering Irom Cape May,
in which the natural channel requires improvement to give channels of the stated
depths and widths. The column adjacent to "miles" indicates the length of natural
channels requiring improvement in each mile of route specified.

                                     Depth of channel, 4 feet.                            Depth of channel, 6 feet.

       Miles.
                                      50 feet      75 feet      100 feet       Length.      50 feet       75 feet      100 feet
                       ILength.        wide.        wide.        wide.                       wide.         wide.         wide.


                        F eet.        Cu. yds.    Cu.yds.       Cu. yds.        Feet.       Cu. yds.     Cu. yds.      Cu. yds.
1...............            600        6, 000      2W.000       40, 000         5, 280      15, 000.      51, c(00       8, 000
                                                                                    200                     2, 000         3, 000
4..................
  ..................---1,700
                       3,00            34, 000       47, 000       60,   000     5, 000
                                                                                 4, 000
                                                                                              64, 000
                                                                                              23, 000,
                                                                                                           89, 000
                                                                                                           64,.000
                                                                                                                        114, 000
                                                                                                                        104, 000
5....................
       7-------------  --    O --      10, 000       19, 000       28, 000       2, 500       22, 000      37, 000        50, 000
                                       12, 000       26, 000       40, 000       3, 300       27, 000      41,000         56, 000
6..................     3,100         ,22,000       32, 000       42, 000       5, 280       52, 000      72, 000        95, 000
                                       40, 000       56,000        72, 000       5, 280       72,000      100, 000      130, 000
                                       14, (00       21, 000       27, 000       4,600        35, 000      52, 000        67, 000
27-...4,100                            34, 000       47, 000       61, 000       4, 300       58, 000      86, 000      113,000
 .---------- ----- 4,00
28   ................ 4,000            34, 000       48, t00       62, 000       4, 400       62, 000      85, 000      110, 000
32..................      .                                                         500                    10, 000        20, 00C
33..................        3,800      33, 000       46, 000       60, 000       4, 000       57, 000      87, 000      120, 000
34.........----........--.  3, 950     30, 000       41, 000       51, 000       5, 000       49, 000      70, 000      112, 000
35..................        2,100      31, 000       53, 000       74, 000       3, 000       58, 000      85, 000      132, 000
37..................        4, 000     40, 000       55, 000       72, 000       4, 200       68,000       94, 003      120, 000
38---------..............   4,000      41, 000       58, 000       74, 000       4, 300       70, 000      95, 0(0      121, 000
39.................         3,000      12, 000       17, 000       22, 000       3, 600       33, 000      46, 000        60, 00,
48.................. ...        -                                                   500                                     3, 00)
49.-----.---~1-------                                                            3, 000                                   14,000
510...         ............ 2,600      41, 000       55, 00(0      71, 000       5, 000       68, 000       94, 000     120, 00
                                       25, 000       37, 000       49, 000       3. 400       46, 000       66, 000       85, 00)
60.................. .......
60.--------------
61.......--.......... ---280
                      5                                                          1, 900        7, 000(      11, 000       14, 000
                 . 5, 280
62...............--                     67, 000      93, 000      120, 000       5, 280      106, 000      143, 000      181,000
63................  5, 280              67, 000      93, 000      120, 000       5, 280      106, 000      143, 000      181, X00
                                        67, 000
                                        67,
                                                     9:1,000      120, 000       5, 280      106, 000      143,000       181, 00
             .....
61...--....--..             5, 280      67, 000
                                            000      93,000       120, 000       5, 280      106, 000      143, 000      181, 000
                                            _           _            _


                        77, 970        727, 003   1, 054, 00    1, 388, 000    103, 600    1,310, 0u0    1, 909, 000   2, 575, 000



  From the foregoing table it will be seen that the length of channel requiring ira
provement to secure a low-water depth of 4 feet is about 15 miles, while for a 6-foot
depth it is about 20 miles. In considering the probable cost of any one of the six
plans for which estimates of quantities are given in the foregoing table, it may be
assumed safely that the greatest economy will result from simply casting over into a
bank parallel to and directly alongside of the proposed channels as much of the
dredged material as can be so placed with a single handling. By this method of dis-
posal the material removed by scows will be reduced to a minimum, with a direct
saving in the cost of the work.
  It can be assumed that a dredge can carry a cut 25 feet wide and at the same time
bank the dredged material directly from the dipper. For channels 50 feet wide this
would result in allowing all dredged material to be deposited directly by the dredge
on an adjacent bank by carrying two parallel cuts, each 25feet wide. If the channel
is increased to 75 feet width, then one cut must be cast over the second time or else
removed in the first handling by scows. If the channel is made 100 feet wide, then
one-half the quantity of excavation must be removed by scows.
  Even assuming that it is as economical to rehandle with the dredge as to remove
with scows, it will be found in the excavation of the channels through the shoal
areas, where often the depth of excavation is fully as great as the depth of channel
proposed, that there will not be room on each bank for the deposition of more mate-
rial than that which is derived from a single cut 25 feet wide.
   A dredge would be obliged to keep a tug at hand, even though no material was
scowed away, to assist in movement from place to place and to keep up the supply of
cbal, fresh water, and supplies. But for such service a smaller tug would suffice than
that required for towing scows. I would estimate the cost of the removal of all ma-
terial which can be banked by the dredge with a single handling at 15 cents per
cubic yard, and for all material which requires to be dredged and removed by scows
at 20 cents per cubic yard, upon the assumption that appropriations were available
so as to permit of an annual expenditure of from $410,000 to $A0,090 from the com-
734          REPORT           OF     TIE       CHIEF          OF       ENGINEERS,            U. S. ARMY.

mencement to the completion of the work.                              Upon this basis the cost of the several
plans w ould be as follows:

Four-foot channel, 50 feet wide :
    730,000 cubic yards, at 15 cents...............................----..                                       $109,500
    Superintendence and contingencies..........--......                                    ............           10,500

                                                                                                                 120, 000
Four-foot channel, 75 feet wide:
   700,000 cubic yards, at 15 cents............-...--                --............     ..                       105,000
    350,000 cubic yards, at 20 cents......            ---.... ----......-..............  --                     .70,  000
    Superintendence trad contingencies........................------------..........                              20,000

                                                                                                                 195,000

Four-foot channel, 100 feet wide:
    700,000 cubic yards, at 15 cents...................................-----------------------------------...    105, 000
    700,000 cubic yards, at 20 cents- ....................................                                       140, 000
    Superintendence and contingencies..................................                                           '25, 000

                                                                                                                 270, 000
Six-foot channel, 50 feet wide:
     1,310,000 cubic yards, at 15 cents----.....................................                                 196,500
     Superintendence and contingencies..................................                                          20, 500

                                                                                                                 217, 000

Six-foot channel, 75 feet wide:
    1,270,000 cubic yards, at 15 cents ....................................                                      190,500
    640,000 cubic yards, at 20 cents..................................------....                                 1281, 000
    Superintendence and contingencies..................................                                           31, 500

                                                                                                                 350, 000

Six-foot channel, 100 feet            wide:
    1,300,000 cubic yards,            at 15 cents ....................................                           195, 000
    1,300,000 cubic yards,            at 20 cents ....................................                           260, 000
    Superintendence and               contingencies..................................                             45, 000

                                                                                                                 500, 000

    The northern 4 miles of the route, or that part of the line through Grassy and Little
bays, is through continuously shoal water less than 1 foot deep. It will be seen from
the previous table that the excavation through the 61, 62, 63, and 64 miles of the route
is nearly one-third of the entire amount. If Atlantic City be made the northern ter-
minus of the route, the work required on the last 4 miles of the line, between Cape
May and Great Bay, would be eliminated and the foregoing estimates reduced about
one-third.
    In relation to the permanency of the dredged channels, it is difficult in all cases to
reach satisfactory conclusions. In the thoroughfares and narrow water-ways I believe
  that improved channels can be maintained by the action of tidal currents, but in the
long dredged cuts which would be required across the bays and sounds there are
strong reasons against the presumption of permanency.
    The length of the artificial channels required across these broad and shallow water
areas. are as follows: Jarvis's Sound. four-fifths of a mile; Grassy Sound, 1 mile;
Leaming's Bay, 14 miles; Ludlam's Bay, 1 mile; Peck's Bay, 1 miles; Grassy and
  Little bays, 4 miles.
    To render such long narrow channels usable, it is necessary that they should be on
  lines which can be defined by ranges, and there can be no assurance that such lines
  will be coincident with the direction of prevailing tidal currents, especially when the
  set of the most energetic currents depends upon the direction of storm winds. Sonim
  of the bays and sounds are several miles in extent, and with such a reach waves of
  considerable amplitude are formed under the impulse of the wind. Such waves mov-
  ing throughthe very shoal water, transverse to the direction of the dredged channel,
  would tend to refill the artificial channel just as the waves efface and change the
  tortuous drains formed by the tidal currents through the broad shoal areas.
     Through the narrow water-ways, channels which follow the trend of the shore-lines
  will not be lacking in definition since they can be easily identified with the configu-
           APPENDIX      G--REPORT         OF LIEUT.     COL. ROBERT.              735
ration of adjacent shore-lines. An inspection of the maps will clearly indicate that
any improved channels which are possible will be too narrow and circuitous to render
them of value to sailing vessels, and that consequently they would only be of value
to craft moved by steam.
  The formation of banks along each side of improved channels by the deposition of
dredged material will generally cause them to act as deflecting dikes and probably
materially aid in the maintenance of the improved channels. At the ends of the
dredged channels the excavated material could be easily disposed so as to form flank-
ing embankments, which would aid in concentrating the currents upon the improved
channels. It is. highly probable that valuable results in the way of diversion and
concentration could be accomplished at many points by closing side channels with
embankments of dredged material.
  The beds of the water-ways through whicb the route under consideration passes
are of considerable value as oyster fisheries. In any plan for the improvement of these
water-ways there would necessarily arise objections to interference with, and injury
to, the private interests involved in these oyster fisheries. To what extent the for-
mation of dredged channels and the deposition of dredged material would injure those
oyster interests, I am unable to form an opinion; parties in interest have stated that
the injury would not be inconsiderable.
  In closing I desire to testify to the valuable services rendered by Mr. Feodore Syl-
vester, and to commend the energy and intelligence with which the survey and the
plotting of the maps was carried on under his personal supervision.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                        L.   Y.   SCHERMERIORN,
                                                                   Assistant Engineer.
  Lieut. Col. HENRY M. ROBERT,
                     Corps of Engineers.
                               APPENDIX H.




IMPROVEMENT OF HARBORS AND RIVERS IN THE STATES OF DELAWARE
  AND MARYLAND, AND OF MAURICE RIVER, NEW JERSEY, AND THE
  INLAND WATER-WAY FROM CHINCOTEAGUE BAY, VIRGINIA, TO I)ELA-
  WARE BAY.




REPORT OF MR. WILLIAM F. SMITH, UNITED STATES AGENT IN CHARGE,
FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1888, WITH OTHER DOCU-
MENTS RELATING TO THE WORKS.

                                 IMPROVEMENTS.

1. Maurice River, New Jersey.              12. Corsica Creek, Marylana.
2. Wilmington Harbor, Delaware.            13. Choptank River, Maryland.
3. Ice-harbor at New Castle, Delaware.     14. Nanticoke River, Delaware.
4. Duck Creek, Delaware.                   15. Broad Creek, Delaware, from its
5. Saint Jones River, Delaware.                  mouth to Laurel.
6. Mispillion Creek, Delaware.             16. Wicomico River, Maryland.
7. Broadkiln River, Delaware.              17. Upper Thoroughfare between Deil's
8. Indian River, Delaware.                       Island and the mainland.
9. Inland water-way from Chincoteague      18. Pocomoke River, Maryland.
      Bay, Virginia, to Delaware Bay, at    19. Removing sunken vessels or craft ob-
      or near Lewes, Delaware.                    structing or endangering naviga-
10. Susquehanna River above and below             tion.
      Havre de Grace, Maryland.
11. Chester River at Kent Island Narrows,
      Maryland.




                               UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                        Wilmington, Del., July 9, 1888.
   SIR : I have the honor to transmit herewith the annual report for the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, of the works of river and harbor im-
provemeunt in my charge.
  I was assisted by Mr. Charles Humphreys, assistant engineer, in the
prosecution of these works during the first five months of the fiscal
year.
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                      Wx. F. SMITH,
                                                        United States Agent.

  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. A.
       ENG 88-       47                                                    737
738        REPORT OF THE"CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                  H i.

               IMPROVEMENT OF MAURICE RIVER, NEW JERSEY.

   Proposals were opened on July 21, 1887, for continuing this improve-
ment with the appropriation of August 5, 1886, and a contract entered
into with the American Dredging Company, of Philadelphia, Pa. The
work was commenced on the 8th of August, 1887, and continued with-
out interruption until the 20th of October, 1887.
   Previous work has been to dredge a channel 100 feet wide from a
point 4 miles below Millville to within 5,000 feet of that place, and
from thence to Millville 50 feet in width; all to a depth ranging from
5 to 6 feet at low water.
   The work during the present fiscal year consisted in widening the
50-foot channel to 100 feet in width at bottom, a distance of 3,050 feet,
making the depth 6 to 7 feet at low water. The total number of cubic
yards of material removed was 29,363, which was deposited on the
banks from 50 to 100 feet from the nearest edge of the channel by a
long boom and force pump.
   There is now an average 6-foot low-water navigation to within 5,350
feet of Millville. The effect of the work done is already of much benefit
to commerce and navigation, and the people interested are pleased with
the results thus far accomplished.
   An appropriation of $20,000 is recommended for the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1890, and if appropriated will be applied to continuing
the dredging for a 6-foot low-water navigation 100 feet in width over
the 4 miles of the river below Millville.
   Credit is due the contractor for the prompt and efficient manner in
which the work was prosecuted.
   The estimated value of commerce on the river is $1,82t,585. The
tonnage of vessels owned on the river aggregates 11,000 tons. The com-
pletion of the proposed improvement will open a competing route of
transportation to the business of Millville valued from $7,000,000 to
 $8,000,000, and which consists principally of the manufacture of iron
pipe, glass, and both manufacture and dyeing of cotton goods.
This work is in the collection district of Bridgeton, New Jersey, which is also the
nearest port of entry. Amount of revenue collected the last fiscal year is $188. 78.

                                     AMOUNTS       APPROPRIATED.


By act passed August 2, 1882 ...-- ............                   .... ...............         ....--- ...      $:3,000
By act approved July 5,; 1884......------....----..--.--.....---..---..--...---...--.---......----.   17,000
By act approved August 5, 1886 .        --..................--...---....--....                 -....... 5, 000

                                          Money statement.

July 1, 1887, amount available .-                                        $4, 967. 26
                                                                    ..----..
                                                 ....---- ----............---..
                                ......--.....-----.....-----.---
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887--......--..----. ----...------....-----...........---.4, 952.42
                                                                      ---......----....
July 1, 1888, balance available .........             ................            ....   .........                14. 84
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 188- ........-
                                                      -                           ..-............            10, 000. 00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889..................                                      10,014.84


   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                 O0, 000. 00
   Submitted in complianch with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
               APPENDIX        H--REPORT* OF MR.               W. F. SMITH.                           739
Abstract of proposals received and opened at 12 o'clock noon of July 21, 1 87, by General
   William F. Smith, United States agent, for dredging in Maurice River, NYew Jersey.

                                                                        Time.                    Price per
No.                   Name and address.                                                         cubic yard,
                                                                                               place meas-
                                                              Commence.      Complete.           urement.


                                                                                                  Cents.
1    American Dredging Company, Philadelphia, Pa........ Aug. 20, 1887     Oct. 20,1887                   14


                              LETTER OF    MR.   O.   W.   WORSTALL.

                                                           MILLYILLE,     N. J.,        lJune 30, IP4-.
  DEAR SII:: In   answer to yours of 25th instant, I can say that I believe there is 10
to 20 per cent. more shipping on our river than there would have been had there been
no improvements made; there are vessels come here carrying 300 to 500 tons, and
built for this trade, which would not have been thought of before the improvements
here made, and one great advantage is that it will b1) a check on the railroad. We
can not be imposed upon very much if we have good water navigation. R. D. Wood
& Co. are building another new vessel to trade here, and I hope you will soon be able
to continue on up to the bridge with the good work that was done last.
      Yours, respectfully,
                                                                            O.     W.     WORSTALL.
  General W    m.   F. SMITH,
                     U. S. Engineer.



                                              H 2.

           IMPROVEMENT           OF WILMINGTON HARBOR, DELAWARE.

   The condition of the harbor from its entrance to Market-street Bridge,
in October, 1886, is given in the last Annual Report of the Chief of En-
gineers. At the close of the last fiscal year a channel 75 feet wide and
15 feet deep at low water had been dredged from Market-street Bridge
to a point 6,200 feet from the outer end of the jetty. Dredging during
the 1)resent fiscal year was continued under the contract with the Na-
tional Dredging Company, dated February 10, 1887, to July 19, 1887, on
which date work was suspended on account of the near exhaustion of
the appropriation. There has been nothing done since. The channel,
75 feet wide and 15 feet deep at low water, was extended to the outer
end of the jetty. The distance dredged was 3,000 feet, removing 31,111
cubic yards. After the dredging was suspended a survey was made of
the dredged channel from Market street to the entrance of the harbor,
and results show considerable filling just above Third-street Bridge and
at the mouth of the Brandywine Creek.
   This shoaling is due to the natural sloping of the sides of the cut (the
depth of cutting in the above cases being from 4 feet to 12 feet in soft
mud), vessels lying aground during low tide outside the channel and
forcing the soft mud into the channel ; unreasonable speed of the steam-
boats navigating a stream 300 to 400 feet wide; washing from the streets
of Wilmington, and freshets in the Brandywine. At the points where
the channel had shoaled the depth of water on the flats had increased.
   The jetty at the entrance has remained in fair condition, and its effect
has been to increase the depth except at the outer end where the ten-
dency is to shoal. It is believed that this could be remedied by extend-
ing the jetty 322 feet further in the Delaware River, and in a direction
to cause the ebb tide in the Delaware to unite parallel with ebb from the
Christiana River.
740          REPORT          OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Owing to the small appropriations the work has been confined to
dredging for the immediate relief of navigation. The amount recom-
mended for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, is $75,000, and if ap-
propriated will be applied to extending the jetty, and dredging to secure
a 15-foot low-water navigation in accordance with the approved project.
  It is estimated that $5,000 to $10,000 will be required annually to
maintain the improvement. The maritime commerce of the port of
Wilmington for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is -   tons, valued
at $-.
  Wilmington is a port of entry, and in the collection district of Delaware. The
amount of revenue collected for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, is $6,654.74.

                                           AMOUNTS           APPROPRIATED.

By   act   approved     July 14, 1836 ........-------..-------......------------------.............                     --                       $15, 000
By   act   approved     March 3, 1837- .................--------------........---------        ...... ------......- -..--                           8,000
By   act   approved     July 7, 1838----
                                      ....-------....---......--...--..--....---...--.....--------------------                                      9, 356
By   act   approved     July 11, 1870 .......................---.....-------                                          ..---                       15, 000
By   act   approved     June 10, 1872 ...--.....---..........   ---................-----------..--------......                                     10, 000
y   act   approved                      ......-----......----..........-----......------......--......----....
                        March 3, 1873-----                                                                                                          6, 000
By   act   approved     June 23, 1874 ...................--                --....--..............--.....                                            6,000
By act approved March 3, 1875 ...-...                      ................-........-............                                                 10, 009
By act approved August 14, 1876 ..........................................                                                                        16,000
By act approved June 18, 1878. .........................--                                                               ..--   -----.........     7, 000
By act approved March 3, 1879 ---..........................                                                  ......    ...........---.             3,500
By act approved June 4, 1880....................                                           .........................                              10,000
By act approved March 3, 1881 ............................................                                                                        50, 000
By act passed August 2, 1882 .------..------....--.... --------......--..............----..---..--.......-------.                                 50, 000
                                                            .........
By act approved July 5, 1884 --................ .... --....--                  ..... ---.... 25, 000
       ac
By act approved August 5, 1886......--......---- .----.............------....----........    18, 750
   Two thousand four hundred and eleven dollars and twenty-two cents
of the above appropriations have been carried to the surplus fund of the
Treasury.
                           Money statement.
July 1,1887, amount available........-------......--.....--....
                                                          -.....----------........----..----                                             $8,      199.26
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                                                   .......................----..
   outstanding July 1, 1887 .....------....---......----....---                                                        ------                6,033. 03

                                                                                --------......------.. 2, 166. 21
July 1, 1888, balance available....-------.... ---....----...... ............------------.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.......................... 30, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ....................                                                                 32, 166. 21
JAmount    (estimated) required for completion of existing project....-------.... 117, 634.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June30, 1890 75, 000.00
   Su bmitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                                H, 3.

                         ICE HARBOR AT NEW CASTLE, DELAWARE.

  Operations during the present fiscal year consisted of placing 252
cubic yards of riprap around Piers K and N at bottom to prevent scour-
ing, and repairing damages to Pier N caused by collision from a steamer.
  The repairs required the removal of 20 stones from the south face, 3
from the back of the top course, and 13 pieces of paving stones. These
stones, as well as those displaced by the collision, were all put in their
proper places again and clamped.                                          Four new clamps were also put on
thle northeast corner stone.
                 APPENDIX              H--REPORT                   OF MR.            W.         F.        SMITH.                 741
   A steam hoister was engaged and the work done by hire of labor and
purchase of material in open market.
   The amount asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, is $15,600,
and if appropriated will be applied to rebuilding Pier H, which is in a
most insecure condition, and the necessity of rebuilding it is urgent.
   The dredging should also extend a short distance above and below
the harbor to create a current to diminish the tendency to fill up.
   New Castle is the only harbor of refuge from running ice in the Dela-
ware River between the Delaware Breakwater and Marcus Hook, a dis-
tance of 76 miles. Its importance to navigation and commerce may be
inferred from the fact that about two thousand vessels and steamers,
all coastwise and foreign, seek refuge there during the ice season on
the Delaware River.
  The ice harbor of New Castle is in the collection district of Delaware, and Wilming-
ton is the nearest port of entry.
  The amount of revenue collected during the fiscal year is $6,654.74.

                                            AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED.

By act approved May 20, 1826 ............---......--.                              ..........--......--        --.     $25, 000. 00
By act approved       March 2, 1829 ......-----....--..----..........                                        .-.         ...   17,895.99
By act approved        July 2, 1836-- ---.......-----------............--............------.....--------... ----              25,000. 00
By act approved       March 3, 1837 ------.............------....--------------.................    -- --------...             10,000.00
By act approved
By act approved
                      July     7,      ..............
                               1838-----                                    .....             ----.........----....           11,573.00
                      August 30, 1852 --..------......-..---...                    ------...........---..........----        15,000.00
By act approved        July 15, 1870...... .......................                                        ..... ....            2,500. 00
By act approved       June 10, 1872 ............                  .............--.............---                             27, 000. 00
By act approved       March 3, 1873...................................                                                        20,000. 00
By act approved       June 27, 1874....... ...........................                                            ......      10,000. 00
By act approved       March 3, 1875 ..............                              ....       .........--.....- -...             20,.     00
By act approved       August 14, 1876...            ............           ...............                          .....     12,000. 00
By act approved                        ..............................----------..--...-----....
                      June 18, 1878--------------------                                                                       10, 000.00
By act approved       March 3, 1879 .....--               ..- ------..-----..                     ---....
                                                                                                      .............             5,000. 00
By act approved       June 14, 1880 -......................................                                                    3, 000. 00
By act approved       March 3, 1881 .---.....----......          --..........------.......---- ---.                           20,000. 00
By act approved       July 5, 1884 ..--...........--       ---....---.....................                                     2,000. 00
By act approved       August 5, 1886---.......................................                                                  5, 000.00
  Of the above appropriations $18,285.05 has been turned into the sur-
plus fund of the Treasury.
                                                 Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available.......----------.....---------........-----------..----.....--...     $853.20
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887-- ------ --- -..............----..--------------------.......................-----....-----
                                                                                                       853.20

Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888....-                                       ....-..............               7, 500.00

iAmount  (estimated) required for completion of existing project.... ...
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890
                                                                                                                          8, 100.00
                                                                                                                          8,100. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1566 and 1867.



                                                             H 4.
                    IMPROVIEMENT OF DUCK CREEK, DELAWARE.

  There were no operations during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888,
for want of funds.
  The survey directed in the act of August 5, 1836, was completed and
a report submlnitted andl printed in the last Annual Relport of the Chief of
Engineers.
742      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The project recommended for the improvement is to give a 7-foot low-
water navigation to the town of Smyrna, Del., the head of navigation.
The channel at the entrance to be 100 feet wide and inside the creek 60
feet in width.
  The estimated cost of the dredging is $37,365.20. To protect the
channel at the entrance by the construction of a jetty would cost, built
of wood, $20,000; made of stone, $53,333.20.
  In case no jetty was built, $2,000 annually would probably be re-
quired to maintain the channel at the entrance.
  Ten thousand dollars was expended in dredging a channel through
the bar at- the entrance to 8 feet at low water; for want of a protecting
work it has filled up to 4. feet. The citizens have spent $6,500 in dredg-
ing inside the creek.
  The commerce of the stream is estimated to be between $2,000,000
and $3,000,000. The amount that can be profitably expended during
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, is $33,000, and if appropriated,
will be applied to dredging a channel inside the stream in accordance
with the project submitted.
  Duck Creek is in the collection district of Delaware; Wilmington is the nearest
port of entry, and the revenue collected there during the last fiscal year is $6,654.74.
                              AMOUNTS    APPROPRIATED.

                                                                                $5,000
By act approved June 14. 1880 .---.........------.....----....------.......--...-
                                                              -..........------..
                                                                         -----.
By act approved March 3. 1881------...-----.....---.........---------......--.-- 3, 000
By act passed August 2, 1882........ ...... .... .... ...... ...... .... ......   ,000

                                 Money statement.

Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1868.......................... $10, 000. 00
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 80,698. 40
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 37, 365. 20
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                         H 5.
           IMPROVEMENT OF SAINT JONES RIVER, DELAWARE.

   At the close of last fiscal year work was in progress under a contract
with the American Dredging Co., dated January 13, 1887, and under
this contract dredging was continued during the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1988, until the end of July, 1887, when operations were sus-
pended on account of the near exhaustion of funds. The result of the
work under the contract was the removal of 10,291 cubic yards of ma-
terial, measured in place, the excavation of a channel 40 feet wide at
bottom and 6 feet deep at low water from the old ship-yard, one-quarter
mile below Dover, to that place, and enlarging the turning basin to 125
feet radius. Also.widening the channel at eight sharp bends between
Lebanon and Dover.
  The dredge was then remnoved to the entrance, and a channel 40 feet
wide and 6 feet deep at low water was excavated through the bar a
distance of 2,400 feet. Of this distance the United States Government
paid fir' dredging 1,050 feet-4,1.00 cubic yards by special agreement
with the dredging company, at 12 cents per cubic yard. The remainder
                  APPENDIX I-REPORT OF MR. W. F. SMITH.                                                           743
of the distance dredged over the bar was paid for by the citizens inter-
ested in the navigation of the river.
   The banks of the river between Lebanon and Dover were cleared of
overhanging trees during the months of October and November, 1887.
   At this date there is a 4-foot low-water navigation through the en-
trance 40 feet wide, and from thence to Dover 6-foot low-water naviga-
tion, 40 feet in width.
   It is proposed to apply the appropriation asked for the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1890, to securing a 3-foot low-water navigation through
the entrance by dredging and constructing a jetty to protect the chan-
nel.
   Since the improvement of this river a steamer runs regularly between
Dover and Philadelphia, and rates of freight between those places have
been much reduced.
   Before the improvement there was no steam-boat navigation on this
river, and the railroad had no competition.
   Freight on calves from Dover to Philadelphia has been reduced from
90 cents per head to 30 cents per head.
   It is assumed other freights have been proportionally reduced.
   By this improvement the business of Dover, valued at $2,000,000, is
offered a competing route of transportation, besides the country bor-
dering on the river, which depends upon hauling their produce many
miles to the nearest depots.
  Dover is in the collection district of Delaware. Wilnington is the nearest port of
entry, at which the amount of revenue collected for the last fiscal year is $6,654.74.
                                          AMOUNTS        APPROPRIATED.


By act approved March 3, 1881...... ...... ............                   .... ....                               $5, 000
                                                                                                      -......--....-
By act approved July 5, 1884..----..---.... ............------------...........-----.---...........-----.... -10,000
By act approved August 5, 1886 .-----.....----............--..----.....--......
                                                                           -------                        --.... 10,000

                                              Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available-----....         ---....-.............. ..............----.             $2, 245. 86
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 .----..... -----......---- -....--....
                                                            ---........---..--- ---..----.........---- 2,245. 50
                                    ------------------......----......--....
July 1, 1888, balance available ....--....................                                                        .36
                                                                       -
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ....-----............----.... ....                           15, 000.00
Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ---...........-----                  --....--....    15, 000. 36
                                                                      -
 (Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........
  Amount that can be profitablyexpended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890
                                                                                             --            20,000.00
                                                                                                           20, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
   harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                         H 6.

                IMPROVEMENT OF MISSPILLION CREEK, DELAWARE.

   There were no operations during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888,
for want of funds. The condition of the improvement is unknown.
   The project adopted is to give a 6-foot low-water navigation, 40 feet
in width from the mouth to the head of navigation, and a 4-foot low-
water navigation at the entrance.                           The tide rises 4- feet at the entrance
and 2) feet at Milford.
744            REPORT            OF      THE        CHIEF           OF       ENGINEERS, IT. S. ARMY.

As far as could be ascertained there has been no change in the com-
mercial statistics since last annual report.
  Misspillion Creek is in the collection district of Delaware.  Wilmington is the
nearest port of entry, at which the amount of revenue collected for the last fiscal
year is $6,654.74.
                                                 AMOUNTS          APPROPRIATED.

By    act   approved March 3, 1879 ----....-------....----....--....-----......               ...--...--------..--....-----....        $3, 000
By    act   approved June 14, 1880 .... ----........----...----..---------....                                                 ----. 4, 000
                                                                                               ----....----....--------....--....
By
By
      act
      act
            approved March 3, 181...               ----..........--------..........-------..------
            passed August 2, 1882 ......-------....-----------....------....--....
                                                                                                     ......-------....
                                                                                             .....------....
                                                                                                                          ------......
                                                                                                                       ---.... ...
                                                                                                                                --
                                                                                                                                        3, 500
                                                                                                                                        3, 000

                                                     Money statement.
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 -- .- ...--.. ..                                        ..    ....   . ...        $, 500. 00

I   Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-......
     Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890
                                                                                                                                55, 000. 00
                                                                                                                                 3, 500. 00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
      harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




                                                                  H 7.

                    IMPROVEMENT OF BROADKILN RIVER, DELAWARE.

  There were no operations during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
  The condition of the improvement is unknown, although it is reported
that the work done in 1885 has maintained itself. There has been no
change in the commercial statistics since the last annual report.
  The improvement is in the collection district of Delaware. Wilmington is the near-
est port of entry, at which the amount of revenue colected for the last fiscal year is
$6,654.74.
                                                 AMOUNTS          APPROPRIATED).

By    act   approved March 3,              187:......----.-----..........---......-----....------
                                                       ...---.           ---
                                                                                                 ..--..----.........--------.
                                                                         ....------.....------...--.......--------......
                                                                                                                                   10, 000
                                                                                                                                    5, 000
By    act   approved June 14, 1880---..-- -...---....---
By    act   approved March 3, 1881---- ....--....       --..---................------- ------................---------------        5, 000
By    act   passed August 2, 1882........---......----         ....----.---...----..--.....----------.......---.....                5, 000

                                                      Money statement.
                                                                                         $10, 000.00
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888..---- --........----..- ...-------------......

     Amount (estimated) required for comlpletion of existing project.       --
                                                                         .---.                                                  21,500.00
     Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890                                                  21, 500.00
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
       harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




                                                                  H 8.

                        IMPROVEMENT OF INDIAN RIVER, DELAWARE.

  There has been no work on this improvement since 1883 for want of
funds; the last information respecting the work done was that the
channel had filled up for want of protecting dike, and no benefit had been
derived from the improvement.
  As the work done effected no benefit the cost of the improvement
will have to remain at the original estimalte, 950,000, andl if the work
                APPENDIX           H-REPORT OF MR.                W. F. SMITH.            745
of improvement is continued the amount should be appropriated in one
sum to secure any good. The project is to dredge a channel 80 feet
wide and 4 feet deep at mean low water through " The Bulkhead," and
thence straight to the inlet, protecting it by the construction of a dike
on its northern side.
   By the completion of the improvement will be offered a competing
route of transportation to a large commerce, consisting of fruits, vege-
tables, and oysters, the perishable nature of which prevents their being
shipped by water while so much uncertainty exists as to the time re
quired to get o sea.
   rhere are fifty saw-mills in operation along the banks of Indian River
and tributaries, and produce annually 54,000,000 feet of lumber, valued
at about $1,000,000. A greater portion of this is hauled from 1 to 5
miles to the nearest railroad station, owing to the difficulties in enter-
ing the Indian River from the ocean.
   When the improvement of the inland water-way from Chincoteague
Bay, Virginia, to Delaware Bay, at or near Lewes, Del., is completed to
Indian River, the commerce dependent on Indian River Inlet will be
greatly increased until the improvement is completed to Delaware Bay.
   After the improvement of the inland water-way is completed a bet-
ter outlet for Indian River will be had through the route into Delaware
Bay than can be given through Indian River Inlet to the ocean.
   Indian River is in the collection district of Delaware. The nearest port of entry is
Wilmington, at which the revenue collected during the last fiscal year amounted to
$6,654.74.
                                       AMOUNT APPROPRIATED.
By act passed August 2, 188 - ..........................-......              .....     $10, 000

                                           Money statement.

  Amount that can be profitably expendedin fiscal year ending June 30,1890           50, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




                                                    H 9.
IMPROVEMENT OF INLAND WATER-WAY FROM CHINCOTEAGUE BAY,
   VIRGINIA, TO DELAWARE BAY, AT OR NEAR LEWES, DELAWARE.

  The commissioners appointed by ain act of the Delaware legislature.
passed April 4, 1887, met in January, 1888, and made the awards for
damages to the land owners by reason of the construction of the pro-
posed water-way.
  The papers were forwarded to the Attorney-General and the title to
the lands were by him approved May 9, 1888, provided the awards have
been paid by the State treasurer. Effort is being made to secure the
proper evidence of payment.
  The work will be advertised as soon as the question of payment is
settled.
  The amount asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, is $100,000,
and if appropriated, will be applied to the improvement, in accordance
with the approved project. By an improvement of 15 miles of the pro-
posed route, 150 miles of navigable water will be rendered available,
giving an outlet to 400 square miles of territory.
746           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S .ARMY.

    The estimated amount of commerce interested in the improvement,
and which will                 be     afforded a competing route of transportation, is
$1,795,000.
                                             AMOUNT        APPROPRIATED.


By act approved August 5, 1886 ....-------------......--------...... ----......------.............-----....--....    $18, 750

                                                  Money statement.

July 1, 1887, amount available .............-------------------------............................ $17, 946. 57
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
                                                       ....----
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ..........--------.. --..------          ....-..---..
                                                            ....------..                         --
                                                                                     --..---......-.... 17.98
July 1, 1888, balance available ......------....-----......-------.......--                                17, 928. 59
                                                                            ------......--......------....---......
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .........................                                    50,000.00

Amount available for fiscal year ending June 30, 1889 ...................                                           67,928.59


   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 100, 000. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
    hafbor acts of 1866 and 1867.




                                                            H io.

IMPROVEMENT                  OF     THE SUSQUEHANNA RIVER ABOVE                                           AND BELOW
                                    HAVRE DE GRACE, MARYLAND.

  There were no operations during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888,
for want of funds.
  The effect of the dredging at the shoal near Watson's Island has
been very perceptible in lessening the tendency of the ice to gorge at
this point.
  There has been no work on the shoals between Specutia Island and
Havre de Grace since the summer of 1885, and the condition of the
channel is unknown. The amount that can be profitably expended in
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, is $20,000, and if appropriated will
be applied to attaining a 15-foot navigation below Havre de Grace, and
continuing the work of cutting off the shoal at Watson's Island to pre-
vent the dangerous ice gorges.
  The commerce on the river consists of stone, ice, coal, lumber, and
fruit.       Estimated value $1,500,000.
  Susquehanna River is in the collection district of Baltimore. Baltimore is the
nearest port of entry, at which the amount of revenue collected for the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1888, is $2,996,220.14.

                                             AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED.


By   act approved August 30,1852-..--..............----                ........... .........--... $10,000
By                                              ---- -.......--
      act approved June 23, 1866....--.....--.....-           -- -- -- .----..----------..........--....-----. 26, 400
By   act approved July 11, 1870............--------------------......-...-......................--------------    12, 000
By   act approved June 14,1880.....----------..--........---  ...-----....---..   ..--..--............---------.  28,000
By   act approved March 3, 1881....-....-- --        -....
                                                          --
                                                  ........---           -..----- . ....               ......--..-- 15, 000
By   act passed August 2,1882 ......--------..........----------...------------....--..------..........           25,000
By   act approved July 5, 1884 .--. ..-.....-..--......--...... ...---..........    -                             20, 000
By   act approved August 5, 186 .-----..-----...............----..-------.............                             6, 000
                  APPENDIX H-REPORT                          OF MR. W. F. SMITH.                                        747
                                              Money statement.

Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 ..........                                                          $10, 000. 00
                                                                                      ..............-----------------------..
 ( Amount (estimated) required for annual dredging........ .... ....-....                                         20, 000. 00
) Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890                                      20, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                       H    II.

IMPROVEMENT OF CHESTER RIVER AT KENT ISLAND NARROWS, MARY-
                           LAND.

   Nothing done at this locality since 1877.
   Chester River is in the collection district of Baltimore, which is also the nearest
port of entry, at which the revenue collected for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888,
is $2,996,220.14.
                                          AMOUNTS        APPROPRIATED.

By act approved March 3, 1873 .. ............           .........         -$15,000 .-....
                                                                  ........--
By act approved June 23, 1874 ----..................... ................-                 ..                           5, 000
By act approved August 14, 1876 ................................                      ......                           5,000
By act approved June 18, 1878 ......-----.................. ....--................                                     3,000

                                              Mloney statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available ..............                      ....-..........--.........                     $2, 500.00
July 1, 1888, balance available ..............................------------------------....---......                2,500.00




                                                       H 12.

                   IMPROVEMENT OF CORSICA CREEK, MARYLAND.

  There has been nothing done during the present fiscal year for want
of funds.
  The original project, which is to excavate a channel 100 feet in width
at bottom and 8 feet in depth at low water, has been completed, except
for a distance of 2,300 feet above Hooper's Landing, where the width
has -been made only to 50 feet.
  The amount asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, if appro-
priated will be applied to increasing the width of the channel, from
Hooper's Landing to a point 2,300 feet above, to 100 feet at bottom and
making the depth 8 feet at mean low water.
  The improved channel has been in constant use.
  Corsica Creek is in the collection district of Baltimore. Baltimore is the nearest
port of entry, at which the amount of revenue collected during the last fiscal year
was $2,996,220.14.

                                              Money statement.

July 1, 1887, amount available ......    -..... ......--....... --........ ....                                      $19.49
July 1, 1888, amount expended (luring fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 ..                                                                                          19.49
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, ~                                --.............         ...---
                                                                                                ..--       ...----. 10,000.00
748    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF--ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                 H 13.

          IMPROVEMENT OF CHOPTANK RIVER, MARYLAND.

   The object of this improvement is to give an 8-foot low-water naviga-
tion to Greensborough, Md., by dredging. The work was commenced
in 1881. At the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1885, a chan-
nel had been excavated to Greensborough 6 feet in depth at low water,
varying in width from 47 feet to 75 feet. An examination of the chan-
nel was made in November, 1886, for 24 miles below Greensborough,
and it was found to be considerably filled in by washing of the banks.
   A contract was made after due advertisement with Mr. Thomas P.
Morgan in December, 1886. Very little work had been accomplished
under the contract at the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1 887,
and operations have continued during the present fiscal year under the
same contract, several extensions to the time for completion having
been granted. The result of the work under this contract with the ap-
propriation of August 5, 1886, is as follows:     Commencing at a point
13,450 feet below Greensborough and working towards that place, a
channel 25 feet wide and 8.5 feet deep at low water was excavated
2,150 feet in length. From this point for a distance of 4,390 feet, a
depth of 5 feet at low water was found. This reach was passed over to
dredge where there was less draught and to extend the navigable chan-
nel to Greensborough.     Commencing again at the upper end of the 5-
foot reach, a channel 25 feet in width and 8.5 feet deep at low water
was excavated 568 feet : from thence to Greensborough, 6,342 feet, the
channel was excavated 40 feet wide and 7 feet deep at low water, and at
Greensborough a turning-basin 125 feet long and 100 feet wide in addi-
tion to the channel width was excavated. There being a small balance
of the appropriation available after completion of the turning-basin, the
dredge was removed downs-tream to the 5-foot draught, and a cut 40
feet wide and 7 feet deep at low water excavated 694 feet down-stream.
   The material removed from the 40-foot channel proved too hard for
the first dredge put on the work, and another and larger one had to be
furnished, and the increase in width was necessary to float this dredge,
and the reduction in depth had then to be made to extend the work to
Greensborough.
   The total amount of material removed is 45,220 cubic yards.
   The material from the 25-foot cuts was deposited by a shute 80 feet
from the edge, and from the 40-foot cut by a long boom behind the old
dredge bank.
   Operations were suspended in May, 1888, owing to near exhaustion
of funds. An examination was made of the river in June, 1888, from
Greensborough to within 3,150 feet of Denton, and the following is the
present condition: With the exception of three shoals, over which there
is 6 feet of water, one 1,100 feet long, 3,200 feet above the bridge at
Denton; one 750 feet long, 8,200 feet above the same place, and one 1,250
feet in length, 15,650 above the same place; there is an 8-foot low-water
navigation 18,200 feet above Denton. From this point a reach extends
3,700 feet, with an average depth of 5- feet at low water. Brick Mill
Landing is at this shoal, and is 20,500 feet above the bridge at Denton;
from thence, for a distance of 4,000 feet, there is an 8 foot low.-water
navigation; from thence to Case's Wharf, at Greensborough, excepting
five.shoals, with an aggregate length of 2,500 feet, over which there is
but 5 feet of water, there is a 7-foot low-water navigation.
   Originally the depth of water betwee      Denton and CGreensborough
                   APPENDIX            H--REPORT               OF MR. W.             F. SMITH.                    749
varied from 2 feet to 8 feet at low tide. A full description of the river
before the improvement was commenced is given in the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1880, pages 634, 635.
  The amount asked for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1890, if appro-
priated, will be applied to dredging in accordance with approved proj-
ect to secure an 8-foot navigation to Greensborough.
   Since the improvement a steamer runs direct to Greensborough from
Baltimore, and another from Greensborough to Denton connecting with
the Maryland Steamboat Company from Baltimore. There are also iour
100-ton schooners and a number of smaller ones, which run to Greens-
borough from Baltimore, Philadelphia, and New York. The large ves-
sels when loaded have to continue the use of lighters. The estimated
value of the commerce on the river is about $800,000. The estimated
value saved to the community by completion of the improvement is
$54,000 annually.
  Choptank River is in the collection district of Baltimore. Baltimore is the nearest
port of entry, at which the amount of revenue collected for the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1888, is $2,996,220.14.

                                               Money statement.

July 1, 1887, amount available--....-------......----.....................-------------------......---....   $8, 849. 97
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887 .............................................                                      8,849.97



 {Amount                                                                          ....
Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888.--------------.................---------

           (estimated) required for completion of existing project - - -- - . 39, 500.00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1890 20, 000.00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
                                                                                                              7,500.00




    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.



                                                         H 14.

                  IMPROVEMENT OF NANTICOKE RIVER, DELAWARE.

  At the close of last fiscal year work was in progress under a contract
with Frank C. Somers, dated January 14, 1887, and under the same
contract continued in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, to February
19. Little had been accomplished at the end of last fiscal year.
   The following is the result of the work with the appropriation of
August 5, 1886 ($10,000) :
   Several shoals were removed from the turning-basin, at Laurel, and
from thence to the Delaware Railroad Bridge, a distance of 1,950 feet,
a channel was excavated 45 feet in width and 5 feet in depth at low
water. At the county bridge the width was increased to 70 feet for a
length of 200 feet, lo make available both draw-spans in the bridge.
   From the Delaware Railroad Bridge to a point 12,350 feet down-
stream, where the 7-foot curve is intersected, the channel was excavated
to a width of 50 feet and 6 feet in depth, at mean low water, and three
bends increased in width to 60, 70, and 60 feet, respectively. A cut
was also made through Collins' Bar, about one-half mile further down-
stream, 600 feet in.length, 50 feet wide, and 6 feet deep at mean low
water.
  The total distance dredged is 14,900 feet. The total amount of ma.
terial removed is 61,747 cubic yards.
750         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The citizens of Laurel also expended between $12,000 and $13,000 in
construction of wharves and dredging in front of them.
  Originally, the portion of the river improved was navigable for light-
ers only. There is now a 6-foot low-water navigation to the Delaware
Railroad Bridge, and from thence to the turning-basin a 5-foot low-
water navigation.
  The estimates for further improvement and commercial statistics, see
under head of Improvement of Broad Creek, Delaware, of these reports.

                                             Money statement.

July 1, 1887, amount available ....................................-------------------------------------.. $8,939.09
July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of liabilities
  outstanding July 1, 1887     ......----..-----                        ......----. ..-----........         8,939.09
For balance of statement, see money statement for Broad Creek, Delaware.




                                                            H 15-

IMPROVEMENT OF BROAD CREEK FROM IT'S MOUTH TO LAUREL, DELA-
                          WARE.

   The act approved August 5, 1886, appropriated $10,000 for "Improv-
ing Nanticoke River, Delaware, continuing the improvement up to and
near the town of Laurel, Del.," and under the head of " Improvement
of Nanticoke River, Delaware," is stated the condition of the work and
the progress made during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
   The amount that can be profitably expended during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1890, is $10,000, and, if appropriated, will be applied to
increasing the width and depth to 50 feet and 7 feet, respectively.
  Congress has passed an act requiring the Delaware Railroad Company
to place a draw in its bridge at Laurel, which, when completed, will be
a great advantage to navigation by permitting all vessels to reach the
turning-basin.
  There has been no change in the commercial statistics since the last
annual report, but the facilities for navigation have been greatly in-
creased.
  Broad Creek is in the collection district of Delaware. Wilmington is the nearest
port of entry, at which the amount of revenue collected for the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1888, is $6,654.74.
                                          AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED.

By act approved June, 14, 1880                 --..-.....       - .......     ...-------...        .                 ...   $5, 000
By act approved March 3, 1881....----.....-----------...........--............                             -------         10, 000
By act passed August 2, 1882 .........................................--....                                                5,000
By act approved August 5, 1886 ....---..-----.........---...----. ----.............--------.--.. ....----...               10, 000

                                             Money statement.

Amount appropriated by act of August 11, 1888 .... -.- --....                                 ..       ... --....       $5, 000. 00

 ( Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                               27, 000.00
I Amount that can be profitably expendedinfiscal year endingJune 30,1890                                               10, 000.00
  SSubmitted in compliance with requirementsof sections 2 of the river and
    harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
                      APPENDIX                 H-REPORT OF MR. W. F. SMITH.                                                                751

                                                                    H 16.

                      IMPROVEMENT OF WICOMICO RIVER, MARYLAND.

  There were no operations during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888.
There has been no work since 1885, at which time the project was com-
pleted. The Channel has been in constant use.
  Full commercial statistics and the benefits to commerce and naviga-
tion were given in last annual report.                                           There has been no changes since
then.
  Wicomico River is in the collection district of the eastern district of Maryland.
Crisfield is the nearest port of entry, at which the amount of revenue collected during
the last fiscal year is $-
                                                      AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED.
By act approved--
                    ...........----......----.-----...---........----...--..........---....----..---.......--.
    June 10, 1872------                                                                                                                            $5, 000
    March 3, 1873 ....................-----
                      ------                    -....---....---...---------..........-------.............                                           5,000
    June 24, 1874----....-----....--......-----..             . --......--....--..--.......................                                         5, 000
    March 3, 1875----....---..... .----....----........................----------------..-------------..-----....                                   5,000
    August 14, 1876 ......------------------------....--..--...--.....---........--......---..-.......----............                              5,000
                    ....-------....---..--......
    June 18, 1878--------                                         ------------....-----......--......---....--........                --..........  5,000
   March 3, 1879 .-..---..--- ----..---..---....------- ----- -..............-..------..----............-......----                                 3,000
   June 14, 1880...--------...... ...-------------.......---------....... ----......----........................                                    5,000
    March 3, 1881- ....---......----....----....   ----....--..--...-----.................-----             ....--.----.......--....---.            2, 000
    July 5, 1884 .----.... ---. --............-------..---...   ---- ....----.--.........-----...----                  -..------....---....        10. 000

                                                         Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available ......                             ---....-..           ...........   ..............                $1, 372. 80
                                                                                ........
July 1, 1888, balance available ..----....................--.--.---........----------                                                1, 372. 80




                                                                    H. 17.

IMPROVEMENT                      OF UPPER THOROUGHFARE, BETWEEN DEIL'S ISLAND
                                    AND. THE MAINLAND, MARYLAND.

  There has been no work at this locality during the fiscal year, the
money available being inadequate to commence operations.
  The project is to dredge a basin with an approach to deep water and
construct a breakwater to protect it from filling, the object being to
provide a harbor of refuge for small vessels, and a place at which steam-
ers can stop and bring the people and their abundant crops, from land
and water, into quick communication with the markets of Baltimore and
Philadelphia.
  This improvement is in the collection district of the eastern district of Maryland
Crisfield is the nearest port of entry. The amount of revenue collected there for the
last fiscal year is $---.
                                                     AMOUNT APPROPRIATED.
By act passed August 2, 1882........... ..............................                                                      ....         $5, 000

                                                         Money statement.
July 1, 1887, amount available ............ ...        .................                                              ......       $4, 669.91
July 1, 1888, balance available........ ... .......................                                                     .....       4, 669. 91
  SAmount   (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........
    Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,1890
                                                                                                                                   15, 000.00
                                                                                                                                   15,000.00
    Submitted in compliance with requirements of sections 2 of river and
     harbor acts of 1866 and 1867.
    752          REPORT           OF     THE       CHIEF     OF    ENGINEERS,      IT. S. ARMY.


                                                            H x8.
                       IMPROVEMENT OF POCOMOKE RIVER, MARYLAND.

       A survey was made of this river in 1884 and the project for improve-
    ment submitted contemplated making a cut-off through the low neck of
    land forming bfour abrupt bends just below Snow Hill, Md., which ren-
    dered navigation both difficult and dangerous.
       The channel to be 80 feet wide and 7 feet deep at mean low water.
    The cut-off to be 1,100 feet in length. The right of way was given the
    United States free of cost. The work was advertised in August, 1887,
    and a contract was made with the Atlas Dredging Company, the lowest
    bidder.
       Owing to ice and extreme cold weather the contractor was unable to
    commence work before the spring of 1888. The contract price being
g   much less than the estimate, it was recommended and approved to ap-
    ply the balance of the available funds to the removal of seven shoals
    below the cut-off and excavating a turning-basin at Snow Hill.
       The work was begun in April, 1888, and completed by the end of the
    fiscal year. In accordance with the above project 53,386 cubic yards of
    material were removed. There is now a good 7-foot low-water naviga-
    tion to Snow Hill, the head of navigation.
      Pocomoke River is in the eastern district of Maryland. Crisfield is the nearest port
    of entry, at which the amount of revenue collected during the last fiscal year is

                                                AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED.

    By act approved-
          June 1, 1878 ..--....--......--.......-----.....--....---..        10, 000
                                                          ...............-....-----
          March 3, 1879..-----.------ -----..-                .
                                                             ----.-------------- ---- -------   -       2, 500
          August 5, 1886 .....----.....-----------.....--                                 -.....  8, 000
                                                                  -........----...---.....-......---..........---


                                                     Money statement.
    July 1,    1887,                                                         ----
                                                                       ----........ $8, 000. 00
                       amount available--..------ ----..---..-..---...------.....--....
    July 1, 1888, amount expended during fiscal year, exclusive of
      liabilities outstanding July 1 1887 ......................... $4, 132. 41
                                                                            2, 645. 10
    July 1, 1888, outstanding liabilities--------... ........--..----........------.
                                                                                                    6,777.51
    July 1, 1888, balance available .........................................                        1,222.49




    Abstract of proposals received and opened September 28, 1887, at 12 o'clock noon, by General
          William F. Smith, United States agent, for dredging in Pocomoke River, Maryland.

                                                                                 Time.               Price per
                                                                                                    cubic yard,
    No.                         Names and addresses.                                                   place
                                                                          Commence.   Complete.      measure-


                                                                                                      Cents.
      1    George W. Parsons, Salisbury, Md .--....-----------
                                                           -........... ----------...        --             22
      2    National Dredging Company, Wilmington, Del .........In 30 days. Pr os ecute                      161
                                                                                      with vigor
                                                                                      until com-
                                                                                      pleted.
      3    American Dredging Company, Philadelphia, Pa ........    Dec. 1, 15887Feb. 1, 1888                11
      4    Frank C.Somers, Philadelphia, Pa ...................... Dec. 13, 1887 June 15,1888               16
      5    Atlas Dredging Company, Wilmington, Del ...             Dec. 1, 1887 May 1, 1888
                                                               --....--.                                    10
           APPENDIX     --- REPORT OF IMR. W.     -   . SMITH.       753

                                  H   ig.

REMOVING SUNKEN VESSELS OR CRAFT OBSTRUCTING OR ENDANGER-
                     ING NAVIGATION.

   At the close of the last fiscal year a contract had been made with Mr.
Edward T. Veasev, of Lewes, Del., under provision of section 4 of the
act of June 14, 1880, for the removal of the wreck of the steam pro-
 )eller J. I. Van Doren from the Broadkiln River, Delaware.
   The work was begun promptly and completed by the 20th of July,
1887, at a total cost of $242.13.
   The wreck was of no value.
        ENG 88     48
                                                        IN                )DE X.
                                                                                                                    Page.
                                         SUBJECT.
                                                                                                 Part I.        Part II. Part III. Part IV.


                                             A.

Adams flume, for river improvement, test of..... ............                 1510
Advisory Harbor Commission at Philadelphia...........--......    86 718
Agate Bay Harbor, Minn., improvement of ....................    231           1812
Ahnapee Harbor, Wis., improvement of....................... 239               1846
                                                                158     1187
Alabama River, improvement of .....---------------......--........----...--..-..
Allegheny River, Pa., improvement of......................... 216             1680
Allegheny River, dam at Herr's Island, construction of ....... 216            1682
Altamaha River, Ga., improvement of.......................   .. 141     1035
Amite River, La., improvement of............................ 168        1247
Annapolis Harbor, Md., improvement of .....................-- .          761
Apalachicola Bay, Fla., improvement of .......................  152     1160
Apalachicola River, improvement of........................... 151       1159
Appomattox River, Va., improvement of......................101           768
Aqueduct Bridge, Georgetown, D. C., reconstruction of........ 106        789
Aransas Pass and Bay, Tex., improvement of..................    175     1307
Aransas Pass, Tex., survey of .................................         1312
Archer's Hope River, Va., improvement of ..............--...--. 101      768
Arkansas River, improvement of .............................. 186       1380
Arkansas River improvement, report of Board of Engineers
on ........................................................ ..         1389
Arkansas River, operations of snag-boats on .................. 185      1378
Ashland Harbor, Wis., improvement of......................--  . 233           1817
Ashley River, S. C., improvement of ........................... 136      983
Ashtabula Harbor, Ohio, improvement of ................... . 276              2013
Atlantic City, N. J., survey of harbor of......................  85 717
Au Sable Harbor, Mich., improvement of ........... ..........263              1962



Baltimore Harbor, improvement of entrance to..................                                       95             756
Btngor Harbor, Me., improvement of.........................                                          13   379
Battalion of engineers-..--......................................                                     8   349
Bayoduce River, Me., between Penobscot and Brooksville, ex-
amination of ................................................                                       22   398
Bayoduce River, Me., improvement of.............................                                     13
Bayou Bartholomew, La. and Ark., improvement of...........                                          179            1351
Bayou Black, La., improvement of ..............................                                                    1251
Bayou Boeuf, La., improvement of ................................                                   179            1353
Bayou Courtableau, La., improvement of ........                                     ............... 170            1254
Bayou D'Arbonne, La., improvement of ......................                                         178            1349
Bayou La Fourche, La., improvement of.......................                                        168            1248
Bayou Macon, La., improvement of ............................                                       180            1354
Bayou Pierre, Miss., improvement of ........................                                        171            1258
Bayou Rondeway, La., improvement of.............                                        .......... 180
Bayou Teche, La., improvement of..............................                                                     1253
Bayou Terrebonne, La., improvement of                               ................                169            1250
Bayou Vidal, La., improvement of.                           .......................                 180
Bear Creek, Miss., examination and survey of..............                                          213                      1639
Beaufort Harbor, N. C., improvement of ..................                                           121             875
Beaufort Harbor, inland water-way to New Berne, N. C., im-
  provement of .--........................................                                          120             871
Beaufort Harbor, inland water-way to New River, N. C., im-
  provement of...................................--                                     ...-        122             882
Belfast Harbor, Me., improvement of.:................                                           ...  14   381
Bellamy River, N. H., improvement of ........................                                        20
Belle River, Mich., ice harbor of refuge at ....................                                                             1972
Big Black River, Miss., improvement of.......................                                       181            1356
Big Hatchee River, Tenn., improvement of.................... 183                                                   1367
Big Hockhocking River, Ohio, from mnouth to Coolville, exam-
  ination of .    .........................................                                         218                      1719
Big Sandy River, W. Va. and Ky., improvement of...........                                          227                      1786
Big Sunflower River, Miss., improvement of ..................                                       183            1365
Biloxi Bay, Miss., improvement of harbor at ................                                        164            1214
Black Lake Harbor, Mich., improvement of ..................                                         256                      1913
Black River, Ark. and Mo., improvement of...................                                        189            1411
              ENG 88-1                                                                                                              1
2                                                                  INDEX.


                                                                                                                    Page.
                                        SUBJECT.
                                                                                                 Part I.        Part II. Part III. Part IY.


Black River Harbor, Ohio, improvement of....................                                        273
Black River, Mo., improvement of .......                         .....................              190
Black River, St. Clair County, Mich., improvement ofmonuth of. 264                                                           1999
Black River, N. C., improvement of..........................-----. 123                                              889
Black Rock Harbor, Conn., improvement of .......-..-                          - - - ..- - .. .       51   558
Black Warrior River, Ala., improvement of ...................                                       160            1198
Black Water River, Va., improvement of......................                                                        772
Block Island, R. I., construction of harbor at .............-                                     .  41   504
Board of Engineers, for fortifications and for river and harbor
  improvements .............................-----------------------------..--.......--......-------   5
Boston Harbor, Mass., improvement of----------..............-- ---------......... 27                      447
Brazos River, Tex., improvement of mouth of......-..........                                        175            1291
Brazos River, Tex., survey of mouth of .......................----                                                 1292
Brazos Santiago, Tex., improvement of harbor at .............                                       176            1320
Breakwater at Cleveland, Ohio, construction of................                                      274                      2001
Breakwater, New Haven, Conn., construction oft.............                                          48   544
Breton Bay, Md., improvement of ...........                         .       ..... ...........       109             815
Bridge, reconstruction of aqueduct, at Georgetown, D. C ......                                      106             789
Bridge across Eastern Branch, Potomac River, Washington,
  D. C., construction of.....................----                     .................             106             795
Bridgeport Harbor, Conn., improvement of....................                                         50   555
Bridging navigable waters of the United States................                                      307                                2371
    Arthur Kill, Staten Island Sound..-...--                              .................         308                                2421
    Arthur Kill, Staten Island Sound, report Boards of Engi-                                                                           2423
      neers on ....................----............                       ...................       308                                2430
      Cumberland River, near Nashville, Ten ....- .                              -..--........   308                                   2438
    Detroit River, at Belle Isle ...............................                       308                                             2450
    East River, at New York City.............................                          309                                             2470
    Great Kanawha River, near Point Pleasant, W. Va-........                           308                                             2444
    Interference of navigation by bridges, causeways, etc ....                         309                                             2525
    Lake Champlain, North Hero and Alburgh, Vt ......----......                        308                                             2431
    Mississippi River at Dubuque, Iowa ......................                          309                                             2492
    Mississippi River at Memphis, Tenn ......................                          309                                             2514
   Mississippi, Missouri, and Illinois rivers, report Board of
      Engineers on ..................                     ..........                   307                                             2371
    Missouri River, at Sibley,Mo .----...........-- ..............                     308                                             2434
    Missouri River, at Nebraska City, Nebr...................                          308                                             2464
    Missouri River, at Omaha, Nebr., and Council Bluffs, Iowa.                         309                                             2467
    Missouri River, at Sioux City, Iowa .......................                        309                                             2474
    Ohio River, at East Cairo, y ...................-----            --..........      308                                             2436
    Ohio River, at Cincinnatii, Ohio, and Newport, Ky ........                         309                                             2480
    Ohio River, at Corks Run, Pa..............---................                      309                                             2497
    Sault Ste. Marie River, Mich ..............................                        308                                             2456
    Sunflower River, Miss .....................................                        309                                             2485
    Tradewater River, Ky----....        ---------------------------.......             309                                             2472
    Tombighbee River, Miss., at Waverly ......................                         309                                             2507
    Tennessee River, at Chattanooga, Tenn ...................                          309                                             2510
    Yazoo River, Miss .-----..----....------.............------------..  -------............
                                                                                       309                                             2485
Broad Creek, I)el., improvement of ............................                          94 750
Broadkiln River, Del., improvement of .....-.................                            90 744
Brunswick Harbor, Ga., improvement of ......................                           142                         1044
Buckhanuon River, W. Va., improvement of .................                             229                                   1794
Buffalo Bayou, Tex., improvement of..........................                          174                         1286
Buffalo Harbor, N. Y., improvement of. ......................                          279                                   2028
Buffalo Harbor, N. Y., railway occupation of north pier ......                                                               2046
Burlington Harbor, Vt., improvement of ......................                          288                                   2098
Buttermilk Channel, N. Y., improvement of ...................                            61 610
                                             C.

Cache River, Ark., improvement of ...........................                                    189
Cahawba River, Ala., improvement of. ......................                                      157               1185
Calcasien River and Pass, La., improvement of...............                                     171               1256
Caloosahatchie River, Fla., improvement of...................                                    146               1093
Calumet Harbor, Ill., improvement of .........................                                   248                         1888
Calumet River, Ill. and Ind., improvement of .................                                   250                         1896
Cambridge Harbor, Md., improvement of.........                 ...............                    93
Camden Harbor, Me., examination and survey of..............                                       22      403
Camden Harbor, Me., improvement of .........................                                      14
Canal at the Cascades, Columbia River, Oregon, construction of.                                  301                         2161
Canal at Des Moines Rapids, Mississippi River, operation
and care of ..           ......................                                                 198                         1521
Canal, Louisville and Portland, operating and care of..........                                  219                         1728
Canal, Saint Mary's Falls, Mich., construction of..............                                  259                         1924
Canarsie Bay, N. Y., improvement of......................                                         65 627
Caney Fork River, Tenn., improvement of ...........                     ........                 212                         1634
Cape Fear River, N. C., at and below Wilmington, N. C., im-
provement of .........-    ....            .    .. .............                                125                895
Cape Fear River, above Wilmington, improvement of ..........                                     124                893
Catawba River, N. C., examination and survey of ..............                                   134                958
                                                                INDEX.


                                                                                                        Page.
                                     SUBJECT.
                                                                                        Part I.    Part II. Part III. Part IV.


Cedar Keys Harbor, Fla., improvement of .................                              149            1116
Cedar River Harbor, Mich., improvement of ................                             236                      1835
Channel between Staten Island and New Jersey, improvement
   of....... .......      .................................
                  ..........                                                            66 631
Charleston Harbor, S. C., improvement of ..................                            134             970
Charlevoix Harbor, Mich., improvement of ....................                          251                      1899
Charlotte Harbor, N. Y., improvement of......................                          282                      2069
Charts N. and NW. Lakes, printing and distribution of .......                          316                                 2810
Chattahoochee River, Ala. and Ga., improvement of ..........                           156            1181
Cheboygan Harbor, Mich., improvement of .......               ..........               261                      1958
Cheesequakes Creek, N. J., improvement of.....................                          73 661
Chehalis River, Wash., improvement of....................                              302                      2174
Chester River, Md., at Kent Island Narrows, improvement of.                                747
Chicago Harbor, Ill., improvement of.......................                            247                      1886
Chickahominy River, Va., improvement of ...............                                114             832
Chincoteague Bay, Va., inland water-way to Lewes, Del., im-
  provement of ......                                     ..........................
                                             ........................                   91   745
Chippewa River, Wis., improvement of .......................                           203                      1542
Choctawhatchee River, Fla. and Ala., improvement of........                            153
Choptank River, Md., improvement of ........................                            93   748
Clark's Creek, S. C., improvement of............................                       128
Clearwater River, Idaho, improvement of......................                          306                      2189
Cleveland Harbor, Ohio, improvement of .................                               274                      2001
Clinch River, Tenn., improvement of ......................                             209                      1606
Clinton Harbor, Conn., improvement of ...................                               47   538
Clinton River. Mich., improvement of.........................                          265                      1973
Coanjok Bay, N. C., improvement of........................                             102             770
Cocheco River, N. H., improvement of.......                ..................           20   396
Cohansey Creek, N. J., improvement of .......................                           84   714
Columbia River, Oregon, gauging waters of ....................                         303                      2177
Columbia River, Upper, improvement of .......................                          305                      2188
Columbia River, Lower, Oregon, improvement of..............                            304                      2185
Columbia River, Oregon, canal at Cascades ....................                         301                      2161
Columbia River, Oregon, improvement of month of............                            301                      2155
Conecuh River, Ala., improvement of..........................                          153            1169
Congaree River, S. C., improvement of ..............................                   133             943
Conneaut Harbor, Ohio, improvement of.......................                           276
Connecticut River, above Hartford, Conn., improvement of....                            46   508                2015
Connecticut River, below Hartford, Conn., improvement of....                            46   530
Contentnia Creek, N. C., improvement of ...........................                    117             858
Contingencies of rivers and harbors, estimates for.............                        306
Coosa River, Ga. and Ala., improvement of...................                           156            1178
Coosawattee River, Ga., improvement of ...................                             155            1175
Coos Bay, Oregon, improvement of entrance of ...............                           297                      2141
Coquille River, Oregon, improvement of mouth of.............                           293                      2137
Corpus Christi, Tex., improvement of channel to .............                          175            1307
Corsica Creek, Md., improvement of ......                ..............                 92   747
Cowlitz River, Wash., improvement of.......                          ..............    306                      2190
Cumberland River, Ky., improvement of south fork of ........                           211                      1633
Cumberland River, Ky., mouth of, improvement of............                                                     1626
Cumberland River, Tenn. and Ky., improvement of............                            210                      1611
Cumberland Sound, Fla. and Ga., entrance to, improvement of.                                          1050
Currituck Sound, improvement of.............................                           lo              7"0
Cypress Bayou, Tex., improvement of ......................                             177            1343
                                        D.

Dan River, Va., improvement of...                   ..     ...............             115             838
Davis Island Dam, Ohio River, operating and care of ........                           214                      1670
Defenses, sea-coast and lake frontier...........................                         4
Delaware Breakwater Harbor, improvement of..............                                81 707
Delaware River, Pa. and N. J., improvement of...............                            76 669
Des Moines Rapids Canal, dry.-dock at.........................                         199                      1527
Des Moines Rapids Canal, Mississippi River, operation and
care of...........................................................................    198                      1521
Detroit River, Mich., improvement of .........................                         267                      1978
Doboy Bar, Ga., improvement of ..............................                          141            1041
Dubuque, Iowa, ice-harbor at ..............                     ..         .........                            1529
Duck Creek, Del., improvement of .........................                              88 741
Duck River, Tenn., improvement of.........................                             210                      1610
Duluth Harbor, Minn., improvement of .....................                             229                      1803
Dunkirk, N. Y., improvement of............................                             278                      2024
Duties and rank of officers of the Corps of Engineers.........                         320
Duxbury Harbor, Mass, examination and surveyof..........                                32 472
                                        E.
Eagle Harbor, Mich., improvement of. ......................                            233                      1821
East Chester Creek, N. Y., improvement of.. ................                            55   574
East River and Hell Gate, N. Y., removal of obstructions from.                          60   603
4                                                                    INDEX.


                                                                                                          Page.
                                              SUBJECT.                                                     Page.
                                                                                         Part I.      Part II. Part III. Part IV.


Eastern Branch, Potomac River, bridge over, at Washington,
    D. C .........................................................                       106              795
Echo Harbor, New Rochelle, N.Y., improvement of ...........                               54   570
Edenton Bay, N. C., improvement of ........................                                               773
Edisto River, S. C., examination of North Fork of.............                           138              991
Edisto River, S. C., improvement of........................                              136              985
Elizabeth River, N. J., improvement of.....................                                69 648
Elk River, W. Va., improvement of.............                      ..........           224                       1760
Engineer Depot, Willets Point ...........                ......................             9 355
Engineer School of Application ............................                             8, 347, 357
Erie Harbor, Pa., improvement of .........................                               277                       2017
Erie Harbor, Pa., preservation of peninsula at Presque Isle....                          278                       2020
Escambia River, Ala. and Fla., improvement of. .....                        ....         153             1169
Eiaminatiors, surveys, and contingencies of rivers and har-
  bors, estimates for ............ ................................                      306
Explorations and reconnaissances, estimates for_...............                          318
Explorations and surveys, Department of the Columbia.......                              317                                  2816
Explorations and surveys in Department of the Platte ....- ...                           317                                  2818
Explorations and surveys in Division of the Missouri........                             317                                  2813
Expiorations and surveys in Division of the Pacific.........                             317                                  2817
                                                   F.

Fairlee Creek, Md., improvement of ........................                               92
Fairport Harbor, Ohio, improvement of.......................                             275                       2011
Falls of St. Anthony, Minn., preservation of ..................                          200                       1536
Fails of the Ohio River, improvement of navigation at........                            218                       1723
Feather and Sacramento rivers, Cal., improvement of ........                             295                       2132
Fish-ways, Falls of the Potomac, erection of.................                            312                                  2766
Five-Mile River Harbor, Conn., improvement of                         ..............      52
Flint River, Ga., improvement of...............................                          155             1175
Flushing Bay, N. Y., improvement of ..................                          ....       56 581
Forked Deer River, Tenn., improvement of......................                           183             1369
fort  Monroe, Va., construction of wharf at ..................                           107              804
Fourche River, Ark., improvement of ...........................                          188             1402
Fox and Wisconsin rivers, impiovement of..                   ..................          245                       1869
Fox River, improvement, operating, and care of................                           247                       1878
Irankford Creek, Pa., improvement of......................                         ..     77 698
Frankfort Harbor, Mich., improvement of .....................                            252                       1901
French Broad River, N. C., improvement of .....................                         116              843
French Broad River, Tenn., improvement of ..................                             208                       1602


Galveston Bay: ship-channel in, improvement of. ..............                           173             1279
Galveston Harlor, Tex., improvement of entrance to ......                                172             1265
Gasconade Iiver, Mo., improvement of.......................                              194                       1448
Gauley River, W. Va., examination of..........................                           226                       1761
Gauley River, W. Va., improvement of..........................                           224
Gedney's Channel, New York Harbor, improvement of........                                 63 617
Georgetown Ha rbor, S. C., improvement of .........                     ........         129              925
Georgetown and Washington harbors, D. C., improvement of..                               104              777
Glen Cove Harbor, N. Y., improvement of....................                               56
Gloucester Harbor, Mass., improvement of .....                 ............               25 442
Gordon's Lan(ding, Lake Champlain, breakwater at.............                            287                       2095
Gowans Bay, N. V., improvement of ......................                                  62 613
Grand Haven H aibor, Mich., improvement of ................                              255                       1911
Grand Marais, Mich., improvement of harbor of refuge at.....                             235
                                                                                                                   1832
Grand Marais, )ainn., improvement of harbor at ..............                            232                       1814
Grass River at Massena, N. Y., improvement of...............                             286                       2092
Great Kanwhai :River, W. Va., harbor of refuge at mouth of..                                                       1759
Great Kanawha River, W. Va., improvement of ..                    ...........            222                       1749
Great Kanawha River, W. Va., operating and care of locks and
dam son .. ....   ............. ...............   ..... .... .......                    223                       1756
Great Pee I)es River, S. C., improvement of........ ...........                          129              920
Great Sodus Harbor, N. Y., improvement of.. ................                             282                       2075
Green Bay Harbor, Wis., improvement of....................                               238                       1842
Green Jacket Shoal. Providence River, removal of ...........                              40 500
Greenport HIarbor, N. Y., improvement of.-...................                             55 577
Gross Point Channel, Detroit River, Mich., improvement of ..                             267                       1978
Guyandotte River, W. Va., improvement of....................                             227                       1791
                                                   H.

Harbor of Philadelphia, Pa., removal of island in front of......
                                                                                          __
                                                                                          78   678
Harbor of refuge, mouth of Great Kanawha River, W. Va.,
  construction of ... . .....   .........................                                223                       1759
Harbor of refufe, Sandy Bay, Mass.........-                  ...........                  25 439
Harbor of refuge, Sand Beach, Lake Huron, Mich .............                            264                        1968
Harbor of refuge, Sturgeon Bay Canal, Wis ....................                          238                        1844
Harlem River, N. Y., improvement of ...........................                          59    598
                                                                     INDEX.                                                           5

                                                                                                                  Page.
                                         SUBJECT.
                                                                                                 Part 1.      Part II. Part III. PartIV.


Hay Lake Channel, St. Mary's River, improvement of.....-..                                       261                      1954
Hell Gate, N. Y., improvement of navigation at........              - ..- .                       60    603
Herr's Island, Allegheny River, lock and dam at..--..--.........                                 216                      1682
Hiawassee River, Tenn., improvement of......................                                     209                      16(05
Hingham Harbor, Mass., improvement of. .....................                                      29    456
Housatonic River, Conn., improvement of. -..-..............                   :                    50   551
Hudson River, N. Y., between New Baltimore and Coxsackie,
  examination  and survey of..----~.......           ..-...........--   .                         68 640
Hudson River, N. Y., improvement of ..........................                                    57 588
Humboldt Harbor and Bay, Cal., improvement of .............                                      296                      2135
Huron Harbor, Ohio, improvement of..........---                ..--    ...---                    272                      1997
Hyannis Harbor, Mass., improvement of......-----................                                  33 484

                                              I.

Ice-harlbor at head of Delaware Bay, Del., construction of....                                    80 704
Ice-harbor at Maaicus Hook, Pa., construction of .............                                    79 701
Ice-harbor at mouth of Muskingum River, coilstruction of .-. -                                   216                      1683
Ice-harbor at Newcastle, Del., construction of ................                                   88 740
Illinois River, improvement of ...                             ........................          249                      1889
Indiana Chute, Falls of the Ohio, improvement of.............                                    219                      1727
Indian River, Del., improvement of............................                                    90 744
Inland navigation from New Berne and Beaufort, N. C., im-
   provement of ...............................................-----                        --   120              871
Inland water-way between Beaufort and New River, N. C., im-
   provement of...............................                                          ...      122              882
Inland water-way from Chincoteague Bay to Delaware Bay, im-
   provement of ..........                ....................................                    91    745
Interference with navigation by bridges, causeways, etc ......                                   309                                 2525
Ipswich River, Mass., improvement of.........................                                     24    438

                                              J.

James Creek Canal, city of Washington, D. C., survey of......                                    107              807
James River, Va., improvement of.    ...............................                              97              761
Jekyl Creek, Ga., improvement of.....................................                            142
Jekyl Creek, Ga., examination and survey of.....   -        .............                        143             1073
Jonesport, Me., improvement of Moose-a-bee Bar at...........                                      11    376

                                              K.

Kanawha River, Great, improvement of.......................                                      222                       1749
Kanawha iiver, Little, improvement of.....................                                       228                       1792
Kaskaskia iver, Ill., from New Athens to its mouth, examin-
ation and survey of... ......................................                                   195                       1453
Kennebec Rivetr, Bath and Augusta, Me., examination and sur-
vey of-------
         ..-------------...                                          -------..................    22    412
Kennebec R iver, Mo., improvement of ........................                                     16
Kennebunk River, Me., improvement of..................                                            19    392
Kenosha Huar bor, Wis., improvement of.......................                                    244                       1866
Kentucky River, Ky., improvement of .....................                                        226                       1770
Kentucky River. Ky., operating and care of locks and dams on.                                    227                       1775
Kewaunee harbor, Wis., improvement of ......................                                     239                       1848
Keyport Harbor, N. J., improvement of ..                       ...................                73    662
Key West Harbor, Fla., northwest entrance to, improvement of                                     146              1;092

                                              L.

Lagrange Bayou, Fla., improvement of .......................                                    152              1162
Lake Champlain, Narrows, N-. Y. and Vt., improvement at .....                                   289                       2102
Lake City, Minn., harbor of refuge at......................199                                                            1529
Lake Pepin, harbor of refuge at Lake City .................                                     199                       1529
Lake Pepin, harbor of refue at Stockholm .............----..---..                               200                       1532
Lakes, northern and northwestern, water levels of.............                                  316                                 2807
Lakes, ptinting and distribution of charts of ................                                  316                                 2810
Laws of Fiftieth Congress, first session, affecting Corps of En-
   gineers ...                                                                                                                       2821
Leonardtown Harbor, Md., improvement of....................                                     109               815
Lewes, Del., construction of piers at..........................                                  81    705
Licking River, Ky., from Farmer's to West Liberty, improve-
   ment of ...............................................                                              227
Link River, Oregon, examination of ...........................                                  304                       2179
Little Harbor, N. H., improvement of.........................                                    21    397
Little Kanawha River, W. Va., improvement of ............                                       228                       1792
Little Narragansett ;ay, R. I. and Conn., improvement of ..                                            508
Little Rod River, Ark., improvement of.......................                                   185              1377
Little River, La., improvement of ..........................                                    179
Little River, Mo., from Hornersville to its junction with the
   St. Francis River, improvement of..........................                                    191
Little Sodus Harbor, N. Y., improvement of...................283                                                          2079
Little Tennessee River, Tenn., improvement of...............                                    209                       1608
6                                                                          INDEX.


                                                                                                                             Page.
                                           SUBJECT.
                                                                                                         Part I.         Part II. Part III. Part IV.

Louisa Fork of Sandy River, Va., examination of ..-..             ....--.                                229                         1795
Louisville and Portland Canal, enlargement of ................                                           218                         1723
Louisville and Portland Canal, operating and care of ........- .                                         219                         1728
Lower Willamette and Columbia rivers, Oregon, improvement of                                             304                         2185
Lubec Channel, Me., improvement of..........................                                              11 374
Luddington Harbor, Mich., improvement of ..................--            .                               253                         1905
Lumber River, N. C., improvement of..................          .......                                   128
Lynn Harbor, Mass., improvement of...... .....................                                            26 445

                                               M1.
Malden River, Mass., improvement of .........................                                             29       456
Mamaroneck Harbor, N. Y., improvement of..................-                                      .        53       569
Manasquan River, N. J., improvement of                                    ...................--.          75       667
Manatee River, Fla., improvement of ........................-.                                          147                 1107
Manchester Harbor, Mass., examination and survey of........                                               32       463
Manchester Harbor, Mass., improvement of....................                                              26
Manistee Harbor, Mich., improvement of...................-                                              253                          1904
Manistique Harbor, Mich., improvement of....................                                            235                          1815
Manitowoc Harbor, Wis., improvement of .....................                                            240                          1851
Mantua Creek, N. J., improvement of ..........................                                            83       711
Maps, military and geographical, compilation of-..............-----316
Marcus Hook Harbor, Pa., improvement of....................                                               79       701
Marquette Harbor Mich., improvement of.....................                                             234                          1831
Matagorda Bay, Tex., improvement of entrance to ............                                            175                 1301
Mattaponi River, Va., improvement of .......                               ...............              112                  826
Mattawan Creek, N. J., improvement of.......................                                              74       663
Maurice River, N. J., improvement of........................                                              86       738
Meadow River, W. Va., examination of .......................                                            226                          1761
Meherrin River, N. C., improvement of.........................                                                               773
Meeker's Island, Minn., lock and dam at ......................                                          201                          1536
Menomonee Harbor, Mich. and Wis., improvement of .........                                              236                          1837
Merrimac River, Mass., improvement of......................                                               23       436
Michigan City Harbor, Ind., improvement of ...................                                          258                          1919
Milford Harbor, Conn., improvement of........................                                             49       548
Milwaukee Bay, harbor of refuge at.............                                 ...............         242                          1859
Milwaukee Harbor, Wis., improvement of .....................                                            243                          1862
Mingo Creek, S. C., improvement of.............................                                         130
Minnesota River, improvement of..........                        ....                                   204
                                                                                                 ...............                     1551
Minnesota River, with a view to its improvement by locks and
dams, examination and survey of ..........................                                             206                          1571
Mispillion Creek, Del., improvement of........................                                            90       743
Mississippi River :
    above the Falls of St. Anthony, improvement of .........                                           201                           1537
    at Des Moines Rapids, improvement of . ..................                                           108                          1518
    at Falls of St. Anthony, improvement of .................                                           200                          1536
    operations of snag-boats on.................................                                        191                          1419
    at Rush Island Bend, Ill., examination and survey of......                                          195                          1452
    reservoirs at headwaters of ...............................                                         202                          1539
    improvement of South Pass, inspection of .................                                          166                 1229
    between the mouths of the Illinois and Ohio Rivers, im.
      provement of.            .................................                                        192                          1422
    between Saint Paul and St. Anthony's Falls, survey of ....                                          206                          1560
    from Des Moines Rapids to the mouth of Illinois River, im                                           196                          1461
      provement of.............................                           ............                  19                           1479
    from Minneapolis, Minn., to Des Moines Rapids...........                                            197                          1480
    upper, operations of snag-boats on........                         .................                196                          1471
Mississippi River Commission ..................                               .      ...........        305
    annual report for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888......                                        306                                     2213
    report of operations from July 1 to November 1, 1887......                                          306                                     2191
Mississippi River, water-gauges on............................                                          184                 1370
Missouri River:
    operations of snag-boats on .--.............-- --                      -..         ........         192                          1419
    from Sioux City to Fort Benton, Mont., improvement of...                                            205                          1536
Missouri River Commission:
    annual report fiscal year ending June 30, 1888 .............                                        307                                     23213
Mobile Harbor, Ala., improvement of ........-...-............                                           159                 1193
Mokalumne River, Cal., improvement of .....                           ..............                    294                          2131
Monongahela River, lock and dam No. 9, operation and care of.                                           215                          1678
Monongahela River, improvement of .........................                                             215                          1676
Monroe Harbor, Mich., improvement of .----......---...-----------.........-- 268                                                     1981
Moose-a-bee B..r, Jonesport, Me., improvement of...--...........                                          11       376
Mosquito Creek, S. C , examination and survey of .............                                          138                  997
Mount Desert, Me., breakwater at ............................                                             13
Mount Vernon, Va., improvement of channel at..............                                              108                  813
Movable dam at Davis' Island, Ohio River, operating and care of 214                                                                  1670
Muskegon Harbor, Mich., improvement of-.--------------..............                                    255                          1910
Muskingum River, Ohio, ice-harbor at mouth of............                                                216                         1683
Muskingum River, Ohio, improvement of----.................                                               217
Muskingum River, Ohio, operating and care of locks and dams on                                           217                         1684
                                                                 INDEX.                                                         7

                                                                                                           Page.
                                      SUBJECT.
                                                                                           Part I.     PartII. Part III. Part IV.


                                          N.

Nansemond River, Va., improvement of---------------------........................           98
Nanticoke River, Del., improvement of ........................                              94   749
Nantucket Harbor, Mass., improvement of..................                                   33   486
Napa River, Cal., improvement of . -...-..                   ....................          290
Narragansett Bay, R, I., improvement of.......................                              39   498
Narragaugus River, Me., improvement of......................                                12   378
Neabsco Creek, Va., improvement of.                       .........................        108             814
Neches River, Tex., improvement of-.........................                                              1260
Neuse River, N. C., improvement of..-....-.....................                            119             866
New Bedford Harbor, Mass., examination and survey of .......                                44   513
New Bedford Harbor, Mass., improvement of.................                                  36
Newburyport Harbor, Mass., improvement of..................                                 22   433
New Castle, Del., ice harbor at.................................                            88   740
New Haven Harbor, Conn., breakwater at, construction of ....                                48   544
New Haven Harbor, Conn., improvement of...................                                  48   540
New London Harbor, Conn., improvement of ..................                                 45   525
Newport Harbor, Cal., survey of ........ ......                         .    .........     293                       2118
Newport Harbor, R. I., improvement of.......................                                40   502
New River, N. C., improvement of ....................................                      123             885
New River, Va. and W. Va., improvement of ................                                 225                       1760
New Rochelle Harbor, N. Y.. improvement of .................                                54   572
Newtown Creek, N. Y., improvement of........................ ....                           61   606
New York Harbor, improvement of............................                                 63   617
Niagara River, N. Y., between Black Rock and Tonawanda,
for a 16-foot channel, examination of. .........................                          282                       2064
Nomini Creek, Va., improvement of ..........................                               109             816
Nootsack River, Wash., improvement of .....................                                303                       2176
Norfolk Harbor, Va., approaches to, improvement of..........                                99             767
Norfolk Harbor, Va., improvement of...........................                              98             764
North River Bar, Currituck Sound, N. C., improvement of ....                                               770
Norwalk Harbor, Conn., improvement of......................                                 51   562
Nottoway River, Va., improvement of ..............                           ......        103             773
Noxubee River, Miss., improvement of....................                                   163            1208

                                          0.

Oakland Harbor, San Francisco Bay, Cal., improvement of .....                              290                       2105
Oak Orchard Harbor, N. Y., improvement of.....................                             281                       2062
Obeil's River, Tenn., examination of, from existing improve-
  ments to mouth of West Fork           ..........................                         213                       1636
Occupancy and injury to public works by corporations, etc. ...                             310                                2687
Ocmulgee River, Ga., improvement of...........................                             155           1173
Oconee River, Ga., improvement of.............................                             154           1170
Oconto Harbor, Wis., improvement of..........................                              237                       1839
Office of the Chief of Engineers ............. .............                               319
Officers of the Corps of Engineers, number of, duties of ... ....-                           3 320
Ogdensburgh Harbor, N. Y., improvement of....................                              285                       2089
Ohio River, improvement of ................................                                213                        1644
Ohio River, improvement of Falls of.....--                       .................         218 219               1723, 1727
Ohio River, survey of, near Evansville, Ind ........                            ........   218                        1715
Olcott Harbor, N. Y., improvement of..........................                             280                       2059
Ontonagon Harbor, Mich., improvement of.....................                               233                       1819
Oostenaula River, Ga., improvement of .....................                                              1175
Osage River, Mo. and Kans., improvement of..............                                   195                       1450
Oswego Harbor, N. Y., improvement of...........................                            284                       2082
Otter Creek, Vt., improvement of .. .........................                              289                       2100
Ouachita and Black rivers, Ark. and La., improvement of .....                              178           1346
Ouachita River, Ark., improvement of, above Camden.........                                178
                                          P.
Pamlico and Tar rivers, N. C., improvement of ..............                               117            854
Pamunkey River, Va., improvement of ........................                               112            828
Pascagoula River, Miss., improvement of ....................                               163           1210
Passaic River, N. J., improvement of .............................                          68   645
Pass Cavallo Inlet, Tex., improvement of, and survey of ......                             175           1301
Patapsco River, Md., improvement of ......................                                  95            756
Patuxent River, Md., from Benedict to Hill's Landing, exam-
  ination and survey of .......................................                            116            846
Patuxent River, Md., improvement of..........................                              110
Pawcatuck River, R. I., improvement of .........................                            43 509
Pawtucket River, R. I., improvement of ......................                               38 496
Pearl River, Miss., improvement of ...........................                             164           1216
Pease River, Fla., improvement of.............................                             147           1102
Pee Dee River, Great, S. C., improvement of ..................                             129            920
Pee Dee River, Little, S. C., improvement of ..................                            128
Penobscot River, Me., improvement of ........................                               13 379
S                                                       INDEX.


                                                                                            Page.
                                  SUBJECT.
                                                                            Part I.     Part IL Part III. Part IV.


Penobscot River, from Bangor to Bucksport Narrows, exami-
  nation and survey of.........................................      22 425
Pensacola, Fla., resurvey of outer and inner bars at.......----..
                                                              -   . 159     1191
Pensacola Harbor, Fla., improvement of ...................... 352           1163
Pensaukee Harbor, Wis., improvement of ...-.................        237          1841
Pentwater Harbor, Mich., improvement of ---------.....---........
                                            .......                 254          1907
Pere Marquette Harbor, Mich. (see Ludington) ...............        253          1905
Petaluma Creek, Cal., improvement of ......................... 295               2133
Petit Jean River, Ark., improvement of--....................... 187         1400
Plattsburgh Harbor, N. Y., improvement of.................... 288                2097
Plymouth Harbor, Mass., improvement of.....................          31 459
Pocomoke River, Md., improvement of .---..-------..---------................
                                                                     95 752
Portage Lake, Mich., harbor lines in ...........................    234          1822
Portage Lake, Mich., harbor of refuge at...................... 253               1903
Port Chester Hartor, N. Y., improvement of...................        53 567
Port Clinton Harbor, Ohio, improvement of...................        270          1986
Port Jefferson Harbor, Long Island, N. Y., improvement of -..           578
Por'land Harbor, Me., channel in Back Cove, improvement of..         17 387
Portland Harbor, Me., improvement of ........................        16 385
Portsmouth Harbor, N. H., improvement of ...................         20 394
Port-warden's line at Philadelphia .............................     86 718
Port Washington Harbor, Wis., improvement of.............. 242                   1856
Post at Willets Point .....--......-.............. ............. 8 345
Potomac RIiver, at Washington, D. C., improvement of........        104      777
Potomac River, at Great Falls, fishways at .............--   ..--. 312                                         2766
Potomac River, channel at Mount Vernon, Va., improvement of. 108             813
Pow-wow River, Mass., improvement of............            ...... 24
Providence River,        R.
                      I., Green Jacket Shoals, removal of...... 40 500
Providence River, R. I., improvement of.......................       39 498
Provincetown Harbor, Mass., improvement of--.. ............          32 462
Public buildings and grounds, District of Columbia..........------. 312                                        2769
Public works, occupancy and injury with navigation by corpo-
  rations, etc..--........------........--.--............-------...................
                                                                    310                                        2687
Pultneyville Harbor, N. Y., improvement of...............2073
Punta Rassa Harbor, Fla., examination and survey of ......... 151           1154
                                        R.

Raccoon River, N. J., improvement of..........................  84 712
Racine Harbor, Wis., improvement of. ........................  244                                   1865
Rahway  River, N. J., improvement of........................... 70 649
1aCLV   L,., 1V1YV   9          / 1V,
                     1-. V.,JA-l"  l,                                  -
                                         LIVUU V1 .......................
Rappahannock River, Va, imrovement of....................111                                819
Raritan Bay, N. J., improvement of............................           67       633
Raritan River, N. J., improvement of..........................           71       652
Reconnaissances and explorations ............................. 316
Red River, Ark., improvement of, above Fulton-..............            184                1375
Red River, La. and Ark., improvement of... ..........                   176
                                                                 ........                  1331
Red River of thoN orth, Minn., from Moorhead to Fergus Falls,
  examination and survey of ................................            206                          1584
Red River of the North, improvement of ......................           204                          1552
Redwood Harbor, Cal., improvement of.........................           291                          2108
Reservoirs at headwaters of Mississippi River, construction of. 202                                  1539
Reservoirs at headwaters of Mississippi River and tributaries,
   surveys for .................................................                                     1555
River and harbor improvements ..............................             10       373
Roanoke River, N. C., improvement of ...................... 115                             840
Rockland Harbor, Me., improvement of .......................             15       384
Rockport Harbor, Me., examination and survey of.. ...........22                   407
Rockport Harbor, Me, improvement of ........................             15
Rocky River, Ohio, improvement of mouth of ..............               273                          2001
Romerly Marsh, Ga., improvement of..........................            140                1033
Rondout Harbor, N. Y., improvement of .......................            58       596
Rouge River, Mich., improvement of ..........................           268
Rouse's Point, Lake Champlain, breakwater at ...............            286                          2093
                                        S.
Sabine Pass, Tex., improvement of ..........................             172               1261
Sabine River, Tex., improvement of...........................                              1259
Sackett's Harbor, N. Y., improvement of ......................           285                         2086
Saco River, Me., construction breakwater at .................             18 389
Saco River, Me., improvement of .................................         18 390
Sacramento and Feather rivers, Cal., improvement of.........             295                         2132
Saginaw River, Mich., improvement of.........................            263                         1963
Saint Anthony, preservation of Falls of.              .        ...... .. 200                         1536
Saint Augustine Harbor, Fla., improvement of ...............             145
Saint Augustine, Fla., survey of, for deep-sea channel on outer
  bar.--....--...                          .........................        151            1123
Saint Clair Flats Canal, Mich...............................                265                      1975
                                                                  INDEX.                                                               9


                                                                                                                  Page.
                                      SUBJECT.
                                                                                              Part I.         Part II. Part III. Part lYV.


Saint Clair Flats 'anal, operating and care of..---............ 266                                                       1976
Saint Croix River, Wis. and Minn., improvement of............203                                                          1547
Saint Francis River, Ark., improvement of ...................190                                                 1414
Saint Francis River from Greenville, Mo., to Arkansas State
                                                                     190
  line, improvement of .--...........--....................--------...
Saint Jerome's Creek, Md., improvement of entrance to ....... 110                                                 818
Saint John's River, Fla., upper, improvement of ..............                                                   1090
Saint John's River, Fla., improvement of bar at mouth of .... 143                                                1079
Saint Jones River, Del., improvement of ......................89 742
Saint Joseph's Harbor, Mich., improvement of ................257                                                          1917
Saint Joseph's River, Mich., improvement of..................        258
Saint Louis Bay, Wis., improvement in ....................... 230                                                         1809
St. Mary's Falls Canal, construction of dry-dock at ............ 260                                                      1953
Saint Mary's Falls Canal, operating and care of................260                                                        1937
Saint Mary's Falls Canal, Mich., construction of.... -.....          259                                                  1924
St. Mary's River, Mich., Hay Lake Channel, improvement of..          261                                                  1954
Salem River, N. J., improvement of.........-           ............... 84 712
Salkiehatchie River, S. C., improvement of.....................      137                                          987
Salt River, Ky., examination and survey of....................       229                                                  1798
Sand Beach, Lake Huron, Mich., harbor of refuge at ..........        264                                                  1968
San Diego Harbor, Cal., improvement of and survey of........ 293                                                          2114
Sandusky (CityHarbor, Ohio, improvement of ...............           271                                                  1988
Sandusky Harbor, Ohio, straight channel, report on survey for.                                                            1991
Sandusky River, Ohio, improvement of .......................         271                                                  1996
Sandy Bay. Cape Ann, Mass., harbor of refuge at .............          25 439
San Francisco Harbor and interior bays, survey of ............       291                                                  2108
San Joaquin River, Cal., improvement of ......................       293                                                  2129
San Luis Obispo Harbor, Cal., improvement of and survey of.. 293
San Pedro Bay, Cal.,near entrance to Wilmington Harbor, for
  an outer harbor, examination and survey of ...- ............                                 293                        2122
Santee River, S. C., improvement of...........................                                 131                933
Saugatuck Harbor, Mich., improvement of ........                              .....            256                        1914
Saugerties Harbor, N. Y., improvement of ..................                                      58     584
Savannah Harbor and River, Ga., improvement of ............                                    138               1005
Savannah River, Ga., from Cross-Tides above Savannah to the
  bar, examination and survey of..............................                                 143               1056
Savannah River, Ga., improvement of, above Augusta........                                     140               1030
Savannah River, Ga., improvement of, below Augusta ......... 139                                                 1026
School of application at Wvillets Point .......... ...........                                8, 347,   357
Schuylkill, Pa., improvement of ............................                                     78     699
Scituate Harbor, Mass., improvement of .......................                                   30     458
Sea-coast and lake frontier defenses .. .......... .....                           ........ 4
Sheboygan Harbor, Wis., improvement of.....................                                    241                        1853
Sheepshead Bay, N. Y., improvement of .....................                                      61     624
Shenandoah River, Va. and W. Va., improvement of...........                                                       804
Shrewsbury River, N. J., improvement of ....................                                     74     665
Skagit River, Wash., improvement of .................                                 .....    303                        2176
Snag-boats on Mississippi and Missouri rivers, etc............                                 191                        1419
Snake River, Wash., improvement of .............-                           ..-.......         305                        2188
Snohomish River, Wash., improvement of ..............                                       . 303                         2176
Snoqualme River, Wash., improvement of.-....                         .............             303                        2176
South Haven Harbor, Mich., improvement of.........                                .......      257                        1916
South Pass. Mississippi River, inspection of improvements at.                                   166              1229
Southport Harbor, Conn., improvement of .....................                                           561
South River, N. J.,improvement of ...........................                                    72     657
Spring Creek, N. Y., examination of ...........................                                  67     638
Stamford Harbor, Conn., improvement of .....................                                     52     564
Staten Island, N. Y., improvement of New Jersey channel-..--                                     66     631
Staunton River, Va., improvement of.........                        .............              114                834
Steel's Bayou, Miss., improvement of...........................                                 182              1364
Steilaquamish River, Wash., improvement of ................                                    303                       2176
Stockholm, Wis., harbor of refuge at...........                  .................              200                       1532
Stonington Harbor, Conn., improvement of....................                                     43     511
Sturgeon Bay Canal, Wis., harbor of refuge at................                                   238                       1844
Sumpawanus Inlet, N. Y., improvement of...................                                       66     629
Superior Bay, Wis., improvement of harbor at.........                               .......     230                       1809
Surveys and examinations for improvement of rivers and har-
  bors, estimates for ..........................................                                306
Susquehanna River, near Havre de Grace, Md., improvement of-                                     91     746
Suwanee River, Fla., improvement of ...........................                                 150              1118
Swanton Harbor, Vt., improvement of............................                                 287                       2094
                                            T.

Tallahatchie River, Miss., improvement of ...........        .................
                                                                     182                                         1363
Tallapoosa River, Ala., improvement of......................         156                                         .1184
Tampa Bay, Fla., improvement of...........................                                     148               1112
Tangipahoa River, improvement of ............................                                                    1245
Taunton River, Mass, examination and survey of ............                                     44 515
             ENG 88-                  2
10                                                                   INDEX.


                                                                                                                 Page.
                                        SUBJECT.
                                                                                                 Part I.     Part II. Part III. Part IV.


Taunton River, Mass., improvementof........................                                    37 492
Tchefuncte River, La., improvement of........................                                 167               1243
Tchula Lake, Miss., improvement of...........................                                 181               1361
Telegraph and telephone service, public buildings, Washing-
ton, D. C., report on ..........................................                             313                                   2794
Tennessee River, above Chattanooga, improvement of ...-.....                                  2!7                         1592
Tennessee River, below Chattanooga, improvement of-.........                          - -     207                         1594
Tensas River, La., improvement of ................... ...........                             180               1354
Thames River, Conn., improvement of ........................                                   45 521
Thoroughfare back from Cape May, N. J., to AtlanticCity, ex-
  amination and survey of .....................................                                86 724
Thunder Bay Harbor, Mich., improvement of- -..- -...............--                        - . 262                         1961
Tickfaw River, La., improvement of ..........................                                                   1246
Ticonderoga River, N. Y., improvement of .........----------------........                    280                        2101
Tillamook Bay and Bar, Oregon, survey and improvement of ..                                   300                        2150
Toledo Harbor, Ohio, improvement of ..........................                                269                        1983
Tombigbee River, Ala., improvement of ......................                                  161               1203
Tombigbee River, Miss., examination for continuous navi-
  gation from Vienna, Ala., to Walker's Bridge                          ...............       166               1226
Tonawanda Harbor, N. Y., and Niagara River, from Black
  Rock for 16-foot channel, examination of .
Tonawanda Harbor, N. Y., improvement of ....................
                                                                        ..................    282                        2061
                                                                                              279
Torpedo defense and experiments -.......                          ...................           9 351
Totusky River, Va., improvement of ..........................                                 111                824
Tradewater River, Ky., improvement of. ......................                                 221                         1747
Trent River, N. C., improvement of ............................                               118                862
Trinity River, Tex., improvement of .......................                                   174               1285
Two Rivers Harbor, Wis., improvement of ...................                                   240                         1850

                                            U.

Umpqua River, Oregon, improvement of .......................                                     298                     2141
Upper Columbia and Snake Rivers, Oregon and Wash., im-
provement of ...............................................                                    305                     2188
Upper Mississippi River, improvement of......................                                    196                     1471
Upper Thoroughfare, between Diel's Island and main-land....                                            751
Upper Willamette River, Oregon, improvement of .............                                     305                     2187
Urbana Creek, Va., improvement of.............                           ...............         112             825
                                             V.

Vermillion Harbor, Ohio, improvement of............ ..........                                   272                      1998
Vineyard Haven Harbor, Mass., improvement of...............                                       34
Volusia Bar, Fla., improvement of .............................                                  145            1088
                                            W.

Wabash River, Ind., improvement of .........................                                     220                      1738
Waccemaw River, S. C., improvement of ......................                                     126             912
Wapoo Cut, S. C., improvement of .............................                                   135             980
Warebam Harbor, Mass., improvement of. .....................                                      35   489
Warren River, R. I., improvement of ..........................                                    38   494
Warrior River, Ala., improvement of .                            ......................      .   160            1200
Washington and Georgetown Harbors, D. C., improvement of.                                        104             777
Washington Aqueduct, D. C ...................................                                    310                                2749
Washington City water-supply, increase of .--................                                    210                                2755
Washington Monument, Washington, D. C., care of.......-...                                       313                                2709
Wateree River, S. C., improvement of                        ......................               132             939
Water-gauges on Columbia River                        -..........................                303                      2177
Water-gauges on Mississippi River and tributaries ..........                                     184            1370
Water levels northern and northwestern lakes ................                                    316                                2807
Waukegan Harbor, Ill., improvement of. ....................                                      245                      1867
Wellflket Harbor, Mass., examination and survey of. .....                                   ..    32   476
Wellfleet Harbor, Mass., improvement of ......................                                    31
Westport Harbor, Mass., improvement of...........                                 .........       3    491
White River, Ark., improvement of ..........................                                     188            1403
White River Harbor, Mich., improvement of.................                                       254                      1908
White River, Ind., improvement of............................                                    221                      1745
Wicomico River, Md., improvement of............ ...-..-......                                          751
Wll~amette River, Lower, Oregon, improvement of............                                      301                     2185
Wilamette River, Upper, Oregon, improvement of............                                       305                     2187
Willets Point, post at.........................................                                    8   345
Wilmington, Cal., construction of breakwater at..-----..-------........                          292                     2111
Wilmington Harbor, Del., improvement of. .................                                        87   739
Wilson Harbor, N. Y., improvement of--.....................                                      280                     2057
Winthrop Harbor, Mass., examination and survey of..........                                       32   468
Winthrop Harbor, Mass., improvement of.....................                                       27
Winyaw Bay, S. C., improvement of...........................                                     130             929
Wisconsin and Fox rivers, improvement of ..................                                      245                      1869
Withlacoochee River, Fla., improvement of ...................                                    149            1114
                                                        INDEX.                                                         11
                                                                                                            ------
                                                                                                  Page.
                                 SUBJECT.
                                                                                 Part I.     Part II. Part III. I Part IV.


Woodbridge Creek, N. J., improvement of .....................                     71   650
Woodbury Creek, N. J., improvement'of.......................                      83   710
Wood River, Oregon, examinlation of .................---        ..........       304                      2177
Wood's Holl Harbor, Mass., improvement of ...................                     34   488
Wrecks in Connecticut River, removal of...--................                      57   5S3
Wrecks in Delaware Bay and River, removal of...............                       85   716
Wrecks in Long Island Sound, removal of ....................                      57   584
Wreck in Hudson River, N. Y., removal of ...................                      67   637
Wreck in New York Harbor, N. Y., removal of...............                        67   637
Wreck in Harlem River, N. Y., removal of ....................                     67   637
Wreck in Delaware Breakwater Harbor, removal of...........                        85   716
Wreck in port of Philadelphia, Pa, removal of .................                   85   716
Wreck in Broadkiln River, Del., removal of...................                     95   753
Wreck in Norfolk Harbor, Va., removal of...-----------------..............---.   104
Wreck in Pascotank River, N. C., removal of.---..-----.....---.......            104
Wreck off Turkey Point, Chesapeake Bay, removal of.........                      104
Wreck in Rappahannock River. Va., removal of ..............                      116             845
Wreck in Mattaponi River, Va., removal of ...................                    116             845
Wreck in Chehaw River, S. C., removal of ....................                    138             991
Wrecks in Saint John's River, Fla., removal of................                   151            1122
Wrecks in Pensacola Harbor, Fla., removal of---..............                    158            1189
                                     Y.

Yadkin River, N. C., examination of...........................                   134             948
Yadkin River, N. C., improvement of..................--         .......          127             917
Yalabusha River, Miss., improvement of....-----.....--..........                                1362
Yaquina Bay, Oregon, improvement of entrance to.............                     299                      2146
Yazoo River, Miss., improvement of.....-- ..--..................----..           181            1359
Yellowstone National Park, construction of roads and bridges in                  314                                  2803
Yellowstone River, Mont. and Dak., improvement of -.........                     206                      1559
York Harbor, Me., improvement of ............................                     19   393
York River, Va., improvement of.............................            ...      113             830



                                                            0
